Latest / Before you say yes / Ep 18. Why reading your insurance policy could save you from a devastating shock: Andrew Hall uncut
Transcript
- 0:00And there are these times when, if you look at this through the lens of how someone can do this and weaponize the product against a partner and have very little regard for the financial outcome for themselves even in doing this, I think that's the moment where the industry has sat back and said, yes, there are times where the legal clause and the exclusion made a lot of sense, but there is mitigating evidence here that needs to be taken into account that this wasn't the fault of one of those parties.
- 0:28and that person has now been left without a home, without a car, without the asset that they jointly owned.
- 0:34And, you know, the perpetrator has had some sort of victory in their minds.
- 0:38Of course, it's not a victory in any shape or form.
- 0:41In fact, it's a crime.
- 0:46I'm Catherine Fitzpatrick.
- 0:47I'm a former senior bank executive now working with companies, governments and regulators.
- 0:52to change the way financial products are designed.
- 0:55This podcast is about financial consent, what to check, what to ask before you share your money, your accounts, or your digital life with someone you love.
- 1:07So before you say yes to sharing your financial life, listen to this.
- 1:37Andrew Hall, CEO, Insurance Council of Australia.
- 1:40And what does the Insurance Council do?
- 1:43So the Insurance Council is the representative body of all the general insurers in Australia.
- 1:47We cover all those organisations that are regulated by APRA that can provide general insurance products, whether that's home and contents, motor vehicle, travel, pet, through to commercial types of insurance, public liability, professional indemnity, medical indemnity and the like.
- 2:03It's basically everything except for health insurance and life insurance, which are two very different sorts of products.
- 2:11Yeah, awesome.
- 2:11Thank you.
- 2:12So insurance is one of those things that people sign up to and then they put in the drawer and they forget about it until they need it.
- 2:21Can you tell me what exactly is an insurance policy and what's it designed to do for someone?
- 2:28Well, I remember when I was young, an insurance policy was something that just made your eyes glaze over.
- 2:33It felt like something, some sort of tax that you just paid and you were never quite sure what it does.
- 2:40At its core, what insurance is, is the opportunity to take a risk off your side of the ledger and have somebody else carry it, pull that risk.
- 2:49at a set cost per month or per year.
- 2:51And when you start accumulating assets and when you start doing things like setting up a business or buying a home, buying a car, taking a holiday, you've got to think about what the risks are in your life and how are you going to protect those if the worst happens.
- 3:03So insurance has always been a relatively simple concept, and that is if we can understand what the risk is and we can give it a price, and that can be shared amongst a big group of people,
- 3:14so that the premiums of the many will pay the claims of the few.
- 3:18And that's ideally what insurance is trying to do.
- 3:20Yeah, so when you're starting out, say in a relationship with someone, you're starting to think about, I'm going to share my money, share my bills.
- 3:31What are the risks people should be thinking about then?
- 3:34Well, from an insurance perspective, when you start sharing things, you are sharing that risk.
- 3:39You're sharing that liability that someone could steal that laptop or they could break into your home and take more things or that the home could catch fire and burn down.
- 3:49Your rental property could burn down around you and you lose all those contents you've bought.
- 3:53Everything you bought from IKEA the week beforehand goes because the lithium-ion battery caught fire in your property.
- 3:59Yeah.
- 4:00I can bore a dinner party senseless these days with the risks that are in people's lives.
- 4:05And if you think about risk too much, you'd never do anything.
- 4:09And I think if you provide, if you look at insurance through a deprivation lens, if it wasn't around, you'd nearly never leave your home.
- 4:18You'd be worried about protecting all the things that you own.
- 4:21And when you start owning things collectively, it brings in an added level of complication.
- 4:27Now, insurers will make that as easy as possible for you.
- 4:31If you own a home or a car or a boat or whatever it is in joint names, an insurance policy can be in both names.
- 4:38It's always important to understand, though, what does that mean when a policy is in both names?
- 4:43And importantly, what's it going to do if the worst happens?
- 4:47Yeah, and I think that's a really good point because what does it mean?
- 4:51Because sometimes we see this podcast is about financial abuse and we can see that products can be misused.
