Latest / Energy Voice – Out Loud / Energy Voice Live: Powering Up the UK Energy Supply Chain in 2026
Transcript
- 0:00Good evening and welcome to Energy VOICE Life.
- 0:08I'm Erica Askland. I'm the news editor of Energy
- 0:11Voice. We are here in Aberdeen in front
- 0:15of a very good looking audience, speaking to a panel of energy
- 0:21industry leaders for this special episode of Energy Voice
- 0:25Out Loud, which will be available on your podcast
- 0:29channel of choice tomorrow evening.
- 0:33You are very welcome to Energy Voice Headquarters in the heart
- 0:37of the energy capital of Europe. This is the fourth such live
- 0:42podcast event, with previous recordings having taken place in
- 0:46Edinburgh and Hull, which we have done in partnership with
- 0:50D20. And so I'd like to say thanks to
- 0:52you for all your support, it's been great.
- 0:56Now we're back here in Aberdeen where all the cool kids are
- 0:59based, including my esteemed colleagues at the Press and
- 1:03Journal. And meanwhile, our neighbors in
- 1:05this building include the North Sea Transition Authority,
- 1:09Peterson, Great British Energy, who are at last able to confirm
- 1:13they are indeed moving downstairs.
- 1:16Our topic today is powering up the energy supply chain in 2026.
- 1:23And our guest tonight have all something very meaningful to say
- 1:27on this. Readers of Energy Voice will
- 1:31probably have heard news today that the latest report from the
- 1:36independent Just Transition Commission has given the
- 1:40Scottish and UK governments efforts to support the workforce
- 1:43that support the energy industry.
- 1:46A resounding bit of AD minus, I'd say maybe AD plus on a
- 1:49generous side. Of course, last year the same
- 1:52Commission was pretty damning of interventions in Grangemouth as
- 1:56well. So many here in the audience and
- 2:00our listeners out in the radiosphere are probably already
- 2:06feeling the truth of this latest report.
- 2:09We probably have for many years already.
- 2:12So I know at Energy Voice, whenever we write about this,
- 2:15whenever we write about jobs, whenever we write about pressure
- 2:18on the supply chain, kind of feel like the Trojan priestess
- 2:22Cassandra, and she's the one who was gifted by the gods with
- 2:27perfect foresight, but doomed that her warnings would be
- 2:32disbelieved or dismissed. Kind of feels like we're talking
- 2:35into a a a void sometimes. But we hope tonight for our
- 2:41audience here and our listeners out there that they will hear us
- 2:46and understand what our panel has to offer tonight.
- 2:50So without much further ado, I will welcome you up.
- 2:53Please take your seats and we'll hopefully order in the in the
- 2:57way that we have on the slides. So thanks ever so much.
- 3:03First, we have Neil Thompson, who's the Chief Executive of
- 3:06Hydra Sun, who are with D20, part of our sponsors tonight.
- 3:12Now, Neil was appointed chief executive of Hydra Sun and Creek
- 3:16recently, 2024. And that was just as SCF
- 3:19Partners announced it would combine its portfolio of
- 3:22services firms, including SCORE Group, Hydra Sun Fuel Cell
- 3:26Systems, Power Star Global E&C into a business specializing in
- 3:32decarbonization, D20. Now you started out there kind
- 3:37of a bit man and boy. You know you've been in the
- 3:39industry for 30 years. You joined the Hydra son in 2003
- 3:44and then were appointed Chief Commercial Officer 2015 and then
- 3:48Chief Operating Officer before your current role.
- 3:50And he has a track record of delivering major projects
- 3:54worldwide across a range of industries and has led the
- 3:57development and implementation of the company's own hydrogen
- 4:00strategy. More of this and on we also have
- 4:05David Marshall. He's Regional Director of
- 4:07Scotland and the North of England for national Gas.
- 4:11So he's in charge of leading the delivery of safe, reliable,
- 4:15efficient gas transmission across the region.
- 4:19He leads a multidisciplinary team which plays a critical role
- 4:23in maintaining EU KS energy security and supporting the
- 4:25transition to a low carbon future.
- 4:27And probably a little bit of hydrogen in there too, maybe if
- 4:30we're lucky. He brings extensive leadership
- 4:32experience from the oil and gas sector, having successfully
- 4:37managed complex assets in diverse and challenging
- 4:40environments of which many of us here are familiar, including
- 4:44Shetland Offshore and West of Africa.
- 4:48Then we have Jeff Curry. He's head of energy private
- 4:52equity at Piper Sandler, as well as being chief financial officer
- 4:57of D20. It's always good to have a money
- 4:59guy in the room. He joined Piper Sander in 2013
- 5:04and brings more than 25 years of international oil and gas
- 5:07industry experience, cross advisory, private equity and
- 5:11industry. He joined KPMG in 1987, went on
- 5:15to become a partner running their oil services M and A
- 5:18business until 2007. He was following that he was
- 5:22appointed as Chief Executive Officer of ITS energy services,
- 5:26an international provider of drilling equipment and services
- 5:29a pushed he held until 2012. Additional to his role with
- 5:33Piper Sandler, he's CFO at D20, as we said, adding his
- 5:37experience in industry, the blotter energy industry and the
- 5:41energy transition. Last but not least, we have Raji
- 5:45James, Chief Commercial Officer of the Port of Aberdeen.
- 5:49He joined the Port in October 2022 and leads it's marine
- 5:54operations across alongside its commercial business development,
- 5:58innovation activity lot going on there.
- 6:01He has more than 20 years experience in Cedar leadership
- 6:03positions within the energy marine sectors with previous
- 6:06roles at utility, ROV Services NC and Stork.
- 6:10So welcome to you all. Thank you very much for joining
- 6:13us. So what I will do is I'll start
- 6:20each of you off. You've got a minute or two.
- 6:22Tell us a little bit about yourselves.
- 6:25Now, we've also maybe going to be addressing this at some point
- 6:28during the evening. You know, we've heard the
- 6:30arguments about the tax burden in the North Sea.
- 6:32They're well rehearsed. Some say the decline in oil and
- 6:36gas will hasten transition to cleaner energy.
- 6:39Others say the decline which we see in everyday consolidation
- 6:42job losses is damaging the supply chain needed to deliver
- 6:46clean energy. Where are you on this?
- 6:48OK. Well, thank you.
- 6:49It's a quite a start to me. If you don't mind, I'd like to
- 6:53put a little bit of context into the room about about Hydra Sun
- 6:56because I think that maybe helps to answer the question.
- 6:58So Hydra Sun's 50 years old this year.
- 7:01So we're part of the fixtures and fixings, if you like, of the
- 7:04Northeast of Scotland. As a business, we service a
- 7:08range of different industrial sectors.
- 7:10So oil and gas is our heritage, but we've, as you rightly said
- 7:13earlier, we've made a play into energy transition and hydrogen.
- 7:17We are also involved in other clean energy sectors, nuclear in
- 7:20particular. Beyond that, general industrial
- 7:23and the marine sector. As a business, we've got
- 7:25operations to the UK in Europe and Caspian internationally.
- 7:30We have network partners in key target markets and we actually
- 7:33export to over 65 countries around the world.
- 7:35So provides a little bit of context to the business in terms
- 7:39of powering up the supply chain, which is the theme.
- 7:42And, and getting back to to where we're at, I think you
- 7:47know, everybody understands the context of where the North Sea
- 7:51is at in terms of the UK sector. And I think that is the the
- 7:55starting point of the conversation.
