Latest / Newcomer Pod / Cult of the Dead Cat (w/Joseph Menn)
Transcript
- 0:05Welcome Silicon Valley hey everybody, Welcome to Dead cat.
- 0:15Tom dirt on here joined by Eric newcomer and we are joined this
- 0:18episode by Washington Post reporter and author.
- 0:21Jomon joke has been covering cybersecurity for years and also
- 0:26has written many books about the topic, including his most recent
- 0:29book, Cult of the dead cow, which we can ask about that.
- 0:32Very fascinating title. I think it involves beta or
- 0:35Rourke in some capacity, so we can discuss that.
- 0:38But the heart of this episode is going to be about a fascinating
- 0:41case. That just concluded this last
- 0:44week involving Joe Sullivan, the former Chiefs security officer
- 0:49at Uber, who was charged and convicted by boilers.
- 0:54Yeah, well, if you read your, we chose article, you do all this.
- 0:58I'm curious how many people are following this Is but I think
- 1:00it's, it's not, you know, the Thera knows trial but I think
- 1:03it's a very significant one and interesting one.
- 1:06Yeah, it's a fascinating case about, you know, bug bounties.
- 1:09The FBI, the FTC Joseph is going to summarize all of it for us,
- 1:13but I will say at the outset because I know Eric will jump in
- 1:16and with here at some point because when he was covering
- 1:18Uber, you were very much involved in the coverage of
- 1:23Joe's ouster from Uber and kind of the precipitate.
- 1:25Yeah, it was the first to report the story, the hack and Joseph.
- 1:29Firing. But anyway, Joseph, thank you so
- 1:31much for joining. Welcome to dead cat.
- 1:33Yeah, thanks nice to be here. Let's just summarize the charges
- 1:37here, like, what was Joe, Sullivan charged with and
- 1:40ultimately convicted of and just give us the backstory on how we
- 1:44got to this point. Okay.
- 1:46Well, I think you have to go back to the hack itself.
- 1:48So there were a couple of young hackers one in Florida, one in
- 1:53Canada, that found in Amazon key used by Uber lying around on
- 1:59good. Ben then use that to get into a
- 2:03unencrypted backup that had information on all over users
- 2:07through 2015 and included phone numbers and other sensitive
- 2:10information. And also a, you know, a store of
- 2:16information about Uber drivers, 600,000 of them including their
- 2:19drivers license numbers, so sensitive stop.
- 2:23They obtain this they sent Joe Sullivan, then Chief security
- 2:27officer at Uber, and I'm gonna Is email and you know, they
- 2:31said, hey, we discovered this vulnerability and we're here to
- 2:35tell you about it, but we were able to download all this
- 2:38information and then there was like this prolonged back and
- 2:41forth with Joe and with other security people there.
- 2:45And after all this happened towards the end of it Sullivan,
- 2:49steered them into Ubers bug Bounty program, which rewards,
- 2:54you know, more or less ethical hackers with some money.
- 2:56If they discover vulnerabilities ideal, Is bug Bounty being?
- 3:01I'm a researcher. I see this flaw.
- 3:03I'm not executing on it, but if somebody were to do this, you
- 3:07know, I would get X Y and Z and then the company out of the
- 3:09goodness of their hearts, pays them to avoid those people sort
- 3:13of becoming like black hat hackers and also because they're
- 3:16effectively working for the company to find vulnerabilities,
- 3:20would you say that's a fair explanation?
- 3:23I would have some number of minor quibbles with, with the
- 3:26way you. Wait it out, you know?
- 3:27Generally they're not the payments aren't.
- 3:29To prevent them from being black hats.
- 3:31Generally, the thinking is that these people, they want to be on
- 3:34the right side of the law and this just makes it less costly
- 3:37for them to make that choice. Yeah they're not at risk teens.
- 3:40Well, this need to be aware as in this case, they seem a little
- 3:43bit more. Yeah, at risk.
- 3:45I mean, the standard bug Bounty is for Uber was ten thousand
- 3:48dollars and in this case it was a ultimately a hundred thousand
- 3:52dollar payment, right? That's right.
- 3:54I'll just fast-forward to get the basic facts of the case and
- 3:57charges out there. They ultimately paid off.
- 4:00The hackers a hundred thousand dollars, they assured themselves
- 4:03that the data had been deleted and been distributed to others.
- 4:07And they had the hackers sign, an NDA saying they wouldn't talk
- 4:11about this and they're actually the wording of that NBA ones up
- 4:14later to be very important and then nobody knows about it until
- 4:18after Travis kalanick is gone. Well, I would say, nobody's many
- 4:21people. The company knew about it
- 4:23including Travis kalanick, whose then CEO Travis gets ousted in a
- 4:27boardroom coup after unrelated scan.
