Latest / Bloomberg Law / Trump Appeals & AI Lawsuits
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: We will keep fighting, and I assure you we didn't
- 0:02Speaker 1: win today, but we will win.
- 0:04Speaker 2: Donald Trump's attorney, Alina Habbat, came out swinging last Friday
- 0:09Speaker 2: after the jury delivered a staggering verdict of eighty three
- 0:12Speaker 2: point three million dollars against the former president in advice
- 0:16Speaker 2: columnist E. Gene Carroll's defamation suit.
- 0:20Speaker 1: We will immediately appeal. We will set aside that ridiculous jury.
- 0:24Speaker 1: And I just want to remind you all of one thing.
- 0:26Speaker 1: I will continue with President Trump to fight for everybody's
- 0:29Speaker 1: First Amendment right to speak.
- 0:31Speaker 2: But in order to appeal the verdict, Trump has to
- 0:33Speaker 2: put up money equal to the judgment with cash or
- 0:36Speaker 2: a bond to maintain the status quo during the appellate process,
- 0:41Speaker 2: and with the probability of yet another verdict this week
- 0:44Speaker 2: in a case where the New York Attorney General is
- 0:47Speaker 2: asking for three hundred seventy million dollars, Trump might have
- 0:51Speaker 2: to put up close to five hundred million dollars in
- 0:54Speaker 2: order to appeal both verdicts. I have made billions of
- 0:58Speaker 2: dollars in business making deals. Of course, Trump has always
- 1:02Speaker 2: bragged about his wealth and under oath. In a deposition
- 1:06Speaker 2: in the New York Attorney General's case. He described his
- 1:09Speaker 2: stockpile of cash as being substantially an excess of four
- 1:13Speaker 2: hundred million dollars. Joining me is Bloomberg legal reporter Eric Larson,
- 1:18Speaker 2: who's covered both Trump trials. So, Eric Donald Trump's lawyer
- 1:22Speaker 2: Alina Habba is floating the idea already of a new
- 1:26Speaker 2: trial in Egene Carroll's defamation suit. What is she saying?
- 1:31Speaker 2: What are her grounds there?
- 1:33Speaker 3: Well, she says that she read in a New York
- 1:35Speaker 3: Post article after the verdict came down that Egen Carroll's
- 1:39Speaker 3: lawyer Roberta. Kaplan and Judge Lewis Kaplan had worked at
- 1:43Speaker 3: the same law firm, Paul Weiss over thirty years ago.
- 1:48Speaker 3: And as the article described, it was a mentor type relationship,
- 1:54Speaker 3: and it quoted an unnamed lawyer there to say this.
- 1:58Speaker 3: And so then Alena Hobba wrote a letter to the
- 2:01Speaker 3: judge raising this article and raising this question and seeking
- 2:05Speaker 3: more information and suggesting that it could be used in
- 2:08Speaker 3: seeking a new trial or on appeal, and you know,
- 2:11Speaker 3: raising questions about this supposed professional relationship.
- 2:16Speaker 2: So what was Roberta Caplan's response? And we should say
- 2:20Speaker 2: that she's no relation to Judge Caplan.
- 2:22Speaker 4: So ROBERTA.
- 2:23Speaker 3: Caplin filed her own letter to the court responding today
- 2:28Speaker 3: saying that this is all hogwash, saying directly to the judge, Yes,
- 2:32Speaker 3: we did overlap for less than two years at Paul Weiss.
- 2:36Speaker 3: He was a senior litigation partner, she was a litigation associate.
- 2:40Speaker 3: She started working there in I think ninety two, and
- 2:44Speaker 3: he left in ninety four to become a judge. So
- 2:47Speaker 3: she said that she doesn't remember working with him on
- 2:49Speaker 3: any case, that there was no close, you know, mentor
- 2:52Speaker 3: type relationship with him. She said that she does recall
- 2:55Speaker 3: specific partners from that period in her life at the
- 2:57Speaker 3: firm that.
- 2:58Speaker 4: She thinks of that way, and he's not one of them.
- 3:01Speaker 3: And she said that this was such a I guess
- 3:03Speaker 3: frivolous argument for Alena Habba to raise in this letter,
- 3:07Speaker 3: you know, and making it public in this way, that
- 3:09Speaker 3: she would consider seeking sanctions and really trying to shut
- 3:14Speaker 3: this down. And I should probably note that just before
- 3:18Speaker 3: we came here to do this recording, Alena Habba filed
- 3:21Speaker 3: another letter responding and basically said especially backed off and said, well,
- 3:27Speaker 3: now that I have this response, this sort of answers
- 3:30Speaker 3: the question I guess this is done.
- 3:32Speaker 4: It's resolved.
- 3:34Speaker 2: So a tempest in a teapot. That's the fastest anything
- 3:37Speaker 2: has been resolved in this trial. I want to get
- 3:41Speaker 2: your take on Hobba's clashes with the judge during the trial,
- 3:46Speaker 2: because they were frequent and often hostile. And what struck
- 3:50Speaker 2: me in particular is that Habba, who's not an experienced
- 3:54Speaker 2: trial attorney, fought about what evidence could be admitted with
- 4:00Speaker 2: this highly respected federal judge who's been on the bench decades,
- 4:05Speaker 2: making these rulings about evidence in everything from terrorist trials
- 4:10Speaker 2: to Sam bangman Fried's trial.
