Latest / Worderella Reads with Belinda Kroll / 21 | I was gonna hide ghosts in a house, but a judge says I have to tell you
Transcript
- Hi, friends.
- Welcome to Wordarella Reads.
- This episode is sponsored, as every episode is, by my Patreon patrons.
- They keep the lights on and the tea hot, and I'm very grateful.
- And if you'd like to join them, there is a link at the end.
- So today's topic is kind of fun and wild, and totally true, by the way.
- So back in 1991, a New York court looked at a house and decided officially that it was haunted.
- Can you believe this? A judge wrote it down, like, in legal opinion, and the reason why the seller lost is because she told everyone about her ghosts in Reader's Digest, of all places.
- So let me set the scene because this is absolutely wonderful and why I wanted to share this with you, because it just made me so happy.
- So there's this 18-room Victorian house in, I think it's Nyack, New York.
- Nyack, New York.
- Yeah.
- The owner, Helen Ackley, she had been telling people for years that her house was haunted.
- Apparently there was a Revolutionary War-era lieutenant in the basement, something that shook the beds, and a spirit that floated through the living room.
- She wrote about it in the Reader's Digest in 1977, and then she also told a local newspaper, in 1982.
- And the house was even on a walking tour, and it was billed as the riverfront Victorian with a ghost.
- And then she decided to sell it, and she sold it to a man from New York City, Jeffrey Stambovsky.
- He offered $650,000 and put down a $32,500 deposit, and only after that did he find out about the ghosts.
- Apparently no one mentioned them.
- I guess the, walking tour brochure wasn't in the closing packet.
- Anyway, he wanted out.
- He asked for his deposit back, and then when that didn't go anywhere, he actually sued.,
- And the first court actually said no, right? So New York had this old rule, caveat emptor, let the buyer beware.
- So the buyer This is why you get inspections on your home, your potential home before you buy it, because it's on the buyer to check.
- If they miss something, then it's on them.
- So caveat emptor says if you're gonna buy something, double-check it's really what you want before you buy it because, you know, it's on you.
- So the case was dismissed.
- Then the appeals court got it, and this is where this story turns deliciously delightful, guys.
- It opens with a line that I would paraphrase as, "The plaintiff, to his horror, discovered that his new house came with ghosts."
- That's the first sentence of a book right there.
- It makes me so happy.
- So with this case, with the appeals court, the judge admitted that under the strict old rule, the plaintiff doesn't have a ghost of a chance.
- That the court knew.
- They know.
- They're doing the bit.
- They're, they're playing There, the wordplay is so funny.
- The court actually said caveat emptor is not so all-encompassing a doctrine of common law that it excuses every kind of silence, and then it steps in in the spirit of equity.
- So it even takes a swing at the old rule itself, calling it a hobgoblin, which should be exorcized from the body of legal precedent.
- I can't quote the song, but I think we can all agree that at some point in this legal document, it also nods to the Ghostbusters theme and its famous question about who you're gonna call.
- It's, what a wild ride, guys.
- And I know i'm talking about this in November of 2026.
- I should've talked about this in October, but you know what? I hadn't found this article yet, and I'm just too tickled, and I have to share it with you because this is real life.
- And, you know, people ask why I write about ghosts, and it's honestly because it, it just makes me chuckle.
- There's a line in the, court proceedings that, a lot of people remember from this case, I guess.
- Because the seller had publicized her ghosts, the court said she, was estopped to deny their existence, and as a matter of the law, the house is haunted.
- The word estopped basically means she said it so loudly that she couldn't take it back.
- She had it published in multiple places.
- She benefited from the Victorian haunted house tour.
- Um, but here's the really funny thing is when you actually take a step back and look at this whole thing.
- The court never actually decided whether the house was really haunted.
- The court didn't determine whether the house was haunted.
- It only decided that the seller couldn't pretend that the house wasn't haunted because the reputation was the legal fact.
- So the thing that sank our poor seller wasn't the fact that there was a ghost in the house.
- It was the fact that she was so loud about the ghost in public and then quiet about it as soon as there was that one conversation about it that really mattered, the act of trying to sell the house to someone else.
- So I mean, again, like I feel like this is a rom-com waiting to happen.
- I don't know.
- So a story about a place isn't just atmosphere, it changes what the place is to the person buying it.
