Latest / PNW Haunts & Homicides / Innocence & Injustice: The Steve Titus Story - Part 1
Transcript
- 0:00Probably not exactly the birthday plans that either of them had envisioned, but they understood
- 0:07that a serious crime had occurred, and they wanted to help if they could.
- 0:11Steve was polite and cooperative throughout the entirety of these interactions,
- 0:17even smiling in the mug shot taken of him at the time.
- 0:20"It's probably what I would do to frame it."
- 0:23"It's funny you should say that because,
- 0:26because of the celebratory nature of their evening up to that point,
- 0:30the pair even asked if a photo of the two of them could be taken."
- 0:34"Hi, Kelsey." "Hi, Caitlin." "Hi, creepy people."
- 0:43"Hello, hello." "Hello, what?"
- 0:45"I'm pretty sure he did something really weird with my eye because
- 0:49some lashes are falling into it." "Oh."
- 0:53"So if I was like that, it's fine, don't mind me." "That's why."
- 0:57"I'm used to being in a podcast and not on a video."
- 1:00"It's true. Yeah, it's a little bit of an adjustment, and I have a lot more lash going on right now.
- 1:07I'm very blonde. It's a real adjustment. If you'll say I super glued my eyelids together."
- 1:15"It kind of looks like it." "Does it?" "Oh no."
- 1:20"I'm kidding. She looks so pretty." "I mean, I look okay, but I'm all done up for our engagement show
- 1:28later. So." "Yeah, and I really brought it down on my side just to make her look even better."
- 1:35"Oh my god." "Yeah, because, um, Cassie and I are engagement show." No.
- 1:40"I won't be in these photos. Just this camera here right now."
- 1:48"All right, fine. I was going to invite you, but whatever."
- 1:52"If you're new to our creepy corner of the world, this is PNW Hunts and Homicides,
- 2:01where we chat about true crime, paranormal, and all things creepy in the Pacific Northwest,
- 2:07and also occasionally mango sparkling wine." "In our show."
- 2:12The show that we're doing right now and presenting for you, we do a tarot reading at the end of every
- 2:18episode for a little deeper insight into what we're talking about for the day. "Yeah, it's true.
- 2:24We'll do it again today." "Yeah, we do it every time." "Yeah, mostly." "Listen, there's always an
- 2:29exception to the rule." "Yeah, usually for like bonuses, which we have on our Patreon."
- 2:34"Sometimes we do bonusy things." "Oh man, we do bonus episodes. What else do we do, Caitlin?"
- 2:45"We're working on getting them videos for every episode. Add free." "Add free they already have."
- 2:52"Yes, just to be clear." "Oh my goodness, do we have any businessy business to get to, do you think?"
- 2:58"I'm an announcement. It's hot today." "Yeah, it's really hot." "And it was hot yesterday,
- 3:04and it went to the beach, and it was a perfect beach day at Oregon." "It was like one of those rare,
- 3:10very rare warm beach days. It was great." "Yeah, that sounds so lovely." "Hey, no, come to Oregon, come to the
- 3:18coast." "Or don't, because there's already too many people here, but you know, whatever, do you?"
- 3:24"Sorry, I made it like really enticing, I didn't mean to. I thought we wanted our creepy friends to
- 3:31come hang out." "We do what?" "Damn it." "All right." "If you live at the coast, I would not be opposed to
- 3:38inviting me to a house party." "Oh, bonfire." "Yeah, type thing." "Yeah." "Are you ready?" "Yeah, I'm ready."
- 3:46"Okay." "Freak my heart." "She's not ready, but here we go." On October 12th of 1980, at 7.22 PM,
- 3:56a 911 call was placed from a secluded road south of SeaTac, the Seattle airport.
- 4:05But SeaTac, if you're nasty. "Yeah, yeah, yeah." "We are." "Yeah, of course." "Of course."
- 4:09Reporting to the dispatcher that a young girl had just been raped, she said that her attacker
- 4:17had instructed her to stand in front of his vehicle until he drove away following the assault.
- 4:24She was terrified that he would shoot her because he'd made no attempt to obscure his face or
- 4:31hide his identity. "Oh, wow. Bulzy." "Pretty Bulzy." "But yeah, I could see how she would come to that
- 4:39conclusion that's fucking terrifying." "He's like, just walk away from the car. Nothing else bad will
- 4:44happen." "Wing-wing, no, Jenudge, Saint-O' War." "When she was able to confirm he left the immediate
- 4:51area, she ran to a hillside home. The humble home was situated on her right-hand side just a very
- 4:59short walk away, which was lucky considering Sunset was over an hour prior to her making that short
- 5:07trek. So, it's guard-outside." "Yeah." "It belonged to Paul Liston. He was a retired carpenter who was the
- 5:18last holdout in the area. Everyone else had sold the property to the airport." "Oh, it was going to be
- 5:25part of an airport expansion at some point." "Okay." So, it was his call that came in to 911
- 5:34dispatch at 722 that evening. The victim's description of her attacker addressed kind of the essential,
- 5:44all of the essentials related to his physical features and appearance, but it wasn't going to give
- 5:51the investigators a lot to go on on that alone. She had been attacked by a white male aged approximately
- 6:0125 to 30, standing about six-foot tall, with a medium build, as well as a beard and shoulder length
- 6:10light-brown hair. At the time of the attack, he was wearing a three-piece cream-colored suit." "What?"
- 6:20"Yeah." "Weird." "That is really weird." "Row weird." "Do you just come from like a wedding or something?"
- 6:28"What?" "Yeah." "Yeah." "It's a weird choice." "Very noticeable too." "Uh-huh." "If there's going to be a lot of
- 6:39weird color palette choices, and that's when you need to remember, this was the 1980s." "Okay."
- 6:49When later questioned, the port police's number one suspect informed them that he didn't even own a suit.
- 6:56Let alone a cream-colored one. "Right." "I don't even have one of those." "Yeah." "Who'd have one of those?"
- 7:04"Oh, well, okay. It's a very impractical wardrobe choice. I would argue." "Yeah." "But I don't know,
- 7:13maybe other people can, you know, function in light-colored clothing. I, for one, would have to swear
- 7:21off like all forms of sauce." "Yeah." "No condiments for this gal." "I don't know how people are doing that."
