Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Market Mood Meltdown
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to The Deep Dive. I'm your host and today, yeah,
- 0:02we're jumping right into the latest numbers from the weekly
- 0:04Investor Sentiment and Volatility dashboard.
- 0:07This is for Friday, September 5th, 2025.
- 0:10And you know, we're not just going to skin the surface here.
- 0:13Our goal is really to dig in, look past all that noise and
- 0:16figure out what these key market indicators are actually telling
- 0:19us about investor mood and maybe market stress levels right now.
- 0:23Look, this isn't about telling you what to buy or sell.
- 0:25Definitely not. It's about arming you with a
- 0:28better understanding, helping you make sense of these signals
- 0:31you know quickly and properly. Think of it like getting you up
- 0:34to speed, giving you that clearer picture.
- 0:36Yeah, exactly. And that clarity is so important
- 0:39because, you know, understanding sentiment and volatility.
- 0:42It's not just some academic exercise.
- 0:44It really helps us get a feel for the market's actual
- 0:46temperature. Are investors like scared?
- 0:49Are they getting greedy or maybe just a bit too comfortable, you
- 0:53know, complacent? Each of those feelings means
- 0:56something different for the markets.
- 0:57So today we'll break down three key things.
- 1:00First, the AAI investor sentiment, that's kind of the
- 1:03pulse of the retail investor. Then the CBOE equity put call
- 1:07ratios, which show us what options traders are doing.
- 1:10And finally, the IC BofA move index that gives us a window
- 1:14into the bond market stress levels.
- 1:16Utah them together and you get a retty decent story.
- 1:18Right. That sounds like a solid plan.
- 1:20O, where better to start than with the individual investor,
- 1:22the sort of everyday folks? Let's kick off with that retail
- 1:24investor ulse, the AAI sentiment survey.
- 1:27It's Weekly gives us that direct read.
- 1:29So what's the latest reading telling us?
- 1:31How are they feeling? OK so the AAII bull bear spread.
- 1:34This is as of September 4th. It came in at negus 10.68%.
- 1:38-10.68. OK, yeah.
- 1:40And just to give that some context, last week it was
- 1:43sitting at -4.84%. So this isn't just a small
- 1:47shift. It really points to a, well, a
- 1:49pretty noticeable deepening of bearish sentiment among those
- 1:53retail investors. They're definitely feeling more
- 1:55pessimistic. Wow.
- 1:56OK, that is quite a jump further into negative territory for
- 1:59individuals. Does that number that -10.68
- 2:02push us into what you'd call extreme territory?
- 2:05Or is it still sort of concerning but not alarming?
- 2:08That's a really good question. So while -10.68% is a
- 2:11significant lean towards pessimism, it's actually not yet
- 2:14in what we usually call extreme territory for AII.
- 2:17Historically, you know, you'd need to see readings below say
- 2:20-15% sometimes even way down into the minus 20s or 30s during
- 2:25really big market shake UPS to call it truly extreme.
- 2:28Think back to like the 2008 crisis or even that sharp drop
- 2:32in early 2020 when the pandemic hit.
- 2:34Those periods saw much, much deeper negativity.
- 2:37So yeah, this reading is definitely noteworthy.
- 2:39Shows folks are bearish, but maybe not quite at that full
- 2:42capitulation point you sometimes see near market bottoms.
- 2:46It does raise an interesting question though, right?
- 2:48What does it really signal when individual investors get this
- 2:51consistently pessimistic? Is it a warning sign?
- 2:54Or maybe you know from a contrarian viewpoint, is this
- 2:56setting up for something else? Yeah, that contrarian angle is
- 2:59always fascinating. OK, so individuals are getting
- 3:02more nervous. How does that stack up against
- 3:04maybe the more professional money trading options?
- 3:07Do their actions back this up or tell a different story?
- 3:10Let's look at the CBOE equity put call ratios next.
- 3:13What's the daily reading showing there?
- 3:15Right. So the daily equity put call
- 3:16ratio again as of September 4th was .62.
- 3:20Now that number is actually considered pretty low.
