Latest / Girls with Grafts / When Scars Become the Scare: Halloween and Hollywood Stereotypes
Transcript
- 0:01[SPEAKER_04]: You're listening to girls with graphs.
- 0:03[SPEAKER_04]: A burn community podcast created by Phoenix Society for burn survivors, a leading nonprofit dedicated to supporting the burn community.
- 0:11[SPEAKER_04]: In this podcast, we'll talk with burn survivors.
- 0:14[SPEAKER_04]: Share resources to help with supporting and improving burn recovery, and discuss how to prevent burn injuries.
- 0:20[SPEAKER_04]: Here are your hosts, burn survivors, and Phoenix Society's marketing team, Amber Wilcox and Rachel Kudlack.
- 0:30[SPEAKER_05]: Hello, everyone, and welcome back to Girls With Graphs.
- 0:34[SPEAKER_05]: I am Rachel Kudlack, I'm one of the hosts of the show.
- 0:37[SPEAKER_05]: And today I won't be joined by my lovely co-host Amber Wilcox, but I was invited to take part in this special Halloween podcast episode with a belt face, Kelsey Farrow, who is the communications officer and program manager at a belt face, welcomed on.
- 0:56[SPEAKER_05]: myself, along with Dr. Wee Stickier, Charlene Pell, and Florida Swift for a special episode all around Halloween and burn survivors and those with visible and facial differences and how we're portrayed in the media.
- 1:12[SPEAKER_05]: So I'm so thankful for Kelsey for welcoming me on today's episode.
- 1:17[SPEAKER_05]: So I'm going to pass it over to her to get us started.
- 1:28[SPEAKER_03]: have a fun one and thank you so much for informing us for this conversation about how to win, how to win past games, major differences, and the sterile types that can appear in the media.
- 1:47[SPEAKER_03]: We often see facial differences used to sit in signal,
- 1:53[SPEAKER_03]: that someone is a villain or a scary or dangerous and today we want to talk about how this how these stereotypes can affect people living with relationships and what we can do to change stereotypes and how the media programs relationships.
- 2:16[SPEAKER_03]: So my name is Cassie.
- 2:19[SPEAKER_03]: I am the communications officer and program manager for a cloud case in Canada.
- 2:27[SPEAKER_03]: I'm joined by some other great amazing people of organizations.
- 2:32[SPEAKER_03]: So I will let everyone into this themselves and further down while looking for help.
- 2:41[SPEAKER_02]: Hi, everybody.
- 2:42[SPEAKER_02]: I am Philadelphia Swift.
- 2:44[SPEAKER_02]: I run face equality international where I am chief exec.
- 2:47[SPEAKER_02]: We are a
- 2:49[SPEAKER_02]: Global membership of community groups, charities, all of whom work with people with facial differences in some way.
- 2:57[SPEAKER_02]: We come in to build out the global campaign to make it easier, to capacity builds and make sure that people are sharing the knowledge together, but also growing campaigns like international face equality week, like Fino face that runs around Halloween.
- 3:15[SPEAKER_02]: Ready, we are about building solidarity for the global cools.
- 3:23[SPEAKER_03]: I think this is a swimming round you go.
- 3:27[SPEAKER_00]: Yes, hi, everyone.
- 3:29[SPEAKER_00]: I'm charling pal.
- 3:31[SPEAKER_00]: And I'm the founder and executive director of Facing Forward and also the co-founder of Card, the coalition for authentic representation of disfigurement and difference.
- 3:44[SPEAKER_00]: At 32 years ago, I survived a private airplane crash on a remote island and endured burns to 64% of my body, including my face.
- 3:55[SPEAKER_00]: And at the time of my accident, there were no programs
- 4:00[SPEAKER_00]: available to help people.
- 4:04[SPEAKER_00]: except just to an altered body and face, and so I began extensively researching and studying and using my background as a communications executive to develop a program called What To Do and People's Stair.
- 4:24[SPEAKER_00]: And I pretty much has been the core of my work for the past 25 years of
- 4:32[SPEAKER_00]: to live fully and have meaningful lives and it's a way of reframing steering because we know that a curious public is going to steer forever.
- 4:46[SPEAKER_00]: So it's again empowering people with disfiguring conditions and in the last nine years I've really focused a lot of my work on media
- 5:02[SPEAKER_00]: Thank you, and I just weren't fighting me.
- 5:05[SPEAKER_03]: Thanks, Ian.
- 5:06[SPEAKER_03]: Thank you so much, darling.
- 5:08[SPEAKER_03]: Rachel, why won't you go ahead?
- 5:11[SPEAKER_05]: Yeah, I am Rachel, could like I'm a burn survivor and a marketing lead at Phoenix Society for burn survivors.
- 5:20[SPEAKER_05]: I'm also a member of Cored, which is the group that Charlie was just referencing.
- 5:24[SPEAKER_05]: So, yeah, I'm really excited to be here.
- 5:26[SPEAKER_05]: I won't go into too many of the details, but like I said, I am a burn survivor.
- 5:31[SPEAKER_05]: I do have some facial scarring and I'm really excited to be part of this conversation today.
- 5:42[SPEAKER_01]: Hi.
- 5:42[SPEAKER_01]: Hi everybody.
- 5:44[SPEAKER_01]: It's nice to be with you today.
- 5:46[SPEAKER_01]: I am Dr.
- 5:49[SPEAKER_01]: Lease to gear.
- 5:50[SPEAKER_01]: Actually, if you want to be formal, but Lisa is totally fine.
- 5:53[SPEAKER_01]: I'm a clinical psychologist and an author and a speaker.
- 5:58[SPEAKER_01]: and a childhood burns survivor.
- 6:00[SPEAKER_01]: I was burned when I was four, um, 65% just just, uh, I guess Charlene and I are like running neck and neck there with our percentages, right?
- 6:10[SPEAKER_01]: But um, I have been, you know,
- 6:16[SPEAKER_01]: It's been wonderful to come into community with other people who have the same concerns and values and issues and I'm also a founding member of CARD, just like Rachel and Charlene and thank you for having me today.
