Latest / The Sperrins: Mining, Power & Community in Northern Ireland / #No.39 Public Inquiry, Private Barriers
Transcript
- 0:00Hello and welcome to the Save Our Sperrins podcast, voices
- 0:04from the frontline. My name is Marella Fyffe, your host and
- 0:08member of the save, our sparse team. And this podcast comes
- 0:12from the Sperrin mountains in Northern Ireland.
- 0:16This is an ancient land shaped by mountains and bogs and by the
- 0:19communities born from them and whose same peoples are now
- 0:24living with growing pressures from mining and large scale
- 0:27upland industrialization. That pressure isn't unique to here.
- 0:33Across the world, the so called energy transition is driving
- 0:37ever more extraction. There's growing demand for critical
- 0:41minerals and rare earth metals, and that demand is landing on
- 0:45local communities, asking them to live with the long term
- 0:49impacts of toxic mining.
- 0:53Season one looked at why the sperm mountains matter to the
- 0:56voices of the people who live here and know this place well.
- 1:00Season two keeps those local voices at the centre, while also
- 1:04stepping back a bit.
- 1:07In season two, we look at extractivism more broadly, how
- 1:11it's been justified, how it's fundamental to a system of
- 1:14accelerated growth plundering evermore from a finite planet
- 1:19designed only to feed predatory capitalism, creating untold and
- 1:24unprecedented misery simply to support the bottom line of a
- 1:27balance sheet in some distant, glass walled boardroom far from
- 1:31the ground we're standing on. Thanks for listening. Let's
- 1:36begin today. I'm speaking with Laura Neal. She is an
- 1:40environmental lawyer working with Friends of the Earth
- 1:43Northern Ireland who has expertise in environmental
- 1:46governance rights and international conventions that
- 1:49affect local public processes. We're going to talk about
- 1:52something that sounds technical, the Aarhus and Espoo
- 1:55conventions, but which actually go to the heart of whether
- 1:59ordinary people such as ourselves have a real voice in
- 2:02environmental decisions. So Laura, thanks a million for
- 2:07coming on the podcast today. I really appreciate it take for
- 2:11you to take some time out of your busy schedule. And can we
- 2:16begin by asking you to tell us a little bit about your
- 2:20background,
- 2:22and let's let's start there, certainly. So I'm Laura, and I'm
- 2:28a senior lawyer for Friends of the Earth, and I'm based in
- 2:30Northern Ireland, and I always have been based in Northern
- 2:33Ireland, and I've been working for Friends of the Earth now for
- 2:36seven years. So we're involved in strategic litigation that
- 2:42protects the planet and supports communities doing likewise. And
- 2:46what that looks like in Northern Ireland is, I don't want to, I
- 2:50don't want to say it in this way, because it sounds like I'm
- 2:53doing it down, but it involves a lot of site battles. But I feel
- 2:57like these site battles are like flashpoints of a much bigger
- 3:01issue, and that's climate change, and the disruption that
- 3:04happens as a result of climate change. So to marginalise
- 3:07something and say, Oh, you just get involved in site battles.
- 3:11Well, you know, everything starts as a safe battle, you
- 3:14know. And if there's many, many side battles on an issue, then
- 3:17we know it's a bigger global issue. So bring on the site
- 3:19battles, as long as I'm not, like protecting a hedge or
- 3:22something, you know, which are important. But, you know, we
- 3:24look for the big side battles, the totemic side battles. And
- 3:28prior to that, prior to this role, I worked in private
- 3:32practice as a lawyer, a solicitor, and although that was
- 3:36very interesting, I just felt like I didn't really fit the
- 3:40mould. So this opportunity came along, and I jumped on it, and I
- 3:44have to say, despite all the adversity that that we
- 3:47experience as an organisation, alongside communities, it's one
- 3:51of the most fulfilling jobs I think I've ever had. Oh, that's
- 3:54wonderful to hear.
- 3:56Thank you. And what about Laura Neil? That's not the lawyer. And
- 4:02what does Laura Neal do when she's not
- 4:07fighting sight battles, per se? Oh, my goodness. Well, you'll
- 4:11know that this world does consume you quite a lot. So I
- 4:15find increasingly, the longer I stay in this job, and the longer
- 4:18I'm immersed in this world, the more it creeps into like, my
- 4:21private life as well, and the work matters. Know exactly what
- 4:25you mean. I find it really difficult to just close the door
- 4:29on work, but it's not work because you find friendship
- 4:32groups and community and really fun people to hang out with. So
- 4:36I find that they bleed into my day to day life. But I'm a mom
- 4:40of one. She's two and a half, so that really takes up most of my
- 4:44time. But prior to that,
- 4:47I just used to do lots of things, lots of fun things,
- 4:52which I will get back to when I don't have a two year old. But I
- 4:55used to surf. I used to, I used to, i.
