Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / The Perfect Storm: Credit Risk and Modern Collections with David Reed
Transcript
- 0:00Treichel: Hey everyone, this is Mark Treichel with another
- 0:02episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:04I'm excited today to be here with David Reed of Reed Jolly, the law firm.
- 0:09David, how you doing today?
- 0:10David Reed: I'm doing great, Mark.
- 0:11It's a pleasure for being here.
- 0:13Thanks for having me.
- 0:14Treichel: You got it.
- 0:14Yeah.
- 0:15And you're on my mailing list and we follow each other on LinkedIn
- 0:18and I, I shoot a lot of different things out in both directions and
- 0:21we had a good little dialogue going on the other day about, about loan
- 0:25quality and it it, it triggered, Hey, let's get you on the podcast.
- 0:29And, I first met you back when you helped NCUA with some strategic planning
- 0:33under the Matt's administration.
- 0:35I think that was back when Dave Marquis was executive director and
- 0:38I was regional director, but, and that's when I got to know you and
- 0:41all that and enjoyed that back then.
- 0:43And I've enjoyed following you since, but, so a lot of my
- 0:46listeners may know who you are.
- 0:48Some of them may not, if you could maybe give me a little bit of your
- 0:50background, that would be great.
- 0:52David Reed: Absolutely.
- 0:53I hope nobody holds this against me, but I'm an attorney by trade.
- 0:57But I always introduced myself as a recovering general counsel.
- 1:01I entered the credit union world By working with credit union here, I'd been
- 1:07practicing for probably about 10 years and I was hired here in Northern Virginia.
- 1:13And my initial job title, which fits well into what we're talking about today was in
- 1:18house counsel slash collections manager.
- 1:22And I had been at a firm in D.
- 1:24C.,
- 1:25I had been doing a lot of civil litigation, a lot of different collections
- 1:28stuff at the state and federal level our twins at the time who they're pushing
- 1:3330 now, at the time they were probably three years old or so, and the D.
- 1:38C.
- 1:39world of law just, it's not a good place if you're you Working in DC with
- 1:44a family in the outskirts of Virginia.
- 1:46So I looked for an in house gig and I went in with the credit union
- 1:50give a shout out to Apple Federal Credit Union in Fairfax, Virginia.
- 1:54Great credit union.
- 1:55And Larry Kelly, the CEO hired me because they were having issues
- 1:59in their collections department.
- 2:00And I sometimes joke that they said they were having a fire in their collections
- 2:04department, but I think that's because they had fired the prior manager.
- 2:08They were looking as they were growing to bring on an attorney anyway, but
- 2:12this was a great doorway to do it.
- 2:14And I started with the promise that, hey, as you learn the business, because
- 2:19I had never worked in or around a financial institution, as you learn the
- 2:23business, your responsibilities will grow.
- 2:25So for the first.
- 2:26Probably 18 months.
- 2:27I was a frontline manager.
- 2:28I wasn't in the I wasn't a director.
- 2:30I wasn't in the C suite.
- 2:32I was the collections manager.
- 2:33So I learned the credit union world from the collections department.
- 2:38And as I began to put processes into place work on some training,
- 2:43change some key personnel.
- 2:44I then was able to hire a collections manager.
- 2:46I became general counsel.
- 2:48A couple of years later, I became VP of general counsel as part
- 2:51of the senior executive team.
- 2:53And then I think probably a year or so before we met.
- 2:57I I left a very friendly parting of ways.
- 3:01We work with Apple still now, and I formed my own little entity, and that's Reed and
- 3:07Jolly, and exclusively work with credit unions all across all across the country.
- 3:13I've also.
- 3:14I had the blessing of being a credit union volunteer for about a decade.
- 3:19I was a member of a supervisory committee of another federally chartered credit
- 3:23union served the last six years.
- 3:26As chairman of the supervisory committee.
- 3:28So I am seeing this this marketplace the cooperative financial services marketplace
- 3:33from a lot of different angles.
- 3:36But the one commonality that I've had throughout is an appreciation of loan
- 3:42quality and the role that the, collections plays not only within the credit unit
- 3:48operations, but also, let's face it.
- 3:50The A of Campbell's is asset quality, right?
- 3:53So it's it's a very important concept and the spotlight's
- 3:57getting shown on that again.
- 4:00Treichel: It sure is.
- 4:00And yeah, that's what kind of triggered our conversation.
- 4:02By the way, another shout out to Apple Federal Credit Union.
- 4:06They have a wonderful first responders first time home buyers
- 4:09program that my daughter and her husband were able to participate in.
- 4:13Oh, wonderful.
- 4:15That's great.
- 4:15David Reed: They have they have always been, I think, on the cutting edge of
- 4:20community based financial services.
- 4:21Treichel: You got it.
- 4:22You got it.
- 4:22But yeah, so the recent issue, a letter to.
- 4:24credit unions came out and I always do a podcast on that.
- 4:28It was always since I left NCUA, it's the one communication from NCUA that
- 4:33I look forward to most every year.
