Latest / Newcomer Pod / The Coming AI Crash No One Wants to Admit | Alex Heath x Newcomer Podcast
Transcript
- 0:00Is the AI bubble going to burst? This week, Tom Daton wrote an
- 0:03article for our Sub Stack that explores the web of mutual
- 0:06dependence between Open AI and its partners, and how if Open AI
- 0:10fails, the tower of cards may fall with it.
- 0:13We're being joined by Alex Heath, founder of the Sources
- 0:16Sub Stack and Co, host of the Access podcast, to explore how
- 0:19much of the entire economy is being propped up by AI.
- 0:22We're also going to talk about Open AI's new Sora video feed
- 0:26and Meta's launch of their new product that they're calling
- 0:29Vibes. Introducing Vibes, the new
- 0:31platform from Meta that lets people with no life create,
- 0:34share and watch short form AI videos.
- 0:37Sucks right? Both are hot on the heels of
- 0:39Mark Zuckerberg's high profile poaching and reflect the world
- 0:42of products that feel further and further away from AGI.
- 0:46This is the newcomer podcast. This podcast is supported by
- 0:59Google. Hey folks, Steven Johnson here,
- 1:02Co founder of Notebook LM. As an author, I've always been
- 1:05obsessed with how software could help organize ideas and make
- 1:08connections, so we built Notebook LM as an AI first tool
- 1:12for anyone trying to make sense of complex information.
- 1:16Upload your documents and Notebook LM instantly becomes
- 1:19your personal expert, uncovering insights and helping you
- 1:22brainstorm. Try it at Notebook
- 1:25lm.google.com. So, Tom, you had a good story
- 1:29out this week about how the entire economy is seemingly
- 1:33propped up by open AI. Are we?
- 1:34Are we about to, you know, hit financial apocalypse if this
- 1:38whole thing runs out? Sell That's that's my one take
- 1:42away from from the story. If if you, if you could do one
- 1:44thing as we've clearly reached a peak and everyone needs to sell.
- 1:47No, I, you know, this, this piece that I wrote.
- 1:51I was really struck by a converse two things.
- 1:53I had a conversation with just an analyst a few weeks ago and
- 1:57he was mentioning to me that that open AI has basically
- 2:01become a systemic risk to the tech industry to, to to the tech
- 2:06economy. And he wasn't even saying it as
- 2:08a negative thing. It was more just that the number
- 2:10of companies that have been connected to and gotten a glow
- 2:14up essentially from Sam and an open AI has grown.
- 2:18And it, you know, partnering that with the number of deals
- 2:23that Open AI has been announcing in the last couple of weeks, we
- 2:25can rundown them, you know, later in the conversation.
- 2:28And the fact that like making announcements seems to be core
- 2:32to what Open AI has been doing recently.
- 2:34And and so the other thing that struck me was this very press
- 2:39savvy and I think a little ham handed move by Open AI to invite
- 2:42all these reporters out to Abilene to kind of gawk at their
- 2:47sprawling data center and bask in the incredible ambitions of
- 2:50Sam Altman and the tech world that he has built around him.
- 2:54The fact of the matter is there were a lot of reporters on the
- 2:56ground. They're mingling with Open AI
- 2:58and and Oracle and other executives there.
- 2:59And this is all part of this big show by the company to basically
- 3:03show off where, you know, where's all your money going and
- 3:05why should you keep writing about us?
- 3:07And like, this is where the money is going essentially,
- 3:12right? It's going towards these, you
- 3:13know, giant data centers, the current 1, you know, being
- 3:17constructed and of increasing ambition in Abilene.
- 3:20And there was like 3 or four other cities that they said they
- 3:23were going to be building data centers into.
- 3:24And what I was trying to like get at in this story is like
- 3:29when the numbers are getting to the point that they are where
- 3:32it's like a $40 billion investment from SoftBank, a $300
- 3:36billion Oracle deal, a $10 billion Broad, you know,
- 3:39Broadcom deal. There's also the 100 billion
- 3:41NVIDIA deal too. Right, sorry, of course, right.
- 3:44The NVIDIA deal which was announced the day before, you
- 3:47know, this, this Abilene trip, it's like all the stocks of
- 3:50those companies that I mentioned that are public have gone up
- 3:54considerably after the announcement.
- 3:55And so you it really starts to make you wonder, what does it
- 4:00mean for a company to get its stock valuation hugely inflated
- 4:05off of a deal that is going to be paid for with money that the
- 4:07company doesn't currently have? Well, it's also going to be paid
- 4:10for with debt. Yeah, a lot of its debt, sure.
- 4:13Certainly debt and and sovereigns and there there's no
- 4:16doubt to the, well, actually I don't know where do you stand on
- 4:19this, Alex? I mean like not that we
- 4:21understand the full world of debt markets and you know the
- 4:24the cash flow of various sovereigns, but like is he going
- 4:29to keep raising this amount of money consistently to be able to
- 4:32fund all of these deals? I mean, I think you have to, as
- 4:36my grandmother said, pay the piper eventually.
- 4:39So this is a giant money snowball and there has to be an
- 4:47outcome on the other side. And yeah, what you were talking
- 4:50about, all these companies with their stocks popping on these
- 4:52deals that are multi year tranches based on certain
- 4:57thresholds being reached, either a mix of equity, a lot of debt,
- 5:02debt that has not been raised yet.
- 5:05That's the bubble, right? That's the AI bubble.
- 5:08And you know, I was reading your your column where you list all
- 5:11these companies that are so intertwined with open AI.
- 5:15You left some out. Actually, it's gotten to, it's
- 5:18gotten to such a point where Reddit's stock went down like
- 5:22almost 10% today, the day we're recording, because some third
- 5:27party web traffic analyzer firm said that like a low single
- 5:33digit percent of their Chachi PT links that they were getting.
- 5:38And Chachi PT have like disappeared like something very
- 5:40like random just from like a similar web or something of
- 5:44like, yeah, like Chachi PT is citing Reddit a little less and
- 5:48the stock goes down like 8%. Interesting.
- 5:50It's like this. I didn't.
- 5:52Yeah, that's. That's the bubble.
- 5:53It's like, I mean, I think Shopify's stock went up when
- 5:57they announced the, the, the merchant partnership with Chachi
- 6:01PT where you can buy things in Chachi PT.
- 6:05The froth and the excitement about this is just insane right
- 6:08now. Right.
- 6:09And, and the volatility, right, that something can go up and
- 6:12down, you know, double digit percentages at times because of
- 6:15a deal whose value isn't even really figuring into the bottom
- 6:19line or the top line of most of these companies.
- 6:21Reddit's an interesting one actually, because I don't know
- 6:24this. Maybe you do.
- 6:24But like, they signed a licensing deal.
- 6:27Yeah. Open AI did with Reddit for
- 6:28training. Did their stock move much on
- 6:30that? I imagine, Yeah.
- 6:31It did when they when they, well, I think they announced it
- 6:33right before they went public. But yeah.
- 6:35They did pop, I think in some extent in their IPO on part
- 6:39because people understand that Reddit is such a great source of
- 6:43human generated data for for large language models to train
- 6:47on. And so if you know you have
- 6:48these licensing deals with Open AI, that's a great business for
- 6:52your social media company if you're kind of the remaining
- 6:54trove of human generated data. Yeah.
