Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Options for Value Investors Explained
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Deep Dive. Our mission here is a pretty
- 0:03simple we take a whole stack of complex financial sources, we
- 0:06dig through them, and we pull out the insights you need to
- 0:09become the expert. Exactly.
- 0:11We do the heavy lifting so you don't have to wade through all
- 0:13the jargon. And we know that you, our
- 0:15listener, are really focused on tracking the big picture, the
- 0:20overall market temperature. Right.
- 0:22And many of you might even be using tools for that, maybe
- 0:25something like the Buffett indicator.
- 0:26We, we actually have an app for that on the iOS store that can
- 0:29help you keep an eye on things. But the goal isn't just about
- 0:32avoiding a crash. No, it's about actively
- 0:35generating wealth. And that brings us right to
- 0:38today's topic, because if you ask any new investor their
- 0:41strategy, you'll get the same answer every single time.
- 0:44Buy low, sell high. The classic mantra.
- 0:46It sounds so simple, so elegant, but in reality it's, well, it's
- 0:52almost impossible to do consistently.
- 0:54It is human emotion just gets in the way every single time.
- 0:57And what's so fascinating, what our sources really dig into is
- 1:02how the big institutions, you know, the names you associate
- 1:05with deep value, with figures like Buffett, how they approach
- 1:09it is completely different. They're not just sitting on
- 1:12their hands waiting for a stock to go up.
- 1:14Not at all. They have strategies
- 1:16specifically designed to generate income, real repeatable
- 1:20income streams from the assets they already own.
- 1:23And this works even if the stock just goes sideways or or even
- 1:26dips a little. So they're turning what most
- 1:29people see as a passive asset into an active cash flowing
- 1:33machine. That's our mission for this deep
- 1:35dive. We're going to unpack this whole
- 1:37strategy of stock rental, which is formerly known as the covered
- 1:40call. We're going to talk about the
- 1:41silent killer of options value a little something called Theta or
- 1:45time decay. And crucially, we're going to
- 1:47look at why the most common get rich quick options trade that
- 1:50you see all over the Internet is actually one of the fastest ways
- 1:54to go completely broke. We're really going to change how
- 1:56you think about these market contracts.
- 1:58But before we jump in, the usual very important reminder.
- 2:03Yes, all the analysis we're about to discuss is based purely
- 2:06on publicly available sources. It's for educational purposes
- 2:10only. This is not and can never be
- 2:13investment advice. Please do your own due diligence
- 2:16before making any financial decisions.
- 2:18And on that note, if you do want to track that market temperature
- 2:21daily, you can search for and download the Buffett Indicator
- 2:24iOS app from the Apple App Store.
- 2:27It's great for getting timely alerts.
- 2:29And for more content like this, longer deep dives, you can
- 2:32always join the Deep Value Club membership or subscribe to the
- 2:35Deep Value Investing podcast channel.
- 2:38OK, let's get into it. Let's do it.
- 2:40So this idea of turning a stock you own into a cash flow
- 2:43generator, the sources we looked at all start with the same core
- 2:46problem. Buy low, sell high.
- 2:49It's just psychological torture. It really is.
- 2:51I mean, think about it. You do your research, you find a
- 2:53great company, you buy it at, say, $100.
- 2:56You feel great. You feel like a genius.
- 2:58It runs up to 110 in a few weeks.
- 3:00Then it pulls back to 105. What does every instinct in your
- 3:04body tell you to do? Sell lock in the 5 bucks before
- 3:08it disappears. Exactly.
- 3:10You're terrified of giving back those paper profits.
- 3:12And that fear, that constant anxiety, is what institutions
- 3:16just engineer out of the equation with these kinds of
- 3:19strategies. They're not focused on the
- 3:21little wiggles. So they look at an asset, it's
- 3:23just sitting there maybe for years waiting for that big price
- 3:27appreciation, and they see a huge missed opportunity.
- 3:30A massive missed opportunity for income, which leads them to the
- 3:33alternative, earning money by, well, renting out the stock they
- 3:37already own. And this is where the covered
- 3:39call comes in. The analogy our sources use over
- 3:42and over is out of a landlord. Your stock holding is your
- 3:44house. It's the perfect analogy, and
- 3:47you're holding it has to be a specific size, the 100 shares of
- 3:50Apple or Microsoft, your own. That's your rental property.
- 3:54And you can't just, you know, rent out the mailbox.
