Latest / Newcomer Pod / Marc Benioff on AI Eating SaaS, San Francisco’s New Mayor & CEO Trump Pandering
Transcript
- 0:00Tom joined the podcast and he got us Marc Benioff.
- 0:04You asked. I delivered.
- 0:06You write, we write in antagonistic stories about
- 0:10Microsoft, and suddenly Marc Benioff wants to come on the
- 0:12podcast. That's not what this was about.
- 0:14This was about a spirited conversation about the future of
- 0:18AI and tech in San Francisco. We sure we're really willing to
- 0:21hold Microsoft to account. It's like Salesforce is like,
- 0:23that's the kind of podcast I want to go on.
- 0:26Yeah, yeah. Look, Marc, you know, I've known
- 0:28Marc for a couple of years. I wrote about him at the
- 0:30journal. I wrote a pretty tough piece on
- 0:33him actually was that's. True.
- 0:35Yeah, I remember that. Didn't he throw like the
- 0:37governor and yo-yo Mai at you? Or is that in the story?
- 0:40Yeah, yeah, they did both speak on his behalf as a great guy.
- 0:43They're still in my phone, by the way.
- 0:45And in California? It's like, oh, Tom might be
- 0:50doing a negative story about you'll, you'll listen to the end
- 0:54of the podcast. By the way.
- 0:55You'll you'll I give my unadulterated take on what I
- 0:58think of Benioff. But Tom was working on what
- 1:01could have been a negative profile was how it what was the
- 1:03angle? At the time, I mean, it was a
- 1:07very tumultuous period for Salesforce.
- 1:09They had five activist investors in the stock.
- 1:13You know, there were major concerns about their margin.
- 1:15And the angle was like, oh, and they just laid people off.
- 1:17And so that was a story basically saying, for those of
- 1:20you who know, Salesforce has this famous Ohana family
- 1:23culture. And the story was like, what
- 1:26does it mean when your family lays you off?
- 1:29Yeah, that's a good question. Yeah.
- 1:30Yeah. And, and, and so anyway, and it
- 1:32ended up being kind of a profile of Mark.
- 1:34Turns out business is just business sometimes.
- 1:37Yeah. And, you know, listen to his
- 1:39credit. Mark is the owner of Time
- 1:41magazine. He understands how media works.
- 1:43And I think he felt like he wanted to, you know, always.
- 1:46Make sure you know you knew that Yo-yo Ma thought positively of
- 1:51him. Yeah, although I encourage
- 1:54people to go back and read that story because the quote from
- 1:55Yo-yo Ma is very funny. You know, Mark is a
- 1:58technologist. He, I, I like talking to him
- 2:00because he came from that era of Silicon Valley.
- 2:03You know, he, he I think one of his first Jobs was working for
- 2:06Apple and he knew Steve Jobs. And so for him to kind of come
- 2:10on and talk about AI as like along the same, you know,
- 2:14spectrum of importance as the Internet and mobile and, and,
- 2:17and cloud is meaningful. You know, we asked him about
- 2:20Internet waves. We asked about what Klarna
- 2:22basically saying fuck SAS, I can build it myself.
- 2:26We asked him, do billionaires have better AI than the rest of
- 2:30us? I gave him a hard time about why
- 2:32billionaires are sycophants to Trump and whether he would take
- 2:37a different tactic. You dug into San Francisco,
- 2:40which, you know, I'm a New Yorker.
- 2:41I barely understood what else. Any other highlights?
- 2:44Stick around, listen to it, it's good.
- 2:47It's Marc Benioff. Yeah, I think, yeah, he, he's a,
- 2:50he's an entertaining guy. He's one of the few people in
- 2:52tech that can actually hold an audience, and I think I'm
- 2:55interested to hear people's thoughts on this one.
- 2:58Yeah, yeah, it's a fun one, all right.
- 3:00Give it a listen. We're excited to have now on the
- 3:03Newcomer podcast Marc Benioff, CEO of Salesforce, which is, I
- 3:06believe, the third largest software company in the world.
- 3:09I hope second. Is it second now OK?
- 3:12Well, we're going to do 41 billion approximately or 40.9
- 3:16billion this year. So when you look at peer
- 3:19revenue, I think it is like probably the second largest
- 3:22enterprise software company. Is it overtaking ServiceNow or
- 3:26who's who's they're? Ten billion 10.
- 3:29They're 1/4 of size. OK, OK.
- 3:31All right, Well, we'll have our research department look into
- 3:33this. Mark is also the owner of Time
- 3:36magazine, which we'll we'll talk about a.
- 3:38Long time copy your numbers Tom. Yeah, we'll, we'll run it
- 3:42through one of one of the agent force programs and see where it
- 3:44comes out. Exactly.
- 3:46Yeah, let's get the AI on the podcast to get clarity on all of
- 3:49this. Yeah, yeah, we'll see who's
- 3:50right. And Mark's also a long time
- 3:52technologist and San Franciscan. What are you, third generation,
- 3:554th, 4th, 4th generation San Franciscan.
- 3:58So we're we're always got a lot to say whenever I whenever I
- 4:01chop it up with Mark about tech. You're like first.
- 4:04I was born in the East Bay. Oh, OK.
- 4:07Yeah, All right. Well, you can still come over.
- 4:09With but my son is first generation.
- 4:10San, you can take you can take Bart over.
- 4:14Exactly. We used to call it bridge and
- 4:15tunnel people. It's no longer appropriate.
- 4:18Trans Bay. Trans Bay Two people.
- 4:20No, we call them bridge and tunnel people, people who came
- 4:22over on the bridge or the tunnel.
- 4:24Because you guys thought you were more sophisticated at San
- 4:26Franciscans, right? Way more.
- 4:29Way more. Yeah, we'll get into San
- 4:31Francisco. Oh yeah, I wanted to start off
- 4:33with this serious AI question. Or just how you think about the
- 4:37artificial intelligence wave we're experiencing in the
- 4:39context of the history of the.com boom, then mobile and
- 4:45then cloud. Like what?
- 4:47What similarities and what differences do you see?
- 4:49Yeah, well, certainly it's not the first gold rush in San
- 4:52Francisco. So is it a gold rush?
- 4:54I guess that yeah, that gets to it right there.
- 4:57Well, there's going to be a lot of gold.
- 4:58So yeah, I would say it's a gold rush.
- 5:02I would say that look, it's a city and an industry marked by
- 5:07history of innovation. And you've, you named a few of
- 5:11them and there's many others. And this one is incredible.
- 5:15What's happening. It's obviously going incredibly
- 5:18fast because a lot of the technology is not proprietary.
- 5:21It's being built in an open source way.
- 5:24And because so much of the technology is open source, it's
- 5:27shared. It's more of a communal asset
- 5:30for the whole industry that's new.
- 5:33Usually these things tend to be very proprietary and so they go
- 5:37slower, you know, like my iOS or Android, like, you know, these
- 5:42operating systems, mobile, you know, phone operating systems,
- 5:45like like as a category it's going to go slower than AI
- 5:49because everything's more proprietary.
- 5:53If if one company has to build, it's slow.
- 5:55If a whole industry is racing towards it, it will be very
- 5:57quick. Exactly together and shared.
- 6:01Do you see, you know what, like you know, mobile had the App
- 6:05Store, cloud had software as a service?
- 6:07Like there is some more excitement about sort of usage
- 6:11based pricing in the AI world or how much do you see a sort of a
- 6:14business model transition along with like a technological 1?
- 6:19Well, I think that there's going to be a business model
- 6:24transition, a technology model transition.
