Latest / Mechanical Engineering Made Simple / (#131) Building a Machine From Slugs to Springs

Transcript

(#131) Building a Machine From Slugs to Springs · Mechanical Engineering Made Simple

• 0:00
  Welcome back to mechanical engineering made simple.
• 0:02
  It's good to be back. You know, usually we take this
• 0:05
  giant stack of articles, maybe some really dense research
• 0:09
  papers, and we sort of wade through them for you.
• 0:11
  Right, we try to find the golden Nuggets.
• 0:13
  Exactly. We summarize, we condense.
• 0:16
  But today we're doing something a little different.
• 0:19
  We are. We're putting on our hard hats
• 0:21
  today. Yes, we're calling this the
• 0:23
  walkthrough story. I've got a pile of heavy duty
• 0:26
  engineering manuals here, chapters on mechanics, machine
• 0:29
  elements, you name it. And instead of just reading them
• 0:32
  like a textbook, we're going to use them to build something.
• 0:34
  A mental build. A mental build from scratch.
• 0:37
  We're going to take all those popular online questions, you
• 0:40
  know, how do gears work? Why do springs break and answer
• 0:43
  them by actually designing a machine in our heads?
• 0:47
  I like this. It's all about practical
• 0:49
  application. We're not just memorizing
• 0:51
  formulas, we're trying to solve a real problem.
• 0:53
  Which is what engineering is, right?
• 0:55
  It is. It's not just the math, it's
• 0:59
  it's decision making under pressure.
• 1:01
  OK, so let's set the scene. Imagine we're in a workshop.
• 1:04
  You can smell the grease. You can hear the hum.
• 1:07
  We have a big electric motor on one side and on the other a
• 1:10
  load. Let's say it's a heavy conveyor
• 1:12
  belt. OK, before we even pick up a
• 1:14
  wrench, you're saying we have to stop and think about the
• 1:18
  invisible stuff. You have to know the rules of
• 1:20
  the road. You can't build anything,
• 1:22
  whether it's a conveyor belt or tiny toggle switch, without
• 1:25
  starting with engineering mechanics.
• 1:27
  All right, so let's unpack that. Where does an engineer actually
• 1:30
  start? What's the very first concept?
• 1:33
  Well, it really starts with defining the state of the
• 1:36
  object. Is it moving or is it staying
• 1:38
  still? And that gives us our two main
• 1:40
  branches, statics and dynamics. OK, static sounds like
• 1:44
  stationary, so I'm guessing that means things that don't move.
• 1:46
  That's the general idea, but it's a bit more nuanced.
• 1:49
  Statics is about bodies in equilibrium.
• 1:52
  Equilibrium. So that means they're either
• 1:54
  completely at rest, like a bridge holding up traffic, or
• 1:57
  they're moving at a perfectly uniform motion.
• 2:01
  The key is that all the forces balance out to 0.
• 2:03
  And dynamic. Dynamics is the Wild West.
• 2:06
  That's for bodies that are not in equilibrium.
• 2:08
  They're accelerating. The forces are unbalanced and to
• 2:13
  understand either of those you had to speak the language of
• 2:16
  scalars and vectors. OK, I remember this from high
• 2:18
  school physics, but let's be honest, I've probably forgotten
• 2:20
  most of it, so give us the refresh.
• 2:22
  A scalar is easy. It's a quantity that just has
• 2:24
  magnitude a number. Like time or volume?
• 2:29
  Exactly. Time, volume, density.
• 2:32
  If I say 5 gallons of gas, that's a scaler.
• 2:35
  It doesn't point anywhere. You can't have 5 gallons north,
• 2:37
  right? But a vector?
• 2:39
  A vector has two properties, have magnitude and direction.
• 2:42
  Force is the classic vector, velocity is another one.
• 2:45
  So it actually matters which way you're pushing.
• 2:47
  It matters immensely. Pushing a car north is a very
• 2:50
  different outcome than pushing it South, even if the amount of
• 2:53
  push is identical. And that leads us directly to
• 2:56
  the grandfather of all engineering rules.
• 2:59
  Sir Isaac Newton. The big three, Newton's laws of
• 3:02
  motion. You literally can't design
• 3:03
  anything that moves without them all.
• 3:05
  Right. Lay them on US.
• 3:06
  Law number one. An object at rest stays at rest.
• 3:10
  An object in motion stays in motion unless you mess with it,
• 3:14
  unless an unbalanced force acts on it.