- 6:57And look, if we were talking and TikTok was a public company,
- 7:02maybe it will be, maybe this Frankenstein TikTok US joint
- 7:05venture will be soon. But if TikTok was public and the
- 7:09Sora 2 launch happened like it did yesterday, the day before
- 7:12we're recording now, I guarantee you TikTok stock would have gone
- 7:15down based off of an invite only beta app that's super buggy,
- 7:19that has no monetization, that who knows how much open AI is
- 7:23committed to it. That's the IT feels like
- 7:26everything is on a nice edge around open AII think you
- 7:29captured that in the piece, but I think it's actually just much
- 7:31broader than we think. 100% yeah, there's, there's a much
- 7:35larger version of it. Maybe someone else can do that
- 7:38talks about the second order effects of and, and it's
- 7:40predictive effects, right. It's just the way people assume
- 7:43things are going to play out because again, we're not dealing
- 7:45with money that open AI really has.
- 7:48I also was thinking on the, you know, if the TikTok, a
- 7:51prospective TikTok stock going down after this Sora 2 launch,
- 7:54you know, after the DeepSeek moment at the beginning of the
- 7:58year, if Open AI were a public stock, it would have collapsed
- 8:03at least briefly with people assuming that, you know, you,
- 8:06they've been undercut in price and, and, and, you know,
- 8:09comparable quality. So it's, it's such a crazy
- 8:12volatile moment. And you know, the company that I
- 8:15homed in on with this, I mean, I mentioned a bunch, but the one
- 8:18that fascinated me the most is Oracle, of course, because
- 8:21Oracle has gone through this pretty incredible transformation
- 8:26over the last six months. Basically where this boring ass
- 8:30legacy database company that had basically missed on out on cloud
- 8:35entirely. Like they were just getting
- 8:37washed by all the hyper scalers managed to snag this open AI
- 8:42data center deal. And it suddenly became like a,
- 8:45you know, a legitimate player as a, as a, you know, as a cloud
- 8:49computing company. They're an AI company all of a
- 8:51sudden. Yeah, Larry Ellison's the
- 8:53world's richest man now. Briefly, briefly.
- 8:56Was oh, yeah, that's true. He slipped.
- 8:58He slipped. But yeah, he's, I'm not going
- 9:01to, you know, cry for him. His his losses here.
- 9:04Yeah, but, but yeah, they've managed to kind of redefine
- 9:08themselves all because of this one deal that came into
- 9:11existence because Microsoft basically said they didn't want
- 9:14to go in on, on Stargate on this, you know, huge data center
- 9:18vision that Sam had. And so I, I, I don't really know
- 9:22where the Oracle story is, is going to go.
- 9:24Like it it, their stock has been down, you know, 15% or so in the
- 9:28last week 'cause I think people are are sort of leveling off the
- 9:31euphoria, but. Well, they have to go out.
- 9:35They have to go out and raise the debt and they have to
- 9:37actually build the data centers and finance it.
- 9:39They don't have the cash flow to finance it themselves.
- 9:41So basically what Sam Altman did, which is pretty genius, is
- 9:45be like, OK, Larry, you figure it out and they have to figure
- 9:48it out now. And they can probably use stock
- 9:51inflation to help, you know, but they don't have the cash flow.
- 9:55It's very telling to me, and I don't think anyone's really
- 9:57gotten to the bottom of this, that a company with tremendous
- 10:01cash flow, one of the leading hyper scalers, Microsoft that
- 10:04owns a huge chunk of open AI has, you would think
- 10:06structurally every incentive to keep building out compute with
- 10:10open AI has stopped doing so. What does that, what does that
- 10:14mean? I don't think anyone's really
- 10:15answered that question, but you know, it would be very natural
- 10:19for Microsoft to continue to partner with open AI and all
- 10:22this stuff, and the fact that Sam is going to Oracle that
- 10:25doesn't have the cash flow to support this instead is pretty
- 10:28telling to me. Yeah.
- 10:30And this is one of those annoying moments where, like,
- 10:32we're all reporters here, so rather than speculate, we should
- 10:35probably figure it out. Yeah, we should just go and get
- 10:38get to the core of it. But since we are here and we
- 10:41don't know the reporter yet, we might as well speculate on it.
- 10:46You know, I came into this piece initially thinking Microsoft had
- 10:49fucked up. You know, you looked at the
- 10:51Oracle pop after the the Stargate, you know, announcement
- 10:55of their earnings. And you're like, man, that
- 10:56should have been Microsoft's money, right?
- 10:58That should have been them appreciating even more because
- 11:01they were the ones that we're going to commit however many
- 11:04more 10s of billions of dollars to building, you know, Sam's
- 11:07Tower of Babel. And then the more I thought
- 11:10about it, I was like, yeah, but maybe, maybe not.
- 11:14Maybe it's actually OK to not buy into every single thing
- 11:17that, you know, you're insane, megalomaniacal, you know,
- 11:21partner wants to go into. And they run a real business
- 11:24with Azure. You know, it does $75 billion a
- 11:27year. Do you really want to hinge your
- 11:30entire future on this company that's already been fairly
- 11:32unstable? And they all freaked out after
- 11:35the, you know, Sam Altman blip. And I I don't again, this is the
- 11:40annoying speculation, but I don't know how much like all
- 11:42that shit figured into the decision not to go in on
- 11:45Stargate. But I could at least follow the
- 11:47logic of like, there's a reason to maybe not do it.
- 11:50And maybe they're not, you know, the most, you know, they're not
- 11:53maybe not the biggest loser in this moment that it might have
- 11:55seemed after the Oracle bump happened.
- 11:58Yeah, I mean, we actually do have a little reporting now.
- 12:01I'm remembering I was at that dinner with Sam Altman where he
- 12:04talked about the AI bubble a couple months ago.
- 12:07And actually I'm remembering now I which.
- 12:09Moved stocks again. It did, which was wild.
- 12:11I should have just like, yeah, posted that during I thought
- 12:14about like live tweeting the dinner and seeing what would
- 12:16happen to like the Bloomberg Walter Bloomberg Twitter
- 12:18account. But so.
- 12:22I. I asked Sam and Brad Lycap, who
- 12:25runs kind of has been running a lot of this, this partnership
- 12:28stuff about this at the dinner. I was like, why is Microsoft not
- 12:31doing this? It seems strange to me.
- 12:33And the version of their response was like, you should
- 12:36ask them. But basically it's that no one
- 12:41hyper scaler can support the ambition that Open AI has and
- 12:45that they're continuing to work with Azure.
- 12:46And I know that's true. It is just strange.
- 12:50Yeah. It's just strange when you see
- 12:51like the market response to what Oracle's doing.
- 12:54And Nadella, to me, comes across as a pretty even keeled
- 12:59financial tactical CEO. And the fact that he's sitting
- 13:05out of this hype hysteria moment, to me is pretty, pretty
- 13:09telling. Yeah, and he of course, had that
- 13:11pretty pretty, you know, vicious is the wrong word.
- 13:15But he had like a nice kind of on, on Sam after the Stargate
- 13:20announcement being like, well, we're good for our $80 billion.
- 13:23Like, we actually have the money to fund our ambitions.
- 13:26And, you know, people were like, oh, that guy's gangster.
- 13:28He's badass at the time. And then when you saw the Oracle
- 13:31pop, you're like, yeah, maybe he looks kind of like a wuss, you
- 13:34know, that he was, you know, only willing to stick to the 80
- 13:36billion that's actually just pocket change now for the
- 13:40trillions that Sam is talking about.
