Latest / Newcomer Pod / The Ongoing Startup Downturn & More PR People Than Reporters to Answer Their Emails
Transcript
- 0:00Hi, I'm Eric Newcomer. And I am Madeline Rinbarger.
- 0:04And this is the newcomer podcast.
- 0:10Each week, Eric and I discuss the VC deals and the drama that
- 0:14went down. Let's do it.
- 0:16Here we go. Let's dive in.
- 0:19Jumping into funding rounds this week, we have two deals to
- 0:22discuss with you, Poolside and Impulse Space.
- 0:26Eric, what's exciting to you about Poolside?
- 0:28I, I broke May 2023 poolside's seed round $26 million.
- 0:37Now it's raising it's series B round and it's $500 million that
- 0:41I think are reported $3 billion evaluation.
- 0:45You know, the CEO here is Jason Warner, the former CTO at
- 0:49GitHub, super smart guy in a obviously extremely hot space,
- 0:53You know, an AI powered developer platform.
- 0:56Everybody is convinced that coders are going to use AI more
- 0:59than anybody, and maybe this. Is the use case that has really
- 1:03jumped off. Exactly.
- 1:04You've got I like the factory CEO, there's augment, there's
- 1:09what what's the 1A cursor is super buzzy.
- 1:11We obviously last week talked about Gary Tan's like forked
- 1:15open source thing. Pair AI with all of these open
- 1:19source coding editor bets. It really is kind of I think I
- 1:22mean it's it's the space where people see AI adoption really
- 1:26hitting its stride and actually creating value for its users.
- 1:30And rather than the sort of experimental corporates that are
- 1:34testing out AI tools but aren't sure which ones they're going to
- 1:36take. Coding is pretty much clear.
- 1:38This is a valuable use case. We're integrating in it right
- 1:41now, so I can see why the sector's.
- 1:44Well, I'm excited for Jason. I will say that poolside $500
- 1:48million round I think came at a time of fatigue with AI
- 1:53companies raising unlimited sums and just sort of some skepticism
- 1:58that throwing money at companies that don't produce much if any
- 2:03money is a good idea. And so he can prove everybody
- 2:07wrong. But it's certainly a big swing
- 2:10and amazing that, you know, I don't know.
- 2:12Later in this episode we're going to talk about how it's
- 2:14been a hot tough time adventure. And yet clearly there are the
- 2:17haves and haves nots and this poolside is a have.
- 2:21Madeline, you want to talk about your deal of the week?
- 2:23Yeah, for sure. You know, I'm interested in all
- 2:26things defense and space world and on the space side of things,
- 2:30Impulse Space, which was founded by Tom Mueller, who was the
- 2:33first employee at SpaceX, raised $150 million in a round led by
- 2:37Founders Fund, who have become known to be pretty associated
- 2:41with this space defense world. I thought they were like we
- 2:43don't follow trends and we did androids, we don't follow the
- 2:47hurt. Isn't this a on trend to do
- 2:50space now? Well, you, I mean, they would
- 2:53certainly push back on that characterization since it's all
- 2:56about the founder, right? So it fits their brand too, you
- 2:59know, with Tom being from the first employee of SpaceX being,
- 3:03you know, top. Of no, it makes a lot of sense
- 3:05for them. But I.
- 3:06Do they're always like, we think different?
- 3:08Like, OK, yeah, space is popular right now.
- 3:11Space is popular right now. Defense is popular.
- 3:14This is not a defense company, to be clear.
- 3:15They're doing orbital device delivery.
- 3:17So it's kind of like the last mile delivery for space.
