Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / The Last Trade E033: Wall Street's Bitcoin Blindspot with Larry Lepard & David Foley
Transcript
- 0:00Before we get into the episode, a quick reminder that this
- 0:02podcast is for informational and entertainment purposes only and
- 0:06nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 0:09Now for a word from on RAMP on RAMP is a Bitcoin asset
- 0:12management platform built on multi institution custody,
- 0:16leveraging our partnerships with industry veterans BITCO and
- 0:19Coincover on ramps. Multi Institution Custody is a
- 0:23segregated vault requiring two of three institutions at any
- 0:26point in time to sign once a client's unique permissions have
- 0:30been met. Our industry leading best in
- 0:32class approach to custody helps individuals and institutions
- 0:36secure new and existing Bitcoin positions.
- 0:39All keys are held in deep cold storage and kept 100% offline.
- 0:44Managed with institutional grade security best practices.
- 0:48The custody solution eliminates single points of failure and
- 0:52reduces counterparty risks, ensuring maximum security and
- 0:55Peace of Mind. Onramp's suite of products
- 0:58includes our custody offering, a spot Bitcoin fund, private
- 1:01wealth services and inheritance planning, and managed wealth for
- 1:04advisors. Whether you're new to Bitcoin or
- 1:07a veteran in the space, we would love to connect with you.
- 1:10To understand your needs and how we can serve you, please visit
- 1:13ourwebsite@onrampbitcoin.com or you can schedule a consultation
- 1:17and connect directly with our team.
- 1:19What you're telling me is that music is about to stop, and
- 1:23we're going to be left holding the biggest bag of odorous extra
- 1:28ever assembled in the history of Darkness 1970?
- 1:334. 198792972. 1000 and whatever we're going to call this.
- 1:38It's all just the same thing over and over.
- 1:40We can't help ourselves. I say when we sell.
- 1:45I say when we sell. Gentlemen, we're on the last
- 1:54trade and we just had the last trade of Bitcoin without an ETF.
- 1:57Today's the first day of the ETF.
- 2:00There's your corny opening for the week.
- 2:01It's. Good.
- 2:03It's all good. Dave and Larry, we're pumped to
- 2:06have you here. Is this a momentous, is this a
- 2:10momentous occasion? That's the that's the big
- 2:13question. Yeah, see it.
- 2:17You know, there's $100 trillion depending upon who's measuring
- 2:20what you're measuring. Let's say there's conservatively
- 2:2340 to $100 trillion of RIA money that couldn't buy a Trezor and
- 2:28couldn't buy GBTC and couldn't buy Bitcoin in any other form
- 2:33that now has the ability to just click a button and buy Bitcoin.
- 2:38I mean paper Bitcoin, admittedly, but it's not the
- 2:42same as holding your own keys. But you know, assuming the
- 2:44auditors are not corrupt, you're actually buying Bitcoin with one
- 2:48of these things. So you're saying you're saying
- 2:53of maybe 100 trillion now there's suddenly demand to get
- 2:58maybe a 1% allocation into an asset class that is currently $1
- 3:03trillion? What's the marginal?
- 3:06Well, and and it's better than that Jesse because as we all
- 3:09know $1 trillion asset class today, you know 70% of that or
- 3:14what we would consider to be pretty damn strong hands that
- 3:17haven't moved their key their coin for over a year or maybe in
- 3:20some cases two. So they're really bidding on,
- 3:24let's call it 300 billion of what I would call tradable coin
- 3:28today, you know, soon to be in April to be growing at you know
- 3:338 tenths of a percent per year and now growing at 1 1/2% per
- 3:37year. I I think, you know, I think
- 3:41people are going to be shocked. I mean I, I, I think Samsung
- 3:43might be onto something here. We'll have to see, I think.
- 3:47The other thing is you know you look at like a Galaxy, you know
- 3:50obviously real smart group of people there that are estimating
- 3:5413 to $40 billion of ETF inflows over the next three years.
- 4:01Like that just sounds too light to me, like way too light when
- 4:04you think about, I mean all sorts of things like you know
- 4:08like we're all getting caught up in the flows and ETFs.
- 4:10But what what no one's talking about in the last five days that
- 4:13I see is this whole macro backdrop which I'm sure we'll
- 4:15get into that might have a Black Swan event that then catalyzes
- 4:22real movements into this asset class.
- 4:24And so the good news is the on ramps to this asset class for
- 4:28those Rias that used to do the traditional 6040 equity bonds.
- 4:33You know if we ever get a, you know a real upside down bond
- 4:36market this beyond ramp to this asset class got really easy.
- 4:41So I I don't know I'm, I don't want to be hyperbolic but I
- 4:43thought Galaxy was way too conservative than that until
- 4:47Larry's point. You know if if if there's a
- 4:49trillion dollars at a minimum over the next few years chasing
- 4:54an asset class of you know call it 300 billion is he saying of
- 4:58of you know call it a third of the Bitcoin market cap.
- 5:02But you know I I just it's unbelievable kind of how much
- 5:07demand over supply this will be and then we don't even and then
- 5:09we could even get into the scarcity and the happening and
- 5:11all that. So it's it's all a lot of
- 5:15interesting things happening. Well, not only the macroeconomic
- 5:21landscape, that's a tailwind behind this right now, but what
- 5:25does the ETF BlackRock coming in?
- 5:27Galaxy Valkyrie, ARK 11 ETFs getting approved.
- 5:32What does that do for FOMO from other types of large investors?
- 5:36Like I wrote this in the newsletter last night.
- 5:37How many nation states does this send a light bulb off in their
- 5:41minds? Like, oh maybe we should get
- 5:43Bitcoin. Like that's a whole slug of
- 5:46capital that I don't think people are even talking about.
- 5:48Everybody's hyper focused on the RAA market, the institutional
- 5:52capital. But what does this do for other
- 5:55layers of the hierarchy of big capital allocators?
- 5:59Yep. Yeah, I mean you think of the
- 6:00sovereign wealth funds that probably haven't really embraced
- 6:03it, you know in in the Middle East and other places.
- 6:07I mean other than El Salvador, there hasn't really been another
- 6:09country to embrace it. You know, none of the big
- 6:13corporations have embraced it other than, you know,
- 6:15MicroStrategy. You know there's there's just
- 6:19not enough coin to go around at these kind of prices and I I
- 6:23think people are going to be shocked at you know the prices
- 6:26that that emerged as a result of that fact.
- 6:29I mean I I can't see how we're not at 100,000 soon and and you
- 6:33know 2 to 500 within a year or two, I mean maybe less but
- 6:38certainly you know within a year or two.
- 6:41Yeah, pretty, pretty incredible. Recent stat from Microstrategy's
- 6:45recent buying spree. They purchased 35% of all the
- 6:50coins mined in the last quarter. Right.
- 6:54And that's and that's a company that's a $10 billion market cap
- 6:58company and it's the 15 hundredth biggest company in the
- 7:01world. Small potatoes really.
- 7:04Right. And he's not stopping.
- 7:09You know, yeah. And now who's joining him is
- 7:11it's Larry. It's it's your old classmates,
- 7:13people who run, you know, BlackRock and other large Trad 5
- 7:17firms who suddenly have a vested interest in getting their
- 7:20clients to think that Bitcoin should be part of their
- 7:23portfolio. Hey Larry, you know who else
- 7:25isn't stopping? None of us.
- 7:27None of the people listening on the pond.
- 7:30I've you know a lot of times I'm sure we've all experienced this
- 7:32in regular world or like Bitcoin world where you go full circle
- 7:35Once you get educated, you kind of like end up back at like the
- 7:38meta level of oh this isn't like good for me or this was like
- 7:41good for Bitcoin and I had this realization we've been talking
- 7:44about. I think we all agree here these
- 7:46products are inferior to holding spot in various forms or
- 7:49fashions. But had this idea of like man,
- 7:51this is a trap and all the things associated with what
- 7:55happened to GBTC independent of like government intervention.
- 7:58Just the fact that the Bitcoin you know is sitting somewhere
- 8:00where you can't take delivery of.
- 8:02But then I had the realization it's like we look at this space
- 8:04so long, we've been looking at it so long that we think about
- 8:07it in the terms of like our allocations versus what a
- 8:09traditional individual that is sane for all intensive purposes.
- 8:14It's a like 1 to 3% alternative asset that sprinkled on top of
- 8:17their 6040. And my hope is and I think this
- 8:20is what we've seen play out as as you get educated with that
- 8:23one 3% whether it's somebody buying on cash app, buying a
- 8:26little through a river or looking at it through their
- 8:29brokerage account, you start to actually pay attention to like
- 8:32what is this thing I'm buying, what am I doing And then you
- 8:34learn about its properties. And that's why I think like this
- 8:37is always long term bullish for the asset, it's underlying
- 8:40fundamentals and companies building the right way because
- 8:42over time that kind of like cream rises to the top of oh
- 8:46wait, I don't want this all thirty 4050% sitting with
- 8:49Coinbase or BlackRock and and that's really where you know
- 8:52companies building the right way step in so.
