Latest / Automotive State of The Union / New Normal Revenue, Steve Greenfield’s Elon Musk Hot Takes
Transcript
- 0:00[upbeat music] Good morning. It is Monday, June 17th. We have Steve Greenfield in the studio today.
- 0:06Tomor- We're talking about the new normal for revenue, uh, the oldest EV maybe 30 years ago, and Steve Greenfield's biggest admirer we're gonna bring in. Not on the show- [laughs]...
- 0:16but we're gonna talk about it [laughs] a little bit. Oh, wow. Okay. Yeah. There you go. Yeah. I think- You're gonna surprise me, huh? Y- well, you won't be surprised. [laughs] Okay. Uh, Steve, welcome to the show today.
- 0:27It's good to see you, Paul. Happy Monday. Oh, happy Monday indeed. Um, we have a lot going on this year. We do have, uh, just so everybody knows, some new episodes dropping.
- 0:36We've been doing this regularly since ASOTU CON. We have a lot of content that is, uh, gonna be released on the drip.
- 0:41We have a new Auto Collabs episode, uh, today, Compliance Is the Green Lantern of the Auto Industry, with Cheryl Nenns.
- 0:47She made this great illustration of compliance being like the Green Lantern superhero that everyone's like, "What? What is that actually, he's actually for? What do they do?" And she had some great stories in there.
- 0:57Uh, you can get that podcast by just searching Auto Collabs or going to ASOTU.com. And is that Ryan Reynolds' version of Green Lantern or...? Yeah. [laughs] That's really funny. [laughs] Yeah. [laughs] No, no, no, no.
- 1:08Uh, Ry- you know, Ryan Reynolds' version of Green- I've never even watched that. See, I think that's her point. Oh, really? That's like the worst movie of all, of all times. See, maybe. [laughs] Oh, is it? Good to know.
- 1:16If you wanna c- if you wanna c- if you wanna cringe, I think it's his biggest regret, in- Oh [laughs]... his life, is doing that movie. [laughs] That's great. Yeah, it's really bad. Really bad. Oh, man. Yeah. Okay.
- 1:25Well, I'll be sure to skip that one. [laughs] Um, also we are dropping, uh, two ASOTU CON Session podcasts a day. These were recorded live to a live audience at ASOTU CON. They're so much fun.
- 1:35They're only 15 to 20 minutes. And, um, these are some of my favorite, and Kyle's as well, because we didn't get to do the interviews, right? So a lot of guest hosts on here.
- 1:44Uh, we have Joe Overby as a guest host, Glen Lundy, Kyle and I, Michael Cirillo, um, Elaine Chicate- Elena Chikatelli. So we have a lot of variety in there, and they're very...
- 1:53These are great, like, walking the dog, drive, driving to work. Play 'em on 1.5 speed. They're done in, like, nine minutes, and you get a big variety. So, a lot of podcast content coming out right now.
- 2:03And if you go to asotu.com, there's a little Podcast tab at the top right. That's the best way to, like, see everything that's going on, and there's, like, a little something, uh, for everybody.
- 2:11But, uh, we have a quick-shot show. We have 12 minutes to get through three stories. And, uh, this is gonna be a lot of fun, Steve. So I'm gonna read the story, and then you know the drill.
- 2:20Uh, we're gonna get your take, um, on what's going- All right... on. So, uh, this is a one of, one part, one of five that Automotive News is doing a series on, uh, this just kind of, like, broad picture.
- 2:30Very good journalism here.
- 2:32But basically, this first piece is the booming revenue period during the pandemic is fading, everybody knows that, leaving dealerships to adapt to, quote, "new normal" in the article it says, which might look a lot like the old normal, which is, uh, marked by high interest rates and rising inventories.
- 2:46They went on to go down and name, uh, five different, uh, organizations. Some are dealer groups. Some are, uh, like CarMax, Carvana. And basically, this is some of the things that they're doing.