- 3:20When, you know, the SpaceX rockets take all of this
- 3:22equipment up, parts of industrial tech up into space
- 3:26for different projects. They, you know, sometimes need
- 3:28to get into outer Earth orbit and connect to different
- 3:30satellites. And so this is the company
- 3:32that's promising to make that last mile delivery much more
- 3:36seamless and a lot less, you know, cumbersome for space
- 3:39Engineers. Kind of crazy that this space
- 3:42company has 150 million but the software sort of coding company
- 3:47has 500. You know, I don't know, just
- 3:49intuitively. Obviously building models and
- 3:51getting GP US is costly but pretty amazing just to compare
- 3:56the two funding amounts. Right.
- 3:57Yeah. Like you think about what
- 3:59actually goes into building rockets and really intense
- 4:03engineering there and it's like wonder, wonder about those
- 4:07totals. I think this is a really
- 4:09promising company. It's one that is fulfilling a
- 4:13need. If if space is hot and it's the
- 4:15next big thing, this will be necessary for industrial space.
- 4:18And there's been kind of, you know, a range of these companies
- 4:20that are building around space manufacturing or like Varda, you
- 4:24know, is doing drugs in space basically.
- 4:27So preparing for our future where we are much more in space
- 4:31than we are now. It could be, you know, another
- 4:33case of maybe being too early, but I think there's real
- 4:36traction here. It also could be, you know,
- 4:38something where this is their pitched mission, but the team
- 4:42there is super talented. They have, and they have a
- 4:44really big culture of innovation to where, you know, something
- 4:45that starts out as a side project could actually, you
- 4:47know, take over and become this really big technological
- 4:50development. There's AI Think accurate view
- 4:52in Silicon Valley that SpaceX is sort of a Starling company and
- 4:57that the satellites are amazing. So building a company that sort
- 5:01of Starlink makes a lot of sense.
- 5:02And it obviously takes some time to build this kind of business.
- 5:06And I think, you know, given that SpaceX is still a private
- 5:09company and it's not a consumer product seeped into the culture
- 5:13less than Tesla, but certainly super important.
- 5:17Should we talk about the big news of the week?
- 5:19It's more of a trend than news, but.
- 5:21It's more what the data is showing, right?
- 5:23There's so many data providers we're looking through like
- 5:25Pinchbook, Carta, Crunch Base, but Crunch Base put it the most
- 5:29clearly saying we are now 9 or 10 quarters into the current
- 5:34startup funding decline, been in this decline for a while.
- 5:37Madeline, you want to give us some of the numbers that stood
- 5:40out to you in this report? Yeah, absolutely.
- 5:43I mean the main thing that surprised me with this report
- 5:46was just how beyond the open a eyes of the world and the haves
- 5:50that are, you know, raising in this quarter the largest venture
- 5:53funding round of all time. Still with that funding round,
- 5:57it's a decline of 10% from last quarter and 22% from the same
- 6:03time a year ago. And Q3 is always slower.
- 6:06You know, VCs need to take their vacations.
- 6:07But it really was surprising to see even with so much AI
- 6:11activity that it's still a down quarter and it continues this
- 6:14trend and any, you know, mid year lift didn't really happen.
- 6:18What stood out to me is just, and I've said this in the
- 6:21newsletter before, but AI has allowed us to sort of paper over
- 6:25the downturn. Narratively.
- 6:27It's sort of like, oh, we have something new to get excited
- 6:29about and there's a lot of AI activity.
- 6:31But I think if we didn't have this new shiny thing to glom
- 6:34onto, there would be much more of a sense that like, oh,
- 6:38there's been a painful period for startups.
- 6:40We all obviously had a bunch of layoffs.
- 6:43There's less investment. Right, venture firms, which
- 6:46typically don't, you know, have layoffs, have had layoffs and
- 6:49even Y Combinator, which we talk about a lot is really, you know,
- 6:51revitalizing the San Francisco tech scene and really getting a
- 6:56lot of investment, a lot of praise around Gary's
- 6:58revitalization of the program. They laid off a ton of their
- 7:01staff within like the last year and people keep leaving.