- 8:57One of the. Realization.
- 8:58Would be true is that investors chase performance and I mean
- 9:01we're up 150 some odd percent last year and I suspect this
- 9:05year is going to be as good or better.
- 9:07And I mean, I was at the gym this morning with a guy who
- 9:09just, you know, he's kicking himself from missing the $15,000
- 9:13buy opportunity. And his logic was that, well, I
- 9:17thought when FTX blew up that was it, all this shit was going
- 9:20away. And I said, well, you know, he
- 9:23didn't do the time to, to differentiate this from FTX.
- 9:26And he said, well what about Ethereum?
- 9:28You know there are use cases there.
- 9:29And I said, you know, OK, maybe but you know the monetary policy
- 9:33there's totally flawed. I noticed this morning they were
- 9:36talking about another 33% dilution in the Ethereum base.
- 9:39So, you know, just, and this is a guy who's a very sophisticated
- 9:44money manager, he knows what he's doing, so to speak, and
- 9:46he's not, he's not a bitcoiner, but I bet she's becoming one.
- 9:51So and there's just going to be a lot of that.
- 9:54I mean it it goes back to how early we all have been and how,
- 9:58you know, people have painted us as being crazy.
- 10:01And yet what we've really seen was quite logical.
- 10:04And we knew we weren't crazy, We were just early.
- 10:09And that brings up a good question.
- 10:12Is this the crossing the chasm moment for Bitcoin?
- 10:16I think that's been a big topic of discussion.
- 10:18And is this the inflection point that really thrust Bitcoin to a
- 10:22level where there's no going back?
- 10:24We're sort of leaving the early adopters phase into mainstream
- 10:29adoption over the next three to five.
- 10:31Years feels that way to me. I mean, if you that that model,
- 10:34Mark Malcolm Gladwell's model says when you get as many years
- 10:36as it takes to get to 10%, it takes the same number to get to
- 10:3990%. And I it's hard to know where
- 10:42we're at, but being at it would strike me that we might be at
- 10:4410%, maybe we're a tad lower, I'm not sure.
- 10:47But boy, this sure opens it up to everybody and it just makes
- 10:52it super easy, you know? Absolutely.
- 10:56So I think it's way earlier than 10% and and that's where that's
- 11:01where the numbers come in that are.
- 11:04It's kind of hard to to believe them really.
- 11:06But you know, you can look on chain at how many addresses have
- 11:100.1 Bitcoin in them, right? So that at this point that's
- 11:14$5000 and that might be too high of a bar at this point, so maybe
- 11:19we should lower it. But that that's the easy cut off
- 11:22to see on Chain. There's 4 million addresses with
- 11:260.1 Bitcoin in them. Which is to say, there's there's
- 11:30at most 4 million people in the world who have saved in an
- 11:36address they control, $5000 worth of coin.
- 11:41To be to be completely fair though, to be completely fair
- 11:43though Jesse, there there are some addresses, there's some
- 11:46people who own it in Coinbase or Gemini or other pieces.
- 11:50I mean you're right that's 4 million self custody people who
- 11:54own 1/10 of a coin or more. You know there's they're
- 11:57probably in all those brokerage accounts.
- 11:59What I would guess I wanted Coinbase say their customer
- 12:02count was like 15 million, 20 million.
- 12:04They've got to be you know 20-30 million brokerage accounts as
- 12:07well that have some right and we don't and we don't know how much
- 12:11but. Absolutely And and then it
- 12:13becomes a yeah, it's it's a bit fuzzy there of like where do you
- 12:17draw the line on what is adoption And you know I think
- 12:20it's I think you can make the argument and I've made it in the
- 12:23past that that you know if you really understand Bitcoin you
- 12:27will have used the network to secure some amount you know to.
- 12:30Have deep, deep understanding. Owns.
- 12:34They're 4 million people with deep understanding I agree with.
- 12:36You exactly And so that's a high bar but that that's zero point
- 12:430.05% of of people in the world like how low we're talking I
- 12:52actually. Will push back.
- 12:53I think it's 110th of whatever you guys just agreed on.
- 12:55The four million, I think with the the measure is material
- 12:58wealth because material wealth basically signals you've looked
- 13:01long enough to at least say if it's on Coinbase and it it
- 13:04evaporates or understand it because a lot of people just
- 13:06have accounts with 100 bucks or $1000 or 4000.
- 13:09I think material wealth, IE over 10% of a single person's
- 13:14personal account or portfolio, is less than 400,000 people
- 13:17globally. No, I find that hard to believe.
- 13:21Jesse, you done some work like a year ago on some of that, right?
- 13:24Trying to figure out that that that was a good day to you had.
- 13:27Yeah, yeah, I I triangulated that you know the the best
- 13:31source we have is, is the Ledger.
- 13:35You know that's the only transparent data that we have
- 13:37out there and and that's where that that 4 million addresses
- 13:41comes from and it's been ticking up nicely over over the last
- 13:44four years that went from 3 million to 4 million.
- 13:47So more people are adopting and you know, despite the fact that
- 13:51that that that in dollar terms has become, has gone from $1000
- 13:56to now $5000 to to meet that 0.1 Bitcoin bar.
- 14:00Yeah, that number is going up. And then from there you have to
- 14:05triangulate like what percent of people have, you know,
- 14:10understand Bitcoin, have meaning meaningfully saved in Bitcoin,
- 14:13but they've done it in GBTC despite, you know, despite
- 14:16understanding Bitcoin and and realizing that it probably
- 14:19shouldn't just have GBTC. And then there it's kind of your
- 14:24classic, you know, back of the envelope consultant math to come
- 14:27up with something. But yeah, the hard and fast
- 14:30numbers are on the Ledger and and and and that's where it's
- 14:34kind of incredible how early it is.
- 14:36You know, if you if you look at just those numbers which really
- 14:40reflect like deep level of understanding of Bitcoin, it is
- 14:44so, so early that you know there's that's when no surprise
- 14:48there's only one Michael Saylor, you know doing this with the
- 14:51corporate balance sheet. There's only one El Salvador so
- 14:54far. We're just so early still.
- 14:57As I recall, I mean, apologize if I'm wrong, but I thought one
- 14:59of the conclusions that I remember reading your analysis
- 15:02was that if we counted people with 10,000 U.S. dollars of net
- 15:07worth in the world, it was well less than 1% of the global
- 15:10population had exposed to Bitcoin.
- 15:13Is that something like that? Yeah, yeah, I was using AI, was
- 15:18using a data source that that said that 2 billion people in
- 15:23the world have a net worth of $10,000.
- 15:26And so that to me is realistically the market for
- 15:30who's going to be interested in savings technology and Bitcoin
- 15:34and savings technology. And so of that number 4 million
- 15:38of 2 billion is half a percent of that group has sorry, less
- 15:45than half of of a percent that that's that 0.05% number because
- 15:54sorry, the other direction I'm. Putting the 2%.
- 16:00Yeah, that's .2% of that group, which you know.
- 16:03However, however way you cut it, it's incredibly small.
- 16:08Larry and David, I'd be curious like you guys have backgrounds
- 16:13in, you know, tradify. You've seen the markets like
- 16:16what has been your pre like dispose or kind of like thoughts
- 16:22around how stuff starts get a little getting a little weird.
- 16:24Like I was, you know, pinging some people before pre trading
- 16:27started, right. And you're looking at 25% up.
- 16:29It's like, did they buy that Bitcoin?
- 16:30They had to buy the Bitcoin because nobody's going to take
- 16:33that risk. So like, you know, you're
- 16:35looking at markets that trade within certain time frames.
- 16:37You have a 24/7 hour, 24 days a week, 724 hours a day, seven
- 16:42days a week global asset. Like walk us through kind of
- 16:45your understanding and at least to the extent you do have it,
- 16:49just the market structure from the authorized participants to
- 16:52the shares and like where things can get dislocated.
- 16:55I don't have that background, but it feels like it's not going
- 16:57to be clean long term as these things start to mature that
- 17:00we're talking about and demand increases.
- 17:02And so be curious if you guys have any thoughts on all that?
- 17:06Well, yeah, I mean, I don't know, Michael, it's funny like
- 17:09Larry and I actually had a conversation yesterday about
- 17:11that of and I'll get to that in a SEC.
- 17:13But I I woke up in the middle of the night thinking about this
- 17:16like I get I think back to the Microsoft, sorry the the
- 17:20Facebook IPO from 12 years ago or whatever it was.