- 4:13Speaker 3: Well, first of all, Judge Kaplan is known for being
- 4:16Speaker 3: pretty no nonsense. He doesn't want to take anything from
- 4:19Speaker 3: any gruffam anyone, and if he makes a decision and
- 4:22Speaker 3: says it's final, he doesn't want anyone going beyond that,
- 4:26Speaker 3: And of course he's very strict about his rules in court.
- 4:28Speaker 3: You know, Trump's campaign spokesman Kevin Chum was kicked out
- 4:32Speaker 3: of the trial when his phone went off. So anyway,
- 4:36Speaker 3: on the last day of trial, before the jury came in,
- 4:39Speaker 3: the judge was having some last minute arguments about the
- 4:43Speaker 3: closing arguments, what they were going to show the jury,
- 4:46Speaker 3: and the defense was upset that a certain slide was
- 4:49Speaker 3: being ordered out of the closing arguments was a compilation
- 4:52Speaker 3: of different tweets that they had made their argument that
- 4:57Speaker 3: Egen Carroll was attacked before Trump issued these defamatory statements.
- 5:00Speaker 3: So anyway, the judge said, no, these aren't properly in evidence.
- 5:03Speaker 3: You're not going to use this. The slide is out,
- 5:05Speaker 3: period done. And she got up and said I have
- 5:08Speaker 3: to say something, and the jet said, no, you won't.
- 5:11Speaker 3: You're very close to me spending some time in the
- 5:13Speaker 3: lock up is how to sit down, and she did
- 5:15Speaker 3: and she did, and she and Trump looked at each
- 5:17Speaker 3: other and they were clearly fuming, and they were not
- 5:20Speaker 3: happy going.
- 5:21Speaker 2: To the verdict. And it's sort of unusual to me
- 5:23Speaker 2: because usually by this time in a case like this,
- 5:26Speaker 2: a high profile case, you hear from one or two
- 5:29Speaker 2: of the jurors. They decide to talk about what they've done.
- 5:32Speaker 2: In this case, they've been as silent as Trump has
- 5:34Speaker 2: been about the verdict. Another astonishing fact. So I guess
- 5:39Speaker 2: they took the judge's advice right.
- 5:41Speaker 3: Well. So this was a rare anonymous jury to begin with,
- 5:44Speaker 3: So because of the risk of essentially Trump supporters threatening
- 5:49Speaker 3: these jurors. The judge said that it would be an
- 5:52Speaker 3: anonymous jury, some sort of the thing you might expect
- 5:55Speaker 3: from like a mafia case or something like that, or
- 5:57Speaker 3: terrorism case.
- 5:58Speaker 4: But of course, during the what are your process and
- 6:00Speaker 4: jury questioning.
- 6:01Speaker 3: They you know, took certain steps to prevent people like
- 6:04Speaker 3: US reporters from being able to piece together who they were.
- 6:07Speaker 3: But after the trial was over, before he dismiss the jury,
- 6:10Speaker 3: he said, you are now free to identify yourselves to
- 6:14Speaker 3: the public. What you can't do is identify each other.
- 6:17Speaker 3: He's like, do not tell anyone about your fellow jurors.
- 6:21Speaker 3: And he's like, and if you.
- 6:22Speaker 4: Want my advice, never ever tell anyone you were involved
- 6:25Speaker 4: in this case.
- 6:26Speaker 2: It's sort of chilling to hear that warning from a
- 6:29Speaker 2: federal judge. Now Trump is going to appeal both of
- 6:33Speaker 2: the eging Carol verdicts. In Carol VERDICTX, so that entails
- 6:37Speaker 2: more than just putting papers into the court. You have
- 6:39Speaker 2: to put up money equal to the judgment amount through
- 6:43Speaker 2: cash or a bond. So what did he do in
- 6:46Speaker 2: regard to the first Carol case where the award was
- 6:49Speaker 2: five million dollars?
- 6:51Speaker 3: He put up five point five million dollars in cash.
- 6:55Speaker 3: So you know, I was told by his lawyer in
- 6:57Speaker 3: that trial, Joe Tacopina, that it was simply a matter
- 7:00Speaker 3: of money. You know, it's cheaper to put up your
- 7:02Speaker 3: own cash than to use a bondsman where you're paying
- 7:05Speaker 3: to use someone else's cash. So Trump obviously is known
- 7:10Speaker 3: to have hundreds of millions of dollars in cash. I
- 7:13Speaker 3: think even the Bloomberg Billionaire's Index own estimation of Trump's
- 7:17Speaker 3: net wealth of three point one billion dollars includes six
- 7:21Speaker 3: hundred million dollars in liquid assets. And as we know,
- 7:24Speaker 3: Trump testified under oath that he has more than four
- 7:27Speaker 3: hundred million dollars in cash. So I would expect him
- 7:31Speaker 3: to put up cash for this appeal.
- 7:34Speaker 2: That is a lot of cash. But you think he
- 7:37Speaker 2: won't put up an appeal bond because he'd lose money
- 7:39Speaker 2: on it.
- 7:40Speaker 3: I mean, I'm just going off of what he did
- 7:42Speaker 3: in the last trial, where he would look at, if
- 7:44Speaker 3: you have the money, why pay to use someone else's money,
- 7:49Speaker 3: Because either way you're going if he loses.
- 7:51Speaker 4: He's going to have to pay that money. So I
- 7:53Speaker 4: guess if I had the money, I would.