- 7:05So I beyond the the success stories, it does really feel
- 7:08like a time of contraction around funding and the size of
- 7:12venture funds. Notably, the New York Times had
- 7:14a story last week about CRV, a very established early stage
- 7:20investor, returning 275,000,000 from its $500 million select
- 7:26fund to investors with a just sort of, I don't know, not not
- 7:32great late stage prices. We don't want to deploy all this
- 7:34money. I texted SAR, one of the top
- 7:37guys over there, SAR Gur and he said as you know, it is easy for
- 7:42firms to expand and raise bigger funds and take more fees.
- 7:45At our core, we want to be in the returns business, not the
- 7:48fee business. Given our view of the growth
- 7:51market. We have concerns on the return
- 7:52profile for that last part of the market and are focused on
- 7:55our core business early. So, so yeah, I mean, founders
- 8:00funded sort of a little bit ago, shifted the money to to a later
- 8:05fund. Now we're having a firm give it
- 8:07back. And certainly there have been
- 8:09like no name firms that have, you know, stopped investing.
- 8:12Any observations? Well, even within the bigger
- 8:15funds, I mean peak, you know, which spun out of Sequoia is
- 8:18there was their vehicle for investing in India.
- 8:21And now as it's done, private fund has pulled back its
- 8:23fundraising goal by I think 465,000,000.
- 8:28And they're also kind of citing growth stage valuations being
- 8:31too high to really see measurable returns that it just
- 8:34doesn't make sense to have as much money if these private
- 8:38investments get larger and larger and these valuations get
- 8:41so big with nowhere to go. It's kind of like, you know,
- 8:44where, where do you go from here?
- 8:46And then the other one is what Gary Tans firm or former firm?
- 8:51He's still affiliated I believe, but initialized capital.
- 8:54Initialized. Yes, they had a sort of shuffle.
- 8:57It's not clear if this fits into the downturn story, but they're
- 9:01they're getting back to basics and some partners are out and
- 9:04cutting cutting down the team. Well, some pretty senior
- 9:07partners are out too, which was a bit of surprising.
- 9:09But like you said, it could just, you know, be a, a
- 9:11restructure, but people are being let go.
- 9:14And it does seem like that's another major fund that's been
- 9:18seeing some shake UPS recently in staffing, even while, you
- 9:23know, other deals or other sectors appear to be really hot.
- 9:26It's it's still there's some trouble under the hood, if you
- 9:29will, in some of these it seems like.
- 9:31Anecdotally, it's just like seed is super hot and crowd and
- 9:35everybody's like, oh, it hasn't corrected.
- 9:38I mean, especially you hear about these YC startups raising
- 9:41out of YC at 200 million valuations that we wrote about
- 9:44like obviously and then. Series A is where everybody sort
- 9:48of who's institutionalized wants to play and then later stage
- 9:53they're like, it's too, I don't know it, it feels like how do
- 9:56you square the circle on that? I, I think one challenge is that
- 9:59there are non economic actors at the early and super late stage,
- 10:04right at the early sort of fun to invest in your friends
- 10:07company. There are a lot of rich people
- 10:08in Silicon Valley that want to be in the mix.
- 10:11Seed investing is waiting to be in the mix.
- 10:12And some of the late stage rounds you have the hyper
- 10:14scalers who might buy the company or want a partner or
- 10:18want a, you know, option call so they can invest irrationally.
- 10:22And so then if your traditional venture fund just trying to make
- 10:26a return, you have to then compete against these sort of
- 10:29non economic actors and and that certainly makes life a little
- 10:33more difficult. Yeah.
- 10:35I mean, it's kind of the messy middle, right?
- 10:36Like no one really wants to play at the point where a company is
- 10:41going from growth to, you know, like they're, they're scaling to
- 10:46the next step, right? They're really getting into
- 10:48becoming one of these later stage unicorns.
- 10:50That's not really what people want to touch right now.
- 10:52There's that great Silicon Valley scene where it's like,
- 10:55you want no revenue. You're.