- 7:31"No condiments for you tonight." "Um." "You're wearing very light-colored clothing." "Oh no." "Oh no."
- 7:40"Okay, well, good thing we had some fancy sauce before we decided to record." "She's cut off from the
- 7:46fancy sauce." "So cool." "Consequences." "The man was driving a blue car with a blue interior,
- 7:56which frankly sounds pretty hideous." "Wow. He's very, what is that called, like, monochromatic?" "Yeah."
- 8:03"Like, keeping in the same color palette just different shades." "I didn't even really pick up on
- 8:09that, but you're so right." "But it was very of the time." "The 80s, am I right?" "What up with YouTube?"
- 8:17Jerry Seinfeld had like, "Oh, right, right, right, right, yeah." "Yeah."
- 8:23She was also able to describe various items that she had noticed inside his car during the attack.
- 8:32But perhaps most importantly, she said that he had a temporary license plate with digits six and seven
- 8:40repeating in some form. So she was pretty sure it was like a six, six, seven, or maybe a seven, seven, six.
- 8:47"Okay." "If it were me, that's exactly how I would bust one of these fuckers. I would rainman the
- 8:55shit out of them. Okay, because numbers that are useless, oh, I will remember them until I die."
- 9:03"Hopefully you don't have to do that ever." "Yeah, yeah, no, I'm just saying like, when I'm driving
- 9:09around in my car, like I'm looking at license plates and I'm just playing all kinds of fun math
- 9:15games with the numbers on people's plates." "We're no." "Yeah." "Now, let me say it out loud,
- 9:23that does seem pretty weird." "Well, weird." "Okay, that's okay, we accept you for who you are."
- 9:29"Okay, great, because that's just kind of the type of neuro-spicy bullshit that my brain picks up on."
- 9:35You know, especially when it's left to its own devices, at length. And I would have to imagine
- 9:42probably most especially when it's attempting to disassociate or going into essentially self-protection
- 9:51mode. So, that's super exciting though, right? Because that's got to be something, like a piece of
- 10:02hard, trackable data that feels evidently, right? Kind of, maybe a little? Yeah. I'm not sure how far
- 10:10you would get though. That doesn't... Yeah, exactly. It's a little bit like, you know, maybe we'll get lucky.
- 10:19Maybe all of the blue sedans with blue interior are registered to plates that start with eights.
- 10:26Who knows? Yeah. As investigators work the case, they began developing the rough outlines of their theory.
- 10:35They felt that it seemed pretty likely that the assailant lived in the area nearby.
- 10:42So, they began searching the area around Pacific Highway Sound. As luck would have it. A light blue
- 10:511981 Chevy Chevette was located at 120 AM. No one was in it at the time it was initially spotted,
- 11:03so officers waited for the driver to return to the vehicle. They figured it was worth sitting on
- 11:11the car for 20 or 30 minutes if that's what it took. I mean, how often is law enforcement going to get
- 11:18handed a potential lead on a silver platter like this? Yeah. Maybe ruminating in the restaurant
- 11:28parking lot set things off on the wrong foot though. They were immediately suspicious of the man
- 11:35leaving the restaurant with a young attractive woman alongside him. Was she his next victim?
- 11:42I don't know. I hope not. They had very little doubt that they had found their man.
- 11:48Because, you know, it's a blue car. So, well, did they...
- 11:52I'm not going to ask any more questions. I'm just going to let you go. You won't be happy with the answers.
- 11:59Yeah. Well, did they check though? I mean, they are... This is literally less than six hours after the
- 12:07car. I'm essentially... So, guys, I don't think you've solved it. I could be wrong, but I rarely am.
- 12:15Yeah, it seems a little bit like... He's your suspect, right? Not like your...
- 12:21Like he's not even a suspect at this point. Because they have no idea who that car belongs to.
- 12:28He's a person of interest. Yeah. At best. A suspected suspect. Yes, exactly. Yeah. There's layers.
- 12:35It's like a Bloomin onion at the outback, you know? However, while this was a white man with a
- 12:44similar hairstyle and facial hair, again, I'd like to say it was the '80s, he wasn't exactly a perfect
- 12:52match in their estimation. Because he was only about 5'8", and the victim believed her attacker
- 12:59had been roughly six feet tall. Yeah, it's like a little bit taller than 5'8".
- 13:04Us. Well, come lunches, four inches. Yeah. The witness could have been mistaken about his height.
- 13:12Sometimes one detail of a victim's statement might be slightly off, especially after such a traumatic
- 13:18experience. But they weren't going to let this probably super guilty dude drive off into the
- 13:25sunset with another would-be victim. They wouldn't let that happen. No. So they sort of made up or
- 13:35maybe exaggerated just a little bit about a minor traffic infraction as the man made his way down
- 13:42the road so that they could pull the pair over. Is that legal? I mean, it's only illegal if you could
- 13:51cut. Okay. And they are police officers, so they probably won't. Probably not at first.
- 14:00The 31-year-old man, Steve Titus, told officers that he and his fiance Mona were returning home to
- 14:10Kent. He had picked her up from Denny's at 930 to celebrate her 21st birthday with a drink.
- 14:17Yeah, it sounds sweet. I don't know if it's true, but yeah.
- 14:21Earlier that day, in the afternoon, he had attended a family gathering until he returned home at around
- 14:28630. From then on, he'd hung out with a friend watching a movie until he left to pick up Mona.
- 14:36Titus assured the officers that his friend that he'd been with prior to picking up Mona could vouch
- 14:43for his whereabouts. Okay, Alibi, City. All right. In fact, right around the time his friend showed up
- 14:52at the apartment, he'd placed a call to Mona at 7pm on the dot. Okay.
- 15:01Steve Titus was a super easygoing dude. So he allowed authorities to search his vehicle,
- 15:09while both he and Mona were questioned individually. He was informed that he matched the description
- 15:16of the attacker provided by the victim. Steve Titus agreed to answer questions at the police station.
- 15:26Even after being told they were investigating a rape allegation involving an attacker
- 15:33that was a preliminary match to his physical description. Yikes. Yeah. Without a lawyer, did he get a lawyer?
- 15:41Well, I mean, if you're not guilty, why would you need a lawyer? Right? Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Why would you?
- 15:55I wonder. Oh, no. Hmm. Let's see how it plays out.
