Latest / The Vegan Report / A Vegan Father Speaks Up. With Adam Walsh | Ep. 54
Transcript
- 0:00Hello everyone, my name is Ryan and you are listening to The Vegan Report.
- 0:05Today we are shedding light on the challenge of raising a vegan kid in a non-vegan world
- 0:13and to discuss this topic I have with me Adam Walsh, an animal rights activist, a long time
- 0:19vegan and a father who has deeply thought about how to successfully transmit his values
- 0:28to his son.
- 0:29He shares those thoughts in this beautiful book titled Bacon is a Vegetable, which is
- 0:36available for order now, I left a link in the description.
- 0:40Adam is also a colleague, a fellow animal rights podcaster, I highly recommend his show,
- 0:47Easy for Animals, again link in the description below.
- 0:52Okay so Adam, welcome to the show, thank you so much for being here.
- 0:56Of course, thank you for having me.
- 0:58I was really looking forward to this conversation because I wanted to talk about the book, yes,
- 1:07but also you're a fellow vegan podcaster and we connected on social media and I thought
- 1:15yeah, let's talk about this, what it's like to be a podcaster in the vegan space.
- 1:22Yeah, yeah and I think we started our podcast at a very similar time as well.
- 1:27We've I think done about five times more episodes than I have, so quite a bit more experience,
- 1:32but yeah, it's been very interesting.
- 1:38I think initially I started my podcast as a way of increasing my experience I suppose
- 1:44in things like public speaking and putting yourself in front of the camera instead of
- 1:49behind it and these kinds of things.
- 1:53But I ended up learning quite a bit from the guests as well, so I hope other people have
- 2:01learnt some things from it, but I feel like I've taken a lot from the guests.
- 2:06Yes, that's a good way of putting it.
- 2:10This podcast is for me something like a vegan school where I'm just learning so much about
- 2:17everything that has to do with animal rights and about myself.
- 2:21Yeah, yeah, especially when guests often say things that makes me think a little bit and
- 2:29think well would I put it in that way or do I even think that or is that a new idea.
- 2:34I often find myself not getting stuck but having long pauses after they finished answering
- 2:41a question so that I can contemplate their answer.
- 2:45Yeah, I think another aspect of mine that I tried to do as well was to prove that you
- 2:51can have conversations with people who you may be, as animal activists or as vegans,
- 2:57who we may be actively opposing.
- 3:00So I've had people on who are essentially the mirror image of us, I suppose, that they're
- 3:07advocating for the use of animals in particularly biomedical research.
- 3:12I did two episodes where in one of them we talked about the use of non-animal methods
- 3:15in their labs and the other one we talked about transparency and researchers talking
- 3:20more about the animals that are used and the need for statistics and things like this.
- 3:25So even though we don't agree on a whole bunch of things, I think I've proved to myself and
- 3:32hopefully to other people that we can still have conversations with people on the other
- 3:37side of the fence, I suppose, so to speak, that we can find some common ground and work
- 3:42towards those things potentially together or at the very least, I guess, in the example
- 3:47to have a conversation about those things.
- 3:49Do you have any plans for your podcast?
- 3:52Not at the moment, life has started getting in the way a little more.
- 3:56So I think I've only this year I did about three or four episodes.
- 4:01And one in particular, which I often think about quite a lot, I would like to get back
- 4:06to it and revisit a little bit.
- 4:08I think I have these like grand ideas for it and that every episode has to kind of approach
- 4:14a big subject and talk about parenting or communication or whatever it might be.
- 4:22But maybe just having more organic conversations, some of those things might come out a little
- 4:26bit as well and people talk more about those experiences.
- 4:29So yeah, maybe I need to relax my approach to it a little bit.
- 4:35When I started podcasting, I looked for other vegan podcasts and there are so many lists
- 4:44out there and I would go through those lists and most of those podcasts were inactive,
- 4:52had been inactive for years for some of them.
- 4:57It's hard to keep a podcast active, live, afloat.
- 5:05I don't know.
- 5:08I wish more vegan podcasters were present in the podcasting scene.
- 5:15I know another podcast that was born at the same time as ours was Sanctuary Life Podcast
- 5:25and they did like I think 10, 12, 8, I don't remember, but a few episodes and then they
- 5:34stopped and they were successful.
- 5:37It surprised me.
- 5:41Yeah, yeah.
- 5:43At least here in Australia, there's very, very limited opportunity to be a professional
- 5:51animal advocate, I suppose.
- 5:54Depending on what your definition of that term is, we have RSPCA, which is quite problematic,
- 5:59but people who work there may still see themselves as animal advocates.
- 6:05The proper real activist groups, there's maybe a handful at best of employment opportunities
- 6:12in those.
- 6:13We all do these things in our spare time, I suppose, in our evenings and our weekends,
- 6:19which at some points, I suppose you can carve out the time for them.
- 6:24But as we know, life kind of ebbs and flows a little bit that one month you'll have every
- 6:29weekend free and you've got a lot of time to sit and edit and obsess over the way that
- 6:34people said certain things and whether we need to include that in the final conversation
- 6:38or the next month, every weekend is so full that you don't even have time to make a cup
- 6:44of tea for yourself.
- 6:47So to maintain a schedule is quite difficult, but I think at least from our side of it,
- 6:54getting the time that is spent putting into even when everything goes well, when you reach
- 7:00out to someone and they say yes, and you meet at a time and you record it and it goes well
- 7:05and there's minimal editing, that could still be a 10-hour investment for a one-hour episode.
- 7:10And then sometimes we get the times wrong, the audio quality is not very good and you
- 7:16have to re-record certain bits.
- 7:19Because all these other factors that come into it as well, so it could often turn into
- 7:24a part-time job just for one single episode a week is a part-time job sometimes.
- 7:30Oh my gosh.
- 7:31Thank you for saying that.
- 7:33Yes, that's now my life.
- 7:40It's very kind of thankless as well, isn't it?
- 7:43That I mean, like we say, I feel that we learn a lot from it and we hope that other people
- 7:48get a lot from it, but we'll sit there and I'll refresh Spotify sometimes and see if
- 7:53anyone else has rated it or check the morning of a release and see if anyone's listened
- 7:58to it on the first day.
- 7:59But it's kind of the, apart from friends and families, the only feedback we get is a listen,
- 8:06but then we don't know how anyone's even received the episode or whether someone stumbled across
- 8:10it because it had a keyword in it that matches their other podcasts.
- 8:13But usually they listen to Joe Rogan and not animal activism.
- 8:19It's very difficult to stay motivated apart from the fact that we do it for animals, I
- 8:26guess.
- 8:27That's the hard part.
- 8:30At first I almost quit this podcasting business because I kept focusing on the number of downloads
- 8:39and how many people were listening and I was thinking, I'm putting so much effort and energy
- 8:47in this episode for what?
- 8:50For a few dozen downloads?
- 8:56I mean, yeah.
- 8:57And episodes that you think.
- 9:00I did one with an Australian activist.
- 9:03He is, as far as I understand, like the group or regional leader for We the Free in Australia
- 9:10and New Zealand, I believe.
- 9:12And we had a conversation and I was inspired by one of the episodes that you did about
- 9:17conservatives because I think particularly in Australia, we have this big gap between
- 9:23even like the left side, the animal appreciating left side and everybody else.
- 9:30And most of the everybody else is conservative.
- 9:32So I kind of talked about him with this and I added it as a bonus episode.
- 9:37So it was only about 10 minutes.
- 9:38I thought that was a good trial to see how a shorter episode might go.
- 9:41It was more conversational and I thought, wow, this is really good.
- 9:44I learned a lot from this.
- 9:46He mentioned a few really good things.
- 9:49This one's going to like impact people.
- 9:51People are going to love this.
- 9:53And again, I'm sitting there like refreshing.
- 9:54I'm like, why is it not taking?
- 9:56Why is it like, I feel like I invested so much of my hope in this episode that this
- 10:00was the one that I was going to change the world with.
- 10:03And you know, 50 people had a go at it.