- 13:43But I, I wonder, you know, when it comes to the money, when it's
- 13:49going to start looking a little shaky, you know, when we're
- 13:52going to start seeing Sam or any of the companies that have to
- 13:56raise money to be able to fund Sam's ambitions, see that
- 13:59there's some pushback from the financial markets and you start
- 14:03to see a sovereign saying like, well, we're not going to go in
- 14:05for that level. We MGX, you know, we don't
- 14:08believe in it to to that degree or show us more revenue or the
- 14:12debt markets maybe saying like Oracle, the second tranche of
- 14:15like the $20 billion that you want to raise, like we're going
- 14:19to Jack up the rates on it because we just don't know how
- 14:22this is going to pay off for you in the near term.
- 14:24And I, I don't follow this stuff too closely, but like the rating
- 14:29agencies are probably going to start, you know, looking at some
- 14:32of these bond offerings and saying like this is looking a
- 14:34lot more precarious than it might have seemed a couple of
- 14:37months ago. So.
- 14:39I got into a little, yeah, I got into a little bit of an exchange
- 14:41with Altman at that dinner about this because he was talking
- 14:43about, he like looked at all of us at the table and like Stone
- 14:46face said, you should expect us to raise trillions, right?
- 14:49And everyone's like eating and we're just like, OK, and, and
- 14:53I'm like, where are you going to get the money, Sam?
- 14:55Where, you know, Sam is a if, if Sam is good at anything, it's
- 14:59raising money, right? He's a, he's a career VC.
- 15:02He does a lot of like investing on the side.
- 15:04He knows where all the pools of capital in the world are.
- 15:06I said that to him like almost verbatim.
- 15:08I was like, where are the trillions?
- 15:10And he got eyes kind of lit up and he started talking about
- 15:14he's going to come up with this new financing instrument.
- 15:17I think he called it. And he was like, if I knew, if I
- 15:20knew what it was, I'd be so excited.
- 15:22I'd just tell you right now we're figuring it out.
- 15:24And then I saw that he mentioned that again.
- 15:26He kind of alluded to that in the recent blog post about
- 15:29Stargate. I think there's going to be an
- 15:32announcement later this year is my bet from him on how they're
- 15:36going to finance it. I can't imagine it's anything
- 15:38other than like some mix of debt and tying like build outs to
- 15:45revenue and Rev share or something.
- 15:47Like there's there's only so many, so many ways you can scan
- 15:50a CAT. Like I'm not really sure what
- 15:51the yeah, the magic. There's debt.
- 15:53Here there's vendor financing and then there's just cash flow,
- 15:57I don't know what. And like another funny thing he
- 15:59said at the dinner was like, we would be profitable if we
- 16:01stopped doing training, which is like, sure, like if you if the
- 16:06grocery store stopped paying for groceries, it would probably be
- 16:09profitable. Way more profitable too.
- 16:12But that was to suggest that there are levers they have in
- 16:15the business, I think where if they need to start making a
- 16:18profit, they could. Which if it's research and it's
- 16:21training, I I don't know if I buy that, but.
- 16:25That's a ridiculous statement because the reason companies and
- 16:28whomever are investing at them at that level is because they're
- 16:31promising AGI. So if they're to say we're going
- 16:33to stop trying to get after AGI and just like try to coast off
- 16:36of our consumer grade product, that's not going to give the
- 16:39kind of returns that SoftBank or any of the number of other huge
- 16:42companies that have put money into Open AI were expecting when
- 16:45they when they, you know, took on that equity.
- 16:47Maybe you can get to AGI through AI Vine with ads.
- 16:51Yeah. We'll get that.
- 16:52That's actually, yeah. We're going to jump into that a
- 16:55bit. What do you, I want to bring up,
- 16:57Alex, your story about ads because we're talking about
- 17:00like, I guess you can also just make money on your own as a
- 17:03company to try to fund these things.
- 17:05What do you, what do you know about open AI's ads?
- 17:08How they're going to start shoving ads into our into our
- 17:11chat? Yeah, this was, I feel like, I
- 17:14feel like I have to plug things now.
- 17:15It's really strange. This was the Sources dot news
- 17:17scoop last week, Fiji Simo, the new CEO of applications at Open
- 17:23AI, which basically the way it's split up now and I don't think
- 17:26this is fully understood externally.
- 17:27It's like Sam is running research safety infra with Greg
- 17:33Brockman and then Fiji has everything else and that
- 17:37includes Chacha PT, the consumer business, marketing, basic, all
- 17:40that stuff that is a normal company.
- 17:43And she is now looking for someone to run all of
- 17:47monetization reporting to her. And part of this mandate, and
- 17:51it's also very clear from the people I know she's talking to,
- 17:55which includes some of her former Facebook colleagues, is
- 17:58that this is to do ads, just to put ads in Chachi BT.
- 18:02I mean, her title is applications.
- 18:03And that didn't make sense until this week when they released the
- 18:06Soar app. I think that there will be a web
- 18:08browser app. I'm sure they'll do others and
- 18:12the idea is to monetize all that.
- 18:14And, you know, it's also including the subscriptions, but
- 18:17it will be ads and they're already thinking through that.
- 18:20Which is like, that's her bread and butter, right?
- 18:22She ran Facebook video. She understands that stuff.
- 18:26She was a pretty critical part of Facebook figuring out
- 18:30monetization in the very early days, even before she was just
- 18:33running video. They that kind of work that goes
- 18:38behind the scenes that no one really thinks about unless
- 18:40you're in it. And it's kind of thankless work,
- 18:42but it's what makes the billions of dollars.
- 18:44It's like ranking optimization, creating like structured data,
- 18:49connecting the dots. It's very telling that you know,
- 18:52she just they just acquired Statsig, which was basically
- 18:57another colleague of hers at Facebook went off and made a
- 18:59start up to sell the a version of the AB testing software that
- 19:04Facebook pioneered. That really is what helped it
- 19:08scale to billions of users and billions of dollars.
- 19:10That tooling is now internal at open AI and that's going to be
- 19:13very critical, I think for them to monetize Chachi PT and he's
- 19:18running engineering now Vija the the CEO of stat stick.
- 19:21So yeah, the, the, the she's getting the band back together
- 19:24and it's like there's there's a small group of people that know
- 19:27how to do this on a scaled platform and that have done it
- 19:30before. And they either worked at
- 19:32Facebook or Google. I have to say with the launch of
- 19:35Vibes and you know, Sora 2's video feed coming back and forth
- 19:40right there, it does seem like given you know, with also Fiji's
- 19:44hiring spree, that opening eye is visualizing as far as revenue
- 19:48goes and profit generation right now coming from competing with
- 19:53kind of app based products that sort of were Meta's bread and
- 19:56butter for a while. Like when in the meta printing
- 19:58money machine it comes from, you know these.
- 20:01Really addictive consumer applications.
- 20:03And so it makes sense if you are looking for money right now to
- 20:07poach the geniuses behind that and build something very
- 20:10similar. But I think in the race between
- 20:13which of the foundation model makers are really pushing with
- 20:17each other right now as we get into the product side, it seems
- 20:19like opening eyes competing more with Meta directly as a rival
- 20:23than, you know, maybe Google, which it was at one point.
- 20:25I think in the model race back in the day with Gemini, it seems
- 20:28like they were much more neck and neck.