- 3:56There's a minimum size requirement here, right?
- 3:58Correct. In the US options market, the
- 4:00whole system is built around contracts that represent 100
- 4:03shares. So to be a landlord, you need to
- 4:06own at least 100 shares of a company.
- 4:09That block of stock is the underlying asset for one options
- 4:13contract. And that's what the covered part
- 4:15means. You have the inventory on hand.
- 4:16You've got it. You have the inventory in the
- 4:18warehouse ready to deliver if the buyer comes calling.
- 4:21You're not promising something you don't have.
- 4:23OK so I own my 100 shares. I'm the landlord.
- 4:26I want my rent. How do I actually sell this
- 4:29covered call? What's the process?
- 4:31You're essentially signing a contract, a rental agreement
- 4:34with another person, the buyer. You're giving them the right,
- 4:37but not the obligation to buy your 100 shares from you at a
- 4:40pre agreed price. Which is called the strike.
- 4:42Price the strike price and that right is only good until a
- 4:45specific expiration date. But the most important part is
- 4:49this. The moment you sell that
- 4:51contract, the buyer pays you instantly.
- 4:54Cash in your account and that cash is the premium.
- 4:57That's the rent. Why is that money considered so
- 4:59secure? Because it's non refundable.
- 5:02It's yours. It is locked into your brokerage
- 5:04account the second the trade executes, and it stays there no
- 5:07matter what happens next, whether the stock goes to the
- 5:09moon, to the floor, or absolutely nowhere.
- 5:12That's the foundation of the whole cash flow strategy.
- 5:15It's immediate and it's tangible.
- 5:17But why is the rent what it is? If Apple is trading at say
- 5:22$150.00, why would someone pay me $3 a share for $300.00 for
- 5:27this contract? Is it just a random number?
- 5:29Oh, not at all. It's very far from random.
- 5:31The premium, the rent, is priced by the market based on a few key
- 5:35factors, but the biggest one is risk, or more specifically, the
- 5:38market's perception of future risk.
- 5:40So how much the market thinks the stock is going to move
- 5:43around? Precisely.
- 5:44In the options world, this is measured by something called
- 5:47implied volatility, or 55. If a stock is seen as very
- 5:50stable, like a big utility company that barely moves, the
- 5:54IV will be low, the rent you collect will be tiny, maybe just
- 5:57a dollar per share. Not really worth the effort.
- 5:59Probably not, but if the stock is more volatile, maybe it's a
- 6:02tech company with earnings coming up or a biotech firm
- 6:05waiting on drug trial results, the IV will be high.
- 6:09The market expects big swings. And so the rent is higher.
- 6:12Much higher. You might get 5 dollars, $10,
- 6:15even $20 per share in a premium. The smart institutional investor
- 6:19is constantly scanning for good, solid companies that happen to
- 6:23have temporarily elevated Ivy. That's how they maximize their
- 6:26rental income. Let's make this real.
- 6:28Let's use the Apple example from our sources, because the numbers
- 6:30here really change your perspective on what's possible.
- 6:33OK. So let's say we own 100 shares
- 6:35of Apple. We bought them at $150.00 a
- 6:37share. That's a $15,000 asset just
- 6:39sitting in our portfolio, right? And our belief, our thesis, is
- 6:44that Apple probably isn't going to suddenly surge past, say,
- 6:47$160 within the next month. It might go up a bit, it might
- 6:50go down a bit, but a huge leap seems unlikely.
- 6:53So we decide to act on that thesis.
- 6:55We go to the options market and we sell one call option with a
- 6:58strike price of $160 that expires in one month.
- 7:01The market is quoting a premium of $3 per share.
- 7:04Which, as you said, is probably because there's some decent
- 7:07implied volatility right now. So we sell the contract.
- 7:10One contract is 100 shares, so that's $3 * 100.
- 7:14Three, $100 in cash appears in our account instantly.
- 7:18OK, $300 that's nice, but it's not life changing.
- 7:21But here is the insight that you absolutely have to grasp.
- 7:23You have to look at it as a return on capital.
- 7:26You just earned $300 on a $15,000 asset.
- 7:30That is a 2% return in one month, 30 days.
- 7:35Right when to put it like that? Now, what if you could do that
- 7:37every month? And that's a big if.
- 7:39Of course, market conditions change, but if you could, you're
- 7:42talking about a potential 24% annualized return on top of any
- 7:46dividends on top of any underlying stock appreciation up
- 7:49to your strike price. A 24% yield?
