Latest / Once Upon a Time at the Oscars / 8th Ceremony Episode
Transcript
- 0:12Hello, everyone, and welcome to Once Upon a Time
- 0:15at the Oscars. The show that takes you through
- 0:17every Best Picture nominee from 1927 to today.
- 0:19I'm Kyle. I'm Ryan. The year is 1936. There's
- 0:23a podcast I listen to about comics, and that's
- 0:25how they start. The year is 1972. Should we start
- 0:30doing that? No, because one of those guys used
- 0:34to listen to this podcast. Used to, though. Hopefully
- 0:37they still do. Okay. But we'll see. Anyway. The
- 0:40year is 1936. You don't have to say their last
- 0:42name. What's their first name? What's the name
- 0:45of the podcast? Zach. Zach. Okay. So, Zach, if
- 0:49you're listening, this is about you. Yeah. That's
- 0:52exactly who we're talking about. This is you,
- 0:53Zach. This is from you. Yeah, you. I got it from
- 0:57you. And now I'm giving it back to you. I learned
- 0:59it from you. Giving back to Zach. I learned it
- 1:01from you. Yeah. Thanks, Zach. You're right. And
- 1:06the year is 1935. But it's also our eighth year.
- 1:10Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah. The film's from 1935, but
- 1:14currently we're celebrating the ceremony of the
- 1:188th Academy Awards in 1936. There you go. Yeah,
- 1:21nailed it. So remember when we said this gets
- 1:23easier? Oh, yeah, it never does. I mean, you
- 1:26know. Next year will be 2027, and we'll be talking
- 1:29about the movies of 2026. It's just the way it
- 1:32is. It's always going to be that way. But I feel
- 1:34like between the year of the movies, the year
- 1:37that the ceremony came out, and then the number
- 1:39ceremony that it is, it's always going to be
- 1:42a little confusing. So it is the eighth year.
- 1:45It is the movies of 1935, and it was held in
- 1:471936. Also, every... season that we talk about
- 2:11these movies we also cover the ceremonies uh
- 2:13so this is our ceremony episode kind of end capping
- 2:16our coverage of the movies of 1935 absolutely
- 2:19and i'm pretty what's the word like feel weird
- 2:27about this year so not weird can i can i share
- 2:31something you you've told me off pod sure you
- 2:33i guess within reason is the correct answer what
- 2:36are we talking about here ryan remember that
- 2:38one thing you swore i wouldn't say out loud this
- 2:40isn't about the rash is it i think of something
- 2:44else think of something else um no you said uh
- 2:47man i just i i cannot wait to see a good movie
- 2:50Yeah. You may have said great, but you were just
- 2:53waiting for like a great movie. And do you think
- 2:56that sums up your thoughts on this year? Yeah.
- 2:59As we always do, a little peek behind the curtain.
- 3:02We're recording this episode as we've already
- 3:05kind of moved into the first, I don't know, six
- 3:07or seven movies of the next year. So a lot of
- 3:13these movies are kind of in my rear view mirror
- 3:16a bit. But do you think you felt that way? For
- 3:19a minute, or do you think that's a more recent
- 3:21thing? I think towards the end of the year that
- 3:23we're talking about today, I started to be like,
- 3:25eh. I need like a banger, you know? Yeah. And
- 3:30the reason for the, not the reason, but another
- 3:32thing that contributes to that, we're watching
- 3:34them in chronological order, right? We're not
- 3:36watching them from like alphabetical. So there
- 3:38is a chance that some of these just in the order
- 3:41they came out, weren't the best year. Right.
- 3:43Yeah. You get back to back, like, Oh, first we're
- 3:45watching Cimarron, then cavalcade, then Disraeli.
- 3:48And you're like, Oh God. But, uh, but yeah, I,
- 3:52so I think this will be an interesting one because
- 3:55there is quite a bit of, history and lore at
- 3:58this uh academy awards ceremony but it's also
- 4:02going to feel more like a reflection i think
- 4:05than i'm used to where i'm reminiscing about
- 4:07the days of your just because we're recording
- 4:10so far after watching the movies true so you
- 4:15guys will be like oh wow i remember when they
- 4:17talked about that and we'll be like hey i remember
- 4:21when we talked about that you know that uh gif
- 4:24of the dog that stares at the muffins or the
- 4:27cupcakes and it has like ptsd and it's like staring
- 4:30past the muffins yeah and like they put uh like
- 4:33helicopters and everything behind the dog to
- 4:35make it look like he's having like a war flashback
- 4:38yeah i wonder if that's how you're gonna feel
- 4:39about some of these movies yeah That's going
- 4:43to be a great animation for us to make of just
- 4:46you staring past cupcakes. I think it's muffins.
- 4:50That's my bet. So, you know, my thought is I
- 4:53see what you're saying in some of the movies
- 4:56that we've seen and how it just it's not that
- 4:58we've watched like, you know, oops, all Midsummer
- 5:00Night's Dream. But it has been like a year of
- 5:05variety with like different the way I feel about
- 5:08these. With that said. I think that I'm still
- 5:11in the honeymoon phase of the coverage of what
- 5:14we're doing. Sure. To where I'm like, oh, it's
- 5:16really cool to see this. And oh, that's neat.
- 5:18So I don't think there's many things that we're
- 5:19rating like two stars and below. Yeah. I think
- 5:22we're mostly around like the two and a half,
- 5:24sometimes mostly three and up, which at the end
- 5:27of the day, three and up is like, hey, it's good.
- 5:30Yeah, absolutely. So I've had a really good time
- 5:33with it, even if the movie doesn't land fully
- 5:35well for me. So hopefully that continues for
- 5:38me. And hopefully the movies that we cover here
- 5:42are going to be a little bit more exciting for
- 5:44you. Yeah, and not even exciting isn't the right
- 5:47word, but I just like the quality, right? Right.
- 5:49I've talked about this on one of our previous
- 5:51episodes or one of our upcoming episodes. I don't
- 5:54even know at this point. I do feel like where
- 5:58we are right now in the podcast and the years
- 6:01that we're covering is kind of a reflection on
- 6:04the modern era of cinema. Sure. In that we're
- 6:08very studio driven now. And that obviously was
- 6:11the case in the 30s. But I think you get a lot
- 6:15of movies that are designed as a product. And
- 6:19I'm starting to feel that comparison between
- 6:22the modern day and now, or excuse me, 1935. And
- 6:27I have that same struggle with the modern movies
- 6:29as well, where I go to see a movie and I'm like,
- 6:31yeah, it was fine. But it felt like somebody
- 6:34went to the store and picked it out of a bushel.
- 6:39And it's just a copy and paste kind of thing.
- 6:41Right. So I think it's when there's really a
- 6:44standout movie that I'm like. I get excited again
- 6:47for the show. I'm like, here it is, baby. We're
- 6:49back with another It Happened One Night. And
- 6:51I will say there are some movies that we'll be
- 6:54talking about in like a month that we've now
- 6:56watched that I'm like, okay, that's enough to
- 6:59like satiate this. And I would even say with
- 7:02this year for 1935 or the movies of 1935, there's
- 7:05a couple that for me are like all timers I'll
- 7:07remember. And we'll get into them here shortly.
- 7:09I don't mean to spoil that. But let's dive into
- 7:11what the ceremony actually was. This was held
- 7:15on March 5th, 1936 at the Biltmore Hotel. A lot
- 7:20of things about this specific ceremony that are
- 7:23pretty interesting, too, that are like highlights
- 7:24to me. And then everything else, as we mentioned
- 7:27off pod, is kind of anecdotal. But the big thing
- 7:30is this. It's in the name here. But you know
- 7:34what? Actually, strike that. Let's build up to
- 7:36it. Let's start with this. Whenever we talk about
- 7:39ceremonies in like the 20 modern ceremonies,
- 7:42I think it's very easy to see a little bit more
- 7:46representation of political beliefs or stances.
- 7:50Sure. So it's interesting to think that this
- 7:53was happening in 1935 as well. Yeah. And while
- 7:57it may not have been like fully political beliefs,
- 7:59unions were a very large part of the conversation
- 8:03at the time. So we actually did see a scenario
- 8:06in which someone, not only stood up for their
- 8:09beliefs and fought for like, you know, against
- 8:11the unions or for their unions, we actually saw
- 8:15them decline an award. Yeah, there were a couple
- 8:17mentions this year of people participating in
- 8:21strikes or honestly, there was a lot of boycotting.
