Latest / Inside Commerce: Ecommerce Strategy, CX and Technology Podcast / EP307: What Does Good Web Design For Ecommerce Actually Mean? An Objective View On Balancing Brand vs. Commerce
Transcript
- 0:00Our direction for me is more about the emotions of design.
- 0:03It's about how should someone feel when looking at it?
- 0:06What, what are the, what are the, all those emotional states
- 0:09that you're trying to convey to people and they're how visually
- 0:13do you execute on that to create those emotional states?
- 0:16It's, it's not something that's innate in me, that level of
- 0:19thinking. I think it is a bit more
- 0:20abstract initially and it is. It's got elements of psychology.
- 0:24You listen to Inside Commerce, a weekly ecom strategy, technology
- 0:27and CX focus podcast hosted by experienced digital consultants
- 0:30and RE platform specialist James Get and Paul Rogers.
- 0:32Get insights into ecom strategy, leading brands, hear from
- 0:35industry thought leaders and leading tech vendors with
- 0:37practical advice to help you improve your online CX.
- 0:43This episode is sponsored by Shopify.
- 0:45Today it's just Paul and myself. So we don't need to do any
- 0:48introductions and we are drilling down into what does
- 0:51good web design for e-commerce like.
- 0:53And the, and the reason for this is, yeah, a lot of you listening
- 0:56myself and Paul, we're we're involved in lots of different
- 0:59projects, whether it is re platform in which design is a
- 1:02fundamental part or it's a brand relaunch or a refresh of an
- 1:06existing site. And design is a fundamental
- 1:09element of everything from branding to functional elements.
- 1:13And design can be approached very structurally or objectively
- 1:17or approached very subjectively. And what we want to pull up on
- 1:20is how do you define good design and then look at some examples.
- 1:24So doing something a little bit different for those of you
- 1:26watching on the video, we're doing screen share and we're
- 1:28going to talk through a few sites as we go through and help
- 1:32provide a little bit of context for that.
- 1:34So let's start with both our definitions, right?
- 1:36So what let's start with you, Paul, if somebody says to you in
- 1:41a room, new client, what is a good, what does good web design
- 1:44mean? How would you articulate it?
- 1:46So I think so I've got quite a strong views on this and even
- 1:51your LinkedIn post I thought would kind of trigger some of
- 1:54those views. So I think and one, there's no
- 1:57such thing as good design. I think 2, I think a lot of
- 2:02people look at a good design as a highly usable, quick to
- 2:07convert a very simple intuitive experience.
- 2:13And I completely agree that's important, but I think it's a
- 2:16lot of what I think makes a good design project is how you kind
- 2:21of optimise towards your traffic.
- 2:23So I think if you're a multi brand site or you know, for
- 2:27whatever reason, all of the demand or the traffic coming to
- 2:30the site is kind of bottom of funnel and they're looking to
- 2:32check out as quickly as possible, I think great.
- 2:35Whereas I think if you're a brand and you know, your mandate
- 2:40is to, you know, create brand awareness, Dr. top of funnel
- 2:44awareness and ultimately appeal to like net new low intent
- 2:49audiences. I personally think it's you need
- 2:53to be thinking more about how you present in the brand, you
- 2:56know, photography, art direction, like content in
- 3:00general. And I think one of the big
- 3:02things that we've been focused on a lot of our clients over the
- 3:05last few months ago into next year is more about that.
- 3:08And it's like there's two sides to it.
- 3:10There's global design and yeah, I guess how you, if you've got
- 3:15one approach, how you design for both of those audiences.
- 3:20The other side to it is then personalization of segmentation
- 3:23and where that falls into this. And like you have your net new
- 3:26use of landing pages and then you maybe start to adapt the PDP
- 3:29so that you've got the bottom of funnel usable hyper, you know,
- 3:34fast, you know, primarily focusing on the information
- 3:37around the transaction versus the kind of prioritizing some of
- 3:42the content that's going to better elevate the brand or the
- 3:45product, etcetera. So you got that.
- 3:48And then I think the only other thing, so I'm really going on
- 3:52here because I think you asked me quite a simple question, but
- 3:55I think the only other thing that's really interesting around
- 3:57this area that I think I often have a lot of friction with.
- 4:01And we also now kind of have CRO and I've historically really had
- 4:05like strong views against a lot of the CRO stuff because I think
- 4:10quite often the KP is are an issue.
- 4:12So you're kind of like you're investing all this money and all
- 4:15that. You in my opinion, you should be
- 4:17investing all this money in design and everything else.
- 4:19And then the only KPI you're looking at is conversion rate at
- 4:22which ultimately comes down to your traffic Max.
- 4:25And you know, if 70% of your traffic's bottom of funnel,
- 4:28you're going to have a great conversion rate, whereas you
- 4:30know, a higher proportion of traffic is top of funnel.
- 4:33Like you kind of need to be looking at almost non
- 4:36transactional metrics. And obviously you kind of want
- 4:38everything to come back to revenue.
- 4:40But but yeah, I think it's, I think we can talk about all of
- 4:42this. But yeah, very interesting topic
- 4:45that's quite close to my heart. What what I love is you started
- 4:48by saying there is no such thing as good website and then
- 4:51continue to explain what good web design was.
- 4:53So you've done well as a start. It differs there, doesn't it?
- 4:56The other thing is the type of customer, the type of product.
- 4:59And this is what I'm trying to get us towards is I personally
- 5:02do believe there's a such thing as good web design, but it's not
- 5:05uniform because this is the whole point is the the brand and
- 5:10therefore the art direction, the customers and therefore the
- 5:14customer needs and what customers respond to.
- 5:17And that is across visual aesthetics, across tonality,
- 5:20style of content, length of content over.
- 5:24And you're right at different parts of the site as well.
- 5:26Some some parts of the site are purely about education and
- 5:31information like category landing pages is a great example
- 5:33of that where you get a lot of people coming in, they're not
- 5:36down in the bottom of the funnel yet.
- 5:37They haven't got to understand in which part of the category
- 5:40they really need to shop through or what price point or what
- 5:43brand within a multi brand. Whereas on APDP, you know full
- 5:47well that there is a much stronger purchase intent.