- 7:52That's huge. That blows most dividend stocks
- 7:54out of the water. It completely reframes the goal.
- 7:56You're not just waiting for the price to go up.
- 7:58You're running a business where your stock is the asset and you
- 8:01are collecting a high yield rent from it every single month.
- 8:03That's the institutional mindset.
- 8:05OK. So that's the why it's about
- 8:07generating a significant high percentage yield.
- 8:10Now let's talk about the two possible outcomes when that
- 8:13month is up. Let's start with the best case
- 8:16scenario for an income investor. The best outcome is that you're
- 8:19right, the stock doesn't search at the end of the month.
- 8:22Let's say Apple is trading at 155 dollars.
- 8:25It went up, but not past your strike price of $160.
- 8:28So the contract is about to expire.
- 8:30The person who bought it from me, my tenant has the right to
- 8:33buy my stock at 160 dollars. But why would they?
- 8:36They can just go on the open market and buy it for $155.00.
- 8:39So they're right is worthless. The contract expires, it just.
- 8:43It vanishes. And what's the result for you?
- 8:45You keep your 100 shares of Apple, which have appreciated by
- 8:48$5 each, and you keep the $300 in rent you collected at the
- 8:51start. And the next day I can turn
- 8:53around and do it all over again, sell a new contract for the next
- 8:56month, collect another premium. That's the cash flow machine,
- 8:59repeatable compounding income. But what about the other side of
- 9:02the coin, the scenario that feels like a trade off?
- 9:06The stock does surge. Apple announces a new
- 9:10revolutionary product and it jumps to 170 dollars.
- 9:14This is when your obligation, what our sources call the
- 9:17overlord clause of the contract, gets triggered.
- 9:20You promise to sell your shares at 160 dollars.
- 9:24And I have to honor that even if the market price is $170.
- 9:27You have to your shares get called away from you at $160 and
- 9:31this is where a lot of newcomers feel like they lost.
- 9:33They see that extra $10.00 of profit they missed from 160 to
- 9:37170 dollars and they feel regret.
- 9:40But did they actually lose money?
- 9:41Let's do the math. Let's do the math.
- 9:43You bought the stock at $150. You were forced to sell it at
- 9:46$160. That's a $10 per share profit
- 9:49right there, OK. $1000. But you also have to add in the
- 9:53$3 per share premium you collected at the very beginning.
- 9:56That's another $300.00. So your total realized profit on
- 9:59the trade is $13 per share, or $1300?
- 10:02So I didn't lose money at all? Yeah, I made a 13% return on my
- 10:05original share price in a month. Exactly.
- 10:07The only loss is an opportunity cost.
- 10:10You gave up the chance at a $20 game for a guaranteed $13 gain.
- 10:14You traded uncertain explosive upside for consistent, stable
- 10:17high yield income. That really clarifies the
- 10:20mindset you need for this. You have to be OK with leaving
- 10:23some potential gains on the table in exchange for that
- 10:26regular paycheck. It's a business owner's mindset,
- 10:28not a speculators. But this all sounds almost too
- 10:33good. What are the big scary risks we
- 10:36need to talk about? Well, risk #1 is what we just
- 10:38touched on, but magnified the selling risk.
- 10:41Or missing the rocket ship. What if it's not just a move to
- 10:44$170? What if Apple announces they've
- 10:48invented a time machine and the stock instantly double S to
- 10:51$300? I still have to sell 160
- 10:53dollars. You still have to sell at $160.
- 10:55That little $3 premium you collected cost you 10s of
- 10:58thousands of dollars in potential wealth.
- 11:00The strategy by its very nature, caps your upside.
- 11:03You will never capture those massive life changing single
- 11:06stock gains. OK, that's a serious trade off.
- 11:08What's risk #2? Risk 2 is, in my opinion, even
- 11:12more critical for people to understand it's the downside
- 11:15crash. A covered call does almost
- 11:17nothing to protect you in a real market collapse.
- 11:19Right. If I'm collecting $300 a month
- 11:22on my $15,000 asset but the stock suddenly drops by $5000.
- 11:28I mean the rent doesn't seem to help much.
- 11:30It's the perfect question and the sources are crystal clear on
- 11:32this. The premium you collect only
- 11:35provides a very slight buffer. In our example, we bought at
- 11:38$150.00. The $3 premium just lowers our
- 11:41effective cost basis to $147. A 2% discount basically.