- 15:59Probably not exactly the birthday plans that either of them had envisioned, but
- 16:11they understood that a serious crime had occurred and they wanted to help if they could.
- 16:17Gosh, especially its Mona's birthday, right? Like, she didn't have anything to do with this at all.
- 16:24Exactly. Steve was polite and cooperative throughout the entirety of these interactions,
- 16:31even smiling in the mug shot taken of him at the time. Oh, because I was probably like, yeah,
- 16:37this is like, I'll probably never get to do this again because I'm like such a good person.
- 16:42Exactly. Probably what I would do to frame it. It's funny you should say that because,
- 16:49because of the celebratory nature of their evening up to that point, the pair even asked if a photo
- 16:56of the two of them could be taken. They figured, won't this be an interesting story to tell at a
- 17:03cocktail party or to our kids someday? Yeah. Oh, remember that birthday of yours that we spent,
- 17:14you know, a good chunk of the night down at the police station. We just wanted to really try to help
- 17:20the police solve this crime. Yeah, it's a crazy story. Yeah, you need proof. Yeah, because man,
- 17:27if you told anybody about what had happened up to this point, they'd be like, no way. Yeah,
- 17:33Pixar didn't happen. Yeah, Pixar didn't happen. Mug shots or didn't happen. Yeah.
- 17:43Because of course, they both knew Steve had zero involvement in the crime.
- 17:48So what was the harm in cooperating with the police? They were just doing their jobs.
- 17:54They were totally doing their job.
- 17:57Totally doing their job the way they're supposed to and not anything else.
- 18:04Feel like you're lying. Sometimes I lie, but it's always on accident. Or to create
- 18:12suspense. Or it's always on accident or it's on purpose. Like I said, or to create suspense.
- 18:19Potato potato. Either way, she's always lying. Yikes. Anywho. Just kidding, I trust her.
- 18:29Not long after their visit to the police station, a photo montage was shown to the teenage victim.
- 18:40In fact, it was just the day of following the attack. And it was conducted in her mother's to come
- 18:47home. She reviewed carefully for some moments and then pointed to Titus, stating that it had to be him.
- 18:57He was the closest one. What do you make of that? Not good. No, no, not good. Immediately based on what she says.
- 19:09You know, red flags. Yeah. Yeah, if these are the only options, that's the guy because he has a beard.
- 19:18Yeah. Yeah. I'd also like to point out that based on the way this is worded, it sounds like she
- 19:29believes that the perpetrator is most assuredly included amongst the photos. And it's up to her
- 19:38to determine which of the men it was, rather than simply reviewing to identify someone.
- 19:47Whether the attacker was amongst the men's photographs shown to her.
- 19:53It's just like a huge set up. It feels like. Yeah. I just don't get worse. And it's like,
- 20:02it's not her fault. It's not her job to know like what the right thing to do in the situation. Exactly.
- 20:08That's what the trained professionals are for. Or in this case, perhaps untrained monkeys.
- 20:17But poor Celia, that was her name, Celia. Of course, as a victim of sexual assault,
- 20:28particularly as a minor, initially her name was kept private. But later, she would decide that she
- 20:36wanted to share her story with the public. Wow. Without an attorney present, Steve Titus was
- 20:44interviewed by law enforcement again. He provided an additional statement regarding his whereabouts
- 20:51at the time of the assault. This session was not recorded. Why not? It's a really good question.
- 21:00Isn't that like evidence? Usually a thing that you're supposed to.
- 21:06Sounds like a good idea to me.
- 21:09That night, Steve Titus had been driving a company vehicle. He worked for Iverse,
- 21:20Seafood as District Manager, overseeing roughly 100 other employees of the company
- 21:26between seven area locations. Well, he did. It didn't take long for his life to be turned
- 21:37completely upside down by this case. He was arrested at the company's office on October 14th
- 21:48by Port Police just days after the crime. Normally, I would say alleged sexual assault,
- 21:57but it's without question that Celia was attacked. However, the question remained
- 22:06regardless of how decided law enforcement seemed. Was Steve Titus the guilty party?
- 22:17Following his arrest, Steve was able to post his bail of $2,500 after spending the night in jail.
- 22:24That's not a lot. Well, it was 1980. I mean, a little bit more, but still, I guess it wasn't murder.
- 22:31I guess I usually hear those things associated with murder. It's a lot more.
- 22:36It does tend to be a pretty significant sum.
- 22:43Well, this is something you'll be interested in. You asked about this, actually. Is it about ghosts?
- 22:47No. His next step was hiring an attorney who luckily believed his pleas of innocence.
- 22:57I would hope so. It's a good word. Well, okay. Defends attorneys don't always believe that their
- 23:03client is innocent. They are just, you know, like anybody else entitled to a good defense.
- 23:09Right. Now, despite the fact that it would not be admissible in court, the prosecution was willing
- 23:17to strike a deal. That if Steve passed a polygraph, the charges against him would be dropped.
- 23:24Oh, boy. Okay. Not admissible in court, but we'll go ahead and drop the charges if you pass.
- 23:32That literally makes no sense, like no sense. It was the '80s wild times. Yeah.
- 23:40The man conducting the examination was dui Gillespie. He was a former Seattle police
- 23:49polygrapher. Now, obviously, Steve is thinking, yeah, I'll do it because he's like, you'll just drop
- 23:58the charges. It's like a medicine. And of course, it'll be like negative, right? Or pass. I don't know
- 24:04what the, yeah. Of course. Of course, I'm going to get off scot free because I didn't do this.
- 24:11All accounts indicated that dui Gillespie, he's the one administering the polygraph that he's a very
- 24:21kind and ethical man. He was also a very well-respected expert in the particular field.
- 24:29Okay. Like being an expert in bullshit doesn't... Yeah. Well, he actually, I will say this, he has
- 24:37some things to say that I think the prosecution probably was like, you don't, you don't, you don't
- 24:46got to say that. He understood the limitations of the polygraph. Okay. But, you know, it's an imperfect,
- 24:56I want to say science because that's the phrase, but it's, I mean, my god, it's
- 25:02pseudo-science is that what it's called? I mean, almost. Yeah, I mean, there's real science involved,
- 25:08but like... There's little little duhickeys that go back and forth. You know, you know, the duhickeys.
- 25:14The duhickeys. Yeah. Is that how they still do it or was that like a really old school type of thing?
