Latest / I Love You Keep Going with George Haas / Path of Enlightenment - Stage Four - Arising and Passing
Transcript
- 0:03So welcome everybody, this is meditation and attachment,
- 0:07deepening your practice. It's July 1st 2021 at 7:35 p.m.
- 0:11Pacific Daylight time and tonight I was going to talk
- 0:15about the fourth stage of the progress of insight, which is a
- 0:20knowledge of arising and passing, but I thought I would
- 0:25pause for a moment and see if anybody had any questions that
- 0:30they wanted to talk about first. I'm totally open to listening
- 0:39and not interrupting you with your teaching, but if I get a
- 0:41chance to ask him how conversation as well.
- 0:44Okay. Anyway, One of the things about
- 0:55the dialogue, around the progress of inside or the Tera
- 0:57vaada practice in the west is the experience of The Dark
- 1:01Knight. And that really is the 6th 7th
- 1:06and 8th stages of the progress of inside the fearfulness
- 1:12around, the deep understanding of no self or non-self the
- 1:19misery around the Understanding of arising and passing the
- 1:24impermanence of things and the discussed that arises in
- 1:30contemplation of the body as something that will grow old,
- 1:34get sick and die. and it comes out of the dissolution
- 1:38experience and then, In particular circles where there's
- 1:46a sense of urgency around the potential harm that Dark Knight
- 1:56or dark night, is a Christian term.
- 2:00Knowledge of the miseries is the Buddhist term.
- 2:04We hit the fourth stage, which is knowledge of arising, and
- 2:07passing that, if you have what Daniel Ingram calls, the A&P
- 2:12event the arise, Rising and passing event.
- 2:15That, that is the, the point of no return.
- 2:18And so, years ago, there was this moment of the cautionary
- 2:27disclaimer that once you go through the arising and passing
- 2:33event, you can't unsee the insights that come from that.
- 2:37And so you're stuck having to practice meditation for the rest
- 2:41of your life, because if you don't, Just be unhappy.
- 2:49And I think the way that I really thought of it is that you
- 2:53go from the perception of everything as being, this
- 2:58continuous flowing movement of experience, and that begins to
- 3:05unravel, and what you see is a combination of this kind of
- 3:09fluid macro experience and then this choppy staccato, sort of
- 3:16it's almost like you're watching.
- 3:19A movie. I'm dating myself.
- 3:23Remember a time when you went to the movie theater, it was
- 3:26actually filmed that they were showing a dotted digital
- 3:29experience, okay? I just thought of the digital
- 3:34equivalent. So, the film breaks and you see
- 3:38a couple of frames that go through the projector and you
- 3:44see the individual frames with a little bit of movement in each
- 3:47one. And then the screen goes.
- 3:49White and the digital world, of course everything just becomes
- 3:52pixelated, right? Chunks of blocks of image,
- 4:00rather than that fluid appearance of The fluid motion
- 4:09of perception. When you're sitting in
- 4:15meditation and you pay attention to the arising and passing of
- 4:19everything, and you begin to see in each sense, gate, where you
- 4:26bring your attention, these small arisings and passings and
- 4:34that the clarity gets so good. That, that the print, the
- 4:38presentation of the solid experience of self and world.
- 4:42Old begins to break up, and you see it just as this sort of,
- 4:46vibratory activity of arising and passing, and you can't get
- 4:51the fluidity back. You can't get that sense of
- 4:55solidness back. That's one way to describe the
- 4:58arising and passing event. The way that I used to describe
- 5:04it is that you come into the chamber in Oz, and the terrible
- 5:10wizard is there as a floating head with flames.
- 5:14And and then little Toto, runs across the floor and pulls back
- 5:19the curtain on the schlubby, snake oil salesman.
- 5:24And as soon as you realize, that the presentation of Oz is
- 5:28actually this mechanical You can't unsee the snake oil
- 5:36salesman and of ignorance and and you can no longer believe in
- 5:44the big terrifying, experience of Oz.
- 5:49And then what are you left with? This understanding that the, the
- 5:57solidness of things, the reliability of that, that solid
- 6:01Miss is actually not. What's there, not, what's
- 6:04happening? The perception of the self is
- 6:07this ongoing? Continuous narrative is actually
- 6:11not that and that do then are confronted with this.
- 6:19Life in a in a body that's constantly changing.
- 6:23And generally speaking not for the better after you get past
- 6:27the age of 30, you might even get to a place where you can
- 6:35contemplate the end of the body, the end of this Incarnation, the
- 6:41end of this period of time. And then, how do you hold that
- 6:47experience? Christian.
