Latest / The Psychology Undergrad Podcast / Informed Consent & Research Ethics: Milgram, Tuskegee & the Rules of Psychology
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the psychology undergrad. So grab
- 0:03a coffee, pull up a chair, and join us for tonight's
- 0:06late night study session. You, me, and our resident
- 0:09expert here, we are on a very specific mission
- 0:12today. We absolutely are. Today is the day we
- 0:15finally conquer chapter four of the source material.
- 0:18Yes. Chapter four, which is, you know, the moral
- 0:21foundations of ethical research. And I know the
- 0:23word ethics can sound, I don't know, kind of
- 0:26dry. Oh, totally. It sounds like reading a legal
- 0:28dictionary. Right, but... Ethics is basically
- 0:31just the branch of philosophy that deals with
- 0:33morality. So we're only looking at what it actually
- 0:36means to behave morally and specifically how
- 0:38you achieve that goal when you're doing scientific
- 0:40research. Yeah. And it's so much messier than
- 0:42people think. When you introduce real, living
- 0:45human beings into a study, it gets... Well, it
- 0:49gets complicated fast. It really does. So to
- 0:51start, there's a framework we need to memorize
- 0:53for this, right? The TCPS2. Exactly. The Tri
- 0:56-Counsel Policy Statement, or TCPS2. And the
- 0:59easiest way for you guys to remember this framework
- 1:02is to just visualize a three -by -three mental
- 1:04grid. OK, a three -by -three grid. Yeah. So think
- 1:07of the three columns as the different groups
- 1:09that are affected by any psychological research.
- 1:12You've got the participants, obviously. Then
- 1:13you have the scientific community. And finally,
- 1:16society as a whole. Right, because a study doesn't
- 1:18just happen in a vacuum. It ripples out. Precisely.
- 1:22And then the three rows of this grid are the
- 1:24core moral principles that researchers absolutely
- 1:27have to follow. Those are respect for persons,
- 1:30concern for welfare, and justice. OK, wait. I
- 1:33actually have a mnemonic for this to help you
- 1:35remember the rows. It's really want justice.
- 1:38Respect, welfare, justice. Really want justice.
- 1:41Oh, I like that. That's actually really helpful.
- 1:44Thanks. I try. So, okay, let's unpack this. Because
- 1:47the easiest way to actually understand what these
- 1:49lofty moral principles are is to look at the
- 1:51historical examples of when they were completely
- 1:54ignored. And these examples are pretty terrifying.
- 1:58Terrifying is the right word. If we start with
- 2:00that first principle, respect for persons, we're
- 2:02basically talking about autonomy. It's the fundamental
- 2:05right of a person to make their own choices completely
- 2:08free from coercion. And in research, that means
- 2:11informed consent, right? Yeah. Exactly. But informed
- 2:14consent isn't just signing a piece of paper.
- 2:16It means documenting an agreement only after
- 2:19you have informed the person of literally everything.
- 2:22that might affect their decision to participate.
- 2:24Which brings us to the Tuskegee syphilis study,
- 2:27and this is where the history gets really dark.
- 2:30This study ran from 1932 all the way to 1972.
- 2:34Four decades. It's just wild to think about.
- 2:37It really is. So the U .S. Public Health Service,
- 2:39they went and observed all these poor African
- 2:41-American men in Alabama, and they told these
- 2:44men they were being treated for bad blood. That
- 2:47was the term they used. Right, which wasn't even
- 2:49a real medical diagnosis. Exactly, it was a lie.
- 2:51In reality, the researchers were just observing
- 2:54them to see how untreated syphilis naturally
- 2:56develops in the human body. And the crucial,
- 2:59just absolutely horrific detail here is that
- 3:01in the 1940s, penicillin became the standard
- 3:05effective treatment for syphilis. They literally
- 3:07had the cure. They had the cure, yeah. But they
- 3:10actively denied it to these men. And they didn't
- 3:13even give them the chance to leave the study
- 3:15to get help elsewhere. it ultimately took, you
- 3:18know, journalists and activists to finally expose
- 3:20it and shut it down. Okay, here's where it gets
- 3:22really interesting to me. From a morality standpoint,
- 3:25I want to push back on the idea of consent here.
- 3:27Because the men agreed to be in the study, right?
- 3:30But if you agree to a study based on a massive
- 3:32lie, did you actually give consent? I mean, legally
- 3:36maybe at the time, but ethically. Not at all.