- 10:08Well, you know, my I reached out actually on Reddit on the podcasting sub Reddit and
- 10:19I asked other podcasters, you know, I just I guess I just rented and I was like, here's
- 10:28what I'm going through.
- 10:31I have this vegan podcast.
- 10:33So I know most of you won't relate to it, but yeah, podcasting is hard and the people,
- 10:41you know, just reach out like a wave of positive comments and advice.
- 10:50And I had this particular person, you know, his name is Ryan, weirdly enough, and he's
- 11:00also a podcaster and he just, you know, gave gave me attention and time as some kind of
- 11:09mentor and, you know, reminded me of why I'm doing what I'm doing and to seek pleasure
- 11:20in, you know, what I'm doing.
- 11:24And honestly, now it's better that I guess that the podcast has taken off from that,
- 11:33you know, period.
- 11:36But I'm doing it for the fun of it.
- 11:41That's the, you know, the bottom line.
- 11:43If the day I will stop having fun, you know, having those conversations and editing everything
- 11:53and then releasing it to the public, I will stop because you need this, you know, you
- 12:04need something positive to get something out of this experience.
- 12:10I'm not getting any money, so at least I'm getting, you know, fun.
- 12:16I'm getting challenged.
- 12:17I'm getting stimulated by this whole experience.
- 12:21Yeah.
- 12:22And I think too that like part of our activism, at least what I think it should be, and sometimes
- 12:30people are very, or other activists are very hesitant to create communities with people
- 12:36who are not directly involved in what we do.
- 12:38Like we try not to have vegan friends or we try not to have friends who are not activists
- 12:41and things like that.
- 12:43That even like reaching out to other podcasters and saying, I have a vegan podcast.
- 12:49Well that then gets them interested in what you're doing.
- 12:52So that is another aspect of how these things can be successful.
- 12:56That's finding ways, I often say that we don't need to build our own communities.
- 13:01We just need to find a way into other people's communities.
- 13:04And whether that's through environmentalism or through podcasting or through whatever
- 13:08it might be, as long as the animals are at the core of our message, then yeah, like if
- 13:14it's a podcasting community and suddenly they're interested in kind of motivating you or helping
- 13:19you out or things like that, they're going to take an interest in yours.
- 13:23And there'll be someone in there who will say, I might listen to this and see what,
- 13:27you know, see what he's on about.
- 13:29And they hear one of your episodes and that changes the way they think.
- 13:33And it's, it's like another way to, like just promoting a podcast as well.
- 13:38It's another way of, of reaching out to people.
- 13:41Yes.
- 13:42And the idea that some of the people I love the most and I admire will accept to give
- 13:51an hour of their time to speak with me just because I have a podcast.
- 13:56I mean, this is incredible.
- 13:58This is like, uh, just amazing.
- 14:02And let me give you an example.
- 14:04I did an episode with whispers read, uh, who is this ASMR artist.
- 14:09I have been listening to whispers, uh, read videos since back when I started college and
- 14:18to have her, you know, on the show, to be able to interview her and to connect with
- 14:24her was just amazing.
- 14:27I thought, thank you.
- 14:28Thank you for sticking to doing, you know, this podcast.
- 14:33And you know, if I had left this, this whole business, um, and it's a business, you know,
- 14:42starting a podcast is like starting a really small business.
- 14:48But if I had left, I would not have had this, um, meeting this encounter with this amazing
- 14:56person.
- 14:57And I'm thinking, you know, it was worth it.
- 15:00Uh, the, the pain of, uh, of everything was worth this pleasant conversation and meeting
- 15:06this wonderful person.
- 15:08Yeah.
- 15:09Yeah, that's right.
- 15:10It's an often say when we're talking about considering like businesses and marketing
- 15:15and things like that, they'll say, we need to consider our strengths, our weaknesses,
- 15:19our opportunities and our threats.
- 15:22And I was only having this conversation with someone the other day.
- 15:25I don't think we need to consider strengths and weaknesses and threats.
- 15:28I think we just need to look for the opportunities because we naturally use our strengths.
- 15:34We shouldn't really consider or shouldn't really worry too much about the threats.
- 15:37We should just do the things that we know are right.
- 15:40And weaknesses can be turned around through taking advantage of opportunities.
- 15:45And that's the only thing we need to really pay attention to the opportunities because
- 15:49that's, that's where it leads to.
- 15:51It can lead to, yeah, sometimes meeting the people you admire the most.
- 15:56Yeah, we're not corporations.
- 15:59We're just one person.
- 16:01We don't have time to, to design a social media plan and, uh, do this SWOT, uh, analysis
- 16:09of what we're providing to the public.
- 16:13You know, we're just doing our best.
- 16:15Yeah, that's right.
- 16:17Yeah.
- 16:18And, um, I think it definitely leads to some great places, even if it's just in yourself
- 16:23and it might not be a direct, um, benefit of doing the podcast, but like helping in
- 16:31outreach, helping in everyday conversations, we get more confident at talking about these
- 16:35things.
- 16:36Okay.
- 16:37Podcasting is one way to connect with, uh, people.
- 16:42Another one is of course, writing a book, see the segue here.
- 16:50And I have, you know, in my hand, uh, bacon is a vegetable.
- 16:56First of all, how did you feel about publishing this book?
- 17:01Because just, you know, doing a podcast, I get, well, I used to be really afraid, like
- 17:10I'm going to put this out there.
- 17:12Um, and people will hear my thoughts and you know, they hear, they will hear me talk about
- 17:19what I think and what if I say the wrong thing?
- 17:23What if, um, I say something stupid?
- 17:28Uh, I had this fear of judgment, but at least, you know, I could edit the podcast and I could,
- 17:37you know, publish another episode the week after maybe to correct myself.
- 17:42That's the, the stories I would tell myself to feel better about, um, you know, posting
- 17:48an episode, but your book, you can't do that with your book.
- 17:53It's no, you can't take it back.
- 17:56So how did you feel about publishing it?
- 17:59Um, yes, it was very mixed.
- 18:02Um, I think I've always put a lot of weight in books and I know there are quite a few
- 18:08ridiculous books that we now have.
- 18:11Um, but I've always put a lot of weight in books.
- 18:13I think 99% of my knowledge or understanding of the world and things like that have come
- 18:19from what I've read.
- 18:21Um, and it didn't, I don't believe it started out with the intention of being a book.
- 18:27It was more just me kind of having like my, my wife is pregnant while I was writing or
- 18:33reading these things.
- 18:34And I was kind of making notes and, and it kind of just evolved into a book, but it was
- 18:41me kind of understanding the initial story was that I, my, my niece and my sister's daughter
- 18:50used to rescue worms from the driveway when it rained because she didn't want them to
- 18:54get squashed.
- 18:55And then a few years later, like we all do, we end up eating meat when we're five or six
- 19:00years old, just as part of the family, um, meals.
- 19:06And I kind of, it just sat with me one day, I'm now going to have a child and I wanted
- 19:11to understand how you went from caring about worms, which even as adults, we, and animal
- 19:17people, we still barely care about worms through to eating meat.
- 19:22So how, how do we get, get through those points?
- 19:25And one of the first things I read, which is where the title came from, was about how,
- 19:31um, how the language that we use, or I think I was probably quite harsh with some of my
- 19:37words.
- 19:38I used words like deception, um, in saying things like that's not an animal, that's a
- 19:46plant.
- 19:47And in this report, it was called, um, children are unsuspecting meat eaters.
- 19:53There was a third of children thought that bacon came from a plant.
- 19:58And I use that example as the, the title of the book, cause I thought it was a bit more,
- 20:03you know, sensationalist, I suppose, I might get people to grab it off the shelf.
- 20:08Um, but a more surprising one was about the same number of people, uh, children, a third
- 20:13of them thought that chicken nuggets came from a plant, even though it has an animal
- 20:18name in the product, they still thought it came from plants.
- 20:21And I thought, well, where, where do they get this information from?
- 20:26And I thought, well, if they're not getting it from anywhere else, they must be getting
- 20:31it from Google because surely their parents are not lying to them adults.
- 20:34We tell people to grow up as like an ambition.
