Latest / Energy Voice – Out Loud / EVOL: UK blows China out
Transcript
- 0:00Hello and welcome to Energy Voice Out Loud, the weekly news
- 0:06podcast that keeps you up to date on the hottest stories from
- 0:10the UK energy market. Each week, three of our
- 0:15reporters give their two cents on the headlines, ensuring you
- 0:20get the first word on the sector that keeps Britain's lights on.
- 0:24What a week it's been. Stay tuned.
- 0:27We are going to be talking about war of wind in UK.
- 0:32Is it Denmark or is it China? Looks like there's been a winner
- 0:35emerging. OEUK has taken issue with its
- 0:41regulator NSTA. And then we find out what
- 0:45happens when you send a big ship to Rosebank.
- 0:49So it has been a heck of a week. I'm here with my colleagues,
- 0:53Mike Bear and Matthew Perry. Hi, guys.
- 0:55How are you? How did you find this week?
- 0:57Been a bit of a welcome back from from holidays.
- 1:01It's you know, you kind of go away and you come back you think
- 1:03I'll just ease back into things, get back into the news cycle,
- 1:06see what I've missed and then bam bam bam one up to the other.
- 1:09It's been a bit of a bit of a hectic week.
- 1:12So far been a bit hectic for sure.
- 1:14Well, I think it was Michael, renewables correspondent for
- 1:17Energy Voice, who ended up getting the biggest bang in a
- 1:21way. Because first it looked like
- 1:24really exciting news that Vestas had finally decided to put their
- 1:29factory somewhere in Scotland, but then it turns out that they
- 1:33are coming because Chinese company Mingyang has been
- 1:37blocked. So tell us a little bit about
- 1:39what's going on with that, Michael.
- 1:41Yesterday was a well Wednesday, if you listen to this on Friday,
- 1:45that it was, it was an interesting one.
- 1:48Definitely that look, I think we know covering offshore wind,
- 1:52reading about offshore wind, listening about offshore wind,
- 1:55the the UK has always suffered from a relatively underdeveloped
- 2:00supply chain. All the big turbine
- 2:02manufacturers, they're either in Europe or they're Chinese
- 2:06companies who've been servicing the Chinese market and now we're
- 2:10looking to expand. So the fact that we've had two
- 2:13factory stories in one day was pretty exciting.
- 2:17So on the one hand, the the winner, Denmark Festus, they,
- 2:24they've been talking about building this nacelle and hub
- 2:28factory for for quite some time. It seemed to have stalled out
- 2:31for quite a while. I think it was back in 2024.
- 2:35I was looking at it and because the the timeline was that
- 2:39predicted me taking a final investment decision in 2025 and
- 2:43then nothing, no word. Every time I got in touch with
- 2:48them they were like, we've got nothing new to report every time
- 2:50I checked any kind of planning portal.
- 2:53Instead of wind turbines, it's been cricket.
- 2:55Exactly. The So, yeah, it was starting to
- 2:57feel like, right, I think we can maybe write this off and then
- 3:00they make the announcement. And I'm not going to lie to you
- 3:04as a journalist, I was sitting there going, what is new here?
- 3:07I think the simple fact that they're talking about it was
- 3:09pretty huge. The it's coming with this £216
- 3:14million investment, 500 jobs. But there were definitely some
- 3:19caveats with it. We don't know where it's going
- 3:21to go. Port of Lisa has long been the
- 3:23the touted most likely location for it.
- 3:26So by the looks of it, that is still on the table.
- 3:30Its final investment decision is also contingent on a good AR-8,
- 3:36which is also putting pressure on that to deliver because AR 7
- 3:40was obviously, I started off calling it a qualified success.
- 3:45I think as we digested it, I think we can call it a regular
- 3:48success. It brought in record amounts of
- 3:50capacity. Definitely, it was good for a
- 3:54lot of developers. I think Bestest is involved in
- 3:57quite a few of those projects, so good for them, but it's still
- 4:02not a done deal. We need to see what happens in
- 4:05AR-8. But that, of course, has been
- 4:07brought forward a little bit. Clearly, you know, someone at
- 4:11Desnaz is listening because Ed Miliband himself came out and
- 4:14said, oh, we're going to rush out AR-8 this year, right?
- 4:17Yeah. Do you think it's because of the
- 4:18pressure to get that supply chain moving?