- 6:51Is this different than like an experience of like do you
- 6:55realization or depersonalization or some kind of dissociative
- 6:58experience? Well, it's very different than a
- 7:02dissociative experience because in a dissociative experience
- 7:05there's an inward withdrawal and a fuzzing out.
- 7:09So the, the extraordinary sensory Clarity of the of the
- 7:14arising and passing events in every sense, gate, wherever you
- 7:18turn, your attention isn't present.
- 7:20In that deep depersonalization is something that often happens
- 7:25in response to this because you can't actually get the solid.
- 7:30Sense of self experience to come back.
- 7:33Reliably enough to believe in it.
- 7:36And you're not yet adapted to the understanding that.
- 7:46That actually, it's always been like that.
- 7:50That the belief in the illusion of the constant, solid
- 7:54experience of self has never been more than a belief in
- 7:58something that's not actually there. and so, when I was early
- 8:06on discussing this phenomenon with shins and he described it
- 8:12as a very manicured, very well-kept Garden surrounded by a
- 8:19high wall through which there was a gate And on the other side
- 8:24of the gate was a jungle that had no no order was chaotic and
- 8:30often frightening. And that the idea was to be able
- 8:36to pass through the gate, from the jungle into the manicured
- 8:40Garden or out of the manicured Garden into the jungle
- 8:44effortlessly. But that in the beginning when
- 8:48you're moving in and out of this belief, in an ongoing experience
- 8:55of self that things are permanent and that the body will
- 8:59live forever. You can't operate the latch on
- 9:06the gate with enough reliability to move in between the totally
- 9:11fixated cultivated experience of self and the freeform experience
- 9:19of the not self. One of the things that becomes
- 9:25apparent as you do, this is that the not-self experience, there's
- 9:32no suffering and some tents. The the identification with the
- 9:36selfing experience shifts into an identification with the
- 9:42awareness itself and there's no suffering and awareness and then
- 9:47when you need to jump into the experience of self, you jump
- 9:50into it and Manifest this Is brilliant capable experience of
- 9:55self, but then when you don't need it, you don't cling to it
- 9:59because you've seen that it's ephemeral and arises based on
- 10:03conditions and that it will arise again based on conditions
- 10:07in the. There's no need to grasp on to
- 10:10it. There's no need to grab onto it,
- 10:15but then you'd have to, of course, allow it to dissolve.
- 10:20So the arising and passing is the seeing the of the arising,
- 10:24and seeing the passing away, and seeing the arising, seeing the
- 10:28passing away. If you look at the, the manual,
- 10:31it describes, A lot of markers that you could use as a way of
- 10:37evaluating that, say some 50 markers of that arising and
- 10:42passing away. If there's no ground to stand
- 10:48on, how do you just continuously fall without the am prehension
- 10:51that you're going to land and splat?
- 10:55Right, one of the metaphors I really liked was that you fly
- 11:02your a bird, and you fly in and out of a bird cage in the bird
- 11:06cage. Everything is relative
- 11:08everything, a solid. But when you fly out of the
- 11:11birdcage, you see that the bird cage is just dropping through
- 11:14space. It's not Actually resting on
- 11:17anything and so that frightens you and you fly back in and want
- 11:22to make everything solid again. But then you begin to
- 11:27acclimatize to it isn't something that you understand
- 11:31from the self side of things, it's something that you get used
- 11:35to that. This is actually how it is.
- 11:40Not only is this how it is? This is how it's always been
- 11:44that your identification, your habit of attaching and making
- 11:49things solid and persisting in this idea that things are New is
- 11:55an unending is what is the illusion?
- 11:59Not the sense that it isn't solid Christian.
- 12:05So is this not necessarily like a single aha moment, like it can
- 12:09be you kind of exploring this space until you.
- 12:13You get that. You it's not going to kill you.
- 12:15You're not going to go insane or whatever.
- 12:20I'm not talking about my thought process at all.
- 12:23No, totally. I get that.
- 12:30Like what what's special about this as opposed to maybe other
- 12:35mystical experiences or even, you know, taking a hallucinogen
- 12:39or something like that? Like what's the, what's the AHA
- 12:41honest of this particular insight.
- 12:46The one of the things about the tenacious nature of self and the
- 12:51tape, tenacious nafe nature of the habit of believing in the
- 12:58continuous experience of self, the the solidness of an ongoing
- 13:03nature of things and that the the the this body will live
- 13:10forever. It's an interesting thing
- 13:11because the body obviously is constantly aging constantly
- 13:15changing and Still, it's possible to imagine that this
- 13:19process of change in age will go on forever.