- 20:30I mean, I think they're competing with both from like a
- 20:33use case perspective. The ambition's actually pretty
- 20:35crazy, I think. I think they're going for the
- 20:37core Google use cases, rebuilding G Suite, an AI
- 20:41version of G Suite from the ground up.
- 20:44They're, you know, trying to replicate Google Cloud with,
- 20:47with Stargate Chechi BT functions a lot that does a lot
- 20:51of the stuff that you would use search for, which, you know,
- 20:54everyone knows. But yeah, I think the meta side
- 20:56is the newer thing. And what explains that rivalry
- 21:00that we've seen playing out over the last year or so?
- 21:03They've hired a ton of X Facebook people at Open AI.
- 21:05And then as we all know, Zuck has gone and spent a lot to hire
- 21:08a bunch of X Open AI people. So yeah, it's a it's a small
- 21:13world, but I see them actually competing with both Google and
- 21:15Facebook. The ad stuff is so interesting
- 21:19to me and Alex, you and I've been like social media company
- 21:22reporters for a long time. And you always see this
- 21:25trajectory that a company goes on where they think they can
- 21:28like reskin the cat on how to make money and they no one ever
- 21:33really goes into it wanting to do ads.
- 21:34And like, famously, you and I both covered famously that we
- 21:38covered it. But just like the whole
- 21:39trajectory that's Evan Spiegel went on Snapchat where he
- 21:42basically tried to go through every other option of making
- 21:46money off of the app before realizing like, fuck, we got
- 21:48eyeballs. This is just what you're
- 21:50supposed to do. Let's just shove ads into it
- 21:53never really made a great business out of ads, but that's
- 21:55a separate point. But like, you know, it's, it's
- 21:58just it's the most derivative and uninspiring way to make
- 22:01money from an Internet product that has a lot of users.
- 22:04But you just, the money is there on the table and, and I guess at
- 22:09some point you realize, like, why are we, why are we beating
- 22:12ourselves up trying to find so many other options when like
- 22:16it's different with chat because obviously they do have real
- 22:19revenue from, from subscriptions and stuff.
- 22:21But this is where there's a. Ceiling to that there's only so
- 22:25many millions of people in the world that will pay a
- 22:27subscription yeah, it's a good business it's billions a year
- 22:30and they are but look at what they're doing in India, which I
- 22:33think will soon be their largest market if it isn't already.
- 22:36They're doing a lower priced subscription because you can't
- 22:41do a $20.00 a month subscription in India and expect hundreds of
- 22:45millions of people to buy it. So their, their ability to like
- 22:48keep eking out incremental gains through subscriptions is already
- 22:51hitting a wall. So they have to do ads.
- 22:53I mean, it's the only way you're going to fund this stuff.
- 22:55It's the only way that. Netflix too, another example.
- 22:57Yeah, it's the only way that by the way, that Meta and Google
- 23:00Fund, whatever they're doing, the metaverse, the glasses,
- 23:04Waymo, Alphabet, all this stuff has been built on the back of
- 23:08that. It's like literally all the
- 23:09cool, weird, sometimes failed, sometimes not crazy Moon, check.
- 23:14Moon shot technology of the last 15 years has been funded by
- 23:18advertising. Yeah, but they're also good ad
- 23:21platforms in their own way. Google and and, and Meta slash
- 23:25Facebook are because when they have really good data and
- 23:28they're monopolies for the categories that they exist in.
- 23:31And so like when it comes to search ads, you know, Google is
- 23:34the only stop shop and they also very effective and done it for a
- 23:37while. And you know, same with Meta and
- 23:39and, and Instagram ads. I don't know what the niche will
- 23:42be for chat. Like they are a monopoly within
- 23:45consumer, you know, AI chat bots.
- 23:48So, you know, the money that will exist in that world, they
- 23:52will probably consume almost all of it.
- 23:55And then obviously, you know, open AI is going directly like
- 23:58you mentioned at Google at search.
- 24:00They are kind of cutting down on search traffic and they're,
- 24:05they're eating into, you know, the amount of views that, that,
- 24:08that search get. And so I, I guess their play
- 24:11will eventually be like, well, if you know, search is getting
- 24:14less attention, you need to bring, you know, this attention
- 24:16over to, to, to, to, to chat. But what I don't know is like,
- 24:20are they going to leverage the data that they need to, in order
- 24:22to have targeted ads? Is that going to be something
- 24:25people are comfortable with? Is it like as a user experience,
- 24:28something that people will, you know, just sort of accept in the
- 24:31way that they did with, you know, news feed ads or, or
- 24:35search text ads? I mean it it is going to be a
- 24:37relatively new experience. I mean, have you guys asked chat
- 24:41CPT what it knows about you? No.
- 24:43No, let's do. That no.
- 24:45I mean, this also came up at the dinner.
- 24:47I was asking Sam about like these profiles that you have of
- 24:50people you have like probably the best advertising profile of
- 24:55an Internet user of any company on earth because of the kinds of
- 24:58things that you tell Chachi BT. And that data is probably not
- 25:02structured in a way it needs to. That's the work that Fiji and
- 25:05this team she's hiring for are going to be doing.
- 25:07And I expect that to take months.
- 25:09It's very hard to do at a platform at their scale because
- 25:12I don't think they had the foresight when ChatGPT was
- 25:14scaling that they were going to do this.
- 25:16So they have to kind of go back and rebuild the plane as it's
- 25:18flying. But there's no question this is
- 25:21going to be a powerful ad platform.
- 25:23I mean, look at what they just did with pulse.
- 25:26The thing it's it's gated right now to the 200 a month pro tier.
- 25:31But it's basically AAI agent to digest every morning that uses
- 25:36your history to say and your connectors to Gmail and whatever
- 25:39and say you should follow up on this e-mail.
- 25:41This is the the plane ticket, blah, blah, blah.
- 25:44Here's like a a bedtime story for your kid tomorrow night.
- 25:47Like Oh my God, that is an incredible ad surface.
- 25:50Wait, Tom, do you have your profile?
- 25:52Do you know what? Yeah.
- 25:52Yeah. Do you want me to read it so I
- 25:54can let lots know how to, how to advertise?
- 25:56To me it says you're really into exercise, nutrition, just
- 26:00letting people know these things.
- 26:01Yeah, these are sports, writing and work because I have maybe
- 26:06used it to to Polish a couple of leads.
- 26:10Personal life. You're from Russia.
- 26:12Interesting. It says personal life.
- 26:16You're from Russia, you had a stomach flu recently.
- 26:19You sometimes like a Jamaican patois accent when we talk about
- 26:22medication. What?
- 26:26Wait, is the last? One true.
- 26:28I don't believe all the other stuff, but please tell me the
- 26:30last one's true. So I did this is this is
- 26:33partially true. When I had covet a couple of
- 26:35weeks ago, I wanted to give it. I wanted advice from it on how
- 26:38to like monitor or to measure out which like fucking sleeping
- 26:42medications I was taking. I don't know, I was bored, I had
- 26:44COVID, I was it was my birthday, I was depressed.
- 26:47And so I was asking it to tell me like, oh, when should I take
- 26:49Nyquil? When should I take Advil?
- 26:51And then in that process I was like, can you also explain this
- 26:53stuff to me in a Jamaican soir? Did it do it?
- 26:59Yeah, it did, but I don't think I can read it on air for.