- 4:21I think so. And let's be fair, the fact that
- 4:23it came out in the in the wake of the Iran war, when we're all
- 4:27talking about energy security and we're really weighing up
- 4:29that whole idea of, OK, is it renewables or domestic oil and
- 4:32gas production, it felt like a signal.
- 4:35They want this done. They want renewables accelerated
- 4:39and they want a success. Now, of course, I think we can
- 4:42all say about our governments that whether they are capable of
- 4:45doing what they want is up for debate, but.
- 4:48Oh, the cynicism I think is seeping into even the lovely
- 4:52Michael Bear. But there you go.
- 4:54I mean, you know, a plan is as good as the territory may be, or
- 5:00it's like heading that way. Although what is what are the
- 5:04folks at Ardor Sea are saying? I mean, they must be feeling a
- 5:07little bit disappointed. I mean, they have like a massive
- 5:13site, you know, there up on the North Coast of Scotland that has
- 5:19been basically offering in his services to the North Sea back
- 5:24when it was Mcdermott's shipyard.
- 5:26You know, thousands and thousands of people worked there
- 5:29and it looked like it was coming again, but maybe not the.
- 5:32Location for bestest facility hasn't been hasn't been decided
- 5:36yet. So maybe hardest year is going
- 5:37to be putting on the charm and saying.
- 5:40That would be absolutely crazy if they decided not to go with
- 5:444th part. Yeah, maybe there's going to be
- 5:46a. Weirdest things to.
- 5:48Happen going on, I think, you know, it was a case that Ming
- 5:52Yang literally the same day as the the Vestas announcement they
- 5:56were blocked, the UK government came in and said, look, we can't
- 5:59do this due to national security concerns.
- 6:02I know that early in the earlier in the year, there were a few
- 6:05events where Ming Yang was speaking and they were really
- 6:08aggressively touting the security credentials of their
- 6:12their turbines because obviously that's long been the big concern
- 6:15if we're going to let a Chinese company into the UK and European
- 6:19markets, you know, we've, we've covered it quite a few times.
- 6:24Sometimes it feels like it's a legitimate concern.
- 6:27Sometimes it feels like people are concerned that the that
- 6:31China is just going to push a button and these winter, but
- 6:33they're just going to fly away and take down all of our
- 6:36electricity. But, you know, on the sort of, I
- 6:40think more realistic, realistic case, there are cybersecurity
- 6:45concerns. You know, we saw with the 5G
- 6:47networks with Huawei that there were concerns about the extent
- 6:51that the Chinese government might be able to use it for
- 6:53surveillance. And it seems that the UK
- 6:56government has finally come down with a decision saying, yeah, we
- 7:00can't allow Ming Yang to to build a sort of supply a
- 7:05factory. Here it's hard to really get in
- 7:06a like a sense of what what that assessment really came came down
- 7:11to because there hasn't really been a transparent process for
- 7:14this assessment. There hasn't been sort of, you
- 7:16know, a report sitting out exactly the reasons why, you
- 7:20know, Ming Yang can't be part of the, it's been really unclear
- 7:23exactly what we were all just sort of speculating as to why
- 7:26these these turbines have been assessed to be a national
- 7:28security concern. But there's no, I guess, word
- 7:31from the government as to exactly what the specific reason
- 7:34is. But I guess what is clear is
- 7:35that clearly the the UK government is prioritizing
- 7:40national security concerns over cost concerns because we know
- 7:44that these Ming Yang turbines are significantly cheaper than
- 7:47alternative options produced by the European manufacturers such
- 7:50as Vestas and Siemens. I think I've spoken to some
- 7:53Scotland developers that put the figure is up to 30% cheaper.
- 7:56I know our colleague Ed has given a good, a good run through
- 8:00as to the, the technological advancements that, you know,
- 8:02companies like not just Mingyang, but other Chinese
- 8:05turbine developers have have broken through in that, that
- 8:09space. So I guess it's will be
- 8:11interesting to see how the Scotland developers particularly
- 8:14react, because we know that so many of them have publicly said
- 8:17that they, they want to see Min Yang come into Scotland.
- 8:22They want those turbines to be available.
