Latest / Politics with Paul / Politics with Paul #47: Will We Ever See a Competitive Third Party?
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the politics with Paul podcast, your home for nonpartisan and nonaudiological
- 0:04analysis of various political topics.
- 0:07I am your host, Paul Rader.
- 0:10Today, we're gonna talk about a potential competitive third party.
- 0:15Why do we not see third parties be more regularly competitive in US elections despite
- 0:21immense dissatisfaction with the Republican and Democratic parties?
- 0:26Have we had third parties that were competitive in the past?
- 0:30What makes a third party competitive?
- 0:32Will we soon see a third party become a regular contender for big time elected offices in the
- 0:38near future?
- 0:40All this and more on tap for today's episode.
- 0:43But first, in October 2024, a Gallup poll found that 58% of adults agree that a third major
- 0:50party in The US is needed because the Republican and Democratic parties do such a
- 0:54poor job of representing the American people.
- 0:58The article on the Gallup website went on further to say that it was their twelfth poll
- 1:04in a row where a majority of the respondents believed a third party is needed.
- 1:09And that although it was a dip from the 63% that wanted a third party in the 2023 poll, it
- 1:16was still around the average that Gallup has measured since they started this poll, maybe
- 1:20even slightly higher.
- 1:22So it may seem weird that we don't see many third party elected officials in government,
- 1:28like, barely at all.
- 1:30You can find them, sure, but they are few and far between, and they are a bit more common in
- 1:35certain states like Maine and Vermont than in other states.
- 1:38But in other states, you just, you can't even really find them.
- 1:41Nevertheless, the discontent with the two major parties might lead one to ask if there is a dam
- 1:47of sorts that will soon break and if we'll start seeing more third party victories.
- 1:53So today, we're talking all things third parties, and that includes what exactly a
- 2:00competitive, quote, unquote, third party looks like, the public opinion about third parties,
- 2:06and a deeper dive into what all that means, the history of third parties, what the most common
- 2:11third parties are, their biggest obstacles they face, and why our system is so given to two
- 2:17major parties.
- 2:19Let's go.
- 2:21First of all, what does a competitive third party look like?
- 2:28It's kind of a nebulous term because third parties candidates do win, but they are most
- 2:35often at the local level.
- 2:36And occasionally, you see them at the state level, more so state legislatures, but they
- 2:41almost never happen at the federal level.
- 2:43And it's been quite some time since we've seen a third party candidate win at the federal
- 2:49level.
- 2:49Not independent in general.
- 2:51There are some that have no party affiliation.
- 2:53We're talking specifically third parties.
- 2:56In this discussion, competitiveness is a it's a rather arbitrary definition.
- 3:00I've noted that when you talk about academic studies, it's very important to operationalize
- 3:08the terms that you're using.
- 3:10And so I'm gonna maybe not backtrack on that per se, but I'm not gonna have a very specific
- 3:19definition.
- 3:20I'm just gonna give a general sense of what I mean.
- 3:23I basically just mean that the a competitive third party is one that wins a bunch of
- 3:29elections in many states across local, state, and federal levels.
- 3:34So by this definition, no third party is truly competitive because at most, they win at the
- 3:40local level, maybe a few seats at the state level.
- 3:45But a big reason that no third party fits this definition is that none of them are what we
- 3:50call ballots qualified in all 50 states where they can run candidates under their party label
- 3:57instead of, say, as a write in where you actually have to write that candidate's name
- 4:02specifically, but it doesn't say that their party on the ballot.
- 4:07And I'm gonna tell you more about what ballot qualified entails.
- 4:12But first, I wanna get back to that poll that we mentioned earlier by Gallup.
- 4:18Because when when media covers polls, it's usually just way too much of a surface level
- 4:23understanding.
- 4:25They don't really dive deep into the polls.
- 4:27Now to be fair, that is partially because a lot of people don't care.
- 4:31The people that watch these media outlets don't really care about the nooks and crannies about
- 4:38the polls, but you should.
- 4:39It's really fascinating.
- 4:40So just a few things to go into because some people may want to take this poll and run with
- 4:48it, but slow your roll for a second.
- 4:50So first, let's talk about the exact wording of the poll.
- 4:55When you do a poll, any sort of public opinion survey, how you word questions, even it might
- 5:03not even seem like an important distinction with a word that you use.
- 5:08It can majorly impact what your poll's findings are.
- 5:12And if you do the poll multiple times, you usually want to keep the same wording each time
- 5:17so as to not influence results.
- 5:20You wanna keep it the exact same so you can more easily comparatively measure a poll unless
- 5:27you find out that later on that the poll's wording is just so bad that it needs to be
- 5:31changed.
- 5:32But generally speaking, you wanna keep the poll wording the same.
- 5:35So the exact question that the poll asks is this.
- 5:41In your view, do the Republican and Democratic parties do an adequate job of representing the
- 5:47American people, or do they do such a poor job that a third major party is needed?
- 5:52Now that that is there's not a badly worded poll.
- 5:56Gallup is a very well respected organization.
- 5:58I'm not gonna say that they're that is not a well worded poll because it's fine.
- 6:04But you still want to think about whether it can be improved because things can always be
- 6:09improved.
- 6:10Or not necessarily that they're improved, but what if we worded it slightly differently?
- 6:15So if we used a word other than adequate so in your view, do the Republican and Democratic
- 6:21parties do an adequate job of representing the American people?