- 7:57There is a decoupling in oil and gas at the moment in terms of
- 8:01what's happening in the North Sea sector in in the UK versus
- 8:05other sectors around the world. And we've never seen that
- 8:08before. There's always been a debate
- 8:10about low cost oil versus, you know the North Sea basin, but
- 8:14what we see now is a difference in that a divergent in terms of
- 8:17what's going on in Norway and West Africa and Brazil versus
- 8:21what's going on in our own North Sea.
- 8:24So from a hydrogen perspective, in terms of powering up the
- 8:27supply chain, our key themes, if you like, are looking at the
- 8:31energy transition and looking at viable projects where we can
- 8:35play. And I think the viable is really
- 8:37important in that context. We're looking at
- 8:40internationalizing the business further from an oil and gas
- 8:42point of view because we see opportunities there and we're
- 8:46looking at diversification where we can see those opportunities
- 8:50in in industrial, in marine sectors and other clean energy
- 8:53sectors. And absolutely the corner of
- 8:57that is delivery to our core customers, both here, existing
- 9:00customers, but around the world. So that's how we see how we try
- 9:05and power ourselves through this situation.
- 9:08But I think we shouldn't take anything for granted that the
- 9:11situation is really challenging. Hydra Sun is a bellwether for
- 9:15the industry. We're the first to come down if
- 9:18spend comes off and we're the first to come back when spend
- 9:21comes back, the nature of products and services that we
- 9:24have to offer. So that's where we see the
- 9:26situation at the moment. As a business it is challenging
- 9:30but we see opportunities. Unfortunately a lot of those
- 9:33opportunities are out with the UK and that has implications for
- 9:37jobs, it has implications for the UK economy.
- 9:41Yeah, very good. Well, thank you very much.
- 9:43Now, David, he's got 65 different international markets.
- 9:47You've just got one. But that said, you've got big
- 9:50plans and huge investment and it kind of seems like gas is going
- 9:54to be here to stay despite maybe what we've heard.
- 9:56Yeah, very much so. So I guess my career journey is
- 10:00a bit like what we're trying to do with the supply chain here in
- 10:03Aberdeen. So I was with upstream oil and
- 10:05gas for the vast majority of my career and seven months ago I
- 10:08moved across international gas and national gas is the main gas
- 10:13distribution network for the UK. So we've got over 5000 miles of
- 10:17high pressure pipeline that takes the gas from places like
- 10:20St. Fergus up in the north of
- 10:22Scotland all the way through the UK.
- 10:25We tap into over 30 power stations and we provide the gas
- 10:30to the distribution networks that feed into 23 million homes
- 10:33across the country. And the reason why I say it's a
- 10:36little bit of an opportunity for us at the minute is that we've
- 10:39we've moved into a regional structure.
- 10:41So right, my remit is setting up the the Scotland North of
- 10:44England region. And I've got pretty much a blank
- 10:47page on that. And one of the elements that
- 10:49we're looking at is how do we engage local supply chain?
- 10:53And historically we've found it very difficult to compete with
- 10:57oil and gas operators. But now as that side of the
- 11:00business or sector kind of slows down, then the supply chain's
- 11:04looking for diversification and we're sticking our hands up and
- 11:07saying, yeah, all those skills that you've got are really,
- 11:10really mis synergistic to what we're trying to do.
- 11:15We've got a, we've just got a five year investment program
- 11:18approved by Ofgem. So we work as part of a
- 11:21regulated industry and we're going to be investing
- 11:24multibillion pounds into the gas network for methane transmission
- 11:29over the next five years. And a lot of that, as I said, is
- 11:33very transferable. We're working with supply chain
- 11:36companies here, some of them sitting and the benches beside
- 11:41me are represented. And as Erica said, then there is
- 11:45that longer term future. So methane's going to be here
- 11:47for decades to come. I think that we can all agree
- 11:49that in this room, but we're looking to diversify into what
- 11:53we call our three molecule strategies.
- 11:55That's methane, it's hydrogen and it's CO2 in the form of CCS.
- 12:00We've got live projects running on off those scopes and our
- 12:05business models all around. How can we repurpose our assets
- 12:09to facilitate that transition into different energy transition
- 12:14technologies? And where we can't repurpose,
- 12:17where do we rebuild? But we think that we've got that
- 12:19highway, that network of pipeline systems that will
- 12:22connect future producers and customers of those transition
- 12:27fuels. Jeff, what is your view on this?
- 12:31You're the 1 putting your money where your mouth is and backing
- 12:33the supply chain. So tell us a little bit about
- 12:36that. And what do you see?
- 12:37It's still attractive in that market.
- 12:40Thanks Erica. So firstly I should correct you
- 12:4425 years should read 40 years but.
- 12:49I'm I'm surprised I couldn't possibly.
- 12:51Yeah, but I am, I'm very, what do you call it, plea that you
- 12:56think it's only 25 years. So 40 years of a career that
- 13:00really started in 1987 in this city and 40 years, 40 years, I
- 13:06wouldn't bore you with 40 years of what I did, but 40 years with
- 13:11three different perspectives. First, as an M&A advisor, you
- 13:15know, doing a lot of deals for KPMG, Hydra Sun, I did 2 deals
- 13:21for Hydra Sun in my time at KPMG.
- 13:23So I know it really well then as a, as a in industry once.
- 13:30Now back again with D20 and then in between as an investor, one
- 13:36of my 360 colleagues here, Matthew, is in the room where we
- 13:41are the major investor in 360 Energy.
- 13:44But they all have common threads.
- 13:46So first thread is Aberdeen, and I say that as a Malaysian who's
- 13:52made Aberdeen my home. Aberdeen has got fantastic
- 13:57skills when it goes overseas and I've travelled the world with my
- 14:01role, my roles. Everywhere I go people talk
- 14:06about the Nazi experience everywhere I go, you know,
- 14:09whether it was as CEO or whether it was as investor.
- 14:14Wherever I go people talk about the Nazi experience and it's,
- 14:18and it's always what you call it, disappointed me that we've
- 14:24never really capitalized on this.
- 14:27I think Aberdeen is the centre of excellence.
- 14:29So that's thread #1 threat number 2 is, you know, it's
- 14:35quite simple really what we are trying to do at D20.
- 14:39You know, we are trying to diversify, we are trying to use
- 14:42our skill sets to actually diversify into other sectors.
- 14:47Gas is a key market, you know, through our gas turbines in in
- 14:54school, Hydra, Sun Neil's already mentioned hydrogen.
- 14:59We are into the power sector to our power star business, you
- 15:02know, but I describe it, you know, I'm a simple guy.
- 15:06I describe it as hub and spoke right.
- 15:09The hub is here. We have in the Nazi, we've got
- 15:14really good skills. So how do we use these skill
- 15:18sets to actually diversify into markets where they are valued
- 15:23And that's what the D20 model is about.
- 15:28And then thirdly, I think the North Sea has got, you know,
- 15:33good opportunities in certain markets.
- 15:37And I think about it as this is a transition, not a Big Bang.
- 15:45So because it's a transition and because we've got to be
- 15:49responsible in how we deliver the oil and gas product, we
- 15:55should do that. But at the same time, we should
- 15:57use the funds that we create from the North Sea to actually
- 16:03develop our diversified diversification strategies into
- 16:07other markets. And that's what we're doing.
- 16:09So it's very simple, fantastic skill sets in Aberdeen,
- 16:14diversification into other sectors where we can use that
- 16:18skill sets, grow oil and gas as much as we can to use that as
- 16:22the funds to make the transition because it is what it's all
- 16:26about, energy and we need energy to power this country and the
- 16:30world actually. And so that's my perspective on
- 16:34on it. I think that is definitely
- 16:36sounds like the map. I'm just wondering if that's the
- 16:38territory, but we'll explain explore that a little bit more
- 16:42as we go on. Roddy, you also, you know, being
- 16:46the man in charge of one of probably the NE greatest assets,
- 16:53you don't really do a lot of export markets either, but you
- 16:56also contribute so much to the industry as well as our outlook
- 17:00on the world. So tell us a little bit about
- 17:03what you're thinking of here. Personally, the same as Jeff,
- 17:05you said 20 years, it's 30. 30I I'm getting on my maths, yeah
- 17:10wrong though. Damn.