- 4:37And this year, I don't know, it was 22, 23 percent of the verbiage in that letter.
- 4:41The highest percentage of any topic that I can ever recall was specifically devoted
- 4:46to loan quality and asset quality and.
- 4:50David Reed: It was
- 4:51Treichel: right.
- 4:52So they're really focusing in on that.
- 4:54And I want to praise them sometimes.
- 4:56I beat them up.
- 4:57I've changed teams.
- 4:58I beat them up when I think they need to be,
- 5:01But I graduated.
- 5:02Yeah, I graduated.
- 5:03Yeah we, I praise them when I think praise is due.
- 5:07And there was a year that.
- 5:08A couple of years back where they had 12 priorities.
- 5:11And I, as I like to say, if everything's a priority, nothing's a priority.
- 5:14That's exactly right.
- 5:15If we focus
- 5:15David Reed: on everything,
- 5:16Treichel: if we're going to be
- 5:17David Reed: number one at everything,
- 5:19Treichel: So they've honed it in, they've got it down to four or five
- 5:21priorities, but, and they devoted a lot of time to asset quality and that's
- 5:25because delinquency trends are up.
- 5:27Ironically, if you look at the numbers today, back to 15, 20 years ago, what
- 5:31we thought was high delinquency today.
- 5:33is different than what we thought was high delinquency back in the day, right?
- 5:38Those are creating some pressures for credit unions and you do some,
- 5:41and so you've seen some things with your clients, with your discussions.
- 5:45I know you do training as well.
- 5:46I've seen you doing, with some photos of you.
- 5:49I think standing on one leg doing some balance.
- 5:52Yeah.
- 5:53And anyway, so that balancing act of collecting the loans,
- 5:56making the loans and all that.
- 5:58Talk about what it is that you're seeing out there with your clients or your
- 6:01credit union discussions on loan quality, delinquency collections, et cetera.
- 6:06David Reed: Absolutely.
- 6:07First of all, just echo everything you just said.
- 6:09I was I am always pleased when the NCUA pulls back the curtain, which they do
- 6:16with the supervisory priorities and say it from our perspective, which let's
- 6:19face it is a pretty good perspective.
- 6:21This is what we're seeing.
- 6:23And I believe this is the second consecutive year that
- 6:25credit risk is up there.
- 6:27But it's the first time with a rocket, not that we.
- 6:31Put too much emphasis on what order it's in, but like you said, the vast
- 6:35majority, certainly the plurality of that letter was focused on credit risk.
- 6:40And it's a concern to a great many of our clients out there.
- 6:44I'm very blessed to be able to practice with with a great credit
- 6:47unit attorney, Bruce Jolly.
- 6:48And we have clients all across the country, and I have been doing an
- 6:53increasing amount of work going back to the delinquency control,
- 6:59collections portfolio management, risk management, which is the label
- 7:02that everything is going on now.
- 7:05And When you read the language of the NCUA letter 25 CU 01, first one out
- 7:12of the box, but they talk about the delinquency, particularly in credit cards
- 7:17and used car loans, and they harken back on credit cards to make their point.
- 7:23They said it's the highest level Since 2010 and just as a quick
- 7:28side note the world shifted on collections in 2010, right?
- 7:33So when I first started in the 90s in the credit union world,
- 7:38and I, like I said, I left at 07.
- 7:41So I left, just right before the world, collapsed mortgage
- 7:45backed securities and all that.
- 7:46But if you would have asked me, Probably even as I was out the door if
- 7:52you would have asked me, is there any way that real estate could dominate
- 7:57delinquencies either by numbers or a percentage or be the major concern
- 8:02from either an operational perspective or from a regulatory perspective.
- 8:05I would have said, of course not, of course not.
- 8:08I can remember, as we were shifting through different allowance for
- 8:11loan and lease loss methodologies, arguing for greater reserves.
- 8:17For a growing real estate portfolio.
- 8:19And I can remember arguing with the examiners, talk about the irony.
- 8:22They're like no, you're reserving too much.
- 8:24I'm like, listen, we're growing, 30 percent portfolio every year.
- 8:27They're like, yeah, but historical loss perspective and, all the
- 8:30things then what happened?
- 8:31Boom, the big short happened and that changed everything.
- 8:35And that kind of started.
- 8:38A different focus on collections with the modification policies,
- 8:41don't extend and pretend.
- 8:43But I only say that I focus on that because from my perspective it's as
- 8:48if that's the last time that anybody really focused on collections.
- 8:53They talk about it.
- 8:54But it's like smiling and nodding and looking at the key performance ratios.
- 8:58But as far as training and staffing and technology and process, there
- 9:05hasn't been a lot of work put into that by A great many credit units.
- 9:11The second thing that they mentioned in the supervisory priorities was in used
- 9:15cars and they made a special point.
- 9:18And this is, and you know how it is when the supervisory priorities or any
- 9:22letters to credit units are created.
- 9:24This thing went through 12 drafts, 14 different subcommittees read it,
- 9:28but they made a special point that said, if you look at the delinquency
- 9:32by portfolio, which is important.