- 6:25What if we say good?
- 6:27So if the parties do an adequate job and but you instead said they do a good job, are less
- 6:34people going to agree with that?
- 6:37Some people might see adequate and go, yeah, I I guess the two parties do okay.
- 6:42But if you say a good job, then they might be like, no.
- 6:45I don't think they do a good job.
- 6:46I think they do an okay job.
- 6:48So if you change that wording in the poll, would the results be any different?
- 6:54Or if you do a different word than representing, so if instead of saying job of
- 7:00representing the American people, maybe you say something like, I don't know.
- 7:06Do they do a good job giving American voters choices?
- 7:11Might seem like that's basically the same thing, but how do people interpret those words?
- 7:16It can how people interpret those words can be totally different.
- 7:21So if you change the wording of the poll, you might get more people that say we need a major
- 7:25third party, or you might get fewer people that say we need a major third party.
- 7:29So, again, I don't wanna say that it's not a good poll.
- 7:32It is a good poll.
- 7:33It's it's and Gallup knows what they're doing.
- 7:35They've been around for a very long time.
- 7:37It's just something to think about when you see these polls.
- 7:40You don't necessarily wanna go, oh, see, this poll says this thing that I really wanted.
- 7:45Well, need to think a little bit more, deeply than that.
- 7:50Another thing that you gotta watch out for polls or watch out for in polls is what we call
- 7:56a social desirability bias.
- 7:59So sometimes respondents will give an answer that they think is more socially desirable
- 8:04because they fear some sort of reprisal, even if there's no potential for it.
- 8:08Like, if Gallup is doing the poll, they're not gonna get upset at you for whatever answer you
- 8:13give.
- 8:13They're just they're trying to find out what people think.
- 8:16But there's this thing in their head where some people don't understand how these polls work,
- 8:21and they are afraid that an answer is gonna be traced back to them, and they're gonna be like,
- 8:26oh, I can't I can't tell.
- 8:27Or what about this person on the other end?
- 8:29Maybe they're not gonna say anything about it, but I don't want them to think I'm weird.
- 8:33So they might say, yeah.
- 8:34You know what?
- 8:34I think a third party is needed.
- 8:36None and this is not necessarily a whole lot of people doing this, but it is something to think
- 8:42about.
- 8:43So they might think it's more socially desirable to say that we need a third party,
- 8:47especially with how toxic and polarized the political climate has been lately.
- 8:52Another thing to look at with this poll is the breakdown by party.
- 8:55You always wanna look at the breakdown by party just to see the difference in party affiliation
- 9:00and what they think.
- 9:01So in that October 2024 poll about whether a third party was needed, support for having a
- 9:09third major party was 53% amongst democrats, 48% amongst republicans, and 69% amongst
- 9:17independents.
- 9:19Wait a minute.
- 9:2069% of independents?
- 9:22That's it?
- 9:23Well, the fact that they're independent, one might think that all or nearly all of them
- 9:29would want a third party, but it's not even close to that.
- 9:32It's a large majority of the independents, and this poll in the past has had a large majority
- 9:38of independents say that a third major party is needed.
- 9:41But when people identify as independents, they have a whole bunch of different reasons for
- 9:46identifying as such.
- 9:47Independents are often treated monolithically when they're not a monolith.
- 9:52There's a lot of different reasons they have for calling themselves independent.
- 9:56Some of them might not actually be independent.
- 9:59They're just giving what they think is a socially desirable answer, going back to social
- 10:03desirability bias.
- 10:05So they're, quote, unquote, Democrats or Republicans in independence clothing, or they
- 10:13are middle of the road voters like a lot of independents are thought of as, but they just
- 10:20flip back and forth between Democrats and Republicans.
- 10:22So they don't necessarily identify strongly with either party, or they may generally lean
- 10:30towards one party, but they still don't think of themselves as a Democrat or a Republican.
- 10:35Or they could just be accepting of the realities of a two party system and just say,
- 10:40you know what?
- 10:42It's I'm just gonna be independent, but I'm it it there is no third party that's gonna come
- 10:48up.
- 10:49Who knows?
- 10:50There's a bunch of different reasons for it.
- 10:51So if you think that it's odd that only 69% of independents would say that a third major party
- 10:56is needed, just take a step back and realize not everybody has the same idea of what being
- 11:02an independent is.
- 11:04So this just goes to show that there is a lot that the poll doesn't go into, which is not
- 11:08necessarily a problem.
- 11:10And it wasn't the aim of the poll necessarily to really dive into why these people say that a
- 11:16third major party is needed.
- 11:18But it does mean that you need to be careful taking too much from the poll, especially if
- 11:24you are somebody who does want a third major party to come into the fold.
- 11:30So a lot of independent sees on this poll, but there are some misunderstandings that they have
- 11:35about how much this poll actually benefits them.
- 11:39For example, this poll doesn't exactly ask why respondents want a third party.
- 11:45Yeah.
- 11:45Generally that they think that the parties both do such a poor job of representing the the
- 11:51American public.
- 11:52But why exactly do people think that?
- 11:55What exactly is the problem that these two parties why are they not exactly represent?
- 12:01Just because they're too far to the left, too far to the right, you would assume that that's
- 12:06the case.
- 12:07Yes.
- 12:07But it doesn't really fully go into specific reasons why people think they do such a poor
- 12:14job representing the American public.