- 17:11Absolutely. And I.
- 17:13Guess for those I haven't spoken to before, I always start with
- 17:15the fact we're Britain's oldest business, being around for
- 17:18almost 900 years and very much anchored in the the City and
- 17:22I'll use as many port puns as I can with anchoring.
- 17:26We're also the largest passage port in Scotland, 7.4 kilometres
- 17:30and we handle around about 45% of all Scotland's commercial
- 17:34traffic, which equates to about 7000 vessels a year.
- 17:39We also operate in a number of key segments.
- 17:42So energy is obviously our biggest market, it's about 60%
- 17:46of our business at the moment. Cargo and general trade are the
- 17:50other areas as well as the ferries to the Northern Isles
- 17:53which most of you have seen. And also we have a rapidly
- 17:56growing cruise market that's been generated by adding S
- 18:01harbour to the the portfolio. And I guess from the ports
- 18:05perspective the debates absolutely isn't theoretical.
- 18:08You know, we see the impact of the policy, the investment
- 18:13confidence and the base and maturity every single day.
- 18:16On the key side for us, we're often referred to as a
- 18:20barometer. And I think when we spoke before
- 18:22we talked about that because we actually connect the the onshore
- 18:26activities to the offshore projects.
- 18:29And I guess in the past, historically our growth has very
- 18:32much come from North Sea oil and gas activity and that's built a
- 18:36lot of the infrastructure we have down there.
- 18:38It's the whole marine ecosystem as well as the the whole piece
- 18:43about the skills workforce that we see out of Aberdeen.
- 18:48And I guess it's that workforce that and what we're here to talk
- 18:52about today is exactly what underpins the new energies that
- 18:56we'll see going forward. The offshore wind sub seal
- 18:58application, the the carbon capture piece and I guess the
- 19:04arguments around tax burdens accelerating has very real
- 19:09consequences for us. We've absolutely seen that.
- 19:12Most of you have read last year 15% of our workforce we had to
- 19:17make redundant last year. And that's very much as a
- 19:19consequence of what we're seeing from a a taxation and a fiscal
- 19:23policy side of things. But it's not all bad news
- 19:27because I think what we have here in Aberdeen is very much
- 19:30world class supply chain, the wall I'm sure touch on it all
- 19:35the the skills we have, the expertise and also the
- 19:38entrepreneurial spirit that most of the companies have here,
- 19:41which spreads out around the globe.
- 19:43We actually transact with about 40 different countries we export
- 19:47to out of Aberdeen and that's mainly from the oil and gas
- 19:51piece that we're seeing. So we're as keen as every
- 19:54anybody to make sure that we we hold on to that and make sure
- 19:58it's nurtured for the next energy that's coming up.
- 20:00Thank you. So we will continue on this
- 20:04discussion a little bit towards the end.
- 20:07We will be taking questions of this panel.
- 20:10So I hope you're here all prepared.
- 20:13But I think what we'll do is we'll maybe start a little bit
- 20:18more David, National Gas. Let's talk a little bit more
- 20:24about opportunities in your supply chain, the ease with
- 20:28which you know, the oil and gas supply chain can plug in to the
- 20:34gas network. And then maybe also touch on
- 20:40there's still some challenges. There's, you know, you, I think
- 20:44the Project Union Hydrogen network is getting progress and
- 20:47traction, but maybe the Carbon Park pipeline up to Saint Fergus
- 20:51is still a little bit of a mystery.
- 20:54But how are you seeing progress from here to there when it comes
- 21:00to transition projects and important transition projects?
- 21:03Yeah. So I guess just firstly then on
- 21:05the the methane side of things in, in terms of what we're doing
- 21:08and how we're engaging with the supply chain.
- 21:10So a lot of what we do is, is very similar to what the the
- 21:14activities that are happening offshore are.
- 21:16So we've got gas compressors, we've got pipes, we've got
- 21:19valves, all those type of skill sets are transferable across.
- 21:25So we're looking at companies that can provide EPC services to
- 21:29us, construction, fabrication valves, all of the electrical
- 21:34kind of maintenance activities as well.
- 21:37So a lot of that is very common between what we're doing on our
- 21:40methane side of things and what happens traditionally with the
- 21:44upstream oil and gas. The real benefit that we're
- 21:47seeing is that it's local workforce.
- 21:50So if we need to get somebody to site quickly, we're able to
- 21:52mobilize somebody from the northeast of Scotland, as I
- 21:55said, rather than bringing somebody up from the South of
- 21:57England. And equally, if I've got a
- 21:59problem, I can call somebody up in Aberdeen and say, come and
- 22:02deal with this and we'll have boots on the ground that same
- 22:05day as well. And we can kind of resolve any
- 22:07problems that we're seeing in terms of the the new project.
- 22:11So we are very much in the early stages of Project Union, which
- 22:15is our hydrogen project and we're we're stepping into the
- 22:18feed stages of that. So we have got funding that's
- 22:21been granted for that. And in terms of the the CCS
- 22:25project, it's a linkage into the Acorn project and we called
- 22:28Scott Connect, which is the pipeline up from Grangemouth up
- 22:32to Saint Fergus as well. And again, we're working with
- 22:34the UK and Scottish Government to get that funding across the
- 22:37line to allow us to get into detailed engineering this year.
- 22:42And a lot of it is around repurposing of infrastructure
- 22:46that we've already got. So as the gas flows from Saint
- 22:48Fergus have declined over over time, we don't have pipeline
- 22:52capacity available to flip pipelines across to those new
- 22:56products. Where we can, we will do that.
- 22:58And we're doing an an awful lot of engineering to make sure that
- 23:01the pipes will have that integrity and the the fitness
- 23:05for service that we require for decades to come.
- 23:09Things like bringing in new gas compressors, that's the type of
- 23:11engagement that we're doing at the minute with the engineering
- 23:14companies and our supply chain as well.
- 23:16Now, one of the interesting things I think about National
- 23:20Gas and its investment is it's trialling, injecting hydrogen
- 23:25into the gas system. You know, the lovely explosions
- 23:30going on at spade, Adam, which you're not allowing anyone to
- 23:32see. Sounds like lots of fun, but I
- 23:35think to a certain extent it underpins that.
- 23:39There's definitely a hydrogen economy on the way.
- 23:44Umm, there's some people who kind of talk about hydrogen
- 23:47being the equivalent of pouring champagne down your toilet.
- 23:51Umm, I don't know. It's a, it's a weird kind of
- 23:53comp, uh, comparison, but maybe tell us a little bit, Neil,
- 23:57about where you see hydrogen in the energy mix and what, what
- 24:03are you playing for? Well, it's definitely changed
- 24:06over time. There's no question that the the
- 24:08market scale is not what it was forecast to be.
- 24:12If you go back three or four years ago.
- 24:15Some of that's driven by changing government policy.
- 24:19I think Scotland has been particularly hit by that and to
- 24:23desness and HAR one round where there was a change in stance and
- 24:27how they viewed the distillery market could be decarbonized and
- 24:31that really affected the Cromartie project and that
- 24:36changing policy landscape really deters investment.
- 24:41So that's a huge challenge for the sector.