- 13:26It's Not Unusual to have people think that they'll live to be
- 13:29100 or 120, or I have a student and I work with, who is quite
- 13:36convinced that she's going to live to be 130, you know, you
- 13:43know, if you look at the math, the odds of that happening are
- 13:48so extraordinary that I Marvel at her.
- 13:52He's at believing that most people have a really difficult
- 14:01time when they hear that the average lifespan in the u.s. is
- 14:07for males, 74. I'm not the average the life
- 14:12expectancy, that's different. Little bit older little bit
- 14:18longer for females. If you 20% of people live longer
- 14:26than that. So 80% of people don't live
- 14:29longer than that. And yet to imagine that that's a
- 14:33life span is not what ordinarily we think. so, This the self is
- 14:46very tenacious and its capacity to ignore the the contradictions
- 14:52to this and I think often what happens with psychedelic
- 14:58experience is that even though the sense of self dissolves and
- 15:05you have the kind of distorted picture of this, you know, the
- 15:13visual field. Apps is all of that stuff
- 15:16happens. There's the a lot of often
- 15:21hallucinations of some sort or another that it isn't enough to
- 15:26actually convince the sense of self that it's not real. because
- 15:34you take a substance, it changes the biology of the brain and
- 15:38then it wears off and you slide out of the sense of self into
- 15:42this other experience, which the self is also having and then you
- 15:46slide out of the experience and you have no agency to come and
- 15:52go any more than you had before unless you repeat the, The
- 15:58Taking of the substance whereas in meditation, if you practice
- 16:04in a way that leads to these kinds of insights, you don't
- 16:08obviously need to do, any use any psychedelics, but you
- 16:16develop the skill at moving out of the experience of solidness
- 16:21into the experience of arising, and passing them for shins and
- 16:26uses the term flow and you develop the skill to move in and
- 16:32out of Fixating things in and out of attaching and so you have
- 16:36agency in whether you do that or not.
- 16:40Not simply acquiring a substance and taking a substance and
- 16:44really not having the experience of any agency in being able to
- 16:49do that. Now it does for some people
- 16:56create an opening and evidence that there is something beyond
- 17:03the very limited solidness of self and world.
- 17:09That then provides motivation to develop practice but I don't
- 17:15notice in and of itself. If it isn't followed, if that
- 17:20opening of Consciousness isn't followed by the development of
- 17:24the skills to be in relationship to it, that perception has a
- 17:29lasting effect. Where change is much in a person
- 17:38if you look at the experience of the US, for instance, the the
- 17:4160s, and the original hippies, and the original psychedelic
- 17:46experience. And you know, Timothy Leary
- 17:50saying that, you know, in 20 years the US was going to be an
- 17:55LSD nation and that we were going to turn away from war and
- 18:00turn away from capitalism because of the insights that
- 18:03were coming from this. That didn't happen.
- 18:12I mean, in fact, most of the I like to call them, 0h is
- 18:15original hippies went headlong into capitalism and as a result
- 18:22of, you know, just the the smallest suppression from the
- 18:30authorities, So something interesting about Timothy Leary,
- 18:39if you look at his life Journey it seems like you had a lot of
- 18:42sort of insecure attachment, you know, it just remember if that
- 18:49kind of fueled the sort of grandiose.
- 18:52I mean, obviously, I don't know much about him, but obviously,
- 18:56he's a Visionary. And he had a lot of, a big
- 18:59effect on a lot of people, but I wonder if his Insecurities sort
- 19:03of pushed him into that. you know, we there's a high
- 19:10correlation between dismissing attachment or avoidant
- 19:14attachment with substance use in some sense, the early
- 19:24conditioning demonstrates to in a convincing way that other
- 19:27people are unreliable and so you can't really rely on them and so
- 19:32that you develop a way of emotionally regulating yourself
- 19:36that doesn't require two to depend on other people.
- 19:40It secure systems, you rely on other people to help you.
- 19:46That's the central source of emotional regulation, the
- 19:49central source of support and you learn collaborative
- 19:53relationship skills so that you can be in relationship with
- 19:57people who will help you and do they support and encourage you,
- 20:01and you support and encourage them.
- 20:05And then for people, that that isn't really a possibility or
- 20:09don't have that skill. Then they offer up these
- 20:12alternatives to having to do that as a way of operating in
- 20:19the world. But at the same time, they're
- 20:21putting themselves at the front of the room, offering the, the
- 20:25teaching that they offer, which is in line with their attachment
- 20:30conditioning, you know, one of the most common experiences of
- 20:36being in the front of the room is people coming in and wanting
- 20:41meditation to take them out of the place where they need to
- 20:46depend on anyone. They want to be completely
- 20:49separate completely self-contained, but they are
- 20:53hoping that meditation will do that for them.
