Latest / The History of Austria: Empire, Collapse, and Reinvention — Fexingo History / The Enlightened Despot: Joseph II and Austria's Failed Revolution
Transcript
- Lucas: So we've spent a lot of time with the Habsburgs, the battles, the palaces, the coffeehouses. But there's one emperor who tried to tear it all down from the inside, and he's fascinating because he failed so spectacularly. Luna: Tear it down? You mean a Habsburg who wasn't about preserving the family empire? Lucas: Exactly. Joseph II, coregent with his mother Maria Theresa from 1765, then sole ruler from 1780 until his death in 1790. Ten years of the most radical reform program the monarchy had ever seen, all driven by one man's conviction that reason alone could remake a state. Lucas: And honestly, if you've been getting value from these conversations about Austria's long history, the way we keep them ad-free is through listener support. If today's talk gives you something you can use, a coffee at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo helps us keep going. Luna: Yeah, we're lucky to have listeners who chip in like that. And it's always good to know the work lands somewhere. Lucas: So, Joseph wasn't just enlightened in the sense of being a reader of Voltaire. He actually tried to implement Enlightenment principles across a sprawling, multi-ethnic empire. He issued over six thousand decrees in a decade, touching everything from religion to criminal justice. Luna: Six thousand decrees. That's like a new law every day. What was he thinking? Lucas: He wanted to create a rational, centralized state. He abolished serfdom in 1781, which sounds great, but he did it so abruptly that landlords had no time to adjust, and the peasants were left with new obligations they didn't understand. He introduced the Toleranzpatent, the Edict of Toleration, giving Protestants and Jews freedom of worship, but he also closed hundreds of monasteries he deemed unproductive. Lucas: He even tried to reform how people were buried. His Cemetery Reform of 1784 banned burials in coffins, ordering everyone to be sewn into linen sacks and buried with quicklime, in common graves, without markers. He wanted to save wood and space, and he thought it was more hygienic. Luna: Wait, no coffins? I get the practicality, but that must have horrified people. Lucas: Horrified is an understatement. In Vienna, they rioted. The idea of being buried like that, without a proper grave, went against centuries of custom and religious practice. Joseph's own courtiers were appalled, and he had to back down within months. That was a pattern: he'd issue a decree based on pure logic, and then reality would slap him in the face. Lucas: He also overhauled the legal system with the Josephine Codex, which abolished the death penalty and judicial torture, and made courts more uniform. But even that was part of the problem: he wanted one law, one language, one administration for all his lands, which meant steamrolling over the traditions of Hungarians, Czechs, Belgians, and Italians. Luna: So he was trying to build a monolith out of diversity. That sounds like it would backfire. Lucas: It did, spectacularly. The most dramatic explosion was in the Austrian Netherlands, modern-day Belgium. Joseph's reforms there, especially his attempts to curb the power of the Catholic Church and reorganize local government, sparked a full-scale rebellion in 1789, the Brabant Revolution. They declared independence and formed the United States of Belgium. Luna: The United States of Belgium. That's a name I never expected to hear. Lucas: And it was a direct challenge to Joseph's whole project. He sent troops, but they couldn't win, and it looked like he might lose the province for good. Then there was Hungary, where he infuriated the nobles by refusing to be crowned king of Hungary, because he didn't want to swear to uphold the Hungarian constitution that he was busy dismantling. Lucas: In 1790, with revolts brewing in Hungary and the Netherlands, and his army stretched thin, Joseph was forced to revoke most of his reforms on his deathbed. He died at 48, reportedly saying he wanted his epitaph to be: 'Here lies Joseph II, who failed in everything he undertook.' Luna: That's heartbreaking. He wanted so much, but he moved too fast and too hard. Did anything survive his death? Lucas: Quite a bit, actually. His brother and successor Leopold II, who was more pragmatic, kept the Edict of Toleration and the abolition of serfdom. The legal reforms, too, had a lasting impact. But perhaps his greatest legacy was the precedent of reform itself, and the warning about what happens when you try to force enlightenment on people who aren't ready for it. Luna: It's like he was a century ahead of his time, but also a decade too fast. Lucas: That's a nice way to put it. The irony is that his reforms, which were meant to strengthen the monarchy, may have accelerated its decline. By alienating the nobility, the clergy, and the traditional elites, he undermined the very structures that held the empire together. His son, Francis II, learned the lesson and turned toward reaction, but the damage was done. Lucas: There's a direct line from Joseph's failures to the 1848 revolutions and eventually the empire's collapse in 1918. Every time the Habsburgs tried to reform, they had to balance so many conflicting interests that they often ended up doing nothing, or too little, too late. Luna: And maybe that's why the empire lasted so long, because it was too complicated to change. But Joseph showed that even a determined emperor couldn't just will it into a modern state. Lucas: Exactly. His story is a reminder that reform isn't just about good ideas, but about timing, patience, and understanding the people you're governing. And it makes you wonder, if he'd been a bit more like his mother, who was pragmatic and incremental, would Austria have been better prepared for the challenges of the 19th century?