Latest / Energy Voice – Out Loud / EVOL X Brookson Legal: Live from Offshore Europe
Transcript
- 0:05Erica Askeland here at Offshore Europe and I'm here with Marcus
- 0:10Kenny, Head of End Hirer at Brooks and Legal.
- 0:14Welcome to Offshore Europe. Thank you, Erica.
- 0:16Very good, lovely to see you again.
- 0:18So we saw you at the P and JDC Thompson offices last night.
- 0:23We had a really great chat, but you know, one of the great
- 0:26things about what we were discussing was the key question.
- 0:31Now Brooks and Legal specializes in advising employers,
- 0:36particularly on IR 35. But first just tell us what is
- 0:41IR 35? Absolutely, Erica.
- 0:43So IR 35 is a piece of legislation that's been brought
- 0:47in to mitigate risk around engaging contractors correctly.
- 0:52So ultimately what the business, what the business is aimed to do
- 0:56is engage a contractor that is a specialised contractor, a
- 0:59subject matter expert, somebody who is not in a business as
- 1:04usual role. Mm hmm.
- 1:05Yeah. Now contractors can work in any
- 1:10field, any sector. There's a lot of them in oil and
- 1:14gas, and we've been seeing them a lot, which is presumably why
- 1:17Brixon Legal has you here in, you know, this locality.
- 1:22But you know, you guys are also working with the likes of
- 1:25Netflix. And tell us a bit about the
- 1:27glamorous side. Absolutely.
- 1:29So we we work with multiple sectors and obviously oil and
- 1:33gas is a big sector for contractors.
- 1:35But the if you look at TV movie series, they're growing rapidly.
- 1:41There are more series coming out every week.
- 1:43And with that there needs to be set building, set construction,
- 1:47joinery, etcetera. And it was a new sector for us
- 1:50to dive into having not really considered it before.
- 1:53So these sectors are really interesting in the fact that
- 1:56they engage contractors to do something that is behind the
- 2:00camera. So there's a lot of behind the
- 2:02camera work that we support businesses with.
- 2:05So yes, some very glamorous clients, absolutely.
- 2:09I expect no less. I expect no less.
- 2:12But the trouble with IR 35, you know, for contractors and
- 2:17employers, there's a difference, isn't there?
- 2:20There's inside and there's outside.
- 2:23So if you're inside, you have like the extra costs like PAYE
- 2:29and all that sort of stuff, pension contributions where if
- 2:32you're outside it's all cash, more cash maybe so, but how does
- 2:37that, what is the kind of current issues with IR 35?
- 2:42There's a there was a big change in 2021.
- 2:45Absolutely. So the legislation previously
- 2:48stated that the responsibility of determining whether you were
- 2:52inside of IR 35, in other words paying contributions or you were
- 2:57outside of IR 35, was down to the contractor themselves.
- 3:01And as you can imagine, with them being responsible, a lot of
- 3:05those people were saying they were all outside of IR 35, which
- 3:09meant that the government were missing out on contributions.
- 3:12The legislation changed. It was changed in 2000 and 1617
- 3:17for the public sector and then it was aimed to be brought in in
- 3:202020 for the private sector. However, due to COVID, that was
- 3:25pushed back another year. So April the 6th, 2021 was when
- 3:29this legislation was brought in to the private sector.
- 3:33Now that changed immediately overnight.
- 3:35So April the 5th the contractor is still responsible for doing
- 3:38the IR 35 determination. However, April the 6th, it was
- 3:42down to the employer to do that determination.
- 3:45A lot of organisations weren't prepared for that.
- 3:48They might have thought they were prepared, but they weren't
- 3:50really prepared for the scale of what needed to be done.
- 3:53And this is a very, very niche piece of legislation, meaning
- 3:58ultimately that these companies need to have a specialist
- 4:01resource in house or outsource it to someone like Brooks and
- 4:05Legal. Well, see, I mean, I think when
- 4:08you have a big legislative change, because Brooks and
- 4:12Legal's model changed, didn't it?
- 4:13It was working with contractors. It shifted to working with
- 4:17employers. But I mean, these things change.
- 4:20And, you know, you're almost worried about the impact.
- 4:22It's like an existential threat, but you've adapted.
- 4:25But you've adapted 'cause what actually you need is to ensure
- 4:32that employers can manage what is a very significant cultural
- 4:37change because they have to persuade their workforce,
- 4:41whether it's contractors or inside, and get them into
- 4:44employment. They have to persuade them to do
- 4:47this. And so is that what you're
- 4:50focused on? Is that how you help?
- 4:52Absolutely. So we, we help obviously from a
- 4:54process compliance governance perspective.
- 4:57But I would say our biggest impact is that cultural or
- 5:01educational shift within these organisations.
- 5:04As you can imagine, if we look specifically, we're here today
- 5:07at the offshore Europe, if we look at all of these
- 5:09organisations that are around us, each and what each and every
- 5:14one of these organisations will employ a contractor in some
- 5:17capacity, but it's whether are they employing a subject matter
- 5:20expert or are they employing a, a business as usual role.