- 11:45That's it. If the whole market tanks and
- 11:47Apple drops to $100, you are still sitting on a massive
- 11:50unrealized loss of $4700. Covered calls are not a hedge.
- 11:54They are not protection against a major drop.
- 11:57So this brings us to what feels like the most important rule of
- 11:59all. It's not about the options
- 12:01strategy itself, it's about the company you choose.
- 12:04It's everything. The absolute non negotiable
- 12:07prerequisite is that you only only run this strategy on high
- 12:10quality companies that you would be happy to own for a long term.
- 12:12Five years, 10 years, a lifetime.
- 12:14You have to be willing to hold it through a crash regardless.
- 12:17Yes, if you're OK owning Apple at $100 because you believe in
- 12:21its long term future, then the covered call just becomes an
- 12:24intelligent way to generate cash flow and slowly lower your cost
- 12:28basis while you wait for the recovery.
- 12:31It's an enhancement to a long term ownership strategy, not a
- 12:35short term trading gimmick. OK, so that really grounds the
- 12:38whole strategy. But to understand why the seller
- 12:41gets paid, we need to zoom out and look at the whole options
- 12:44market, because for every seller, there's a buyer.
- 12:47Exactly, And most people, when they hear options, they think of
- 12:50the buying side. They think it's just pure
- 12:51gambling. So let's dismantle that.
- 12:53Our sources say you can understand the entire options
- 12:56universe through two simple everyday analogies.
- 12:59Insurance and a deposit. If you can get your head around
- 13:01those two things, you can understand all four basic
- 13:04quadrants of options trading. Let's start with the buyers
- 13:07perspective, because their risk is always clearly defined.
- 13:10And let's start with the defensive move, the PUT option.
- 13:13The PUT option is your car insurance.
- 13:17The fear you're trying to solve is a stock you own or the market
- 13:19itself plunging in value. That's the car wreck.
- 13:22So if I'm the put buyer, I'm the car owner.
- 13:24I'm paying a premium, the insurance fee for protection.
- 13:28And that premium is non refundable.
- 13:30You pay it, it's gone. The person on the other side,
- 13:32the put seller, is the insurance company.
- 13:34They collect that fee upfront. And the strike price in this
- 13:37analogy? The strike price is the
- 13:39guaranteed payout value. When you buy a put, you are
- 13:42buying the right to sell your shares at that fixed strike
- 13:45price, no matter how low the actual market price falls.
- 13:48OK, let's use the Tesla example from the source material.
- 13:51Tesla stock is at $100. I'm worried about a crash so I
- 13:55buy a put with $100 strike price and it cost me $5 a share A.
- 13:59$500 insurance policy for your 100 shares.
- 14:03Now the crash happens, the stock plummets to $80.
- 14:06Yeah. What happens for me, the buyer?
- 14:08You're very happy you bought insurance.
- 14:10You can exercise your right and force the seller, the insurance
- 14:13company, to buy your stock from you at the promised $200 even
- 14:17though it's only worth $80 on the market.
- 14:18So I saved myself from a $20 loss, and since the insurance
- 14:21only cost me $5, I came out ahead by $15 per share.
- 14:25You turn defense into a winning offense.
- 14:28You risked a small defined amount, the $5 premium, for a
- 14:32potentially huge payoff if disaster struck.
- 14:35That is the definition of a limited risk, high potential
- 14:38reward trade. And the seller?
- 14:40The insurance company. They collected their $5 premium,
- 14:43but now they have to pay out $20.
- 14:46They have a net loss of $15 per share.
- 14:49They accepted a small guaranteed profit in exchange for taking on
- 14:52a massive potential loss. OK, that makes perfect sense for
- 14:55puts. Now what are the other side?
- 14:57The care all option? The source calls this the house
- 14:59deposit model. Right.
- 15:01The goal here isn't protection from a loss.
- 15:04The goal is to lock in a low price on something you think is
- 15:07about to become much more valuable.
- 15:09It's an offensive, speculative move.
- 15:11So the call buyer is like a potential home buyer.
- 15:13They pay a non refundable premium which is the deposit to
- 15:17secure the right to buy the house the stock at a specific
- 15:20strike price in the future. And the call seller, which is
- 15:23who we were in the first section with our covered call, is the
- 15:25landlord or the homeowner collecting that deposit.