- 3:39It's like taking a religious vow without ever
- 3:41being allowed to read the sacred text. The physical
- 3:44signature is on the paper, but the moral agreement
- 3:47is just completely absent. That's a really good
- 3:49analogy. And building on that, true consent requires
- 3:53capacity. You have to be capable of understanding
- 3:56what you're agreeing to, which is why modern
- 3:59research has massive protections for what we
- 4:01call vulnerable populations. Like children, right.
- 4:04Because you can't just explain a complex psychology
- 4:07study to a five -year -old. Right. For children,
- 4:10researchers need to get informed consent from
- 4:12the parent or guardian. But, and this is key,
- 4:15they also need the child's assent. Assuming the
- 4:17child is old enough to understand basic language,
- 4:20they have to personally agree to participate,
- 4:23too. Oh, I have a memory tool for you guys for
- 4:25this one, too. Think of it like this. Consent
- 4:28is the legal contract. Assent is the personal
- 4:31agreement. Consent is contract. Assent is agreement.
- 4:35That's perfect. And it's not just kids. Adults
- 4:38with diminished capacity, like if someone has
- 4:40severe mental limitations or, you know, a coma
- 4:42patient, they require extra legal and ethical
- 4:45measures, too. Because they can't advocate for
- 4:47their own autonomy. Exactly. And the other big
- 4:49thing about consent is that it is not a one -time
- 4:51deal. It's an ongoing process. Researchers have
- 4:54a strict duty to keep participants informed of
- 4:56any changes as the study goes on. You can withdraw
- 4:59your consent at literally any time. Okay, so
- 5:01that's respect for persons. Let's move to the
- 5:03second principle on our grid, concern for welfare.
- 5:06Yeah, so concern for welfare is basically the
- 5:08ultimate moral scale. You are constantly weighing
- 5:11the risks of the research against the potential
- 5:13benefits. And when we say risks, we're talking
- 5:16about like... Physical harm, obviously, but also
- 5:19psychological harm or even privacy violations,
- 5:22right? Exactly. And the benefits could be a helpful
- 5:26new medical treatment or just contributing to
- 5:28general scientific knowledge or even just the
- 5:31participant getting paid or getting course credit.
- 5:33Right. So to really look at the extreme tension
- 5:36between risk and benefit, we have to talk about
- 5:38Stanley Milgram. Oh, boy. The Milgram obedience
- 5:42study. 1963. This is probably the most famous
- 5:45or infamous study in psychology. Yeah, it's heavy.
- 5:50So participants came into the lab thinking they
- 5:52were just testing the effects of punishment on
- 5:54learning. An authority figure in a lab coat instructed
- 5:57them to give increasingly strong electric shocks
- 5:59to another participant in the next room every
- 6:02time that person got a memory question wrong.
- 6:04But the setup was entirely fake. The person in
- 6:06the other room was what we call a confederate.
- 6:08a fake participant, like an actor helping the
- 6:11researcher. Exactly. So there were no actual
- 6:14electric shocks. The screams coming from the
- 6:16other room, the desperate complaints about a
- 6:19heart condition, and the eventual terrifying
- 6:21silence. It was all just pre -recorded audio.
- 6:24But the real participants didn't know that. They
- 6:26thought they were actually torturing this guy.
- 6:28And the result of the study was just, it's chilling.
- 6:31Most of the real participants kept administering
- 6:34the shocks right through the screams, going up
- 6:36to lethal voltage levels, just because the researcher
- 6:39calmly told them they had to continue. The psychological
- 6:42toll on those participants was horrific. Milgram
- 6:45used his own words in his notes to describe it.
- 6:48He talked about subjects sweating, trembling,
- 6:51stuttering, and literally digging their fingernails
- 6:54into their own flesh. Just from the stress of
- 6:56it all. Yeah. And the specific details are wild.
- 6:5914 out of 40 subjects showed this bizarre, nervous
- 7:02laughter. Three of them had full -blown, uncontrollable
- 7:05seizures of laughter. One person, a confident
- 7:08businessman, walked in. Within 20 minutes, he
- 7:10was reduced to a, quote, twitching, stuttering
- 7:13wreck. Wow. Okay, so I want you, the listener,
- 7:16to weigh this for a second. This is the ultimate
- 7:18moral trolley problem because the data from that
- 7:21study fundamentally changed psychology. It helped
- 7:24society understand horrific historical events
- 7:27like the Holocaust or, later, the mistreatment
- 7:30of prisoners at Abu Ghraib. It showed us the
- 7:32terrifying power of authority. Right. So what
- 7:36does this all mean for us as psychology undergrads?