- 17:24And and I don't know if you go back and look at a stock chart
- 17:27actually I could share the screen if you want and pull it
- 17:29up but you know basically well I I won't bother but but but if
- 17:35you look back at the the the Facebook IPO the thing kind of
- 17:39moon shot it up the first few hours and then bang the next
- 17:42three months absolutely got cut in half down 50% and it was the
- 17:46classic like well there you go it was too much hype going into
- 17:50it institution sold to retail sting craters And so you know
- 17:56having touched the stove like that and market over years you
- 17:59you get nervous when you see this hype and build up to this
- 18:01ETF and and whether it's going to be 40 billion and you know of
- 18:06inflows over how long will it be be and where will the price go.
- 18:10It it just naturally gets me nervous in the short run.
- 18:15But in the medium term we we look at kind of those flows we
- 18:19talked about and just how early we are in terms of global
- 18:22adoption like Jesse just talking about and just how easy the on
- 18:26ramps are. Now for your regular folk RIAA
- 18:30to do these portfolio construction analysis now to
- 18:33realize that better risk adjusted returns happened to
- 18:36your portfolio. If you get away from an old 6040
- 18:40equity bonds and you start adding in Bitcoin and then and
- 18:44oh by the way Mr. Jones you can buy you know this ETF and and
- 18:48own some Bitcoin and have that portfolio like this just becomes
- 18:52this virtual positive feedback loop over the next 6 to 9 to 12
- 18:56months of money coming in and and and those ETF forced to go
- 19:02and turn around and buy Bitcoin and and suddenly you just get
- 19:05this virtual feedback loop. So it feels highly probable that
- 19:09while there is some risk that this has gotten overhyped and
- 19:12people could get disappointed seven days from now because the
- 19:15money isn't as flowing in as fast.
- 19:17I do think that over 6 to 9 to 12 months, as Larry was saying
- 19:22earlier, the money is going to flow in and then we haven't even
- 19:24got into a Black Swan event, which again, we'll get into
- 19:27macro, I'm sure. But eventually you're going to
- 19:30have people running to inflation hedge assets when the money
- 19:36supply of the Fed begins flowing again.
- 19:38And Lori Logan, who I think is one of the Dallas Fed chairs,
- 19:41probably one of the most important people to listen to.
- 19:44She's the one who was the big architect around all of the
- 19:47programs from 2020 that the Fed used to go throw money in the
- 19:51system And here she is saying over the weekend this you know
- 19:54four days ago that it might be time to to stop with QT.
- 19:58She's seeing some of the issues in the repo market and reverse
- 20:02repo market. And so I'm being long winded but
- 20:05to land the plane we just see more high probability of
- 20:09positive catalyst for Bitcoin and flows of capital and macro
- 20:13backdrop that I think that you know as Marty's asking about to
- 20:17an inflection point. I think we will look back at
- 20:20this as a key inflection point and in the Zen philosophy too, I
- 20:25think we'll look back and say that Sam Bankman freed, we might
- 20:27have been one of the best blessings ever for Bitcoin
- 20:29because it began to teach the global markets about the
- 20:33difference between Bitcoin and crypto.
- 20:36And Gary Gensler and the SEC helped to kind of further
- 20:39educate that through processes like this.
- 20:42So let me pause there. But you know, I was excited.
- 20:46Let me add a few things Michael. So I think the job of these guys
- 20:52is to make the price of their product, you know, their ETF,
- 20:55track the price of the coin, you know, one for one with as little
- 20:58slippage as possible. And so I'm, I'm guessing I don't
- 21:01know this for a fact, but I'm just guessing based on how these
- 21:04things typically work that that they've got, you know, internal
- 21:08algorithms designed to kind of instantly buy as they get more
- 21:13flows in, they get more purchases, they attract money
- 21:16into their, you know, into their bucket.
- 21:19They literally have to instantaneously turn around and
- 21:22buy the coin. Because if they don't, you know,
- 21:25the coin does a God candle goes up 10,000, well then they're
- 21:28going to slip. They're not going to, you know,
- 21:29they're, you know, at the end of the year somebody's going to
- 21:32measure how they did against the coin and they don't want to have
- 21:34a lot of slippage if any. And so I think it's going to
- 21:38really be kind of one for one, they see, they see new flow in.
- 21:41They instantly buy coin. Where it gets interesting is, of
- 21:45course, they close down at 4:00 PM because the market shuts.
- 21:49And So what happens if a God candle happens overnight?
- 21:51Well, you know, everyone who's in it already participates, but
- 21:54you can't go buy the ETF, you know, in the middle of the
- 21:57night. And so, but that's fine.
- 22:00In the morning, the new price opens up and you want to bring
- 22:03new money in. Fine, bring it in and you're
- 22:05paying the higher price now. So I think that it'll actually
- 22:08be, you know, if they do it right, and I presume they will.
- 22:12And another thing, another two other comments I want to make.
- 22:14One is that some people say, well this is going to be paper
- 22:17Bitcoin. This, you know, look, we know
- 22:19who we're dealing with here and I've dealt with the gold guys
- 22:21for 30 years, so I can, I know how good they are at screwing
- 22:24around with this shit. But I think that in this
- 22:26particular case they're going to be auditors involved.
- 22:29And so for these people to, you know take money in and not buy
- 22:33the coin IE create paper Bitcoin I think is going to be a problem
- 22:37unless they can find a corrupt auditor which is possible but I
- 22:41wouldn't rate it as highly likely.
- 22:42So I I think that they're going to, they're actually going to
- 22:45it's not going to be paper Bitcoin and there's nothing in
- 22:47the filings and all that. And and so I want to move to the
- 22:49GLD which is the gold ETF which is very similar to these things
- 22:53and and create a lot of problems over in the gold space.
- 22:56But you know in that particular ETF filing, there are all kinds
- 23:00of outs where they could have custodians and sub custodians,
- 23:03they could buy paper gold, they could have futures contracts.
- 23:05And of course one of the things that a lot of us who looked at
- 23:07that thing said is these guys are buying paper gold from
- 23:10Lehman Brothers and if Lehman Brothers fails, the gold's not
- 23:12going to get delivered. And these don't have any of that
- 23:16language in the ETF filing. So I think they've actually got
- 23:19to legitimately buy the coins. Final point, Nikko on Twitter
- 23:25had it this morning, a really great chart and I retweeted it.
- 23:27I don't know if you guys have the ability to pull it up, but
- 23:29it shows basically when the gold ETF was approved in 2004 and
- 23:33then what happened to the gold price between 2004 and 2011?
- 23:38And it was pretty substantial. You know, the the appreciation
- 23:41in gold. So, you know, people weren't
- 23:44going out and buying gold coins. That was a pain in the ass in
- 23:48the early 2000s. You know, to go to your, I mean,
- 23:50the people just didn't do it. But suddenly, you know, ETF
- 23:53arrives, you can buy a gold proxy.
- 23:56Turns out it was quite flawed, but you can still buy a gold
- 23:59proxy. There you go.
- 24:00And you know, look at that, right.
- 24:03What was that November of 2004, the first, you know, GLDETF
- 24:07comes out boom. And so you know, will this
- 24:12repeat exactly? Probably not.
- 24:14But I think the trend is, is pretty indicative of what's
- 24:17going on. So we're, you know, we're, we're
- 24:20incredibly pulled up on this whole thing.
- 24:22I mean and you know, Sailor is too, right.
- 24:24I mean he's the one of the smartest guys, if not the
- 24:26smartest guy in the space. And he just said, you know
- 24:29folks, this is a once in a generation opportunity to front
- 24:32run a lot of money that that you know, wants to own the ship but
- 24:37can't because of the structure. Your typical RIAA cannot own
- 24:40Bitcoin or could not own Bitcoin until today.
- 24:43And so that's that's really, that's the news story here and I
- 24:48think we're now in uncharted waters And you know, Samson Mao
- 24:51says he thinks it's going to 1,000,000 bucks.
- 24:52I mean who am I to say he's not right?
- 24:55I mean, you know, I mean, I'm not sure, I bet on it for sure,
- 24:58but I mean obviously I think it's getting to a million
- 25:00eventually, but what's the time frame?
- 25:03I don't know, it could be faster than we think.
- 25:05So those are kind of my thoughts on how it's working.
- 25:11And anchoring back to the analog of Facebook's IPO that you
- 25:15explained, Dave like that's people have been calling the ETF
- 25:18launch the IPO moment for Bitcoin.
- 25:21But like we all know and there's exchanges that trade 24/7 365.
- 25:27Like the difference here is that Facebook going public has a
- 25:30bunch of insiders that want to liquidate some of their stock to
- 25:32monetize all the work they put in for for many years.
- 25:36And I think this is a different animal in the sense that
- 25:39everybody that's bought in has bought in just because because
- 25:43of what Larry just explained that you have the chance of
- 25:45front run immense amounts of capital.
- 25:48And I I don't think there's dynamics of like an IPO launch
- 25:51insider's dump is going to play out and things are going to get
- 25:54really weird. Yeah, it's a great point Marty,
- 25:56that that in that case of of Facebook you had institutions
- 26:01selling to retail, but then the mom and pop got held holding the
- 26:05bag. Now look to be clear, Facebook
- 26:08went down 50% in the next three months.