- 8:26Wow. A lot of boycotting of the Academy Awards
- 8:29this year due to a lot of things that were going
- 8:31on with the studios and strikes and unions trying
- 8:34to form. We talked a lot in the previous ceremony
- 8:38about how Frank Capra was kind of working for
- 8:42both sides of the playing field where he was
- 8:45president of the Academy Award or just the Academy
- 8:47itself. But he was also trying to like build
- 8:51together the Screen Actors Guild and things like
- 8:54that. And a lot of the Academy's fate was like
- 8:59up in limbo. So that was still present here now
- 9:01with the Great Depression still going on and
- 9:04people. not sure what was happening with the
- 9:06banks so you had people say no forget the academy
- 9:11they did not treat us right they tried to take
- 9:13away our wages and like freeze the industry they
- 9:17weren't looking out for us why should we support
- 9:19it So it was kind of a dark year. It was. And
- 9:22then you have someone in between, like, you know,
- 9:25the people who would attend and be very excited
- 9:27and forget about all this, and the people who
- 9:29would boycott it. And you'd have someone down
- 9:30in the middle. And in this example, that would
- 9:32be Dudley Nichols. He was the writer for The
- 9:35Informer, and he won the award for the screenplay
- 9:39for The Informer. And he was actually the first
- 9:42person to decline the Academy Award. He went
- 9:45up on stage and said that he didn't want to demean
- 9:48the honor of receiving this award. But at the
- 9:51same time, he felt it was important to speak
- 9:54to the antagonism of the industry guilds and
- 9:57everything going on with the unions and make
- 10:00that a little more aware. So I think you're right
- 10:03that the boycotting and everything has been happening
- 10:05for a little bit. And again, Frank Capra has
- 10:07not been silent about this stuff. But at the
- 10:10same time... I think this is the first public
- 10:12display of like, hey, thanks, but no thanks.
- 10:16Yeah. Yeah. And that happens, you know, a few
- 10:18times in the future. Marlon Brando is probably
- 10:20the most famous one. Also, pretty soon we'll
- 10:23be talking about him as well. Spencer Tracy as
- 10:26well for Patton, which he's got a wild line about
- 10:30declining that. He was not. Careful about demeaning
- 10:35the honor of the award. Let's just say that.
- 10:38I'm very excited to get to that. It's pretty
- 10:40wild. But yeah, I think that it's so interesting.
- 10:44Like you said, it's another comparison to the
- 10:46modern day. And I think that it's wild that it
- 10:50almost lines up with like a hundred years difference
- 10:52where you're starting to see very similar things.
- 10:55Not that we haven't been seeing. the political
- 10:57nature of the Academy Awards for years and years.
- 11:00Oscars so white. Really, every best picture winner
- 11:04seems to come on the stage and speak about something
- 11:07that they believe in, which, real quick, how
- 11:10do you feel about that? People using the Academy
- 11:14Awards and winning an award as a platform to
- 11:17speak about? whatever really i never really thought
- 11:20that there would even be a reason to be against
- 11:22it to be honest yeah like i i feel like you know
- 11:25even in the movies that we see here there's political
- 11:27or there is expression of belief and whether
- 11:30that be down to like you should treat people
- 11:32the right way or actually this organization is
- 11:35terrible right i think that that's always in
- 11:37the movies and i think that you have a lot of
- 11:39people who go up there and say first and foremost
- 11:41like thank god And, like, that is a religious
- 11:44belief. So, like, it's all the beliefs that they
- 11:46have. So, I mean, as long as it's not, hey, I'm
- 11:50looking directly at you, and you're a terrible
- 11:51person, you should die. Probably okay to share
- 11:54some of these opinions. So, I always just thought
- 11:57of it as, like, hey, this is your time. You express
- 11:58yourself how you like. Yeah, I agree. I kind
- 12:01of look forward to seeing people speak out. Because
- 12:06I think that it's rare that... Even these high
- 12:10profile, big name celebrities are in such a huge
- 12:13spotlight where they can speak to so many people
- 12:16all at once because the Academy Awards, you wake
- 12:18up the next morning and that's all anybody is
- 12:21talking about. Yes. So even if you're not like
- 12:23a big movie fan and you're not seeing these,
- 12:26you know, marketing interviews and things where
- 12:30people might say a little bit more, more often,
- 12:33you're probably going to hear what they said
- 12:35at the Academy Awards. And I'm all for that.
- 12:38I think you should be able to use your platform.
- 12:40It's always after the awards that I see people
- 12:42like, meh, you're an actor. You should just act.
- 12:45You don't have to say anything. And I'm like,
- 12:46they're also a citizen of somewhere. Like, it's
- 12:51so weird. I always take it as a little bit of
- 12:53like a, you know, what do they call it? Backseat
- 12:57driving. Oh, yeah. Oh, they should do it this
- 12:59way. Right. You're clocking into your nine to
- 13:02five. Yeah, yeah. I think that this actor is
- 13:04going to be okay. It's like when you see the
- 13:07videos of somebody working out and showing you
- 13:09how to work out. And they're doing like 50 pull
- 13:11-ups in a row. And then the meme is the guy like
- 13:13with his hand behind his back just like forms
- 13:16a little off. It's almost exactly like that,
- 13:20really. The second thing that happened here and
- 13:22the reason that I think we're getting a little
- 13:24bit more into the notoriety of this. this year
- 13:28is that we've talked recently about write -in
- 13:31votes and how this has become more of a trend
- 13:34with the Academy Awards. And this is actually
- 13:38the last year in which we do it. We won't see
- 13:40write -ins after this. Hooray or nay? I think
- 13:45I'm just impartial. I think I see the benefit
- 13:48of it, but I think for me, my initial thought
- 13:51is I can see the detriment in it more than I
- 13:55can see the betterment. Now, just to clarify,
- 13:58is it a write in vote for the nomination or a
- 14:00write in vote for the win? I believe it's for
- 14:02the win. Yeah. So that to me, I have a little
- 14:06concern about. I think the write in votes for
- 14:08nominations makes much more sense. Sure. But
- 14:11I think that the write in votes for wins just
- 14:13kind of comes down to if we're really saying
- 14:15campaigning is an issue with some people, you
- 14:18could just campaign and be like, hey, everybody
- 14:19vote for me, even though I'm not technically.
- 14:22you know up here um so i i don't want to say
- 14:25that i'm like pro or against uh i think it's
- 14:27an interesting thing but i think there's a reason
- 14:29it was short -lived i think there's a reason
- 14:31that it was introduced like maybe last year the
- 14:33year before and only lasted two or three years
- 14:35yeah so absolutely i don't know what do you think
- 14:37uh i'm not really a huge fan of it i think it
- 14:42just makes everything a little too muddy it allows
- 14:44for The possibility of like gross controversies
- 14:48where people are using the ability to write in
- 14:51to be malicious or to take away from maybe somebody
- 14:55that they just aren't a fan of. Well, we've talked
- 14:58about a number of performers that were difficult
- 15:01to work with, or at least there's notoriety around
- 15:04their reputation on set. So that makes it to
- 15:07where, again, I don't think it's necessarily
- 15:08a bad thing that people are pointing out, hey,
- 15:10this isn't fun to work with you. But if they
- 15:13pride themselves in the work that they do. It's
- 15:15going to cause them not to be nominated because
- 15:17people don't want to vote for the person they
- 15:19don't like. Right. Yeah. So this was an interesting
- 15:22year just because it was the last time that we
- 15:23saw this happen. And people benefited from this.
- 15:26Right. There wasn't just nominations that were
- 15:28right in votes. There were wins that were right
- 15:30in votes. Well, there was one. That's true. That's
- 15:33it. And, of course, we'll get there, and we'll
- 15:35talk about that person as we get there. But,
- 15:37you know, other people did benefit, though. You
- 15:40are right. Like, there was one winner, but I
- 15:41would argue that Bette Davis benefited greatly.
- 15:44She did not win, but she received enough votes
- 15:46to really become somebody in, like, the mainstream
- 15:50eye. And I think that did wonders for her career
- 15:54for the rest of her life. So you are correct.
- 15:57Well, and even in Best Actor, you know, Captain
- 16:00Mutiny on the Bounty had three nominations for
- 16:04Best Actor. And they didn't win. None of those
- 16:09three actors won. They weren't even in second
- 16:11place. And they weren't in second place because
- 16:14the person in second place was not really a nominee.
- 16:16And we'll get there. It's crazy. Very interesting.
- 16:20The final thing that I want to talk about, and
- 16:22we can breeze past this a little bit, there's
- 16:24one word that we haven't said in this episode
- 16:26so far. Actually, that's not true because you
- 16:28said the title. But other than that, we've been
- 16:30saying a lot, Academy Awards, the award itself.
- 16:34This is the first year in which we are recalling
- 16:37the name of the award being Oscar. It's crazy,
- 16:40isn't it? Now we think of it as the Oscars, right?
- 16:43I mean, it's in the name, Once Upon a Time in
- 16:44the Oscars. But we've been saying the Academy
- 16:46Award year, the eighth year, and we've been saying
- 16:48things like outstanding production instead of
- 16:50best picture. And that's because we're trying
- 16:53to use the terminology of the time. Right. But
- 16:55now we're getting to a point where the name Oscar
- 16:57is actually becoming present. And it's becoming
- 17:00present. And here's what I think is the most
- 17:02interesting thing about this. It's not like,
- 17:04oh, hey, it's called Oscar because of this. There
- 17:06are three separate examples of why it might be
- 17:10called Oscar. Right. And they're all separate.
- 17:12There's no commonality between them. No. And
- 17:15what's kind of amazing to me is that no one has
- 17:18stepped forward and said, no, this is actually
- 17:19what it is. There's, I think, three separate
- 17:21people with their own thoughts of why this happened.
- 17:45applied it to the paper or gave the newspaper
- 17:48columnist the idea of Oscar. That's still up
- 17:52for debate. Right. And the columnist you're speaking
- 17:54about is Sidney Sklossky. And the first time
- 17:58that was written was in a column that they wrote.
