Latest / SleepWise: Learn Softly, Sleep Deeply / 5 Speeches That Changed the World | A Calm Bedtime Story
Transcript
- 0:00Good evening and welcome back to Sleep Wise.
- 0:04Tonight we drift into one of the quietest mysteries of human
- 0:09life, the strange way that certain words spoken aloud at
- 0:16certain moments refuse to disappear.
- 0:21Most of what we say passes without record.
- 0:26The conversations of a single afternoon, the murmured
- 0:30greetings between neighbors, the apologies and reassurances and
- 0:34small jokes that fill an ordinary day.
- 0:38These vanish almost as soon as they are spoken.
- 0:42They are not lost in any sad sense.
- 0:46They simply do their work, and then they let go.
- 0:51That is the natural fate of language, to be useful for a
- 0:55moment and then to fade gently into the air that carried it.
- 1:00And yet every so often a voice finds a moment, and the words it
- 1:06speaks settle into the world and stay.
- 1:10They are repeated by strangers who never knew the speaker.
- 1:16They are written into books, carved into stone, taught to
- 1:21children long after the room they were spoken in has been
- 1:25emptied and forgotten. The chairs are gone, the lamps
- 1:31are gone, the listeners are gone, and still the words
- 1:36remain. Tonight we will visit five such
- 1:39moments. Not battlefields, exactly.
- 1:43The one will be a battlefield. Not laboratories, though science
- 1:48will join us before the night is done.
- 1:51We will visit rooms, podiums and open air places where someone
- 1:57stood up or simply sat down and chose to speak and the world
- 2:04leaned in to listen. It is tempting to think these
- 2:08speeches survived because they were grand or thunderous.
- 2:13Most of them were not. Some lasted only two minutes.
- 2:18One was a single sentence delivered by a man too exhausted
- 2:23to stand. Another was offered quietly by a
- 2:28stranger in a cardigan in a small committee room to a
- 2:34senator who had not expected to be moved that afternoon.
- 2:39What they share is something subtler than power.
- 2:44They arrived at the right silence.
- 2:47They knew when to begin, and more rarely, they knew when to
- 2:52stop. They did not try to fill every
- 2:56corner of the room with words. They trusted the space around
- 3:01them, and the space remembered them.
- 3:05Tonight is not a study of rhetoric.
- 3:08There will be no rules of oratory, no diagrams of
- 3:12persuasion. We are here only to listen
- 3:15gently to the reasons certain voices still reach us across
- 3:21years and continents and centuries, to consider what it
- 3:27costs to speak honestly and what is sometimes gained by saying
- 3:34less than expected. So let your shoulders soften.
- 3:40Let the day's voices, the meetings and messages and small
- 3:44frictions settle behind you like dust returning to the floor of a
- 3:50quiet room. The speeches we will visit
- 3:54tonight have already been delivered.
- 3:57Their work is long done. We are only guests now,
- 4:03listening from a great distance in the soft glow of our own
- 4:08evening. If these journeys help you rest,
- 4:13you can follow Sleep Wise and share it with someone who might
- 4:17enjoy falling asleep while learning something new.
- 4:22Now, with the night around us and the world growing still, let
- 4:28us begin. Before we step into our first
- 4:33moment, it is worth pausing on something that often goes
- 4:38unmentioned. For most of human history, a
- 4:43speech could only travel as far as a single voice could carry
- 4:47it. There were no recordings, no
- 4:51microphones, no cables stretching the sound of one
- 4:55mouth across a continent. If you missed the moment, you
- 5:00missed it. The words drifted into the sky
- 5:05and were gone. This is a strange thought to
- 5:08hold, because it means that almost every great speech and
- 5:12human memory survives only because someone, somewhere wrote
- 5:18it down. Sometimes a scribe recorded it
- 5:22as it was being delivered. More often it was reconstructed
- 5:28afterward from the imperfect memories of those who had been
- 5:32present, sometimes decades later, sometimes by someone who
- 5:38had not even been there at all. That fragility is part of the
- 5:44story. The words we are about to visit
- 5:47to night have been carried to us through a long chain of human
- 5:53attention. Some are reliable in nearly
- 5:57every syllable. Some are slightly different from
- 6:01what was actually said in the air.
- 6:04The Roman historians who recorded ancient speeches often
- 6:08filled in plausible language where memory failed.
- 6:13The biographers who preserved early American oratory sometimes
- 6:19shaped a sentence until it shone a little brighter than the
- 6:23original moment. This is not a flaw to be
- 6:27corrected. It is the nature of the human
- 6:31voice passing through human hands on its way to becoming
- 6:36history. What we remember of a speech is
- 6:41rarely an exact transcript. It is something gentler and
- 6:47stranger. It is what stayed for the
- 6:51speeches we will visit to night. This matters in different ways.
- 6:57Two were captured on film and survive in their exact spoken
- 7:02form, with all their pauses and hesitations.
- 7:07One was written down faithfully by witnesses on the day it was
- 7:12delivered. Another survives partly through
- 7:16translators in the careful memory of those who heard it.
- 7:20And one of the most famous, our first, exists in several
- 7:25slightly different versions because the speaker himself
- 7:31revised it in the days that followed.
- 7:35So tonight, let us listen the way one listens to a story
- 7:40passed down in a family, with patience, with affection and a
- 7:49willingness to forgive the small distances between what was said
- 7:55and what was kept. Our first stop is a small town
- 8:00in Pennsylvania on a cool afternoon in November of 1863.
- 8:07The air smells of fallen leaves and turned earth.
- 8:11A new cemetery has just been finished, the grass still thin,
- 8:15the markers freshly placed, the rows stretching farther than the
- 8:21eye can comfortably follow. A great crowd has gathered on
- 8:26the hillside above. The headline speaker is one of
- 8:30the most celebrated orators in America, and almost as an
- 8:35afterthought, a tall, tired president has been invited to
- 8:41offer a few appropriate remarks. He has accepted, and the country
- 8:47has no idea what is about to happen.
- 8:51To understand what happened that afternoon, we have to step back
- 8:56four months into the summer of 1863, when the small town of
- 9:03Gettysburg, PA, became the site of the bloodiest battle ever
- 9:09fought on American soil. For three days in early July, 2
- 9:15great armies met in the fields and orchards just outside the
- 9:20town. By the time the fighting ended,
- 9:23more than 50,000 men had been killed, wounded or were missing.
- 9:29The number is difficult to absorb.
- 9:33It was as though every man in a small city had been struck down
- 9:39in the space of 72 hours. Many bodies lay where they had
- 9:44fallen, scattered across miles of farmland, in barns, beside
- 9:50stone walls, near streams that ran red for days afterward.
- 9:56Gettysburg, itself a town of fewer than 3000 residents, was
- 10:01overwhelmed. Houses became hospitals.
- 10:06Churches became hospitals. Schools became hospitals.
- 10:11The smell of the dead settled into the streets and would not
- 10:16leave. Neighbors who had recently been
- 10:20farming and walking to market found themselves attending to
- 10:24wounded strangers from places they had only read about burial
- 10:30in the days after the battle was hurried and imperfect.
- 10:35Some men were laid to rest where they fell, with little more than
- 10:39a shallow covering of earth. By August, it was clear that
- 10:44something more dignified had to be done.
- 10:48A young attorney named David Wills was placed in charge of
- 10:53organizing it. He bought the land, arranged for
- 10:58the careful reburial of the dead, and planned a public
- 11:02dedication ceremony for November.
- 11:05For such a solemn occasion, the most important task was choosing
- 11:12the speaker. Wills wanted the finest orator
- 11:17in America. That choice in 1863 was not a
- 11:23difficult one. It was Edward Everett.