- 15:28So if the stock price soars like a housing boom, the buyer wins
- 15:32big. They can exercise their right to
- 15:34buy the stock at the low locked in strike price and immediately
- 15:39sell it at the much higher market price.
- 15:40Huge profit potential and if the stock price stalls or drops, the
- 15:44buyer just walks away. They're not obligated to buy.
- 15:48All they lose is their initial deposit, the premium.
- 15:50So when you look at it from the buyer's perspective for both
- 15:54puts and calls, it seems like the perfect deal.
- 15:57Your loss is always capped at what you paid, but your
- 15:59potential game is theoretically huge.
- 16:02And that's the perception. Limited risk, unlimited reward.
- 16:06But our sources call this a huge trap.
- 16:08And the reason for that is one single powerful word.
- 16:11Expiration. Expiration.
- 16:13Let's go back to the car insurance analogy.
- 16:15If I pay my insurance premium for a full year and I'm a good
- 16:18driver and never get a scratch in my car, what happens to that
- 16:21money? The.
- 16:21Insurance company keeps it, you get nothing back.
- 16:24Exactly, and statistically most people don't crash their cars in
- 16:27any given year, and most houses don't burn down.
- 16:30And similarly, most stocks do not experience a massive crash
- 16:34or a massive skyrocket in any given 30 day window.
- 16:37They just kind of drift. They drift and because of that
- 16:40the seller, the insurance company, wins in the long run.
- 16:43They are playing the odds. Time is constantly on their
- 16:45side, causing the value of that insurance policy or that option
- 16:49to decay to 0. So the price I pay for an option
- 16:52isn't just about where the stock is right now, it's a payment for
- 16:55time. You've nailed it.
- 16:57The price of an option is made-up of two distinct
- 16:59components. The first is intrinsic value.
- 17:01That's the real tangible value. If the stock is at $105 and you
- 17:05own a call option with $100 strike, it has $5.00 of
- 17:09intrinsic value. You could exercise it right now
- 17:10and make 5 bucks. Right.
- 17:12But the second part is extrinsic value or what we call time
- 17:15value. This is the extra amount you pay
- 17:17on top of the intrinsic value purely for the chance the
- 17:20possibility that the stock will move even further in your favor
- 17:24before the contract expires. So if the stock price hasn't
- 17:27even reached my strike price yet, my option has 0 intrinsic
- 17:31value. Zero.
- 17:32The entire premium you paid is pure extrinsic value.
- 17:35It's a payment for hope. It's a payment for time.
- 17:38And that value is constantly disappearing.
- 17:39Every second of every day. And that process, that constant
- 17:43erosion of extrinsic value has a name.
- 17:45It's called time decay and it's the invisible force that makes
- 17:49options selling the profitable long term strategy for the
- 17:52house. This brings us to the Greek
- 17:54letter that gives every new options buyer nightmares.
- 17:58Theta. The vampire of value.
- 18:00It's the ghost story of options trading, right?
- 18:02You buy a call, you were right, the stock went up just like you
- 18:05predicted. You check your account, right
- 18:08and you're losing money. How is that possible?
- 18:10Because you were fighting an enemy you couldn't see, you were
- 18:12fighting time. Theta is the metric that
- 18:15quantifies this daily loss. It tells you exactly how much
- 18:19value your option is expected to lose every single day just due
- 18:22to the passage of time, assuming the stock price doesn't move at
- 18:25all. The analogy from our sources is
- 18:26fantastic. It says to think of an options
- 18:29price as an ice cube with a coin frozen inside it.
- 18:32It's the perfect way to visualize it.
- 18:33The coin inside is the intrinsic value, the real solid value
- 18:38based on the stock price right now, the ice packed all around
- 18:41that coin. That's the extrinsic value, the
- 18:43time value. It's the part that's
- 18:45speculative, the part that's melting, and.
- 18:47Theta Theta is the sun. Exactly.
- 18:49The sun is always out. It is constantly, relentlessly
- 18:52melting that ice. When you buy an option, you are
- 18:55buying that whole ice cube and you are in a race.
- 18:58You need the stock price the coin to increase in value faster
- 19:02than the sun is melting the ice away.
- 19:04Wow, So I could be directionally right, the stock could be going
- 19:07up, but if it's not going up fast enough to outpace the
- 19:09mounting? The total value of your
- 19:11investment shrinks. You can be right on direction
- 19:13and still lose money on the trade if you're wrong on timing
- 19:16or magnitude. Let's put some hard numbers on
- 19:18this because that's where it really hits home.