- 7:57Speaker 2: He's been fundraising off his legal trump for some time.
- 8:01Speaker 3: My understanding is that he does raise millions of dollars
- 8:04Speaker 3: for his campaign, right this is for money that's not
- 8:08Speaker 3: necessarily being used for his defense. But he has been
- 8:12Speaker 3: using money for legal expenses, because if a candidate can
- 8:15Speaker 3: show that a case is related to something having to
- 8:18Speaker 3: do with his candidacy or his presidency in this case,
- 8:21Speaker 3: as some of these cases do, that he could use
- 8:24Speaker 3: some of that money for legal fees. I don't know
- 8:26Speaker 3: that that would translate into this Egan Carroll case or
- 8:30Speaker 3: even the New York Attorney General civil fraud case. But
- 8:34Speaker 3: he does also have packs these super political action committees.
- 8:37Speaker 3: Those are not supposed to coordinate in any way with
- 8:40Speaker 3: a candidate. Though it's unclear that it's such a gray
- 8:43Speaker 3: area from these experts I talk to. I'm not an
- 8:45Speaker 3: expert on those, but the experts I do talk to
- 8:49Speaker 3: say that it's a real gray area, and that the
- 8:50Speaker 3: Federal Election Commission does not do a lot of enforcement
- 8:55Speaker 3: in this area, and that if anything, they've sort of
- 8:57Speaker 3: chipped away a little bit at enforcements to be so.
- 9:01Speaker 2: Then obviously the damages can't be paid from that. Not
- 9:04Speaker 2: that any of these funds have enough money to cover
- 9:07Speaker 2: these damages.
- 9:08Speaker 3: We know that the Attorney General is seeking three hundred
- 9:11Speaker 3: and seventy million dollars in this civil fraud case, plus interest,
- 9:16Speaker 3: which could put it over four hundred million dollars. Honestly,
- 9:19Speaker 3: and then you add on the Egen Carrol verdicts. It's
- 9:23Speaker 3: a huge amount of money. And even if you were
- 9:26Speaker 3: able to somehow use donated money for that, that's money
- 9:30Speaker 3: that is now being taken away from his effort to
- 9:32Speaker 3: be elected. And also it might be a little bit
- 9:36Speaker 3: more of a difficult cell potentially to donors who are
- 9:42Speaker 3: donating to a campaign a cause. MAGA is a lot
- 9:47Speaker 3: more than Trump's legal troubles, right, It's supposed to.
- 9:51Speaker 2: Some days it doesn't seem like that. But as you mentioned,
- 9:54Speaker 2: the Bloomberg Billionaires Index has him at a networth of
- 9:57Speaker 2: three point one billion, and that's the most and least
- 10:00Speaker 2: leveraged it at any point in the past decade. So
- 10:03Speaker 2: his assets, as you've written about, have been appreciating.
- 10:07Speaker 3: Yeah, I mean, there's no question that he has some
- 10:10Speaker 3: very valuable assets that they've been appreciating, and that he's
- 10:13Speaker 3: a very wealthy man. In fact, that's exactly the argument
- 10:17Speaker 3: that Egan Carroll was making to try to get the
- 10:20Speaker 3: jury to hit him with a significant punitive damages award,
- 10:23Speaker 3: which which it did. So, you know, there's no suggestion
- 10:27Speaker 3: that Trump is going to be going broke here. And
- 10:30Speaker 3: in fact, in the last few years alone, you know,
- 10:34Speaker 3: since this lawsuit was you know, filed, the New York lawsuit,
- 10:38Speaker 3: his assets have gone up almost a half billion dollars.
- 10:43Speaker 3: So he was you know, at a round two point
- 10:46Speaker 3: five point six and now three point one that it
- 10:49Speaker 3: shot up, you know, in the you know, since he
- 10:52Speaker 3: his presidency.
- 10:53Speaker 4: So he's done very well for himself.
- 10:57Speaker 3: And even though the New York state lawsuit qu U
- 11:00Speaker 3: of inflating his assets wildly for years, as much as
- 11:05Speaker 3: three point six billion dollars a year, he actually does
- 11:08Speaker 3: have money regardless of that. But the point of the
- 11:12Speaker 3: New York case is that he was able to get
- 11:15Speaker 3: much lower interest rates on hundreds of millions of dollars
- 11:18Speaker 3: loans for over a decade by saying that he was
- 11:21Speaker 3: at worth way more than he actually was, even if
- 11:23Speaker 3: he did have money.
- 11:24Speaker 2: And we'll be waiting for the judge's decision in the
- 11:27Speaker 2: New York fraud trial, he promised he would try to
- 11:30Speaker 2: get it in by January thirty, first tomorrow. Thanks so much, Eric.
- 11:34Speaker 2: That's Bloomberg legal reporter Eric Larson. Coming up next. The
- 11:38Speaker 2: estate of George Carlin is suing over a comedy special
- 11:42Speaker 2: purporting to be an AI generated impression of the late comedian.
- 11:47Speaker 2: I'm June gross. When you're listening to Bloomberg.
- 11:55Speaker 4: Thank you, thank you.
- 11:56Speaker 5: I like to start off with a heartfelt apology. I'm
- 11:59Speaker 5: sorry it took me so long to come out with
- 12:01Speaker 5: new material.
- 12:02Speaker 2: But I do have a pretty good excuse.
