Latest / Automotive State of The Union / Carvana Dealership #2, Buffett Cashes Out BYD, Amazon AI Ad Assist
Transcript
- 0:00Good morning, it is Tuesday, September 23rd. This is the Automotive State of the Union. I'm Paul Jay Daly. That's Kyle Mountsier.
- 0:06Today we're talking about Carvana buying dealership number two, Warren Buffett buying his way out of the BYD, or selling his way out, and Amazon leaning way into the AI creative assist. Watch out.
- 0:19It's about to get so weird. It's already- [laughs] About to get? It's already weird, if you haven't noticed. If it ain't weird enough, it gonna get weirder. I know. It's great. It, it is great. It is great.
- 0:28I love this world. It's so sideways, and it's amazing. [laughs] Like, the fact that we get to cover what we cover every single day just simply blows my mind. And- There's Kyle's new quote: "I love this world.
- 0:37It's sideways." It's [laughs] what a sh- what a T-shirt. [laughs] What a T-shirt. But you have to, you have to write it, like, sideways. I'm not a big fan of vertical hor- vertical text. But- Yeah...
- 0:47that might, that might sum it up. It's like, "I love the world, it's sideways" going down or something. [laughs] Yeah. So good.
- 0:53Uh, speaking of things that aren't sideways, tomorrow we have our next Asotu Edge Quickshot webinar, Best Dealership Cost Reduction Targets in 2025, with Doug Austin of Strategic Source and Matthew Haken of Prestige Auto Collection.
- 1:05We're gonna show you. They're, they're gonna show you. They're gonna tell you, "This is where you can reduce costs. This is how Matthew, an actual dealer with a group, did it," and they're gonna do that all for free.
- 1:16All you have to do is sign up for the webinar. Go to asotu.com. If you can't make it in person, which we always hope you do, then you can definitely get the recording.
- 1:25So asotu.com, sign up for the webinar, save a bunch of money, send us a note and tell us how much you saved. Fair enough? [laughs] I like it. All right. Today [laughs] we- Easy. You know, sometimes- Save money...
- 1:35we, we always joke about this. Sometimes in the summer season especially, the news cycle in automotive gets real slow. It gets slow. Right? Just nothing happens. And then boom, here it hits.
- 1:42And this morning I woke up, I was like, "We are back." And it just rips. Yeah. We are back. All right, let's talk about it. Carvana making another, another big move into franchise new car sales.
- 1:50This time it's happening in Dallas. The company has agreed to acquire Park City's CDJR Fiat, marking its second foray into the world of traditional dealerships.
- 1:59It's their second franchise dealerships after buying, uh, Jerry Reiner's CDJR in Casa Grande, Arizona earlier this year, which is right near their headquarters, actually.
- 2:07Wood Motor Company owner Chip Johnson, who sold the Dallas store, said it was simply the right time to sell, and Carvana's offers made sense for the future of the dealership, AKA, they were paying the money.
- 2:17That's right.
- 2:17The deal reflects Carvana's ongoing experiment in blending its digital-first model with the in-person dealership experience, and a Carvana spokesperson said, quote, "We are in the very early days of testing it as a franchise dealer, and we look forward to continuing to learn as we focusing on delivering exceptional customer experiences."
- 2:34Man, stepping into the game a little further. Here's the thing. I am so bullish about this. Couple reasons. One is when Carvana came on the scene, every single dealer
- 2:48right-sided their, their ability to, like, think more critically- Mm-hmm... about the broader customer experience. Without a doubt. We talked about what omni-channel means. Uh- It was a great gift to the industry...
- 2:57like, it was a gift to the industry. Now we're gonna see that gift perpetuated into franchise new car sales. If you're afraid of it, get over it.
- 3:05This is not, uh, uh, they're not gonna go buy 2,000 stores tomorrow and take over the industry.
- 3:11Um, but what they're gonna do is give us a viewpoint on what it looks like to think completely differently, uh, because from, because they come from a different position.
- 3:19The other really interesting thing to me here is the fact that they're going a- after Stellantis dealerships.
- 3:24I don't know what the relationship i- is there, but- I mean, having more than one, like, not going too broad, it makes sense that they would stick with that. You know what I mean? Yeah.
- 3:31'Cause they're from out of a different city.
- 3:32But even, like, just going after two Stellantis dealerships is just not something you would normally do, is, especially with the high day supply on a, on a, like, a thesis that is predicated on a low day supply- Uh-huh...
- 3:43right, in order to increase profitability. So it's kind of, like- Hmm... an interesting, like, maybe someone was like, "If we can do it with CDJR, we can do it with anything" We can do it anywhere, right?