- 6:37[SPEAKER_03]: Absolutely.
- 6:37[SPEAKER_03]: Thank you.
- 6:38[SPEAKER_03]: Well, so much.
- 6:40[SPEAKER_03]: Um, so, um, we, what to focus on a little bit about on explaining what a face difference actually is.
- 6:54[SPEAKER_03]: I know that sometimes there can be, uh, questions about what we mean by
- 7:08[SPEAKER_03]: being used to explain what they're like.
- 7:12[SPEAKER_03]: So I want to pass it on the facilitator to give us a little overview of now patient differences.
- 7:21[SPEAKER_03]: And why some regularization seems different terms in different locations and more?
- 7:31[SPEAKER_03]: So I'll pass it on until you get it.
- 7:35[SPEAKER_02]: course and crucially I forgot to say I have a facial difference myself, I have facial scarring that I got in a car accident when I was 22 years old.
- 7:45[SPEAKER_02]: So that is one type of a facial difference that is an acquired facial difference that is what we should say someone might have through accident or disease that of course can be congenital conditions, things that people might be born with, birthmarks, clefts and then there are.
- 8:00[SPEAKER_02]: Episodic so facial differences that can change over time, pull these skin conditions and the language changes it's constantly evolving from person to person and place to place and that is very much okay.
- 8:14[SPEAKER_02]: That is what makes my job rather interesting is the fact that it is okay to self-identify, to choose the words that you feel most aligned to.
- 8:25[SPEAKER_02]: I personally am happy to reclaim the word disfigurement because it is the word that gives me rights, it is the word that is enshrined in lots of the quality laws across the globe, but also to me it's not the word that is negative, it's often the associations and I think there is power in reclaiming words as has been done in parallel movements such as the queer community
- 8:55[SPEAKER_02]: I think there is a lot to be learned from that, and I do think that the more we focus in on language, the more we keep ourselves away from the real, the real matter at hand whilst also recognising the importance of self-identification, and I think facial difference if and out is a great neutral term that I think has been largely coined in North America in recent years, and we at FEI have kind of
- 9:22[SPEAKER_02]: led into the fact that actually it's really come from activists, the grassroots community, focusing in on this term and therefore we have led by what we feel people are associating with most right now in this space.
- 9:41[SPEAKER_02]: and therefore it is more neutral, it is more inclusive and it is a great way to give the general public who often don't know what the right language is and there can be an uncomfortable mess around the right language.
- 9:55[SPEAKER_02]: I think it's a great term to be able to advise someone who doesn't know about this issue to use or often visible differences are word that we hear a lot as well which we tend
- 10:08[SPEAKER_02]: a condition that impacts the face and body or just the body alone.
- 10:13[SPEAKER_02]: That's the very long-winded way of talking about language.
- 10:18[SPEAKER_03]: I don't see anything, isn't it?
- 10:20[SPEAKER_03]: Yeah, and so I asked the staff to mention that I was going with
- 10:31[SPEAKER_03]: Uh, what we have somehow which is a, uh, congenital neurological, uh, condition and so that process facial paralysis.
- 10:41[SPEAKER_03]: Um, um, and so that would be, again, an example of, uh, I think it's a different step.
- 10:51[SPEAKER_03]: You want to go in with, um, really dimensioned there's, um,
- 10:57[SPEAKER_03]: there's different types of faces of visitors.
- 11:00[SPEAKER_03]: So you can acquire faces of visitors or some of them at the start of it.
- 11:08[SPEAKER_03]: So they come and go as well.
- 11:10[SPEAKER_03]: I think one of the things that is discussed a lot in the faces of different communities is how
- 11:27[SPEAKER_03]: It's the assumption that is a public plan have about someone who's a patient who's been for any kind of things, really, so I think some of them most common misconceptions are that people with patients who have intellectual disabilities, which is not obvious
- 11:55[SPEAKER_03]: not easily in the case, and so I'm really seeing someone for who they are, and not just that I think it is.
- 12:08[SPEAKER_03]: So I wanted to open it up to everyone who kind of maybe wanted to talk about their own personal experiences or maybe what
- 12:24[SPEAKER_03]: Some of them are actions that they have gotten in the public, showing I'm going to call on you just to if you want to talk about maybe some of the misconceptions that you have experience or if you have experience in anything in public that you want to come off the note note.
- 12:50[SPEAKER_00]: You know, early on, gosh, I would say probably 18 months or a year, 18 months after my injury, I still was wearing pressure garments, and I had a UVAX mask, which is the mask that you were to try to flatten the scars on your face to minimize the scarring.
- 13:11[SPEAKER_00]: And like out in public, people treated me like I was contagious.
- 13:17[SPEAKER_00]: I vividly remember that and I would be with my sister because I couldn't, you know, I was too vulnerable and couldn't be on my own doing, you know, a lot of things and we would be out shopping, for example.
- 13:32[SPEAKER_00]: and people would come right up to my sister and to me.
- 13:35[SPEAKER_00]: And instead of they'd say, is she going to be okay or what happened to her?
- 13:41[SPEAKER_00]: And thank goodness I had a sister who immediately said, well, she's standing right here, why don't you ask her?
- 13:48[SPEAKER_00]: So I mean, that's a good example to of what you mentioned, people think often think that there are also intellectual disabilities, which may or may not be the case.
- 14:00[SPEAKER_00]: I think as well as I change and after considerable reconstructive and plastic surgery like even today, it's rare, it's rare today because I'm so outgoing, I very much believe in disclosing, which you know, Kathleen Bogart has done a lot of research on that.
- 14:22[SPEAKER_00]: I think that when I say disclose, I just put it out there immediately when I meet a stranger.
- 14:29[SPEAKER_00]: If I, you know, I can detect that they're wondering what happened to me, they're curious.
- 14:34[SPEAKER_00]: We're all curious.
- 14:36[SPEAKER_00]: And so, you know, depending on my mood and how much I want to say, I'll just say, oh, I'm up here in Survivor, I'm doing great.
- 14:43[SPEAKER_00]: How are you doing today?