- 9:34So a lot of people say, Oh our overall percentage is this.
- 9:37Okay.
- 9:37What is it in credit card and use cars and home equity lines of credit?
- 9:41And we'll probably talk about that in a few minutes, but it's the
- 9:43highest delinquency and charge off ever in used car loans.
- 9:48Ever.
- 9:49So what I'm seeing out there is, I'm not going to be overly dramatic like
- 9:54the NCOA sometimes but it is a little bit of the perfect storm, right?
- 9:58Credit cards, use card loads if you have economic instability.
- 10:03I don't know.
- 10:04Let's pick high inflation, right?
- 10:06Things like that.
- 10:07These are two areas where people of, dare I say, modest means they focus
- 10:13a lot of their borrowing, right?
- 10:15And credit cards help them cover what they're doing.
- 10:18And what I'm seeing is that many credit units are getting caught flat footed.
- 10:23With the rising tide of delinquency, and as they go to address it they're
- 10:30addressing it with processes and technology, or the lack thereof like
- 10:35they were doing 10 or 15 years ago and the market has passed them on that.
- 10:38So I work with a lot of different credit unions on basically just,
- 10:43digging out all of the, the layers and looking at, what the core
- 10:48mission is of the credit unit, right?
- 10:50Which is to serve the membership, the white hat of the financial
- 10:53services sector, right?
- 10:54We're owned by the borrower, which is different.
- 10:57And then look and see Better ways, especially to utilize
- 11:01analytics and technology.
- 11:03If I had, if I had to say what I'm seeing missing out there, it's the leveraging
- 11:08of analytics that are probably being used within other areas of the credit union,
- 11:12And leveraging technologies that are being used by other parts of the credit union.
- 11:18The, the ability to text, the ability to engage a borrower, in a chat, if
- 11:23they get on your bill payment system, if they get on your mobile app or whatever
- 11:28technologies that are being used.
- 11:30By marketing and lending for other areas, but not being used in collection.
- 11:34So there's a retooling.
- 11:36Treichel: You don't reach your member by leaving leaving it
- 11:39on their home phone anymore.
- 11:40I'm answering machine.
- 11:42Hey, with the credit you do, we'd like to call you and you've got the things you can
- 11:45say, the things you can't say, but right.
- 11:48Very
- 11:48David Reed: important.
- 11:49Very important that I talked to you.
- 11:50Treichel: Yeah I hadn't thought about the, the text on a loan saying, Hey,
- 11:55I haven't got, or you need to reach out about your car loan or whatever.
- 11:58But yeah, I mean that, that makes a lot of sense.
- 12:00So you talk about the inflation, the perfect storm and there, there's a.
- 12:06I think it's the used car guy podcast.
- 12:08It's a guy who's on LinkedIn, but I followed him a little bit and
- 12:11more so during the pandemic when, he'd say used Corollas are going
- 12:16for 40, 000 or whatever, right?
- 12:19Okay, this can't end well, right?
- 12:21So then you get into, okay, this is the aftermath of cars being
- 12:25expensive of inflation being inflation and then people, right?
- 12:29Life happens, right?
- 12:30People get divorced.
- 12:31People pass away spot that their financial condition changes and we're seeing
- 12:36a little bit of that kind of bubble up into some of this data and and at
- 12:42the same time, then you've got Yeah.
- 12:45You've got the attack on fees the nomenclature, junk fees, overdraft
- 12:49you get, every year to be every year to be pick a number every year.
- 12:54It's harder to be 100 million dollar credit.
- 12:56It's harder to be a 300.
- 12:57It's harder to be a.
- 12:58A billion dollar credit, because there's more competition and
- 13:01you're getting nibbled away.
- 13:02David Reed: Yeah,
- 13:06Treichel: that's right.
- 13:07Yeah, that's right.
- 13:08They're coming from inside the house, right?
- 13:10Yeah, we met the
- 13:11David Reed: enemy and they are us right?
- 13:13Treichel: And then here we are with, the other thing when you're talking
- 13:15about going back to the stat 0809.
- 13:18The 2010 back then it was a lot of the delinquency is, it was in one of the
- 13:23states where I'm at the San States.
- 13:24You had, oh, Nevada.
- 13:26Yeah.
- 13:26Now there's a
- 13:26David Reed: blast from the past, florida, the states, the
- 13:29Treichel: sand states, the states where it was, and so you had the
- 13:31haves and have nots with real estate delinquency and I don't.
- 13:35I'm not seeing that right now anywhere, but have you seen anything
- 13:39where there's pockets of, maybe California with the fires, we're
- 13:42going to see some issues there.
- 13:44Oh yeah,
- 13:44David Reed: just, the natural disaster aspect, that, that
- 13:47will play its way through.
- 13:48NCOA, again, to their credit immediately has stepped in with
- 13:52central liquidity funding and another, flexibility for those credit units.
- 13:56Now it is.
- 13:58I guess I would say a couple of things.
