Latest / The Morning Rundown / A Livestreamed Execution Plan, Trump's Nobel Grudge, and SNL's Saturday
Transcript
- 0:14[Maya] I'm on my second coffee, and the news has already lapped me.
- 0:18[David] Only second?
- 0:19[David] Maya, it's a three-cup weekend.
- 0:21[Maya] Totally.
- 0:22[Maya] Okay, so welcome to the Morning Rundown.
- 0:24[Maya] I'm Maya, that's David, and we've got a pile to sort through.
- 0:28[David] We do.
- 0:28[David] There's a Livestream plan that might not be the plan anymore.
- 0:32[Maya] Wait, really?
- 0:33[David] Keep that thought.
- 0:33[David] I'm not saying more yet.
- 0:35[Maya] Fine, tease me.
- 0:37[Maya] Then there's the Nobel business and a grudge that apparently has a
- 0:40[Maya] pulse.
- 0:41[David] And Saturday Night Live had a few things to say about it.
- 0:44[Maya] Of course they did.
- 0:45[Maya] And the weekend itself got cut short, which, I mean, come on,
- 0:48[Maya] who asked for that?
- 0:49[David] Nobody.
- 0:50[David] Not a single person.
- 0:51[Maya] I'd like to file a formal complaint with the sky, but we'll
- 0:54[Maya] get there.
- 0:55[David] We will.
- 0:55[David] I promise.
- 0:56[David] It's a lighter ending to a heavier morning, so stick around for
- 0:59[David] all of it.
- 1:00[Maya] So anyway, the heavy one first.
- 1:02[David] Right.
- 1:02[David] Let's start with a story that has people across the aisle uneasy.
- 1:06[Maya] Okay, so a Pentagon official says the execution of the Fort Hood
- 1:11[Maya] shooter, Nidal Hasan, will be Livestreamed.
- 1:14[David] Livestreamed, like on the Internet.
- 1:16[Maya] That's the word the official used.
- 1:18[Maya] It started with Defense Secretary Hegseth saying the firing squad execution would
- 1:23[Maya] be public.
- 1:24[Maya] Then the official went further and said, "Will be Livestreamed."
- 1:27[David] Wait, so those are two different things.
- 1:29[David] Public could mean a handful of witnesses in a room.
- 1:32[Maya] Right.
- 1:33[Maya] That's the gap people are chewing on.
- 1:35[Maya] CNN's reporting from October eighth has the date set for December third
- 1:39[Maya] at one in the afternoon.
- 1:40[David] Let me stay on that gap because I think it's the whole
- 1:42[David] ballgame.
- 1:43[David] Public has limits built in.
- 1:45[David] A room only holds so many people.
- 1:47[Maya] And a livestream doesn't have a room.
- 1:49[Maya] Anyone with a connection could watch it.
- 1:51[David] Which changes who the audience is.
- 1:53[David] Not a few witnesses with a reason to be there, just whoever
- 1:56[David] happens to click on it.
- 1:57[Maya] And that's the part that gives people pause, whatever they think of
- 2:00[Maya] the sentence itself.
- 2:02[David] Right.
- 2:02[David] Though, to be careful, what we actually have is public from Hegseth
- 2:05[David] and will be livestreamed from the official.
- 2:08[David] I don't want to pile more on top of that.
- 2:09[Maya] Agreed.
- 2:10[Maya] Sticking to the words as reported.
- 2:12[David] Hmm.
- 2:12[David] And the firing squad itself is rare.
- 2:15[Maya] Very.
- 2:15[Maya] CNN's reporting says it would be the first Army execution of this
- 2:19[Maya] kind since World War II.
- 2:21[David] Since World War II.
- 2:23[David] So this isn't just a procedure, this is a historic one, and
- 2:26[David] they're talking about putting it on a stream?
- 2:28[Maya] Which is why the how matters so much.
- 2:31[Maya] A rare event in a system that doesn't do this often is
- 2:34[Maya] going to get watched closely.
- 2:36[David] And closely watched can go two ways, careful and dignified or a
- 2:39[David] circus.
- 2:40[David] The difference is how it's handled.
- 2:42[Maya] And here's what I find interesting.
- 2:44[Maya] You'd expect the pushback to come from one side.
- 2:47[David] Sure.
- 2:47[David] The usual lanes.
- 2:48[Maya] But CNN reports bipartisan criticism.