- 5:50Therefore it's functionally more, it's functionally clear
- 5:54about what you need to do. But equally, some people can
- 5:56come into APDP who don't know the brand and therefore you need
- 6:00some additional content coming back to your personalization
- 6:02thing. So I, I think there are some
- 6:04principles we can follow. What I found interesting, a
- 6:07couple of people I think is Andy Jackson from Studio Rotate who
- 6:10shared on my post about he's saying that he always goes back
- 6:13to Dieter Ram's definition as a benchmark, which is good design,
- 6:17is innovative, makes a product useful, it's aesthetic, makes a
- 6:21product understandable, unobtrusive, honest, long
- 6:23lasting, down to the last detail, environmentally friendly
- 6:28and it's as little design as possible.
- 6:29And I think those are really good benchmarks.
- 6:30And we're going to touch on some of those because some of that is
- 6:33visual, some of that is functional, and some of that is,
- 6:36is, is I guess systemic and and operational.
- 6:42So let's move on and let's talk about because breakdown design,
- 6:48in order to execute good design, you've got to go through a
- 6:50design discovery process, which could be a matter of weeks.
- 6:53It could be a math. I mean, sometimes it's really
- 6:55long. It's over a month's period of
- 6:57intense amounts of research data in customer insight gathering.
- 7:01Let's not we don't want to spend an hour talking to people
- 7:03because people fall asleep. But what are the?
- 7:06What are the techniques and principles that in your
- 7:09experience, make a design discovery process effective?
- 7:12So I think this is really interesting because I think
- 7:15obviously we talk a lot about change management and I think a
- 7:19big part of design discovery for me is like is people and it's
- 7:22managing opinions and it's kind of prioritising and it's kind of
- 7:28balancing inputs. So I think you've got Oka on
- 7:31this list, which is a client we worked with.
- 7:33And I think one of the challenges that we had going
- 7:37into that project where a redesign, you know, was one of
- 7:40the big drivers for the business case was that there was quite a
- 7:44lot of different types of stakeholders with kind of strong
- 7:48views. And essentially the product team
- 7:51wanted to deliver a re platforming project, but elevate
- 7:53the brand. Whereas, you know, the kind of
- 7:57marketing and brand that's were way more focused on like bigger
- 8:01conversations, I guess. So there's kind of like a bit of
- 8:04push and pull. So in that scenario, I think the
- 8:07design discovery part of it was, you know, trying to collect the
- 8:13right inputs early from those kind of brand and marketing
- 8:19stakeholders. So understanding like, you know,
- 8:22from a marketing brand feel, you know, like like you say, kind of
- 8:28tone out all of that, just collecting all of that and then
- 8:32basically trying to also build the foundations for like the
- 8:36functional kind of overall UX And you know, some complex
- 8:40journeys in here, like the kind of modular sofas, few other
- 8:44areas, kind of cushion bundling, all of that kind of stuff.
- 8:48So we kind of got those two things.
- 8:49And then it was a case of trying to basically take all that,
- 8:53condense it down along with kind of our inputs and then almost
- 8:57like present back to the Group A view and kind of basically a
- 9:04view of like the priorities, the most important things to get
- 9:08across by template and by customer segment, kind of how we
- 9:13could best use the content. And we essentially ended up with
- 9:15like a spec with like agreed examples per area.
- 9:22And then we'd almost kind of built a vision of like all of
- 9:26the the experience and to be. And then we went out to the
- 9:30agency, which was bow and they then fleshed it out based on
- 9:34like pretty detailed spec. But to be honest, the reason why
- 9:37I think this is interesting is because I don't think that's
- 9:39always necessary. I think that is more about the
- 9:42people that are involved in the project and how you manage the
- 9:45politics or different stakeholders or different goals.
- 9:49So it is a semi political thing, but I think it ended up being a
- 9:52really nice process. But I think, you know, this is a
- 9:56really, and I do think we could on about this for hours because
- 9:58I think there's probably certain brands where the best design
- 10:01discovery is just a very, very creative person.
- 10:04Just like doing things with very little process and
- 10:07documentation, being super creative and just taking like
- 10:10fundamental parts of the site or fundamental parts of the brand
- 10:13and just like being really creative.
- 10:15And then there's others like the project you're working on a
- 10:18minute, which is similar to OCA, whereas a bit more complexity
- 10:22around like the journeys. And I think I say is this is a
- 10:24really difficult one. There is essentially no I almost
- 10:27right, there's no right answer. You've just got and I think
- 10:30you're obviously you're, I think you're, you've got a lot of
- 10:33background in de risking change and all of this.
- 10:37I think you've got the governance angle to it as well.
- 10:41What do Mattel, Victoria, Beckham, Sennheiser and Glossier
- 10:46all have in common? They power their businesses
- 10:49with. Shopify Shopify is the most
- 10:52innovative and scaled commerce platform on the planet.
- 10:57It also happens to have the best converting check out on the
- 11:00planet Shopify Powering the future of enterprise commerce.
- 11:06Find out more at Shopify dot. Com slash enterprise.
- 11:09You mean I'm the dole person to your creative mastermind, is
- 11:13what you're trying to say. I definitely know I'm the
- 11:15creative now. I think they, yeah, I think it's
- 11:18more that you probably bring more structure and I think you
- 11:21probably bring an angle that I'm not as.
- 11:25I don't, I think in, I think in create in the, in the creative
- 11:28and design discovery part of an overall discovery project, you
- 11:32have to have a bit of unstructured thinking in there
- 11:35as well. You, you cannot structure every
- 11:38part creativity otherwise it's not creative.
- 11:40But you need to have a structure to the process to know what your
- 11:43outputs are and how you get there in a succinct manner.
- 11:46Because the problem is, I guess without any milestones, you end
- 11:51up going off on tangents. And I think So what you've
- 11:53touched on for me makes perfect sense is there are a lot of
- 11:56abstracts you start off with. And the the critical bit for me
- 12:00is answering the question of when someone says we want to be
- 12:02innovative or we want to elevate the brand is I want to know what
- 12:07that means. What what does elevate mean?