- 20:36You should, you know, you should want to be a grownup.
- 20:40So surely grownups are not lying to their children.
- 20:43They must be getting it from Google.
- 20:45It's got to be the internet.
- 20:46We're told all the problems are the fault of the internet.
- 20:49And so I Googled it and apart from a couple of jokes, and there was an anime episode that
- 20:56had a meat tree.
- 20:58Um, I couldn't find anything.
- 21:00It wasn't like someone had made this, you know, drawing this long line between bacon
- 21:04and vegetable.
- 21:05There was nothing.
- 21:06So I thought the only place it's coming from is their parents or their teachers or like
- 21:11someone is telling them, no, that's not, that's not an animal.
- 21:14It's different.
- 21:15And so I kind of, as I tend to do, I don't, when I say I read a lot, I don't just read
- 21:20one or two books on a subject.
- 21:21I'll read 15 or 20.
- 21:23So I like, and from both perspectives as well, I'll often look at what does the other side
- 21:30say?
- 21:31Like I agree with this side, but you know, obviously the earth is a sphere, but what
- 21:36if it wasn't?
- 21:37Maybe I'll read a book about flood earth and see what they have to say.
- 21:41But this one like really took me down like more of a practical part, because this was
- 21:48kind of, I think I write it as more of a guide for myself of like identifying the points
- 21:52along where my son's going to encounter some of these things as he grows up and what I
- 21:57can do to help educate him better, I suppose.
- 22:02Um, and not necessarily, you know, indoctrinate him like all of us vegans do with our children,
- 22:09but um, yeah, I kind of just guide him in the right ways and make sure that he doesn't
- 22:15think that bacon is a vegetable.
- 22:21That's something I really love about the book that it is the trigger for it is the fact
- 22:28that you are going to become a father and you have to really think totally about how
- 22:37to raise your child and think about your vegan values and how to, I guess, transmit that
- 22:47to, to your son.
- 22:50And I love how it's a really personal and vulnerable reflection and you it's even chronological.
- 23:05So you know, we follow you through that adventure, intellectual adventure.
- 23:13And yeah, I guess if we stay on the theme of fear for most vegan parents out there,
- 23:23maybe that's a really big fear to have a child who one day will grow up to deny, well, reject
- 23:33his vegan values, the vegan values that his parents had, um, and become a one more, uh,
- 23:45meat eater.
- 23:47And so I think that book is also very helpful to address that fear, that legitimate fear
- 23:56and problem that many vegan parents out there might be experiencing.
- 24:03Yeah, that's right.
- 24:05And even, um, even in referring to your previous question, um, like the personal fear of putting
- 24:12these thoughts into the page that I often say that, and maybe we do all think this of
- 24:17ourselves sit in this little weird spot that doesn't fit into many boxes.
- 24:21Like I'm vegan and I'm atheist and I'm harshly honest, but I'm also very realistic.
- 24:30So I, I think I'm accepting of the fact that it's likely he's going to eat meat.
- 24:40I mean, it's almost certain that he will at some point want to try it, but given, you
- 24:45know, just the makeup of our society and the friends that he's going to have and these
- 24:49kinds of things, it's likely that he's going to eat meat.
- 24:52But we often joke that we've got a few big farm sanctuaries, um, around Melbourne here.
- 24:59And so we often joke that if he ever has a, you know, a beef burger or a chicken nugget
- 25:03or something, the following day we'll be going to a sanctuary just to say, well, now you
- 25:06need to talk to the chicken and you need to explain why you ate their friend so that he,
- 25:12like he's got this constant reminder that this is what I'm contributing to.
- 25:18And I think it's, it's kind of balancing the values, I guess, too.
- 25:24That is that I would say that probably honesty is one of the biggest values that we have
- 25:30and being honest about, you know, I need to pay for someone to kill an animal for me to
- 25:34eat.
- 25:35Well, then also with that comes a lot of other things that we maybe can't control quite as
- 25:43much that even as vegans, it's, there's a quote in the book from American journalist
- 25:52called Michael Levitan.
- 25:53And he says, is that why we all hate vegans?
- 25:56Because we agree that they're morally superior.
- 25:58So even like even he's admitting that, like what they're doing is right, or it's, I don't
- 26:05even turn better, but it's, you know, they've realized so that he's admitting that like
- 26:13they're morally superior or he's suggesting this.
- 26:15But he's also saying that's why we hate them, because we understand that they know something
- 26:20that we don't know.
- 26:23So I think just making sure that he, he makes that connection for himself, because we all,
- 26:29we all have, maybe not all of us, but most people, I imagine most vegans, and all the
- 26:38vegans who I have met have had some kind of, you know, moment in their life where they
- 26:42watched a documentary or saw a chicken being slaughtered or whatever it might be that triggered
- 26:49them into becoming vegan.
- 26:52And so by like, I hypothesize this in the book as well, that, that may be that we need
- 26:57to be exposed to animal cruelty to appreciate that animals are harmed, which is very, very
- 27:03hard to accept.
- 27:04But it could be that I have to allow him to eat meat and then to foster the environment
- 27:16in which he will be exposed to animal cruelty, even if it's just through a documentary, so
- 27:22that he can, that switch will trigger in him himself and not because he's been told to,
- 27:29but because he's lying to it for himself.
- 27:34What do you say to the many vegans out there who are anti-natalists, who don't want to
- 27:42bother with having children because of those deep, you know, moral problems, puzzles?
- 27:52Yeah, I think even, cause I was, I don't think I was anti-natalist, but I think personally,
- 27:59I just didn't see much of a point in having children.
- 28:01Like I kind of, maybe for selfish reasons, you know, I enjoyed my life.
- 28:04I liked the things that I was doing.
- 28:06I enjoy going on holidays.
- 28:09And then my girlfriend at the time is now my wife, we, like, she wanted a few kids.
- 28:15So I don't like to say that he was the compromise because we didn't compromise on him.
- 28:19He's wonderful.
- 28:20But I had this thing where I thought, I don't think most people really think about why they
- 28:30have children.
- 28:31I think they just have them because other people have children.
- 28:34You'll often see a friend group, for example, all of their kids are the same age.
- 28:38They've all had their kids at the same time.
- 28:40So we kind of, you know, over the course of quite a while, and this was, you know, through
- 28:47our relationship and we'd gone to Cambodia and we've gone to India for a few months.
- 28:52So we kind of had a lot of time to really sit and consider this question.
- 28:57And we kind of boiled it down to, because we want to pass on our experiences.
- 29:01We want the next generation to be better at what they need to be better at than we have
- 29:06been.
- 29:09And I guess the short way of responding would be that if vegans didn't have children, then
- 29:15vegans may die out because we're perpetually going to be have to, we're always going to
- 29:21be trying to convince people to not eat meat as opposed to raising vegans.
- 29:27And I know that kind of sounds a bit cultish because that's what some, you know, like,
- 29:35for example, religious groups do.
- 29:37They'll say, well, we need to have 10 kids so that we can pass on our knowledge and populate
- 29:41all these kinds of things.
- 29:44But I think there's like a, there's like a point where there is too many kids, but there's
- 29:51also a point where there's not enough kids with the right values and the right families.
- 29:55And there's, I mean, depending on which reports you read, there's some reports that, you know,
- 30:01for like doctors and teachers and all these like more educated, more like people who consider
- 30:09their lives a bit more and consider their impact on the world.
- 30:12They're the ones who have less kids and the people who don't care about the world have
- 30:16more kids.
- 30:18So like using Hollywood as an example, I suppose, where like that potential direction is idiocracy,
- 30:27where the dumbest person in the world is suddenly the smartest person in the world.
- 30:30And we're all watering our crops with Coca-Cola.
- 30:34That there's like, there's a way that we can help prevent that.
- 30:37And I think it's like, I always return to education.
- 30:40It's all through education.
- 30:41And sometimes that happens.
- 30:44It has to start at home with our own children.
- 30:46But it's equally valid that if other people are having thoughts that, you know, they don't
- 30:52want children, they don't see the point.