- 4:29Dalls new CEO comes in daraa and their codes were showing.
- 4:33Yeah, thank you for pronouncing that for me and Tony West is
- 4:37general counsel a lot, a lot of big figures and this sort of
- 4:41bubbles up again as a topic and there's a new investigation and
- 4:46then they basically decided to throw Joe to the Wolves but the
- 4:50charges were, for not for the payoff itself, but for what is
- 4:55called misprision of a felony, which is a rarely charge
- 4:59statute, that A crime. We all have strong intuitions
- 5:02and moral sensibilities of a like I barely know what it is.
- 5:05Yeah, I did have to go to Google Translate to make sure I
- 5:08pronounced it correctly. It's misprision, this
- 5:10presentation. There you go.
- 5:12So it is, it is not only failing to report a felony but actively
- 5:16concealing one like taking an affirmative actions to prevent a
- 5:19felony from coming to light. And he's also charged with
- 5:22obstruction of justice because there was an FTC investigation
- 5:27of previous breaches that Uber, that was wrapping up.
- 5:29And this was, I guess, pointedly not disclosed to them when it
- 5:33should have been according to prosecutors.
- 5:34Those are the charges, right? And he is being fired from Uber.
- 5:37That was a story in and of itself, right?
- 5:39And there was controversy at the time around, why he was fired
- 5:42and the nature of it but the he could have been fired and not
- 5:46been charged with the crime here, right?
- 5:48These are almost unrelated incidences correct.
- 5:51I wouldn't say they're unrelated.
- 5:52So his firing was controversial within the company.
- 5:56He was not seen as one of the most employees.
- 5:59Not see him as one of Travis's, like, you know, Ki Hench people.
- 6:04You know, he was seen as one of the, you know, the more recent
- 6:07hires and grownups, you know, he hadn't been implicated in a lot
- 6:11of the other sketchy stuff that over was involved in.
- 6:14And then it's not just that he was, you know, he wasn't charged
- 6:18randomly, the Uber folks, that remained worked hand-in-glove
- 6:22with the US, attorney's office to charge Joe.
- 6:25And, you know, they walk them through the whole thing.
- 6:28They built a lot of the case. Case.
- 6:30And then, you know, quite another obvious suspect would
- 6:34have. Been the lawyer who is working
- 6:36under Joe Craig Clark. And Craig Clark was so nervous
- 6:40about all of this that he got immunity from the feds in order
- 6:43to testify against Joe and Joe and turn had blamed like some of
- 6:47this on the legal advice he got from Craig.
- 6:50So, it is weird. That Joe is not only charged
- 6:54with this very unusual crime, at least one of them, but that he
- 6:59The only person from Uber that has been convicted of anything
- 7:02as far as I know, an executive ranks, despite all the other
- 7:06stuff that was going on there. And that he was the only one
- 7:08that was taken down for this particular thing, when the CEO
- 7:11and others were involved, and let's just do a little bit of
- 7:13background on Joe, because we should definitely set up for our
- 7:17audience. That this is a fairly
- 7:18well-established. Well-regarded person in the
- 7:21cybersecurity industry. I mean, what was his background
- 7:23before, you know, taking on this position of uber.
- 7:26So he was actually a federal prosecutor back in the day.
- 7:29And he was one of the early enthusiasts about developing
- 7:34cybercrime as expertise. So in fact, he was, he worked in
- 7:40a couple of different offices but in in the San Francisco us,
- 7:43attorney's office, which later prosecuted him he helped set up.
- 7:47It was a, you know, initial member of their cyber team and
- 7:50then he, you know, like Manny he left public service to make some
- 7:54decent money and he went to Facebook where he was in the
- 7:58earlier phases. Facebook, he was the chief
- 8:02security officer there, you know, as was sort of well known
- 8:06in the field from that point on because Facebook was the subject
- 8:09of a lot of attacks. A lot of attention and, you
- 8:12know, he did a lot of things that are now, serve industry
- 8:14standard practice, including, you know, red teaming, you know,
- 8:18hiring people to attack the company to see how they did and
- 8:21they also paid bug bounties and stuff like that.
- 8:23So he went he was there and then he went to cloudflare, which is
- 8:27maybe, you know, arguably more interesting because good for him
- 8:30because lots of international stuff, terrorists to have all
- 8:33kinds of really sketchy. People use cloudflare.