- 12:18But even for people who do think that there needs to be a third major party, yeah, maybe
- 12:24there's agreement generally that there needs to be a third party, but people have varying
- 12:29reasons for wanting one.
- 12:32And what they want that third party to look like is going to differ differ.
- 12:36So if you're on Spotify or Apple or wherever and you're not able to see the visual, I'm
- 12:42gonna try to describe it as best as possible.
- 12:45So imagine this imaginary line between democrats and republicans, and you have a third
- 12:52party in the middle.
- 12:55Now if you're you're generally leaning democrat, but you want a major third party,
- 13:01maybe you're somewhere in between that third party and democrat, but you're not necessarily
- 13:07quite fully towards a third party.
- 13:11You want that third party to come a little bit closer to you, not too far to the left, but you
- 13:16want it to come closer to where you are.
- 13:18Or you're a republican generally, and you have this republican side and then the third party
- 13:24in the middle, but you might still be a bit closer to the republican party still.
- 13:29You just think they're too far to the right, and so you want that third party to come closer
- 13:33to you.
- 13:34So there's a whole lot of leeway, whole lot of room for that third party to line up in in
- 13:42regards to where it would be on the partisan spectrum.
- 13:46But how people want that third party, we're on that imaginary line that people want that third
- 13:53party to be could be very different amongst people.
- 13:58And again, just because people want a major third party doesn't mean they actually want it
- 14:03in the middle.
- 14:04And I'm gonna show you later on how there are some third parties that actually think the
- 14:10Democratic and the Republican parties are not far enough to their respective sides.
- 14:14So they may actually want a third party that's further out there, further to the right, or
- 14:18further to the left.
- 14:21Depends on who you ask.
- 14:22And, also, the poll doesn't dive into how likely people are to vote for a third party.
- 14:28Yeah.
- 14:28They may want a third party, but when push comes to shove, they don't necessarily act on
- 14:34that.
- 14:34It's this difference between what we say and what we do do.
- 14:38Excuse me.
- 14:39And even in polls where people threaten to vote third party, they often don't go through with
- 14:43it for various reasons, which we will, of course, talk about towards the end of this
- 14:48episode.
- 14:49But generally speaking, they might not know about third party candidates.
- 14:53Maybe a third party isn't on the ballot for the election in question.
- 14:58Maybe they think that particular third party is just weird and wacky.
- 15:03Maybe they just are so focused on not wanting the major party that they dislike more to win
- 15:09that they will just, quote unquote, suck it up and vote for the lesser of two evils.
- 15:14So lots of people may want a third major party, whether there's one that is there for them to
- 15:21vote on.
- 15:21And even if there is one to vote on, whether they're actually going to vote for that third
- 15:25party, that's where there's a little bit of a disconnect.
- 15:31But, again, third parties have won in the past.
- 15:34They don't win very often.
- 15:36But historically, we can point you some examples.
- 15:39Now, again, this is not talking about all independence.
- 15:44Some sometimes third parties are considered independent.
- 15:46Sometimes they're not.
- 15:47That's a whole other conversation.
- 15:48We've had a forget which episode it is, but we've had a podcast on that before.
- 15:53This is strictly talking about people who identify with a specific third party.
- 15:58Otherwise, there would be a lot more people to add to this list of victories outside the
- 16:03Democratic and Republican parties.
- 16:05So just third parties here.
- 16:07Third party victories used to be a lot more common overall.
- 16:11There's been spurts over time where more of them have won at different points.
- 16:18Part of the reason that third party victories used to happen much more is that the party
- 16:23structures for the Democratic Republican parties weren't nearly as robust and efficient
- 16:29as they are now.
- 16:30The strategies and tactics for expanding and mobilizing voter bases weren't always as
- 16:36effective.
- 16:36And then before the Republican party came into existence, there was the Whig party.
- 16:40And then before the Whig party, there was the Federalist party.
- 16:44Back then, there was a lot they didn't know about mobilizing voters and getting them to
- 16:50turn out for their candidates.
- 16:52There's also the fact that ballot access laws, which are the laws that govern how candidates
- 16:58for different affiliations or for no affiliations at all, how they can run for
- 17:02office, they were less stringent earlier on.
- 17:05They've gotten tighter as time has gone on.
- 17:08The two main parties found ways to make barriers to entry greater for third party and
- 17:14nonparty candidates.
- 17:15And, also, voter psychology, this whole voting for the lesser of two evils has become a lot
- 17:21more common over time as well.
- 17:23And just the sheer number of people that have identified with the Democratic and Republican
- 17:29parties has also increased as well relative to the third parties.
- 17:34So there have but there have been spurts here and there of third parties coming up with
- 17:39success at various levels of government.
- 17:41For example, we had populists and silver candidates in the eighteen nineties.
- 17:46Back then, there was a big political debate about whether the money supply for The US
- 17:55should be based on the gold or the silver standard.
- 17:59Progressives in the nineteen tens, they came and then went.
- 18:04And then there's been a couple of times we've had breakoffs from the two major parties.
- 18:08For example, in the post civil war era, we had the liberal Republican party, which was
- 18:14completely separate from the Republican party, although they didn't really last very long.
- 18:19But we've also had independent Democrats around the same time and for even a little bit longer
- 18:24than them, but eventually, they kind of I wouldn't say quite disappeared, but they
- 18:29certainly weren't as numerous even though there wasn't a whole lot of them to begin with, at
- 18:34least not necessarily.