- 24:44The shape of these HAR 1, HAR 2 project requirements requires 15
- 24:50year off take agreements. So it really requires long term
- 24:54commitment. And again, I don't think the
- 24:57government has really thought through that.
- 25:00There's two sides to that equation.
- 25:01There's obviously the the developer who's producing the
- 25:05gas, but equally there is the recipient who has got to sign up
- 25:09to that agreement and has to make changes to their
- 25:12infrastructure to be able to receive the hydrogen into into
- 25:17their side of the business. And that's not covered by the
- 25:19funding in in the HAR 1 allocation.
- 25:23So I think from a Scotland point of view, it's a tough place to
- 25:26be at the moment. If I look at it more broadly in
- 25:30the UK, there are HAR One projects progressing, there's
- 25:35eleven you're going at the moment.
- 25:37Whether they all get through FID remains to be seen.
- 25:40We're actively involved in four of those at the moment in terms
- 25:45of in terms of quoting them, they're they're in England,
- 25:48there's a project in Scotland that's not hard related that
- 25:51we're looking at at the moment. And we see in Europe that there
- 25:54is progress being made in Europe as well.
- 25:57The market has changed and I think to the one of the benefits
- 26:00of the market changing is that the with the bubble, if you like
- 26:04bursting that what projects are more likely to come now to
- 26:08fruition are realistic. And I think from a supply chain
- 26:12point of view, the real challenge in hydrogen certainly
- 26:15up until now is the amount of effort you put in to then find
- 26:19that the project actually doesn't go ahead.
- 26:21So it's difficult enough to win a project, anybody in the supply
- 26:25chain knows that, but then to put that effort in and then the
- 26:28project doesn't go ahead, you know, so the cost of opportunity
- 26:31acquisition becomes untenable. So I think that's a real
- 26:35challenge for the the hydrogen sector going forward.
- 26:39Where does it play? You know, there's obviously
- 26:41there's lots being written. I think from a hydrogen point of
- 26:44view, our position is that we're high pressure gas specialists,
- 26:48whether it's methane, hydrogen or another gas.
- 26:51So that's why we're in it. We're, we're not here to to try
- 26:55and portray hydrogen as being a solution to everything.
- 26:57We're just here to say there's a market segment and if it's there
- 27:00and it's viable, we want to play in it and be successful in it.
- 27:05I think it's a long slow burn is the reality of it.
- 27:08In terms of where the market will go.
- 27:11It feels like from a mobility point of view, that's going to
- 27:14be much more construction, heavy duty vehicle orientated.
- 27:18That's certainly, you know, where Europe's going.
- 27:20That's where we see funding in the UK going into the
- 27:23construction sector. The Thames Crossing for example
- 27:27is a good example of that. And certainly in the in Scotland
- 27:32where we see the grid upgrades companies are looking at the
- 27:35construction side of that and looking at how they can
- 27:38decarbonize their construction vehicles through the use of
- 27:42hydrogen. So, so there will be
- 27:43opportunities there. It will not be to the scale that
- 27:47was once thought. And I think you when I talked
- 27:50last year at the master class in Aberdeen, I, I put that view
- 27:54into the room and I said to to the supply chain in the room,
- 27:57this is not going to replace the North Sea.
- 28:00Nobody should even think that that is the case.
- 28:04But there, there are potential opportunities there.
- 28:07Right now, however, what you see is a consolidation of the
- 28:10market, a reduction in the number of manufacturers playing
- 28:13in the market, a reduction in the number of developers and
- 28:17therefore a reduction in the supply chain, but hopefully out
- 28:20of that a more realistic market. Realism doesn't sound very
- 28:23exciting, but at least you know it's something we can count.
- 28:26On well, it, I think, I think, I think that's what we need
- 28:29though. I think we need realistic policy
- 28:32that gives certainty for investors that allows the supply
- 28:36chain to understand what the future of that market segment is
- 28:39and therefore whether they want to invest in it and where they
- 28:42want to participate in it. What we don't want is, you know,
- 28:46changing policy all of the time. You know, we're changing prime
- 28:50ministers in an annual basis. We're changing energy ministers
- 28:53all of the time. It's no wonder we don't have a
- 28:57stable policy environment from an energy perspective.
- 29:01But that's what we need. We need that in hydrogen as much
- 29:04as we need it in oil and gas as much as we need it in wind.
- 29:07Now, Jeff, you've already admitted that you've been around
- 29:11for a little bit longer. You've seen a bit of boom and
- 29:16bust. You've seen some of these
- 29:18investment cycles. Have you ever seen on industry
- 29:24so hamstrung by government policy and how much does that
- 29:29piss you off? A lot.
- 29:31There we go. No, I mean in all, in all
- 29:34honesty, a lot of what Neil said I would concur with, you know
- 29:40what do investors? Well, let me come back to your
- 29:43cyclical point. Investors could cope with
- 29:47cyclicality because they build it into their models, but what
- 29:52they cannot cope with is uncertain fiscal policy, right?
- 29:56Because you don't know, you come in as an investor, you come in
- 30:00and you adopt. If it's an oil and gas, you take
- 30:03a much oil and gas upstream. So for the operators, you take a
- 30:07much longer time horizon. Your investment horizon is much
- 30:12longer. You're doing because of
- 30:14everything that's going on, even in a private equity context, if
- 30:18you're coming in with, if you're investing in a service company,
- 30:21typically it used to be 5 years, but because of the because of
- 30:26what's happened since 2014, it's been longer.
- 30:31Now what do you invest? Is that cyclicality point you
- 30:35can cope with? I've never seen it this bad.
- 30:40But I think where there's where there's difficulty, there's
- 30:45opportunity, right? So consolidation is definitely
- 30:49an opportunity. Diversification is an
- 30:52opportunity because what do investors really look for,
- 30:55right? They look for quality management
- 30:58teams who can drive the business into growth because it's all
- 31:04about growth and they can generate good returns from that
- 31:10growth. So, you know, whether it's in
- 31:14energy transition hasn't gone away, energy transition is just
- 31:18paused, you know, or, or pausing in certain cases.
- 31:23I don't think it's paused. I think it's pausing in certain
- 31:26places. This morning I was at a meeting
- 31:29where, you know, where in the US, we've heard a lot about
- 31:35offshore wind licenses being pulled back, but the onshore
- 31:40wind market is thriving. So this contact of mine was
- 31:44telling me because there's a lot of ONM work that, you know,
- 31:49plays to the onshore wind market.
- 31:53And therefore, where did those skills come from?
- 31:55It comes from the Nazi. That's what they're doing.
- 31:58So I think that's opportunity. I think that's opportunity for
- 32:04us to use our skills to diversify.
- 32:07There's a wall of money out there and they don't know where
- 32:11to put it because because oil and gas went out, there was a
- 32:17big push into energy transition. That's kind of pausing paused,
- 32:24you know, so it's slower, it's going to take time.
- 32:27And so they are looking for opportunities where you've got
- 32:30good management teams who are driving growth in the business.
- 32:34And it doesn't matter so much today whether those businesses
- 32:39have come from oil and gas. You know, three years or four
- 32:43years ago, if you said the word oil and gas, it would be a
- 32:47really dirty word in investment circles.
- 32:50Sure. And it's not anymore.
- 32:52It's coming back a little bit. It's coming back and
- 32:54diversification takes both industry as well as geography.
- 32:59So I think it's up to us in the room, managers in the room to
- 33:06actually drive the growth. And I think cyclicality is not
- 33:11an issue you build into, you build into your investment case
- 33:15that cyclicality point, you know.
- 33:18So anyway, that's all by answer. Question.
- 33:22So you're, you're outraged, but still very measured in your
- 33:25discussion, which is very good and really useful to have that.
