Latest / Pedagogically Speaking / Are Your Students Actually Learning? 4 Ways to Know
Transcript
- Ilana: Have you ever walked out of a lesson thinking, that went really well? Only to discover the next day your students remembered almost nothing from that entire lesson. Or, you know, maybe you've had the exact opposite experience where, you know, that lesson that you did felt really messy, you felt like you were stumbling, the students looked like they were struggling and you weren't sure if it was working, but then a week later they were confidently applying the concept that you had taught them on their own. And I think that really does stem from this idea that teachers are supposed to look for engagement in their lessons and use that as a metric to see if students are learning, right? So smiling faces, busy classrooms, hands in the air. But engagement, it's not the same as learning. Today we're talking about one of the most important questions every teacher asks. Do you actually know if the students are learning something? Welcome back to Pedagogically Speaking. My name is Lana Heffer. Here we explore the thinking behind effective teaching, and each episode we take one aspect of teaching and try to unpack it. Not just about what to do, but really why does it matter? today's topic is one that has shaped nearly Every decision I make as a teacher. Learning is invisible. We cannot see learning happening. Sometimes I think teachers think they can, but really what you're seeing is behaviors. Students can look engaged or they could be compliant or busy. maybe they're quiet or enthusiastic. Honestly, none of those behaviors really guarantee that learning is happening. Instead, you need to look for evidence. So today I'm gonna share four practical ways to collect the evidence that you can tell whether or not students are actually developing their understanding or if they're actually just nodding along, looking busy, completing the work. So One of the biggest shifts that happened in my own teaching journey was when I realized that learning is invisible. Think about that for a moment. Has there ever been a time in your classroom where you were convinced that students were learning only to realize it wasn't happening? Let me know in the comments below. We can't actually see learning. We can't look into a student's mind and watch their understanding grow. What we see are those behaviors. Students raising their hands, them completing assignments, maybe they're participating in discussions, filling out some worksheets, or looking engaged. But those behaviors are very separate from learning. They're simply the visible things that students do while learning might be happening. Even now, for me, after 16 years in the classroom, this still throws me. I'll be teaching, we're talking about the lesson and activity, a student comes up, then that student and I are talking, and that student is so enthusiastic and excited. They're so happy that we're doing this lesson today. They're excited to be doing their work. They love it. And so then I'm like, this is going great. Then I get their work back or I check in with them after ten minutes, after they've started the activity that they're so excited to start. And then I realize that yes, they are still super happy, but they did not understand the lesson at all. They didn't understand the lesson at all. And it happened to me last academic year, and it will probably happen to me again in the upcoming academic year. And it still gets me. It still gets me. And I think where we get ourselves into trouble as teachers is that we definitely mistake performance for learning. let's go through an example. imagine student A and yesterday they studied the vocabulary words for Taurus quiz. Today they answer every question correctly. They're confident they're quick and from the outside it looks like they've mastered the material. Okay, let's look at student B. during a lesson on suffixes and prefixes, 'cause they did a lot of those in term three last year, they hesitated. They asked questions, they made mistakes, they weren't always sure of themselves. and if you were there watching the lesson unfold, you might even think they were struggling or not paying attention. But then a week later that student, student B, encounters a new situation, maybe they're writing a paragraph, and they can independently apply what they've learned. They make the connections, they're they can explain their thinking now and transfer that understanding to something they've never seen before. Right? So they've moved on. So here's the question, which of those students learned more? What do you think? I think if we only looked at today yesterday's lesson or yesterday's quiz, we'd probably say student A. But if we care about learning that lasts, learning that students can access, retrieve, apply, build on. Student B may have actually developed a deeper understanding, the deeper learning. And you know, that's because learning isn't an event. We always wait for these like aha moments, these big moments in learning, right? But really, learning is a process, and that process unfolds over time. You think about when you start I I think about this all the time, especially w for those transition years, right? Like how often are parents and teachers really stressed out about the learning that happens in grade four and grade five. And then I'm always like, you know, grade six is the review. Again, like they're gonna be pulling out the base ten blocks. Maybe they're gonna be using those cuisinaire rods. Like this is all going to keep happening. They're going to keep doing those Those like, you know, little one-page like tests on addition, subtraction, multiplication. They're going to be doing so much stuff because and that really does show us that you might be introduced to a concept in one grade and it might take you three grades to master it so that in grade eight then you can even move beyond that, right? So yeah. Learning is slow and it looks messy. And a lot of the times students And anyone who's learning something new really needs to wrestle with an idea before it finally clicks. and I actually think it's the struggle that is the learning. So one idea that's really stayed with me is this. And it came to me when I was hiking in the forest. and my daughter wanted me to find her. and we were in this beautiful redwood forest. Trees are huge. It's it's magical. And as you can imagine, big, you know, trees that are hundreds of years old. I you can't see little kid. So I would look for her footprints. Right? Living in a bit of a wet area. there's often mud, I can look for some footprints. and that's when I kind of thought everything leaves