- 8:35So it's really interesting from like an intelligence
- 8:39perspective, as well as a law enforcement and and Guard Riders
- 8:42security perspective. And also Cloud fairs like a
- 8:44security company. So he was playing a more Central
- 8:47role there after Uber, right? Just I'm sorry yes, I skip to
- 8:50know because I mean he's hired a doober in 2015 and then
- 8:55basically hours and after really bad reach, okay?
- 8:58After a bad dream. Right.
- 9:00And then out stood in November 2017 and so yeah, he's not sort
- 9:04of the super early days Travis, but he's there for some of the
- 9:09core sort of Travis years and ands when those years come, to
- 9:14an end. Yeah.
- 9:15Well and and Joseph was characterized this a little bit
- 9:18but you know Eric from just covering Uber, so intensely
- 9:20during that period. How does he kind of fit into
- 9:23that the Travis hierarchy? I mean, he's not a founding guy,
- 9:25he's not one of his, you know, one of his guys who builds the
- 9:28app but he is A key player in the scaling of the service.
- 9:32Right? And ensuring that it remains at
- 9:34least for a Time free of major, breaches of data.
- 9:37And you know, the kinds of things you would need for an app
- 9:40that is catering to millions and millions of people, right?
- 9:42I mean I certainly a lot of people agree with the idea that
- 9:47it's crazy, that all of all the executives at Uber who have
- 9:51gotten convicted of something, it's Joe Sullivan who I do
- 9:54think, as a former prosecutor was seen, as sort of a stand-up
- 9:58guy and definitely not. Some DieHard Uber Loyalists and
- 10:01definitely sort of a professional executive coming
- 10:05from Facebook, that said, you know, Joe Sullivan, you know is
- 10:09given some legal Authority at the company.
- 10:11I mean, part of this case, is there sort of a weirdness of the
- 10:16his Deputy reported up to him and not sort of the general, the
- 10:20overall legal officer, Joe Sullivan was also like
- 10:24responsible for some, I believe the physical surveillance that
- 10:27Hoover did including over like Jean Through their competitor.
- 10:30Well, it's not illegal. I don't think it.
- 10:32You know, he's involved in some of the sort of intense Travis
- 10:36are alike. We want to know like what's
- 10:38going on with our competitors. So, I don't totally agree with
- 10:42the idea that this is somebody who totally divorced himself
- 10:45from the aggressive behavior of uber during the Travis kalanick
- 10:50era and then sort of figuring this out, hack out fits into the
- 10:54sort of Travis strategy of, you know, one might say like,
- 10:57creative problem solving when I Comes to navigating trouble and
- 11:02a sort of legal, gray areas. Yeah, well, let's get to the
- 11:05case itself because as you say, there is a bit of a Divergence
- 11:09between the bug Bounty program and you know, the way you sort
- 11:13of deal with white hat hacking and what the government actually
- 11:15was charging him with. So why is it that the FTC is
- 11:19even investigating Uber during this period?
- 11:22And what are the actions that Joe took that ended up, you
- 11:24know, getting him charged with a crime?
- 11:27Well, there was a, there was a massive Beach in in 2014 that
- 11:30was kind of similar. It was like a great a great
- 11:32spill of user data. And so the FTC was investigating
- 11:37and it was going to, you know, come up with you know, various
- 11:40sort of consent decree type stuff where they have to agree
- 11:43to do some basic Good Housekeeping in terms of real
- 11:47security for that stock and it was near the end of that
- 11:50investigation is is one of the sort of the irony is here there.
- 11:54They, you know, they were still asking questions but we are on I
- 11:58think the fifth or sixth. Six round of questions that the
- 12:02FTC had sent over before this happens.
- 12:05And before Joe gets in trouble, they go to another attorney.
- 12:09The Privacy attorney they had, they had a privacy, a tuber, and
- 12:14she is somebody who is being kept, roughly in the loop about
- 12:17this breach by Craig Clark. So, Craig Clark, had a dotted
- 12:21line to, you know, the general counsel's office.
- 12:24It is true that Joe was, Deputy general counsel, but he didn't
- 12:27sort of caucus with the legal department.
- 12:29He Have meetings with the legal debate.
- 12:31Does that make it even sketchier?
- 12:33Why? Then he's Deputy general counsel
- 12:35but he's not sort of looped into that hierarchy.
- 12:38I don't know better being sketch here.
- 12:40I think they're, you know, it's a nice title to have.
- 12:43It may have been a little advised and in retrospect but he
- 12:45wasn't I think he wanted authority to do certain things
- 12:50and you know Uber as you know from covering the company was
- 12:53super siloed. You know, there is exactly.