- 33:29So we'll get you more on that later.
- 33:30But Roddy, I think, you know, you might even beat Jeff with
- 33:36your 900 years as a port operator.
- 33:39You're younger. You're younger, not personally
- 33:42obviously, but interestingly, you know, we've seen the port
- 33:50put like lots of money into S Harbour and you know, now you're
- 33:56also kind of building in the potential for future fuels for
- 34:02marine and electrification for boats, even though that's
- 34:07probably a bit more expensive than actually just fueling up
- 34:09with diesel. But maybe that's, well, we'll
- 34:12wait till that happens. But surprisingly entrepreneurial
- 34:17happenings over at the port. So how are you though deciding
- 34:21where to place your bets? Well, I guess, yeah, if we we
- 34:24look at the 400 million investment that we did or 420
- 34:28million, that was all about diversification and that was all
- 34:32about, but not specifically diversification into other
- 34:35segments. It was all about coping for
- 34:37larger oil and gas vessels. Because this decision was taken
- 34:412012 when our board put together the plan for what they were
- 34:45looking to do, which was a huge, huge step for a board that this
- 34:49was effectively 12 times the turnover of the port at that
- 34:53time. So it was a a massive
- 34:55investment. And I guess what that did was it
- 34:59did a number of things, but it, it really, it's a huge tick in
- 35:03the box for confidence for what Aberdeen in the northeast is for
- 35:07the, for the energy industry, Not just for energy, but for
- 35:11some of the other segments that we we, we play in now too.
- 35:14And I guess we kind of did a almost like a health check of
- 35:18all the different segments that we're looking at.
- 35:20So, you know, what can we do in the, we knew declining basin tax
- 35:25burdens, all these sort of things which were putting North
- 35:27Sea under pressure. So we then started looking at
- 35:30how we can look at other markets within those segments.
- 35:32So if we look at oil and gas, if you go down there today, you'll
- 35:35see 3 Jack UPS sat in the port. You know three years ago before
- 35:39we had S Harbour, you just wouldn't have seen that.
- 35:41So we're able to pull in some some different.
- 35:44So that's part of our diversification strategy.
- 35:46The other areas, cargo trade, you know, we want to open up the
- 35:51hinterland in and around the port for the North East instead
- 35:54of most of the traffic going down either down South or even
- 35:59further afield into Europe before it's dispersed around the
- 36:02globe. We'd like to do that here.
- 36:04We've got a world class facility, it's got the
- 36:06capabilities to be able to do that.
- 36:07So we're using the infrastructure that's been built
- 36:10up over the years to diversify the port's portfolio.
- 36:14And we have spin off businesses too, like cruise for instance, 3
- 36:18years ago I think we had 17 cruise vessels.
- 36:22Yeah, last year we had 65. This year we got 73.
- 36:25And it's just, and that's not about the port, it's about
- 36:28what's inland, you know, whether it's Balmoral, whether it's
- 36:32spending money in Aberdeen City centre.
- 36:33All these things will help the the the community to to look at
- 36:37diversification from a different way.
- 36:39I used to always hear people talk about diversification for
- 36:46the city in the region and how, you know, when it was a downturn
- 36:51in the 80s or something like that, and they'd go to the City
- 36:54Council and say, oh, you got to help us out here.
- 36:57And then the City Council would say, well, sorry, you know, when
- 37:00we came to you and asked you for widening out a little bit, you
- 37:04know, you weren't listening because it was all oil and gas.
- 37:08Are we actually diversifying now into something that isn't so
- 37:13heavily reliant on one area and still energy though?
- 37:17I mean, maybe from your point of view, because you're quite
- 37:19connected to the city and the Shire.
- 37:22No, absolutely. And it's, you know, we, we don't
- 37:25talk about transition anymore because if you look at the
- 37:28history of the port, you know, 60 years ago there was no oil
- 37:31and gas. It was all about fishing.
- 37:33Prior to that it was shipbuilding or it was textiles
- 37:36or it was farms. So it, it's a natural thing over
- 37:39the history of a, an area that you will get into different
- 37:42industries. And what we say is it's not
- 37:44about transitioning now it's, it's, it's a restructuring.
- 37:47So you're restructuring on how you can get business and where
- 37:50it comes from. And and we're trying to use all
- 37:52the assets that the port has to be able to do that.
- 37:55Now I was going to focus maybe a little more on Neil.
- 38:00What do you expect to see? Do you see have any expectations
- 38:05for the Scottish Government elections for example?
- 38:09In in what respect? Well, maybe good news.
- 38:11Are you expecting any good news maybe to emerge from that or are
- 38:15you? We didn't refuse one news.
- 38:19Absolutely. Yeah.
- 38:20Yeah. OK.
- 38:23I don't see that landscape changing hugely.
- 38:26I think obviously the, you know, the outcome of the election and
- 38:29whether the SNP has a majority or whether they're in a
- 38:32coalition with the Greens will have implications for their
- 38:36energy policy. I dare say it has in the past.
- 38:41Ultimately the money sits in the real policy decision sits at
- 38:45Westminster from from my perspective, both in terms of
- 38:48oil and gas and in terms of of hydrogen and clean energy.
- 38:53So I don't have huge expectations for the elections
- 38:58in all honesty, to be fair, to be said.
- 39:01I think really we need to see what comes out of out of UK
- 39:06policy, you know, after the the May elections and whether
- 39:10there's any change there. And that could go either way
- 39:12depending on how the government pivots, whether it pivots more
- 39:16to the left, whether it pivots more central, we don't know.
- 39:20But I think that is of more more relevant I think to to this part
- 39:25of the world in terms of what what happens next.
- 39:27How about you, David? Are you looking for anything
- 39:30particular to come out of either Scottish Government elections or
- 39:35maybe a shift in policy from Westminster that might enable
- 39:42this industry to thrive a little bit more?
- 39:45Not really in terms of the election results to be honest.
- 39:47I I think that what we're doing. You guys could skip the Scottish
- 39:51questions. Yeah, I'll leave this on, David.
- 39:53I, I think what we're trying to do is just work with whoever's
- 39:56in, in power at the minute just to, to try and, yeah, highlight
- 40:01the, the critical requirements that our energy infrastructure
- 40:05continues to bring for the nation and the required
- 40:08investment in that. And that kind of longer term
- 40:11picture. So we're investing over a five
- 40:12year window as part of this regulatory period.
- 40:16But our hydrogen project and and the CCS projects are much, much
- 40:20longer project as well. So it's not really that kind of
- 40:23short term focus that we've got, but just making sure that we're
- 40:28sharing the good news that we're trying to do and trying to work
- 40:30past that. And I know that, you know,
- 40:34clean, Clean Power 2030 is kind of saying that it's not going to
- 40:41be gas power in the energy mix, although that it will, you know
- 40:47that the number, the amount of it kind of sends tends to shift
- 40:50over time. Do you have a clearer view on
- 40:52where gas is going to be in Clean Power 20-30?
- 40:54You must have a thought about that or two.
- 40:57Yeah. So as I said, we we see gas
- 41:00being around in the energy mix for decades to come.
- 41:03And I think that we need to look at how we decarbonize and how we
- 41:07decarbonize those end users. And that very much fits into the
- 41:11hydrogen projects that we're looking at where hydrogen would
- 41:13be a substitute for those hard to decarbonize industries and
- 41:19CCS where we have got big industry as well.
- 41:22We're looking at capturing that that CO2 and piping it up as
- 41:26part of the Acorn project. So it's very much part of the
- 41:29the mix and we just need to make sure that we're pressing all
- 41:32three ahead. But I think you have decades to
- 41:35come for the the methane side of the business, certainly.