a footprint, doesn't it? Like Everything leaves a trace. So just like with life, learning leaves traces, and those traces are absolutely identifiable, right? And it's your job as a teacher to be able to notice those traces, identify those traces. And those traces might be a student making a connection between two concepts. You know, maybe they've read something and they can understand the relationships between what they've read and to themselves. You know, maybe there's a connection there or a connection to the world. maybe the student has asked a thoughtful question. or like I love it when a student can explain something in their own words. this one's trickier. for me with the students that I teach, but it's always fantastic when they've recognized something that they've done like incorrectly, right? Like a a misconception that they've corrected. and any real ability to use their learning in a completely new context. You know, maybe they're able to teach maybe they've learned something and they can teach one of their peers what it is, right? So those are the moments that tell us that learning and understanding is developing. So if engagement isn't enough and performance doesn't always tell the whole story, what should we actually be looking for? I think it's actually simple. We need to look for the evidence of thinking, not evidence of activity. Because your classroom is exceptionally busy, right? Students are working in groups. They're completing graphic organizers, they're using the whiteboards, they're building models, they're participating in discussions, and they're having fun, because learning is fun. And all those things are wonderful, but none of them on their own can actually tell us whether learning is happening. A room full of busy students isn't necessarily a room full of learning students. And I think we always are like obsessed with this idea, like, are the students on task? Are they task? Are they doing this? Da-da-da. no, are they talking? Are they talking about What we're doing or are they talking about something else, right? And instead of that, I think it's a better idea to think, okay, can this student explain their thinking? And not just like, can this student give me the right answer, but can they explain their thinking? Do they know how they got there? Are they able to get there again if if the question looks a bit different, right? How do they understand the formula? And how did they arrive there? Sometimes the explanation tells us far more than the answer itself. A student might get the correct answer for a completely wrong reason. That certainly happened to me, when they get the right like numerical answer, but then I'm like, how'd you get that? And they tell me and I'm and it's not nothing close to the correct way of doing another student might make a mistake but reveal a sophisticated line of thinking that needs a minor adjustment. So all of that is extremely valuable evidence. And then another question that we can ask is are my students able to connect ideas? So can to can they link today's lesson to something they learned last month? Or can they see the patterns in the lesson that we're doing? Can they make the connections across subjects or to their own experiences, right? Learning becomes more I want to say durable. Durable? Yeah, we'll go with durable. Learning becomes more durable when students begin building those connections instead of collecting isolated facts. another question we can ask is can they apply what they've learned somewhere new? This is where we move beyond memorization. Imagine your students have learned how to calculate area. Solving the examples from the textbook is one thing, but what happens when you ask them to figure out how much flooring is needed for an oddly shaped room, right? Or they they create tree houses and then they need to know you know how much flooring they have to use. Suddenly they're using the concept. instead of repeating the procedure. And I think that's extremely powerful evidence of learning. And then yes, like I talked about this earlier, I love it when they can teach someone else. So can they teach this concept to someone else, you know? Have you ever and I think that's the reason why it's my favorite, because like if you've ever seen a student try to explain something to another student, you immediately know if they've figured it out, right? Because when they have to put their thinking into their own words And they're organizing their ideas to answer the questions and they're responding to misunderstandings. You get this this beautiful window into what they've actually understood. And also like how their brain works, you know, like our brains are so different. And I think we're really wired to think that everyone thinks the the same way that we do, and everyone thinks like from even just like getting from point A to point B, like, well, of course everyone would do it the same way. But they really don't, and even in my own personal life, like there's times even just yesterday when I was like, and that's a beautiful example of how you and I think differently when I was I was talking to my husband. but it's true, like it's really nice to get those windows into how people think because it can also help us in future lessons as well. And it's just super fascinating, I think, for me. but yeah, teaching is one of the best demonstrations of learning, I think. And if a student can do it, that's fantastic. And the last question I ask is. Can they recognize their own mistakes? Like I mentioned earlier, that's definitely not something that happens with a lot of the students I see. but we all know, yeah. But you know that learning isn't about never making a mistake. It's about students being able to recognize when they've made a mistake. You know, can a student look at their work and say, I see where my thinking went off track? can they revise their understanding? Can they explain what's changed? And it's those moments that let us know the learning is still happening. It's still like ongoing, right? so yeah, the next time you're walking around your classroom, Instead of simply looking for students who are busy, try looking for these types of evidence of learning. You know, listen to their conversations, ask them to explain their thinking, notice the questions that they're asking, and watch how they respond when they're challenged, because those are the moments where the learning starts to become visible. Okay, maybe you've listened to all of this and you're like, well, what does this look like in your in my classroom? When you're gathering evidence of learning, it's not that you need to create more assessments or spend more time marking. It