Latest / Janoub Podcast / Yemen, with Afrah Nasser
Transcript
- Sherif Mansour: Hello everyone, welcome to the JANU podcast. I am honored today to have a very special guest, Afrah Nasr, a Yemeni journalist, an award-winning journalist, a researcher, a visiting fellow at the Arab Center, and also a good friend. Afrah is gonna talk to us about Yemen today, the tensions surrounding it, and it couldn't have been any more timely for me as an Egyptian. We have scheduled this talk before the Egyptian government have said that they are going to help Saudi Arabia with troops in the war in Yemen. The events are going rapidly. We'll try today not to focus on the news, but on the perspective of someone who is both Yemeni, Ethiopian, a journalist, a researcher, and above all, someone who can give the global South's perspective about current events. Afrah, thank you. I hope. You have a chance also to introduce yourself the way you want to be introduced. Go ahead. Afrah Nasser: Yeah, yes. Thank you. Thank you, Sharif. it's a pleasure to be in your podcast and your new initiative, Global South. And and I think Yemen fits very well in in your approach and your The print that you want to leave in this world. So yes, my name is Afrah Nasser. we go very back, you and me, as friends and fellows defending human rights at different international platforms. I remember vividly when we met I think in in person, in like face to face, the first time it was in the UN Human Rights Council. where we were talking like that was during the beginning of the war in in yemen in 2015. So I've worked as a journalist in Yemen. I'm from Sanaha. I I led a blog about Yemen's uprising in 2011. And since then I freelanced as an independent journalist with many media outlets. and recently I worked also at the UN Envoy For Yemen office in Jordan, and currently I am a fellow at the Arab Center in Washington DC. And if I'm not writing about Yemen, I'm reading about Yemen. So this is this is this sums up my career so far in the past 18 years. Sherif Mansour: Thank you, Afrah. We also remember the time after we first met. It was when the Committee to Protect Journalists gave you an award and you had trouble coming to the U.S. getting a visa even as someone who was Yemeni at the time. was 2017. But even when you used your European passport, they would reject your visa. And I called racism on that one. And I remember having Christiane Amanpour writing a letter to State Department to help you get the visa. And eventually you came, she handed you the award. And you mentioned her as a model, an example that you as a young kid would look at the TV and say, I want to be that person one day. That's why you want to be a journalist. How have that changed over the last 10 years in your words? Afrah Nasser: Yes. you took me back to two thousand seventeen, when Committee to Protect Journalists and you were like heading the Middle East department in the organization and called me that I was awarded among other three journalists the international f press freedom award at that time. And I remember like like the whole struggle with coming to the US, although I was like, you know, Yemeni and also I had my Swedish passport. It just it like it it really it was very ironic for me because I was always like covering Yemenis, like they were the stories and then suddenly I became the story. So so that i to me that was so ironic. Like it was it was eye-opening. Like the the plight of Yemenis is so real. The marginalization is so real. But overall, like when I think about my experience with Committee to Protect Journalists and the Award at that time, and what is happening to t today to a lot of journalists, especially in like our colleagues in in Gaza with the genocide. It makes me think about who is like a worthy victim and who's unworthy fi victim in the the new context of the genocide that we are in. unfortunately like the the the plight of journalists in palestine and gazza doesn't get the the attention and action that it deserves globally and especially from like steam esteemed international organizations like committee to protect journalists so there is no doubt that that time it was like innocence time I remember when I was taking the award from Kristiana Amanpur and I was like, you know, she was delivering the pr the prize and I was like be careful of what you wish for. it was like you know, as if I was manifesting that moment all all these years and it happened. And I and I think we need also another manifestation where it where there is like a bigger equality and justice for everyone in global south and everyone is worthy victims, regardless of their color, ethnicity, location, religion. you know all of this. You've you've talked about this in your podcast for many, many and and since you left CPJ also. Sherif Mansour: Thank you. And just this week, Christiane Amanpour have announced that she is leaving CNN, leaving behind her legacy, but also her attempt within CNN to fight against Israeli censorship and also against this upcoming merger, which could make CNN also a lot worse and less independent. I'll leave it at that. I just wanted to move to the point that you have done work from inside Yemen as a journalist from exile. You were able to come back after the uprising and even after you won the award and you have had that experience of being inside also UN rooms talking to policymakers. You think Yemen is the most forgotten kind of humanitarian crisis over the last 10 years? Afrah Nasser: So yes, I have a different perspective today. Like since I started journalism in in two thousand and and and and eight I like at that time my awareness was when I was inside Yemen like was was Yemen is very important and we are as we say in in Yemen and Asl Arab, we are the origin of Arabs and we had that pride like living in in Yemen in that bubble, you know? And then and I think that kind of gave me the courage to start the blog and write with this confidence that I will speak about Yemen in English to the international audience. When at that time in 2000 and and eight or