- 12:10Is it just about the site feels flat and non interactive and
- 12:13there's poor transitions and it just feels like a catalog site.
- 12:16And we actually are a yeah, we are an inspirational and design
- 12:20their business. And therefore that's what the
- 12:22look of it is. Or is it that, do you know what
- 12:24walk into our store and you feel the experience and you feel the
- 12:27design and the the creativity in the store.
- 12:30And walking through the store feels like a journey.
- 12:32Whereas on site it feels like a functional product selling
- 12:35mechanism. And that's what we want to
- 12:37change. I think we you have to lock it
- 12:38down to something specific and tangible.
- 12:41And then on the back of that, coming back to your point, you
- 12:44go show us your top 4-5 sites that achieve this and how do
- 12:49you, and in your, from your experience, how are they
- 12:51achieving it? I think once you've got those,
- 12:53you take the abstract team, turn it to something tangible.
- 12:56I think then you're in a stronger place.
- 12:58Yeah, I think what I think something is quite interesting
- 13:01about this episode so far. I think we recorded this three
- 13:04years ago. We would have focused almost
- 13:07entirely on usability UX like kind of how the fundament like
- 13:13I've, I feel like now there is like almost like a default
- 13:17approach to PLPPDP and check out and there's like, almost like a
- 13:21core template that is applied as like a default.
- 13:26And I think that I, I think that now what we're talking about is
- 13:31actually where historic care. I think we would have been like
- 13:34both of us probably would have played the role of like
- 13:36governing the UX and usability side, making sure that, you
- 13:41know, the site is performant. Whereas now I think with,
- 13:44because it's, I guess more competitive, you know, because
- 13:47of the way marketing's gone as well, it feels like we're both
- 13:50actually kind of advocating. So you're on the JW Anderson
- 13:54site now, which is new. I think probably 75% of the
- 13:57industry would absolutely RIP this to shreds.
- 13:59I love it. And I think it really like
- 14:02resonates with their customer and their brand.
- 14:05But I think it's just interesting that we're doing
- 14:08this episode. And I reckon if you went back to
- 14:09the start of even when we started the podcast, yeah, we
- 14:12probably would have come at this from a different angle.
- 14:14What? I think the industry's changed a
- 14:15bit now and you kind of have to stand out and you have to be
- 14:19thinking more about Yeah brand than you might have done
- 14:23historically. Yeah, I I agree.
- 14:27And I think this comes back to the wider industry understanding
- 14:30that that in econ we focused too much on middle to bottom of
- 14:34funnel and conversion and less on the top of funnel.
- 14:37And actually, unless you are a somebody who's just selling
- 14:42commoditized items where it is just a, a transactional, some
- 14:46people are going to buy and they're going to buy normally on
- 14:48the face, it's got the best price at the time they want to
- 14:50buy and can deliver it when they want to deliver it.
- 14:52If you're a brand and you're building an audience and you're
- 14:55building customer loyalty and unlike ongoing, you know, repeat
- 15:00customers, you have to educate people and buy people into the
- 15:05benefits of shopping view, especially when you are a higher
- 15:09price point than like the mass market.
- 15:11So I think there's that fundamental understanding.
- 15:13Therefore design plays a role and it plays a role not just in
- 15:16the overall site, but it plays a role in terms of how you execute
- 15:19content within even transactional pages like PLPS
- 15:24and PDPS. The the style of that content
- 15:27and how well it it by brings people in and it communicates
- 15:31campaigns, promotions, etcetera is important.
- 15:34Which leads you on to my next question.
- 15:36It's a role of art direction. And I've worked on a few, you
- 15:39know, you've worked on a lot more like high end premium
- 15:41brands and I have, but I've worked with a few over the years
- 15:44in jewellery, fashion and beauty, skin care, and the
- 15:48degree to which art direction is an an internal expertise varies
- 15:51massively. Jewellery company where they had
- 15:54an entire an art direction team of like 3 different people
- 15:58involved and they came from high end like publishing and creative
- 16:02roles into determining like the art direction for every single
- 16:05facet content created and very very specific rules and
- 16:09guidelines about what was and wasn't permissible through to.
- 16:14We leave it to an agency to come up with a creative treatment
- 16:17that we review and say we like or don't.
- 16:18So what I'm not, I'm not asking the question about how do you
- 16:22determine what you need, but what what is the role of art
- 16:25direction and what value does it add?
- 16:27I mean, I think that this is kind of how essentially how you
- 16:33present your brand and your product artistically.
- 16:37And it is, it's the identity for me of like the brand.
- 16:43I think this is a really interesting one because I think
- 16:45this is a bit that often gets overlooked.
- 16:48And it's interesting because like you say, a lot of brands
- 16:50have internal people that would, even if they're not art
- 16:53directors, they would kind of own creative direction for the
- 16:56business. So they would play that role.
- 16:59And, and I think where a lot of sites fall down is where you
- 17:03either have, and I wouldn't, I mean that we obviously know a
- 17:06lot of agencies I think that have this level of creative
- 17:11thinking that also build websites like Bow Lime Sharp Web
- 17:14and plenty of others. But I think that often where you
- 17:21kind of got that internal team and then you've got a dev
- 17:24agency. I think often that's where you
- 17:26start to get the more kind of flat traditional approach where
- 17:29art direction isn't really up for grabs or they're kind of
- 17:34taking a set of brand guidelines and then they're applying kind
- 17:38of traditional design best practices or like UUX best
- 17:43practices. Whereas I think the best sites
- 17:45and one of the ones that I've worked on that I think is
- 17:49interesting. So the Frankie Shop is one of
- 17:51our longest serving clients. I don't think Laura remind me
- 17:55saying this, the site's not new. Now.
- 17:56I don't love the site overall anymore like and I think, but I
- 18:00love the brand. Like their content is
- 18:03incredible. Their photography is like
- 18:05amazing. And I think the first priority
- 18:08going into that project, which is really refreshing, is that
- 18:11how do we best present the brand?
- 18:14How do we best get the most out of our content?
- 18:17How do we set the foundations for the team to create the best
- 18:20content? How do we become, you know, web
- 18:23first with some of that stuff? And I think, you know,
- 18:26photography is, is often the biggest part of this.
