Latest / Automotive State of The Union / Affordability Is the Battlefield, Close Now or Cry Later, Target’s Intern CEO
Transcript
- 0:00Good morning. It is Wednesday, August 20th. This is the Automotive State of the Union. I'm Paul Jay Daly. This is Kyle Mountsier.
- 0:07Today we're talking about affordability, cr- c- close your deal now or cry later, and Target's new CEO, which feels a lot like a little bit of an automotive story. Yeah. I'll tell you why later. It's, it is.
- 0:19It's like- You're like, "Oh, the rest of the world can do it, too. That's neat." They can. But the- Cute party trick... typ- [laughs] You know? [laughs] Yeah, right. You did it once. Congratulations. Got 'em.
- 0:30I know, I know. Got 'em. Oh, man. Um, so first things first. We have a webinar today. Today. We do have a webinar. So- It's with Mary. Yes. And that cat's smart and smooth all at the same time. Smart and smooth.
- 0:40We're talking about the 2025 Halftime Report of Dealer Reputation. So we got tons of data that they're gonna share with us. We've seen some of it already. It's fantastic.
- 0:49Dealer Reputation's gonna help us make adjustments in the second half of the year. You should be there. You should share it with the people who are thinking about marketing, CX, um, your GMs.
- 0:59You have to start by signing up, though. Go to asota.com, sign up for the webinar. Right. You can be there live with us today at 2:00 Eastern, or you can get the recording and check it out later. There you go.
- 1:08You can watch it on 2X speed if you don't have the time. You know what I'm saying? Easy. Yeah, you should do it. Easy. Asota.com, right there at the top of the page you can sign up. We hope you join us.
- 1:14Hey, we also released a podcast yesterday, uh, with a new friend, Curtis Gardner. He's a, a technician that is really trying- This is fun, yeah...
- 1:22to change the way that technicians are perceived in the industry, the way that they interact with their tech and their tools, and all those types of things.
- 1:29Uh, you can follow him on LinkedIn, but Curtis Gardner and us, we got to sit down. You can search it anywhere where you find your podcasts. Search Auto Collabs. That's Auto Collabs, and we'll hang out with you.
- 1:39Sounds great. Let's talk about some news. Got a lot of reports coming out this time of year. So many reports.
- 1:43But it's great when we get this, uh, this, like, first-party data or, or I guess this generated report that isn't widely known, but we're trying to make it l- widely known.
- 1:52At the halfway mark of 2025, our friends at the Dave Canton Group, uh, they released a market outlook report showing US retail auto mark- market is a mix of high prices, resilient demand, and major structural shifts.
- 2:04Despite headwinds, some smart dealers are still in the driver's seat in control. Affordability the top issue. No surprise, 52.1% of buyers carrying negative equity in 84-month loans. Now nearly 20% of all new f- Whoa...
- 2:1920% of all new financing- 20% of auto loans are f- 84 months... is negative equity. That's bananas. Oh. Oh, is that what it's saying? Yeah. Oh my gosh. That is crazy. All new car. New car financing, yeah.
- 2:31I mean, there are some cars- It's- There's some cars if the interest rate's right that that actually makes sense. Like, if you're gonna buy, like, a, a Toyota 4Runner- You, yeah...
- 2:39and you're gonna keep it- You, you do what works... stretch it out. Right. Yeah, stretch it out. Keep it. That's right. Why wouldn't you?
- 2:44Uh, consumers are sticking with their preferred segment, but trading down in size and trim with value-focused models from brands like Buick and Mazda gaining a lot of traction.
- 2:53I definitely can see Mazda winning that game. For sure. 40% of all US consumers say they would buy a Chinese-made vehicle if it was 10% cheaper than other cars sold in the US. Hm.
- 3:0575% of dealers expect Chinese OEMs on US lots within 12 months. Wow. That is probably a major, major, uh, thing we should be paying attention to.
- 3:15Poten- three out of four dealers are like, "I think we'll have a Chinese vehicle on a US lot in a year." That's crazy.
- 3:21Well, I saw, I mean, this isn't Chinese, but I saw V- VinFast is really starting to, like, pour the gas on opening Rooftops. So. They all, they all- they had some momentum.