- 19:20Let's say a stock is at $100. I'm bullish so I buy a call
- 19:24option with 105 stock strike price that expires in one month
- 19:28cost me $2.00. $200 for the contract.
- 19:32Then you look at the options data, the Greeks, and you see a
- 19:36value for Theta. It's quoted as say Nash in .05.
- 19:40The negative sign means it's a loss for me, the holder.
- 19:42Right. And since 1:00 contract is 100
- 19:44shares, that means you are paying a daily rent or a daily
- 19:47decay of $5 just for holding that position.
- 19:50So if I buy it today for $2.00 and tomorrow the stock is still
- 19:54exactly at $100, no change at all.
- 19:56The price of your option will have automatically dropped to
- 19:59$1.95. You lost $5 purely because one
- 20:02day. Passed.
- 20:03And the person who sold it to me.
- 20:04They just made $5. A portion of the premium they
- 20:07collected has now been realized as pure profit.
- 20:10And here's the most important part.
- 20:12The stock price moving is uncertain.
- 20:14It's a guess, but time passing is a certainty.
- 20:16Right, the sun always comes up. The sun always comes up the
- 20:19options market prices in that certainty of decay.
- 20:22That's why selling premium is a high probability income
- 20:25generating strategy for institutions while buying it is
- 20:29a low probability speculative bet.
- 20:31And you mentioned something earlier that's critical.
- 20:33This melting process, this decay, isn't a steady constant
- 20:37drip. No, and that's the trap.
- 20:39It is a nonlinear killer. When you buy an option with a
- 20:42lot of time left, say 90 days or 60 days to expiration, the Theta
- 20:47decay is very gentle. The sun is low in the sky that
- 20:51nannies are .05 might only be 90 zero .02.
- 20:54It's a slow melt. You don't really feel it
- 20:56day-to-day. You don't, but as you get closer
- 20:58to that expiration date, the decay curve accelerates
- 21:01dramatically. It gets steeper and steeper.
- 21:03And once you get into that final month and especially the final
- 21:06week. It's no longer a slope, it's a
- 21:08Cliff. The probability of the stock
- 21:10making the massive move you need it to make drops exponentially
- 21:13as time runs out. If a stock needs to move $10, it
- 21:16has a decent chance over 60 days to move $10 in two days.
- 21:20The odds are astronomical. And the options time value has
- 21:23to reflect that vanishing probability.
- 21:25It collapses. That gentle 9 to 0.05 Theta from
- 21:29a month ago can easily become 9 to 0.20 -, 0.3 O or even more in
- 21:34that final week. You're losing value not just
- 21:36daily, but almost hourly. This explains why the sources
- 21:39give such a strong warning about wentflees, those options that
- 21:41expire in just a few days. Buying weeklies is like trying
- 21:44to run a foot race against a bullet train.
- 21:47They're cheap for a reason. The ice is almost completely
- 21:50gone. You have to be right on
- 21:52direction, magnitude and timing down to the day or even the
- 21:55hour. If you're even a little bit
- 21:57slow, the accelerating Theta will wipe you out.
- 22:00So for the learner, the paradigm shift is to stop fighting Theta
- 22:03and start using it to switch sides.
- 22:06Switch. Sides and become the seller.
- 22:08Make time your friend. You collect the premium upfront
- 22:12and you let the steady, certain accelerating decay of that time
- 22:15value become your stream of income.
- 22:18Which brings us full circle right back to the covered call
- 22:21strategy. It's a Safeway to be a seller to
- 22:23collect that rent and let Theta work for you instead of against
- 22:26you. That's the whole game.
- 22:27You're leveraging Theta for income while covering your
- 22:30primary risk with the shares you own.
- 22:31OK, so we've made a pretty strong case for being the
- 22:34seller. Collect the premium, let Theta
- 22:36be your friend. But this is also where some of
- 22:38the the biggest, most catastrophic risks in all of
- 22:41finance are hiding. Yes.
- 22:43We need to talk about risk asymmetry.
- 22:45It's a concept that's it's not intuitive for a lot of people.
- 22:49The button dilemma from the source material frames it
- 22:52perfectly. Imagine Ioffer you a button.
- 22:55If you press it, there's a 99% chance I give you $100.
- 22:58Most people would press that button in a heartbeat. 99% odds
- 23:02for 100 bucks. Great deal.