- 11:27Everett is a name that has faded almost entirely from memory now,
- 11:33but in his time he was the country's most celebrated public
- 11:38voice. A former senator, governor and
- 11:41president of Harvard, he had spoken at the unveiling of
- 11:46monuments and the funerals of national heroes.
- 11:52His speeches lasted hours and were considered masterpieces of
- 11:58classical eloquence. To invite Everett was to honor
- 12:03the dead with the very best America could offer.
- 12:07Almost as an afterthought, several weeks later, Wills also
- 12:12sent a letter to the president of the United States inviting
- 12:17him to attend and to offer, in his careful phrasing, a few
- 12:22appropriate remarks. Lincoln was not the headliner.
- 12:27He was the courteous postscript. He accepted.
- 12:32In the days before the ceremony, Lincoln worked on what he would
- 12:36say. He had no team of speech
- 12:40writers. The few words he was preparing
- 12:44were his own, drawn from years of brooding over the meaning of
- 12:48the war and the country fighting it.
- 12:51The night before the dedication, he arrived in Gettysburg by
- 12:56train. The town was full.
- 13:00Lincoln stayed at the home of David Wills in a small upstairs
- 13:04room and made his final adjustments by lamplight.
- 13:10Outside, the November air was cold.
- 13:14The graves were waiting. The morning of November 19th
- 13:18dawned cool and overcast, though the sun broke through at
- 13:23intervals. As the crowd gathered, perhaps
- 13:2815,000 people came to the hillside above the new cemetery.
- 13:34Many had travelled by train and wagon.
- 13:39Some were the families of men buried in the fresh ground
- 13:43below. Some were officials and military
- 13:47officers in dress uniform. Most were ordinary citizens who
- 13:52had come to witness an occasion they sensed was important,
- 13:57though none yet knew how important it would become.
- 14:01A military procession opened the ceremony.
- 14:05There were prayers and hymns. A band played a slow, mournful
- 14:09piece. Then Edward Everett rose to
- 14:13deliver the main address. He spoke from memory, without
- 14:18notes, for over 2 hours. His oration was a sweeping
- 14:23survey of the battle and the war.
- 14:26He compared Gettysburg to the great battles of antiquity,
- 14:30woven classical references, and honored the men buried below.
- 14:36It was the kind of speech people had paid to hear in lecture
- 14:41halls. The crowd listened, sometimes
- 14:45restlessly, as the long sentences rolled forward.
- 14:51The afternoon wore on. The wind shifted.
- 14:57People shuffled their feet against the cold.
- 15:01When Everett finally finished, there was applause, music and a
- 15:05brief pause. Then Lincoln stood up.
- 15:10He was tall and thin, dressed in a dark suit that seemed slightly
- 15:15too short for his long arms and legs.
- 15:19He held a single page of notes. He adjusted his spectacles.
- 15:25He began to speak in the high, reedy voice that surprised many
- 15:30people the first time they heard it.
- 15:32They expected something deeper from a man who looked the way he
- 15:36did. What followed lasted roughly 2
- 15:40minutes. It was about 270 words.
- 15:45He did not mention Gettysburg by name.
- 15:49He did not mention the Union or the Confederacy.
- 15:53He did not list the generals, name the regiments or recount
- 15:59the battle. He went somewhere else entirely.
- 16:04He went back to the founding of the country 87 years earlier and
- 16:09asked what the country had been founded on.
- 16:13He named the proposition that all men are created equal, and
- 16:19asked, without quite asking it directly, whether a nation built
- 16:24on such a proposition could survive a war this terrible.
- 16:29He suggested that the dead in the ground below had given the
- 16:34living an unfinished work, that they had not died for a battle
- 16:40or a war, but for an idea about what a country could be.
- 16:47And then he sat down. Some in the audience were not
- 16:51sure he had finished. The applause came late and was
- 16:55scattered. A photographer setting up his
- 16:58camera missed the entire address, still adjusting his
- 17:03lens when Lincoln returned to his seat, there is no clear
- 17:09photograph of the moment. Everett, the great orator, had
- 17:13filled the air for two hours. Lincoln had taken less time to
- 17:18speak than it takes to read his words aloud.
- 17:22Now he himself reportedly leaned over to a friend afterward and
- 17:28remarked that the speech had not gone well.
- 17:32He was, in this moment, almost completely wrong.
- 17:37In the days that followed, the response was uncertain.
- 17:42Some newspapers praised Lincoln's brief remarks.
- 17:46Others dismissed them. A paper in Chicago called the
- 17:51speech silly, flat and dishwatery.
- 17:55Even some of Lincoln's allies thought he had missed an
- 17:59opportunity, that he had given too little where so much had
- 18:04been expected. But there were others, more
- 18:08attentive listeners, who understood almost at once that
- 18:13something unusual had happened. Edward Everett, of all people,
- 18:19may have been the first. The next morning he sat down and
- 18:24wrote a letter to the President. He told Lincoln that he wished
- 18:29he could flatter himself that he had come as close to the central
- 18:35idea of the occasion in two hours as Lincoln had come in 2
- 18:40minutes. It is one of the gracious
- 18:43moments in American history, the great orator quietly bowing to
- 18:50the strange power of the spare president he had nearly
- 18:54upstaged. Over the months and years that
- 18:57followed, the address grew quietly larger.
- 19:02Newspapers reprinted it. School children memorized it.
- 19:07By the time of Lincoln's assassination, 18 months later,
- 19:12the speech had begun to take on the weight it still carries.
- 19:17By the next century, it was carved in stone at the Lincoln
- 19:22Memorial in Washington, where visitors still pause to read it
- 19:27in silence. What had Lincoln understood that
- 19:31Everett, with all his eloquence, had not?
- 19:36Perhaps simply this. He had understood that the
- 19:41cemetery itself was already speaking.
- 19:45The graves, the families, the cost, stretched across the
- 19:49hillside in long, careful rows, the silence over the freshly
- 19:54turned earth. All had their own voice.
- 19:59A long speech would have competed with that voice.
- 20:02A short speech could let it through.
- 20:06Lincoln did not try to fill every space.
- 20:10He trusted the dead to do part of the speaking.
- 20:15He gave the day a few quiet sentences, lifted what those
- 20:20sentences pointed toward, and stepped back.
- 20:24The ceremony then completed itself in the listener and in
- 20:30the time that followed. There is a lesson in this for
- 20:34anyone who has ever wished to say something important.
- 20:38The most powerful thing a voice can sometimes do is stop.
- 20:44To say less than the moment seems to demand, to leave room
- 20:50for the listener to feel, to think, to remember.
- 20:54This idea will return more than once tonight.
- 20:58We will meet a man on a cold mountain who said a single
- 21:02sentence and ended an entire chapter of his people's history.
- 21:08We will meet another in a courtroom who spoke for hours
- 21:13and then fell silent for 27 years.
- 21:18We will meet a quiet man in a cardigan whose 6 minutes of
- 21:22plain speaking changed the mind of a senator who had decided not
- 21:29to be moved. But before we leave Gettysburg,
- 21:33let one image remain. The November afternoon, the
- 21:38graves still fresh, a tall man on a wooden platform speaking in
- 21:44his high, quiet voice for 2 short minutes and then sitting
- 21:49down into the long silence that followed.