- 18:36And then you had the states' right party in the late nineteen forties, which they were really
- 18:40just Democrats, but they were they broke off into their own thing from the main party for a
- 18:46time because of the party's increasing acceptance of civil rights.
- 18:51Back then, Southern Democrats were very much anti integration.
- 18:56They were very pro segregation.
- 18:59So for a time, you had that state's right party that came up, and they actually even won a few
- 19:04states in, I believe, it's the nineteen forty eight presidential election.
- 19:09Now as for specific offices, for president, there has never been a third party president.
- 19:18There have been third party candidates that have had stronger than usual showings, though.
- 19:23Most notably was Teddy Roosevelt.
- 19:26He was a Republican president before, but later on in 1912, he ran as a as a progressive party
- 19:33candidate or what he called his bull moose party.
- 19:37He ran because he was very disappointed in his protege.
- 19:42William Taft did not think that he was sufficiently progressive enough, so he
- 19:47seriously ruined Taft's chances.
- 19:50Taft maybe wouldn't have won anyways against democrat Woodrow Wilson, but he certainly
- 19:56wasn't gonna win with Teddy Roosevelt coming into the fold.
- 20:00So and Teddy Teddy Roosevelt had something like he won, I think, six states electoral votes,
- 20:07and then he won, like, 20% of the of the popular vote, I think.
- 20:15But he he he had a very strong showing for a third party.
- 20:17Still didn't come close to winning, but he did have a very strong showing.
- 20:21Ross Perot, he, in 1992, his more successful campaign still didn't win any electoral votes,
- 20:29but he won, I think it was 18 to 20,000,000 popular votes.
- 20:33He was completely independent in 1992.
- 20:36So the nineteen ninety two election doesn't really apply to this converse say say excuse
- 20:41me, to this conversation.
- 20:44But he, in 1996, ran as a reform party candidate, and he still had a pretty good
- 20:52performance as a third party candidate, but he performed much worse than in 1992 when he was
- 20:56not of a party at all.
- 20:58And then William Wirt, who was the anti Masonic party candidate in 1832, he was actually once
- 21:04the attorney general of The United States.
- 21:07He was the first third party candidate to win a state's electoral votes.
- 21:11He won in Vermont, and that this was before the Republican party even came into existence.
- 21:19As for other offices, we can also look to the US house and US senate.
- 21:24In the eighteen thirties, the nullifier party saw some success in both chambers.
- 21:29Nullifiers were people who believed that the states had a right to nullify federal laws if
- 21:35they deemed them unconstitutional.
- 21:38It was a very highly charged conversation as to whether these states had the power to
- 21:47invalidate certain federal laws back in the early days of The US system of government.
- 21:56From 1849 to 1855, you really saw free soilers in both chambers of congress.
- 22:03They these were people that opposed the expansion of slavery, not necessarily outright
- 22:08calling for its abolition, but they did at least oppose its expansion in the territories
- 22:15as The US expanded westward.
- 22:17During the civil war, there were unionists slash unconditional unionists, which were
- 22:22basically republicans under a different name.
- 22:25And in some states, they did basically replace republicans, but overall, they were considered
- 22:31a separate party.
- 22:33And if you look at the congress, there were Democrats and Republicans, and then people who
- 22:38identified as unionists.
- 22:41The American Labor Party in the nineteen forties, although that was really just in the
- 22:44US house.
- 22:46And then for the last third party members that we've seen in Congress, US senate, I'll
- 22:53highlight two people.
- 22:54Technically, Joe Lieberman during his last term from 2007 to 02/2013, he ran on the Connecticut
- 23:02for Lieberman ticket, but he was mostly a pure independent and independent democrat.
- 23:09If you wanna talk about somebody who was completely third party, there was James L.
- 23:14Buckley in New York.
- 23:16He was simply called a conservative party candidate.
- 23:20In in New York, there is a conservative party that is separate from the Republican party.
- 23:26And then in the US house, there was an American labor member from 1949 to 1951.
- 23:33Other than those few people, we have not seen third party members in either the US house or
- 23:40the US senate for quite some time.
- 23:42If we move on to state executives, third parties, third party victories, there's not
- 23:49many, but it occasionally happens.
- 23:51The most recent third party victor for governor was Jesse Dabadi Ventura, mostly known for pro
- 23:58wrestling before his time as governor.
- 24:00He won as a reform party candidate in 1998 as the governor for Minnesota.
- 24:07Other governors include Lowell Weicker junior, who was a Connecticut party candidate.
- 24:13He won in 1990.
- 24:15Orland Loomis, one as a progressive in Wisconsin in 1942 for governor, but he died
- 24:22before taking office.
- 24:24And then there was also Philip f Lafollette, another progressive governor for Wisconsin.
- 24:30The Lafollettes are a well known Wisconsin political family.
- 24:35He won in 1934 and 1936 as a progressive, but in 1930, he won as a republican.
- 24:42And there are a few other third party winners for governor in other states as well.
- 24:48I'm just highlighting a few examples.
- 24:50I could not confirm other potential state executives that were third party members, like,
- 24:57for example, attorneys general, but there are undoubtedly, there's gonna be a few examples.
- 25:02It would just take a little bit more diving in.