- 8:24And, you know, it, it shows a bit of a break with the the
- 8:27government and, and Jurgen Meyer of GB Energy, because he's been
- 8:30quite outspoken as saying that we should be welcoming that
- 8:33investment. The SNP government, you know,
- 8:36I've said that, you know, the UK government is sabotaging
- 8:38Scotland's industrial future. So there's a bit of a political
- 8:41element going on there. But yeah, it's, it's I guess
- 8:44what's still really unknown is exactly what the, the the factor
- 8:49is That's that's, you know, got the security buffins down in
- 8:55London concerned by. You've been taking our page out
- 8:58of the the Trump playbook because isn't that the what he's
- 9:01been using to quash a bunch of the the US offshore wind farm,
- 9:05these sort of vague, undefined national security concerns that
- 9:09no one actually seems to know what they are, but there's
- 9:12lawyers fighting over. Them well, I'm sure a big part
- 9:14of it is obviously considerations, you know, the,
- 9:17we've seen the geopolitical landscape change quite
- 9:20significantly from the start of Trump's second presidency.
- 9:23And the UK's relationship with Europe, with the EU has really
- 9:27become a sort of a key focus, you know, that it, it has felt
- 9:31like that the UK and the EU are facing, you know, Russia, China,
- 9:35and now even, you know, the, the US is, is not maybe the, the
- 9:38partner it once was for Europe. And so I'm sure that there have
- 9:41been discussions with the EU and, and companies like so
- 9:45countries like Denmark, Germany, you know, about allowing a
- 9:49Chinese company in, you know, it's similar, I guess, to the
- 9:51discussions about the, the vehicle supply chain in Europe,
- 9:55you know, the, the impact of Chinese electric vehicles on the
- 9:58European supply chain. But it seems as if potentially
- 10:03some kind of discussions have been had about protecting the
- 10:06wider European supply chain. You know, we, we've seen
- 10:11discussions of the Hamburg declaration earlier this year,
- 10:14lots of cooperation between North Sea neighbors on offshore
- 10:16winds. So I, I again, we're not Privy
- 10:20to these discussions, but I'm sure that this could potentially
- 10:23be seen as the UK taking one for, for the team potentially
- 10:29and, and protecting their European allies.
- 10:31So Europe over China is the answer here and I'm afraid we
- 10:38have to move on. But stay tuned, we'll take a
- 10:41quick break. And coming back, our Aberdeen
- 10:46correspondent Ryan Duff went to the Offshore Energies UK big
- 10:54shindig where they were talking about how much gas they could
- 10:59the North Sea could start producing.
- 11:00But they also took a swipe at the regulator, the North Sea
- 11:04Transition Authority, and he speaks to their head of research
- 11:09to find out a little bit more about that.
- 11:11Stay tuned. Be the first to hear breaking
- 11:14energy news through the Energy Voice app, available to download
- 11:18for free. You get features like saving the
- 11:21articles you want to return to access to the Energy Voice
- 11:25supplement. You can read exclusive E Forward
- 11:28content and even listen to the Energy Voice Out Loud podcast.
- 11:32If you work in the UK energy sector, stay in the loop by
- 11:36saving the Energy Voice app to your home screen.
- 11:39Download the app through the Apple App Store or Google Play
- 11:43for breaking energy news on the go by searching Energy Voice
- 11:47app. I'm joined at the OUK business
- 11:51breakfast this week with Ben Ward, market intelligence
- 11:54manager for Offshore Energies UK.
- 11:56How are you doing today, Ben? Very well, an excellent session
- 12:00this morning. I thought the presentations were
- 12:02fantastic and the panel session even more so.
- 12:04So first of all, just a massive thank you to all of our to all
- 12:08of our panelists, our speakers and then principally also our
- 12:11sponsor Deloitte for our business breakfast sessions.
- 12:14Certainly. And do you know what you are the
- 12:16man who made the business outlook report happen.
- 12:19I was reading through it yesterday.
- 12:21There's some interesting points in there.
- 12:23I'm going to start on the the comments around the regulator,
- 12:26if that's OK. There was questions about
- 12:28maximizing economic recovery that that policy suggestion that
- 12:33sorry and Wood came out with a few years ago.
- 12:35It was the IT was the mandate of the NSTA.
- 12:38Now it's now it's the North Sea transition deal.