- 26:10It was one of the most phenomenal buying opportunities.
- 26:12It's up literally like 100 X from there and and so you know I
- 26:17I think that that's similar thing I I'm just saying could
- 26:21play out in the short run where you know I think you're kind of
- 26:24it just feels like the market's broadly in the last two months
- 26:27since the Halloween bottom has had a little levered speculator
- 26:32citadel type trend following investor pop in the markets.
- 26:37Right. And and ignoring now global
- 26:38economy And so I'm just saying that you know and partly because
- 26:42I'm hoping I'd I'd actually like to see Bitcoin settle back in
- 26:46and then be able to keep adding and just buying more Now like
- 26:50you guys we're always dollar cost averaging and ultimately it
- 26:53won't matter we'll look back someday on these prices they got
- 26:55what a bargain this was at 48,000.
- 26:59But I think you're right Marty to agree that the irony is we're
- 27:04selling a mom and pop retail on that Facebook IPO.
- 27:07This is the exact opposite. This is now the IPO of Bitcoin
- 27:11as you're saying. But for the institutions now to
- 27:13start getting involved and all of us that have been here for a
- 27:16while now you know we're we're kind of riding that way.
- 27:19We front random as Larry's saying.
- 27:21So yeah I this is in in general let me be clear on the medium to
- 27:26longer term like as Larry said we couldn't be more bullish.
- 27:29I mean this is this is really a huge catalyst to allow anyone in
- 27:34the world to buy it and the beauty of this asset class is
- 27:37anyone in the world can buy it so long as you have a mobile
- 27:40phone. And one last final point this
- 27:45guy was just listening to someone overnight was making
- 27:47this point that you know if 50% of the world is supposed to have
- 27:52CBDC's thrown upon them in the next year.
- 27:57Again in that spirit of that Zen philosophy of if same bank and
- 28:00freed might have been ended up being the best thing that
- 28:02happened to Bitcoin to to to create that delineation between
- 28:05crypto and Bitcoin here maybe these CBDC's as this gentleman
- 28:10was pointing out each creates a a a tutelage for people in the
- 28:15world to understand how to trade digital cash and therefore the
- 28:21eventual run away from Fiat currencies to Bitcoin become
- 28:26that much easier that they're doing a favor for Bitcoin
- 28:30ultimately by introducing CBDC. So you know, again, I don't want
- 28:34to get too philosophical of that, but but sometimes the
- 28:37things that you think are so bad aren't they're actually they're
- 28:39actually really good. And that.
- 28:42I mean, I just saw a stat on Twitter or an hour into the
- 28:46trading day, there's $1.7 billion of volume across these
- 28:5011 ETFs. How many?
- 28:54How many new Bitcoin? Not maybe not Bitcoiners as we
- 28:56would define them as people holding their own keys, but how
- 28:58many people, new people have material exposure over $10,000
- 29:04to Bitcoin today? Yeah.
- 29:06I don't believe. Did we just add?
- 29:08Looks like there's been 600,600,000,000 billion in or or
- 29:13million in no billion in in GBTC as well, right?
- 29:18Yeah. No counted in that.
- 29:23So there was an interesting tweet the other day that said
- 29:28can you say you're early if you if you got in after the ETF.
- 29:33You know we joke around being so early I think that would like to
- 29:35your crossing the chasm point it's kind of like this is it's
- 29:37it's a mainstream it's as mainstream as you can get from
- 29:40like. Yeah, it's absolutely a new a
- 29:43new era, but but yeah, to to to that crossing the chasm point.
- 29:47Weirdly I I still think that that is way in the future for
- 29:51us. We're still in, you know based
- 29:53on the numbers I was talking about firmly in the innovators
- 29:57stage. It just feels like we've come so
- 29:59far 'cause we have but you know the next 15 years will be going
- 30:04through the the the steep part of the S curve the adoption S
- 30:08curve and and Larry I was, I was just reflecting on you know the
- 30:14the chart you brought up about about gold was an amazing one to
- 30:18show the power of adding a a channel of buying power to an
- 30:24asset. But the the you know the the big
- 30:28difference you've already pointed out and done a great job
- 30:32of highlighting how bitcoin's more auditable and that you know
- 30:37creates this barrier to to the paper Bitcoin problem.
- 30:42But on top of that gold is has kind of historically been the
- 30:45domain of nation states right. Like it's it has such a long
- 30:49history that it has become so centralized over time and
- 30:53Bitcoin you know doesn't have any nation states hoarding it at
- 30:57all yet and so it's it's kind of hard to you know who has the
- 31:02authority to to meddle in a paper gold market and and muddy
- 31:08the waters really only nation states are are are able to do
- 31:11that and get away with it I think or you know with with the
- 31:14blessing of nation states at least and there's no in order to
- 31:19muddy the waters you have to have you have to control some of
- 31:22the supply. Or at least be a.
- 31:25Player in that market and there there's no nation state player
- 31:28in Bitcoin yet, so I think that's an additional barrier to.
- 31:32Effectively I would agree with that.
- 31:36Yeah, I would agree with that. I mean I would also assume that
- 31:38the on chain analytics people will be able to see and figure
- 31:42out. I mean look, you know, we just
- 31:45figured out earlier there's all, you know the the Black Rock
- 31:48Trust is already to date, we're going to be open a couple hours
- 31:51now has already bought $400 million worth of Bitcoin.
- 31:56You know you can't hide that that's you know there's got to
- 31:58be some on chain transactions going on.
- 32:01Somebody's going to be able to figure out where they are now
- 32:04they can kind of keep adding addresses and doing different
- 32:06stuff and I'm sure they will try and mask what they're doing as
- 32:09much as they can. But, you know, there's a bunch
- 32:12of great people who do on chain analytics that are going to be
- 32:15able to, I think, look through and see some of this shit.
- 32:18And you can never do that with gold.
- 32:19I mean it's the gold is just completely opaque and and
- 32:22frankly, I think a lot of people, you know, a lot of the
- 32:24nation stays lie about the gold. I mean, I think, you know, the
- 32:26United States is supposed to have 261 million oz or 8133
- 32:30tons. And I don't think we do.
- 32:33I mean, Ron Paul told me personally he's pretty sure that
- 32:36Fort Knox is empty. So and I, you know, I, I I can't
- 32:41dispute that. So you know, yeah, this is a
- 32:45much better mechanism all around.
- 32:48Can we talk about Franklin Templeton putting laser eyes on
- 32:51Benjamin Franklin? Is that does that mean we?
- 32:53Does that mean we won? Or like what is?
- 32:56Close. There's so many great things
- 33:00that are coming out of this. So the other one I love is of
- 33:02the Valkyrie guys deciding to name their checker symbols Burr.
- 33:06I mean, how great is that about trolling these guys?
- 33:11You know, there's just a lot of, there's a lot of good stuff.
- 33:14And then, of course, you know, yesterday's debacle.
- 33:17How about SEC nodding have not having a 2FA you know check on
- 33:22their on their website I mean. It's poetic.
- 33:25It's poetic. It's beautifully poetic.
- 33:27It's just clown world all over the place.
- 33:29And yeah, maybe it's a good chance to move into kind of the
- 33:33other side of the macro piece, which David and I are writing
- 33:35our fourth quarter letter about. Thanks for tuning in.
- 33:38If you're interested in exploring any of these topics
- 33:40further, or want to learn more about how we can help you secure
- 33:44a new or existing Bitcoin allocation, get in touch with
- 33:47our team at on rampbitcoin.com. We look forward to supporting
- 33:50you on your Bitcoin journey. The December numbers just came
- 33:56out and the December U.S. Federal deficit is 20%, up 20%
- 34:00year over year. So for the quarter ended
- 34:02December the US ran a 500 round numbers, 510 I think $500
- 34:08billion deficit and and the first quarter is typically
- 34:11small. So that would imply compared to
- 34:13the other. So that would imply that you
- 34:15know for the year or next year we're going to be over 2
- 34:17trillion. We were 17 last year would have
- 34:20been more but the student debt thing got turned around.
- 34:22But anyway you know $2 trillion deficit in a theoretically
- 34:26healthy economy, you know with 34 trillion of debt, you know
- 34:31they they we think that in our letter talks about this.
- 34:34We think that what happened last week or I should say maybe not
- 34:37two weeks ago is before you know Powell pivoted on the 13th.
- 34:42But before that, you know the the US Treasury bond melted down
- 34:4620% in September, October and went over the 10 year, went over
- 34:505%. And we think that that set off
- 34:52alarm bells and that's what led to them all coming out and say
- 34:55no, no, no, we're probably done with this rate hike cycle and it
- 34:58brought the 10 year back in and it created liquidity in a lot of
- 35:01areas which they needed to do because you know something was
- 35:05breaking. And our view is they're right on
- 35:08the edge of something breaking and we don't know when it will
- 35:10formally break and break in size.
