Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / The End of the Appreciating Asset: Tesla’s FSD Pivot
Transcript
- 0:10Welcome back to the Deep Dive. Today we're going to analyze
- 0:13what is, I think one of the most significant and kind of stealthy
- 0:18strategic pivots in recent automotive history.
- 0:21For years we've all heard about one specific feature, full self
- 0:24driving or FSD. It's always represented this,
- 0:28you know, high stakes promise of level five autonomy where the
- 0:31car just drives itself, no human needed.
- 0:33And that promise has always been just around the.
- 0:36Corner exactly just around the. Corner.
- 0:37And now it seems that corner has been turned, but maybe not into
- 0:41the autonomous paradise that so many people were expecting.
- 0:45We've gone deep into your stack of sources here, the SEC
- 0:47filings, social media announcements, the regulatory
- 0:50battles to really unpack this massive shift, right?
- 0:53And our focus today is on 2 deeply intertwined actions by
- 0:57the company that completely redefined what FSD is, both
- 1:01legally and for your wallet. So we're exploring how they
- 1:04first subtly changed the very definition of upon me in
- 1:07corporate documents, probably to meet internal goals, and then
- 1:10how they just completely dismantled the pricing model.
- 1:13They killed the idea FSD as this expensive one time purchase.
- 1:18And made it subscription only. So the core question for you,
- 1:21the current or maybe future EV owner is simple.
- 1:25What does all this mean for the trustworthiness of the
- 1:28technology and, you know, the longevity of your investment?
- 1:32Let's get into it, and I think we have to start with the
- 1:34language with a quiet redefinition of what autonomy
- 1:38even means. It's the perfect place to start
- 1:41because there's this fundamental, almost frustrating
- 1:44contradiction that has existed for years.
- 1:46They call it full self driving. Right, the name itself is the
- 1:48promise. But if we.
- 1:49Look at the actual industry standards you know from the
- 1:52Society of Automotive Engineers SAE.
- 1:55The system is what universally recognized as level 2.
- 1:59Level 2. Not even close to level 5.
- 2:01OK, let's just make sure we are crystal clear for everyone
- 2:04listening. What does that distinction
- 2:05really mean in the real world? Well, level 5 autonomy, which is
- 2:09what full self driving implies, means the vehicle can operate
- 2:12anywhere, anytime, under any condition.
- 2:15No human needed. You can take a nap, read a book.
- 2:19You're not the driver anymore. You're not the driver, you're a
- 2:21passenger. But level 2, which is where FSD
- 2:24actually lives today, is just it's partial driving automation.
- 2:28It's an advanced driver assistance system.
- 2:31The keyword there being assistance.
- 2:33Exactly. The driver must maintain full
- 2:35control. You have to have your hands on
- 2:37the wheel, you have to supervise the system constantly.
- 2:39In fact, their own manuals tell you very clearly that the
- 2:43feature does not make the vehicle autonomous.
- 2:45So the company's been fighting this battle for years, right
- 2:48between its marketing name and the technical reality.
- 2:51But that conflict just got a kind of official internal
- 2:54corporate resolution, a new, much more flexible definition.
- 2:57That's it exactly. And this shift was quietly
- 3:00integrated into documents related to Elon Musk's.
- 3:04They're truly staggering. Proposed $1 trillion
- 3:08compensation package. Or trillion dollars.
- 3:10To hit the enormous milestones tied to that pay package, the
- 3:14company realized that, you know, relying on actually achieving
- 3:17true Level 5 autonomy, A breakthrough that's still years
- 3:20away, was just way too risky. So instead of meeting the goal,
- 3:24they just changed the goal posts.
- 3:25Precisely. The Board deliberately moved
- 3:27away from using those concrete recognized SAE standards
- 3:31entirely. They just stopped using the
- 3:33industry benchmark. Threw it out the window.
- 3:35And what do they replace it with in those SEC filings?
- 3:38What's the language that gives them all this breathing room?
- 3:41The new definition for FSD is. Well, it's far broader.