- And this actually, it actually brought me back to, so back in undergrad I took a folklore and urban legends class for my English minor, and I got into this argument about whether, hotels were actually haunted, right? So like the pr- the professor in the room was kind of saying "Are hotels haunted or are we just led to believe that they're haunted, so then by the time we get there..."
- And my side was maybe, which I know is inconclusive, you can't say maybe in a debate where the question is a yes or no answer.
- But I live in a world of, gray scale, and I don't really understand black and white logic,.
- I don't know.
- I digress.
- The, the other side was, no, you heard it was haunted while you were booking, so of course you're gonna notice every creak.
- You walked into the hotel primed.
- You're not experiencing a ghost, you're experiencing like you've been preconditioned to experience the things that people told you were going to experience, essentially.
- So it's hard to, believe your own senses when your senses have been told, "Hey, these things are coming."
- So obviously I lost because how do you argue with preconditioned bias, And honestly, I didn't care enough to try to win because I'm just woo and logical enough to know that I had lost the situation and there was no point in burning energy over this, this classroom, debate.
- But again, that's why this court case delighted me and why I had to share it with you guys because the priming is the whole point.
- The seller primed an entire town and the court said, "Well, mm, it counts then."
- So again, another small detour.
- I swear it all comes together because I do have a plan.
- Someday I am going to find a house.
- I'm gonna renovate it into like a Victorian style rental.
- And I'm gonna hide little ghosties everywhere, and then I'm gonna invite y'all to book it, to stay.
- I am probably switching away from short-term rental to more of a midterm rental just because of the current market that I live in.
- That's stuff down the line trying to figure out how to actually make it work.
- But the reason why I'm bringing it up is because I had to look up Ohio law, and as a person who is not a lawyer, I was curious how would this case fly today? Right? Like, okay, someone's trying to sell me a house.
- We agree on a price.
- We get into contract.
- We're going into closing, and between the time that we get into contract and closing, I learn that the house apparently has a ghost.
- Now, honestly, as you all know, for me, I probably, I would ask what type of ghost it is and whether it is a malicious ghost or, a cute and friendly ghost like Casper.
- Because if it's cute and friendly, I'm totally keeping it and I'm using it as a reason to market and rent it out to people.
- But in Ohio today, as of 2026, it's still a buyer beware state, and so there's this form called the seller disclosure form, and that one mostly talks about the physical condition of the house.
- There's even the state's real estate division put out a spooky season reminder that sellers aren't required to disclose to home buyers if they believe they live in a real haunted house.
- So there is no ghost clause, which honestly makes me think that maybe Ohio and I, are both a little too relaxed about ghosts.
- But this is what I took from the Ackley case.
- Her problem was never the ghost.
- It was talking up the ghost and then clamming up.
- So my plan, should I ever make this little rental thing happen, is ghosts go on the booking page right at the top.
- Spectral disclosure, full, everyone's gonna know.
- I probably am not gonna find a haunted house, you guys.
- I'm just probably gonna find some cute ranch, and I'm gonna make it look, you know, modern Victorian so that way it feels cozy and comfy to come visit.
- But again, a rental isn't a sale, so the disclosure form doesn't even really apply to me, and rentals fall under a different part of Ohio law.
- And which laws, relate to my delulu dream property that I've been talking about all depend on how I set it up.
- So, you know, before anyone actually sleeps there, I'll probably have to call like an actual Ohio attorney and an insurance plan on, hey, if there's a ghost in my rental property, what am I supposed to do? If I ever sell the place,, I now know that I have publicized the ghosts, and Ms.
- Ackley is probably saying hi from somewhere.
- So that's my little ghost law story that just made me chuckle, coming into this Thanksgiving season.
- Do I believe in haunted houses? I don't know.
- I like them as a concept,, and I find it deeply satisfying that a court looked at the whole thing and said, "If you told the whole town it was haunted, you can't pretend it isn't."
- So here's my random question for you this month.
- Is a haunted hotel really haunted, or were you just primed for the haunting? And would a haunted house put you off booking, or would you pay more for it? Come tell me over on Patreon.
- You should be able to make comments, I think.
- Anyway, thanks for going on this delightful random little detour.
- I had to share it with you because this article just had me smiling from ear to ear and...
- What a great way to go into the holiday season.
- You can find everything, the newsletter, Patreon, the books, all of it at wordarella.com/links.
- I will see you next time either with another ghost story or just what I've been reading lately or maybe even details on this Delulu rental I'm gonna make happen.
- I'll catch you guys later.
- Bye for now.