Latest / Kentucky Tonight / State & National Politics and Political Discourse
Transcript
- 0:02[♪♪]
- 0:10>> GOOD EVENING.
- 0:11WELCOME TO KENTUCKY TONIGHT.
- 0:11I'M RENEE SHAW.
- 0:12THANKS FOR JOINING US.
- 0:16OUR TOPIC TONIGHT: STATE AND
- 0:17NATIONAL POLITICS AND POLITICAL
- 0:18DISCOURSE.
- 0:19THE SHOOTING DEATH OF
- 0:21CONSERVATIVE ACTIVIST CHARLIE
- 0:22KIRK LAST WEDNESDAY IS PROMPTING
- 0:24A RENEWED DEBATE ABOUT THE TONE
- 0:25AND LANGUAGE OF MODERN AMERICAN
- 0:26POLITICS.
- 0:28AMONG THE QUESTIONS PEOPLE ARE
- 0:31ASKING: WHERE IS THE DIVIDING
- 0:32LINE BETWEEN LEGITIMATE
- 0:33CRITICISM AND HATE SPEECH?
- 0:35WHAT KIND OF LANGUAGE GOES “TOO
- 0:36FAR?”
- 0:38GIVEN THE INTENSE RESPONSE TO
- 0:39KIRK’S DEATH, WHERE DO WE GO
- 0:40FROM HERE?
- 0:42WE WILL ALSO TALK ABOUT OTHER
- 0:44POLITICAL MATTERS, INCLUDING
- 0:45KENTUCKY’S 2026 U.S. SENATE
- 0:46RACE.
- 0:48WE’RE JOINED IN LEXINGTON BY:
- 0:50AMY WICKLIFFE, A REPUBLICAN
- 0:52STRATEGIST AND PARTNER WITH
- 0:53MCCARTHY STRATEGIC SOLUTIONS;
- 0:56JONATHAN MILLER, A DEMOCRAT AND
- 0:57AN ATTORNEY WITH FROST BROWN
- 0:58TODD;
- 0:59AND TRES WATSON, A REPUBLICAN
- 1:01CONSULTANT, FOUNDER OF CAPITOL
- 1:02REINS PR, AND HOST OF THE
- 1:04KENTUCKY POLITICS WEEKLY
- 1:05PODCAST;
- 1:07AND IN OUR LOUISVILLE STUDIO:
- 1:08SHERMAN BROWN, A DEMOCRATIC
- 1:10STRATEGIST AND PARTNER WITH
- 1:11MCCARTHY STRATEGIC SOLUTIONS.
- 1:14WE WANT TO HEAR FROM YOU.
- 1:16YOU CAN SEND YOUR QUESTIONS AND
- 1:17COMMENTS BY X — FORMERLY TWITTER
- 1:19-- AT PUB AFFAIRS KET.
- 1:22SEND AN EMAIL TO K-Y TONIGHT AT
- 1:23K-E-T DOT O-R-G.
- 1:25OR USE THE WEB FORM AT K-E-T DOT
- 1:27O-R-G SLASH K-Y TONIGHT.
- 1:28OR YOU CAN CALL 1-800-494-7605.
- 1:29WELCOME TO ALL OUR GUESTS.
- 1:38BECAUSE WE OFTEN SAY THAT
- 1:40"KENTUCKY TONIGHT" IS THE TABLE
- 1:41WHERE THE HARD CONVERSATIONS ARE
- 1:43HAD.
- 1:44AND THIS IS INDEED, GOING TO BE
- 1:46A HARD CONVERSATION AND OUR
- 1:47THOUGHTS AND PRAYERS GO OUT TO
- 1:49THE FAMILY OF CHARLIE KIRK, OF
- 1:50COURSE AND ALL OF THOSE WHO HAVE
- 1:53SUFFERED GUN VIOLENCE AND OTHER
- 1:55POLITICAL ACTS OF VIOLENCE.
- 1:57SO AS WE VIEW THIS DEBATE NOW,
- 2:01IN LIGHT OF WHAT'S HAPPENED IN
- 2:02THE LAST FIVE TO SEVEN DAYS, IS
- 2:05THERE ROOM, JONATHAN MILLER FOR
- 2:07TWO THINGS TO BE TRUE?
- 2:08THAT WE CAN DENOUNCE OUT RIGHT
- 2:11THE VIOLENCE THE POLITICAL
- 2:13VIOLENCE THAT CLAIMED THE LIFE
- 2:15OF THIS CRIST WHILE NOT
- 2:18SILENCING SPEAK THAT IS CRITICAL
- 2:22OF THE SPEECH HE USED?
- 2:23>> ABSOLUTELY AND THAT IS WHAT
- 2:25THE FIRST AMENDMENT IS ABOUT AND
- 2:26WHAT CHARLIE KIRK WAS ABOUT IN
- 2:28TERMS OF TRYING TO STIMULATE
- 2:32DEBATE AND IMPASSIONED DEBATE.
- 2:34THE QUESTION FOR THE COUNTRY
- 2:35RIGHT NOW, I THINK, WE ARE TO
- 2:40PLAGUER RISE FROM CHARLIE KIRK
- 2:42WE ARE AT A TURNING POINT AND
- 2:44WILL WE FOLLOW THE PATH SET BY
- 2:46FOLKS LIKE THE GOVERNOR OF UTAH,
- 2:48CALLING FOR TEMPERS TO BE
- 2:53AABATED AND TRY AND FIND MORE
- 2:55COMMON GROUND OR FOLLOW THE PATH
- 2:57OF TOO MANY POLITICIANS OVER THE
- 2:58LAST WEEK WHO HAVE ENGAGED IN
- 3:01BLAME SHIFTING AND POINT SCORING
- 3:03AND TRYING TO USE THIS AS A WAY
- 3:06TO BUILDUP THEMSELVES OR TEAR
- 3:08OTHER PEOPLE DOWN.
- 3:09IF IT'S THE LATTER PATH, I THINK
- 3:12WE'RE GOING TO HAVE TOUGH MONTHS
- 3:15AHEAD.
- 3:15>> Renee: WHERE DO YOU SEE
- 3:16THINGS, AMY WICKLIFFE?
- 3:17>> I THINK WHERE WE GO FROM HERE
- 3:20IS ON US, ALL OF US.
- 3:22TO QUOTE THE GOVERNOR COX AGAIN,
- 3:24I THINK HE WAS THE PERSON WE
- 3:26NEEDED IN THAT MOMENT WITH HOW
- 3:28HE COMMUNICATED TO THE NATION.
- 3:29AS HE SAID, THIS IS WHERE WE
- 3:31CHOOSE DO WE ESCALATE?
- 3:33OR DO WE FIND THE OFF-RAMP?
- 3:36AND I'M VERY CONCERNED IF WE DO
- 3:38NOT FIND THAT OFF-RAMP VERY SOON
- 3:40THAT OUR NATION THERE'S A LOT AT
- 3:42STAKE.
- 3:43WHAT WE'VE SEEN IS A STAIN ON
- 3:45OUR DEMOCRACY.
- 3:46RIGHT?
- 3:48AND I'M VERY WORRIED THAT IF WE
- 3:50DO NOT HAVE LEADERS FROM THE TOP
- 3:51DOWN AND THAT INCLUDES THE WHITE
- 3:53HOUSE ALL THE WAY DOWN TO OUR
- 3:55LOCAL GOVERNMENTS CALL FOR
- 3:57TAKING THE RHETORIC DOWN AND
- 3:59TAKING THE TEMPERATURE DOWN AND
- 4:02WHAT MATTERS IN THIS WORLD AND
- 4:04RECOGNIZING THAT EACH OF US ARE
- 4:06MOTHERS, SISTERS, BROTHERS,
- 4:08DADS, WE'RE HUMAN.
- 4:10AND THE MOMENT THAT WE FORGET
- 4:11THAT AND THE MOMENT WE FORGET WE
- 4:13ARE ALL AMERICANS, IS VERY
- 4:15TROUBLING FOR ME TO WATCH.
- 4:17>> Renee: WE'RE SEEING A LOT
- 4:18DEVELOP TODAY, TRES WATSON WE'RE
- 4:21HEARING OF FIRINGS OF PEOPLE
- 4:22FROM THEIR PLACES OF EMPLOYMENT
- 4:24BECAUSE OF HOW THEY'VE RESPONDED
- 4:26AND WE ARE JUST CONCERNED MANY
- 4:27ARE, ABOUT THE DIRECTION OF
- 4:29WHERE WE GO FROM HERE.
- 4:31HOW DO YOU SIZE UP WHERE WE ARE
- 4:33AT THIS PARTICULAR MOMENT?
- 4:35>> IT'S HARD TO WALK BACK FROM
- 4:38WHERE WE ARE RIGHT NOW, BECAUSE
- 4:40OF SOMETHING THAT MAKES THIS
- 4:42COUNTRY GREAT WHICH IS THE FIRST
- 4:43AMENDMENT.
- 4:44NO OTHER NATION HAS A FIRST
- 4:46AMENDMENT QUITE LIKE OURS QUITE
- 4:49AS BROAD AT OURS THAT ALSO MAKES
- 4:51IT DIFFICULT TO FIGURE OUT HOW
- 4:54TO STEP IN WHEN THINGS MAKE --
- 4:58MAY GET OUT OF HAND.
- 5:00FREE SPEECH DOES NOT MEAN
- 5:02CONSEQUENCE FREE SPEECH.
- 5:03YOU NEED TO BE COGNIZANT BUT AS
- 5:05A SOCIETY WE NEED TO DRAW A LINE
- 5:08BETWEEN WHAT IS CELEBRATING THE
- 5:11DEATH OF AN INDIVIDUAL, AND WHAT
- 5:15IS BEING CRITICAL OF AWHAT HE
- 5:17SAID.
- 5:17ONE PROBLEM HERE IS AN ISSUE
- 5:20WITH SOCIAL MEDIA SPECIFICALLY
- 5:21BUT FREE SPEECH IN GENERAL.
- 5:23ONE OF THE MOST IMPORTANT THINGS
- 5:24IS KNOWING WHEN TO USE AND IT
- 5:29AND NOT TO USE IT.
- 5:32IF SOMETHING DIED YOU DON'T LOSE
- 5:34YOUR FACEBOOK ACCOUNT IF YOU
- 5:36DON'T TWEET.
- 5:36YOU CAN SAY NOTHING AT ALL AND
- 5:38THAT IS PERFECTLY ACCEPTABLE.
- 5:40AND SOME PEOPLE NEED TO LEARN
- 5:41THAT LESSON.
- 5:43BUT WE'LL TALK THROUGH THE NIGHT
- 5:45ABOUT THE EFFECT OF SOCIAL MEDIA
- 5:47WHERE WE'RE AT.
- 5:49MIKE TYSON HAD A GREAT QUOTE A
- 5:51LOT OF THESE PEOPLE ON SOCIAL
- 5:53MEDIA THEY NEVER GOT PUNCHED IN
- 5:55THE FACE BEFORE.
- 5:56AND I THINK YOU HAVE PEOPLE OUT
- 5:58THERE WHO BECAUSE THEY ARE
- 6:00EITHER SHELTERED IN REAL-LIFE OR
- 6:02THEY ARE SHELTERED ON-LINE, THEY
- 6:05DON'T INTERACT WITH PEOPLE OF
- 6:07OTHER BELIEFS AND OTHER PARTIES
- 6:10AND IT ENCOURAGES THEM TO SAY
- 6:12THINGS ON-LINE THAT ARE
- 6:14INFLAMMATORY AND DOESN'T GIVE
- 6:15THEM AN ANCHOR IN REALITY WHEN
- 6:17THEY HEAR SOMEONE FROM THE OTHER
- 6:21SIDE.
- 6:22I'M CONCERNED ABOUT WHERE WE'RE
- 6:24AT.
- 6:24>> Renee: GOOD POINTS THERE AND
- 6:25TO YOU SHERMAN BROWN IN
- 6:27LOUISVILLE.
- 6:27BECAUSE I HEARD THE PHRASE TODAY
- 6:29IN A CONVERSATION ABOUT KEYBOARD
- 6:33COWBOYS.
- 6:33PEOPLE CAN MAKE THESE
- 6:35INFLAMMATORY REMARKS ON THE LEFT
- 6:37OR RIGHT AND THERE DOESN'T SEEM
- 6:39TO BE CONSEQUENCE FOR THAT
- 6:41EXCEPT THE PRICE WE ALL PAY FOR
- 6:43THAT.
- 6:43PICK UP ON THAT POINT THAT TRES
- 6:46WATSON WAS MAKING AND EXPRESS
- 6:47YOUR THOUGHTS WHERE WE ARE AT
- 6:49THIS PARTICULAR TIME?
- 6:52>> I THINK IS THIS AN
- 6:54INTERESTING POSITION AND A PLACE
- 6:56WE FIND OURSELVES.
