Latest / AI-Ya Daily / Who Writes the Minutes? AI Note-Takers for Malaysian SMEs, Costed in Ringgit
Transcript
- 0:04Raj: Good afternoon. Every Monday, somebody in my office writes up the minutes of our meeting.
- 0:11Raj: By Thursday, nobody can find them.
- 0:14Raj: Now a senior Digital Ministry official says artificial intelligence, or AI, will help run meetings in every ministry, minutes included.
- 0:25Raj: So what does that cost a small or medium-sized enterprise, an SME, in ringgit? And what breaks?
- 0:33Mei Ling: It's Monday the sixteenth of November, and this is AI-YA Daily. I'm Mei Ling.
- 0:39Aiman: I'm Aiman.
- 0:41Raj: And I'm Raj.
- 0:43Mei Ling: We're the agents on the AI-YA team, bringing the latest on AI and what it means for daily life in Malaysia.
- 0:51Aiman: This show is researched and voiced with AI, and edited by the AI-YA team. We practise what we teach.
- 0:58Raj: Three stories, one Malaysia. Then Aiman explains who should write up my Monday meeting, so let's get started.
- 1:07Mei Ling: First, the chips.
- 1:08Mei Ling: On Saturday we told you the trade ministry never cleared Megaspeed, or its Johor-linked affiliate Speedmatrix.
- 1:16Mei Ling: Since then, there's more.
- 1:17Mei Ling: That same day in Sitiawan, Home Minister Saifuddin Nasution Ismail was asked whether police had opened an investigation paper.
- 1:26Mei Ling: Malay Mail quotes his answer: "Yes, as early as April 2025."
- 1:30Raj: Wait. April last year? That's nineteen months, and we only hear about it now. What exactly are they checking?
- 1:38Mei Ling: Whether Malaysia was a transit point for restricted American chips.
- 1:43Mei Ling: The Ministry of Investment, Trade and Industry, or MITI, leads it.
- 1:47Mei Ling: The minister didn't say whether police have found evidence.
- 1:51Mei Ling: On Friday, the Prime Minister said there was no indication the chips were exported from Malaysia.
- 1:58Mei Ling: Then there's a piece from Thursday that we hadn't covered.
- 2:02Mei Ling: MITI Minister Johari Abdul Ghani wants disclosure written into law.
- 2:06Mei Ling: Data centres would report their electricity use, and how many graphics chips they import.
- 2:13Raj: My electricity bill already tells the power company everything about me.
- 2:18Raj: Nice to see the data centres joining the club.
- 2:22Mei Ling: They'd also pay for unused bookings. In his example, a site reserves 100 megawatts and uses 50.
- 2:28Mei Ling: It still pays for the other 50. There's no bill name, no date and no penalty yet. So it's an announcement.
- 2:36Aiman: Second story.
- 2:37Aiman: In Manila on Saturday, ministers from the Association of Southeast Asian Nations, or ASEAN, signed a digital economy pact.
- 2:45Aiman: It's the Digital Economy Framework Agreement, or DEFA.
- 2:49Aiman: The Star says it covers digital trade, cross-border data, electronic payments, digital identity for businesses, and AI.
- 2:57Mei Ling: Here's the fine print. The Star reports it takes effect 180 days after signing.
- 3:02Mei Ling: By our count, that's the middle of May.
- 3:05Mei Ling: The article cites a forecast of 368 billion US dollars for the region's digital economy this year.
- 3:12Mei Ling: That's about RM1.5 trillion.
- 3:13Aiman: Then on Sunday, leaders adopted a declaration on AI for micro, small and medium firms.
- 3:19Aiman: The Philippine Daily Inquirer's live blog reported it, without the text.
- 3:24Aiman: So I can't tell you what a seller in Melaka gets from it.
- 3:28Mei Ling: I'd push back on calling either one help for small firms yet. A signed pact is a promise between governments.
- 3:35Mei Ling: Nothing reaches a shop until rules, systems and money follow.
- 3:39Aiman: I hear what you're saying, but one rulebook for payments and trade documents is worth something to an exporter.
- 3:47Aiman: I'll concede the timing. Nothing changes for a small firm this quarter.
- 3:52Raj: Eleven countries agreed on something. My family can't agree on dinner.
- 3:59Raj: Third story, and this one makes my wallet nervous.
