Latest / Consequential / How Serbia's Students Took Down Their Government
Transcript
- Benson: At the end of October, Serbia's longtime strongman leader Aleksandr Vucic and his party, the Serbian Progressive Party, or SNS, was unceremoniously booted from office by voters, bringing to an end his decade and a half of rule first as Prime Minister, then as President. He was trying to return to office as Prime Minister in this election. It marked a stunning fall from grace for a man whose perch at the helm of the country in one form or another had looked secure up until recently. Made all the more stunning was the fact that He wasn't taken down by an opposition political party or even a charismatic opposition leader, but by the nation's students. Their victory at the ballot box was the culmination of two straight years of sustained protests demanding answers after a deadly disaster that shook the country's second largest city. This is consequential. To better understand how all this happened and what lessons young people and supporters of democracy around the world can take away from it, I spoke this week with Natasha Kovachev. She's a journalist who has covered the student protests, and now the student lists landslide election victory, and she is from Novi Sad, the city that is in many ways at the very center of this story. Benson Cook: before we get to the election result, I I want to backtrack to how this movement started because it was it was almost exactly two years ago. It was November 1st of 2024, when part of that train station in Novi Sad collapsed, which killed 16 people. I remember that story making the news here in North America at the time, but We heard relatively little about it, all that would happen afterwards anyway. so walk us through how that spark led two years later to this nationwide movement that took down the government. Natasa Kovacev: Hello and thank you for having me. first to tell you that, and well, it's a difficult question. very simple on one side, and on the other hand, it's quite difficult because so many things happened in these two years. It's very difficult to to like count them all. But definitely that was the moment. So the the concrete canopy collapsing for from newly renovated railway station in Navisad. Was definitely a moment that transformed Serbian society two years later, or transformed it during that process, during these two years. What happened straight after that was the anger, actually. People went out to the streets to protest because of the event. I come from Novi Sad, so I can speak like I can give you information from the first hand. So we also This renovation project. It was a really big project, very expensive one, funded by the government, and it was given to Chinese companies, Chinese state companies. They were renovating the railway and also the railway station in Novi Sand and some others. And actually, we also, you know, these workers and everything that was being done over there. But one of the first things that the government officials told us just after the canopy collapsed, only maybe two hours after that, while the searchers, the rescue teams were all still searching for the for the survivors, they told us that out of the whole station, only that part, only the canopy was not renovated. And yeah. it was one of the first statements we heard from the officials. Even the the minister for reconstruction, Goran Vesich, who is now indicted in this process, he was the one who told us, as the journalists standing there, this information. And I remember people being very, very angry after that because they just couldn't believe that One of the first things that the government would do is to try to wash their hands, you know, from the whole situation and to say, Benson Cook: Right. Natasa Kovacev: we don't know what happened, I mean, we're not responsible. This was the only part that wasn't renovated and we don't want to know why. So that was the first thing that made people very angry. they went out to the streets and this protest just never ended in these two years, you know. But what what they fueled And was actually the the oppression that was rising. So the government was becoming more and more let's say dangerous. I believe that I will not be wrong if I say it that like that. Because the oppression against people who stood up against what happened and who went to the streets and against the students who decided to block their universities and their faculties, asking for justice. Actually that that oppression was unbelievable. You I can I cannot even describe it, you know. The university professors and later the school teachers as well decided to to support the students and also to stop working. So at one longer period in I think a few months that lasted for a few months the universities were not operating, they were completely blocked. The students were living in their inside their faculties, they all slept there for months, and people organized themselves to cook food for them and to bring food for them. They brought blankets and other stuff. So this solidarity was amazing. And it happened not just in Novi Sad, it started, you know, happening everywhere in Serbia, Novi Sad, Belgrade. other parts of the country. So the whole universities in all cities just stopped working. So the professors joined them and the school teachers as well and they decided not like that schools should also not work in this period because the whole country should stop until we get answers and until justice is done. So the parents also decided not to send their children to school. And we had two or maybe