- 18:28But to me, I think, and to be honest, the Frankie shop, you
- 18:32know, online is their primary channel.
- 18:35I personally think this is what makes the brand.
- 18:37They're a very visual brand. Yeah.
- 18:40And I think, you know, the best brands will put this at the
- 18:43forefront of the project. But yeah, the role of art
- 18:47direction to me, for me, it's like it's the content.
- 18:50It's the brand elements and it's kind of the bits that make you
- 18:55feel about a design versus the function.
- 19:00Yeah, I agree. And I, I think sometimes it's
- 19:02conflated with like brand guidelines and brand guidelines
- 19:04are distinct, but they follow, they flow out of art direction.
- 19:07But, and brand guidelines are critical because you've got to
- 19:10know about, you know, you uses, uses of fonts you like, colour
- 19:14palettes, all those things that create consistency.
- 19:17But our direction for me is more about the emotions of design.
- 19:21It's about how, how should someone feel when looking at it?
- 19:25What, what are the, what are the, what are those kind of like
- 19:27emotional states that you're trying to convey to people And
- 19:30they're, how visually do you execute on that to create those
- 19:34emotional states? So it's, it's got, it's not
- 19:37something that's innate in me. I respond to it visually, but
- 19:41that level of thinking, I think it, and it is a bit more
- 19:43abstract initially. And it is, it's got elements of
- 19:45psychology and it's got behavioural elements and it's,
- 19:48it is, it's relevant to certain businesses and not others.
- 19:52So let's come on to it. So we talked about a few
- 19:53examples. And for those watching the
- 19:55video, you'll see these sites in the background.
- 19:57You see how very different they are visually.
- 20:01And now it's come on to like interactions.
- 20:03I'm getting some more functional and fundamental elements because
- 20:07e-commerce doesn't sit in just a design bubble.
- 20:09It's there to sell as well. There has to be functional
- 20:12coherence in there. So we're going to look at
- 20:14interaction design, nailing the aesthetics for clearance and
- 20:18like functional coherence. So.
- 20:20Making sure that the functional ability of the site is coherent
- 20:24with the design. So you can introduce something
- 20:26amazing, but it's an ask to use or it doesn't work properly on
- 20:29mobile or on particular interactions.
- 20:32It causes issues on the screen and makes it difficult for for
- 20:34shoppers to use it. So let's talk about interaction
- 20:37design and I'm going to come back to the oak one.
- 20:40I know you guys worked in it. I'm using it in the current
- 20:43project I'm working on with a, a, a like a furniture brand.
- 20:49And yeah, no site is 100% perfect.
- 20:52We'll know and there's always a chance for improvement.
- 20:54What I like about this is that there are lots of sites that use
- 20:57transitions to create a like feeling of interaction on the
- 21:02page. And like you're, you're part of
- 21:04that story. But often it's quite jarring.
- 21:06It will be blocked content that's suddenly a transition,
- 21:09then no more transition and it doesn't feel like it flows to
- 21:11the page. And for me, the the ultimate
- 21:14design comes and it was, there was a quote from Sir Anton,
- 21:17who's Aceo at Greben, who's got a lot of amazing.
- 21:21I mean, they're renowned for doing quite beautiful sites,
- 21:23including the Sandquista. And I've got up here is he said
- 21:26a design concept we use is digital salesman replication,
- 21:29which is about how well a site helps the customer in the way
- 21:31the best in store salesperson would do.
- 21:33We ask the right questions, guide people to the right place,
- 21:35give the right suggestions. Great salesperson can have an
- 21:38outsize impact on sales on the same applies applies online.
- 21:41They're available 24/7 through UX.
- 21:44So I think it's a lovely way of framing it.
- 21:46And what I like about it, if we take the home page, it's there's
- 21:49movement and there's simply it's not an overburdening of content
- 21:52on top of the you're not attracting for it.
- 21:54But actually there's simple font changes to help you focus on
- 21:58where you should look. There's some nice interactions,
- 22:01standard ones. That's a standard traction, but
- 22:04it's things like these additional elements coming in
- 22:06where you've got this added functionality using known
- 22:09patterns like slide out draw so you don't click people away.
- 22:13You've got these nice little transitions and highlights
- 22:16across different text links. So that mean this one where
- 22:19you've got like 5 different elements, it's done being done
- 22:22to death and things like tabs. But this treatment is visually
- 22:25more engaging and more impactful.
- 22:27And it's a nice mix between like video text content, like bold
- 22:31headlines, really bold product imagery and things like this,
- 22:34which I like where you have a premium brand focusing on the
- 22:38products but having really soft interactions to then lay over
- 22:41like product information, rather than having that straight from
- 22:44the beginning, which is a bit more visually.
- 22:46I'm crowded. And then little things like
- 22:49animations of text, like turning change in different colours as
- 22:52you come through. So it just feels like that to me
- 22:55is is the example of of how you build AI guess a, a coherence in
- 23:01that visual journey, but you're still fundamentally an
- 23:04e-commerce site promoting product.
- 23:05Completely agree. And I think I have to say with
- 23:08this project, so by association and a delivered work they did,
- 23:11the kind of design they took what we put together.
- 23:14And I think this to me is, you know they're very strong in this
- 23:17area. I think if you look at all of
- 23:18the kind of themes that they are really strong and kind of
- 23:22consistent kind of usage of animation and transitions and
- 23:27that yeah, we're kind of creating that kind of engaging
- 23:30experience. But yeah, I completely agree.
- 23:32I think one thing that you said at the start that I've had a lot
- 23:36of conversations around recently.
- 23:37So as you say, Anton is like real voice for a lot of this
- 23:41stuff in the industry. We have a very, very strong end
- 23:44to end on creative. And I'd say Ed, who we both know
- 23:48is the other one that I've spoken to about it's a lot, but
- 23:51we, I think we've got so many brands because you use the words
- 23:56essentially what I think that quote was saying was like you've
- 23:59got your flagship store and you're kind of trying to create
- 24:02the same flagship experience for web.