- 21:53The silence the world has been listening to ever since Lincoln
- 21:59had spoken over the dead and asked what their sacrifice could
- 22:03mean. 14 years later, on the other side of a wide and
- 22:09changing country, another leader would speak not over the dead,
- 22:14but over the living. Over exhausted, freezing
- 22:18families who had walked nearly 1200 miles through some of the
- 22:23most difficult terrain in North America, he would speak in only
- 22:30a few brief sentences. And like Lincoln, he would
- 22:34understand that to say less sometimes is to say more than
- 22:40any longer speech could. The speech we're about to visit
- 22:45was not delivered in a cemetery. It was delivered in a snow
- 22:51covered Meadow in northern Montana, beneath the low Gray
- 22:57sky, with the breath of horses and tired soldiers visible in
- 23:04the cold air. It was not given by a head of
- 23:08state in a tall hat. It was given by a chief whose
- 23:13people had been pushed to the edge of their endurance, almost
- 23:19to the edge of an international border, and whose very presence
- 23:24in that Meadow was the result of months of running.
- 23:30The year was 1877. The man's name in English was
- 23:36Chief Joseph. In his own language, he was
- 23:40called Hinma Tu ya Latkekt, which is often translated as
- 23:46Thunder rolling down the mountain.
- 23:49To understand the weight of his words, we have to walk back into
- 23:54the world he came from, a world of clear rivers and deep
- 23:59forests, of salmon runs that filled the streams in summer and
- 24:05horses that grazed in the high meadows.
- 24:09A world that only a generation earlier had seemed to most of
- 24:15its people steady, ancient and unchanging.
- 24:20So let Gettysburg drift gently into memory.
- 24:25The November afternoon, the rows of graves, the tall man on the
- 24:29platform speaking in his high, quiet voice.
- 24:34We are going West and we are going back.
- 24:38Back to the Pacific Northwest of the early 19th century, into a
- 24:43long Green Valley between 2 mountain ranges, into the wide
- 24:47rolling country beyond it, into a way of life that had been
- 24:52carefully fitted to its land for many hundreds of years.
- 24:57This is the world of the Nez Perce.
- 25:01It begins, as so many quiet stories do, in a place its
- 25:07people loved. There is a tenderness to such
- 25:11stories, and a sadness too, because we already know how they
- 25:15end. We know that the valleys will
- 25:18not stay safe. We know that the long horse
- 25:22herds will be scattered, the lodges burned, the rivers
- 25:26crossed in flight. We know that the chief who will
- 25:31eventually speak to us in the snow has not yet learned how to
- 25:35be that chief. He is still at the start of our
- 25:39story, simply a young man growing up in a quiet place that
- 25:45taught him how to listen and how to choose his words with care.
- 25:50For now, let the Meadow in Montana wait.
- 25:56Let the soldiers and the snow and the long line of exhausted
- 26:00horses stand still in the future.
- 26:04We have a Green Valley to visit first and a way of life to walk
- 26:10gently through before the running begins.
- 26:16The Nez Perce, who called themselves Nemipu, meaning
- 26:20simply the people, lived in the high plateau country where
- 26:25Idaho, Oregon and Washington meet.
- 26:29Their traditional homeland stretched across roughly
- 26:3317,000,000 acres of mountain valleys, river canyons and
- 26:38rolling grasslands. It was a varied and abundant
- 26:44country. 5 great rivers ran through it, including the Snake,
- 26:49the Salmon, and the Clearwater. Salmon arrived each year in
- 26:55numbers difficult for a modern person to imagine filling the
- 26:59streams with their bright bodies.
- 27:03Commas bulbs grew in the meadows.
- 27:06Elk moved through the forests in their seasons.
- 27:10The Nez Perce way of life was shaped by these rhythms.
- 27:15Families followed the salmon to their spawning grounds in spring
- 27:19and summer. They harvested Kama's roots in
- 27:22the high meadows in Midsummer. In autumn they haunted in the
- 27:28mountains. In winter they drew together in
- 27:32sheltered valleys, in long lodges warmed by careful fires,
- 27:40telling the stories that had been told there for as long as
- 27:44anyone could remember. In the early 18th century,
- 27:48horses came into their world from the South, and the Nae's
- 27:52purse became some of the finest horse breeders on the continent.
- 27:58They developed the spotted breed, now known as the
- 28:02Appaloosa. With horses, their range
- 28:06widened. They crossed the Bitterroot
- 28:09Mountains to hunt Buffalo on the plains, but always they returned
- 28:14to their valleys. When Lewis and Clark stumbled
- 28:18out of the mountains in eighteen O 5, exhausted and starving, it
- 28:23was the Nez Perce who fed them. The expedition would not have
- 28:30survived without that kindness. Almost every American account of
- 28:36the early Pacific Northwest passes through Nez per SE
- 28:40hospitality. For decades after, the
- 28:44relationship between the Nez Perce and the United States
- 28:47remained, if not equal, at least peaceful.
- 28:52A treaty in 1855 recognized Nez Perce land, including the
- 28:59Wallowa Valley in northeastern Oregon, where Joseph's band
- 29:04lived. The Wallowa was a place of
- 29:07extraordinary beauty. Lakes lay among high mountains.
- 29:12Wide grasslands rolled down to the river.
- 29:16To Joseph's family, it was home beyond questioning.
- 29:22Then, as so often in American history, gold was found.
- 29:27In 1860, prospectors discovered gold on Nez Perce land.
- 29:33Settlers poured in. The promises of the 1855 treaty
- 29:38became inconvenient. A new treaty was negotiated in
- 29:421863, which ceded almost 90% of the original Nez Perce homeland,
- 29:48including the Wallowa Valley. Joseph's father refused to sign
- 29:54it. He never accepted that the
- 29:56document had any standing over his people.
- 30:00The federal government called it a treaty anyway and acted as
- 30:05though it bound everyone for the next 14 years. 2 Understandings
- 30:11of the law moved in parallel. Like two rivers that did not
- 30:17meet. The government held that the
- 30:20Wallowa Nez purse were trespassers on their own land.
- 30:27The Wallowa Nez purse held that they had never agreed to leave
- 30:31it. Then, in 1877, the patients of
- 30:36the United States Army finally ran out.
- 30:41Joseph was not by nature a war leader.
- 30:45He had spent years trying to negotiate.
- 30:48He understood, perhaps more clearly than the men sent to
- 30:52negotiate with him, what would happen if his people were pushed
- 30:56into open conflict with the United States Army.
- 31:01He counselled patience. He spoke softly in counsel and
- 31:06listened more than he spoke. In the spring of 1877, an Army
- 31:12general named Oliver Howard arrived in the region with
- 31:16orders to remove the Wallowa Band to a reservation in Idaho.
- 31:22Howard gave them 30 days. Joseph asked for more time.
- 31:27The cattle were scattered across the high country.
- 31:31The rivers were swollen with snow melt.
- 31:35Crossing them with women, children and herds would mean
- 31:39losses no people could absorb. Howard refused.
- 31:44The Nez purse began their reluctant move.
- 31:47And then, almost at the last moment, a few young men,
- 31:52grieving losses and angered by the long humiliation, struck
- 31:56back at white settlers along the Salmon River.
- 32:00The leaders had not approved it, but once it began, there could
- 32:05be no return. Joseph and the other chiefs
- 32:10gathered their bands and fled. What followed was extraordinary.
- 32:16Roughly 750 Nez Perce, including women, children and the elderly,
- 32:24set out across the mountains, hoping to reach safety somewhere
- 32:30the Army could not follow. Only about 250 of them were
- 32:35warriors. The rest were simply families
- 32:39trying to live for more than three months.
- 32:43They ran. They crossed the Bitterroot
- 32:47Mountains. They moved through the Big Hole
- 32:51Valley in Montana, where they were attacked at dawn by
- 32:55soldiers and lost dozens of women and children before the
- 33:00warriors could organize a defence.
- 33:04They crossed the Yellowstone region just as it was becoming
- 33:08the world's first National Park, frightening tourists who had
- 33:13never imagined being inside a war.
- 33:17They climbed through high passes and narrow trails, with soldiers
- 33:22pursuing from several directions at once.