- 6:27There can be usage based pricing.
- 6:28There's also per user price pricing.
- 6:31You know, it's all-encompassing because it it's connecting to
- 6:34every aspect of the technology. I'm sure you know, like for
- 6:38example, my chat TPT, I'm paying by the user per month right now.
- 6:42It's not usage as far as I know. That is, you know, I'm paying
- 6:46like 20 bucks or something and I'm getting chat TPT or Claude.
- 6:51I have I've crock. That's also per user pricing.
- 6:55Do Salesforce employees have access to one of the chat bots
- 6:58officially? We have probably many.
- 7:01Yeah. It's my guess.
- 7:03There's not one. Yeah, yeah, there's not one.
- 7:05We're investors also in a number of these companies.
- 7:08We also deploy a lot of them directly through Slack.
- 7:11And then, you know, Slack is becoming kind of this meta level
- 7:14for AI where I'm talking to the AI, the AI agents are talking
- 7:18back to me, I'm sharing, I'm collaborating, they're talking
- 7:22to each other. If it explained to me, if you
- 7:24want to put it at the same significance of cloud, of
- 7:28mobile, of the Internet itself, what, what is the transformation
- 7:31exactly here? Like, explain it to me as if I
- 7:33was, you know, a mother in the Midwest.
- 7:37A golden retriever. You know, I feel like
- 7:38everybody's rewatching that movie anyway.
- 7:40God. It's a good question because,
- 7:43well, yeah, movies. Let's take movies.
- 7:45We saw War games. We saw Minority Report.
- 7:47We saw Terminator. We saw her and we realized that
- 7:51in all of these movies about the future and the sci-fi, there's
- 7:55some AI in there, there's some robotics in there, there's some
- 7:57drones in there. Seems like it's all happening
- 8:00simultaneously. You know, that said, here I am
- 8:02in my office and there's no robot walking around yet.
- 8:06Here we are on this podcast, we're on the newcomer podcast.
- 8:10There's no AI that we're talking to on the podcast today.
- 8:13So we're not quite there yet, are we?
- 8:16So not to say that maybe in a year that might not be true like
- 8:20I'm waiting to, you know, we have you guys, you're I'm sure
- 8:23you're great, talented, well researched, but I think we can
- 8:28see that there is the potential for a level of scale with this
- 8:33technology that's amazing. And our imaginations are all
- 8:36going wild and are excited. You know, how's it going to
- 8:39change my inner side by software industry.
- 8:42And you know, we're getting ready to report our earnings,
- 8:44you know, in a few weeks and we still have to manage our
- 8:48financials and manage our HR and.
- 8:51I I thought you'd be sort of boom time AI, weren't you
- 8:54shouting Asian force from from the rooftops?
- 8:57You sound a little bit more measured.
- 8:58Or have you seen things that make you more apprehensive about
- 9:02what's going on in AI? Well, I think that I want to get
- 9:06to the other side of the coin. The other side of the coin is I
- 9:10would say for the last 26 years at Salesforce, I'm working in
- 9:13this multi $100 billion enterprise software industry
- 9:17that's like our Tam or we call our total addressable market,
- 9:20you know, building software that addresses all of those things.
- 9:23Today I walk you through these customer examples where we're
- 9:28building digital labor for these companies, and that's a maybe 3
- 9:34to $12 trillion opportunity. It wasn't that long ago, maybe
- 9:37six months ago, Tom was still employed at the Wall Street
- 9:40Journal. He came to Dreamforce.
- 9:42He sat with our customers. He was building agents.
- 9:45Multiple times. It took you a while.
- 9:46It took you a while to get your, your, your organization together
- 9:49to have me sit with a real customer.
- 9:50I recall that. I watched him build an agent and
- 9:53employ an agent, and maybe that was the first time he built and
- 9:57deployed an agent with Agentforce.
- 9:59And you know, you always, you know, you never forget your
- 10:02first. So I'll just say that this is
- 10:06like an incredible moment where, yeah, there's huge potential.
- 10:12It's much bigger than ever before.
- 10:15But we're at the beginning of our journey.
- 10:17So how do we think about that? It's very simple.
- 10:19We always overestimate what you can do in a year in our industry
- 10:23and underestimate what you can do in a decade, and certainly
- 10:26underestimate 2 decades. And in the case of Salesforce,
- 10:30underestimate what you can do in 2 1/2 decades.
- 10:33So yeah, it's an incredible moment.
- 10:36And we should all feel completely excited that we are
- 10:39alive to watch this and to work with these large language models
- 10:44to become more productive, to augment ourselves, to deliver
- 10:48digital labor, to improve our society in many incredible ways
- 10:54like healthcare and education. It's it's awesome.
- 10:57How much has AI transformed your life or like, I mean, one thing
- 11:01that's interesting about the iPhone, right, is that sort of
- 11:05the iPhone I have, and I presume whatever iPhone or phone you
- 11:08have are are the equivalent. There's no sort of like
- 11:11billionaire iPhone like with Chachi BT with sort of AI
- 11:16models. I mean, you could build your own
- 11:18open source stack. Like do do you have sort of a, a
- 11:22better AI than we do? And how much like custom stuff
- 11:26are you trying to put together to just sort of see if it can
- 11:28come up with better ideas for like Salesforce than you do with
- 11:32your team? A day does not go by then I'm
- 11:34not using one model or another. I would say that, of course,
- 11:39Salesforce, we've been fortunate to be pioneering many of these
- 11:42AI tools for many years. Everyone knows prompt
- 11:46engineering really came out of Salesforce's research team.
- 11:49We did the first coding models. Everyone knows Cogen.
- 11:53We have other models that we X Gen. others that we've done that
- 11:55have been pioneering. We felt like our obligation was
- 11:59primarily to do the research and contribute to the open source
- 12:01community and then build it into our core platform.
- 12:05That has been really our mission around AI.
- 12:08When it comes down to myself, rarely does a day go by that I'm
- 12:13not using one of these amazing AI models.
- 12:16I use it in all kinds of different ways.
- 12:18Right now, we just finished our quarter.
- 12:20I have all of our numbers. I'm looking at our numbers.
- 12:23I'm, you know, using models to kind of look at my business plan
- 12:28against my performance, look at what's working, what's not
- 12:31working, how to tune, how to improve, how to refactor, how to
- 12:35restructure. Before I had to use an analyst.
- 12:38I don't. Do are your analysts trying to
- 12:40tell you no, you're getting the numbers wrong?
- 12:41You need humans like the hallucinations or.
- 12:45Yeah, I'm the analyst. I am the analyst and I'm the
- 12:48individual contributor. I'm a manager, I'm a leader.
- 12:52I do all three things. And as an individual
- 12:55contributor, I'm much more productive than ever before
- 12:58because I have tools that are giving me the ability in many
- 13:01cases to be unlimited. So I can come up with key
- 13:04insights about, you know, not only just my life, but my
- 13:08company, my industry and by. Yeah, it's also very important
- 13:12to learn how to ask the right questions.
- 13:14None of this happens without the right prompt.
- 13:16I don't have to tell you that. You probably know, like that's
- 13:19the one thing, like it's not going to come up with all of
- 13:22those questions. I sit down with a lot of people,
- 13:25by the way, different kinds of people.
- 13:27Like I have a friend of mine just lost his job at the FDA,
- 13:30took the retirement package. Thinking about what he wants to
- 13:33do next. He's like a three-year old
- 13:34technical expert. He's like telling me how much he
- 13:38knows about the AII sat with him and I'm like, hey, let's just
- 13:41ask it a bunch of questions based on what you know about the
- 13:43technology. And we kind of ferreted through
- 13:46to actually build a business plan, a slide deck, a company
- 13:51name, a logo, you know, all of these.