- 30:53Like I said, I don't think there is a need to have children if you like your life, you
- 31:01like what you do, you don't see the point, then that's equally valid.
- 31:05Yeah.
- 31:06Yes.
- 31:07That movie is amazing.
- 31:10It's so insightful.
- 31:11It's so ridiculous.
- 31:12It's so insightful.
- 31:13It's bizarre, isn't it?
- 31:15It's yeah, it's the most ridiculous film.
- 31:18And even watching them, I feel silly for watching this film.
- 31:22Like the philosophical analysis of it is amazing.
- 31:26Yeah.
- 31:27Well, let me ask you this directly, because I think the ties between this movie and veganism
- 31:36and this anti-natalist trend in the vegan community is far greater than we think.
- 31:45And I've been pondering over that.
- 31:49Do you think that there is a relationship, there's a correlation or relation between
- 31:56being smarter and becoming vegan?
- 32:01And I remember, you know, in the first years when I was considering becoming vegan, I would
- 32:07go and look up, you know, famous vegan people.
- 32:11And you had all the great minds of, you know, you had, I think Einstein was vegetarian,
- 32:19you had Da Vinci, you had all of those great minds.
- 32:23And so I'm really wondering, do you think that smarter people tend to consider more
- 32:31seriously, you know, becoming vegan, vegetarian and so on?
- 32:37But yeah, I guess breaking it down even more, it depends on what we define as like smart
- 32:45or intelligent, I guess, as well.
- 32:49I would probably say no, because a lot of the people that I admire aren't vegan or vegetarian.
- 32:55I think they try hard to be.
- 32:56And it wasn't the last time he was in Melbourne, but the time before I went to see Richard
- 33:01Dawkins talk.
- 33:02And this was before I was vegan or vegetarian.
- 33:05And I remember someone saying to him, the whole question was just, why are you not vegetarian?
- 33:11And this is from someone who I, and I still look up to, who I have admired and learned
- 33:16from for most of my life.
- 33:20And he's always got the answers for everything.
- 33:23Like he considers things very well so that he always has the answers for things.
- 33:27And even in the interview or the questions leading up to that one, he answered them so
- 33:33well and like so powerfully.
- 33:36And this one, there was just silence.
- 33:38And he just looked up from his chair and just said, I don't know.
- 33:40I don't have a good answer for that.
- 33:43And I think that's part of the reason why I like him is because he does allow himself
- 33:48to be vulnerable like that and admit when he doesn't have the answer.
- 33:52And I put a quote in my book from him that something about the evolution of a hippopotamus.
- 34:00And he said, it's going to be hard to accept, but I guess I'm going to have to.
- 34:04And I kind of like that.
- 34:05That he's like, even if I don't believe, he might say that he doesn't believe things,
- 34:10but even if I don't believe that I'm going to have to because it's a fact.
- 34:15And so I don't, yeah, like it depends on, like if we look at someone like him and say,
- 34:21well, he's intelligent, he's not vegan.
- 34:23So maybe it's not a smart thing.
- 34:24But then, like you said, there's other, like some literal geniuses who were at least vegetarian.
- 34:34I don't know.
- 34:35I don't know if it's necessarily that vegans are smarter or smarter people are vegan.
- 34:43I think it depends a lot on what your interests are and possibly even like your experiences.
- 34:50Like I said, that I supported Animals Australia and Sea Shepherd even before I was vegetarian.
- 34:58So of course I was outraged at factory farming while I was sitting there eating my chicken.
- 35:05And I thought it was horrible that we're wailing in the oceans, but it just didn't click for
- 35:11me until I had a personal experience.
- 35:13I went to Cambodia and walked through a food market and there was scaling fish and slurring
- 35:21the throats of chickens.
- 35:22And it just like seeing it right in front of me was the trigger.
- 35:27I don't, yeah, I think there's lots of sub communities within veganism as well, which
- 35:32I was going to say troubling, but not troubling, but I think from my perspective being a realistic
- 35:44based honest kind of person that, you know, like a lot of vegans are also into wellness
- 35:51things and they don't take vaccines and all these kinds of things.
- 35:56I know that's a whole nother conversation as well, but I think there's this maybe idealized
- 36:07kind of person that's healthy and morally superior, like we were saying the quote before,
- 36:16and that person has to be vegan.
- 36:19But those kinds of perspectives would only come from vegans as well.
- 36:23I'm not sure that we would ask if we asked a meat eater or anyone else in the population
- 36:28if smarter people are vegan, their immediate response is going to be, of course not.
- 36:32I'm not sure if that's really much of an answer.
- 36:35It's just me thinking about the question, but it is.
- 36:39And another argument against vegans being smarter is personified by Neil deGrasse Tyson.
- 36:48And I know you also mentioned him in the book.
- 36:51I think in the first pages.
- 36:54And it's one thing to be, you know, passively non-vegan like Richard Dawkins.
- 37:00It's another to push the most ridiculous arguments against veganism and be this incredibly intelligent
- 37:12man.
- 37:14When you try to understand what's happening here, how can Neil deGrasse Tyson be talking
- 37:23about plants having emotions?
- 37:25Well, I'll let you talk about it.
- 37:29Yeah, well, exactly.
- 37:31And I mean, even just being factually wrong saying that I think he's and I'm not going
- 37:38to get the quote right, but his quote was something like there's two kinds of food,
- 37:44animal based food where you don't have to kill anything or anyone, we would say.
- 37:49And that's milk and honey.
- 37:52But of course, exactly.
- 37:54We hear that statement, we just think, well, that's ridiculous.
- 37:56Of course, where do you think veal comes from?
- 38:00And what do you think happens to the cows after they're too old to produce enough milk
- 38:06anymore, not even no milk, but enough milk, as if they just go off and live down the back
- 38:11of the farm and they have happy, wonderful lives.
- 38:15And that's right.
- 38:16I think that was that was exactly my point.
- 38:19I think firstly, that if you're not like if it's not in your interest area to go out of
- 38:25your way to say, what about this?
- 38:28And then even another step further and saying, but don't plants bleed?
- 38:33Doesn't a tree suffocate?
- 38:35Like it's beyond ridiculous.
- 38:38If that chapter of the book, I believe it was called Starry Messenger, if that didn't
- 38:44have someone's name on it, we would be laughing the whole way through it.
- 38:49And it's like it's a different thing when you attach someone like him to it.
- 38:55And you think how is someone of that intelligence or that understanding of how not just the
- 39:00world works, but the universe works so ignorant on something that's fundamentally true about
- 39:07biology and about farming and all these kinds of things.
- 39:11But it kind of comes back to something that we learned, or we hopefully learned during
- 39:19the COVID pandemic, was that just because someone has doctor in front of their name
- 39:23or PhD after it doesn't mean they're an expert in everything.
- 39:27And like a good example is Australia's performance at the Olympics.
- 39:33Our break dancing person has a PhD in break dancing.
- 39:40Ray Gunn, I think her name was.
- 39:43Yeah.
- 39:44Yeah.
- 39:45So like trying to, I believe it's called the white coat effect that, you know, someone
- 39:52who's a doctor of astronomy should probably not be commenting too much on biology or evolution
- 40:00beyond their general understanding of it.
- 40:03Like that's for, you know, Richard Dawkins can comment on biology because he's a biologist
- 40:08and Neil deGrasse Tyson can comment on astrology, astronomy, sorry, because he's an astronomer.
- 40:14He's not a biologist, even though he would have a general understanding of that.
- 40:21And yeah, there's lots of these experiments that have been done where people go into shopping
- 40:29malls, for example, and have medical information on a table.
- 40:33And it's exactly the same two days in a row.
- 40:35The only difference is that one day the person is dressed in normal clothes and the next
- 40:39day they're dressed in a white coat.
- 40:42And the day that they're wearing a white coat, people talk to them more, they listen more,
- 40:47they take more information.
- 40:49It's the exact same thing.
- 40:51It's not different, but it's just because they're wearing a white coat.
- 40:55And we kind of do the same things when we go to GPs.