- 33:26They covered roughly 1200 miles. They fought a series of battles
- 33:31and skirmishes, often outnumbered, often without
- 33:35supplies, often with the wounded slowing their pace.
- 33:41And again and again, they outmaneuvered the soldiers sent
- 33:46to catch them. Newspapers across the country
- 33:50followed the chase. Some readers cheered for the
- 33:53army. Others found themselves quietly
- 33:57admiring the small, exhausted force trying so hard to reach
- 34:02freedom. Joseph was not the chief
- 34:05military strategist. That credit belongs largely to
- 34:09other Nez Perce leaders, including his brother Olacort
- 34:14and the war chief's Looking Glass and two HUL HUL Zoet.
- 34:20But Joseph carried a different weight.
- 34:23He held the families together. He kept the noncombatants
- 34:27moving. He spoke to them in the cold
- 34:30mornings and tended the wounded. By late September, they were
- 34:36within 40 miles of Canada. The border was almost insight.
- 34:42They stopped to rest in a Meadow at the foot of the Bear Paw
- 34:46Mountains, believing they had nearly outrun the war.
- 34:52They had not. On the morning of September
- 34:5630th, while the families were still in camp, a fresh column of
- 35:01soldiers under Colonel Nelson Myles attacked from the South.
- 35:08The battle that followed was bitter and exhausting.
- 35:13The Nez purse fought from rifle pits dug into the cold ground.
- 35:19Snow began to fall. Some of the people in the chaos
- 35:23slipped away through the lines and made it across the border
- 35:28into Canada. Others, including most of the
- 35:32warriors who had led the long flight, were killed.
- 35:36For five days, the siege continued.
- 35:40The wind grew colder. Food ran out.
- 35:44The wounded suffered without medicine.
- 35:47Joseph's brother Olacott was dead, so were Looking Glass and
- 35:52Tu HUL HUL Zote. The chiefs who had organized the
- 35:56flight, who had outwitted the army across 1000 miles of
- 36:02mountains, were now silent in the snow.
- 36:05On October 5th, 1877, Joseph rode out under a Gray sky to
- 36:12meet General Howard and Colonel Miles.
- 36:16He carried his rifle across his saddle.
- 36:19The wind moved across the open Meadow.
- 36:23The soldiers and his own people watched.
- 36:26He dismounted, handed over the rifle, and began to speak.
- 36:31The words he spoke that day were translated and written down by a
- 36:36young Army officer named Charles Erskine Scott Wood.
- 36:42The version that has come down to us is brief, simple and
- 36:46almost unbearably tired. He spoke of the chiefs who were
- 36:51dead. He spoke of the children
- 36:54freezing in the hills, of those who had run to the mountains and
- 36:59had no blankets, no food. He said his heart was sick and
- 37:05sad, and he ended with the line that has carried his voice into
- 37:10history. From where the sun now stands,
- 37:14he said, I will fight no more forever.
- 37:18It is worth pausing on that sentence.
- 37:20It is not, on its surface, dramatic.
- 37:25It contains no metaphor, no flourish.
- 37:29But it does something rare. It marks an ending with absolute
- 37:35precision. He did not say I am defeated.
- 37:40He did not say I surrender, He said something quieter and
- 37:45stranger from where the sun now stands.
- 37:49From this exact moment, on this exact day, in this exact light,
- 37:55I will fight no more. And then the word that gives the
- 37:59sentence its weight forever. It is the speech of a man who
- 38:05knows that a chapter is ending and who refuses to allow the
- 38:10ending to be vague. He chooses the moment himself.
- 38:16He places it in time. He gives it a precise hinge upon
- 38:22which the rest of his life and his people's life will turn.
- 38:28In doing so, he turns a defeat into something else.
- 38:33Not a triumph, not a comfort, but an act of dignity.
- 38:40The power to name the ending even when one has lost the power
- 38:45to prevent it. The translation may have
- 38:48polished his actual word slightly.
- 38:51The exact phrasing may not be what he said in his own
- 38:55language, but the shape of the moment, the weight of the chosen
- 39:00finality that is real. It cannot be edited out.
- 39:07He ended with those words and stepped back into silence.
- 39:14The promises made on that Meadow were not kept.
- 39:18Joseph and his people had been told that they would be sent
- 39:23back to the Idaho reservation where some of their relatives
- 39:27lived and where they could begin to rebuild.
- 39:31Instead they were marched E 1st to Fort Leavenworth in Kansas
- 39:38and then S to Indian Territory, what is now Oklahoma.
- 39:45The land was hot, swampy and unfamiliar diseases.
- 39:51The Nez Perce had no resistance to swept through them.
- 39:56Children died first, then elders, then the strong.
- 40:02In the years that followed, Joseph spent much of his life as
- 40:07a kind of. Diplomat for the dead.
- 40:10He traveled to Washington. He met President Hayes.
- 40:15He met President McKinley. He met Theodore Roosevelt.
- 40:20He spoke quietly and respectfully to men whose
- 40:25government had broken every meaningful promise made to him.
- 40:31He asked again and again Only one thing, to be allowed to take
- 40:38his people home to the Wallowa Valley.
- 40:42The answer was always the same, no.
- 40:46In 1885, after years of pressure, the surviving Nez
- 40:52Perce of his band were finally moved N but not to the Wallowa.
- 40:58Some were sent to the Idaho Reservation.
- 41:02Joseph and the rest were settled at Coalville, a reservation in
- 41:07North Central Washington. It was a kinder place than
- 41:11Oklahoma, but it was not home. He lived out the rest of his
- 41:17life there. He continued to ask for the
- 41:20Wallowa. The years passed.
- 41:24His hair turned white. He became a familiar figure to
- 41:28journalists and dignitaries, a living symbol of an era many
- 41:33Americans were already turning into nostalgia.
- 41:37But he was not a symbol. He was a man who had lost almost
- 41:42everything, and who carried that loss with great patience.
- 41:48He died in September of 19 O 4 by his own fire at Coalville.
- 41:56His doctor reportedly said that he died in the end of a broken
- 42:01heart. He was buried near a small lake
- 42:05on the reservation. He never returned to the valley
- 42:09where he was born. His surrender speech, those few
- 42:13brief words spoken in a snowy Meadow in 1830, Eleven, became
- 42:19one of the most remembered pieces of oratory in American
- 42:24history. Not because it was elegant in a
- 42:28literary sense, not because it argued anything, but because it
- 42:33held, in a few honest sentences, the entire weight of what was
- 42:39being lost. The chiefs who were dead.
- 42:44The children freezing in the hills.
- 42:47The world that was ending, the decision made in cold light to
- 42:53mark that ending with one's own voice.
- 42:56Sometimes a speech becomes great not because of what the speaker
- 43:03put into it, but because of everything that had been taken
- 43:07away before it. Joseph's words carry that
- 43:11emptiness. They are powerful precisely
- 43:15because they do not try to be more than they are.
- 43:19Lincoln had said much in his short minutes by trusting the
- 43:23silence around his words. Joseph said even less.
- 43:29He led a single sentence and an era from where the sun now
- 43:35stands. And now, gently, we leave the
- 43:39Meadow in Montana and the long flight that ended there.
- 43:46Joseph spoke at the end of a fight he could not win.
- 43:51The army was already on the field, the chiefs already dead,
- 43:57the families already broken by snow and hunger.
- 44:01His words marked an ending of finality accepted, even chosen
- 44:09in cold light. The next voice we will visit
- 44:13chose differently. He stood not in a Meadow at the
- 44:17close of a long flight, but in a wood panelled courtroom on a
- 44:23different continent, with the power of a hostile state arrayed
- 44:28against him. He was not surrendering.
- 44:32He was speaking into the certainty of a long
- 44:36imprisonment, perhaps a death sentence, and trying to leave
- 44:41behind something that would outlast both.