- 20:59And, you know, I mean, I have reports from different people
- 21:03that monastic communities are, are also Engaged in that idea
- 21:08that we can withdraw from the need to be interdependent in
- 21:14with other people. Well, I mean, I'm just wondering
- 21:18how does this idea not to bring you away from the topic of your
- 21:22discussion, but the idea of dissolution in the idea that,
- 21:27you know, you really can't depend on any constructive
- 21:31thought, you know, in all all other people that you perceive
- 21:37are, just, it's just a mental construction about five
- 21:41Aggregates which you really don't, you can't, you can't
- 21:46really I understand them because you can't even understand your
- 21:49own five Aggregates, you know. So I just really see how this
- 21:53this teaching. It's very kind of it leads one
- 21:58into a state of being very nihilistic in terms of the
- 22:02potential for Meaningful attachment relationships.
- 22:13Yes, there is that. Yeah do totally makes sense.
- 22:19The idea that interpersonal relationships are scary and
- 22:24painful that I don't know how to operate them.
- 22:28That I can't trust my own perceptions of what's happening.
- 22:33And I need to be relieved of that suffering.
- 22:40Who's one way to view that? So the, you know, I always think
- 22:44of it as this fork in the road in One Direction is Neil is mmm.
- 22:49None of it matters. Nothing matters.
- 22:51Actually because nothing lasts, there's no contribution that can
- 22:55be made. That will have any enduring
- 22:57impact. But the other direction, of
- 23:01course is full engagement, knowing perfectly.
- 23:05Well, all of those conditions are true.
- 23:08And yet still pushing in the direction of, of the pursuit of
- 23:13things that are meaningful, the pursuit of connection knowing
- 23:17full. Well, that all of that will be
- 23:20lost. So it takes the quality of the
- 23:25present moment from being this nihilistic hopeless.
- 23:29Barren place that needs to be endured and hopefully I can
- 23:33figure out how to do that with no attachment to anything or
- 23:37anyone. And flips it into this fully
- 23:41going in fully engaging, fully experiencing everything that can
- 23:46be experience knowing that it is just going to be lost at the end
- 23:52of each moment. We have this idea that we can
- 23:56reserve ourselves from the suffering by preserving
- 23:59ourselves from participating and it's lost in both cases, but in
- 24:05one case you have the whole experience of it and it's Lost.
- 24:09And in the other you don't have any experience and it's and the
- 24:13potential of the moment is lost so you can go in and fully
- 24:20engage and really be present and engaged and alive and learn how
- 24:31to lose it. So that you don't cling to it.
- 24:35So you don't suffer from the clinging to it as opposed to
- 24:39just being aversive to the experience of loss.
- 24:42To the point that you withdraw from participating in in that.
- 24:47So I could sort of I brought it said of ironic then that the
- 24:51skills of self-definition and sub-agency and you know secure
- 24:57attachment are really like the counterbalance to this sort of
- 25:04Total deconstruction of Self in the world in total loss of
- 25:09agency due to the fact that there's no self control
- 25:13anything. So it seems like we really need
- 25:15to sort of intervention like a bridge that we can you know be
- 25:19referencing while doing this work, right?
- 25:26It's like someone like someone should teach meditation and
- 25:29attach. Oh, you think You know, you come
- 25:39in and you want to stop suffering.
- 25:44And, you know, one of the principal ways of doing that is
- 25:48to is to begin to reduce stimulus.
- 25:53And you can really reduce it to almost nothing.
- 25:58And so you don't have that experience of connecting and
- 26:02losing, but it shins and used to call it the emptiness of nothing
- 26:11as opposed to The Emptiness of everything.
- 26:15Why not be free rather than having to constantly restrict
- 26:22And narrow and withdraw to be engaging in everything that
- 26:28arises. I often think of relationships
- 26:34as finding good traveling part companions.
- 26:40That you're pursuing your exploration, you're finding
- 26:45things that are meaningful to you, you're exploring and then
- 26:49you have these people you travel with that.
- 26:51You can express and share that with and they're also doing that
- 26:55exploring and searching and finding and then they have you
- 26:59that they can then exchange that, what they've discovered,
- 27:06one of the things you you learn when you teach is that That you
- 27:11have to translate the experiences that you have in the
- 27:15meaning that you find into an expression that other people can
- 27:20understand. And part of that is making sense
- 27:24of it in a way that's different than just being with it without
- 27:29that expression. And so it actually helps you see
- 27:36it in a different way than you might have seen it before.