- 12:04Speaker 5: I was dead.
- 12:08Speaker 2: When podcasters Will Sasso and Chad Coulchin released their hour
- 12:13Speaker 2: long comedy special entitled George Carlin I'm Glad I'm Dead,
- 12:18Speaker 2: they billed it as AI generated created by an AI
- 12:22Speaker 2: trained on decades of the late comedians material. So Carlin's
- 12:26Speaker 2: estate sued the duo, citing the right of publicity and
- 12:29Speaker 2: copyright infringement. But now the podcasters are claiming that, in fact,
- 12:35Speaker 2: the special was actually written by a human. One of
- 12:38Speaker 2: the podcasters changing up what's at stake in the lawsuit.
- 12:43Speaker 2: If it sounds confusing, it is, but it's happened before
- 12:47Speaker 2: joining me is Zien Tang, a professor at UCLA Law School.
- 12:51Speaker 2: Let's start with the first iteration of this, which was
- 12:54Speaker 2: supposed to be AI generated. Tell us about that.
- 12:57Speaker 5: So the claim that was at the center of the
- 13:01Speaker 5: complaints was that the comedians Will Sasso and Chad Coulstin
- 13:07Speaker 5: had fed thousands of hours of copyrighted material from the
- 13:14Speaker 5: comedian now deceased, George Carland into an AI model, and
- 13:21Speaker 5: then once that AI model had been trained on all
- 13:25Speaker 5: that Carlan material, it was able to fit out or
- 13:30Speaker 5: generate a entirely new comedy routine based off of Carlin's jokes.
- 13:38Speaker 2: And in the lawsuit by Carlin's estate, they're making two
- 13:41Speaker 2: different claims, one based on copyright and the other on
- 13:45Speaker 2: the illegal use of Carlin's name and likeness.
- 13:49Speaker 5: Well, so it would be a copyright claim in the
- 13:51Speaker 5: sense that there was a lot of copyrighted content that
- 13:56Speaker 5: was fed into the Large Life which model the LM,
- 14:01Speaker 5: which resulted in a copy of the material being made
- 14:05Speaker 5: while the LLM was being trained. So that's one claim,
- 14:09Speaker 5: and then the right of publicity claim is based off
- 14:13Speaker 5: of the replication of the comedian's voice. You know, are
- 14:18Speaker 5: both claims that have been lodged against AI or generative
- 14:23Speaker 5: AI companies for the past year, both on the training data,
- 14:28Speaker 5: with a number of similar lawsuits, many of them class actions,
- 14:33Speaker 5: have been making the same claims with regard to the
- 14:37Speaker 5: training of llms based on copyrighted books, for example, or
- 14:42Speaker 5: copyrighted comedy routines. There's, for example, one currently pending in
- 14:47Speaker 5: federal court filed by the comedian Sarah Silverman, representing herself
- 14:51Speaker 5: in an entire class of plaintiffs. The complaint alleges whose
- 14:55Speaker 5: material have all been copied into the LM and then
- 14:59Speaker 5: on the write a publicity claim. There's been similar allegations
- 15:04Speaker 5: made against ais, such as the Drake Weekend mashup that
- 15:09Speaker 5: went viral a few months ago, in which the AI
- 15:13Speaker 5: basically is trained on a celebrity's voice and then is
- 15:17Speaker 5: able to generate an entirely new work or new song
- 15:22Speaker 5: but using that voice.
- 15:24Speaker 2: Now have any of these lawsuits progressed to the point
- 15:29Speaker 2: where there's been a legal opinion about whether this is
- 15:34Speaker 2: a violation of copyright.
- 15:36Speaker 5: So no, So there have been some courts that have
- 15:41Speaker 5: issued opinions that have basically denied or dismissed certain claims
- 15:46Speaker 5: filed by the plaintiffs, but certainly no opinion issued by
- 15:52Speaker 5: a court that has definitively answered the question of whether
- 15:56Speaker 5: or not the use of copyrighted material as trained data
- 16:00Speaker 5: for the AIS constitutes copyright infringement, or and even if
- 16:05Speaker 5: it is technically copyright infringement in the sense that there
- 16:08Speaker 5: is a copy being made when the material is ingested,
- 16:12Speaker 5: whether that copying is protected by the defense of fair use.
- 16:18Speaker 2: You study this, you teach this. What's your opinion.
- 16:22Speaker 5: I think it's a deeply complicated issue. I certainly think
- 16:25Speaker 5: that there is a line of cases that have preceded
- 16:29Speaker 5: this based on, for example, whether or not it is
- 16:32Speaker 5: fair use or Google to scan massive amounts of copyrighted
- 16:37Speaker 5: books in order to create their Google Books function, which
- 16:42Speaker 5: I think a lot of US use, in which you
- 16:44Speaker 5: can search within books and it'll return snippets of in
- 16:48Speaker 5: many cases copyrighted books, and it's helpful for researchers to
- 16:52Speaker 5: be able to search within books, many of which are
- 16:54Speaker 5: out of print. Now, those prior decisions have held that
- 16:58Speaker 5: such uses are fair even if their technical copyright infringements.