- 44:45He spoke for nearly three hours, and then he sat down and waited
- 44:54to learn whether he would live. The year was 1964.
- 45:00The country was South Africa. The man's name was Nelson
- 45:07Mandela. Where Joseph's speech was a
- 45:11single sentence carrying the weight of a world that had
- 45:14already been lost, Mandela's was a long, careful, almost
- 45:20methodical statement aimed at a world that did not yet exist.
- 45:26He was not speaking for the present.
- 45:29The present in that courtroom was already against him.
- 45:35He was speaking for a future he might never see.
- 45:39He was placing his words into time itself, the way one might
- 45:44bury a letter in a wall, hoping that someone generations later
- 45:51would find it and understand. This, too, is a kind of brevity,
- 45:57though it does not look like it at first. 3 hours is not short,
- 46:03but Mandela's speech is brief in a deeper sense.
- 46:08It is brief in claim. It does not try to argue
- 46:13everything. It does not try to win the
- 46:15trial. It does not even try to save his
- 46:18life. It tries to do only one thing,
- 46:22to name plainly and exactly what the struggle was for and what
- 46:28kind of country he hoped one day to see.
- 46:31To understand why he stood in that courtroom and why his words
- 46:36still travel, we have to step gently into the world he was
- 46:40speaking from, a world arranged by law into the bodies that were
- 46:47allowed to enter certain rooms and the bodies that were not, a
- 46:53world in which his very presence in a public courtroom was
- 46:59already an act of defiance. So let the snow of Montana drift
- 47:05behind us now. Let the Meadow grow quiet.
- 47:11We are crossing the wide ocean and a wide century.
- 47:15We are arriving in a country shaped like a great wedge at the
- 47:18bottom of Africa, where mountains meet the sea, where
- 47:22vineyards and cities and townships sit beside one another
- 47:28in uneasy nearness, and where, for many decades, the answer to
- 47:34almost every question about a person's life began with the
- 47:39color of their skin. The story we are about to enter
- 47:44is not a comfortable one, but it is one of the great stories of
- 47:49the 20th century, and the words at its center were spoken by a
- 47:54man who had decided before he ever opened his mouth that he
- 48:01would speak the truth and accept what came of it.
- 48:05His name was Nelson. The country was waiting.
- 48:09South Africa in the middle of the 20th century was a country
- 48:14built on a painful idea. The idea was that human beings
- 48:21could be sorted by birth into separate categories, and that
- 48:26those categories could be enforced in nearly every detail
- 48:30of daily life, where a person could live, where they could
- 48:35work, whom they could marry, what benches they could sit on,
- 48:40what schools their children could attend.
- 48:44The system was called apartheid, an Afrikaans word that means
- 48:50apartness. Apartheid did not begin all at
- 48:54once. South Africa had long carried
- 48:57the legacies of colonization, of land taken and labor exploited.
- 49:03Black, mixed race and Indian S Africans had lived for
- 49:08generations under laws that denied them most of the
- 49:12protections white S Africans enjoyed.
- 49:16But in 1948, a new government came to power that decided to
- 49:21formalize, to harden, and to extend that separation into
- 49:26something more deliberate and more total.
- 49:30In the years that followed, a long series of laws redrew the
- 49:35country. The Population Registration Act
- 49:39required every citizen to be classified by race.
- 49:44The Group Areas Act assigned different races to different
- 49:48urban zones and forcibly removed those who lived in the wrong
- 49:53place. The Bantu Education Act narrowed
- 49:58the schooling available to black children.
- 50:01Pass laws required black S Africans to carry identification
- 50:07at all times and to produce it whenever asked on penalty of
- 50:12arrest. To live under such laws was to
- 50:15be reminded daily that once full humanity was not recognized by
- 50:22the state. A grandmother could be moved out
- 50:26of her home of 40 years because the neighborhood had been
- 50:31reclassified. A child could be denied a school
- 50:36because of how she had been registered at birth.
- 50:41A young man could be stopped on the street, ask for his pass and
- 50:48jailed for forgetting it. There was also, alongside this,
- 50:53a world of ordinary life. Marriages and births, weekends
- 51:00and music, soccer matches and church services, Tea on Stoops
- 51:07in the warm evenings. People did not stop being people
- 51:13because the laws had become cruel.
- 51:16Resistance to apartheid was not new.
- 51:20The African National Congress, the ANC, had been founded in
- 51:241912, long before apartheid acquired its official name.
- 51:30For decades, its leaders had tried to oppose racial laws by
- 51:34petition, by letter, by peaceful protest, by appeals to
- 51:40international bodies. They marched, they wrote, They
- 51:44spoke. The government answered with
- 51:47arrests, bans and rising violence.
- 51:51In 1960, in the Township of Sharpville, police opened fire
- 51:57on a peaceful crowd protesting the past laws. 69 people were
- 52:03killed, many shot in the back as they tried to flee.
- 52:07The world was shocked. Within weeks, the ANC was
- 52:12banned, its leaders were forced underground and the long
- 52:17question whether peaceful resistance alone could end
- 52:21apartheid became impossible to avoid.
- 52:26It was into that question that a young lawyer named Nelson
- 52:31Mandela had stepped. Mandela had been born in the
- 52:36rural trance K in 1918, into a family with traditional standing
- 52:42among his people. He was sent to mission schools,
- 52:46then to university and finally to Johannesburg, where he
- 52:52trained as a lawyer. He and his colleague Oliver
- 52:55Tambo opened the first black law practice in the country in a
- 53:00small office where clients lined up out into the street.
- 53:06For years, Mandela had been one of the public faces of
- 53:10nonviolent resistance. He believed, like many of his
- 53:14colleagues, that peaceful protests sustained over time
- 53:19could shame and pressure even a hostile government into change.
- 53:25Sharpville eroded that hope. After the ANC was banned,
- 53:31Mandela and a small group of leaders made one of the most
- 53:35difficult decisions of their lives.
- 53:39They concluded that a strictly nonviolent approach was no
- 53:45longer enough. In 1961, they founded a small
- 53:50armed wing called Umconto we Siswe, which means Spear of the
- 53:56Nation. Its first acts were carefully
- 54:00limited. They were aimed at
- 54:03infrastructure, at power lines and government buildings, with
- 54:07strict orders to avoid loss of life.
- 54:11The hope was to demonstrate that the system could be made
- 54:14unworkable without becoming a war against ordinary people.
- 54:19Mandela went underground. He grew a beard.
- 54:23He moved between safe houses for a time.
- 54:26He travelled abroad, training briefly in Algeria and Ethiopia.
- 54:32The press began to call him the Black Pimpernel, A teasing
- 54:37nickname for a man the police could not seem to catch.
- 54:41Then in August of 1962, returning from a meeting near
- 54:45Durban, he was stopped at a roadblock.
- 54:50Some accounts say a foreign intelligence service had tipped
- 54:54off the police. Others suggest a more local
- 54:58betrayal. Either way, the long evasion
- 55:01ended. He was tried, convicted of
- 55:05inciting workers to strike and of leaving the country without a
- 55:09passport, and sentenced to five years in prison.
- 55:14It might have ended there, but while he was serving that
- 55:18sentence, the police raided a farm in Rivonia, north of
- 55:23Johannesburg, and discovered documents linking Mandela and
- 55:28other ANC leaders directly to Umkonto Wee Sizwe.
- 55:35A new trial was opened. The charge this time was
- 55:39sabotage, which under South African law could carry the
- 55:44death penalty. 11 men, including Mandela, stood accused.
- 55:52The eyes of the world turned slowly toward a courtroom in
- 55:58Pretoria. Mandela faced a choice any
- 56:02defendant in such a position must face.