- 13:53He couldn't believe it. You know, he thought he had had
- 13:55it all wired up and then he got it came out of it super
- 13:58motivated where it's like, well, I can build this next
- 14:01generation. To this specific just do, do you
- 14:04think you have a fancy, do you have, do you have access to a
- 14:06fancier system than we do or do you think or you're
- 14:09fundamentally using sort of the mass market and it you see an
- 14:12equivalent? I think that I just want to use
- 14:15the the stuff that everybody else is using.
- 14:17But you know, I'm an investor personally in some of these
- 14:20things, likeyou.com. Richard Socher, who's been a
- 14:23incredible AI researcher, a lot of folks know came out of
- 14:26Stanford Deep Learning Pioneer was the one who I think authored
- 14:30the paper on prompt engineering. He's startdu.com.
- 14:33That's the company I'm personally invested in.
- 14:35Salesforce has invested in a number of the really great model
- 14:39companies like Anthropic and others Cohere Others Mr. All
- 14:43Hugging Face, Not Open AI because only one company was
- 14:49invested in them. Which company was that, Mark?
- 14:51Starts with them. Yeah, Yeah, we might get to
- 14:54them. I actually want to go.
- 14:56You you mentioned my demo that I had at Dreamforce last year and
- 15:01you know, that was through Slack.
- 15:02We we built an agent. I'd rather call it an initiation
- 15:05than a demo. Like a like a gang initiation,
- 15:09essentially. I won't.
- 15:10I'm not going to have more fast terms that I could use.
- 15:13OK, well, whatever you want to call it, I got we.
- 15:15Were aggressive with you. I think I had to personally
- 15:18bring you down and say, Tom, we're going to now build an
- 15:20agent. This is gonna be important for
- 15:22your career to understand what the agents are.
- 15:25We're gonna show you how these models work, how the data works.
- 15:28Let's just do it piece by piece. Come on.
- 15:30I got the applesauce out and the little tiny spoon gave a little
- 15:34bit. You're like that.
- 15:36That's so good. Another little spoonful.
- 15:39Another little spoonful. And then you are like, oh, this
- 15:42is so yummy. And I said yeah.
- 15:44Yeah, yeah. That that's by the way, every
- 15:46conversation I've ever had with an editor in my career is, is,
- 15:49is, is is a downstream version of that.
- 15:51So you see now you see what my life is like.
- 15:54And I imagine your customers too.
- 15:56But but that was a, a, that was agent Force, you know, original,
- 15:59that was basically building a, you know, a prompt interactive
- 16:02agent. And then a couple of months
- 16:04later I get invited end of the year to another event, this time
- 16:07held at a hotel where you guys are rolling out Agent Force 2
- 16:10point O, which is which is agentic.
- 16:13These are agentic tools. So within a matter of months you
- 16:15guys went from rolling out, you know, a basic chat bot type.
- 16:19Well, Agent Force was agentic at the beginning, Tom, and it was
- 16:23also it. But what it's version 2 had was
- 16:25the reasoning model. That was where we really had
- 16:28broken through and we started to really say like it's not just
- 16:32LMS that are important, but also reasoning models and LMS
- 16:35together are like going to provide us a new level of
- 16:38intelligence and capability. That's where I think a lot of us
- 16:41should be more excited than we are because you know, LLMS are
- 16:44cool and have come a long way, especially in the last like four
- 16:48or five years. But reasoning models are like
- 16:50pretty brand new. But the way that they learn is
- 16:53not with these kind of somewhat semi static data sets extended
- 16:57through these RAG techniques, but they're like stacking their
- 17:00intelligence to expand their capabilities.
- 17:03And I think that is something that's still somewhat
- 17:06underappreciated that LMS plus reasoning models are going to
- 17:11give us some kind of, we're still in early days, but it's
- 17:15it's a case for optimism. But also a case for complication
- 17:19in the marketplace, right, because you guys are you just
- 17:21introduced, you know, and you guys have a lot of enterprise
- 17:23customers, you know, not digitally native customers that
- 17:26are using have been using Salesforce for for for years.
- 17:30They just learned about, you know, agent Force One point O
- 17:32and then a couple of months later you guys come and explain
- 17:35agentic tools to. That why is there so much change
- 17:38in the technology business? But it's, it's a tough sell.
- 17:41It's a tough sell. I know, 'cause you know, Mark, I
- 17:44also talked to customers and I know it's a tough sell.
- 17:46OK. That's what this is what you're
- 17:47trying to say. Yeah, the rate of innovation is
- 17:50exceeding the rate of adoption because we are going so fucking
- 17:56fast, like it is really fast. So the rate of innovation is at
- 18:03a moment in our industry exceeding even what customers
- 18:06can accept and adopt and some customers can't.
- 18:10Like I have all kinds of stories we can talk about.
- 18:12Well, you know, you saw thousands of customers being on
- 18:15boarded at the agent force in September and October.
- 18:19It's been only been six months now.
- 18:20We see so many of them with deployed systems.
- 18:23That's amazing. But there's, you know, we have
- 18:26hundreds of thousands of customers.
- 18:28So we don't have hundreds of thousands of customers on agent
- 18:31force yet. We have hundreds of thousands of
- 18:33customers on social or on mobile or on the cloud or you know, on
- 18:38analytics around Slack. We have, you know, almost
- 18:401,000,000 customers, but you know, we're still at the
- 18:43beginning of Asian Forest with single digit thousands.
- 18:47And those customers are just, you know, at the beginning of
- 18:50their implementations and their tuning and setting up rumour
- 18:53time. We set up the guardrails and we
- 18:55set up the semantic layer and we setting up the action layer and
- 18:58we're setting up the application itself and all the structure so
- 19:01that we can kind of make this work for the customer.
- 19:04And so, yeah, we're still at the beginning of an incredible
- 19:07journey and we should all be pretty jacked right now in our
- 19:10industry because our whole industry just kind of boom, just
- 19:14got reborn. And at some level, you know, I
- 19:16just heard this last week, so I'll steal it.
- 19:18Where humanity's kind of like a chrysalis, like giving birth to
- 19:21this new form of life, which is this artificial intelligence
- 19:26that's going to be this kind of self learning, self growing
- 19:30technology. And that is kind of amazing
- 19:33what's happening. Like I can't even completely get
- 19:36my head totally around it. We've seen it, the movies.
- 19:40You're falling in love with your AI bots over here.
- 19:43You're imputing consciousness onto them.
- 19:46Or it's it becomes hard to sort of not sort of get attached to
- 19:50your chat history the more context it hasn't.
- 19:53Yeah. Well, I mean, it's going to be a
- 19:54different kind of consciousness. I mean, like, one thing is, you
- 19:58know, like us here, you know, especially, you know, for those
- 20:02who have, you know, you know, we know what suffering is.
- 20:07So therefore we have compassion. Because we know suffering.
- 20:11So AI doesn't know suffering exactly.
- 20:15So is it, it can simulate compassion or simulate empathy,
- 20:20but it's not really compassionate because it isn't
- 20:23suffering. So, but some may.
- 20:26So like I just saw like on Twitter yesterday, there's a
- 20:29brain organoid, you know, which is kind of, we can talk about
- 20:32that. They've grown an organic AI
- 20:35that's powering a robot. And when you look at that, it's
- 20:38on my Twitter feed, it's like crazy stuff.
