Latest / The KAJ Masterclass LIVE / Global Politics: Decoding the Complex Landscape with Irina Tsukerman
Transcript
- 0:19Welcome to this very special series on the global politics on
- 0:23the KJ Master Class Live. I am your host Khudanya Ajay and
- 0:27together we inaugurate our new fortnightly show with the
- 0:30esteemed Irina Superman, a US based national security and
- 0:35human rights lawyer, as well as the renowned geopolitical
- 0:39analyst. Her writings and commentary have
- 0:41appeared in diverse US and international media and have
- 0:44been translated to over a dozen languages in World in the World
- 0:49According to Irina Sukerman, we will traverse the geopolitical
- 0:53landscape, delve into pressing international issues and gain
- 0:57insight from Irina's expert perspective.
- 1:00Join us every other week as we empowered you with the knowledge
- 1:03to navigate the world of global politics.
- 1:06So without further ado, let's step into the world according to
- 1:10Irina Superman and begin our journey to understand in global
- 1:14politics better. Welcome to the show, Irina.
- 1:18Thank you so much for having me. You are welcome to the show and
- 1:22a lot of people globally will benefit from what we are going
- 1:26to talk about. We will understand the power
- 1:28flow in global politics today. So firstly, let's let's look at
- 1:34this whole world in a in a different sense altogether.
- 1:39Irena, you know this was the first time a few months back,
- 1:42you know the Dooms jet clock is as close as closest to midnight
- 1:47than ever and that was one of the reasons was the the war,
- 1:52ongoing war in Ukraine few months later, where does we,
- 1:56where do we stand together in terms of global politics?
- 2:00Are we much more secure today, or is the Dooms jet clock moving
- 2:06very closer to midnight? Let's start with this, and then
- 2:09we'll look at the state of global politics today.
- 2:13Well, I'd say it's somewhere in the middle.
- 2:15I've never bought into the concept of the Doomsday Clock.
- 2:18I think it's a fiction to create panic and to push certain
- 2:22agendas into a certain direction.
- 2:25If the people are panicking, they will push for drastic
- 2:28measures rather than recent discourse.
- 2:31So no, I don't think we're anywhere near.
- 2:35Any sort of doom. But I do think that the politics
- 2:39today, all over the world, has become more polarized and less
- 2:43informed, and there's a great deal of tension and conflict and
- 2:49opportunities to react rather than to affirmatively pursue a
- 2:56particular thoughtful direction. And I think we're seeing, you
- 3:00know, a certain geopolitical. Realignment that is based on on
- 3:05the 1. The tension between long term
- 3:08interested interest and traditional alliances and short
- 3:12term economic and political gain.
- 3:14And I think until these tensions are resolved, these alliances
- 3:19that you seem to do to continue to be fluid in unstable, leading
- 3:24to unstable, in the conflicted courses of action by the various
- 3:29actors and stakeholders. Absolutely, absolutely.
- 3:34So let us look at the different issues, different things that
- 3:38are going in, going in global politics.
- 3:41One is the the thing that is making a lot of news is about
- 3:45Macron's withdrawal from Niger. What does it mean for the world?
- 3:51How do you assess international power dynamic in the region now?
- 3:55Now they are pulling out their ambassador 1500 troops there and
- 3:59the biggest thing where we want to understand for especially for
- 4:02this part of the world arena, is that why only France?
- 4:07Why not us? It has also got 1000 troops
- 4:10there. So let's start with the fact
- 4:13that Macron is being asked to leave.
- 4:16It's not that he's terminating the alliance is that his
- 4:20announcement is a poor is a related reaction to the
- 4:24development that happened weeks ago when Niger essentially
- 4:28kicked the French out and terminated diplomatic and
- 4:31military relations after a coup displaced the elected government
- 4:38with the. With the junta of a military
- 4:41personnel that was responding to popular pressure fueled in part
- 4:48by Russian propaganda but largely anti colonialist in
- 4:52nature that has blamed France for unequal treatment economic
- 4:57taking advantage of Nigeria economically and essentially was
- 5:02calling for decolonization from France and France unlike the
- 5:06United States has had a long. From colonial presence and post
- 5:12colonial presence across West Africa and for the past couple
- 5:18of years there's been a number of crews and attempted crews
- 5:23eventually leading to anti colonialist, anti French regimes
- 5:30with displacing pro French regimes.
- 5:36So the US is actually there. As part of a counterterrorism
- 5:41contingency, but they do not have significant political
- 5:45involvement. They did promise humanitarian
- 5:49and security aid to countries that that are combating
- 5:55terrorism and that are resisting the Russian entry into the
- 6:00political scene. But they have actually been
- 6:03criticized for being involved insufficiently in African
- 6:06affairs, which is. A fair criticism, but what they
- 6:09cannot be blamed for is having any sort of colonial presence
- 6:12simply because they they were not there historically or
- 6:17politically. There is a but but it's not just
- 6:21the French who are getting kicked out.
- 6:23Actually, the UN peacekeepers were also asked to leave in.
- 6:2612,000 members of the peacekeeping forces were asked
- 6:32to leave in. In a lead up to the removal of
- 6:36the French troops and that was a major red flag.
- 6:39Everyone claims to have been caught by surprise regarding the
- 6:43coup. But this these measures that
- 6:45you're leading up to those events should have pointed out
- 6:49where the general direction of of this whole situation.
- 6:56So that leaves a very complicated situation on the
- 6:59ground. The French have had a very mixed
- 7:02history in the region. On the one hand, they themselves
- 7:05favored particular families and interests in governments, and
- 7:09they were involved in a lot of political corruption.
- 7:12They were not invested in any sort of building up civil
- 7:16societies or local law and order, and this has resulted in
- 7:21a very unequal situation on the ground.