- 7:39Is it morally justifiable to torture one person
- 7:41psychologically if the resulting data save society
- 7:44from future atrocities. It's the classic trolley
- 7:47problem, just applied directly to scientific
- 7:49research. And that's a debate that ethicists
- 7:52still argue about today. But to close the loop
- 7:55on welfare, I want to clarify another huge point
- 7:57of confusion that trips people up. And that's
- 7:59the difference between privacy and confidentiality.
- 8:02Oh, yeah. People use those interchangeably all
- 8:04the time. All the time. But there's a simple
- 8:06way to think about it. Privacy is the participant's
- 8:10fundamental right to decide what personal info
- 8:12is shared. It's their boundary. Like, do I want
- 8:15to tell you my medical history or not? Exactly.
- 8:18Confidentiality, on the other hand, is the researcher's
- 8:21agreement, their promise, not to disclose that
- 8:23information without authorization once they have
- 8:26it. Privacy is about the participant. Confidentiality
- 8:29is about the researcher's duty to protect the
- 8:31data. Okay, that makes perfect sense. So let's
- 8:34connect this back to that three by three mental
- 8:36grid we talked about earlier. Yeah, let's expand
- 8:37the grid. Because concern for welfare isn't just
- 8:40about the participant in the lab. Bad research
- 8:43harms the broader scientific community and society
- 8:45as well. Right, like if a study is just poorly
- 8:48designed from the jump, it wastes money, it wastes
- 8:51grant funding, it wastes effort that could have
- 8:54gone to productive, helpful research. And even
- 8:56worse, the result of bad research can be misunderstood
- 8:59or misapplied by the public. Which brings up
- 9:02the MMR vaccine research. I think this is the
- 9:04perfect example of how bad science harms society.
- 9:07This was that infamous study that mistakenly
- 9:10linked the MMR vaccine measles, mumps, and rubella
- 9:13to autism. Right. A study with deeply flawed
- 9:16methods that caused massive public panic. bearing
- 9:23false witness on a massive societal scale. When
- 9:26researchers violate integrity like that, it's
- 9:28not just a little academic oopsie in a journal
- 9:31somewhere. No, the real -world consequences are
- 9:33immediate. Exactly. People panicked and avoided
- 9:36the vaccine, which put actual, limbing children
- 9:40at an increased risk of real -world preventable
- 9:42diseases. And then other scientists had to waste
- 9:45years of resources and funding on unnecessary
- 9:48follow -up research just to debunk it. It broke
- 9:51the public trust and that takes decades to rebuild
- 9:55which transitions perfectly into the third row
- 9:57of our grid seeking justice justice the third
- 10:01core principle right justice is basically about
- 10:03treating participants fairly and equitably so
- 10:06for example let's say you're testing a brand
- 10:07new highly effective psychotherapy and you have
- 10:10an experimental group getting the therapy and
- 10:12a control group getting nothing to compare the
- 10:14results yeah but if the therapy clearly works
- 10:17Seeking justice means it is only fair to offer
- 10:19that successful therapy to the control group
- 10:21once the study is over. You don't just send them
- 10:24home. Because they helped you prove it worked.
- 10:26They deserve the benefit. Exactly. But historically,
- 10:29we've seen massive failures of societal justice.
- 10:32For a long time, institutionalized people, folks
- 10:36with disabilities, or racial minorities bore
- 10:38a completely unfair share of the risks in scientific
- 10:42research. Right. They were targeted because they
- 10:44were vulnerable. Like bringing us back to the
- 10:47Tuskegee study. Poor African -American males
- 10:50were specifically targeted due to their vulnerable
- 10:54status in society. They didn't have the resources
- 10:56to fight back or ask questions. And the government
- 10:58exploited that. Completely and to give you a
- 11:01sense of the timeline of that injustice It took
- 11:0465 years from the start of the Tuskegee study
- 11:06for a US president to formally apologize It wasn't
- 11:09until 1997 that Bill Clinton finally apologized
- 11:13Stating that these men who thought they had found
- 11:15hope in free medical care quote were betrayed
- 11:1865 years that is that is just staggering a profound
- 11:22failure of justice So tying justice back to the
- 11:25necessity of acting with integrity and being
- 11:28truthful. I mean We just said you shouldn't lie
- 11:30to people like they did in Tuskegee. But I want
- 11:33to raise a massive paradox here. OK, let's hear
- 11:36it. Think back to the Milgram obedience study.
