Latest / Tech IPO Conversations with Fexingo: Public Software Companies and Capital Markets / Why Post-IPO Companies Choose Direct Listings Over IPOs
Transcript
- Lucas: So it's June 21, 2026, and we've been watching a fascinating shift in how tech companies are going public. We saw it with Spotify back in 2018, Slack in 2019, and then Coinbase in 2021. More and more, mature private companies are choosing direct listings over traditional IPOs. And today I want to dig into why — specifically what's really driving that decision. Luna: And why now? I mean, the IPO machine has been around for decades. What changed? Lucas: Great question. The short answer is that founders and early investors realized the traditional IPO process is actually pretty inefficient. When a company goes public through a bank-led IPO, the underwriters typically price the shares below what the market will pay. That's called underpricing, and it's basically leaving money on the table — money that goes to the first-day buyers, not to the company or its existing shareholders. Luna: Right, I remember the numbers on that. Spotify's reference price was $132, but it opened at $165.90. That's about 25 percent left on the table. Lucas: Exactly. And Coinbase's reference price was $250, but it opened at $381. So the market was clearly willing to pay more. In a direct listing, there's no underwriter setting an IPO price. Instead, the stock exchange sets a reference price based on private market trades, and then supply and demand determine the open. The company doesn't issue new shares, so there's no dilution. And existing shareholders — employees, founders, early investors — can sell directly into the public market. Luna: But doesn't that also mean the company doesn't raise any new capital? That seems like a big trade-off. Lucas: It is, and that's the key distinction. A direct listing is not a fundraising event — it's a liquidity event. The company is already well-capitalized and doesn't need the cash. Coinbase, for example, had over a billion dollars in revenue before going public. They didn't need to raise money. They wanted to give their employees and investors a way to sell shares without the lockup periods that come with a traditional IPO. Luna: And that lockup thing is huge. In a traditional IPO, insiders are typically locked up for 90 to 180 days. With a direct listing, there's often no lockup at all. That changes the whole dynamic. Lucas: Right. And that's one reason we've seen companies like Palantir and Asana also go the direct listing route. But it's not for everyone. If you're a younger company that needs capital to grow, you probably want a traditional IPO where you sell new shares. Direct listings are really for mature companies that have strong balance sheets and just want to create a public market for their existing shares. Luna: So what about the role of the banks? In a traditional IPO, the underwriters provide price stabilization — they can buy shares to support the stock if it drops. In a direct listing, there's no such backstop. Doesn't that create more volatility? Lucas: It can, and we've seen that. Coinbase's stock has been volatile — it opened at $381, then dropped sharply in the months after. But the argument from proponents is that the market finds the right price more efficiently anyway. And in practice, direct listings have worked well for companies like Spotify, which has traded steadily since its listing. The key is that the company needs to have a well-known brand and a lot of investor awareness going in. Luna: And that's probably why we haven't seen many smaller companies try it. It requires a certain level of recognition and demand. Lucas: Exactly. Let me give you a concrete comparison. In a traditional IPO, the bank's job is to gauge demand and set a price that balances the company's desire for a high price with the investors' desire for a pop. That pop — the first-day gain — is essentially a subsidy to institutional investors. In a direct listing, that subsidy goes away. The entire value of the company is captured by the sellers. Luna: So if I'm an early investor in a company that's thinking about going public, I would much prefer a direct listing. I get to sell at the market-clearing price without any underpricing and without being locked up for six months. Lucas: Exactly. And that's why we've seen a lot of venture capital firms pushing for direct listings. They want liquidity on their own timeline. The pushback has come from the stock exchanges themselves — the New York Stock Exchange and Nasdaq — because direct listings don't generate the same underwriting fees. But the exchanges have adapted. The NYSE now allows direct listings with a primary capital raise, which is a hybrid model. Luna: Oh, I hadn't heard about that. So a company could do a direct listing and still raise new money? How does that work? Lucas: The NYSE introduced rules in 2020 that allow companies to sell new shares in a direct listing alongside existing shares. So you get the liquidity event and the capital raise in one shot. It's still not as common as a traditional IPO, but it's a sign that the market is evolving. The SEC has been supportive, and the trend seems to be toward more flexibility. Luna: It sounds like the traditional IPO is becoming less of a default option and more of a choice among several. And for listeners who are founders or investors, the question is: which path is right for your company? Lucas: And that's exactly what we're seeing. The IPO landscape is fragmenting. You've got traditional IPOs, direct listings, SPACs — although SPACs have cooled off significantly — and even some companies staying private longer through tender offers. The key takeaway is that there's no one-size-fits-all. The decision depends on your capital needs, your shareholder base, and your time horizon. Luna: Well, if today's conversation was useful to you — especially if you're building or running a company thinking about these decisions — the way these episodes stay ad-free is through listener support. You can buy me a coffee at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It's a simple way to keep these conversations going. Lucas: Yeah, we really appreciate it. And it helps us keep the focus on the substance, without any commercial breaks or sponsored segments. So thank you to everyone who has already supported the show. Luna: Alright, back to the topic. Lucas, you mentioned that direct listings require a lot of investor awareness. Which companies have been the most successful with this model so far? Lucas: Spotify is probably the textbook example. They went public in April 2018 on the NYSE with a direct listing. They had a massive global user base, a well-known brand, and strong revenue growth. The stock opened at $165.90 and has since done well — it's around $190 now, I believe. Slack followed in 2019, though Slack was later acquired by Salesforce. Coinbase in 2021 was the biggest test, and despite the volatility, it showed that even a crypto company could successfully list without underwriters. Luna: And what about the most recent ones? I know there have been a few smaller companies in 2025 and 2026. Have any of them worked? Lucas: There have been a handful. Companies like Amplitude and Braze — both software companies — chose direct listings. Amplitude listed on Nasdaq in 2021, and Braze in 2021 as well. More recently, in 2025, a company called Rippling — the HR software firm — did a direct listing on the NYSE. It's still early, but the model is gaining traction. The common thread is that they're all well-capitalized, high-growth software companies with strong recurring revenue. Luna: So it sounds like if you're a founder with a profitable, growing company and you don't need the cash, a direct listing is worth serious consideration. Lucas: Absolutely. And the other advantage is that you avoid the distraction of the roadshow. In a traditional IPO, the management team spends weeks pitching to institutional investors. In a direct listing, you still do some investor education, but it's much lighter. You can stay focused on running the business. Luna: But there's also the risk of a failed listing. If there isn't enough demand, the stock could open lower than expected. In a traditional IPO, the underwriters can adjust the price. In a direct listing, you're at the mercy of the market on day one. Lucas: That's a real risk. But I think for the kinds of companies that choose direct listings, the management team is usually confident that there's enough demand. They've seen strong interest from private investors, and they know the brand is well-recognized. In practice, we haven't seen a direct listing fail to open. The stock might trade down after the first day, but that happens with IPOs too. Luna: True. And the long-term performance really depends on the business fundamentals, not the listing mechanism. Lucas: Exactly. The listing method is just the starting point. What matters is whether the company can execute and grow. But for companies that are ready, a direct listing can be a more efficient, less dilutive path to the public markets. And I think we'll only see more companies consider it in the coming years. Luna: Well, it's definitely something for every founder and investor to understand. Thanks, Lucas. Lucas: Thanks, Luna. And thanks to our listeners. We'll be back soon with another episode.