- 3:50[laughs] We'll throw Fiat in the mix, too, so. Right. Yeah. If you really want a challenge- Oh, wow... throw Fiat in the mix. Um, I, I, I don't know if this is true. We'll have to research this.
- 3:59When they bought the first store, one of the questions that we were talking about is what happens when certified pre-owned vehicles are going to be listed on Carvana's site as used cars, right?
- 4:08An obvious advantage- Mm... in bringing those two worlds together. And, um, you know, I think, we- we'll research and see if that happens. I, I still, I still retain the first time I ever saw Ernie Garcia, uh, Jr.
- 4:19speak was at an automotive news retail forum, and he blew everyone's mind because he approached it like a startup market analyst would, and he said, you know, "People buy used cars every..."
- 4:30I can't remember what the data point was, but every three-point whatever years. Imagine if we could speed that up by 30%, then we can literally- That's it... control, increase the market for, for our product.
- 4:41And he said they believe they can do that through making it less painful to buy a car and making it fun so people would wanna do it more often. So- Interesting... um, yeah, so excited to see what they do with this.
- 4:50Um, every other dealer in the market in the industry, it's like this is another call to say, like, "Hey, you gotta keep up. You gotta give the customer what they want. You gotta push down on your value propositions.
- 5:00You have to build your own brand." And in the end, that's what wins the game. It, it doesn't matter where they buy it, here or here or here.
- 5:06It really does matter how they view the experience coming in, how they view it leaving, who they talk about, and, uh, who begins to own that family garage. Yep, exactly. All right. Speaking of family garages.
- 5:17Segregate the best. Segway. Time. [upbeat music] Warren, I wonder what Warren Buffett drives, by the way.
- 5:24Warren Buffett and Berkshire Hathaway have officially cashed out completely of their wildly successful bet on Chinese EV maker BYD after holding the stock for 17 years. Those aren't, those aren't buy/sell guys.
- 5:36They're not flippers. Um, Berkshire conser- confirmed it no longer owns a single share. This is the end of- Wow...
- 5:43a $230 million investment made in '08 at Charlie Munger's urging, which grew to nearly 9 billion at its peak.
- 5:50BYD shares skyrocketed about 3,800% during Berkshire's ownership, making it one of the firm's most lucrative EV-related plays ever.
- 5:58Buffett hasn't given a detailed reason for the exit, but voiced concern about geopolitical risks tied to China and Taiwan.
- 6:05On BYD, Buffett told CNBC, quote, "It's an extraordinary company run by an extraordinary person, but I think that we'll find things to do with the mon- I, I think we'll find things to do with the money that I'll feel better about."
- 6:16Yeah, I can't imagine being that, that deeply invested in a company that is kind of like-... creating a lot of, uh, or is, not creating, it's in the middle of a lot of tension. Yeah. Right?
- 6:26Uh, and for Warren Buffett, who's such a central, uh, y- you know, player in US economics, uh, really, like- Absolutely... people are watching what, the way he, he pivots. Um, here, here's, here's the fun stat.
- 6:38Warren drives a 2014 Cadillac STS- [laughs]... purchased for him by his daughter. [laughs] Which is the thing that someone's that great with, that's that great with money would do with that event. It's a great car.
- 6:48I love this car. It's so comfortable. I mean, how- So comfy... here's the real question. This, I guarantee you, this is the one that you wanna buy off trade. Right. It's probably got, like, 11,000 miles on it. Trust.
- 6:59Perfection. No one's ever sat in the backseat. You know, [laughs] you know what I mean? Yeah, you're right. But, uh, props to Nathan, our producer, for coming up with that so quick. What a scope. I love that.
- 7:06What a scope. The, the other thing that I wanna note here is for people that think that EVs just came out of the blue- Check the math... check this. 2008. This thing has been going for a long time. Mm-hmm.
- 7:18And BYD didn't just come on the scene three, four years ago when we started hearing about them. They've been, they've been building a business over a long time.
- 7:25And, you know, you look at Tesla, you look at some of these EV providers, this is also to the OEMs that are looking to get in the EV game.
- 7:32Like, if you just started two or three years ago, you're nine years out from having proficiency in the marketplace. Mm-hmm.
- 7:38Um, and, and that's honestly a dangerous proposition for the OEMs that are built on ICE vehicles because they have to have this long runway. They have to have this investment portfolio.
- 7:48They have to have the ability to lose money for a significant amount of time. That's right. Um, and, and, uh, we always forget that, like, this type of, a $230 million investment in EVs in 2008, come on. Yeah.