- 20:40And then it's like that type of AI may actually be suffering.
- 20:47Like it may it's come out of brain stem cells.
- 20:51They're they grow these organoids.
- 20:53Whoa. That's like, yeah, that's like a
- 20:55different kind of thing we're talking about in organic, you
- 20:58know, AI that's growing as an Organism.
- 21:01Yeah. But these aren't the things you
- 21:02guys are, I'm assuming, talking about on the front lines with
- 21:05your sales team trying to get enterprises to buy agent force.
- 21:08I'm not selling any brain organoids to our Internet
- 21:11customers right now. That's what you're asking.
- 21:12You're not there yet. I'm just out there riffing.
- 21:14But no, if you want to know what I'm selling to customers, like
- 21:17we have a customer Smartsheet, which you probably like.
- 21:20It's like a cloud spread, like cloud Excel, you know, and
- 21:24they've got 13 million users. They're amazing company and
- 21:28they've built Agentforce right into the app.
- 21:30So you're like working with it. You can get your support and you
- 21:32can get your service. You can increase and decrease
- 21:35your the number of users, your license force.
- 21:37You can change your password. You can do all these things on
- 21:40Agentforce right inside Smartsheet.
- 21:42You can go to 1800 account now to do your taxes and 70% of all
- 21:49of their questions have been fully autonomously answered by
- 21:54Agentforce now. So that's, you know, has a high
- 21:58cool factor. So let me cut you off there for
- 22:00a second because this is interesting to me because I sort
- 22:03of see two implementations of what you guys are selling.
- 22:05There's the internal workplace stuff, you know, ways to make a
- 22:08workforce more efficient, the way you interact with your Co
- 22:11workers, putting together reports, slideshows, whatever,
- 22:15you know, writing up marketing documents.
- 22:16And then there's customer facing stuff.
- 22:19Explain to me the the the the progress you're seeing on
- 22:22customer facing stuff. Yeah, so it's bifurcated like
- 22:25you just said, there's two worlds 1 is we're augmenting our
- 22:27self with AI. We all know that I'm on Chachi,
- 22:30PT, anthropicyou.com, Grok, Gemini, whatever.
- 22:35And I'm learning, I'm growing. I'm asking it questions.
- 22:38Hey, what do you know? Tell me everything you know
- 22:39about me based on my chats, you know, hey, look at these
- 22:44numbers. Tell me, you know, how do I make
- 22:46this division even more successful?
- 22:48And then there's the digital labor.
- 22:51So that's the productivity component.
- 22:53So we're deploying service agents or sales agents or
- 22:57marketing agents or, you know, sales development
- 23:00representatives and these are autonomously working like I just
- 23:04said, like for 1800 accountant, they, we provided them digital
- 23:09labor that resolve 70% of all of those questions that they had.
- 23:14Or if you go to help.salesforce.com, the one I
- 23:16have, we've done more than 500,000 customer resolutions,
- 23:20you know, using Agentforce. So it's a split like over here,
- 23:25we're augmenting human beings, making them more productive.
- 23:28Over here, we're creating new kinds of digital labor, giving a
- 23:34company a new kind of employee. And an example, like with Gucci,
- 23:38when we gave them this technology and we said, hey,
- 23:42we're giving you digital labor, they actually transformed it and
- 23:44used it only for human augmentation and raised their
- 23:47sales 35% in their Florence call center.
- 23:50That was an amazing example. And I'm sorry, how?
- 23:54How was how was generative AI able to raise sales by 35%?
- 23:58It's basically an AI interacting with a human being.
- 24:00You're saying an AI did a better job?
- 24:01So Gucci has this amazing call center in Florence.
- 24:05We took our technology, we delivered it to them.
- 24:09How are they going to use it? We kind of just showed you two
- 24:11ways and they, these employees only were doing, you know,
- 24:16customer service. Like, hey, I have the my bag I
- 24:19need repaired. Oh, yeah, we'll repair your bag.
- 24:21Hey, I bought this garment from you.
- 24:24I've torn it. I need it refined.
- 24:25We'll send it in. We're going to send it back to
- 24:27you. It's just a customer service
- 24:28center. Then all of a sudden those
- 24:31people were able to really understand all the products
- 24:35they're able to send, understand all the capabilities.
- 24:38So they were able to sell, not just service, and they turn
- 24:43themselves into a sales and service center and revenue went
- 24:46up 35% in that Florence call center.
- 24:49So that's an example. I'll give you another really
- 24:52cool example, Disney. So Disney, you know, we've been
- 24:55running all the customer touch points for years.
- 24:58So like the Disney Store, you know, the people selling the
- 25:01cruise ships and the real estate and the, you know, the cast
- 25:06members, they call them cast members.
- 25:08These are their employees. Like in the park, they have the
- 25:09Disney guides. You probably interview, have
- 25:11kids and they take your, you know, their Disney guide gives
- 25:15you like a tour around the park. And you know, on those phones
- 25:18have always been sales force and slack where they keep track of
- 25:21the tour and then they're talking to other guides.
- 25:23Now, you know, the the agent force says, Hey, you're bringing
- 25:29Mark to Galaxy Edge, you're bringing him to the Millennium
- 25:32Falcon ride. But it just, it's down right
- 25:35now. So I know you're on your way.
- 25:37I can see her halfway there. You need to make a right turn
- 25:40and take him to Toontown. I just looked at all of Mark's
- 25:43rides. Everything he loves, everything
- 25:45he's looked at on Disney Plus. Mark has opted into all of this,
- 25:48but that ride is down. But he's going to love this ride
- 25:51over here. And before that guide would have
- 25:54to kind of stop and go, oh, too bad Millennium Falcon is down.
- 25:58What do I do? Talk to his friend?
- 26:01Oh, hey, have you thought about taking Mark over here?
- 26:03Maybe over here? In this case, the, the, the, the
- 26:06agents already looked at every ride, all the lines, what's
- 26:10working, what's not working, my ride history, the weather
- 26:13patterns, every single piece of data point.
- 26:14It needs to make the right decision and then say Nope,
- 26:17Toontown, that's the one for you, right?
- 26:20So essentially what you're describing here is a tool that
- 26:22assists an employee to make them better at their job.
- 26:25A a copilot augmentation augmentation, but that's.
- 26:29Not all augmentation. Yeah, sure, sure.
- 26:31Some people call those Co pilots, but that doesn't sound
- 26:35to me like a a digital labor force though.
- 26:38You're talking about digital labor that's not replacing
- 26:40someone that maybe makes them better at their job, maybe makes
- 26:42them more profitable for their employer that they they, they
- 26:45get greater revenue out of their interactions with customers.
- 26:47But how is that digital labor? So digital labor is 2 forms 1 is
- 26:55that you know, like right now look, I have 9000 support agents
- 27:00at Salesforce, OK. And we have this new agent force
- 27:06also. So we have a service force now
- 27:07we have an agent force. And that agent force is
- 27:10resolving a lot of customer support and service issues, even
- 27:14doing some sales autonomously without interactions from
- 27:17humans. So those humans have actually
- 27:20quite a bit less to do because it's being done by the digital
- 27:24labor. And another example is there are
- 27:28robots that are made by all kinds of different companies
- 27:33today. And some of those robots are
- 27:36just manifestations of agents. And those robots could be on
- 27:41assembly lines, they could be in your home, they could be in a
- 27:44hotel, clean, and they are interoperating and interacting
- 27:49with those, you know. Is sales force in that business
- 27:53like are you going to try to build the agents that might
- 27:56power a robot or is that an area that?