- 12:41What is OUK looking to see change with these comments that
- 12:45it's put into its report? So I think what we're looking
- 12:48for here is a as a trade association and, and
- 12:51representing EU KS offshore energy sector is, is really
- 12:55policies and regulation that supports investment into the
- 12:58basin. We published as part of our
- 13:01business outlet report this year some our annual business
- 13:03sentiment survey results. So that gives us an opportunity
- 13:06to, to really garner an understanding of, of where
- 13:09current policies and current regulation is, is, is, is, is is
- 13:15taking industry, how industry is, is responding to those.
- 13:18And I think what was most striking from those results was
- 13:21that in last year's survey, 9 out of 10 supply chain companies
- 13:26indicated that that in order to grow their business, they'd be
- 13:29looking at at overseas investment.
- 13:33This year that sentiment has worsened within the UK and
- 13:36principally from the from those from, from those notes, we were
- 13:41able to identify from members that that, that most of them
- 13:44were referencing a referencing the fiscal and regulatory
- 13:49environment as being restrictive for their ability to invest
- 13:52within the UK and the the current climate.
- 13:55And that also seeps through into into our operator members who,
- 13:58who particularly our oil and gas operator members who are, who
- 14:01are put forward fiscal and regulatory regimes as being the
- 14:06main issue for for investing in in the UK.
- 14:09So I think to answer your question, Ryan, we're what we're
- 14:12looking for is, is really a fiscal and regulatory
- 14:15environment that supports domestic production.
- 14:16We're an incredible incredibly geopolitically in stable time at
- 14:22the moment. And you've seen that with, with
- 14:24energy prices at the moment, oil and gas prices fluctuating on
- 14:27the daily, on the daily market, particularly surrounding
- 14:31everything going on in the Middle East.
- 14:32So it's times like this that really brings forwards to to to
- 14:36not just the industry but also to the general public, the
- 14:40importance of homegrown energy, the importance of having a
- 14:43domestic supply. So what we want to to see is an
- 14:46environment that allows us to really achieve our potential.
- 14:50So I, I've got a few questions off the back of that.
- 14:52So I'll start with the topic around the, the war in the
- 14:55Middle East. We're seeing price increase now.
- 14:57It was, it was discussed in the panel session there.
- 15:00But, you know, we hear people say, well, increasing oil and
- 15:04gas production here in the UK, that's not going to impact
- 15:07people's bills. Commodities are traded on an
- 15:09international market. How can OE UK justify saying
- 15:14that the war in the Middle East means that we need more oil and
- 15:17gas production here in the UK? OE UK has used the term policy,
- 15:21not geology a good few times in recent reports to describe the
- 15:24idea that, you know, it's tax policy, it's ledge is
- 15:27legislation around licensing. That's what's causing the
- 15:29decline, not not the appetite or not the geology in the UK.
- 15:37You highlighted 111 projects, £50 billion of investment could
- 15:42be associated with them. Billions of barrels could come
- 15:44out of UK waters as a result. However, your own graph shows
- 15:49that we're not getting going to get to 2015, 2020 levels.
- 15:53I go UK's report last year with Westwood said that I think we
- 15:56could meet around half of our oil and gas demand.
- 16:00How do you justify still saying it's a policy geology argument?
- 16:04So I think the data is relatively clear in terms of the
- 16:07ask that we set out within that exercise.
- 16:10So we went out directly to to operate a skin understanding
- 16:14what could be done in an environment where the fiscal
- 16:16policy did actually change and that we did have a renewed
- 16:20approach to to future licensing. So I think just in the fact that
- 16:23we were able to identify 111 projects that weren't being
- 16:26considered currently under the current environment, it really
- 16:31does highlight the, the, the, the, the appetite that would be
- 16:34out there in an environment where you did have changed to
- 16:37both your fiscal and regulatory environments.