- 14:01The core message is this, this is the time to prepare, right?
- 14:04You need to look at your internal processes.
- 14:06You need to refigure those.
- 14:08You need to give some amount of an extra emphasis on collections as
- 14:12opposed to collections always being at the end of the parade, getting
- 14:15the old computers and when all the highlights come out of new, new software
- 14:20or new upgrades and core processing.
- 14:22There's all these stuff for marketing and lending and I.
- 14:25T.
- 14:25And security and cars, nothing ever for collections.
- 14:28And we need to flip that a little bit.
- 14:30But it is nowhere like where we were in oh nine or 10, which is good.
- 14:35People talk about is there a bubble coming up, and that's always important
- 14:40for us to think about, but there's so many tools in place now for shock testing and
- 14:44concentration testing and all of that.
- 14:48Treichel: Yeah, I agree.
- 14:48I agree.
- 14:49The agency's in a better position as far as the training that they've given
- 14:53their staff, the expectations on ALM.
- 14:57Shocking the portfolio, the NEV test, they've, the industry at NCUA has
- 15:02collectively raised the bar with that.
- 15:04I would agree on that.
- 15:05Hey, one thing I've talked about a lot and I've seen in my credit union conversations
- 15:10when someone is dealing with NCUA relative to their exam is we're seeing a lot of
- 15:15corporate governance being raised as you get an exam report you got, last year you
- 15:20were a two this year, a three last year, or you were a one this year, you're a two.
- 15:24But you have document resolutions and examiner findings.
- 15:27They tend to be linking those back to corporate governance from what I'm seeing.
- 15:31Are you, have you experienced any of that in your conversations with oh my gosh.
- 15:35David Reed: A absolutely.
- 15:36So I do a lot of, again, a great amount of my time is spent in the training area
- 15:41and I had the opportunity to host to emcee the supervisory committee and internal
- 15:46audit conference the big one this year.
- 15:48And corporate governance is front and center.
- 15:51It has been for a long time, right?
- 15:53The general direction and control of a credit unit is handled
- 15:56by the board of directors.
- 15:57Examination teams have always looked at board minutes to a certain extent.
- 16:03But as as the financial services, the cooperative financial
- 16:07services marketplace continues to evolve and become more complex.
- 16:11I think there's a more there's an enhanced approach to make sure that it's not just
- 16:16the management team that's keeping up with what's going on in the world, right?
- 16:20Because one of the things that we're seeing in collections is sometimes
- 16:23what I think examiners have seen in the boardroom, which is this
- 16:26is always the way we've done it.
- 16:28Let's face it.
- 16:28The reason that 701.
- 16:294 came out, I can remember somebody telling me that the concern
- 16:34amongst examiners amongst the, the NCA was that the major that
- 16:39the major exercise aboard power.
- 16:42And then this is, of course, in the aftermath of, the real estate, collapse.
- 16:47Because I think 701.
- 16:474 came out in either 07 or 08.
- 16:50It was they were same time period.
- 16:52But they said that the big exercise aboard, governance was double thumbs up.
- 16:58And that's just that's not enough, right?
- 16:59Day to day operations are handled by management.
- 17:01But the risk appetite And a general understanding of where the credit union
- 17:06is going has to be handled by the board.
- 17:08So I'm seeing a lot more emphasis in that.
- 17:12And part of it is that you see that struggle in, in our outside
- 17:16role as outside general counsel to credit unions all over the place,
- 17:19we've seen that struggle with a board that is well overactive.
- 17:24And sometimes a board that's like an absentee landlord.
- 17:27Oh, hey, if you think that's right, that's fine.
- 17:28What's for dessert?
- 17:30So there's a lot more emphasis on that.
- 17:32But really, I tell people again, take a deep breath on governance.
- 17:34What they're talking about is all the machinery that runs the credit unit.
- 17:38How does the board operate?
- 17:39When you look at compliance management system, it starts with the, the
- 17:42board and the senior management team.
- 17:44What's the level of communication?
- 17:46Is the board, does the board understand what's going on?
- 17:49And yeah, we're seeing that more and more being able to show that the board
- 17:53is receiving information something more than just a line item on the CFO's
- 17:58report, that they understand what's going on in the portfolio, what efforts
- 18:02are being made if I was speaking to a collections exclusive group, I'd say, I
- 18:06would always say, don't, Collections is not about delinquency and charge off.
- 18:12That, that is a measurement of the health of the loan portfolio, right?
- 18:16We're about making contact with the members and working through
- 18:19a pretty simple formula, right?
- 18:21And that formula is, what's going on with the member, married up to what
- 18:26tools the credit unit has, and that gives us the best chance of success.
- 18:30So we want to share success stories with the board, as, as well.
- 18:35But going back to what you're saying, I've worked with a, number of creditors.
- 18:38So give me a call.
- 18:40And the board chair will say yeah, the the examiner in charge made a comment that
- 18:45our delinquency delinquencies have been going up, every month for the last six
- 18:49months, and they were very disappointed that there was no discussion recorded in
- 18:54the board minutes about loan quality and about collection efforts and the things
- 18:59like that, that everything was about new business lines and new technology.