- 27:39And in bridging that experience, your internal personal
- 27:45experience with someone else and relating it in a way that they
- 27:48can understand and then they respond by relating back to you
- 27:54their experience. It becomes a dance really of of
- 28:04an exchange of perspective, which really in many ways,
- 28:07deepens each person's understanding not only of the
- 28:10other but of themselves in that process.
- 28:16So I think in the west still meditation, particularly Buddha,
- 28:23Buddha Dharma is not so mainstream that everybody is
- 28:27coming. I think that that bell, curve
- 28:30really still applies a little low functioning and people come
- 28:36because they're in suffering and they usually exhausted.
- 28:42The typical Western approaches to relieving that suffering and
- 28:47have not found relief. And then people in the middle
- 28:51who are caught up in the routines of daily life, don't
- 28:56have time or energy to pursue it and because They don't have a
- 28:59strong motivation of suffering to do it.
- 29:02They don't value it enough to participate and then when you
- 29:07get up to the other end, the super functioning end of things,
- 29:11where they easily go after things and get them.
- 29:16And still find a sense of meaninglessness or
- 29:19dissatisfaction in that Pursuit. They come because they're
- 29:24looking for meaning, they're looking for something that would
- 29:28be of lasting value. Having seen that the material
- 29:35aspects and the social position aspects don't provide that One
- 29:43group is hardly resource and the other group is overly resource
- 29:47because of the inequality in equal nature of the way that our
- 29:53society operates. One of the things that's also
- 29:57happening now that's very distressing to most people is
- 30:01that it's it's hard to know what is and isn't true.
- 30:05Because our media has abandoned truth.
- 30:12As its operating principle. This has been a 40-year
- 30:17transition from, you know, in our country, for instance, at
- 30:23one time, the news had to be true.
- 30:28And Reagan change the rules so that it no longer has to be
- 30:31true. And so, You can say anything.
- 30:40And it's reported in the same way as if it's if it is true.
- 30:49Most of us who can mentalize that a you know know know how to
- 30:58characterize it. Most will look in mentalize.
- 31:02Well can see immediately that that most of what this is isn't
- 31:05true. But because there's no
- 31:08alternative to that. There's no reliable source of
- 31:11what might be true. It's very hard to discern.
- 31:15What is and what isn't? But people are don't mentalize.
- 31:20Well, can't. And so they simply accept what
- 31:23isn't true as true and then operate from the place of that.
- 31:29So, for instance, with the pandemic, you would think that
- 31:35600,000 deaths was concerning. In terms of people who have
- 31:42died, and I would guess that that number is fairly fairly
- 31:48substantial underestimation of what's actually happened.
- 31:54And yet, we won't be able to achieve a sort of group immunity
- 32:02a group protection from it. Because there's a contingent of
- 32:08the population that simply thinks it's a hoax.
- 32:11That the 600,000 deaths have not happened that it's a It's a
- 32:19government plot to track you, I mean amongst the other ideas
- 32:27that are about that. What do you do with that?
- 32:36So, That tends to produce a high level of fearfulness and a sense
- 32:44that nothing can be counted on. Nothing can be tracked.
- 32:54Which is not so different than this arising and passing, right?
- 33:06So, if you get into that side of it and you see, everything is
- 33:10arising and passing. Everything is impermanent the
- 33:13sense of self, solidifies around one version, but if you let it
- 33:17go, and it just immediately solidifies around another
- 33:20version comes and goes, but there's a no openness to that
- 33:24and a capacity to track how those responses go.
- 33:29It doesn't Harden around these ideas so much and you have a
- 33:35tendency to be able to operate in a way that's constantly being
- 33:39realigned with the experience of the present moment, rather than
- 33:43fixating rigidly around an idea, that is a delusion and
- 33:50Unsupportable. If you were to continuously,
- 33:53take in information and then of course you form intentions and
- 33:58take actions, which create these karmic threads.
- 34:05I think in the Tera vaada way of thinking, there is no Collective
- 34:09Karma, there's only individual Karma And in some schools of
- 34:16Mahayana, there is the sense of a collective Karma.
