Latest / The LoCo Experience / EXPERIENCE 219 | Geopolitics, Russia-Ukraine, Regional Economics, and Competitive Advantage in Business and Life with Constantin Gurdgiev, Ph.D. and Associate Professor of Finance at the Monfort College of Business at UNC.
Transcript
- 0:00In this episode of the LOCO Experience Podcast, I hosted Konstantin Grieghev,
- 0:04PhD in Associate Professor of Finance at the Montfort College of Business.
- 0:08Konstantin outlines his work in the fields of economics, geopolitics, and finance,
- 0:13sharing insights from his research on geopolitical risks,
- 0:15tariff impacts, and financial market volatility. He also discusses his teaching and research
- 0:21positions in the United States and Ireland, emphasizing his efforts to integrate
- 0:25real-world applications into academia through internships and student engagement.
- 0:30Konstantin delves into the complexities of the Ukraine-Russia conflict,
- 0:33drawing on his expertise in Russian and Irish economics. He discusses the historical
- 0:38and geopolitical context that has contributed to the ongoing tension,
- 0:41and critiques the Western approach to handling the situation.
- 0:45The conversation also touches on broader themes like the weaponization of economic systems,
- 0:49challenges to U.S. economic hegemony, and the multi-dimensional nature of modern global conflicts.
- 0:55Konstantin also reflects on regional development issues,
- 0:58specific to Northern Colorado, including regulatory burdens,
- 1:02the high cost of living, and the need for regional cooperation between cities to maintain
- 1:06competitive advantage. He suggests practical steps such as reducing state-level taxes,
- 1:11and regulatory burdens to foster business growth.
- 1:14The episode concludes with personal reflections on his family and life experiences.
- 1:18It's an intriguing journey, and I hope you'll join me in enjoying my conversation with Konstantin Grieghev.
- 1:25Let's have some fun.
- 1:35Welcome to the Local Experience Podcast. On this show, you'll get to know business and
- 1:39community leaders from all around Northern Colorado and beyond. Our guests share their stories,
- 1:44business stories, life stories, stories of triumph and of tragedy, and through it all,
- 1:48you'll be inspired and entertained. These conversations are real and raw, and no topics are off limits.
- 1:55So pop in a breath, men, and get ready to meet our latest guest.
- 2:02Welcome back to the Local Experience Podcast. My guest today is Konstantin Grieghev,
- 2:08and he is an associate professor of economics among other things at UNC,
- 2:14and I saw him speak at a Biz West event last fall, I guess, or early in the New Year.
- 2:19Early in the New Year, exactly. Yeah, yeah. So thanks for taking the time to be here.
- 2:23My pleasure. And for probably the most of my listeners that have never heard of you,
- 2:29could you just set the stage a little bit? It looks like you've got your fingers in a lot of pies.
- 2:34I don't know about whether they're pies or mouse traps. This is a big question,
- 2:39always isn't it? So first of all, little correction. Yes, so I'm associate professor of finance.
- 2:44A finance? Sorry. Monfort College of Business at UNC. That's my main job.
- 2:50Economics is a part of UNC as well, but they're not part of MCB. I am economist by trading,
- 2:55so my PhD is actually, you know, for my scenes is macroeconomics and finance,
- 3:00theoretical stuff. So I used to study economics. I do some economic analysis these days,
- 3:05because I'm kind of in a weird area of finance that a lot of people miss when they are operating
- 3:11in the local economy. I work in a geopolitical risks and geopolitical uncertainty,
- 3:19part of finance, so it's macro stuff. So we look at the whole countries moving,
- 3:23the whole markets moving, wars, conflicts, sanctions, all these things. Tariffs. Tariffs? Yes.
- 3:32This is more of a trade factor, but then of course, how does that impact finance? In fact,
- 3:37I have a couple of graduate students currently doing some work. So in addition to teaching at UNC,
- 3:42I also have a visiting position in Ireland in Trinity College Dublin and I have graduate students
- 3:47there. So they do a lot of work with me in terms of the research. And tariffs? Yes,
- 3:52absolutely. Like out of 15 students that I supervise this year, there are two of them actually
- 3:57are doing work on tariffs. So it's a pretty big deal. It is huge deal. Of course. I mean, look at
- 4:02the markets. Yes, I mean, we've had an absolutely amazing period. I don't remember who said,
- 4:08you know, that, you know, sometimes, you know, nothing happens in decades and then decades
- 4:12happen in one day or one week. We had that one week exactly. Last week was unprecedented by
- 4:18any comparatives. But then again, when you think about the big from the last 25 years or so
- 4:24of our history, are very much unprecedented. You have the global financial crisis, which was
- 4:30out of traditional sync for the traditional crisis time of things or market reactions to things.
- 4:37It was systemic. It was very deep. Then we went on to the exactly. Yeah, not only finance,
- 4:43but real economy. I mean, the great recession, you have to go back in a non-incleture to great
- 4:50depression to see something like that. So it's once and a hundred years of end. Then we had COVID
- 4:54pandemic. I mean, my god, if you were in my field, you would actually kind of think like, how can
- 5:01we come try something that great? That's so good to see. As terrible as it is, it is exactly. You
- 5:07correct. You know, we studied things which are dismal. You know, and this was pretty dismal event.
- 5:13And then, of course, we have geopolitical crisis going on since then, 2022, Ukraine,
- 5:18Russia War. You know, you have the 2016, 2017, 2020 periods in terms of the elections.
- 5:27And then we have new election this last year, 2024, which are historically unprecedented.
- 5:34Yeah, whether it is a political science history, it is history history. It's economic policy history.
- 5:40It doesn't matter. So when we entered the last probably three weeks span of time,
- 5:46there were some indicators of what was happening. Some of the market participants started reacting
- 5:50an anticipation of that. In other words, they took the administration on this, you know,
- 5:56for what they were saying, okay, as being truthful and intended to do these types at that
- 6:01roughly speaking scale and all. But by and large, even those market participants who had this kind
- 6:07of, you know, foresight could not expect the level and the uncertainty and the volatility of
- 6:13the decision making that we have witnessed. Oh, and it's on. It's off. It's on. It's on. It's
- 6:18off. Exactly. It's delayed for 30 days. It's delayed for 90 days. If we were a piece of steel,
- 6:22we would turn into Damascus quality steel. The Epic stuff. Yes. What was that?
- 6:28That's about a sword. Targaryen or something like that from the Game of Thrones. Yes. I forgot
- 6:34the name that they use there. But we're not still. We're human beings. And so we are scared. We're
- 6:40uncertain. We are panicked. Yeah. Behaviorally, we are in perfect our decision making in kind of
- 6:46circumstances. As you can see from markets that go like this. Absolutely. Yes. And we kind of think
- 6:51of the markets as more rational than average agent. Well, we kind of saw that. You know, they're not.
- 6:56Fair enough. I was actually listening to Dave Ramsey on whose podcast? Oh, Sean Ryan.
- 7:06Sure. Okay. Yeah. I think something like that. Something Ryan. Anyway,
- 7:11and he was talking about how kind of the Reagan pulling us out of the recession of the late 70s
- 7:18a little bit was so much more about people's mindsets shifting than it was actually about
- 7:24this regulation or this tax or this thing. And he was optimistic that once we can stop the
- 7:31gyrations, maybe people will kind of, you know, sentiment is huge. Yeah. Absolutely. Beyond
- 7:35adults, we as humans react to that. That's called leadership. In fact, most of the politics,
- 7:40most of the political leadership when you go back in history and look at it, it's not about
- 7:44capability. It's about projection. It's about message. Reagan had happened to have the correct
- 7:51message. If you look back today at what Reagan was saying about, say, for example, immigration
- 7:56policies, what he was saying about economy, what he was saying about the balance and act between
- 8:02the winners in the economy and the losers in the economy. And then you lay the path beyond Reagan
- 8:07because, of course, eight years of Reagan have been transformative. And they laid the foundation for
- 8:12the kind of what we call compassion, conservatism of the early 1990s. Of course, it all dies in the
- 8:19mid 1990s. He has with Newt Gingrich revolution and compassion as part disappears. And then,
- 8:25you know, so when you look at that progression, Reagan really strikes a great comparative.
- 8:31He is a big transformative type of a president who was mostly not resting on the
- 8:39competency of execution, but rather on the quality of messaging and conviction. We miss Reagan
- 8:46today, definitely. And I'm not saying that because I would approve of Reagan's policies being
- 8:52deployed today, some of them are meaningful. Again, remember that Reagan was the last president
- 8:57we had who have enacted substantial enough fundamental enough immigration reform, which was an
- 9:04immigration reform, which reinforced our ethos of this nation, the ethos of the melting pot,
- 9:10the ethos of opportunity land. Yes. And then did it, like, was it restricted from there or just
- 9:17too many people wanted to sign up for it over time? No, it's not. The system broke down because
- 9:24it became there's no no perfect system can survive through the test of time because time changes
- 9:30things. The flows have changed the migrants. The objectives of the migrants have changed.
- 9:34We needed to keep the system adjusted to that. We needed reforms. After Reagan, there was no
- 9:40reform of the immigration policy at all. We had kind of patchwork, you know, kind of, you know,
- 9:45all. Where was clearly broken? Yeah, correct. Yeah, we were, you know, we were first put in plaster
- 9:51on basically, you know, like razor cuts, yes. Then on shark bites, the plaster didn't change.
- 9:58We still walk blindly saying, no, no, you couldn't hold that. We knew that because the entire
- 10:04immigration reform has ended culminated in DACA, you know, it culminated in basically, if you
- 10:11use the parlance of the 1990s, Bill Clinton's policies, yes, don't ask don't tell. We have
- 10:16these people here. We would like to normalize them. We can't normalize them. They deserve to be
- 10:21normalized. Right. We can't normalize them. They should be here. We can't normalize them.
- 10:26But let's pretend that that's okay. Right. You know, and so, you know, in the end, the dreamers,
- 10:32you know, in the end, that was the effectively the nail in the coffin of the, in my view,
- 10:39as an outsider, coming into the United States of what was the great promise, the shining, you
- 10:44know, city on the hill, the torch that has led the countries and societies to transformation,
- 10:52not only in terms of the outward mobility of people, sending them to the United States, but also
- 10:57internal, identity of people and internal, political changes as well. So it seems like our populations
- 11:04in the US have become, you know, and maybe for lack of recessions and things, but more reluctant
- 11:10to move around for opportunities and to leave the inner city crappy economies and move to North
- 11:17Dakota and rugged and oil well, you know, it's not so much moving to North Dakota and working on
- 11:21oil well. I mean, you are striking something. You're touching on something that is empirical
- 11:25regularity, which has transformed the change, the balance of economic power and economic dynamism
- 11:32between the continents over the last say 50 years. If you go back to the 1990s, United States is
- 11:39an example of the high internal mobility of people. As you mentioned, people looking for opportunities,
- 11:45it doesn't mean going to North Dakota. It means a doctor moving from, say, for example, rural Texas
- 11:50to the urban New Jersey, okay, bringing for Collins population up from 50 to 150. But also when
- 11:58you talk about the population numbers, it is a mobility which was driven by opportunity. It was
- 12:03mobility of the younger middle class, lower middle class. Exactly. Bingo, you've got it, okay.
- 12:11What happened in this century is that with the great recession and even before the great recession,
- 12:17with the cost of housing rise, with the pressures in the cost of living, pressures of a cost of
- 12:22education and health care, all of those three major expenditures that happen over the life cycle
- 12:29that we have, have depressed mobility of people. It depressed social mobility of people and
- 12:34economic mobility of people. Fewer people moved today from the lower middle class to the upper
- 12:38middle class than before. Fewer people moved today from, say, for example, the bond location to
- 12:45the next location. COVID pandemic a little bit disrupted them, but that kind of was very short.
- 12:49Well, in the ability for remote work and stuff, you know, that's where COVID pandemic came in.
- 12:54For the cheap living, but keeping their job in San Francisco. Exactly. And that was the only part
- 13:00of the departure. When you look at other continents, when you look at Asia Pacific, for example,
- 13:05where the kind of the breakdown, economic reduction of the, you know, violence of nationalism
- 13:11has led to the greater mobility of people. You look at Europe, where the European unification
- 13:16process and the European Union has fostered. It's not just your own community. That's a lot of
- 13:20liquidity to their opportunities. Exactly, but it's also liquidity to ability to move.
- 13:25Yes, the polls will go to Germany for college. Correct. And I remember I was in European Union
- 13:31at the time living on when Poland became the part of the European Union. And it debates that
- 13:36was happening right before, before that session, before 2004, where the people from those countries
- 13:42come and in should be allowed all of the rights of working privileges, ability to, you know,
- 13:48access social welfare nets and supports and health care supports and things like that.
- 13:54And I was at the front of that debate as well in Ireland, where we were kind of caught in between
- 13:59as a society. In the end, Ireland made that decision that people coming into European Union should
- 14:05have immediate access to all of the benefits of being a part of the European Union. It gave a huge
- 14:10boost to Irish economy. Sure. And you had so much skills coming into the countries. So much.
- 14:16Oh, they're standard living as like crazy. Exactly. Of course, 30 period. That's true, but that was,
- 14:23you know, remember before there's a lot of, there's a lot of changes that have happened before.
- 14:27So the accession of 2004 and subsequent additions to the European Union and the mobility
- 14:33within the European Union has benefited Ireland beyond any belief, any belief. When you look at
- 14:38actually microcosm of Colorado, in a way, the history of Colorado compared to say, for example,
- 14:44the history of Wyoming is indicative of exactly the same dynamics. You have, Colorado has always
- 14:50been more open to the economic development, to the mobility of people, more welcoming to people
- 14:55coming in. Well, there's way nicer here. Well, yeah, monkeys are better. Look, don't, you know,
- 15:00fly fishing is better. I can talk about that. Yes, that's the reason I leave Colorado as well. Yes.
- 15:05But beyond everything else, there's one thing that you want. You want people to come in on the
- 15:10basis of the merit selection. You want people to come in to pursue the dream. You want people to come
- 15:16in to build their own, build new things, add value. And we've benefited through that in Colorado's
- 15:23history in the past. It's changing. Today's migration in the last probably say three to four years.