- 16:39And I think so those 111 projects are based on real
- 16:44projects. They're real things that our
- 16:47member organizations are considering and they're spread
- 16:50across. So we're not talking about 111
- 16:52new fields that could be developed, but what we are
- 16:54talking about are 111 projects that are spread across new
- 16:59fields, infill wells, enhanced economic recovery, which extends
- 17:04the life cycle of the lifespan rather of, of existing
- 17:08infrastructure. Which means that by promoting
- 17:11domestic production and bringing on, on those, those, those new
- 17:15projects, you're able to extend the life cycle of, of existing
- 17:18projects, which in terms snowballs and, and, and, and
- 17:21allows you to, to, to increase production, not just from, from
- 17:25developing new projects, but extending the life of, of, of
- 17:29others. So I think ultimately to answer
- 17:32your question, it's the, the fact that we have £50 billion
- 17:35worth of cash capital investment opportunity 111 projects really
- 17:39does show that there that there is an appetite that extends
- 17:43beyond the current policy and, and, and, and fiscal
- 17:46environment. And I think it's also key to
- 17:48note that within our within our modelling, we were asked that we
- 17:51did ask members around what could be done in an environment
- 17:56where there was a replacement mechanism that came in for the
- 17:59energy profits levy, something that still captured windfall
- 18:02taxes. But ultimately when prices were
- 18:04low, as we saw in in 2025 and 2024, it would have enabled
- 18:10capsules to be invested in those periods where prices were lower
- 18:14and wasn't a restrictive tax that caps the amount of
- 18:18investment that could be done within the basin.
- 18:20So I think what operators are really looking for is that
- 18:24certainty is that understanding. And I think in our presentation
- 18:27today we showcased what the impact of having an unstable
- 18:31fiscal regime can have on on on the value of of of assets within
- 18:36within a basin. When we compared Norwegian to to
- 18:39to UK to UK assets. And we have seen a substantial
- 18:43reduction in terms of the value that that UK assets are being
- 18:47traded at compared to our North Sea neighbors in in Norway.
- 18:51And when we look across the the waters to Norway, we can see a
- 18:54very different picture for the fiscal environment where yes,
- 18:57there is a headline tax that is very similar to what we've got
- 18:59in the UK, but it's been stable throughout.
- 19:01There are capital allowances and decommissioning allowances and
- 19:05exploration allowances that allow for investment as well as
- 19:08ensuring that there are continued tax receipts.
- 19:10So what we're looking for really is an environment that that that
- 19:13allows to capture the windfalls when there are windfalls, but it
- 19:16also allows freedom to to invest when when those windfalls aren't
- 19:20around. Perfect.
- 19:21Well, thank you very much, Ben, for joining us.
- 19:23And stick around, because after the break, we've got yet more
- 19:25stories from the North Sea. Hello, I'm Ed Reid, the editor
- 19:30of E Forward. E Forward is a membership
- 19:32community that brings together the entire UK energy supply
- 19:36chain, every hub, every sector, every stage.
- 19:39Our aim is to deliver growth to the energy sector, working with
- 19:42industry and policy makers to unlock the UK's opportunities
- 19:45and advantages. This is the movement to secure
- 19:49increased investment, improved policy making and better
- 19:52collaboration by providing our members with visibility,
- 19:55influence and access. Join me forward today.
- 20:03Imagine you are on the FPSO outside of Namibia and you see
- 20:10protesters and kayaks come and start painting the sides of it.
- 20:13That would make you the FPSO due to come to the Rosebank field.
- 20:19And let's not forget what Rosebank is.
- 20:21It is EU KS largest unproduced oil and gas field.
- 20:25It's actually not in the North Sea, it's in the West of
- 20:27Shetland. But it is the locus of the
- 20:31future of the UK oil and gas industry.
- 20:35Because we're waiting to find out if it's going to come on
- 20:38stream or not. The developers, Adjura certainly
- 20:43seem to think it is as they've are bringing this boat over,
- 20:47although Greenpeace has other ideas.
- 20:49And yet this has become the very locus of major debates in
- 20:53Westminster. And for this we are going to
- 20:56speak to Matt Perry, who has all of the details on what's going
- 21:00on. What's going on, Matt?
- 21:01Well, it's. Feeling like a little bit of a
- 21:03never ending story at this point, isn't it?
- 21:05Because we've been talking about Rose Bank, I think as far back
- 21:07as when I started Energy Voice in 2023.
- 21:10That was when consent for the field was first granted by the
- 21:13previous Conservative government.
- 21:15But of course. Were you traumatized by that
- 21:17documentary too? That Energy Voice produced that.
- 21:21It was one of our opuses and it was just a huge amount of work.
- 21:25You would go on the site and have a look, but were you
- 21:28involved in that? Yes, I had a little bit of
- 21:30involvement with that, but it almost feels as though we need
- 21:32to make, you know, a Part 2 at this point because the story is
- 21:35certainly not finished. But to the, as you said, the
- 21:39Rose Bank, Petroyal Rose Bank, formerly known as the Petroyal
- 21:42Na FPSO, is on its way to Shetland.