- 2:56So I'll read through them and then, uh, Steve, you just give us your commentary on what you think bubbles to the top, what you're seeing. So first one is Asbury Auto, uh, acquired by Lar- they acquired Larry H.
- 3:06Miller and Jim Coons, uh, integrating a lot of new F&I products across their stores to boost revenue.
- 3:12Asbury generated 14.8 billion in revenue in 2023 and expects to complete a full integration of those two large groups by the end of the year.
- 3:20AutoNation is focused on diversifying operations, um, with acquisitions like RepairSmith, uh, you know, repair on-demand or on-site. Expanding also their e-commerce parts business.
- 3:31They launched autonationparts.com and remain selective with their mergers and acquisitions. Uh, CarMax, they've extended their goal to sell two million vehicles.
- 3:39They pushed that out to 2030, so they're being a little more realistic. They've opened five new stores. Uh, they also reported a 5.2% drop in vehicle sales and six... or retail sales, and 6.6 decline in wholesale sales.
- 3:54Carvana, uh, have been a little bit of a rollercoaster over the last 12 months.
- 3:57They reported a net profit with a 17% increase in revenue, and they've been focusing on leveraging their ADESA auction sites for growth, turning 'em into reconditioning facilities, um, so, and inspection facilities.
- 4:10Last one, Group One, uh, continued acquiring lots of high-revenue stores and expanding internationally while, uh, divesting of their underperforming dealerships.
- 4:20So, um, they expect to finalize the purchase of, uh, Lynch Scapes UK retail operations in the third quarter of 2024. So a lot of deal- like, big notable groups doing, taking different approaches.
- 4:32What do you make of this? Well, and, and Lithia two weeks ago announcing that they're gonna buy back shares because stores are over, over price. Yeah.
- 4:40So, I mean, the biggest natural acquirer of stores over the last few years is now saying, "Rather than buy stores at this price, we're gonna buy back shares and s- support our, our share price that way."
- 4:50So yeah, interesting. I mean, the one, the one thing that really resonates re- me th- through, through all of that, uh, Paul, is the shortage of used vehicles, right?
- 4:58So not only did we have this shortage of new cars two or three years ago, which is coming through the pipe now and, and affecting folks like CarMax. If they could acquire more cars, they would.
- 5:08You know, Carvana's gonna have a shortage of these nice low-mileage two to three-year-old vehicles as well. But the, the double whammy really is that a lot of those consumers that paid above MSRP- Mm-hmm...
- 5:18now their cars on regular depreciation schedules are coming back into the market, we're hearing from dealers, and they're way, way underwater. Like, so much so that they're shocked and angry.
- 5:28They don't know who to be angry at. Mm-hmm.
- 5:30And they've, they've got [audio glitches] off a purchase of a vehicle because it's so much negative equity, that it's really, really hard for dealers to roll that into the next purchase.
- 5:37So I think every single dealer, all, all, all the groups that you mentioned, are gonna be feeling this pressure of the shortage of used vehicles, which is gonna keep prices high- Mm-hmm... um, for some time.
- 5:48But, you know, to, to get those really good quality low-mileage two to three-year-old vehicles just isn't gonna happen for a couple of years until we get back to, you know, where we're selling new cars now- Yeah...
- 5:59inventories have come backWe'll be okay in two to three years from now, but in the interim, I think there's gonna be a lot of pain for retailers.
- 6:06Do you see, do you see these efforts to go into, like, deeper in F&I or deepen- deeper into service products becoming the new norm? So service is a little bit of a m- mitigator.
- 6:17You look what AutoNation's done with RepairSmith. You know, w- when they made that acquisition, there was a lot of hype that we were gonna go to full EV.
- 6:24Many of the automakers were pro- proclaiming we were gonna go full EV. And, you know, the, the service intervals on EVs, as you know as well as I do, are, are, are a lot longer. Yep.
- 6:33And, you know, you, you don't need oil, regular oil changes, et cetera, for consumers to come in. So how, how are we gonna mitigate some of that? I think a lot of those potential headwinds have gone, gone away.