- 5:00But we also know that there are cases where an asset might be in one person's name, the insurance is in two people's names or vice versa.
- 5:10How does that all work?
- 5:11Yeah.
- 5:12Well, ultimately the insurance is covering an item, so it's underwriting the risk of that item or that home or an event, like a holiday or something like that.
- 5:23And what the insurer is looking to do is cost the risk of something going wrong with that item.
- 5:29Now, it all depends on the insurance policy, which is why we always say you should read your policy and understand how it works and how the cover is provided and offered.
- 5:39And the way insurance is sold for 99% of the products that most people will buy, it's a direct relationship with the insurer.
- 5:47So at the time of what we call underwriting, which is where you put in all the information about the thing you want insured, you need to make sure all that information is correct and make sure that that information accurately reflects the situation for that item.
- 6:01So if it's a car, if it's jointly owned, or if it's owned by one person, if it's a home, if there's a mortgage over that property, which bank has that mortgage and the like.
- 6:09All that information needs to go in.
- 6:11That's how the product is then priced and offered to you.
- 6:14And I think it's being very clear then, if you've got an insurance policy, for example, for your car, and it only covers one person to drive that car, both people who are driving that car need to be aware of that.
- 6:26It would probably not be the right policy to have.
- 6:29And they're the sort of questions that you should always ask and check.
- 6:33I know myself, when I was renewing an insurance policy recently for my own car, I realized some of the quotes I was getting was limiting the number of people or persons who were actually eligible to drive my car and then claim if something went wrong.
- 6:48And I was just aware that my partner drives my car, my brother may drive my car when he's visiting us and the like.
- 6:54So I wanted a policy that would cover family members and others.
- 6:57And a couple of quick questions, I found the right ones that did that for me.
- 7:02How did you know the questions to ask?
- 7:05Because insurance can be a pretty, it's a complex product actually.
- 7:10And if you say you bore people at dinner parties about insurance, I bore them about terms and conditions.
- 7:17Really boring.
- 7:18But, you know, there's a lot of information to read.
- 7:21How did you know what to ask and what questions would you ask?
- 7:26I think it varies for everybody because we all think about things differently.
- 7:31And I think the way insurance is sold these days, it is far more intuitive and helpful for people because it's largely a digital online experience.
- 7:40It will actually prompt you with questions which make you sit back and think, well, who would be the drivers of a car?
- 7:47Or where am I going on holidays so I need travel insurance for?
- 7:50Will I be rock climbing?
- 7:52Will I be on a motorcycle?
- 7:53And often people think to themselves, well,
- 7:55Well, I'm not going on a motorcycle, but if you go to Bali, more often than not, you get on a motorcycle to avoid the traffic jam to get home after dinner.
- 8:03So that is a risk.
- 8:04And if you have an accident, you need to make sure that you're covered.
- 8:07So I think it's those prompts you go through in the underwriting, but even at a more basic level...
- 8:14If you just think about what are the risks that I'm worried about?
- 8:18And if I'm looking for an insurance policy, is it going to do what I need it to do if the worst happens?
- 8:23And I think once you're clear about those risks, you can much better source the sort of insurance policy that you need that's going to be right for you.
- 8:31Quite often we say, there's a phrase, too long, didn't read it.
- 8:35And that happens with product disclosure statements that come with insurance policies.
- 8:40They are very long because they are legal contracts.
- 8:43But I think, I believe insurers do do a very good job these days of being very clear about what the key elements of that policy are.
- 8:51And I think being aware of those key elements is critical for anybody.
- 8:55Yeah, I think that's a really good point because I know from my experience in managing complaints, say, around insurance many years ago, people didn't always understand what they were buying.
- 9:09So then they were disappointed
- 9:12that they weren't covered for that.
- 9:14And then obviously the insurance industry had some issues through the floods inquiry where that was also another issue.
- 9:22People didn't know that they weren't going to be covered potentially, and there are a whole range of reasons.
- 9:28Why do you think that is that there might be a mismatch between what customers think they're covered for, but what they're actually covered for?