- 7:24On the other hand, they were. Effective in terms of combating
- 7:28counter terrorism troops, and without their presence, we are
- 7:31seeing already a proliferation of jihadist threats, separatism
- 7:37and a lot of opposition to Wagner and to local governments.
- 7:46And some of the separatists don't really care who is in
- 7:50power, the care, but their own interests, which are not being
- 7:53observed by either party and. It's also a dangerous
- 7:57combination of counter coup forces and separatists joining
- 8:02forces. There are some of the jihadist
- 8:04organizations such as Al Qaeda in opposing governments and
- 8:10trying to kick the governments out of the territories they are
- 8:13claiming for themselves and also opposing Wagner's presence.
- 8:19There's a big potential for a regional instability and war.
- 8:25These societies are very tribal. They don't necessarily hear as
- 8:28much about national borders as about family and tribal
- 8:33affiliations and interests. So we can see a lot of borders,
- 8:38commissions and tribal movement back and forth and it's all
- 8:42going in a very unclear direction, right?
- 8:46For the outside world, what is it that they France has been
- 8:51there. Is it the uranium, uranium
- 8:53deposits that is there? And after so many years of being
- 8:57there, you know the Niger is the world heavily indebted, poor
- 9:03countries, it comes under that. And that is why a lot of people,
- 9:07there is a political popular support to the coup itself that
- 9:11a lot of people think that the civilian leadership which was in
- 9:14power till now, they have not delivered.
- 9:16Now whoever is in power, let's at least they will bring better
- 9:20life for them. How does this work?
- 9:22A lot of countries down in that region are having coups and
- 9:26military governments are, you know, getting installed.
- 9:30So there's some truth to the fact that uranium was a major
- 9:34interest of France in in the region of France is heavily
- 9:39reliant on civilian nuclear technology for its
- 9:43electrification process and. Uranium is nitrous, very rich in
- 9:48uranium, and part of the problem was the disagreement between the
- 9:53public and the government and France over the price fixing
- 9:57because. The population was unhappy with
- 10:01the Yale that Niger was getting out of the French.
- 10:03They wanted more of a partnership and less over
- 10:06friends taking a monopoly attitude towards towards this.
- 10:11So that was A1 practical source of dissatisfaction.
- 10:14A lot of it was about optics and history, not necessarily current
- 10:19events because France is no longer controlling the the
- 10:22country, but the local currencies are very responsive
- 10:26to the French influence and. No one particularly cared for
- 10:30the French meddling in local politics.
- 10:32The fact that France was actively back, in particular
- 10:36families and interest, regardless of the outcome, was
- 10:39seen as inappropriate political influence.
- 10:43The irony is that the new government is very much doing
- 10:46the same with the help of Wagner.
- 10:48It has. It has displaced the government
- 10:53without any elections whatsoever, did not wait for new
- 10:56elections to bring itself. Into our position and in the two
- 11:04years the last administration was in place, yes it is true
- 11:09that many things were continued to be mismanaged, but it is also
- 11:13to the divorce progress on counter terrorism front and now
- 11:19this populist push for a change is not taking external and other
- 11:25threats into consideration so. This is not going to necessarily
- 11:31solve all the problems. Yes, they got rid of friends,
- 11:34but Russia has a very similar, if not worth attitude.
- 11:37It has been more successful in corrupting governments, which is
- 11:41how it now ended up in this position of being asked to enter
- 11:46the country. But it's still corruption, even
- 11:48if it's a, you know, better managed corruption with with
- 11:52more favorable objects. Absolutely, absolutely.
- 11:56We don't know whether all these military governments coming to
- 12:00power, military leadership coming to power in most of these
- 12:03nations doubt there. But the good part here in G20
- 12:07summit that recently concluded earlier this month is that you
- 12:11know African Union has become part of G20 now.
- 12:14So help us understand, you know, the outcomes of G20 summit and
- 12:19that what that means for a for the world, for the near future.
- 12:23So let's start with the African Union accession.
- 12:26It's a significant development, but it's ironic because everyone
- 12:30is saying what a huge breakthrough it is.
- 12:33But you know, Africa is 54 different countries.
- 12:36So what they're saying is they consider this entire continent
- 12:40or, you know, gathering of countries.
- 12:42Almost as one member. So in the long run, will it
- 12:46necessarily address the individual interests of each
- 12:49state? How can they resolve the tribal
- 12:51issues and the battle between, you know, building up nation
- 12:55States and these tribal and fluid local interests?
- 12:59I don't know. It is true, however, that Africa
- 13:02is long overdue for having some sort of a seat.
- 13:05As at the table, even if there is a lot of internal
- 13:08disagreements over what what that actually means, it is also
- 13:12true that a lot of it comes from concerns first about natural
- 13:16resources, which have become primary concern for many
- 13:21countries in light of the climate change initiatives that
- 13:25require alternative sources for energy electrification and and
- 13:31these raw materials. That are abandoned in Africa and
- 13:34of course the race, the geopolitical competition with
- 13:40China and Russia, with China having gained a lot of influence
- 13:45and ground in Africa. Interestingly, neither China nor
- 13:49Russia showed up at the G20 summit.
- 13:53So this concept of whether these global gatherings are, as you
- 13:58know, unified as once war remains.
- 14:02A big question and what happens later on if they continue to
- 14:06push for alternatives and with the African unions to opinion is
- 14:10going to be very interesting, but it's certainly significant
- 14:14development. There is this efforts to court
- 14:17the global S to give them incentives to stay with Western
- 14:21countries and to not become subjected to Chinese and Russian
- 14:27political influence and not just economic.
- 14:31Our partnerships, absolutely, absolutely.