- 10:56Some revenue pre revenue. But like no revenue you're,
- 11:00you're, you know, unlimited growth potential.
- 11:03Moving on, I do want to call back.
- 11:04Eric, you had some pretty popular tweets last week about
- 11:08the PR rification of the media world.
- 11:10I don't know if you want to elaborate a little more on how
- 11:14many many PRS per journos you're seeing these days, especially in
- 11:17tech press. I think I was just like, it was
- 11:19Friday and I'm like, I'm still drowning an e-mail for the week
- 11:23and I said, judging from my inbox, the gap between the
- 11:25amount of money spent on tech PR versus the capacity of the tech
- 11:28press to write stories is mind boggling.
- 11:31Market failure somewhere. Certainly no hate to PR people.
- 11:35I mean, I think there are some generic pitches that I would
- 11:38prefer not to receive that if you read my coverage, it's like,
- 11:42would I ever write this? But but for the most part, it's
- 11:46more on the media side that I'm observing really because it
- 11:48makes sense to me that there are there's so many companies that
- 11:51raise $100 million. They all should probably hire
- 11:54APR person and get some attention, but there's just not
- 11:57the media apparatus to meet them on the other side or to be
- 12:01interested in what they're doing.
- 12:03What's kind of the solution? Because the imbalance has been
- 12:05the case for a while. It just feels like, especially
- 12:07right now, every other day I get a pitch about a tech company
- 12:11launching a new feature or, you know, raising a $5,000,000 seed.
- 12:15And there's simply is not the capacity to write about that if
- 12:19you want. Press, my point here is like the
- 12:21demand is from companies to be covered, whereas so much of the
- 12:24industry, the media industry thinks of it correctly as the
- 12:29demand of readers and sponsors to pay or consume content that
- 12:34they can then monetize. But we have this weird problem
- 12:37where there's clearly another market which is to be covered
- 12:40and the PR industry is monetizing that very well.
- 12:44But then it does they don't get all the way there because they
- 12:47need media as a vehicle to get that content out for the most
- 12:51part. And so what's what's the answer?
- 12:53Like, I don't know. I mean some of it has been these
- 12:55sort of the industry built sort of publications like future
- 13:00Andreessen's like blogs I think are successful.
- 13:03But yeah, they didn't it's hard to build independence and, you
- 13:06know, be also working for clients.
- 13:09You do have what like Paki McCormick has called like the
- 13:12techno optimistic media with his not boring.
- 13:15You know, you have turpentine somewhat us where it's like, OK,
- 13:19I was. Going to say we're pretty techno
- 13:21optimistic, yeah? We're pro tech.
- 13:24We don't have the bandwidth or priorities to like cover a bunch
- 13:26of funding rounds. Yeah.
- 13:28So we're not we're not big enough to solve the problem.
- 13:30I am like, man, what's the right way to structure like, oh, pull
- 13:35together like $200,000 from the industry and we'll cover defense
- 13:38tech. Or it's like, I feel like I
- 13:40wouldn't. I could not.
- 13:41The challenge is like SpaceX funds you.
- 13:43It's like they want positive coverage of SpaceX.
- 13:46Like no media outlet wants to promise that.
- 13:48But I do think I'd be willing to say, oh, there's money to cover
- 13:52space tech broadly and we can like be positive and negative
- 13:56about who we want. You sort of have a sense for our
- 13:58all overall disposition. But then there's this sort of
- 14:01collective action problem that no like 1 space company is going
- 14:04to be like, oh, I'm going to fund overall space coverage.
- 14:07And I feel like that that's sort of the problem.