- 5:00I go skiing, I used to do all those things, and I still love
- 5:02all that stuff. But, you know, I don't, I would say I don't think
- 5:08I really took the time to really appreciate and value nature in
- 5:11the way that a lot of campaigners that I meet do, and
- 5:14I'm starting to understand that the older I get, the better I
- 5:17get at appreciating just what's around me and slowing things
- 5:20down. So I'm trying very hard to do that, but I love going to the
- 5:22pub. Love going for dinners out, loved it all that kind of stuff,
- 5:27and it's all very normal, really.
- 5:30Well.
- 5:32Thank you. It just gives our listeners a little overview of
- 5:38you in your life. So today we're talking about our house and
- 5:42Espoo conventions,
- 5:44and to get us going in that direction, for someone listening
- 5:49with no legal background, such as myself, and what does the our
- 5:53house convention actually mean to the person on the street?
- 5:58Yeah. I mean for me, when I first heard of our house, and I
- 6:01have to say, it doesn't come up in private practice a lot. It's
- 6:04not a kind of thing in the middle of your family and
- 6:07criminal and all that kind of law like so I was fairly new to
- 6:10it when I started in this job, but when I first heard of our
- 6:14house, all I could think of was the madness song
- 6:18our house in the middle of our street. Do you want to give us a
- 6:21bar? Absolutely not. Nobody needs to hear that. You've all
- 6:24suffered enough.
- 6:26But yeah, so in a very basic sense, I could go on about this
- 6:31for a long time, but it just lose it on myself and bore your
- 6:35listeners. So the Aarhus convention and technically the
- 6:38SP convention as well, are both international treaties. So that
- 6:41is where two countries or multiple countries agree to sign
- 6:46a document that they will hold themselves to, and Aarhus in
- 6:50particular, was named so because I think it was signed in Aarhus
- 6:55in Europe, I'm not exactly sure where that is anymore. I did
- 6:58know that, but that is a quiz question for later on, but
- 7:02that's, that's where it got its name from, and it is, as I say,
- 7:07an international treaty that's supposed to protect a person's
- 7:10right to live in a healthy environment, full stop. So it
- 7:15annoys me from the get go, that that there was a that was
- 7:18necessary to put an international treaty in place to
- 7:21do that, because surely that's normal. But anyway, so the
- 7:24artist flashes that out. And there's a number of member
- 7:27states of which Ireland and the UK and most of the EU are part
- 7:31of. And it has at its very core three pillars, like three legs
- 7:35of a stool. That's how I think on it. And the first one is that
- 7:39it entitles members of the public to access to information
- 7:43about environmental decisions that will affect them. Secondly,
- 7:48it affords them public participation in environmental
- 7:51matters that will affect them, and, thirdly, access to justice.
- 7:55So what we find is the our house convention and its application
- 8:00in domestic law,
- 8:02because you can't just challenge a treaty, you know, that's
- 8:05between member states. We're the lowly public but it has
- 8:08transcribed its way into our laws. And so, you know, you can
- 8:11walk into a court here in Belfast and say that, you know
- 8:15the Aarhus convention, this narrow house convention that and
- 8:17you'll be relying on local laws, but it has become a valuable
- 8:23weapon in environmental campaigning because of those
- 8:26three pillars that allow
- 8:28NGOs civic society and any person on the street to access
- 8:32information. That's really crucial, and you know, that's a
- 8:35huge barrier to being productive in environmental issues, you
- 8:41know, and to really grasp what's at stake here, and to speak the
- 8:45language of developers and governments. So that idea of
- 8:48access to information is really important. And again, public
- 8:50participation is everything. I mean, if something is going to
- 8:53happen in your place, or the place around you, or the place
- 8:57that you care about, you're entitled to participate in that
- 9:00decision making, and then the Access to Justice stuff, as if
- 9:03you feel like you have been, you know, aggrieved in any way, you
- 9:06have a right to take a stand about that. Now, obviously it's
- 9:09not just a blanket, you know, I feel annoyed about this.
- 9:13Therefore, it's much more nuanced than that, and we find
- 9:16that the art has convention and its application has been the
- 9:20subject of a lot of back and forth between civic society
- 9:23campaigners and states, and every year, there's an
- 9:25implementation report that goes out from respective member
- 9:30states, and they tell the our house Compliance Committee,
- 9:32which is like an oversight body of the whole mechanism, how
- 9:36they've been doing, what they've been doing, to make sure that
- 9:38these three pillars are still very important in people's lives
- 9:41and civic society also has a say in that as well. We have like a
- 9:44rival implementation report where we call them out on the
- 9:47fact that a lot of what they might be saying is not strictly
- 9:50true. So that kind of back and forth dialogue goes on and on
- 9:53and on in the background. And while it's still a very valuable
- 9:57tool, it's still a.
- 10:00Subject to a lot of debate, you know, because the rights aren't
- 10:03absolute, but are guaranteed in our house, and they're so broad
- 10:07and overreaching, it's really hard to pin them down, and that
- 10:11is why
- 10:13having like a flash point such as this public inquiry into the
- 10:18gold mine is a really good way to understand how our house
- 10:23operates and what it's supposed to do, and we're seeing the
- 10:26application of the our house convention in real time. So
- 10:29that's why it's so important,
- 10:32and that's clarifies a lot for me, at least. So can I just push
- 10:37the question on a bit? So if something that's described as a
- 10:41public inquiry into a major environmental proposal such as
- 10:45the dalradian planning application. What standard would
- 10:49you expect under our house for the public inquiry? What would
- 10:54it look like, in your opinion? Well, I mean, I would suggest
- 10:59that
- 11:01you need to put the public in public inquiry.