- 14:35So this happened in New Delhi. So obviously we were watching
- 14:39this very carefully. And now this goes to Brazil, if
- 14:43I understand. So what?
- 14:46What has been the whole understanding of yours?
- 14:49We are looking at it from that part of the world.
- 14:52Is it what has been the major outcome?
- 14:55There was a declaration finally earlier people thought there
- 14:59will not be, I know there will be.
- 15:01There were concerns about a few things.
- 15:03But I just wanted to you to understand from that, from that
- 15:07perspective, how does it look like?
- 15:10What has been the gains for some, you know, for nations like
- 15:14India who has, you know, held this presidentship very, very
- 15:18well, and now it goes to Brazil, another BRICS nation?
- 15:22So, so it's interesting because it was a huge win for India
- 15:28first in terms of just having all these countries there.
- 15:32Second, there has been a big outcome addresses shortly about
- 15:36agreements about transportation and economic links to to Europe,
- 15:41to the Middle East and of course.
- 15:47This India pushed for a compromise solution concerning
- 15:51Ukraine and Russia, and the fact that it was able to gain some
- 15:54sort of consensus in itself. For it is politically a big
- 15:58victory, whether it's a big victory for the world and.
- 16:02You know, international interest in this is another question.
- 16:06But for India, without a question, it's a major boost,
- 16:09it's a major political boost and it is showing as a very major
- 16:13emerging global player with a particular role to play.
- 16:17And like many countries, it's not seeking to necessarily
- 16:20mediate in every conflict or to put itself in the middle of
- 16:24various. Controversies, but it has its
- 16:27own interests. It's pursuing them and it wants
- 16:29to be seen as a major economic and political powerhouse that
- 16:34that you that will be playing a voice in global affairs.
- 16:39Where that voice ends up going remains to be seen.
- 16:42Where the consequent bilateral and multilateral relations, it
- 16:48would be smart for the United States and needed to engage more
- 16:52there is already. A great deal of engagement with
- 16:54India on quality defense issues and climate change and energy
- 16:59initiatives. There's some technology movement
- 17:02from the US, but if US wants to keep India in its camp, it will
- 17:08need to do a lot more. And I think this is the real
- 17:11message here. Think Prime Minister Modi
- 17:14understands very well that Brooks is a vehicle more for
- 17:18messaging than for real economic change.
- 17:21The members are too diverse, too distrustful of each other, and
- 17:25too conflicted to really use this vehicle effectively to push
- 17:32for any common interest because they don't really have a lot of
- 17:36common interests other than to be seen and respected as they
- 17:42acclaim. India and China are economic
- 17:45competitors. They have trade and diplomatic
- 17:48relations, but I think these tensions will only.
- 17:51Crash more in the future because China is pushing hegemony and
- 17:57India just wants to be left alone and to succeed and to
- 18:02succeed through soft power, not through a military means.
- 18:06But all of this will be will need to be resolved through
- 18:11diplomacy, through trade, through agreements and through
- 18:15understanding that. And these countries will use
- 18:19bricks to try to push for leverage, to try to send a
- 18:23message to the West. Brazil is a very complicated
- 18:28story. The leader there has been jailed
- 18:31for corruption. President Zula is very much in
- 18:34line with Russia, China, Iran. All three countries are being
- 18:38perceived increasingly as questionable at best by India.
- 18:42It has had a long history with Russia, but you know, and still
- 18:46has a lot of trade. More Even so than before, due to
- 18:50the economic advantage of the current situation.
- 18:52But it also kind of wants to be involved with the countries that
- 18:57don't have a president who is being pursued internationally
- 19:01for arrest. And Iran has become also a
- 19:04problem for India in recent years as well.
- 19:06So they are probably looking for some sort of a shift maybe
- 19:10towards South Korea, Middle East, Japan.
- 19:14African countries where it's has very good relations, even Brazil
- 19:17and Lula on the one hand has ties to all these states.
- 19:21But on the other hand, he's also a pragmatist who wants to stay
- 19:24in power if China's economy tanks, and it cannot sustain the
- 19:29same level of support if Russia continues to accumulate
- 19:35political. Problems.
- 19:39Then it may seek to kind of shift its way towards India,
- 19:42towards Turkey, towards states that the scene is a little bit
- 19:46more stable and long term promising.
- 19:49So that's where there is an opportunity for influence as
- 19:54well, even if right now it seems unlikely, right?
- 19:58Right. So let's move from G20 to the
- 20:01United Nations General Assembly. How would you look at it?
- 20:05A bit dramatic this time. At the same time, the president
- 20:10of the of Ukraine was also there.
- 20:12He want he went. He met Biden and all the defense
- 20:17expectations that he had to help us understand that.
- 20:20But along with Canada and the defense bill to help Ukraine at
- 20:24the same time help us understand from this G Unga highlights
- 20:29perspective from Zelensky's visit to the US what the outcome
- 20:34has been. How should the world look at it?
- 20:36And then the Canada and its defense bills.
- 20:41So Zielinski's visit to the UN was, you know, went about as
- 20:46expected. He's continuing to push for
- 20:48international support against Russia in we must not forget
- 20:53that in addition to the military crisis, there's also an economic
- 20:58crisis, a refugee crisis. Millions of Ukrainians have left
- 21:02the country. How to bring them back?
- 21:05How to ensure economic continuity in Ukraine?
- 21:08Reconstruction. All these remain big questions.
- 21:12China has expressed interest in reconstruction in Ukraine.
- 21:15Some people are saying it's too early.
- 21:18There's been an alliance between Japan and Turkey looking to also
- 21:21provide reconstruction assistance jointly.
- 21:26So. So there's this attempt to kind
- 21:28of. Put forward some sort of a plan
- 21:31for economic recovery because this has been a huge crisis.