- 34:29How do you know what's meaningful to you and have you
- 34:34investigated that? how good of an Explorer are you
- 34:44and have you investigated why the ability to explore that you
- 34:50have is the way that you have it another way to put that as Have
- 34:58you explored your conditioning to see how that affects the way
- 35:04that you assemble this experience of solidness out of
- 35:08this undifferentiated? Unfix ating raw, sensing
- 35:12experience You taking the raw data, it's compared to the
- 35:24database. If there's a close enough match
- 35:27of that undifferentiated unfix, ated sensing data, attaches to
- 35:33meaning and the perception of solid self and World arises
- 35:38conceptual reality arises. And in if each moment you are
- 35:43remaking it. Then in each moment, the those
- 35:49experiences all shift change and you get used to that constant
- 35:56shifting and changing. You acclimatize to the nature of
- 36:03things as they really are. And so that fluidity is
- 36:08constantly happening, if you create an experience of self,
- 36:13and in the next moment, there's contort are contradictory
- 36:16information in the way that you formulated it.
- 36:19You simply drop the formula, the previous moments formation, and
- 36:25reformat it in the next moment, constantly flowing.
- 36:30Constantly changing with no clinging no aversion.
- 36:38It's quite fluid again. But it's different than the
- 36:43belief in solidness. It's their, there's no need to
- 36:48defend that you don't form sense of self, that then feels real,
- 36:54and then can feel attacked and need needs to be defended.
- 36:58It just simply comes and goes and what you notice as you move
- 37:02in, and out of Ultimate Reality, into conceptual reality, out of
- 37:09awareness, into solid self-esteem.
- 37:12And world, there's very little suffering in that.
- 37:17One of the things that was so mind-blowing about this
- 37:20experience, for me, the first time that it happened is, I was
- 37:25stunned by the high level of suffering.
- 37:29That was my ordinary experience attaching to these very limited
- 37:37ideas of myself and the very limited ideas of what the world
- 37:42might offer me and the tremendous pressure cooker of
- 37:46suffering that Rose in response to that and then to Simply step
- 37:51out into awareness, where none of that was there and then to
- 37:57come back in and it all returned And so there was that period of.
- 38:06So I wouldn't even use the word horror of being trapped in the
- 38:11in the confinement of the experience of self and longing
- 38:17for the sense of no self. But then getting stuck on that
- 38:24side and not being able to function as an ordinary
- 38:28householder particularly Christian.
- 38:33Curious, was there something about the duration, or the
- 38:37quality of this, no self experience, that was different
- 38:42than like, I'll have I'll be meditating and I'll get
- 38:46concentrated and it doesn't seem like myself is really there.
- 38:50So, it's like I have these little experiences all the time.
- 38:54I don't really make much of them in this kind of insight way.
- 38:58So what, what do you think? Is there a is there a quality?
- 39:02You can identify that kind of flip the switch for you.
- 39:08I think that I would get trapped in the pressure cooker of self
- 39:12and not be able to get out and it really magnified were
- 39:18heightened, the sense of ordinary suffering and without
- 39:23the contrast between relatively no suffering.
- 39:26And the intensity of the suffering of being trapped in
- 39:29self really was mind-blowing how difficult particular.
- 39:37Formulations of self, could be to, to inhabit.
- 39:43As I got better and better at mu of moving in and out of those
- 39:46experiences. Of course you come into the
- 39:50formulation of a suffering sense of self and you recognize the
- 39:54intensity of it and you simply back out and reformulated
- 39:57without the suffering. And so you don't have that
- 40:00experience, but it's when you don't have any agency and you
- 40:05can get, you know, bam, you're trapped in it and it still
- 40:08happens occasionally and I have people that I talk it can help
- 40:14me come out of it, but It's, you know.
- 40:21So different and that easy flow back and forth between fixation
- 40:26and non fixation. The one area that it still comes
- 40:31up with being certain relationships where trauma
- 40:35bonding is that is activated rather than collaborative,
- 40:39attachment is activated. And then all of a sudden all of
- 40:43the, the that conditioning comes online and the quality of trauma
- 40:50bonding for me is Terror, it's that level of intensity.
- 40:57And if you get stuck there, then you're in this heightened
- 41:01experience of Terror. And then you come out of course,
- 41:06and it vanishes, just like any ordinary experience of arising
- 41:12and passing. So it's it's just the getting
- 41:15stuck. Now that occasionally happens,
- 41:19that so painful. But I also, because this is, you
- 41:25know, the, my practice is fairly long.
- 41:28I recognize that I'm trapped and I can't get myself out, but that
- 41:32it's not real. And that I just need to get
- 41:35somebody to help me and then I can come out.
- 41:39And I don't since I don't believe it, the intention and
- 41:44actions, I take are not informed by the terror, so I'm not
- 41:48creating devastating Karma. Ah, you know, as I like to say
- 41:52I'm not destroying relationships because I'm in so much pain.