- 14:10I'm I'm not I. Think I kind of like where where
- 14:12could you have a sponsored beat per SE and where would people
- 14:15want to fund? Maybe I mean, feel like this is
- 14:18more common on the nonprofit end of media, but where, you know,
- 14:21certain groups say, hey, we really need like a community
- 14:24real estate reporter. We're going to put together this
- 14:25grant so this nonprofit newsroom can hire the reporter to cover
- 14:29our industry, you know, because in part they want the stories to
- 14:32come out. And I think there could be a
- 14:34model for that. It's just, you know, you know,
- 14:36of course going to always have to balance that sort of like,
- 14:38you know, church and state of, you know, coverage and who's
- 14:41funding you. I, I mean, the way that the
- 14:44support ends up happening is through sponsorships, you know,
- 14:49like, like, I mean, even at Bloomberg, I think, you know,
- 14:52the website would sometimes be organized around like cloud or
- 14:55like security. And I'm like, those aren't like
- 14:57our main beats, but I do think sometimes it was.
- 14:59So it's like, oh, you have security advertisers, you have a
- 15:02security landing page. So there's certain cases where
- 15:05it's almost, you build, you know, the things that people
- 15:09want, that sponsors want, and then you get that stuff
- 15:12sponsored. It's like, oh, you're writing
- 15:14about cloud. Which there is some, I mean,
- 15:15there's a case to that to be, you know, in the news business
- 15:18too, like you should have, you should be writing for an
- 15:21audience that wants to read your stories.
- 15:23And if there's a vested interest, you know, in a certain
- 15:26industry, then in, you know, you do sometimes shift your coverage
- 15:30to make make that, you know, fulfill that need.
- 15:32But. I, I feel like most sponsors are
- 15:35assessing like reader engagement and they're, they're really
- 15:38thinking about the audience. I never hear a sponsor.
- 15:41I mean, I think there are sponsors people have spawned.
- 15:44We are not big on sponsorships, to be clear.
- 15:46We're like an events business and then a subscription business
- 15:48and we sponsorships, we need to spend more time on them.
- 15:52But most of the time sponsors are thinking, who am I reaching
- 15:57with this? And not like, let's help out
- 15:59newcomer. And it's not really as
- 16:01sustainable. Like I never wanted to ask like
- 16:05my friends to subscribe to newcomer like when they didn't
- 16:08need to. And then similarly, you can't
- 16:10really build a big business by saying like, support us.
- 16:14We should exist, you know, And so then.
- 16:17You really? You you want it to be
- 16:20economically rational for people to do it anyway.
- 16:23But my point was that I do think it's in, there's got to be a
- 16:26world where people want more like upbeat coverage of the
- 16:30space industry. Like, how do they get it?
- 16:31I think it's sort of an unanswered question.
- 16:33Yeah, remains to be seen. Madeline, what?
- 16:36What are you thinking about this week?
- 16:38Well, we're, you know, as you know, Super Valley is coming up.
- 16:41November 20th. November 20th, coming up soon, a
- 16:44little more than a month away, and I'm actually putting
- 16:47together a panel on biotech and AI for this year's River Valley,
- 16:51a new topic for us. I'm looking, you know, to meet
- 16:54with founders in the space that could be a good fit.
- 16:57So if anyone wants to reach my inbox, it's Madeline at Newcomer
- 17:01Co Send me your pitches. I'd love to talk to some more
- 17:04promising founders in biotech, using AI to create new drugs or
- 17:08therapies and, you know, cure aging, all that kind of stuff.
- 17:11So please. Please reach out.
- 17:13Well, I'm thinking a lot about the bull and bear case for open
- 17:16AI. So we'll see if I, I'm, I'm
- 17:19feeling optimistic about that piece.
- 17:20So trying to put that together. The four year anniversary of
- 17:25newcomer is October 24th. So I'm starting to try and like
- 17:29part of why I'm tweeting about media and everything, you know,
- 17:32I'm just sort of, oh, what are my reflections?
- 17:35So trying to to get organized with some reflections there.
- 17:39Cool. Well, that's this weeks episode.
- 17:41Thanks for listening to Newcomer Podcast.
- 17:43See you next week.