- 21:35You know, at the same time Ukraine seems to be making
- 21:38breakthrough in the South to its counter offensive.
- 21:41But we are still looking at a very long protracted conflict.
- 21:45The bottom line is Russia is a bigger economy with a bigger
- 21:49population and very significant resources and alliances.
- 21:53It has made a lot of political breakthroughs in the
- 21:56international community, so Ukraine's role in in this is not
- 22:00going to be easy. There's been this multiple
- 22:04ongoing talks and peace diplomatic initiatives behind
- 22:09the scenes. Some people are claiming that
- 22:13Crimea will ultimately be sacrificed to you, to Russia.
- 22:17Others are claiming that a permanent Russian presence
- 22:20anyway in Europe is going to be. A permanent security problem,
- 22:26But is Lenski's doing what he can in trying to kind of channel
- 22:32support the visit to the US with Biden that that part of it went
- 22:37well with Congress? Not so much.
- 22:39The Republicans are fighting over money, over keeping the
- 22:43government open and avoiding a shutdown.
- 22:46And Ukraine has been a subject of controversy.
- 22:49It's not a huge part of the budget.
- 22:52Despite claims by some organizations that it is, but
- 22:57some senators, such as Rand Paul, who have had long links to
- 23:02Russia, have essentially taken the political process over US
- 23:08budgetary. Very domestic oriented issue
- 23:12hostage over specifically Ukraine aid and blew it up into
- 23:16something huge and significant. So now we have we have finally
- 23:23gotten some sort of a proposal for compromise solutions to keep
- 23:26the government open. There's other domestic financial
- 23:31matters that are being discussed and debated, but.
- 23:35Turning Ukraine aid into a pivotal question is not really a
- 23:39defense matter because from a defense perspective, we are
- 23:43spending very little without having to have our troops on the
- 23:46ground or having to do all that much.
- 23:49It is a much more of a political information warfare effort and
- 23:53we are seeing that play out in Canada, the same dynamic space.
- 23:57Is persistent. The Trudeau government has been
- 24:00supportive of Ukraine. There's a concern that should it
- 24:03not be reelected, Conservatives coming in are kind of on the
- 24:09same side as this isolationist conservative group in the United
- 24:15States and some parts of Europe and the Canada has been played.
- 24:20By a number of scandals invite of this visit that actually
- 24:24overshadowed a very successful discussion.
- 24:28There was this incident that was due to poor voting, including
- 24:33some former Nazi individual who was applauded by the speaker
- 24:37hunter or something like that if I remember the name correct.
- 24:42And the speaker ultimately resigned.
- 24:44He was sacrificed by the party to avoid embarrassing to do.
- 24:49But this now been another crisis with India and that's not going
- 24:56well at all. Absolutely, absolutely.
- 24:59So obviously with Canada, there is India.
- 25:02What is happening down there at Canada?
- 25:05What do they want? What is what does Trudeau wants?
- 25:10Means is, was it necessary at this point in time if they have
- 25:16so many, you know, proof, why do not they just hand it over to
- 25:19India? Why do just go so publicly?
- 25:22He was recently here. He met a lot of officials here.
- 25:26So why? Why this?
- 25:27I do not know. How.
- 25:28What do you make out of this whole thing that is going on
- 25:31between India and Canada with the state of affairs, the state
- 25:35of politics, the state of international relations between
- 25:38the two countries? So just to summarize the
- 25:41situation for those in the audience who are not familiar
- 25:45with any of the stories at the UN to donate the very rare and
- 25:49very dramatic public accusation against India, claiming that the
- 25:58activists in Canada and that supposedly Canadian intelligence
- 26:05had evidence of that. Later on, a U.S. diplomat
- 26:09claimed that the intelligence came from 5I countries, the
- 26:14English speaking intelligence alliance.
- 26:17But neither of them said what that evidence was, you know,
- 26:21pointing to the Indian intelligence services now the
- 26:24truth of the matter, that particular activist.
- 26:26Was not some, you know, you know, quiet political critical
- 26:31journalist or anything like that.
- 26:32He came to Canada under false pretenses.
- 26:35He came the fictitious fake documents and fake name that he
- 26:40gave to the locals, claimed asylum.
- 26:43And all of this comes in the middle of the fact that there is
- 26:46a group of such activists in Canada who are apparently quite
- 26:50violent, subverse political subversive, and they're known
- 26:53for insigating terrorist attacks inside.
- 26:56India and there's a big comfort. Pakistan and China have all been
- 27:01backing this particular activist, as has been Canada
- 27:04politically. Why it has chosen to take the
- 27:07position, nobody knows, but to those specifically has very
- 27:11close links to China. And if there's been a lot of
- 27:16criticism of his handling of Chinese espionage inside the
- 27:20country recently, this public accusation may be.
- 27:25A way to try to divert attention from his own negligence
- 27:29concerning Chinese environment and whatever corruption may
- 27:33there be. Whether or not there is actual
- 27:35evidence pointing towards the intelligence services is unclear
- 27:40because it is very risky step to try to assassinate somebody.
- 27:48In on the territory over allied country and not somewhere you
- 27:53know when there is a very high possibility of a scandal in the
- 27:56event such action is discovered, Could it have been some other
- 28:00party that has intervened? A rogue fraction of the
- 28:03intelligence arrival. From the same circles, who was,
- 28:08you know, doing a false work, ISI or anybody else?
- 28:11It's unclear because we're right now we just don't.
- 28:14We're not seeing the evidence. But what I can tell you that in
- 28:16terms of the communication pattern, this whole story is
- 28:20very similar to the scandalous Khashoggi situation, where
- 28:24likewise earlier on the US intelligence claimed that the
- 28:29evidence was pointing out to pointing to the Crown Prince.