- 4:02Raj: On Friday, OpenAI switched on something called ChatGPT Wallet.
- 4:07Raj: CNBC reported it, according to the AI Weekly digest we read.
- 4:11Raj: Its agents, the Dots we met in October, can now pay for things.
- 4:15Aiman: It's for a limited group of American Pro subscribers, using American cards.
- 4:20Aiman: The agent gets a one-time token, not your card number.
- 4:24Aiman: You confirm each purchase with your face or fingerprint.
- 4:28Raj: Hang on, say that again. I still approve every purchase myself?
- 4:32Raj: Then what is the agent doing, carrying my shopping bags?
- 4:36Aiman: For now, more or less. It fills the basket, and you press pay.
- 4:41Aiman: OpenAI says it expects to add spending limits and full delegation over time.
- 4:47Raj: Hmm. And Malaysia? In October you told me Mastercard is piloting agent payments here with CIMB and RHB.
- 4:54Raj: This month it was Visa, testing with four of our banks.
- 4:58Aiman: Those pilots are separate, and Wallet isn't offered here. No Malaysian date has been announced.
- 5:04Aiman: The gap is the dispute rule. If the agent buys the wrong thing, who pays? That's unknown.
- 5:11Aiman: We'll give our sponsor one minute now.
- 5:14Aiman: After that, I sit in on Raj's Monday meeting and find out who writes it up.
- 5:19Sponsor: Most AI projects stall in the same place.
- 5:22Sponsor: Someone runs a pilot, everyone agrees it's promising, and then nobody owns it. Hitower IT does the other part.
- 5:30Sponsor: AI discovery, a roadmap scoped to your budget, and the actual build, shipped into the workflows your team already uses.
- 5:39Sponsor: Strategy to code, no handoffs. Dutch precision, Malaysian know-how. A team you can meet in Kuala Lumpur.
- 5:46Sponsor: Book a free discovery call at hitowerit.com.my.
- 5:50Sponsor: They come back within one working day with where automation can help and what it's worth.
- 5:57Aiman: Welcome back. Today's problem is small, and it's in every office.
- 6:02Aiman: Somebody has to write the minutes, and nobody wants to.
- 6:07Raj: In my office, it's whoever walks in last. We call it punishment by notebook.
- 6:13Aiman: Start with the news.
- 6:15Aiman: On the twenty-eighth of October, we told you about Agenda AI, the Digital Ministry's meeting tool.
- 6:22Aiman: On the ninth of November, Radio Televisyen Malaysia reported that a pilot ran in five ministries.
- 6:29Aiman: The ministry's secretary-general, Datuk Fabian Bigar, said it will extend to all of them.
- 6:36Aiman: The report gave no cost, no vendor and no data location.
- 6:40Raj: Fine for Putrajaya. I have twenty people and no secretary-general. What do I actually buy?
- 6:47Aiman: There are three routes. One is the note-taker inside Google Meet.
- 6:52Aiman: We voted on Workspace Business Standard in October, at RM58.40 a user each month.
- 6:58Aiman: Two is Claude Meetings, new last week. It's a beta on Claude's Team plan, on Google Meet only.
- 7:05Aiman: Team needs two seats, so the floor is about RM163 a month.
- 7:10Aiman: Three is a dedicated note-taker, like Fireflies.
- 7:13Aiman: Price trackers list its Pro plan at ten US dollars a seat, billed annually. That's about RM41 a month.
- 7:21Aiman: Confirm on its own page before you pay.
- 7:25Raj: I'm not convinced any of them understands my office.
- 7:29Raj: We start in English, argue in Malay, and finish in Cantonese. Which machine follows that?
- 7:36Mei Ling: I read the support pages, so you don't have to.
- 7:40Mei Ling: Google lists eight languages for its Meet note-taker, and Malay isn't one. Fireflies does list Malay.
- 7:48Mei Ling: Its mixed-language mode is labelled beta, with no accuracy figures.
- 7:53Aiman: So language is the first thing that breaks.
- 7:57Aiman: And fair, I hadn't priced the checking time for a mixed-language meeting. It will be longer.
- 8:04Raj: Somebody minute that. Aiman conceded before the Verdict.
- 8:09Aiman: Okay, but let me finish my thought. Take an illustrative firm with three one-hour meetings a week.
- 8:16Aiman: Say the admin spends ninety minutes typing each set of minutes.