- 11:05And that's kind of my understanding of the application
- 11:08of our hosts, you know, like,
- 11:11what could be more important than this inquiry for those
- 11:15three pillars to be completely in perfect operation and
- 11:18synergy? You know, for the public to participate in this
- 11:21public inquiry. They need to have access to information to
- 11:23allow them to participate. They need to be able to participate
- 11:28effectively. So saying you're allowing the public to
- 11:31participate is one thing, but actually engage in a meaningful
- 11:34participation based on the idea that you have a developer with a
- 11:39lot of experts and loads of money behind it. And every you
- 11:42know, lots of environmental law expertise and lots of industrial
- 11:46expertise versus the government that has a lot of the same and
- 11:49then you've got, you know, the members of the public in the
- 11:51middle that are seeking to get involved. How do you make them
- 11:54actually feel meaningfully involved? And that's, that's the
- 11:58that's the crux of the artist issue here?
- 12:03It's fine to give someone a seat at the table, but when they
- 12:05don't have an understanding of the information, or they're
- 12:08drowned by information, or the information is incoherent and
- 12:12inaccessible to an average person with no planning
- 12:15expertise or no environmental law expertise, then I would say
- 12:19that you're feeling in your Aarhus commitments. But as we
- 12:22see with this case, it's just it's unravelling at a rate. But
- 12:27the Aarhus should be a cornerstone of a public inquiry.
- 12:29It should be the go to guide for how you run these things.
- 12:35So in our case, the inquiry won't be streamlined online, as
- 12:40you rightly know, and members of the public are not permitted to
- 12:43record proceedings, and also, children are not allowed to
- 12:47attend, which, in practice, excludes breastfeeding mothers
- 12:51in our group, of which we have two at the moment. From a legal
- 12:55perspective, how do these kind of restrictions sit with the
- 13:00participation standard you've just described
- 13:04well, I think, I think when we look at the test of someone on
- 13:09the street hearing about this for the first time, I think that
- 13:12anybody could tell that this is not affording an adequate
- 13:15standard of public participation.
- 13:18But there's deeper issues that we have called out as an NGO,
- 13:22along with fellow NGOs working in the civic sector,
- 13:27there's like a discrimination here that is not just rooted in
- 13:30an international treaty about environmental rights. You know,
- 13:33sex is a protected characteristic. You shouldn't be
- 13:35discriminated based on your sex, and yet, we see the arrangements
- 13:38here, facilitated by the planning of Peace Commission as
- 13:41being discriminatory to women.
- 13:45The frustrating thing for me is the lack of streaming, the lack
- 13:49of online witnesses. So virtual appearances or witnesses, and
- 13:53the kind of very arbitrary way in which security handled people
- 13:57in the audience, they could be rectified so quickly. Do you
- 14:01know, if you don't want to entertain the idea of lots of
- 14:04children in a very serious place, and as a parent of a two
- 14:08and a half year old, there is no worst place I would want to
- 14:10bring her is to public inquiry, because she's feral at the best
- 14:14of times in the best possible way, and she'd be swinging off
- 14:16the lampshades so but at the same time, I wouldn't want to
- 14:21not be afforded the opportunity to have my say. So that's the
- 14:24bind you're in. And if the PAC really wanted to include people,
- 14:29they could just flip any one of those switches and transform
- 14:32things so they could stream things online, for instance,
- 14:35which means that people with childcare and responsibility or
- 14:38people who can't get time off work, it just doesn't extend to
- 14:40women. It's extends to a lot of people, most people who can't
- 14:43afford to take six weeks off work to sit in a centre in Oman.
- 14:49You know, that would afford them the opportunity to be engaged in
- 14:52the process, but they won't do that. And the frustrating thing
- 14:55is, as well, is that they have done it in the past for other
- 14:58inquiries. That's right, all.
- 15:00For, yeah, and for general planning appease. It has been
- 15:02facilitated. As we know, post covid These arrangements are in
- 15:06place and they work. You know, people can stream things online.
- 15:10Do you know they can watch along? And the reason, the thing
- 15:14that underscores the whole notion of it, to me, aside from
- 15:17the fact that it's potentially discriminatory that it, that it
- 15:21denies the public their opportunity to be involved, is
- 15:25that there's no rationale for it. You know, we have asked
- 15:28repeatedly, as an organisation, you should start streaming. You
- 15:31should record proceedings for people to catch up on. You
- 15:34should do this, that and the other. And they have said no,
- 15:36but it's a no full stop. We have settled the procedures, and I
- 15:41want to know, why. Why? Know? Why? Why have you decided this
- 15:44is the right way to do because you're, you're making things
- 15:46deliberately difficult for yourself, because there are
- 15:48going to be questions about breastfeeding and children, and,
- 15:52you know, it's like, you could, you could flip any one of those
- 15:54switches, transform it and fully include the public. Yeah. You
- 15:59know, it's really interesting, because we were at a hearing
- 16:02there with the PAC on Wednesday, and it was, it was online.