- 9:36I think one of the challenges insurers have always had for a very long time, not just in this country but around the world, is sometimes people don't want to think about the worst.
- 9:47It's not necessarily in everyone's instinctive nature to want to think about what happens if things go wrong.
- 9:53But it is really important to just go through that checklist if something goes wrong.
- 9:58And you talked about the floods and that was a massive experience for those communities that were impacted by those flood events in 2022.
- 10:08It was also one of the...
- 10:09It is now the biggest insurance loss that Australia has experienced in our history.
- 10:14So we had 330,000 claims lodged after the floods in 2022.
- 10:20And if you think about that, 330,000 and, you know, on minimum, probably two people per home, but more than that, that's probably a good million, a million and a half people who needed to call on an insurance policy for help.
- 10:34One of the problems that emerged out of the 2022 flood crisis was that a number of insurers no longer gave the opportunity to cover yourself for flood or they removed what they call flood opt out.
- 10:50And often when people saw their premium, they knew they lived in a flood zone and they had made a decision, rightly or wrongly, that they didn't want to pay that extra expense for the flood cover.
- 11:03And quite often I'd hear it in some of these communities, you know, that river has always flooded.
- 11:09It happens every 10, 15, 20 years.
- 11:11We'll be right.
- 11:11We've recovered before.
- 11:13I just wanted insurance for everything else.
- 11:14But then the flood actually happens.
- 11:17And it comes to the point where they're sitting in front of their insurance company in the recovery center.
- 11:22And I saw so many cases of where the husband or the wife had made a financial decision about their premium and they had opted out of the flood cover.
- 11:32And the insurer had to tell them, I'm sorry, your home wasn't covered for this event.
- 11:37And it's devastating.
- 11:38And we've seen since then a lot of work go into the industry around how to communicate with customers about what they're covered for, particularly in the flood areas.
- 11:48It is an unresolved problem we have in Australia because we have 220,000 homes that sit in high risk flood zones in Australia.
- 11:55That's about a million people.
- 11:57who in the next five to 10 years, their home will flood.
- 12:00There's no question about it.
- 12:02Increasingly, they're finding it very hard to find affordable insurance.
- 12:06And the primary driver of that is the flood risk.
- 12:09Insurers find it very hard to price a home that they know they're gonna have to replace every five to 10 years.
- 12:14They're very expensive.
- 12:15So we're working with the government on solutions around all of that.
- 12:19But it is a case when you're doing it jointly, for example, you've got to have a conversation around the kitchen table, you've got to talk to each other about what are the risks that we're prepared to carry and what aren't.
- 12:29Even when it comes to your excess, another boring element of insurance, and again, your eyes can glaze over.
- 12:37But if you see your excess at the highest possible level, some insurers offer it up to $10,000.
- 12:43What that effectively means is that if anything breaks in your home under $10,000, you need to find that that money won't be covered in your insurance policy.
- 12:52And it can be very hard to find $5,000 to replace the hot water system all of a sudden, you know, $3,000 to replace a laptop that's broken or stolen.
- 13:00These are the sorts of things that both parties need to be aware of and get comfortable with.
- 13:05We're happy to carry that risk and pay a cheaper premium or we'll pay a little bit more in our premiums to cover it.
- 13:12Yeah.
- 13:12So it's going in eyes open, eyes wide open and being very deliberate about the conversations you're having both in your home and with your insurer and being deliberate about the decisions you're making about what risk am I prepared to take on.
- 13:30I think there's been some really interesting work that the insurance, that insurance companies and the insurance industry has done, particularly when it comes to domestic and family violence and financial abuse.
- 13:43And one of those, I feel like we need to have a little bell, actually, that goes nerd alert, feminerd alert, because we're going to go right into this.
- 13:53But there is, in my research around the design to disrupt paper on insurance, one thing that survivors said is that they were unable to make a claim if their partner or ex-partner may be damaged or destroyed property because there's the malicious damage exclusion in an insurance policy.
- 14:15But what I thought was really promising was there's also a number of insurers who said, actually, we still want to be able to have some flexibility to pay out those claims.
- 14:25Can you explain a little bit about that?