- 19:03And they're like, they asked me what I thought about collections
- 19:05and I said I don't think about collections, which guess what?
- 19:08That's the wrong answer, right?
- 19:11Treichel: Yeah, there's a definite what's in the board minutes.
- 19:13What's missing from the board minutes?
- 19:15Are there trends?
- 19:17Another board minute is, we haven't talked about possibly be wanting to
- 19:21merge another credit union into ours and our strategic plan for 5 years.
- 19:27And then this year, we're applying to merge 3 credit unions and because
- 19:30the opportunity came up and you may push, say, hey, this didn't seem to
- 19:34be like it was part of your plan.
- 19:36Suddenly, it's all your plan.
- 19:39How does that make sense with the risk appetite and everything else?
- 19:42Yeah, there's definitely, a lot of focus on those type of things.
- 19:46Hey, one thing you said too, about providing outside OGC assistance to, to,
- 19:51to credit unions a buzzword out there.
- 19:54And I think probably attorneys were way ahead of the game on this as far as
- 19:58how they operate in that environment.
- 20:01But the fractional CFO, the fractional.
- 20:05You know that the word fractional and services is out there in the
- 20:09world and it's starting to pick up in credit unions, but really the OG
- 20:13having an outside general counsel has been a fractional service forever.
- 20:17Have there been any changes?
- 20:19Any thoughts relative to that?
- 20:21Just that statement I made?
- 20:22The fraction.
- 20:23David Reed: So first of all, yeah, you're absolutely right with
- 20:25the fractional and I get that.
- 20:27I used to love to work with the Office of Small Credit Unions and things
- 20:30like that and talk about how they could build up economies of scale
- 20:33with three or four credit unions, let's say, yeah, below $50 million.
- 20:36And they would go out and they would hire an IT person or things like that.
- 20:40And that makes sense.
- 20:41But if you're a larger, more complex credit unit and you're,
- 20:44you're fractionalizing this or that it can become a bit problematic.
- 20:48Fortunately in the legal services, we are I hope I'm not going to get,
- 20:52too much feedback, negative feedback on the, but we're a commodity you
- 20:56could use us on a cafeteria plan a lot easier than you could use it or CFO.
- 21:01And I'm not arguing against fractional again.
- 21:03I think that has a role, but if somebody is, classic example, right?
- 21:08Marijuana related businesses.
- 21:10To the extent that I'm ever on travel and let's say you're sitting, sitting
- 21:13someplace having a cool, refreshing beverage, having, your Caesar salad and
- 21:18the weary traveler next to you ask what it is that you do, if I am going to
- 21:23engage in my two responses are number one I'm a Chip and Dale's dancer,
- 21:26Treichel: right?
- 21:27Exactly.
- 21:27That's you could, yeah, that, and you can pull that off.
- 21:30David Reed: They look at me and they usually have a little bit of a confused
- 21:33look and I go I'm on disability.
- 21:35Treichel: The other thing that I
- 21:37David Reed: say that always will either get them laughing or in the conversation.
- 21:40I said, Oh I help clients bank marijuana money.
- 21:43But the that that concept, if somebody's interested in doing
- 21:46that, I've been, I can't even count the number of of executive teams
- 21:51or boards that bring me and said, okay, let's just talk about this.
- 21:54Tell us about risk.
- 21:55Tell us about what you're seeing.
- 21:57Tell us about, what we need to think about.
- 21:59Once that project is done, they're yay or nay.
- 22:02Now I can just be used as needed and I go away.
- 22:04So I think we were a little ahead of the game of that, it's interesting.
- 22:09On that on that note that when the N.
- 22:11C.
- 22:12U.
- 22:12A.,
- 22:12when you read, and again, I want to say it's four paragraphs, but like you
- 22:15say, it's a quarter of what they wrote.
- 22:19And as they always do the whole purpose of the supervisory priorities is, hey, we
- 22:23think these are risks to credit unions.
- 22:26Yes.
- 22:26So we're telling all of our people boots on the ground.
- 22:29We're saying, Hey, this is a risk.
- 22:31And, I jokingly say this if I'm teaching compliance or if I'm teaching
- 22:34governors or whatever, I said, All right if your examination team has been
- 22:38told this is an area of risk, do you think that they're going to make an
- 22:42administrative record of those items?
- 22:45Treichel: Yeah, pretty good chat.
- 22:46Pretty good chance that some of your conversation or material amount of
- 22:50your conversation is on asset quality is on credit risk during you better be
- 22:55David Reed: prepared.
- 22:56Treichel: You better because they're giving
- 22:57David Reed: you a guidebook, but they talk about of the things that
- 22:59they're going to look at, they talk about, loan underwriting,
- 23:02they talk about risk management, allowance for loan and lease loss.
- 23:05And I always jokingly tell people, I said, I'm not worried about
- 23:08anybody's modification policy ever because you have one because they've
- 23:12been looking at it for 15 years.