- 24:04I think one of the big, most frustrating conversations I have
- 24:07with clients are not conversations more situations is
- 24:10we've got brands that will spend, you know, upwards of
- 24:12£1,000,000 building or refitting a store, but yet they won't
- 24:18invest, you know, 100K as a forty, £50 million retailer in a
- 24:24design project when they're kind of overall direction of the site
- 24:29hasn't been looked at for like 4 or five years.
- 24:31And I think yeah, I find that like a really annoying thing in
- 24:35our industry where you could I guess it's because that you
- 24:38can't really add tangible maybe it's hard to add tangible KPIs
- 24:43to design work versus in store. I guess it's also like you know,
- 24:48is a a shot front by just being people overlook this area so
- 24:51much like especially pre and embarrassed.
- 24:54Yeah. I, I think the problem for me
- 24:56lies in that, that people want to measure the impact of
- 24:58investment, which is fundamentally should.
- 25:00And end of day, if you're, if you're a head of or a director
- 25:04or AC suite or an investor, you want to know that spending money
- 25:07is having a benefit. Now that benefit might not be
- 25:11financial. It might be in other ways.
- 25:13I could, I don't know how else you might measure it, but
- 25:16typically in e-commerce, right, we'll talk about revenue
- 25:18measures. So coming back to your point, in
- 25:21the beginning, you've got to nail down your KPIs.
- 25:22The issue with doing a rebat from where you're migrating to a
- 25:25new tech stack and you're doing a complete and utter brand
- 25:28redesign is when you land that and the metrics change is what's
- 25:31driven it. How much of it is the tech or
- 25:34functional changes? How much of is it the design
- 25:36treatment? And can you therefore actually
- 25:39attribute A incremental benefits to the investment splitting the
- 25:44two out? And I know you don't.
- 25:46I know often people take every platform as a time to do it all
- 25:49in one, but I often find a couple of phases, which is get
- 25:53the tech for us. Because to me, fundamentally, if
- 25:56you're changing technology, it's a tech project.
- 25:58Fix known issues with user journeys and like you know,
- 26:02outdated design stuff, that's fine.
- 26:04But don't fundamentally re engineer the design players and
- 26:07do that as a phase two because then you've got far easier way
- 26:11to to measure and validate that it's having an impact.
- 26:14I know not everyone agrees with that approach.
- 26:16So. I was going to say I think we
- 26:17could debate this quite a lot, but The thing is I think it I
- 26:20mean it depends. I I think I agree with both
- 26:22arguments. I think I've had some very
- 26:24annoying situations where someone's re platform like
- 26:28their, their approach to tracking has changed, like under
- 26:32mentally, they've changed the structure of the site, you know,
- 26:36the catalogues change, the markets are able to fulfil to
- 26:39change and then you know, trade has dropped and they're like,
- 26:42it's the redesign. So I completely agree, it's
- 26:45annoying and it's much easier to measure if you do them
- 26:48separately. But I think I also have another
- 26:50frustration at the moment with the industry in that there's so
- 26:54many re platform projects at the minute where it's a nice brand.
- 26:59There's a huge amount of opportunity with the scope of
- 27:01the project. And instead of treating it as an
- 27:04opportunity to achieve a huge amount of work in a very
- 27:07efficient way, because it's the only time you're ever going to
- 27:10get that like, you know, everyone focused delivering, you
- 27:13know, a CapEx project in a certain way.
- 27:16And then they'll do 100K project.
- 27:19They will, you know, just lift and shift or like base beam.
- 27:22And then they'll be like, we'll come back to redesign and then
- 27:24they never come back to redesign.
- 27:26So I think there's like the efficiency argument, but
- 27:29obviously effects the project, adds risk, you know, requires
- 27:34more time, everything else. And then there's your argument,
- 27:37which I do completely agree with.
- 27:39And I have been personally impacted by a number of times
- 27:42where, yeah, the is hard to measure.
- 27:46And so, yeah, I think that's like it's kind of what's it like
- 27:48chicken and egg or yeah, I think it's hard to measure it.
- 27:51It there's no right answer, and This is why we work in a nuanced
- 27:55environment, right? I think the most important thing
- 27:57is appetite for risk. And yet you get a sense when
- 27:59you're working with clients about how how risk averse versus
- 28:02how willing they are to just leap into something different.
- 28:05And when you have a risk averse business, trying to change
- 28:09everything at once normally ends up in in chaos and it's very
- 28:15hard to manage and keep people on track.
- 28:17I'm I'm very much a fan of unless there is a fundamental
- 28:21need to redo it all. Like if you know your user
- 28:24journeys are wrong, you know that the data and the insights
- 28:26tell you you've fundamentally got the wrong user journeys.
- 28:29Like the, the, the creative assets are completely wrong.
- 28:32Everything about it is wrong and outdated, Then fine, that's a
- 28:35that's a reinvention. But actually, if it's just do
- 28:39you know what? Some of these journeys aren't
- 28:41quite right and our product photography is, is poor and we
- 28:45don't have enough shots and our lifestyle imagery isn't engaging
- 28:48it, then that's not a reinvention.
- 28:50That's more about AI. Guess what you said earlier, and
- 28:54I don't know what you call it a elevation.
- 28:57And I think I'm, yes, I, I like to, I like to think initially
- 29:00more elevate rather than completely renovate.
- 29:03Think, I think This is why you and I are completely different
- 29:06as well. And now we haven't actually
- 29:08talked that much about this since we've flattered the
- 29:09project. But I think in general, I think
- 29:12my appetite for risk is very high.
- 29:14And my ideal approach for project is I guess you either do
- 29:19as much as possible to maximize the value or I guess you get it
- 29:22done as quickly as possible to like realise the value to go
- 29:26into something else. Whereas I think, I guess This is
- 29:28why, you know, you've obviously come from like, you know, really
- 29:31big projects and you're more like, you know, how do we do
- 29:35risk? How do we structure the project
- 29:37properly? But I think that's why we
- 29:39probably work quite well together as well.