- 17:02Speaker 5: They're still protected by fair use because they are technologically
- 17:06Speaker 5: transformative uses of copyrighted works, because they are using the
- 17:11Speaker 5: copyrighted works for a wholly different purpose. I think in
- 17:14Speaker 5: this case similar arguments could certainly be made, and I
- 17:18Speaker 5: could see certain judges making that determination based on the
- 17:22Speaker 5: transformative nature of what AI does and the fact that
- 17:26Speaker 5: maybe what you would argue is true to the name
- 17:29Speaker 5: training data, the LLM, the large Language Model, is simply
- 17:33Speaker 5: learning from the copyrighted material, not to wholly reproduce the
- 17:39Speaker 5: copyrighted material on the output side, but instead to create
- 17:44Speaker 5: a wholly new, transformative work. I think that argument is
- 17:48Speaker 5: somewhat complicated by recent lawsuits, including one that has been
- 17:52Speaker 5: filed against the New York Times, which alleges that even
- 17:56Speaker 5: on the output side, apparently through the prompt engineering that
- 18:02Speaker 5: the lawyers for the Times did, what they were able
- 18:05Speaker 5: to get the AI to do was to generate entire
- 18:10Speaker 5: news articles that replicated, word for words New York Times
- 18:15Speaker 5: articles that have been published. And so if that's true,
- 18:19Speaker 5: then certainly you would say, well, the work that's generated
- 18:23Speaker 5: by the AI is a direct infringement, and moreover, maybe
- 18:30Speaker 5: even the ingestion of the copyrighted work into the language
- 18:35Speaker 5: model is also an infringement that is not protected by
- 18:39Speaker 5: fair use because it is ingested for the purpose of
- 18:44Speaker 5: directly competing with the plaintiffs the author's income streams because
- 18:49Speaker 5: it is substitutive of the plaintiff's works and is likely
- 18:53Speaker 5: to harm the market for plaintiff's works. And I certainly
- 18:57Speaker 5: think that another argument that plaintiffs might use is that
- 19:00Speaker 5: currently there are active licensing discussions going on between content
- 19:06Speaker 5: holders and AI companies to try to license large amounts
- 19:11Speaker 5: of this material for training data purposes. And if that's true,
- 19:16Speaker 5: a court might say, point in to a long line
- 19:19Speaker 5: of cases, that this is a licensing market that plaintiffs
- 19:24Speaker 5: has typically been able to monetize and are currently monetizing
- 19:28Speaker 5: with these licensing agreements that have been entered into, and
- 19:31Speaker 5: so therefore the unpaid for use of all this copyrighted
- 19:36Speaker 5: material in training data would constitute a harm to the
- 19:42Speaker 5: plaintiff's licensing market, and therefore it's not fair use.
- 19:46Speaker 2: There's a twist to the case because after the lawsuit
- 19:51Speaker 2: was filed, a spokeswoman for the podcasters said this was
- 19:56Speaker 2: not actually created by AI. Quote it's a fiction podcast
- 20:00Speaker 2: created by two human beings, Will Sasso and Chad Culchin.
- 20:06Speaker 2: The YouTube video I'm Glad I'm Dead was completely written
- 20:09Speaker 2: by Chad, so surprise surprise, they're saying it's not AI.
- 20:16Speaker 5: Yes, So if that's true, then of course, if the
- 20:21Speaker 5: material was entirely written by Chad, and if the voice
- 20:27Speaker 5: is just an imitation, then so focusing first on the
- 20:32Speaker 5: on the copyright claims, so then the copyright claim is
- 20:35Speaker 5: gone because you have fully original material that's been written
- 20:39Speaker 5: by the comedian himself. And then on the right of publicity.
- 20:42Speaker 5: The voice imitation the thing that has always complicated this
- 20:46Speaker 5: right of publicity claim. Even if it were an AI
- 20:49Speaker 5: that was actually spitting out towards Carlin's voice and not
- 20:53Speaker 5: some voice imitation, the right of publicity claim was always
- 20:57Speaker 5: complicated by the fact that this is a comedy special
- 21:00Speaker 5: This is an expressive work, and right of publicity claims
- 21:04Speaker 5: typically have found that such expressive works are protected by
- 21:08Speaker 5: the First Amendment. Right publicity is slightly different from copyright,
- 21:12Speaker 5: but both share this idea right that there are certain
- 21:15Speaker 5: uses that are defensible, even if we might consider them
- 21:19Speaker 5: technical uses of a celebrity's image or technically copying of
- 21:23Speaker 5: copyrighted content. So in the right of publicity context, it's
- 21:27Speaker 5: clear that the use of a celebrity's image or the
- 21:30Speaker 5: use of a celebrity's voice in a commercial is a
- 21:33Speaker 5: violation of a celebrities right of publicity. But when we're
- 21:35Speaker 5: talking about something that's an expressive work, like a comedy routine,
- 21:39Speaker 5: for example, then most courts have help. But that is
- 21:42Speaker 5: expression that is protected by the First Amendment, that comedians
- 21:45Speaker 5: should be able to, for example, make them commentary about
- 21:49Speaker 5: celebrities by imitating them, by maybe even exactly reproducing their voice,
- 21:55Speaker 5: by exactly reproducing their image on some type of already
- 22:00Speaker 5: such as a newspaper parody that uses the celebrities image.
- 22:05Speaker 5: So expressive works get really broadly way under a write
- 22:08Speaker 5: of publicity law, and that's why the writer of publicity
- 22:11Speaker 5: claim is always going to be much harder to indicate
- 22:14Speaker 5: than the copyright claim.