- 14:45[SPEAKER_00]: That's what particularly with adolescents or children, you know, I will go out of my way to stoop to their level and make eye contact with them when I can.
- 14:59[SPEAKER_00]: And I just asked them, have you ever met a burn survivor before and just try to engage with them?
- 15:05[SPEAKER_00]: But where I was going with that is that in restaurants, for example, what still happens and I don't pay any attention to it
- 15:14[SPEAKER_00]: We'll have people that will be seated next to us, and this particularly happens with men, and they'll ask to move to a different table, so they don't have to look at me.
- 15:26[SPEAKER_00]: Or in earlier on, I would have hostesses at restaurants, try to see us at the table in the back near the restroom.
- 15:37[SPEAKER_00]: And I would just say, you know, no, thank you.
- 15:39[SPEAKER_00]: We don't want to sit there, you know,
- 15:45[SPEAKER_00]: And everybody, you know, you've got to be really comfortable with yourself and with your body and with your appearance to be able to do that and everybody's not there and we can't expect everybody to be there because they're in different places, you know, adjusting to their difference and you know, there's so many variables involved as far as family support and
- 16:12[SPEAKER_00]: and things like that.
- 16:13[SPEAKER_00]: But though there was one that there and I'll share this because it's what you never want to do.
- 16:19[SPEAKER_00]: But again, early on, you have to visualize me, I was like maybe 99 pounds, and head to toe, and bandages, and that mask, and out, trying to set up a household
- 16:42[SPEAKER_00]: And we were actually at Macy's, and my sister was with me, and I noticed these two older women sort of standing to the side, and they were just gawking at me.
- 16:53[SPEAKER_00]: You know, there's a difference between a stair and a glare and a gawk.
- 16:58[SPEAKER_00]: And they just, you know, were whispering.
- 17:01[SPEAKER_00]: And finally, I just walked right over to them, and I just asked them, what the hell are you staring at?
- 17:06[SPEAKER_00]: That's not what you do.
- 17:09[SPEAKER_00]: But I was very newly burned.
- 17:11[SPEAKER_00]: I didn't have the resources.
- 17:14[SPEAKER_00]: I hadn't learned how to deal with the situation at that time.
- 17:19[SPEAKER_00]: But again, I've taken enough time.
- 17:22[SPEAKER_00]: But those are the three or four examples that really stand out for me.
- 17:30[SPEAKER_03]: Thank you, Chairman.
- 17:31[SPEAKER_03]: Thank you, Chairman.
- 17:32[SPEAKER_03]: And I think what you've said is very important.
- 17:37[SPEAKER_03]: is that not everyone with the pieces of notes will hang out in the same way, but everyone is comfortable talking about their pieces of notes or answering questions, but some people are, and education
- 18:07[SPEAKER_03]: And when we are all so much more than our citizens.
- 18:13[SPEAKER_03]: So I want to move on to talking about how to mean.
- 18:21[SPEAKER_03]: And this is kind of the point that if one of our is to dive into
- 18:37[SPEAKER_03]: helpful without the intent of being harmful.
- 18:44[SPEAKER_03]: So, Dr. Elise, I'm one moment, you can just slide off.
- 18:49[SPEAKER_03]: They're just questions by, kind of discussing by using facial differences as having any class in, and have me make enough of that on the facial difference community.
- 19:06[SPEAKER_01]: Sure, I'll I'll I'll start us off, but there's a lot of wisdom in this room.
- 19:11[SPEAKER_01]: So
- 19:14[SPEAKER_01]: I am entirely sure that most people when they're going shopping for Halloween costumes for their little kiddos, they're not thinking about this issue at all, right?
- 19:27[SPEAKER_01]: They're just thinking what's going to be fun for their child.
- 19:30[SPEAKER_01]: Maybe their child, you know, saw a scary movie and they want to embody that character and the parents go great, great idea.
- 19:42[SPEAKER_01]: And they're not thinking about the impact on people with the visible difference.
- 19:48[SPEAKER_01]: But it is jarring and upsetting and discouraging to see faces reflected back to me.
- 20:01[SPEAKER_01]: Anyway, burned faces, scarred faces, it, you know, my face is not a costume, right?
- 20:10[SPEAKER_01]: I'm just a person, I'm just a person doing the best I can with what I have.
- 20:17[SPEAKER_01]: It can feel like our situations, our struggles, our lifelong struggles are being mocked.
- 20:27[SPEAKER_01]: Um, also, and we'll get into this.
- 20:30[SPEAKER_01]: I know a little bit more in, in a little bit.
- 20:33[SPEAKER_01]: Um, associating burns and scars and facial difference with bad characters and evil characters actually has a big effect on the societal perception of who we really are.
- 20:48[SPEAKER_01]: And it's not a good one.
- 20:50[SPEAKER_01]: But I want to pass it along because there's, there's, again, a lot of wisdom in this room.
- 20:57[SPEAKER_03]: Yeah, absolutely.
- 20:58[SPEAKER_03]: Thank you.
- 20:58[SPEAKER_03]: That was that was a really great, and that was a great way to start off.
- 21:05[SPEAKER_03]: Until I'm going to pass along to you while you think that having wind classrooms can be detrimental to the face of the difference coming to me.
- 21:19[SPEAKER_05]: Yeah, no, thanks Kelsey and I completely agree with kind of how Lisa opened this up by saying, no, so many folks aren't actually thinking about this.
- 21:28[SPEAKER_05]: They see a popular character that's often a villain with a scar and whether it's a child or themselves, it's pop culture.
- 21:36[SPEAKER_05]: It's the cool costume to be this year and they're not actually thinking about what that may, how that may impact or affect those who do have visible and facial differences.
- 21:47[SPEAKER_05]: on a day-to-day basis.
- 21:49[SPEAKER_05]: So I know we'll get more into that, but you know I also think of it also on the flip side of even after Halloween is over because obviously this conversation is really important right now, but it happens all year long with the steering, the questions.