- 29:42You have to have contrasting approaches in order to come up
- 29:45right? And there there's normally an an
- 29:47in between in terms of you, you don't want to be 100% risk
- 29:50averse because you don't change anything and you replicate
- 29:52inefficiency. And I see that in non design
- 29:55areas like function areas where I say, oh, this is how we do it,
- 29:57but that's not the right way of doing it.
- 30:00I have lots of conversations around that, Mona especially
- 30:02like product data, for example. But the next point on this is
- 30:05around functional coherence because it's all well and good
- 30:09to come up with something that's creative, that's visually
- 30:11beautiful, but it's got to be able to work functionally within
- 30:15the constructs of how people discover products, buy products,
- 30:19etcetera, on the website. And a couple of interesting
- 30:22quotes I thought from my post was basically as a customer,
- 30:27functional actually is #1 for me.
- 30:29So that's Hannah Spicy. He's a clavier cotton for
- 30:32premium brands. We've got Will Lock who's a
- 30:34global digital director at Noble Panacea saying for E com, I tend
- 30:38to fall back on 2 words findability shop ability.
- 30:41That sums up for me. So the need to ensure that the
- 30:45functional elements are factored in design.
- 30:47And the example I've gotten here, I think it's really nice
- 30:50is from O Polly. And this to me is where you have
- 30:54really, really nice creative design execution, but you
- 30:57haven't fundamentally changed anything from how people expect
- 31:00functional elements to work on the side.
- 31:01So this is for one of the like the looks and occasions, the
- 31:06fact that they're, they're basically, it feels like the
- 31:08video's playing across the products and they're interacting
- 31:11with each other, all done in one, one shoot basically, but
- 31:14then cut up into different product videos, but it's still
- 31:17exactly the same. Instead of the standard
- 31:18interaction where I go over the product and it overlays a new
- 31:21one, I've now got a bit more playful, fun video and they're
- 31:24amazing cost efficiencies in doing things like this as well,
- 31:26because you're not having great multiple videos, you're taking
- 31:29one and just splicing it. Yeah, exactly.
- 31:32I think this is interesting. So free quotes, I think I half
- 31:35agree with them and I completely agree with all your points on
- 31:38OPA. And I think essentially
- 31:41intuitive experience is a non negotiable in terms of someone
- 31:45being able to, you know, function very easily flow
- 31:50through a process and kind of intuitively know how to
- 31:56purchase. I think that's quick or you
- 31:58can't, you know, that's a non negotiable.
- 32:00But I think for me, I think the even the wording here and like,
- 32:05you know, Hannah is, I'm a huge fan of Hannah.
- 32:07We work over all the time. She's excellent and CRM.
- 32:10But I think as a customer, functional is number 1.
- 32:13I hear a lot of agencies say that kind of stuff.
- 32:16And I do agree, but I think you're not building in most
- 32:19instances, you're not building for the customer because the
- 32:22customer already knows the product.
- 32:23The customer already knows brand like and as a, you know, I guess
- 32:27like if you when you're at that point where you're where you are
- 32:30a customer and you're going to transact, you transacted before.
- 32:33I think function is everything that I personally think
- 32:36nowadays, particularly with, you know, the proportion of traffic
- 32:41to the brands that we work with that's coming from top of fun or
- 32:43brand awareness activity, whether that's from a social
- 32:46perspective, which usually is mainly or out of home or
- 32:50connected TV or, you know, influencer market and whatever
- 32:54else. These people have 0 intent.
- 32:56And I think content is more important personally a lot of
- 33:01the time. But I think again, like it's so
- 33:03hard to measure. And I think the other thing I
- 33:05was going to moan about is they're like degrading of tools,
- 33:10the measuring behaviour on site, Like if there is an accessible
- 33:14content square that's, you know, providing digestible information
- 33:18around how people are using websites, I think it'd be way
- 33:22easier to kind of measure some of this stuff.
- 33:24But yeah, I think maybe I've been brainwashed as well because
- 33:27of the type of brain you'd really work with that.
- 33:30But but I so I'm doing my devil's advocate as I like to.
- 33:34I think I think that the two are completely related because yes,
- 33:39you have to have a page that if I'm coming from, I'm in
- 33:44discovery mode. I've seen a social post pick
- 33:46your social challenge that for example, and it's, it's, it's
- 33:51like a visually compelling post that's got me excited, whether
- 33:54it's about a, a cat, whether it's like a campaign angle could
- 33:58be like environmental one, because I want to buy from
- 34:01environmental and conscious brands like Patagonia, for
- 34:03example, or passenger. And I might have bought into a
- 34:07concept, but I but when I get there, I need to be now teased
- 34:11further into what's important about this.
- 34:13Where do I go and how do I contribute?
- 34:14And what are the products and why should I consider this?
- 34:17Or it could be I've seen something just looks beautiful
- 34:20and it looks cool and I want to find out more about it.
- 34:23Or it could be a technical product.
- 34:24And therefore, so you've got all these different angles and
- 34:26fundamentally the thing when I land, the thing that's going to
- 34:29get me most is the structure of that landed page experience and
- 34:33the way that the content and the copy pulls me into the journey
- 34:35further. So I fundamentally agree,
- 34:37however, if my interaction with that page is an absolute arse
- 34:41because I've gone the the people design, I've gone all creative
- 34:44and amazing video and everywhere.
- 34:46But actually, you know the how the where do I go?
- 34:49Like what am I meant to do? I want to find I want to find
- 34:51this info out or you don't have it or how do I get to the
- 34:53product or you haven't thought through that journey properly.
- 34:56The 2 are you shouldn't compromise the former with the
- 35:00latter. But when you're executing that
- 35:02creatively, you need UXUI specialist to go right, OK, this
- 35:07is how you've got to make it build in mobile into desktop.
- 35:11And you're going to have to lose this to make this functionally
- 35:14coherent and also performance so that it doesn't create a
- 35:17ridiculously slow and awful page.
- 35:20So I think the UXUI bit comes after the create treatment.
- 35:23Yeah, I completely agree to be found.
- 35:25I think we both said the same thing.
