Latest / Friendship Project: Friendship, community & belonging / When Your Growth Makes Them Uncomfortable: Letting Go With Grace | Friendship Project
Transcript
- I made a promise to my best friend last week that I knew, deep in my bones, she would never be able to keep. And yet, the moment the words left my mouth, I felt a strange, heavy relief wash over me, like I had finally put down a bag of rocks I didn’t even know I was carrying. We need to talk about the invisible contracts we sign with the people we love. You know the kind. They aren’t written on paper. They don’t have witnesses or notary stamps. But they are heavier than steel. We make promises to our friends based on who they used to be, or who we hope they will become, rather than who they are right now, in this messy, complicated season of their life. Let’s sit with that for a second. Think about the last time you said yes to someone when your heart was actually screaming no. Maybe it was a coffee date. Maybe it was helping them move. Maybe it was promising to listen to the same story for the tenth time this month. We do it because we want to be good friends. We do it because we fear that if we pull back, we’ll disappear. But here is the truth that hurts to admit: sometimes keeping a promise isn’t an act of love. Sometimes it’s an act of self-abandonment. And sometimes, it’s a trap set by our own need to feel needed. Let me tell you what happened to me. My friend Sarah has been going through a divorce that feels less like a separation and more like a slow-motion car crash. For months, I promised her I would meet her at that terrible, overly expensive coffee shop on Tuesdays at seven p.m. to process everything. Every Tuesday, I sat there. I checked my phone. I ordered a latte I didn’t want. I watched the door, expecting her to walk in with her hair messy and her eyes red, ready to pour out her soul. But she never came. Not once. At first, I told myself she was overwhelmed. Then I told myself she was busy. Then, quietly, I started to resent her. I resented her for making me wait. I resented her for breaking the ritual that I had built my entire week around. I felt foolish. I felt invisible. And worst of all, I felt angry at myself for having the audacity to expect anything from her. I thought, 'If I really loved her, I wouldn’t mind waiting.' But that wasn’t true. I minded. I minded so much it kept me up at night. I was holding onto a promise that existed only in my head, while she was living in a reality where she simply couldn’t show up. Here is where it gets tricky. How do you distinguish between supporting a friend in crisis and performing support for your own peace of mind? When someone is drowning, we often throw them a rope and then stand on the shore demanding they climb up, even though they’re too exhausted to swim. I realized that my Tuesday promises were a performance. I was playing the role of the 'Good Friend' who shows up, regardless of circumstances. But Sarah wasn’t asking for a stage manager. She was asking for a witness. And I was so focused on managing the logistics of our friendship—the time, the place, the agenda—that I missed the actual connection. I was keeping a promise to an idea of her, not to the real woman who was struggling to get out of bed. This is a hard pill to swallow. We often confuse consistency with loyalty. We think that showing up at the exact same time every week proves our dedication. But if the other person can’t meet you there, your consistency becomes a wall instead of a bridge. It creates distance. It creates guilt. It creates a dynamic where one person is always giving and the other is always receiving, until the giver runs dry and the receiver feels ashamed. So, what do we do when we realize we are the one holding onto a promise that the other person has already let go of? Or worse, when we realize we made a promise we never intended to keep, just to soothe our own anxiety about the relationship? I had to have a conversation with Sarah that terrified me. I called her on a Wednesday, not Tuesday. I didn’t mention the coffee shop. I didn’t mention the missed appointments. I just asked, 'How are you really doing?' And she broke down. She told me that every Tuesday I waited for her, she felt a spike of panic. She knew she couldn’t come. She knew I was sitting there. And instead of feeling loved, she felt judged. She felt like a failure because she couldn’t meet the standard I had set. My promise, which I thought was a gift, was actually a burden. It was a reminder of what she couldn’t do. This changed everything for me. I realized that by keeping the promise myself—by waiting for her—I was inadvertently enforcing a standard she was failing to meet. We need to stop keeping promises that serve our ego and start keeping promises that serve the human being in front of us. If they can’t keep their end of the deal, do we drop the rope? No. We change the game. We stop playing tug-of-war and start sitting together in the dirt. This brings us to the practical part, because I know you’re listening and thinking, 'Okay, Rhiannon, that’s beautiful, but how do I actually do this without sounding like a jerk?' It starts with lowering the stakes. Instead of scheduling rigid, high-pressure commitments like 'Tuesday at 7 PM,' try offering flexible, low-energy options. Send a text that says, 'I’m thinking of you. No need to reply, but I’m here if you want to vent, or if you want silence, or if you want to watch a dumb movie together.' See the difference? One is a contract. The other is an invitation. An invitation can be declined without guilt. A contract feels like a debt. When I shifted my approach with Sarah, I stopped waiting for her. I started sending her care packages. I started texting her memes when I saw something that reminded me of her inside jokes. I removed the expectation of reciprocity. I didn’t ask her to call me back. I didn’t ask her to plan the next hangout. I just showed up in small, manageable ways that didn’t require her to perform wellness. And slowly, the pressure lifted. She started reaching out again, not because she owed me a meeting, but because she felt safe enough to be imperfect. We’re all just figuring it out as we go, and sometimes figuring it out looks like staying home in pajamas and eating cereal for dinner. That’s okay. That’s human. There is a profound freedom in releasing the need to control how your friend shows up for you. When I let go of the Tuesday promise, I didn’t lose Sarah. I gained her. I gained the real version of her, the tired version, the confused version, the version that doesn’t have it all together. And honestly? She was more lovable to me than the curated version I had been waiting for. I learned that friendship isn’t about matching energy levels perfectly. It’s about expanding your capacity to hold space for mismatched energy. It’s about being the steady ground when the other person is shaking. It’s about understanding that sometimes, the most loving thing you can do is stop asking them to keep a promise they physically or emotionally cannot keep. Tell me more about why that matters to you. Why does it feel like a betrayal to let go of these expectations? Is it because you’re afraid that if you stop trying, they will forget you? Or is it because you’re afraid that you won’t be enough on your own terms? These are the questions we have to ask ourselves. Because until we answer them, we’ll keep waiting at coffee shops for people who are nowhere to be found. Thank you for letting me into your kitchen table today. Thank you for your vulnerability, your attention, and your presence. I hope you give yourself permission to drop the heavy bags today. You don’t have to carry them all. I’ll see you next time. Until then, be gentle with yourself. You’re doing better than you think.