- 6:42But, um, ser- service is still 50%-plus of a dealer's profit, and they've gotta make sure that they capture the vehicles in operation, especially because they had fewer vehicles sold, uh, during, during COVID.
- 6:54So I think that, um, you know, there will be folks, um... Ed Roberts is a great example of really innovating- Yeah...
- 6:59around bringing service to the folks in the local community, um, via, via vans, um, mo- mobile repair, um, vans. And I think that you're gonna see a lot more innovation.
- 7:09And they're just gonna have to really make sure that the profitability makes sense vis-a-vis getting the consumer to bring the vehicle in or using a valet service to bring a vehicle into, to the service base.
- 7:21We're also seeing, I think, a lot more technology deployed or developing for service scheduling, um, fixed ops, you know, optimization.
- 7:29So it'll be interesting to see how these, these new AI technologies are also, uh, leaning into the service side of the business in, in a very similar way they're leaning into the, the, the sales side of the business.
- 7:39It feels like to me- Uh- Like there's- Yeah... a balance happening there- W- wait, wait... for the first time in a long time. Yeah.
- 7:45I, I think, I think we're starting to see a, a new wave of innovations across both variable ops and fixed ops. But fixed ops has largely been neglected.
- 7:52You know, I've talked about that compared to the amount of innovation that's occurred on, on, on, on, you know, one, getting, getting a dealer one incremental sale- Mm-hmm... whether it's a new or used vehicle.
- 8:01And I'm excited. Like, we, we've got a few companies that are doing exceptionally well that we've invested in on the fixed op side. And, uh, we're continuing to see a, a, a nice level of innovation on the fixed op side.
- 8:12Yeah. That's always good for everybody. Uh, speaking of things that are good for... well, maybe not everybody. Stop. Segway. Time. [upbeat music] But they're good for at least one person.
- 8:21[laughs] Tesla shareholders have affirmed Elon Musk's multi-billion dollar compensation package, ensuring his position, uh, a- atop the world's most, uh, you know, financially speaking or, like, s- share value speaking, most valuable automaker.
- 8:34However, Tesla is facing some legal challenges on, uh, this 2018 stock option deal, but the company's now valued at $48 billion. This was as... We talked about this a little last week.
- 8:44So basically, he's celebrated with some on-stage antics, uh, did, did- [laughs]... some quintessential kind of [laughs] Elon Musk dance, including, uh, you know...
- 8:52But he's now talking about these other things like visions of billions of humanoid robots- [laughs] Yeah... uh, a $30 trillion valuation for Tesla.
- 9:01Basically said, you know, "We can, we think we'll, we'll sell a billion of these things. It costs us, you know... We'll sell them for $20,000. They cost us $10,000 to make." This all gets everybody excited.
- 9:11Uh, the Model Y is still the top-selling vehicle in the world. Um, Ark Invest, who is very bullish on Tesla's future, they say the share price could hit $2,600 by 2029. Uh, currently, the, the price is around $180.
- 9:25And they talked a lot about the, the, you know, proposed robotaxi business, um, comprising 90% of the company's value. So we have, like, this robotaxi 90% of the value. We have humanoid robots and AI.
- 9:37Uh, one shareholder said, "Old Elon has returned." [laughs] So you had a comment on this, uh, some commentary in a, in a LinkedIn post and also in your, uh, weekly insight report, which if you don't get it, you should.
- 9:49Go to automotiveventures.com and get it. Comes out every Monday morning.
- 9:53Uh, basically, it said, "Tesla's core business is faltering and Elon Musk's hype has barreled past the boundaries of outright fantasy, damaging the custom- company's reputation and entangling it in legal battles."
- 10:05So you obviously have, uh, some thoughts and opinions on this. Give, give, uh, give us the CliffsNotes. Yeah. I mean, it's, it's hard to be reaching for the moon, or Mars in his case, when you, you...
- 10:17the, the core business is really suffering, a- and it is right now, right? I mean, we've seen, uh, month-over-month declines in Tesla volume.