two months or three, I'm not sure it was a while ago. So it was last year sometimes in the spring. Benson Cook: Yeah. Yeah. Natasa Kovacev: we had this long period when children were not going to school. You know, some of them were, but most of them weren't. And the government decided to punish all these professors, first by not giving them salaries, by freezing their salaries, and later there were also layoffs, a lot of them. So people started losing their jobs because they supported the students' movement and they supported these protests, and because they were actually asking for for the institutions to do their job and to find and hold accountable those. Were responsible for the tragedy. So that's like a a long story short, but after that, you know, everything started cumulating. we had Benson Cook: Yeah. Natasa Kovacev: like the biggest protest that Belgrade has ever seen. It happened on March 15th last year. more than half a million of people came to Belgrade. The students called them to to join them in this protest. And well, people expected a lot from that protest, but the students were very definite about their decision not to let any kind of violence happen. So when they got information that there could be violence provoked by the other side, they decided to like tell people to go home. Thank you for joining us, thank you for being part of this protest. But we believe that now it's time To end it because it's not safe anymore. We cannot guarantee the safety, especially w considering that number of people. But that night something happened, and there are videos you can find online about a very, very strange thing happening because you know 16 minutes of silence was actually a symbol of these protests. I don't know if you If you saw that. So from the beginning of the protest, people were standing still in silence for 16 minutes because there were 16 victims of this tragedy. So one minute Benson Cook: Right. Natasa Kovacev: for every every victim. And this was like this happened every week in this during these two years. People were every Friday at 11:52, so that was the exact time of the tragedy, they were standing in silence for 16 minutes. And of course on March fifteenth in Belgrade they also did the same thing. So you can imagine half of a million people standing in central Belgrade streets in complete silence for 16 minutes. And during this silence, they were you can see it in the in the videos, they are just at the same time people are start starting screaming and like going from the middle of the street. they're running from something. We didn't know what they were running from, and later many of them, hundreds of them, described the same thing. it was like an airplane approaching. It was yeah, a very strange sound that looked like an airplane rip approaching and like going into the mess. And many of them had difficulties with Their ears with with hearing, some of them even had like difficulties with the bypass they had inside their their bodies. Benson Cook: wow. Natasa Kovacev: Yeah, headaches, and some of them even fainted. They couldn't explain what happened. So, you know, there were doubts that the government used some kind of sonic weapon on its own citizens that night. And it was a huge story. And until today they deny it. So they are always saying that they didn't do it. There were some investigations into this story, but you know, we never got actually we never got the answer what happened on March fifteenth. And after that, because the students had like four or five main demands since the beginning of their protest, and that didn't change the whole time. And one of the or the first demand was that the government should should give us all the documents about this huge renovation pro project. And also of course that they should arrest, find, and name those responsible. So when that didn't happen, the students decided, I think it was May last year, that they should organize themselves politically. And that was the first time when they came out saying that okay, now we are a political movement, so now we are also asking for early elections. Not just everything that we named so far, but also this. And that's actually when this whole political part of the story began. Benson Cook: one of the things that that I I I have found so fascinating about this movement is that unlike a lot of these Gen Z uprisings that we've seen in places like Nepal and Bangladesh in the last couple of years, this wasn't this wasn't really a revolution in a traditional sense. They they partnered with members of civil society and the electoral opposition in some ways to to take down the government at the ballot box. So how how did that process work of the developing of the student list? Natasa Kovacev: Well that's very interesting because this was so different than anything else that we could see all around the world and and what you Benson Cook: Yeah. Yeah. Natasa Kovacev: just mentioned. why? Because the students didn't want to cooperate with any opposition parties, with no no other movements, you know. They were like and it was a very important part of their struggle and their fight to remain very unpolitical. Let's say unpolitical, that nobody can put them on either side of the political spectrum. And also you know, inside this students' movement, there are a lot of people and a lot of different ideologies. They decided not to put any of them first. They had like this agreement that they have they have an enemy. Who they should face together. And no political, ideological differences should be an obstacle to that. So they decided not to