- 18:01And they said that they were referencing like
- 18:03an old vaudeville joke. Will you have a cigar
- 18:05Oscar? And that's they wanted to avoid like multiple
- 18:09synonyms for the Academy Award statuette. So
- 18:11they used this. So that kind of stuck. You mentioned
- 18:14Betty Davis earlier. There's a. rumor that she
- 18:19named it after her husband, who was Harmon Oscar
- 18:22Nelson Jr. And then the first thing that I saw
- 18:25here was Margaret Herrick, who at the time was
- 18:29the Academy's librarian, and at a later date,
- 18:32the executive director, said to have named it
- 18:34after like an uncle, like Oscar Pierce. So there's
- 18:37three separate scenarios, and they're all different.
- 18:40I think that one is... the most widely accepted.
- 18:44Well, you got to think like just in terms of
- 18:45the position that she was in. As close as she
- 18:49was to the Academy Awards themselves. It has
- 18:51the most influence. Right. But I do think this
- 18:54is a scenario in which you can see all three
- 18:56of these and say, well, at some point it was
- 18:58just said and it's stuck inevitably. Right. I
- 19:00kind of agree with you. And this is probably
- 19:02why it's first mentioned that this is more likely
- 19:04to be that one. But I think it's still really
- 19:07interesting that there isn't like a source code
- 19:09it's not just the one thing it's there could
- 19:11be a number of scenarios i love that it's it's
- 19:14a mystery who knows um i do wish in hindsight
- 19:17we would have called the show once upon a time
- 19:20at the academy awards and then when this year
- 19:23happened it was like a big like new logo reveal
- 19:26and you're talking about like doing a thunderbolts
- 19:28new avengers type thing exactly where we like
- 19:31rip the poster yep yeah and and it's you and
- 19:34me just waving and we're like Can we change the
- 19:37name? And everyone's like, we know what it becomes.
- 19:41Oh. Like and subscribe. I think we should still
- 19:46do it. Yeah. It's a little late now. Well, I
- 19:49think we just have a poster that says Once Upon
- 19:50a Time in the Oscars, and then we rip it, and
- 19:51it still says the Oscars underneath it. That's
- 19:54good. We should also just, every time they add
- 19:55a category from here on out, just be like, we're
- 19:58back, baby, and now we're talking about dance
- 20:01direction. Just like ACDC playing in the background.
- 20:05Or what if we have a poster of Once Upon a Time
- 20:06in the Oscars, rip it, and then it says Academy
- 20:08Awards, and then underneath that, we rip that,
- 20:11and it says Oscars. Yeah. So we just restart.
- 20:14We're going to need one of those skyscraper posters
- 20:17because it's just going to keep going, baby.
- 20:20Or a Skyrider. Or no, what is it? The plane that
- 20:23has the banner behind it, but it just keeps going.
- 20:27Keeps going. And so long that there's a parasailor
- 20:30hanging onto the tail end of it. I know we're
- 20:34running a little long here, so we might as well
- 20:35hop right into the actual nominations. A couple
- 20:39things. Special Awards is something we always
- 20:41talk about. This year went to David Wark Griffith
- 20:44and listed here for his distinguished creative
- 20:47achievements as director and producer and his
- 20:50invaluable initiative and lasting contributions
- 20:53to the progress of the motion picture arts. This
- 20:56one I think is really interesting because previously
- 20:58we've talked about Walt Disney for the first
- 21:01animated feature. Well, not previously. That's
- 21:04coming up. But like cartoons and everything he's
- 21:06done. But we haven't really seen a lot of contribution
- 21:10to film and motion picture arts itself. What
- 21:13are your thoughts on D .W. Griffith? Don't like
- 21:15him. I feel bad saying that because obviously
- 21:19he is well known for being one of the pioneers
- 21:23of narrative film. One of those films being Birth
- 21:27of a Nation, which is just kind of an awful movie.
- 21:31You know, I don't know if it's good or bad, but
- 21:32I've been seeing it out in the wild more often
- 21:34with like the secondhand stores that I go to.
- 21:36Yeah. Some people would say it's bad because
- 21:38like, oh, why are they selling it? I would almost
- 21:40say it's good because there's people that are
- 21:41like, oh, I'm I'm fine. Thanks. Trading it in.
- 21:44They've turned it in. Yeah. I mean, look, over
- 21:49100 years ago, I understand that things were
- 21:51different and all of that. But like he. He made
- 21:53a movie that changed the narrative of a very,
- 21:55very important piece of U .S. history. And it
- 21:59almost single -handedly brought back the rise
- 22:02of the Ku Klux Klan. So it's like, eh, you know,
- 22:05this isn't great. But even in addition to that,
- 22:08I've seen his film Intolerance, which is over
- 22:11three hours long. I think that sometimes we look
- 22:16at his work and praise it in a huge way as being
- 22:20one of the first. we kind of neglect stuff that
- 22:24was going on in other countries and things. And
- 22:26it's like he's so well -received just because
- 22:30Hollywood was the big thing and not somewhere
- 22:34else in the world. People were doing what he
- 22:36was doing is what I'm saying. I wonder if the
- 22:38writing of this is intentional, where it says,
- 22:41hey, for your contributions to the progress of
- 22:44motion picture arts and not for that thing that
- 22:47you did. Yeah, yeah. Not a fan, personally. I
- 22:51would probably agree with you on that. All right,
- 22:54so let's dive into the actual categories. We're
- 22:56going to start, as always, with short subjects.
- 22:58This is broken into three categories, as always,
- 23:00cartoons, comedy, and novelty. For cartoons,
- 23:03The Calico Dragon, Harmon Icing MGM, Three Orphan
- 23:07Kittens, Disney, Who Killed Cock Robin, Disney,
- 23:12and the winner here was Three Orphan Kittens
- 23:14for Disney. Have you watched any of these? I'm
- 23:18sure that I've seen Three Orphan Kittens, just
- 23:20being somebody that grew up with Disney cartoons,
- 23:22but I don't remember. I can't say I'm familiar
- 23:25either. Yeah. I'm going to be honest. I was very
- 23:27busy this year, so I have not seen a lot of these
- 23:30extra movies. You shout it out when you have.
- 23:32I won't ask. You got it. For comedy, we had How
- 23:37to Sleep, MGM, Oh, My Nerves, Columbia, and Tit
- 23:42for Tat, Roach, MGM. The winner here was How
- 23:45to Sleep for MGM. It's curious here because How
- 23:50to Sleep, in parentheses, it says miniature.
- 23:53And that is kind of like the production company.
- 23:56When we were talking about the cartoons, it's
- 23:58like Silly Symphonies or Happy Harmonies. So
- 24:02here it says miniature. Tit for Tat is a Laurel
- 24:04and Hardy picture. Yes. Which we've not talked
- 24:07a lot about. They showed up in... Hollywood Review?
- 24:11Exactly, yes. That's the only time we've really
- 24:13covered them. So it is interesting to me how...
- 24:17much of a presence they have at the Academy Awards
- 24:18throughout history. And it's just something we're
- 24:21like, yeah, they were in one thing that we saw.
- 24:23They really are the Jay and Silent Bob of this.
- 24:25Yeah. Of like, they're just kind of there. And
- 24:28they're like, hey, what did they do? And just
- 24:29kind of hung out. Isn't it funny how Jay and
- 24:32Silent Bob, you can trace back to like Abbott
- 24:35and Costello. Yes. And Laurel and Hardy. Like
- 24:38it's, it's so weird. I think it kind of speaks
- 24:40to what we. You know, we'll talk in a later episode
- 24:43about Mr. Deeds Goes to Town and the Adam Sandler
- 24:47of it all. So Frank Cabra versus Adam Sandler.
- 24:49I think we said a similar thing about Kevin Smith
- 24:52and John Cassavetes, Richard Linklater. And I
- 24:56think that it's a similar thing of like there
- 24:58is always a re not a rehash, but like a new edition
- 25:01of something we've seen before. And there's always
- 25:03some kind of need for it. So the comedy duos.
- 25:06And yeah, I understand the need of Jay and Bob
- 25:09is not necessarily. I'm more laughing at John
- 25:12Cassavetes 2 .0. And then it's just Kevin Smith
- 25:15and like his jerseys. Him on the set of Degrassi.
- 25:19Yeah. He's like, dude, I don't know. I was hanging
- 25:21out with Harley, you know? John Cassavetes 2
- 25:24.0. I was like, so I guess I can't say that.
- 25:27In a row? In a row. I would love to see John
- 25:31Cassavetes talk about Salsa Shark. And for novelty,
- 25:35we had Audioscopics MGM. Camera Thrills, Universal,
- 25:41and Wings Over Mount Everest, Educational, which
- 25:43did take home the win. Yeah, that sounds fun.
- 25:47It does sound fun. I was also going to say How
- 25:49to Sleep does sound like it would be novelty
- 25:50and not comedy. Yeah. It's just, hey, here's
- 25:54how you do it. Well, it depends on who's doing
- 25:56it. If I'm showing you how to do it, it's a comedy.
- 25:58It would be great if it was 10 minutes long and
- 26:00it was just you sleeping. At the 10th minute,
- 26:03you just wake up and you're like, that's how.