- 27:58Where are we've already done it, we've demonstrated it in our
- 28:01last three conferences that agents get manifested into these
- 28:05robots as I think is a good way to say it.
- 28:07Would you say that, you know, here's these incredible robots,
- 28:09amazing technology, but the robot has a model that it's an
- 28:14we're operating on the models kind of helping it do this move
- 28:17around. Like customer support, customer
- 28:20support clearly number one in terms of where agents are
- 28:23having. Right.
- 28:23If you look like the Aloha model that's come out of Stanford,
- 28:26which is like a really good model for training a robot, and
- 28:31like the videos are mostly these robots cleaning these hotel
- 28:36rooms. And so there are these cool
- 28:39robots, they're cleaning their motel hotel rooms.
- 28:43They're trained using this Aloha model.
- 28:47And now I open my door and I come in, there's a robot
- 28:49cleaning my hotel room. And it says, oh, hi, Mark.
- 28:52Do you want us to leave the room?
- 28:54And you know, thank you for being a good customer of our
- 28:57hotel chain. And how do you want it?
- 29:00Sorry, we're here. Do you want us to stay?
- 29:02Do you want us to leave? And how do you want us to
- 29:06interoperate with you in the future?
- 29:07And is there anything else you want us to say to management
- 29:09right now? Or is there anything else that
- 29:11you need? So there is an interoperability
- 29:14between that digital labor, the robot, the agent and even what
- 29:21we do with the customer platform.
- 29:24You think white collar jobs are the most threatened still, or
- 29:26you think this robot use case opens the possibility that we
- 29:29see sort of aggressive progress in blue collar jobs or?
- 29:33Well, we already know there's robots in the factories and
- 29:37there's, there's, I mean, robots are a part of life already.
- 29:42We just maybe not have them necessarily in our homes.
- 29:44Well, maybe we have, you know, some of the vacuum cleaner
- 29:48lawnmower robots or something. But I have that unitary dog, you
- 29:53know, and it's hooked up to Salesforce, by the way.
- 29:56So it can see, you can talk and it can interact with Salesforce
- 29:59and talk back, but it's somewhat still limited functionality.
- 30:02But when you look at some of the things that are coming, whether
- 30:04it's Tesla, Optimist or Figure or a lot of these new robot
- 30:08companies, Unitary etcetera, and you start to have the ability to
- 30:14operate in a home or business environment and connected with
- 30:17an agentic platform, it's going to have a lot of functionality.
- 30:20That said, here I am. Let me just check, no robot
- 30:24here. No, we're not there yet.
- 30:26And, and look, you know, what we've been talking about so far
- 30:28seems to be a very rising tide situation.
- 30:31You you pitched, you know the sales force product in
- 30:34particular, I tried to trigger you earlier by bringing up
- 30:37Copilot. You, Tom, tried to trigger me.
- 30:40Yeah, Mike, you would never do such a thing.
- 30:42We'll let the audience decide if I got a rise out of you.
- 30:45But you know, I heard an interview with this guy, Satya
- 30:49Nadella, who who basically described AI as a replacement
- 30:53for SAS. That's effectively, you know,
- 30:56these CRUD databases, which is effectively what SAS.
- 31:00Right, all right. Give me your response.
- 31:02And his company? Korna is saying it right and
- 31:05Shopify is. Usually, of course, yeah, the.
- 31:06Comment Let's not get distracted with Korna.
- 31:09Microsoft, Microsoft, sorry, their claim.
- 31:11Those guys withdrew their claim. Yes, right after pressure from
- 31:14people like you. By the way, I'll give you
- 31:16credit. Though, I mean, I look, let me
- 31:19give you my vision, which is first we just described digital
- 31:22labor revolution, which could be a gentic, it could be robotic.
- 31:25These are two different types of things that are happening that
- 31:29are so significant. And there's many other things in
- 31:32the industry can talk about satellites and comms and you
- 31:36know, there's many things happening all at once.
- 31:38But for sure AI is the biggest transformation.
- 31:41Now, when we talked about the fundamental transformation of
- 31:44software, and it's software going to change and transform,
- 31:48there's no question it's going to come more dynamic, it's going
- 31:50to come more intelligent, It's going to mold itself directly to
- 31:54me, all of these things. But you know, we also know what
- 31:58reality is today and just, you know, I have my phone here and
- 32:02look down at my phone. Oh yeah, I still have apps on my
- 32:04phone. And let me just say, transform
- 32:07my phone into the Marc Benioff phone and only show me exactly
- 32:12an app designed for me based on my preferences and the user
- 32:16interface and the type, you know, for my age that's
- 32:19appropriate for me in size and language.
- 32:23Oh, wait, it didn't didn't happen.
- 32:24But you could imagine that there is a moment where software will
- 32:29become more dynamic shaping to me.
- 32:32And we have that running at Salesforce also.
- 32:34But let's also talk about what Salesforce is.
- 32:37So, you know, it's a series of applications like sales service,
- 32:41marketing, commerce, Mule soft or integration platform.
- 32:46Are you know, Tableau Analytics, Slack, you know, I think you've
- 32:50used that now. We we are Slack customers.
- 32:52Slack, thank you and we. Weren't at the journal so I had
- 32:55to leave so I could join Slack. Thank God.
- 32:57And then here's the thing that's interesting.
- 33:00So now we also have a data cloud that's deeply integrated with
- 33:04all of those apps, and we have our genetic layer that we just
- 33:07went through. So now we have a new version of
- 33:09Tableau. Tableau is the most popular
- 33:11business intelligence analytics platform in the world.
- 33:14Incredible company acquired it, I don't know, 7-8 or nine years
- 33:17ago. I can't even remember how many
- 33:18years ago. And we've rebuilt it completely
- 33:21and just show the new version 2 weeks ago at the user conference
- 33:24in San Diego. And it's the slack that all
- 33:27these customers love. They call themselves the Data
- 33:29fam 'cause they're like the data family and but we put on it in a
- 33:34gentic layer agent force and we also hooked it into our data
- 33:37cloud so that they could all work off of common data
- 33:40repositories, but then integrate with other things.
- 33:42It's also embedded inside Slack. It's also embedded inside of all
- 33:46of our applications. It also is a marketplace of all
- 33:49these other applications. It has an action layer.
- 33:51It has a semantic layer. I, I, I get the connectivity
- 33:55argument, but you know, aren't you a little worried that like,
- 33:58you know, I could take a picture of Slack.
- 34:00I can go in like lovable or cursor and it will RIP off sort
- 34:04of your general design and some of your features.
- 34:07Go for it and let's see how far you can get.
- 34:09And by the way, you might be able to get some distance, but I
- 34:14think we know there are limits right now.
- 34:16Prototype, I think, you know, like first draft.
- 34:19And I think eventually, yeah, maybe all software will be built
- 34:24and designed by the AI. We won't need software
- 34:26companies. But today I think you'd really
- 34:29love Tableau. Next, if you're an analyst, you
- 34:31could sit there, you can talk to it.
- 34:33You can work with the model just like you're doing.
- 34:34You can do all those things and you can get all the
- 34:36visualizations. And you're still going to need
- 34:39high quality data management with a sharing model and a
- 34:42security model. Look, if you're at a bank, you
- 34:45can see your customers account balances.
- 34:47You cannot see my account balances.
- 34:50You know, like there is how data has to be highly regulated, it's
- 34:55managed, it's governed, security is critical.