- 8:02One of our LinkedIn viewers says, "BYD might do well to license their technology to other automakers." Ooh. A lot of talk about that. I think, I think there should be a lot of au- automakers open to that.
- 8:12And for BYD- Sure... what a great way to, to get in the market, learn about the market. I'm sure- Ooh, little sneaky... I hope they're talking. I know. Little sneaky. I know. [laughs] Speaking about not so sneaky. Stop.
- 8:21Amazon. Big way. Amazon can't sneak anywhere. [upbeat music] [laughs] Amazon is stepping deeper into AI for marketers, rolling out a controversial chat assistant. Conversational. Conversational, sorry.
- 8:32Conversational chat assistant designed to act as a creative partner for brands advertising- Oh... on its platform. Okay. This is kind of a, I think it's a little bit in response to what Meta's been doing. Yep.
- 8:42The tool lives inside Amazon's creative studio and is launching in beta at no cost to advertisers. Yep, free. It's free creative. Yep, free.
- 8:49This is Amazon's first conversational AI ad assistant built to help with research, brainstorming, storyboarding, and production, uh, display, and video ads.
- 8:58The assistant uses Amazon's shopper data and Bedrock foundation, like Nova and Anthropic Claude, um, to give marketers a bunch of campaign-ready assets. "The goal is to level the playing field," says Amazon.
- 9:11Their VP, Jay Richmond, said, "This is about more than speed. It's about giving every advertiser and agency access to the kind of strategic, high-quality creative support that once only large brands could afford."
- 9:22You know what's really funny is that VP Jay Richmond, that looks like ChatGPT wrote his quote. I know. It reads like ChatGPT wrote it. [laughs] It does.
- 9:31We're pr- we're getting pretty good at sniffing those out, and I'm thinking that PR department was like, "What does Jay think about this?" Do, do, do, do, do. This is about, it's about- Not about this.
- 9:40It's about the- This is not about this. Okay. It's about this but pure GPT. I have a few thoughts on this. Number one, we gotta ask our boy Car- Carson Henry what he thinks about this.
- 9:46There are some people- Ooh, good call. Yeah... doing some great stuff in Amazon. Um, I would love to know their thoughts on this. But I think this principle, Meta hit it, Amazon's hitting it now.
- 9:54It's, um, it's a principle you and I have talked about quite a bit. It was part of the founding principle actually of ASOTU. Uh, it came out of Jim McKelvey's book, The Innovation Stack, on why he founded Square.
- 10:05He said, "There are this many people in the little circle who do credit card processing." He's saying- Yep...
- 10:10"We believe that there's a huger, a way bigger circle outside that center that would do credit card processing if it was simple, and easy, and accessible."
- 10:20So I think Meta and now Amazon is realizing we have our big advertisers in this little center, but there's a much bigger group of small businesses and independent sellers- Yeah...
- 10:28that would engage us if we made it easy for them to run campaigns and generate ads. So I think this is a great use for the tech. Yeah, I think, uh, th- I mean, and auto is a little bit of this.
- 10:37Obviously, we have a lot more agency partners. We have a lot more creative. We spend a big budget.
- 10:41But all of, uh, and, and this is gonna be wild because of the brands that can compete, even, like, the independent shops that can now go into Facebook or Amazon and launch campaigns with full creative- Mm-hmm...
- 10:52in the, like, way less time than it would take anybody else to launch this. This is gonna be... It is. It's a, it's a playing field leveler.
- 11:00And, and I know, like, you know, obviously, like, con- we have a creative agency, and so there's always this attention on, like, well, how good is the ad? How good is the creative? How good is the marketing?
- 11:10And, you know, for some things, precision matters, being on brand matters. For the majority of sellers on Amazon and Meta, it's just gotta be good enough, right?
- 11:21Which is just the reality of getting people's attention and delivering ad value when people are spending marketing dollars. Here's the free creative. What does my hun- $100 get me? Yeah. Right?
- 11:31And if that gets you $200 back, you're doing it. Well, and, and the other point of this is it allows you to faster test, iterate, and invest, right?
- 11:41Test quickly, iterate on the testing, and then invest in the thing that won. In the thing that works. Right? Mm-hmm. Yeah. I mean, I don't know about you, but I feel like we did quite a few laps on that show today.
- 11:52It's only been 12 minutes. Mid laps. Hey, we got a whole day out there, so whatever you're doing, test, iterate, invest, care about people, love people, love cars, but love the people more. We'll see you here tomorrow.
- 12:01[upbeat music] Keep running. Keep running. Keep running. And move the right. Keep running. Keep running. Keep running. And move the right.