- 3:45It's way less specific. It's now defined, as I'm quoting
- 3:48here, an advanced driving system capable of performing
- 3:50transportation tasks that provide autonomous or similar
- 3:54functionality under specified driving conditions.
- 3:57Autonomous or similar functionality.
- 3:59That is the definition of maximum wiggle room.
- 4:02It's huge. It sounds less like engineering
- 4:04and more like a legal architecture.
- 4:07That's the whole point. And here's where it ties
- 4:09directly back to that compensation package.
- 4:12By avoiding the rigid SAE benchmarks, they make it
- 4:15exponentially easier to count current, you know, supervised
- 4:19Level 2 improvements toward those massive internal milestone
- 4:22targets. So just making the system a
- 4:24little better at lane keeping can now count towards a multi
- 4:27billion dollar goal. It could, because those targets
- 4:31aren't just about technical performance.
- 4:32They're also tied to financial metrics like subscription take
- 4:36rates and usage goals. So instead of promising true
- 4:40unsupervised level 5, they can now hit their goals by simply
- 4:43improving the existing supervised features.
- 4:46It's a masterful, if maybe a little cynical, legal move.
- 4:49They've defined success on their own terms.
- 4:51But surely this kind of transparent shifting of
- 4:53definitions invites regulatory action, right?
- 4:56Oh. Absolutely.
- 4:57The regulatory scrutinies have been constant and in some cases
- 5:00pretty severe. The California DMV, for example,
- 5:03is continuing its case, charging that the branding itself is
- 5:07fundamentally misleading. You're saying you just can't
- 5:09call it full self driving, right?
- 5:11They argue it implies A capability that the vehicle just
- 5:14doesn't legally or practically have.
- 5:16And we've seen the company react to this pressure almost on a
- 5:20global scale. They're being pragmatic.
- 5:22They're adjusting the terminology.
- 5:24In the US they are now labeling the system Full Self Driving
- 5:28Supervised. Putting the fine print right in
- 5:30the name. And in China, where the
- 5:32regulators are often even tighter, they've switched to a
- 5:35much more accurate name, intelligent Assisted driving.
- 5:39Which is what it is. Which is what it is.
- 5:41It's a tacit admission that the feature requires constant human
- 5:44oversight, and what's fascinating is that the public
- 5:47facing name is shifting to reflect Level 2, while the
- 5:51internal corporate definition is broadening to still count those
- 5:54same Level 2 improvements towards their biggest financial
- 5:56goals. OK, so the definition shift was
- 5:59about protecting the company legally and making sure massive
- 6:02internal milestones could be hit.
- 6:04But the only way to truly fix the financial liability and the
- 6:07sinking customer belief that plummeting take rate was to
- 6:11dismantle the whole pricing structure.
- 6:13And this brings us to the change that hits customers right in the
- 6:16wallet, the end of the appreciating asset.
- 6:20This is where that high stakes narrative truly just but it
- 6:25falls apart. The era of FSD as a capital
- 6:27purchase is over. The company announced that after
- 6:30a certain date, you can't buy it upfront anymore.
- 6:32Subscription only. Subscription only.
- 6:34It's the end of FSD is a product that is attached to the vehicle.
- 6:37And for years, that upfront purchase wasn't just a
- 6:40transaction, it was like the heart of the whole disruptive
- 6:43story that fueled their valuation.
- 6:45Let's walk through the history of that promise, because it
- 6:47explains why so many customers are so disappointed.
- 6:50The initial promise was almost mythical.
- 6:53It was a key pillar of the company's whole identity by FSD.
- 6:57Now the story went and the price will only go up as the software
- 7:00gets better. Right, get in on the ground
- 7:02floor early. Adopters paid as little as
- 7:04$5000. That price just crept up and up,
- 7:07eventually hitting a staggering peak of $15,000 in late 2022.
- 7:1215. 1000 The whole incentive was built around this idea that the
- 7:16software was an investment. It would eventually let your car
- 7:19become a robo taxi, turning your vehicle quite literally into a
- 7:23highly valuable appreciating asset.
- 7:25I mean, that truly was a disruptive claim, the idea that
- 7:28your personal car would actively make you money and go up in
- 7:32value over time just from a software update.