- 35:26I think it's more when you go into some processes and like the
- 35:30only real as like we need to improve conversion rate overall
- 35:35as a global thing rather than thinking about new customers,
- 35:39all these audience said here and we need to make it easier to
- 35:42purchase. And I do think that's still
- 35:44really common. There's something else I was
- 35:47going to say that, but I've, I've forgotten it, to be fair, I
- 35:51think. Oh yeah, that was it.
- 35:54I was going to say obviously some people would count on this.
- 35:57So one of the things we've talked about before and earlier
- 35:59you mentioned Palace historically on the podcast, we
- 36:02talked about Supreme and you know, we've worked with like
- 36:04Dover Street Market and Stu in the past.
- 36:07And there are some businesses actually intentionally create
- 36:11friction. And we worked with very, very,
- 36:13very high end luxury brand ones. And they were like, you know,
- 36:17we, we don't want people to really know how to check out and
- 36:20like they didn't really have any substance behind it.
- 36:22It's just that they want to be unique and they want their
- 36:25customers to kind of, you know, work to purchase, etcetera.
- 36:29And I think that's something I probably I disagree with.
- 36:31I get it from a brand perspective.
- 36:34I think some brands take that a bit far personally.
- 36:37I, I do. And herein lies the, the, the
- 36:40beauty of of coming back to the point about what metrics are you
- 36:43measuring success against? Because at the end of the day,
- 36:45if a brand doesn't care about people transacting and buying
- 36:47online, they're really not bothered and they just want to
- 36:49create the most insane create experience.
- 36:51Fair play. That's their decision, their
- 36:53prerogative. I think it's mental as well and
- 36:55I'd never advocate that to anybody.
- 36:57However, I do understand the friction because you do have the
- 37:01whole thing of buyer's remorse If you if you, if you just push
- 37:04people so quickly into a product decision that they end up
- 37:06regretting. We know it can translate to high
- 37:09returns and we know it can translate into a drop off and
- 37:11repeat purchases. So you've got to have that
- 37:13balance between product education, discovery and
- 37:16enjoyment bit of buying people into the brand, the product, the
- 37:19process before you push it, but also make the purchase journeys
- 37:23so simple for those who are ready to buy the it's it's this
- 37:27is what the functional account for me is.
- 37:28I can land on the PDP and have an amazing storytelling PDP.
- 37:31And you see this in things like AV equipment, right, like the
- 37:35high end headphones, beautiful product pages, But actually, you
- 37:40know what the the buy the add to basket is pinned.
- 37:43If I can buy it, if I'm ready and I've already done my
- 37:45discovery, I'm ready. I can buy it.
- 37:47I don't need to read and look at all the videos.
- 37:49But equally, if I want that experience, I can.
- 37:51So that to me is what functional coherence is.
- 37:54It's it's taking your point about the different audiences
- 37:57and where they're coming from and building the page that
- 37:59doesn't slow down a high intent butcher, but gives those who
- 38:03need education more. And I think people like Palace
- 38:06are actually quite smart because their friction is is done before
- 38:10you're ready to buy. So turning the site off so you
- 38:14can't get into the shop until the new like X weeks before the
- 38:17new drop gums in and they build up the hype in social.
- 38:22Then everyone's excited and I want to get in the shop.
- 38:24Then it opens, bam. Then you've got a page where
- 38:27actually a step, what would normally be a like PLP is now a
- 38:31visual list like this and there's loads of sold out things
- 38:34because then you're creating the fear of missing out.
- 38:37So they're tapping into the psychological principles because
- 38:40they know that people are so bought into that brand, they
- 38:43want something from the new range.
- 38:44And then when you get the product page, it's just really
- 38:46cool and irreverent copy, but actually it's easy to buy the
- 38:49product. Yeah, Yeah.
- 38:51I think that's always an interesting one.
- 38:52I've had a few discussions with some of our clients about that,
- 38:55that love the whole turning site off piece, but it is obviously
- 39:00very hard to measure unless you kind of split test it.
- 39:04But you know, that's an interesting one.
- 39:06Imagine telling that to a mass market department store.
- 39:09Econ Yeah, let's just start it off 3 weeks.
- 39:11I know now I'll see a simple one do it.
- 39:13I wouldn't expect to do it actually.
- 39:15And you know, still kind of think it's the right thing to
- 39:17do. I think this just because you're
- 39:20showing the civil Espalenza. I think this is an interesting
- 39:22one as well. So they're a bit quirky with
- 39:24navigation and I we've copied this of a few sites.
- 39:27So this is the all page. So they have a shop all page and
- 39:30essentially it's just, you know, a wall of product and I really
- 39:34like it. I think it's just a bit more of
- 39:35a creative way to essentially show your catalog if someone's
- 39:39kind of expressed that they want to see all products and on
- 39:42mobile it's really nice as well. I think it's rows of like four
- 39:44or five on mobile. And then if you go up to the
- 39:47top, the new, the latest is the same.
- 39:51So this has got a vertical scroll and then on mobile it's
- 39:56horizontal and it's just again, just a bit more engaging, quite
- 40:00a nice way to browse the catalog.
- 40:02You obviously wouldn't necessarily want this.
- 40:05I mean, you definitely wouldn't want this site wide.
- 40:07You'd probably only want to. On certain for kind of certain
- 40:11experiences, but I think it's it's really nice and I
- 40:14personally really like when brands and sites kind of just
- 40:18invest a bit more in uniqueness in places.
- 40:22Yeah, and it's interesting how many fashion brands are going
- 40:24on. Sorry, Money Clothing is another
- 40:25one, very much more basic pages. It's all about the product.
- 40:30Yeah. And I think I do understand that
- 40:33when you're in a when your audience is very much it's all
- 40:37visual that when you're building a brand and a quite a niche
- 40:40audience and they're buying based on the look of the
- 40:43product. They're not they're not thinking
- 40:44should I buy from this brand or they're thinking which item
- 40:47should I buy from the brand? Yeah, it's it is interesting.
- 40:50And and again, these these things are easy to validate and
- 40:54test as well. And I guess people listening is
- 40:57if you, if you are doing something very different and
- 40:59you're you're, or you wanted to do something very different,
- 41:02changing it without knowing what the impact is, is crazy.