- 15:29You can see the pivotal change. We have more over all the community. The younger community has
- 15:34been pushed out to the east and people's kids have moved here from California and now they have
- 15:41kids of their own. So the grandparents move here from that's okay. That's not a problem. The problem
- 15:46becomes when the people's kids start moving out of them. I see. And that is something that we're
- 15:52witnessing today. It's already starting. We already have it say, for example, these school
- 15:56district there is reductions in terms of the kids and romans. You know, they overestimated the
- 16:01impact. They kind of got two cautious in their own planning. So that's a little bit of a correction
- 16:06there. But you can see that trend happening. The problem when that is repeated, when that process
- 16:10continues over say decade plus, we're going to where risk can get into the point like the rest
- 16:16of the United States that will become ossified. And when you become ossified, you become less
- 16:21on this competitive. And now that is hard. What are the competitors as hard? What is color
- 16:27doing wrong if I may interject? Oh, well, I mean, okay. Or is it just running on? I think it's not so
- 16:32much. I don't think it's so much as something that is what's colorado is doing wrong, but rather
- 16:37from my perspective, what color is not doing? So we were driving from Salt Lake City this weekend
- 16:42and it's a long drive. Yeah. Should've been listening to the local experience. Well, you know,
- 16:47it's kind of my, you know, my better half is kind of my local experience podcast. So two of us
- 16:51were talking about we were talking exactly about this. And she is a professional and marketing,
- 16:57you know, she does strategic marketing advisory in a beverages industry. Okay. And so the two of us
- 17:03were talking about this. I'm a big fan of organic local growth. What we mean by this is that it is
- 17:10growth, which starts on the basis of the demand locally. And it organically finances itself
- 17:17instead of attracting high-speed growth rates by bringing in capital from the outside. It organically
- 17:24gradually grows, but it grows at fast enough rates to actually escape the velocity or escape the
- 17:31pool or the gravity rather. Okay. Again, escape velocity to escape that gravity of the immediate
- 17:37local market. Yeah. Yeah. And what I think colorado is not doing enough is that it is not
- 17:43creating the momentum in the core sectors where we can be super competitive and super innovative.
- 17:51And I'll mention those sectors that I think, you know, in terms of growing internal local talent
- 17:57and in terms local enterprise. Yeah. Whether it is profit enterprise or non-profit enterprise.
- 18:04So the sectors I mean, I actually agree food. Okay. It's very important. High value added
- 18:10tremendously big universe of agri food. We think of agri food as farmers, but it isn't. It's not
- 18:16just farmers. It's a process of food. Yeah. It's the creation of new types of food. It is also
- 18:22research and development. It's associated marketing. It's associated biotech. Yeah. You start going
- 18:29through the lines of enterprises and areas that support the proper agri food sector. Again,
- 18:37fall back on Ireland because I spent 16 years there. Great example. High value added agriculture.
- 18:43High value added food production. The country which started with having effectively no cuisine
- 18:48of its own to be in a heavy weight in global markets. You can buy adish agri food products today
- 18:55in a shelves in in Colorado. That's it. You can't buy Colorado goods out there. Yeah. That's the
- 19:01problem. Okay. So that's one step in stone, but there is other associated sectors. So for example,
- 19:06then food retailing. Right. When transportation. Restaurants. Okay. Transportation. You're right
- 19:12completely. There's associated things with that hospitality and entertainment sector. Okay.
- 19:19Integrating our natural assets such as mountains, for example. Yes. And everything that goes with it
- 19:27together with the food sector, with the drink sector, which we have very healthy in terms of
- 19:31beers. We are we have a very nation week, but trying to rise wine production sector, which is very
- 19:39interesting. I'm fascinated by that. Again, because of my better half, I'm blessed to be able to go
- 19:44to the governor's cop and enjoy and meet people who are passionate, who are great. They are trying.
- 19:51They're at the very beginning, compared to say, for example, the French, Italians,
- 19:54you know, the Californians, they're not there. But can they get to that level? They can. Because
- 20:03they have passion, because they don't have talent. Yeah. Yeah. It will take generations. So
- 20:07support in this type of the organic development, organic growth that starts small, starts locally
- 20:12angry. You travel to somewhere. There's a couple of reasons. Palazzo. Exactly. They weren't
- 20:18still on anything outside of Colorado, 10, 15 years ago, mostly. And that's fine. Yeah. That's fine.
- 20:23But now that people come in here, and that's how a lot of, for example, if you take big production
- 20:27regions like, say, Pasarobles in California, yeah. Pasarobles started by selling grapes to Napa
- 20:34and to Sanoma producers, because they could grow great grapes, but they couldn't make great wine,
- 20:40necessarily. So, right, a joint in Pasarobles is Shalom, you know, which was a part of the, you know,
- 20:46challenge of the of Paris, you know, you know, of course, you know, so you have kind of some
- 20:52individual producers like that. But by growing grapes, they started acquiring the expertise.
- 20:58So by about say 80s, they start getting to production of their own wine. They start with small
- 21:04volumes. They start organically selling it at the vineyards and to their own clients lists.
- 21:10You had to travel there to discover them. Once you traveled and discovered them,
- 21:13you became the customer, the word of mouth and things like that. It's now a multi-billion dollar
- 21:18industry there. It is a rival to the major producers like Monterey, for example, in central coast.
- 21:24It is the certainly has bit, you know, I think, Santa Barbara area. And it is kind of the third
- 21:32largest producer on the west coast, yes. But it's also the quality of the production. So for
- 21:36example, if you think about kind of the scale of things, yes. Back in the 1970s, you would buy
- 21:42maybe a vineyard or 1980s, a vineyard there for three million, four million dollars.
- 21:47Okay. I think last year there was a Dow Brothers. So the vineyard for nine hundred million dollars.
- 21:55And it's not a huge thing. And you can't even get one for 20 million. No, no, no, no,
- 21:59forget it. You might get like a backyard for 20 million, you know? I mean, you might park the
- 22:04tractor. You know, half an acre. Yeah, exactly. Okay. So it's not Dow Brothers. It's not a very
- 22:10big, huge kind of buy, if you want footprint, but you can buy their stuff everywhere. And it is a
- 22:17high-end vine. It is a high-quality vine. It's a rival to the big European producers. Is there
- 22:22that much margin in it? I guess if you get the really good reputation, it doesn't cost that much more.
- 22:27Economics of vine making a very kind of very complicated. Right. If you can sell it for 200 bucks a bottle,
- 22:31you know, that does a lot of work. You can produce some things for two hundred dollars a bottle.
- 22:36I think the kind of the bulk of it would be in the 50, 60 dollar territory, which is sufficient
- 22:42enough margin. Yeah, yeah. But it is also a lot of that is based on auxiliary additional sales
- 22:48or beyond wine. There is events and things like that as well. A lot of it is based on a brand
- 22:53reputation. Brand reputation is important. Brand capital is super important. And finance, for
- 22:58example, we have difficulty valuing those things because we always need to attach the dollar amount.
- 23:03That's something that I love working with my students, you know, on and give them the appreciation
- 23:09and understanding of how complex the forms of capital we really face today. It isn't just about
- 23:14the loan. It is about what is the underlying asset supporting that? What are you acquiring?
- 23:19We used to think in terms of buildings. We used to think in terms of machinery and equipment.
- 23:23Not really. We now think in terms of the brands. We now think in terms of the access to the capital.
- 23:29Think of NVIDIA. Yes. NVIDIA is a great example. It doesn't have factories.
- 23:34It's entire value is in its own designs, in its own patents, in its own intellectual property.
- 23:42You can't touch that. You can't really physically move it from one file to another file,
- 23:49from one side of the room to another side of the room. You can ship it though across the borders.
- 23:54You can find locations on domiciles for it, where you would extract the greatest value.
- 23:59Again, you think of Ireland, Holland, Denmark. These are big traditional locations for the
- 24:06offshore domicile of intellectual property. They hold vast amounts of intellectual property
- 24:11for pharmaceutical companies, for the companies like NVIDIA, for other tech companies and so forth.
- 24:17Colorado, by the way, when going now from the hospitality sector, from things that we think
- 24:22of traditionally, oh, this is just past services, which is not true, should not be seen as such,
- 24:28because if this high value added service, it can be not just high margin, but also significant
- 24:33volumes, so the revenue streams from it can be significant unemployment effects. We can go
- 24:38also to the more modern economy, and we can look at where Colorado is really successful,
- 24:42and so far has been competitive, but has been pressured. Airspace, for example.
- 24:47In the airspace area, we compete with the likes of Texas. We are competing with the likes of
- 24:52say, California. How are we going to compete when the scale in those two locations alone?
- 24:57And then, of course, we also have the Washington state of Washington, where the scale there is so
- 25:02much greater than it is in Colorado. And that gravity just kind of draws those smart people to that
- 25:08place. Yes, that's true. And they also have policies to do so. Well, California less so,
- 25:13Texas now, much more so. Of course, we have Georgia, for example, which is trying to incentivize
- 25:18that Alabama. You have, there's a heat and competition around the United States.
- 25:24Well, I just came back from Hollywood. I was in Orange County, or the weekend, and we went
- 25:27up to Hollywood for the day, and the board walked there and stuff, and it was like, just thinking
- 25:34about how Hollywood can keep its mojo at this point in time. You know, you got states like Georgia,
- 25:41states like Montana and Idaho, bidding to have films and crews there. Their actors are a lot
- 25:47cheaper and a lot more eager to sign on for non-descript roles and stuff. And so the the monopoly of Hollywood
- 25:54is seems like at least being threatened. Hollywood doesn't make money by shooting movies.
- 25:59Right. I mean, Hollywood makes money by having intellectual property in those movies.
- 26:03This is why Hollywood doesn't make movies inside Hollywood anymore. They all over the place.
- 26:08From our point of view, though, it's really great to see that finally we're starting to recognize
- 26:12the idea that we have the Rocky Mountains in the movie, but it's really in Canada film.
- 26:16Right, right. It's really something for the mentally screwed up, yes? So I'm really glad that we're
- 26:21bringing trying to bring more and more incentives, more proactive incentives in terms of supporting film
- 26:26production here in Colorado. Again, a great sector, which can be again scaled if you just a location
- 26:33for production. That's one thing for filming. You need to have production. You need to have studios.
- 26:38You need to have computer computing. People don't have to do that. Correct. You need to have talent.
- 26:43We have computational facilities. We have ability to bring more of those. So for example,
- 26:48things like data centers, data centers, we always think of, hey, that's IT, yes. But without data
- 26:53centers, you cannot have processing. Shipping it, sending it across the satellite networks is time
- 26:59consuming, lag dependent, and expensive. So having the support of the backbone of the infrastructure
- 27:06here probably is a good idea. And if you start with that, you start going down, of course,
- 27:12how do we provide water for cooling? How do we provide energy? What sources of energy we're
- 27:17using? What the cost of energy? So all of a sudden, these traditional sectors, which we always
- 27:21thought of, hey, you know, like this is a dirty industrial stuff behind the scenes, it becomes
- 27:26closely aligned with modern sectors of production and investment, yes. So it is a part of the
- 27:33economic development that is very hard to crack. One of the things I've set up a number of times
- 27:39over the last few years is that in these days, especially during like COVID when they created so much
- 27:45money, you know, flooded the system almost with it to keep the liquidity going and whatever.
- 27:50But energy is more like money than money is like money anymore because you can't just print
- 27:56energy. You've got to pull it out of the ground or suck it out of the sun or whatever. And all
- 28:01those data centers and things like that, you know, computers sound nice and clean and stuff and
- 28:07all the little stuff that happens behind the screen when I push buttons. But it's really, you know,
- 28:11a bunch of coal and natural gas mostly being burned so that those data centers can spin.
- 28:16Tremendous. Yes, absolutely. And the energy mix here in Colorado is very problematic, yes,
- 28:21because of course, us using to reduce the cost of energy using coal is definitely questionable.
- 28:28We have natural gas, one of the very big producers, we should be using that more of that.
- 28:34There's a big concern from our point of view that the scale of the, say, for example, AI quantum
- 28:39computing and general computing as well, scale of using demand for energy is so much higher.
- 28:46Anything we have experienced before, that really you look at the base generation which has to
- 28:52rely on nuclear. You can't use the fossils or intermittent renewables. You'll have to bring
- 28:59big base and you have to bring nuclear problem from our perspective when nuclear is cooling.
- 29:05Yeah. And that is, but that is something that we are overcoming as a technology develops,
- 29:10so for example, things like small modular reactors, they can be much less scaled, you know,
- 29:17cooling. You can have cooling, which is based on the basically reservoir as opposed to the
- 29:21traditional cooling. You have to have a massive river where you have to have a massive supply of
- 29:26ocean water or something like that. Gotcha. Gotcha. So that gives us a little bit of an advantage.
- 29:31So we should start thinking about how do we integrate the modular reactors into the energy
- 29:36production and grid here. If you look, for example, also at the other sources, like say water
- 29:42again, we should start thinking more practically, how do we create the water sources and access to
- 29:48water and quality of water, which is filtering, of course, and bringing it up to standards that
- 29:53can support modern technologies. For example, Fab manufacturing for the processes, microprocessors,
- 30:00chips and things like that, yes. We have quite a lot of them. A lot of them are going into Arizona,
- 30:07where there is no water. We have why? Well, I mean because of the incentives. They have
- 30:11very strong incentives. And because they now have developed the processes where it's almost like
- 30:16sealed loop use of water. So you do not have to rely on a continuous solution. Well,
- 30:20and I suppose evaporative cooling is actually pretty efficient there when it's 100 degrees and
- 30:246% relative. Exactly. So we should be at that race as well. We should be at those games as well.
- 30:30We got the quantum computing coordinator here, which is awesome, which is great to have, okay. Great
- 30:36win to the governor, great win to the people in Denver. Fantastic, but we now need to branch out of
- 30:42it to provide the support for computational facilities for not just quantum computing but all
- 30:47of the joining and related industries. So you can see how many opportunities we have. Exploring
- 30:54those opportunities is we're blessed with them, okay. Exploring those opportunities requires
- 31:00certain way of changing the way we do things. One of the things that I observed here, and I observed
- 31:04that on the relationship between say, for example, within the northern Colorado, between the
- 31:09cities, within the northern Colorado, we were exploring the possibility of getting an NSF ground
- 31:16to support the kind of ideation stage of the policy formation for the integrated development
- 31:22of infrastructure systems within the northern Colorado. And the whole thing came to a
- 31:28screeching hold because the different cities don't want to talk to each other. It's almost like
- 31:33we want to build our own little empire. And then the little empire becomes, I used kind of the
- 31:39example of Weber. Used to be a larger city in Colorado. Yeah, it was actually bigger before
- 31:46than Colorado Springs. Is that right? Yeah, that's right. And it kind of decayed over a period of
- 31:53time due to internal and external neglect effectively, okay. It became a kind of a spot for
- 32:03high unemployment, for example. Yeah. It also became a city where there was much less of the
- 32:09different diverse development in terms of the economic development. Yep. More linked to the
- 32:15combination of the kind of, you know, traditional sectors. And then the Colorado Springs took the
- 32:20wind out of the company. Right. Right. So, well, do you think being closer to Denver helped
- 32:25Colorado Springs anyway? Of course it does. Yeah. Beyond the endows. But can you pair that? Can you
- 32:31respond to that? Through the more coordinated? I wasn't actually suggesting that
- 32:36this probably should have competed with Colorado Springs directly. I'm saying Colorado Springs
- 32:42and probably should have cooperated more. We are beyond that kind of economy where you can have
- 32:47a very competitive adversarial relationship. Yeah. It is more about the economy where you have to
- 32:53find the mutual ways to build added value, create added value. So my argument has been, for example,
- 32:59the in order for the Northern Colorado to thrive and survive into the next say a couple of decades
- 33:06if not longer beyond that, we have to compete with Denver. We have to compete with Denver,
- 33:10Boulder corridor. Yeah. In order to do so, we cannot afford not to cooperate across the border
- 33:17with Cheyenne. We cannot afford not to cooperate with the likes of between the Fort Collins,
- 33:23Greeley and Loveland. We need to start building concerted cooperative channels of infrastructure,
- 33:30transport infrastructure, roads infrastructure, sure. But also energy infrastructure, water
- 33:36infrastructure and also intellectual property infrastructure or intellectual mobility infrastructure.
