Latest / Manager Mondays with Fexingo: People Management, Team Leadership, and First-Time Managers / How to Manage an Employee Who Won't Take Ownership
Transcript
- Lucas: So you've got a direct report who does good work — when you tell them exactly what to do. But the moment you say 'use your judgment,' they freeze. Or they come back with twenty questions about a decision they could have made themselves. Luna: Right — the 'I just wanted to check with you' employee. It's exhausting because you end up doing their thinking for them. Lucas: Exactly. And the irony is, if you're a first-time manager especially, you might actually encourage this without meaning to. You're so relieved they're asking instead of going rogue that you reward the behavior by giving them the answer. Luna: So how do you break the cycle? Because just saying 'take more ownership' rarely works — they nod and then they're back in your office the next day. Lucas: You need a structure. The one I've seen work best is what I call the Three Options Rule. It's simple: any time an employee brings you a problem, they have to also bring at least three possible solutions. Luna: Three? That seems like a lot. What if they genuinely don't know? Lucas: That's the pushback you get at first. But here's the thing — the rule isn't about having three perfect answers. It's about forcing them to engage with the problem. Even if all three options are bad, they've started thinking in terms of trade-offs. Luna: So you're training the muscle, not evaluating the output. Lucas: Exactly. I saw this in practice with a marketing coordinator named Priya. She was brilliant — great at executing — but every single campaign decision came to her manager. 'Should I use blue or green on this banner?' 'Should we send the email Tuesday or Thursday?' Her manager was spending two hours a day answering questions Priya could have answered herself. Luna: And what happened when the manager introduced the Three Options Rule? Lucas: First week was rough. Priya would show up with options like 'Option A: blue. Option B: green. Option C: maybe purple?' And the manager would have to say 'Okay, which one do you recommend and why?' That forced Priya to actually evaluate. Within a month, she was only coming to her manager when there was a real strategic question — like a budget trade-off or a brand risk. Luna: So the rule shifts the dynamic from approval-seeking to recommendation-making. The employee doesn't just present the problem — they present a point of view. Lucas: Exactly. And the manager's job becomes 'yes, go with that' or 'here's a constraint you didn't consider' — instead of 'here's the answer you should have figured out.' It saves time and builds confidence. Luna: But what about the employee who says 'I don't know, that's why I'm asking you'? I had a manager who used to say 'if you don't know, go find out and come back.' It felt harsh. Lucas: It can feel harsh, especially if the person is junior or new to the role. So you have to scaffold it. You can say 'I get that you're unsure. For this week, let me give you a framework: here are three lenses to think about — cost, time, and quality. Come back tomorrow with one option that optimizes for each.' Then next time, they do it themselves. Luna: So you're teaching them how to think, not just what to decide. Lucas: Right. And there's a subtler layer here. Sometimes the lack of ownership isn't about skill or confidence — it's about fear. If the last time they made a decision on their own, they got criticized for it, they learned 'check with the boss or get burned.' Luna: Psychological safety. If your team doesn't feel safe being wrong, they'll never take ownership. Lucas: Exactly. I once worked with a senior engineer who had been a top performer for years, then after a re-org, he became incredibly passive. Kept asking his new manager for approval on routine code commits. Turned out his previous manager had publicly blamed him for a production bug — even though the decision to push was a team call. Luna: So he learned that ownership was punished. The manager had to rebuild trust. Lucas: Yeah. And that took explicit conversations — 'I want you to own this. If it breaks, we'll fix it together. I'm not looking to blame, I'm looking to learn.' Then gradually, he started making calls again. Luna: So the Three Options Rule works, but only if the environment actually rewards the effort of thinking. Lucas: Right. If you shoot down every option they bring, they'll stop bringing options. So when an employee brings you three options, even if they're not great, you have to find something to affirm. 'I like how you thought about the timing. Let's tweak the approach.' Luna: What about the employee who brings three good options but still wants you to pick? 'All three work, which one should we do?' Lucas: That's a sign they're still looking for cover. You say 'You've done the analysis — I trust your judgment. Go with the one you think is best and tell me what you learned after.' That last part is key — they get feedback from the outcome, not from you. Luna: So you're shifting accountability to the result, not the approval. Lucas: Exactly. And over time, the employee starts owning the whole process. That's when you know you've succeeded — when they stop asking 'what should I do?' and start saying 'here's what I did and here's why.' Luna: That's a great marker. Let's talk about the flip side — what about the employee who takes too much ownership? The one who goes rogue and makes decisions without consulting anyone? Lucas: Ha — the grass is always greener, right? But seriously, that's a different problem. With that person, you need guardrails, not empowerment. You say 'I love your initiative. From now on, any decision over $5,000 or any change to client-facing messaging needs a quick sign-off.' It's about scope. Luna: So ownership isn't binary — it's about appropriate scope. Lucas: Exactly. And you calibrate it per person. A junior associate might own the research, a senior analyst owns the recommendation, and a director owns the strategy. You match the level of ownership to their experience and the risk involved. Luna: So if you're a manager listening, what's the one thing you do tomorrow? Lucas: I'd pick the one decision that comes to you most often — the one you're tired of making — and next time, when the employee asks, say 'I'd like you to come back with three options and your recommendation. Let's talk tomorrow.' Then follow through. Luna: And if they come back with nothing? Lucas: Then you have a coaching conversation about why they're stuck. Maybe they need more information, more authority, or more confidence. But you don't give them the answer. You help them find it. Luna: I think that's the hardest part for new managers — sitting with the silence and not jumping in. Lucas: It is. But that silence is where their ownership starts. Luna: Hey, quick thing — if today's episode gave you a practical takeaway you can use this week, that's exactly what we're here for. And the reason we can keep these episodes ad-free and focused on real tools is listener support. Lucas: Yeah. If you've ever gotten value from something we've shared — whether it's a framework like this or a past episode on delegation — consider tossing a coffee our way at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It's a small gesture that keeps us going. Luna: Totally. And it really does help us keep doing this. So thanks for being part of it. Lucas: Alright, back to it. One more thing I want to touch on — what do you do when the employee is very senior and still won't take ownership? I'm thinking of a head of product I worked with who had been a director for years but constantly escalated to the VP. Luna: That's a different dynamic — they have the experience but not the willingness. Is it a trust issue or a power issue? Lucas: In that case, it was both. The VP was a micromanager, and the director had learned that any decision could be overruled, so why bother? The fix was for the VP to publicly delegate and then back off — 'This is yours. I won't override unless it affects company strategy.' And then actually not override. Luna: So the manager has to model the behavior they want to see. If you want ownership, you have to give up control. Lucas: Exactly. And that's scary for a lot of managers. But the alternative is you stay in the weeds forever. Luna: So to wrap — the Three Options Rule, scaffold for juniors, trust rebuild for the burned, and calibrate scope for seniors. Lucas: That's the playbook. Next episode, I want to talk about something that came up in the comments — how to manage a team member who always says 'I told you so' when things go wrong. Luna: Oh, that's a fun one. See you next Monday.