- 23:03But there's a catch. There is a 1% chance that if you
- 23:08press it, you lose everything you own.
- 23:10Your house, your car, your retirement savings, everything.
- 23:14Now does anyone press the button?
- 23:15No rational person would. The potential reward is small
- 23:19and finite, $100, but the potential loss is catastrophic
- 23:24and life altering. The risk and reward are wildly
- 23:27asymmetrical. And that is the perfect analogy
- 23:30for naked selling, specifically selling naked calls.
- 23:33This is a huge trap for people. They learned about the nice
- 23:36steady income from covered calls and they think, hey, what if I
- 23:39skip the expensive part of buying the 100 shares?
- 23:41What if I just sell the call contract by itself and collect
- 23:44the premium? It's pure profit.
- 23:45It's a fundamentally flawed and incredibly dangerous line of
- 23:48thinking. We have to be very clear on the
- 23:50terms a covered call is safe because because you own the
- 23:52underlying stock, you have the cover, you have the inventory to
- 23:56deliver if you're asked to. But a naked call?
- 23:58A Naked Call is selling that same promise.
- 24:00The promised to deliver 100 shares at a certain price
- 24:03without owning any of the stock. You are writing a check that you
- 24:07do not have the funds in the bank to cash.
- 24:10You're just hoping the check is never deposited.
- 24:12The sources have another great analogy for this.
- 24:15It's like picking up a coin in front of the steamroller. 99
- 24:18times out of 100, the steamroller is far away.
- 24:21You walk out, you pick up the coin, the small premium, and you
- 24:24walk away feeling smart. You get these small, reliable
- 24:27wins. At that one time.
- 24:29That one time the market becomes irrational, the steamroller is
- 24:32moving at full speed, and the consequences are total and
- 24:36irreversible. Let's breakdown the mechanics of
- 24:38how this leads to infinite loss in normal peaceful times.
- 24:42You sell a naked call, the stock doesn't move much.
- 24:45The option expires. You keep the premium.
- 24:47Easy money. It feels like running a boring
- 24:49insurance company where no one ever files a claim.
- 24:52But then the hurricane hits. Short squeeze, a takeover
- 24:55announcement, some kind of Black Swan event sends stocks surging
- 24:59vertically. And you, the naked seller, are
- 25:01on the hook. You have an obligation to sell
- 25:04shares at the low strike price, but you don't own them.
- 25:07So you are forced to go on to the open market and buy those
- 25:09shares at whatever the current skyrocketing price is just so
- 25:13you can immediately turn around and sell them at the much lower
- 25:15price you promised. Let's use the numbers.
- 25:17A stock XYZ is at $100. We think it's going nowhere, so
- 25:22we sell a naked call with a strike of $110.
- 25:25We collect a $5 premium. Our maximum possible game on
- 25:28this trade is locked in. It's $500.
- 25:30It can never be more than that. OK, now scenario one.
- 25:34The stock has a good run and goes to $150.00.
- 25:37To fulfill our contract, we now have to buy the shares at 150
- 25:40and sell them for $110. That's a $40 per share loss.
- 25:44We can subtract the $5 premium we collected.
- 25:46So our net loss is $35 per share.
- 25:48So a $3500 loss on one contract? Painful, but maybe not the end
- 25:53of the world. Right, but the real disaster is
- 25:55scenario 2, the Black Swan, the GameStop style irrationality
- 26:00where stock doesn't just rise, it goes parabolic.
- 26:02What if XYZ stock surges to $500?
- 26:05No math gets terrifying. I have to buy a $500 to fulfill
- 26:08my promise to sell at $110. That's a $390.00 per share loss.
- 26:13Minus your little $5 premium, you have a net loss of $385 per
- 26:18share. For one contract, that's a loss
- 26:21of 38,500. Dollars from a trade where your
- 26:23maximum possible gain was only $500?
- 26:26And what if you sold 10 contracts thinking it was easy
- 26:29money? You just lost $385,000 And
- 26:32because a stock's price can in theory go up forever.
- 26:35Your maximum possible loss is unlimited.
- 26:38It is mathematically infinite. You are accepting a tiny fixed
- 26:42reward in exchange for literally unlimited risk.
- 26:45It is one of the worst asymmetrical bets in all of
- 26:47finance. And there's a mechanism that
- 26:49makes this even worse, that ensures you can't just wait it
- 26:51out the margin call trap. This is the part that so many
- 26:54people ignore. A rookie naked seller might see
- 26:56the stock at $500 and think this is crazy.