- 5:24And it's really about understanding the nuance between
- 5:27those. Now you, you'll know yourself in
- 5:30the world that we we live in today that projects scale up and
- 5:34scale down and you need a workforce that can scale up and
- 5:37scale down to match that. So for us, it was very much
- 5:40about educating these businesses on how to sustainably grow but
- 5:46also supercharge your growth by having a compliant, robust IR 35
- 5:51process that is managed by professional legals,
- 5:55professional legal professionals like ourselves who are here to
- 6:00educate businesses, mitigate risk, improve compliance and
- 6:04improved process so that these organisations can quickly scale
- 6:09up to deliver against the project and then quickly drop
- 6:11off again. It allows them to have that
- 6:13flexible workforce doing it compliantly with minimal risk,
- 6:18minimal liability. So you keep on talking about
- 6:22compliance because I think the issue is, is if you as an
- 6:27employer are not compliant, guess what, HMRC ain't gonna
- 6:31like that. So I mean, what kind of like
- 6:33sanctions do employers risk if they don't toe the line?
- 6:38It's complex stuff, right? Absolutely, extremely complex
- 6:41and now what we find today, we've not had any major
- 6:44announcements in the private sector in terms of organisations
- 6:48that have been penalised or fined.
- 6:50We know that that is coming absolutely 100%, but we do know
- 6:56as well that there are hundreds of organisations that have been
- 6:59approached by HMRC. What they really need to
- 7:04understand from a from a compliance perspective is are
- 7:08they demonstrating reasonable care as an organization?
- 7:11Now reasonable care constitutes having a robust process in
- 7:15place. Having a professional services
- 7:19organization working in partnership with you to build
- 7:22your process, your frameworks around compliance and governance
- 7:25to make sure that they are engaging their flexible
- 7:28workforce correctly. Now if they're not doing that,
- 7:31there are multiple fines and penalties.
- 7:33Absolutely. So if they have not paid the
- 7:36relevant contributions to a contractor that was should have
- 7:39been inside, but they've been paying them gross.
- 7:41As an outside contractor, you will have a legacy.
- 7:45Now that legacy could be, at the moment it's four years since the
- 7:48legislation came in. HMRC can go back seven years.
- 7:53So these organisations need to be aware of all of this.
- 7:56But not only that, you can be prosecuted as ACEO if you are
- 8:00not following the relevant guidelines, but are also
- 8:04demonstrating that you are trying to evade doing this
- 8:07correctly. So it's extremely risky to not
- 8:10engage it correctly, but it's also extremely risky to think
- 8:14you're doing it correctly and not quantifying that.
- 8:17So we as an organization we will on many occasions parachuting,
- 8:22retrospectively review their processes and their audits and
- 8:26assist them in ring fencing any potential liabilities whilst
- 8:29building a future proof process for them that is absolutely
- 8:33compliant. So if this legislation has been
- 8:36in place since 2021, why is it only now that HMRC is cracking
- 8:41down? So this legislation has actually
- 8:43been around for 26 years, but this, this piece of legislation
- 8:49has shifted since 21. Now organisations are on board.
- 8:54Absolutely, most organisations understand what their commitment
- 8:58is to engaging flexible workers, but it's whether they are
- 9:02committed to going all out or trying to do it themselves in
- 9:08house. Now I suppose a, a, a way of
- 9:13thinking about this is there are a number of providers in the
- 9:16market that can support organisations from an IR 35
- 9:19perspective. However, we're the only law firm
- 9:22in the whole of the UK that specialized in this niche piece
- 9:25of legislation. And ultimately it's like
- 9:29anything. If you want to pay for a cheap
- 9:33pair of jeans they will only last so long.
- 9:36No different to IR 35. If you want a cheap process it
- 9:40will do a short term job but it won't last the test of time and
- 9:44ultimately HMRC would identify risk non compliance and RIP the
- 9:49process up. So for us it's very much about
- 9:52this legislation is here to stay, do it correctly.
- 9:57I understand what your obligations are as an
- 9:59organization, but also understand what your business is
- 10:04and what their strategy is for the next 1224 thirty six months
- 10:07so you can forecast when you might need to flex up and flex
- 10:10down as a business. You know what, you know, we're
- 10:13here at Offshore Europe. You know, a lot of employers, a
- 10:18lot of businesses are maybe kind of like having uncertainty.
- 10:22I mean, there's always uncertainty, but I think in
- 10:26uncertain times, workforce flexibility can kind of be your
- 10:31friend, absolutely, but you have to do it right, I suppose.
- 10:34Yeah. And I suppose for us it is
- 10:39difficult to get the message across that being compliant and
- 10:43compliance isn't everybody's topic, but being compliant.
- 10:47The C word. Absolutely.
- 10:49Compliance governance, 2 words that I wouldn't really put next
- 10:54to strategy and super growth. But absolutely if you are
- 10:58extremely compliant and you build a robust process from the
- 11:01start, it allows you that flexibility to supercharge your
- 11:05growth. You will attract talent the
- 11:07other operators in the market will not be able to do because
- 11:11they don't have such a robust process.
- 11:12Having a robust process allows you to get more contractors
- 11:16outside of IR 35 because you are meeting the requirements of the
- 11:20legislation. The more outside IR 35, the more
- 11:23attractive you are as an organization.
- 11:25Well, the answer is clear. Marcus, thank you ever so much
- 11:29for joining us on this stand. We've been talking to Marcus
- 11:32Kenny from Brooks and Legal, and we're going back to the show.
- 11:36Thank you.