- 21:46It's had a pit stop off the coast of Namibia because it's
- 21:49taking a bit of a roundabout route to avoid the Red Sea and
- 21:54the Suez Canal. Because, you know, it came very
- 21:57close to being stuck in the the Gulf because it was at DP World
- 22:01dry docks in Dubai, managed to skirt through the Strait of
- 22:04Hormuz before Donald Trump launched the Rockets at Iran.
- 22:09But of course, you know, anytime we mention the word Rosebank, it
- 22:12really has become, you know, the, the, the catalyst for, as
- 22:15you said, the anti oil and gas campaign groups such as
- 22:20Greenpeace, They've rendezvoused with the FPSO off the coast of
- 22:25Namibia. They've held up some protest
- 22:27banners, they've painted some slogans on the side of the ship,
- 22:31but really this has all been timed to coincide with some
- 22:34Westminster debates this week that were taking place.
- 22:36We saw the Conservatives put in a motion at the start of the
- 22:40week wanting to see the government remove its windfall
- 22:45tax on the North Sea oil and gas producers and approve the
- 22:48Rosebank and Jackdaw oil fields. That was beaten by 200 and 97108
- 22:54votes. And then we've also seen the
- 22:58Prime Minister's Questions. Yesterday.
- 23:00We saw the Prime Minister's skier Starmer and Conservative
- 23:03leader Kimi Badnock clashing over North Sea oil and gas
- 23:08policy. And we've got the full video of
- 23:10most of the exchange on the Energy Voice website.
- 23:12And it is it's quite, you know, quite an interesting little
- 23:18clash that they've got going on because we have seen Kimi
- 23:20Badnock calling on the calling the Prime Minister weak and
- 23:25saying there's energy policies being run by Ed Miliband and
- 23:28calling on him to just go ahead and approve the projects.
- 23:31And then Sir Keir Starmer is retorting with, you know,
- 23:34there's the legislation and you know, it's up to Ed Miliband and
- 23:37you can bade not comes back with you can change the legislation.
- 23:40You're the Prime Minister, just a very, you know, typical almost
- 23:43kindergarten spat as we see from politicians.
- 23:45There was a very funny picture where, you know, Keir Starmer
- 23:49just was having his head hung down and in his hands and, umm,
- 23:53I seem to remember, uh, Kemi Betanock saying, umm, something
- 23:57about how, uh, you know, she's got the unions and uh, you
- 24:02renewable UK, uh, on her side, you know, which umm, you know,
- 24:06you think should have been on, uh, well, she's drawing sides, I
- 24:09guess in a black and white, umm, argument that has lots of grey,
- 24:13but nevertheless, uh, it was a good piece of, uh, entertaining
- 24:17rhetoric. Umm, So yeah, go to Energy Voice
- 24:19and watch the video. For sure.
- 24:21I'm also at an interesting point where he pointed to comments
- 24:24made by a senior Tory figure in 2022.
- 24:28It said that its investment in nuclear renewables, it will
- 24:31reduce our dependence on fossil fuels and keep our consumer
- 24:34costs down. Obviously, there was a clash
- 24:35over the prices of energy, and guess who that senior Tory
- 24:39figure in 2022 was? It was Kemi Badenoch.
- 24:41So the Prime Minister was throwing out Kelly's old
- 24:45comments against her. But yeah, no, honestly, there
- 24:48was not much change. It was clearly there's a lot of
- 24:51political theater, but I think that we're only going to see
- 24:54this ramp up because, you know, the, the FVSO is moving N it's
- 25:00heading to the North Sea. I'm seeing more and more
- 25:02notifications of different surveying and, and that works
- 25:05going on at the site ahead of the planned installation this
- 25:09summer. But of course the project does
- 25:12not have consent because that was overturned by the Scottish
- 25:16court last year, thanks to a legal action launch by
- 25:19Greenpeace and uplift. So, you know, the the UK
- 25:22government is introduced updated environmental impact assessment
- 25:27guidance that needs these projects need to take into
- 25:30account scope 3 or downstream emissions.
- 25:33And Rosebank and Jackdaw have resubmitted their consents, as
- 25:37has if MGS Cambo project, which is also in the West of Shetland.
- 25:41But as yet we've not seen a decision come through.