- 25:06I I saw a few that's that supposedly were third party, but then I found another source that
- 25:11said that they were either republican or democrat.
- 25:13So I didn't wanna put any of them on here.
- 25:17And then state legislatures, besides some local offices, this is really where third parties
- 25:24shine historically.
- 25:27Some state legislatures have had a relatively colorful third party history, partly because
- 25:33there's more chances for them to win at the state legislative level than at the federal
- 25:37level.
- 25:38And they also need to garner much fewer votes than at the federal level because they're
- 25:43representing a lot fewer people.
- 25:45But if some examples were in the Alaska State House, there are a few libertarians that won in
- 25:51the early 1980s.
- 25:53In the Vermont House, since 1990, we've had two to seven Vermont's progressive party candidates
- 26:01win in every election since 1990 and sometimes even had one or two Vermont progressive party
- 26:12winners in the state senate there.
- 26:15And then in Virginia, in both chambers, this is going much further back, but there was the
- 26:20readjuster party in 1881 and 1883.
- 26:24They won significant representation in that chamber, even even won a majority of both
- 26:30chambers in 1881, which was highly impressive for a third party at any point in time.
- 26:35And that was in response to the high state debt that was incurred during the civil war.
- 26:40That's really what brought the readjuster party into existence, but they flamed out pretty
- 26:45quickly.
- 26:45They kinda disappeared completely after those first few years of the eighteen eighties.
- 26:54So history shows that third party candidates do win occasionally, but it happens almost no.
- 27:03I don't wanna say almost never, but it happens only occasionally.
- 27:07So why is that the case?
- 27:11Well, first of all, why parties exist in the first place?
- 27:15I've highlighted this book in a couple of previous episodes.
- 27:18This is why parties, a second look by John Aldrich.
- 27:23He really gives an in-depth look at the reasons not only why parties exist in American
- 27:29politics, but why they have such strength.
- 27:32And he also does talk about why third parties really don't ever if they do gain some level of
- 27:40strength, it is not for long.
- 27:42I mentioned the book in the tenth episode of this podcast.
- 27:47But first, we need to understand what exactly is a political party.
- 27:50So one way to define it is that they are a party is a group of people with similar views
- 27:56and preferences that band together to achieve certain goals.
- 28:00And there's plenty of incentives for people to join parties.
- 28:04Generally, it's much harder to achieve your goals if you don't have a coalition, especially
- 28:09when it comes to what we call pork barrel legislation, which are projects specific to a
- 28:15district or several districts.
- 28:18You, if you don't have a party, you have a lack of organization because there's too many
- 28:22competing interests.
- 28:24You kind of need a band together and the majority party, if there is one, usually can
- 28:29pass whatever bill they want.
- 28:31So it really behooves people to come together as part of a party.
- 28:36And also parties, it's a lot easier to mobilize voters to turn out because voters that identify
- 28:42with either the Democratic or Republican party usually turn out at much higher rates than
- 28:47independents do.
- 28:50And and to some extent, third parties, but third party membership is also very low.
- 28:55And party identification gives a cue to voters about a candidate's general views.
- 29:01More on that later.
- 29:04And, also, ambitious politicians wanna climb the ladder, and that really only happens
- 29:10through party affiliation.
- 29:12So structure will almost always beat out a lack of structure in political competitions.
- 29:20Organized interests perform much better than disorganized interests.
- 29:24So that's why we have parties, generally speaking, as a brief overview.
- 29:30But why don't we have more than two major political parties?
- 29:36Enter DuVerge's law.
- 29:38So it's not an actual law, but it is an axiom of sorts.
- 29:43Basically says that political systems that use single member districts, meaning their
- 29:47districts are only represented by one person, and a plurality voting system tend to favor two
- 29:53parties.
- 29:54So in other words, if it's just the one person who gets the most votes wins, two parties are
- 29:59going to duke it out for the seat, the vast majority of the time.
- 30:03A third party might make a strong push at times, but at some point that party or another
- 30:09party will fade away as people conclude that they won't win at all if they split up too
- 30:14much.
- 30:14Again, it goes back to that, quote unquote lesser of two evils mindset when it comes to
- 30:20voting potentially for a third major party.
- 30:23And you can contrast that with proportional representation systems that use multi member
- 30:28districts.
- 30:29And there are a few state legislatures in The US that use multi member districts, including
- 30:35Vermont, which I mentioned before, have more third party members in elected office than you
- 30:42would typically see.
- 30:44Some European countries use these proportional representation systems with multi member
- 30:49districts where multiple people can win a seat in a district based on how much of the vote the
- 30:54party wins instead of being a winner take all scenario.
- 30:58But you don't get proportional representation in The US.
- 31:03Even in those states that do use multi member districts for a given office, they don't use
- 31:09proportional representation.
- 31:12But that being said, there are third parties that exist today.
- 31:17So what is what who are these third parties, and what is their membership?
- 31:22So states have their own rules for what third parties voters can register as and what
- 31:28candidates can run as.
- 31:30As of January 2025, according to Ballopedia, 11 states have only the Democratic and Republican
- 31:36parties as ballot qualified.
- 31:40Even in states where a third party is ballot qualified, it's usually only one or two third
- 31:47parties that are also on the ballots along with Democrats and Republicans.
- 31:53Although one aberration is my state, Florida, which actually has 16 ballot qualified parties.
- 31:59So, yeah, that that you rarely get anything like that.