- 2:51[Maya] Republican Senator Thom Tillis called it beyond disgusting.
- 2:56[David] Whoa.
- 2:57[David] That's a Republican on a Republican administration's plan.
- 3:00[Maya] Yep.
- 3:00[David] And think about how unusual that is.
- 3:02[David] A senator from the president's own party using language that blunt.
- 3:06[Maya] It's not a throwaway criticism.
- 3:08[Maya] I mean, beyond disgusting isn't procedural language.
- 3:12[Maya] That's a gut reaction.
- 3:13[David] I mean, come on, that tells you something.
- 3:15[David] And I'll say it as someone who's pretty hawkish on justice for
- 3:18[David] this guy.
- 3:19[David] Hasan is the Fort Hood shooter, and nobody is lining up to
- 3:22[David] defend him.
- 3:22[Maya] No.
- 3:23[Maya] And I'm not going to get into the details of the victims
- 3:26[Maya] beyond that because the families are the point here.
- 3:28[Maya] They lived through it.
- 3:30[David] Totally.
- 3:30[David] So the conservative worry isn't sympathy for the man.
- 3:32[David] It's about whether the government should turn a punishment into content.
- 3:36[Maya] Right.
- 3:36[Maya] Law and order folks tend to care a lot about the dignity
- 3:39[Maya] of the process.
- 3:40[Maya] The military has its own system, and it deserves to be taken
- 3:43[Maya] seriously.
- 3:44[David] Mm-hmm.
- 3:45[David] Justice that's slow and solemn is the whole idea.
- 3:48[David] A stream with a viewer count cuts against that.
- 3:50[Maya] And the families, do they want to watch?
- 3:53[Maya] Do strangers want to watch?
- 3:55[Maya] I don't know.
- 3:55[Maya] And I'm not going to guess for them.
- 3:57[David] Fair.
- 3:57[David] Nobody should speak for them.
- 3:58[Maya] What I keep wondering is who the audience would even be.
- 4:01[Maya] Someone watching for duty is one thing.
- 4:04[Maya] Someone watching for the spectacle is another.
- 4:06[David] And some conservatives would say it's the same logic as the death
- 4:08[David] penalty itself.
- 4:10[David] If the state does it, the state owes its seriousness, not showmanship.
- 4:13[Maya] Which doesn't mean the plan is wrong in every detail.
- 4:16[Maya] We don't know the reasoning behind going public.
- 4:18[Maya] We just have what's been reported.
- 4:20[David] Right.
- 4:20[David] And December third is still weeks away, so there's plenty of time
- 4:23[David] for that reasoning or the plan to shift.
- 4:26[Maya] And it sounds like it might because with this much heat from
- 4:29[Maya] both parties-
- 4:30[David] Yeah, that plan may not even survive the week.
- 4:33[Maya] Okay, so the livestream plan has a new wrinkle this morning,
- 4:37[Maya] and it comes straight from the top.
- 4:40[David] Oh, go on.
- 4:41[Maya] NBC News reports that Trump told reporters he absolutely approved the plan.
- 4:47[Maya] Now he's saying he'll decide whether it gets livestreamed.
- 4:50[David] Wait, really?
- 4:51[David] Absolutely, and then I'll decide.
- 4:54[Maya] Those two sentences are doing a lot of work next to each
- 4:57[Maya] other.
- 4:58[David] Mm.
- 4:59[David] I mean, come on, that's a pretty quick walk from absolutely.
- 5:02[David] Something happened in between.
- 5:03[Maya] Well, NBC says there's pushback from Republicans and others, so the people
- 5:08[Maya] he usually counts on are not exactly cheering.
- 5:11[David] Right.
- 5:11[David] And I'd say that matters more than the others.
- 5:14[David] When your own side gets uneasy, the calculus changes fast.
- 5:17[Maya] Totally.
- 5:18[David] But notice how narrow the question is.
- 5:20[David] What he says he'll decide is whether it gets live-streamed.
- 5:24[Maya] Right.
- 5:24[Maya] That's the piece that's now open.
- 5:26[Maya] The live stream is the part with the question mark on it.
- 5:29[David] And there's a practical worry in that NBC piece, and I think
- 5:32[David] it's the one that should keep people up.
- 5:34[Maya] The martyr thing.
- 5:35[David] Yeah.
- 5:35[David] NBC reports concern that live streaming could make Hasan a martyr for
- 5:39[David] people who are looking to commit mass violence.