- 33:41We need to have a high quality connectivity between the different areas. We need to have the
- 33:47interlinked and coordinated policies between the universities here, community colleges here,
- 33:53all the way down to middle schools. We need to have, we need to stop building little
- 33:59empires and start focusing on the region overall. Yeah. I think the, my sense is that the chambers
- 34:05of commerce like each other quite a bit within those three cities, but that the city, the government
- 34:11authorities are a little different game and so on. It's very interesting. Yeah. I kind of, I get that
- 34:15feeling that there is a bit more cooperation when you start talking to say, for example,
- 34:19people responsible for economic policy. Yeah. But that's because in every textbook, they know
- 34:24cooperative games, you know, with a better outcome than non-cooperative games. Fair enough. I mean,
- 34:30you don't want to have prisoners dilemma. Yes. And we have enough common if you want vocabulary
- 34:35to kind of say, yeah, we know what prisoners dilemma leads to. Yeah. But when you take politicians
- 34:41today, and this is very interesting, I think it's very astute observation because I think it also
- 34:45is the mark of our times, which you are putting your finger on is exactly that, that polarization
- 34:50that we have in a policy spectrum comes from the political spectrum polarization. And the political
- 34:56spectrum polarization is evident all the way to the Washington DC. How much cooperation does the
- 35:02Congress today achieve? Almost zero. Exactly. When you go back in history, has there been a
- 35:08transformational president in the United States history who has not become transformational
- 35:14president by achieving consensus and achieving the, you know, all leading the majority of the Congress?
- 35:19Of course not. We think not. Exactly. So we can't do anything because we have these kind of
- 35:25politics of extreme polarization. Yeah. Yeah. I wouldn't we've spent a fair bit of time on Northern
- 35:31Colorado, which has been super interesting. But cool. I want to zoom up a little bit. Okay.
- 35:37Your LinkedIn profile suggests you're kind of an expert in
- 35:41Russian and Irish economic factors and things. And like I want to talk about like financing
- 35:51war, financing economies. You know, part of what I've said, I'm a libertarian minded guy for a
- 35:58long time and one of Reagan's old quotes I think is, you know, tax what you want less of and
- 36:03subsidize what you want more of. And I generally abide by that notion. And so if we could get to
- 36:12a less income tax financed economy government function in the US and do so through some combination
- 36:20of tariffs and I've been a fan of the FairTox FairTax.org kind of a consumption tax because
- 36:28we kind of want less consumption. Anyway, according to all the, you know, the climate
- 36:34people and stuff like that. And so like instead of trying to get people to hide their income or
- 36:39not make any income, like let's just tax consumption. Yeah, that's okay. Look, there's a there are
- 36:45different ways of taxation. There are different tools for taxation. Some of it has been tried in
- 36:52different jurisdictions and generates different results. Consumption tax is very interesting. Yes,
- 36:56we have a sales tax in the United States. Sales tax is non-discriminatory in so far as it is
- 37:02applies to say, for example, where you manufacture the goods or services where you produce them.
- 37:08It is also non-discriminatory in so far as, you know, which component to use, right, in the
- 37:13production. Yes. So it is more of a tax on the actual consumption rather than the tax on the value
- 37:18added. In the European Union, for example, in the rest of the world, it is mostly the value added
- 37:24tax, which is again not as discriminatory on the basis of where the things are made, but rather
- 37:31on the basis of who adds value pays the tax. Yes. So there's a lot of interesting things which go
- 37:37with both of those. There are some advantages disadvantages for those things. Okay, but when we go
- 37:41towards greater automation, when we go towards a greater contribution of technological capital
- 37:47in the production and in the value added, you're right. We want to go away from the idea of income
- 37:52tax, because income tax penalizes work by us. Yeah. Whether it's work when we invest in ourselves
- 37:59and our parents invest in us by educating us, or it's a work that we pursue ourselves by
- 38:06creating ourselves. Or it is a physical work that we do literally spend an hour on the job
- 38:11doing whatever we do. Okay. It's the effort which you actually want to reward rather than penalize.
- 38:18Yeah. So I would be all in favor of moving away from the income tax based economy. Okay.
- 38:24The United States is not quite an income tax based economy. It's mostly debt based. Right.
- 38:28So we're not taxing. Yeah, good thing we don't tax our people.
- 38:32In favor of shifting completely towards the consumption taxes and wealth taxes.
- 38:37And the reason why wealth taxes are important. Okay. It's because you have to realize that a lot of
- 38:42wealth at a high level, not the level that you and I are familiar with. Okay. But at the level of say
- 38:47billionaires and multi-millionaires, a lot of that wealth is the income. These people don't need to
- 38:52pay income tax at all because they are living off or diverging their wealth. Okay. So we can introduce
- 38:59a tax on wealth which is not prohibitive to the general upper middle class and below part of
- 39:04the population. We can't tax the one percent. I'm not saying I'm not in a territory of the,
- 39:10you know, Sanders or Bernie Sanders like that by any possible means I come from the
- 39:15libertarian tradition of thinking as well. Just like yourself, especially on economic side.
- 39:20I mean, you know, have background studying under the University of Chicago School of Economics.
- 39:26So I would be in favor of that. Let's also add to that another tax which is, you know,
- 39:32I've done some work in an Irish context because it was part of the International Monetary Fund
- 39:37review of the Irish taxation policies after the global financial crisis and so forth. And that's
- 39:42the tax on land. Site value tax or land value tax. Practice in some parts of say, for example,
- 39:49Pennsylvania and the United States. Some other parts as well in the United States. You know,
- 39:53and it's a very different than property tax. It's different. It is assessed against the value of
- 39:59the site on which the property sits. So you can make an effort and improve the land. Okay.
- 40:05But our own improvements are not going to be taxed. What will be taxed if say, for example,
- 40:10a local government decides to put a school nearby the, you know, nearby your site and that
- 40:16increases the value of the site without you doing it. That value then will be captured in the
- 40:21value of land, not in the value of the structure that you have with a garden that you have there
- 40:26growing or whatever else. Okay. So alternatively, of course, what happens when the government decides
- 40:31to put a highway next to your house in which case your value of the land drops and you get effectively
- 40:38partially compensated through the lower taxation. Yeah, interesting. So I mean, again, you know,
- 40:44there has been research done in the United States on that primarily actually on the
- 40:47Georgia society and the likes, you know. Okay. And there's a lot of interest in that. So go back
- 40:52to the wealth tax with me. Is that something that would be like not not a transfer of wealth,
- 40:58like an inheritance thing, but more like a pay 0.5% every year. Yeah. No, it would be actually based
- 41:04on the actual value of wealth. You can have it on an annual basis. I think inheritance tax will
- 41:10already have that. Right. Fine with me. I think, you know, you have just like with, say, for
- 41:16example, flat taxes, you have a very generous upfront deduction. So again, you're not snaring into
- 41:22that. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. People who are if I got three hundred thousand other house, I shouldn't
- 41:26have to pay a extra five hundred dollars a year. Yeah. Absolutely. Of course. Or you have, you know,
- 41:31if you are inheriting a house, which is, you know, family house, which is two million dollars,
- 41:35don't pay anything. That's fine with me. Okay. You don't use this taxation in order to generate revenue
- 41:41alone. You use this taxation to reorient the society's value. Yeah. Yeah. You want to have the
- 41:47value in a society where people not accumulating houses as well, but rather accumulating other things,
- 41:54like businesses, like, you know, ideas, like human capital. So when you think about it, do we want
- 42:02to encourage formation of fixed capital formation in this economy? Probably not so much. Yes, we want
- 42:08to have good infrastructure at a high level, of course, at a high kind of if you want aggregate
- 42:12level. Sure. Whatever good roads. We want to have good communications and so forth. But, you know,
- 42:18apart from that, we want to have usable real estate that we live in. It doesn't require a huge
- 42:24amount of the parts of GDP invested on ongoing basis. Some of our policies, like I was just thinking
- 42:31about the interest deduction on your home mortgage or your rental property mortgage or whatever,
- 42:35you know, that's an incentive to carry debt. Correct. Yeah. And I don't know why we should have taxes
- 42:41against the incentive. We do that. Not because we want to incentivize the carry of the debt,
- 42:46where it's originated from. But today, it's because we can't abolish that because if we abolish
- 42:50that, all of a sudden, even what we call affordable houses are going to become unaffordable instantaneously.
- 42:57So, we, in a way, kind of create, it's, you know, if you go back to the philosophy of
- 43:02your own, like in a physics, yes, in all days, you know, in the Ptolemaic, you know, kind of
- 43:07walled, yes, you had to draw these weird things called epicycles, yes, the force fields which
- 43:12didn't exist in order to counterbalance the planets. So, it's to make the earth the center of the
- 43:17universe, yes. And sooner or later, you started to come to the point where those epicycles are
- 43:22descriptors of everything. And you know they don't exist. So, you've got a problem. The same
- 43:28without tax and subsidies policy. And this is a painful day today, of course, yes. I mean,
- 43:33because we're talking about the 15th of April, actually, you're talking about, it's a great example,
- 43:37okay. You can have a middle class family, like my, my own, where your tax forms amount to about
- 43:43170 pages. Yeah. It is insane. It is literally insane. So, taxation system in the United States,
- 43:50and I'm not getting the burden of doing your taxes. It's almost as bad as the taxes that you
- 43:55actually pay. It's a total industry. And it holds us hostage once a year, okay. And if you're in
- 44:00business, it holds you hostage more often than every payroll. That's right. Yes. So, I mean,
- 44:05the insanity of it is that we don't even think about the fact that we have all of this
- 44:10infrastructure that creates no value. Yeah. And we can have a simplifying reforms and we can
- 44:16have a change. As you said, for example, a good example would be moving towards more consumption
- 44:21based taxes. A good example would be to remove as much as possible and flatten out there after
- 44:28the structure of say income tax. Yeah, maybe a 12 page tax return. Yeah. Well, we shouldn't,
- 44:33you know, like if you are working, say, for example, if you have one source of income, active
- 44:38income, and maybe one source of passive income, you should not be filing the form, you know,
- 44:43more than say two, three pages. Who the hell needs all of that stuff? Who the hell actually checks
- 44:49all of that stuff? Who manages all of that stuff? There's a lot of jobs reliant upon having all those
- 44:54pages to check. To honest, personally, I think that most of those jobs are pretending to do the job.
- 44:59Oh, yeah. And in the end, there is an outcome. And everyone is sitting and praying that nobody will
- 45:04check. Because to be frank, I don't think there is a possibility of, you know, fully
- 45:12completing those hundreds of pages of tax forms without missing something. Somehow, I mean,
- 45:20the next tax fraud and they can throw you in prison. Well, of course, if it is intended,
- 45:24if it isn't intended to tax fraud, but I mean, again, the separation between what is the
- 45:30tax fraud versus the tax mistake is kind of, you know, a little bit more arbitrary than I would like
- 45:35that to be. But I can tell you that, you know, I was talking to a colleague of mine, who is a
- 45:39professor of finance here in the United States, not in this state, you know, today. And we were both,
- 45:45you know, kind of was supposed to be working on the paper that we are supposed to review. And
- 45:51both of us can't actually review the paper because we are both mired into taxes completely.
- 45:57I mean, this is, you know, these are two people with the PhDs in economics and finance,
- 46:02who are struggling. And we have advisors hired for that. So it wasn't like, you know,
- 46:07struggling, you know, by ourselves, you know, doing it. So there is something fundamentally wrong
- 46:12with this system that we have. It is not incentivizing things we want to incentivize.
- 46:17Yeah. It is penalizing quite often effort by people. It is penalized and it over decades
- 46:23in generation that translates into the change in culture and preferences. And once you get to
- 46:30that territory of kind of change, you know, there all is so deep that changing it and reversing it
- 46:36is not impossible, but so daunting that a lot of people give up. Yeah. Yeah. I think there's a
- 46:42lot of young kids right now, even that are like, no way I'll ever buy a house, you know,
- 46:46and yeah. And you know what, if you save 10% of your income and live like a coyote for a long time,
- 46:53that's it lie. You'll be able to eventually, you know, yes, no, I mean, again, it's hard to,
- 46:59first of all, we expect the young people. I have two kids, you know, one is 18, another one is 14.
- 47:07And you know, it's very hard to expect from those kids to behave the way we want them to behave.
- 47:13Because we, our generation has created for them the trappings of social media, of peer pressure,
- 47:21of kind of, you know, high expectations, you know, they're all carrying a thousand dollar phones
- 47:26in their pockets right now. So you can say things like, you know, you shouldn't be doing that and
- 47:31they turn around and say, but Dad, you work for that. You create that. You use that yourself all
- 47:38of the time. So in a way, it is very hard to see how we're going to get out of this, you know,
- 47:45the problem and predicament that we have that has grown over the last say 25 years or so.
- 47:51And I'm using millennium as a break point, but started, of course, before the millennium, yes.
- 47:55How we're going to go not so much back, but forward towards the values that we have lost,
- 48:02that we would like to have. We know we should have. And yet, we have worked so hard to dismiss.