- 35:13But you know we Silicon Valley Bank was an example of something
- 35:16breaking. They stuffed that one back in
- 35:17the can, but they're going to, you know something is going to
- 35:20break here. And if you read you know the
- 35:22Zero Hedge premium stuff I mean you know as David was alluding
- 35:25to you know Lori Logan and and the basis trade and you know
- 35:29there's there's a lot it's it's it's pretty complicated stuff
- 35:31but there's a lot of there are a lot of indicators that would
- 35:34suggest that the monetary plumbing is getting really
- 35:38messed up and that things are quite tight and that they're
- 35:41already starting to loosen. And I'm, I was surprised, we
- 35:44were surprised by this morning CPI report.
- 35:46We thought they'd have it rigged to come in low and it didn't it
- 35:49kind of came in slightly hot and that's not going to help them.
- 35:53But we think we think that they they don't want to pivot because
- 35:57Powell doesn't want to be Arthur Burns.
- 35:59But we think they're actually being forced to pivot because of
- 36:03the the US federal government interest expense and how much of
- 36:06the budget it's chewing up. If they don't get those short
- 36:09term rates down out of that 5% range, you know they're they're
- 36:13going to, they're going to run into a complete, you know, bond
- 36:15market disaster. And so our view is that they
- 36:19will declare whether they have it or not, they're going to
- 36:22declare victory on inflation and start you know unwinding QT and
- 36:27or dropping interest rates even though they say they're not.
- 36:32You know, they also said they weren't going to, they weren't
- 36:34even thinking about, thinking about raising and they said
- 36:36inflation was transitory. And you know, they're they
- 36:39consistently lie and are wrong. And you know at the end of the
- 36:42day, their number one mandate is keeping the system functioning.
- 36:46And it seems to us that there are a lot of clues that suggest
- 36:49that the system is close to not functioning and and by the way,
- 36:53gold and Bitcoin smell it, right.
- 36:55I mean that's why Bitcoin was up 150 last year.
- 36:58Gold was up 13 or 14% last year. I mean you know in in a in a
- 37:02very negative real interest rate environment, you know I mean I'm
- 37:07sorry in a in a in a positive real interest rate environment
- 37:10or close to positive real interest rate environment where
- 37:12they've really raised aggressively.
- 37:14You know these two monetary, sound monetary assets have done
- 37:17pretty well. And we we think that's only set
- 37:20to continue and it's you know to us it's a matter of when not if
- 37:24and and we think the win is probably sometime in this year
- 37:262024. I ran the left side of the bell
- 37:30curve analysis last week and in but at the end of 2008 the ratio
- 37:37of national debt and two money stock was 1.29 and today it's
- 37:401.63. So we've expanded the debt way
- 37:44more than we have the monetary base.
- 37:46And as Parker Lewis likes to say, there's too much debt and
- 37:49not enough dollars. So you just think again left
- 37:51side of the bell curve looking at that ratio, they're going to
- 37:54have to revert back to the mean by expanding the monetary base?
- 37:57Yeah, this is this is Lynn's famous chart.
- 37:59That's just you've got to have the monetary base go up in in
- 38:02concert with the debt or else the whole thing blows up.
- 38:05You know, so it's it's it's coming and you know that's
- 38:10that's enormous, that's a macro event that's enormously positive
- 38:14for sound money assets, just enormously positive.
- 38:17And but they've held, they've held it off.
- 38:19I mean, I and I give them credit.
- 38:20I thought it was all over with Silicon Valley Bank and they
- 38:24they managed to stuff that one back in the can.
- 38:27But if and when a crisis hits and they have to unleash the
- 38:32monetary spigot that will ensure that Fed will be Arthur Burns in
- 38:37in this. Oh, absolutely.
- 38:38There's no question. That's where that's where
- 38:40they're headed. Although, you know, there are
- 38:43some, I mean gunlock and others who say we could get some low
- 38:46inflation prints. I mean, David has done the
- 38:48research and pointed out that, you know, some of the housing
- 38:51stuff has come in a lot. I mean, the food was a problem
- 38:54in today's report, but the housing and other things have
- 38:56have come gotten a lot softer. And honestly, I mean, the
- 39:00difficulty in navigating all of this is we're dealing with
- 39:03numbers that are, you know, they're cooked.
- 39:05I mean that are, you know, we're dealing.
- 39:07I mean they they lie about all this shit.
- 39:08So it's fuzzy at Beth, right? You know, housing is 38% of the
- 39:15housing and rent owner's equivalent rent is just like 38%
- 39:18of the CPI. And just looking at kind of
- 39:22where those numbers are trending here over the next few years,
- 39:25few months because of the lag effects like we're definitely
- 39:28good despite today's surprise of CPI.
- 39:31The number is going to keep working its way down it it most
- 39:35most highly probable that it will play out that way.
- 39:37And so you know but you know I I think that we're talking about
- 39:41as more just that bigger issue. I mean like I I think probably
- 39:45the there's there's some black Swans out there that no one in
- 39:49the world even none of us are even thinking about that could
- 39:51pop up. But I think the biggest thing
- 39:54that I'm hearing that, you know, a lot of major Wall Street banks
- 39:57worry about is when does one of these auction, treasury auction
- 40:02things really go afoul And and and then suddenly you get what
- 40:06we witnessed kind of early fall this year with the 10 year
- 40:09moving toward 5%. When do you see that happening
- 40:12throughout the curve, even in the T-bills, and suddenly now
- 40:15people start losing real faith in the bond market again?
- 40:20That's why I think the CTF is a big deal because I think then
- 40:22it's going to be really easy for the RIA to say maybe you should
- 40:26go buy some of that Bitcoin ETF Mr. Jones and and and and with
- 40:31with 2% of your bonds and and we'll see just an easy flow out
- 40:35that that's probably when the treasury will be mad as hell
- 40:38that Gensler allowed these on ramps to happen so easily so.
- 40:41Hey, Larry. And you mentioned cooking the
- 40:43numbers. The one of the stats that rung
- 40:46out to me I saw earlier in the week was from Peter St.
- 40:48Ong about why are GDP like we keep being confounded about?
- 40:52Like what? What's happening?
- 40:53Why are the numbers what they are.
- 40:55It doesn't make sense and like anecdotal references.
- 40:58And he tweeted GDP and jobs to find slow down predictions.
- 41:01Question mark because most new jobs 56% last year were
- 41:04disguised as government spending in in New York and Chicago or
- 41:08Illinois. It was 113% in Illinois and 50
- 41:12or 121% in New York. So all the economies shrinking,
- 41:17you know, government spending, government expenditures.
- 41:19And so when I heard that early in the week, it was a little,
- 41:22it's kind of scary in the sense of like you're at this like tail
- 41:25end of this cycle where the government is basically taking
- 41:28up over 100% of jobs in these two states.
- 41:31And how many are below that right on that cusp.
- 41:33But you just threw out those two numbers.
- 41:35Yeah. And the government has never
- 41:36been a bigger percentage of the economy except World War 2 where
- 41:39it was a huge percent. But and that's that'll be in our
- 41:41quarterly report as well which we're in the process of
- 41:43finishing up. But you know one of the things
- 41:46that we found interesting and people wonder what the biggest
- 41:48surprise to us last year was the stock market held together and
- 41:51the GDP held together kind of grew at I don't know call it A2,
- 41:547% rate annualized. And and the thing that we found
- 41:59a chart that we put in our report that we thought was very
- 42:01interesting which shows that you know in COVID the the spending
- 42:04kind of took a real quantum jump up.
- 42:06You know government spending was in the mid fours and went to 6
- 42:10plus and seven actually in one year a trillion dollars.
- 42:13We're talking about U.S. Federal government spending
- 42:15crisis has passed by a couple of years and yet we've only come
- 42:18down from that peak of 7 to 6.1. So you know, what's really
- 42:23keeping the economy going is, you know, bionomics and this
- 42:27inflation control plan and all these, you know, all these
- 42:29government programs that they're out there spending on and money
- 42:33they're sending around everywhere.
- 42:35And so and of course they're doing it all with that.
- 42:39You know, they don't have that money.
- 42:40They're just, you know we're borrowing it.
- 42:41So you know we've kind of got a a fake economy and and fake GDP
- 42:46numbers based on you know, the the borrowing and you know it
- 42:51it's, I mean something's got to give, right.
- 42:53Either they've, they've got to stop borrowing so much and try
- 42:56and close that deficit or you know or or worse things will
- 43:00happen in terms of you know, people will lose faith in the
- 43:04currency. I mean the the way to, to go
- 43:06back to the inflation point, you know, the dollar has been very
- 43:09weak and understandably so because of, you know, this tilt
- 43:12toward easing. And I think that's going to
- 43:13continue. And where I think it all becomes
- 43:15relevant is eventually the dollar will weaken enough that
- 43:18the dollar price of oil will go back up again.
- 43:21You know, it'll be kind of hanging around in this 80 range,
- 43:237080 range. And when that starts to happen
- 43:26that that'll be the beginning of the Next up wave in inflation.