- 16:07People were able to access it, and which was nice for the
- 16:10people who were able to access it. But so why isn't it and is
- 16:14it been influenced by someone else not to have it online? You
- 16:17bring up a good point there. I just want you to say something a
- 16:21little bit more about lack of online witnesses. Just say a
- 16:26little bit more about that Well, because the inquiry hasn't
- 16:30really kicked off proper, and I'm pretty sure we'll get to
- 16:33that at some point, you know. But just as a footnote, the
- 16:36initial kind of procedures and how we're going to run things.
- 16:40Type discussion was streamed online. It was available for
- 16:43some time after that initial meeting of the PAC so we know
- 16:47they have the facilities to do it. They know that. We know that
- 16:49they're adequate and they could do it, but they're just refusing
- 16:52to for some unfathomable reason. If there is a reason, please
- 16:55tell us. Please understand and tell us, or explain to us. You
- 16:58know we're entitled to that, and you know what creeps in and it's
- 17:03stead then, is a distrust of the process, you know, which you've
- 17:06just highlighted for why reason? What else could you possibly
- 17:09have you know that that would stop you from streaming things
- 17:12online? If there's a valid reason, please let us know, and
- 17:15we'll consider it. But yes, in terms of witnesses, so
- 17:19what we have at the minute now is a planning public inquiry,
- 17:24which is to be held in the place where the to be affected by the
- 17:31environment, by the proposal. So it's not to be held in Dublin or
- 17:34Belfast, you know. And that's right, it's to be held in Omaha,
- 17:38which will be impacted by this gold bank. Should it be granted
- 17:41permission? So that's right. However, it is a creature in its
- 17:46time. So you have to go to the stroll Art Centre. You have to
- 17:50be there. You have to bring all of your papers, all of your
- 17:54people that you need to speak. They all have to be there in
- 17:56time to speak to a specific timetable. There's no remote
- 17:59witnesses, none of that stuff, and that it just feels very old
- 18:04school. It feels like, you know, we're doing something like 50
- 18:07years ago, when there wasn't the modern tech that we have. But
- 18:10it's actually prejudicial to members of the community, and
- 18:14also, I would say, NGOs as well, because when you're looking to
- 18:18speak to something that is, you know that warrants a certain
- 18:22level of expertise,
- 18:24you're going to need an expert witness to come in and speak to
- 18:27that on your behalf, to give you legitimacy before the plan and
- 18:31the pays commission. And that's something that happens across
- 18:33the board. Happens in courts as well. You get yourself an expert
- 18:36witness, someone that knows more about the issue than you do,
- 18:38that proves your point or speaks to something that you're
- 18:41concerned about. And we're a small place, and there aren't
- 18:45many gold mining experts on the island of Ireland, particularly,
- 18:51to speak to the adverse effects of gold mining, which we know
- 18:54there are many globally, but it just so happens a lot of those
- 18:57people learn about the adverse effects of gold mine because
- 19:01they are somewhere else other than Northern Ireland or
- 19:04Ireland,
- 19:06yeah. So they're mostly located in far flung countries across
- 19:10the world that have been, you know, the victim of gold mining
- 19:13operations, and you need to get them then to a small art centre
- 19:17in OMA Do you know?
- 19:19And that's incredibly a, like, expensive and B, impractical,
- 19:27considering that we were all set to go last year for six weeks,
- 19:32everybody had brought their experts or had their experts
- 19:34flown in, and the whole thing collapsed. So what do you do?
- 19:37You know, do you send them packing, back off to where they
- 19:40came from at expense to you again, because someone has
- 19:42forgotten to do something that's vitally important to the
- 19:45validity of the inquiry. So the idea of having remote witnesses,
- 19:49because we have this technology available, will be so much more
- 19:54like efficient in terms of having people with authority
- 19:59able to speak.
- 20:00To these issues that communities want to have their voices heard,
- 20:05and it would facilitate that. And the issue is, you know, I
- 20:10understand that, you know, the preference is always to have
- 20:13people in person like that's, that's, you know, it's important
- 20:16that these things are done up front for transparency. But
- 20:19we've managed through covid to do things like this. And a lot
- 20:23of you know the kind of virtual, remote attendance, kind of
- 20:26practices and procedures endure, even in courts, you know, and
- 20:30they are, they're not just a free for all. You have to ask
- 20:33for permission that it is granted in certain extenuating
- 20:36circumstances for you to appear remotely. And it's just a very
- 20:39valuable tool that could be utilised here, and it's not, and
- 20:43it's just causing great impracticalities for
- 20:45communities, for NGOs and people who do not have the resources to
- 20:48have the expertise right there in the room at the time for six
- 20:52weeks, potentially more, yeah, and that's has been our
- 20:57experience all the way along.
- 20:59We have one expert coming in from the States.