- 25:19You know, I don't know. I would assume. Yeah. And they're just not in popular usage. Yeah.
- 25:29Not, I mean, certainly not with the frequency that they once were. So I can't imagine like,
- 25:35you're not going to be upgrading your polygraph machinery at this point. I was thinking, like, maybe
- 25:39now it's like on a computer and they like look you up, but it's like on a computer screen, you know,
- 25:44not just like... And it could be. I think I have seen tests where it's like, oh, this doesn't look like,
- 25:49you know, we time-traveled back to 1930. Yeah. But yeah, I don't know. If anyone's taken a
- 25:56polygraph recently, email us and let us know what it was like. Yeah, right after you email your lawyer.
- 26:02Because who the hell let you do that? I mean, some people just have to take them like in the military.
- 26:09Which is just... Okay, we can't go down this road. We can't go down this road. I'm just going to get
- 26:19upset and then I'm going to start losing eyelashes and I can't with this. No. But I have no strong
- 26:27feelings on the topic as per usual. All right. Both the prosecution and defense agreed to him
- 26:35administering the polygraph exam to Steve. Because that's the deal they struck. And like I said, he's known
- 26:43for being like fair, ethical, he's a good dude. And he's real good at this. Unfortunately, when Steve
- 26:53failed the polygraph test, because turns out being real anxious might impact the result.
- 27:03There was only one other option offered in lieu of prison time, admit guilt, and submit to a
- 27:12treatment program at a state hospital for sexual psychopaths. Oh my god, the real guy is still out there.
- 27:20Wait, no, Cassie, they've got him. No, they don't. Yeah. You've been Steve didn't do it. It's not great.
- 27:32Steve is such like a nice guy name. I feel like maybe that maybe I'm biased because like I have an
- 27:37uncle named Steve. Yeah. My mom's wife and his name is Steve. Steve. He's probably not listening,
- 27:43but that's okay. Yeah. My mom will be like, Steve, I play this for you real quick.
- 27:47Do you know what I realized? What? The like, I think it was the Beetlejuice episode. I mentioned my
- 27:54mom like three different times that I'm constantly talking about my mom. Yeah. Well, is that
- 28:00weird? She's adorable and lovely. She's funny and just, yeah, I'm not seeing the problem, I guess,
- 28:08is what I'm getting at. I love my mom. Sorry. I just love my mom. I'm like, again, still not seeing
- 28:15the problem. I'm obsessed. Have you seen the show Smothered? That's not like it's reverse mother.
- 28:23She's like, God, I wish I could get away from my mom. Of course, being the honest and exuberant young man
- 28:34that he was completely assured of his innocence. Steve declined and so the case went to trial.
- 28:42That's the place where we're supposed to have a very well-defined set of rules to help a jury
- 28:50of his peers determine whether he was guilty of the crime beyond a reasonable doubt.
- 28:56Just a quick refresher on that process because there's been a few things that haven't gone exactly.
- 29:02Like, there's most. Yeah. What's unreasonable doubt? I don't think that's, I think that's one of those
- 29:12terms that like doesn't really go both ways. It's like, is it doubt? Just say doubt. Yeah. I don't know.
- 29:19Well, okay. So they do define what reasonable doubt is. So I guess the flip side there is
- 29:27unreasonable doubt. But the way that they define it, it's not really intended to be like
- 29:33two opposites. It's intended to be more like, you know, we are specifically outlining
- 29:42what qualifies. I guess that's true. Yeah. Yeah. I don't know. I don't know. I might have been just talking
- 29:49out of my ass. It sounds right to me. I was thinking too of like how they picked the jury. Like,
- 29:53they don't want anyone who's biased. So maybe like, yeah. Unreasonable doubt would be like,
- 29:58oh, you're a super biased against this person. Yeah. Well, sir, you believe that all people of this
- 30:04race gender or creed are criminals. So I'm going to say that's unreasonable.
- 30:11Dn reasonable. Dn reasonable. On February 25th of 1981, the trial began. So that's just about four
- 30:23months after the attack occurred. So that's pretty quick. That is really fast. Well, fast.
- 30:31The defense tried to argue that the victim's identification of Steve from the photo array
- 30:37should be excluded from evidence. Cassie's nodding her head and she doesn't even know the half of it yet.
- 30:44It's unreasonable. No doubt. No doubt, bra. Very unreasonable.
- 30:50His photos were differently sized and styled compared to the other five included.
- 31:00What? I mean, why not just circle his photo with a red pen and draw in arrows pointing to him while
- 31:08you're at it? Like, did any of the other dudes even have like beers in hair? I have no idea.
- 31:15Yeah, I haven't read a lot about what anyone else in the photo array, like what they looked like
- 31:23or anything because everybody's so focused on the fact that like, um, hello, that was all of that
- 31:29was so improper. Yeah. And improper is a polite way of saying, fuck up.
- 31:34Shouldn't that immediately be like what's that called when they do something wrong in it?
- 31:42I mean, it should be stricken and should like that shouldn't have been admissible. Yeah. Hello.
- 31:48Like what? I take it your so upset that it might have been included. Did I not say that already?
- 31:55No, I don't think so, but you kind of gave me a way to do every shot. You're not hiding your feelings.
- 32:01No, I'm not very good at it. I have no poker face. This so-called evidence really should have been
- 32:08excluded, just in case you were unclear on my thoughts up to this point. However, the judge left this
- 32:16to the jury to decipher. So yeah, he was like, yep, that's totally allowed. Because you know, so often
- 32:23juries are made up of brilliant legal minds, obviously. Yeah, they have the training to know what should
- 32:32be allowed in the courtroom. Yeah. Yeah. And they know what a proper photo array should look like.
- 32:41We're so lucky that we're so educated in this country that we all just get that basic knowledge
- 32:47through school, you know, we're essentially all Brainiacs. Yeah. I can't believe we made it through
- 32:52that with the straight face. Why do we even need the judge? The fuck is the judge for?
- 32:56I mean, that's kind of, I was like, you had one job. You had one job. You know, be the judge. You make
- 33:03the decisions. Whew, I feel it in my temples. Yeah, just like a like an ice pick right to the brain.
- 33:10Okay, but everything else will probably be super legit and linear and point to the clear
- 33:17cut guilt of the man in question, right? Right. They've they've hit their quote of mistakes.