- 25:44So obviously the pressure is piling up from both sides.
- 25:47You know, we're seeing obviously the ramp up of protest actions
- 25:51from Greenpeace calling on the, the government to, to quash
- 25:56these to go full scale, full tilt on renewables.
- 25:59We're seeing, you know, Aberdeen Grampian Chamber of Commerce is
- 26:01never shy backwards and coming forwards.
- 26:04So, you know, it's, it's something that we are only, I
- 26:07think going to be talking more about as the months go on and
- 26:10the FPSO gets closer to UK waters because it's still
- 26:13undecided. We're, we're in a strange place
- 26:15that then FPSO is, is charging ahead to the, you know, set
- 26:21itself up at Auk oil field, but it does not have consent to do
- 26:25so. And this was because the, the,
- 26:27the judge in his decision allowed development work on both
- 26:29Roy's bank and Jackdaw to, to go ahead because the arguments from
- 26:32Shell and Equinor was that they'd already spent hundreds of
- 26:35millions of pounds on, on this work.
- 26:37And so it's sort of this, we're in this weird grey zone where
- 26:40the projects don't have approval, but they are allowed
- 26:42to keep going on as if they do have approval at this at this
- 26:46stage. My question the other night, as
- 26:50you know, Michael was saying that he likes shouting at the
- 26:52television whenever there's reporting about Trump.
- 26:54But I was shouting at the I found myself shouting at the
- 26:56television wondering, well, you know, how did the protesters get
- 27:01to Namibia, You know, if they kayaked their, you know, hats
- 27:06off to them. And, yeah, didn't require jet
- 27:08fuel or didn't require hydrocarbons, you know, and I
- 27:13know, Look, look, OK, I know that that's an old chestnut.
- 27:16And, you know, you know, they're trying to kind of talk about,
- 27:20you know, how we live life in the future rather than how we
- 27:24live life now. But, you know, there's a lot of
- 27:26people who are arguing that how we live life now, you know, is
- 27:30really important and can't be, you know, kind of like scrapped
- 27:33because everyone does talk about, you know, the need for an
- 27:37energy transition. And but that there's a, there's
- 27:41a currently disputed, you know, in the UK in particular dispute
- 27:46over whether that transition, you know, kind of will require
- 27:50the likes of Rosebank and Jackdaw or other aspects of
- 27:55production potentially being developed West of Shetland or
- 27:58not. So, and interestingly, the
- 28:01reason why that's a long segue into I was just, I was up early
- 28:04this morning and Sarika Energy put out an update and of course,
- 28:10they've been buying plenty of assets, including a lot of gas
- 28:15assets West of Shetland. And they think that, you know,
- 28:18by the end of the year, once all these acquisitions settle in,
- 28:21they will be more of a gas producer.
- 28:23And then of course, they're going to be owning the, you
- 28:26know, Shetland gas production plant where all of that gas gets
- 28:30piped in. And they actually came up all
- 28:33right. And we we hear a lot from
- 28:34industry, we hear a lot from Offshore Energies UK as you
- 28:37heard in the middle bit. And we also heard about the need
- 28:40for gas. You know, people say the
- 28:42transition fuels, people say that 85% of the UK households
- 28:46still use gas to, you know, heat themselves.
- 28:50And then there's also cars and all that other stuff that
- 28:54requires gas currently still in the system.
- 28:57So and they are setting up their four point plan to, you know,
- 29:02suggest maybe or the the chairman, David Latin had sent
- 29:07out his four point plan. But, you know, the one that kind
- 29:11of touched me most, I think, you know, was how he said that the
- 29:19North Sea, you know, just actually needs to deserves
- 29:24better. It's people.
- 29:26And the basin, just because of course, it employs so many
- 29:31people and they work quite hard to make sure that we have, you
- 29:35know, oil and gas and that you can get to Namibia if you need
- 29:37to. Anyway, I'll stop ranting, but
- 29:41what do you think? When do you think we're going to
- 29:43hear about Rosebank? Matt, have you had any, you
- 29:47know, intimations, you know, did you change your views?
- 29:50Well, the, the clock is ticking and I think surely it should be.
- 29:54I, I, I imagine it will be in the next two months because I
- 29:57think it would be bad optics for the government to have this FPSO
- 30:01off the coast of Shetland and installing itself.
- 30:03And they still haven't made a decision.