- 28:34In Saudi Arabia, but never provided evidence for the
- 28:38claims. And then later on you learned
- 28:41that several interested parties had a direct stake in political
- 28:45outcomes concerning certain geopolitical events, namely
- 28:49Turkey and Syria and Qatar that was having an e-mail crisis and
- 28:55various internal factions in South Saudi Arabia.
- 28:58So the pattern is very much the same.
- 29:01There's a very big claim claiming support from the.
- 29:04Intelligence community. But notice that all of it is
- 29:06coming from political figures. Nobody in the intelligence
- 29:10community is actually saying anything.
- 29:13So the question is, why not produce an Intelligence Report?
- 29:17Why not have the director of the intelligence service actually
- 29:21make credence? Because in reality that's not
- 29:23how intelligence works. There's a comprised report
- 29:28assessing likely factors and lackless scenario very often
- 29:32there isn't a concrete. Evidence taking this is who we
- 29:36did it, who did it. This is we're talking about
- 29:38intelligence and not law enforcement.
- 29:41There is a high likelihood these are the factors that you have
- 29:44considered and so on and so forth.
- 29:46All of that is reported to the Prime Minister and his people
- 29:51and they ultimately decide whether or not they find this
- 29:55intelligence credible and what policy they make based on that,
- 29:59so. There may have been some
- 30:02reporting about certain factors, but that doesn't mean that there
- 30:06was a conclusive decision. Yes, the intelligence did it and
- 30:11this is how they did it includes responsible.
- 30:13It sounds to me like it was a much less clear assessment,
- 30:18whether from the Five Eyes, from Canada itself, and that the
- 30:22Prime Minister and he has chosen to make it into a political.
- 30:28Accusation based on that, with what may be lacking the details,
- 30:32that's that he can turn over. I think he believes it to be
- 30:36true based on the analysis. But there may not be evidence
- 30:41clearly pointing irrefutably that such and such intelligence
- 30:47person did it. They kicked out one diplomat.
- 30:51That they accused of being the head of intelligence.
- 30:53But they didn't even claim that that particular diplomat had
- 30:57anything to do with this particular story, just that he
- 30:59was being kicked out because they're mad at the intelligence.
- 31:02Not that he was in any way responsible for facilitating
- 31:06that a legit operation. So all of that to me sounds very
- 31:09murky. It sounds like a big political
- 31:11scandal that's growing bigger over nothing.
- 31:14And I do think that the timing. Has to be political because if
- 31:18you're investigating intelligence services and you
- 31:21have tensions with the country accusing of meddling in your
- 31:25elections, why have you never heard about it before?
- 31:28Because in the US there are plenty of countries that are
- 31:31meddling in the US politics and we hear about it constantly.
- 31:35So the fact that there's been this computer mute, completely
- 31:39mute button on alleged Indian meddling and all of a sudden?
- 31:44That years, for years it's been a problem.
- 31:46It's to me doesn't seem like a very convenient political
- 31:50timing. Absolutely, absolutely.
- 31:54Governments come and go, leaders come and go.
- 31:57But the relations between country and its people remain
- 32:01and without credible in evidence or could they could have shared
- 32:05something much more credible with the government.
- 32:07They could have investigated, evaluated it.
- 32:10Then it's a different story. And that is why our foreign
- 32:14minister Jaishankar he said political convenience shouldn't
- 32:17determine counterterrorism. That was at the United Nations
- 32:21General Assembly. And I don't know how do you look
- 32:25at the relations going forward getting impacted by this thing
- 32:29which I guess will never be able to you know come in into open
- 32:33because it is just an accusation and it will be very difficult to
- 32:37come out with anything because by the by now the Mr. Trudeau
- 32:41had already come out, if you had anything.
- 32:43How do you look at then this impacting you know, India,
- 32:47Canada relations because they even Canadian military people
- 32:51are not wanting it to link with the political situation.
- 32:55A lot of exercise exchange is happening there here in India
- 32:59with Canada. So I do not know how do you look
- 33:02at it going forward between the impact of this particular
- 33:06incident on the relations between India and Canada in
- 33:10terms of international relations.
- 33:12Short term, politically, it's turning into big scandal because
- 33:17now India is launching. Indian diplomats have launched
- 33:20accusations claiming the Trudeau had cocaine in in his airplane.
- 33:25The Canadian counterparts rejected that claim.
- 33:28Nobody knows what will happen and whether it's even, well not.
- 33:32Does it really matter whether had Trudeau?
- 33:35Had cocaine on his plane or not? The question is what does Canada
- 33:38want out of this diplomatic incident?
- 33:43If they if they're interested in terminating relations with
- 33:46India, they could have just done so immediately.
- 33:49This is completely unacceptable. You we demand you know XYZ or we
- 33:55are terminating relations instead they just keep on going.
- 33:58They kicked on this diplomat but they keep on persisting.
- 34:02Now a U.S. diplomat is diplomat is coming.
- 34:04Coming in now. This means that they're getting
- 34:09the United States involved because they've mishandled the
- 34:11situation. It is not normal for a third
- 34:15party, no matter how close and ally they are, to have to
- 34:18intervene in a bilateral scandal between two states.
- 34:21This is not normally done. The fact that the US diplomat
- 34:24had to go on record with such a statement thing shows that the
- 34:28situation is already out of control.
- 34:30So what did to do? Intent.
- 34:32If he wanted a small distraction, why did he not leak
- 34:36it through the media? Then he could have had a small,
- 34:39limited scandal. Everybody would traded some a
- 34:42media campaign for a while. And on political level, you
- 34:46know, it would have been a distraction.