- 26:58It's a bubble. It'll crash back down to $150.00
- 27:01next week and I'll just close my position then for a much smaller
- 27:03loss. But you're broker won't let you
- 27:05wait. They can't afford to.
- 27:06They absolutely cannot. As that stock is surging, your
- 27:10unrealized loss is growing by the 2nd, and your broker
- 27:14requires you to hold a certain amount of cash or collateral in
- 27:17your account to cover that potential loss.
- 27:20It's called a margin. And as the loss gets bigger, the
- 27:22margin requirement skyrockets. Skyrockets.
- 27:26Eventually, the cash in your account will fall below the
- 27:28required level and the broker's risk management computers will
- 27:31automatically trigger a margin call.
- 27:33And that's not a friendly phone call asking for more money.
- 27:36No, it's an automated force liquidation of your position.
- 27:40The broker will not wait for the stock to come back down, they
- 27:42will go into the market immediately and buy the shares
- 27:45at the peak at the highest possible price to close your
- 27:48position and stop the bleeding. They're saving themselves by
- 27:51bankrupting you. They are ensuring their own
- 27:53solvency. You are systematically kicked
- 27:56out of your position at the point of maximum possible
- 27:58financial pain. It perfectly illustrates that
- 28:01famous market saying the market can remain irrational longer
- 28:05than you can remain solvent. The margin call ensures it.
- 28:08It's just a brutal, brutal mechanism.
- 28:11It really hammers home why the covered part of the covered call
- 28:14is not optional. It's the entire safety
- 28:16mechanism. It's everything.
- 28:17You must have the cover. So after this whole deep dive,
- 28:21what does this all mean for you, the listener?
- 28:25We started with this high level goal of generating wealth and
- 28:28really got into the weeds of institutional mechanics.
- 28:31I think the biggest take away is just to demystify what options
- 28:34are. They aren't lottery tickets,
- 28:36they're just contracts. They're contracts for risk
- 28:39transfer, built around the simple ideas of insurance or a
- 28:43deposit. And the most important choice
- 28:45you have to make is which side of that contract you want to be
- 28:48on. Do you want to be the buyer
- 28:50where your risk is small and your potential is huge, but you
- 28:54have the relentless force of time working against you?
- 28:56Or do you want to be the seller where your reward is capped and
- 28:59your income is steady and you have time working for you?
- 29:02And we've seen that understanding Theta is
- 29:04everything, that time decay is the silent killer for the buyer,
- 29:08but it's the reliable engine of profit for a responsible seller.
- 29:12Right. The seller wins more often not
- 29:14because they're smarter, but because they're betting on the
- 29:16most common market outcome that not much will happen.
- 29:20They're selling insurance and most of the time the house
- 29:23doesn't burn down. And to do that responsibly,
- 29:26strategies like the covered call are just essential.
- 29:30They are how you eliminate that terrifying unlimited risk of
- 29:34naked selling by simply owning the asset you're making a
- 29:37promise about. You're trading away that moon
- 29:39shot potential for consistent high yield cash flow.
- 29:43And at the end of the day, the safest and most effective option
- 29:46strategies all come back to one thing.
- 29:48You have to own the underlying asset.
- 29:51Which makes it a strategy for long term investors in high
- 29:53quality companies, not for day traders.
- 29:56So the final thought for you to chew on isn't just how much
- 29:59money do I want to make, it's what kind of risk asymmetry am I
- 30:02truly willing to accept? Betting your entire financial
- 30:04life for the chance at a small game, as we saw with naked
- 30:07calls, that should always, always give you pause.
- 30:10Absolutely. Well, if you found this deep
- 30:12dive interesting and you want to hear more on related topics or
- 30:15get access to even more advanced content, we welcome to join the
- 30:19Deep Value Club membership. Or you can just subscribe to us
- 30:22on the Apple or Spotify Podcasts channel.
- 30:25Deep value investing. And one last time, for those of
- 30:28you focused on the big picture, on tracking that overall market
- 30:32temperature, don't forget to check out the Buffett Indicator
- 30:34app on the Apple App Store. It's a great tool for daily
- 30:37insights and bubble alerts. And as always, everything we
- 30:40discussed today was for educational purposes only.
- 30:43It is not investment advice. Please do your own research
- 30:46before making any decisions. Until next time, keep diving
- 30:49deep.