- 40:57We think our GPs are so wonderful and amazing because they're doctors, but they're also
- 41:05GPs.
- 41:06Like they're not, if your leg needs to be amputated and you're not going to go to your
- 41:10GP, you're going to go to a specialist.
- 41:11Like they're kind of the triage and they can help a lot of things.
- 41:17So I think it's understanding where someone's expertise is.
- 41:22And there can be other things applied to it.
- 41:25Like as animal activists, we're obviously not biologists and we're not experts in farming
- 41:29practices and all these kinds of things either.
- 41:32That there is some benefit to having general knowledge.
- 41:36But when you're trying to educate someone, we still rely on experts.
- 41:41We rely on plant-based dietitians and we rely on medical researchers who don't use animals
- 41:47and the processes that they go through and things like that.
- 41:49So I think it's, yeah, Neil deGrasse Tyson's an interesting one.
- 41:54I think he's become so generally popular now.
- 41:59He's been on like the Simpsons and Big Bang Theory and stuff like this as well.
- 42:04So almost everybody knows who he is.
- 42:05So everybody seeks him out for information, even if it's not relevant to the conversation.
- 42:10Yeah, it's crazy that he became a vehicle for those bad ideas and those attacks that
- 42:25we consider being trolling against vegans.
- 42:29Yeah.
- 42:30And like I say in the book too, it's not just like he, one of his defenses of a previous
- 42:38I think a Twitter post that he'd made about cows.
- 42:43He said, I'm just stating a fact.
- 42:46But I think that's a really narrow view of it as well because there are children and
- 42:50high school kids who look up to people like that and they'll say, well, if he thinks that,
- 42:55I think that.
- 42:57Whether they don't critically think about it or if it reinforces an existing opinion.
- 43:03But I think people like that need to understand the influence that even just stating a fact,
- 43:11which whether it's a fact or not, I think his Twitter post was a cow is a biological
- 43:16machine created by humans to turn grass into protein or something like that, which is not
- 43:22necessarily untrue, but whether it's relevant to anybody's conversation ever.
- 43:28And it didn't seem to appreciate the impact that making a statement like that would have
- 43:35on intelligent conversation generally.
- 43:39And I think that's where some, going back to the smarter question, some smarter people
- 43:49are not necessarily socially or what I'm trying to say, like they don't have the social skills
- 43:57to understand how information is being perceived.
- 44:00They're just putting information out into the world and letting it kind of live a life.
- 44:04But we also need to understand how it's being perceived.
- 44:08And I think we can use this as a self-critical thing as well, that when we use certain words
- 44:11in our outreach, it can have the effect of alienating people or we can soften some of
- 44:18our language to help get them on board.
- 44:22And it's the same kind of lesson, I think.
- 44:26And also you mentioned the king of podcasting, Joe Rogan, and he always say, you know, I'm
- 44:34a comic.
- 44:35Why do you go and listen to me talk about and follow my advice concerning COVID or whatever?
- 44:44I'm not an expert in that.
- 44:46I'm just a comic.
- 44:48And I feel we should say the same about Neil deGrasse Tyson.
- 44:54He's not a biologist.
- 44:57He's not a philosopher, an ethical philosopher.
- 45:05It's the responsibility of his audience to think of him as an expert in this field and
- 45:14the rest, the things he says in the margins.
- 45:19Well, let's listen to that with some skepticism.
- 45:26Yeah.
- 45:27And I think we can learn from that as well, that bringing it back to the book, that the
- 45:32way that we talked about children, they look up to us as the source of knowledge and they
- 45:41take after our actions.
- 45:43And it's like, you know, Christian parents are more likely to have Christian children,
- 45:49and a rugby league fan is more likely to have a rugby league child and all these kinds of
- 45:53things.
- 45:56There's a big influence there that I think we need to understand.
- 45:59And so even just, and I mentioned a few of them in the book, some offhanded comments
- 46:03and actions can have quite a lot of impact on a child's development when they're mirroring
- 46:10a lot of things.
- 46:11My son at the moment, he's almost two and he's mirroring everything, all of our words,
- 46:16he will repeat back to us and a lot of our actions, he will repeat back to us.
- 46:21And sometimes it's quite funny and other times we think, Oh, don't know about that.
- 46:25But it's all very impactful when I think one example I used in the book was we're in an
- 46:36electronic store one day and this kid walked up to a table full of electronic tablets and
- 46:45said, what are these?
- 46:47And the mom said, well, these are so people can watch videos and write and all these kinds
- 46:54of things.
- 46:55And he said, how did they get here?
- 46:58And she said, you could tell more questions that he asked her, very quickly she lost interest
- 47:05in answering to the point where she literally just walked away.
- 47:08She didn't even answer the next question.
- 47:09She walked away.
- 47:11And I just stood there, probably very weirdly staring at this child in the middle of a department
- 47:16store thinking, because he had kind of frozen as well.
- 47:21It was like he was processing what had just happened.
- 47:23And I thought these are like, these are lessons he's going to learn.
- 47:27Don't ask too many questions.
- 47:29Maybe even worse, don't ask mom too many questions.
- 47:33You know, I don't need to understand how things work properly.
- 47:37All these kinds of things that will then impact potentially the rest of his life, because
- 47:42it's very hard to break out of some of these habits that we form.
- 47:46If you learn not to ask questions, then it's very hard to say to someone, it's okay to
- 47:53ask questions, even if you're afraid of the answer.
- 47:57So I think as even on a smaller scale, which is probably more relatable to what we do and
- 48:03what most people do to understand the little things that we do and how they have impacts
- 48:08on children.
- 48:09And yeah, like potentially even that they don't understand where their food comes from,
- 48:15which I think is even whether they're vegan parents or not, I think having the conversation
- 48:20saying we killed a chicken or we paid someone to kill a chicken for your salad is still
- 48:26appropriate.
- 48:27And maybe there's different ages where that might be appropriate.
- 48:30But I think I would rather be honest in the communication than just forcing people to
- 48:37be vegan.
- 48:39And I asked this actually of a guest, one of my podcast episodes.
- 48:48And yeah, we said like, if you could snap your fingers today and make everyone vegan,
- 48:52would we?
- 48:53And he said, no, I wouldn't because then people don't know why they're vegan.
- 48:55They haven't made the journey to get there.
- 48:57They haven't like we would save a lot of animals lives.
- 49:00It's true, but more potentially trillions of them.
- 49:03But people would very quickly fall back into other practices, I think.
- 49:08And like they wouldn't understand why they're doing these things.
- 49:11It's all I think education is always the always the answer.
- 49:15Yeah.
- 49:16Well, you are competing.
- 49:18Well, at least, you know, first of all, at least your wife is also vegan.
- 49:23So you're, you know, both on the same page about those values.
- 49:31So you're not competing against the cultural views of your wife.
- 49:38You're both on the same page, but you are competing against other, you know, exterior
- 49:43agents, such as teachers or Disney.
- 49:51And that I really wanted to get to.
- 49:55You talk about in the book, the disnification of animals.
- 50:00And that is something that just, you know, keeps coming back to my mind, you know, when
- 50:10I think about animal rights and how animals are perceived, you know, and it's that story
- 50:19about Nemo and how this movie, this big production.
- 50:27And I know it's Pixar.
- 50:28It's not Disney, but same.
- 50:31But this big production that for, you know, for the first time portrayed a fish as a sentient
- 50:39creature and you know, the whole plot of the movie was about animal abuse and getting out
- 50:48of a tank.
- 50:51If you had to design the perfect animal rights movie about fish, you could have made Nemo.
- 51:01Yet when that was presented, when, you know, people watch that, their first instinct was
- 51:08to go and purchase clownfish.
- 51:11Right.
- 51:14And you know, it's just, I can't, it's so hard to understand it.
- 51:20And you tackle that problem and you talk about how we portray animals in, how we have portrayed
- 51:29animals in Disney movies and so on.
- 51:32Yeah.
- 51:33I think it's such a good example.
- 51:34I think I didn't, I didn't talk about Nemo in the book.