- 34:48It would have been forgotten. But he launched an official
- 34:51accusation at the international platform, causing complete
- 34:56embarrassment to everyone involved.
- 34:58This is not a situation where you can.
- 35:00Now, you know, cut, move back. You cannot.
- 35:05You know if you had, he had first privately engaged with the
- 35:08Indian government, they could have said, listen guys, you
- 35:11don't like it, don't do it again.
- 35:12Here's what's going to happen if you do it again, you know, and
- 35:17this is what we expect from you now.
- 35:18And then you could have had, you know, toned down the rhetoric
- 35:22handle that managed it when you launch a public.
- 35:25Accusation out of the blown international stage.
- 35:28There's no moving back from this because now it's a big
- 35:32provocation. It's a big aggressive move and
- 35:36neither the United terminate the relations diplomatically, not
- 35:40take any concrete measures. I just think it's a really big
- 35:44miscalculation by Trudeau. He did not handle it well at
- 35:47all. It was not.
- 35:49Professional. It was not good from Canada's
- 35:51national security for relations with India and it's going to be
- 35:55very hard to manage. And it's turning into a big
- 35:59embarrassment for Canada because of the situation with the
- 36:03terrorists being hosted there. Now there's scrutiny about all
- 36:07these people and it's all over the media now.
- 36:09It's even reaching UK because now there are articles looking,
- 36:14you know, looking at the activity in the UK.
- 36:16It's actually turning into a positive boost.
- 36:19For India, because from India's perspective, they want those
- 36:23groups to be scrutinized all over the world because they are
- 36:26problem for them politically. So if Trudeau wanted to benefit
- 36:30India, this is actually beneficial from a security
- 36:34perspective because now we're looking at these groups and what
- 36:37they're doing and we're looking at Canada's handling of this
- 36:40case and it's been handled very badly.
- 36:44There's a question how somebody comes in the false pretences
- 36:48into a country and he's not deported once they found out
- 36:51that he gave the room information.
- 36:53He's not arrested. He's not investigated.
- 36:56Why are the covering for a terrorist?
- 36:58And if it was a terrorist that was killed, yes, you, you know,
- 37:01you still don't want another country meddling in the
- 37:04territory. But what are you doing about
- 37:06your own security issues? Are you, if you're hosting
- 37:09terrorists and you don't even know who they are, right?
- 37:14Right. Moving on from this particular
- 37:17issue, let us look at Russia's growing relations with the
- 37:22Middle East. Help us understand what is
- 37:25Russia doing there with the Middle East?
- 37:28What is it wanting there? What is it that Middle East
- 37:32wants from Russia? So.
- 37:36It's interesting because Russia's interest in the Middle
- 37:39East is not new. People think it is, but they
- 37:41don't know the history. Russia wanted access in the Gulf
- 37:45since before even the Soviet revolution.
- 37:49From the days of the Tsar, it was seeking access.
- 37:52That's how we ended up with Iran, with the Pak, with
- 37:55dynasty, a compromise with the with the British, the annexation
- 38:01of Rawas, the oil and gas rich Arab territory that is now part
- 38:05of considered to be part of Iran.
- 38:08And with the Caspian divisions and Russia looking for you know.
- 38:15And ingress into the area with the with the issues with Turkey,
- 38:21constant fighting over this over well over a century with Turkey
- 38:25over the the Ottoman Empire with the access to them both person
- 38:30there. There are denials Russia
- 38:32considered. The middle is strategically
- 38:35important, even before oil was discovered.
- 38:38And since then, of course, the energy issue is one of its top
- 38:42priorities, because that's where the money is, where that's where
- 38:46the influences and. Now, many of the GCC states are
- 38:49also, in addition to just having those resources, they're also
- 38:54wealthy countries that have invested a great deal into
- 38:57various industries in into AI, into technology, into businesses
- 39:03and financial institutions. And so Russia wants that
- 39:07influence as well, and it has been successful because.
- 39:11Contrary to what everyone thinks, during the Cold War,
- 39:14when the Saudis and all these other countries were supposedly
- 39:19aligned with the United States against the Soviet Union, some
- 39:24of the actors were maintained, some sort of a communication
- 39:30with the Soviet factions and intelligence factions and.
- 39:34After the end of the Soviet Union, they've invested into the
- 39:39energy sector in Russia all over the GCC, Russia, Qatar and Iran
- 39:44from the gas Cortel in 2008. So their relations have gone and
- 39:48cooperation have grown significantly on many levels,
- 39:51not just, you know, obvious security issues and defense
- 39:55issues and and Saudis and Emiratis have also.
- 40:00Initially through private individual investments, but also
- 40:04increasingly government connections.
- 40:07There's been a great deal of energy related cooperation and
- 40:11now in UE we've seen gold versus gold is being rejected from
- 40:16imports all over the world. But it has found that very
- 40:19welcoming, A welcoming place in UE which is making money from it
- 40:24and after with gold is from UE is being sold all over the
- 40:29world. It comes from a lot of it comes
- 40:31from Africa as well, from Wagner's smuggling of gold from
- 40:36GRC and various other African states.
- 40:40So all of that is finding its way into the Middle East.
- 40:43We are also seeing an effort by the Saudis to mediate between
- 40:47Russia and Ukraine. And while this interest when
- 40:50they were never all that involved in that part of the
- 40:52world politically, energy issues, energy negotiating
- 40:57favorable term over access to energy in Ukraine as well as
- 41:01what does Russia have to offer in this context, in the context
- 41:05influence in Eastern and Central Europe through energy issues.
- 41:10So Russia has very strong geopolitical interests.
- 41:14It's not merely just getting weakening US in various in US
- 41:20relationship with GCC yes it does want to do those things but
- 41:24why? Why does it care so much?