- 5:41[Maya] That's a heavy one.
- 5:43[David] It is.
- 5:43[David] Think about it.
- 5:44[David] The whole point of the punishment is justice for the victims.
- 5:47[David] But a broadcast hands a certain kind of person a moment to
- 5:50[David] rally around.
- 5:51[Maya] And you can't un-broadcast it.
- 5:53[David] Exactly.
- 5:54[David] Once it's out there, it's out there.
- 5:56[David] Clips, reposts, all of it.
- 5:57[David] Whoever wants to build a shrine around it can.
- 5:59[Maya] Careful, though.
- 6:01[Maya] I only know what NBC says.
- 6:03[Maya] It reports the concern and the Republican pushback, and I won't put
- 6:06[Maya] words in anyone's mouth beyond that.
- 6:08[David] Fair enough.
- 6:09[David] Stick to what's reported.
- 6:10[Maya] So the open question is simple: Does he keep the stream, tweak
- 6:14[Maya] it, or drop it?
- 6:15[David] Which apparently is now his call.
- 6:17[David] Meanwhile, the late-night crowd has already made up its mind.
- 6:20[Maya] Oh, they have.
- 6:21[Maya] SNL's cold open had Colin Jost playing Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth.
- 6:25[David] Of course it did.
- 6:26[Maya] Deadline says he was once again overcompensating while talking about plans to
- 6:31[Maya] live stream an execution.
- 6:33[David] Overcompensating.
- 6:34[David] That's the Hegseth character in one word, isn't it?
- 6:36[Maya] Pretty much.
- 6:38[Maya] Strutting through a subject that nobody else wants to touch with a
- 6:40[Maya] ten-foot pole.
- 6:42[David] And SNL wasn't done with Trump that night.
- 6:44[Maya] Nope.
- 6:44[Maya] They took a swing at his other big story of the weekend
- 6:47[Maya] too.
- 6:48[David] The Nobel?
- 6:49[David] Oh, this one I want to hear.
- 6:51[Maya] Okay.
- 6:51[Maya] The Nobel.
- 6:52[Maya] Rolling Stone says Weekend Update's Colin Jost joked that Trump, who is
- 6:57[Maya] fuming about losing the Peace Prize, is taking it all in stride.
- 7:02[David] Taking it all in stride.
- 7:03[David] Sure.
- 7:04[Maya] The stride is doing laps, David.
- 7:07[David] Fair.
- 7:08[David] So who actually won?
- 7:09[Maya] Navi Pillay.
- 7:11[Maya] The Washington Post covers the fallout, and it says Trump spoke at
- 7:14[Maya] a Syracuse rally on Friday evening.
- 7:17[David] And he was calm about it?
- 7:20[Maya] He called the decision an indelible stain on Norway.
- 7:24[Maya] The Post also reports he called it disgraceful and embarrassing.
- 7:29[David] Wow.
- 7:30[David] Okay.
- 7:31[David] I'll say it.
- 7:31[David] Losing stings, but Norway didn't do anything to him personally.
- 7:35[David] A committee picked a winner.
- 7:37[Maya] Right?
- 7:38[Maya] I mean, come on.
- 7:39[David] Who is Pillay, though?
- 7:40[David] Most people couldn't pick her out of a lineup.
- 7:42[Maya] Forbes describes her as a South African jurist and a former UN
- 7:46[Maya] human rights chief.
- 7:48[David] So a serious resume.
- 7:50[David] Not a surprise pick if you follow that world.
- 7:52[Maya] And she has a sense of humor.
- 7:55[Maya] Forbes says she joked that she might share the prize with Trump.
- 8:00[David] That's smooth.
- 8:01[David] Gracious and a little needle in one line.
- 8:03[Maya] Totally.
- 8:05[David] And it's a nice contrast, honestly.
- 8:07[David] One side is making a joke, the other is calling it a
- 8:09[David] stain.
- 8:10[Maya] Different temperaments.
- 8:12[Maya] Forbes also says Trump re-shared a post attacking the Nobel Committee, and
- 8:17[Maya] that Israel's foreign ministry condemned the award.
- 8:20[David] Now, Trump's case rests on a claim he's made over and over
- 8:24[David] that he settled eight wars.
- 8:26[Maya] Forbes calls that claim dubious.
- 8:29[David] Which is the polite word for it.
- 8:31[David] Look, I'm no fan of the Nobel Committee's track record, but if
- 8:34[David] you want the prize, the pitch has to survive a fact check.