- 34:58And then you have those 3 layers, the application layer,
- 35:00the data layer and the eugenic layer.
- 35:02So then we can start to decide, all right, which of these layers
- 35:06is transforming, which one's going away?
- 35:09What about the foundation, the fundamental platform layer as
- 35:11well, which might include things like the federation of the data,
- 35:14the search of the data? This is the life of a technology
- 35:17CEO with journalists. At first, our line of attack is,
- 35:21oh, you're coming up with technology too quickly.
- 35:23Your customers can't figure it out.
- 35:24And then we're like, but your customers are going to rebuild
- 35:27your technology from the ground up and they're going to be as
- 35:29sophisticated as you by. The way that's just why I love
- 35:32what I do. This is why I like it. 26 years
- 35:35later, you know, here I am, I love this and I just want to,
- 35:39you know, let's just ride this wave and like go with it.
- 35:43You know, this is going to be fun.
- 35:44It's going to be fun for my customers and it's going to be
- 35:47fun for us. And we want to take you along
- 35:50with us and we want to go with you and we want you to
- 35:52contribute. We want to contribute.
- 35:55And I was teasing Tom earlier about how, you know, we showed
- 35:58him what an agent and a gentic layer is for the first time.
- 36:01That's meaningful to me. Like we want to be a head.
- 36:03We want to show you. We want to be like we want to
- 36:06be, hey, the first time you ever heard about agents and Agentic
- 36:09was Salesforce, you know, and we have some new stuff coming that
- 36:13you're going to get that feeling from as well.
- 36:16What do you use the product? And I want to go to San
- 36:17Francisco. So but I can't help.
- 36:19But you know, we use Slack and we use AI all the time.
- 36:21Like I'm constantly on chap GPT. Why isn't Slack sort of
- 36:24harassing me a little bit more, you know, to to do stuff with AI
- 36:29in the platform or like human, sorry, superhuman, my e-mail
- 36:32client, you know, almost my chagrin is sort of trying to
- 36:35force its AI features on me. How much do you think about?
- 36:38You're basically saying why is Slack not more like Clippy?
- 36:41Or yeah, should you be or like how do you think about the
- 36:44trade-offs of like you like slack?
- 36:45We're not gonna like clutter it it's.
- 36:47Slack has been and I think that Slack has really evolved
- 36:50beautifully and has really embraced AI aggressively.
- 36:53And you know, there's there is another level and you'll see
- 36:57more functionality getting added and.
- 36:59But you're not gonna are you gonna force like how much do you
- 37:01see across the company pushing it?
- 37:03There could be a nudge, yeah. Yeah, A.
- 37:06Nudge, here's my, here's my last question on this topic here.
- 37:08And looking just broadly across tech and you know, the, the
- 37:11years that you've worked within it, how disruptive is AI in
- 37:14terms of the order of the, the, the, the balance of power within
- 37:18the industry? Is there an upstart that you see
- 37:21that could actually upend and take down a large incumbent
- 37:24right now, making them obsolete in the way that we've seen in
- 37:27other revolutions 'cause as I see it, as a reporter, it seems
- 37:30like almost aside from potentially what open AI
- 37:33becomes, it's all been owned by the tech giants.
- 37:36All the transformation, all the upheaval, all of the disruption
- 37:39is basically been owned by the cloud companies, the big
- 37:42software companies like you. And I haven't seen the kind of,
- 37:45you know, what is the Uber of AI, What is the, you know, the
- 37:48AWS of AI. Well, I don't know.
- 37:51I think you are seeing, first of all, with AI, we have to
- 37:53remember open source is a key part of the revolution.
- 37:57A lot of this innovation has come from open source.
- 38:01So let's bow to open source because that without that we
- 38:06would not have the speed that we have #2 You are seeing a lot of
- 38:11new companies. I mentioned a few of them, like
- 38:14Open AI, anthropicyou.com, Perplexity, I mean, there's a
- 38:19list of them and many other hundreds, thousands of other AI
- 38:23startups. And then you also have, yes, the
- 38:28established companies as well who are also trying to do that.
- 38:31There is some tension. You can see it even with the
- 38:33Microsoft Open AI Alliance. So you can see that Microsoft is
- 38:37working on their own large language model.
- 38:39They have hired Mustafa Suleiman, who was not just the
- 38:42CEO of Inflection, but before that was the founder of
- 38:45DeepMind, incredible executive known and myself for a long
- 38:48time. And there's no love lost between
- 38:52Sam and Mustafa. We all know that and I've seen
- 38:56it myself first hand. I can speak to it with
- 38:58authority. And so all of a sudden you see
- 39:02Open AI who was deeply dedicated to the Microsoft infrastructure,
- 39:06saying that they're going to build their own independent data
- 39:10centers and are building the first one, Stargate, you know,
- 39:13with Crusoe and you know, their CEO Chase, and he's on the case.
- 39:20So I think that this is really like interesting that there is
- 39:24some drama there. And even though they say there's
- 39:28no drama, we know there is drama and.
- 39:31Tom reported the copilot. The copilot figures were you?
- 39:34Were you surprised it was as small as it was or?
- 39:39Well, Tom knows I wasn't surprised.
- 39:41No, but that doesn't mean Mark was a source on it.
- 39:44But certainly, you know, you've look, you've been on this for a
- 39:47while, Mark I. Was not surprised because I've
- 39:50been saying for a while that I mean I use the products.
- 39:54How hard is this to figure out? I have these things on my phone
- 39:56as like this one doesn't work. This one does.
- 39:59They what they have GitHub, they have this kind of what they
- 40:02call, what did you call it? copilot, Tom, you know, where
- 40:05the developer and I thought that was the one that was actually
- 40:08pretty cool where the developer had a copilot helping them write
- 40:12more code. You know, we had Cogen we're
- 40:14trying to do with LMS and then all of a sudden there's this
- 40:16company cursor that comes along and then there's windsurf and
- 40:20then it's like, and what was that over there?
- 40:22Oh, wait. Oh well, so much for that idea.
- 40:26So. It's like it kind of goes to
- 40:28show how you got to go faster. You have to be more creative.
- 40:32You have to. We're in a tornado, you know,
- 40:36we're, if, you know, like my friend Jeffrey Moore, like he's
- 40:39written about this, We're crossing the chasm.
- 40:42There's like craziness underway and yeah, each company's trying
- 40:46to do what they're doing. Like we're it, we're doing,
- 40:49we're agent force first, we're building agent force companies.
- 40:51Like I already gave you some examples.
- 40:53Now I can give you, you know more examples of the Disney and
- 40:56I gave you 1800 account. And we, we, we want to make sure
- 40:59we talk about another passion of yours, San Francisco.
- 41:04I I'm curious, is it a new dawn in San Francisco or how do you,
- 41:07how do you rate the mayor? How?
- 41:09How different do you think it is?
- 41:10I've known the mayor for a long time and I'm excited.
- 41:14Look, we need to change. Everybody knows that.
- 41:17Look, I'm always an optimistic person.
- 41:19San Francisco has so many great things about it.
- 41:23I could go through it in detail. And look, I love San Francisco.
- 41:28I've invested a huge amount in the city, not just for my
- 41:32company, but, you know, large individual philanthropist, built
- 41:36the children's hospitals in San Francisco and Oakland, Cancer
- 41:39Research centers, microbiome research centers, other things
- 41:43that Mike, regenerative biology, other things that I'm, you know,
- 41:46really excited about at UCSF. We've put $150 million in the
- 41:50San Francisco and Oakland public schools.
- 41:53We've done a huge development of public parks.