- 3:31Um, I'm trying to remember who the, the gentleman was that we saw when we were at the Automotive Ventures China Summit, uh, about a month ago. Um, oh, man, I can't remember his name.
- 3:42I will remember it, though, at some point. Tou Yi Lee? No. Uh, no. Or no. Different dude. Um- No... bald, white guy, kinda tall. Okay, either way. Oh, I don't remember. Either way.
- 3:53Um, he present- he made a present- Peter Rebuild? No. No. [laughs] Was he kinda tall? Uh, yeah, that's actually it. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah, it wasn't secret. [laughs] Yeah, that's fair. You got us. That's so funny.
- 4:01You got us. But basically he, he just wrote a pretty interesting comment on his blog the other day where he said he highly... He's like, "I'm making a prediction.
- 4:10Predict that Trump is gonna announce some kind of major China deal that's gonna clear-" Wow...
- 4:14"the path for billion, like, multi-billion dollar investments in a southern state to build a plant to build the cars that they're gonna sell in the US." Whoa. And he, he's no slouch. Ah, I'm gonna remember who it was.
- 4:26No slouch. He's really plugged in, but he was so specific about multi-billion dollar plant in a southern state. Like, he knew. Like, yeah, it's like he knows.
- 4:33So, um, this report from Dave Canton, uh, and the Dave Canton Group, uh, super thankful that they, they're doing the work and sharing it so open-handedly. Here's a quote from Dave Canton.
- 4:42He says, "US dealers are proving once again how resilient they are, how sophisticated their customer-focused business models have become," which is fun to see. Yeah. I think it's right.
- 4:52I, I, I think, I think that's exactly right, is, is, uh, you know, for all of the things where people will be like, "We're behind on tech. We're struggl-" You know, the, the sopisti- sophistication is there- Yeah...
- 5:02and it's leaning in. Actually, yesterday, you know, this is crazy. Um, you know, uh, um, uh, oh, what's the agentic AI? Um, um- Hm. Uh, there's a new agentic AI. I forge- uh, now I forget what it is.
- 5:18But, um, they basically created a way for the automotive segmen- uh, sectors to self-select elements that you could create AIs, um, and agentic AI for auto- retail automotive. Like, it is in their platform.
- 5:35And so this is, like, outside industries coming in because they're recognizing that dealers are savvy enough to s- and, and indus- Hey, that's great... to create, uh, on top of these models.
- 5:45So, uh, you're g- I, I think that no matter what happens, whether it's interest rates or, or, or inventory headwinds or trying to... Like, dealers are gonna figure this out because they are savvy. Oh, very good.
- 5:57This is exciting stuff. I feel like we're watching this in real time. Yeah. All right, speaking of real time. Stop. Segway. Time.If you think the lead is dead after day three, think again.
- 6:11A new report from our friends at Foureyes analyzed over eight million leads, showing a 30-day close rate of just 16.2%, revealing how fast opportunities can fall off and where smart dealers are still winning.
- 6:2573% of sales happen in the first three days, but one in four still close after that. Close rates do drop from 12% to 2% on days four through seven. How about that? Wow. Wow.
- 6:37Follow-up efforts also plunge after day three is a-- they're calling it a coincidence that is costing [chuckles] dealers real-- right, it's a real coincidence- For sure... if follow-up stops, right?
- 6:46[chuckles] Used vehicles close faster than new, but new car deals are stretching further than the 30-day window. That makes sense as well. Internet leads are closing slower, but still produce late-month wins.
- 6:57Leads created in the last week of the month have a 17.3% close rate overall. That's fantastic.
- 7:03Oh- Yeah, basically the variance between the first half of the month and the second half of the month is about 2%, which doesn't seem like a lot, but when you're talking about hundreds, uh, hundreds of leads, you know, those late-month closes, I think that it-- uh, and this is something that, that everybody in the industry has been, has been trying to point to and, like, trying to find the data on for a long time.
- 7:24And, and I appreciate Foureyes putting this out kind of in their purview of all the stuff that they're seeing, is
- 7:31we've got a problem where we get so excited about the thing that's right in front of us, and we forget the long tail opportunity. You know, the shopping cycle is somewhere in that 60-day range.