- 3:22Low and low means. Low in options terms generally
- 3:26signals more bullish positioning among those equity option
- 3:29traders. It's actually well below any
- 3:32kind of bearish threshold that would normally make a sit up and
- 3:35take notice. OK.
- 3:36Just so I'm clear and everyone listening is to a lower ratio
- 3:39means traders are buying more calls betting on prices going up
- 3:43compared to puts which are bets on prices going down or used for
- 3:46hedging. Right.
- 3:46Exactly. Yeah, that's the standard
- 3:48interpretation. It suggests, you know, more
- 3:50optimism, maybe an expectation for prices to rise, or at least
- 3:53less fear about a big immediate drop.
- 3:56When call volume outweighs put volume like that, it usually
- 3:59points to a more confident stance in that part of the
- 4:01market. That's a really interesting
- 4:04contrast, isn't it? Especially right after hearing
- 4:06about the deepening retail gloom.
- 4:09Now, what about the slightly longer view for these options
- 4:12traders? Does the five day average tell
- 4:14the same story or does it complicate things well?
- 4:17Looking at the five day average for the CBOE equity put call
- 4:20ratio, it's actually been hovering pretty close to its
- 4:23historical norms, roughly around .6, which is typical over the
- 4:26last five years or so. Fairly normal then.
- 4:29Yeah, pretty much indicates consistent behavior there.
- 4:32We're not seeing any sort of extreme lurch towards fear or,
- 4:36you know, wild exuberance and this.
- 4:39If we kind of step back and connect the dots, this is where
- 4:41it gets really interesting. You've got the retail folks, the
- 4:44AAI crowd showing this growing pessimism.
- 4:48But then you have the options traders, often seen as more
- 4:51sophisticated or institutional, looking relatively bullish or at
- 4:54least stable and confident within their normal range.
- 4:57That divergent is definitely something.
- 4:59It really is. Retail investors might be
- 5:01reacting more to headlines, sentiment shifts, maybe a bit
- 5:04more emotionally. Options traders could be
- 5:06positioning based on different ONA factors, fundamentals,
- 5:10complex hedging strategies, maybe specific sector views.
- 5:14It creates this this real tension in the signals.
- 5:17So does the retail fear signal trouble ahead, or is it, like
- 5:22you said, a contrarian sign that maybe the pros are right to stay
- 5:24calm? That's the $1,000,000 question,
- 5:26isn't it? Historically, extreme retail
- 5:28fear has sometimes preceded market bottoms, but it's
- 5:32notoriously tricky for timing. It's definitely a dynamic to
- 5:35watch closely. Absolutely.
- 5:37OK, so we have this split view. What about the broader system?
- 5:40Sometimes the bond market gives us clues about underlying stress
- 5:43or maybe lack of it. Let's dig into the IC BofA Move
- 5:48Index that measures bond market volatility, right?
- 5:51Often a lead indicator. That's right.
- 5:53The MOVE index essentially tracks expected volatility in
- 5:56U.S. Treasury bonds, and as of
- 5:58September 5th, the value is sitting at approximately 88.26.
- 6:0288.26 And how does that read Good, bad, indifferent.
- 6:06Well, the interpretation is pretty clear.
- 6:08Bond market volatility is quite subdued, very much subdued
- 6:12actually. And importantly, it's
- 6:13comfortably below any kind of extreme threshold we'd worry
- 6:16about. OK, good to know, but just for
- 6:18context, what would be an extreme level for move E when
- 6:21the alarm bells really start ringing there?
- 6:23Yeah, good point. We typically start getting
- 6:25concerned if move E pushed up into the 150 plus range in
- 6:28really acute crises, it can shoot much higher.
- 6:30Think back again to 2008. It's spiked well over 150, even
- 6:34hit 200 briefly. Same thing during the initial
- 6:36Covad shock in 2020, big jumps over 150.
- 6:39That signals intense stress, liquidity problems, real
- 6:42systemic fear. So seeing it down here around 88
- 6:45suggests that the let's call it the plumbing of the financial
- 6:48system. The bond market seems pretty
- 6:51stable. There isn't widespread panic or
- 6:53fear about major financial stress brewing there, despite
- 6:56what the retail sentiment might suggest.
- 6:58So the bond market is basically saying keep calm and carry on.