- 33:23Totally, except there would be some changes to the timeline in witness testimony.
- 33:31And that would become another troubling aspect of the case and trial, though for some,
- 33:37perhaps only in hindsight, because everything really is clearer in hindsight, I guess.
- 33:46You guys, we have something really exciting to share with you. Let's hear a few words from our new pod
- 33:52besties. Do you find true crime podcasts to murder? Do you breathe oxygen? If you've answered yes
- 34:01to any of these questions, then we have the podcast for you. Live Laugh Larsony, a true petty crime
- 34:06podcast, brings the drama to dumb criminal stories, presenting each crime as a fully produced short
- 34:11story. Our variety show podcast has it all sound effects, parody songs, terrible reenactments,
- 34:18and did we mention drama? Join us, Amanda and Trevin, each Wednesday as we share our dreadful
- 34:23dilemmas, killer facts, and then jump into the sick and twisted world of petty crimes. Let's roll the clip.
- 34:28Amy had another solution to dance. Using her drunken misstep as the starting point,
- 34:37Amy's feet quickly improved and Irish jig. The river dance continued to pick up the pace,
- 34:44as she spun around and proceeded to stomp her feet rapidly on the hard ground. You can find
- 34:50Live Laugh Larsony on Apple, Spotify, or wherever you listen to podcasts. Bye. See ya.
- 34:57Check them out, creepy people. You can find their info in our show notes.
- 35:07Now, we don't usually do much in the way of trigger warnings, but I will say maybe fast forward,
- 35:13like 30 seconds if sexual assault is particularly triggering for you. We won't be describing the attack
- 35:21itself, but something is about to happen in the trial that can only be described as a gross
- 35:31retraumatization of the victim. I mean gross in both senses of the word, very exaggerated,
- 35:39and also it gives me the ick. Fast forward. Look at her over there. Push in the buttons.
- 35:48The batteries are... Yeah. You're like a mom's like stomping her foot on the floor of the card,
- 35:59trying to break. At one point during the trial, the prosecutor asked the victim whether she
- 36:07recognized her attacker in the courtroom. Clearly pointing to Steve, listen if she doesn't know who
- 36:15the guy is, maybe you shouldn't be pointing him out, but also like what other dude is like, yeah,
- 36:24on a pedestal, but he's sitting at the defense table. Yeah, so exactly. That's what I was trying to get
- 36:30at. I don't think it could be much clearer than that. Okay, but that's not even... that's really not even
- 36:36the bad part. He took it a step further, asking her to approach Steve and... this is a quote,
- 36:44"Step down off the stand and walk over to the defense table and get as close to Titus
- 36:53as he was to you on the night you were raped."
- 36:56"Literally shaking your face." "Do you not hear your side?"
- 37:01"This was a man, I assume." "How did you guess?"
- 37:07"Wild guess." "Yeah, wild guess."
- 37:10The victim followed instructions and quickly erupted into tears,
- 37:18sobbing hysterically. The prosecution's tactic no doubt having the intended effect.
- 37:24But here's the thing, facing a courtroom full of people and telling her story of that traumatic night
- 37:32and eventing her life could have easily driven her to tears alone. But forcing her to face a man
- 37:40that she now believed to be the perpetrator, it's unthinkable. And in this particular exercise,
- 37:53I believe it proved to be incredibly unethical for a whole host of reasons. And my God,
- 38:02how badly do you want to win this case? You know, if he's guilty, I can understand being passionate
- 38:09about it. But to do that to the victim, I have a hard time thinking that there's any justification
- 38:19for that. "I'm thinking." "Yeah." When the state's own forensic specialists were called to the
- 38:26stand by the prosecution, they said there was no evidence found that substantiated the girl had been
- 38:34in Steve Titus' car. No evidence? Huh? Because she wasn't. Right, right, right. I know every time
- 38:46I read that, every time I say it in my head, I'm seeing Kanye rush the stage, "I'm gonna let you finish."
- 38:55I'm assuming there's gonna be something after that that's better. 18 fingerprints were lifted.
- 39:05And none of them were from the victim. Various fiber samples taken from his vehicle also proved
- 39:12contrary, obstructive, fruitless, and otherwise counterproductive to their case against Titus.
- 39:20Sometimes when I get fired up, I like to use multiple adjectives. I have to say, "I'm a little
- 39:27bit trial if there's no evidence." Such a good question. It really is. Literally everything,
- 39:38everything is hedged on this witness identification, this, you know, victim identification, and it's so
- 39:47faulty. What? Yeah, ex. There was no damning DNA staining on the vehicle's interior. The fibers
- 39:58found within the vehicle's interior didn't match the victim's clothing. Hair found in the vehicle
- 40:05was not a match for the victim either. They were, quote, "disimilar to the victim." And I'm sorry,
- 40:13how does someone violently rape someone in their car and eradicate all evidence of that in just a matter
- 40:24of hours? But like there's other like hairs and fibers and things. Right. Yeah. So it's like, okay,
- 40:30well, he didn't just take this and like have the thing like full on Walter White, wiped down.
- 40:38Like maybe he hung up plastic everywhere. Yeah. That's, you know what? That's not something she would
- 40:45remember and be able to recall. No. Yeah. You make a good point. I'm sorry. Not just a hat rag,
- 40:51this one. I like that. No, it really points to like just how unreasonable it is to think that like
- 40:59that's possible. Oh, by the way, he also watched a movie with his friend and you know, took a call
- 41:07from his girlfriend and he did all of this in addition to absolutely scrubbing that thing clean.
- 41:15Except if anybody else is DNA. Right. You just tweezered all the hairs out.
- 41:20Because there's no way. Like there's no liquid. Yeah. Guys, gross, but I'm sorry. There would be
- 41:29something. You telling me there's no bodily fluid anywhere, anywhere after that? You're going to look
- 41:37me dead in the centers of my soul and tell me there wasn't any bodily fluids. Nothing that you could
- 41:46pick up that like hair too. I know all like not all women have like thick hair, but most of us,
- 41:53you just sit there and think you're careful. So behind, I'm sorry. Yeah. Also like the fibers that were
- 41:59taken from the victim, presumably from the vehicle's interior did not match. It's just like, I'm sorry,
- 42:06but like what do you have here? You just found somebody who was a white guy driving a blue car.