- 41:06This is where tests come in. And this is where you should
- 41:09incrementally improve design and you should, you know, fix design
- 41:12issues, elevate your visual, you know, photography, your video
- 41:15content, whatever it might be, your storytelling, your copy.
- 41:18But before fundamentally changing the layout of like
- 41:22APLP, test the crap out of it. But it might just, it might
- 41:26screw you, screw your product. Click through rates.
- 41:29I think this leads on nicely to the next podcast you will be
- 41:33recording when I go off to get married next week with Anya and
- 41:38Nick. So Nick's are head of CRO.
- 41:41I've historically been quite sceptical around COO and I still
- 41:45am in a lot of ways. And he and I have debated a lot
- 41:48around this kind of stuff. And I actually think one thing
- 41:50that's happened in the industry recently that's been really
- 41:53positive is historically if you want to run CRO, you'd have to
- 41:58go and spend a minimum of 10 KA month with an agency that's
- 42:00quite isolated over here. And a lot of the testing would
- 42:04be like volume around kind of smaller tests, whereas now via
- 42:10tools like visually and as agencies and consultants and
- 42:14whatever else, a bit more comfortable with testing.
- 42:17I think a lot more of our clients are doing like ad hoc
- 42:20testing when it's right to test something.
- 42:23So like a new PDP or a new approach to, you know, something
- 42:26in the car. And I think, I think that's
- 42:28something that's also helping this area and some of the stuff
- 42:31we've discussed. The barrier to entry to test is
- 42:34much lower. Yeah, I'm looking forward to
- 42:36that one because I'm just going through it with another client
- 42:39at the moment and they are updating their, their main nerve
- 42:42and they they can't test it. They're making changes.
- 42:46They'll measure it through click through rate.
- 42:47But it would be absolutely great to be able to AP test that and
- 42:51do a, do a much more like scientific comparison before and
- 42:54after. Let's get on to the final couple
- 42:59of ones. So design documentation, how
- 43:02important is it? What, what is good design
- 43:05documentation? What?
- 43:06What should people have to ensure future consistency?
- 43:09I mean, I think that's a great question.
- 43:11I don't know, I don't feel like I'm the right person to answer
- 43:14that or like we're maybe the right people to answer that.
- 43:16I think I think it's really interesting some of the tools
- 43:21that people are using nowadays and some of that like the little
- 43:23Figma add-ons and all that kind of stuff.
- 43:27And I think, you know, there's a lot more kind of technical
- 43:32designers out there as well, and there's a lot more kind of work
- 43:37being done around like design pattern prototyping and
- 43:41everything else. But yeah, I feel like for me
- 43:43going into a redesign, I think the higher level documentation,
- 43:48I think like you said earlier, the more data you can have
- 43:51around the customer and the product and the business, the
- 43:54better as like a foundational thing.
- 43:57I don't think it's a case of basically using documentation to
- 44:02collect as much insight from the different stakeholders around
- 44:05what they're trying to achieve and what's important to them as
- 44:07possible. And then I think it's that if
- 44:12you're working with a designer or agency or whatever, just like
- 44:17I guess just making sure that the documentation gives some
- 44:22like freedom, but within a set of parameters.
- 44:25And with all that other stuff I just said, yeah, I feel like, I
- 44:31mean, we've had, we've done podcasts with Ed and Anton
- 44:34before, but it would be good to have maybe I actually think a
- 44:38really interesting podcast with like a modern kind of full stack
- 44:42creative person would be really interesting because I find all
- 44:47the stuff that's happening within Figma at the moment.
- 44:49And yeah, and even like Figma to front end, like some of the
- 44:54stuff that's been built around that, I think it's fascinating.
- 44:57So I think that'll be a really good podcast.
- 44:59Yeah, I I agree. And that's what I was thinking
- 45:00of is I'd, because there is traditional documentation, which
- 45:04is brand guidelines, which is normally like a massive PDF.
- 45:08But actually the, the more modern approach is, is to have
- 45:11things in repositories where you could have annotated files when
- 45:16the linked assets that can then be downloaded.
- 45:18And I, I think that's where I see it heading as well as is,
- 45:22it's more fluid because design moves, it's not rigid.
- 45:25And if you have APDF, it's a pain in the arse to have to then
- 45:28go and recreate it. Recreate it, What version you
- 45:31want? Has everyone got the right
- 45:32versions? So yeah, having a succinct
- 45:35online repository where people can access it and it's locked
- 45:38down for who controls the edits versus who can like access
- 45:41assets is really important. Although I know we could
- 45:45probably talk for hours more on this because it is despite the
- 45:48fact that I think you can be very objective about defining
- 45:52good design as long as as long as you get around to buy into
- 45:55the definition that you're using, there is inevitable
- 45:58subjectivity to this. So I would I really enjoy this.
- 46:01I'd love to hear from people listening.
- 46:03I do what what do you agree with?
- 46:05What do you disagree with? Like to you, what is good
- 46:07design? Which sites are well designed
- 46:09and do you like and why do you like them?
- 46:11Love to hear. Do reach out to Paul and I when
- 46:14we put the post on LinkedIn. I'd love you to add fire the
- 46:16comments because there's no right answer on this.
- 46:19Any any closing comments Paul for our our wonderful listeners.
- 46:23And then Vince, I think there's a few follow up topics we could
- 46:26cover for sure that we should plan it.
- 46:28But no, I don't think so. Well, thanks for listening
- 46:31everyone. Hope it's useful.
- 46:32Until next week, you're listening to the Inside Commerce
- 46:36podcast hosted by experienced consultants James Gert and Paul
- 46:40Rogers. Inside Commerce is your fast
- 46:42tracked additional knowledge featuring interviews with
- 46:44leading e-commerce retailers, industry thought leads and the
- 46:47C-Suite, key tech companies to explore the latest digital
- 46:50strategy, customer experience and tech.
- 46:52Discover what the latest trends really mean and get practical
- 46:55advice based on the experience to help fine tune your ecom
- 46:58strategy and taste. Follow us on LinkedIn and reach
- 47:01out to James and Paul if you'd like to discuss an Ecom's
- 47:04project. We hope you enjoy the latest
- 47:06episode.