- 41:37We're still building new gas plants, apparently, so that
- 41:40might be something to consider. Jeff, you were nodding.
- 41:43Are you kind of keen on seeing more gas plants, even if they
- 41:46have CCS? That would be good, wouldn't it?
- 41:48Just want to feed your head perhaps?
- 41:50Yeah. I mean, what do I say to that?
- 41:55Firstly, I think there's a bit to learn from the Norwegian
- 41:58model. So the Norwegian model, being
- 42:02the preeminent gas supplier to the European continent is
- 42:08something we should learn from. You know, they're doing it in a
- 42:11responsible way. You know, they went
- 42:13electrification, they electrified their platforms
- 42:16years and years ago. I think that's the second thing
- 42:19we could learn from them. But in a because SCO is involved
- 42:24in gas turbines I'm told, and I don't have the exact stat so
- 42:30forgive me if I'm wrong, but it's a multi year backlog for
- 42:36getting a new gas turbine. I mean, that tells you something
- 42:41about the demand for gas because it's not gas or wind or solar or
- 42:49or hydrogen. It is oil and gas and
- 42:54renewables. That's what we need to work to.
- 42:57And I don't understand why this is so difficult to understand.
- 43:02You know, we've got a huge demand, oil, oil and gas is
- 43:06rising. The demand for oil and gas is
- 43:08rising. We've got a huge.
- 43:11We can't live without oil and gas.
- 43:13You know, for those of you that attended the Scottish Energy
- 43:18Forum dinner on Friday night last week in Edinburgh.
- 43:22Very interesting. Very interesting, interesting.
- 43:24And Philip Lambert, Lamberts Lambert speech where he spoke
- 43:30about 80% of each and every one of us here today, 80% of our
- 43:37needs, our power needs is, is from oil and gas.
- 43:43That tells you something about where we need to be.
- 43:47And that's what I think the politicians need to think about
- 43:52and support it because we've got significant resource here to,
- 43:57to, you know, to serve our needs and reduce our decarbonisation
- 44:03rather than, you know, importing it and paying, I forget the
- 44:09stats. Is it 7 times?
- 44:10Is it, it doesn't matter 7 times emissions by importing it.
- 44:15It's just crazy. So why is it so difficult?
- 44:19I don't understand that. Yeah, I understand too.
- 44:24I'm going to ask you about LNG, David.
- 44:27Is that something that, I mean, I don't, we don't have any in
- 44:29our geography. So it's maybe a little bit out
- 44:32of your purview, but National Gas has LNG terminals.
- 44:36Yeah, absolutely. So we've got LNG terminals in
- 44:39Wales, Milford Haven and also at we take it from the the Isle of
- 44:43Grain as well. So those are two key supply
- 44:49supplies into our national infrastructure now.
- 44:52And as I said, in the past, the, the main kind of dominant supply
- 44:56source was the North Sea virus in Fergus.
- 44:59But now we've got much more of an even split between Androids
- 45:04and Fergus, which has got a lot of Norwegian gas in it and then
- 45:07the two LNG terminals further South in the country as well.
- 45:10And and between those that that provides the the nation's energy
- 45:14needs from a gas perspective. I hope I wasn't talking against
- 45:17your business model. We're we're agnostic as to where
- 45:21the gas comes from. We just move it around.
- 45:22I. Just need some gas.
- 45:24Yeah, very good. OK, now I am tempted to open up
- 45:29to the audience for some questions.
- 45:33We have someone with a mic who, if you are able to wait until
- 45:38someone with a mic comes to you, then I will also maybe ask if
- 45:43you tell us who you are and what your question is, if you're
- 45:46willing to do so knowing that this is going to be broadcast.
- 45:49Although no images, so it's just a voice.
- 45:51So you can be a little bit anonymous that way.
- 45:56Any questions first for any brave spoke there?
- 46:02Ah, Finlay, Mike is coming your way.
- 46:06Thank you very much. Thank you.
- 46:07Finlay Anderson, Head of Corporate at Gilson Gray
- 46:10Solicitors. Question for Jeff.
- 46:13Jeff, you talked about consolidation and
- 46:15diversification being two big responses to the current
- 46:19challenge. Totally agree.
- 46:21It feels like consolidation is is very much Auk focused model
- 46:29of of driving economic viability, particularly for the
- 46:33bigger players. You can name a whole bunch of
- 46:34names in the last couple of months who have responded to the
- 46:36last budget by doing exactly that.
- 46:39Diversification in from Auk perspective feels very, very
- 46:44challenged for all the reasons that you've discussed about
- 46:47government policy, access to grid, access to infrastructure,
- 46:52the the speed of change in our grid and infrastructure
- 46:56etcetera, versus international diversification, which is where
- 46:59we see the huge growth opportunities.
- 47:02That in itself is a huge challenge because it's it
- 47:06encourages the supply chain to look internationally and look
- 47:08abroad when we really need it to be.
- 47:12We need to find solutions for here.
- 47:13I wonder how you feel about all that.
- 47:16So there are several parts of that question.
- 47:20So consolidation, when I was referring to consolidation, yes,
- 47:24upstream oil and gas and operators, it's, it's a, it's a
- 47:31classic way for them to actually get their returns because of the
- 47:36fiscal regime and the impact that, you know, the fiscal
- 47:40regime is having on tax and, and cost base and all that good
- 47:46stuff. But there's also consolidation
- 47:48in the service sector. And so, you know, given the
- 47:52topic for today, I was also referring to the service sector.
- 47:56So that's one thing I would say, I think, you know, consolidation
- 48:01gives you more critical mass and ability to actually execute your
- 48:10strategy in, in what you call it in controlled way.
- 48:15So at D20, why did SCF put these businesses together?
- 48:19You know, yes, the overall strategy was decarbonization
- 48:23diversification. It started off as as brown to
- 48:28green, it's now brown to growth because growth that I said
- 48:33earlier is the driver for investment returns.
- 48:37So, and then if you look, we've done in the last two years,
- 48:42we've done 7 acquisitions and we did 5 in in in 2025.
- 48:51And if you look at those, if you look at those investments, 2 had
- 48:59USUS, what do you call it? Connect.
- 49:05It was connected to the US market, but they were in gas
- 49:08turbines. We invested in another business
- 49:11in minerals for EV and electrification.
- 49:19We invested in a business for hydro sun to drive industrial,
- 49:25more Southern England industrial.
- 49:28So you know, they are just examples, examples of what we
- 49:32are trying to do, you know in our own small way trying to do
- 49:37in with regards diversification because diversification, the
- 49:40more diverse we are, the less susceptible we are to the
- 49:45vagaries of 1 market. So again, I will say we're not
- 49:52clever people, we're just practical people trying to do
- 49:56the simple stuff well. And if we do the simple stuff,
- 49:59well, you know, hopefully we'll make some money and deliver some
- 50:03return for our shareholders. But it's not rocket science,
- 50:07it's common sense. Common sense.
- 50:11It's a word that I, I'm very kind of suspicious of, but I
- 50:14think actually also Finley, you know, brought up this
- 50:19interesting point and, and I'm wondering if Neil has something
- 50:23to say. And, you know, it was something
- 50:25that, you know, we've been kind of talking on already.
- 50:28And I hear so many people saying, well, everywhere that
- 50:31there's an energy industry around the world, you'll hear,
- 50:35uh, an Aberdonian accent. Umm, and you know, we so much
- 50:38accustomed to it. And I think actually they're all
- 50:40working for Hydrasen in 65 different international markets.