- 41:57I'm just looking for the people that can help me and trying to
- 42:00get with them so that that I can be relieved of it.
- 42:05But even though I have that insight and I don't believe it,
- 42:08it doesn't mean I can always get myself out of it which is the
- 42:12the nature of secure collaborative relationships.
- 42:17When you can't do it for yourself, you have around you.
- 42:19The people that can that know how to help you and you just
- 42:22have to go ask them to help you and then they help you.
- 42:26And then when they get stuck in the same way, they just come to
- 42:29you and ask you to help them and then you help them.
- 42:33And that's the, the agreement Jake's.
- 42:38So I just want this was on my mind before we got online today.
- 42:43I thought there's one thing I want to hear George speak about
- 42:46today. It's about Trauma, bonding
- 42:48because some knots, I just wonder if you could share about
- 42:51that and sort of just the feedback.
- 42:53What I just heard from you is though even though you have this
- 42:56capacity of insight to know that all Fabrications are totally
- 43:01impermanent and not selten, what not?
- 43:03But you can still get in this zone of kind of being locked
- 43:08into an agitated State and the remedy for you to get out of
- 43:13that is to have a secure collaborative.
- 43:16Ship, that. That's what helps you out of it.
- 43:18So one was just my affirming, my interest in the topic and to is
- 43:23just feeding back what I just under understood.
- 43:26You say, right? That's correct.
- 43:31So you develop a relationship. You authentically express
- 43:37yourself to the other person, you accept their authentic
- 43:41expression, and then you learn about each other.
- 43:45And the way that you're Shooting operates.
- 43:48And then you learn ways to help other people when they get stuck
- 43:57and then they learn how to help you when you get stuck.
- 43:59And so the trade is, I'm available to you when you need,
- 44:05when you can't get yourself unstuck and you're available to
- 44:08me when I can't get myself unstuck so, so what a trauma
- 44:14bonded situation be like, okay. Presented with some situation,
- 44:19which for some reason, triggers you into a sort of fear State
- 44:23and then the response is, you go to the person that's triggered
- 44:28you and you kind of demand them to help you out.
- 44:31You demand them to sort of. Are you excited us to them?
- 44:35I don't go to the person. I'm trauma bonded with in a
- 44:41moment of activation. Okay.
- 44:45It's very likely that are also triggered and that we are locked
- 44:49in together. Okay, so the last example was
- 44:56the person was no longer the person, the person was my
- 44:59mother. and I was no longer responding to the things that
- 45:04the person did in the present moment as if they were them I
- 45:09was reacting as if they were my mother and it was, you know,
- 45:14Sixty years ago. And even though there was an
- 45:19awareness that that was an actually what was happening?
- 45:23The responses were still unconsciously in that way.
- 45:29So But in order for that, trauma bond to work, it's it's
- 45:38two-sided. They're also engaged in.
- 45:44Then I'm, I am not me. I'm there.
- 45:49I'm going to guess that it's their mother too.
- 45:53So, two guys and were each relating to each other as if we
- 45:57were each other's mothers and in a really unhealthy painful
- 46:08friend of mine as if he's my mother, I don't want to relate
- 46:15to him like he's my brother. I want to relate to him like
- 46:18he's who he is in this moment, right?
- 46:20That's when you come out of it, of course.
- 46:23And you're back into the present moment, your back into the
- 46:26conditions, as they are now, you're not trapped in the
- 46:30unbearable bind of that trauma experience.
- 46:36So then you can actually operate in a way that's useful.
- 46:43It's getting dark in here. Let's turn on some lights.
- 46:49You're going to say so that's always just kind of around the
- 46:53corner for people with certain types of conditioning is that no
- 46:57matter how much your practice program is is there's always
- 47:01this potential that through your engagement in the world.
- 47:05You know, there could be this hairpin trigger without, you
- 47:08know you can be trying to do a business thing or a social thing
- 47:11and then this thing could go off and then you're like sabotage
- 47:15mode and this this, you know, Advanced States Meditation,
- 47:19don't cure that. You need another medicine to be
- 47:22working with that situation. Yeah, that's where the
- 47:26collaborative relationships. Come in the secure collaborative
- 47:30relationships. You know, you just get somebody
- 47:34on the phone and say it's happening again and they know
- 47:39exactly what to do and then they do it and then in 10 or 15 or 20
- 47:46minutes you're out of it and then you can respond in a more
- 47:52skillful way. I mean, do people really support
- 47:55each other on that level? I mean, I'm just so uninformed.