- 14:28I think this is a great example of the excellent work that the industry has been able to do with yourself, Catherine, with FLEQUITY and the like.
- 14:36In insurance contracts, as I said before, they're legal contracts and they're built around and designed around providing cover where it's genuinely been an unanticipated risk.
- 14:47And so clauses have been drafted, exclusions have been put in place.
- 14:52And you can understand why those exclusions were there.
- 14:55If you choose to, you know, deliberately smash up your car with a sledgehammer and then claim an insurance claim, the insurer is going to ask the question, why are we paying this out?
- 15:05This wasn't an accident.
- 15:06It was deliberate.
- 15:08malicious damage it's driven a lot by what's happened in the past around fraud and still continues to happen you know the way we can see insurance products defrauded there's always a clever new way that people are coming up with to
- 15:23to gain a system and access money.
- 15:24And the problem is everybody pays for that through their premiums.
- 15:29But then there are these times when, if you look at this through the lens of how someone can do this and weaponise the product against a partner and have very little regard for the financial outcome, for themselves even, in doing this, I think that's the moment where the industry has sat back and said, yes,
- 15:47There are times where the legal clause and the exclusion made a lot of sense, but there is mitigating evidence here that needs to be taken into account that this wasn't the fault of one of those parties.
- 15:59And that person has now been left without a home, without a car, without the asset that they jointly owned.
- 16:05And, you know, the perpetrator has had some sort of victory in their minds.
- 16:10Of course, it's not a victory in any shape or form, in fact,
- 16:14It's a crime.
- 16:15But, you know, insurers do need to find that flexibility.
- 16:19And it's challenging, I think, in a sector where you rely very heavily on contractual enforcement to be able to manage insurance products and pay the right claims.
- 16:30But I think it's also important that insurers think with a human mind and look at circumstances.
- 16:36And I think this is where the work is leading them to think about the vulnerabilities that people have in those sort of circumstances and be able to take that into account.
- 16:44Yeah, and the insurance industry has had guidelines for some time, very comprehensive guidelines actually, around supporting customers who might be experiencing domestic and family violence.
- 16:58Are there any developments there or how do they work and what's within the winds?
- 17:04Well, the industry has been doing a lot of work in the broader space of vulnerability and the misconduct of others clause is one of those issues.
- 17:13I think the work that has been done across the sector, every insurer has taken, it's fair to say, their own individual approach to understanding this.
- 17:23They all have different types of products and markets, ways that they sell their product, whether it's direct or through brokers and the like.
- 17:31So it does have to be tailored for the insurer.
- 17:34But I think the baseline message that we want to give consumers from an insurance counsel perspective is that all of them are very signed up to providing those protections.
- 17:44And it is simply, it is often a case of asking for it.
- 17:48Now, I know that can be very hard and how do you do it even?
- 17:51How do you pick up the phone to disclose to somebody that you're going through this sort of a circumstance?
- 17:57There's training now that is very much in place for insurers.
- 18:01There's ways to be able to contact them, to be able to arrange a time for a phone call that's appropriate and safe to do so.
- 18:09All those sorts of things are now in place.
- 18:12And all of these will be part of, we have an industry code which sits over and above all the regulations that we are required to meet in this country.
- 18:20That code is currently up for review.
- 18:22We're working through that at the moment.
- 18:24And what I'm hoping is that alongside that code, those vulnerability frameworks, how we handle people in those circumstances, will also be better spelt out and insurers will have targets and goals that they'll be able to meet and demonstrate that they're doing the work to be able to protect their customers.
- 18:41Yeah, you talked about it can be hard to ask for that help.
- 18:47Have you got any practical tips on the kinds of things you might want to say to your insurer if you need a bit more extra care because you found yourself in additional circumstances like domestic and family violence?
- 19:01Yeah, insurers have very comprehensive vulnerability training these days.
- 19:05Although, having said that though, I will first acknowledge that it can still be very hard to identify vulnerability if people are not clear about it.
- 19:15So there's words, for example, and situations that can be expressed to an agent that will trigger extra care and diversion and the like.