- 51:38And even thinking back to it, I think I, from the examples that I remember putting in there
- 51:42were examples that I had when I was growing up that I maybe could have learned from, like
- 51:48that presented opportunities to learn from, or were some of the reasons why I thought
- 51:51certain things about certain animals.
- 51:53So yeah, so one of them is babe, which I guess most people talk about.
- 52:00And I think there's some really good lessons in there, even just about communicating and
- 52:06understanding that animals have, like animals can communicate, they have the ability to
- 52:15communicate and we just need to listen a bit better to them.
- 52:18And there's a really good quote as to, a really good bit in the film where the first time
- 52:24babe goes and talks to the sheep.
- 52:28And from my memory of the film, he's like a little bit nervous and he's like, the farmer
- 52:31wants me to do this.
- 52:33And the sheep, one of the sheep just respond and says, all you need to do is ask.
- 52:37And I think that's one of the best moments of the film because it kind of says, like
- 52:41anybody can get along with each other.
- 52:43We just need to talk a little bit more.
- 52:44We need to make sure we're communicating on the same level.
- 52:48And there are some minor issues, I think with babe and that everyone speaks English.
- 52:53So obviously sheep and pigs would have different dialects and things like this.
- 52:58But I mean, there's lots of, lots even just James Cromwell being in the film, that's the
- 53:06film that made him consider his impact.
- 53:10And a lot of responses to the film were that if people weren't vegetarian, then they reduce
- 53:16their meat intake.
- 53:17And there was a report I read on the instances, I think it was called the babe effect or something
- 53:22like that.
- 53:23And the effect that a film like that had.
- 53:26But yeah, it's interesting that, I don't know, Finding Nemo is a animated film, but it's
- 53:34interesting that, and maybe we just didn't really discuss it much more, that after babe,
- 53:39there wasn't like an increase in demand for pigs as pets, but there was an increase in
- 53:43demand for clownfish as pets.
- 53:47And I wonder if something else that maybe I neglected to explore was not just the way
- 53:54that animals are portrayed in the films, but the way that the films are marketed in that
- 54:00everything from a film can be owned now.
- 54:04So like when there was babe, you couldn't like, at least I remember, you couldn't go
- 54:09out and buy like a babe action figure.
- 54:11And I feel like if it was released in 2024, you could probably go out and buy a babe action
- 54:16figure.
- 54:17Whereas when Nemo came out, there were a lot of like, we were just used to Disney marketing
- 54:23things and especially in a time of like huge films like Toy Story, where you could go out
- 54:28and buy Woody and Frozen, where you could go and buy Elsa.
- 54:33Well, of course, even with a film that does have a lot of animal rights messages in it,
- 54:39like Finding Nemo, if you don't get those messages, or I guess even if you do, you can
- 54:46still go out and buy a clownfish toy.
- 54:49But also, the next step is that well clownfish are actually quite accessible, that they do
- 54:55fit into a tank that you can sit on your nightstand.
- 54:59They shouldn't be in a tank that small, but they can fit into one.
- 55:03So it's very easy to have one at home, a live clownfish, not just a toy.
- 55:10And so yeah, there's a lot to be said about the communication or the marketing, I suppose,
- 55:17between the two children of these films and whether that's the intention.
- 55:22And from the book that I referenced, The Diznification of Animals, she makes a very good point that
- 55:27everything in animation needs to be, is deliberate because you need to draw it, you purposefully
- 55:33put it there.
- 55:34So like one example that again, I didn't explore in the book is the film Madagascar, which
- 55:39I watched with my son the other day.
- 55:43And in it, there's the lemur population on Madagascar has a king.
- 55:48But as far as like I read a book by Lucy Cook about a year ago, and she referenced this
- 55:57film in it and said, but lemurs don't have kings, they have queens, like it's a matriarchy.
- 56:04So the filmmakers deliberately made the head of the lemurs a king, even though they hopefully
- 56:11knew very well that it was supposed to be a queen.
- 56:13Like that was a deliberate choice.
- 56:16And so like there's lots of conversations, I guess, around whether it's appropriate to
- 56:21portray matriarchy in films when we're not used to that.
- 56:24We're used to kings and princesses, not queens necessarily.
- 56:28If they are queens, then they're evil queens.
- 56:33And then there's even some older films where just really subtly there was in Fantasia,
- 56:41there was a scene where like a toy soldier gets lost down a drain.
- 56:46And like all the rats in the drain have like really sharp teeth, sharp claws, red eyes.
- 56:51And for people who don't see rats, I mean, when was the last time most of us see a rat,
- 56:56unless you live in like India or New York, you don't really see them that much.
- 57:00So that's our impression of rats.
- 57:03And maybe some of the damage was repaired with films like Ratatouille and things like
- 57:08that where they're portrayed as more, you know, a bit cuter and likeable.
- 57:12But yeah, I think the Nemo example is very interesting and a good one of the way that
- 57:21maybe the way that we market or films are marketed to us and the dimension that they
- 57:28take on after the film as well or beyond just sitting and watching a 90 minute film that
- 57:32you can now incorporate all these things into your life.
- 57:35You can have fish tanks and participate in the enslavement of animals or the capture
- 57:44of animals that you just watched a film about releasing the animals and how much they don't
- 57:50want to be in a tank.
- 57:51Yeah, it's very, it's very strange.
- 57:53But that's such a great insight and analysis.
- 57:58I never thought about it, about how the clownfish was just a marketing toy and that it relates
- 58:09to the era in which we live.
- 58:13And yeah, that's the difference between Finding Nemo and Babe.
- 58:18Yeah, it's truly fascinating.
- 58:21And you know, likewise, there are some animals that are, I guess, attractive to us and then
- 58:30other that, you know, repel us like the rats or even, you know, the pigs.
- 58:37And I'm thinking of, you know, the logo of my podcast and also the cover of your book
- 58:45where we see a pig.
- 58:48And you know, at first that image of a pig when the illustrator presented me with that
- 58:56picture of, you know, logo drafting, I thought, no, I don't want a pig on, you know, representing
- 59:06my show.
- 59:10And then I had like a pause and I thought, oh my, it's been like nine years.
- 59:17I have been vegan for the last nine years and still this has, you know, power over me.
- 59:26Those strong images, those associations are still ingrained in my mind.
- 59:36Yeah, yeah.
- 59:38And I have one that I particularly struggle with, but occasionally give into is that I
- 59:48grew up in central New South Wales, a state here in Australia.
- 59:52I think it's the second most populous state in Australia.
- 59:56It may be the first, but literally right in the middle.
- 1:00:00And there's a free, not free range, open range zoo there.
- 1:00:04So it's still in enclosures, but they're quite big.
- 1:00:07You know, it's not, you know, the Serengeti, but you know, they do get to wander around
- 1:00:12a little bit, but you still do see like the tiger tracks because they're pacing back and
- 1:00:15forward and things like this.
- 1:00:17But growing up, that's what you did every week.
- 1:00:21Like we would go to the zoo just about every week and go and see different animals.
- 1:00:26And that's, I think in hindsight, I probably look at that as where I first appreciated
- 1:00:33animals, even if it wasn't to the point where I didn't want to eat them, but it's still
- 1:00:39something that I can't shake.
- 1:00:41Like even we'll watch, you know, a documentary on TV and I'll think, oh, we need to take
- 1:00:45Desmond my son.
- 1:00:46We should take him to see a tiger.
- 1:00:49Like again, just the first thought is let's go to the zoo because that's what I did for
- 1:00:53like, you know, with my family, I did that for 15 or 16 years.
- 1:00:58And then even after that, I bought a house just down the road from the zoo.
- 1:01:01So it was nice to go and get a coffee, or nice for me to go and get a coffee and sit
- 1:01:06in front of a tiger for an hour and drink a coffee just staring at a tiger.
- 1:01:09That was, that's a nice place to drink a coffee for a human.
- 1:01:12It's not nice for the tiger, but it's something that yeah, is so deeply ingrained into me
- 1:01:18that my first thought is let's go to the zoo, even to the point where I don't realize what
- 1:01:23I'm doing sometimes until we get into the zoo.