- 23:15And everybody has the same challenges as far as, when Cecil came to town and
- 23:19all of that, but they also make sure that they talk about two other things.
- 23:23Yeah.
- 23:23third party risk, right?
- 23:26Because collections is filled with third parties, right?
- 23:29Collection agencies, collection law firms, repossession companies
- 23:34people that they use for foreclosure skip tracers, all of that.
- 23:39But then they also, again, within credit risk, Made a special shout
- 23:44out to board reporting, right?
- 23:47So anytime you see board reporting, that's governance, right?
- 23:49That is governance.
- 23:50What is your goal?
- 23:52What is your board thinking about that now?
- 23:55And it's okay if the board says, Hey, this is a trend, right?
- 23:58We talked about, financial literacy when that came out.
- 24:01That was really the big impact of 701.
- 24:024 in the entry rules and regulations was that that paragraph three on.
- 24:08Having a general working understanding of accounting and finance, but it's
- 24:12not only what the number is right now, it's what the trends are.
- 24:15And so it's okay for them to go to management and say, all right
- 24:18what are you doing about this?
- 24:20It's not okay.
- 24:22Don't worry about it.
- 24:23Treichel: Yeah.
- 24:23I didn't pick up that board reporting reference.
- 24:26That's very powerful words.
- 24:28Cause I, what I picked, one of the things that my team and I
- 24:31had did a podcast on the letter.
- 24:33And we talked about the fact that we were anticipating at some juncture
- 24:36corporate governance in and of itself will be a topic in one of these letters,
- 24:40particularly because that's what we'd be.
- 24:42but that's a hat reporting.
- 24:44So if there's has gone up, if your coll is problematic and
- 24:52that's impact, you can bet your
- 24:56If they don't like what they're saying, the chances of there being
- 24:58a document resolution on corporate governance has gone up because of that.
- 25:03So that's a, that's an excellent point.
- 25:05You made 1 other point about the 3rd party, the reference to the 3rd party.
- 25:09It gives me a good opportunity to.
- 25:12To cross sell my other podcast, which is credit union regulatory guidance,
- 25:17which is in a an audio book styled AI built program where I go through NCOAs.
- 25:25NCOAs or OCCs or CFPBs, whoever, any guidance that I think credit
- 25:30unions might like to listen to, I put it in the audio book style and
- 25:35I just redid the third party letter.
- 25:38I think it came out today or yesterday.
- 25:40The day we're, the day we're recording this, where you can listen
- 25:43to the full guidance NCUA has on third parties and it's, it, there's
- 25:47a lot of good information there.
- 25:49It's an older letter but those core principles remain the same.
- 25:53And there's also, by the way, if you're looking to beef up your third
- 25:57party due diligence, there's really good guidance from FDIC out there,
- 26:01while NCA doesn't rely on that.
- 26:03It's it's very exhaustive and I guarantee you if you could, if you
- 26:08read through the third party due diligence and the governance that FDIC
- 26:13requires, if you go through that and go, yeah, our program looks really good.
- 26:17You're going to, you're going to pass your exam with flying colors without a doubt.
- 26:21David Reed: And first of all, I love that because like you, I'm a
- 26:25true practitioner of this, right?
- 26:26Which means I'm a little bit of a geek, right?
- 26:28And you have to look at what's going on.
- 26:31And, I just did a a webinar.
- 26:34for the credit unit webinar network.
- 26:36Shout out to that.
- 26:37And it was on the compliance outlook.
- 26:39What's coming up and of course it talks about elections have
- 26:41consequences and all of that.
- 26:43But the week before I did it, supervisory priorities came out.
- 26:47Travis Hill at FDIC gives his his bombshell statement on Friday.
- 26:52This is a new direction at FDIC.
- 26:56OCC had already put out in the fall their their compliance
- 27:00outlook for fiscal year 2025.
- 27:04And of course, FDIC has a great publication what's it called?
- 27:08Risk Review.
- 27:09I think which is a really good market.
- 27:10And then, of course, Federal Reserve has their compliance
- 27:13outlook and things like that.
- 27:14And we need to look at all of that.
- 27:15And guess what?
- 27:16I hope everybody's buckled in.
- 27:18But credit risk is being touted at OCC, at FDIC, and let's remind OCC,
- 27:25National Banks, FDIC works with the state on non Federal Reserve member
- 27:32community banks, and then Federal Reserve works hand in hand with the
- 27:34state on community banks that are also members of the Federal Reserve System.
- 27:39And this is a this is a marketplace trend because it's an economy trend.
- 27:44The deal is and where I have been spending a lot of my time, literally
- 27:50over the last year or so, is that there are unfortunately a lot of credit unions
- 27:54that, that they are operating with, this is always the way we've done it.
- 27:58And guess what if old school collections has two moving parts, that's it.
- 28:02Just two.
- 28:04And it's the ability to pay and the willingness to pay.
- 28:09And you need 'em both, right?
- 28:11You need 'em both.
- 28:11Yep.
- 28:12Yep.