- 7:41And what we've seen is typically when, when customers are interacting with you, they're in that 30 to 45-day range of their shopping journey. Um, and so-- and whether that be in the showroom or online.
- 7:52And so you've got a little bit more long tail that you gotta be paying attention to.
- 7:56Uh, I think that the ri- going back to the rise of AI, uh, the rise of tools that can, that can lengthen the follow-up cycles- Mm-hmm...
- 8:04that can, that can be more, uh, like, in tune with where the shopper is in their journey are, are definitely gonna change, like, the overall close rate.
- 8:11Because you get that, like, skim off the top, the s- the stuff that's early phase- Yeah... the, the, right when you get in touch with people, but it's that long tail that, um, you know, that it, it doesn't matter.
- 8:23I, I don't care if you're a salesperson in, in-- it doesn't matter what industry. Like, the long tail is harder. That's right. Always. Every time and always.
- 8:31And look, we, we, we have front row seat for dealers who do really well at follow-up, and then we have front row seats for dealers who have amazing businesses and great lead generators, and they're leaving so many leads on the table, but constantly thinking they need to spend more money- Yep...
- 8:46right, for more leads when it's, you know, the real winners are like, "How do we nurture the leads that we have, make sure our follow-up's right, make sure we're squeezing all the juice?"
- 8:54Um, and so yeah, this data helps us see. Thanks, Foureyes. [chuckles] There you go. Oh. Oh. Oh. Trying to-- what's the, what's the- I see, I see what you did there. Is it? Is it? I see what you did there. All right.
- 9:06[chuckles] All right, let's- Yeah. Let's get into this one. Let's talk about Target. [chuckles] Target, a big brand retailer, is making some headlines as it has promoted a true company insider to the CEO role.
- 9:17Uh, Michael Fedelke, i- who started with the company in 2003 as an intern, will become CEO on February 1st, a move that, uh, reflects a bunch of deep institutional knowledge, uh, but it's spark- sparking debate about the need for an outside perspective.
- 9:34Uh, Fedelke joined Target as an intern and worked his way up through roles, uh, in merchandising, finance, operations, and HR. He e- has even served the company as COO and CFO.
- 9:45Um, he'll succeed Brian Cornell, who's been the CEO since 2014. Um, and, uh, and so Fedelke, his quote was, "To be clear, we have work to do to reach our full potential."
- 9:56So I think that, like, someone with the most savvy can-- someone with a lot of savvy can look around and not just keep things the way that they are, but recognize that there's a lot of opportunity.
- 10:06Um, recent, uh, data on their performance is Q2 sales dropped by 0.9% to 25.2 billion. Still not too shabby. Um, Target expects continued softness into the rest of 2025.
- 10:20Well, Target does have their Halloween stuff out the earliest, I think. That's true. Right? It's a little bit- They also have Christmas stuff. Oh, gee whiz. [chuckles] Leave me alone.
- 10:28Um, but I, I, I love this story where an intern made his way all the way up to CEO. 20- 2003 he started, which is the year I started in business.
- 10:36So he's been working at that same company, working his way up the ranks as an entrepreneur, basically, getting all the way to the seat of CEO of Target, which isn't just the CEO, it's CEO of a major company.
- 10:46A lot of- Big company... complexity. Yep. A lot of scrutiny. And, you know, we-- you and I were talking a little before the show, and it's like, "Oh, this is a nice party trick where a company, an intern made it to CEO."
- 10:55The cool thing is, is like, yeah, it's very rare when you hear stories like this in the rest of the world, but in automotive, how many times have we heard detailers becoming GMs, becoming owners- Come on...
- 11:05over and over and over and over again. So it's great to see- And in faster timelines. Oh, a little bit. Are you kidding me? [chuckles] And I'm sure before his internship, there was, like, a lot of college and...
- 11:15You know what I mean? Yep, yep. So this, this reminds us how, how fortunate we are to have that opportunity in this industry every day and see it in real life.
- 11:23And our goal is to make this industry the place that everyone wants to work in. We're pushing hard for that.
- 11:29We think you should be pushing hard for that because the more great people we have banging down the doors to get in, the tech will be better, consumer experience will be better, and auto will be seen as a contributor to society, not anything else.
- 11:40We'll see you here tomorrow. [upbeat music]