- 1:01:25And I'm like, that's right.
- 1:01:27This is where they keep the animals in cages because it's just, it's just part of my nature.
- 1:01:34It's like the education that I had growing up.
- 1:01:38And it's like, again, it's not like I blame my parents for forcing me to, you know, accept
- 1:01:44that we need zoos or anything like that.
- 1:01:46It's just, it's just what you did.
- 1:01:48And yeah, I'll still like, I'll go to the zoo and you know, I'll still look at the cage
- 1:01:55and I'll say, Oh God, they're a little bit small or, you know, that's not an endangered
- 1:01:58species.
- 1:01:59Why are we breeding them as if it makes me feel a little bit better about being there.
- 1:02:04But you're right.
- 1:02:05It's very, I think if we're honest with ourselves, it's very hard to remove some of those things.
- 1:02:13And it's much easier to, you know, to, well, I feel like being vegan, whatever the definition
- 1:02:21of vegan is, at least being plant based, that having a plant based diet is easy.
- 1:02:26I don't feel like it was hard to get rid of animal products from my diet.
- 1:02:32But some of these like entrenched things are really quite difficult to shake, especially
- 1:02:38when I'm looking at educating my child.
- 1:02:40And I'm like, with animals like tigers, it may be that by the time he's old enough and
- 1:02:48has enough money to travel to Asia to see tigers that they don't actually exist anymore.
- 1:02:54They might be extinct except in zoos.
- 1:02:56So if I'm to teach him about a tiger, do I tell him that they don't exist anymore?
- 1:03:01Or do I take him to the zoo to show him a tiger, but also saying that the tiger shouldn't
- 1:03:06be here.
- 1:03:07That was stolen from their home.
- 1:03:09And it's very, it's very tricky.
- 1:03:11And it's the same with rats.
- 1:03:13I, rats are one of my favorite, I've kind of, I guess, you know, having an interest in particularly
- 1:03:21animals in labs.
- 1:03:25Rats are kind of one of the ones that I've gravitated towards most.
- 1:03:30But yeah, still, it's still like this impression of a dirty rat, even though I know that they're
- 1:03:37not dirty at all, they're very, very clean.
- 1:03:41And they're incredibly adaptable to their environment.
- 1:03:43And that's why they've survived so well in places like New York, because they just adapt
- 1:03:49so well.
- 1:03:50But yeah, there's still like these impressions of, you know, get a little shiver when you
- 1:03:54think of a rat or a cockroach or whatever it might be.
- 1:04:02And a lot of it, I think I mentioned it really briefly in the book, a lot of it is this misinformation
- 1:04:07that we had when we grew up that we thought, you know, dogs are colorblind, I still often
- 1:04:12look at my dog and think, how does he see the world?
- 1:04:14But he's not colorblind.
- 1:04:15He just can't see all of the colors in the way that we do.
- 1:04:19And it's very difficult to break out of some of those, those ways of thinking.
- 1:04:25And I think saying the word pet is a good one as well.
- 1:04:28Like, how many vegans do we chat to in our conversations?
- 1:04:31It will still say my pet at home.
- 1:04:34But then when we're talking to someone in outreach or in other conversations, we'll
- 1:04:39kind of check every single word before we say it out loud and we'll make sure we say
- 1:04:43companion animal, whether it makes that much of a difference to the conversation.
- 1:04:47I'm not sure.
- 1:04:48But it's like just these things just flow off our tongues.
- 1:04:52And then so much easier than I think we would admit to.
- 1:04:58Yes.
- 1:04:59I absolutely agree with everything you just said.
- 1:05:05And yet about the zoo part, you know, they are fascinating places.
- 1:05:12You know, I often hear vegans talking about zoos as open air prisons.
- 1:05:18But at least with prisons, you have criminals in them.
- 1:05:24People who, you know, most likely have done things to deserve to be locked in, or at least
- 1:05:32they're there not to harm the general population.
- 1:05:35But those animals are innocent of any crimes.
- 1:05:39So I guess, you know, a better analogy would be it's like the Truman show with those zoos.
- 1:05:46Yeah, well, yeah, that's true.
- 1:05:49But yeah, in the criminal system, I mean, it's very different in Australia than it might
- 1:05:54be in a lot of other places that, yes, about hopefully about rehabilitation.
- 1:06:00But yeah, that's right.
- 1:06:01Like if you're born into a zoo, it's not like even through these breeding programs.
- 1:06:05And like I said, I'm often amazed when they'll have a baby giraffe, for example, but giraffe
- 1:06:09are not endangered.
- 1:06:12It's obviously there to get people into the gates and they won't ever be released back
- 1:06:17into the wild because they're just not going to be able to fend for themselves.
- 1:06:21Like they know when they're getting food and they know when they're being cleaned and all
- 1:06:25these kinds of things in a zoo.
- 1:06:26They're very, I guess the word was probably institutionalized maybe.
- 1:06:32So like sending them out into the, you know, sending them back to where they should have
- 1:06:38been born.
- 1:06:39They're never going to be able to survive there.
- 1:06:42They have to stay in a zoo once they're in a zoo, which is very hard to think about and
- 1:06:47often have this argument or discussion with people.
- 1:06:50It's like if we were successful in all of our campaigns tomorrow and they say, we're
- 1:06:54not using animals for anything anymore.
- 1:06:58That is a really quite, I mean, it's better than killing them, but also there's going
- 1:07:03to be billions of animals that are going where?
- 1:07:08So if we release all the animals for labs in Australia, we use between eight and 10
- 1:07:11million a year.
- 1:07:12Most of those animals have already been bred and most of them are rats and mice and fish.
- 1:07:17So where do the animals go if we just end medical research tomorrow?
- 1:07:21And I think it would be the same with zoos.
- 1:07:23If we shut or if we stopped zoos, if we outlawed them and made them illegal, then like the
- 1:07:29animals are going to have to live out their lives in a zoo anyway.
- 1:07:31I think maybe a better way of approaching it would be to stop breeding programs in zoos,
- 1:07:38unless the animals were definitely going to be reintroduced into the wild, certain rhinos
- 1:07:42and things like that, which can be.
- 1:07:44But yeah, I think there's still an argument even from an animal rights perspective.
- 1:07:50I guess they'd be called sanctuaries then and not zoos maybe.
- 1:07:54Yes.
- 1:07:55But I have no problem with zoos or sanctuaries that understand that and become a tool for
- 1:08:10advancing animal protection, advocacy.
- 1:08:18Yes.
- 1:08:21Just for that and for creating that contact that children and adults need with animals
- 1:08:29to stop thinking of them as legumes.
- 1:08:32Yes, exactly.
- 1:08:35Yeah.
- 1:08:36Yeah, we I think we need to find a better way.
- 1:08:40Yeah.
- 1:08:41And another good example is dinosaurs.
- 1:08:42I was going to say we need to find a better way of appreciating animals without necessarily
- 1:08:48needing to capture them or breed them in captivity.
- 1:08:53And dinosaurs is probably a good example that every two or three year old at some point
- 1:08:57is going to be obsessed with dinosaurs to the point they can name them these horrible
- 1:09:02big Latin names that we're all supposed to know.
- 1:09:06But they've never met a dinosaur.
- 1:09:08You can't go to a zoo and say dinosaur, but they still have this really huge appreciation
- 1:09:14of them.
- 1:09:15They know all about them.
- 1:09:16They know where they lived.
- 1:09:20I think there's more lessons in that.
- 1:09:22And it's not something that I've explored too much.
- 1:09:24More lessons in that and how we teach children to appreciate animals without always having
- 1:09:30to be in front of one.
- 1:09:31I think it's an added layer if you can be in front of one.
- 1:09:36But I think dinosaurs teach us that you don't necessarily need to be right in front of one
- 1:09:41to for children to appreciate them or to like them or and there may be a bit more with that
- 1:09:47that there's like the border between fantasy and imagination I think.
- 1:09:52Whereas dinosaurs don't really fit into fantasy because they were real.
- 1:09:58But they still allow children to use their imagination as to what they might have sounded
- 1:10:02like and these kinds of things.