- 30:05So I think, you know, I, I'd be looking at potentially early May
- 30:08would be my prediction, but it's purely speculation.
- 30:11But I think it is interesting that, you know, as you said,
- 30:14amidst this energy crisis that Rosebank is continuing to
- 30:19capture a lot of this, you know, protest and, and controversy,
- 30:24whereas the Jackdaw field is, is sort of slipping under the radar
- 30:27at this point. And I think it, it, we are
- 30:29seeing a distinction in sort of treatment between oil,
- 30:33predominantly oil projects, which Rosebank is and
- 30:36predominantly gas projects, which Jackdaw is.
- 30:37You know, the gas from Jackdaw will be pumped mostly directly
- 30:41into the, the UK gas system. You know, it'll, it'll kind of,
- 30:46and you know, OUK CEO David Warehouse was being questioned
- 30:50about this at the Westminster committee yesterday, you know,
- 30:52saying, well, why what the, some of the MPs on the, the, the
- 30:56committee, we're asking why should we care about First Bank?
- 30:59You know, it's sold on the international market.
- 31:01You know, this and the other. And he was making the point
- 31:03that, you know, that's, that still contributes tax dollars to
- 31:06the Exchequer. It employs people in the UK.
- 31:08But also, and this point, I've not heard really much from, from
- 31:12the industry, but he said that up to 80% of that oil will go to
- 31:15European refineries. And if you're thinking about it
- 31:17in terms of the, the geopolitics of, of the, the energy crisis,
- 31:22obviously we spoke about with, with Ming Yang investors
- 31:25earlier, the UK is really looking to, to deepen those
- 31:29relationships with European partners.
- 31:31If there's oil coming out of, of the UK waters going straight to
- 31:34our refinery in Rotterdam, that contributes to wider European
- 31:38energy security. And not just the, the UK also as
- 31:42well, it would contribute to the bottom line of all of these oil
- 31:44and gas companies. That's for sure as well.
- 31:46But I guess that's sort of the argument that the, the industry
- 31:49is hinging at the moment. And I think it is potentially A
- 31:52persuasive 1. You know, you don't see Norway
- 31:54saying, well, we have already got 5 million people.
- 31:56We only need this much oil and gas.
- 31:57We're not going to drill anymore.
- 31:59They see themselves as an energy security provider for the rest
- 32:02of Europe through their their pipelines.
- 32:04So I think that is how the the UK industry is seeming to to
- 32:08pitch itself as it's not just about or solely about the UK
- 32:12energy security, but about sort of a wider European perspective
- 32:15is seems to be the, the, the communications line that they're
- 32:19they're going with now with regards to Rosebank.
- 32:21You know, what's driving me bonkers is, you know, kind of
- 32:23people getting confused about the difference between energy
- 32:28security and cheap energy. Umm, energy security is umm, you
- 32:33know, about supply and as you say, uh, being able to deliver,
- 32:38uh, energy to, you know, people in the UK, but also to a system
- 32:42on which, umm, you know, a lot of the globe relies on,
- 32:46particularly Europe, where a lot of refining capacity is for oil
- 32:49and gas. Umm, but then, uh, you know, the
- 32:53whole thing about umm, cheap oil and gas.
- 32:55Uh, I was reading about how actually, uh, you know, it
- 32:59depends on how, what you're measuring in terms of, you know,
- 33:02the actual cost and what it will eventually cost.
- 33:05But frankly, you know, when it comes to, you know, energy
- 33:10security, the question is, are you going to be a seller of, of
- 33:14energy or a buyer of energy? And when costs are very high,
- 33:18guess which ones it's better to be.
- 33:21If you're a seller, then of course you get all the benefits
- 33:23from it, including jobs and tax income.
- 33:27And then of course, you know, if you get all that tax income, you
- 33:29can do what you want with it. You can charge what you'd like
- 33:32for your own domestic audience. And so I'm just going to leave
- 33:35that rent right there and I'm going to say thanks ever so much
- 33:40to Michael and Matt for once again sharing the insides of
- 33:44your brains for this Energy Voice Out Loud recording.
- 33:49And then, of course, I'd also like to thank you, the listener.
- 33:53We love you. We thank you for tuning in.
- 33:57We hope you tune in against next week because that's what we do
- 34:01here at Energy Voice Out Loud every week.
- 34:04Thanks very much. See to you soon.