- 19:25On anything, I always say to people, pick up the phone and have a conversation with your insurer.
- 19:31There are other ways of doing it these days, and a lot of them have chatbots, for example, that are staffed by humans and agents and will also detect that sort of wording.
- 19:40But if anything changes in your life, having a conversation, it's not the first thing you'd have a conversation with.
- 19:48There are other people in your world that you would talk to, probably.
- 19:52But when you start thinking about your financial arrangements, just like you would around your banking and your accounts or anything like that.
- 19:58Call your insurer and tell them, this person's no longer living with me, does that change anything for my premium?
- 20:05I'm in a situation where I'm not sure what is happening with something, can you please not email me, or this is my preferred manner of contact.
- 20:14We have to respect that.
- 20:16If you don't want a phone call, you tell your insurer, please don't call me, use this as a method for contacting me.
- 20:23Otherwise, live systems can make mistakes and can accidentally issue a notice or a renewal or something like that, which is going to fall into the wrong hands at that point in your life.
- 20:35So it's critically important to talk to them and don't feel afraid to raise it with your insurer that they are trained.
- 20:41And if the call center person you speak to, they will more than likely divert you off to somebody who is trained to be able to provide you with that support.
- 20:50Andrew, how important is it to understand whose name a policy is in, who is covered, who can make changes, who can cancel it?
- 21:00It's really important for insurance because insurance from a couple of perspectives.
- 21:04First of all, from an underwriting perspective, the insurer needs to understand who it is that they are covering and what rights or obligations they have, because insurance does actually put obligations on consumers as well.
- 21:17You are obliged to drive safely.
- 21:19You are obliged to keep your home well maintained and good repair.
- 21:24So understanding who has those obligations is really important.
- 21:28The other interesting thing about insurance, where it differs enormously from a banking product, is that it is very easy to cancel an insurance policy.
- 21:39And there's a lot of safeguards built into insurance policy so that if somebody takes one out and then in a few days time realize it's not quite what they needed, they're able to cancel it and they can get their premium back and the like.
- 21:51The downside with that is, again, unlike a banking product that has a lot of signatures on it, a lot of paperwork involved, if you try to change an account or redo a mortgage, for example, it is quite easy to cancel an insurance policy.
- 22:07And that's for a raft of good reasons that have come in over the years.
- 22:11It's designed to empower the consumer to take control of their own finances and determine if they can get a better deal, they can...
- 22:18absolutely opt for it you an insurance policy at its most lasts for usually 12 months maximum so it renews every year as well so understanding how an insurance policy generally works is the first step because if you understand how it works you can then make sure that you're well protected within that process so every year when the renewal comes in and we've been living through and it's a
- 22:43Every year, while inflation has been sitting around 3% to 4%, in fact, in building, for example, it's sitting near 10%.
- 22:50So again, if the house burns down, it may have cost $500,000 to replace it in 2020.
- 22:56But in 2026, 2027, it's going to cost you more than likely close to $1 million.
- 23:04So you have to adjust those sorts of elements of your insurance policy.
- 23:08And again, anyone can call up at any point and do that.
- 23:11It also means they could call up and adjust it down.
- 23:14So you wouldn't want a scenario where somebody calls up and makes the sum insured so low that it's never going to do the job it needs to do if the house was damaged.
- 23:25They're the sorts of things that you need to be very aware of and make sure that as the owner of that policy and the co-signature of that policy, that the communications are set up, that you are alerted and that you are fully across any of the changes to what's happening with those policies.
- 23:41Yeah, that example is one that has really stuck with me.
- 23:46A woman that participated in the research from my paper described how she'd been paying a house insurance policy for many years and didn't know that the policy had been cancelled by her ex-husband until after he'd threatened to burn the house down with her and the children in it.
- 24:07And the premium had also been repaid to him.
- 24:11So she was like, why didn't I know about this?
- 24:14Why wasn't I informed?
- 24:16And I know a number of insurers have now moved so that they are saying to, if you are,
- 24:23are co-insured on the policy, they'll send an alert.
- 24:26So there's a good reason to do things, but there can be a flip side when there is a nefarious motive from somebody.