- 22:07[SPEAKER_05]: is when we will see you know someone posting themselves on social media with a facial scar and then you get those comments of like oh you look like this character from this movie are like you look like a Halloween costume.
- 22:22[SPEAKER_05]: So it's almost that like after effect that because of how some folks in
- 22:29[SPEAKER_05]: treat Halloween and dressing up with these villains, then it's like you'll year-long effective.
- 22:36[SPEAKER_05]: Oh, well, now your face looks like a villain.
- 22:43[SPEAKER_03]: Yeah, absolutely.
- 22:44[SPEAKER_03]: Thank you, Rental.
- 22:46[SPEAKER_03]: And I've seen
- 22:59[SPEAKER_03]: And I think that is an important point.
- 23:03[SPEAKER_03]: And it kind of brings me to my next point, my next question of what if someone says, oh, it's just a classroom, it's just Halloween.
- 23:19[SPEAKER_03]: What will be the best way to respond to that?
- 23:31[SPEAKER_02]: I think it's a common, like, come back, isn't it?
- 23:35[SPEAKER_02]: Oh, it's just make, believe it's not real.
- 23:38[SPEAKER_02]: It's not real life.
- 23:39[SPEAKER_02]: We can make the distinction between fiction.
- 23:42[SPEAKER_02]: And I think the research indicates that that's absolutely not the case.
- 23:48[SPEAKER_02]: We know terms like implicit bias or increasingly in our kind of dialogue nowadays.
- 24:00[SPEAKER_02]: how often do we see facial differences regarded as beautiful?
- 24:06[SPEAKER_02]: How often do we see the love interest in a film?
- 24:11[SPEAKER_02]: Who has a facial difference?
- 24:12[SPEAKER_02]: How often do we see just an incidental character that's just happens to be in the background?
- 24:17[SPEAKER_02]: Like the hero, the positive character, I think the issue
- 24:26[SPEAKER_02]: and it is insidious.
- 24:27[SPEAKER_02]: It's right from when a child is, it's not just films and TV, it's actually in children's books as well, which is the concept that I think scares me the most.
- 24:39[SPEAKER_02]: So it's not make believe what the way that we interact with the world is through stories, the way that we learn about others is through stories, especially if that's someone that's not in your immediate
- 24:54[SPEAKER_02]: we can estimate that one in 111 people have a facial difference but lots of people within this room if it wasn't for social media or charities or big events we never would have met each other so actually this doesn't impact that many people so
- 25:10[SPEAKER_02]: if every time you interact with facial difference, it's a negative character that the one that you say, oh, you shouldn't trust them.
- 25:16[SPEAKER_02]: They've got a scar or their character arc is that they got injured and then they turned about to be a body.
- 25:23[SPEAKER_02]: Obviously, that's just going to reinforce an aversion to difference.
- 25:29[SPEAKER_02]: You might be able to tell, okay, actually, it's just,
- 25:33[SPEAKER_02]: may believe it's not real, but it will reinforce the negative narrative and it will reinforce the idea that that is not the person that you will be attracted to, that is not the person that you want to be friends with, that is not the person that deserves dignity, rights, respect, and therefore I don't think I think it's incredibly simplistic for us to say that oh it's just may believe it's not real because stories are so, so fundamental to the way that
- 26:02[SPEAKER_02]: how powerful the media is right now, more than ever.
- 26:05[SPEAKER_02]: And actually, that's an important point.
- 26:08[SPEAKER_02]: When you see the the rhetoric around politicians as well, especially kind of the ones in the public eyes, especially when you see female politicians, often it's their appearance that will be attacked.
- 26:20[SPEAKER_02]: so often it is that we have this deeply ingrained connection between morality and someone's goodness and their appearance and it is the stories that we hear that just constantly reinforce that.
- 26:35[SPEAKER_02]: So now I don't believe in that rhetoric of it's just make believe.
- 26:41[SPEAKER_02]: but that wasn't a very simple clap-back that you can get into a conversation with someone around.
- 26:46[SPEAKER_02]: That was what you asked before, I didn't have it.
- 26:48[SPEAKER_02]: To pegs on my mood, sometimes I'll be polite, sometimes I'll be very much not polite.
- 26:55[SPEAKER_03]: Yeah, absolutely.
- 26:56[SPEAKER_03]: No, that is perfect.
- 26:57[SPEAKER_03]: Thank you so much for that.
- 26:58[SPEAKER_03]: Please go ahead.
- 27:01[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, Kelsey, could I back up?
- 27:02[SPEAKER_00]: I'm sorry, Lisa, that is the reason I was up here.
- 27:06[SPEAKER_01]: Okay, let me just add one more thing in here, which is, and I'm sitting here thinking as we're talking.
- 27:14[SPEAKER_01]: If you think about other, shall we say minority groups?
- 27:20[SPEAKER_01]: People of color.
- 27:22[SPEAKER_01]: Black people, Hispanic people.
- 27:28[SPEAKER_01]: people in wheelchairs, these would not be used as Halloween costumes.
- 27:34[SPEAKER_01]: It would be offensive, and everyone would know that it's offensive.
- 27:41[SPEAKER_01]: Our faces should be in that category as well.
- 27:46[SPEAKER_01]: It's offensive, everyone should be able to recognize.
- 27:50[SPEAKER_01]: We're not going to use something that's special
- 28:00[SPEAKER_03]: Thanks.
- 28:00[SPEAKER_03]: Awesome.
- 28:01[SPEAKER_03]: Yeah.
- 28:02[SPEAKER_03]: Charlie, please go ahead.
- 28:03[SPEAKER_00]: Well, I want to back up here for a minute because I want to go back to the costumes and I want to tell you this a quick story because this is really disturbing.
- 28:13[SPEAKER_00]: It's been 40 years since Freddie Kruger appeared on the stage.
- 28:19[SPEAKER_00]: And yet, these masks
- 28:22[SPEAKER_00]: take up a lot of space in these retail outlets that sell the Halloween costumes.
- 28:28[SPEAKER_00]: When I went looking to just see what was out there this year, there was a little girl who might have been five or six years old with her mother, with a little toddler in her arms, and a little girl immediately went over to this Freddie Kruger.