- 47:58Yeah. Why would I don't know?
- 48:04You know, like, I don't know, like it's just it's not just the
- 48:10potential. I can call someone and have this
- 48:13topic be like totally normal like because normally in society
- 48:16trauma and, you know, this sort of suffering is it's it's not
- 48:21something that's in our mainstream dialogue, you know?
- 48:25Well, it's if you if you believe that it's actually happening and
- 48:29it's real and that you have to take action in response, Dance
- 48:33to it, then usually your intention and actions have gone
- 48:36off already and you're down the road of more suffering.
- 48:46But yes, I think that when I talk about A and B relationships
- 48:50where you really are able to express everything, these are
- 48:54these are the things car. You don't have to talk about it.
- 49:00It's not like you have these heavy conversations. you know, I
- 49:10have a friend, I can tell from the quality of his voice where
- 49:13he's at, because I know him well enough and then I can respond
- 49:21automatically without him even requesting anything.
- 49:25Because I can tell the his mind state by his presentation, you
- 49:30want to know the people closest to you that.
- 49:32Well, so that, you know, how to respond.
- 49:36So that when you call them, they can tell by the way that you're
- 49:39presenting the. Hello. what mine State you're in
- 49:44and what they might have to do in order to help you, you know,
- 49:50the people that are closest to your in charge you were charged
- 49:54with their care and you have to provide it when they need it and
- 50:00if they if they even if they don't know they needed but you
- 50:03recognize that that's where they're at you provide that care
- 50:07for them and then they do that for you and so you don't have to
- 50:11have, you know, What I like to call it the talk.
- 50:13We just have to interact. And, and if you can put
- 50:24strategically enough people around you, that have that
- 50:27intimate knowledge of you, you move through life in a way that
- 50:31that has much less suffering. Obviously, when you go for
- 50:37things that you really want, you could get them and we'll lose
- 50:41them, of course, or not get them or get something else.
- 50:44And there's a suffering that can arise in that.
- 50:51But when you really shift into this understanding that this
- 50:57secure base, this this Inner Circle is really what supports
- 51:01you as you move through life. It becomes more valuable than
- 51:05all of the rest of that stuff and actually, in being in that
- 51:11exchange with other people. the meaning is there and so all of
- 51:17the rest of it getting and finding meaning in social
- 51:21position or material or whatever it is, obviously you want to be
- 51:27if you want to have the four basics food clothing, shelter
- 51:31medicine, Did you want to meditate?
- 51:43I want us to do the just don't go on technique.
- 51:54See. because that's the one that really sort of points in the
- 52:06direction of things, not being so solid, Alright, go ahead and
- 52:12take your meditation, postures. So any comments or questions
- 52:30about what we just did? So thank you all for coming.
- 52:36We are doing a series of level 1 classes starting on Saturday,
- 52:42July 10th. So 9 a.m. to 4 p.m.
- 52:46We're going to take us take everybody through the level one.
- 52:51Curriculum in three Saturday's. And then on the fourth Saturday,
- 52:58we're going to do meditation and For collaborative relationships.
- 53:05So starting on the 10th every other Saturday for two months
- 53:08will do Des longs. We have a leopard.
- 53:13A level twos starting in September.
- 53:21The registration is open on the website and the dates are all
- 53:25there if you want to take a look at that.
- 53:28It's recommended that you do the level 1 course before you do the
- 53:31level 2 course but some people don't mind jumping into the deep
- 53:36end of the pool. So if you don't do the level 1,
- 53:39you can come right into the level two.
- 53:43The space is. There are limited.
- 53:47With my schedule, the way it is there.
- 53:49There are only ten spaces for participation in the class with
- 53:53been touring. So we'll leave it more open for
- 54:00people just to attend with how And then we've decided to return
- 54:06to in-person Retreats. And so the we have a retreat in
- 54:11December December 26th until January 1st, in Badger
- 54:17California, at the seven circles Retreat Center, that's limited
- 54:22to 16 spaces. We haven't opened that up, but
- 54:25if that's something that you're interested in, we think that it
- 54:27would probably fill up pretty quickly.
- 54:30Thank you for coming to the, to the class.
- 54:32Gasps I offered on a Donna basis down, is the Pali word for
- 54:37generosity, which means I offer the teaching freely, but I do
- 54:40hope that you'll make a donation to help support me.
- 54:42And also, support the work that met a group is doing.
- 54:46There's a link for a donation on the website.
- 54:50Thank you for coming. I hope to see you soon somewhere
- 54:52on the path. I see you soon.
- 54:55I see you soon.