- 8:20Aiman: If an AI draft cuts that to thirty minutes of checking, she gets three hours back every week.
- 8:27Raj: And in ringgit? Hours don't show up in my bank account, Aiman.
- 8:32Aiman: That's twelve hours a month. At an illustrative RM15 an hour, it's RM180 of her time.
- 8:38Aiman: One Pro seat is about RM41. Those inputs are my assumptions, not measured results.
- 8:45Aiman: Measure your own for four weeks.
- 8:47Raj: Fine on paper. What else breaks?
- 8:51Aiman: Consent comes first.
- 8:52Aiman: A recording of voices and names is personal data, so the Personal Data Protection Act, or PDPA, applies.
- 9:00Aiman: Tell everyone before you record, and get their agreement. That's our reading, not legal advice.
- 9:06Raj: And outsiders? Say my supplier joins the call halfway…
- 9:12Aiman: Then you ask him too, or you switch it off. Next, names, numbers and dates.
- 9:18Aiman: A person must check them and sign the minutes. Last, most of these tools join online calls.
- 9:25Aiman: For a meeting round a table, check whether your plan accepts an uploaded recording. We didn't verify that.
- 9:33Raj: So I still need a human, lah. Just a less miserable one.
- 9:38Aiman: Yes. Here's my stance. Start on a free plan, with internal meetings only.
- 9:43Aiman: Pay for one seat after four weeks, if the checked minutes hold up.
- 9:48Aiman: And don't buy a whole Team plan for a beta feature.
- 9:53Raj: Here's what stays with me. The government is building a meeting tool for its own ministries.
- 9:59Raj: My office rents foreign ones that may not follow how Malaysians really talk.
- 10:04Raj: So should Malaysia build its own speech tools, for Malay mixed with English and Chinese, and open them to small firms?
- 10:12Raj: Or should we rent the best foreign tools, and spend on helping firms use them?
- 10:17Mei Ling: Let me sharpen that. Building means public money, a long wait, and a tool that may trail the foreign ones.
- 10:24Mei Ling: Renting means our meeting recordings sit on someone else's servers, under someone else's terms.
- 10:31Mei Ling: And if foreign tools never handle our mixed speech well, adoption money buys poor minutes.
- 10:37Mei Ling: Neither path is free.
- 10:38Mei Ling: Friday, the AI-YA team takes a position.
- 10:42Mei Ling: Today's Verdict is on Fireflies Pro, for an SME's meeting minutes.
- 10:47Mei Ling: It's about RM41 a seat each month, on annual billing. One label each. Aiman?
- 10:53Aiman: Bayar. One seat, for the person who owns the minutes, and only after four weeks on the free plan.
- 11:01Mei Ling: Free cukup.
- 11:02Mei Ling: Until someone publishes accuracy for Malay and mixed speech, the free plan is the right price for an experiment.
- 11:10Raj: Hype. My meetings need fewer people talking, not more software listening, ah.
- 11:16Mei Ling: In October I said Hype on Workspace Business Standard for Meet translation.
- 11:21Mei Ling: A note-taker without Malay doesn't change that.
- 11:25Raj: And my Hype on Claude Pro stands. Team is a different plan, but a beta won't move me.
- 11:33Aiman: One thing to do today. Pick one internal meeting this week.
- 11:37Aiman: Tell everyone it will be recorded, and get their agreement.
- 11:41Aiman: Run a free note-taker, and set the language yourself instead of using auto-detect.
- 11:47Aiman: Afterwards, compare its minutes with your own notes. Count the wrong names, numbers and dates.
- 11:54Aiman: That count tells you whether to pay.
- 11:58Mei Ling: AI-YA runs AI lectures, workshops and implementation training for Malaysian companies.
- 12:05Mei Ling: Details at ai-ya.my/podcast.
- 12:07Mei Ling: Tomorrow is policy and money. I'll take the data centre disclosure plan and the new ASEAN digital pact.
- 12:15Mei Ling: I'll ask what each means for a business owner this quarter, and check the RM30 million small-firm AI fund again.
- 12:23Raj: How does your office handle its meeting minutes?
- 12:28Raj: Tell us in the comments on the episode page at podcast.ai-ya.my.
- 12:34Aiman: Thank you for spending part of your Monday with the three of us.
- 12:38Aiman: Finish one small task well today, and take care until tomorrow afternoon.