- 48:11Talk to me about, by the way, I didn't even ask you, you've got an accent. It seems you're from
- 48:18somewhere Eastern European, I guess. Oh, I would like, I'm a mix of pretty much everything under
- 48:24the sun. Very trying to be very quick, you know, just, I was born and raised in Soviet Union
- 48:30in Moscow. I am of Russian and Armenian descent. Okay. I immigrated into the United States
- 48:40in 1999. So like Armenian because you're one of your parents, like, from the genocide there,
- 48:46in Turkey and stuff, or was it common? It was a little bit before. It was before. Yeah, it was
- 48:50common. Yeah, of course. Well, there's a little uncle of Armenia up there in by Lithuania or
- 48:54something, too, right? No, no, no, no, you're thinking about, there's, you know, it's out of by John,
- 48:58there's a whole war, but that's the Soviets created that mess. So there's a war going on there,
- 49:05of course. Yeah, but Armenia always kind of had link links with Russia because of the orthodoxy
- 49:12because of the religion and because, of course, you know, cultural as well. So my, you know, predecessors
- 49:18from Armenia moved to Russia proper back in the 1840s. Gotcha. The hints my last name is
- 49:25Russified. Okay. Back in the days, if you went to Imperial University, you had to
- 49:29crucify your name and accept Christianity. Of course, they already were Christian and they
- 49:33crucified the name. So that's kind of the terminology of it. So I was born in Soviet Union. I grew
- 49:39up in the Soviet Union. And in my year 21 of my age, I moved to the United States to California.
- 49:48And I spent 1990s in the United States for education. No, I first knew that because I had a business.
- 49:55And the business that was started with two American partners. Okay. From California,
- 50:01the registered in California. And then soon or later, because they had their own businesses,
- 50:04they had to run, I had to come to LA to run the business. Okay. I was kind of managing it on a
- 50:10Soviet life business. It was a brokerage company. Okay. So we were trying to broker joint ventures
- 50:15between the and investment flows between the Soviet enterprises and the US based companies.
- 50:21Sure. And it was successful on the side of finding the projects. And then kind of, you know,
- 50:27of course, recession of the 1990s killed us off. So I moved in 1990 to the United States to
- 50:34run the business. And it was actually very easy to do back then because there wasn't really anyone
- 50:40else moving from Soviet Union through any business. Right. So and then I ended up closing the business
- 50:45when we became kind of, you know, we ran into basically cash flow problems. And you know,
- 50:50we had investors lined up. We couldn't, you know, get over the hump. Yeah. And so in 1993,
- 50:56I figured out that I have to go and finish my education. And I started an engineer and back in
- 51:01the Soviet Union at the time. So I went to UCLA and I said, you know, I'd like to finish my degree.
- 51:07They looked at my transcript back in the days it was before computers. So it was a very big book
- 51:12that actually found my school in Moscow, translated my grades into the UCLA scale or whatever it was.
- 51:19And they kind of said, what would you like to study? And I said, you know, I always want to do
- 51:23something international. So I said, you have too much mathematics and physics in order to do
- 51:29international studies. But there is an economics degree and you can do, you know, basically
- 51:34an international specialization in economics. So I knew nothing about economics. I knew it was
- 51:40international. I always wanted to study something international. So I said, fine. So I came in into
- 51:45the third year and to UCLA, finished that, went on to the masters, then went on to do the
- 51:50PhD. Chicago. So no, no, no. First, actually at UCLA, I did my masters in mathematics there.
- 51:58And then I went to Chicago to University of Chicago to do the PhD.
- 52:03Wasn't the happy time for me was a bit personal kind of tough year. So I transferred from there
- 52:08to Johns Hopkins. And I was in Johns Hopkins. I met in Chicago my partner currently, my
- 52:16better half. And we moved to Baltimore. And I was into my second year of PhD there. And I got
- 52:24effectively just opportunistically, you know, had counted. Okay. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
- 52:30So trained to college Dublin in Ireland, you know, through the network. And henceforth comes
- 52:35the Irish economy. So in the year 2000, you know, we moved, you know, to Ireland for a couple
- 52:41of years. When times are happened. Yeah, exactly. I mean, it was great. Absolutely. It was right
- 52:45peak of the kind of second wave of the Celtic tiger before it became what I call Celtic Garfield,
- 52:52that was it. It was boom time. It was dot com boom and everything. And we moved for a couple
- 52:58of years, 16 years later, two kids, a dog, houses and everything else. You know, Irish citizenship
- 53:05and everything, you know, we kind of came back in 2016 for I was in business a little bit for a
- 53:12while day in Europe. And then I sold out of business there and decided to go back to academia.
- 53:20So we moved to California back to where I started from in the United States. I spent four
- 53:26years there in Monterey. Oh, no, great place. Absolutely. Love it. Still go back there all of the
- 53:34time. A lot of friends, fantastic place. pandemic hit. I lost my job. And I was on the market. So
- 53:43did the land you hear? Northern Colorado gave me an offer. I couldn't refuse. So we moved here.
- 53:51So it's kind of it's very interesting because I mean, I'm you know, I became over the 1990s period
- 53:57in particular, a mountain goat. So I love climbing. I love you know, being up in the mountains. I love
- 54:02hiking, I love fly fishing. I love foraging. So even though we lived on the coasts in California
- 54:08and in Ireland, you know, a house in Ireland is literally on the sea front. And you know,
- 54:14I always kind of drawn to the mountains. And my wife comes, you know, her family comes from
- 54:20Northern Italy. We have a house in the Alps there. All right. So moving here was for me a very
- 54:25natural move. Yeah. You know, I'm kind of maximizing that and we spend the entire winter of
- 54:32fly fishing because you can't do it in California because I have seasons. Oh, really.
- 54:36And here you can go, you know, any river, you know, it's like there's open water. Exactly. You
- 54:42have a little bit of the open water. You can fly fish. We spend all of the winter, you know,
- 54:46up in the mountains as well. So I'm pretty much every week, you know, so you're happy. I am happy.
- 54:51I'm happy in a different way as well in terms of my life as well. When you grow older, you kind of
- 54:58discover things that more matter that are more importantly become usually slower things.
- 55:02And for me, that's exactly what's happening. Yeah. I'm kind of, you know, decided that all of the media,
- 55:09you know, I've done that. Not interested that much anymore. Public engagements don't really need
- 55:16them either that much. Being able to do quietly research without the rat race that a lot of
- 55:22universities engage in. Yeah. Yeah. One of the things about the population, all these things.
- 55:27Well, we have, yeah, of course, but the pressure say one of the best part of UNC from my point of
- 55:32view is that I can do my research there. Yeah. No one tells me which areas I should be specialized in.
- 55:38Going to the likes of say CU Boulder, you are forced to actually be specialists in a very
- 55:43narrow area. You need to pursue publishing to the point, not just publisher pairs, but publishing
- 55:48the top 10 journals in a discipline. And come up with the conclusions that are in line with
- 55:56our general philosophies. Exactly. Exactly. Exactly. Yes. So in my world now, I have the
- 56:04luxury of basically saying, I'm interested in this. Let's do that. Okay. And to give you
- 56:10example, like I mean, I have a call through for example, who comes with an interesting data set,
- 56:14you know, quite recently. And says, let's do that. But the data set on Indonesian banks.
- 56:21Fine. Sure. I can do that. You know, exactly. And my colleagues would appreciate that. Yeah.
- 56:27And you know, you know, in terms of my job appraisal and everything else, it counts as much.
- 56:31Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. And there's a luxury to that, of course, you know. Well, and, you know,
- 56:36I think it seems to me anyway that the Montper College of Business is really an interesting
- 56:41opportunity. You know, it's it's fairly well funded and supported. They're they're savvy.
- 56:46They've recruited a bunch of smart people into the program and not just as an economist,
- 56:52but you've been in business at least a couple different times as well. And so you kind of appreciate
- 56:56not the just the academic instinct of your field, but actually putting them rubber to the road.
- 57:02Of course. And we do that. And that's that's very important as well. So I mean, like one of the very
- 57:06big things, and I have an 18 year old who is going to college right now and a decision-making
- 57:10is in a local college. So I'm kind of three right now. Uh, cost is very important. Of course,
- 57:15consideration because, you know, you don't want me to prep down a bunch of things. You don't really
- 57:20exactly. You know, I'm actually not a person who likes that. I mentioned our guiding before. Yes,
- 57:25our guiding growth. I'm a big fan of funding things from the cash flow you generate. So I don't
- 57:31want him to graduate with any that at all. Yeah. Uh, there's a bit of a tug of war because here,
- 57:36of course, doesn't understand it yet. I mean, hey, we'll all be there, you know, and when you look
- 57:40back and you say, oh, my mom did say that. Yeah, that's true. You know, I should have listened,
- 57:44you know, well, I like that. You know, but we learn from our own bruises. I have some, uh,
- 57:48some advice from my own background. My so my dad started a farm. He was a motorcycle mechanic going
- 57:54back to 14 years old. And then he started farming evenings and weekends for 14 years or something
- 58:00he farmed evening weekends. But eventually the farm was working about the time I was going to college.
- 58:05And, uh, dad said, well, son, you know, the farms doing good enough now. We could help you with
- 58:10your school in a little bit. Um, but I think you get a lot more out of it if you pay for it yourself.
- 58:16And that's amazing. Yeah. He was right. I mean, at the time I bet you you were going like, what
- 58:21that? He was right. I mean, everybody I knew that flucked out. Yeah. Their parents were paying for
- 58:26it. Yeah. So I haven't been for at least a little bit. So I mean, like we learn different
- 58:32things. So yeah, I mean, but when you think about one of the advantages that of the, um,
- 58:37UNC and Monfort College in particular is that we are actually laser focused on the idea that
- 58:43all of the people going through the program in business. It doesn't matter whether you're
- 58:46starting marketing, you're starting management, you're starting finance, okay. We'll have a full
- 58:51portfolio of internships. And those internships can be structured in so far as they can be repeated
- 58:58over the period of time. We want to place you example a little bit of a few different things.
- 59:02So even like people like myself, we're running around all of the time trying to find new opportunities
- 59:07for internships, okay. So for example, we I was talking to a big healthcare provider in a area
- 59:13here now in in the state of Colorado, um, who is going to come on board with offering
- 59:19internships for all of students. Pretty awesome. There's sometimes you get students who want to
- 59:24do international as well. You try to find for them opportunities international
- 59:28challenging out of Greeley, but nonetheless, that's our job. We want to do that. So everything we
- 59:33teach has to be aligned, not just we don't, unlike other universities, unlike what we call R1
- 59:39level universities, research focused universities. We're not training kids to go or kids or young adults
- 59:45to go into a PhD program down the road. We don't disadvantage them in that sense as well. We give
- 59:52them the ABCs, but if they want to do a PhD, they probably should either look at different
- 59:59universities or look at the career path to PhD. So in other words, you graduate. Yeah. I didn't
- 1:00:04implore a little help. You pay for your. Exactly. But also who will give you a frame for what you want
- 1:00:09to study. Yeah. Of course, the PhD by itself. Yeah, where do I point it? Exactly. Yeah. So from that
- 1:00:14point of view, we're much more applied. Our view is and we constantly do that. I've served, for example,
- 1:00:19on the curriculum committee. I want to graduate committee nowadays as well. We constantly look
- 1:00:24at it from the point of view opportunities. I had international affairs for the MCB and part of
- 1:00:32my job is explicitly, even when we talk about the exchanges for the faculty, international exchanges,
- 1:00:38we always condition them as to what's the benefit for students? What doors does it open for students?
- 1:00:44What opportunities are open for students? Okay. We're trying to structure the programs where we
- 1:00:49bring students out. We try to support them. We have scholarships for that. Not only we have
- 1:00:54scholarships, unlike other universities where you have the student body, some of which can afford
- 1:01:00additional two, three, five thousand for a trip abroad to study. We actually structure it on a
- 1:01:06basis. There should be no additional cost for students compared to what they actually incur in
- 1:01:11their normal semester. That's cool. So most of our programs are like that. And since I joined,
- 1:01:16we had this big debate with the international affairs office, for example, who wanted to structure
- 1:01:23more of the traditional study abroad educational opportunities where you go for a semester and it
- 1:01:30is a third party provider. Yeah, you screw around. Hold your hand and everything else. No, no,
- 1:01:34it's a serious program. Don't take me wrong. They're great as well. But they're much costly. So we
- 1:01:38kind of managed to restore that balance. We want our students to go irrespective of their
- 1:01:44income, irrespective of their financial opportunities. And we want them to do that because it opens
- 1:01:50doors because it opens different horizons because the company's internationally trading companies
- 1:01:54even based on Colorado will look at your CV or your resume when you're graduating from college and
- 1:02:00they will try to identify those students who have that experience, who have that exposure to
- 1:02:04international dimension in their classroom and so forth. So yeah, absolutely. If there's somebody
- 1:02:10listening and they might have internships available for their medium-sized business out there
- 1:02:15in the northern front range, can they just stock you in LinkedIn or something like that? Absolutely.
- 1:02:19Any channel, I mean, you know, first of all, you can, you can bloody Google me, okay?
- 1:02:24And you can get my email. If it's private email, use it whichever way. If you see me at any event,
- 1:02:30you know, stop me. We are looking for that. And it's not just, don't call me at the office because
- 1:02:35I don't answer phone calls. But call me on my cell phone. Call me in any way, shape or form, okay?
- 1:02:42And it also applies to other colleagues of mine. You can reach out to anyone. If you go on MCB's
- 1:02:47website, you have all of us with our email addresses, email any of us and there will be this
- 1:02:53same support as well. We want to see that more. We will, in fact, actually in other programs,
- 1:02:59in other universities, you would have probably an administrator dealing with you if you want an
- 1:03:04intern. If you reach out to somebody like myself and you say, I'm looking for this skill set
- 1:03:09in intern, we will, I will reach out to my faculty. You know the 23 people that are looking
- 1:03:14well, not to 200 people, okay? Like say, you know, 400 people, we have an hour in finance, we have
- 1:03:19about 200 plus students. So, but we know them because there's about, you know, say 10 of us
- 1:03:26who are teaching them and I can email all 10 of us and somebody will come up with the list of
- 1:03:31different students. We can discuss them and we can then offer them as your interns. That's the
- 1:03:38level of work we do. And it's totally normal from our point of view and it's totally expected from
- 1:03:44our point of view because when somebody says that we are student-centric, everyone says that, okay?
- 1:03:48Yeah, yeah. We actually genuinely have to be student-centric because A, we have to compete with
- 1:03:53the bigger universities and better funded universities. And there's a lot of competition in the
- 1:03:58Northern Colorado Territory of course, yeah? We also have to work with students which come from so
- 1:04:04many different diverse backgrounds. Mm-hmm. Who are interested in so many things? Yeah, yeah. I
- 1:04:09imagine some of your students are, they're, they're a first-time college student in their whole family
- 1:04:14and they're coming from Kansas or from Sterling. Or 40%? Yeah. And it's a stretch for them to afford
- 1:04:19the tuition that UNC charges. Absolutely. And a lot of the other ones are like, it's half as much
- 1:04:26as CSU so I'm going to go there instead because it seems it's good. Absolutely. Or it's too big. CSU's
- 1:04:31scary and big and I would rather just go to a school where I'm going to know. There's a lot of
- 1:04:34legacy things. There's a lot of pool into UNC from students who know somebody who graduated.