- 6:57I THINK ABOUT THE INTERNET IN
- 6:59GENERAL IT WAS SUPPOSED TO BE
- 7:01WHEN PEOPLE FIRST WERE GETTING
- 7:03ON, IT WAS VERY MUCH A PLACE
- 7:05THAT WAS A PLACE WHERE YOU WOULD
- 7:07FIND PEOPLE AND BRING US
- 7:08TOGETHER.
- 7:09IF MORE INFORMATION AND I KNOW
- 7:10MORE INFORMATION ABOUT TRES AND
- 7:15AMY AND JONATHAN I LEARN ABOUT
- 7:17THEIR INTERESTS AND EXPERIENCE
- 7:17AND IT SHOULD BRING US TOGETHER.
- 7:19AND WHAT HAS REALLY HAPPENED AS
- 7:22FAR AS THE INTERNET IS CONCERNED
- 7:24YOU FIND OUT OKAY I CAN SEND
- 7:26SOMETHING OUT AND SAY SOMETHING,
- 7:28AND FIVE PEOPLE AGREE WITH ME I
- 7:30HAVE FIVE NEW FRIENDS AND THEY
- 7:32CAN BE ONE PERSON SPREAD
- 7:34THROUGHOUT ALL OVER THE PLACE.
- 7:37THIS IS VERY MUCH THE SAME WITH
- 7:41THE SPEECH WE'RE HEARING FROM
- 7:42DIFFERENT PLACES IS NOT THAT IT
- 7:44IS A POPULAR THING, NOT THAT
- 7:47IT'S EVEN A POPULOUS TYPE OF A
- 7:51CONVERSATION, WE'RE TALKING
- 7:53ABOUT MINORITY SMALL GROUPS OF
- 7:55PEOPLE ON BOTH ENDS OF THE
- 7:57SPECTRUM WHO ARE THE LOUDEST,
- 7:59WHO ARE TAKING A LOT AND SAYING
- 8:01A LOT OF THINGS.
- 8:05SOMETIMES INFLAMMATORY.
- 8:05AND THINGS THAT PEOPLE DISAGREE
- 8:07WITH.
- 8:08I THINK IF SOMEONE DOES SAY
- 8:10SOMETHING YOU DISAGREE WITH YOU
- 8:12HAVE EVERY RIGHT TO SAY YOU
- 8:13DISAGREE WITH THEM.
- 8:14IF IT IS RACIST YOU HAVE A RIGHT
- 8:16TO SAY SOMETHING IS RACIST AND
- 8:18THE TIMING ON THAT IS ACCURATE.
- 8:24THAT YOU DON'T HAVE TO SAY IT
- 8:27IMMEDIATELY BUT WHEN PEOPLE
- 8:28START TALKING ABOUT THINGS OUT
- 8:30THERE OR A PERSON SPECIFICALLY,
- 8:32YOU KNOW, YOU ARE ALLOWED TO SAY
- 8:34THE THINGS YOU NEED TO SAY IF
- 8:37THAT IS WHAT I ARE FEELING AND
- 8:39COMING FROM AND YOUR EXPERIENCE.
- 8:41>> Renee: I GUESS MAYBE THE LINE
- 8:42IS CALLING SOMETHING RACIST OR
- 8:45FASCIST AND NOT CALLING THE
- 8:46PERSON A RACIST OR A FASCIST.
- 8:48DO YOU UNDERSTAND MY DISTINCTION
- 8:51THERE?
- 8:51DOES THAT MAKE SENSE?
- 8:52>> ABSOLUTELY.
- 8:54>> Renee: TARGETING THE SPEECH
- 8:55BUT NOT THE PERSON.
- 8:56>> ABSOLUTELY.
- 8:58I THINK AND YEAH, WE'VE HAD A
- 9:01DELAY HERE, I THINK THE POLICY
- 9:03ITSELF THAT IS WHAT WE'RE
- 9:05TALKING ABOUT.
- 9:07IF SOMEONE IS TALKING ABOUT
- 9:08SOMETHING, WHERE THE
- 9:11CONVERSATION STARTS YOU ARE
- 9:12TRYING TO UNDERSTAND WHERE
- 9:13SOMEONE COMES FROM.
- 9:14RIGHT?
- 9:15IF THEY ARE EXPLAINING THEIR
- 9:17SITUATION WHY THEY ARE FOR A
- 9:19POLICY, IF YOU FEEL THAT IT, YOU
- 9:22KNOW, AS THE INTENT IS TO HURT
- 9:25SOMEONE EXPLAINING AND ASKING
- 9:27THAT QUESTION AND TRYING TO
- 9:28START OUT THE CONVERSATION OF IS
- 9:31THIS WHERE IS THE PERSON COMING
- 9:34FROM?
- 9:35ASKING QUESTIONS I DON'T THINK
- 9:36IS A BAD THING RATHER THAN
- 9:38JUMPING TO CONCLUSION OR
- 9:41ASSUMPTION THAT SOMEONE IS
- 9:43AUTOMATIC THINKING THAT WAY OR
- 9:44THAT'S THE REASON FOR IT IS
- 9:46TRYING TO FIGURE OUT WHERE THEY
- 9:48ARE COMING FROM.
- 9:49I DON'T THINK WE GIVE EACH OTHER
- 9:51THAT CREDIT NOW.
- 9:52PEOPLE ARE IMMEDIATELY IF YOU
- 9:54HEAR I HAVE A D BEHIND MY NAME,
- 9:58I ALREADY AGREE WITH AMY AND
- 10:01TRES NOT JONATHAN AND SHERMAN
- 10:03BECAUSE THEY ARE DEMOCRATS.
- 10:04A LOT OF TIMES I AGREE WITH AMY
- 10:07AND THAT IS A GOOD THING.
- 10:09AND I AGREE WITH TRES.
- 10:12THESE ARE THE WAY WE CAN HAVE
- 10:14THESE CONVERSATIONS AND FIND
- 10:15MORE COMMON GROUND BECAUSE WE
- 10:18FIND THINGS WE CAN WORK ON
- 10:19TOGETHER.
- 10:20AND I THINK THAT IS SOMETHING WE
- 10:21NEED TO GET BACK TO AS FAR AS
- 10:24THE WAY WE OPERATE AND JUST
- 10:26COMMUNICATE IN OUR LIVES.
- 10:28JUST NOT IMMEDIATELY ASSUMING
- 10:30BECAUSE THAT PERSON HAS A D
- 10:33BEHIND THEIR NAME OR R OR I
- 10:35BEHIND THEIR NAME THAT I'M NOT
- 10:37GOING TO AGREE WITH THAT PORN.
- 10:39>> Renee: GOOD POINT.
- 10:40>> I WANT TO ECHO WHAT WAS SAID
- 10:43MY FATHER GAVE ME GOOD ADVICE
- 10:45WHEN I STARTED IN POLITICSFY WAS
- 10:48ANGRY AND IF SOMEONE CHALLENGED
- 10:50ME, IF I REALLY GOT ME UPSET THE
- 10:53BEST THING TO DO IS SLEEP ON IT.
- 10:55AND THEN COME UP WITH A RESPONSE
- 10:57THE NEXT DAY.
- 10:58AND THAT'S WHAT THE OLD MEDIA
- 11:00WAS LIKE.
- 11:01YOU WOULD WRITE A LETTER TO THE
- 11:03EDITOR OR WOULD WRITE A LETTER
- 11:09EXCHANGE TO AN OPPONENT.
- 11:11BUT, NOW, IT'S WITH YOUR PHONE
- 11:13IN YOUR HAND IT'S SO EASY FOR
- 11:15YOU TO IMMEDIATELY TAKE THAT
- 11:17ANGER OUT AND TO CONTINUE TO
- 11:20BUILD ON WHAT IS A NEVER ENDING
- 11:24PROBLEM.
- 11:24AND SO I WROTE A BOOK ABOUT THIS
- 11:27WHOLE ISSUE 20 YEARS AGO.
- 11:29IT'S STILL AVAILABLE ON-LINE
- 11:31[LAUGHTER]
- 11:32THE COMPASSIONATE COMMUNITY.
- 11:33AND THE IDEA OF MY BOOK WAS THAT
- 11:37WE ALL HAVE THE SHARED VALUES
- 11:38WHETHER YOU ARE DEMOCRATS OR
- 11:39REPUBLICANS AND WHETHER YOU ARE
- 11:41JEWISH OR CHRISTIAN OR MUSLIM,
- 11:43AND THOSE SHARED VALUES ARE THE
- 11:45TYPES OF THINGS WE CAN BUILD A
- 11:47SOCIETY ON.
- 11:47I WENT AND LOOKED AT IT AND ONE
- 11:51OF THE GREAT SOLUTIONS I THOUGHT
- 11:53IS WHAT SHERMAN WAS TALKING
- 11:54ABOUT THE INTERNET WAS GOING TO
- 11:56BE A GREAT DEMOCRATIZING FORCE
- 11:59AND ABILITY TO GIVE PEOPLE
- 12:01WITHOUT BIG MONEY TO HAVE THEIR
- 12:02SAY IN POLITICS AND REALLY SHARE
- 12:05THOSE VALUES THROUGH SOCIAL
- 12:06MEDIA.
- 12:07FIND THOSE SHARED VALUES.
- 12:08AND I WAS COMPLETELY WRONG AND
- 12:11THE OPPOSITE HAPPENED.
- 12:15SO THE GENIE IS OUT OF THE
- 12:17BUILDING WHAT CAN WE DO TO TRY
- 12:19TO GET PEOPLE TO TAMPER DOWN
- 12:21THEIR TEMPERS AND TO FOCUS MORE
- 12:24ON THE GREAT VAST MAJORITY OF
- 12:26ISSUES WHICH WE ALL AGREE ON AS
- 12:28OPPOSED TO OBSESSING OURSELVES,
- 12:30ATTACKING OTHERS ON THE MINOR
- 12:33SMALL MINORITY ISSUES THAT WE
- 12:35DISAGREE.
- 12:35>> Renee: HOW MANY TIMES HAVE WE
- 12:38HEARD LEGISLATIVE LEADERS COME
- 12:40ON THIS PROGRAM AND SAY 90% PLUS
- 12:42OF WHAT HAPPENS IN THE GENERAL
- 12:45ASSEMBLY IS BIPARTISAN HAS BROAD
- 12:49BIPARTISAN APPEAL AND CONSENSUS.
- 12:50IT'S ONLY THE FEW THINGS AND
- 12:52MORE THAN 90% PROBABLY THE 5% OF
- 12:55THINGS THAT GET A LOT OF
- 12:58HEADLINES AND TAKE UP THE INK
- 12:59AND THE SOCIAL MEDIA SPACE.
- 13:01MOST OF THE TIMES PEOPLE GET
- 13:03ALONG.
- 13:03>> THAT IS TRUE.
- 13:04I WISH MORE PEOPLE COULD SEE
- 13:06THAT I ALWAYS ENCOURAGE ANYONE
- 13:08TO COME AND WATCH THE PROCESS AS
- 13:11IT UNFOLDS.
- 13:12BECAUSE THAT'S WHAT YOU WILL
- 13:13SEE.
- 13:13YOU WILL SEE REPUBLICANS AND
- 13:15DEMOCRATS WORKING ACROSS THE
- 13:17AISLE.
- 13:17I WAS TALKING TO A LEGISLATIVE
- 13:20FRIEND THE DAY AFTER THE
- 13:21SHOOTING AND TRYING TO FIGURE
- 13:23OUT WHAT IS OUR ROLE?
- 13:25WHAT CAN WE DO?
- 13:27AND WHEN WE THOUGHT ABOUT THE
- 13:29DIFFERENCES THAT WE HAVE BETWEEN
- 13:30REPUBLICANS AND DEMOCRATS, WE
- 13:33LARGELY AGREE ON POINT A AND
- 13:36LARGELY AGREE ON POINT B IT'S
- 13:40THE LINE HOW WE GET THERE.
- 13:41AND JUST BECAUSE WE DISAGREE HOW
- 13:43WE GET THERE, DOES NOT MEAN IT'S
- 13:46NOT WORTH HAVING THE
- 13:48CONVERSATION TO FIND
- 13:50COMMONALITIES.
- 13:50AND I THINK THAT IS IMPORTANT TO
- 13:51REMEMBER.
- 13:52I ALSO THINK THAT POLITICAL
- 13:54DISCOURSE AND POLITICAL VIOLENCE
- 13:56UNFORTUNATELY, AMERICA HAS A
- 13:57HISTORY OF THAT.
- 13:58THIS IS NOT A NEW PHENOMENON IN
- 14:01AMERICAN POLITICS.
- 14:02WHAT IS DIFFERENT NOW IT HAS
- 14:04BEEN ACCELERATED BECAUSE OF
- 14:06SOCIAL MEDIA, BECAUSE OF A 24/7
- 14:09NEWS STREAMING.