- 27:01No, you. It actually did it.
- 27:04Oh yeah, yeah. I'll send it to you later, Alex.
- 27:06Again, I don't think I could read it out loud, but it was
- 27:08very funny. I got.
- 27:09I got good mileage out of that. OK, so at least some of this is
- 27:12true. I don't know why I decided I'm
- 27:14from Russia. Are you like what it was wrong?
- 27:17Because I was very, very specific about COVID, which had
- 27:19no stomach flu. Are you have you, are you like a
- 27:21fan of Putin? Have you been like asking a lot
- 27:23for like pro Putin propaganda or what?
- 27:26I do love my strong men, Yeah. So it interpreted from that and
- 27:30then movies and culture and then other bits.
- 27:34You've asked about products such company accuracy checks.
- 27:36OK, so I do do some fact checking through ChatGPT to ask
- 27:40about Broadcom, Oracle, NVIDIA Confluent.
- 27:44That's the high level sketch. Do you want me to keep going?
- 27:46No, I don't chat. I don't.
- 27:48What's yours Alex? Let's.
- 27:50Go clean, I'm scared to do mine. Madeline, why don't you read
- 27:53yours? Well I searched mine and it
- 27:54didn't work very well because I have a separate ChatGPT account
- 27:58for my personal use and right now I'm only logged in for the
- 28:02newcomer business account so it only knows things related to me
- 28:05about business. But it does say, here's what
- 28:09I've learned about Madeline Rinbarger.
- 28:11You are an employee at Newcomer. And here's your e-mail and your
- 28:16Twitter handle. And it.
- 28:18I joined Newcomer as the publication's first reporter to
- 28:22cover startups and venture capital and previously was at
- 28:26Business Insiders. So it knows a lot about my work
- 28:28history, but it knows very little about what I like to
- 28:30search. So if I go to my personal
- 28:32account, that's where the juicy details will really lie.
- 28:34But. Yeah.
- 28:35So here's here's mine. You're I see the tech journalist
- 28:38currently launching your independent media venture.
- 28:40You're leaving The Verge where you're a deputy editor to run
- 28:42your publication sources, new companion podcast access with LS
- 28:45Hamburger. You cover the inside
- 28:47conversation, the tech industry, AI, big tech executive level
- 28:50developments. You regular interview top
- 28:52figures like Mark Zuckerberg, Sam Altman, Dylan Field, Brett
- 28:54Taylor, Andrew Bosworth. You're setting up a California
- 28:57LLC. You're evaluating credit cards
- 28:59and banking. You've been negotiating
- 29:01distribution and sponsorship deals.
- 29:03Reach out. By the way, if you're listening
- 29:04to this, you carefully think about revenue splits,
- 29:07monetization models, long term growth strategies.
- 29:09You enjoy cooking, You're into travel.
- 29:11You like film photography, You play poker.
- 29:13You enjoy gardening and plants kind of.
- 29:15I mostly ask about that for my wife.
- 29:17You like efficient direct answers and then it keeps going.
- 29:20So like this? Is that would help.
- 29:22So you're just getting pissed off at it via like you're taking
- 29:24too. Long, I don't like this, keep it
- 29:26quick. Like I don't like when the
- 29:28blowback to four O is happening. I was like, what are people
- 29:30talking about? Like I don't want this thing
- 29:32like pretending like it's my friend.
- 29:35Yeah. But.
- 29:36So you were, Yeah. No, this is like, this is like
- 29:38an advertiser's wet dream. Like.
- 29:39Yeah, it's honestly a lot more detailed than I feel like even
- 29:42on Meta. I know you can go in your
- 29:44settings and search how much from your Facebook profile it
- 29:46can glean about you. And this is, I'd say on par with
- 29:50that. So in terms of data, they're
- 29:52kind of neck and neck with Facebook there about what they
- 29:55can. I would say it's more, I would
- 29:57say it's more because it's like, it's like search, it's an intent
- 30:00based environment. Whereas meta is having to infer
- 30:04based on more passive interactions, scrolling, liking,
- 30:08sending something. Those are like, they're not.
- 30:11They're implicit, they're not explicit.
- 30:13Whereas you're literally telling Chachi PT what you want, what
- 30:16you're thinking about, your deepest, darkest secrets.
- 30:19So yeah, the, the opportunity financially is tremendous.
- 30:21The responsibility is even greater.
- 30:24And well, have you? Gotten a sense, you know, very
- 30:28early days about like where they're trying to put guardrails
- 30:30in on how data is used. I mean, I asked, I asked Sam
- 30:33about that at the dinner, and he was like, yeah, it's a huge
- 30:35responsibility. We think about it, but like,
- 30:37we'll figure it out. Yeah, by the way, you guys can
- 30:40read it later, but I threw in my Jamaican Patois answer into the
- 30:43chat again. I do not feel comfortable
- 30:46reading it out loud. It should be the cold open.
- 30:50Yeah, yeah. Well, I tried to get the voice
- 30:52to do it but. Good God.
- 30:55Yeah, no. Good thing we didn't read this.
- 30:57Yeah, I can't. We've all seen the Adrian Brody
- 31:00SNL clip, and as much as he does resemble me in some ways, I
- 31:05don't want to. I don't want to experience that
- 31:07level of cancellation. You don't want to do a Ross
- 31:09Trent bit here so. Let's talk about let's talk
- 31:13about what's going on in our socials these days with, with
- 31:16Sora 2 and and and meta vibes. Alex, I've seen you post some of
- 31:22your some of your slop on the feeds.
- 31:27The slop factory mining away. Madeline, you got an invite
- 31:32code. Have you, have you played around
- 31:33with it yet? I did, yes.
- 31:35I just started playing around with it.
- 31:37So I was, I was generating myself kind of gardening some
- 31:42strange plants. I think I was on a little
- 31:44shopkick there for a bit, but I have not.
- 31:48I have noticed that the guardrails are pretty intense
- 31:51about what it can or cannot generate.
- 31:52Like I tried to get it to generate me jumping off of the
- 31:57Empire State Building onto a Phoenix and then flying away and
- 32:01it will not let you use the prompt jump off a building.
- 32:04It will not let you generate that.
- 32:06So it actually the content moderation is pretty limiting
- 32:09honestly, from what I found a lot of stuff to do cuz avoiding,
- 32:12you know, they're really sensed about like the self harm kind of
- 32:14like dangerous images stuff. But I found that interesting
- 32:17like. You can get around it, though.
- 32:19Like I, yeah, I asked it to make me look like Superman.
- 32:22It wouldn't do it. And then I was like, you know,
- 32:23red superhero with a Cape flying.
- 32:26And it was like a mix of soups and Avengers.
- 32:28I mean, the the IP theft is, is incredible.
- 32:31There was a Wall Street Journal story that they're basically
- 32:34telling all the studios you have to opt in to not have your IP
- 32:38featured in this. So I've seen like straight up
- 32:41Pokémon. The Pokémon and and Mario and
- 32:45Luigi. Rick and Morty.
- 32:46It's struck a deal with Nintendo.
- 32:48I've seen a lot of SpongeBob too.
- 32:50Yeah, I mean, Rick and Morty, like there's no way they got all
- 32:53these deals. There's no way.
- 32:56So we're just betting that this will play out how it has with
- 32:59all the text based copyright AI stuff, which is like years of
- 33:03litigation, some settlements and by the time it really gets to
- 33:07like a ruling war on like a GII mean, I think that's the play.