- 43:29But that might be, you know, three months, six months, nine
- 43:32months from now, who knows. And the other, the final point
- 43:35would be that it's an election year and I saw somebody tweet
- 43:39out, I don't know how accurate it was.
- 43:40It could be wrong. But there was actually
- 43:42discussion going on in Washington DC about some kind of
- 43:46a tax break this year in an election year to try and grease
- 43:49the skids for the like, which which it would just be shocking
- 43:51to me. I mean they they absolutely,
- 43:54positively need to get more fiscally responsible and yet you
- 43:57see almost nothing in that direction.
- 44:00And of course they kicked the can on the on the whole debt
- 44:03ceiling. You know, it doesn't have to get
- 44:04addressed now until January of 2025.
- 44:06S you know, they can kind of do whatever they want between now
- 44:09and then. And my my sense is they will.
- 44:12And that's why I think a deficit this year of 2 trillion, that's
- 44:15the low end of the range. I think it could easily be
- 44:18222426, maybe even three who knows.
- 44:21But you know in an in an election year, they're going to
- 44:24pull out all the stops, right? And if we keep the pace?
- 44:28Of Q 4/20/23, it could hit 38 trillion by 2020.
- 44:33Well that's that's exactly right.
- 44:34That's that's another thing we discovered and I wish somebody,
- 44:37maybe somebody smarter than we are in terms of government
- 44:39accounting, there might be some inter government accounts but
- 44:42you know they had a deficit last year of 1.7 trillion.
- 44:47But if you look at the debt at the beginning of the year and
- 44:49you look at the debt at the end of the year, you know the
- 44:51difference is more like 2.5. So there's, you know, there's
- 44:55something like 678 trillion, $800 billion.
- 44:58It's not, I mean the debts going up, the deficits, either the
- 45:02deficit's under reported or there's some kind of funny
- 45:04accounting going on. But yeah, I mean and if you look
- 45:07at the the OMB reports, I mean they were saying maybe we'd get
- 45:10to 3840 trillion dollars in 2027 or something.
- 45:13Well, hell no. We're going to, as you point
- 45:15out, Marty, we're going to be there next year.
- 45:16We're going to be at the end of next year.
- 45:18We'll be at 38 probably and all of this stuff manifests.
- 45:21Manifests itself in the real world like you're amiss to not
- 45:26talk about like the degradation of like products and services in
- 45:29society. We talk a lot about it here and
- 45:31other individuals. But you can see material effects
- 45:34of like products and services being delivered and the the most
- 45:36recent. It's not funny but it it kind of
- 45:38isn't like complex systems. This was it.
- 45:40Delta the airplane like the. They're blowing up.
- 45:47Yeah, they're they're, they're falling apart, right.
- 45:49Yeah, exactly. And.
- 45:51I think another. Landmine from the macro backdrop
- 45:55that we haven't discussed yet, it's just the geopolitical
- 45:57situation in the world, what's going on in the Red Sea right
- 45:59now. A lot of the BRICS countries
- 46:03becoming emboldened and sort of banding together, not being
- 46:09happy with US foreign policy. You have the Red Sea coalition,
- 46:13which is a Western LED coalition in the Red Sea that has no
- 46:17allies that are actually in countries that border the Red
- 46:20Sea and I think the only one that's involved may be Oman.
- 46:24I could be wrong, but we're we're really expanding, trying
- 46:30to expand our influence and doing it pretty sloppily right
- 46:32now. And you can see that situation,
- 46:34the election year, and the geopolitical situation forming
- 46:38for a perfect storm of a shit show that could just really like
- 46:43the US and the S Oh, absolutely. Yeah.
- 46:45No. And it's.
- 46:45It's interesting. Everyone's kind of ignoring all
- 46:47that stuff, right? It all that's not even on the,
- 46:50you know, the radar screen right now for a lot of people.
- 46:52Everyone's thinking about just the election and the economy.
- 46:55And yeah, we could, we could easily have a Black Swan in some
- 46:58other country or or at a larger level.
- 47:02Interestingly, China, though, has been having a lot of
- 47:04troubles and I saw some data that shows that they're printing
- 47:06like crazy too. I mean, in fact, I think it was
- 47:08Preston who had a really good chart on Global M2 or maybe it
- 47:12was incrementum that showed that, you know, in spite of the
- 47:15Fed tightening and and the USM two actually declining at a
- 47:18global level, it really hasn't dipped all that much.
- 47:22And and this isn't uncommon, I mean all these central banks
- 47:25like one one guy will get tighter and then the other guys
- 47:27will loosen the compensate for it, right.
- 47:30And that's not uncommon. Yeah.
- 47:34And I keep coming. Back to how the the history of
- 47:39rate height cycles they you know, they they hike, they hike,
- 47:42they hike, they pause and then you know ten months after the
- 47:47the last hike they start cutting and everybody is excited that oh
- 47:51OK great we're going to we're going to see relief.
- 47:54Now markets will boom, but if they tend to start cutting
- 47:58because they know that some that the system can't take it
- 48:02anymore, you know they're cutting.
- 48:04Because things are broken and very bad and they've generally
- 48:06always gone too far. And yeah, David's got a great
- 48:09chart on this. I don't know, maybe we can pull
- 48:10it up. It shows.
- 48:13Share. Let me share my screen.
- 48:14I. Know Is this working guys?
- 48:15Can you see it this Bloomberg chart Logan's got?
- 48:19It we're still seeing it. There you go.
- 48:21Yeah. So yeah, I mean, it's exactly.
- 48:23That point Jesse just made that this is going back to 50 years,
- 48:27right? The white line is the federal
- 48:28funds rate. The red shades are recessions
- 48:32going back to 1970. Here we put in the blue line,
- 48:35the SP500 and gold as the sound money proxy here over 50 years.
- 48:39And the key thing to look at is look at the white line that
- 48:43looked from left to right going back to the 70s.
- 48:46Every time they Jack the federal funds rate, invariably there's a
- 48:51pause at the top. And so if we look at, yeah,
- 48:55good. You can just see the arrow here
- 48:57like like look at, I mean let's just stop here kind of in in 99
- 49:01two thousand, right when they raised rates in late 99, two
- 49:04thousand, then there's a pause and then the recession lag
- 49:08effect kicks in at the higher rates and the stock market
- 49:12begins to break kind of in the later phases of the pause.
- 49:14That same thing happened with Bernanke here in O4 trying to
- 49:17pop the housing bubble. He paused for a year.
- 49:21Stock market had to blow off top before then the recession kicks
- 49:25in, the stock market falls over and then they have to cut rates
- 49:30rapidly to try and you know, steady the economy and this
- 49:32levered fragile economy. And I think that even happened
- 49:36here in in 1817 and 18 with Bernay Powell takes the baton
- 49:41from Yellen as the Fed chair. He tries to, you know end some
- 49:45of this shenanigans and pauses. But then everything was breaking
- 49:49down in the repo market. We had the December of 18 stock
- 49:52market collapse and they they stop that and then obviously
- 49:55COVID happened. But look here, I mean here's
- 49:57this rapid increase of the last year and change and and here's
- 50:03our pause and yet the stock market's marching on the
- 50:07economy, ignoring all sorts of geopolitical risk.
- 50:10But you know, our view is that there's a definitely a high
- 50:13probability of maybe the soft landing thing doesn't play out
- 50:16like Yellen's been skating with the Stanley Cup on and recession
- 50:20ensues, stock market begins to collapse and then all your Luke
- 50:23Roman theory of now deficits really expand and the Fed is
- 50:28forced to kind of really not only cut rates but do a lot more
- 50:32QE. Here we go again.
- 50:34I mean that that's that macro catalyst we were talking about
- 50:37that could absolutely begin to moon shot Bitcoin rapidly at
- 50:41that point in time. But yeah, I think go ahead and
- 50:44then you get the one of those. Pauses.
- 50:46Gold did. Extremely well.
- 50:47And gold was the proxy for Bitcoin in the olden days,
- 50:51right? And and.
- 50:52You know that that would cause the repeat of the 70s, the the
- 50:58inflation spike and then and then it seems like it's it's
- 51:02coming down. Oh, turns out you got to do a
- 51:04lot of stimulus and then you have an even bigger second wave
- 51:09of inflation. No, that's exactly right.
- 51:11They're. Always behind the curve.
- 51:13And they, you know, they really, they really don't know what
- 51:15they're doing. And This is why, you know, just
- 51:17we should never have had a central bank.
- 51:19I mean they, you know, they started off, they blew a bubble,
- 51:22they financed World War One. You know, we had this, the mini
- 51:25depression of the 20 of 1920 and we had the big depression of 29.
- 51:29I mean it's just, and these guys just do it over and over again.
- 51:32I mean, I, you know, I tweeted a week ago, you know, Bernanke,
- 51:36you know, pours gasoline on his neighbor's house and then lights
- 51:39it on fire and then calls the fire department and writes a
- 51:43book and claims he's the hero with the courage to act.