• 3:16
  So things are lazy. They keep doing what they're
• 3:18
  doing. That's inertia.
• 3:20
  The resistance to change law #2 is the famous one.
• 3:23
  The equation force equals mass times acceleration F equals MA.
• 3:28
  That's how we figure out how big of an engine we need.
• 3:31
  Precisely. And the third one is that for
• 3:32
  every action there's an equal and opposite reaction.
• 3:35
  You push on the wall, the wall pushes.
• 3:36
  Back exactly. If it didn't, your hand would go
• 3:38
  right through it. OK, now here's where things get
• 3:41
  weird, especially for anyone who didn't grow up with the metric
• 3:44
  system. The source material has this
• 3:45
  whole units debate. Oh, the units debate, a source
• 3:49
  of endless headaches. In the metric system, the MSI,
• 3:52
  it feels so clean. You have kilograms for mass,
• 3:55
  newtons for force. Simple.
• 3:57
  It is, but in the US customary system we have a unit for mass.
• 4:01
  That sounds like a garden pest. The slug we have the slug I.
• 4:05
  Have to ask, please explain this plug.
• 4:07
  Is this a joke? It is not a joke, I promise.
• 4:09
  See, most people confuse mass and weight.
• 4:11
  They use them interchangeably, but they're very different.
• 4:14
  Mass is the measure of inertia, how much stuff is in an object.
• 4:19
  Weight is just the force of gravity pulling on that mass.
• 4:23
  OK, that makes sense. So in the US system, if you're
• 4:25
  talking about inertia, you're talking about slugs.
• 4:27
  If you're talking about the force of gravity, you're talking
• 4:29
  about pounds. So if I buy a 5 LB bag of sugar,
• 4:33
  I'm buying weight. You're buying the force that
• 4:36
  gravity is exerting on that sugar.
• 4:37
  Yes, but if you took that bag to the moon, it would weigh less.
• 4:42
  In deep space it would weigh 0. But it would still have the same
• 4:45
  mass. It would still have the same
• 4:46
  number of slugs, and if you threw it at something in space,
• 4:49
  the damage it does is all about its mass.
• 4:51
  It's slugs. I love that officer.
• 4:54
  I didn't hit him with 5 lbs, I hit him with .15 slugs.
• 4:57
  Good luck with that argument. All right, so we've got our
• 5:01
  rules. We know about vectors, inertia,
• 5:03
  and even slugs. Let's go back to the workshop.
• 5:06
  Motor on the floor 10 feet away. A big fan.
• 5:09
  We need to spin. How do we get the power from A
• 5:12
  to B? Right, power transmission.
• 5:14
  You basically have three main options to your toolkit.
• 5:17
  Belts, chains or shafts. Let's start with belts.
• 5:21
  The manuals talk a lot about V belts.
• 5:24
  Why V? Because of the cross section,
• 5:26
  it's shaped like a trapezoid or AV, and this is crucial.
• 5:30
  It wedges itself into a pulley, or what we call a sheave.
• 5:33
  Why is the wedge shape so important?
• 5:35
  Why not just a flat belt? It's all about friction
• 5:37
  multiplication. A flat belt just sits on top.
• 5:40
  Pull it hard enough and it will slip.
• 5:42
  But AV belt when you apply tension, it pulls itself deeper
• 5:45
  into the groove it wedges in. So.
• 5:48
  It grips the sides. And that creates way more
• 5:50
  friction, letting you transmit more power without slipping.
• 5:53
  But the critical thing for any designer, and this is a huge
• 5:56
  trap for beginners, is you can't just look at horsepower.
• 5:59
  You have to consider the service factor.
• 6:01
  What does that mean? Service factor.
• 6:03
  Means you have to ask, how is this machine actually used?
• 6:07
  Are you running a little desk fan for maybe 3 hours a day or
• 6:10
  are you running a rock crusher 24/7?
• 6:13
  I'm guessing the rock crusher needs a much beefier belt even
• 6:16
  for the same size motor. Much beefier.
• 6:19
  The service factor is a multiplier.
• 6:22
  If you design for intermittent duty but run it continuously,
• 6:25
  that belt will overheat, stretch, and snap in a week.
• 6:28
  You've also got to worry about tension, right?
• 6:30
  The notes mentioned a tight side and a slack side.
• 6:33
  Yep. Think of a bicycle chain.
• 6:35
  When you pedal, the top is tight and the bottom loop is loose.