or nine, we were not many Yemenis writing in English about Yemen inside Yemen. And then that awareness changed and and evolved into something very different when I lived in in Europe and Sweden, and my interaction with international journalists and the international audience was that Yemen was neglected and forgotten and not important. but today I can tell you like it's a mix of both. Like Yemen is important and not important. And you can see this when Yemen is suddenly breaking news all over like the the international media when there is a bomb, there is explosion, there is the you know the the Strait of of Babel Menda, the Houthis. And this question always comes up who are the Houthis? Who are the Houthis? We already told you, like, so there is this surge that comes when there is something happening in Yemen, it becomes suddenly important and not forgotten. But once the explosion is off, once everything stops, Yemen slides under you know the the carpet and it's not important anymore. And my conclusion is that unfortunately we live in a world where The international media, the mainstream international media, dominates media in general. and they dictate what is important and what is the breaking news, what is not. and this kind of like on and off coverage on Yemen, where it's w at one time it's important, at what not w another time it's not important. makes Yemeni portrayed in in those media outlets as only victims. They're portrayed as victims, where like, you know, they're a political agency is hidden, the roots of the conflicts is hidden, and it it undermines international public opinion pressure on peace, on conflict resolution in Yemen and diplomat international diplomatic efforts also. So if there is someone listening to us from our fellow Western journalists I would just tell them like keep on covering Yemen, not only when it's breaking news, because as you can see, Yemen is like what happens in Yemen impacts global economy. So it's of your interest to cover Yemen. Of course, like Yemenis have like a bigger pride than just, you know, boxing Yemen in in a global economy or whatever. But I think from a Western journalist perspective, this is like you know, a niche for you where you have to keep on covering Yemen regardless if it's breaking news or not. Sherif Mansour: You also kind of talked in the past about regional dynamics and connecting both origins of your own story, Ethiopia and Yemen, to the Horn of Africa and Bab al-Mandab. You've talked about how it has been futile for now a long time for Saudi and its coalition. including US and other allies, Israeli and other, to just rely on bombing in order to continue the humanitarian suffering but achieving no strategic or military goal. Have that changed recently and what do you think the recent escalations impact not just the Gulf countries but also The Horn of Africa. Afrah Nasser: It's interesting you brought up Ethiopia. It's just to me it's it's a huge headache that the war in both countries in in Yemen and Ethiopia where I have roots have reserved resumed at the same time. And it's been Unbelievably triggering for me. Just what my grandfathers have gone through, what my parents have gone through, and then we're just in this continuous cycle of of violence, death, misery. I cannot tell you like all the calls I have from people inside Yemen or in Ethiopia, because I I I still have like some relatives in Ethiopia as well. The the level of misery pessimism and agony I I just cannot describe. Like I I get like goosebumps thinking about it. look the way to like the way to deal with all these conflicts without dealing with the the the the core the the core reasons of why the conflicts began It's it's a recipe for another conflict coming on your way. Like we cannot like we cannot expect these countries will have stable and flourishing nations with peace, stability, justice, without dealing with the deep roots of the problem. I've seen that in Ethiopia, in Ethiopia's civil war in the seventies, eighties. And I see it now in Yemen. Like this is what happened in the sixties, you know, with the Houthis taking over of Sana in two thousand fourteen, to where we are today. Even with the atrocities that the Saudi-led coalition committed in Yemen, like nobody dealt about that. I wrote a I wrote a piece about the war like when when when the UAE left Yemen earlier this year, nobody talked about the w the war crimes that it imprint imprinted in Yemen. And I wrote a piece about that and it didn't get much attention. And it was like, of course, like it Like it's as if the international community want these countries to continue with wars and arms sales flourishing where we see contracts between the US and European arms factories with the Gulf States, Saudi Arabia in particular, we're talking about billions of dollars contracts. So so without dealing with the deep roots of the of the conflicts, we can like, I don't know, just have like wishful thinking that the the war or the escalation will ease at some point or there will be peace. but if we talk about Yemen in particular, you have to have a multi multi layered intervention to to end the Houthis threat because Houthis are not like they're no more Yemeni problem. They're like a global a regional problem, an international problem. And I think there is no one single way to deal with the Houthis. It has to be like from a multi-layered, different directions. And and I leave that to, you know, to the military experts and political experts to to think of how so it's it's just so like it it's just ridiculous to simplify dealing with Houthis with just one one single method. Sherif Mansour: You also wrote and said that peace in Yemen has to start from the bottom up. And I have also earlier on this podcast discussed in Sudan with women rights advocates, their role in discussing peace, in influencing negotiations and the need for them to be on the table. And at some point I wanted also to discuss regional accountability because in some ways what I've discussed with my Ethiopian friend last episode is that we in