- 24:33So I think that that point about checking what it is, being aware of how it works is really critical.
- 24:39What I'm asking of every single guest on this podcast is to complete this sentence before you say yes.
- 24:48Before you say yes, find out what happens when something goes wrong.
- 24:54Yeah, I love that.
- 24:55And that's part of the conversation actually.
- 24:58We're also talking about consent because young people are much better educated about what even is consent.
- 25:07How do you ask for it?
- 25:08How do you give it?
- 25:09How do you accept it?
- 25:10How do you then change your mind and have those conversations in a sexual relationship?
- 25:16But we're not necessarily having a consent conversation about money.
- 25:20And so part of that is maybe avoiding thinking about what happens if something goes wrong as well.
- 25:27And it's probably one of the more frustrating things for our industry because without getting boring, we're really limited on how we can provide financial advice.
- 25:37We're actually not allowed to.
- 25:38There is this area where if you ask certain questions, we won't actually be able to give you an answer.
- 25:44But basically, again, it's where we started our conversation.
- 25:48Think about...
- 25:50What's the worst that could happen and what would I need to get back into the position I was before that happened?
- 25:54It's like the definition of resilience, which is what insurance is all about.
- 25:58And you talk about finances quite often.
- 26:01It's very clear, for example, your mortgage and it's seed in your mind how much money you owe the bank to pay down your mortgage.
- 26:09But what would happen if that house burnt down and was no longer there?
- 26:12How much money would you need to rebuild a house?
- 26:15or pay that loan out.
- 26:17And they're two different things as well.
- 26:19You may only owe half a million dollars, but it could cost a million dollars to rebuild that home.
- 26:24Those sorts of conversations you need to have, not just with yourself, but you've got to have it when you're in a relationship and you're in a partnership with somebody else.
- 26:32You've got to have that conversation.
- 26:35If we lost the house,
- 26:37What would we need to get back on our feet?
- 26:39What does it really cost to rebuild this home that we're living in?
- 26:42And it's staring into that fact.
- 26:45I think that's the other interesting thing about insurance.
- 26:48It often will drive a conversation about risks that you've avoided having.
- 26:51The flood risk is one example.
- 26:53You know, we bought the house because it was cheap.
- 26:54Well, now it's time to have a conversation about why it was cheap and that's the flood risk.
- 26:59So sometimes insurers do find ourselves in this position of having conversations about risk that people have not had the gumption to really lean into themselves.
- 27:09But once you've had that conversation and you understand what they are, the power is actually within yourself to take control of that and protect yourself.
- 27:18against all of that.
- 27:19And you may have to get advice, you may have to get financial advice, you may have to go and or seek some help from a financial counselor, perhaps if the circumstances warrant it.
- 27:28There are people out there, legal aid and others who will help you through all of that.
- 27:32But understanding that is a critical first step.
- 27:34I think it's really important to another risk, and obviously the reason that I do the work that I do and that I'm raising these conversations through this podcast, is we also don't necessarily think about what's the risk in our relationship.
- 27:51What happens if something in the relationship goes horribly wrong?
- 27:55And it could be an illness, it could be someone losing their job, but it also could be somebody who...
- 28:01tries to control you and abuses you through your access to money or in other ways or there's violence.
- 28:08And no one goes into a relationship thinking that's going to happen, but there is an opportunity as you start thinking about the other risks.
- 28:17What do I need to do to look after myself?
- 28:19How could I set myself up in case that happened as well?
- 28:23Two people on an insurance policy, who gets to operate it, who gets to cancel it?
- 28:29And I think this is the issue that not just in insurance, but across financial services, banking, superannuation, everywhere else, these are products that were designed back in the day without thinking about that human element of jealousy and revenge.
- 28:44And they're nasty elements that when weaponized can really wreak havoc on people's lives.
- 28:51And I think the more financial institutions like insurers can think about, what are those risks that our products present?
- 28:58And how can we just build in the protections that people need or the processes to deal with it when and if that happens, then they're much stronger and they're better products and people can have a lot more confidence in all of that.
- 29:11And I think that's what the industry is determined to do.
- 29:14Thank you.