- 7:01Pretty much, yeah. It's not flashing red warning
- 7:04lights about imminent doom. Now, what's fascinating, or
- 7:07maybe worth questioning, is whether that calm reflects
- 7:10genuine stability or perhaps a bit of complacency, especially
- 7:14when you see nervousness elsewhere.
- 7:16The bond markets calm, but is it too calm?
- 7:19That's always a background thought.
- 7:20OK, this has been super helpful walking through each piece.
- 7:23We've got the bearish individuals, the fairly
- 7:25confident options players, and this calm bond market.
- 7:28So let's try and synthesize this, pulling it all together
- 7:31from this week's dashboard. What's the main take away?
- 7:34OK, summing it up, First the AII sentiment at Negashi 10.68%.
- 7:39It definitely shows a pronounced lean towards bearishness among
- 7:42retail investors, but crucially not yet hitting those historical
- 7:45extreme levels. Second, the equity put call
- 7:48ratios, both the daily .62 and the five day average near .6
- 7:52signal relatively bullish or at least stable and non fearful
- 7:55positioning among equity options traders.
- 7:58No signs of extreme worry there. And 3rd of the movie index
- 8:01around 88 that confirms bond market volatility remains, you
- 8:04know, pretty low. It's far away from levels that
- 8:05would indicate major systemic stress.
- 8:07And any major alerts triggered this week based on those
- 8:10numbers. No, based on our usual
- 8:12thresholds, no extreme alerts were triggered this week.
- 8:15The AAII bearishness is definitely something to keep an
- 8:19eye on. It's noteworthy, but the CBOE
- 8:22ratios and the movie index are all operating within their
- 8:25normal non alarming ranges. So the key take away really is
- 8:29this divergent we've talked about.
- 8:31You have this pocket of pessimism with retail investors,
- 8:34but the signals for more professional traders and the
- 8:36core bond market suggests a lack of extreme stress or broad
- 8:40bearishness. It's not a simple story, right?
- 8:43It's not just markets bullish or markets bear.
- 8:46It's doubly complex. Exactly.
- 8:47It makes you ask, you know, is retail sensing something early
- 8:51or are they potentially wrong footed here and the markets
- 8:54underlying structure is more resilient than they think?
- 8:57That synthesis really drives home the point.
- 8:59You need to look at these different signals together.
- 9:01So this week we've seen this interesting mix.
- 9:03Individual investors getting gloomier, options traders
- 9:06holding steady or even bullish, and the bond market staying
- 9:09remarkably calm. Understanding these currents?
- 9:12Well, that's how you build your own informed view rather than
- 9:15just reacting, right? Absolutely.
- 9:17And it does leave us with a kind of provocative question to chew
- 9:20on, doesn't it? While the dashboard isn't
- 9:22screaming extreme alert anywhere right now, what does this
- 9:25specific blend, this rising retail fear combined with pretty
- 9:29low overall volatility actually tell of us?
- 9:33Is it underlying confidence holding things up?
- 9:35Or is it maybe a touch of complacency creeping in?
- 9:38Confidence or complacency? That's a great thought to
- 9:42ponder. Yeah, something to keep in mind
- 9:44as we see how these signals develop.
- 9:45We'll definitely be tracking it. And for anyone listening who
- 9:48wants to, you know, keep tabs on market temperature more
- 9:51regularly, you might want to check out the Buffett Indicator
- 9:53app. You can just search for it on
- 9:54the iOS App Store. It gives daily updates on market
- 9:57valuations and potential bubbles.
- 9:59Great suggestion and thanks again for walking us through all
- 10:02that. Just a reminder to everyone
- 10:04listening, all the analysis we discussed is based on public
- 10:06information and it's really just for educational purposes.
- 10:09It's definitely not investment advice.
- 10:11Please do your own homework before making any investment
- 10:13decisions. If you enjoyed this and want
- 10:15more, please subscribe to us on Apple or Spotify podcast.
- 10:18Just search for deep value investing and hey, don't forget
- 10:21to check out the episode description for our recommended
- 10:24Value investing book list. Until next time, stay curious.
- 10:27And keep digging deeper.