- 41:27Because of money. At the end of the day, money is
- 41:31power, and if US is less involved, those countries and
- 41:35Russia in the shots with the most influential members of
- 41:39their families. If they're investing in Russia,
- 41:41then Russia has a prominent access to circumventing
- 41:46sanctions, to procuring weapons, to gaining advancing control
- 41:54around the world, propagating its messaging, active measures,
- 42:00defense and security alliances, intelligence.
- 42:04It has new allies. It has a new power structure in
- 42:08place. Right, right.
- 42:11There are concerns of you know new bout of violence in the
- 42:15Middle East and this with with an alleged how the attack on
- 42:19Barony base drone attack. So what does that mean?
- 42:23What is the reality of it all, and who is behind it?
- 42:28The the real, the real stakeholder here is Iran, which
- 42:32has been using its cookies as purpose.
- 42:35It has trained them, it has owned them, it has collaborated
- 42:39in them, offered them political protection.
- 42:41But it is using them to weaken the region and to essentially
- 42:46force the countries into its sphere of influence, very
- 42:50successful. So the timing of this incident
- 42:53is unusual because as we speak, there are ongoing deliberations
- 42:59between the cookies and the Saudis and there are other
- 43:03members of the Arab coalition, the Yemen government, the STC in
- 43:08Riyadh. It was a huge victory for the
- 43:10cookies that Saudis after years of war intentions invited them
- 43:17to to Riyadh. And United States is thought to
- 43:21be behind this invitation because this invitation happened
- 43:24only a couple of weeks after a major US high level delegation
- 43:30visited Saudi Arabia. So we are seeing that there's US
- 43:35has made part of its foreign policy this settling the war in
- 43:39Yemen no matter what the cost. And in large part their interest
- 43:43is in pursuing some sort of a political deal with Iran.
- 43:49And for Iran, Yemen is key and having hootie is normalized with
- 43:54the rest of the region, and with the US as well is also very much
- 44:00a high priority. No matter what they say, Iran
- 44:03has been quiet. They have not been publicly
- 44:05seeing much other than supporting the peace process,
- 44:08but they are the ones who are controlling The Who is The Who
- 44:12is always travel to Iran for meetings with high level
- 44:17officials. There's even been an Iranian
- 44:20ambassador who will who later died in the mysterious
- 44:23circumstances in in Sanaa. So we are seeing that very much.
- 44:28It's centered around it runs looking to expand its fears of
- 44:31influence, looking to kind of achieve supremacy in the region
- 44:37through religious, not just political means, gain control.
- 44:42Ultimately, the two calling mosques, discrediting the Saudi
- 44:45royal family and succeeding in doing so because already without
- 44:50compromising on anything really. It has gotten normalization
- 44:56agreements from all these countries.
- 44:57It has gotten physical access to those countries, financial
- 45:01access to the systems, diplomatic recognition and
- 45:06influence. And it can afford to do so even
- 45:09when its proxies violate the terms of cease fires and
- 45:14continue attacking ours. And you know, this attack on
- 45:18Bahrain is a signal to the the Saudis.
- 45:21It's a social message to the rest of the world.
- 45:24We are so powerful that you don't have to respect the
- 45:27political processes, the diplomatic processes ongoing,
- 45:31and we can do this to your advice and you're not going to
- 45:34do anything about it. This is the message to Riyadh.
- 45:37And they're right because after this attack with drones, you
- 45:43know, nothing happened. And where are those drones
- 45:46coming from? Are they all from Iran?
- 45:47No. A lot of these drones are
- 45:49Chinese made, and some of them were paid for by Qatar in the
- 45:53past. And there's been scandals about
- 45:55it. And again, no one is doing a
- 45:57thing that the United States, not the Saudis, Bahrainis, the
- 46:01ally, the Hootie's are not publicly claiming
- 46:04responsibility, even though they normally do.
- 46:07But there is no one else who would have access to that kind
- 46:10of weapons. ISIS and Al Qaeda would not do
- 46:13that. And because they don't have
- 46:16those means, they they can certainly attack, but through
- 46:19shooting or bombs, things like that.
- 46:22Not they don't yet have access to sophisticated drones.
- 46:26And it was a huge attack that killed two people and wounded
- 46:30around 50, which is a hard, very big number for very small
- 46:34country like Bahrain. So we're seeing the true Bahrain
- 46:37which is not normally all that on the front lines of these
- 46:43Yemen related discussions is part of the coalition.
- 46:46But it's not talked about a lot all of a sudden but target in
- 46:49this country this message is being sent to their ally saying
- 46:54we've got here like you're going to do this on our terms or else
- 47:00this will. You know this is what we can do
- 47:03to you and you can't do anything because here they're going to do
- 47:06that and you're not going to complain or and the talks or
- 47:11choose Iran of anything. And that's exactly what
- 47:13happened. There's been silence.
- 47:17Absolutely, absolutely. So moving from that region to
- 47:20the big region and the big impact, that's the China, what
- 47:25is happening in with China's economy.
- 47:28Is it moving towards some difficult times is will its
- 47:32vision will it will its what you call thought process for itself
- 47:37of looking at the world about Bri what what is going to happen
- 47:41the you know unemployment numbers and all these things how
- 47:45is it going to impact help us understand this you know that
- 47:50what what is going to be the impact on China itself if the
- 47:53impact of Chinese economy the. The slow down there and as well
- 47:58as the impact of Chinese economy on the world if there is, if its
- 48:04economy becomes stagnant, Well China's made a huge number of
- 48:08economic and political mistakes that has landed in this
- 48:13position. The real estate bubble was not
- 48:17never going to be a real economic substitute.