- 32:03In fact, you never get anything like that except in Florida.
- 32:06There are a couple states that have, like, 10 or 11 parties, but not 16.
- 32:11But even in states where a third party is ballot qualified, the number of registered
- 32:16voters for that party is quite minuscule compared to the Democrats or Republicans.
- 32:23A third party might achieve maybe 2% of the overall registered voter electorate at best,
- 32:33but usually it's around like 1% or less than 1% of voters that are registered with that third
- 32:40party.
- 32:41It's a lot more common to see them as just completely independent where they don't have
- 32:45any party registration whatsoever.
- 32:49And even in states that don't track party registration of voters, because some states do
- 32:54just register voters as registered voters, and that's it.
- 32:58They don't actually register as a party.
- 33:01The estimation of their third party voters would be similar to those states.
- 33:07So if they did track party affiliation of voters, their third party members are gonna be
- 33:14it's gonna be a very small piece of the pie.
- 33:16But that being said, the most common third parties that you see in The US are the
- 33:23libertarians, the greens, and constitution.
- 33:26Libertarian, by far, you see the most often.
- 33:2938 states have a libertarian party that is ballot qualified.
- 33:35The Green Party is ballot qualified in 23 states, and the constitution party is qualified
- 33:40in 12 states.
- 33:43The Green Party is a much further to the left party, and the constitution party is much
- 33:47further to the right.
- 33:50So constitution is often more conservative than a lot of Republicans are.
- 33:56Green party is often a lot more liberal than a lot of Democrats are.
- 34:01But there are some third parties that are much more unique to specific states like the Alaskan
- 34:06independence party in Alaska.
- 34:08You have the peace and freedom party in California.
- 34:12There's the Colorado center party, the Jeffersonian Party of Florida.
- 34:17There's the Aloha Aina Party in Hawaii, Natural Law Party in Michigan, and then the Vermont
- 34:23Progressive Party.
- 34:24So some more unique, quirky third parties in certain states.
- 34:32But what why exactly do third parties run into these roadblocks?
- 34:37What exactly are these roadblocks that they run into?
- 34:40As I just described, there are very third parties are not ballot qualified at every
- 34:47state, and even ones that are ballot qualified in multiple states, those are few and far
- 34:53between because third parties just face a lot of roadblocks to not only winning elections,
- 35:00but even competing in them in the first place.
- 35:03I talk about some of them in my book, why independents rarely win elections and how they
- 35:08become more competitive.
- 35:09That's available on Amazon, but I'm gonna just highlight several of them here.
- 35:15So first of all, ballot access laws.
- 35:19So these are laws that are governing how candidates for different affiliations or no
- 35:24affiliations can run for office.
- 35:26And for third parties to be able to run candidates under their party label, they have
- 35:31to meet certain requirements to become ballots qualified.
- 35:35So mention that word ballot qualified several times.
- 35:41A party has to reach a certain threshold of support where candidates can be listed on the
- 35:46ballot with said party affiliation.
- 35:49And what those requirements are going to be different from state to state, but it could be
- 35:52something as simple as filing a petition to be that third party.
- 35:58They might need to be organized around a specific candidate.
- 36:01They might need to win a percentage of the vote.
- 36:04Otherwise, they must stay as a write in, or they need a certain number of registered voters
- 36:09to be affiliated with that party for that party to run candidates as that party label.
- 36:18And this is much more onerous for third parties than it is for Democrats and Republicans.
- 36:24There's also a fact that for specific candidates, there are two main ways for them to
- 36:29get on the ballot.
- 36:30They either pay a fee or they gain a certain number of petition signatures from voters who
- 36:36can then vote or who can vote in that race.
- 36:40So if I'm running for congressional district, Third Congressional District Of Georgia, I
- 36:47can't get petition signatures from people that are registered in the Fourth They have to be
- 36:51Third District voters.
- 36:52If I'm running for governor in Georgia, then I can get anybody's signature that is a
- 36:58registered voter in the state of Georgia because that's a statewide election.
- 37:03Now what that fee is and the number of petition signatures that they need, that is going to
- 37:09depend on the race in question, state and local laws, etcetera.
- 37:15Most well funded democrats and republicans are just gonna pay the fee and just get it over
- 37:20with.
- 37:22But for third party, and in a lot of cases, candidates that are of no party at all, but for
- 37:29third party candidates, oftentimes, the fees are either higher than they are for the
- 37:35Democratic or Republican candidates, or the option to pay a fee is not even there.
- 37:41You have to get petition signatures.
- 37:43I've mentioned this several times on the podcast is very cumbersome to get petition
- 37:49signatures for anything.
- 37:50I've done it before.
- 37:52On a campaign where I had get petition signatures to get a candidate on the ballot.
- 37:57It was not exactly what I would call fun.
- 38:00So these petition signatures are oftentimes that third party candidate's only option.
- 38:07And not only that, the number of petition signatures they need to get are often much
- 38:12higher than the Democrats or Republicans need to get.
- 38:16I remember there was a case there was an internship I did during grad school, and there
- 38:21was an independent candidate that in Texas, I think it was, he eventually did not make the
- 38:29ballot, but he needed something like nine times the amount or the number of petition signatures
- 38:34that a democrat or republican needed.