- 1:04:41Maybe not in their family but in their neighborhood, in their area as well. That's one of the
- 1:04:46things there's another attractor as well. So at UNC in the outskull in MCB in particular, we
- 1:04:51expect our students to be fully time working. So we're accommodating them. We don't, we don't
- 1:04:56require them but we expect them. We know that a lot of them will be. Well, all of them will have
- 1:05:02part-time jobs guaranteed. Okay. Most of them have more than part-time job in a traditional way.
- 1:05:06It's more than half load. So as a result of that we try to accommodate them as much as possible. So
- 1:05:11one of the things we did and that came in and forced this year and it's continued all in
- 1:05:15out as well. We have switched from the five day teaching to four day teaching. So when I have
- 1:05:21Monday, you take Monday Wednesday in person or Tuesday, Thursday in person and then Friday is
- 1:05:28remote. So it's down to myself and my students to decide how we want to work that day. I usually
- 1:05:35just post some material for them. I'm available if they want to reach out and we can have one on one.
- 1:05:40Sure. We can have with a group meeting. It's kind of your research time and different
- 1:05:44things like that too. No, not really. It's still a student time. How to present it? Student time.
- 1:05:48So I'm available to them. It's just that when we work together, we work say for example on the
- 1:05:52project. Okay. So again, hands-on experiential learning is facilitated through it. But if you are
- 1:05:58working or if you have to commute back home for the weekend and so forth, you can do it. Yeah.
- 1:06:03So we try to accommodate as much as possible those type of flexibility. We offer now a completion
- 1:06:09degree online, which you can finish degrees online as well. So there's a lot of different
- 1:06:15modalities. Okay. Yeah. And it is successful for us. Okay. So one of the most successful programs
- 1:06:20in the MBA, for example, and our MBA is fully online, fully remote. Right. There is no
- 1:06:26requirement for synchronous, but again, we have the flexibility. Do I get to know my fellow MBA
- 1:06:31students or anything? It's up to the projects. Yes, 100%. So my class, so I'm teaching one class now,
- 1:06:37I'm going to teach two classes in the program starting in the fall. My class is all required
- 1:06:42group work. I also hold not synchronous, but kind of, you know, preset hours. So once a week,
- 1:06:50I have two hours where I'm available. Anyone can come in on Zoom at any moment in time during those
- 1:06:57two hours. They can come in to discuss the questions. They can come in to discuss life. By
- 1:07:02dolphin, actually, that happens more than different questions and finance. And it's an opportunity
- 1:07:08also for students to talk between themselves. Sure. So even though they're physically separated,
- 1:07:14of course, I can be anywhere located and a lot of them allocated in different states as well.
- 1:07:18Sure. And even in the Colorado, they distributed as well. There's somebody who is up in the mountains,
- 1:07:22you know, somebody who is in the western Colorado, you know, you have an ability to have a forum.
- 1:07:28So yes, I mean, the answer is we would like to have much more community. We would like to have
- 1:07:33much more building of a traditional interaction between students, networks, and so forth. We are
- 1:07:39working on it. We have created, for example, a student advisory body. So there's an alumni body,
- 1:07:46which is advising us, which is pretty large. It started with, I think, originally five people.
- 1:07:52This is the second year that it is in existence. And I think it's now about 20. Oh, well,
- 1:07:57of course, there's alumni network, which is kind of formal and traditional network. Sure.
- 1:08:01But that's kind of managed that university giving their time, right? Yes, absolutely. And this
- 1:08:07event is now we're going to have, I think, the second event where it's coming up, we're going to
- 1:08:12have in Denver meeting. And we're trying to scale that up as well. So, you know, go.
- 1:08:18Or those path graduates. Yeah. So we're going to have a lot of jobs in every region and
- 1:08:22stuff. Ultimately, every couple of months, we would have a network and event. That's the hope
- 1:08:26that we are heading. And towards and the networking event in bigger areas like Denver, Metro,
- 1:08:33like, say, for example, Boulder, yeah, and so forth. So yeah, very cool. My, uh, my alma mater is
- 1:08:40North Dakota State, which back in those days was a rival with UNC in Division Two football.
- 1:08:47Oh, okay. They, they traded titles a few times back 20 years ago. I don't know if they are
- 1:08:52still, you know, I honestly don't know North Dakota State moved up a level. Okay. All right. So
- 1:08:56there's one FCS now. Okay. I think they've won like 12 out of the last 15 championships.
- 1:09:01Okay. I'm pretty ignorant about those parts. Yeah. Not of my kids. I am. What we call football
- 1:09:08isn't football around here. Yes. Yeah. But no, look, I mean, you know, it's fine. Yeah. Yeah.
- 1:09:12It's locally, you know, I mean, there is also like the, you know, if you think about different
- 1:09:16levels and types of football, and we think about soccer versus American football, I'm starting
- 1:09:22to think about say Irish football, yes. And then Australian rules as well. And all of a sudden,
- 1:09:27you kind of get completely, yeah, exactly. It looks totally different. Yes. I mean, uh, you know,
- 1:09:33it isn't drag bit. It isn't your football, but it is something like football. It's true.
- 1:09:38I want to take a quick break. Yeah, party break. And then we'll come back. And I want to talk a
- 1:09:43little bit about the kind of risks in the world. You know, what can we look forward to in the next
- 1:09:49six to 12 months, both economically, but also conflict risks. All right. Yeah. Fun. Cool. Okay.
- 1:09:59Hi, this is Clint Jasperson, managing partner at Purpose Driven Wealth. We believe financial
- 1:10:05clarity leads to a life of contentment and purpose. Our mission is to guide clients through
- 1:10:10the complexities of wealth management, retirement planning, and legacy using a values driven,
- 1:10:17stewardship based approach focused on provision, contentment, and enjoyment. With more than a
- 1:10:23century of expertise through thriving, we offer tailored strategies to help individuals and
- 1:10:28families achieve their goals and embrace generosity, whether you're navigating a life or business
- 1:10:34transition, or planning for the future. We're here to partner with you every step of the way.
- 1:10:39To learn more about Purpose Driven Wealth, call 970-330-7411. And we're back. So one of the reasons
- 1:10:51I first reached out back a few months ago was I thought with your name, you might be kind of an
- 1:10:56expert on the Russia Ukraine region and insights about, you know, is it really about the rare earth?
- 1:11:02Is it really about NATO? Is it really about poking the bear until the bear had to claw back?
- 1:11:10All of these things. You don't poke the bear for no reason. I mean, there is a bear there.
- 1:11:18If you hike into the mud, don't poke the bear. No matter what the reason is. But you know,
- 1:11:23the way it's kind of is the allegory. Yes, don't poke the bear. There is a history. Yes,
- 1:11:29there's a long-term history. There's issues. Russia sees itself for whether it's right or wrong.
- 1:11:36As a, you know, not necessarily super power, but perhaps a power to be reckoned with.
- 1:11:41Yes, somebody respected. Correct. And it regained that respect by, you know, hard effort.
- 1:11:49Not always the most constructive effort. But nonetheless, from the Russian perspective,
- 1:11:53with this constructive record, it's a very important effort as well. It's a geopolitical power which
- 1:11:58kind of sees, you know, kind of similar to America in not sense that it sees itself as a messenger,
- 1:12:04as the dominant player in the region, if not globally. So, poking the bear was
- 1:12:14ill-advised. Like the acceptance of Lithuania and all these? No, not so much. That was okay.
- 1:12:19So, this is a very interesting thing about this. You know, we kind of, we first, originally,
- 1:12:23when the process of the breakdown of the Warsaw Pact, and a kind of Soviet empire started,
- 1:12:30we actually overestimated the extent of sensitivities that was involved. From Russian perspective,
- 1:12:36the Baltic states were never naturally a part of Russia. They were more like Finland or whatever.
- 1:12:41Exactly. Bingo. And this Finland is a great example. Yes, Finland was incorporated into Russia
- 1:12:46as a basically fully autonomous entity, with its own parliament, with its own government, with its
- 1:12:51own rules, laws, and everything else. In the Soviet? No, that was before. No, wait a little
- 1:12:56way before. In the Russian empire, yes. So, when the Soviet, sorry, when the Russian empire itself
- 1:13:02dissolved, when the Tsar abdicated, it dissolved the connection because the Tsar was never the Tsar
- 1:13:09of Finland. Right. He was basically a large duke of Finland. Yeah, yeah, yeah. So, in a way,
- 1:13:15the art disappearing, there was no other connection between Finland and Russia. Nobody else
- 1:13:19came into that agreement, if you will. So, there was no basic. We've had a student with us from Finland
- 1:13:23right now. My wife and I are hosting an exchange student. That's awesome. So, I've learned a fair bit.
- 1:13:27Like, you know, exactly. And it's an amazing nation, by the way. Yeah. History of it is amazing.
- 1:13:32The ability of that, you know, society and that culture to survive next to this giant.
- 1:13:38Yeah. Russia. With the history of the end also, by the way, being waged between Russia and Sweden,
- 1:13:44Sweden has. Yeah, they were assholes too, for a lot of time. Well, they had the aspirations,
- 1:13:48right? Yeah, yeah, yeah. The aspirations of the nice women. And so, and so did, of course,
- 1:13:53Poles, yes. Sure. And Lithuanian, Polish Lithuanian kingdom and all. So, that whole neck of the woods
- 1:13:58had been very much contested, of course, over the centuries as well. But apart from the history
- 1:14:03itself, and the history doesn't form who we are beyond the endowed. There is a lot of kind of
- 1:14:07insecurity in Russia as well. NATO presents that insecurity and presents that pressure.
- 1:14:13You know, Ukraine conflict really started way before 2014. There was a constant pressure and
- 1:14:21pool within Ukraine, which modern Ukraine is the Soviet creation, yes. It bolted on the Western
- 1:14:26Ukraine, which was never really, really a part of the old traditional Ukraine or the Eastern Ukraine.
- 1:14:33And this kind of dichotomy, the difference, yes, creates a very tremendous, you know,
- 1:14:39force, kind of like a North versus South element, like in the U.S.
- 1:14:43Less so, but it more like, say, North versus, you know, Republic of Ireland.
- 1:14:49Like this, say, Protestants and Catholics. Yeah, more like that.
- 1:14:52You have the religious difference as well. Yeah. You have a Catholic Western Ukraine,
- 1:14:56and you have the Orthodox history. Oh, yeah. And you have also other minorities as well,
- 1:15:02yeah, well, probably a lot of non-religious Western Ukraine then too.
- 1:15:06Probably actually, or Catholic identifying, but not too active. Neither one, you know,
- 1:15:11that's more like Central Ukraine, which is administrative European, like Nipro area,
- 1:15:15all the way to Kiev, non-secular, okay. Much more kind of modernized, much more, you know,
- 1:15:21industrialized or whatever, yeah. Exactly, yeah. So, I mean, this is all, of course,
- 1:15:26very much, you know, we, West Curtain on the side of much more complexity than this, okay.
- 1:15:35So, when those, so, yeah, no, it's true. Oh, good luck.
- 1:15:41I'm a wrong person for that. So, there is a lot of history there, and then history goes back,
- 1:15:46there's some good things, there are some bad things between it, of course. So, yes, the West
- 1:15:51has played a less than smart role in a process. That doesn't absolve Russia.
- 1:15:58Sure. Exactly. Absolutely. It played less constructive role rather than, you know, like the West
- 1:16:04played the smart role. I was terrified when Biden shot the long-range missiles into Russia
- 1:16:09after losing the election. I was like, what are you doing? Like, I'm not sure that was allowing
- 1:16:14that. Yes, but on the other hand, of course, if you take the position from the point of view of
- 1:16:19supporting Ukraine, right? That is intellectualism. This is what they need. They need more than that.
- 1:16:24And where do you stop? And that's the whole problem. Yes. So, in a way, I'm actually in line with
- 1:16:30Trump administration on the fact that that war should never have been started. Yeah. 100%.
- 1:16:36The problem is that the wishful thinking doesn't work forward. Yeah. Well, in the argument I hear
- 1:16:42about, you know, giving Russia a piece of Eastern Ukraine and having an agreement that's signed
- 1:16:48and forces done and stuff is that, you know, after Trump has gone, next crappy president we've got
- 1:16:55in the office, Russia's going to take Ukraine, and then they're going to take Poland, and then they're
- 1:16:58going to take the rest of it. I don't think that Russia will take Poland. I don't think that Russia has
- 1:17:02any ambition in terms of the additional territory gains. I don't think it wanted Eastern Ukraine either
- 1:17:08to begin with. But now you've had a bunch of people dead. But now it's in Ukraine. Yeah.
- 1:17:15I would be of the view that from my point of view, Ukraine is an independent nation. And sovereign
- 1:17:19states should not be attacked. They, no matter what, if they do attack, then defense is just
- 1:17:26but non-defensive war is not justifiable. But this is my personal view. Sure.
- 1:17:30We are as they say where we are. And this is a big problem because how do you resolve? How do you
- 1:17:36get out of here? The difficulty we have is less logistics of the who controls the ground. But more
- 1:17:44of logistics who has the trust. Nobody has the trust. We don't trust the Russians. Russians don't trust
- 1:17:50us. Ukrainians don't trust the Russians. We don't trust Ukraine. And don't trust Ukraine.
- 1:17:56Yeah, even Poland. Except for the Europeans. Even Poland. No, I mean, even Europeans.
- 1:18:00Europeans say that they trust Ukraine, but do you honestly know, do you really think that the
- 1:18:04French trust Ukraine? Or for that matter, French trust anyone, but the French, yes. I mean,
- 1:18:10if you look at the, for example, Italians, and you look at Melanie, she comes in from the point
- 1:18:16of view into the political real marriage. Right. She's the mega of, you know, she's worser
- 1:18:21magu. I mean, you know, like it was before magu got accused of being fascist, you know, she was
- 1:18:27accused of being fascist, yes. And now she's one of the leaders of the kind of freedom movement.
- 1:18:33Well, and France would have that leader too, potentially if it's kept for the funny business,
- 1:18:37they pulled with the election. Oh, that's right. So I mean, like, and Germany too,
- 1:18:40and everywhere, the only countries like Ireland that the ones which are saying, we don't have
- 1:18:45the right wing, but then you have the, you know, corner of the grave. So there is the paradox
- 1:18:53of that is that we're in extremely complex environment. We are not only environment where we
- 1:18:58deal with risk. If you use the proper terminology, we deal with what in the 1990s US military,
- 1:19:05the US army has labeled wuka, volatility, uncertainty, complexity, and ambiguity.
- 1:19:12And that is an environment where things don't just happen as kind of unpleasant events.