- 26:05Yeah. Case closed. Where's my check? Do you want
- 26:10to tackle Dance Direction for us? Yes. So this
- 26:13is a new category. Why do you do the devil horns
- 26:14and everything? I'm really in that mood. I keep
- 26:18doing it. But Dance Direction is a new category
- 26:21here this year. So this is a big deal. We talked
- 26:23about it with a lot of the Fred and Ginger. Obviously,
- 26:29it's huge musical time at the Academy Awards
- 26:31and just in film in general. So this is something
- 26:35that's going to stick around for a long time.
- 26:37And I am kind of predicting that when this goes
- 26:40away, it's because the industry itself has transformed.
- 26:45Right. With that, we have Busby Berkeley for
- 26:48Lullaby of Broadway and The Words Are in My Heart
- 26:51from Gold Diggers of 1935. Bobby Connolly for
- 26:55Latin from Manhattan. which is a number from
- 26:58Go Into Your Dance, and Playboy from Paris, which
- 27:01is a number from Broadway Hostess. Dave Gould
- 27:04for I've Got a Feeling You're Fooling from the
- 27:07Broadway melody of 1936, and Straw Hat from Follies
- 27:11Berger. Berger? Berger. I don't speak French.
- 27:16Sammy Lee for Lovely Lady and Too Good to Be
- 27:20True from King of Burlesque. Also my nickname.
- 27:23King of Burlesque? Yeah. Or Lovely Lady. Oh,
- 27:27yeah, either one works. Too good to be true.
- 27:29Hey. Hey. I think I'm pretty, it's pretty right
- 27:32down the middle. You think so? You're like, no,
- 27:33that makes sense. I love that. Hermes Pan for
- 27:38Piccolino from Top Hat White Tie. Nope. Dang
- 27:42it. Hermes Pan for Piccolino and Top Hat White
- 27:48Hat. Is it Top Hat, White Tails? White Tie and
- 27:53Tails. White Tie and Tails. Thank you. Top Hat,
- 27:55White Tie and Tails from Top Hat. There's more.
- 27:58Leroy Prins for It's the Animal in Me from Big
- 28:02Broadcast of 1936. Goodness. And Viennese Waltz
- 28:06from All the King's Horses. Finally, Benjamin
- 28:10Zimak for Hall of Kings from She. That was the
- 28:14most difficult thing I've ever done in my life.
- 28:16Well, here's what's weird. They have listed in
- 28:18this, you know, the research that we've done,
- 28:20they have Top Hat listed as Piccolino and Top
- 28:23Hat. When we both know that it's Top Hat, White
- 28:26Tie and Tails. No, it's listed as Top Hat, White
- 28:29Tie and Tails. It's on the next line. Really?
- 28:32Another correction. Watch out. I had to edit
- 28:36so much out of that because I was just stumbling
- 28:38through it. The most frustrating thing about
- 28:40this category, I think, is that you can be nominated
- 28:43for multiple songs. across multiple movies yes
- 28:47and it just complicates the whole thing but that
- 28:49being said dave gould did take home the win for
- 28:53i've got a feeling you were fooling and straw
- 28:56hat which were from broadway melody of 1936 and
- 29:00foley's berger respectively got that right berger
- 29:04i said it right no respectively because i know
- 29:06that's a mystery oh yeah yes i just didn't have
- 29:08to think about it too much but we did talk about
- 29:10broadway melody of 1936 we both thoroughly enjoyed
- 29:13that number this makes a ton of sense you know
- 29:15as much as we love tap hat white tie and tails
- 29:18uh from top hat i think it makes the most sense
- 29:21in the world that the um i got a feeling your
- 29:23fooling number is the one to be nominated because
- 29:25it is the one that just took me by surprise the
- 29:27most yeah and i absolutely loved it i really
- 29:29like broadway melody of 1936 yeah i had a great
- 29:32time i liked it a lot more than the original
- 29:34yeah Oh, Bessie Love. I know. Moving on. Moving
- 29:38on, we have Assistant Director. This one's actually
- 29:40comically much shorter than the one that Kyle
- 29:42just got through. It's like when you do popcorn
- 29:45reading in school and one kid has to do like
- 29:48two pages. Then they go, okay, Ryan. And you
- 29:51say, duh, boy. The grass was wet. Moving on.
- 29:56With that said, Assistant Director has four nominations.
- 29:59For Assistant Director, we have Clem Beauchamp.
- 30:01And Paul Wing, two separate nominations, but
- 30:04each of them for Lives of the Bengal Lancer.
- 30:07We have kind of a trend here, a little running
- 30:09joke, not really a joke, that whenever an assistant
- 30:12director is nominated, you're like, well, what
- 30:15went wrong on that set? Right. And if they traveled
- 30:17for the set, you're like, well, what really went
- 30:19wrong on the set? And how many extras were there?
- 30:22Correct. So that's kind of the case with Lives
- 30:25of Bangle Lancer, which we know was filmed on
- 30:27location in some areas. Right. Eric Stacey for
- 30:30Les Miserables, 20th Century, and Joseph Newman
- 30:33for David Copperfield, MGM. Something that's
- 30:37interesting here is that we actually saw two
- 30:39wins. It's important to note that despite me
- 30:42saying Clem Beauchamp and Paul Wing, they were
- 30:44two separate nominations. But they both won for
- 30:48Lives of a Bengal Lancer. Again, this is one
- 30:50that's actually filmed on location with Les Mis.
- 30:53I'm not sure if that was filmed in France. And
- 30:56if it was, it's not like France. And obviously
- 30:59going to India for Lives of a Bengal Lancer.
- 31:01It makes a bit of sense why we'd see assistant
- 31:03director here, especially, like you said, the
- 31:05amount of extras, things that can go wrong. So
- 31:08Clem Beauchamp and Paul Wing did take the win
- 31:11here. Yes, they did. That really is something
- 31:14that I want to just research so much more to
- 31:17understand. Because it's so often that the assistant
- 31:19gets nominated but not the director. And I just
- 31:22wonder, what does this mean? What's going on
- 31:25on that set? Do we want to know? Yeah. Yeah,
- 31:30I don't know. That's a question. Moving on to
- 31:32that is arguably one of your favorite categories.
- 31:35Love it. We can break this up into the two subcategories.
- 31:39Music. Song. So first up, we have Cheek to Cheek
- 31:44from Top Hat, the RKO Radio film. Lovely to Look
- 31:49At from Roberta, RKO Radio. and Lullaby of Broadway
- 31:54from Gold Diggers of 1935, First National. The
- 31:59winner for this one is actually one we didn't
- 32:02get to experience, unfortunately, and that is
- 32:04Lullaby of Broadway from Gold Diggers of 1935,
- 32:06going to Harry Warren and Al Dubin. Didn't you
- 32:10watch Gold Diggers of 1935, though? I watched
- 32:12Gold Diggers of 1933. Ah, that's the difference.
- 32:17Okay. I was going to ask how you felt about this.
- 32:18I'll be honest. With the popularity of Cheek
- 32:21to Cheek, after this is uh after this film i
- 32:24i could have thought or could have swore that
- 32:27we would see that win here yeah but obviously
- 32:29that's more looking at it retroactively than
- 32:31in the moment right um so i guess it's worth
- 32:33checking out gold diggers of 1935 which i have
- 32:36in the busby berkeley collection so i'm excited
- 32:38and we love a busby we do Am I doing this category
- 32:42as well? Yeah. Okay. Hey, it's old music. Then
- 32:44we also have the scoring category, and this one's
- 32:47exciting. We have the Informer RKO Radio. Score
- 32:50by Max Steiner, our boy, who returns a million
- 32:54times. Love it. Thanks for King Kong, buddy.
- 32:56Mutiny on the Bounty, an MGM picture. Score going
- 32:59to Herbert Stothert. And Peter Ibbotson, Paramount
- 33:04Studio. The score by Ernst Toke. You could skip
- 33:07past that. I saw it too. Gotcha. The winner here.
- 33:11I think is my preferred win. The Informer. Yeah.
- 33:15RKO Radio for Max Steiner. I think so too. I
- 33:17think The Informer is a movie that, you know,
- 33:19we talked previously a few minutes ago about
- 33:21how we have seen some movies that we just weren't
- 33:24like super thrilled on. I think The Informer
- 33:26for me is probably the big win for me personally
- 33:29in this year. So music, cinematography, acting,
- 33:35I think that a lot of this, directing especially,
- 33:38my God. I do think a lot of this owes itself
- 33:41to score. Yes. And while I did like Meet Me on
- 33:44the Bounty score, I think that it was adventurous.
- 33:47It still doesn't capture the noir elements of
- 33:51what we will see in the future, like the early
- 33:53stages of noir, German expressionism and whatnot.
- 33:55I think it captures it perfectly with this score.
- 33:58Yeah. So very, very good work on Max Steiner.
- 34:00It's so funny, too, how we talked about the Letterboxd
- 34:02review that was like. I love this movie except
- 34:04the score. It was too cartoony. And I'm just
- 34:07like, no, it's so good. It's so perfect. It puts
- 34:10you in that world. And I love it too because
- 34:12it really does feel like a unique piece of music
- 34:15that is made for that film. Yeah. And I think
- 34:19Max Steiner is kind of like the leading man in
- 34:22that type of score. I mentioned King Kong. Like
- 34:25that is the birth of that whole concept. And
- 34:28he's continuing to do it here with The Informer.