- 38:37And it's been a little while now, so I forget the exact details, but I think he needed
- 38:42something like 45,000 petition signatures, which might seem like it's not difficult
- 38:48because of how many people are in Texas, but it's believe me, it's very difficult to get
- 38:54people to stop, to sign the petition signature, to know what they're signing for.
- 38:59They hear that you're running for office.
- 39:02They may pester you with questions like, oh, why should I vote for you?
- 39:05Or if you're not of the affiliation that they're looking for, they might not even sign
- 39:10the petition anyways.
- 39:11Even if you get these petition signatures, a lot of times, whoever the voting officials are
- 39:16in a state or in a county, when they validate these signatures, for whatever reason, five to
- 39:2410% of the signatures you get are going to be invalidated.
- 39:28And you won't know why.
- 39:30So you actually have to get more petition signatures than you would think you have to
- 39:35get.
- 39:36So if you had to get 45,000, you really need want to get more like 50,000 to 55,000 to make
- 39:42sure that you have enough after some are invalidated.
- 39:46But in any case, it's very onerous to get these petition signatures.
- 39:52And for third party candidates, it's often the only way they can't pay a fee, and they usually
- 39:58have to get a lot more petition signatures than the Democrats or Republican candidates do.
- 40:04Another obstacle that third party candidates face is that the party label inherently comes
- 40:11with some sort of prior perceptions, whether those are fair or not.
- 40:14Now that's not unique to third party candidates.
- 40:17Democrats and Republicans have that same sometimes it's an issue.
- 40:22Sometimes it's a boon.
- 40:23Depends on what the race is.
- 40:26But it can be much more challenging in the case of third party candidates.
- 40:31So a party affiliation is inherently a heuristic, a mental shortcut that we use to
- 40:37make our decisions on who we vote for.
- 40:40And even though there are varied views within the party because of their nature as coalitions
- 40:45where people need to band together, they don't necessarily agree on everything, but they band
- 40:49together with the people that think most like them so they can win more contests, win more
- 40:54political battles.
- 40:56There are still generally some accurate or inaccurate existing beliefs about them.
- 41:02Sometimes you'll find party members within each of those parties that aren't are they they sort
- 41:08of buck the trend a little bit of the rest of their party.
- 41:11But generally speaking, they you have some prior perceptions of the party that at least
- 41:18makes sense.
- 41:20But for third parties, there are generally less differences within those parties than within
- 41:26democrats and republicans because their specific views led them to that third party in
- 41:31the first place instead of sticking with democrats or sticking with republicans or just
- 41:35becoming a complete independent.
- 41:38So if you're a Libertarian party candidate, you're a Libertarian party voter.
- 41:44The rest of the voters that are registered as Libertarian party members are gonna think very
- 41:50similarly to you, much more similarly than if you were Republican and you encountered some
- 41:55other Republicans or you're a Democrat and you encounter some other Democrats.
- 41:59Same thing with a Green Party candidate or a Constitution Party candidate or any other third
- 42:03party candidate.
- 42:05There's a lot more rigidity in those third party candidates and voters views than if you
- 42:13had if you compared them to Democrats and Republicans.
- 42:16And then when you are of a certain party label, comparisons to fellow party members simply by
- 42:23being the same party are inevitable.
- 42:27You have somebody that runs as a republican right now.
- 42:30There's inherently some sort of comparison to Donald Trump, whether those candidates invite
- 42:35those comparisons or not.
- 42:37When Joe Biden was in office, Democrats had that same thing where, oh, you're the party of
- 42:42Joe Biden, and then you were compared to him.
- 42:46It's just par for the course.
- 42:48And if people are more aware of your third party, they're going to compare you to other
- 42:52third parties that they have encountered in the past or third party candidates and members that
- 42:58they've encountered in the past.
- 43:00Speaking of which, a third big issue that third party candidates often encounter is that
- 43:06they're generally perceived to be unserious candidates.
- 43:11Now whether that's right or wrong in certain cases, sometimes they are seen as too goofy or
- 43:16uninformed, and they have a lot less room for error than Democrats or Republicans do.
- 43:21Go back to the twenty sixteen presidential election.
- 43:24Gary Johnson, the libertarian candidate for president.
- 43:28He was questioned about the city of Aleppo, which was an epicenter of the Syrian civil war.
- 43:35Gary Johnson was asked about that, and he said, what is Aleppo?
- 43:39And not that he was really gaining a whole lot of traction anyways, but if he was, that
- 43:46completely tanked his chances of making any sort of noise in the presidential election.
- 43:52So some of these third party candidates are perceived as too far out there or too narrowly
- 43:58focused.
- 43:58For example, greens and constitution party candidates, green party candidates, their
- 44:02environmental views are a core part of their platform.
- 44:06That's why they are the greens.
- 44:08Constitution party candidates are very focused on state's rights, for example.
- 44:14So they kind of get treated as, okay, these are weird people.
- 44:18We're not gonna vote for them.
- 44:21And then a fourth big issue that third party candidates often face is simply they're just
- 44:29perceived as uncompetitive.
- 44:31Even if some people want to vote for a third party, they feel they are, quote unquote,
- 44:36wasting their vote.
- 44:37They they must vote for the, unquote, lesser of two evils.
- 44:42So these candidates are often considered too risky, and voters are often risk averse unless
- 44:48they hate the status quo that much.
- 44:50It's sort of that the devil you know versus the devil you don't know.