- 1:19:18What happens in these environments is systemic crisis, big things, big wars, not just small
- 1:19:24skirmish, not some kind of stable, relatively balanced conflict that happened in 2014
- 1:19:31in Eastern Ukraine, but actually full out wars and that's 2022. So from this point of view,
- 1:19:39even devising any sort of the response, has to start with the proposition, what's the worst case
- 1:19:46scenario that you're going to get? And up until what, 2022, we had the worst case scenarios,
- 1:19:53we're going to have a lot of people dead. Now we have the worst case scenario of the nuclear
- 1:19:59war. Effectively everybody is dead. And if you go historically, who normalized that reality?
- 1:20:06It was interactions. It was actually the first idea of the winnable nuclear conflict,
- 1:20:12so-called limiting. It came out in the United States and it was codified in early notice
- 1:20:18by the likes of the Atlantic Council or the Council of Foreign Relations in the United States.
- 1:20:24The advisers to our policymakers, the advisers to our national security heads in Congress,
- 1:20:31in the White House and everywhere else. So in a way, we are- Now is that because of the pressure
- 1:20:38of profit from- Is it military industrial complex? That's a very interesting thing. So military
- 1:20:43industrial, it did some research on military industrial complex and part of kind of, you know,
- 1:20:47there is very surprisingly for the size of the military industrial complex. If you go into
- 1:20:51finance and economics literature, there aren't a lot of papers, nobody- Not a lot of direct evidence of
- 1:20:56old. No, it's not that. It's just nobody really started- Not a popular subject. It's not a
- 1:20:59popular subject. It's not a public subject. So when I had myself in a couple of my graduate students
- 1:21:06back, I think around 2013 started the research on that. And it took me until 2023 to publish
- 1:21:12the first paper on it. Because nobody wanted to take it. Journals are not interested.
- 1:21:18And what's the punch line? So the punch line is the following. The military industrial complex
- 1:21:23doesn't make money out of the direct immediate wars. What they make money out of the two things.
- 1:21:31One is kind of pipeline of ordering the budgets. So the budgets of war are more important than
- 1:21:39the wars themselves. And the second thing when things become really uncertain, when things not
- 1:21:44just blow up, but they blow up in an unpredictable way. So again, it's not the risk. So there's two
- 1:21:52things that investors in military industrial complex like they like the steady pipeline of orders
- 1:21:59that they can program into the future. So that's our regular budget. But the wars themselves,
- 1:22:07the spikes, the moments of this acceleration in the uncertainty about the future demand.
- 1:22:13It always kind of leads to the promotion or the support of the military industrial complex stocks.
- 1:22:18So in a way, you can see now why would constantly need this kind of drive towards being
- 1:22:28belligerent? Bellicose. United States is in a way, Jimmy Carter was correct in saying that in
- 1:22:35its history, this is probably the most war in nation on the face of earth. Even though we haven't
- 1:22:42fought really a war on our own for quite a long time, blessed we are by that. But we have supported
- 1:22:49where the directly or indirectly vast numbers of conflicts. It is, unfortunately, it is the geopolitical
- 1:22:59reality today. And we're going to see more of it. I think one of the biggest risk points of this,
- 1:23:06seeing Chinese and North Korean troops joining the Russians on the fronts and stuff like that,
- 1:23:12is like, that's the last thing we really want. Not so much Chinese. Chinese are staying cool on that.
- 1:23:16There is some argument, there is some kind of reporting coming out of Ukraine that they have
- 1:23:24traced some Chinese conscripts, not conscripts, but the contract soldiers. But that's not the
- 1:23:33thing. North Korea is a different story. Russia has signed, basically, a common defense clause
- 1:23:40with North Korea. That happened in 2023. And as a result of that, Russia actually.
- 1:23:48A win for North Korea, because they're like, hey, it's a huge win for North Korea.
- 1:23:53Plus, a great export for, they got a bunch of starving men in North Korea, better to get a nice
- 1:24:00paycheck sent to the homeland. The numbers of them are limited. I mean, you're talking about
- 1:24:045,000 to 10,000. As far as we have the credible information that actually went in. All of them,
- 1:24:12as far as I understand, have stayed within Russia proper. So it's the Kursk region where Ukraine
- 1:24:18had the counteroffensive, remember? That's where they fought. They haven't crossed as far as I know
- 1:24:24into the Ukraine territory, which of course would be probably an act of war against Ukraine by
- 1:24:31North Korea. It's very hard to even trace what exactly is the act of war these days. How far
- 1:24:38do we move? Back in the days, it used to be, you send a very stern letter to the leader of the
- 1:24:42other country, and then you send a knight with a bill of where you ask for things and demand the
- 1:24:51things. And then there's kind of the act of war. Yeah, exactly. Bingo, exactly. It used to be like,
- 1:24:59and you go back to the 19th century in the history of warfare. I mean, you have the first event
- 1:25:05of the so-called barbaric or modern war happens in 1812 in Russia, Napoleon's campaign in Russia.
- 1:25:13And it was the first time when they encountered the concerted resistance, organized resistance by
- 1:25:18the non-combatants, the partisans, the locals, the peasants with pitchforks. Yeah, yeah. It shocked
- 1:25:24Europeans. Yeah, yeah, yeah. It shocked that you find European. Because we have professional armies.
- 1:25:28Yes, and we fight army for army. We don't touch the peasants, yes. I mean, and here's the peasants
- 1:25:33touching you. Right, right. So that changed the modern warfare, yes, and since then we're kind of
- 1:25:39evolved. Well, and even the Revolutionary War with the Americans, where the British are like,
- 1:25:44we line up and then we stand this far apart and we shoot each other. You guys are hiding behind
- 1:25:48trees. That's right. Yeah, exactly. Exactly. So, I mean, like, you know, and that kind of
- 1:25:54noble structure of the campaigns and military campaigns has disintegrated over the years, yes.
- 1:26:00So we now today are in the war environment where it is, you have the non-human actors,
- 1:26:08yeah, all the drones and stuff. Not only drones, robots. Sure. We effectively turn the war field
- 1:26:15or the battlefield into the constant test and lab for new technologies. It's happening on the
- 1:26:21western side and on the Russian side as well. So in this environment to kind of go around and
- 1:26:26kind of scream about the North Koreans, I mean, it's almost like, you know, yeah, not that significant
- 1:26:32compared to all the rest is going on. Well, and if you start thinking about this drone technology,
- 1:26:37like, do we, are we, can we keep up now? You know, very interesting question. So, I mean,
- 1:26:43Russia has managed to, and this is goes to the my profession and kind of my field of expertise as
- 1:26:49well, you know, we were all taken completely unprepared by the ability of the Russian economy to
- 1:26:56switch to the kind of military industrial complex. Russia had really not a meaningful military
- 1:27:05budget. Yeah. Yeah. Before the war. It has retooled its economy very successfully. It has
- 1:27:10managed the ways to bypass tremendous sanctions, which have never been deployed in the history against
- 1:27:16any other country in a past. Yeah. To the point where it almost like to me was a risk of devaluation
- 1:27:23of the dollar. Like, if you could just take somebody's money, right? So they're not driving the
- 1:27:28devaluation of the dollar themselves. No, but the risk of another currency replacing the dollar,
- 1:27:33you know, bricks or something because we just took a few billion dollars, you know, we've started
- 1:27:39that process and what we call that, you know, in my profession, we call that weaponization
- 1:27:43of economic systems. Yeah. They can be financial systems. They can be trade systems. The United
- 1:27:48States over the last, say, and it's really started with the late 1990s. Yeah. I ran sanctions.
- 1:27:55The very big move was, of course, the second Gulf War. Sure. And their
- 1:28:01after it's accelerated tremendously. By now, we have weaponized absolutely everything we have.
- 1:28:07We have weaponized aid. We have weaponized humanitarian assistance. We have weaponized
- 1:28:13health provision. Anything that is outward looking in the United States, you know, from our treasury
- 1:28:19department to our health, again, to our food supplies is all weaponized. When you do that,
- 1:28:26you create incentives, both push and pull incentives for the nefarious or adversarial actors,
- 1:28:32whether they are Russia, Ukraine, sorry, Ukraine, China, but even Ukraine, Poland as well. They're
- 1:28:39not adversarial, but they're competitive in many ways, okay, as well. All of these different
- 1:28:45players have used, to some extent, the United States weaponized in its systems to resist that.
- 1:28:51Yeah. Yeah. So the idea of, say, for example, de-dolarization of the economy, a global economy.
- 1:28:57We think of it as the kind of, you know, juxtaposition between Russia plus China and maybe
- 1:29:02other breaks against the United States. The biggest challenge to the US dollar in the last 25
- 1:29:08years has not been, you are global, or gold, it was euro. Oh, yeah, sure. So when you think about it,
- 1:29:17it's euro, Europeans are our allies. Well, but we create an opportunity for them to effectively
- 1:29:23benefit from what we've benefited for decades of the, you know, post-bredenwoods structure. Yeah.
- 1:29:30Yeah. Yeah, yeah. Maybe they can carry that torch for a while and be the
- 1:29:34There is a great advantage to it, but there's also a huge burden to that. Sure.
- 1:29:39You mentioned being policemen to the rest of the world, which creates a draw on our own resources.
- 1:29:44Yes. We're all obligated to that because we invest more in a global if you want security
- 1:29:51than we invest in the roads and railroads in the country. Sure. We certainly invest more in Pentagon,
- 1:29:57which is an outward projection of our power, then we invest in healthcare in this country. Sure.
- 1:30:02So, I mean, yeah, there is a burden to that, a massive burden. Yeah. So, yes, there are benefits to
- 1:30:09having this dominant hegemonic position in the global economy, but also in military, in industrial
- 1:30:16space. That's a heavy yoke. But there is also, correct. Yeah. There is also a cost. There is
- 1:30:20no free lunch. Yes. So in a way, you know, the challenge that we're witnessing today to the US
- 1:30:28economy, US dollar, US hegemonic is so multidimensional. It's very different from the
- 1:30:33Cold War challenge when you had the literally juxtaposition of two suits. Sure. Yeah. Yeah.
- 1:30:39And there was more tension to that. Sure. But the changes. We'd see magazines all the time
- 1:30:46comparing the size of our nuclear stock models and stuff. Correct. Yes. That's where we got at,
- 1:30:50you know, but the tension was almost one dimensional. Now it is so multidimensional that you have
- 1:30:57the challenges to the United States. I'll give you an example of how to take tariffs.
- 1:31:01Take tariffs. Yes. The tariffs have triggered the reaction between, and kind of if you want
- 1:31:05trade war, of course, he has stood for that between China and the United States. Sure.
- 1:31:09But behind the scenes, I think it was yesterday, there was a conversation happening in Beijing
- 1:31:15about the need and they are projecting that it's a public, yes, projection of the conversation,
- 1:31:19of course, that we get. Yeah. And about the need to have a closer relationship in terms of
- 1:31:26investments flows in terms of trade, in terms of diplomacy, in terms of all cultural links between
- 1:31:32China and Vietnam. Vietnam has drifted towards the United States orbit far enough that it is now
- 1:31:39an alert from the Chinese point of view. And the Chinese are going to deploy whatever soft
- 1:31:44diplomacy they usually deploy, which usually involves investment and trade, but also cultural
- 1:31:50exchanges, also education. Yeah. Well, because Vietnam was one of the first countries to respond.
- 1:31:55We're in. We're talking. Yeah. Absolutely. Yes. So there is a very interesting, this type of
- 1:32:01challenges back in the Cold War era would be happening way before the actual confrontation
- 1:32:07in this place. Right. And they would be much more stable. Right. Right. Now they're multi-demand.
- 1:32:12The president would send emissaries four months before a deal was made. Of course.
- 1:32:15Yes. Absolutely. And we're going to Texas. And one of those is our orbit. We can rely on them
- 1:32:21being in our orbit. Yes. With exception of, of course, in your non-aligned states, like say India,
- 1:32:26which always kind of threaded both dimensions, you know. But in by and large, there was either my
- 1:32:32camp and your camp. No, there is my camp and one thing, your camp and another thing. And I'm
- 1:32:37playing an independent one for now, you know, in a third thing. Well, yeah, the Europe is really a
- 1:32:42hard thing to figure out. How does that fit in? That's another Spanish, for example, for
- 1:32:46an minister today coming out with a statement that he believes that Europe should be in alignment
- 1:32:52with a close alignment with China. So I mean, here we have the president of the United States,
- 1:32:58who is trying to both counter China. But I mean, at the same time, some people say that he's
- 1:33:03building the, you know, alliances between the, you know, or he's incentivizing the Europeans
- 1:33:08to kind of join the United States in a position to China. How's, you know, taken over Greenland,
- 1:33:13then, you know, school in Denmark, feeds into that. I'm not sure, you know, is it really
- 1:33:19screwing Denmark, though, or would it be a burden lifted from them that we would gladly carry?
- 1:33:25So far, they had not given us indication that it would be a burden. No, they don't talk like that.
- 1:33:28But when I look at it, like from a big picture, almost like they have to send a bunch of money
- 1:33:32to Greenland every year, it's like, you know, Vladimir Putin probably has made an argument at
- 1:33:36some point in time that lifting off the Eastern Ukraine from the rest of Ukraine would lift the burden
- 1:33:40from, yeah, you don't want to have the finance. But yeah, I mean, no, I don't think so. I think,
- 1:33:48you know, I think the notion that President Trump is playing some sort of a seven-dimensional
- 1:33:53chess game here is a little bit straight ahead of, you know, what President Trump is doing.
- 1:33:59He's a projection map and saw how big Greenland is. Yeah, I don't know, but there's beyond that.
- 1:34:05Of course, you know, he's also, he's clearly the President who is driven by the desire to be put
- 1:34:10in the textbooks. Sure. He's to the textbooks. And what biggest thing you can do other than
- 1:34:17add territory? There's other things. I mean, the whole, you know, north, the Arctic Ocean,
- 1:34:25the access to the Arctic Ocean. Sure. The United States only has that through a small part of
- 1:34:31Alaska, you know, we can't really be players with just that Canada is clearly kind of, you know,
- 1:34:39very hesitant as well. You know, so you have this, you know, there is, there is incentives, of course.