- 48:20It can only sustain a growth in moving people from property to
- 48:26the medical for so long. It's a one time deal, you did it
- 48:30once but then people expect their standard of living to keep
- 48:33growing. 3rd issue was over relying on industrialization and
- 48:41that's really developing its own service sector or manufacturing
- 48:47that's independent of this export heavy kind of jobs.
- 48:53Now that our companies have been moving out of China for years.
- 48:57By the way, prior to this political crisis, for economic
- 49:01reasons, China has never, you know, even China has been moving
- 49:06some of its businesses to nearby countries because it's cheaper,
- 49:10but it has never developed independent industries.
- 49:13It has had to steal technologies from the West.
- 49:16It has been employing a lot of people who cooking them for
- 49:20spinners but not for real jobs. You know, stealing technology is
- 49:24not a job. It's something that you get paid
- 49:26for to occupy. But it's not the steel that
- 49:29produces anything. It's not, it's not growing.
- 49:32It doesn't Spice don't grow the economy and it's the other
- 49:40political problem is that it has a Z in his in his further anti
- 49:48western fervor has cracked down on a western company so much
- 49:53that now it's you know the there's a capital flight from
- 49:57the country. Investors are leaving.
- 50:00They're not. They're concerned about having
- 50:05the money disappear, for obvious reasons.
- 50:08Companies don't want to be harassed.
- 50:10They don't want to be investigated.
- 50:13So they're leaving. And there's been an effort to
- 50:15galvanize local domestic investment, but that too can
- 50:19only go so far, because even domestic investors are scared.
- 50:23You can force them to do certain things, but then at the end of
- 50:27the day, unless you confiscate their money, you can't
- 50:29completely force them to everything.
- 50:32And if you confiscate all their money, it's going to be like the
- 50:34Soviet Union. Yes, the some of the elite
- 50:38elites will get richer and more powerful, but the the economic
- 50:42bubble cannot sustain the economy.
- 50:44There's been also lots of expenditures simultaneously to
- 50:47all of these things. China has been spending a lot on
- 50:51international projects like the Bri and it's the situation has
- 50:57gone so bad that it's been trying to recover full, full
- 51:01investments from small, poor, mismanaged countries like Sri
- 51:06Lanka. And you know, it's trying to
- 51:08call that, but when you're trying to call, that's from
- 51:11everyone at once. If your event, what's going to
- 51:13happen? Everyone's going to flee.
- 51:16They're going to see, OK, the investor, you know, first of
- 51:19all, a, I can pay all of that at once because that's not what we
- 51:22agree to and that's what I'm not ready for that.
- 51:25And second, other people will see that you're trying to
- 51:27collect this and they say you must be in trouble and then
- 51:30they're going to withdraw their own investments from you, from
- 51:34the bank if the bank suddenly comes, you know.
- 51:37So this is what's exactly what's happening.
- 51:40China trying to collect and that's actually scared of its
- 51:44own investors. And you know, the problem is
- 51:49China is never going to admit that none of this is really
- 51:51working, especially not in combination.
- 51:54That it's dragging down its own economy and the space of
- 52:01international hegemony is unsustainable.
- 52:04Because for China, the most important thing is to save face,
- 52:07to be perceived as powerful, to project power and to counter its
- 52:11enemies, to be seen as the number one.
- 52:13So it cannot afford to kind of withdraw and take a step back
- 52:18and say, well, we are going to focus on domestic economy and we
- 52:22are kind of made a mistake here. And they cannot afford to do
- 52:25that because that will be seen as weakness and they will rather
- 52:30actually collapse and then, you know, internally then admit
- 52:33weakness and lose face Culturally.
- 52:36This is a real problem for them. They're in a dilemma.
- 52:39So don't expect China to move away from its foreign policy,
- 52:43its strategy, but do expect them to be a lot weaker domestically.
- 52:49And I think there's a real opportunity here for other
- 52:52countries to kind of gain up financially, economically and
- 52:57just kind of call this out, call out that a lot of this strategic
- 53:02technological announcements are based on outright theft and
- 53:05there is no real investment into intellectual development in
- 53:10China. There's no expert of ideas.
- 53:13There's nothing that's, you know, contributing to anything
- 53:16positive. And start withdrawing.
- 53:20Start withdrawing investments from their start.
- 53:22Stop giving China so much power. Stop giving them power that they
- 53:26don't have and cannot independently develop.
- 53:29They're not self starters. They're heavily dependent on
- 53:32being in financial relations with other countries.
- 53:35Yes, it's going to be painful and no, it's not going to happen
- 53:38overnight. It's going to be a very long
- 53:40process because you cannot immediately withdraw from huge
- 53:44Chinese investments without finding substitute investors for
- 53:48other countries are going to have to step up.
- 53:51I think it's more healthy for US and Europe to have more diverse
- 53:55investors than to rely on one big one with the dubious history
- 53:59anyway. So it's not going to be easy.
- 54:01It's going to be, it's going to have a major economic impact
- 54:06everywhere, but it's going to be necessary because you don't want
- 54:10country, you know, making everyone else so dependent on
- 54:14itself and then taking completely drastic, reckless
- 54:20decisions that are endangering investments.
- 54:23You don't want that to happen. Absolutely, absolutely.
- 54:28Thank you very much for helping us understand this complex
- 54:33complexities of international relations and we have covered
- 54:38the whole world in this. The discussion, Irina and I am
- 54:42sure a lot of benefit, a lot of takeaways will be there from
- 54:48this discussion. So thank you very much once
- 54:52again and I am sure a lot of people will benefit from the
- 54:56next, from the other discussions that we are going to have every
- 55:00fortnight that we have worked out on with on this, it is a
- 55:04wrap on this very special edition of the KJ Master Class
- 55:08Life. Thank you so much indeed.
- 55:10For joining us. Thank you so much.