- 14:10WE CAN'T AVOID IT.
- 14:12IT'S RIGHT THERE.
- 14:13SO WITH THAT COMES ALONG HYPER
- 14:16PARTISANSHIP.
- 14:18MISINFORMATION CAMPAIGNS AND ALL
- 14:19OF THAT FUELS A LOT OF THIS
- 14:23ANGST OUT THERE COUPLED WITH
- 14:25INDIVIDUALS WHO FEEL THEY CAN
- 14:28SIT BEHIND A KEYBOARD AND CAN
- 14:29SAY WHAT THEY WANT WITHOUT A
- 14:31CONSEQUENCE IS NOT THE WAY OUR
- 14:32SOCIETY NEEDS TO GO.
- 14:33THE WAY OUT IS THROUGH DIALOGUE
- 14:36AND THROUGH THESE CONVERSATIONS
- 14:37WE'RE SITTING DOWN AND HAVING
- 14:38THESE FACE TO FACE.
- 14:41AND I HOPE WE CAN HAVE
- 14:42OPPORTUNITIES TO DO THIS MORE.
- 14:46>> Renee: TRES YOUR ROLE AS A
- 14:48PODCASTER?
- 14:49>> BEFORE I WANT TO SAY
- 14:51SOMETHING MECHANICALLY IN THE
- 14:52WAY WE RUN POLITICAL CAMPAIGNS
- 14:55THAT IS ALSO CHANGED IN THE LAST
- 14:5610 YEARS OR SO.
- 14:58THAT FEEDS WHAT AMY WAS TALKING
- 15:01ABOUT, ABOUT 2016, 2014 WE
- 15:04REALIZED ON THE CAMPAIGN SIDE
- 15:06THAT YOU WORK WITH LIMITED
- 15:09MONEY.
- 15:09YOU HAVE TO BE AS EFFICIENT AS
- 15:11HUMANLY POSSIBLE YOU HAVE TO
- 15:12RAISE MONEY FROM DONORS AND THE
- 15:15RUSH ON INVESTMENT ON RETURN ON
- 15:19INVESTMENT TRYING TO TURNOUT
- 15:20VOTERS WHO THEY SHOW UP TO VOTE
- 15:22THEY ARE GOING TO VOTE FOR MY
- 15:24GUY IS A BETTER RETURN ON
- 15:27INVESTMENT THAN TO CONVINCE
- 15:29UNDECIDED MEMBERS TO VOTE FOR
- 15:30YOU.
- 15:31THE CAMPAIGNS ON BOTH SIDES OF
- 15:32THE AISLE HAVE PIVOTED AND THEY
- 15:34ARE TALKING IT IT BECOMES AN
- 15:40ECOCHAMBER ON THE CAMPAIGN TRAIL
- 15:41THE MOST EFFICIENT WAY TO WIN
- 15:43YOUR RACE IS TALK ONLY TO YOUR
- 15:45VOTERS.
- 15:46AND PUT ON THE SIDE VOTERS IN A
- 15:48BOX THEY DON'T MATTER.
- 15:49IF I CAN TURNOUT MY BASE I WIN.
- 15:51AND I THINK THAT'S AFFECTED THE
- 15:53WAY YOU SEE SOME OF THE
- 15:55CAMPAIGNS TALK.
- 15:55AND I CAN TELL YOU THE YOUNGER
- 15:58PEOPLE COMING UP TO THE CAMPAIGN
- 16:00WORLD THAT I SEE, AND CERTAINLY
- 16:02NOT ALL OF THEM, BUT A GOOD
- 16:04CHUNK ON BOTH SIDES THEY ARE
- 16:06MORE INTERESTED IN CLICKS
- 16:07ON-LINE AND INTERESTED IN OWNING
- 16:09THE LIBS AND THE CONSERVATIVES
- 16:12AND NOT GETTING OUT A MESSAGE
- 16:13THAT HELPS YOUR BOSS OR THE
- 16:15COUNTRY OR YOUR PARTY, IT'S
- 16:18ABOUT LIKE WHAT CAN I DO TODAY
- 16:20FOR ENGAGEMENT?
- 16:21AND IT CAN GET DANGEROUS.
- 16:23I CAN TELL YOU SOMEBODY WHO I
- 16:26HAVE GREAT RESPECT AND
- 16:29ADMIRATION FOR MACK BROWN.
- 16:31HE GAVE ME A WIDE BIRTH TO SAY
- 16:33WHATEVER I WANTED.
- 16:35ONE OF THE FEW GUARDRAILS HE PUT
- 16:37UP HE DIDN'T WANT ME TO USE
- 16:40WORDS LIKE WAR OR FIGHT BECAUSE
- 16:42A CRAZY PERSON MAY TAKE THEM
- 16:44SERIOUSLY.
- 16:45HE WANTED ME TO STAY AWAY FROM
- 16:47PHRASES LIKE THAT.
- 16:47I THINK THAT ON THE CAMPAIGN
- 16:49SIDE, WE CAN DO BETTER IN HOW WE
- 16:52TALK ABOUT OUR OPPONENTS AND OUR
- 16:55PLANS.
- 16:55>> Renee: BUT WE HAVE HEARD
- 16:57THOSE EXACT WORDS THE LAST FIVE
- 16:58DAYS THAT HAVE ELEVATED PITCH
- 17:00THAT WE ARE AT WAR, AND THAT
- 17:02WE'RE READY TO FIGHT ON BOTH
- 17:04SIDES.
- 17:05RIGHT?
- 17:06NOW IT'S COMMON VEN KNACK LAR.
- 17:08>> AND I DISLIKE IT.
- 17:11AGAIN, HOW WE GET OUT OF THIS
- 17:13IS WHAT WE SAW HAPPEN TO CHARLIE
- 17:15KIRK WAS PURE EVIL AND PURE
- 17:18HATE.
- 17:18THE WAY TO ADDRESS THAT IS NOT
- 17:20WITH MORE HATE.
- 17:21IT IS WITH LOVE.
- 17:23AND IT IS WITH KINDNESS AND IT
- 17:25IS WITH A WILLINGNESS TO
- 17:28UNDERSTAND HOWEVER SINGLE
- 17:30AMERICAN VIEWS THIS WORLD
- 17:31THROUGH THEIR LENS BECAUSE IT'S
- 17:33ALL DIFFERENT AND IT DOESN'T
- 17:34MEAN EITHER IS WRONG.
- 17:36I JUST WE HAVE A LOT OF SOUL
- 17:38SEARCHING TO DO AS AMERICANS.
- 17:40AND I HOPE WE GET THERE.
- 17:41>> Renee: AND TO THE POINT YOU
- 17:42WERE MAKING JONATHAN ABOUT A
- 17:45SHARED SET OF COMMON VALUES,
- 17:47SOME WOULD SAY THAT'S BEEN
- 17:49DISRUPTED THERE'S NOT A SHARED
- 17:51SET OF COMMON VALUES.
- 17:53DO YOU BELIEVE THAT'S TRUE?
- 17:55>> NOT AT ALL.
- 17:56I BELIEVE VERY STRONGLY IN THE
- 18:00GOLDEN RULE THAT IS NOT ONLY
- 18:04SOMETHING THAT JESUS PREACHED
- 18:06BUT BEFORE HIM, RABBI FROM THE
- 18:08JEWISH TRADITION AND YOU CAN SEE
- 18:10IT IN EVERY WORLD RELIGIOUS
- 18:12TRADITION OR EVERY WORLD TRIBAL
- 18:15SPIRITUAL TRADITION, THE IDEA
- 18:17THAT TO LOVE YOUR NEIGHBORS
- 18:19YOURSELF AND PARTICULARLY
- 18:21EXPRESS LOVE TOWARDS THOSE OF
- 18:22YOUR NEIGHBORS WHO ARE
- 18:24DISADVANTAGED THE POOR, THE
- 18:27ELDERLY, THE YOUNG.
- 18:28THAT IS SOMETHING THAT ANIMATES
- 18:30ALL OF US WHETHER WE ARE
- 18:32DEMOCRATS, REPUBLICANS OR
- 18:33INDEPENDENTS AND SOMETHING THAT
- 18:35CAN HELP BRING THE COUNTRY
- 18:37TOGETHER IF WE CAN FOCUS MORE ON
- 18:39THAT.
- 18:40AND I'M HOPEFUL THAT WE WILL SEE
- 18:43THIS NEXT CROP OF PRESIDENTIAL
- 18:44CANDIDATES ON BOTH SIDES TAKE UP
- 18:48THAT MANTLE TO BRING THE COUNTRY
- 18:51TOGETHER BECAUSE IT'S NEEDED AND
- 18:54WE ARE SORELY IN NEED OF LEADERS
- 18:56TO PUT THEMSELVES OUT LIKE THAT.
- 18:59>> Renee: WHAT DO YOU DO IN THE
- 19:01MEANTIME?
- 19:01AND WHAT DO YOU SEE AS YOUR ROLE
- 19:03WHEN WE THINK WHERE DO WE FIT IN
- 19:06TO HELP ADVANCE POLITICAL
- 19:08DISCOURSE AND CIVILITY?
- 19:10I TAKE PRIDE ON WHAT WE DO ON
- 19:12"KENTUCKY TONIGHT" THAT IS WHAT
- 19:14WE DO TO BRING STAKEHOLDERS
- 19:17TOGETHER WITH A CONVERSATION
- 19:18WITH DIFFERENT PERSPECTIVES.
- 19:19WHERE DO YOU SEE YOUR ROLE?
- 19:23>> WELL, A COUPLE THINGS TO
- 19:25ANSWER THAT.
- 19:26I WANT TO GO BACK TO SOMETHING
- 19:28THAT AMY SAID I'M NOT TRYING TO
- 19:30GET AWAY FROM YOUR QUESTION.
- 19:31IT IS A TOUGH DISCUSSION.
- 19:34BUT THE FIRST PART IS ON OUR
- 19:36LEADERS.
- 19:36SHE TALKED ABOUT FROM THE WHITE
- 19:38HOUSE DOWN.
- 19:38AS WE DO THAT, I THINK THAT THE
- 19:40FIRST PART IS THAT OUR LEADERS
- 19:43NEED TO BE INTENTIONAL WHEN THEY
- 19:45ARE EMPHASIZING RESPECTFUL
- 19:46DISCOURSE.
- 19:47THAT IS NUMBER ONE.
- 19:49WHEN THEY ARE ACTUALLY MEAN THAT
- 19:50AND SAYING IT AND NOT GOING OUT
- 19:52AND SAYING SOMETHING ELSE THAT
- 19:54IS NOT DIRECTED AT THE WHITE
- 19:55HOUSE THAT IS ACROSS THE BOARD
- 19:56AS FAR AS DOING THAT FOR OUR
- 19:59POLITICS.
- 20:00THAT DISCOURSE AND THAT
- 20:02DISAGREEMENT, THOUGH, OVER IDEAS
- 20:04SPECIFICALLY, SHOULD NOT
- 20:05DIMINISH THE HUMANITY OF THOSE
- 20:07WITH WHOM WE DISAGREE AND THAT
- 20:09IS WHERE I WANT TO FOCUS IS THAT
- 20:12BACK ON THAT WHEN WE'RE TALKING
- 20:14TO OUR FAMILY THERE ARE FAMILY
- 20:16MEMBERS WHO DON'T TALK TO EACH
- 20:18OTHER RIGHT NOW BECAUSE OF WHERE
- 20:20THINGS R AND THAT IS OUR ROLE
- 20:21NOT JUST IN YOUR FAMILY BUT JUST
- 20:23AS YOU ARE GOING OUT RIGHT NOW,
- 20:25AGAIN I'M TALKING TO THE FOLKS
- 20:27THAT ARE WATCHING THIS AND IF
- 20:28YOU ARE A DEMOCRAT OR
- 20:31REPUBLICAN, TONE IT DOWN AND IT
- 20:33DOESN'T MEAN STOP HAVING
- 20:35FEELINGS AND THOUGHTS AND HAVING
- 20:37STRONG OPINIONS ON WHERE THINGS
- 20:39ARE.
- 20:40BUT REALIZING THAT THE PERSON
- 20:41THAT YOU ARE TALKING TO,
- 20:43SCREAMING AND CALLING THEM A
- 20:44NAME OR WHATEVER YOU ARE DOING
- 20:46IT'S NOT GOING TO WORK AND MOVE
- 20:48SOMEBODY OVER TO YOUR SIDE.
- 20:50CERTAINLY ANY TYPE OF VIOLENCE.
- 20:52WE LOOK BACK AMY MENTIONED AGAIN
- 20:55POLITICAL VIOLENCE HAPPENED
- 20:56THROUGHOUT THE COURSE.