- 21:04And even the way the timetabling is done,
- 21:08he has to stay. He has to come into the start of may and at the
- 21:12end of the May, and his 17 days in between, where he'll not be
- 21:16needed for a particular topic, for the topics and but here he
- 21:20is having to stay until his date comes up again towards the end
- 21:24of May. And of course, there's the expense of having to put him
- 21:28up and air tickets and all that. And also we've, you know, folk
- 21:33from Dublin and other places, and they all have to be put up
- 21:37by us, you know. And,
- 21:40yeah, it doesn't make it easy for us.
- 21:44Moving on
- 21:46and a little bit off tangent, under environmental and human
- 21:49rights laws, are there circumstances where restricting
- 21:52access might be justified, and how do you assess whether those
- 21:56restrictions are proportionate? Well, I mean, that's, that's a
- 22:00really interesting question, because that you know,
- 22:03that goes to what I'm speaking about in that, if there are
- 22:06justifications for this, tell us, do you know if a blanket no
- 22:12is the most frustrating thing you know? And as I say, we have
- 22:15written to the PAC who organises the plant, who is charged with
- 22:19organising and hearing the public inquiry, and said that,
- 22:21look, we have concerns about accessibility. You know, of this
- 22:24so far, stop, have a think, implement these changes. They're
- 22:28they're free to do like a streaming service is, you know,
- 22:32is not expensive. You know, they're not if the if it doesn't
- 22:35work, stop it, you know, roll back on it. But you know, if you
- 22:38are adamant that you you want everybody to be there in person
- 22:41despite the adversity against them. Explain your rationale,
- 22:45because, you know, based on your question there Marella, like,
- 22:47you know human rights law in particular is always a balancing
- 22:50act, because your rights aren't absolute. Because, you know
- 22:54there is no one like, I can't say that my right to life trumps
- 22:57your right to life, and therefore, you know anything
- 23:00that I'm doing that protects my right to life. Prejudice is
- 23:02yours. Mine is more valid than yours, and most of human rights
- 23:05law that we see is about the courts apportioning this
- 23:10balancing act between the validity of rights versus the
- 23:13state or those people who the state represents. So I
- 23:17understand that there may be reasons for the way in which the
- 23:21inquiry is deemed to be conducted at the moment, but we
- 23:24need to see what those are. If you're talking about a
- 23:26transparent inquiry, if you're not going to allow streaming, if
- 23:30you're not going to allow remote witnesses, if you're not going
- 23:34to then afford people the responsibility to bring their
- 23:36children or their you know, to you know, anything that may be
- 23:39holding them back, if you're not removing those barriers as well.
- 23:43What's the reason why? Why? Why? What could cost? You know,
- 23:47because I can't think, I can't think about what they could be.
- 23:51And I have thought, what's the rationale for this? Why are they
- 23:53being so driven to this one way of doing things and not
- 23:57exploring other options? Given how controversial This is, given
- 24:01how sprawling it is, given how huge it given how easily it
- 24:05could all come crashing down. Surely you'd want to afford the
- 24:07most transparency. And yet they're just doggedly sticking
- 24:10to this. The procedures have been set angle. It won't stop us
- 24:14raising those issues, because I feel like as this goes on, they
- 24:17will manifest, and the problems that will associated them with
- 24:20with will manifest, will manifest more and more and more.
- 24:24So it's that drum that we'll keep buying in. But,
- 24:29I mean, I couldn't fathom why
- 24:33restricting access might be justified. I couldn't I can't
- 24:36think right now, but that's, that's, there may be a reason,
- 24:39but just tell us what it is. So participation is technically
- 24:43loud but practically difficult.
- 24:47Does that do you think undermine the spirit of our house in your
- 24:51Absolutely, absolutely. I mean, there are so many subtle ways
- 24:56that you can undermine the spirit of our house. Do you know
- 24:59you can.
- 25:00Can, you can afford someone an opportunity to be at the table,
- 25:04but drawing them in information. I alluded to that in the patent
- 25:07and earlier in the discussion. You can, you know,
- 25:12manoeuvre in ways that you understand, perhaps as a
- 25:15planning expert, that will deliberately bamboozle the
- 25:18general public.
- 25:21You know, there, there are ways that you can be really subtle
- 25:23about it, but this is so overt, you know, it just feels like,
- 25:26you know, those three cornerstones of information, or
- 25:29of information, public participation and access to
- 25:34justice, are really undermined by this process, from the get
- 25:37go, and we haven't even gone into the detail yet, you know,
- 25:41and that's really frustrating, because what does that say about
- 25:44the validity of the process, the decision which then flows from
- 25:47it? You know, if we're having issues like this, which are
- 25:51fundamental to the hearing of the inquiry, and they're not
- 25:55resolved before the thing even starts again, where does that
- 25:58see us at the end of the inquiry? How was my feeling
- 26:02about hell of a journey, absolutely one that we're ready
- 26:06for, but I just feel like there's so many small fixes that
- 26:10could be in place that aren't in place, and there's no valid
- 26:12reason why, and it does undermine the our house
- 26:14convention.