- 28:48[SPEAKER_00]: mask, and her mother was starting to help put it on her, but the little entered the little toddler started screaming, crying, you know, so upset about it.
- 29:01[SPEAKER_00]: But this is what
- 29:03[SPEAKER_00]: is so disturbing because these characters migrate off the screen into the schools, into the aisles of the shopping places where you buy this merchandise.
- 29:16[SPEAKER_00]: There were cups, there were little bobbleheads of different kinds of characters with scars and different sorts of
- 29:30[SPEAKER_00]: And I mean, this is what little five and six-year-olds.
- 29:35[SPEAKER_00]: It makes you really wonder if that little girl had seen for a group or what you really hope and pray never happened.
- 29:44[SPEAKER_00]: But it was absolutely just just so disturbing to see that.
- 29:52[SPEAKER_00]: And again, with clay face,
- 29:54[SPEAKER_00]: When people go to the movies this weekend to see Clayface, they're going to be able to buy a cup.
- 30:01[SPEAKER_00]: This is going to be his face melting.
- 30:04[SPEAKER_00]: They're going to sip their sodas out of this cup with this melted face on it.
- 30:10[SPEAKER_00]: And we'll again get into that a little bit later, but these things become a part of our culture.
- 30:20[SPEAKER_00]: that we're exposing to children just like Lisa and there are no programs in school and I work in schools.
- 30:31[SPEAKER_00]: There are no social and emotional skills training in public schools in America to teach people how to interact with others that look out of the ordinary or that they have disabilities.
- 30:45[SPEAKER_00]: Now, wonderful nonprofits, just like I'm about phase in CCA and the Phoenix Society Reintegration
- 30:58[SPEAKER_00]: beginning to get into these programs.
- 31:01[SPEAKER_00]: But, you know, just like we've said, if the scarcity of representation on television and film, and then the only major representation shows us as the villain, and then that's what society thinks.
- 31:18[SPEAKER_00]: That's why they're afraid.
- 31:20[SPEAKER_00]: That's why they have
- 31:29[SPEAKER_03]: Thanks, absolutely.
- 31:33[SPEAKER_03]: And I think I will put people realize how that you said it, how deeply ingrained the standards are and and and and I and I see it today as well.
- 31:49[SPEAKER_03]: On, you know, also familiar and I have and the most
- 32:00[SPEAKER_03]: Um, what you said about classics, like the Milton case, I've seen comments saying the same thing, like the old facements, like it's monthly and, and so comparing, um, feelings to actual neural people is helpful and, and there are so many alternatives to costumes
- 32:27[SPEAKER_03]: I'm not using face of instances as part of classes.
- 32:31[SPEAKER_03]: And so it's, it's funny about listening to these conversations that we're having today and talking to your friends and family and community about why these classes are so harmful to a regular community of people.
- 32:56[SPEAKER_03]: We're in conversation, thank you so much for all of this.
- 33:02[SPEAKER_03]: And now I'm going to do the wrong to touch on the media.
- 33:09[SPEAKER_03]: I'm sharing a time in the media and how some of the TV use
- 33:24[SPEAKER_03]: And so for them, so something about how, how only these stones have been in, how only kids are exposed through these characters, we think of them to this.
- 33:41[SPEAKER_03]: And what comes to mind for me, the first character that comes to mind is skull from lightning.
- 33:48[SPEAKER_03]: And skull has a skull.
- 33:51[SPEAKER_03]: And, and that time is what sets him apart and what makes him work evil.
- 34:01[SPEAKER_03]: And so, I'm wondering if anyone else has trying this as an example.
- 34:20[SPEAKER_03]: pattern.
- 34:21[SPEAKER_03]: And again, children are only following you again.
- 34:25[SPEAKER_03]: But I know that FBI has done extensive work on this topic.
- 34:31[SPEAKER_03]: So we're able to explain a little bit about that.
- 34:37[SPEAKER_03]: How it's helpful to the business of community.
- 34:41[SPEAKER_03]: And maybe
- 34:48[SPEAKER_02]: Sure, yeah, I think it's a testament to some of the people here in this room and that have really been behind some of the campaigns that have gone on, so whether that is what is now card, but what was previously, I guess a group of just wonderful change makers doing doing wonderful things, but we at FBI together with members of card and I want to say Nikki Averton, who used to work at the, um,
- 35:19[SPEAKER_02]: Phoenix Society puts together a position paper, which is still available and accompanying that now.
- 35:26[SPEAKER_02]: It is a petition which is on this very issue and within that position paper there is a combination of what research does exist to demonstrate the level of negative characters that have existed and I guess the link between representation of disability, disfigurement and
- 35:47[SPEAKER_02]: Historically, which has gone into lots of narratives.
- 35:50[SPEAKER_02]: It's in fairy tales, it's in old texts.
- 35:53[SPEAKER_02]: It's not just on our screens, it's in theater.
- 35:56[SPEAKER_02]: We've got Phantom of the Opera.
- 35:58[SPEAKER_02]: We've got all sorts of different films.
- 36:01[SPEAKER_02]: There's the latest odyssey that we know which has been a really bad one.
- 36:06[SPEAKER_02]: We've got some upcoming Marvel films that are coming out.
- 36:08[SPEAKER_02]: We know that later on in the year, where Wolf is going to be coming out, where they've given Lily Rose Depp a fake cleft.
- 36:16[SPEAKER_02]: Every bond villain seemingly has a facial difference as well.
- 36:21[SPEAKER_02]: So this issue is massive.
- 36:23[SPEAKER_02]: And no amount of us seemingly shouting up is seeming to get to the change makers, the producers, the casting agents, the writers, the people in the positions of power who get to make these decisions, who don't look like us.
- 36:38[SPEAKER_02]: They don't have our lived experiences.
- 36:40[SPEAKER_02]: Because I can tell you that if they did, they wouldn't be writing in these scripts,
- 36:46[SPEAKER_02]: teaching, not just young people, but also teaching adults that we are not to be respected, we are to be feared, we are less than we are to be othered.