- 1:34:47But I mean, you know, would you go about it, by the way, you've got his gun? No, I mean,
- 1:34:54yeah, you certainly know the track from Canada to join the United States. No, I don't. Do you think
- 1:34:58Canada should be a state or 10 smaller states? That's a question, which I think is so is
- 1:35:06at Eric at this stage. I think the United States needs a North American customs and labor market
- 1:35:17union. Yeah, we need to have the relationship with our neighbors that are again cooperative and
- 1:35:22constructive to the point of being similar to the European Union. That would be free mobility of
- 1:35:27later. Yeah, you can preserve identity. You can preserve. I mean, look, Canada has multiple identities
- 1:35:34itself. Yes, Quebec versus, you know, the rest British Columbia versus the rest. Well, in all the
- 1:35:39Midwestern ones, right? They're basically North Dakotans. Well, they might not just say that
- 1:35:45it's North Dakotans, but yeah, so exactly. So you can have that. We have tremendous diversity
- 1:35:51within the United States, of course, as well. We have the South. We have Florida, which is
- 1:35:56different from the South. Sure. I mean, you can narrate the different why why is Canada so focused
- 1:36:01on carbon credits and preventing global warming when it's so cold up there? They benefit from
- 1:36:08a little warm up. This is interesting. In economics, there is a kind of subfield of environmental
- 1:36:14economics, which looks at that, you know, at kind of, you know, what are the rebalance in the
- 1:36:20facts? They can raise corn up there instead of just wheat. And interestingly enough, so the former
- 1:36:24student of mine took his first job, you know, years ago, working for a big family office in
- 1:36:31Europe. And one of the deals that he was working on structure was the purchase of a large chunk
- 1:36:36of permafrost land in Northern Canada. Okay. And the premise was that it will turn at certain
- 1:36:43points in time to agree with that. In a hundred years, isn't it farmland? I mean, you can see,
- 1:36:47for example, like say, you know, you know, winemakers and sound of California moving father and father
- 1:36:52norms. We have now a wine being made in Canada, you know, we have wine returning back to the British
- 1:36:57Isles, you know, so, you know, not since Roman times, it was there. At scale, you know, so yes,
- 1:37:05there are, of course, gains to be had in certain areas. Okay. The problem becomes is that the
- 1:37:11problems of the south will be imported into the west. All right. One of the big drivers is the
- 1:37:18whole migration, for example, yes, we have that at scale now starting to happen in the likes of
- 1:37:24the Middle East, in the likes of parts of Africa, where there is a combination of conflicts,
- 1:37:30plus, you know, searing heat, violence, and then heat, and then impact on soil, impact on
- 1:37:36quality of soil, impact on water, livability, and so forth. So when you think about this,
- 1:37:42in the past, we're always, we are comfortable with saying, for example, things like energy
- 1:37:46has driven wars before. There were wars for oil. Yeah. We know historically, there were wars for
- 1:37:52salt. Sure. Because of the importance of salt in preserving food, yes, in a past. Why we have
- 1:37:58a difficulty thinking in terms of the geopolitical crisis of being driven by mass scale changes
- 1:38:04in a livability of different parts of the world. Yeah. And it doesn't mean that you have to believe
- 1:38:10in a completely, you know, cataclysmic, apocalyptic type of the environment change, you know,
- 1:38:17scenario. So do we have to be more open to changes in sovereignty or boundaries or alliances or
- 1:38:23unions then? I think we have to be more open to how we define sovereignty. Yes. It doesn't mean
- 1:38:30that you have to give up on your ability to control your own borders. It doesn't mean that you
- 1:38:35have to give up on the ability of having your own identity. It doesn't mean that you have to give
- 1:38:41up on trying to chart your own path that suits your specific culture, your history, into the future.
- 1:38:50But it does mean that we have to be more comfortable with change. Yes. I'm going to call a time
- 1:38:57out because we've got a couple more segments that are mandatory. And I do want to get
- 1:39:02able to hear in time. First, we have the ping pong ball challenge. And I'm going to have you
- 1:39:15draw three balls out of there. I'm going to ask you the question from my list that's associated
- 1:39:19with those balls. Okay. You grab the whole thing over to you if you like. Let's do that. All right.
- 1:39:24So just grab any three numbers out of there. And then you can set that back a little bit. Let's see
- 1:39:29if any of the numbers actually I find lucky. All right. Okay. So yeah, what's the first number
- 1:39:37you'd like me to? I'll start backwards. One. Number one. Yes. Number one. That was fun.
- 1:39:45First time this question has been asked. I think what's your favorite childhood memory?
- 1:39:49My favorite childhood memory. Probably is a set of memories that form me. Okay. I'm a big fisherman.
- 1:39:59I like fly fishing. I'm a big forage as well. And I grew up in the city of Moscow. Yeah, when
- 1:40:05you said foraging earlier, I meant to ask, but like for mushrooms and things like that.
- 1:40:09Edible mushrooms, edible berries, you know, herbs, you know, my last foraging was actually in December
- 1:40:17back in on the central coast in California. Okay. And it was a pork chini that I brought the whole
- 1:40:22box off back fresh. Nice. And I had some air buds. This is an Italy mostly. So that was
- 1:40:28California. Okay. Yeah, also in Italy as well in Alps. We do that as well there. Yeah. So I
- 1:40:33forage pretty much for everything. I including for the firewood for my little barbecue pit.
- 1:40:39Okay. So I like barbecue with a natural wood fire. So I forage for the wood as well.
- 1:40:45So that favorite childhood memory? So my favorite memory would be my river I grew up on because I
- 1:40:50grew up in Moscow city. And we had a property outside. We still have that property outside of Moscow.
- 1:40:56And it's a country home or whatever. Exactly. It's a couple of acres of land.
- 1:41:03Yeah. Right on the river. And I grew up there and I spend that. And so that river is my probably
- 1:41:09your kind of most treasure. You can always call up that sound of that river. That's right. Yeah.
- 1:41:13Absolutely. Thank you. You can feel it. You can see it. You can smell it. Yeah. Yeah.
- 1:41:18Never leaves quite. Yeah. Next question. Oh, yes. 20. 20.
- 1:41:27What's your go-to excuse when you want to get out of plans with someone?
- 1:41:33Other than saying I'm Russian. I don't make plans. Yeah. Exactly. You don't want to make plans with me.
- 1:41:41What's my favorite excuse when I get to get out of something? Usually it is a work.
- 1:41:47Sorry. You've got to work. We always, yeah. Exactly. There's so much stuff I have to do.
- 1:41:51You know, I can't go to a concert. That's my usually. My wife actually goes like you know,
- 1:41:56let's go to a concert. You can go for it. It is. You know. Oh, no, no. I'm, you know, I'm working.
- 1:42:01So yeah, that probably would be pretty banal but usual. Yes.
- 1:42:06I don't like relying on things like say health. Right. Because it's kind of almost like a bad
- 1:42:10woman. Yeah. Yeah. So I don't, you know, if I say to someone, if I tell someone that I'm genuinely,
- 1:42:17that I'm sick, I'm usually probably genuinely sick. Yeah. But if I say like I have to work,
- 1:42:23they probably will kind of know in me. They will say is it workout or is it work or is it work like
- 1:42:29doing research because you know, I like doing that. Right. Right. You know, or is it literally
- 1:42:33great in papers? Who doesn't? Exactly. Um, last one. Oh, yes. Number seven. Number seven.
- 1:42:41How do you define happiness? Um, I define happiness and I experience happiness on a small scale.
- 1:42:49I don't define it on a big scale of big events and I define it on a everyday experience. Yeah.
- 1:42:54For me, happiness is when I'm up in the mountains and I'm actually just free. Free from
- 1:43:02bullshit of everyday life. Yeah. Don't think about nothing. Free from things like thinking
- 1:43:06about taxes or thinking about how I'm going to pay for the tuition of the kids or how I'm going
- 1:43:10to afford volleyball fees or, you know, what even the free from the idea of what I'm going to eat.
- 1:43:17Yeah. You know, today. Yeah. Yeah. Um, it is literally, you know, kind of a friend of mine. No,
- 1:43:22decisions to be made. My mountaineering partner, uh, here, you know, he actually says that,
- 1:43:27you know, I have religious experience when I'm in the mountains, uh, when I'm in the forest, you
- 1:43:31know, uh, and it is like it, you know, it is something where you encounter something bigger than
- 1:43:36yourself, more permanent than yourself and something that doesn't judge you. Doesn't make any
- 1:43:41view of you. Yeah. Yeah. You don't even exist for it. You know, I think that I, uh, I was reflecting
- 1:43:47on a, uh, phrase, I think my dad's custom combiner in Texas, uh, told him this phrase, but he's,
- 1:43:54like, imagining on a rock and chair sitting in front of a house, uh, sometimes I sits and thinks,
- 1:43:59and sometimes I just sits. Yeah. Uh, and that notion of just sits, you know, even if hiking through the woods,
- 1:44:05you know, just moving through the space and seeing the things completely different. Right. Listen
- 1:44:09to the birds or looking at the clouds. Yes. Like, you know, like, you know, I'm going to go on Saturday,
- 1:44:15for example, up into the mountains. And, uh, you know, there's, I know that trail. I know the river
- 1:44:19there. I know the waterfalls there. Last time I was there, you couldn't see the river. You actually
- 1:44:24hiking over it, but you can hear it. Yeah. And that experience every, every moment is different.
- 1:44:31Yeah, every, every time you take the trail, it's a different trail. So there's no such thing as
- 1:44:36common in, who said that? I mean, one of the Greeks, you know, said you can't step into the same
- 1:44:39river twice. Yes. Yeah. You know, and it's probably, it's the most acute observation of reality.
- 1:44:44You can't step into the same time twice. Yeah. And the only time you experience that and you know
- 1:44:50that is when you are fully free and that's it. I think we, uh, we bribe our listeners to listen to
- 1:44:56the whole show. And so, uh, so the lucky listener that writes in with the answer to that first question,
- 1:45:02the favorite childhood memory, um, that being the summer cabin, uh, outside of Moscow and the river
- 1:45:09especially around it, uh, we'll get you $25 from Chiba Hut from Loco Think Tank. Um, we didn't
- 1:45:16really talk about your family too much. Your kids are your, your, your, your spouse, your partner,
- 1:45:22care to talk a little bit about that, uh, influence in your life. A huge influence, of course.
- 1:45:27The family is probably the most important tanker we have in life. Yes. That's the only thing that
- 1:45:32we have that physically connects us to time, which is an important dimension for us as human beings,
- 1:45:39um, and also to spaces. Okay. So, um, I have two wonderful kids, completely different character guys.
- 1:45:46My oldest one is a golfer. I mean, was on a team for the, um, fossil rich high school, um,
- 1:45:52competitive golfer, he is kind of like a person who can go and play it in halls without blowing up.
- 1:45:59My 14 year old will blow up. Can't play golf. She is a volleyball player. Uh, she played
- 1:46:06rugby before, so she's a very kind of, uh, paraffin strong, uh, but also is kind of amazing to
- 1:46:12watch her evolution as well. She is becoming, you know, she moved from being kind of a very strong
- 1:46:17personality to being a strong personality, but also a kind of feminine balance. Yeah. Self-restrained
- 1:46:23a little bit. Yeah, both are very good students. Um, both are kind of, you know, not academically
- 1:46:29minded. Hopefully they're going to go into academia. I'm really happy with that. Uh, my oldest is kind
- 1:46:34of currently looking at, you know, doing finance because of business dimension. So applied finance.
- 1:46:40My youngest one is still kind of having big dreams and she wants to do kind of medicine slash
- 1:46:45biology, um, in her kind of studies. Um, and she's oriented towards that, which is always amazing
- 1:46:52at my point of view. It's really great to see my partner. I call her my better half because she's
- 1:46:57a better half of me. She's more balanced than I am. Okay. Uh, she's what's her name? Uh, Jennifer.
- 1:47:02Hi, Jennifer. Um, so hopefully you'll listen to this. Absolutely amazingly beautiful human being.
- 1:47:07Okay. Uh, we've met, uh, now, yeah, where did you grab her? I forget you. So we met 30 years ago.
- 1:47:13Uh, where were you then? Chicago. Oh, yeah. Uh, we met 30 years ago this year in Chicago and, uh,
- 1:47:19you know, we spent those 30 years so far and, uh, I mean, was it, was it a romance right from the first?
- 1:47:26Yes, it was instantaneously. We have a lot of very interesting and strange connections for the
- 1:47:30Russian versus, you know, she's, you know, of course, she was born in Michigan, uh, but she is half a
- 1:47:35Italian. Okay. Uh, almost half Cherokee. Oh, um, and she works in a completely different field.
- 1:47:42Yeah, she comes from advertising for, you know, degree isn't sculpture. So she's an art major. Uh, we've
- 1:47:48met, uh, randomly through kind of third party friends. Okay. Um, and the first time we met, we had a
- 1:47:54fight. We had an intellectual debate discussion, which was very heated, uh, where she was trying to
- 1:48:00convince me that there is such a thing as an American art. And I was trying to convince her that all
- 1:48:05of the American art is really European art. Then it's derived from European art. Uh, not necessarily,
- 1:48:10not a fantastic copy, but I mean, it's very different. Uh, so we had an art history debate. Um,
- 1:48:17her view was, uh, you know, sadly, that what the hell does this economist from university
- 1:48:22know about art? Uh, and my view was, uh, kind of probably around the same kind of look how good she
- 1:48:28gets when she gets sassy. Oh, no, absolutely. Uh, hot. I mean, but anyway, um, so we hit off right,
- 1:48:36right away, um, her background growing up between the United States and Italy kind of matched my
- 1:48:42background growing up in other totalitarian, uh, okay, of course, yes, um, in Soviet Union, but
- 1:48:49also having a very strong connection with Italy, um, because I had family members in Italy. So,
- 1:48:54when I grew up in the Soviet Union, I was able to travel to Italy all the time. In fact, my Italian
- 1:48:59was better than that. Uh, so we actually cut off very well from the very beginning, um, and it's
- 1:49:07been, uh, absolutely up and up and up. Oh, and you had almost 12 years, uh, just the two of you
- 1:49:13before you started making little. Absolutely. Yeah, more than that. Uh, yeah, no, um, yeah. So 18 years
- 1:49:19versus you know, 30 years, about 12 years, you're right. Yes. Uh, so we had a tremendously productive
- 1:49:25adventure together. Yeah. There was a period when we painted together and exhibited. Um, and, uh,
- 1:49:31of course, it was a period when we were building the family as well, subsequently. Um, you know,
- 1:49:37genuinely, what works for us, yeah, interestingly enough, is that we retain our differences
- 1:49:43in the fields that we work in, in the interests we pursue, and we can bring those differences
- 1:49:48every day to a dining table and we can share them learn from each other, different things
- 1:49:54you're learning. That learning process, like, as I said, we spent seven hours on the road, me and her
- 1:49:59talk, um, and the youngest one sleeping because she was competing in Salt Lake City in a, uh,
- 1:50:06volleyball tournament there versus I was, of course, I took some time off in the mountains myself,
- 1:50:11um, you know, did a bit of a climb in there and, you know, we were for seven hours on the road
- 1:50:17and we were having a conversation. After 30 years, after 30 years, and that's why, you know, like,
- 1:50:22I mean, that's, there's, there's a way of saying that you find your soulmate. Yeah. Uh, she's
- 1:50:28certainly my soulmate. Awesome. Yeah. Well, glad to hear that.