- 26:16So moving back to the Espoo convention for a minute. Can you
- 26:19explain the well, you've already explained the ESCO convention,
- 26:23but when cross border, environmental impacts trigger
- 26:26additional obligations, could you talk a little bit around
- 26:29that in relation to the public inquiry? Yeah, so I don't really
- 26:33think arts bandwagon there, but because it's something that I
- 26:37think is so obvious in this, in this, this particular case. But
- 26:40SP as well is that is a place in Finland, I do know that, and
- 26:45that's where the SP convention was signed, and that is about
- 26:48trans boundary, like communication in relation to an
- 26:53environmental project that is likely to have significant
- 26:57effects on another state. So that sounds really complicated,
- 27:01but it's like kind of like saying keeping your neighbours
- 27:05involved in something that might affect them.
- 27:09Yeah, exactly.
- 27:12And it sounds like it is quite ancillary to the idea of a gold
- 27:18mine, but when you actually think about the sprawling nature
- 27:20of this gold mine
- 27:22and how we operate on this island. Of course, there is
- 27:27going to be a trans boundary concern that will affect people
- 27:30in the South. You know, we've got shared rivers. We've got
- 27:34shared air, like that part of the world is very close to the
- 27:37border, like there is a lot of connectivity there. And what
- 27:41transport, what Espoo Convention does. Again, you can't just rock
- 27:45up to Espoo in Finland and say someone's breached the
- 27:49convention, you know, like, get the blue lights going like, this
- 27:52is terrible. It's much more subtle than that. So Espoo is
- 27:56transcribed into national laws. So our environmental impact
- 28:01assessment laws, for want of a better expression, will be
- 28:05compliant with the espu convention. So what that
- 28:09requires, and I'm paraphrasing here, because I could be at this
- 28:13all day, is it
- 28:16requires
- 28:18the North to notify the South
- 28:21that this gold mine is happening, and then for the
- 28:24South to inform the people that live there that they have a
- 28:27right to be involved and to have their views known. And you'll
- 28:32know yourself that you know the issue of trans boundary
- 28:37communication caused the gold mine inquiry to collapse last
- 28:41year, yeah, because it wasn't done. It wasn't that. It wasn't
- 28:44done. It wasn't done adequately to the letter of the law. And
- 28:48all the parties in the South that should have been informed
- 28:50weren't informed. That was recognised, and the whole thing
- 28:53collapsed. And then everybody that was entitled to be informed
- 28:56in the South was informed in terms of state government type
- 29:01organisations. And then there was a new consultation run
- 29:06that afforded an opportunity for people in the south, whether
- 29:09they be NGOs citizens, anybody to have their say as well. So
- 29:14now that's been included. We're back on the rails again,
- 29:17figuratively, and we should move on. But the idea that that that
- 29:22kind of vital thing was overlooked even in the detail,
- 29:25because there was an element of it done a trans boundary
- 29:28consultation. I think they consulted with the council and
- 29:31Donegal, but that's not what the law requires them to do. It's
- 29:36much more detailed than that and much more sprawling than that.
- 29:38So that's been corrected, and we're back on the rails again,
- 29:41but it's a pretty fundamental thing. I mean, the person on the
- 29:43street can tell that this gold mine will have implications for
- 29:47people in the south. And I think the groups that campaign on
- 29:53this issue in the south are entitled to their views as well,
- 29:57you know. So
- 29:59the fact.
- 30:00That was just kind of circumvented is really
- 30:02frustrating and doesn't set us in good stead for the resumption
- 30:05of the inquiry, if that's the kind of thing that they're
- 30:08overlooking. So I'm Joe Bloggs in the south, and I'm feeling
- 30:11that the public process has fallen short of our house on
- 30:15Espoo.
- 30:17What would be the sort of first steps or a mechanism to
- 30:21challenge that. You know, where would I start if I was going to
- 30:24challenge that? You don't need to go into every detail, an
- 30:27overview,
- 30:29your first letter to No. So there are, like compliance
- 30:35mechanisms within those international treaties. So there
- 30:39is, for example, an Aarhus Compliance Committee, where you
- 30:42can issue a complaint. Friends of the Earth have issued a
- 30:45complaint in the past to the our house Compliance Committee, and
- 30:48they can review whether a state has obliged by its obligations
- 30:53under our house for instance, I think there might be something
- 30:56similar in terms of espu but I'm not entirely sure.
- 31:01But those things take a long time, and what that is is an
- 31:05entirely separate scrutiny process, and it can take years.