- 36:55[SPEAKER_02]: So it's been part of our work at FFI for a long time to try and advocate for inclusion within the creative arts and recognizing the importance of inclusion from the inside out.
- 37:08[SPEAKER_02]: We have seen some progress in terms of, I guess, representation externally.
- 37:14[SPEAKER_02]: We've seen incidental kind of representation, particularly of people with disabilities, ready moving forward in the likes of the Barbie movie.
- 37:22[SPEAKER_02]: We saw kind of lots of incidental representation, but we have not seen our leading ladies, our leading guys, our leading men's.
- 37:30[SPEAKER_02]: We have not seen anything as good as it needs to be.
- 37:39[SPEAKER_02]: There's a long way to go, and we recognize that we need to be reaching people in positions of power, and that's why it's been such a joy to work with people from card who are in the room.
- 37:49[SPEAKER_02]: We're doing the talks, speaking to the customs directors, they're forging alliances with disability groups, they're speaking to documentary makers and trying to build allies so that there is someone in the room that essentially puts their hand up and says, hey, this is not okay.
- 38:06[SPEAKER_02]: it is bizarre that these films are reaching our cinemas and no one feels empowered enough to raise a hand and say this is not okay, this is highly offensive and it just goes to show how much I guess there is to do to disrupt the power imbalance of who it is that is making these films and green lighting these films and who it is behind the scenes that actually is being represented
- 38:36[SPEAKER_02]: From the inside out, we need to see writers, we need to see people in production, we need to see actors who can just act and not have to also be an advocate.
- 38:48[SPEAKER_02]: shouldn't have to be advocating for themselves and others in doing a whole other job on top of the job of acting.
- 38:56[SPEAKER_02]: And also having to weigh up the balance of, hey, should I accept this role where I'm playing like a zombie?
- 39:03[SPEAKER_02]: Or should I not actually eat and not pay my way to live?
- 39:09[SPEAKER_02]: Do you what I mean?
- 39:10[SPEAKER_02]: That's the toss-up here, is that people deserve opportunities and great to have people
- 39:17[SPEAKER_02]: who have lived experience playing these roles, but on balance with that, I know that people are having to weigh up the morality of these big decisions with their, you're essentially playing into those okay exterior types.
- 39:31[SPEAKER_02]: So, I'll stop there, so think about it, breath.
- 39:35[SPEAKER_03]: Yeah, thanks so much for that.
- 39:39[SPEAKER_03]: That's, that's really great.
- 39:47[SPEAKER_03]: Uh, like we talked about with the Halloween costumes, um, there are, again, the people who say it's just a movie, um, it doesn't matter.
- 39:59[SPEAKER_03]: It's just a movie and I think, or it's just a kind of drama on TV.
- 40:04[SPEAKER_03]: But I think, like we have time on the longer we have seen how, um,
- 40:14[SPEAKER_03]: seep into the public perception of the older patients and nurses and how that really does affect the real people living with patients and nurses.
- 40:31[SPEAKER_03]: And so I think there is a
- 40:44[SPEAKER_03]: What we've got is a blessing in talking about that and in, like, you know, having more positive representation of people with cases and cases.
- 41:15[SPEAKER_03]: And I think that's a very important point as well.
- 41:24[SPEAKER_03]: I want to open it up.
- 41:27[SPEAKER_03]: Does anyone else have anything they would like to discuss before we kind of wrap it up?
- 41:38[SPEAKER_00]: I was just going to add on a positive note here.
- 41:41[SPEAKER_00]: This new research by the Center for Appearance Research, their random controlled experiment where they had 103 people.
- 41:52[SPEAKER_00]: And what they did is they showed images to these people of individuals with a disfigurement.
- 42:00[SPEAKER_00]: And one of three versions, one is positive.
- 42:03[SPEAKER_00]: And there was a positive,
- 42:04[SPEAKER_00]: caption underneath it.
- 42:06[SPEAKER_00]: The second was neutral, you know, which is a neutral statement, and the third was negative, with some sort of negative caption about the person associated with that image.
- 42:21[SPEAKER_00]: And they clearly found that the negative image impacted the 103 people that viewed these images.
- 42:32[SPEAKER_00]: And so, you know, that affirmed what has beforehand I've been called anecdotal, like even these, I mean, this is a really important piece of research because it's the first peer-reviewed research that proves that showing those negative images with the negative captions causes people to
- 43:00[SPEAKER_00]: to be more likely to stay or to be more stigmatizing the behavior would be.
- 43:06[SPEAKER_00]: And that's despite the fact that there are two outstanding studies like one study looked at the top 200 U.S.
- 43:26[SPEAKER_00]: And they found out of those 200 films that 98 of the character has had a disfigurement.
- 43:34[SPEAKER_00]: And 61 of those 98 were villains.
- 43:41[SPEAKER_03]: So now we're going to move half of it up with, I don't know what you can do to make sure that having a game is one, one, and one.
- 43:51[SPEAKER_03]: Um, and that includes things like thinking about everything that we talked about earlier and just wanted to, um, that would be thinking twice about using splurins or other species differences as part of, you know, a costume or a child costume.
- 44:14[SPEAKER_03]: And really ask yourself what been packed your costume or the child costume.
- 44:21[SPEAKER_03]: might help others.
- 44:24[SPEAKER_03]: Also, it's important to share the information, the emails, and share this information with your friends and family and community.
- 44:34[SPEAKER_03]: And we learn that this is really something top of mind that everyone is thinking about.
- 44:42[SPEAKER_03]: And then I'll let the others speak to this, but they're on petitioned and other things that you can sign and they're into for more information about how to start.
- 44:59[SPEAKER_03]: Not only, they're having lots of things, but how to really make things really our company safe twice about using,
- 45:10[SPEAKER_03]: features it in terms of environments.
- 45:14[SPEAKER_03]: So I'm going to pass this along and run from if you want to tell us a little bit about some actual elements that people can paint and maybe we're going to get more information.
- 45:29[SPEAKER_05]: Yeah, of course.