- 7:35No other car company in history has ever dared to make a promise
- 7:38like that. And it worked for a while.
- 7:40It fueled the hype machine, but then, you know, reality set in.
- 7:44The robo taxis never came. The robo taxi promise was
- 7:47consistently delayed, and by 2023 the company was facing
- 7:51intense pressure on deliveries and the take rate, the
- 7:55percentage of new buyers actually paying for FSD, was
- 7:58plummeting. The market just stopped
- 8:00believing it was going to happen tomorrow.
- 8:01And that led to a pretty painful and I'd say frankly, humiliating
- 8:05price reversal last year. Yes, faced with sinking demand,
- 8:09they slashed the price of the upfront purchase dramatically
- 8:12from $12,000 down to 8000. And at the same time they have
- 8:16the subscription price dropping it from 199 a month to just
- 8:21$99.00 a month. If we just look at the math at
- 8:23that time, it tells the whole story of why the upfront sale
- 8:26failed at $8000 upfront versus 99 a month you'd have to
- 8:32subscribe for nearly seven years. 80 months. 80 months just
- 8:35to break even for a system that still requires your constant
- 8:39supervision. That's the critical point.
- 8:42The math only worked if you had immediate faith that the car was
- 8:45about to become level 5 autonomous tomorrow, and since
- 8:49that just kept not happening. The incentive to fork over 8 or
- 8:53$15,000 just vanished. It stopped being an investment
- 8:56and it just became an expensive, depreciating bet on a future
- 9:00that never showed up. So by going subscription only
- 9:03now, the company is eliminating that choice altogether.
- 9:06And crucially, they're formally killing the promise of the
- 9:09appreciating asset. That narrative is dead.
- 9:12And that has huge implications for their liability, doesn't it?
- 9:15Absolutely. The pivot to subscription only
- 9:18is a masterstroke in containing legal liability for new
- 9:21customers. When you bought FSD for 15
- 9:25grand, you were essentially paying for a guaranteed future
- 9:29state for level 5 and. When that didn't arrive.
- 9:32Customers could potentially have grounds for a lawsuit, right?
- 9:35Breach of contract. Misleading advertising.
- 9:37Because they paid for a product they were told would gain value.
- 9:40Exactly. But now new customers are just
- 9:42leasing a service. They're paying month to month
- 9:45for what they get this month, The Level 2 supervision.
- 9:48If the service is bad or if level 5 never arrives, you just
- 9:51cancel your $99 subscription. So the liability is contained to
- 9:55one month's fee, not a $15,000 asset.
- 9:58Precisely. They formally separated the
- 10:00technology promise from their financial liability.
- 10:03It's no longer a product liability.
- 10:05It's a continuous service revenue stream.
- 10:07Which brings us squarely to the market implications.
- 10:10I mean, from a pure business standpoint, moving to a
- 10:12subscription is a necessary financial lever.
- 10:15It gives you a steadier stream of recurring revenue, which Wall
- 10:18Street loves. Of course, especially as the
- 10:21company is dealing with, you know, slowing car sales and lost
- 10:23subsidies and. If we're being honest, it's
- 10:26finally the more honest pricing model for what FSD is today.
- 10:30It is. It's a Level 2 driver assist
- 10:32feature. This is a way to stabilize the
- 10:34financials by getting existing users who want the latest beta
- 10:38features to sign up for that monthly fee.
- 10:40While this helps the balance sheet and protects the company
- 10:42going forward, we have to talk about the customer pain,
- 10:46specifically the people who bought that high-priced package
- 10:48at its peak. That's where the human element
- 10:50is just a cute. Imagine you're one of the people
- 10:53who paid $15,000 for FSD in late 2022.
- 10:58You essentially pre purchased 12 years of a subscription for a
- 11:02product that is still fundamentally in beta.
- 11:05It still requires your supervision.