- 28:12And and we can help with we can actually help with both, right?
- 28:17Willingness in that you wanna be a member of the credit union.
- 28:19Use the products and service ability in this that, the reason
- 28:23I think a lot of people don't.
- 28:25speak to the credit unit about delinquency is the same reason they
- 28:28don't speak to anybody about delinquency.
- 28:30They, they don't like the fact that they are delinquent.
- 28:32And number two, they fully expect that the person's going to say, I want
- 28:36every last dime that's due right now.
- 28:38Treichel: Yeah.
- 28:38Yeah.
- 28:39David Reed: And, I just bought groceries a little while ago, which
- 28:43Shout out to my wife, Diane Reed of CU Doctor for putting the trust in
- 28:47me to send me out to a grocery store.
- 28:49But when you're paying close to 7 for a dozen eggs, that's, that, that's an issue.
- 28:57Apartment prices keep going up.
- 29:00Home ownership is an increasingly distant dream for a lot of people.
- 29:04And, there's this concept out there called financial wellness.
- 29:08And financial wellness goes beyond, Oh, I'm current on everything right now.
- 29:12financial wellness is, can I plan for the future?
- 29:14Am I comfortable where I am?
- 29:17And going back to what you said, one of the things we've always dealt
- 29:20with but I think we're dealing with more now is that concept of our
- 29:24members hitting an unexpected store.
- 29:27An unexpected expense.
- 29:28A child gets divorced, loses work, has to come back in.
- 29:32A parent has to come back in.
- 29:34Loss of overtime, a change in administrations and suddenly whole
- 29:38departments are being laid off.
- 29:40And credit unions know this when they think about it, right?
- 29:45If you look at your average member, look at everybody.
- 29:48Look at all, 100, 000 accounts.
- 29:51What does that average account look like over the course of a month?
- 29:54And for most credit unions, the average as many, so are the median more above and
- 29:59below, but I think average is probably better for this, but, people get paid and
- 30:04then that, their account goes down to zero or in many cases below zero, and then it
- 30:10comes back up and what's in their savings.
- 30:12Four or five hundred dollars, guess what?
- 30:14Four or five hundred dollars.
- 30:16Is it going to pay to get an arm reset that's broken?
- 30:21It's not going to pay for a new transmission.
- 30:22It's not going to pay.
- 30:24If your hot water heater blows up.
- 30:26Treichel: Yeah.
- 30:26And those are the thing, every time I go to the store or buy something
- 30:29on Amazon and I look at the prices, you get numb to it a little bit,
- 30:33but when you realize you used to pay 2 for eggs, and you think about.
- 30:38How blessed you are that you're able to do.
- 30:40Oh, that's the
- 30:41David Reed: word.
- 30:41Treichel: But the flip side of that is how do people do it?
- 30:44And if they, and if I'm thinking how do people do it, being in that pressure
- 30:49cooker of having to do that, of having to make that car loan, needing that
- 30:52car to get to work, all those things.
- 30:55And it's, those are difficult conversations and you want to
- 30:58approach them with care, but you also, you want to have those
- 31:02conversations so you can educate them.
- 31:04Yeah.
- 31:05To do the best while mitigating the loss to the credit union.
- 31:08It's a delicate balancing act.
- 31:10David Reed: And again, and that's one of the reasons that I do this big fat
- 31:13balding guy, balances on one leg, right?
- 31:16Because we do want to make loans.
- 31:18We do want to grow.
- 31:19We do want to acquire new members, but I make reference to this all the time.
- 31:23The book that I read every day it's got a lot of great stuff in it, but
- 31:26one of the things it says is it's easy to love somebody that loves you.
- 31:30Even bad people could do that.
- 31:31The hard part is to love somebody that hates you.
- 31:34And what does that have to do with credit units?
- 31:35It's easy to love an 820 that comes in and wants to buy that
- 31:40late life Harley Davidson.
- 31:42And now we can cross sell them on an RV loan.
- 31:44We can cross sell them on a 50, 000, visa.
- 31:47But what do we do with the person that comes back in second time in a year?
- 31:52They have a 580 credit.
- 31:55And they want to get another modification of that loan,
- 31:58Treichel: right?
- 31:58David Reed: Because if it comes down between, being able to pay for their
- 32:01kids after school program or making that next payment on the credit
- 32:06card, we know who's going to win.
- 32:08Treichel: Sure.
- 32:10Great.
- 32:10David Reed: And, so it's, it is, we have to be proactive.
- 32:14So yeah, we have to educate.
- 32:15We have to let everybody know again that we're in the solution business.
- 32:19That's why I've been literally preaching for 20 plus years.
- 32:22I'm reasonably certain I'm the person that came up with the
- 32:25the phrase member solutions.
- 32:28As opposed to the collections department collections, you're not going to get
- 32:31many people to come to your pizza party If you're the collections department,
- 32:34but member solutions and Look at those analytics that we're using to make pre
- 32:40approved offers of credit to market to new areas I was getting ready to
- 32:44hold my text phone on the word audio you know my telephone, but if I get
- 32:49a text message from my credit union saying fraud alert I look at it.