Egypt and Ethiopia have used Sudan as a proxy battlefield. And unfortunately, Yemen is a proxy battlefield right now and accountability has to be bottom up but also regional. Afrah Nasser: Yeah, go ahead. Sherif Mansour: I want to ask where do you think some hope in terms of the efforts of women leading peace process, seeking accountability, and also basically surviving? Because they are the ones who are now impacted the most with 250,000 people forced out. facing all humanitarian crisis, hunger and other violations. How do they survive and what role they should play in impacting what's happening to them? Afrah Nasser: Yeah, so You know, the warring parties in Yemen they fight about everything, but the one thing they agree on is excluding women. It's just amazing like how women are a threat to their political work, their diplomatic work, or whatever room, if it's negotiation or organization or whatever it is, they they don't want the women to be in the room. I say that with keeping in mind that the Yemeni government recently have appointed around three or four female ministers. And from my you know, like insights with contacts from people within the Yemeni government, those appointments of these women came as a pressure by the international community, not as a genuine like feminist struggle or. or you know, like a desire from the government itself for gender equality or whatever. So so it is just a d decoration, you know, it's just a decor. and it doesn't really reflect what you just mentioned, like how women are working in a bottom-up approach. if we go back to Yemen, Now, if we go to every village, there is a lot of women that are doing the hard work where they're doing conflict resolution within one village and another. And there are a lot of y women who are community leaders that we don't know about. They they don't, you know, promote themselves on social media as others do. And I had the chance to speak to some of them while working at the UN Envoy office because I were I was working in the gender inclusion department. And it's just fascinating what women are doing in Yemen, holding the society together, holding the social fabric, whatever remains of it together. But From my experience, I, you know, I I speak to media and podcasts like this many, many times. And like every time I am in a panel with other Yemeni male panelists, it's just so bizarre the emotional distance they have to the to the Yemeni cause in general. And I learned something that We Yemeni women, if we're given the chance, this war will be over very, very soon. Because we are invested emotionally, spiritually, in our land, and in the talk that we talk, in the work that we do, in the money that we send to our families, in the jobs that we do to support other fa our families, unlike the male mentality in Yemen, I with no exaggeration, the male mentality today in Yemen it's just all about war. It's all about propaganda, it's all about you know just putting the drum for this side against this side, as if they forgot what unites every Yemeni, which is the land, the nation. So I I just hope. Yemeni women are given the chance, like like you know, organic, like true chance to lead conflict resolutions on on the multi-layered, on the ground, on the international level, regional level. I just really hope that will will happen very soon. there are a lot of mobilization that happen behind closed doors, but They're just waiting for the for for the right, you know, opportunity. Sherif Mansour: Thank you, and you touched on another nerve here, I think, when we discussed Sudan, the exclusion of women. And in some ways, that also what I'm going to discuss next week, talking about Afghanistan, another governing system who have women apartheid. And in some ways, it's... fitting going through the list and also making sure that women voices are heard. I want to end with another apology when I think people have expected me to do that every episode. Now I have done it for Gaza as an Egyptian and I've done it for Ethiopia as an Egyptian and in some ways Yemen. kind of fit in the same pattern of how the Egyptian government, not just now, but historically, have put its influence on the wrong side of history. And I hope that whatever the Egyptian government decide to do and the Saudis is not gonna mean more suffering for Yemenis on the hand of the Egyptian than others. regional partners. Is there anything you want to leave with for our audience that makes you hopeful or you want to share? Afrah Nasser: Can I can I say something just about Egypt just quickly? Sherif Mansour: Yes. Afrah Nasser: I want to say about Egypt's potential role in the conflict in Yemen, that there is a lot of analysis going on about what will happen, what it will not happen. And I think it's just too excitement and and and we we have not seen anything yet about the shape of that role yet. Even like, you know, a few months ago with the pact between Saudi Arabia and Pakistan and Turkey, it didn't materialize anything on the ground. So maybe it's just you know, kind of a PR thing. maybe it's too soon to to judge the role. so I just want like, you know, to say that it's still unknown what that role will be and and def but definitely Egypt is impacted by economically by what's happening in the Red Sea. so we have to keep that in mind. What keeps me hopeful You know, I I don't know where I read this, but I read somewhere that tyranny, tyranny's best tools is desperation and depression and despair of the people. So if we have that despair, I think we're giving it to tyranny and dictatorship and you know, autocracy and and all these injustices in in the word. So what gives me hope is that resistance is within me. It's just not to despair. Sherif Mansour: Afrah, thank you very much for giving us your time. I am hopeful because of people like you and hopefully there will be another chance when you come back to the podcast and it's going to be a better time for Yemenis and for Egyptians. Thank you again and have a good rest of your day. Afrah Nasser: Thank you. Thank you so much, Sharif.