put it like first. And it was very interesting to see how they brought their decisions. For us journalists, it wasn't always easy to understand it. Because, of course, we want a person we can talk to. Yes, when you need a statement, when you need to clarify something and when you need them to answer to one of your questions. But you know, it was always a procedure. You call them and tell them, Okay, I would like to talk to somebody and then they had to to discuss among themselves, make this decision altogether on whether they will talk about it and who will be the first person who will, you know. give you the answers in front of the students movement. So it was always a long procedure of making this decision, but I think in the end it was very clever. Yeah. Benson Cook: Yeah. Natasa Kovacev: It was really very clever. And that that was the thing that kept them together and that brought to this. Benson Cook: Was this this sort of working in partnership to decide how they were going to move as a collective? Natasa Kovacev: Yes, and also not to let you know there is always a possibility to bring something out of context, you know, that when we hear a statement and you know like label it to somebody saying, Okay, this whole movement thinks this or that or does this or that and they were very, very strict about it that they should bring these decisions all together in they call it plenums. I don't know the exact word in English, maybe it's the same. I know, yes. So Benson Cook: Yeah. I would say plenum in English too, yeah. Natasa Kovacev: this is how they brought all their decisions up. Yeah. Benson Cook: Yeah. that's so interesting. That's so interesting. Did did anyone that you spoke with in, you know, the days and weeks leading up to election day expect them to win by this like fifteen or twenty point margin that they ended up winning? I mean, it it wasn't even really particularly close in the end. Natasa Kovacev: If I can say I was the only one who thought they would be such a majority. Of course there are Benson Cook: Yeah. Natasa Kovacev: some colleagues who from Novi Side who Benson Cook: Yeah. Natasa Kovacev: were there the whole time and who also believed that something like this was possible. But for example, I was talking to a lot of my colleagues who come from different countries in the region, and none of them believed this could happen, you know. they always told me, No way, I mean No way, he's too powerful politician to be thrown down by a group of students. You're silly to believe that, you know, and what I was trying to explain to them is that nobody who wasn't there these two years, following it so up closely can understand, you know, this kind of energy that was a accumulating in Serbia among the people who were supporting this movement or let's call it the better let's let's say it better actually among people who were fed up, with the the criminal regime. Because what was happening in Serbia was like we had organized crime, organized criminals leading our country. And it Benson Cook: Yeah. Natasa Kovacev: was really I mean this moment, the event at the railway station in Avisad was I believe a moment when many people realized that. Benson Cook: I I I have to say I was somewhat surprised that Vucic conceded as quickly as he did. I mean, it only took like two hours or so. What was it like when that moment happened that sort of made this all very real? Natasa Kovacev: It was unbelievable. First, I also didn't expect that he would concede. Benson Cook: Yeah. Natasa Kovacev: I expected that he would bring out everything he had, you know, out of the streets trying to defend his position. And I also expected him to like I expected violence in the streets actually, because I expected him to go out and say that he won. And I knew that if that happened people would explode because as I mentioned they are fed up with all of this. And every election before that, you you know, we had local elections a few months ago in some of the municipalities, in some of the cities, and it was terrible. I mean I was there on the ground and I don't remember seeing so much corruption and violence very very out in the open in the street during the election day. they were buying votes very transparently and bringing out some very violent young people black dressed in black with sticks with it was unbelievable, really. And we saw it out in the streets. So I expected something similar to happen on the twenty fifth of October, and it was a big surprise for me when he came out and said we lost. I was I just froze for a moment and thought, okay, is this really happening? And Benson Cook: Yeah. Natasa Kovacev: I I believe that was the reaction of most of the people because we can s see it on social networks and on on on the in the media how people reacted, you know. They just everything poured out of them and there was you saw it the whole the huge celebration out in the streets and I I think we still don't believe it. Benson Cook: Well, I mean, so now now that they've won, they have to actually govern. And and as you mentioned, this is a list of of people with a a diverse range of of ideological views, but now they have to all come together. And it's it's it's easier perhaps to to hold these plenums and these discussions when you're in opposition and and you can come up with a with an easy answer to a journalist. It's quite another to have to do that and then put it into practice in the form of of governing. How prepared is this student list to form a government and probably more importantly unwind this state capture that we've seen after 15 years of