- 32:54Treichel: If
- 32:54David Reed: I get a text message from another one of my I'll say trusted
- 32:58vendors I take a look at that.
- 33:00And, if the collections team is not being proactive, if they're not utilizing
- 33:06analytics that they already have all the data points they have, especially
- 33:10if they're the, primary financial institution to whatever that means, the,
- 33:14in the days of neobank and near banks.
- 33:16But if we're not using all of that to try to be proactive, People
- 33:20wake up one day and they're not able to pay and they go silent.
- 33:24And that's the biggest thing are, the people that go hardcore delinquency,
- 33:28especially on credit cards and use cars and things like that, really on anything.
- 33:32They just don't know what to do next,
- 33:35Treichel: right?
- 33:36David Reed: They don't know who to trust.
- 33:38And there's a lot of people out there shouting at him, right?
- 33:40Pawn shops.
- 33:41Treichel: Sure.
- 33:42David Reed: Any number of places.
- 33:43And I always, tell people if you want to know how important, your
- 33:47collections function is look at it as a rescue mission, right?
- 33:51Because next time you're driving down the street and look at all the other
- 33:54people that want to work with your members that are in that lower level.
- 34:00Check cashing, title lending, we buy ugly homes, credit
- 34:05doctors, bankruptcy attorneys.
- 34:08So we need to up our game.
- 34:09We need to use all the tools that are available and try to help them.
- 34:13Plus it helps our bottom line, right?
- 34:15People forget charge offs.
- 34:17Come right out of income, right?
- 34:18Treichel: Out of income, right off your net worth, and NCUA is there with
- 34:22their bean counting pencil to make sure that you're still well capitalized.
- 34:25So David, this has been great.
- 34:28Has there been any final thoughts as we wrap up today?
- 34:32And then beyond any final thoughts, if someone wants to get in touch
- 34:36with you, after you give your final thoughts, give your contact information
- 34:40in case anybody would like to reach out and continue this dialogue.
- 34:44David Reed: Absolutely.
- 34:45So yeah, threefold.
- 34:46Number one that the collections function should not be judged primarily by
- 34:52charge off and delinquency, right?
- 34:54Because one of the other things that the NCOA pointed out in the
- 34:57supervisory priority letters is, and I'm trying to think of what word
- 35:01they used, they used one of those good good regulatory speak words.
- 35:04They didn't say that loan growth was down.
- 35:07They said it had been moderated, but simple ratio as loan growth
- 35:12goes down, delinquencies and charge offs go off because guess what?
- 35:15It's a ratio,
- 35:16Treichel: right?
- 35:17David Reed: We need to look at the dollars that are moving and
- 35:20the members that are being helped.
- 35:21So that's what number two again, be proactive, take a tour,
- 35:26look and see how you're doing.
- 35:27How you're contacting members in all the other departments, texting chatting,
- 35:32teams meetings, whatever it is, all of those ways that everybody else in lending
- 35:38and card services and marketing and I.
- 35:41T.
- 35:41And even B.
- 35:42S.
- 35:43A.
- 35:43They get, are anti money, anti terrorist financing, they get all the good toys.
- 35:48We'll see if we could leverage that.
- 35:49And the final thing is again, this is a great time just to kick the tires
- 35:54and to see how you're doing things right to, to make sure it matches
- 35:57not only the challenge of what's going on in the marketplace, but
- 36:00also meeting all the opportunities that a credit unit has again, to
- 36:04utilize all of those different tools.
- 36:07Treichel: And then if someone wants to reach out and reach you,
- 36:09I know I see you on LinkedIn, I've got your email and phone.
- 36:12But how could someone best reach you?
- 36:14The
- 36:15David Reed: best way is by far, gonna be by email address which
- 36:18is gonna beDavid@reedandjolly.com.
- 36:24That's R-E-E-D-A-N-D.
- 36:26J.
- 36:27O.
- 36:27L.
- 36:27L.
- 36:28Y.
- 36:28dot com.
- 36:30And are my telephone number?
- 36:31703 675 9578.
- 36:35But as email is by far the best.
- 36:37Even if I'm traveling, which I do extensively, I'm able to check
- 36:40that a lot of times, whereas phone calls are a little bit less.
- 36:44And I'd love to help people in any way I can.
- 36:45I'm passionate about credit unions.
- 36:48And I'd like to think that I bring value in my in my maybe less than routine
- 36:54opinions on the member solutions area.
- 36:57Treichel: Very good.
- 36:58This has been a lot of fun and I'll put your email in my show notes and
- 37:01David, I want to thank you for being here today to share your wisdom
- 37:05with me and with my listeners.
- 37:06David Reed: Great.
- 37:07Thanks so much for having me.
- 37:08Treichel: You got it.
- 37:08And listeners, I want to thank you for listening.
- 37:11As always, I hope you'll listen again soon.
- 37:13This is Mark Treichel signing off with Flying Colors.