• 6:39
  Belts do the same thing. You need that difference in
• 6:41
  tension to create grip. OK, so belts rely on friction,
• 6:45
  which means they can slip. What if I can't have any slip?
• 6:48
  What if I'm running a printing press and everything has to be
• 6:50
  perfectly timed? Then you graduate to chains.
• 6:54
  Chains and sprockets give you positive engagement, no slip
• 6:57
  allowed. And how do we size those?
• 6:59
  It's all geometry. You look at the pitch diameter
• 7:01
  and you count the teeth. Usually you're trying to create
• 7:03
  a reduction ratio. So making the load spin slower
• 7:06
  than the motor. Exactly.
• 7:08
  A small sprocket on the motor, a big one on the load.
• 7:11
  If you have 10 teeth on the motor and 20 on the load, that's
• 7:14
  a 2 to one ratio, half the speed, but twice the torque.
• 7:18
  Makes sense, but what if I just wanted direct connection?
• 7:20
  No belts, no chains, just a solid metal bar.
• 7:24
  That's a shaft, the rotating backbone of the machine.
• 7:28
  But shafts have a hidden enemy, a ghost in the machine.
• 7:31
  Which is. Critical speed.
• 7:33
  That sounds bad. It is.
• 7:34
  Every object has a natural frequency, a speed at which it
• 7:38
  wants to vibrate like a guitar string.
• 7:40
  OK, if you spin a shaft at a speed that matches that natural
• 7:43
  frequency, you hit resonance. The vibrations amplify.
• 7:47
  The shaft starts to whip around like a jump rope.
• 7:49
  And that's not good for the bearings.
• 7:50
  It destroys them. It can literally vibrate the
• 7:53
  whole machine to pieces. So as a designer, you calculate
• 7:56
  the critical speed and you make sure you never operate there.
• 7:58
  You run well below it, or you accelerate through it very, very
• 8:01
  fast. You never hang out at critical
• 8:03
  speed. Never.
• 8:04
  One more shaft problem. They never line up perfectly
• 8:07
  right. The motor might be an inch lower
• 8:09
  than the fan. Misalignment, yeah, for that we
• 8:11
  use universal joints or U joints.
• 8:14
  You see them under tracks, but the manuals warn us they aren't
• 8:18
  magic. They have limits, specific
• 8:21
  torque ratings and angle limitations.
• 8:22
  You can't just bend them 90°. OK, so we've connected our motor
• 8:25
  to the load, but if I just flip the switch, the motor goes from
• 8:28
  zero to full speed instantly. That sudden jerk is going to
• 8:32
  snap something. It absolutely will.
• 8:34
  You need to manage the inertia. The slug returns.
• 8:37
  Well, this is rotational inertia.
• 8:39
  The texts call it WR squared. WR squared break that down.
• 8:43
  W is the weight, R is the radius of gyration, which is basically
• 8:47
  how far out that weight is from the center of rotation.
• 8:50
  And the key thing is it's not just about how heavy The thing
• 8:53
  is, it's about where that weight is located.
• 8:55
  Give. Me an example.
• 8:57
  OK, imagine 2 flywheels. Both weigh 10 lbs.
• 9:00
  One is a solid disk, the other is like a bicycle wheel with all
• 9:03
  the weight out on the rim. Got it.
• 9:05
  The bicycle wheel has a much, much higher WR squared.
• 9:08
  All that weight is far from the center.
• 9:10
  It's much harder to start spinning and much harder to
• 9:12
  stop. Like a figure skater pulling
• 9:14
  their arms in. Exactly.
• 9:16
  So to manage that startup, to get that heavy flywheel moving
• 9:19
  without breaking the shaft, we need a clutch.
• 9:21
  Which lets us engage the power gradually.
• 9:24
  The notes talk about cone clutches and magnetic clutches.
• 9:27
  Right, different ways to do it, but for any clutch, the biggest
• 9:31
  design factor, the thing that kills them is heat.
• 9:35
  Heat. Think about it, when you're
• 9:36
  slipping the clutch to get a heavy load moving, you're
• 9:39
  converting all that kinetic energy from the motor into
• 9:43
  friction, and friction is heat. Like rubbing your hands together
• 9:47
  but with steel plates. Exactly.
• 9:48
  If you cycle that clutch too fast, Start Stop, Start, Stop,
• 9:52
  you generate heat faster than the clutch can get rid of it.
• 9:54
  And you? Cook it, you bring it out the
• 9:56
  surfaces glaze over and it stops working.
• 9:59
  The expert rule here is the heat to be dissipated must be
• 10:03
  compared to the capacity of the unit.