- 56:05He could plead. He could deny.
- 56:09He could try to minimize his role and hope for leniency.
- 56:14Or he could do something else. He could refuse to defend
- 56:18himself in the ordinary sense and instead used the moment to
- 56:23speak past the judges, past the prosecution, past the apartheid
- 56:29government itself, to a wider audience that did not yet know
- 56:34it was listening. He chose the second path.
- 56:38He would make an opening statement from the dock rather
- 56:42than testify under cross examination.
- 56:46He would not be questioned. He would rise and speak and let
- 56:51his words stand as the heart of the defence.
- 56:55On the morning of April 20th, 1964, in the Palace of Justice
- 57:01in Pretoria, Mandela rose in the dock and began to read.
- 57:06He had worked on the speech with his colleagues, drawing on his
- 57:10own life, the history of the ANC and a careful argument about why
- 57:17a movement of patient men had finally taken up arms.
- 57:23He spoke for nearly three hours. The courtroom was full.
- 57:29His mother sat in the gallery. Reporters from around the world
- 57:33filled the press benches. He spoke first about himself,
- 57:39about growing up in a rural homestead, listening to elders
- 57:44tell stories of how the country had once been before colonial
- 57:49conquest, about becoming a lawyer, and about the daily
- 57:54indignities lawyers of his color encountered in courts where they
- 58:00were officially professionals but unofficially second class
- 58:05men. He spoke about the founding of
- 58:08Umconto Y Siswe. He explained, with the calm of
- 58:14someone who has nothing left to hide, that he had chosen
- 58:18sabotage carefully with strict instructions to avoid loss of
- 58:23life because nothing else had worked.
- 58:28He did not deny the charges, he explained them.
- 58:32He addressed the suggestion that the ANC was simply a front for
- 58:37foreign communism. He spoke about why some of its
- 58:41members had accepted help from the Communist Party in a country
- 58:46where almost no one else would help, but insisted that the AN
- 58:51CS vision was its own, rooted in African history and African
- 58:57aspirations. He spoke of the dignity of work,
- 59:03of the desire of black S Africans to live as full
- 59:07citizens, to walk the streets without a pass, to send their
- 59:12children to schools that prepared them for a real future,
- 59:16to love and marry whom they wished to vote.
- 59:19And then near the very end, after nearly three hours of
- 59:24careful, patient explanation, he set aside the prepared text.
- 59:32He looked up from his pages and he spoke directly to the judge.
- 59:38He said that during his lifetime he had dedicated himself to the
- 59:43struggle of the African people, that he had fought against white
- 59:47domination and against black domination, that he had
- 59:52cherished the ideal of a democratic and free society in
- 59:58which all persons would live together in harmony with equal
- 1:00:02opportunities. He said it was an ideal he hoped
- 1:00:06to live for and to achieve. And then, looking the judge in
- 1:00:11the eye, he added the words that would echo for the rest of the
- 1:00:16century if need be. It was an ideal for which he was
- 1:00:21prepared to die. The court room was silent.
- 1:00:26The judge, a man named Quartus de Witt, did not speak
- 1:00:30immediately. He gathered his papers.
- 1:00:34The proceedings continued in their measured way.
- 1:00:39The verdict and sentencing came in June.
- 1:00:42Mandela and seven of his Co accused were convicted.
- 1:00:47The expected sentence was death. It did not come, whether because
- 1:00:54of international pressure or unease within the South African
- 1:00:59legal community or some calculation, we will never know.
- 1:01:04The judge sentenced them to life imprisonment instead.
- 1:01:09Mandela was 45 years old. He would serve 27 years. 27
- 1:01:17years is a long time, long enough for children to be born
- 1:01:23and grow up, long enough for a country to harden and slowly,
- 1:01:29slowly, to soften again. Long enough for the man who had
- 1:01:35spoken in that courtroom to become, in the eyes of the
- 1:01:39world, a kind of patient absence, a name on lists of
- 1:01:45political prisoners, a face on banners at protests in distant
- 1:01:51cities. A myth, almost.
- 1:01:54While the man himself broke rocks in a quarry on Robben
- 1:01:58Island and watched the years pass.
- 1:02:02He was finally released in February of 1990.
- 1:02:06He was 71 years old. The country he walked back into
- 1:02:11was not yet free, but its long unfreezing had begun.
- 1:02:17Four years after that, in 1994, in the first election in which
- 1:02:22all S Africans of all colors could vote, he was elected
- 1:02:26president of the country that had once tried to put him to
- 1:02:30death. The ideal he had spoken of from
- 1:02:34the dock, the democratic and free society for which he had
- 1:02:39been prepared to die, had finally become possible to live
- 1:02:44for after all. His Rivonious speech is now
- 1:02:48considered one of the great political speeches of the 20th
- 1:02:53century. It is taught in classrooms, it
- 1:02:56is studied by lawyers, by activists, by historians.
- 1:03:01But its real power, the deeper reason it still travels, is
- 1:03:06harder to teach. It lies in the fact that he
- 1:03:10meant every word and proved it by waiting.
- 1:03:15He waited in a small cell on a windswept island.
- 1:03:21He waited through the deaths of friends, the birthdays of
- 1:03:25children he could not hold, the slow erosion of his own youth.
- 1:03:31He waited while world leaders argued about whether to support
- 1:03:35him. He waited while the country he
- 1:03:39loved nearly tore itself apart. And when he finally walked out
- 1:03:45of prison, he did not retreat into bitterness.
- 1:03:50He kept the same patience in the same direction, until the ideal
- 1:03:56he had named was no longer only a hope.
- 1:04:00Lincoln had trusted the silence around his words.
- 1:04:04Joseph had compressed an ending into a single sentence.
- 1:04:10Mandela trusted time. He spoke for three hours and
- 1:04:15then waited for almost 3 decades and the words held.
- 1:04:21Now gently, our journey shifts again.
- 1:04:27The next voice we will visit will surprise us.
- 1:04:32We will leave Pretoria and the long shadow of apartheid and the
- 1:04:38court rooms and prisons that shaped a continent.
- 1:04:42We will arrive somewhere much smaller and much quieter.
- 1:04:47A committee room in Washington, a hot afternoon in May of 1969.
- 1:04:55A senator who has been in a cutting mood all day looking at
- 1:04:59his watch, and a slim, slightly nervous man in a cardigan who
- 1:05:05has been given 6 minutes to speak about something most
- 1:05:09people in the room consider unimportant.
- 1:05:13He will not speak about freedom or empire.
- 1:05:17He will not face execution or imprisonment.
- 1:05:21He will speak plainly about how children feel, and the room,
- 1:05:27against its own expectations, will go very quiet.
- 1:05:33Fred Rogers was an unlikely figure to find at the center of
- 1:05:38a political fight. He was a soft spoken
- 1:05:42Presbyterian minister who had wandered into children's
- 1:05:47television almost by accident after watching the early days of
- 1:05:53the medium with quiet alarm. Most of what he saw on
- 1:05:58television aimed at children in the late 1950s and early 1960s
- 1:06:03struck him as loud, frantic and faintly cruel.
- 1:06:09Pies in faces, people falling over, adults shouting at one
- 1:06:14another for laughs. He believed children deserved
- 1:06:18something gentler, so he set out to make it.
- 1:06:22By 1969, his program, Mr. Roger's Neighborhood, had been
- 1:06:28on public television for two years.
- 1:06:31He spoke directly into the camera, as though to one child
- 1:06:35at a time. He took off his outdoor coat and
- 1:06:39put on a cardigan. He changed his shoes for
- 1:06:43sneakers. He sang quiet songs about
- 1:06:46feelings, about anger, about being scared, about sad days.
- 1:06:52He visited factories and museums in slow, calm segments.