- 20:57I WAS WORKING ON THE CAMPAIGN IN
- 21:002010 WHEN THE ALTERCATION
- 21:03HAPPENED OUTSIDE OF THE KET
- 21:05STUDIOS BETWEEN RAND PAUL
- 21:07SUPPORTERS AND A CONWAY
- 21:09SUPPORTER AND THE RAND PAUL
- 21:13SUPPORTERS KICKED OR STOMPED ON
- 21:17THE CONWAY SUPPORTER.
- 21:18BOTH CAMPAIGNS DENOUNCED THAT
- 21:20PERSON IT WAS ONE PERSON BUT
- 21:22BOTH CAMPAIGNS AND BOTH
- 21:23CANDIDATES AT THE TIME DENOUNCED
- 21:25IT SAID POLITICAL VIOLENCE WAS
- 21:27NOT APPROPRIATE AND NOT EVER
- 21:29APPROPRIATE.
- 21:30AND WE CAN'T GET TO THAT
- 21:32OPINION.
- 21:32THAT IS OVER A KICK.
- 21:33SO FOR THIS, WHEN YOU'VE GOT AN
- 21:37ASSASSINATION OF SOMEONE WHO
- 21:39WHETHER YOU DISAGREE WITH HIM OR
- 21:41NOT, IS NOT --
- 21:44CAN --
- 21:44WE CAN'T HAVE THAT.
- 21:45AND WE HAVE HAD THESE THINGS IN
- 21:46THE PAST AND WE NEED TO TONE
- 21:48DOWN THE RHETORIC.
- 21:50TO ANSWER YOUR QUESTION FOR US
- 21:52IT'S FINDING COMMON GROUND AND
- 21:54THINGS YOU CAN WORK ON WITH
- 21:56SOMEONE AND REALLY GOES BACK TO
- 21:58AS JONATHAN SAID ABOUT THE
- 22:00GOLDEN RULE.
- 22:02THAT'S WHERE WE ARE.
- 22:03WE'RE ALL TRYING TO GET TO TREAT
- 22:05OTHERS AS WE WOULD.
- 22:07I SEE A LOT OF TIMES PEOPLE
- 22:09DISAGREE ON IMMEDIATE AND YOU GO
- 22:11IN THE BIOAND IT IS A BIBLE
- 22:14VERSE OR SOME TYPE OF SOMETHING
- 22:16I AM A PROUD WHATEVER FAITH, AND
- 22:19I'M READING YOUR TWEETS AND THEY
- 22:21ARE NOT SHOWING THAT.
- 22:23IT'S NOT EXACTLY WHO YOU'RE
- 22:25DESCRIBING YOURSELF.
- 22:27SO I'M TRYING TO FIGURE OUT FOR
- 22:29MYSELF HOW I'M CONVEYING MY
- 22:30THOUGHTS AND MY BELIEFS.
- 22:32I TRY TO THINK ABOUT THAT.
- 22:34I HAVE AN 11-YEAR-OLD AND I WANT
- 22:36TO MAKE HIM PROUD IF I'M
- 22:38SCREAMING AT SOMEBODY OR MAD
- 22:39ABOUT IT IT'S NOT DOING THE JOB
- 22:41AND I TRY TO THINK ABOUT ALL THE
- 22:43TIME.
- 22:44>> Renee: I HAVE A FORMER PASTOR
- 22:45WHO NEEDS TO SAY MAKE SURE YOUR
- 22:47VIDEO MATCHES YOUR AUDIO THAT IS
- 22:50THE TENNESSEE WAY OF PUTTING
- 22:51WHAT SHERMAN SAID.
- 22:53BUT, TO GET BACK TO THE POINT
- 22:55THAT SHERMAN WAS MAKING ABOUT
- 22:57AND WE REMEMBER THOSE OF US
- 22:59AROUND THEN IN 2010 THAT
- 23:02INSTANCE THAT HAPPENED OUTSIDE
- 23:03OUR STUDIO AND HOW QUICK THERE
- 23:06WAS A DENOUNCE.
- 23:07OF THAT WHEN AN EFFIGY OF
- 23:10GOVERNOR ANDY BESHEAR WAS HANGED
- 23:11FROM A TREE OUTSIDE NEAR THE
- 23:13GOVERNOR'S MANSION.
- 23:14BOTH REPUBLICANS AND DEMOCRATS
- 23:16DENOUNCED THAT.
- 23:16I DID A SHOW AFTER JANUARY 6TH
- 23:19WHERE REPUBLICANS AND DEMOCRATS
- 23:21SAT IN A STUDIO AND TALKED ABOUT
- 23:26THAT INSTANCE.
- 23:27AND WHAT THAT DID FOR WASHINGTON
- 23:29AND HOW WE SHOULD MOVE FORWARD
- 23:31BUT IT SEEMS LIKE WE HAVE
- 23:35SOMEWHERE HIT A POTHOLE OF
- 23:38SEISMIC PROPORTIONS ABOUT WHAT
- 23:40WE VIEW AS INFLAMMATORY AND
- 23:42SOCIALLY ACCEPTABLE OR
- 23:44UNACCEPTABLE.
- 23:44>> THAT IS THE FEELING WE HAVE
- 23:47GOTTEN THE HABIT OF KEEPING
- 23:49SCORES AND WHEN ONE SIDE DOES
- 23:51SOMETHING, WE LIKE TO WHIP OUT
- 23:53OUR NOTEBOOK AND SAY BUT YOU
- 23:56DIDN'T SAY THIS OR DO THIS AFTER
- 23:58THIS HAPPENED.
- 23:58AT SOME POINT IN TIME, THE
- 24:00ADULTS IN THE ROOM HAVE TO BE
- 24:02WILLING TO SAY I WILL PUT MY
- 24:04WEAPON DOWN AND HANDOUT TO SHAKE
- 24:06YOURS.
- 24:06IF YOU WANT TO USE IT AGAINST ME
- 24:09IS FINE BUT I'M LETTING
- 24:10EVERYTHING THAT WAS BE.
- 24:12AND I'M WILLING TO WIPE THE
- 24:14SLATE CLEAN AND MOVE FORWARD.
- 24:15I POSTED THIS FRIDAY.
- 24:18SEPTEMBER 12TH I'M WILLING TO
- 24:20GIVE EVERYONE GRACE AND I WILL
- 24:22JUDGE YOU FROM WHAT YOU SAY FROM
- 24:25SEPTEMBER 12TH FORWARD IF YOU
- 24:26WANT TO BE PART OF THE SOLUTION
- 24:28I'M THERE WITH YOU.
- 24:29IF YOU WANT TO BE PART OF THE
- 24:30PROBLEM I WILL POINT IT OUT AND
- 24:33SAY YOU'RE BEING PART OF THE
- 24:34PROBLEM BUT I'M WILLING TO LET
- 24:36THINGS THAT YOU'VE SAID IN THE
- 24:37PAST IF YOU ARE WILLING TO
- 24:39CHANGE AND MOVE THE COUNTRY
- 24:41FORWARD.
- 24:42>> Renee: YEAH, I HEARD YOU SAY
- 24:43A COUPLE OF TIMES THINGS
- 24:45HELPFUL, NOT HELPFUL AND
- 24:47SPEAKING OF SEPTEMBER 12TH AND
- 24:49THE CONVERSATION AFTER SEPTEMBER
- 24:5211th, 2001 WHEN PEOPLE WILL
- 24:53SAY THAT IS THE WORST DAY IN
- 24:55MODERN HISTORY AND THE NEXT BEST
- 24:57DAY WAS SEPTEMBER 12TH IT WAS A
- 25:00UNITED COUNTRY COMMITTED TO
- 25:01FIGHTING TERRORISM AND LOVING
- 25:02BROTHER AND SISTER.
- 25:04>> I WISH WE COULD GO BACK TO
- 25:06THAT.
- 25:07I TRULY WISH THAT WE CAN GO BACK
- 25:09TO THAT UNITY THAT WE FELT THAT
- 25:11LEADERSHIP THAT WE SAW ON
- 25:14SEPTEMBER 12TH OF THAT YEAR.
- 25:16BECAUSE THE WHOLE COUNTRY UNITED
- 25:18AROUND ONE THOUGHT THAT AMERICA
- 25:21IS THE GREATEST NATION IN THE
- 25:23WORLD.
- 25:23AND HOW DARE SOMEONE ATTACK US.
- 25:25>> AND THERE WAS NOT A SINGLE
- 25:28WORD OUT OF GEORGE W. BUSH'S
- 25:30MOUTH DURING THAT PERIOD OR RUDY
- 25:31GIULIANI'S MOUTH THAT WAS
- 25:34ATTACKING TRYING TO TIE THE
- 25:35TERRORISTS TO THIS LIBERAL
- 25:38IDEOLOGY RUNNING THE COUNTRY.
- 25:40AND THOSE WERE LEADERS AT THE
- 25:42TIME WHO UNDERSTOOD THAT THIS
- 25:44WAS A MOMENT FOR TO TRANS END
- 25:48THOSE DISPUTES AND BRING PEOPLE
- 25:49TOGETHER AND WE ARE NOT SEEING
- 25:51THAT RIGHT NOW.
- 25:52AND, AGAIN, I'M HOPEFUL THAT
- 25:54OVER THE NEXT COUPLE YEARS THAT
- 25:56WE'VE HIT A TURNING POINT.
- 25:59MAYBE WE'LL USE THE ETCH ASKETCH
- 26:04TO WIPE OUT THE PAST BUT FIND
- 26:07LEAD HERS LIKE COX, A
- 26:10REPUBLICAN, WHO WANT TO BRING
- 26:12PEOPLE TOGETHER.
- 26:13>> AMY AND I JONATHAN AND
- 26:15SHERMAN ALL KNOW HUNDREDS OF
- 26:18POLITICIANS IN OFFICE RUNNING
- 26:20FOR OFFICE, WERE IN OFFICE.
- 26:22I CAN COUNT ON ONE HAND AND I
- 26:24DON'T NEED TO USE MY FINGERS THE
- 26:28PEOPLE WHO ARE TRULY IN IT FOR
- 26:30BAD PURPOSES.
- 26:31I MAY THINK A LOT ARE MISGUIDED
- 26:34OR DUMP OR BAD SOLUTIONS THAT
- 26:37DOESN'T MEAN THEY ARE NOT
- 26:38SINCERE ABOUT THEIR DESIRE TO
- 26:39HELP THE COUNTRY AND THAT WHAT
- 26:41WE LOST.
- 26:42IF I DON'T AGREE WITH THEIR
- 26:44SOLUTION WE THINK THEY ARE EVIL
- 26:47AND BAD AND MUST BE STOPPED.
- 26:50NOT WELL, THEY HAVE GOOD
- 26:53INTENTIONS I JUST DON'T LIKE
- 26:55WHAT THEY ARE TRYING TO DO.
- 26:56ONE OF MY FAVORITE TERMS IS
- 26:59AGGRESSIVE CONTRAST IN
- 27:00CAMPAIGNS.
- 27:00THERE IS A DIFFERENCE BETWEEN
- 27:03AGGRESSIVE CONTRAST AND NEGATIVE
- 27:05CAMPAIGNING THE SAME WITH WORDS
- 27:06THERE IS A DIFFERENCE BETWEEN
- 27:08AGGRESSIVE DEBATING, AND JUST
- 27:12PLAIN GOING FOR KEEPS.
- 27:14AND WE'VE GOT TO GET BACK TO
- 27:16WHERE WE UNDERSTAND THAT WE CAN
- 27:20DISAGREE AGGRESSIVELY BUT STILL
- 27:22GET ALONG.
- 27:22>> Renee: THAT'S RIGHT.
- 27:23YOU CAN HAVE A BAD IDEA BUT IT
- 27:25DOESN'T MAKE YOU A BAD PERSON.
- 27:27>> THAT'S RIGHT.
- 27:28AND WE ALSO HAVE TO BE AND IT'S
- 27:30NOT GOING TO HAPPEN █OVERNIGHT
- 27:31BUT WE ALSO HAVE TO BE WILLING
- 27:33TO CALL OUT THOSE IN OUR SPHERE
- 27:36AND OUTSIDE OF OUR SPHERE WHEN
- 27:38WHAT THEY ARE SAYING IS NOT
- 27:41RIGHT.
- 27:42WE HAVE TO BE WILLING.
- 27:42AND THAT IS REALLY HARD.
- 27:45>> Renee: IT'S RISKY.
- 27:46>> BECAUSE WE HAVE ALL SEEN
- 27:48FRIENDS AND COLLEAGUES AND
- 27:49OTHERS WHO MADE STATEMENTS OVER
- 27:51THE PAST COUPLE OF YEARS, RIGHT?
- 27:53THAT WE HAVEN'T AGREED WITH AND
- 27:57SOMETIMES YOU WANT TO SAY PULL
- 27:59THAT BACK.
- 28:00AND WE HAVE TO BE WILLING TO
- 28:02HAVE THOSE CONVERSATIONS BUT
- 28:03THEY HAVE TO BE WILLING TO
- 28:04LISTEN IT GOES BOTH WAYS.