- 10:23He announced, I think, as of last week or the week before that the, the, the Model Y, uh, is not getting a refresh this year. Yep.
- 10:30So, you know, the, the best-selling car i- i- in, in the world as of last year is, isn't getting the refresh that was due. And, you know, the sales will suffer, right?
- 10:38I mean, Glenn Mercer recently came out very astutely and said, "The biggest driver of, of market share increases is a, is a model refresh," not surprisingly. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.
- 10:48And all, all of the T- Tesla product is pretty long in the tooth except for the Cybertruck now. And Cybertruck sales have been a, a little bit lackluster. So, um, you know, ne- never, never bet against Elon.
- 10:57Uh, I think it was interesting for, for those that haven't listened to the actual recording, uh, of the shareholder meeting, um, it's worth listening to that, that, that bit because he says things like, you know, "We're, we're gonna need more than one of these Optimus hu- uh, robots for every human on the face of the earth.
- 11:13And, you know, if we can, can make them for $10,000 and sell them for $20,000 and we, we sell something like a billion of... a billion, a billion robots a year, a billion- [laughs]...
- 11:23then, you know, we, we, we should be able to do a trillion of profit a year."
- 11:26And to your point, you know, he, he backs into the math and says, "And if we're worth 20 to 25 times a trillion dollars in profit, then Tesla could be worth, you know, $20 to $25 trillion- [laughs]...
- 11:39just based on Optimus alone." I- Forget Ark Invest and the autonomous vehicle.
- 11:43So, I mean, the most, the, you know, the, the most pricey stock right now is in Nvidia and, and Apple at, you know, just north of $3 trillion.
- 11:50To think that Tesla's gonna be worth $20 to $25 trillion within a few years based on Optimus sales is, like, it's, it's out there. But, I mean, you can't bet against this guy. You cannot bet against this guy. Yeah.
- 12:01I mean, I think so much of it is, is managing the... Like, I've read, I read the biography this year, and it was very revealing in, like, how the inner workings, and I always wonder, like, how long can that sustain?
- 12:13'Cause if you pull Elon out of Tesla, like, there is no, there is no Tim Cook, right? Like- Right... uh, that's apparent. You know, we were talking about- Yeah... Tesla, um, you know, like, maybe partnering with dealers.
- 12:24Hague wrote this thing last week, you know, open letter to Elon Musk, and, and my perspective on that is, like s- like, not in a Steve Jobs world, which was, like, in my mind, like, the Elon Musk.
- 12:33Like, you need a Tim Cook who would come in with Tesla and understand, like, there's broader profitability that aren't so, you know, based on these dreams and aspirations.
- 12:42But that article, you posted it, and you put it at the very top. Your, your, uh, top admirer, I think, is, uh- [laughs]... revealed in this comment you put at the top of your newsletter. And, um, here, do we have it?
- 12:54We're gonna put it on the screen, and this is from Tony Lu- Tony Lai, yeah... Tony Lai, and he says, "You are an embarrassment, Steve Greenfield. Turns out you don't know much about this pay package deal.
- 13:02People are fools listening to you," which I, I think I'm the only reply to that comment. I was like, "So I listen to Steve. I guess I'm a fool," you know? [laughs] Well, thanks, Paul. You're my one supporter out there.
- 13:12[laughs] Yeah. But no, I, I, I, I respect the, the open dialogue that- Absolutely... social media, uh, sites pr- pr- present. But it's also funny.
- 13:19Once in a while, I just gotta, um, pluck out the good ones and, and post them on the newsletter. Yeah, I know. So we really appreciate that. We appreciate, uh, the work you're doing. We appreciate you.
- 13:28Thanks for coming on the show, making a little time on a busy Monday morning to give us some of your thoughts. Um, hope you have a great week. Thanks, Paul. Good seeing you. All right.
- 13:36We'll see you here bright and early tomorrow morning, everybody. Have a good Monday.
- 13:40[upbeat music]