- 22:15Speaker 2: So going back to the copyright claim for a moment,
- 22:17Speaker 2: I just want you to explain why you think that
- 22:21Speaker 2: there's not a copyright problem if it was written by
- 22:25Speaker 2: the comedians themselves, and how artists can look to other
- 22:30Speaker 2: artists for inspiration.
- 22:32Speaker 5: Yeah, so copyright law protects the original expression, but it
- 22:37Speaker 5: does not protect ideas. And so that's why artists being
- 22:41Speaker 5: inspired by other artists has existed since the beginning of time. Right,
- 22:45Speaker 5: you take an idea that's in some other work. The
- 22:49Speaker 5: classic example is the rom com or something like that.
- 22:51Speaker 5: There have been so many rom coms that has been made,
- 22:55Speaker 5: but I keep watching them, yes, exactly, and they all
- 22:58Speaker 5: contain the sort of same lying idea about you know,
- 23:02Speaker 5: a starcross relationship that then you know, has a lot
- 23:05Speaker 5: of comedic foibles. Eventually the characters end up at the end.
- 23:08Speaker 1: Right.
- 23:08Speaker 5: That's all unprotectable ideas, and folks are free to build
- 23:12Speaker 5: off of those ideas and generate their own protectable expression. So,
- 23:17Speaker 5: of course, if the claimate issue, assuming that there was
- 23:20Speaker 5: no AI in which it had copied large amounts of
- 23:25Speaker 5: the actual George Carlin copyrighted content, but assuming that the
- 23:30Speaker 5: comediant himself wrote the skits, then even if it's in
- 23:35Speaker 5: the style of or the same manner of joke, so
- 23:38Speaker 5: long as the expression is wholly different, so long as
- 23:42Speaker 5: the comedic routine is not an exact duplication word for
- 23:46Speaker 5: word or very close paraphrasing even of a George Carlin routine,
- 23:52Speaker 5: but instead maybe takes the idea of a George Carlin
- 23:54Speaker 5: joke and expands upon it, takes the style of his
- 23:58Speaker 5: comedic humor and expands upon it. That is all fair
- 24:01Speaker 5: game under a copyright law, and you wouldn't even need
- 24:03Speaker 5: to bring in the fair youth doctrine at all. You
- 24:06Speaker 5: would just say, I'm only taking the unprotectable ideas, I'm
- 24:10Speaker 5: not copying the protectable expression of George Carlin's comedy routine.
- 24:15Speaker 2: Coming up next on the Bloomberg Lawn Show, I'll continue
- 24:18Speaker 2: this conversation with UCLA Law professor Zien Tang. So why
- 24:23Speaker 2: isn't the lawsuit being dropped? Remember, you can always get
- 24:26Speaker 2: the latest legal news by listening to our Bloomberg Law podcast.
- 24:30Speaker 2: You can find them on Apple Podcasts, Spotify and at
- 24:33Speaker 2: Bloomberg dot com, slash podcast Slash Law. I'm June Grosso
- 24:38Speaker 2: and you're listening to Bloomberg. The State of George Carlin
- 24:41Speaker 2: is suing two podcasters over an hour long comedy special
- 24:46Speaker 2: purporting to be an AI generated impression of the late comedian.
- 24:50Speaker 2: Only it turns out the podcasters now say that, in
- 24:53Speaker 2: fact the special was actually written by a human, and
- 24:57Speaker 2: that can make a big difference to the claims the lawsuit.
- 25:01Speaker 2: I've been talking to Professor Zen Tang of UCLA Law School,
- 25:04Speaker 2: so let me ask you this. Then, the lawsuit argues
- 25:08Speaker 2: that the special quote has no comedic or creative value
- 25:12Speaker 2: absent itself proclaimed connection with George Carlin, and it doesn't
- 25:16Speaker 2: satirize him as a performer or offer an independent critique
- 25:21Speaker 2: of society. How does that play into what we've been
- 25:24Speaker 2: talking about.
- 25:25Speaker 5: Yeah, so I think they are trying to preempt the
- 25:29Speaker 5: argument that this is protected by either copyrights fair youth doctrine,
- 25:34Speaker 5: which prioritizes transformative works. And of course, remember this lawsuit
- 25:38Speaker 5: was filed back when they thought there was actual copying,
- 25:42Speaker 5: at least in the training of the AI portion. And
- 25:45Speaker 5: then they're also trying, of course, on the right of
- 25:47Speaker 5: publicity front, to claim that this is not an expressive work,
- 25:50Speaker 5: but it is somehow a work that directly capitalizes on
- 25:54Speaker 5: an income stream that George Carlin would be entitled to.
- 25:57Speaker 5: I think that argument is weak because it's clearly a
- 26:00Speaker 5: comedy special. It's just not an advertisement for right of
- 26:03Speaker 5: publicity purposes, and write publicity law has been very clear
- 26:07Speaker 5: that what it's targeting is advertisements that directly impinge upon
- 26:11Speaker 5: a celebrity's right to monetize their image for purposes of
- 26:15Speaker 5: selling a product. Now, on the copyright front, the lawsuit
- 26:19Speaker 5: was filed with the understanding that the AI had ingested
- 26:23Speaker 5: all these large amounts of copyrighted content. So if that's true,
- 26:27Speaker 5: then the complaint was trying to preempt the argument that
- 26:31Speaker 5: the ingestion of all that copyrighted material was solely to
- 26:35Speaker 5: just learn from it for purposes of generating a wholly new,
- 26:40Speaker 5: transformative work that is a parody of George Carlin's comedy routines,
- 26:47Speaker 5: and in fair use doctrine, courts have always privileged these
- 26:50Speaker 5: more transformative work that take the underlying copyrighted work and
- 26:56Speaker 5: do something different with it. Parody is the copyrighted work.