- 41:55You've probably been to the Tunnel Tops park in the
- 41:57Presidio. I think it is a truly an
- 42:00incredible moment for San Francisco.
- 42:03I also look at all the other things that we have tried to do
- 42:07with, you know, obviously we have had a huge homeless problem
- 42:10for decades, since the 50s when my grandfather was a supervisor
- 42:15in San Francisco. I'm in these public schools.
- 42:19I don't know how many people are doing the research and were in
- 42:22the public schools doing the work.
- 42:24You know, public education is super important to me.
- 42:27It has been for a long time. I'm in the schools.
- 42:30A huge percentage of the kids in the San Francisco and Oakland
- 42:33public schools don't have homes. And these family, their family
- 42:38homelessness is a huge issue. And that really tugged at my
- 42:42heartstrings. I'd walk with my grandfather to
- 42:46work for sure when I was a kid. And you know, the homeless
- 42:49shelters used to be on Market Street, right where the Twitter
- 42:52headquarters are. So that's not a new homeless
- 42:54area. The Tenderloin is not new.
- 42:57It's been there for deck 45678 decades and used to be called
- 43:03Skid Row. It was like really like, these
- 43:06are difficult things. And you know, I have invested in
- 43:11and worked with maybe every homeless organization in San
- 43:15Francisco from the Salvation Army, you know, the UCSF to
- 43:20Hamilton to glide each and everyone like if they're working
- 43:25on this, they're, they know who to come and ask help from.
- 43:28And you Prop C also is about 10s of thousands of families.
- 43:35I think there's a lot of misinformation on Prop C.
- 43:37So I was just with a friend of mine last week.
- 43:38We're debating it and I'm like, let's get out Chachi PT and
- 43:42we're going to ask it. For Microsoft haters, I mean.
- 43:45I guess you're saying Chachi PT is distinct from Microsoft, but
- 43:47you do you do use Chachi PT. I use checks.
- 43:50I use them. All and then I was like.
- 43:53The analysis of Prop C, our city, our home.
- 43:57And here's the data set and connected it to SF Gov.
- 44:01All the data's there. And you know, there's no perfect
- 44:04solution for homelessness. There's no finish line.
- 44:08You know, our society, capitalism, we have no
- 44:10guardrails so there can be in some extremeness.
- 44:13And we know we don't have enough homes.
- 44:16We know San Francisco is a city of elite folks who pay very high
- 44:20prices to live there and a lot of people have to end up moving
- 44:24because of that. We are only on 7 square miles
- 44:27for incredible tiny sliver of land and we're trying to jam all
- 44:32these people in there. And we're not like other
- 44:35countries where we build social housing right inside our
- 44:38mainline housing, which a lot of other folks do.
- 44:41So there's different ways and homelessness has been something
- 44:45that I've definitely continue think that we have to focus on,
- 44:50and I hope that the mayor continues to to focus on that as
- 44:53a major issue. He ran one of the largest
- 44:56philanthropic organizations in San Francisco and work with them
- 44:59a lot on all of these issues. Yeah.
- 45:01But let's let's also cut to the other part of this this point,
- 45:04which is that, you know, when you came out, you know, in in
- 45:08favor of Prop C, you really ran against the current of a lot of
- 45:12people in the tech industry and people like Jack Dorsey and I
- 45:15saw even Elon, you know, who you're fairly friendly with, you
- 45:20know, essentially blaming you for the state of the city and
- 45:24and that your support of this thing was, you know, the reason
- 45:27San Francisco is. Yeah, well, it's silliness, and
- 45:29that's why I just went right to the AI and said, hey, you tell
- 45:33me. That was your unbiased response
- 45:36to be Elon. That's why you got to go.
- 45:38You got to go. To rock and send it to Elon.
- 45:40Like your great. State these guys are great sales
- 45:43people and you can say whatever you want on social media.
- 45:47But the cool thing about the AI and what I love about it and I
- 45:50love that at Grok feature is you can just say, hey, at Grok, tell
- 45:55me everything about prop C our city, our home, the results.
- 45:58Here's the data set. You can give it the URL, you
- 46:01know, from SF Gov and now tell me the success and failure of
- 46:06this. And is this all true or is this
- 46:08false? And you'll, you'll see like 10s
- 46:11of thousands of kids and families have gotten homes.
- 46:15And that may not be the political orientation of some
- 46:19people, but housing and public education is and public health
- 46:26are my areas that I worry about the safety net in a city like
- 46:30San Francisco. And I've invested in the safety
- 46:33net. And so yes, public housing,
- 46:35public health and public education are three things that
- 46:38I've invested in. And some of the other executives
- 46:40that you've mentioned, I won't go through their philanthropic
- 46:43history because I am friendly with them.
- 46:45I try not to call people out and assassinate people, you know,
- 46:49online. Look, they haven't done anything
- 46:53that this isn't what they do. They build companies, they move
- 46:55on. So that's not what I'm doing, am
- 46:59I? You can see my, you know my
- 47:00history. Well, you also remain in San
- 47:02Francisco, which a lot of these people didn't.
- 47:04They're either, you know, in Austin or in the case of Dorsey,
- 47:07Africa. Would the world be a better
- 47:09place right now if you had bought Twitter versus Elon?
- 47:12I don't know I would. I can't even imagine by the way
- 47:16you get close. I when I yes, but when I was
- 47:19when I was looking at that, my dreams and my vision for that
- 47:24wasn't any of these things. And then I don't know, the
- 47:27political environment has become so hot.
- 47:29I don't know if I would have been the right owner.
- 47:31So I mean, I think that he's been a much better owner.
- 47:35I mean, it's been impressive to see what he's done with the
- 47:37platform. I.
- 47:37Think, well, he hasn't made it a great business.
- 47:39I mean, maybe he's potentially made it into a more.
- 47:42Controversial numbers? I can't speak to that.
- 47:44Yeah. I mean, you're, you know,
- 47:46looking nationally. I mean, you're, you know, sort
- 47:48of an outspoken person who sort of leads with your heart.
- 47:53It feels like we're in this moment where tech executives are
- 47:56just sort of cozying up to Trump because that's sort of the
- 47:59smartest, smartest move. Or what do you what do you make
- 48:02of some of your peers? Just sort of like flattering the
- 48:06president. You weren't there at
- 48:08Inauguration Day, were you? No, I mean, let me just speak to
- 48:11this directly. So number one, I've worked
- 48:14inside a Republican administration.
- 48:16I was Republican. I worked inside the Bush
- 48:19administration, I was the chairman of the PCAST.
- 48:22When I was in my 30s, I realized that I'm better as an advisor
- 48:27and outsider and consultant, and I decided I would never take
- 48:31another government job after that.
- 48:34So that was where I am now. It's one of the reasons I bought
- 48:38Time magazine, because I could be independent.
- 48:41I wasn't going to make political contributions.
- 48:43I haven't made any political call contributions of any type
- 48:46since 2018. So that is my highest order bit
- 48:52around that. And I would say that when I when
- 48:56we want to talk about, you know, president's change, my values
- 48:59don't change and then I try to align with these presidents and
- 49:03Trump is no exception. I've aligned with him.
- 49:06If you remember the first Trump administration, I came up, we
- 49:09talked about homelessness. I also focus a lot on forests
- 49:14and reforestation, which I believe is a major issue in the
- 49:17climate. And Trump aligned with me and we
- 49:20launched 1 trillion trees together, you know, and it's
- 49:23been written about extensively, but he got completely
- 49:26behind1t.org. And by the way, that's been an
- 49:29incredible thing, even globally, where even China has come in
- 49:33with 70 billion trees and Xinhua, you know, came forward.