- 34:31I do want to point out as well. that although
- 34:34I am crediting Max Steiner here, of course, he
- 34:37was the composer, the award until 1938 did not
- 34:40go to the composer, but it went to the head of
- 34:42the studio, which I don't really love. I think
- 34:46that's something that we see with sound as well
- 34:48in these current years, which I guess is fine
- 34:51because, you know, here's one for you, Douglas
- 34:53Shearer. But I do think, like, Max Steiner deserves
- 34:58that Academy Award on his mantle. So I do want
- 35:01to point out that Never mind. Max Steiner was
- 35:04the head of the department. That's not always
- 35:07the case. But it's not that he did the score.
- 35:13It's that he was the head of the department.
- 35:16And that's why he got the award itself. It's
- 35:19almost like it's so convenient that he hired
- 35:20himself for the job. It's almost like he learned
- 35:23this at this point. And he was like, oh, so it
- 35:25goes to the studio. Oh, that's me. Oh, wow. That's
- 35:29what it was. And that lasts until 1938. So we'll
- 35:32have about three more years to cover before we
- 35:35see any change in that. Absolutely. Next is film
- 35:38editing. The nominees are, as such, David Copperfield
- 35:42for MGM. This was Robert J. Kern. The informer,
- 35:46RKO Radio, was George Hively. Les Miserables,
- 35:4920th Century United Artists. This was Barbara
- 35:51McLean. Lives of a Bengal Lancer, Paramount,
- 35:54Ellsworth, Hoagland. A Midsummer Night's Dream
- 35:57for Warner Brothers, Ralph Dawson. And Mutiny
- 36:00on the Botany for MGM, Margaret Booth. The win
- 36:05here, much to our chagrin and Kyle's nightmares,
- 36:09is A Midsummer Night's Dream for Ralph Dawson.
- 36:13Yeah, I'm going to be honest. Mickey Rooney aside,
- 36:16I don't think this was correct. I agree. I think
- 36:20that, you know, we talked a bit about, well,
- 36:24here's a look into the future. We will talk a
- 36:27bit about Shakespeare adaptations and how it
- 36:30can be done. And maybe the... Maybe the fault
- 36:34in something like A Midsummer Night's Dream is
- 36:35how faithfully it tries to recreate the fantastical
- 36:39elements of Midsummer Night's Dream. In that
- 36:41the filming is so fantastical, the cinematography
- 36:45at least, that I think it kind of is to its own
- 36:48detriment. And that's why I think film editing
- 36:51doesn't make a ton of sense for A Midsummer Night's
- 36:53Dream. I much rather would have seen it for The
- 36:55Informer. I think even Les Mis. Had really good
- 36:58editing. Yeah. Mutiny on the Bounty is a big
- 37:01one for me. Oh, sure. With all the action. There's
- 37:03so much action. And I think that movie flows
- 37:05really well in a way that I certainly don't think
- 37:09Midsummer Night's Dream does. And after researching
- 37:12more about Margaret Booth, I'm just like, give
- 37:14her every win. She's so cool. So, yeah, that
- 37:18is a prime example of, I don't see it, guys.
- 37:22I think you dropped the ball. I wonder if it's
- 37:24almost like an Avatar kind of win where it's
- 37:26like, wow, look what was possible. And you're
- 37:27like, yeah, but is it good? Yeah, but just isn't
- 37:30it interesting looking? Man, Kid Mickey Rooney
- 37:33reminds me of Spider in Avatar. Don't ruin Avatar
- 37:37for me. Welcome to my world, man. I don't know.
- 37:41Oh, no, I don't like that. That was film editing.
- 37:45Nice. So following that, we have sound recording
- 37:47for all of our Horror of the Overlooked fans.
- 37:51You're going to love this one. at least partially,
- 37:54Bride of Frankenstein, Universal Studios, and
- 37:58that's Gilbert Curlin, the sound director, Captain
- 38:00Blood, Cosmopolitan, that is Nathan Levinson,
- 38:04the sound director, The Dark Angel, Goldwyn United
- 38:07Artists, Thomas T. Moulton, I Dream Too Much,
- 38:12RKO Radio, for Carl Dreher, The Lives of a Bengal
- 38:15Lancer, Paramount Studios Sound Department, Franklin
- 38:18B. Hansen, Love Me Forever, Columbia Studios
- 38:22Sound Department, John Livideri. Naughty Marietta,
- 38:26MGM Studios Sound Department, Douglas Shearer.
- 38:29What up, man? $1 ,000 a minute, Republic Studios
- 38:33Sound Department. Nobody attached to that. Interesting.
- 38:36I guess it was just whoever showed up to work
- 38:38that day. It was like a compilation. Or all of
- 38:40Republic. Yeah. Thanks a million, 20th Century
- 38:44Fox Studios Sound Department, E .H. Hansen. And
- 38:49the winner for sound recording goes to Naughty
- 38:52Marietta, The MGM Picture, and Our Friend Douglas
- 38:56Shearer. This is another one I didn't get. Yeah.
- 38:59I didn't get the nominee or the win for this
- 39:00one. Well, I didn't. But I also don't fully understand
- 39:05it. To me, I think that something like The Bride
- 39:07of Frankenstein, even Captain Blood. I mean,
- 39:10Captain Blood has so much swashbuckling and cannons
- 39:12being fired that you'd think the sound recording
- 39:15of that. Would take precedence of like, wow,
- 39:18look at what we're able to do now in balancing
- 39:19all these things. Right. Also, a lot of extras
- 39:21on set at one point. That's true. Naughty Marietta.
- 39:25There are some scenes with multiple extras on
- 39:29site. And I don't really even think it's even
- 39:32close to something like Captain Blood. But I
- 39:35don't know. I just don't really understand it.
- 39:37You know. There's a few movies here that I'm
- 39:40unfamiliar with that we did not watch for the
- 39:41show, but of the ones we have seen, Naughty Marietta
- 39:44is the only identifiable musical. That, of course,
- 39:47always plays a part in sound recording. And when
- 39:50we were talking about the film itself, I do recall
- 39:53there being scenes where conversation is being
- 39:57had while another character is singing a number.
- 40:00And you are able to pick up on the individual
- 40:03parts, the dialogue, but also the lyrics. So
- 40:07that is kind of like showcasing progress of sound
- 40:11recording in film, I would say. It's a good point.
- 40:14I'm sure the musical aspect is carrying a lot
- 40:16of weight there. Right. I do think, though, I
- 40:18mean, Bride of Frankenstein is just, that's something
- 40:21else. That's the one for me, I think. Yeah, absolutely.
- 40:24I would say that. But even when you take the,
- 40:26you know, my personal preference out of it, I
- 40:28think Captain Blood just like on its own stands
- 40:30higher. So next is Art Direction. Art Direction,
- 40:35we have three nominations. The Dark Angel, Goldwyn
- 40:38United artists for Richard Day. Can't believe
- 40:40they did a Buffy spinoff so early. I know. You
- 40:42know what I was going to say is, what was the
- 40:44Jessica Alba TV show? Was it Dark Angel? I think
- 40:47it was just Angel, wasn't it? No, Angel was the
- 40:50spinoff of... Oh, Buffy. Okay, so you're talking
- 40:52about something else. You know what we're both
- 40:53thinking of? We're both thinking of Touched by
- 40:55an Angel. Ah. No, we're not. I do, honestly,
- 40:58we'll look it up after this. I do think that
- 41:00there is a Jessica Alba show called Dark Angel
- 41:02that lasted like two seasons. Gotcha. There's
- 41:06one person at home that's like, you're right.
- 41:08Yes, I love that show. It's Jessica Alba. And
- 41:11Taylor, hello. Well, yeah, Jessica Alba. Lives
- 41:15of Bengal Lancers, our second nominee. That's
- 41:17Paramount for Hans Dreher and Roland Anderson.
- 41:20Top Hat for RKO Radio, Carol Clark and Van Ness
- 41:23Poglossi. Did we confirm which one of those was
- 41:26right? Nope. Great. Nor will we. I'm sure we're
- 41:29keeping that in. And the winner for Art Direction
- 41:31was The Dark Angel for Richard Day. Neither of
- 41:35us have seen this one. Nope. No, the only, well,
- 41:38we saw the other two, but yeah. I'll say, with
- 41:41Art Direction, Lives of a Bangalancer being filmed
- 41:43on location, Art Direction seems a little interesting.
- 41:48Yeah, and if you'll remember, Lives of a Bangalancer
- 41:51was filmed on location, the footage was destroyed,
- 41:54and then they had to recreate everything. You're
- 41:57right. So, like, that is a big... display of
- 42:01creativity and skill i'm not sure if it filmed
- 42:04on location but top hat the whole second half
- 42:06of that film takes place in france right or no
- 42:09italy yeah not filmed on location that was all
- 42:12studio because we talked about how they had to
- 42:14paint the canals and everything yes because the
- 42:16set was so white yes you're right okay yeah so
- 42:19it makes a bit of sense uh But again, with art
- 42:22direction, I would have thought maybe like Captain
- 42:24Blood, Mutiny on the Bounty. I know some of those,
- 42:27Mutiny on the Bounty, they actually filmed on
- 42:29the water. Captain Blood, I think they had like
- 42:31some backgrounds and art direction makes the
- 42:33most sense there. But congratulations to Richard
- 42:35Day and the team behind the Dark Angel. Yeah,
- 42:38funny enough, we will also be recording an episode
- 42:41for the future where Richard Day was the, spoiler
- 42:44alert, the winner of the art production for the
- 42:48movie we're going to talk about. Great. Popular
- 42:51name. Big name we'll see a lot. Next up, we have
- 42:53Cinematography. Barbary Coast, Goldwyn, Mrs.