- 27:00Speaker 5: It targets the copyrighted work to make a commentary about
- 27:03Speaker 5: the copyrighted work. A recent Supreme Court case that was
- 27:05Speaker 5: decided last year involving the artist Andy Warhol, had said,
- 27:12Speaker 5: did Warhol intend to comment upon this photograph that he
- 27:17Speaker 5: appropriated and took and created into a self screen? The
- 27:21Speaker 5: Supreme Court had said, no, he didn't intend to comment
- 27:24Speaker 5: on it. He didn't intend to parody it, so therefore
- 27:27Speaker 5: it's not fair use. So I think some of the
- 27:29Speaker 5: language in that complaint is trying to get at the
- 27:32Speaker 5: same issues that the Supreme Court was grappling with which
- 27:35Speaker 5: is when they thought that the comedians had actually copied
- 27:39Speaker 5: towards Carlin's work to create this new work. They wanted
- 27:44Speaker 5: to say, you know what, but the new work isn't transformative.
- 27:46Speaker 5: It's not commenting upon Carlin's works, it's not satirizing it.
- 27:51Speaker 5: It has no transformative purpose. But of course now that
- 27:55Speaker 5: they are claiming that this is wholly original content, then
- 27:59Speaker 5: we're in a very different games because according to them,
- 28:03Speaker 5: there was not even copying of any George Carlin copyrighted
- 28:08Speaker 5: works because there was no AI that was ingesting large
- 28:12Speaker 5: amounts of copyrighted content.
- 28:14Speaker 2: People may wonder why say it was created by AI,
- 28:17Speaker 2: And it's not the first time that companies have been
- 28:20Speaker 2: exposed or people have been exposed for masquerading as AI.
- 28:26Speaker 2: Because of the the hype about AI. There was supposedly
- 28:29Speaker 2: an AI drive through company, Presto Automation, that touted its
- 28:34Speaker 2: automated ordering technology, and filings indicate that it's actually human
- 28:40Speaker 2: beings who are powering a majority of the orders. So
- 28:43Speaker 2: it's an attempt, I guess, to get a hold of
- 28:46Speaker 2: the moment where people are fascinated or repulsed by AI.
- 28:52Speaker 5: Yes, I think it's certainly trying to as you say,
- 28:56Speaker 5: that's one example. The Great Weekend example, which apparently was
- 29:00Speaker 5: actually created by AI is another one. And I think
- 29:04Speaker 5: it's just trying to generate publicity for the stunt, and
- 29:11Speaker 5: you know, shock people, and it's always a was this
- 29:15Speaker 5: actually created by AI? Oh, We're going to actually do
- 29:17Speaker 5: a grand reveal a few days later and say we
- 29:20Speaker 5: tricked you. You thought this was AI actually a human
- 29:22Speaker 5: being created or vice versa. Of course I could see
- 29:25Speaker 5: stunt saying, oh, this was a human being that wrote this,
- 29:28Speaker 5: and then maybe the stunt becomes later that it was
- 29:30Speaker 5: generated by AI. Perhaps the podcasters didn't think that the
- 29:37Speaker 5: Carlin estate would immediately respond with a lawsuit, right, not
- 29:41Speaker 5: all these types of uses end up in court, and
- 29:45Speaker 5: so maybe the filing of the lawsuit kind of jolted
- 29:49Speaker 5: them into realizing that the Carlin estate was serious about
- 29:54Speaker 5: protecting his voice and his copyrighted material. Because certainly, I
- 29:58Speaker 5: think some other artists have been a little bit more
- 30:01Speaker 5: welcoming of the experiments around AI, or at least they
- 30:06Speaker 5: might have reached out to the producers first and said, hey,
- 30:10Speaker 5: you know, can you tell us more about this? This
- 30:13Speaker 5: wasn't authorized. We're a little upset about this, in which
- 30:16Speaker 5: case maybe the comedians would have gotten an opportunity to
- 30:19Speaker 5: explain themselves and explain that it was a big joke.
- 30:23Speaker 5: But of course the Carlon estate actually immediately proceeded to
- 30:27Speaker 5: a lawsuit, and I think that probably caused the comedians
- 30:31Speaker 5: to come clean.
- 30:32Speaker 2: A lawyer for Carlin's estate says, the lawsuit is going
- 30:36Speaker 2: ahead despite this new claim by the defendants. Quote, we
- 30:40Speaker 2: don't know what they're saying to be true. What we
- 30:43Speaker 2: will know is that they'll be deposed, they'll produce documents,
- 30:46Speaker 2: and there'll be evidence that shows, one way or another
- 30:49Speaker 2: how the show was created. So we'll speed ahead.
- 30:55Speaker 5: Yeah, I mean, and you know, of course lawyers say
- 30:58Speaker 5: these things. This stunt generated a lot of publicity. It's
- 31:02Speaker 5: unclear how much money was actually generated from this. And
- 31:07Speaker 5: if it still comes out that even if some amount
- 31:10Speaker 5: of evidence is willingly produced that shows that there was
- 31:13Speaker 5: actually no copyrighted works that were ingusted into any kind
- 31:18Speaker 5: of LLM, then the potential damages that the plaintiff can
- 31:24Speaker 5: receive just basically evaporate. So in that case, the parties
- 31:30Speaker 5: will probably settle, or the plaintiff will voluntarily dismiss the lawsuit.