- 28:07UNTIL WE HAVE A SOCIETY WHO IS
- 28:09WILLING TO CALL IT OUT IN A
- 28:11RESPECTFUL WAY AND SAY HAVE YOU
- 28:13THOUGHT ABOUT HOW THAT COMMENT
- 28:15MAY HAVE OFFENDED OR MAY HAVE
- 28:17COME ACROSS?
- 28:18HAVE YOU THOUGHT ABOUT IT
- 28:19THROUGH THIS LENS?
- 28:20AGAIN, WE'RE GOING TO GET OUT OF
- 28:23THIS THROUGH DIALOGUE AND WE
- 28:25HAVE TO BE WILLING TO NOT JUST
- 28:26THE LET RICK RHETORIC CONTINUE.
- 28:30HELPING OR NOT HELPING WHEN IT'S
- 28:32NOT HELPING WE HAVE TO BE
- 28:34WILLING TO SAY THAT.
- 28:35>> Renee: WE ARE ALL NOT IN 2026
- 28:38YET BUT WE ARE IN THE THROWS OF
- 28:41A HEATED SENATE PRIMARY ALREADY
- 28:42ON THE REPUBLICAN FIELD AND WE
- 28:43HAVE SEEN THE COMMERCIALS
- 28:45ALREADY.
- 28:45IF YOU WANT TO RATE SOME OF
- 28:47THOSE?
- 28:49SOME OF THE TONE AND EVEN SOME
- 28:50OF THE WORDS THAT ARE CHOSEN IN
- 28:54THOSE ADS YOU HAVE TO BLEEP IT
- 28:55OUT, RIGHT?
- 28:56IS THAT HELPFUL OR NOT HELPFUL?
- 28:58>> I MEAN, I THINK THE WORDS
- 29:03THEMSELVES, THE BLEEPING WORDS
- 29:05WE ARE IN 2026.
- 29:06WE'RE BEYOND THE CENSORING PART.
- 29:08I THINK THAT'S WHATEVER.
- 29:11BUT EVERYBODY HAS A POTTY MOUTH
- 29:13THESE DAYS.
- 29:13IT IS WHAT IT IS.
- 29:15I'M MORE CONCERNED ABOUT TONE
- 29:18AND TENOR THAN THE WORDS.
- 29:21THIS IS A WEIRD CAMPAIGN.
- 29:23BECAUSE USUALLY THE WAY YOU
- 29:25WOULD RUN A CAMPAIGN, YOU WOULD
- 29:27START WITH RUNNING POSITIVE ADS
- 29:29TO BUILDUP YOUR POSITIVE NAME
- 29:31ID.
- 29:32WHEN YOU GOES NEGATIVE IT BRINGS
- 29:34YOUR OPPONENT DOWN AND YOU DOWN.
- 29:36THE HOPE IS YOU BRING YOUR
- 29:38OPPONENT DOWN TO A LEVEL WHERE
- 29:40YOUR DROP IS EVENED OUT.
- 29:43THIS THING NEGATIVE STARTING
- 29:45NATE MORRIS IS UNKNOWN, DANIEL
- 29:48CAMERON HAS NAME ID.
- 29:50ANDY BARR IS WELL-KNOWN IN
- 29:53CENTRAL KENTUCKY THERE WAS A
- 29:54RUSH TO DEFINE NATE MORRIS.
- 29:56SO I UNDERSTAND STRATEGICALLY.
- 29:58BUT IT ALSO SETS A REALLY AWFUL
- 30:01TONE FOR THE BEGINNING OF THE
- 30:02CAMPAIGN WHEN WE SKIPPED OVER
- 30:04THE NICE ADS WITH THE FAMILIES
- 30:06WALKING ON THE BLUEGRASS TALKING
- 30:07ABOUT HOW I LOVE THE STATE AND
- 30:09LOVE THIS COUNTRY.
- 30:10WE WENT STRAIGHT TO THE
- 30:11NEGATIVE.
- 30:13SO I DON'T KNOW IF THE ADS SAY
- 30:16ANYTHING ABOUT WHERE WE'RE AT OR
- 30:18IF IT PLAYS INTO THIS
- 30:19CONVERSATION BUT I THINK
- 30:22GOING --
- 30:22BEING SO NEGATIVE FROM THE WORD
- 30:24GO, CERTAINLY DOESN'T CAST A
- 30:27GOOD LIGHT ON WHERE WE'RE
- 30:30HEADED.
- 30:30>> Renee: SHERMAN TO YOU WITH
- 30:30THAT QUESTION, TOO.
- 30:31I MEAN AS WE ARE RAMPING UP WITH
- 30:35SEVERAL MONTHS TO GO BEFORE THE
- 30:36PRIMARY AND THE GENERAL ELECTION
- 30:38OF NEXT YEAR, I MEAN, YOU KNOW,
- 30:41WHERE DO YOU SEE THE POLITICAL
- 30:43DISCOURSE GOING?
- 30:43AND DO YOU THINK IT WOULD BE
- 30:45WISE FOR CANDIDATES TO
- 30:48RECALIBRATE THEIR TONE AND
- 30:51TENOR?
- 30:51>> I'M HOPEFUL THAT THEY ARE.
- 30:53I'M HOPEFUL THAT, AGAIN, I THINK
- 30:56BACK TO TRES' POINT EARLIER WHEN
- 30:59HE WAS TALKING ABOUT PEOPLE
- 31:00GETTING INTO POLITICS, STATE
- 31:03REPRESENTATIVES, STATE SENATE
- 31:04BOTH SIDES OF THE AISLE THEY GET
- 31:06IN THIS FOR THE RIGHT REASON
- 31:08THEY WANT TO DO GOOD.
- 31:09THEY WANT TO HELP THEIR
- 31:10COMMUNITY AND HELP PEOPLE THAT
- 31:12THEY SEE AND KNOW AND I'VE SEEN
- 31:16GUYS GET IN A RACE AND LITERALLY
- 31:18BE TALKING ABOUT A STOPLIGHT
- 31:20THEY NEED TO GET PUT IN.
- 31:21AND TALKING TO THE GOVERNOR WHAT
- 31:23THEY CAN DO FOR HIM IF THEY WERE
- 31:25TO WIN.
- 31:25THINGS LIKE THAT HAVE VERY MUCH
- 31:28THAT LOCAL FEEL, I THINK FOR
- 31:30THIS WHEN YOU ARE TALKING ABOUT
- 31:33THE THREE GENTLEMEN THAT TRES
- 31:36WAS TALKING ABOUT, IF I'M
- 31:38WATCHING AND THEY ARE DISCUSSING
- 31:40THINGS, ATTACKING EACH OTHER ON
- 31:42POLICY OR ATTACKING EACH OTHER
- 31:44ON YOU ARE ALWAYS GOING TO HAVE
- 31:47THE TIE THIS PERSON IS CLOSE
- 31:49WITH THIS POLITICIAN BECAUSE
- 31:51THAT POLITICIAN IS NOT POPULAR.
- 31:52BUT IF IT IS TIED TO SOMEONE WHO
- 31:58IS MORE CHARISMATIC THAT IS ONE
- 32:03THING OR MORE INFLAMMATORY THAT
- 32:05IS ANOTHER.
- 32:06AND THOSE ARE MUCH DIFFERENT
- 32:08CONVERSATIONS I'D LIKE TO SEE
- 32:10MORE HOPE FOR OUR COUNTRY AND
- 32:13PEOPLE TALKING ABOUT GETTING
- 32:15BACK TO IF YOU WANT TO TAKE, GET
- 32:18AMERICA BACK ON TRACK AND THE
- 32:20PLACE WHERE IT WAS, I WOULD LOOK
- 32:22AT A REAGAN.
- 32:23I WOULD TAKE THAT AS FAR AS THE
- 32:26RHETORIC TAKE GEORGE BUSH OVER
- 32:28WHAT WE HAVE RIGHT NOW.
- 32:29AND DEMOCRATS ARE LOOKING AND
- 32:30SAYING CLEARLY, BARACK OBAMA WAS
- 32:34TALKING ABOUT HOPE AND CHANGE
- 32:37AND AT THAT TIME I DID NOT AGREE
- 32:40WITH GEORGE W. BUSH BUT I DIDN'T
- 32:41THINK HE WAS AN EVIL MAN.
- 32:44AND DISAGREED WITH A LOT OF HIS
- 32:47POLICIES.
- 32:48I'M LOOKING AT IS IT IN THAT WAY
- 32:50AND THINK ABOUT THAT McCAIN
- 32:52CONVERSATION THE DEBATE WITH HIM
- 32:54AND OBAMA WHERE HE STOPPED A
- 32:56LADY FROM TALKING ABOUT OBAMA IN
- 32:57A WAY THAT WASN'T A GOOD
- 33:00AMERICAN HE WASN'T FROM HERE
- 33:02THAT HE WASN'T EVEN BECAUSE THEY
- 33:05HAD THE --
- 33:07WASN'T BORN IN HAWAII HE WAS
- 33:09KENTUCKIAN.
- 33:11I LOOK BACK AT THOSE
- 33:13CONVERSATIONS ROMNEY AS WELL,
- 33:14AND WHERE ARE THEY?
- 33:15THAT IS WHAT I'M TRYING TO
- 33:17FIGURE OUT.
- 33:17ON THE DEMOCRAT SIDE, GAVIN
- 33:21NEWSOM TROLLING THE PRESIDENT
- 33:22WHILE I UNDERSTAND WHY HE IS
- 33:24DOING IT, NOT HELPFUL.
- 33:26BUT HE CAME OUT IMMEDIATELY AND
- 33:28SAID AS FAR AS CHARLIE KIRK THAT
- 33:31THIS IS WHERE THINGS ARE AND
- 33:34SAID HE WAS SORRY FOR THE FAMILY
- 33:36AND FOR HIS KIDS.
- 33:37BUT YOU READ THE COMMENTS EVERY
- 33:39COMMENT WAS LIKE YOU WERE JUST
- 33:40SAYING THIS AND JUMPING ALL OVER
- 33:42HIM.
- 33:43SO I'M HOPEFUL THAT PEOPLE SEE
- 33:44THAT AND REALIZE THAT WE DO HAVE
- 33:51TO PUT I DON'T REMEMBER WHO SAID
- 33:53IT WE HAVE TO PUT OUR HANDOUT
- 33:56AND COMING FROM THE DEMOCRATIC
- 33:57SIDE OF THE AISLE I AM HOPING
- 33:59THAT SOMEBODY WILL SHAKE THAT
- 34:01HAND THAT IS WHAT IT'S GOING TO
- 34:02TAKE IS OUR LEADERS THAT ARE
- 34:04DOING.
- 34:05I'M PROUD THAT ANDY BESHEAR IS
- 34:06DOING THAT AS OUR GOVERNOR AND
- 34:08HAS BEEN DOING THAT.
- 34:09AND TALKING MORE OF
- 34:13COLLABORATION AND WORKING WITH
- 34:15ACROSS THE AISLE.
- 34:16I'M HOPEFUL WE CONTINUE THAT
- 34:19CONVERSATION THAT IS OUR
- 34:21DISCOURSE FOR THE NEXT PERIOD.
- 34:23I'M NOT SURE WE ARE THERE RIGHT
- 34:25NOW.
- 34:26NOT SURE IT'S COMING SOON IT
- 34:27WILL TAKE ALL OF US TO DO THAT.
- 34:30>> Renee: HOW DO WE GET PAST THE
- 34:31US VERSUS THEM THE NATURE WE'VE
- 34:34SEEN COME TO PLAY?
- 34:35>> I THINK WE HAVE TO DO WHAT
- 34:36WE'RE DOING RIGHT NOW.
- 34:37AND I THINK PEOPLE HAVE TO BE
- 34:39OPEN TO THOSE CONVERSATIONS.
- 34:42GOING BACK TO THIS U.S. SENATE
- 34:44RACE TO TRES' POINT IT STARTED
- 34:47OFF SO NEGATIVE WE SKIPPED OVER
- 34:49THE NICE INTRO ADS WE HAVE A
- 34:51NICE AD FROM CONGRESSMAN BARR
- 34:54THIS WILL BE AN EXPENSIVE U.S.
- 34:55SENATE RACE.
- 34:56WE ARE NOT NEAR OUR MAY PRIMARY.
- 34:59>> CONGRATULATIONS TO ALL THE TV
- 35:00STATIONS IN THE STATE.
- 35:04>> Renee: COMMERCIAL TV
- 35:05STATIONS.
- 35:05>> THEY STARTED SO NEGATIVE TO
- 35:07SELF CORRECT BACK TO A DIFFERENT
- 35:09TYPE OF TONE IT'S GOING TO TAKE
- 35:11A LITTLE BIT AND I'M NOT SURE
- 35:13ALL CANDIDATES IN THIS RACE ARE
- 35:15WILLING TO DO THAT.