- 1:10:05Yeah, I think we can learn a lot from potentially exploring that a little bit more.
- 1:10:13And I am looking forward to the next book.
- 1:10:20I've thought about it.
- 1:10:23I thought now that I've written this one theorizing about how we educate children on animals, I
- 1:10:30need to put it into practice now.
- 1:10:31How am I actually doing it and how am I dealing with the conversations that I'm having to
- 1:10:36have and pushing back against people who think I'm neglecting my child because I'm forcing
- 1:10:42him to be vegan and all these horrible things that I do to my child.
- 1:10:47Yes.
- 1:10:48And that's what I want to know.
- 1:10:51How theory and practice clash and what is your experience now of being in that seat
- 1:11:00of being a dad, being vegan and having to again transmit those values to your child
- 1:11:08in a society that is not at all sympathetic to the vegan values.
- 1:11:18And it's a true challenge.
- 1:11:21I hope that future generations of vegans will not have to face the social pressure of being
- 1:11:31judged for their choices from everywhere, from media to your family, to friends, to
- 1:11:42colleagues.
- 1:11:43Yeah.
- 1:11:44Yeah.
- 1:11:45And I think I'm very fortunate and then we have a lot of either vegan or plant-based
- 1:11:50friends or people who understand.
- 1:11:53It's like you do you, that's fine.
- 1:11:55We know why you do it.
- 1:11:58But yeah, there's definitely some challenges.
- 1:12:00It's I guess the same thing that when you tell someone that you're vegan or you don't
- 1:12:04eat animals, suddenly they become a dietician.
- 1:12:07It's the same with having a child.
- 1:12:10Suddenly they're like, but where is he getting his protein from?
- 1:12:13And you need to make sure he's getting enough of this and getting enough of that.
- 1:12:16And I think we're very privileged in Melbourne here in Australia to be able to have access
- 1:12:23to so much food, real food, not animal food or animal-based food.
- 1:12:31And so we do a lot of cooking as well.
- 1:12:34We don't eat out a whole lot, even though there are quite a few options when we do eat
- 1:12:37out.
- 1:12:40And we've added extra layers to it as well.
- 1:12:42We haven't really done things like sugar and he's coming up to his second birthday.
- 1:12:48So he didn't have that much cake and sweet things and stuff like that.
- 1:12:52So he likes bitter food.
- 1:12:54He likes fruit and things like that, but he's fine with broccoli and stuff like that as
- 1:12:57well.
- 1:12:58So whereas other kids we seem to be hearing have this beige food phase where they'll eat
- 1:13:04nothing but French fries and fried food.
- 1:13:10He's fine eating rainbow food, we call it.
- 1:13:12So blueberries and broccoli and bananas.
- 1:13:18I think also we have the, I guess, as a parent, it's kind of the benefit.
- 1:13:24And I don't mean that to sound horrible, of having his grandparents live away.
- 1:13:33So my wife's from London, so her parents live in the UK and I'm from central New South Wales.
- 1:13:39And my parents live about a thousand kilometres away.
- 1:13:42So we've been able to kind of freely look after him, I suppose, or raise him.
- 1:13:49Whereas most parents would have their parents very close by, they'd be coming over quite
- 1:13:55a bit more often.
- 1:13:58I think there would be a lot of benefit to that as well.
- 1:14:02And they do come to visit quite a bit, which is wonderful.
- 1:14:05But yeah, there's not, I think we don't have the same kind of influences over him as a
- 1:14:12lot of other people might struggle with, and having people living a lot closer with them
- 1:14:17or bringing their existing opinions and lifestyles with them.
- 1:14:27And we've also, whether we stick to this or not, at the moment, we're pursuing a home
- 1:14:35schooling, mostly because I want him to have, you know, often when people say they're homeschooling
- 1:14:40their child, it's because they want to narrow their experiences.
- 1:14:42It's like we want to raise them as a Christian or we want to raise them as a whatever, but
- 1:14:47we want to do the opposite.
- 1:14:48We want to expand his things.
- 1:14:49So we want him to have more access to arts and sports and these kinds of things.
- 1:14:56And taking him to sanctuaries, like farm sanctuaries as part of that.
- 1:15:02And so he may not have as many influences from fixed social groups as other children
- 1:15:10might as well.
- 1:15:11Like his social groups are going to be quite a bit bigger and quite a bit more diverse
- 1:15:15because he'll be going to these different places as opposed to the restriction of a
- 1:15:19school class.
- 1:15:23But in saying all of that, he's almost two.
- 1:15:26So he's still very, very new and I think as far as the challenges so far have mostly just
- 1:15:34been with some minor instances with medical people who will kind of say, oh, you should
- 1:15:42do this or you should do that.
- 1:15:44And of course, being half responsible vegan parents, we'll just immediately call our plant
- 1:15:51based dietitian and say, our GP just told us we should be giving him this.
- 1:15:54Is this true?
- 1:15:55And of course, they'll just shake their head and we're like, okay, cool.
- 1:15:58Thanks.
- 1:15:59So I think I would add that to it as well to have some kind of professional support
- 1:16:03in, particularly with diets, I think to make sure because it is a constant concern when
- 1:16:09you're trying to grow someone healthily.
- 1:16:13There are some of those things, like we said, they're deeply entrenched.
- 1:16:16There's always that thought of, is he getting enough protein?
- 1:16:18Is he getting enough iron?
- 1:16:20And it's okay when it's you.
- 1:16:22You can feel like when you're a bit low in iron or don't have as much energy and things
- 1:16:27like these, you can correct it.
- 1:16:28But with a two year old, he can't say, I don't have as much energy today.
- 1:16:33So it's a lot more difficult, but I think it can be made a lot more easy by having access
- 1:16:40to a few kind of professional support, particularly nutritional support.
- 1:16:45Yeah.
- 1:16:46Yes.
- 1:16:47And I'm absolutely for homeschooling.
- 1:16:50I'm a big fan of Peter Gray and his book, Free to Learn, which I recommend.
- 1:16:58Yeah.
- 1:16:59I even interviewed him in a past incarnation of this podcast and maybe I should release
- 1:17:08my interview with him since we're talking about this.
- 1:17:14But yeah, I mean, let's think about this month.
- 1:17:19Let's think about the future generation of vegans and let's build a better world for
- 1:17:25them.
- 1:17:26Let's make their fight less hard and their veganism less obstructed with so many inconveniences.
- 1:17:38Yeah, exactly.
- 1:17:40And I think that's thinking about how we're setting up the next generation.
- 1:17:46That's kind of what each subsequent one does.
- 1:17:48And I think there's some generations that are a little more self-centered in on themselves
- 1:17:53or their society or their culture or whatever it might be.
- 1:17:57But ultimately, we want it to be set up for the next people, the next generation to, like
- 1:18:03you said, have a slightly easier time with the things that we had a hard time with because
- 1:18:07they're going to have a hard time, particularly with changing environments and political polarization.
- 1:18:14And these things are going to be much harder for them.
- 1:18:18So if we can make these things easier now, then they won't have to deal with that quite
- 1:18:23as much as we have had to.
- 1:18:25Those are great parting words.
- 1:18:27Adam, did you want to add something before I stop the recording?
- 1:18:32No, again, thank you so much for having me.
- 1:18:34I really love your podcast.
- 1:18:35I've learned quite a lot.
- 1:18:37And yeah, I'm just very happy to talk about these things.
- 1:18:43Well thank you so much, Adam.
- 1:18:44Thank you so much for your time, for having written this book.
- 1:18:47It's another joy of, you can't see it, but here it is.
- 1:18:54It's another joy of, you know, podcasting, being able to meet the writers behind the
- 1:19:00books you read.
- 1:19:01Yeah, what an amazing treat.
- 1:19:04So again, thank you so much, Adam.
- 1:19:07Thank you everyone for listening.
- 1:19:09I kindly invite you to share this podcast with the vegans you know.
- 1:19:13Let's encourage more people to take action.
- 1:19:16Again, thank you so much for caring, and I will see you next Tuesday for a new episode.