- 11:07You bought into the ultimate technological fantasy and now
- 11:09you're left with the system. Price is a cheap service that
- 11:12you just heavily overpaid for. That is a painful lesson in
- 11:15technological depreciation. And the risk of buying promises
- 11:18instead of products. And this whole painful history
- 11:22also puts their pricing in really stark contrast with what
- 11:26the rest of the market thinks Level 2 assistance is actually
- 11:29worth. We're seeing a much more
- 11:30pragmatic market emerge, one that isn't relying on these
- 11:34future robo taxi promises. I mean, look at the competitors.
- 11:37Rivian, for instance, announced its Autonomy Plus feature.
- 11:41OK, what are they charging? They priced it at $50.00 a month
- 11:44or a one time fee of just $2500. 2500 upfront versus Tesla's 8000
- 11:50For a comparable Level 2 system, that speaks volumes.
- 11:53It really sets the market ceiling for what buyers believe
- 11:56advanced supervised assistance is worth.
- 11:59That $8000 sticker price was living in a completely different
- 12:03financial reality based on a future that was always just out
- 12:06of reach and. It's not just other car makers,
- 12:08right? There's pressure from tech
- 12:09providers, too. Yeah, you're seeing companies
- 12:11like NVIDIA, which launched an open source platform for
- 12:14automakers, starting with Mercedes-Benz.
- 12:16The goal there is to foster competition, standardized the
- 12:19hardware, which puts even more pressure on software pricing.
- 12:22And of course, you can't ignore international competitors.
- 12:26Especially in China, where the EV competition is just fierce,
- 12:29several manufacturers there offer similar systems for a
- 12:32fraction of the cost. Sometimes the features are just
- 12:35included in the price of the car as a standard safety feature.
- 12:38All of which just makes a high cost upfront FSD purchase
- 12:43impossible to justify today. Impossible.
- 12:45So to summarize the final significance of all this, the
- 12:48transition to subscription only confirms that FSD is
- 12:51fundamentally a service you lease for its current utility.
- 12:54Not an appreciating asset you purchase as an investment.
- 12:58Exactly. The company is now pragmatically
- 13:00adjusting its financial model to reflect where autonomous
- 13:03technology truly stands in 2025. And the reality is, level 5
- 13:08unsupervised driving is still out of reach.
- 13:10It is so by moving to subscriptions and redefining
- 13:13success internally, they're managing expectations,
- 13:16minimizing future liability, and ensuring steady revenue from
- 13:19what they have right now. OK, let's bring this all back
- 13:21together for you, our listener, so you have the clearest
- 13:24possible take away from this deep dive.
- 13:27Our analysis really reveals 2 crucial strategies in motion.
- 13:32First, the corporate definition of autonomy.
- 13:34It's in quietly broadened in SEC filings to fit existing Level 2
- 13:39features. Right.
- 13:40And that gives them the flexibility to hit these
- 13:42enormous internal compensation and usage milestones without
- 13:47actually delivering a robo taxi. And 2nd, that dramatic strategic
- 13:50shift to a subscription only model completely eliminates the
- 13:54promise of a future robo taxi, minimizing long term liability
- 13:57and replacing that risky upfront purchase with a more sustainable
- 14:01month to month service fee. It's based on current supervised
- 14:04utility. Should get today.
- 14:06This shift really represents the moment the company formally
- 14:08decided to manage reality rather than just sell a dream.
- 14:11But this race is a fascinating question for the future, and we
- 14:14want to leave you with a final thought to chew on.
- 14:16Given this fundamental redefinition of the goal posts
- 14:19and the complete overhaul of the pricing model, is this pivot a
- 14:22positive step? I mean, does it create a more
- 14:25transparent, more honest market for advanced driver assistance
- 14:29where you only pay for the supervised help you actually
- 14:31get? Or does this change simply
- 14:34redefine the terminology so that true unsupervised level 5
- 14:38autonomy just remains A perpetually moving and
- 14:41perpetually sold target? That's the big question.
- 14:44That is the ultimate question to grapple with as this technology
- 14:47matures. Thank you for joining us on this
- 14:49deep dive into the rewriting of Full Self Driving.
- 14:51We hope this is giving you the knowledge to be well informed on
- 14:54this high stakes technological and financial pivot.
- 14:57Find us next time for another session of the Deep Dive.