rule by Butchitz and the SNS? Natasa Kovacev: We didn't think they were capable to do this, you know, as well. So I would like to give them a chance. I don't know. I think th that's all we can do right now. it's important to mention that this student list actually consists of university professors, doctors, you know, astrophysics, I don't know, farmers, people who have all kinds of experience in different fields and not many of them have like a lot of political experience. Many of them don't have any kind of political experience. And I I read some I think the the science journal just put out a story saying that Serbia probably just elected the the educated parliament in the world which is Benson Cook: Probably. Yeah. Natasa Kovacev: which is a very nice thing if we look at it so these are all people who have results in in areas and in fields that they are experts in. And let's see how they will manage with with this story. Because so far, at least in Serbia, we only saw politicians doing their job badly, you know. Benson Cook: Yeah, fair. Natasa Kovacev: This is a chance to see something something else. And I have to mention, today's what eight day it's been eight days after the elections and we cannot put down our phones because the events are happening so fast. I don't know if you follow it, I probably you're not because I mean even people in Serbia cannot follow what has happened so far. But let me just tell you that only a Benson Cook: Yeah. Natasa Kovacev: day only a day after the elections we we have two main big TV stations public serv public service Serbia and the public service of Vojvodina, which is a province where Navi Sad is based. So both of these public services who were pro-regime media, you know, they were like the way that they were reporting on everything that was going on in these previous two years is very shameful. Very, very shameful. And just the day after the elections, they went out publicly apologizing to their viewers for everything that they've done. And and w we already saw like different managers and different editors getting, you know, into this into these televisions and like doing this job differently. So that was one change. and there were so many of them. The the prosecutor's office woke up after I would say a winter sleep or how Because we saw for the first time in many many years the state prosecutor issuing an order to to her colleagues that they should let this new newly formed commission get in and search all their cases, all these very, very important cases that are of public interest. Also the she told them to stop and prevent destroying like the official documents in state institutions because what we also saw in the previous few days was that there were a lot of people, directors of different state institutions, trying to destroy the documents and people trying to stop them in doing that. You know, the employ employees, unbelievable. And also we saw some arrests being made. So even today, today was a very interesting day because the owner of one bank that was very close to to the ruling party was arrested and that bank lost its permission to work because yes, because the prosecutor's office said that they suspected they were trying to get the money out of the country. So you can imagine. It the amount that they mentioned was around forty-five billion dinners. So that's let's say f nearly four hundred million euro. That's the amount that the owner of this bank tried to get out of the bank and of the country. And that happened today, so he was arrested today. Also, Benson Cook: Wow. Natasa Kovacev: like in the afternoon, we found out that some other arrests were being made, people who were buying off votes during the elections or who were organizing voters to come from Bosnia and Herzegovina into Serbia to give them like the right to vote. You know, there are so many things that I don't even I I don't even know where to start to explain what happened. So you know Benson Cook: Right. And I'm sure and I'm sure too that, you know, because we're we're now speaking on on Monday, this episode will come out on Thursday evening. I can't even imagine how much more will happen in the next couple of days, right? Natasa Kovacev: Yeah, of course, of course. Benson Cook: so events are are are really happening at at at at such a such a clip. It will be so interesting to see how how all of this how all of this develops. I did see that apology video from Natasa Kovacev: No. Benson Cook: from the I think from Voivodina uh's public television station it was the one that I saw. Natasa Kovacev: Yes. Yes, that was the first one and I would say that that was actually a genuine one, a a sincere Benson Cook: Yeah. Natasa Kovacev: one. More sincere than the other from from the other public service. Benson Cook: all my years as as a as a journalist, I don't think I've ever seen that in in in any anywhere, an apology for for for for captured coverage really in that way. even on and I I think you know the the most direct example that we can think of contemporarily is Hungary, where you didn't really get an apology from from those captured institutions. They they they the government just shut them down before they could I mean. They had plenty of opportunities too. They had many weeks and then and then the new government just shut them down. Do you think that maybe this was a reaction to what happened in Hungary and they were trying to get out ahead of of of the horse there? Natasa Kovacev: I I don't think that was a reaction to what was happening in Hungary. I think it was the reaction to what was happening in Serbia, was