- 11:39If Milgram had greeted his participants at the
- 11:41door and said, hey, just so you know, the shocks
- 11:44are fake, that guy's screaming as an actor, we're
- 11:46just pretending, the study would be completely
- 11:49useless. Obviously. Nobody would feel the pressure
- 11:51to obey. Exactly. So as a researcher, your moral
- 11:55duty to act with integrity completely conflicts
- 11:57with doing valid research that actually benefits
- 12:00society. It's a paradox. And what's fascinating
- 12:02here is that this ethical conflict in psychology
- 12:04is completely unavoidable. You can't just wish
- 12:07it away. Almost no behavioral research is 100
- 12:11% risk -free or completely transparent. Well
- 12:15-meaning, highly competent researchers frequently
- 12:17disagree on exactly where to draw the line. Okay,
- 12:19to prove your point about how weird that line
- 12:21can get, I have to introduce the urinal study.
- 12:23Oh yes, the 1976 study. Yeah. Middlemist, Knolls,
- 12:28and Matter, they were doing a study on personal
- 12:30space. And their methodology was unique. That's
- 12:34one word for it. So the setup was this. The researchers
- 12:37secretly hid in a public men's room stall. And
- 12:40they used a periscope, literally a periscope,
- 12:43to secretly observe people and time, how long
- 12:47it took participants to begin urinating when
- 12:49a confederate was standing at a nearby urinal.
- 12:52I mean, you can imagine the controversy when
- 12:54this was published. Oh, people lost their minds.
- 12:57This critic, G .P. Kutcher, in 1977, he basically
- 13:00called it an unjustified assault on human dignity.
- 13:03Which is a very fair critique. You're spying
- 13:05on people in a bathroom. Right. But the researchers
- 13:08defended it. They said they actually interviewed
- 13:10a preliminary group of participants beforehand
- 13:12and explained the study, and those preliminary
- 13:15people said they weren't bothered by the idea
- 13:16of being observed. So they used that as their
- 13:19ethical shield. Hey, we asked a focus group,
- 13:21and they said it was fine. Yeah. Which leads
- 13:23to my final pushback. I want to ask you, the
- 13:26listener directly, who gets to be the ultimate
- 13:28moral judge here? If those preliminary subjects
- 13:32didn't care, does that magically make it ethical?
- 13:34This is a tough question. Right. Or is human
- 13:37dignity an absolute sacred standard that you
- 13:40just do not cross, even if some random individual
- 13:43says, yeah, whatever, it's fine? And that is
- 13:45exactly why the TCPS2 framework exists, because
- 13:48you need a way to navigate that gray area. So
- 13:51to kind of synthesize our whole study session
- 13:53here, remember your 3x3 framework. You are always
- 13:56applying respect. welfare, and justice to the
- 13:59participants, to science, and to society. Really
- 14:02want justice. Exactly. Ethical conflict basically
- 14:05can't be eliminated in psychology, but it can
- 14:07be managed. You manage it by deeply minimizing
- 14:10the risks, by taking absolute responsibility
- 14:12for your participants, and by being able to clearly
- 14:15and logically explain your moral decisions to
- 14:17others, like an ethics board. Which means there
- 14:19are no easy answers. So, as we wrap up, I want
- 14:23to leave you with a lingering question for your
- 14:24own late night pondering. This builds right on
- 14:27that tension between truth and scientific discovery.
- 14:29The paradox. Yeah. So if doing groundbreaking
- 14:33psychology requires us to sometimes deceive people
- 14:36or violate their personal space or induce a bunch
- 14:38of stress and if zero risk research is basically
- 14:42a total myth. Does becoming a successful psychological
- 14:45researcher inherently require you to compromise
- 14:48your own personal moral purity? That is heavy.
- 14:51Right. Like, can you be a perfect saint and a
- 14:53perfect scientist at the exact same time? Or
- 14:56does the job just require you to get your hands
- 14:58dirty? Something to think about. Definitely.
- 15:00Well, thank you guys so much for joining our
- 15:02late night study session. Keep thinking, keep
- 15:04questioning, and we'll catch you next time. Signing
- 15:06off from the psychology undergrad.