- 31:10So that's one avenue that you can you can pursue, but if you
- 31:14were to drop everything and pursue a complaint to, you know,
- 31:17the treaty bodies themselves, that's going to take up a lot of
- 31:21time. It's not going to get resolved in the time that this
- 31:23inquiry runs, and you'll miss your opportunity to implement
- 31:27directly into the inquiry. What we have done as an NGO is
- 31:31complain directly to the PAC and we've, as I said, we've written
- 31:35to them number of times outlining our concerns about the
- 31:39procedural aspects of the planning inquiry as it's
- 31:42intended to run, and we've been flatly told, you know,
- 31:45everything's settled, just stop writing to us, but we will
- 31:48continue. But I think it's important to kind of flag those
- 31:52concerns all the way through, because what you're doing is
- 31:57like, I think after letter one in the Pac said we're not going
- 32:00to change our procedures. We still kept writing because we're
- 32:04not writing to the PAC anymore. We're writing to the wider, like
- 32:09public. We're right right into we're leaving a breadcrumb trail
- 32:14for us to look back on and say, We called this out all the way
- 32:18through. You had an opportunity. We told you this wasn't going
- 32:21right, and we want our concerns noted. So that's kind of the
- 32:24position that we're in at the minute. And I would suggest that
- 32:27if anybody feels that their rights are being prejudiced by
- 32:30the application of this inquiry or how it's intended to run,
- 32:33that you mark that, that you you make your grievances known, but
- 32:36you don't let it distract you from engaging in the process in
- 32:40as in so far as you're able to
- 32:43that's a good place to get started, and much to mull over
- 32:46there. And there is a very, very big discussion going on through
- 32:51all our groups at the minute around this.
- 32:54Anyone who's feeling shut out or frustrated about this, what
- 32:58would you like them to understand about their rights,
- 33:02that they have them, that they're there and they are
- 33:05supposed to be utilised, and they're like, I don't think,
- 33:10I don't think like, I don't think everybody is meant to be a
- 33:14campaigner in the way that you guys are that frontline role.
- 33:17I'm certainly not, I'm certainly not like, I'm paid to support
- 33:20you guys in a job that I love, and I love doing it, but am I
- 33:24that person that that would would be brave enough to do what
- 33:28you guys do? Probably not, but the tenacity that you show as
- 33:32groups is just so inspiring, and I think that no matter how much
- 33:38they try to grind you down like know that your rights are there,
- 33:41that that
- 33:44they're Yeah, that they're there, you can act on them. It
- 33:47might be frustrating. The process might look like it's
- 33:49it's weighed against you, and to a certain extent, it is, but you
- 33:53just have to keep going at it. Do you know you have rights, and
- 33:57people can't take them away without a fuss? You know? Yeah,
- 34:00yeah. So it was good to remind ourselves of that. And it's, it
- 34:04feels good to have people like you behind us, to be honest, as
- 34:07well. Well, it's up. Marella, it's simple as this, like,
- 34:10you've as much right to be there as anybody else in the room.
- 34:14Nobody's extra special, important, you know. Yes,
- 34:18there's this idea that, like, you know, with the plan and the
- 34:21pays commission that you're a third party objector, or
- 34:24whatever kind of terminology they they use, but your voices
- 34:29can still be heard, and they should be heard, and the kind of
- 34:32that kind of like intimidation, of like you have lesser of a
- 34:35position at the inquiry is just not valid, not in something like
- 34:39this, Not at all, because it's a public inquiry, like it's down
- 34:43to you guys to put the public into public
- 34:47inquiry coming up to our second but last question for stepping
- 34:52back a moment from the legal detail, what do
- 34:55you think it's saying about our democracy going forward, if
- 34:58environmental decisions of this scale.
- 35:00Feel inaccessible to ordinary families.
- 35:05Oh, it's a big question, isn't it? Yeah, thinking about that
- 35:09all night, what does it say about democracy? I don't, you
- 35:12know. I don't know. I wish I had the answer to that. I don't
- 35:15know. It does scare me a wee bit. But do you know what
- 35:18actually scares me? It's like how much of this has gone on in
- 35:21the past and has been unnoticed and undocumented, like we feel
- 35:26like this is an exceptionally, you know, egregious thing, you
- 35:29know, how dare they put a gold mine in sparings? And how dare
- 35:32they, you know, deny us an opportunity to have our say, and
- 35:35how dare they limit our opportunity to have our say, all
- 35:37those kinds of arguments. But it makes me wonder, like, How many
- 35:40things have gone on that, you know, have just slipped under
- 35:44the radar because people don't know enough, yeah, to raise the
- 35:47issues, or don't know that their their rights are being
- 35:49prejudiced, or that the things that are happening, you know,
- 35:52how much unfairness have we taken in the past, just as red,
- 35:56you know? Yeah, that's what concerns me. So I don't know
- 35:59whether it's I'm a massive history nerd, and I don't know
- 36:01whether it's because I just tend to be a bit happier reflecting
- 36:04in the past, but that's what that's I look back, and I think,
- 36:07my goodness, like if this, if these are the issues that are
- 36:10coming up with us, and we're tackling them together, and
- 36:14we're raising a big stink about it, how many other people
- 36:17weren't afforded that opportunity in the past, You
- 36:20know, and I don't know what that says about the future, but if
- 36:23you forget the past, you can, what does it what does it say?
- 36:26If you, if you forget the past, you're doomed to relive it,
- 36:29something like that, something like that.