- 35:15>> AND THERE IS A REASON WHY
- 35:17THEY DO THAT.
- 35:18THERE IS A REASON WHY THEY
- 35:20ENGAGE IN PROTECT ACTIVE AFD FER
- 35:22ADS BECAUSE IT WORKS.
- 35:24AND THERE IS REASON WHY THE
- 35:28MESSAGES ON TWITTER AND OR
- 35:30WHATEVER IT'S CALLED, AND SOCIAL
- 35:32MEDIA ARE SO DIVISIVE AND ANGRY
- 35:37AND HIGHLIGHTED BY EMOTION IS
- 35:39BECAUSE IT WORKS.
- 35:40SO IT REALLY IS GOING TO TAKE
- 35:42ALL OF US AND NOT JUST
- 35:44POLITICIANS OR RECOVERING
- 35:46POLITICIANS, BUT EVERY CITIZEN
- 35:47TO RECOGNIZE THAT THIS IS A FLAW
- 35:50THAT WE ALL HAVE RIGHT NOW.
- 35:52AND WE WOULD ALL BE DOING BETTER
- 35:55IF WE TURNED DOWN THE NOISE OF
- 35:57THESE NEGATIVE ADS AND THESE
- 36:00AWFUL THINGS BEING SAID ON-LINE
- 36:02AND FOCUS MORE ON THE VALUES
- 36:04THAT THE CANDIDATES SHARE
- 36:05WHETHER THEY ARE DEMOCRATS OR
- 36:06REPUBLICANS.
- 36:07>> I'VE BEEN PUTTING OUT A
- 36:08POLICY PROPOSAL THAT I THINK
- 36:10WOULD HAVE SOME EFFECT.
- 36:13CONGRESS NEEDS TO ACT.
- 36:14I DON'T THINK THERE IS ANY ISSUE
- 36:16WITH FREE SPEECH, CONGRESS
- 36:20SHOULD USE BAN THE ALGORITHMS TO
- 36:24BAN THE USE OF ALGORITHMS TO
- 36:27DELIVER THAT CONTENT TO USERS.
- 36:28A LOT OF WHAT IS GOING ON NOW IF
- 36:31YOU GO ON TO X OR FACEBOOK, AND
- 36:34X IS EASIER TO DISPLAY IT YOU
- 36:36HAVE THE PEOPLE YOU FOLLOW AND
- 36:38THEN YOU HAVE THE FOR YOU.
- 36:39AND MY FOR YOU IS A HEALTH SCAN
- 36:42IT IS AWFUL.
- 36:43IF THAT IS ALL I READ, I WOULD
- 36:46BE DOWN AT BUD'S GUN SHOP MAXES
- 36:49OUT MY CREDIT CARD BECAUSE
- 36:52SOMETHING'S COMING.
- 36:53AND PEOPLE READ THAT BECAUSE
- 36:54THAT IS WHAT DEFAULTS WHEN YOU
- 36:56OPEN YOUR APP.
- 36:57THERE ARE COMPANIES OUT THERE
- 36:58WHO ARE PROFITING OFF OF
- 37:01DELIVERING THOSE DIVISIVE
- 37:03MESSAGES BECAUSE THE CAMPAIGNS
- 37:05NEGATIVE WORKS NEGATIVE GETS ICE
- 37:07AND CLICKS NEGATIVE GETS
- 37:09ENGAGEMENTS AND THAT IS WHAT
- 37:11PAYS THE SOCIAL MEDIA COMPANIES
- 37:12THEY ARE PROFITING OFF THE
- 37:14DIVISION OF AMERICANS.
- 37:16WE NEED TO STOP THAT.
- 37:17AND AGAIN, THERE'S NO FREE
- 37:19SPEECH VIOLATION.
- 37:20PEOPLE ARE STILL ABLE TO USE THE
- 37:22APP AND SAY WHATEVER THEY WANT
- 37:24BUT THE COMPANIES SHOULD NOT BE
- 37:25ALLOWED TO PROFIT OFF OF THE
- 37:27DIVISION OF AMERICANS.
- 37:29>> Renee: SOCIAL MEDIA HAS BEEN
- 37:31AROUND A LONGTIME NOW.
- 37:31I DIDN'T GET ON X OR TWITTER
- 37:35UNTIL 2011 BUT I'M LATE TO
- 37:37EVERYTHING.
- 37:38WHY IS IT SEEMS TO BE SO MUCH
- 37:40MORE INTENSE?
- 37:40THE ALGORITHMS?
- 37:42>> THE TARGETING OF ADS THE
- 37:45ALGORITHMS USED AND WHEN WE LOOK
- 37:48AT HOW CAMPAIGNS HAVE CHANGED
- 37:50AND WHY CAMPAIGNS ARE SO ENGAGED
- 37:53IN THE SOCIAL MEDIA AND WEB ADS
- 37:56IS YOU CAN REACH MORE VOTERS
- 37:59QUICKLY.
- 37:59IT IS A LOT EASIER TO REACH AND
- 38:02TARGET THOSE VOTERS THAN TO GO
- 38:03OUT AND WALK IN A PARADE FOR TWO
- 38:06MILES WHICH ARE VERY IMPORTANT
- 38:08THINGS TO DO.
- 38:09AND WE TALK ABOUT THE SIXTH
- 38:10DISTRICT RACE, THAT IS WHERE
- 38:12THEY ARE FOCUSED AND THAT IS
- 38:13WHAT WE'RE SEEING.
- 38:15WE HAVE TO BRING BACK THE NOTION
- 38:17THAT CANDIDATES AND CAMPAIGNS
- 38:19CANNOT SUB IN AND CALL IT IN AND
- 38:21DIAL IT IN FOR SOCIAL MEDIA
- 38:24OUTREACH.
- 38:25THERE HAS TO STILL BE THIS OLD
- 38:27SCHOOL WAY OF CAMPAIGNING THAT
- 38:29I'M CONVINCED YOU CANNOT
- 38:31REPLACE.
- 38:32AND THAT IS GETTING OUT AND
- 38:34SHAKING HANDS AND TALKING TO
- 38:35PEOPLE FACE-TO-FACE.
- 38:36AND THAT IS WHERE YOU DON'T SEE
- 38:38THE DISAGREEMENT.
- 38:39THAT IS WHERE YOU DON'T SEE THE
- 38:42ANGST.
- 38:43YES, YOU MAY HAVE DISAGREEMENT
- 38:44ON ISSUES BUT IT ALLOWS
- 38:46CANDIDATES TO HAVE FACE-TO-FACE
- 38:48CONVERSATIONS AND ALLOWS VOTERS
- 38:49ACCESS TO THOSE INDIVIDUALS TO
- 38:51BE ABLE TO SEE THEM FOR WHO THEY
- 38:52ARE AND NOT IN A 30-SECOND CLIP.
- 38:55>> AND THE SOCIAL MEDIA
- 38:56OVERLORDS MADE SERIOUS MISTAKES
- 38:58IN THE PAST FIVE YEARS AS WELL.
- 39:00THEY MADE A MISTAKE BY BANNING
- 39:03DONALD TRUMP FROM SOCIAL MEDIA.
- 39:04I THOUGHT IT WAS A BIG MISTAKE
- 39:06AND IT CAUSED TREMENDOUS ANGER.
- 39:08BUT I THINK THE REACTION HAS
- 39:10ALSO BEEN A MISTAKE BY NOW
- 39:13TAKING OFF ALL OF THE
- 39:15GUARDRAILS.
- 39:17MY --
- 39:17I DON'T KNOW IT IS THIS WAY BUT
- 39:19MY FOR YOU ON TWITTER IS FILLED
- 39:22WITH ANTISEMITIC ATTACKS ON MY
- 39:25PEOPLE AND IT'S CONSTANT.
- 39:27I TRY TO HIDE AND DELETE THEM
- 39:29AND THEY KEEP COMING BACK.
- 39:31AND AGAIN, EVERYBODY HAS THE
- 39:33RIGHT TO BE ANTISEMITIC AND SAY
- 39:35BAD THINGS ABOUT OTHER PEOPLE
- 39:37BUT THE PLATFORMS DON'T HAVE TO
- 39:41ALLOW THAT OR MANAGE IN WAYS
- 39:43THAT FIND BALANCE WHERE WE HAVE
- 39:45FREE SPEECH BUT IT IS NOT A
- 39:46STREAM OF HATE.
- 39:48>> Renee: SHERMAN?
- 39:50>> YES.
- 39:51I THINK AMY AND JONATHAN TAPPED
- 39:54ON WHAT I WAS GOING TO SAY.
- 39:56BUT I WILL GO A DIFFERENT ROUTE.
- 39:59EMPATHY IS GONE AS OF RIGHT NOW.
- 40:00WE'RE NOT SEEING ANY TYPE OF
- 40:04EMPATHY WHEN IT COMES TO WHAT
- 40:06PEOPLE ARE GOING THROUGH, HOW
- 40:09THEY ARE REACTING TO A LEADER OF
- 40:11THEIRS OR SOMEONE THAT THEY
- 40:13IDENTIFY WITH OR GO BACK TO THE
- 40:18CHARLIE KIRK IMMEDIATELY PEOPLE
- 40:20JUMPING IN AND SAYING HOW THEY
- 40:23FEEL ABOUT HIM.
- 40:24THE SAME THING YOU COULD ARGUE
- 40:27WITH THE MURDERS IN MINNESOTA OF
- 40:29THE TWO LEGISLATORS.
- 40:31AND AS THAT ASSASSINATION THERE
- 40:34AND THE RESPONSE FROM OUR
- 40:36LEADERS AND SPECIFICALLY FROM
- 40:38DONALD TRUMP SAYING HE DOESN'T
- 40:40WANT TO TALK TO GOVERNOR WALTZ,
- 40:44THERE'S NO EMPATHY OF TRYING IT
- 40:46FIGURE IT OUT.
- 40:47AND AGAIN, WE GO BACK TO I DON'T
- 40:50WANT TO HAVE A CONVERSATION
- 40:51ABOUT WHAT HAPPENED IN THE PAST
- 40:53BECAUSE OF WHAT IS HAPPENING
- 40:55NOW, THAT EMPATHY NEEDS TO BE
- 40:58SOMETHING THAT WE'RE ALL LOOKING
- 40:59AT AND TRYING TO FIGURE OUT.
- 41:01AND THE ALGORITHMS WE CAN BLAME
- 41:03THAT.
- 41:04BUT THAT PLAYS A PART I DON'T
- 41:05THINK IT IS THE ONLY THING.
- 41:07I THINK WE'VE GOT TO BE MINDFUL
- 41:09THAT IS A MEDIUM.
- 41:11IF THEY WORK BECAUSE OF WHAT YOU
- 41:13ARE SEARCHING FOR AND LOOKING
- 41:14FOR AND WHO YOU FOLLOW I'M NOT
- 41:17SAYING IT'S ALL WRONG, THAT IS
- 41:19DOVE NATURALLY A PART OF IT BUT
- 41:21IT'S NOT THE ONLY THING GOING
- 41:22ON.
- 41:23AND WE HAVE TO ADDRESS TOP TO
- 41:25BOTTOM HOW PEOPLE ARE TALKING
- 41:26WHO THEY ARE TALKING TO, WHY
- 41:27THEY ARE TALKING THAT WAY.
- 41:30AND TRES I ONLY HAVE TO TALK TO
- 41:32MY BASE THAT IS WHAT YOU SEE THE
- 41:34PRESIDENT DOING AND YOU SEE
- 41:36DEMOCRATS DOING THAT AS WELL.
- 41:38WE DON'T HAVE ONE PERSON
- 41:40SPEAKING FOR US SO IT'S
- 41:41DIFFERENT WHEN THAT GETS TO THE
- 41:4328 RACE AND WE'RE GOING TO BE
- 41:45THERE CLOSER WITH THE MIDTERMS
- 41:47IS WHEN YOU WILL SEE START
- 41:49POPPING OUT AND ARE THEY ONLY
- 41:51TALKING TO THE BASE OR TREATING
- 41:53THIS AS A BROADER CONVERSATION
- 41:55AND TO GET BACK TO THAT
- 41:57SEPTEMBER 12TH AS WE TALKED
- 41:59ABOUT 2001 CONVERSATION AND THAT
- 42:01WAS EMPATHY AND LOOKING AT
- 42:04EVERYBODY.
- 42:04AND I THINK PRESIDENT BUSH
- 42:08BRINGING EVERYBODY TOGETHER HE
- 42:10KNEW WHAT WE WERE ALL GOING
- 42:11THROUGH AND WHAT WE NEEDED TO
- 42:13HEAR AND IT WAS MORE OF THAT
- 42:14CONVERSATION.