• 10:05
  You have to calculate the energy rate.
• 10:07
  So for our machine we need to know how often the operator is
• 10:10
  going to hit the on button. Yes, engineering is always about
• 10:13
  the context of use. OK, let's move to the muscle.
• 10:17
  We've got movement, but maybe we need to multiply our force lift
• 10:20
  something really heavy. Then you're talking about gears
• 10:23
  and power screws. I love gears, they're just so
• 10:26
  cool to look at. But the text gets into some
• 10:28
  really specific geometry. It talks about the line of
• 10:31
  action. It sounds like an action movie
• 10:33
  title, doesn't it? It really does.
• 10:35
  Coming this summer line of action.
• 10:37
  In reality, it's an invisible line.
• 10:40
  When two gear teeth touch, the force pushes along a very
• 10:43
  specific path. That path is called the line of
• 10:47
  action. Why does that line matter so
• 10:48
  much? Because if the gears are
• 10:50
  designed right, the contact point slides smoothly along that
• 10:53
  line, which ensures constant speed.
• 10:56
  If the geometry is off, the gears will grind and vibrate.
• 11:00
  The books list a few types. You have spur gears, the simple
• 11:04
  flat ones, then worm gears. Worm gears are amazing.
• 11:08
  It looks like a screw turning a gear.
• 11:10
  They give you this massive reduction in speed, but with a
• 11:13
  distinct sliding action they generate a lot of heat.
• 11:16
  And what if we need to push something in a straight line
• 11:18
  like a car Jack? Then you use a power screw.
• 11:20
  You convert rotation into linear push.
• 11:22
  The thing that stood out to me here was the balance of
• 11:25
  friction. It's a very delicate trade off.
• 11:27
  Think about that car Jack. When you stop turning the
• 11:29
  handle, what do you want the car to do?
• 11:31
  I want it to stay up. I do not want the car's weight
• 11:35
  to spin the handle backward and come crashing down.
• 11:38
  Exactly. That's called self locking and
• 11:40
  it requires a certain amount of friction in the threads.
• 11:43
  But if you have too much friction, it becomes incredibly
• 11:47
  hard to turn the handle in the 1st place, so.
• 11:50
  You need enough friction to be safe, but not so much that it's
• 11:52
  impossible to use. Engineering is always a trade
• 11:54
  off. All right, our machine moves.
• 11:56
  It lifts, but now we need it to return to its start position or
• 12:01
  maybe absorb a shock. We need springs.
• 12:04
  The unsung heroes of machinery, compression, extension, torsion,
• 12:09
  even Belleville washers. Belleville washers are those
• 12:11
  little warped donut things, right?
• 12:12
  That's a good way to describe them.
• 12:14
  Conical shells. You can stack them up to handle
• 12:16
  massive loads in very small spaces.
• 12:19
  The real aha moment for me in this section was about
• 12:22
  handedness. Oh this is so critical,
• 12:25
  especially for torsion springs. The kind of twist like on a
• 12:27
  clothespin. Does it really matter which way
• 12:29
  it's wound? Clockwise or counterclockwise?
• 12:31
  It matters immensely. You have to design the spring so
• 12:34
  that the load winds it tighter. You want the coils to close down
• 12:38
  on themselves. What happens if I design it
• 12:40
  backward if the load pushes against the wind?
• 12:43
  The spring opens up, the diameter of the coil actually
• 12:46
  gets bigger. That's bad.
• 12:47
  It's catastrophic. If that spring is on a shaft,
• 12:50
  the diameter grows until it binds against the shaft or the
• 12:52
  housing the machine seizes. It can snap the spring.
• 12:56
  So right hand versus left hand isn't just a preference.
• 12:59
  It is life or death for the machine.
• 13:01
  And Speaking of spring death, we have to talk about
• 13:03
  electroplating. Ah yes, the scary story.
• 13:07
  Hydrogen embrittlement. The Silent Killer.
• 13:09
  So I make a spring. It's strong, but it's just plain
• 13:12
  steel. I want it to be shiny and resist
• 13:14
  rust, so I get it plated with zinc or Chrome.
• 13:17
  During that chemical plating process, tiny hydrogen atoms can
• 13:21
  sneak into the steel. They get trapped inside the
• 13:23
  crystal lattice. And what do they do in there?
• 13:26
  They create immense internal pressure.
• 13:27
  They make the steel brittle like glass.