- 42:57Ray June. The Crusades, Paramount, Victor Milner.
- 43:03Les Miserables, 20th Century United Artists.
- 43:06That's Greg Tolan. Big fan of him, personally.
- 43:09And A Midsummer Night's Dream, Warner Brothers,
- 43:12Hal Moore. And this is the big deal here. This
- 43:16is what you talked about at the beginning of
- 43:18the show. The three nominees were the first ones
- 43:21listed with Ray June, Victor Milner, and Greg
- 43:23Tolan. However, the first and only write -in
- 43:27winner in Academy Award history was Hal Moore
- 43:30for A Midsummer Night's Dream. Yeah, I don't,
- 43:34um, I don't get it. I just, I want to say that.
- 43:38Like, when you have something like The Informer.
- 43:41Like, I absolutely love the camera work in The
- 43:45Informer. Again, we keep talking about that scene
- 43:48where... I forget the character's name. But he
- 43:51is being captured and shot at by the police.
- 43:55And you could see his fingernails gripping the
- 43:58top of the staircase and actually screeching,
- 44:01causing marks as he's falling. But you don't
- 44:04see him being shot. Just such a good framing
- 44:07device on this. And I thought it was such good
- 44:09storytelling and acting without seeing the actual
- 44:12person. So I would say that would be cinematography
- 44:14for me specifically. Midsummer Night's Dream,
- 44:17again, I think it's just you really have to be
- 44:20into the fantastical side of this because it's
- 44:23very shimmery. A lot of people complain about
- 44:24J .J. Abrams and his lens flare. Welcome to the
- 44:27beginning. Right. It's just all glitter. It's
- 44:30all glitter, all glare all over the place. And
- 44:33there's good work in it. I really like the transformation
- 44:36scene of James Cagney into the donkey makeup
- 44:41prosthetics. But outside of that. I can't say
- 44:45I was, like, blown away by the visuals. Yeah,
- 44:48I mean, there is the scene where all of the fairies
- 44:51come out of the mist and they climb up, like,
- 44:53towards the moon almost. Or there's, like, an
- 44:55escalator, like, de -escalating and they're coming
- 44:57down from, like, the ray of sun to the ground.
- 45:00Yeah. Like, there is a lot in this. Probably
- 45:03the part I like the most about this movie is
- 45:05how it harkens back to, like, the early silent
- 45:08film era of, like, George Maley's and all of
- 45:10that. I love that camera trickery. the like substance
- 45:16of the movie the meat of the movie i'm just i
- 45:19can't stand it but i do think it is like visually
- 45:22stunning so i understand people being really
- 45:25enamored with this back in 1935 i think that
- 45:28in the modern day when we look back we do have
- 45:32more praise for somebody like um how more No,
- 45:36like John Ford and his cinematographer in that
- 45:40film, who I do not have written down. I apologize.
- 45:42We would if it was nominated. Yeah, yeah. But
- 45:45I think that's what it is. There are certain
- 45:48directors and their films that we look back now
- 45:52and we're like, look at this. This is just incredible.
- 45:53And I think John Ford and the Informer is one
- 45:56of those. I would even say Les Mis. Yeah, yeah.
- 46:00I just think that Midsummer Night's Dream, while
- 46:02I didn't like it, I am almost... This is the
- 46:05one that, like, I'm okay with. I don't know if
- 46:07it deserves, like, a whole write -in, which is
- 46:09kind of why I'm okay with that going away next
- 46:12year. But, you know, take the glory while you
- 46:16can, Midsummer Night's Dream. That's right. And
- 46:18congratulations, Hal Moore. Next is writing.
- 46:21And that comes into two categories, of course,
- 46:23both original and screenplay. Starting in original,
- 46:26we have Broadway Melody of 1936. This was for
- 46:28Moss Hart. The Gay Deception. This was for Don
- 46:32Hartman and Stephen Avery. The Scoundrel, which
- 46:35was for Ben Hecht and Charles MacArthur. And
- 46:37this original story nomination or category went
- 46:41to The Scoundrel for Ben Hecht and Charles MacArthur.
- 46:46Not one that we've seen. Not one that we've seen.
- 46:48We have talked about Ben Hecht before, though,
- 46:51I believe for our front page episode. Oh, and
- 46:56I love the front page. Yeah. Tim, my brother,
- 46:59actually has a movie club, Cromdor's movie club,
- 47:02where they cover different movies every month,
- 47:04and everyone watches it, and Tim writes a piece
- 47:07about it. Nice. Just did the front page. Oh,
- 47:09good for them. I think his Letterboxd review
- 47:11is, who among us hasn't kissed our bro's fiance
- 47:14right in front of them? And he's referring to
- 47:16when Walter kisses his fiance. Yeah. And he texted
- 47:20me. He was like, hey, it was pretty good, but
- 47:22what? And then he put that in his review, so
- 47:26pretty good. For the screenplay, which normally
- 47:31is like an adaptation, right? For screenplay,
- 47:33we have The Informer for Dudley Nichols, Lies
- 47:36of a Bengal Lancer, which is Ahmed Abdullah,
- 47:40John L. Balderston, Grover Jones, William Slavins
- 47:43McNutt, and Voldemort Young. And Mutiny on the
- 47:46Bounty, which is Jules Firthman, Talbert Jennings,
- 47:49and Carrie Wilson. The informer, Dudley Nichols,
- 47:53did take the win here. And as we mentioned before,
- 47:56Dudley Nichols, of course, he did win because
- 47:58he actually turned down the Oscar statuette,
- 48:02as it's now known. Right. Yeah. And he was the
- 48:05first person to ever do so. Not the last, as
- 48:07you mentioned. Right. And we'll get there. This
- 48:09is iconic behavior. Big deal. Yeah. Very big
- 48:13deal to be. And you know what? Honestly. Even
- 48:17more credit that it's not like a best actor or,
- 48:20you know, best picture win. Right. Because when
- 48:23it's something like a writing category, a lot
- 48:26of people probably would be like, yeah, sure,
- 48:27good job writing. But let's like talk about the
- 48:29movie stars. Important that someone behind the
- 48:32scenes is going to step up and stand up for this.
- 48:34Right. The actors and stuff, they're usually
- 48:37in the limelight. So to turn down an Oscar and
- 48:41not get that one moment, it's less of a big deal
- 48:44for them. than it is for somebody like Dudley
- 48:46Nichols. And that honestly feels like maybe I'm
- 48:49just kind of like wish casting a little bit with
- 48:50this. That feels like a John Ford team move.
- 48:55Like it feels like John Ford is picking his team
- 48:57well when someone like that stands up. You have
- 48:59to imagine something like John Ford is like proud
- 49:01of something like that. That's just my initial
- 49:02thought. You know, I don't know enough, but I
- 49:06kind of see what you're saying. You know what
- 49:07I might be thinking with that is I might be thinking
- 49:09that David Lynch portrayed him in The Fableman.
- 49:10I was like, David Lynch would have supported
- 49:12that. It is very hard to separate the two now.
- 49:15Yeah, especially. For actress, you want to take
- 49:18this? Or no, director. Yeah, so speaking of John
- 49:22Ford, we're moving into the directing category.
- 49:24Here we have The Informer, RKO Radio, John Ford,
- 49:28The Lives of a Bengal Lancer, Paramount, Henry
- 49:31Hathaway, and Mutiny on the Bounty, MGM, Frank
- 49:36Lloyd. We not only watched all these movies,
- 49:40we've seen movies from all of these directors
- 49:42in previous years. But I am happy to say that
- 49:46the winner was John Ford for The Informer. Now,
- 49:49Frank Lloyd has seen a win here before, at least
- 49:53a win for Cavalcade. Correct. Do you think that
- 49:55he was anticipating a follow -up here? I don't
- 49:59know. I don't know how kind of cocky. a lot of
- 50:03these people were in comparison to somebody like
- 50:05frank capra see and i don't even think cockiness
- 50:07is what i'm referring to here i think it's more
- 50:09so when we talk about the trends that we see
- 50:11at the uh the ceremonies yeah whether we see
- 50:14hey i did cavalcade and that did really well
- 50:16so maybe i continue making epics like this right
- 50:18and especially like epics of large scales mutiny
- 50:21on the bounty was a larger scale than cavalcade
- 50:23in terms of like set and everything so i wonder
- 50:25if that was like oh yeah this is kind of a shoe
- 50:27-in but i i agree with what i think you're saying
- 50:31and what you were going to say if you already
- 50:32that john ford i think we both agree this is
- 50:35the deserved win of all of these for us yeah
- 50:38and i i think the big deal here is and what probably
- 50:41backs up your theory i don't know that anybody
- 50:44was expecting john ford to win because the informer
- 50:46is such like a low budget low scale production
- 50:49and The scene you were talking about where the
- 50:53guy is being shot at and he's hanging out of
- 50:55the windowsill and it's slipping away out of
- 50:57frame. Like all of that stuff was designed meticulously
- 51:01to kind of get around the code or to film things
- 51:04that they couldn't film other ways. So it's almost
- 51:08like guerrilla movie making, guerrilla tactic
- 51:11movie making. And I think that like from a film
- 51:16studies point of view, like. There's a lot to
- 51:19be showcased there with John Ford. But at the
- 51:21time, I'm sure most people were like, it's Mutiny
- 51:24on the Bounty. It's like this giant pirate movie.