they also saw these landslide results from the election. So it was very obvious to them what was going to happen next. And I have to say that these public services are in Serbia, unfortunately, they're not very objective and like free. media, independent media. They are very much connected to any government that is currently in in place, in position. But this government this government was so strict and I don't know. It was it was umpo impossible for for these people, many of these people to work to do their jobs properly. Of course there is always a choice. You can choose to do it or to get out. And do something else. That's what I would choose. But you know, not many people think like that, and of course everybody has his or her own reasons. But that's important to realize that these media were never so objective and so independent. And now this apology is actually the first step towards maybe getting there, Benson Cook: one of the things that I have always found so fascinating about Alexander Vucic as a political figure is that in some ways he was kind of a product of the US and the EU. They tolerated him and all of the democratic backsliding that happened in in Serbia on his watch for 15 years because he he kept a lid on the Kosovo issue, among other things, especially after the signing of the Brussels Agreement in 2013. Is there any indication? I know you you mentioned the student list that there's a lot diversity of ideological views within that movement that is now the government. Is there any indication of where Where things might head on that issue under this new under this new Natasa Kovacev: What we heard so far is that they will continue leading Serbia towards the European Union. So they will continue these negotiations with Kosovo. And we also heard, and that was before the elections, that they will not put sanctions on Russia. So that was the same Benson Cook: Yes. Natasa Kovacev: thing that Vucic it's it's his foreign policy as well. So not we didn't hear much about these big questions from them so far. But I believe that the reason behind it is this whole mess that is going on right now in Serbia. especially the parliament wasn't formed yet because as we heard we have to wait for the final results of the election. And after that there should be held assembly session of the assembly where they should take over power formally. And after that they should form a government and start ruling the country. So I believe that in the coming days we will hear answers to all these questions. But for now what we heard was that they will continue with this EU process of Serbia. And I hope that they will do it better and faster than the previous government because we are stagnating for I believe now four or five years that we haven't opened any chapters in this EU negotiations process. So it's really it's really been a a staggering point. Benson Cook: as sort of a closing thought, in in a world in which we are increasingly seeing young people stand up and take charge when they they see things in their government that they don't like, why should listeners care about what has happened in Serbia and is happening? Natasa Kovacev: Because what happened in Serbia showed us that it's possible to to rule out these people who are obviously corrupted and who are so powerful that we thought we could not do anything about it, you know. And this movement has shown that we can do it. And for me personally, like maybe the best or the biggest value. of everything that happened in the previous two years in Serbia was this solidarity among people. You know, it's unbelievable what amount of solidarity they they just shown. among each other, with the professors who lost their jobs, people were collecting money for them. You know, it's also an important thing. Among journalists also, I come from a group of journalists from Novi Sad. Who decided to put the public interest first. And we didn't care about exclusives, we didn't care about, you know, let me have something that my colleague doesn't have. We decided, we made a group of people coming from different media outlets, and we were sharing all our information and all our stories, pictures, videos of all the events, because it was very important for us to pass this story from our city to send this information that were correct and that were true to other places because the level of fake news and the level of like spins cov coming from different sides was unbelievable as well. So I would say that this solidarity actually sh has shown us that everything is possible. Benson Cook: Absolutely. Everything is possible when we have the truth. I I I think so. Natasa Kovacev: Yeah. Benson Cook: Well, Natasha Kovachev, thank you so much for for joining me on this episode of Consequential. And sharing the importance of of solidarity and truth with us today. Natasa Kovacev: Thank you very much for having me and for talking about this important topic. Benson: And thank you so much for tuning in to Consequential. Things are very busy around the world at the moment, from a sea change close to home in Washington, DC, to the absolutely bananas past week and a half or so in Brazilian politics, plus whatever seems to be developing on the associate membership front with Canada and the EU. We will have another deep dive on an important story out there in the world in another two weeks. If you haven't yet, please subscribe wherever you listen to your podcasts and you can always Always find us at it's dot consequential on Instagram. You can always email me at Benson at its consequential.com. Take care. We will see you next time.