- 33:11Classic tech industry play, you know, just, like, basically
- 33:14break the law or, you know, get to a point where you get sued
- 33:16for allegedly breaking the law and then pay a speeding ticket.
- 33:19Yeah. And then everyone kind of moves
- 33:20on. It's like YouTube, Viacom all
- 33:22over again. I mean, you remember.
- 33:23All Yeah, Yeah, right. And we saw what happened to the
- 33:26industry after that. I mean, it does get fairly
- 33:27depressing if you're someone who cares about that stuff.
- 33:30But the thing that I guess everyone is trying to figure out
- 33:35right now and I'm on the fence about is like, is this really
- 33:40that big of a moment, this Sora two thing that we're seeing?
- 33:43Or is it just, you know, a fad that dominates our algorithms
- 33:49for a couple of days, a week or two, and then it just kind of
- 33:51fades into the background as another kind of cool feature.
- 33:55And it's hard to have this conversation, it feels like,
- 33:57because we're in the midst of this deluge of all of this, you
- 34:02know, just being overwhelming. That's basically all I see on my
- 34:05fucking feeds right now. I mean, where do you stand on
- 34:08this? Because I think you and I are
- 34:09going to come out on different places.
- 34:10Alex The. Top three apps the.
- 34:11Maximalist argument. The top three free apps in the
- 34:13App Store right now in order are Gemini, Chachi, PT and Sora.
- 34:17So that's within like 24, not even 24 hours and.
- 34:22It's not even public access yet. It's not public access.
- 34:25The reason it's going to work and the reason it is a success
- 34:29and meta vibes was a slot failure is the cameo thing is
- 34:34being able to feature your friends opt into sharing your
- 34:38likeness with other people. Sam Altman opted into sharing
- 34:41his likeness with everyone on the app so he's like the main
- 34:43character. Like you cannot.
- 34:45If you scroll through the feed it's just non-stop like Sam
- 34:48Altman's GPU. Jokes.
- 34:49Oh yeah, Alex, I was. I was joking with Tom earlier
- 34:51that half of my Sora feed is Sam Altman and the other half is
- 34:55Jesus. So.
- 34:56Yeah, and like he wanted that, clearly.
- 34:58And like, I think you know, all these Tuxeos love attention and
- 35:01I'm sure Zuck is fuming that he's not like the main character
- 35:04of. Vibes could you have imagined if
- 35:05this the shoe was on the other foot and Vibes had a cameo
- 35:08version and you know Zuck, it should have himself up to the
- 35:11front. People would like it would.
- 35:12People like that, though. People have been meaner about
- 35:15it, you know, because people just have a natural revulsion to
- 35:17Zuck, either his personality or the.
- 35:19Technorati books, The Technorati books but normal people would
- 35:23like. Again, who's to say because it
- 35:26didn't happen, But like, Sam kind of has this, you know,
- 35:29dorky philosopher image that people, you know, lightly make
- 35:32fun of, but you don't see this level of pure hatred.
- 35:34Whereas suck, you know, really does bring a darkness out of
- 35:37people because of the way he is. I know you.
- 35:39You know you're closer to him than I am as a, you know,
- 35:42interview subject, but you think this could have happened with
- 35:46the same exact situation with with Zuck in the Sam position
- 35:49and and vibes just had this cameo feature.
- 35:51I don't know if the exact thing. I mean like chachi BT has such a
- 35:55Halo. Like the vibes are good.
- 35:57Everyone wants to know what open eye is doing.
- 35:59Like they have the they're the belle of the ball.
- 36:02Like anything they do is going to get the most attention.
- 36:04So sure, it's not the same. At the same time, I think, and I
- 36:08wrote about this in sources last night, is like, I think Meta
- 36:11fundamentally misunderstood that people.
- 36:15It's not that people don't want AI slop, it's just they want AI
- 36:18slop with their friends in it. And I think the reason people
- 36:21were. Ironic for the social media
- 36:23option you. Know the media company for the
- 36:25friend company? Yeah, for the social media
- 36:27company to not understand this, right.
- 36:29And they clearly rushed it out. I actually know this.
- 36:31They rushed it out because they knew that Sora was coming, the
- 36:35Sora app was coming and they wanted to be first.
- 36:37And they're not even using like custom models that are using Mid
- 36:39Journey and Black Forest. And it was very hacked together.
- 36:43Like the they tried to get me to write about it and and gave me
- 36:46access. I think it was the first person
- 36:48to get access like before it launched and like the metadata
- 36:51was broken. Like it was like text strings on
- 36:54the captions that weren't England.
- 36:55Like, like didn't make sense. Like it was so rushed together
- 36:59and you saw the dunking on Twitter about it because it was
- 37:02it was, it was like there was no, there was no humanity to it.
- 37:06It was just like all these crazy fantastical.
- 37:09It was like deviant art on steroids.
- 37:11And like there's a market for that.
- 37:13That's fine. Like that is an interesting
- 37:15idea, but. It's it is the news feed to a
- 37:18degree at this point. Kind of.
- 37:19I mean, the news feed at least still has people in it.
- 37:21It may not be people you want to see or it may increasingly be AI
- 37:24characters, but like the meta vibes feed is like a dog that
- 37:27looks like a Unicorn, you know, flying like into hell.
- 37:31Like it's all this crazy stuff and like Sora is like I this is
- 37:35what I call it. It's like it's AI vine.
- 37:37It's like completely what it is. It's like vine but AI generated.
- 37:40It's funny, it's light hearted, it features your friends faces,
- 37:44you know, like that's the better approach.
- 37:47Right, well, so, but then this brings us to the question,
- 37:50'cause you make the Vine comparison.
- 37:51I mean, that obviously was a phenomenon in its day.
- 37:55Gets bought by Twitter, they kind of kill the whole thing and
- 37:57and you know, Tiktok comes along to basically take short form
- 38:00video and make it into a massive industry.
- 38:03But how do you know that what's happening right now as we're in
- 38:06the heat of this moment isn't just going to be another Studio
- 38:10Ghibli moment or, you know, Facebook filters moment or MSQRD
- 38:14or any sort of thing that people kind of enjoy in that particular
- 38:18moment. It's fun.
- 38:19You can put it out there, you get some attention for it.
- 38:21And then it just was like a toy that you put back onto the shelf
- 38:24because it didn't fit intrinsically into the way you
- 38:26really want to express. Your I mean.
- 38:28Studio gets hacky. I mean, Studio Ghibli added like
- 38:31100 million users to ChatGPT, so I don't really to buy the
- 38:34argument that that was like a fad that like didn't matter.
- 38:36Well, but are these people using I'm, I'm not saying it won't
- 38:39have benefits to open AI or to ChatGPT, but I'm saying as a
- 38:42medium as a, as a mode of expression.
- 38:45Again, it's only based on what I consume through my socials.
- 38:48But like I don't see the Studio Ghibli thing happening anymore.
- 38:50It was a couple of weeks, which is more than I thought it was
- 38:53going to be. But like, you know, does this,
- 38:56you know, is this just a, a feeding mechanism for more
- 38:59people to sign up for ChatGPT? Yeah.
- 39:01Or, or I guess Sora in that. Or do you think like this is
- 39:04going to be sustained as a, you know, mode of expression as
- 39:07another way to people to create shit?