- 42:15WE ARE NOT GETTING THAT RIGHT
- 42:16NOW FROM OUR PRESIDENT AND
- 42:19HONESTLY I WAS HOPING HOPEFUL
- 42:22I'VE BEEN HOPEFUL BEFORE FOR HIM
- 42:24BUT I WAS HOPEFUL THAT DAY AND
- 42:25IT WASN'T THERE.
- 42:27>> Renee: WE ALSO KNOW THAT
- 42:30CONGRESSIONAL LEADERS, MEMBERS
- 42:33OF THE DELEGATION ALSO ARE NOT
- 42:37HAVING TOWN HALLS, RIGHT?
- 42:38FOR ALL KINDS OF REASONS AND TO
- 42:40GET TO AMY'S POINT ABOUT
- 42:43ENGAGING WITH VIEWERS AT A
- 42:49DIFFERENT LEVEL NOT JUST SOCIAL
- 42:51MEDIA THERE ARE OPPORTUNITIES
- 42:52BUT THEY CAN BE FRAUGHT WITH
- 42:53SECURITY CONCERNS AND THINGS YOU
- 42:55FEAR OUT OF PERSONAL SAFETY.
- 42:56>> AND ESPECIALLY NOW.
- 42:58I THINK THAT THERE'S NOT ONE OF
- 43:01US, RIGHT, WHO ARE IN THE
- 43:04POLITICAL SPHERE WE ARE NOT
- 43:05CANDIDATES WE DON'T HOLD OFFICE.
- 43:11BUT DIDN'T FEEL ROCKED BY WHAT
- 43:13WE SAW HAPPEN.
- 43:14BECAUSE ALL OF US HAVE BEEN TO
- 43:17NUMEROUS RALLIES, PARADES,
- 43:20FORUMS, TOWN HALLS, YOU NAME IT
- 43:22WHERE YOU JUST WALK IN.
- 43:24AND YOU HOPE AND WE TAKE FOR
- 43:27GRANTED WE ARE IN A SAFE SPACE
- 43:28TO BE ABLE TO HAVE THAT
- 43:30DISCOURSE.
- 43:31AND THAT PEOPLE IN THE ROOM WILL
- 43:32BE CIVIL.
- 43:33AND THAT WE WILL TAKE CARE OF
- 43:35EACH OTHER EVEN THOUGH WE WILL
- 43:36DISAGREE.
- 43:38AND SO, YES, WHAT I'M FEARFUL OF
- 43:41IS THAT WHAT WE SAW HAPPEN IS
- 43:44GOING TO RESTRICT THAT ACCESS
- 43:47SOMEWHAT.
- 43:47AND THAT IS A SHAME.
- 43:49BUT THAT IS THE REALITY OF THE
- 43:52WORLD WE LIVE IN.
- 43:53AND YOU KNOW, WATCHING THE NEWS
- 43:55BEFORE COMING IN HERE, I THINK
- 43:57MEMBERS OF CONGRESS ARE HAVING
- 43:59DIALOGUE WHAT TYPES OF SECURITY
- 44:01MEASURES ARE PUT INTO PLACE.
- 44:02WE GO TO LEGISLATIVE CONFERENCES
- 44:04I RECEIVED AN E-MAIL FROM A
- 44:07NATIONAL LEGISLATIVE
- 44:07ORGANIZATION THAT WANTED
- 44:08EVERYBODY TO KNOW THEY ARE
- 44:10REVISITING ALL SAFETY PROTOCOLS
- 44:12AND MEASURES FOR WHEN GUESTS AND
- 44:16LEGISLATORS ATTEND THE
- 44:17CONFERENCES.
- 44:19THE WORST THING IS WE PUT A
- 44:21BARRIER BETWEEN VOTERS AND THE
- 44:22CANDIDATES FOR OFFICE.
- 44:24>> Renee: AND BARRIERS FOR GOOD
- 44:25PEOPLE TO RUN.
- 44:26>> THAT IS ONE OF THE THINGS I
- 44:28WILL I'M MOST CONCERNED ABOUT
- 44:30SINCE THE GABBY GIFFORD
- 44:33SHOOTING.
- 44:33ONE OF THE THINGS THAT MAKES
- 44:35AMERICA GREAT OUR LEADERS COME
- 44:36FROM US WE DON'T HAVE A HOUSE OF
- 44:40LORDS.
- 44:41OUR LEADERS COME FROM US AND
- 44:42PART OF WHAT KEEPS THEM GROUNDED
- 44:44IS THE ACCESSIBILITY.
- 44:46MITCH McCONNELL WHEN HE WAS
- 44:48SENATE MAJORITY LEADER ONE OF
- 44:50THE MOST POWERFUL POLITICIANS IF
- 44:52YOU HAD 50 BUCKS YOU COULD GO TO
- 44:54LUNCH AND BE 25 FEET FROM MITCH
- 44:56McCONNELL.
- 44:57IF YOU WANT TO SEE ANDY BESHEAR
- 44:59SPEAK OR RAND PAUL OUR LEADERS
- 45:01ARE ACCESSIBLE IT'S GOOD BECAUSE
- 45:03THEY GET TO SEE REALITY.
- 45:05MITCH McCONNELL SHOPS AT THE
- 45:07KROGER AND TAILGATES HE IS OUT
- 45:09AND ABOUT.
- 45:10YOU CAN TALK TO HIM RESPECTFULLY
- 45:12OR NOT.
- 45:13THAT IS YOUR CHOICE.
- 45:14BUT THEY ARE ACCESSIBLE.
- 45:16AND WHEN WE START PUTTING UP
- 45:18WALLS BETWEEN THE GOVERNED AND
- 45:20THOSE DOING THE GOVERNING, NOT
- 45:21ONLY DOES IT MAKE THEM LESS
- 45:24RESPONSIVE TO US, BUT IT STARTS
- 45:28TO FEED YOUR PARANOIA, FEED YOUR
- 45:30FEAR AND THAT BELIEF THAT THEY
- 45:32ARE DOING WRONG THINGS BECAUSE
- 45:33WE NO LONGER HAVE THAT
- 45:37FACE-TO-FACE INTERACTION.
- 45:38I'M FEARFUL NOT JUST AS
- 45:40POLITICAL OPERATIVE AT THOSE
- 45:42EVENTS AND DOESN'T WANT TO HAVE
- 45:44TO BE DUCKING STRAY SHOTS THAT
- 45:47IS HORRIFIC BUT WORRIED ABOUT
- 45:48THE FUTURE OF OUR COUNTRY AND
- 45:50HAVING THE REPUBLIC THE WAY IT
- 45:51IS AND THE RESPONSIVENESS AND
- 45:54THE CITIZENRY TO ELECTED
- 45:56RELATIONSHIP WE'VE GOT.
- 45:58>> Renee: AS WE LOOK ON THE
- 46:00250TH ANNIVERSARY OF THE
- 46:02DECLARATION OF INDEPENDENCE LOOK
- 46:03WHERE WE ARE?
- 46:04>> I LEFT ELECTED POLITICS 18
- 46:06YEARS AGO.
- 46:08AND ONE OF THE REASONS WHY I
- 46:12DECIDED NEVER TO RUN AGAIN WAS
- 46:14THE COURSENING OF POLITICS AND
- 46:17HOW UGLY IT HAD GOTTEN AND BOY,
- 46:222007 WAS A HOUSE OWN EDEN
- 46:25COMPARED TO NOW.
- 46:26ONE OF THE THINGS I'M FEARFUL IS
- 46:28WILL THIS NEXT GENERATION OF
- 46:31PUBLIC SERVANTS OF COMMUNITY
- 46:34ACTIVISTS OF PEOPLE WHO WANT TO
- 46:35MAKE A DIFFERENCE FOR THE RIGHT
- 46:37REASONS ON THE LEFT OR THE RIGHT
- 46:38WILL THEY PUT THEIR NAME ON THE
- 46:40BALLOT?
- 46:42AND WILL THESE SECURITY CONCERNS
- 46:43BE PART OF THAT CALCULATION?
- 46:46MY WIFE IS EXCITED ABOUT ME NOT
- 46:48BEING IN POLITICS AND JUST THIS
- 46:51PAST WEEK HAS ADDED TO THE FUEL
- 46:53TO HER FIRE AS TO WHY SHE IS SO
- 46:56GLAD THAT I AM A PRIVATE CITIZEN
- 46:58NOW.
- 46:59AND THAT MEANS WE'RE GOING TO
- 47:01HAVE MORE PEOPLE WHO ARE IN IT
- 47:03FOR THE WRONG REASONS AND THAT'S
- 47:06COMPILING THE PROBLEMS FOR
- 47:08DEMOCRACY.
- 47:08>> Renee: BUT YOU ARE STILL
- 47:11PUBLIC FACING, RIGHT?
- 47:12AND STILL INVOLVED IN THIS
- 47:14POLITICAL DISCOURSE.
- 47:15ARE YOU EVER CONCERNED QUITE
- 47:18FRANKLY, ABOUT BEING SO PUBLIC
- 47:20FACING AND SHARING YOUR OPINIONS
- 47:22JUST AS YOU ARE DOING NOW?
- 47:23>> SURE.
- 47:25ABSOLUTELY.
- 47:26BUT, I THINK, THE UPSIDE TO IT,
- 47:29RIGHT, WE SHOULDN'T BE FEARFUL.
- 47:31AND SHERMAN AND I HAD A GOOD
- 47:34CONVERSATION HOW WE KNEW TONIGHT
- 47:35WAS GOING TO BE HARD.
- 47:36BUT WE BOTH AGREED THAT IT'S
- 47:38HARD BECAUSE IT MATTERS.
- 47:40AND SO, I THINK, THAT'S EVERY
- 47:43TIME WE'RE GIVEN THESE
- 47:45OPPORTUNITIES, THE PRIVILEGE
- 47:47THAT WE HAVE TO BE ABLE TO SIT
- 47:48HERE AND SHARE OUR EXPERIENCE ON
- 47:51A PANEL AND THE STATE OF THE
- 47:52NATION AND THE COMMONWEALTH IS A
- 47:55GREAT PRIVILEGE THAT WE HAVE.
- 47:56AND I THINK IT'S WORTH IT EVEN
- 47:58IF WE CAN CHANGE ONE OR TWO
- 48:00MINDS TO MAYBE PAUSE AND TAKE A
- 48:02BEAT AND JUST THINK.
- 48:03>> LOOK, I AM A PARTISAN I DO A
- 48:09PODCAST I'M ON LARRY GLOVE RADIO
- 48:12THEY LET ME GUEST HOST NOW AND
- 48:15THEN I'M NOT GOING TO PULL MY
- 48:17PUNCHES.
- 48:18I'M GOING TO ADVOCATE FOR MY
- 48:20CAUSE AND I'M GOING TO
- 48:23AGGRESSIVELY AGAINST CANDIDATES
- 48:24I WOULD NOT LIKE TO SEE ELECTED
- 48:26IN OFFICE.
- 48:26IT DOESN'T MEAN YOU HAVE TO STOP
- 48:28ANY SORT OF NEGATIVE
- 48:30CAMPAIGNING.
- 48:31IT'S EFFECTIVE BUT THERE IS A
- 48:32WAY YOU CAN DO IT.
- 48:33THE CONTEXT MATTERS AND THE
- 48:35FRAMING MATTERS AND THE WORDS
- 48:36THAT YOU CHOOSE TO USE MATTER.
- 48:39AND YOU KNOW, I THINK THAT THERE
- 48:41IS A MEDIUM THERE IS A MIDDLE
- 48:43GROUND WHERE WE CAN STILL HAVE
- 48:45POLITICS IS NOT TOUCHED IT'S
- 48:47TACKLE FOOTBALL AND WE CAN STILL
- 48:49HAVE THAT WHILE NOT CAUSING AND
- 48:53FOR MENTDING THE POLITICAL
- 48:55VIOLENCE WE'RE SEEING RIGHT NOW.
- 48:57>> Renee: GETTING BACK TO A
- 48:58LITTLE BIT OF RACES ALMOST
- 48:59BEFORE US AND I WANT TO REVISIT
- 49:01U.S. SENATE RACE ANYTHING ELSE
- 49:03YOU WANT TO TALK ON THERE?
- 49:05WE TALKED ABOUT THE CAMPAIGNING
- 49:06STYLE?
- 49:07>> THE LATEST POLLING WE SAW
- 49:09COME OUT IT WAS AFFILIATED WITH
- 49:12A PRO BARR PACT BUT WHAT WE SEE,
- 49:15RIGHT?
- 49:15I THINK IT WOULD TREND WITH WHAT
- 49:18WE'RE ALL SEEING HAPPENING ON
- 49:20THE CAMPAIGN TRAIL RIGHT NOW
- 49:21WHICH IS THAT BARR IS STARTING
- 49:24TO INCREASE HIS NUMBERS AND GAIN
- 49:25ON CAMERON.