- 51:45I mean, you know, what the what the fuck?
- 51:47I mean, you know, I mean these guys just they just keep doing
- 51:51it over and over and over again, which actually that was
- 51:53interesting. In the last Powell press
- 51:54conference, he said something I thought was interesting where he
- 51:56said, you know, that they were willing to start cutting before
- 51:59inflation, headline inflation got to 2% because there's a lag
- 52:03effect. And it's like the first time
- 52:04I've ever heard him, you know, talk about a lag effect.
- 52:07And then, you know, it implied that maybe he's thinking of
- 52:09trying to get ahead of this curve knowing what's coming.
- 52:12But we'll see. It's he does not want to be
- 52:16perceived as burns. And yet I I don't really see how
- 52:20he can avoid it. I mean the reason we're all so
- 52:23comfortable in our investment thesis over a longer time frame
- 52:26is just that the math is, is what it is And you know one
- 52:30can't continue to grow the debts in excess of the underlying
- 52:32money supply without having eventually you hit a hard wall.
- 52:37And so as a result we know with you know as as Foss used to say
- 52:41or says you know it's you know, Fiat debasement, it's 100%
- 52:45certainty, it's just how much and what time frame.
- 52:49So it's coming and you know, the good news is, you know we'll
- 52:54have $1,000,000 Bitcoin. You know, the bad news is we
- 52:57might also have $70.00 gasoline. We'll have to see.
- 53:01Larry, how do you perceive? Or how do you, how does your
- 53:04guys network perceive what's happening?
- 53:06You know, we know some friends mutually that introduced us and
- 53:09you guys made it through and you know, I think being recognizing
- 53:13gold value early helped with that.
- 53:15But just curious, kind of like the scene up in Boston, the
- 53:18Northeast, you guys been around the the yeah.
- 53:22It's you. Know it's kind of.
- 53:24Amazing how well Fiat has treated so many people.
- 53:27I mean David's got a brother who has a very Fiat job, very high
- 53:31high level position and you know it Fiat's been really good to a
- 53:36lot of people And so they don't really want to recognize or or
- 53:40you know, that they might be wrong or that they might be on
- 53:44the wrong side of this trade it it kind of threatens their
- 53:47worldview. We do have one SMA client who
- 53:50was a Fiat guy I used to work with in the venture business and
- 53:52they went off and he did extremely well and he's he's
- 53:55probably worth half a billion dollars and he gets it.
- 53:57He he completely gets it. But I would say he's the
- 54:01exception, not the rule. I think the rule, you know, in
- 54:04the neighborhoods that David and I live with, the people our kids
- 54:06played sports with, etcetera, is that, you know, what are you
- 54:10guys talking about? You know, everything's great.
- 54:13You know, we're rich. We just bought a new Land Rover.
- 54:15You know, we make a ton of money but it's it's all going to
- 54:19change. You know it's the first shall be
- 54:22last is is what I think and can't happen soon enough from my
- 54:26point of view. It's been a it's been a long
- 54:29time coming. I mean, as you guys all know
- 54:32I've been fighting this battle long before Bitcoin existed.
- 54:35So which gives me the perspective to know that we are
- 54:39right and to also understand that there are times when it's a
- 54:42shitty battle to be fighting. You know, And you know, I've
- 54:46been pleasantly surprised with the Bitcoin price this year.
- 54:48And you know, we have Bitcoin in the fund.
- 54:50We have Bitcoin companies in the fund.
- 54:52I I'm personally half my half my personal assets are in Bitcoin,
- 54:55but the other half are in gold and silver.
- 54:57And I must admit, the gold and silverside is driving me nuts.
- 55:00You know it's like come on guys, let's let's get going here.
- 55:04And and Dave and I were, Dave and I were discussing this
- 55:06yesterday. I mean there's no doubt that
- 55:07Bitcoin is taking some of the shine away from gold and silver.
- 55:10I mean, gold and silver market's about $13 trillion, but really
- 55:14only probably 3 or 4 trillion of that is tradable cause a lot of
- 55:17it's on, you know, women's necks and jewelry in India and China
- 55:20and maybe 25% of it's in central banks.
- 55:23That's not, you know, they're adding, but they're not.
- 55:25They're not selling, but they're that's not up for sale in any
- 55:28given day. So let's call it $4 trillion on
- 55:32any given day of tradeable gold coins and bullion in the world.
- 55:36You know, absent the paper and you know, at the margin,
- 55:40bitcoin's a trillion dollars of the total market cap.
- 55:43And you know, they're young people, They're not buying any
- 55:46gold. They're buying Bitcoin instead.
- 55:47So while I think they will both appreciate, you know as you guys
- 55:51have heard me say there's no doubt Bitcoin's the much faster
- 55:53horse and I think I think gold will eventually you know become
- 55:58much less important in the entire sound money trade.
- 56:00But I also think that with the central banks doing what they're
- 56:03doing and they're buying and and the and the potential for a
- 56:06reset occurring which I think is reasonably high that the those
- 56:10people will probably try to reset the gold before they try
- 56:13to reset the Bitcoin. Did you know one of the most?
- 56:16Exciting points of all this. We touched on it a little bit is
- 56:19Wall Street's going to get a nice surprise in that they may
- 56:22think they get their bearings of the next couple and and
- 56:25everybody globally the next, let's call it 90 days.
- 56:28Jesse's version of the Super Bowl is, you know, set to
- 56:31happen, I think right now, like April 16th or whatever.
- 56:33And. You're just going to get.
- 56:35Smacked in the face with this supply shock and the flexibility
- 56:39is going to come from that. I don't think they're prepared
- 56:41for. Yeah, I think that's.
- 56:44Super Bowl Yeah, Imagine what? Happens if.
- 56:46We wake up one day and Bitcoin's $300,000, I mean, you know, the
- 56:50think of the FOMO that's, you know, that's going to exist.
- 56:53And I mean, you know, now, now you're a wealthy human being
- 56:56anywhere in the world and somebody says, you know, where
- 56:59are you on Bitcoin? I mean, you got to seriously
- 57:01start to think about it, right? I I joke around that when.
- 57:04That happens. We it's obviously ties in our
- 57:06product and thesis, but I think people throw their keys out of
- 57:09the window, they become so nuclear, they're like, Oh my
- 57:12God, get this amount of capital out of anything that I can
- 57:15actually touch. I don't think we're prepared for
- 57:17it. When that price gets to where it
- 57:19is, the amount of like it's going to be a very different
- 57:22world, 300 KBTC. When you say throw the keys out,
- 57:25what do? You what do you mean in other
- 57:26words, they're going to be just a ton of buyers coming into it
- 57:29or no, I mean like right now we. Sit on, I would say fairly
- 57:32confident in our custody situation.
- 57:34We feel good. Like wherever it is solid, when
- 57:37that price hits 90 K will be one thing but $300,000 I don't think
- 57:41our brains when he thinks about like like in my personal setup
- 57:45or thinking about I was talking yesterday, I had a lot of
- 57:47conversations was about even if I lost it all right now I feel
- 57:52like I can make it back like I can make the money back.
- 57:55Would you imagine like a 10X from here and you lose all of
- 57:58that? You're like, I can't ever make
- 58:00this back like this is there's no coming back from, you know,
- 58:02and that reality of like, well, what do you do with the asset?
- 58:05It's just a different, like, calculus on how you protect
- 58:07something versus how we think about it today.
- 58:09I don't think it's actually just like priced into anybody, let
- 58:12alone people that have been looking at the asset for 10
- 58:14years, let alone the future buyers.
- 58:16It's just a different world. It's the gravity will completely
- 58:19change AT300K, basically. Yeah, I mean, it's hard to.
- 58:21It's you. Know thinking about how far it
- 58:24can go. I mean and I I love sailors
- 58:26coming you know it's going up forever Laura and I think he's
- 58:28right but I mean to me I can see a couple 100,000 that that's
- 58:32clearly you know within my I mean that's like to me that's
- 58:35falling off a log we get there in whatever time frame but we'll
- 58:37get there and I can actually see a million after that.
- 58:40I I just don't know I mean I you know I've seen 50 million a coin
- 58:45and Carlos sorry I said that I've seen 10/20 you know who
- 58:47knows it's it's nuts right you just you don't really know.
- 58:52Well, I was going to say what one one data.
- 58:55Point we've looked at historically is in the late
- 58:571970s, call it 7980 after that whole inflationary and chaotic
- 59:03period of the 70s, you know you had global sound money assets,
- 59:08gold and silver at that time. If we just isolated those two,
- 59:12it basically got to high single digits as a percentage of global
- 59:15financial assets. And so if you take gold, silver
- 59:19and Bitcoin today and say, OK, what percentage of global
- 59:22financial assets are those? We're we're under 1%.