- 39:09Who knows if it will be sustained, but I think it
- 39:11clearly has, as they say, product market fit within the
- 39:151st 24 hours, which we can't say that Metavibes did so.
- 39:19Oh yeah. You know, it's #3 on the App
- 39:22Store, it'll probably be #1 at some point this week.
- 39:25It's not even open to the public.
- 39:28It's just funny. Like I've laughed when I'm on
- 39:31it, which is like something you will never say using that AI.
- 39:35And I think that says a lot. Like there's something about AI
- 39:38that is AI content that is silly and jokey and featuring people,
- 39:43you know, and their faces that is just way more approachable
- 39:46and feels like oddly human in a really strange Black Mirror way.
- 39:50But it's something you can't, it's like you can't look away
- 39:52from. At least that's my experience.
- 39:53So it's like, I mean, it's slop. Like it's not.
- 39:56I'm not pretending that this is like, you know, the same thing
- 39:59as like solving, you know, cancer with AI, but.
- 40:03I mean. Or making a real, you know,
- 40:05movie or or TV show or something.
- 40:07I mean, that's yeah, this goes off the branches off in a whole
- 40:10different discussion. But you know, anytime a tech
- 40:13video creation tool goes off in the way this one has, you do
- 40:16have people out there being like, oh, Hollywood's fucked.
- 40:18Oh, this is the only way that we're going to be making movies
- 40:20in the. Oh, it was always fucked.
- 40:22Yeah, I also just want to disregard that point.
- 40:24It's just a whole different conversation, but.
- 40:26Yeah, short form video isn't comparable to like cinema, Yeah.
- 40:30Yeah, it is its own thing. And like film festivals have a
- 40:32separate track for AI video, like they do consider it its own
- 40:35genre. For now, right now, for now, for
- 40:38now. But yeah, as a creator, you
- 40:43know, sorry, not myself as a creator, but as someone who's
- 40:45like, played around with this stuff.
- 40:47You're a creator, Tom. Don't sell yourself.
- 40:49Am I? Yeah.
- 40:50Am I? I don't know.
- 40:51I like to consider myself a philosopher influencer.
- 40:57I didn't have as much fun as I thought I was going to have on
- 40:59it. I don't know.
- 41:00I made a couple of videos. Most of them were me and Sam
- 41:02just hanging out, just sort of fulfilling my fantasies.
- 41:05But. Please do tell.
- 41:08It just, we were, you know, talking, we were podcasting.
- 41:11That's all I really think about. And you know, I, I did one video
- 41:15where it was me and Sam and we were, I turned into a mech and I
- 41:19wanted to stomp him actually, like I was going to be a giant
- 41:22mech and stomp him. But I, I I typo and I said stop
- 41:24him and it made it sound like I was trying to stop him from
- 41:27achieving AGII did a video of me like as a as a, as a man.
- 41:32This was not creative stuff. This is just my fault I guess.
- 41:36I was like a, a, a, a you got. A drink.
- 41:37I was in AI, was in a western. I was coming into town and I was
- 41:40like, kind of a like, like a baddie from the good, the bad
- 41:43and the ugly. And I was like, you know, where
- 41:46are all the tech reporters? I want them out here and I want
- 41:48them gone. That's a good.
- 41:51I don't know. Are you happy with your?
- 41:52Are you happy with your? Your sort of.
- 41:53Video I need to think about it more.
- 41:55I mean, like you, I struggle with creativity, but you know,
- 41:58it's the thing that the thing that it works about it is the
- 42:01remixing. Like, you know, Katie and the
- 42:03topless, who I would say is much better at this, will just like
- 42:06make something because I've allowed anyone to use my
- 42:08likeness and then I can remix it.
- 42:11I can be like, oh, that's an interesting idea.
- 42:12I want to like put myself in a GPU jail as I'm reading the
- 42:15newspaper about Sora hitting number one in the App Store,
- 42:17which is something I did this morning.
- 42:19And like, that's fun. That's like no other platform
- 42:22you can do this on. Like at least it's new.
- 42:24It's probably going to destroy society in some way.
- 42:28Yes. It's like I there's a really
- 42:30good argument that like, are we lighting up data centers and
- 42:33poisoning the climate to create the slop?
- 42:36Like, there's a lot of good arguments about why you
- 42:37shouldn't do this. At the same time, like, I
- 42:40laughed last night. And you know what?
- 42:41Like in launching a company, I haven't had a lot of time to
- 42:44laugh. So that was nice.
- 42:46As we saw from from your chap GPT records, none of them had
- 42:48anything to do with with mirth. There was not you, you Alex,
- 42:52either a mirthful person. I, I guess maybe like to close
- 42:56off this, this section of it like you're basically already
- 43:00described it as a success. Like it it's it's high enough on
- 43:03the App Store. It's gotten enough attention on,
- 43:06you know, our socials that this did everything that Sam wanted
- 43:09it to do. I mean, resounding, like, day
- 43:12one success. Yeah.
- 43:13I mean, I think like Meta, the largest social media company in
- 43:17the world that can like promote things on Instagram, Meta Vibes
- 43:21was not in the top 20. Anything.
- 43:23Like, no. So the vibes are the vibes are
- 43:27changing, as they say. Yeah, the vibes are off.
- 43:30What does Google need to do to respond?
- 43:32I've been having a lot of fun with Nano Banana.
- 43:34Yeah, I mean, they're #1 tool. And I think all this is showing,
- 43:37by the way, that like, people just want this AI stuff to help
- 43:39them make things and like create and be expressive.
- 43:42And honestly, reminds me of when we covered Snap Tom and they had
- 43:45all those viral moments with the face filters, which really
- 43:48propelled Snapchat through a lot of key growth moments.
- 43:51It was like face swap, the crying thing, like all of that
- 43:57was like, it was new at the time and people ate it up and it was
- 44:00viral. And it's great for a social
- 44:02product. And like, Gemini's going through
- 44:04that right now, they're #1 nano bananas, crushing, and then
- 44:08Chachi, BT is number 2, and swords #3 and it's like those
- 44:11are the three tools right now that are letting people do weird
- 44:14new things with AI that are expressive and weird and fun.
- 44:18Yeah, the fun thing with Snapchat was always so
- 44:22interesting with with Evan Spiegel because he had this
- 44:25commitment to saying Snapchat as a toy, we are not trying to, you
- 44:30know, have effects on society. He would get a little off, you
- 44:33know, that that mission at times because he would say this is
- 44:36like essential to how young people communicate and we are
- 44:39giving in the platform to express themselves in ways they
- 44:42wouldn't be able to otherwise. But and literally in the S1, he
- 44:45was saying like, this is a toy. You know, Sam has to sort of
- 44:48balance the like, we have made a fun toy with the like, yeah, we
- 44:51are curing cancer and this is going to have huge job
- 44:54displacement. And, and I don't think he's
- 44:57figured out the message yet on that.
- 44:59Exactly. Like I saw this morning, he was
- 45:02trying to like, you know, split the baby on like, well, it is
- 45:05important that we do these things because we need to show
- 45:08off what our technology is capable of doing along the way.
- 45:11And then also we'll do the AGI thing.
- 45:13It's all a step towards that. Yeah.
- 45:15I mean there's that's a debate inside Open AI.
- 45:18I mean, you've got a lot of people who join these labs to
- 45:20invent AGI and to, you know, increase GDP and create like
- 45:26amazing productivity software. And now they're being told to
- 45:28create like AI TikTok. So you're going to have a
- 45:31culture clash for sure. Yeah, yeah.