- 51:26Of course it's going to win. So I think you're
- 51:28right. I think you're right. But I am very pleased
- 51:30that John Ford won. And I think that they are
- 51:32right to a degree. And we'll get there. They're
- 51:34just not right about directing. Yeah. So for
- 51:37Actress, there were six nominations. Just had
- 51:40to count that in real time. Of them, Elizabeth
- 51:43Bergner for Escape Me Never, which was Will Cox,
- 51:46United Artists. This was a British production.
- 51:49Claudette Colbert in Private Worlds, Paramount.
- 51:52Betty Davis in Dangerous, Warner Brothers. Katherine
- 51:56Hepburn in Alice Adams, RKO Radio. Miriam Hopkins
- 52:00in Becky Sharp, Pioneer, RKO Radio. Merle Oberon
- 52:04in The Dark Angel, Goldwyn, United Artists. And
- 52:07the win here went to Betty Davis in Dangerous
- 52:10Warner Brothers. It did. We're obviously familiar
- 52:14with Betty Davis. Did you see Dangerous ever?
- 52:16I did not see Dangerous ever. I will say that
- 52:21Betty Davis historically felt like this was a
- 52:25pity Oscar. Interesting. Yes. If you'll remember
- 52:28last year, there was the write -in controversy
- 52:31with Betty Davis where she was. Oh, what was
- 52:35the movie? I started it. Where Bette Davis had
- 52:39such a huge campaign behind her role in Of Human
- 52:42Bondage. She thought for sure that she had the
- 52:45support and that she was deserving of her performance
- 52:49in that movie that she would win last year. And
- 52:52of course, Katharine Hepburn took it home. So
- 52:54this year, she won the award, but she thought
- 52:58that it was just as a, oh, well, you really deserved
- 53:01it last year, so we voted for you this year.
- 53:04And she hated that. Like, I think that she went
- 53:08home and she was just like, whatever, threw the
- 53:10Oscar in the corner. And she was like, eh. See,
- 53:12I take this as, like, you could really look at
- 53:14that either way. Because let's look at the flip
- 53:17side of this. If you thought that you really
- 53:18deserved it and you lost to, like, Katharine
- 53:21Hepburn and Alice Adams, who I probably would
- 53:24have said would have been my pick in these. Yeah.
- 53:26Not just because that's, you know, one of the
- 53:28ones that we watched, what we talked about here.
- 53:30But because, especially towards the end, you
- 53:32see her cracking. And, like, that is just such
- 53:35a brilliant performance on Katherine Hepburn's
- 53:37part. I could see Bette Davis being like, oh,
- 53:39well, they didn't even get the win for this one.
- 53:41It feels like a negative mentality across the
- 53:43board. Yeah. So I would take the win for Bette
- 53:46Davis, girl. Like, take the win, and you're not
- 53:49the last we'll see of you. Well, I think that's
- 53:51the thing. Like, she is Bette Davis, of course,
- 53:53but she's not Bette Davis yet. That's right.
- 53:56She's on her way. She's really working towards
- 53:58that. the iconic betty davis so katherine heffern's
- 54:02near the peak here obviously not in terms of
- 54:04popularity but in terms of like her um achievement
- 54:07in acting acting yeah well you say peak she still
- 54:11has a long way to go oh sure but i know i know
- 54:13there's a little bit of space between this and
- 54:15something like the philadelphia story that we'll
- 54:17get to sure yeah oh man i'm excited for that
- 54:20i am too 1940 1940 yeah i'm excited so moving
- 54:24on to the actor category a little less controversial
- 54:27We have Clark Gable without his mustache in Mutiny
- 54:30on the Bounty, MGM Pictures. Charles Lawton in
- 54:33Mutiny on the Bounty, MGM Pictures. Victor McLaglin
- 54:37in The Informer, RKO Radio. And Frank O'Tone
- 54:41in Mutiny on the Bounty, MGM Pictures. You know,
- 54:44I opened this up saying, a little less controversial,
- 54:47this is the only time there were three actors
- 54:49nominated from one movie in the acting category.
- 54:55including supporting. Right. So I think this
- 54:57is one of those circumstances where the votes
- 55:00were split between all of these people. And because
- 55:04of that, maybe Charles Lawton was like the best
- 55:08actor after all. But because, you know, votes
- 55:11were dished out to Clark Gable and Frank O'Tone,
- 55:13Victor McLaglin ended up taking home the win.
- 55:17There's another interesting wrinkle here, and
- 55:18we kind of teased it a little bit at the beginning,
- 55:20and that's that the write -in nominees also made
- 55:23that the second most nominated or voted for person
- 55:27in this category wasn't even one of the nominees.
- 55:30It was Paul Muni of Black Fury, and he was second.
- 55:35So this was the time where they're still releasing
- 55:37that information, right? So obviously, Victor
- 55:39McLaglin won. As he should have, I'm going to
- 55:43say. But then second was Paul Muni for Black
- 55:47Fury. Again, not nominated at the time. And third
- 55:51was Charles Lawton. So I think you're half right.
- 55:54I think that the votes were a little split between
- 55:57which actor of Mutiny on the Bounty deserved
- 56:00it. But also, I think the write -in nominee and
- 56:04the write -in wins for... Paul Muni, I think
- 56:08that also took away from anyone voting for those.
- 56:10So that's where I think it makes it kind of interesting,
- 56:13and probably for the better, that they get rid
- 56:15of these writing nominations, because then you
- 56:16have to vote for those people that are nominated.
- 56:19And that makes it a little bit more, hey, if
- 56:21you're really split, then that's a fault of the
- 56:24movie being so good, I suppose, and having great
- 56:26performances. But still interesting that it didn't
- 56:28get the win, but it did cause Charles Lawton
- 56:30to be further down the list. Yeah. Well, the
- 56:32cool thing about that is... You see this happen
- 56:35with three actors nominated in one movie, and
- 56:38then Paul Muni showing up because of the write
- 56:40-ins. So not only next year do they do away with
- 56:43write -ins, so there's one thing gone, but the
- 56:46three actors in one movie, they say, this is
- 56:48a problem. Let's add the supporting actor and
- 56:52actress category. That feels like Charles Lawton
- 56:54sent a letter the next day. Maybe he did. He
- 56:57was like, Frank O'Tone was a supporting actor
- 57:00at best. Yes. I looked better than Clark Gable.
- 57:04He had no mustache. Elsa, send this out for me.
- 57:08Elsa's like, I'm too busy celebrating Bride of
- 57:11Frankenstein being nominated for Best Sound Recorder.
- 57:12She's just flossing in the bride dress. God,
- 57:17I want to see that. Our final category here is
- 57:20best picture or outstanding production. And I
- 57:23will fly through these as quickly and as accurately
- 57:26as I can. Alice Adams for RKO Radio. Broadway
- 57:30Melody of 1936, MGM. Captain Blood of Warner
- 57:35Brothers Cosmopolitan. David Copperfield, MGM.
- 57:38The Informer, RKO Radio. Les Miserables, 20th
- 57:42Century United Artists. And the win here did
- 57:59go to Mutiny on the Bounty. This feels a little
- 58:02bit like... Hey, we know that The Informer was
- 58:08probably the best -looking movie here, so they
- 58:10deserve Best Direction, but the one we liked
- 58:12the most. was Mutiny on the Bounty. I don't think
- 58:16we got this right. I certainly understand. I
- 58:18certainly understand why, and I'm not even mad
- 58:20like, hey, this shouldn't have won. It's just
- 58:23more so, God, I love the Informer so much. And
- 58:26what I liked about, or what I wanted the most
- 58:28out of Mutiny on the Bounty, I think Captain
- 58:30Blood did better. I think so too. So this is
- 58:32almost like the best actor situation all over
- 58:35again, where it's like, well, any vote I would
- 58:36have put towards Mutiny on the Bounty, I probably
- 58:38would have put for Captain Blood instead. Yeah.
- 58:40So... Now we're kind of split and the Informer
- 58:43wins is the way I would see it. Yes. What do
- 58:45you think? I agree, like in hindsight, for sure.
- 58:49I think that during this time, like Mutiny on
- 58:53the Bounty is this big sprawling epic. You have
- 58:55some of the biggest actors in the year. When
- 58:59Charles Lawton shows up in a movie, it's a huge
- 59:01deal. When Clark Gable, winner of Best Actor
- 59:04for It Happened One Night, shows up, it's a huge
- 59:07deal. And also Frank Lloyd. I mean, he won Best
- 59:11Director, Best Picture before. This movie had
- 59:14everything behind it pushing towards this is
- 59:18going to be the Best Picture winner. That being
- 59:21said, this win also marks a historic occasion
- 59:24where this is the last time in history a movie
- 59:28wins Best Picture without taking home any other
- 59:31win that night. So far. No, this is the last
- 59:34time. Well, I mean like 2027 and on. Oh, OK.