- 49:36And so that they're joining in the Republic of Congo is joined
- 49:41and many people have joined. And so that's an area where I
- 49:44can align. And I hope that I will find
- 49:47other areas. I already know there's going to
- 49:49be other areas. But you don't think CEOs are
- 49:51uniquely afraid to criticize Trump?
- 49:53I mean, it is a. It is a different mood than than
- 49:57in the past. I think that you have to find
- 50:00opportunities to align and move forward, and that's what I tried
- 50:05to do on the first one. By the way, I've what I learned
- 50:08in the Bush administration was that I was not going to agree
- 50:13with everything in that administration.
- 50:16I won't go through in details. Obviously, one of my closest
- 50:19friends was the Secretary of State Colin Powell, who ended up
- 50:22joining our board. And I just learned that I'm not
- 50:26going to be able to align with every aspect of a political
- 50:29organization because I have my own unique values and beliefs
- 50:34and vision for the world. So, but I can, I don't have to
- 50:39do everything, but I can align on some things.
- 50:42And I think that if I don't align on those some things, I'm
- 50:44doing myself a disservice to my own core values.
- 50:48And that's where I found, for example, the opportunity to work
- 50:53on reforestation. And I will find other, I
- 50:55guarantee you now because I already know I'm working on it.
- 50:58Other things where I feel good, where I can say, yes, these are
- 51:01my values and I'm going to you know, you know, I'm doing like
- 51:04huge programs on ocean philanthropy and I'm very
- 51:07worried about ocean health. I'm worried about the same
- 51:10things. I will find the opportunities.
- 51:13And by the way, I've tried that, for example, in the Biden
- 51:15administration and I only I made some progress on some things and
- 51:19other things I did not like, for example, the replant act I felt
- 51:23was very important. And then other things I was very
- 51:26disappointed on ocean how they how they assessed and move
- 51:30forward on the oceans. It is diversity, equity,
- 51:33inclusion debt at Salesforce still alive or where I mean this
- 51:37administration hates sort of DEI is are you holding the line
- 51:41there or how do you think about that?
- 51:43I've always just caught. I'll just tell you how I look at
- 51:45it, which is I've always looked at that totally differently.
- 51:48I've really believed that. It's about, you know, do we
- 51:53believe in equality? You know, I, I believe that
- 51:57we're all created in some level with equality in, in our hearts
- 52:01and that we can come together on this.
- 52:03And so we should provide equal opportunity, we should provide
- 52:07equal access and we should provide equal pay.
- 52:11And that means that specifically like on men and women, you know,
- 52:15we audit at Salesforce. Do we pay men and women equally
- 52:18for equal work? And a lot of companies don't do
- 52:21that. Just it's an easy audit.
- 52:23We use this thing called an HR management system and we can
- 52:26just say, do we pay? We could ask the LLM which we
- 52:29do, do we pen, do we pay men and women equally?
- 52:33And it'll say yes, here, here and here, but not in this
- 52:35country or in this acquisition you just made.
- 52:38And then we'll equal it out and kind of feel good about that.
- 52:40And then because of that we have, you know a lot of
- 52:44operating units that are female lead.
- 52:46That's not nothing that we've actually targeted happen like
- 52:51that. Marketing, legal, you know,
- 52:53finance communications have become female led organizations.
- 52:58Some are are some are still dominated by men.
- 53:02That's great, like engineering, others is fine.
- 53:05And then it you know what they're shifting over time.
- 53:08They move around and because we're not assigning those, we're
- 53:12not creating quotas. We're, you know, just saying let
- 53:16let's just let this. But you did previously, I mean
- 53:19TEI was about creating if not necessarily a quota about an
- 53:22emphasis on hiring people that were under represented in these
- 53:25companies. I mean you guys have gone
- 53:26through a transformation in which you previously did include
- 53:30diversity as a criteria and I think just this year took that
- 53:33out. So this is a.
- 53:35Shift it's own. I think that there's certain
- 53:37things that we are definitely adjusting that have only
- 53:41appeared in the last year. A lot of stuff post pandemic
- 53:44appear that I think maybe got too aggressive.
- 53:48So I don't disagree. I like reboot back by the way, I
- 53:51wrote a whole book on this. So like what I it's not like I
- 53:55have to rescind anything in my book.
- 53:57You know, the things that are in my book are what I actually
- 53:59believe and those are the things that we're leading with.
- 54:02And you can read that book. It's called Trailblazer and it's
- 54:05about how to bring these core values into your business.
- 54:09And that is extremely important to me that I run a business.
- 54:12Look like one of the best decisions I made was 26 years
- 54:16ago when we started Salesforce. We put 1% of our equity, 1% of
- 54:19our profit and time into a foundation.
- 54:23It's worked out really well. We've done 10 million hours of
- 54:26volunteerism, giving away a billion dollars and 50,000
- 54:29nonprofits and NGOs for free in our service.
- 54:31And we also started to pledge1%.org.
- 54:34We've recruited 20,000 other companies to do this with us all
- 54:38over the world. So they've given away billions
- 54:41of dollars to their local communities.
- 54:44That's important to me. These are the things that are
- 54:47important. And by the way, I'm not just
- 54:49building products, I am also building a company in a culture.
- 54:53And that's a critical part of what we're doing every single
- 54:57day. And you worked in a company who
- 54:59I have a lot of respect for the CEO, Rupert Murdoch, you know,
- 55:03at News Corp. And Tom, you were there.
- 55:05And it's a different set of values.
- 55:07And like Rupert and Robert Thompson, who I know incredibly
- 55:11well, brilliant CEO, you know, I have a lot of respect for
- 55:16different cultures and different businesses.
- 55:18I work with them, especially as you go around the world,
- 55:21different countries. But I want to have my company be
- 55:25a certain kind of company built on trust, customer success,
- 55:28innovation, equality and sustainability.
- 55:31Those things are important to me.
- 55:32You're not gonna gonna have a hard time ripping those out of
- 55:34my heart. That's who I am.
- 55:36Right. I I think that's probably as
- 55:38good a place as any for us to end here for for for my sake and
- 55:41for, for Eric, since I'm getting increasingly urgent messages
- 55:44from the people, Mark. Oh, OK, well, so.
- 55:46But look. You forgot what you wanted.
- 55:48Yeah, we had a great time. And I, I just wanted to say, you
- 55:51know, I do journalists, you know, can be a little bit like,
- 55:54oh, I know, I don't have any point of view.
- 55:56I think, you know, a newcomer, we have much more of a
- 55:58perspective. And certainly the 111 program is
- 56:01an inspiration. And you know, we do, I do
- 56:05applaud you for what you've done in instilling a value.
- 56:08And it's certainly, I think in a world where company, you know,
- 56:12people want meaning so much. And I mean, you run sort of a
- 56:17software company and the fact that you can bring meaning as
- 56:21part of that work, I think is really valuable and something a
- 56:25lot of people in tech need to figure out.
- 56:29Even even if I want you to be more of a warrior on, on some of
- 56:32these Trump issues. I, I'm, I'm happy how you're
- 56:36building your company and we appreciate you coming on the
- 56:38podcast. Right.
- 56:39Oh no, I'm thanks Mark. I'm grateful to be with you and
- 56:42look, I'm happy to do it anytime.
- 56:43This doesn't have to be a one and done all.
- 56:45Right. Thanks so much.
- 56:46See you. Bye, guys.