- 1:06:57He used puppets to talk about the things children worried
- 1:07:01about but rarely had words for. The show looked nothing like the
- 1:07:07rest of television. Some critics found it dull.
- 1:07:11Others, watching with their children, found themselves
- 1:07:15quietly grateful. But public television itself was
- 1:07:20new and fragile. It was funded partly by the
- 1:07:25federal government, and that funding was now under threat.
- 1:07:30President Nixon, hoping to redirect federal money toward
- 1:07:35other priorities, had proposed cutting the budget for public
- 1:07:39broadcasting in half, from $20 million to 10.
- 1:07:44The proposal had to go before a Senate subcommittee where its
- 1:07:49fate would be decided. The chairman of that
- 1:07:52subcommittee was Senator John Pastore, a Democrat from Rhode
- 1:07:57Island. Pastore was not a cruel man, but
- 1:08:01he was a no nonsense 1. He was famously skeptical of
- 1:08:07what he considered soft please for funding.
- 1:08:11He had been listening to testimony for hours by the time
- 1:08:15Fred Roger's name appeared on the schedule.
- 1:08:17The room was warm. The papers were stacked.
- 1:08:21Pastore wanted things to move along.
- 1:08:24When Rogers entered the room, he carried no slick presentation.
- 1:08:29He had no film clips to show. He had a folder with a few pages
- 1:08:35of typed notes. He was slim, slightly nervous
- 1:08:40and dressed in a quiet suit. He sat down at the witness table
- 1:08:46and waited for his turn. Pastore looked at him with mild
- 1:08:51impatience. He had agreed to give Rogers 6
- 1:08:55minutes. He gestured for him to begin.
- 1:08:59What happened next has been preserved on film.
- 1:09:04The exchange has been viewed many millions of times since.
- 1:09:10But on that May afternoon in 1969, no one in the room knew
- 1:09:15they were about to witness anything memorable.
- 1:09:18They expected a routine appeal for federal money on behalf of a
- 1:09:23children's show that, frankly, most of the senators had never
- 1:09:28seen. Rogers began to speak.
- 1:09:31His voice was soft, almost too soft for a Senate hearing room.
- 1:09:38The microphone strained slightly to catch him.
- 1:09:42He did not begin with statistics.
- 1:09:45He did not begin with the structure of public broadcasting
- 1:09:49or the merits of educational programming or the threat of
- 1:09:54cutting half the budget. He began somewhere quieter.
- 1:10:00He thanked the senator. He said he wanted to share what
- 1:10:04his program tried to do. He spoke about feelings.
- 1:10:08He said that children grow up with feelings they do not yet
- 1:10:12have words for anger, sadness, fear, frustration.
- 1:10:19He said his program tried to give those feelings names and to
- 1:10:23help children understand that the feelings themselves were not
- 1:10:28bad. That a child who could name a
- 1:10:31feeling and learn that others felt it too was a child a little
- 1:10:37less alone. Pastora, who had been ready to
- 1:10:41keep things moving, did not interrupt.
- 1:10:44He listened. Rogers explained that the show
- 1:10:48did not try to entertain children with constant motion or
- 1:10:52noise. It tried instead to slow down
- 1:10:56with them, to meet them at their own pace.
- 1:11:01He talked about the difference between, on the one hand,
- 1:11:06programming that bombarded young minds with stimulation and, on
- 1:11:11the other, programming that respected their inner lives.
- 1:11:16Then he did something unusual. He began to recite from memory
- 1:11:22the lyrics to a song he had written for the program.
- 1:11:27The song was about anger, about what to do when you feel like
- 1:11:32punching something or yelling at someone, about finding ways to
- 1:11:37manage strong feelings without hurting others or yourself.
- 1:11:41He recited the words slowly, plainly, as if he were singing
- 1:11:47them to a single child sitting across from him.
- 1:11:51The hearing room, which had been busy with shuffled papers and
- 1:11:56quiet side conversations, grew very still.
- 1:12:00When he finished, there was a pause.
- 1:12:04Pastore, who had spent the day being skeptical, looked at the
- 1:12:09man across from him. The senator was visibly moved.
- 1:12:14He said quietly that he had goosebumps.
- 1:12:18And then, almost without thinking, he added the line that
- 1:12:23has been remembered ever since. I think it's wonderful, he said.
- 1:12:29Looks like you just earned the $20 million.
- 1:12:33The funding was saved. What had happened?
- 1:12:37Rogers had not argued. He had not negotiated.
- 1:12:41He had not flattered the senator or appealed to his sense of
- 1:12:44duty. He had simply described with
- 1:12:48absolute sincerity what his work was for.
- 1:12:53He had spoken in a voice that did not raise itself.
- 1:12:58He had treated a tired, skeptical politician the same
- 1:13:02way he treated a four year old at home, in front of the
- 1:13:06television, as someone worth speaking to gently, as someone
- 1:13:12whose feelings mattered. The senator in that moment was
- 1:13:18not a senator. He was a person, and Rogers had
- 1:13:22quietly addressed the person rather than the role.
- 1:13:26There is a lesson here that returns us to a thread we have
- 1:13:30been following all night. Rogers did not say more than the
- 1:13:35moment required. 6 minutes, a few quiet sentences, a song he
- 1:13:41could have skipped. He trusted the smallness of his
- 1:13:45words to carry their weight. And in that committee room, in
- 1:13:51the hot late afternoon, the smallness was enough.
- 1:13:57We have moved tonight from a battlefield to a Meadow, from a
- 1:14:01Meadow to a courtroom, from a courtroom to a small hearing
- 1:14:06room with a tired senator and a man in a quiet suit.
- 1:14:11Each setting has grown smaller and more intimate.
- 1:14:16Each speech has whispered in its own way the same secret that
- 1:14:22power and meaning do not belong to volume.
- 1:14:26Now for our final stop. The journey reverses itself.
- 1:14:31We will leave the rooms of human affairs entirely.
- 1:14:36We will rise above the buildings, above the cities,
- 1:14:40above the weather, above the atmosphere itself.
- 1:14:44We will travel outward, past the Moon, past the inner planets,
- 1:14:50past Mars and the asteroid belt, past Jupiter, past Saturn, until
- 1:14:57we are very far away from anything that has ever held a
- 1:15:01microphone or argued in a parliament or sentenced a man to
- 1:15:06prison. We will arrive at the edge of
- 1:15:09the solar system, where a small spacecraft built by human hands
- 1:15:14is sailing into the dark. The spacecraft is called Voyager
- 1:15:191. It was launched in 1977, the
- 1:15:24same year that Chief Joseph Surrender Meadow lay quiet under
- 1:15:29summer grass. Nearly a century after the fact,
- 1:15:34Voyager carried instruments to study the outer planets and a
- 1:15:39small gold plated record bearing greetings from Earth and a
- 1:15:43camera. For more than a decade, it sent
- 1:15:47back astonishing images. It photographed Jupiter's
- 1:15:51storms. It revealed the rings and moons
- 1:15:55of Saturn. It became, by the late 1980's,
- 1:16:00the most distant human made object in the universe.
- 1:16:05In 1990, as Voyager continued its long outward drift, an
- 1:16:11astronomer named Carl Sagan made an unusual request.
- 1:16:16He suggested that the spacecraft, before its camera
- 1:16:20was shut down to save power, be turned around not toward another
- 1:16:25planet, not toward a star, but back, back across the immense
- 1:16:31distance it had travelled, back toward the small blue world from
- 1:16:36which it had begun. The engineers were initially
- 1:16:41uncertain the maneuver would offer almost no scientific
- 1:16:45value. The Earth would appear in any
- 1:16:48such photograph not as a planet but as a speck, a grain less
- 1:16:55than a pixel. That, Sagan said, was precisely
- 1:17:00the point the command was sent. Voyager turned.