• 13:30
  The spring looks perfect. You install it and then under a
• 13:33
  totally normal load snap, it just breaks, no warning.
• 13:37
  Is there a cure for this? Baking.
• 13:39
  You have to put the springs in an oven right after plating.
• 13:41
  The heat drives the hydrogen out.
• 13:43
  If you skip that step, you've got a ticking time bomb.
• 13:46
  Wow, That brings us perfectly to our final segment.
• 13:49
  We're calling this one CSI Engineering.
• 13:52
  Forensics and failure. The source text has this great
• 13:54
  detective story. A company had a batch of 5000
• 13:58
  springs fail. They were for a high power
• 14:01
  switch mechanism. So big dangerous electrical
• 14:05
  switches. You do not want those to fail.
• 14:06
  Exactly. The springs were supposed to be
• 14:09
  music wire, the gold standard. ASTM A228 Very tough stuff.
• 14:14
  But they kept taking a permanent set.
• 14:16
  They just weren't springing back.
• 14:17
  So the engineers did a chemical analysis.
• 14:20
  And this is where it got tricky. Chemically, music wire and a
• 14:23
  lower grade material oil tempered steel are almost
• 14:26
  identical. Same carbon, same manganese.
• 14:29
  The chemistry was a dead end. So.
• 14:30
  How did they solve it? They had to go deeper.
• 14:32
  Microscopic analysis They cut a sample, polished it, and put it
• 14:36
  under microscope at 100 to 400 times magnification and.
• 14:40
  What do they? See the green structure?
• 14:42
  Oil tempered seal looks more tensitic.
• 14:43
  It has a needle like crystal structure from being heat
• 14:46
  treated but music wire gets its strength from being cold drawn
• 14:49
  through. Dye.
• 14:50
  It's stretched. Right.
• 14:51
  And that's stretching gives it a cold work structure.
• 14:55
  Under the scope you see long fibrous grains.
• 14:59
  The microscope revealed the truth.
• 15:01
  The manufacturer had used the wrong stuff.
• 15:03
  Exactly. It looked the same, weighed the
• 15:05
  same, chemically it was the same, but structurally it
• 15:09
  couldn't handle the stress. A 5000 piece recall.
• 15:12
  That is a very costly mistake. And a dangerous one.
• 15:16
  It just shows you that engineers have to understand materials on
• 15:19
  a microscopic level, not just the dimensions on a drawing.
• 15:22
  So let's recap our journey. We actually build a machine in
• 15:25
  our heads. We started with Newton's laws,
• 15:27
  all that invisible stuff. Then we built a drive system,
• 15:30
  selecting belts based on the service factor and making sure
• 15:33
  our shafts avoided that deadly critical speed.
• 15:35
  We. Controlled it with clutches,
• 15:37
  making sure we didn't burn them out.
• 15:38
  We multiplied force with gears and screws respecting that
• 15:42
  invisible line of action. And we reset the whole thing
• 15:44
  with springs, being super careful to wind them the right
• 15:47
  way and bake out that hydrogen so they don't snap.
• 15:50
  And finally, we learned that when things break, sometimes you
• 15:53
  need a microscope to find out why.
• 15:54
  It really shows that a machine isn't just a collection of
• 15:57
  parts, it's a collection of physics decisions.
• 16:00
  That's a great way to put it. The math can get complex, you
• 16:03
  know, calculating torque and stress and inertia.
• 16:05
  But the goal of all that math is really very simple.
• 16:09
  What's that? Reliability.
• 16:10
  Yeah. And safety.
• 16:11
  We do the math so that when you flip the switch, the machine
• 16:14
  does its job and nobody gets hurt.
• 16:16
  That's the whole point. That's the essence of
• 16:18
  engineering. And hey, Speaking of solving
• 16:20
  problems, here's a thought to leave you with.
• 16:23
  We talked about hydrogen hiding inside steel.
• 16:25
  It makes you wonder what other invisible slaws are hiding in
• 16:29
  the things we use everyday, just waiting for the right conditions
• 16:32
  to pop up. It's enough to make you want to
• 16:34
  carry a microscope everywhere. Or at least bake your springs.
• 16:37
  Exactly. Well, that wraps up our mental
• 16:40
  build for today. If you haven't already, get over
• 16:42
  to our YouTube channel Mechanical Engineering Made
• 16:44
  Simple, where we post hands on how to videos, visual
• 16:47
  breakdowns, and practical engineering walkthroughs.
• 16:50
  You can actually use a family that solves together, stays
• 16:53
  together.