- 45:30[SPEAKER_05]: I mean, I think the biggest take away of what you can do if you're listening to this right now is just remember that small actions small conversations can help.
- 45:41[SPEAKER_05]: change perceptions, whether it's around Hollywood or media, you know, when sometimes it's really daunting to think of, you know, especially with cardboard, small group and we're building, but to take on Hollywood is sometimes really scary to think about in the sense, because Hollywood's been around for a long time, uh,
- 46:01[SPEAKER_05]: And we're not going to, you know, change everything overnight, but by having no small conversations with your friends and family sharing this webinar with your community on social media, you know, especially if parents or caregivers are listening, having those conversations with your children around Halloween and perceptions, you know, just those small actions can make a big difference over time.
- 46:27[SPEAKER_05]: Um, so, you know, I know we were talking a lot about Halloween, but again, this conversation lasts all year long.
- 46:34[SPEAKER_05]: It's not just around this time of year, so I really encourage you again to talk to your friends and family, start that conversation.
- 46:42[SPEAKER_05]: Um, I know we would love to have you join our card group.
- 46:46[SPEAKER_05]: Um, so we'll make sure we maybe can share some info in the notes for the webinar, but we have a Facebook group, a Google group,
- 46:54[SPEAKER_05]: We're working on a website right now so we'd love to have you join and I'm sure Lisa and Charlene may have more to add there too.
- 47:00[SPEAKER_05]: But I think if everyone can take one small action after this webinar today, then we can really start building that momentum to make greater change.
- 47:11[SPEAKER_03]: Yeah, absolutely.
- 47:24[SPEAKER_03]: and if anyone is interested in joining, definitely will come to the phone or one of the others who are thinking of them for that reason.
- 47:34[SPEAKER_03]: That would be a lot of them.
- 47:36[SPEAKER_03]: Lisa, I will call on you anything to add and we add to the items that you would like to see.
- 47:42[SPEAKER_03]: We'll fit.
- 47:44[SPEAKER_01]: Well, you both did a great job already.
- 47:47[SPEAKER_01]: I'll just maybe add in just to supplement all of your ideas.
- 47:54[SPEAKER_01]: First of all, we talked about a card, and that stands for, and that we set it, but just one more time, the coalition for authentic representation of difference and disability.
- 48:05[SPEAKER_01]: Excuse me, just figure me in the difference, boy.
- 48:08[SPEAKER_01]: And so our goals, just so you know when you're really clear what we're trying to do, we're trying to
- 48:14[SPEAKER_01]: Um, reduce and maybe even eliminate, um, the use of scars and disfigurement, uh, to signify felony and TV and movie.
- 48:25[SPEAKER_01]: We're looking to increase positive representation of people who look different.
- 48:31[SPEAKER_01]: We're looking to help advise the entertainment industry on best practices and most important maybe we're looking to educate everyone that we can possibly talk to about this issue.
- 48:45[SPEAKER_01]: So just listening to this is we've already achieved some of our goals that you have listened to our message today.
- 48:54[SPEAKER_01]: If you want to know a little bit more, I did a TED talk a couple years ago, it's called scarred, not scary.
- 49:02[SPEAKER_01]: And if you google my name and scarred not scary, you'll find it.
- 49:05[SPEAKER_01]: And it's a, you know, quick, 18-minute overview of
- 49:09[SPEAKER_01]: this issue and a little bit more detail and I think it can be helpful too and we have in addition to we would love if you would join us we have um there's a petition through face-to-quality international that is petitioning Hollywood to stop these dangerous representations there's a new petition through changing faces so we can use your voice um you know as Rachel said
- 49:39[SPEAKER_01]: And we are small, but we have right on our side.
- 49:47[SPEAKER_01]: And we have compassion on our side.
- 49:49[SPEAKER_01]: And anytime you are spready helping to spread our message, teaching kids, maybe if they see a scarred person that they don't have to be scared of them, teaching kids if they see a scarred villain on film to kind of maybe even stop the film for a minute and say, you know what?
- 50:09[SPEAKER_01]: That's scar doesn't mean they're scary.
- 50:11[SPEAKER_01]: They're just scary because that's their character, but that's scar that has nothing to do with it.
- 50:16[SPEAKER_01]: I know plenty of people who are scarred, who are wonderful people.
- 50:19[SPEAKER_01]: So don't think it's the same thing.
- 50:21[SPEAKER_01]: Help us educate.
- 50:23[SPEAKER_01]: Okay, I'll stop now and maybe pass along to you, Charlene.
- 50:27[SPEAKER_00]: And this is why I decided to go last because you all have done such an eloquent job of talking about all the wonderful things that we can can do.
- 50:37[SPEAKER_00]: You touched on one that I thought of that takes to take a little planning maybe for next year that those of us that do any work in schools could possibly suggest some sort of program prior to Halloween where we
- 50:52[SPEAKER_00]: talk about this issue and introduce it or maybe come up with some sort of activity or something to bring people together.
- 51:01[SPEAKER_00]: You know, whether it might be a mask making fun of it and then talking about the mask and you could enter.
- 51:08[SPEAKER_00]: We've.
- 51:10[SPEAKER_00]: you know, how that the mask for villains, you know, the prosthetics.
- 51:16[SPEAKER_00]: So, but again, I think that like what Rachel and everybody's kind of talked touched on to is these grassroots individual conversations, even like the one I just had moments ago with a group of women from church that talking to them, showing them that Freddie Kruger mask and talking
- 51:40[SPEAKER_00]: the screen into schools, into the shocks, and those sorts of things that, you know, it doesn't happen overnight, but little by little you educate people and you make them aware because like Lisa said early on in the presentation.
- 52:00[SPEAKER_00]: Other than Hollywood, I think it's a rarity that people intentionally do these things.
- 52:06[SPEAKER_00]: I think it's a lack of education that causes so much of the problem.
- 52:12[SPEAKER_00]: And then the other thing, and I need to do a much better job of this because I don't have any time hardly to spend a social media.