- 59:26And and so again, in the world in the 1970s, you only had 35%
- 59:32debt to GDP. You didn't have 125% like you do
- 59:35today that this this is a much more fragile system that now
- 59:39than it was then. And so, you know, when we do the
- 59:42math on that and say, OK, well, what if you just went back to 8%
- 59:46of global financial assets on Bitcoin, gold and silver?
- 59:50You know, the it's pretty easy to get the prices like 405
- 59:53hundred thousand a coin and Bitcoin and having gold and
- 59:57silver go a hell of a lot higher as well.
- 1:00:00But that's where that math's pretty easy to see if if over
- 1:00:04the next five years. I think the one thing that
- 1:00:05people have to remember is. I think we, we live in a
- 1:00:08microwave world where we're used to having our food in 15
- 1:00:11seconds. And I think people think, well,
- 1:00:13OK, Bitcoin will be at 400,000 by December of this year.
- 1:00:16But these things take time. And you know, Michael, you're
- 1:00:20asking about the Boston crowd and and I'd say, you know what I
- 1:00:23would say that the soccer mom, soccer dad test that I see is
- 1:00:27everyone's in this Fiat world. Like Larry's saying, like hey,
- 1:00:30the stock market works. These, these 12 central bankers
- 1:00:32seem to have the market. What what's the Fed going to do
- 1:00:35to save us this time And it and it scares the hell out of all of
- 1:00:39us because we know we've studied this in financial history enough
- 1:00:42to know like God, this is this is not going to end well.
- 1:00:46But I think what happens is Jeremy Grantham, a great value
- 1:00:49investor up here in Boston has pointed out that commodities are
- 1:00:53where the great fortunes are made.
- 1:00:54And and Bitcoin is a commodity and it's the scarcest commodity
- 1:00:59in the world. And if if you knew and if you
- 1:01:02just have an 8 year patient low time preference horizon, you
- 1:01:06you'll make fortunes here. Given this backdrop of where we
- 1:01:10are as a percentage of global financial assets, these inflows
- 1:01:12that are coming, how commodities work, what the global central
- 1:01:16banks are going to have to do to support the global economy, the
- 1:01:20demographic challenges with baby boomers maturing, things like
- 1:01:23that. You can't kick the can much
- 1:01:25anymore. And so like this to us seems
- 1:01:28just like the highest probability like I can't imagine
- 1:01:32on any other asset outperforming Bitcoin over the next 10 years
- 1:01:36or even maybe five years than than this asset class given the
- 1:01:40scarcity properties and and given that backdrop.
- 1:01:44So like I I think everyone to answer your question Michael is
- 1:01:47just you know too caught up in their stock market 40 year old
- 1:01:51model world of of the feds got your back and rates come down
- 1:01:55but they're they're not watching all these other trends that that
- 1:01:58we're all early on it's amazing. To me.
- 1:02:02How? How?
- 1:02:03Well, you know, the average investor has been trained to buy
- 1:02:06the dip because in 40 years of deflation, it basically has
- 1:02:10always worked. And you know, that's the
- 1:02:13advantage of being 66 and you see a bunch of cycles and it's
- 1:02:16as if bear markets have been outlawed or something.
- 1:02:19Bear markets and stocks have been outlawed, you know what I
- 1:02:22mean? And that's just not realistic.
- 1:02:24I mean, you know, you're going to have labor cost pressures,
- 1:02:28You're going to have falling margins, you're going to have
- 1:02:29falling demand and you're going to have tighter money and you're
- 1:02:32going to have and you're going to have better alternatives.
- 1:02:34I mean, I I know many wealthy people who are like why do I
- 1:02:37need to mess with the stock market?
- 1:02:38I can buy a one month treasury and get 5 percent, 5%'s a nice
- 1:02:42yield on all the money I've got. So, and by the way, I think, I
- 1:02:45think that 5%'s going to go higher and I think the tenure's
- 1:02:48going to go higher. I mean, I think the big, the
- 1:02:50other big macro thing we haven't really discussed, but you know,
- 1:02:52we feel it very strong is that we are no longer in a
- 1:02:55deflationary world. We're just not, I mean there are
- 1:02:58deflationary aspects of the world as Chuck Booth points out,
- 1:03:01the technology and so forth. But but right now we've under
- 1:03:04invested in real stuff for 40 years and real stuff is about to
- 1:03:09come back with a vengeance. And so you know that's going to,
- 1:03:13that's going to change what works in the stock market.
- 1:03:16I mean the stock market in the 70s was a bad place to be.
- 1:03:19The the bond market in the 70s was a terrible place to be.
- 1:03:22I mean, Henry Kaufman called them certificates of
- 1:03:24confiscation. And you know, we think this is
- 1:03:27the 70s on steroids. So you know, to me, the biggest
- 1:03:31decision everybody's got to make right now is, is they look at
- 1:03:34their asset allocation, you know, how much they want in
- 1:03:36stocks, how much they want in bonds and then how much they
- 1:03:39want and what we consider sound money assets.
- 1:03:41And you know, we talk to people all the time that have nothing
- 1:03:44in the sound money asset bucket and we scream at them that
- 1:03:46they're idiots. And of course, you know we've
- 1:03:48got 100% in the sound money you know, bucket and and probably
- 1:03:52we're idiots too for being for being so overweight in one
- 1:03:55category. But we believe what we believe
- 1:03:58and you know it's what's that irresponsibly long in a Business
- 1:04:07School sense we're extremely irresponsibly long.
- 1:04:10My HBS professors would would criticize me massively, but you
- 1:04:13know what I I mean, I just don't give a fuck anymore.
- 1:04:18He probably should buy some Bitcoin just in.
- 1:04:19Case it catches on, Yeah, well. David and I were at a macro
- 1:04:24conference up there. And I mean it's, you know, you
- 1:04:27want to talk about, you want to be the turd in the punch bowl.
- 1:04:29You just talk about Bitcoin or you talk about a sovereign debt
- 1:04:32crisis. I mean, you got to remember.
- 1:04:34I mean and that's what leaves these people vulnerable, by the
- 1:04:37way. You got to remember just how
- 1:04:38fat, happy and stupid all these Fiat masters are.
- 1:04:41I mean, they think they're geniuses.
- 1:04:44They just, they think they're absolute geniuses And and and to
- 1:04:46be fair, they have been, I mean, they've crushed us.
- 1:04:49I mean it's, you know, playing that game has been an extremely
- 1:04:54lucrative game to play, but history would suggest that
- 1:04:58things are changing. So that's that's.
- 1:05:02That's how we see it. They're changing.
- 1:05:05And they're changing rapidly. Right now, ETF is here, Marty
- 1:05:08says. We're gonna win.
- 1:05:09Right, Marty. Oh, we're gonna win.
- 1:05:11He's let me just look at the state.
- 1:05:14There are days you know. There there are days.
- 1:05:19They're weeks. They're months sometimes during
- 1:05:20the bear markets where where your spirits get low sometimes
- 1:05:24it doesn't always feel fun. I mean, you know, it's really
- 1:05:27nice to be at this landmark where this ETF got approved, but
- 1:05:30you know, kind of the run up to it, it was just like, oh,
- 1:05:32really? Are you not?
- 1:05:33We're gonna have to go through all this shit again.
- 1:05:36Yeah, it's behind us now. Now we're in the winning.
- 1:05:38Phase We're always winning. Dave and Larry, it's.
- 1:05:44Been a pleasure. I wish we had more than an hour
- 1:05:47to talk, but likewise. It was great to have you 2 on
- 1:05:51today. Momentous day whether you think
- 1:05:55getting Bitcoin exposure be the ETF is right or wrong, there's
- 1:05:58nothing you can do about it. It's in the world now.
- 1:06:00People are going to buy it and it seems like there's a lot of
- 1:06:03people buying it right now. Or probably it's a good thing
- 1:06:05there's there's no. Way it's there's no way it's
- 1:06:07anything but a good thing it it does open the the door to
- 1:06:09possible games but I I think it'll be harder to game this
- 1:06:13than it is was to game gold and so I think that's a good thing.
- 1:06:18Awesome. Great.
- 1:06:20Thanks. Jenny Thing.
- 1:06:23Thanks guys. Good to be here.
- 1:06:25Yeah, fantastic. Dave and Larry, thanks for for
- 1:06:28joining us. Let's do this again when the
- 1:06:30when the crisis really hits. Yes.
- 1:06:33Yeah. That'll that'll happen and some
- 1:06:36rivets going to pop and it's going to be you know March of
- 1:06:392020 or 2019 all over again. You you know it's coming.
- 1:06:42We just don't know when we'll talk about whatever acronym.
- 1:06:45They come up with to plug the hole.
- 1:06:47Yeah, I'm sure they've got a few figured.
- 1:06:49Out. Yeah, BTFP 2.
- 1:06:51Yeah, exactly. Thanks guys.
- 1:06:52People see. You all thanks guys.
- 1:06:54All right. See you guys next week.