- 49:27CAMERON LEADS THE PACK RIGHT NOW
- 49:30BUT WITH BARR MAKING SIGNIFICANT
- 49:32MOVES, BARR'S FUNDRAISING IS
- 49:33STILL TREMENDOUS AND GIVES HIM
- 49:35THAT BIG ADVANTAGE WHERE
- 49:37CAMERON'S FUNDRAISING HAS NOT
- 49:38MET THAT MARK.
- 49:39SO I THINK, WE'LL SEE IF MORRIS'
- 49:42NUMBERS START TO MOVE.
- 49:43I WOULD LOVE TO SEE A POLL THAT
- 49:47SHOWS PHASED UNPHASED TO SEE
- 49:48WHERE THE CANDIDATES ARE.
- 49:50HOPEFULLY WE WILL SEE THAT IN
- 49:51THE COMING MONTHS.
- 49:53>> THIS IS A WEIRD CAMPAIGN.
- 49:55BECAUSE YOU HAVE DANIEL CAMERON
- 49:57WHO HAS ALMOST UNIVERSAL NAME ID
- 50:00AMONG REPUBLICAN PRIMARY VOTERS
- 50:01AND MASSIVELY AND HE IS ALSO I
- 50:04WOULD SAY THE LEAST LIKELY OF
- 50:06THE THREE TO WIN.
- 50:08>> Renee: WHY?
- 50:08>> HIS FUNDRAISING IS STRUGGLING
- 50:10IN A U.S. SENATE CAMPAIGN IT
- 50:12BECOMES MUCH MORE ABOUT THE AIR
- 50:13WAR THAN THE GROUND WAR.
- 50:14IT IS A WIG STATE IT'S EXPENSIVE
- 50:17TO CAMPAIGN IN AND RUN ADS IN.
- 50:20AND I THINK THAT BARR YOU
- 50:23ALREADY SEE BARR'S NUMBERS UP
- 50:25AND HE WILL MOVE FASTER UP,
- 50:28TIM'S ASSUMING POURIES IS GOING
- 50:30TO BE COMING WITH POSITIVE NAME
- 50:33ID STUFF.
- 50:34WE'RE GOING TO MOVE RETURN BACK
- 50:36TO THE BEGINNING WITH THE INTRO
- 50:38PIECES.
- 50:39AND I THINK THAT YOU ARE GOING
- 50:41TO SEE CAMERON WITH THE LEAD
- 50:43THROUGH LATE JANUARY, FEBRUARY,
- 50:45MAYBE IN MARCH.
- 50:46BUT ONCE HE GETS PAST THEY ARE
- 50:51GOING TO FAST HIM FAST.
- 50:54THEY ARE HAVING THIS TROUBLE
- 50:55RAISING MONEY AND IT SAYS THAT
- 50:57THERE'S GOING TO BE A HUGE SHAKE
- 50:58UP ONCE THE OTHER TWO CANDIDATES
- 51:01CATCH UP.
- 51:02>> Renee: COULD THAT BE BECAUSE
- 51:03THIS IS NOT AN ELECTION YEAR
- 51:05PEOPLE MAY NOT BE PAYING
- 51:07ATTENTION DOES THAT IMPACT ON
- 51:08ONE'S ABILITY TO RAISE MONEY?
- 51:10OR INDICATIVE OF STRENGTH OR
- 51:12WEAK NNS.
- 51:12>> IT HELPS CAMERON'S NAME ID
- 51:16FLOAT HIM ON TOP LONGER BECAUSE
- 51:18PEOPLE AREN'T PAYING ATTENTION
- 51:19TO THE OTHERS.
- 51:21SO THIS BAKED IN NAME ID LETS
- 51:25HIM IMPROVE.
- 51:26>> Renee: TO YOUR POINT OF THE
- 51:28INVERSION HOW THIS CAMPAIGN
- 51:30UNFOLDED MAYBE THERE'S POLITICAL
- 51:33CALCULUS TO GO AFTER YOUR
- 51:36OPPOSITION EARLY AND DO THE WARM
- 51:38STUFF LATER?
- 51:38>> I SAID IF I WAS ANDY BARR
- 51:42CAMPAIGN I WOULD HAVE RUN AN AD
- 51:44DURING THE DERBY LAYING OUT THE
- 51:46CASE OF NATE MORRIS SMOTHER THE
- 51:48CAMPAIGN BEFORE IT GETS STARTED.
- 51:50ONCE YOU START FIGHTING BACK AND
- 51:53FORTH IT MAKES IT HARDER.
- 51:55IF I HAD BEEN OUT THERE I WOULD
- 51:57HAVE BEEN TRYING TO DEFINE
- 51:58EARLIER.
- 52:00TO WAIT UNTIL HE GOT IN THE RACE
- 52:02AND A AIR WAR, I WOULD LOVE TO
- 52:04SEE WHERE THE NUMBERS ARE TO SEE
- 52:06WHAT THE EFFECT OF THE ADS WERE.
- 52:09>> Renee: I WANT TO GET TO HE IS
- 52:11NOT ON THE BALLOT AND THAT IS
- 52:14GOVERNOR ANDY BESHEAR.
- 52:15JOHN JOHN THERE WAS A PIECE IN
- 52:17THE JURY JURY LAST WEEK OR
- 52:19BEFORE COURIER-JOURNAL ABOUT
- 52:21BROWN SAYING HE NEEDS TO
- 52:22CONSIDER RUNNING IN THE U.S.
- 52:24SENATE RACE BECAUSE HE WOULD BE
- 52:25A GOOD CANDIDATE.
- 52:26ARE YOU TRYING TO CONVINCE HIM?
- 52:28>> I HATE TO DISAGREE WITH
- 52:30CHRISTIE BROWN SHE LIFTED UP MY
- 52:33GUBERNATORIAL CAMPAIGN AND MADE
- 52:34ME A SERIOUS CONTENDER AND
- 52:37SOMEONE I VALUE TREMENDOUSLY.
- 52:39BUT I DO DISAGREE WITH HER.
- 52:41AND THE GOVERNOR'S MADE CLEAR
- 52:43THAT HE WANTS TO NOT RUN FOR
- 52:46THIS AND SERVE OUT HIS TERM AND
- 52:48I THINK HE'S CERTAINLY
- 52:50INDIRECTLY MADE CLEAR THAT HE'S
- 52:52GOING TO RUN FOR THE PRESIDENCY
- 52:54IF A LANE DOES OPEN.
- 52:56AND I DO THINK THAT HE'S GOT AS
- 52:59GOOD A CHANCE AS ANYBODY IT IS A
- 53:02LONGSHOT FOR EVERYONE.
- 53:02I THINK HE HAS AS GOOD A CHANCE
- 53:05AS ANYBODY AND TO GO BACK TO THE
- 53:06MESSAGE AND SHERMAN MADE THIS
- 53:08POINT HE HAS BEEN TALKING ABOUT
- 53:10HIS CHRISTIAN VALUES AND ABOUT
- 53:12UNITING THE PUBLIC AND ABOUT
- 53:16TRYING TO GET OVER THIS NASTY
- 53:19INNOCENCE POLITICS.
- 53:22IF THAT MESSAGE IS RESONANT
- 53:25MAYBE HE HAS A SHOT AT WINNING.
- 53:27>> Renee: SHOULD THE GOVERNOR
- 53:28TAKE A PASS ON THE SENATE RACE
- 53:30BECAUSE HE WANTS TO CONTINUE AND
- 53:31SERVE OUT HIS TERM AS GOVERNOR
- 53:33AND LOOK AT A SERIOUS RUN FOR
- 53:35THE PRESIDENCY?
- 53:37>> HE'S ALREADY SAID HE IS NOT
- 53:41RUNNING.
- 53:41HE SAID THAT PRIVATELY.
- 53:43HE SAID THAT PUBLICLY.
- 53:45HE'S NOT RUNNING FOR U.S.
- 53:46SENATE.
- 53:47AND THAT'S NOT HAPPENING.
- 53:49I DO THINK THAT AS FAR AS THE
- 53:52CONVERSATION THAT HE HAS BEEN
- 53:55HAVING, I WAS WITH HIM, THERE, I
- 53:58WAS THERE IN OKLAHOMA WHEN HE
- 54:00SPOKE TO THE OKLAHOMA DEMOCRAT
- 54:02PARTY AND THERE AND THIS IS WELL
- 54:05BEFORE LAST SUMMER.
- 54:06AND THERE HE IS TALKING AND
- 54:09GIVING --
- 54:09HAVING A SPEECH ABOUT UNITY AND
- 54:11ABOUT RHETORIC THAT CONVERSATION
- 54:14THERE WAS OTHER THINGS IN THERE
- 54:16HE TALKED ABOUT POLICY AND WHERE
- 54:17HE DISAGREES WITH THE PRESIDENT
- 54:19AND DISAGREES WITH THINGS AT THE
- 54:21FEDERAL LEVEL.
- 54:22AND AT THE STATE LEVEL.
- 54:24HE DISAGREED WITH MANY THINGS
- 54:26BUT THERE WAS NEVER AN ATTACK ON
- 54:28SOMEONE AT THAT TIME.
- 54:29AND I'M HOPEFUL AGAIN THAT WE
- 54:31CAN GET BACK TO THAT OF CLEARLY
- 54:33I'M SUPPORTIVE OF ANDY BESHEAR
- 54:35HAVING WORKED FOR STEVE BESHEAR
- 54:37FOR FIVE YEARS.
- 54:40HE'S SOMEONE THAT I BELIEVE IN
- 54:41AND WATCHING AND PROUD OF.
- 54:43I DON'T SEE THAT CONVERSATION --
- 54:47I THINK THAT CONVERSATION IS
- 54:49WHAT WE NEED AND I DON'T SEE
- 54:50ENOUGH OF IT RIGHT NOW AND I'M
- 54:52HOPEFUL THAT IS WHERE IT IS.
- 54:54AND IF THAT'S WHAT PEOPLE WANT,
- 54:56THEN LIKE JONATHAN SAID THERE IS
- 54:58A LANE FOR HIM.
- 55:00AND I'M HOPEFUL THAT'S WHERE I
- 55:03WANT AND WHAT I WANT OUR
- 55:05POLITICS TO BE AND THE DISCOURSE
- 55:07TO BE THAT WE CAN ALL DISAGREE
- 55:09WITH WHATEVER IT IS.
- 55:10BUT, YEAH, ABSOLUTELY I THINK
- 55:12THAT IS WHERE HE IS LOOKING.
- 55:14AND HE'S TALKING TO THE RIGHT
- 55:16PEOPLE AND MAKING MOVES AND
- 55:18LOOKING AT THAT OPPORTUNITY IF
- 55:21IT ARISES.
- 55:23>> Renee: SO FROM THE DEMOCRATS
- 55:24WE KNOW THAT PAMELA STEVENSON IS
- 55:26MOUNTING A CAMPAIGN.
- 55:27WE EXPECT ANOTHER DEMOCRAT TO
- 55:29JUMP IN?
- 55:30JONATHAN MILLER?
- 55:31>> I THINK THAT THIS IS PROBABLY
- 55:33A BETTER QUESTION FOR CHUCK
- 55:36SCHUMER.
- 55:37AND THE FACT IS THAT FOR A
- 55:40DEMOCRAT TO HAVE ANY CHANCE IN
- 55:41THIS RACE, OTHER THAN ANDY
- 55:44BESHEAR INCLUDING ANDY BESHEAR
- 55:45THERE NEEDS TO BE A COMMITMENT
- 55:47FROM THE NATIONAL PARTY TO SPEND
- 55:50MILLIONS MAYBE TENS OF MILLIONS
- 55:51OF DOLLARS ON THIS SEAT.
- 55:53AND I KNOW THEY'VE TALKED TO THE
- 55:56GOVERNOR.
- 55:57I KNOW ROCKY ADKINS GETS BROUGHT
- 56:00UP.
- 56:01BUT UNLESS SCHUMER AND THE DSCC
- 56:04MAKES THAT COMMITMENT IT WILL BE
- 56:06A TALL HILL TO CLIMB.
- 56:13>> Renee: I THANK YOU ALL FOR
- 56:14THIS CONVERSATION TONIGHT.
- 56:15AND I HOPE THAT YOU FOUND IT
- 56:17HELPFUL AT HOME AND WE HOPE YOU
- 56:19WILL JOIN US ON "KENTUCKY
- 56:20EDITION" WHERE WE'LL TALK MORE
- 56:21ABOUT THE ISSUES CONFRONTING YOU
- 56:24AND WHAT WHATEVERS AT 6:30
- 56:26EASTERN 5:30 CENTRAL HERE ON
- 56:29KET.
- 56:30I'M RENEE SHAW THANK YOU FOR
- 56:31WATCHING TONIGHT.
- 56:32TAKE GOOD CARE AND I'LL SEE YOU
- 56:34SOON.