- 1:50:32This episode is sponsored by Loco Think Tank. Loco Think Tank provides spirit collaboration
- 1:50:37for business owners. We build smart, safe places to help business leaders navigate every stage
- 1:50:42of the business journey and we love what we do and who we do it with. Our model features
- 1:50:46gift-back-minded business veterans and the role of Loco facilitators. We're always looking for
- 1:50:51abundance-minded individuals to add to our membership, facilitator team, local community,
- 1:50:56or to feature on this podcast. Listeners of this podcast who go on to become members of
- 1:51:00Loco Think Tank get their sixth month of membership for free. Just mention the Loco Experience
- 1:51:05Podcast on your application. To learn more, visit our website at locothink Tank.com. That's
- 1:51:11l-o-c-o-think-tank.com. Our final segment, the closing segment, is the local experience
- 1:51:19and that's the craziest experience of your lifetime that you're willing to share with our listeners.
- 1:51:24Oh, okay. Anything, like, local, local. Crazy. Yeah. Local, crazy. I mean, growing up in the Soviet
- 1:51:31Union and haven't gone to the Soviet military, you know, the Soviet army for two years,
- 1:51:36you can't have a many of choices of crazy. Yeah. I mean, when I grew up, you know,
- 1:51:43if you think about it, kind of, right, of passes. Was it intense at that time in the Cold War and
- 1:51:47stuff too? That was very intense and so far is that I was, of course, you know, I grew up in the 1980s
- 1:51:53and there was this breaking point of very what we call an inflection point, yes,
- 1:52:00of the change that Gorbachev brought in as well. I mean, there is a lot of crazy experiences
- 1:52:06you know, I mean, we used to, when I grew up, for example, when we would go to the proms,
- 1:52:10equivalent of the proms, for example, we couldn't buy alcohol because Gorbachev has banned alcohol
- 1:52:16sales in the evenings. So, I mean, I remember we were drinking pretty much anything that burns,
- 1:52:22you know. So, you know, underage drinking and my background and my childhood would have
- 1:52:28involved, you know, I mean, industrial alcohol. Oh, thank you. Yeah. Robin alcohol, stuff that
- 1:52:35does bad things to you, you know. So, crazy experiences. And even though the rest of the Russians,
- 1:52:42the older people and stuff had trouble getting vodka or whatever. Yes, yes, yes, exactly. That's why
- 1:52:46that during that period in the like 1990, mid 1980s. Yeah. There was tremendous amount of deaths
- 1:52:55amongst the kind of older generation Russians who would be addicted to alcohol. Sure.
- 1:53:01Who had to basically consume more. Yeah, they were drinking a quarter of our good day and then they
- 1:53:06got to start. Yeah, correct, yes. So, they switched to break foods. Oh, down. And, you know, we didn't
- 1:53:12do that as teenagers of course, but we witnessed that, you know. So, I mean, there was, you know,
- 1:53:18we used to go, for example, fishing in the wilderness area outside of Moscow and you couldn't get a
- 1:53:24train there, passenger train, because there's no stops there. So, we would actually pay off
- 1:53:29under the table to the, you know, the train, the conductor, train conductors to drop us off
- 1:53:36there and we would get on the cargo trains, yes. Yeah. So, you know, they stopped, they would stop
- 1:53:41for us. And then they would pick us up on the pre-prescribed day, you know, like a week later.
- 1:53:48And one time we were going and we left and we did our fishing and we did our camping and we got
- 1:53:54picked up and they told us that the day we left was a big holiday. Half of the crew of the whole
- 1:54:02depot was about 50 people. Okay. Basically ended up in the hospital and, you know, quite a few of
- 1:54:07them died from drinking black brake fluid. And, you know, like if you want crazy, you know, we were
- 1:54:13teenagers, sitting with them when they started. Wow. And they were offering us to drink, of course,
- 1:54:19because we had, you know, yeah, we had a whole week or back back in the camp, you know,
- 1:54:23what to do. Maybe just one bottle for the road. Like, you know, not what to do that, you know,
- 1:54:28even with teenagers, you're headless chickens, but you still don't know what to do. Interesting.
- 1:54:32So, they kind of experiences like that, okay. So, was your family middle class throughout this
- 1:54:39season career? Yes, of course. Yeah. So, my, my original family, my parents come from the
- 1:54:45most medical background. Okay. So, doctors, my grandmother was a professor of medicine. I mean,
- 1:54:53part of my family on my Armenian side, they died way before I was born. So, there's out of
- 1:55:00the down in all my father from there. And, you know, but from my mother's side of the family,
- 1:55:06most of them were in the medical field. There's some of them were professionals, you know,
- 1:55:11and administrators. So, a little more upper middle class, at least when there was a middle class.
- 1:55:15But you have to remember that in the Soviet Union, things were upside down. Yeah. Yes. So,
- 1:55:19if you're a medical doctor in the Soviet Union, you earned less money than if you walked to the
- 1:55:24factory, versus if you walked in the factory, you made more money than the medical doctor did. So,
- 1:55:29kind of if we think about here, medical doctors are up, right, right. Well, the education we require
- 1:55:34of it. Well, yes, requires it. Of course, but you're also, you know, your earnings and your wealth
- 1:55:39that you accumulate. So, it was exact opposite of that in the Soviet Union. So, big contention,
- 1:55:44for example, between, and that influenced me as well in terms of my current career as well.
- 1:55:49Of course, big contention was within my family, between my grandmother, who was the academic
- 1:55:54medical doctor. So, she was a professor of medicine. She was a surgeon, and so she kind of,
- 1:56:01chose that career. And my father, who was originally a research doctor and then switched because
- 1:56:07of the low pay that the research doctors had, kind of started his own underground practice.
- 1:56:13So, he was getting, you know, he was getting private clients. Yeah, yeah.
- 1:56:17He would pay him, you know, a dish because the weight was too long or things like that. Because no,
- 1:56:22because there's no income, you couldn't make ends meet, you couldn't afford it. You know,
- 1:56:26you couldn't regularly be a regular doctor. So, yeah, being a professor of medicine, your
- 1:56:29salary was back in the days, well, it wasn't like, you know, supposed associate professor of medicine.
- 1:56:35The salary back in those days would have been a quarter of what he would earn if he worked
- 1:56:39privately. Interesting. So, that influenced me as well because my grandmother drove my family.
- 1:56:47She was the power figure in my family. And she actually kind of instilled that idea of research
- 1:56:54focus into me. So, for me, it was kind of, even though I started my career in business,
- 1:56:59I always gravitated towards my life. And your dad kind of started more in research,
- 1:57:06but got entrepreneurial because he had some. That was a big rift between him and my grandmother.
- 1:57:12Interesting. Any questions for me, Constantine? This has been a fun conversation.
- 1:57:17Yeah, of course. I mean, look, I mean, we started a conversation with a kind of, you know,
- 1:57:20local Northern Colorado. Okay. And you asked me, you know, what can be done in terms of how can we move
- 1:57:28Northern Colorado to stronger and stay competitive? Yes, but also more resilient. Not just
- 1:57:33stronger. It's more resilient, more being able to adapt, more being able to put forward the value
- 1:57:39addition that actually can be translated outside of Colorado as well. Yes. What in your view
- 1:57:45can do that? What do you think we are not focusing enough? That's a good question. You know, I think
- 1:57:54regulatory burden has increased a lot on business. You know, I was a banker for 15 years before I
- 1:58:00started local think tank. So that's 25 years. It has to be twice as time consuming to, you know,
- 1:58:07in the family and medical leave act, if you get five employees, and then you got this,
- 1:58:12if you get 10 and you got to do this and that, and it's just kind of daunting. And especially for
- 1:58:17those little companies, the one, two, three companies that are or the 49 person company that once
- 1:58:24they hit 50, then they're going to have to do a whole bunch more expensive things too. And so that
- 1:58:30that burden at every level is definitely one of the challenge, I think.
- 1:58:36You know, certainly for Fort Collins, we don't really have like industrial sites and things. We've
- 1:58:43got a staff of 12 economic development people, but there's really not very many places for them to
- 1:58:50bring companies from outside into. And so I'm unclear personally why it should be such a large
- 1:58:56staff in that space. They're doing a lot of business engagement and, you know, things around
- 1:59:01utilities and stuff. So that's kind of the real ground level stuff here, you know, being a
- 1:59:07libertarian minded, though, I think, you know, reducing state level taxes, I think is going to
- 1:59:12be a competitive advantage for states. I think I heard two or three states just announced that they're
- 1:59:17moving toward getting rid of state taxation. On business. No one personal, you know, tax other
- 1:59:25things instead of income tax, because that's been a big driver of people moving to Florida,
- 1:59:30people moving to Tennessee, things like that. And so I think at least trying to get into the
- 1:59:37middle sector of the state income tax burden would be good. Yeah, it's a good question. I think,
- 1:59:45you know, whatever can be done, which mostly is regulatory of the cost of housing. It's not
- 1:59:50mostly regulatory, but probably 20% of the cost of a house is, you know, our 57 insulation when
- 1:59:58really our climate doesn't really require anything more than 30 or something, but you got to put
- 2:00:02the 57 in because we, the 57 is better than the 30. Well, is it really, you know, what if you
- 2:00:09can't get the 57 or if it's five times as much? So there's just a lot of building code obligations
- 2:00:14that that are good in theory, but end up making everybody's rent $300 a month higher.
- 2:00:23Um, so those are the things. Okay. Yeah. I mean, that's for workforce things so people don't get
- 2:00:30quite as big a shock when they come here for some jobs. That's true. Of course. I mean, the
- 2:00:36problem is that you wouldn't be coming in for the jobs anymore in Colorado. Right. Of course,
- 2:00:40they're not living as so high already. Right. Right. Unless you are working in the sectors like,
- 2:00:44say, you know, computational sectors or the higher margin type jobs. Yeah, technology jobs.
- 2:00:50I mean, even manufacturing things and we talked about agribusiness a little bit, you know,
- 2:00:54there's going to be low end jobs there, but there's also going to be higher end jobs there in
- 2:00:57manufacturing, especially robotics and so forth. But again, you know, that is probably not so much
- 2:01:03driven by the cost of living, but rather by the availability of sites. Yeah. Availability of energy,
- 2:01:09availability of access to the transportation networks and things like that. And I think that's
- 2:01:13where Greeley has Fort Collins and, and leveling to an extent beat. They got so much more water.
- 2:01:18They got so much more green space, you know, to the south and east, especially, but also elsewhere.
- 2:01:24That's suitable. Well, not green, but that's suitable for industrial development. Call it.
- 2:01:29So I think that's a competitive advantage for, you know, east of I-25 realm.
- 2:01:34But then on the other side, you know, it doesn't have that great connectivity.
- 2:01:38Right. The roads connectivity is not there. So transportation is going to be harder.
- 2:01:42True. Well, regional cooperation. Like there's probably the number one thing for Northern Colorado
- 2:01:47is regional cooperation. Yes, we need a cluster in the fact, you know, and it's a cluster in the
- 2:01:51fact also means that you have places with higher quality of living, like Fort Collins. And then
- 2:01:57you have the places which have the ability to create the green sites, as you said, for development.
- 2:02:02And so forth, which can be not just Greeley, leveling is a natural development for the extension
- 2:02:08of the Fort Collins as well. So you have this natural corridor where the energy is clear. Well,
- 2:02:12and Cheyenne is probably more on industrial and energy-densive side.
- 2:02:19Well, because they have, especially with the air force improvements going on up there,
- 2:02:22there's going to be a lot of critical mass of systems and connectivity and data centers,
- 2:02:27probably. Absolutely. So there is an idea for that. And it's a good question why, you know,
- 2:02:33what eight economic development officers? I think in Fort Collins. Well, there's a few that are
- 2:02:39more in the small sector. They're going to be on in a few weeks, so I shouldn't
- 2:02:44I'm not going to show you more than before. But it would be, it's actually quite interesting,
- 2:02:51because in being here for three and a half years now, you know, and being an economist by train
- 2:02:58and being involved before with the things like say policy development, you know, exercise taxation
- 2:03:04law development in Europe. I actually find myself completely not being, you know,
- 2:03:12in any way, shape or form engaged here. I'm not making an effort myself, so it's not to say.
- 2:03:20At all, but there is no outreach from the 12 in economic development.
- 2:03:25You know, there is no outreach from the likes of Greeley either.
- 2:03:30You know, so it's very interesting that to me, it is indicative of this idea of the
- 2:03:36siloed thinking that we have in a corporate world and haven't worked at IBM. You know, I'm
- 2:03:43familiar with a giant corporate siloed way of thinking where everyone builds their own empire.
- 2:03:48We build the walls around their own empire. And we still have this fortress mentality.
- 2:03:54One of the challenges with with government employees I've been told is that everybody compares
- 2:03:59themselves to one another by the size of their staff. Yes, that's true by expenditure.
- 2:04:04Yeah, yeah, it's the big of a big of a department. Do you oversee it? It's like the it's the
- 2:04:09curse of the IT department in the corporate world equivalent. Yeah, they are, you know, their CVs
- 2:04:15look or their SMS look and read like I was in charge of installing $150 million system.
- 2:04:23Yes, sure, sure. You never really read what the system was supposed to do.
- 2:04:26It's been a $30 million system that worked better. Yeah, yeah. This is also why every purchasing,
- 2:04:32you know, kind of decision favors large companies like Microsoft and IBM. It's because you can't
- 2:04:38really go wrong. Yes, you spend a lot, you know, and you have kind of big support. Well,
- 2:04:43it doesn't really. That's a big question, you know, doesn't work. Yeah.
- 2:04:47Constantine, I've enjoyed the conversation. Thank you for making time.
- 2:04:50Thanks, thanks. Hopefully you get a bunch of calls with companies that when I have interns
- 2:04:55from Monfort College of Business. Would love to. We would absolutely welcome that. Oh, not
- 2:04:59phone calls. Yeah, messages. Phone calls, email, slow mail, absolutely. We'll take it in
- 2:05:07Anderson, right? In 84. Godspeed, young man. I appreciate you being here. Thanks, cheers.
- 2:05:15Thank you for listening to this episode of the Logo Experience podcast, proudly produced and
- 2:05:19sponsored by Logo Think Tank, Colorado's premier peer advisory organization. This is your
- 2:05:25producer, Ava Menus, to find all of our episodes or nominee a future guest, check out our website
- 2:05:30at thelogoexperience.com. You can also find us on Instagram, Facebook, YouTube, X.com, and LinkedIn
- 2:05:37at the Logo Experience. To support the show, be sure to follow, subscribe, and share. Until next time,
- 2:05:43stay Logo.