- 31:35Speaker 5: To bring a lawsuit like this all the way to
- 31:38Speaker 5: the trial or fact finding stage, where there are depositions
- 31:42Speaker 5: and there's discovery, is an incredibly costly endeavor, And if
- 31:47Speaker 5: what the comedians are saying is true, it would behoove
- 31:50Speaker 5: them to or would do them well to immediately try
- 31:55Speaker 5: to ward off that expensive fact finding by producing some
- 31:59Speaker 5: amount of evidence to show that, in fact, there was
- 32:02Speaker 5: no AI training involved. And certainly I think that's been
- 32:06Speaker 5: the complaint against a lot of this training data that's
- 32:09Speaker 5: been fed into the LMS is the very opacity of
- 32:13Speaker 5: the system, and that it's never clear. Then the plaintiff
- 32:17Speaker 5: has no visibility into what the defendant is doing, what
- 32:21Speaker 5: their process was, what materials were actually fed into the LM.
- 32:26Speaker 5: This is true not just of the comedians, but of
- 32:28Speaker 5: course of large companies like open Ai. How are you
- 32:32Speaker 5: to figure out what open Ai was training their LLLMS on.
- 32:36Speaker 5: It's all proprietary. That's been always one of the big
- 32:40Speaker 5: complaints from the plaintiffs, and so in those cases you
- 32:43Speaker 5: want discovery to force the company to produce evidence. But
- 32:47Speaker 5: in this case, these are two individual comedians, you know,
- 32:50Speaker 5: I think the amount of money at stake is vanishingly
- 32:53Speaker 5: small if they are able to produce some evidence that, yeah,
- 32:59Speaker 5: that this material was wholly written, original written content.
- 33:05Speaker 2: One AI lawsuit down. Who knows how many more to come?
- 33:08Speaker 2: Thanks so much for being on the show. That's Zen
- 33:11Speaker 2: Tang of UCLA Law School. In other legal news today,
- 33:15Speaker 2: a Delaware judge has struck down Elon Musk's fifty five
- 33:19Speaker 2: billion dollar pay package at Tesla. The decision means that,
- 33:23Speaker 2: more than five years after Musk was granted the largest
- 33:27Speaker 2: executive compensation plan in history, Tesla's board will have to
- 33:31Speaker 2: start over and come up with a new proposal. Following
- 33:34Speaker 2: a trial that started more than a year ago, Delaware
- 33:37Speaker 2: Chance Rey Court Chief Judge Kathleen McCormick sided with an
- 33:41Speaker 2: investor who complained that the twenty eighteen package didn't have
- 33:45Speaker 2: proper disclosures about the performance benchmarks required of Musk and
- 33:50Speaker 2: that the board had conflicts of interest in approving it.
- 33:53Speaker 2: The judge wrote in the final analysis, Musk launched a
- 33:57Speaker 2: self driving process red calibrating the speed and direction along
- 34:02Speaker 2: the way as he saw fit. The process arrived at
- 34:05Speaker 2: an unfair price, and through this litigation, the plaintiff requests
- 34:10Speaker 2: a recall. The ruling leaves the future of Musk's fortune
- 34:14Speaker 2: in Limbo worth some fifty one point one billion dollars.
- 34:19Speaker 2: The options were one of his most valuable assets. Without them,
- 34:23Speaker 2: his net worth would drop to one hundred and fifty
- 34:25Speaker 2: four point three billion, making him the third richest person
- 34:29Speaker 2: in the world, after spending most of the past couple
- 34:32Speaker 2: of years at number one, according to the Bloomberg Billionaire's Index.
- 34:37Speaker 2: It's the second legal loss for the billionaire in court.
- 34:40Speaker 2: In May, he failed to persuade an appeals court to
- 34:43Speaker 2: release him from a twenty eighteen agreement with the US
- 34:46Speaker 2: Securities and Exchange Commission that his Twitter posts about Tesla
- 34:50Speaker 2: be screened. And that's it for this edition of the
- 34:52Speaker 2: Bloomberg Lawn Show. Remember you can always get the latest
- 34:55Speaker 2: legal news by listening to our Bloomberg Lawn podcast. You
- 34:59Speaker 2: can find them on Apple Podcasts, Spotify and at www
- 35:03Speaker 2: dot Bloomberg dot com, Slash Podcasts, Slash Law, and Attorneys
- 35:08Speaker 2: and attorneys looking for legal research. Whether you're an in
- 35:11Speaker 2: house council or in private practice, Bloomberg Law gives you
- 35:15Speaker 2: the edge with the latest in AI powered legal analytics,
- 35:19Speaker 2: business insights, and workflow tools. With guidance from our experts,
- 35:24Speaker 2: you'll grasp the latest trends in the legal industry, helping
- 35:27Speaker 2: you achieve better results for the practice of law, the
- 35:30Speaker 2: business of law, the future of law. Visit Bloomberg law
- 35:33Speaker 2: dot com. I'm June Grasso. Stay with us. Today's top
- 35:37Speaker 2: stories and global business headlines are coming up right now.