- 1:17:06Its camera looked back across 3.7 billion miles of empty
- 1:17:11space, and then, on Valentine's Day in 1990, it took the
- 1:17:17picture. The image, when it returned to
- 1:17:21Earth, showed mostly blackness. Streaks of scattered sunlight
- 1:17:27ran across the frame, artifacts of the camera looking too close
- 1:17:32to the sun. And inside one of those bright
- 1:17:36bands, almost invisible at first, was a single tiny dot, a
- 1:17:42pale blue point of light. That was home.
- 1:17:46That was every continent and ocean.
- 1:17:49That was every city, every village, every farm.
- 1:17:53That was every human being who had ever lived, every emperor
- 1:17:58and every slave, every battlefield, every cradle, every
- 1:18:03cathedral, every act of cruelty and every act of kindness, all
- 1:18:10of it contained in a fraction of a single pixel of light.
- 1:18:16Sagan looked at the image, and then, in his soft and patient
- 1:18:21voice, he began to speak. Sagan's reflection on the pale
- 1:18:27blue dot was not delivered as a speech in the ordinary sense.
- 1:18:33It was written. He spoke it later, in his own
- 1:18:39voice as narration. There was no podium, no audience
- 1:18:45clapping, no microphone in a Senate chamber.
- 1:18:49There was only the photograph and his patient writer's voice,
- 1:18:55drawing the listener gently toward something difficult to
- 1:18:59feel any other way. He invited his readers to look
- 1:19:04again at that small dot. He said that everyone they had
- 1:19:09ever loved, everyone they had ever heard of, every human being
- 1:19:16who had ever existed, had lived out their lives there on a mote
- 1:19:23of dust suspended in a sunbeam. He spoke of all the rivers of
- 1:19:32blood that had been spilled by generals and emperors so that in
- 1:19:38glory and triumph they could become the momentary masters of
- 1:19:44a fraction of a dot. He spoke of the
- 1:19:49misunderstandings between groups of people who, on this tiny
- 1:19:54stage, were so close to one another and yet treated each
- 1:19:59other as if they were enemies in some vast separate world.
- 1:20:06He spoke of how often human beings had forgotten how small
- 1:20:13the stage really was. And then, in the same gentle
- 1:20:18voice, he turned the lens the other way.
- 1:20:22He said the image also showed something else.
- 1:20:26It showed how rare and precious that pale blue dot is, because,
- 1:20:33so far as anyone has been able to discover, it is the only home
- 1:20:39any of us has ever known. There is no evidence yet, he
- 1:20:44said, that help will come from elsewhere to save us from
- 1:20:50ourselves. It was not a despairing speech.
- 1:20:54It was not, in the end, even sad.
- 1:20:58It was simply true, and true in a way that could only be felt
- 1:21:04from very far away. Sagan understood that distance
- 1:21:09can be a teacher. From up close, every quarrel
- 1:21:13feels enormous, every grievance is real, every loss is the size
- 1:21:19of 1's own life, which is the only life one has.
- 1:21:24But from far away, the same quarrels and griefs become
- 1:21:30impossibly small, not unimportant, just small, held
- 1:21:36inside something larger and more patient.
- 1:21:40To stand on the pale blue dot is to feel one's own life as urgent
- 1:21:46and meaningful. To see the pale blue dot from
- 1:21:513.7 billion miles is to feel something different, A
- 1:21:59tenderness, A protectiveness, a recognition that all of us are
- 1:22:05passengers on the same fragile vessel, travelling together
- 1:22:10through an enormous quietness, and that whatever differences
- 1:22:15seem to divide us are not nearly as deep as the simple fact of
- 1:22:22sharing a single fragile world. Lincoln had spoken over a
- 1:22:28battlefield, asking what the dead had given the living.
- 1:22:33Joseph had spoken in a snowy Meadow, marking the end of a way
- 1:22:38of life. Mandela had spoken in a
- 1:22:42courtroom, naming an ideal he was prepared to die for.
- 1:22:48Rogers had spoken in a hearing room, describing how children
- 1:22:54feel. Sagan, alone among them, did not
- 1:22:58need a room at all. His speech was delivered to the
- 1:23:03universe itself, on behalf of every person who had ever lived
- 1:23:09on. A small blue speck of light.
- 1:23:13And the speck listened, and so gently.
- 1:23:18Our journey is ending. We began with a thought that
- 1:23:24most words pass without record, that most voices vanish into the
- 1:23:30air that carried them, but that now and then a voice finds the
- 1:23:36right silence, and what it says there lasts.
- 1:23:42We have visited five such voices to night.
- 1:23:46They could not have been more different from one another.
- 1:23:51A president, a chief, a prisoner, a children's host, an
- 1:23:56astronomer, a cemetery, a Meadow, a courtroom, a hearing
- 1:24:02room, a photograph from the edge of the solar system.
- 1:24:07And yet, as we looked at them more closely, the same quiet
- 1:24:13truth came forward again and again.
- 1:24:18Power and meaning do not belong to volume.
- 1:24:22Speeches are not great because they are loud or long.
- 1:24:28They are great because they arrive at the right moment and
- 1:24:32trust the silence around them and refuse to fill more space
- 1:24:39than they need. Lincoln spoke for two minutes
- 1:24:43and let the graves do the rest. Joseph spoke a single sentence
- 1:24:50and ended an era. Mandela spoke for three hours
- 1:24:56and then let 27 years finish his argument.
- 1:25:01Rogers spoke for 6 minutes and changed a senator's mind by
- 1:25:06treating him like a child who deserved to be heard.
- 1:25:11Sagan spoke into the empty distance, reminding us that all
- 1:25:17our voices belong to a single pale blue point of light.
- 1:25:23Each of these voices was, in its own way, an act of trust.
- 1:25:31Trust that words spoken honestly in the right place would be
- 1:25:37carried. Trust that listeners somewhere,
- 1:25:42sometime, would hear them. None of these speakers could be
- 1:25:48sure of that when they spoke. Lincoln thought his speech had
- 1:25:53failed. Joseph spoke, knowing his world
- 1:25:58was ending. Mandela spoke believing he might
- 1:26:03be sentenced to death. Rogers spoke into the impatience
- 1:26:09of a tired senator. Sagan spoke to a universe that,
- 1:26:14so far as anyone knows, had no listeners at all.
- 1:26:20And yet the words held. They are still holding now,
- 1:26:25travelling quietly through us on a small blue planet, late on an
- 1:26:32ordinary evening. Outside the room, the world
- 1:26:36continues. Cities turn their slow lights on
- 1:26:40and off. Snow falls somewhere, and
- 1:26:44somewhere else the warm rain begins.
- 1:26:48Voices speak and are forgotten, and a few will be remembered.
- 1:26:55We do not know which ones. The speakers themselves rarely
- 1:27:00know. They simply do their honest work
- 1:27:04and trust the silence to carry it to night.
- 1:27:09Perhaps that is the gift to keep.
- 1:27:13Not the names, not the dates, not the perfect sequence of
- 1:27:18every speech we have visited. Only the mood of it, the sense
- 1:27:25that even small voices spoken truly can travel further than
- 1:27:33they imagine. Let the cemetery rest.
- 1:27:37Let the Meadow rest. Let the courtroom rest.
- 1:27:42Let the hearing room rest. Let the spacecraft drift on into
- 1:27:49the long dark with its faint message still in its hold.
- 1:27:56The world is full of noise, but somewhere, always, of voices
- 1:28:02finding the right silence and quietly saying something that
- 1:28:07will last. The room is dim, the day is
- 1:28:11done, the voices have spoken, and now they rest.
- 1:28:17And so gently, do we Good night.