Latest / Against the Odds: Real People Who Refused to Give Up / The Courage to Be Bad at Something New | Against the Odds
Transcript
- There is a specific kind of shame that lives in the back of your throat when you realize you are terrible at something you’ve always loved. It tastes like copper and feels like you’re being found out. I want you to picture a scene with me. It’s Tuesday evening. The kitchen is quiet, except for the hum of the refrigerator and the frantic sizzle of butter hitting a hot pan. You are standing over a cutting board, knife in hand, trying to julienne carrots. And they aren’t julienned. They are chunks. Jagged, uneven, suspicious lumps that look less like a garnish and more like a crime scene. You sigh. You throw them into the pot. You stir. You eat. It’s edible, technically. But as you chew, there’s this tiny, sharp voice in your head saying, "You used to be good at this. Or at least, you were okay at it. Now? Now you’re just... pretending." We have all been there. Maybe it wasn’t cooking. Maybe it was painting, or coding, or learning to play the ukulele for your niece’s birthday. Maybe it was trying to knit a scarf and ending up with a tangled mess that looks like a nest for a very confused bird. That feeling—that sudden, humiliating drop into beginnerhood—is heavy. It feels like we’ve lost a part of ourselves that we thought was permanent. Like our competence was an identity we wore well, and now the fabric has worn thin, and we’re exposed. Let’s sit with that for a second. Why does starting over feel like failure? I think it’s because we live in a culture that worships mastery. We scroll through social media and see the finished product: the perfect sourdough loaf, the flawless watercolor, the ten-minute mile. We don’t see the first hundred attempts where the bread looked like a brick, the watercolor looked like mud, and the mile felt like torture. We are taught that if you are good at something, you stay good at it. If you stop practicing piano for five years, you lose the skill. If you take a break from running, you get slower. This is true, biologically speaking. Skills fade without use. But here is what the narrative leaves out: it implies that losing a skill is a moral failing. It suggests that you should be ashamed for not maintaining peak performance in every area of your life. But you are not a machine. You are a human being who changes, who ages, who shifts priorities, who gets tired. When you pick up a new hobby—or return to an old one—you are not signing up for instant excellence. You are signing up for the messy, awkward, frustrating process of relearning. And that requires a bravery that we rarely celebrate. Our egos love competence. Competence is safe. Competence means we know what to do next. Competence means people praise us. Competence means we are valuable. When we are beginners again, that safety vanishes. We don’t know the rules. We don’t know the shortcuts. We make mistakes that would embarrass a child. And so, we resist. We tell ourselves, "I’m too old for this," or "It’s not worth the time," or "Maybe I’ll just watch someone else do it instead." We protect our self-esteem by staying on the sidelines. But here’s the truth: that protection comes at a cost. The cost is stagnation. The cost is the slow death of curiosity. I remember a friend of mine, Sarah, who stopped painting in her twenties because she felt she wasn’t "talented" enough compared to her peers. She spent decades telling herself she’d never paint again. Then, last year, at forty-five, she bought a cheap set of acrylics and sat on her porch. She made a mess. She painted a tree that looked like a green finger. She laughed until she cried. Not because the painting was good, but because she remembered what it felt like to create without judgment. She reclaimed a part of herself that had been dormant. She didn’t do it to become a master artist. She did it to remember how to play. There is a concept in Zen Buddhism called Shoshin, or "Beginner’s Mind." It refers to having an attitude of openness, eagerness, and lack of preconceptions when studying a subject. As beginners, we are free from the baggage of expertise. We ask questions. We notice details experts might overlook. We are humble. We are curious. There is a profound freedom in being bad at something. When you are bad at something, no one expects anything from you. No one is watching. You are invisible in your struggle. And in that invisibility, you can experiment. You can fail without consequence. You can discover what you actually enjoy about the process, separate from the outcome. Do you like the smell of turpentine? Do you like the rhythm of chopping vegetables? Do you like the way your fingers feel on the keyboard? These small sensory joys are often buried under the pressure to perform. When we allow ourselves to be beginners, we strip away the performance. We return to the pure act of doing. It’s playful. It’s light. It’s a rebellion against the idea that everything we do must have a purpose or a profit. So, how do we invite this bravery back into our lives? How do we give ourselves permission to be terrible? First, lower the stakes. Give yourself permission to produce garbage. Tell yourself, "I am going to make a really ugly painting today." Say it out loud. When you remove the expectation of quality, the anxiety dissolves. Second, choose activities that have no audience. Don’t post your knitting on Instagram. Don’t show your journal entries to your friends. Keep your beginnerhood private. Let it be your secret playground. Third, focus on the ritual, not the result. Set a timer for fifteen minutes. Just show up. Show up even when you want to quit. Show up even when you feel stupid. Consistency builds confidence, but only after you’ve survived the initial discomfort. It wasn’t pretty, but it was progress. Every time you choose to try despite the fear of looking foolish, you are rewiring your brain. You are teaching yourself that your worth is not tied to your proficiency. You are building resilience. You are proving to yourself that you can handle uncertainty. And that is a superpower. I want to remind you of that episode we talked about recently, "Gratitude in the Ruins." We discussed how gratitude isn’t about ignoring pain or forcing happiness. It’s about finding anchors in the storm. Being a beginner is a storm. It’s chaotic and disorienting. But within that chaos, there are anchors. Maybe it’s the satisfaction of finally tying a knot correctly. Maybe it’s the moment your body remembers a dance move you haven’t done in years. These micro-moments of connection are gifts. They remind us that we are still growing. Still changing. Still capable of wonder. Don’t underestimate the power of small rebellions. Choosing to learn something new when you’re tired, when you’re busy, when you feel inadequate—it’s a radical act. It says, "I am still here. I am still interested in the world. I am not done yet." And that matters. It matters deeply. So, go ahead. Buy the sketchbook. Download the language app. Sign up for the class. Make the mess. Embrace the ugliness. It’s not a sign of weakness; it’s a sign of life. You didn’t just survive this week; you outlasted it. And tomorrow, you get to try again. Be gentle with yourself. I’ll see you next time.