- 8:37[Maya] Wait, really?
- 8:39[Maya] You're taking Norway's side?
- 8:41[David] I'm taking the side of the argument being sturdy.
- 8:44[David] Trump supporters would say he's brokered real deals, and that's a debate
- 8:47[David] worth having.
- 8:48[David] The grudge, though, that's the weaker part.
- 8:51[Maya] Mm.
- 8:51[Maya] And a rally's a funny place to air it.
- 8:54[David] Right.
- 8:54[David] A crowd that came for politics got a prize postmortem.
- 8:58[Maya] Either way, the reaction is still the story.
- 9:01[Maya] The prize went elsewhere, and the grumbling is what's making headlines.
- 9:05[David] And that's why Weekend Update had an easy target.
- 9:08[David] Jost didn't need to invent anything.
- 9:10[David] The fuming was already reported.
- 9:12[Maya] Speaking of which, a different kind of letdown.
- 9:15[Maya] Saturday night in Indio.
- 9:17[David] The Headtrip Festival?
- 9:19[Maya] Yep.
- 9:20[Maya] Lightning forced organizers to suspend the show before headliner Calvin Harris ever
- 9:25[Maya] played.
- 9:25[David] Oh, no.
- 9:26[David] Right before the big finish.
- 9:28[Maya] ABC7 in Los Angeles says attendees were told over screens and loudspeakers
- 9:33[Maya] to return to their vehicles and shelter.
- 9:36[David] Screens and loudspeakers.
- 9:38[David] So no way to miss it.
- 9:40[Maya] And organizers had already adjusted the schedule to try and dodge the
- 9:44[Maya] storm.
- 9:45[David] Wait, they saw it coming and still got caught?
- 9:48[Maya] Looks like it.
- 9:49[Maya] Weather doesn't read the lineup.
- 9:52[David] Imagine waiting all night for the headliner, and the sky books the
- 9:55[David] final act.
- 9:57[Maya] Sitting in a car in the desert, headphones on, no Calvin.
- 10:01[David] Honestly, safest call.
- 10:02[David] Nobody wants to be the tallest thing in a field during lightning.
- 10:05[Maya] Totally.
- 10:06[Maya] The part that sticks with me is the order of events.
- 10:09[Maya] Organizers adjusted the schedule, the storm still won, and the headliner never
- 10:14[Maya] got on stage.
- 10:16[David] A lot of planning for a night that ended with attendees heading
- 10:18[David] to their cars.
- 10:19[Maya] Which makes the sky the real headliner.
- 10:23[David] Fair.
- 10:25[Maya] Okay, so if you only carry one thing out of today's show,
- 10:28[Maya] make it this.
- 10:29[Maya] Watch what Trump decides on the livestream.
- 10:31[David] Yeah, the Nobel grudge and the storm-cut festival were the lighter stuff.
- 10:35[David] This is the one with real weight.
- 10:37[Maya] Fair.
- 10:38[Maya] The sky got its moment, but this one's got consequences.
- 10:41[David] Look, the decision is his now, and it's a short list of
- 10:44[David] outcomes.
- 10:45[David] Either the cameras roll or somebody quietly finds a reason they don't.
- 10:49[Maya] And I'd bet there are a lot of people in the building
- 10:52[Maya] hoping for option two.
- 10:53[David] Including folks who usually back him on this stuff, which tells you
- 10:56[David] something.
- 10:57[Maya] Totally.
- 10:58[Maya] Which means by the next time we talk, this might already be
- 11:01[Maya] settled.
- 11:02[David] Maybe.
- 11:03[David] Keep an eye out.
- 11:04[Maya] And if it moves before we're back, we'll tell you where it
- 11:06[Maya] landed.
- 11:07[David] Fair.
- 11:08[David] In the meantime, enjoy what's left of your Sunday.
- 11:11[Maya] Also, quick confession, I had my second coffee before the show, and
- 11:14[Maya] I'm already reaching for a third.
- 11:17[David] Of course you are.
- 11:17[David] It's a three-cup weekend, remember?
- 11:19[Maya] All right, that's us.
- 11:21[Maya] I'm Maya.
- 11:21[Maya] Thanks for spending the morning with us.
- 11:23[David] And I'm David.
- 11:24[David] Go enjoy your coffee, and we'll catch you next time.
- 11:27[Maya] Take care, everybody, and that's the rundown.