- 42:12That's as far as we got. Man. The detective changed the time estimates related to Steve Titus'
- 42:23return home from his family gathering by nearly 30 minutes. On the stand, the detective said that
- 42:31Titus reportedly arrived home at 655 rather than 630 as he had very definitely previously stated.
- 42:40The only period of time that Steve Titus is aware about could not be confirmed by someone else
- 42:49present with him was the 40 minute period from the time he left his parents at shortly after 6 p.m.
- 42:57So 610 to put a round number on it to the 650 arrival of his friend, 40 minutes.
- 43:05Whereupon they decided to watch a movie. Ron Parker, the detective,
- 43:14which feels like a generous assessment, the detective that spoke with Titus to collect his statement
- 43:23did not complete a written record of the account and details until months later. Coincidentally,
- 43:33just days to the trial commencing. And I happen to know that that's actually pretty much
- 43:43totally legal. Usually that would only happen in the case of a traffic infraction.
- 43:52But yeah, it's, I would say in this case, I guess, it doesn't appear to be technically illegal
- 44:00what he did there. Super unethical and because he changed facts of the case or, you know,
- 44:07testimony, that part, yeah, that's not, that ain't cool. Can't do that. How is that legal to like keep
- 44:14in there? So how this works is basically, if you're changing facts of the case or testimony,
- 44:22things that people have said, obviously, that is not legal. I am not arguing that. I'm saying they
- 44:29don't have to actually record or like complete the citation paperwork in a lot of instances
- 44:37until like six months later. They have like a six month grace period in a lot of jurisdictions.
- 44:44So if you are speeding and a police officer sees you speeding, they can just send you a ticket
- 44:49like six months later. This is not that. Yeah, there's no like details that matter. So I don't. Yeah.
- 44:56How are you, how are you recording this six months later when you didn't record the statement? Yeah.
- 45:07It doesn't make sense. It's very like, yeah, I can't remember what I fucking ate yesterday. Like
- 45:15six months from now. How many other cases are you working on to? Exactly.
- 45:21Facts that are important. Like, how do you just remember it all? How can you be sure that you're not
- 45:27getting details of like any details of the case? You know, I mean, oh my god, it's just, it's,
- 45:36it's so unconscionable. And like, regardless of whatever grace period or window that they have to
- 45:43be able to like report things, it's like, right, but you took a statement. Like, you already did that.
- 45:48This is recorded. This is something that like, and this is going to be presented in court.
- 45:54So I think you got a pretty good field for how things are going so far. Yeah, not great, not great.
- 46:05Not great. Not looking up. Not great. But you're going to have to wait a little bit to
- 46:12get some information about the rest of the trial. Because it's really hard to divorce some of the
- 46:21remaining details of the trial from the other thing that happens. There's more. Mm-hmm. Okay.
- 46:30But I will say, I think we end this on a relatively high note for true crime. Okay.
- 46:41What's that? Oh, no, I mean, at the end of part two. Well, tell me the end.
- 46:45I know she's like, you mother tracker. Okay. So the end is, there's going to be a little bit of light
- 46:54at the end of the tunnel. I don't know. It's after you fuck us all up though. It's okay. Yeah. You're
- 46:59cool. I mean, it's, it still feels, um, pretty unsatisfying on the whole. Just because it's like,
- 47:07yikes, we had to go through all this to get to there. I seem super not worth it. So it's a long walk
- 47:15for a short glass of water, um, in some respects. But I think it's a really important story.
- 47:20I trust you. Like I said earlier. Yeah. She's like, for sure. Fuck, I'm very sorry.
- 47:25Oh, well, are we going to do some tarot? Let's do tarot time. Two states tarot,
- 47:36dash, pp, cat. Yeah.
- 47:40Yeah. To both. They're going to come. What did she get? Is that literally the same one that we just
- 47:57put away? Is it? Yes. Okay. It's the eight of ones. Eight of ones. Okay. Well, we both shuffled it.
- 48:09That's weird. Yeah. We put, we drew that for, wasn't Beetlejuice, was it? No. I think it was your last one.
- 48:18Oh, interesting. Yeah. It had to have been. Because like, what else would we draw for? Oh my gosh. It
- 48:24makes so much sense. Immediately. I'm looking at the keywords and I'm like, yep. Okay. So weird.
- 48:29We shuffled the crap out of it. We really did. We really did you guys. We really did. We also don't
- 48:37like drawing the same cards. No. It's like not as fun to keep reading the same thing. So we wouldn't
- 48:41do this on purpose. It's a little old. I know. It's thinking we should get like different,
- 48:46like different books. Oh, yeah. We should. Yeah. Because we're still learning. I mean, we don't
- 48:51have them all memorized. There's no way we could, this is like how we are learning is to keep reading
- 48:56the same thing over and over. So yeah. But it would kind of be nice to vary it up a little bit more.
- 49:01Yeah. I know. We do a little bit. Well, this one has like the little book. Yeah. I feel like those
- 49:06interpretations aren't really as developed. So yeah. There's like little stories. But okay. So we
- 49:13should add to our to-do list tonight. We should look for some more books. Okay. If anyone has
- 49:19recommendations, yeah. Because you can't really have too many books. I don't, I don't think anyone
- 49:25has ever said that ever in the history of forever. I'm sure lots of people. It's a really stupid people.
- 49:32I love it. Okay. Who left the bag of idiots open? Yeah. That's right. Them don't like books.
- 49:43They, oh, okay. Eight of ones are keywords are action, excitement, new experiences and urgency.
- 49:54When the eight of ones appears, you can expect your life to speed up big time. It feels like an
- 50:01understatement. This card suggests lots of action and excitement coming your way. Ooh, excitement
- 50:07doesn't always have to be like a positive though. Yeah. It can be bad. Yeah. Yeah. This was for the
- 50:12school one. Yeah. This is the Carpe Diem card. Whatever you put into motion now takes off at a rapid pace.
- 50:21Oh my god. This isn't saying how well it fits. This case as well. Yeah. I feel like that's on like
- 50:27like the cops side because this poor man didn't like do anything. Yeah. So like nothing he did put
- 50:34this into motion. It was all like the police's fault basically. I mean, yeah, definitely in terms of
- 50:39like what we're thinking of who's that fault for how this evolved. I think, you know, you're
- 50:48definitely talking about like that's, you know, that's on law enforcement, but I will say there are
- 50:54choices that every single person made along the way that played a role in it. Not that they're at fault,
- 51:01but it does, it does change how things, you know, it changes what is set into motion.