- 59:38Yeah. Who knows what will happen in 2029? Probably
- 59:42not that, but probably not. You know, there it
- 59:44is. But yeah, I mean, that to me, that's always
- 59:47a showcase. And I say always it's happened like
- 59:49three times, but it is kind of telling of the
- 59:52movie itself. Probably the best opportunity this
- 59:55had to win would have been the acting category
- 59:58if there wasn't all the kerfuffle with three
- 1:00:01nominees and the write ins and all of that. But
- 1:00:04I do think that, like, maybe this isn't the best
- 1:00:07picture. Well, and we're not the ones to say.
- 1:00:10There are only two people who can say that, and
- 1:00:12that is, well, two organizations. One, the Academy.
- 1:00:15That brought this up. And two, the Academy. Our
- 1:00:18Patreon members who can tell us if they think
- 1:00:23that everyone got it wrong and there should be
- 1:00:25a different movie. And feel free to do that.
- 1:00:27Every year we look at the Patreon to see whether
- 1:00:30or not you have voted that another film should
- 1:00:33have won Best Picture. And this is the portion
- 1:00:35where we tell you what, Kyle. I will tell you
- 1:00:38that although we have made a case, Ryan, of why
- 1:00:42we think Mutiny on the Bounty. is not the Best
- 1:00:44Picture winner. And maybe something else truly
- 1:00:47deserved it. The Academy of Once Upon a Time
- 1:00:51at the Oscars disagrees with us, and they have
- 1:00:54chosen Mutiny on the Bounty as the Best Picture
- 1:00:56winner. You know, this is where I would stand
- 1:00:58up and say, y 'all got it wrong. I get it. I
- 1:01:02understand, and I think that's probably the right
- 1:01:04call. It's not what I would have voted for, but
- 1:01:07I certainly understand why. Right, yeah, this
- 1:01:09isn't like... It's more personal preference.
- 1:01:11You guys have not committed a crime against us
- 1:01:14with this one. Right. But, yeah, no. Do you think
- 1:01:17that'll happen? Yes. Do you think Bryce and everyone
- 1:01:19else will be like, hey, Mickey Rooney should
- 1:01:22have won Best Supporting Actor for Midsommar?
- 1:01:24Yeah. Yeah, it's coming. Something's going to
- 1:01:26happen. No, but we appreciate you guys voting
- 1:01:29in that category. category in that patreon exclusive
- 1:01:33poll it is something fun that we do on the show
- 1:01:37where we allow you guys to vote and kind of partake
- 1:01:40in the journey that we're going up through together
- 1:01:44so you know what we should do what's that we
- 1:01:46should do what the academy stopped doing after
- 1:01:48this year and we should allow write -in nominations
- 1:01:50oh no we should allow write -in nominations for
- 1:01:53like what movie came out in 1937 19 whatever
- 1:01:56blank uh that you think should have been nominated
- 1:01:59and won for best picture I feel like that opens
- 1:02:01the doors for so many terrible things. Or maybe
- 1:02:04we should have done it for these two years. We
- 1:02:05should have, yeah. Damn, I didn't think about
- 1:02:07that. Bummer. In hindsight, that would have worked.
- 1:02:10We'll call that the Bryce exclusive. Exactly.
- 1:02:12Because I don't think anyone else would have
- 1:02:13contributed to that. That's true. Or it might
- 1:02:15be the only thing other people contributed to.
- 1:02:18But we appreciate you guys. participating in
- 1:02:21that if you do want to support us on patreon
- 1:02:22we've talked about the different perks and things
- 1:02:25you get but also it does financially help the
- 1:02:27show pay for like the hosting costs as well as
- 1:02:30like equipment if we have to buy that i think
- 1:02:33we're due for another boom arm because i'm tired
- 1:02:35of hunching over so i'm gonna be saving up for
- 1:02:38that but uh Yeah, we appreciate any financial
- 1:02:41backing you guys do, and we try to offer as many
- 1:02:44cool perks as we can for you guys. And I think
- 1:02:46we're going to do some cool stuff here soon.
- 1:02:48I'm very excited for this next year. Yeah. But
- 1:02:51also, I'm going to come out and say it. Normally,
- 1:02:54this is where we would read the write -ins and
- 1:02:57emails that we get talking about the different
- 1:02:59movies we covered this year. We would get those
- 1:03:03from you guys at home to hear your thoughts.
- 1:03:06We did not get any of those this year, which
- 1:03:08is fine. That's completely fine. But we look
- 1:03:11forward to those. So if you do have thoughts
- 1:03:12about any of the movies we'll be covering next
- 1:03:14year, I would love for you guys to get those
- 1:03:17in before the ceremony episodes so we can talk
- 1:03:19about them. But let's talk about next year just
- 1:03:23briefly, just running through things. Yeah, so
- 1:03:26that's going to be the... The ninth? The ninth
- 1:03:30Academy year. The ninth Academy year that we're
- 1:03:32going to cover. We have a lot of good stuff to
- 1:03:35bring up in that specifically. Now, this is one
- 1:03:38that I think we're about, what, seven of the
- 1:03:43ten in that you and I have watched? Not that
- 1:03:46we've recorded, but that we've watched. Yeah.
- 1:03:48So we're about, you know. Seven tenths through.
- 1:03:50We're almost done. Almost done. I think there's
- 1:03:53a lot of really interesting stuff to bring up.
- 1:03:55I will say one of the most split that I think
- 1:03:57we've been on, one of the movies we've been the
- 1:03:59most split on, is coming up. I won't reveal which
- 1:04:01one that is. Also, I'll just say this. I think
- 1:04:04this is one of the years where I've had the most
- 1:04:07physical media of these movies. Yeah. Or at least
- 1:04:10do now. I think by my count, I have five. of
- 1:04:14the 10 nominees that's half and it's very cool
- 1:04:17to be able to do this both you know 4k blu -ray
- 1:04:19dvd like split across that it's a lot of fun
- 1:04:22not just for the special features but also you
- 1:04:24know you ensure quality to these yeah the closed
- 1:04:27captioning is great and it's just fun to be able
- 1:04:29to contribute to that um how are you feeling
- 1:04:31about that year so far It's definitely been a
- 1:04:34mixed bag for me. Sure. But to kind of hype up
- 1:04:37the audience, we do have some cool stuff. I'm
- 1:04:38not going to go through the whole list of movies,
- 1:04:41but I will say some things to look forward to
- 1:04:43is you have Paul Muni returning in a role. We
- 1:04:47have not seen him since I Am a Fugitive from
- 1:04:49a Chain Gang, so that's very exciting. You have
- 1:04:52a Frank Capra film with Gary Cooper. Super cool
- 1:04:55to see that. The introduction of William Wyler.
- 1:04:59acclaimed film director that works a lot with
- 1:05:01betty davis we'll see them working together multiple
- 1:05:03times also he did ben hurt not none of that we'll
- 1:05:07be talking about but like it is a build -up to
- 1:05:08that yes um but also lots of william powell and
- 1:05:13myrna lloyd and i where we are in the season
- 1:05:17so far that's what i'm most excited about yeah
- 1:05:20i think um Without getting too into specifics,
- 1:05:23I think that we are in a rise. I think that previously
- 1:05:26I've talked about Wallace Beery and a number
- 1:05:28of people being like my favorite to see. I think
- 1:05:31that we will see a rise of that in this year
- 1:05:33that I'm really excited to get into. Rise, Lord
- 1:05:37Beery. Just expecting that actor that I'm talking
- 1:05:42about to Wallace Beery. They expect one of us
- 1:05:44in the Wreckage Brother. Oh, yeah. But yeah,
- 1:05:48looking forward to next year. So the schedule
- 1:05:51for that will be out very soon on the first of
- 1:05:54the month. First episode will be dropping September
- 1:05:562nd. That's a Wednesday. And we will be talking
- 1:05:59about the story of Louis Pasteur. Paul Muni,
- 1:06:03baby. But that's really going to do it for the
- 1:06:068th Academy Ceremony. We hope you guys have enjoyed
- 1:06:09the movies and are looking forward to the batch
- 1:06:12of 10. This is the last time we'll be doing these
- 1:06:14split month things as well. That's right. Things
- 1:06:17are just going to be more straightforward from
- 1:06:19here on out. This was the end of the 12 nominations.
- 1:06:23So we'll get back to 10. Which is why when you
- 1:06:25said Ruggles of Red Gap, I was like, that is
- 1:06:29a name I have not heard in a millennium. We are
- 1:06:33going back to 10. And it'll be pretty good to
- 1:06:35have that for another, I don't know. a seven
- 1:06:39years like half a year yeah yeah well half a
- 1:06:42year in real time for us right right for sure
- 1:06:43but that's gonna do it for this episode thank
- 1:06:46you guys so much i'm kyle i'm ryan and we'll
- 1:06:50see you at the movies