really is about making just those really small shifts in the questions you ask yourself and you ask your students. What are you noticing? When are you checking for understanding? Instead of asking what is photosynthesis, you might want to ask, How would the world change if plants couldn't photosynthesize? instead of an answer that really just checks for vocabulary or key concepts, now your students have to really think and they have to connect the ideas about plants, food chains, oxygen, ecosystems, and human life. They have to know they have to use what they know instead of simply repeating it. The great thing about this is that it works in every curriculum area, right? So instead of asking what happened in this chapter, you could ask Why do you think that character made this decision? Instead of what's the formula, you could ask, how do you know this is the right strategy to solve the problem? The kinds of responses you can get from tweaking the questions you ask can give you much richer and more meaningful evidence of your students' understanding. Secondly, use those exit tickets. They don't need to be elaborate, and often I find the best way to do it is just on a sticky note. At the end of the lesson, I might ask students three simple questions. What did you learn today? What are you still wondering? Can you give me one example of what we learned? And that's it, you know, and I give them a few minutes for that. And those three questions tell me what the students are taking away, what they're still uncertain about, and whether they can actually apply the concept. It only takes as much time as you give it, but it really does change how you can plan your lesson for tomorrow. Instead of guessing what the students need next, you have the data right in front of you. Third, listen more than you talk. I had this colleague, Mrs. Pole, and this is her quote, you have two ears and one mouth, so you need to listen twice as much as you talk. And I love it. When students are working, absolutely resist that urge you have to jump in with explanations right away. Okay. Instead, pause and get curious. Walk around the room, ask a simple question. Tell me how you figured that out. It is amazing what you can learn from those answers. Sometimes students have the right answers for reasons that will not help them next time. sometimes they have the wrong answer, but their thinking absolutely works. They've just made a little mistake, easily easy to fix. Sometimes you discover something that a student took away from your lesson that you didn't say, and a few of the students got that, maybe they're all friends or they're all talking to each other, and suddenly you know that, I'm gonna do a mini lesson tomorrow and really kind of hone in on this concept so they fully understand it because somewhere along the lesson they got a little bit lost. When we can spend more time as teachers listening, than explaining, you know, so listening to the e students explain themselves to us, students show us how they're thinking. And that's definitely the the evidence you're after. lastly, we need to come back to the learning a bit later. One of the biggest mistakes that gets made is checking for understanding at the end of lesson. And sure, students can tell you what they've learned ten minutes after they've learned it, but Really what we want to find out is do they still understand it a week later or two weeks later? You know, can they retrieve that information without being prompted? are they able to apply it in a different context? And then we know has that learning been able to become stuck in their brains? You know it's not something you need a test to find out. You can just start with a lesson Start your next lesson with a question from a week ago. Ask students to explain a concept that they haven't thought about in a few days. Have them solve a familiar problem with a new twist. if they can retrieve that learning after the time has passed, that is really powerful your goal isn't for students to remember something just until the quiz and then forget about it afterwards, right? The goal is to like use all those lessons as building blocks so they can like build the knowledge and carry it with them and start plugging it into new ideas and using that learning long after they've left your classroom. the mindset shift When we ask ourselves, did I teach it? We're talking about did I explain it? Did I provide enough examples? Did I cover the content? Did I make a good lesson? but it's not about delivering the information. Students don't learn because we said something clearly enough, or we created a beautiful slideshow, or we designed the perfect activity. Teaching is about creating the conditions where students can make meaning. It's about designing experiences that challenge your students to think, connect, question, apply, and ultimately change their understanding. The real measure of teaching isn't what you've delivered, it's what students are able to do with what they learned. So instead of looking at a lesson and thinking, did that go well? You could always ask yourself, what did my students show me about their learning? What evidence did they give me? What question what did their questions show me? what did their conversations tell me? What can they do now that they couldn't do before? Because when you start looking for evidence of learning, your role as your as a teacher begins to shift and you become less like a presenter, and more like a guide, The person who's noticing, adjusting, responding to students' thinking. Okay, I have a challenge for you this week or when you get back into the classroom from break. Choose one lesson, any lesson, new lesson that you're creating, an old lesson, not a perfect lesson. Choose a moment during that lesson and say, What evidence do I have that learning actually occurred? A quiet classroom doesn't always mean learning is happening, a busy classroom doesn't always mean learning is happening, a challenging classroom doesn't always mean a failed lesson. When we are looking for evidence instead of activity, We can see classrooms differently. And when you can develop that lens, you start noticing the traces of learning that gets left behind each student. And you may never look at teaching the same way again. If this episode gave you something to think about, I'd love to hear from you what's one way that you gather evidence of learning in your classroom. Share your thoughts in the comments. If you're interested in conversations about the thinking behind effective teaching, be sure to subscribe to Pedagogically Speaking. Or if you're listening on Apple or Spotify, please leave a five-star review. See you next time.