- 45:34And and it, it makes me wonder, you know, because there are
- 45:36companies out there that are still dedicated.
- 45:38I mean, basically Ilya Soskvar's company is out there saying like
- 45:42it's AGI or nothing. And I mean, you, that's
- 45:46interesting. But about this internal debate
- 45:48there, like I got to think that's a good recruitment tool
- 45:50for for SSI, right? For sure, basically.
- 45:53Say like. Even I was going to say there's
- 45:55even a bunch of other startups jumping into this space too.
- 45:58Periodic Labs came out of stealth on Tuesday and they're
- 46:02coming around. You know, they've, it was
- 46:04basically a lot of the scientists who defected from
- 46:06Open AI and DeepMind who wanted to be using this tech to, you
- 46:10know, look at the genome and discover new chemicals and do
- 46:13drug discovery and scientific discovery.
- 46:15And they basically, in my opinion, that's like, oh, there
- 46:18was this mass defection of some of these researchers who are
- 46:22motivated by meaningful work, quote, quote, you know, starting
- 46:25their own company. So it does seem like people are
- 46:27just doing this in a way where they maybe will go out and start
- 46:30their own business. Yeah, No, I think this will be I
- 46:33mean, this is a good story, wink, wink.
- 46:35But like that this culture clash of AI people building the stuff
- 46:39who want to build AGI science breakthroughs, curing cancer.
- 46:45And I would put like Demists in this camp, I would put Iliasa.
- 46:50Certainly thinks he is over at. Microsoft, I don't actually know
- 46:54what the slop is. You should have him on the pod
- 46:56and then and then I don't know if he's.
- 46:57If he's dying to talk to me, but.
- 46:59Yeah. And then Zach and then I guess
- 47:01Sam now to a degree who are like, oh, we can also do this
- 47:05slop and we can do like social and we can make this very
- 47:09consumery because we have to make a business in the near
- 47:11term. That's a culture clash for sure.
- 47:14And that's fun to cover. Yeah, and it's also it it it
- 47:17speaks to the moment that we're in where you have this whole
- 47:22group of young people younger even than than than than you,
- 47:24Alex, who are part of this AI, you know, San Francisco AI
- 47:28revolution, who are, you know, these extremely grind set don't
- 47:34even date. They're all they believe is that
- 47:37they're being part of some sort of socially transformative
- 47:40technology. And that's the only thing that
- 47:43they talk about. Like, I don't know if that's the
- 47:45entirety of the movement, but it's a it's a it's a core part
- 47:47of it. And you know, that's what's
- 47:50gotten them excited. I don't know how skillful they
- 47:52are. I don't know how important
- 47:53they're going to end up being to all of this, but like.
- 47:55Those people are you're never going.
- 47:58To have anything the 996 kids, I mean, they they don't they they
- 48:01there was a great line. There's this New York magazine
- 48:03article about them the other week that was really great.
- 48:05That was just like, most of them aren't dating, but almost all of
- 48:07them are hiring and like, what's the difference?
- 48:10That's how they view social interactions.
- 48:12And like for them, Sora 2 is not that is not the off ramp they
- 48:15want. I don't know.
- 48:16I mean, we have the, we have the Friends CEO on Access this week,
- 48:20the Access podcast, who's going viral for all those billboards.
- 48:25Oh yeah, the. Subway ads, I've seen all those
- 48:27AI pendant that you wear that your friend and he's like 22 and
- 48:32is exactly the archetype you're talking about, Tom.
- 48:34And it was really interesting to talk with him like he's already
- 48:37like, how do I build my company for AGI?
- 48:40Like a lot of these people that are that age and coming up and
- 48:43starting companies, they, there's a phrase for this.
- 48:47It's escaping me, but they're basically already like they're,
- 48:50they're rushing to build before you know, none of this matters.
- 48:54Oh yeah they're like if AGI comes by 2027 you only have like
- 48:582 years to amass generational wealth or you're the amassing
- 49:01wealth thing and. Like, yeah.
- 49:03And that really came through for me with Avi.
- 49:05Like I think there is this like like fervor and like insane
- 49:11drive to do as much as possible in a short amount of time and
- 49:15like open AI basically. Collect.
- 49:17Personified. Collect as much before none of
- 49:19it matters anymore. Just like fill your bag with
- 49:22lucre before the whole fucking thing.
- 49:23Just like goes goes under. Yeah, what a fun time to be
- 49:27alive. The perfect place.
- 49:30To end the episode. And I got a podcast plug in.
- 49:34Look at that. Yeah, yeah.
- 49:36Well, by the way, I mean, since we're we're winding down here
- 49:39and you've mentioned it a couple times, you've done a good job
- 49:41plugging yourself, but is there anything you want to mention?
- 49:44I mean, we didn't really tee it up in the episode, but like, you
- 49:46recently left The Verge, you know, you are a creator and an
- 49:52influencer and maybe. You've joined us in newsletter
- 49:55World Independent Media. Yeah, I'm on sub Stack sources
- 49:59dot news, the Access podcast with Ellis Hamburger and Vox
- 50:03Media, A former Snap employee, Tom.
- 50:05Former SNAP employee. Sorry, Madeline, you're probably
- 50:07like, why are these guys talking about Snap?
- 50:09Like, I don't think about Snap at all.
- 50:11And it's because we, no two people on earth have devoted as
- 50:15much reporting, thinking power to Snap as Tom and I.
- 50:18So of course we're going to talk about it on the spot.
- 50:20The amount of times that I on vacation felt it necessary to
- 50:23discuss people that like, oh, you know, there's a shake up in
- 50:26the growth group. It was a simpler time, you know.
- 50:29See, I love that I love harkening back to the the social
- 50:33media awards days is quaint for me is that reporter during.
- 50:36The AI, it was like talking about like the young kids, you
- 50:39know, running, you know, the, the, the AI scene.
- 50:41And certainly like young reporters, they do not
- 50:44understand and give a fuck about the Snapchat days.
- 50:47It is of 0 interest to them. I was like, man, you don't
- 50:49understand. This was the open AI of its
- 50:51time. Like the chaos within that
- 50:52company mattered so much to people.
- 50:54And now I just sound old. We're old, It's OK.
- 50:59We're old. It's OK.
- 50:59You're not old. Well, you can keep generating
- 51:02Sora videos of youth. It'll be great.
- 51:04Yeah, All my prompts are like at Tom D'oton, but younger Sam
- 51:09Ultimate. Yeah.
- 51:10Yeah, it is. Very.
- 51:11We're beautiful. It is very weird to be meeting
- 51:13founders who like are have businesses with millions in ARR
- 51:17and it's like, oh, you're 10 years younger than me.
- 51:19Yeah, it does make you feel really old.
- 51:21But yeah, no. Anyway, I'm sources, not news.
- 51:24Check me out. And yeah, thanks for having me
- 51:28guys. This is fun all.
- 51:29Right. Thanks for doing it, Alex.
- 51:30Yeah. Thanks again for tuning into
- 51:32this episode of the Newcomer Podcast and shout out Alex Heath
- 51:36for joining us. That was a lot of fun.
- 51:37If you're new here, please like and subscribe.
- 51:40It really helps out our channel and listen to new episodes every
- 51:43week wherever you get your podcasts.