- 51:08That is true because he did design to like go with them and do the right thing. Yeah. But yeah,
- 51:15that definitely is like punished for being a good guy. Yeah. The eight may also indicate a whirlwind
- 51:23trip. This card shows a busy period in your life when you feel catapulted towards something you desire.
- 51:34Oh, I don't know. Okay. I'm going to have to think about that. Maybe not to I feel like, yeah,
- 51:39some of the wording. I feel like something that's like attracted to you. Maybe not like something you
- 51:45want, but like something that's drawn to you. I don't know. What do you think? Yeah. I agree. Oh, okay.
- 51:53I was like, I was like, I want to make sure I didn't cut you off. You know, you always say it better than me.
- 51:57No, sometimes I'm a potato. Perhaps you feel a sense of urgency in financial areas and may need to
- 52:08make split second decisions. Okay. Well, we might have a little bit more on that in part two.
- 52:14In a reading about work, the upright eight suggests a time of inspiration when things happen fast
- 52:24and you have to make quick decisions. Your career moves rapidly forward and you have to hustle to keep
- 52:33up. This card can also represent job-related travel, which is so interesting because obviously,
- 52:41if you're investigating a crime and you're going, you know, travel can be, you know, not necessarily
- 52:48international, like between to comments, yeah, or, you know, if you are somebody who represents seven
- 52:54locations of a local seafood restaurant chain. I don't know. Yeah. Oh, and it did like, it moved
- 53:03really fast, too. And they had to, they obviously made some decisions that were hasty. Yes. But I don't
- 53:10understand why. I guess just like get it done faster. Yeah. I think I feel some of the reversed
- 53:22ones energy from this card, too. So it's kind of interesting. I'm, I'm going to pull from the other
- 53:31half of the deck after this. I feel like we did that last time, too. Like we, like, it related
- 53:36with both sides and it just, yeah. I feel like sometimes it kind of just clarifies. But I feel like
- 53:42this card, this is like one of the cards in particular that you pull and even like the imagery of
- 53:47the birds kind of like flying around on it, I feel like it could like go either way, like up or down.
- 53:53Yeah. There's a couple of cards that we've gotten that are like, I'm just, I just keep doing it.
- 53:58And I'm doing the eight. The like, yeah, yeah, figure eight. Yeah. In a reading about love, the upright
- 54:07eight points to a passionate and exciting romance. It can indicate a sudden love affair that
- 54:13sweeps you off your feet or a hasty marriage. It's interesting. Hmm. Okay. Steven Mona,
- 54:22were they like would they like me? They were a little bit of a whirlwind romance in a way. Yeah.
- 54:28Okay. Oh boy. Okay. Yeah. Five of points. Yeah. Okay. So we've got, that's, I mean, just very
- 54:41definitive ones energy. Okay. Oh wow. Wow. Wow. Wow. Okay. Key words. And I was like as soon as I looked
- 54:49at that one, I was like, I think I'm remembering some of the like, principles of this card and
- 54:57sort of the, oh yeah, okay. Did we say it's like two bobcats or something fighting each other?
- 55:03Like wrestling, which is like just the imagery of two people like, having a tussle, I don't want to say.
- 55:11I think that the keywords and just the description of the traditional tarot card are going to make it very
- 55:20clear. Key words are competition, ego battles, disagreements and confusion. So I can't find one of
- 55:33those that doesn't fit. And when the five of ones appears, it suggests a struggle for power,
- 55:42money or recognition. Ego battles may interfere with the smooth flow of life. In some cases, it shows
- 55:50competition for resources or control. Confusion and disagreements exist. And in the traditional deck,
- 55:58it literally shows five different presumably, you know, male figures that appear to be like
- 56:05battling with like, staffs. They're like kind of play fighting like in the way that like, maybe young
- 56:11boys would. Oh gosh. Okay. The interpretation. Bickering and self-interest cause irritation.
- 56:20And you need to concern yourself with getting matters back on track. Wow. There's aspects of the
- 56:28case that I've researched that I didn't even put in my notes for part one that that is just like,
- 56:33woo, front of mind, I might have to try to talk a little bit about that.
- 56:38Discontent may arise from differences in philosophy or personality. When this card shows up,
- 56:47you may be defending your territory, putting up a fight to hold on to what you think is yours.
- 56:54Try to assess the situation objectively. This may be a mock battle or a conflict of egos
- 57:01that lacks genuine substance. Wow. Cannot make that shit up. That is the same. Like,
- 57:08defendant, even the user were defending like mock trial. Yeah. What I kept here. I know. Yeah,
- 57:19this was a mockery. Anyways, in a reading about money, this card may show your financial situation
- 57:27is unstable or competition is heading into your take. Arguments about money and spending cause
- 57:36tension. In a reading about work, the five can represent competition in the marketplace.
- 57:43In-house conflicts or stubbornness may also cause problems. Perhaps you're confused about your
- 57:50direction or you lack self-confidence. I think some people were definitely confused. Yeah. I mean,
- 57:56some people might have had a little too much self-confidence. Arguably.
- 58:00In a reading about love, this card suggests you're letting your ego rule. You may stubbornly
- 58:08refuse to compromise or make necessary changes. The five can also reveal differences of perspective
- 58:15that cause problems. I would say putting it as differences of perspective is quite generous in
- 58:25this case, but yeah. Yeah. Wow. Okay. So the part that I, the first sentence, literally of the
- 58:35interpretation, big ring and self-interest cause irritation and you need to concern yourself with
- 58:41getting matters back on track. So Steve Titus' initial defense counsel said that he would get
- 58:51really frustrated only because he could really tell that he really felt that Steve Titus was
- 59:01innocent. He really felt that like deep in like his gut and not everyone that you represent as
- 59:09like a defense attorney is going to be innocent. In fact, arguably, probably maybe a majority of the
- 59:18people that you're going to represent are guilty of something and it may not be as violent or as
- 59:23awful as this crime, but a lot of people they don't did the damn thing. But he just really felt like
- 59:31he didn't do this. Like there's, I just, I can't picture it. I believe him and he knew enough
- 59:39about the timeline to know that pieces of it were fabricated in some of the second round of
- 59:47testimony and the different statements that were brought to court. And his frustration not only
- 59:56came from the fact that he felt like Steve Titus was innocent, but that because Steve was so passionate
- 1:00:04and he was so clearly like, how can this happen? How can I be, you know, facing a conviction when
- 1:00:12I didn't do this? And you know, like I have alibi witnesses, all of these different things.