- 50:45Umm, but I mean, are we, uh, doing ourselves, doing the UKA
- 50:51disservice by sending our best people, you know, into these
- 50:55other markets? And I mean, it's not your
- 50:58responsibility, you know, it's not, you know, you're just
- 51:01trying to get the jobs done. So what?
- 51:04What are you, what are you seeing in terms of that dynamic?
- 51:07Well, I think, you know, people will go where the employment and
- 51:10the jobs are, right? So that's the reality of it.
- 51:13And I think the UK taxpayers should be worried about it
- 51:17because there is a flight of people overseas.
- 51:21I think we probably can see that those of us who live in this
- 51:25area and we can see it in terms of people who have departed
- 51:28these shores, who are working in West Africa, Australia, the
- 51:31United States. And many of them have relocated
- 51:35there with their families and therefore they're no longer tax
- 51:38residents in the UK. So, and these are high paid
- 51:41jobs. Now from a supply chain point of
- 51:44view. And talking to to your point, I
- 51:46think the the, the danger for the UK from a supply chain point
- 51:50of view is that it's an ecosystem.
- 51:52And if the work isn't here, then certainly international supply
- 51:57chain companies will gravitate to other markets where there's
- 52:00more work and be your proximity to their customers.
- 52:04And that ecosystem then feeds through through the whole supply
- 52:08chain. You know, we we supply
- 52:10operators, of course, we do BP shelves, but we also supply most
- 52:15of the supply chain itself in terms of what we do.
- 52:18So if that supply chain moves, it has a detrimental impact on
- 52:23our business here. And we are then in a position
- 52:26where we need to think about our proximity to those customers, if
- 52:29they're moving to, you know, Dubai, they're moving to Houston
- 52:33or wherever it might be. So I think that is a challenge
- 52:36for the supply chain going forward in terms of the scale of
- 52:40the supply chain here, in terms of making sure we anchor
- 52:44companies here, high quality jobs here.
- 52:46We need to have a basin here. You know, we, we, the, if we
- 52:51don't have a North Sea that is robust and flourishing and
- 52:55across all the energy sectors, then you, you will not have a
- 53:00flourishing strong supply chain. And that is the reality of the
- 53:03situation. So, you know, where does the
- 53:07supply chain go? It will go where the work is.
- 53:09Because, you know, back to Jeff's point, you know, we have
- 53:12to make a return for our investors.
- 53:14That's just, that's just the the hard, no knocks of life.
- 53:18Can I just add something Erica? Neil's covered Hyderson.
- 53:25So I wouldn't repeat what Neil said, but I was I was fortunate
- 53:29to be in Peterhead two weeks ago, you know, at the school
- 53:32facility and it happened to be the day where where 50
- 53:37apprentices were graduating. What a proud moment as a as a
- 53:44member of the wider D20 group, that was 50 people, young kids
- 53:50who are being trained. And then when you then when you
- 53:53look at where they go, they don't just end up in Peterhead.
- 53:58You know, if you look at scores leader in Australia, an ex
- 54:06apprentice, look at the look at the leader in America's ex
- 54:12apprentice. If you look at the leader in our
- 54:15industrial side, ex apprentice, so I think that you know we are
- 54:20trade, we are investing and Hydra Sun has also got the
- 54:23skills Academy. We are investing because and I
- 54:28absolutely concur with Neil's point about that.
- 54:31We need a market here to actually develop these, continue
- 54:36to develop these skills, but we are still trying to do it
- 54:40because even in the international market, let's not
- 54:42forget we've got fantastic skills in Aberdeen that's not OR
- 54:48and UK broadly. Let's not induce it.
- 54:50That's some, I think, something that everyone here really feels
- 54:56deeply. Although I'm wondering, is it
- 54:58too late for me to sign up for the apprenticeship scheme?
- 55:00How many years have you been? Only three?
- 55:03Only three, or maybe a few more. Any questions out there in the
- 55:09audience? Ah, that gentleman there.
- 55:11Hi Alan McLean, Ashtead Technology.
- 55:14Really building on the the points that Neil and Jeff have
- 55:17just made and also reflecting back what they said earlier
- 55:21around. Neil's frustration with
- 55:23deferrals on FID and projects. Jeff mentioning the pause in the
- 55:29energy transition in recognising that skills will be lost,
- 55:33equipment will be lost overseas. And the entrepreneurial spirit
- 55:38and innovation, which is great in the city is excellent, could
- 55:42also be lost. What more noise can we make to
- 55:47get industry and government to recognise the risk that that
- 55:50poses? Thank you very much.
- 55:53I can assure you from the point of view of energy voice.
- 55:57We are constantly making that noise and I I didn't mean to get
- 56:01a bring up Cassandra by whether doom you know that no one's
- 56:04listening, but you know, I think speaking and persistently not
- 56:13just delivering messages, but telling the stories behind the
- 56:17impacts of what it actually happens and how it actually
- 56:23impacts people on the ground is is probably useful as well.
- 56:27So we're trying and then obviously I know our panels, you
- 56:32know, each have something else that they would probably like to
- 56:34say about that. We, we spend a lot of time
- 56:37lobbying Scottish Government as well as UK government.
- 56:42Is it deaf ears? I guess in the room they talk a
- 56:46good game. But I feel when we get outside
- 56:48the room and it comes into the headlines, then it's a different
- 56:50story. And I think they still go back
- 56:52to manifestos and This is why we're doing it.
- 56:55But I think it's to me, there's a tipping point coming.
- 56:58You can always feel it. It has to happen.
- 57:01We're getting quizzed over some minute things now which are
- 57:05about jobs, which are about the supply chain, which are coming
- 57:08directly from government now, which we haven't had in the
- 57:11past. And I think guys like David
- 57:13Whitehouse and these guys are doing a great job with the
- 57:15lobbying piece. But I think all of us need to
- 57:17make sure we have their their voices out there.
- 57:19And I I almost get to the point where we need to start being
- 57:22militant about it, but I can't say that.
- 57:25Sign up here. There's a question there in the
- 57:29back. Thank you.
- 57:30Philip Imperiali from Aberdeen Renewable Energy Group.
- 57:32So it was kind of building on on your point there.
- 57:35My questions like well, OK, so policies complex, I think you
- 57:40mentioned that and and you both I think both a couple of you
- 57:45panel members mentioned they're not expecting much change in the
- 57:48government, the governments in the in the near term.
- 57:51So it's kind of like I'm kind of going with Roddy.
- 57:55You know, we had success when we had mirror because the maximize
- 58:01economic recovery that led to an OGANST.
- 58:06So that changed things. So is there and I know there's a
- 58:10new group has been recently pulled together to have a look
- 58:13at that for Aberdeenshire. But do we build on both the
- 58:17question and what Roddy was saying about do we need to be
- 58:21stronger and militant is the same kind of thing?
- 58:23But do we need to be much more ruthless with the messaging?
- 58:27Because it's currently falling on deaf ears despite many visits
- 58:32from politicians to the area. Ruthless messaging.
- 58:36Anyone have an appetite for that?
- 58:39I think we do get a lot of visits, but it's probably not
- 58:41from the right people, you know, I, I don't think we're seeing
- 58:44the people actually make, you know, when was Mr. Miliband last
- 58:47in Aberdeen, you know, things like.
- 58:50That I think one of the most positive things that's come out
- 58:54of the challenges that we've got is I, I don't ever can remember
- 58:58in my, my career where all of the interested parties in the
- 59:03industry have come together, you know, so in UK, you know, the
- 59:08supply chain, the operators, the trade unions, all speaking with
- 59:13one voice. So I think we shouldn't lose
- 59:15sight of that. I think that's a fantastic
- 59:18platform. I find it incredible that Labour
- 59:22government would not listen to the, the GMB union that that is,
- 59:28you know, I, I, I think probably one of the better ways we have
- 59:31in for me, I think we've got to talk over the heads of the
- 59:36politicians to the public. We need to use the CBI.