- 44:54So they're either gonna just stick with what they know, or they're gonna just sit home and
- 45:01not vote at all unless they really feel like this current situation sucks.
- 45:07We need something different.
- 45:09And so this becomes a self fulfilling prophecy.
- 45:12People think that third party candidates don't have a chance, so they don't vote for them.
- 45:17And then those third party candidates don't have a chance because people aren't voting for
- 45:20them.
- 45:20And then on and on, the vicious cycle goes.
- 45:23And it also doesn't help that they are often called spoilers by both the two major parties
- 45:29and the media.
- 45:30So it's just really reinforces this perception of them as uncompetitive.
- 45:35And a lot of times, they aren't competitive.
- 45:37So all that leads to this final point or multiple points about this final question here.
- 45:46Is there really a potential for a major third party to arise and give a real challenge to the
- 45:53Democratic and Republican parties.
- 45:55And, again, specifically for a third major party, not independents in general.
- 45:59So we're not talking about candidates who don't have a party affiliation at all.
- 46:04That's a totally different topic.
- 46:06Well, not totally different, but it's it's largely different.
- 46:10I'm gonna be honest with you about this question.
- 46:12Is there really potential for a major third party?
- 46:15It's highly unlikely, at least anytime soon, and at least for the national context.
- 46:22Even when they've had better than usual showings for presidents, they still haven't
- 46:26come even close to winning an election, and they don't really build on their momentum.
- 46:32They have a big showing in one presidential election, and then four years later, they
- 46:39either have a very paltry, relatively pitiful showing compared to what they were four years
- 46:46prior, or they don't run at all.
- 46:49And that I'm talking mostly about president there, but it it the same thing applies for
- 46:55governor's races, other state executives, US house, US Senate.
- 47:00They might have a really strong showing, and then nothing happens.
- 47:05They don't really build on any sort of momentum even if they have some momentum in the first
- 47:10place.
- 47:12And then get to go back to the general obstacles that third parties face that we just
- 47:16talked about, particularly in terms of perception by the public.
- 47:19Yeah.
- 47:20Maybe people hate the Democratic and Republican parties.
- 47:23Maybe they really want something different.
- 47:24But even when the opportunity arises to vote for a third party, voters rarely take that
- 47:30chance to vote for them, or there really isn't an option for that third party.
- 47:36And there might not even be an option to write somebody in.
- 47:39And then writing candidacies are notoriously difficult to achieve victory with.
- 47:48These third party candidates are often treated as unserious and goofy and uncompetitive.
- 47:54And even when the media does give them attention and often highlights them as spoilers
- 47:58or wacky or, hey, look at that what this idiot said.
- 48:02And then they have no room for error third party candidates.
- 48:07They have to basically be perfect on everything to give themselves a chance.
- 48:13Democrats, Republicans, obviously, they have little room for error too, but they have a
- 48:19little bit more leeway to make a mistake on the campaign trail than a third party candidate
- 48:25does.
- 48:27And then even if you put the public perceptions aside, there's just a major uphill climb when
- 48:32it comes to ballot access laws, often highly difficult to get on the ballot as a third party
- 48:38candidate.
- 48:39And for the third party to even be a ballot qualified party in the first place so that they
- 48:45can run candidates on that party label is notoriously difficult.
- 48:51So that being said, they can will still win some lower level races like in state
- 48:56legislatures or local offices from time to time, and those are still important.
- 49:01Even if they are often treated as like they don't matter, those are very important, and we
- 49:07should care about those races more in general regardless of whether third parties running
- 49:12them or not.
- 49:13But right now, that is the best bet for third parties to win more elections, and they're
- 49:22gonna be very localized achievements by the third party.
- 49:29Like for example, in Vermont, the Vermont progressive party, the, that's very limited to
- 49:36Vermont.
- 49:37They're not going to really spread out.
- 49:38Not to say that there aren't progressive parties in other states, but the Vermont
- 49:43progressive party is a more unique party specific to Vermont.
- 49:48And they for a third party, they are pretty successful, but compared to democrats or
- 49:54republicans, they're still dwarfed in number.
- 49:57So if we're talking about being a specific third party being competitive in a ton of
- 50:05states and regularly being competitive across state, federal, and local offices, Don't expect
- 50:14that anytime soon.
- 50:16But, hey, who knows?
- 50:18Maybe something crazy will happen in the next five, ten, fifteen, twenty years, and maybe a
- 50:24third party will be more regularly competitive against the democratic and republican
- 50:30candidates.
- 50:31But history and and current events dictated that's probably not going to happen anytime
- 50:39soon.
- 50:40So but, anyways, that's gonna do it for today's episode of the politics with Paul podcast.
- 50:45As always, thank you so much for listening and watching.
- 50:48Please like, comment, subscribe, and share the podcast with your friends and family and
- 50:53anybody else you know.
- 50:55My links in the show notes below for Facebook, LinkedIn, my book, why independents rarely win
- 51:02elections and how they could become more competitive, very relevant to this topic in
- 51:07particular.
- 51:08And some of the information I pulled was from that book, my five day educational email course
- 51:16about how we can more effectively depolarize our political climate here in America.
- 51:24My matchmaker FM profile, if you wanna potentially be a guest on this podcast or have
- 51:29me as a guest on your podcast.
- 51:31And there's a couple other things.
- 51:34But other than that, that's it.
- 51:36So as always, thank you so much for listening, and until next time, take care.