- 1:00:19And he would just rail against like what the hell is the system that this is allowed to happen?
- 1:00:27And it's completely understandable, but it wasn't productive. He's like, and he had this conversation
- 1:00:36with Steve, but also with members of his family where he would say, listen, you guys are paying me
- 1:00:44$120 an hour to have this conversation or it might have even been, even back then, it might have been
- 1:00:51$300 an hour. I can't remember what number he said now. As soon as I said 120, I was like, that doesn't
- 1:00:59quite feel right. I think it was 300 an hour. At any rate, you are paying someone a significant sum
- 1:01:06to have these conversations where they're trying to develop your defense and they are trying to
- 1:01:12represent you legally. And while that frustration is super understandable, it's like, this is not
- 1:01:20productive. It's not good. It's not a good use of your time. It's not a good use of your funds.
- 1:01:26Like we have to move on. Let's make the most of all of our resources so that we can prove that
- 1:01:32you are innocent. And we can get you out of this situation, but can like super understandable
- 1:01:40why somebody would just be driven to, I mean, damn near the point of madness about, like I didn't
- 1:01:50do this. How can this happen? It would be terrible. You'd be absolutely beside yourself, I feel like.
- 1:01:58The money thing, too, kind of made me think of how much funding like the police department had.
- 1:02:07I'm sure that they're always trying to like speed things along and want people to do things
- 1:02:12faster so that you don't spend the money on it. Yeah. I mean, I don't know for sure, but I assume.
- 1:02:17Yeah. I mean, the other aspect of that too, and it's not something that I delved into specifically
- 1:02:23in part one, but Steve's parents threw the entirety of their life savings into his defense.
- 1:02:33Everything they had basically. I mean, yeah, what else you can't not.
- 1:02:44Yeah, I mean, and the worst part is like, you know, these are people's livelihoods.
- 1:02:51They were not young people. I'm sure at some point that would have been money that was designed
- 1:02:58to help them be able to retire. And my God, but how do you let your child go to prison for a crime
- 1:03:07that he didn't commit? A crime that they were, I mean, they were such a key part of his alibi.
- 1:03:14Having been, you know, he came from a family function. And when we really look at the timeline and
- 1:03:24the places where all of these things occurred, it is just not physically possible. I remember I did
- 1:03:32read a book about this case where they talked about this guy is either the fastest or the longest
- 1:03:42dick in the West. And they're because they were like, either he did this in like 15 minutes. And like,
- 1:03:50that was a lot of things he had to do and pull off in 15 minutes or he's literally stretching his
- 1:03:56dick all the way from Kent, which I thought was a hilarious visual. It was pretty funny. Yeah.
- 1:04:03And you know what? Steve definitely was the bigger-dicked man in this situation. I said, but I said.
- 1:04:11There was something you said in the beginning of the interpretation about it was just,
- 1:04:16it probably goes without saying, but it was about power, like wanting power. And you know,
- 1:04:21everything I've consumed about true crime usually says that like a rape isn't really about
- 1:04:27like sexual gratification. It's about having like power over somebody. Yeah. That's true. You know,
- 1:04:34I honestly, because so much of what we talked about in part one was really focused on the fact that
- 1:04:40it's like, wow, how is this even going to trial? And so I'm thinking about it in terms of like ego battles
- 1:04:47and power struggles and everything in terms of the law, the legal system and law enforcement.
- 1:04:55But it hadn't even occurred to me that like, yes, I mean rape is a crime where someone is trying
- 1:05:01to assert dominance and they are trying to, you know, gain power and control over someone. So that is,
- 1:05:08wow, I, and even more the fact that he let her live too. So obviously, it wasn't about killing her.
- 1:05:15Right. Yeah. It was, it was really just about that. Well, yeah. Oh boy. Oh, oh boy.
- 1:05:23I feel like I could go on about this case for so long. For another episode.
- 1:05:29Yeah. And you know, we're not just going to be talking about Steve Titus' trial because they're,
- 1:05:38I can't really say much more without giving it away. Don't go and look up the case, you fuckers. No
- 1:05:43spoilers. I mean, if you want to look it up, I guess, but there's just, there's a lot. I mean, to call
- 1:05:51it a bloom in onion is, it's not an overstatement. There's a lot. Yeah. We're going to bring in some new
- 1:05:58characters in part two. And yeah, okay, we'll see. We'll all be here. Yeah. She's like, baby. So you. Yeah.
- 1:06:09I'm not going to read what's in the little book because I feel like we did a good job and
- 1:06:15Caitlin has a photo shoot to get to. I do. She's got to like go be happy and in love and whatever.
- 1:06:23God, that sounds exhausting. I'm just kidding. I'm very excited. It is really hot, though. So I'm a little
- 1:06:30bit nervous that I'm going to like just melt. I think hopefully there's like just a nice breeze,
- 1:06:35not too much to ruffle your hair, but enough to make you feel cool. We'll be here in the shade. Wish me luck.
- 1:06:42Everyone wish her luck right now. One, two, three, go. Okay, I did it.
- 1:06:50Oh, okay, you guys. It's really hot and these lashes will fall off if the humidity is too high.
- 1:06:57Have a creepy ass day. See you next Tuesday.
- 1:07:04Next Tuesday. Stay away from monochematic outputs and cars. Yeah. Because they might get you in trouble.
- 1:07:11Also, beards. Apparently no one has beards anymore anyway, which is a pay trail bonus joke.
- 1:07:17Yeah, sorry. You had to be there. Yeah. Yeah.
- 1:07:24I don't know how to drink a breather swallow or
- 1:07:42okay. All right. I see what you did there. I'm not going to say it. Yeah.
- 1:07:49That's what she said. And just like that, she said it. Sorry, Michael Scott was just nagging me in the back of my head to say it.
- 1:07:59As he does. He wouldn't let me not. Yeah. That makes sense.
- 1:08:04pnwhauntsandhomicides.com