- 59:40We need to look at other institutions and connect with
- 59:44the British public as much as we can to get the message home
- 59:48through through them into their constituencies to get the
- 59:51message home in terms of how it's damaging jobs, how it's
- 59:54damaging their own income, how it's destroying tax revenue that
- 59:59pays for hospitals, pays for schools and everything that we
- 1:00:02need to defend this country. So.
- 1:00:05I, I think that's where we have to go.
- 1:00:07I think the political class as it is just now will not change
- 1:00:11and therefore we need to go direct to direct to the, the
- 1:00:14public. That's just a personal view.
- 1:00:16It's not a company view, it's a personal.
- 1:00:19View, just to be clear. Very good, yeah.
- 1:00:23We wouldn't have an industry, we wouldn't have an industry if we
- 1:00:26continue to have these high prices for power with four times
- 1:00:32the price of power compared to the US, how can we compete
- 1:00:38effectively? You know, it's a big burden just
- 1:00:44powering up everyday operations. So I think the politicians need
- 1:00:50to sort of sit back and you know, Neil's point earlier about
- 1:00:55whether it's a change in Prime Minister or it's a change in the
- 1:01:00energy secretary, You know, not having that stability is really
- 1:01:06unhelpful. We don't have a we don't have a
- 1:01:09clear enough industrial strategy.
- 1:01:13And from industrial strategy will come energy strategy that
- 1:01:18that's what I think. Can we personal view not company
- 1:01:22and. I think if we had this
- 1:01:24conversation three years ago, we'd be talking about the oil
- 1:01:27industry versus the renewals industry.
- 1:01:29And I think that's the one change that we've seen as they
- 1:01:32come together now and talk about energy.
- 1:01:35And it's, it's probably only in the last year where we've seen
- 1:01:37that really tighten up. And I think that's how we get.
- 1:01:39Stronger, I agree. You've seen, you know, the
- 1:01:43industry itself, whether it's, you know, the operators, the
- 1:01:48supply chain in between the operators and the developers of
- 1:01:53renewable energy projects are kind of trying to speak off the
- 1:01:57same page. And that has been a specific
- 1:02:00shift. And actually, I think you're,
- 1:02:02you're right. Umm, you know, particularly
- 1:02:04about prices, umm, when people are talking about the energy
- 1:02:10industry, the only first major engagement point they have with
- 1:02:15it is they're built. Uh, it comes in and they look at
- 1:02:18it and, uh, you know, it means that for some it's, uh, that
- 1:02:22means that they can't eat because they're going to heat
- 1:02:24and whatever. But I think, umm, what also is
- 1:02:29the issue is, uh, they have no kind of concept really of what
- 1:02:36we do here. Umm, you know, are they
- 1:02:38offshore? Uh, you know, they don't see us
- 1:02:41do that, which is, uh, very interesting.
- 1:02:43And it's useful to maybe try to get those messages across.
- 1:02:46And I think maybe just to reflect on what Jeff said, umm,
- 1:02:50you know, is there any point in decarbonizing anything if we
- 1:02:53have no industry left to decarbonize because the gap
- 1:02:56because energy prices are too high?
- 1:02:58These are all things that I think it would probably help us
- 1:03:01a lot if we do so I think we'll get close to wrapping up, but
- 1:03:10I'll give you one last question each.
- 1:03:12Hopefully it will be snappy and then move on for there will be
- 1:03:16more snacks and drinks afterwards and chat because
- 1:03:21everyone here I think probably has more to say off the record
- 1:03:24than maybe on the record. But with regards to the energy
- 1:03:29supply chain, the strength of it and the people that it employs,
- 1:03:35is it doom or gloom or are we going to survive and thrive?
- 1:03:42Optimistic or pessimistic? Well, yes, we're going to
- 1:03:45survive. I think the challenge is the
- 1:03:49scale of the supply chain that will survive and how many jobs
- 1:03:52that actually provides in this part of the world.
- 1:03:56That I think is the bit that is open to debate and will be
- 1:04:01determined by policy decisions going forward.
- 1:04:05I think that's the reality of it.
- 1:04:07So I'm am I optimistic? Of course, I'm optimistic for
- 1:04:11the business that however is tempered with what does that
- 1:04:16mean for this part of the world versus what it might mean for
- 1:04:19jobs in other parts of the world.
- 1:04:21So for me, I come back to the central theme.
- 1:04:24We need a vibrant successful North Sea to anchor jobs and
- 1:04:29supply chain here to have that thriving supply chain empowering
- 1:04:33the supply chain of the future. Thank.
- 1:04:35You, David. Yeah, I guess I'm optimistic
- 1:04:38from a gas transmission perspective.
- 1:04:40I think there's a real opportunity for the supply chain
- 1:04:42to diversify into different areas, gas transmission being
- 1:04:45one of them. And as I said, we've got a, a
- 1:04:48big workbook over the next five years of activity where those
- 1:04:51skills are very complementary to what's happening with the
- 1:04:54upstream oil and gas. But I do agree with Neil that,
- 1:04:56that upstream oil and gas is the the foundation that the supply
- 1:04:59chain works on. But maybe maybe to Finley's
- 1:05:03point earlier as well, actually I, I think whatever the supply
- 1:05:05chain does that kind of embrace that diversification, then it
- 1:05:09opens up opportunities as well and the business model become
- 1:05:13become more nimble and seek out other opportunities too.
- 1:05:18Jeff, optimistic or pessimistic? I'm naturally optimistic, so I'm
- 1:05:24a glass half full guy. And so I think, you know, I
- 1:05:29agree with what Neil and David have said, we do need a supply
- 1:05:32chain here that is thriving. But this is an industry we
- 1:05:39talked about. Cyclicality is an industry
- 1:05:41that's been through cycles many times and we always come out of
- 1:05:46it stronger. This is just another one that
- 1:05:50this industry knows how to deal with challenges in a way that
- 1:05:55most other industries don't. And we already taking action.
- 1:06:01We are not sitting on our bums and inner just and just allowing
- 1:06:09what what is being thrown at us to define our future.
- 1:06:16We are taking, we are taking action and I'm sure not just the
- 1:06:21companies I'm involved with, but the companies in this room and
- 1:06:24beyond are doing exactly the same thing.
- 1:06:27So I'm optimistic. Pessimist.
- 1:06:30No, I'm, I think it's all been covered, but you know, there's
- 1:06:37massive challenges out there, but there's also huge
- 1:06:39opportunities and it's, it's making sure you position the
- 1:06:42business to make sure that you're capturing those
- 1:06:44opportunities. So and I think the Northeast
- 1:06:46more than any other place and certainly in the UK has that
- 1:06:49ability to be able to do that. So I think we're well positioned
- 1:06:51from that perspective. We just need a little help on
- 1:06:54the political side. A little help y'all, That's all
- 1:06:57we need, but I just wanted to draw it to a conclusion.
- 1:07:03I would like to do so first by thanking everyone who has joined
- 1:07:08us here tonight, Neil Thompson of Hydra Sun, David Marshall of
- 1:07:12National Gas, Jeff Curry of D20 and last but not least, Rodney
- 1:07:17James of the Port of Aberdeen. And could we thank them in the
- 1:07:19time honored manner? And thank you for joining us and
- 1:07:28thanks to the listener out there for tuning in again to Energy
- 1:07:31Voice. Oh, I've been Erica Askland,
- 1:07:34we've been having a fabulous evening and we'll see you all
- 1:07:36soon. Thank you.