- 52:21[SPEAKER_00]: But we really must do a better job of promoting
- 52:25[SPEAKER_00]: all of these things that we all do, like, you know, like Lisa's TED talk or her, you know, or she posts a lot and doing that or, you know, things with the Phoenix is that all the organizations, everybody that's doing something to promote this cause, because we've kind of siloed and we've got to find a way out of that silo.
- 52:52[SPEAKER_00]: and to break those algorithms that keep us talking to the people that we don't really need to reach.
- 53:02[SPEAKER_00]: So that's something.
- 53:04[SPEAKER_00]: Again, if you're a speaker or a writer, write, try to publish things, share them, and we are going to commit to
- 53:13[SPEAKER_00]: to doing a better job, you know, just like this podcast, I keep calling out a podcast, the webinar, to share it with other people and ask them to share it.
- 53:23[SPEAKER_00]: So I'll leave it at that, and again, Kelsey, thank you so much for putting this all together.
- 53:32[SPEAKER_03]: Absolutely.
- 53:32[SPEAKER_03]: No, thank you all for being here and sharing all of this.
- 53:42[SPEAKER_03]: who want things to take away, that you all have said, and this has been very meaningful, so I will continue to help you here.
- 53:52[SPEAKER_03]: And like you said, Charlie, we need to kind of bring out a
- 54:10[SPEAKER_03]: One of the most important things that you can do if you want to watch him is to share this one of our this information for friends and community and family and make sure that everyone serves this message and is educated about these differences and how they are in the same sense in a lot of ways.
- 54:39[SPEAKER_03]: Thank you all so much for the time of being here.
- 54:44[SPEAKER_03]: Thank you everyone who is watching.
- 54:46[SPEAKER_03]: We really, really appreciate your time as well.
- 54:50[SPEAKER_03]: And we really have appreciated being able to share this message and our experiences with everyone.
- 54:59[SPEAKER_03]: So thank you.
- 55:01[SPEAKER_03]: And yeah, share this as well as you can.
- 55:06[SPEAKER_00]: And happy Halloween at the state hall.
- 55:09[SPEAKER_00]: Yes.
- 55:10[SPEAKER_03]: I don't know.
- 55:12[SPEAKER_03]: Thank you.
- 55:13[SPEAKER_01]: OK.
- 55:14[SPEAKER_01]: Thanks, Kelsey.
- 55:15[SPEAKER_01]: Thank you.
- 55:21[SPEAKER_05]: Well, thank you again to Kelsey and about face for hosting today's podcast episode.
- 55:27[SPEAKER_05]: To just quickly wrap up, as I know, we had a few technical difficulties at the end of the episode.
- 55:34[SPEAKER_05]: Don't you love technology and when just decides to kick Kelsey out and start some computer upgrades at the time of our recording.
- 55:42[SPEAKER_05]: So I just wanted to kind of quickly recap some points to remember after today's episode.
- 55:50[SPEAKER_05]: I think the big theme of it here is there's a lot of work to do and using your voices and your stories can make a difference.
- 55:59[SPEAKER_05]: You know, but we're not going to change it overnight.
- 56:01[SPEAKER_05]: We have to make a few small steps at a time to see big change in the future.
- 56:06[SPEAKER_05]: You know, we talked a lot about kind of intent versus impact on the episode.
- 56:11[SPEAKER_05]: And, you know, most who will don't intend to harm with their Halloween costumes or with these portrayals of villains or those with differences.
- 56:20[SPEAKER_05]: But that doesn't mean that costumes can't be harmful.
- 56:24[SPEAKER_05]: One tactic, you know, sometimes I may use
- 56:27[SPEAKER_05]: If someone says, you know, it's just a costume.
- 56:30[SPEAKER_05]: It's meant for fun.
- 56:31[SPEAKER_05]: You know, you can apply with, yes, how will an is meant to be fun?
- 56:35[SPEAKER_05]: But using someone's everyday appearance or difference doesn't make a costume funny or for fun.
- 56:42[SPEAKER_05]: It does have impacts on how we view ourselves or how others view us on a day-to-day basis.
- 56:51[SPEAKER_05]: You know, in the biggest takeaway from that is, you know, scars aren't scary.
- 56:55[SPEAKER_05]: a physical difference whether that's on your face or your arm or anywhere in your body shouldn't be used as a shorthand for evil or danger.
- 57:04[SPEAKER_05]: We need to start having more positive patrols of burn survivors and any moment with the visible difference or hidden difference for that matter.
- 57:13[SPEAKER_05]: in movie and film and books in media because representation does matter repeated materials influence how we see others and how we see ourselves and that's not okay we to my point you know we need to have and see more positive materials of those with visible differences.
- 57:34[SPEAKER_05]: I know with this episode's coming out right around Halloween and of course this is a very timely conversation
- 57:43[SPEAKER_05]: you know, burn survivors, navigate assumptions and sigma long after Halloween ends, whether that's common.
- 57:49[SPEAKER_05]: So on social media or just comments out in public, you know, scars aren't scary.
- 57:55[SPEAKER_05]: And we need to continue to make an impact to change that, that connotation.
- 58:02[SPEAKER_05]: And whether you're listening to this as a burn survivor, as someone with a facial difference or
- 58:08[SPEAKER_05]: just a friend or ally of our community, everyone can help.
- 58:12[SPEAKER_05]: Thoughtful costume choices, conversations, especially with children and authentic representation can make a difference.
- 58:21[SPEAKER_05]: So thank you again, Kelsey, and about face for hosting today's episode, and I hope we all can have some takeaways and celebrate Halloween in a fun, enjoyable way for all.
- 58:33[SPEAKER_05]: Thanks, everyone, and I will see you again on our next episode.
- 58:43[SPEAKER_04]: Thanks so much for tuning in to this episode of Girls With Graphs.
- 58:47[SPEAKER_04]: If you are enjoying this content, please feel free to rate, subscribe, and leave our review wherever you listen to your podcasts.
- 58:53[SPEAKER_04]: This helps others find the show, and we greatly appreciate it.
- 58:57[SPEAKER_04]: Thanks again for listening, and we'll catch you in the next episode.