- 36:32And
- 36:34I can think of another, a number of environmental disasters,
- 36:37which, if possibly no more was known about them at the time, we
- 36:42wouldn't be in the position today, for example, my boy dump
- 36:46for one and lochney to number two. You know the and there are
- 36:51things that have gone on under the community noses without
- 36:54anyone really been able to say or do anything about it. But
- 36:59perhaps, perhaps those days are changing. Come to our last
- 37:04question, what gives you hope about all of this?
- 37:10Do you know the fact that you and I are sitting on a Friday
- 37:13afternoon talking about this stuff? Do you know like and
- 37:17that's a conversation that we're both really passionate about,
- 37:20and the issues are really that we're really passionate about.
- 37:23And I know that we're not the only people talking about this
- 37:25stuff on a Friday afternoon, on Friday afternoons and any other
- 37:28afternoon like I know there are people in the pubs up and down
- 37:30the country and coffee shops and houses and kitchen tables
- 37:33talking about this stuff, this thing in particular.
- 37:37And that gives me hope to know that the idea that you can just
- 37:41do this stuff and nobody raises an eyebrow.
- 37:45I think is a fallacy moving forward. I think we have a
- 37:48highly informed public now and a campaigning, campaigning groups
- 37:53that are highly informed, highly sophisticated, and are capable
- 37:57of bringing it with you know, it's not a David and Goliath so
- 38:01much anymore. I know it feels like that, but the energy and
- 38:04the enthusiasm and the connections that campaigning
- 38:07groups have in relation to this Goldmine proposal
- 38:11is what gives me hope. Do you know like, even though the odds
- 38:15are stacked against you, and even though all of these
- 38:18mechanisms prevent you from taking part, you're still there
- 38:22frontline, giving them. I'm not going to swear, but, you know,
- 38:26saying your bit, and I just think that's really inspiring.
- 38:29And I think that's you can take that in any context, even
- 38:32outside of the environment, environmental context. And
- 38:34that's a fantastic story like this is something I'm going to
- 38:37be telling my wee one when she's old enough to appreciate it
- 38:40about how proud I was to be there. Yeah, watch all that
- 38:43unfold. And once you see that up front, it's really hard to get
- 38:48it out of your your mind. Like I remember speaking to campaigners
- 38:52long time ago, and they were talking about the state of the
- 38:55place, as we do often, you know. And they were like, Wouldn't it
- 38:57be great if you could just unknow the things you know, so
- 39:00it's your oblivious to it all, and you could just continue
- 39:02going on in your own little world. But once you know, like
- 39:05you know of all these, these harms that are being done, and
- 39:09you just can't forget them. But I would say that's that's all
- 39:12that's a really tragic thing, and it's quite sad. But also,
- 39:15once you know about all the class stuff and the class people
- 39:18that exist in this little world, it's really inspiring. And you
- 39:21think, my goodness, I am so glad that there are people out there
- 39:24doing this stuff, A, so that some people don't have to, but
- 39:27B, just so that someone is there on that right side of history,
- 39:30as far as I'm concerned.
- 39:33On that note, Laura, thank you very much for a brilliant
- 39:35conversation. As I said earlier in the conversation, I'm really
- 39:40glad that we've people like you behind us, because I don't know
- 39:44where we'll be without you today, for all you and friends
- 39:47the earth and others like you have done in a support system.
- 39:50So thank you. Absolute privilege like, and there's nothing better
- 39:54that I like as well, in a weird way of just you know, knowing
- 39:57that there's a meeting with you guys that we're all going to
- 39:59talk about. So.
- 40:00Something and that, you know something's going down, we're
- 40:02going to do something. It feels so wonderful like it just feels
- 40:06like, regardless of the result, the fact that we're able to do
- 40:09something is great and it's a privilege. Thank you. All right,
- 40:14thanks.
- 40:16Well, there you go. That wraps up another week, a really
- 40:21insightful conversation with Laura, helping us lay the legal
- 40:25framework alongside what people here are experiencing on the
- 40:29ground. It occurs to me that conventions such as these are
- 40:34meant to be real, not just written down somewhere. How can
- 40:37a public inquiry be called public if not everyone is able
- 40:41to participate. The practice of participation means that if
- 40:45everyone in Donegal, or indeed the rest of Ireland, wanted to
- 40:49follow these proceedings, then technically, it's not possible.
- 40:53And when mothers can't attend, exclusion becomes very real.
- 40:57We know that the right of participation exists. The
- 41:00question is whether we can experience it in reality. On the
- 41:04day, we have to ask ourselves, is the spirit of environmental
- 41:08legislation really being honoured here? Environmental
- 41:13decisions affect water, air, land and future generations, our
- 41:18full participation cannot be conditional. I feel this
- 41:22discussion will not end with this episode.
- 41:26If this conversation has struck a chord, you might want to go
- 41:29back to episode seven, human rights in the hills, defending
- 41:33the defenders. And episode 35 when public is in public, where
- 41:38we explore these questions from different angles.
- 41:43You can pick up the links in the show notes.
- 41:46We'll be back again with another conversation soon. For the air
- 41:50we breathe, the water we drink, the earth that supports our
- 41:53Community Health for generations to come, we hold the line. You.