- 12:55Yeah. I think he wanted to have to
- 12:58exercise some Or over over things that he couldn't without
- 13:01that title, right? But it is clear that there that
- 13:05the Craig, you know, did blow the whistle on other things.
- 13:10A lot has been made of the fact that, you know, he was reporting
- 13:12to Joe, but he also, he also told his success of privacy
- 13:18bosses in the general, counsel's office about what was going on
- 13:21with this case and those and the and those were the people that
- 13:24were answering the FTC questions.
- 13:27There was some emails that was in there.
- 13:29Couple emails introduced as evidence that asked, Joe to look
- 13:33over some stuff and say, you know, is this, right?
- 13:35Even your problem with this. And one of those answers out of
- 13:39the long series of answers was there haven't been any bad
- 13:42breaches, you know, since that or something like that.
- 13:44And that's what he got in trouble for not flagging, but it
- 13:48wasn't like the strongest it. You know, it wasn't the
- 13:50strongest evidence in the world. I think there was more problems
- 13:53with the wording of the ndaa, which said that in order to get
- 13:57this hundred thousand dollar check, They said or maybe was
- 14:01Bitcoin. They said the statement said we
- 14:04have not taken or capped any data from Uber as part of our as
- 14:09part of our Explorations and they have lost that was false
- 14:13because they had. So the jury you know the lawyers
- 14:16in the case got into like who did the edits on that NDA and
- 14:21Joe did some edits but did not that one.
- 14:24So the prosecutors were arguing that even though Craig Clarke
- 14:26was the one who had put in those words, Joe should have.
- 14:29Edited that and maybe he was like the brains behind that ad.
- 14:33I mean it is thin. I mean is it is really thin.
- 14:36It seems like there was a lot of judgment call in this, you know,
- 14:39by interpretation by the by the feds and by the jury but when
- 14:43dark comes in and ask Joe about this, Joe doesn't tell Dora all
- 14:49the details of the case. Correct.
- 14:51So there is an email in early email where Joe briefs dhara.
- 14:57The okay. There was an incident or
- 14:58handling it this way. And that email was fairly
- 15:01circumstance act and he tasked his people to brief him.
- 15:05And one of his people had sent an email saying, well, we
- 15:08basically got extorted and, you know, it was terrible.
- 15:11And then Joe gives Dara pretty sanitized version of what it
- 15:16doesn't include the amount of money calls it a bug Bounty,
- 15:19right? Yeah.
- 15:20And all Uber's bug bounties before this, like 10,000 was the
- 15:24max, this was 100,000, these people downloaded the files,
- 15:28normal bug bounties, you Don't download the I'm sorry, but I'm
- 15:31just like, I think there's an interesting discussion in this
- 15:34comes in through your story. Definitely like now we're in
- 15:37this era, where everybody's paying for things.
- 15:40Would we leave you this in the same light?
- 15:43I get, I get that point. I'm happy to have that
- 15:45discussion, but the idea that this was a Hack That Was Then
- 15:49tried to frame during a bug Bounty during a time when Uber
- 15:53was in trouble with the FTC and negotiating with them, to make
- 15:56sure that this didn't fit in to the kind of breach that they
- 15:59would need to. This close to the FTC.
- 16:01It just seems like a pretty compelling case to me and and
- 16:05now the jury jury has convicted them.
- 16:07And I still think that like the tone from sort of cybersecurity
- 16:11world is like shocked that there would be convictions here.
- 16:15Let's get to that in a second because I want to understand in
- 16:18the in the in the course of the case here, what was the
- 16:21characterization that the prosecution had of why Joe would
- 16:24do that? Why Joe would, you know, keep
- 16:26this from dhara in a way that you know, they do?
- 16:29Defined as criminal as misprision and obstruction of
- 16:32justice. I mean Joe is a tenured security
- 16:34officer used to be, you know, with the US attorney's and what
- 16:38was the kind of depiction at the prosecution had on why someone
- 16:41would do this. They were arguing that he was
- 16:43acting out of embarrassment that he didn't want is reputation as
- 16:48you know a very respected member of the security defense security
- 16:52world to be torn asunder because he allowed this terrible Beach
- 16:56to happen on his watch. I personally I think that holds
- 17:00water, there's all the internal traffic about the matter.
- 17:04It shows that for quite a while. While they were working on, this
- 17:09Joe is saying we don't know whether this is going to be
- 17:11something, we have to disclose or not.
- 17:13We don't know whether we can call it a bug Bounty and pay
- 17:17some money and have it go away or we'll have to disclose it.
- 17:20But that was certainly something that they were, you know, they
- 17:23saw as a major possibility. The reason they didn't in the
- 17:26end was that they were convinced that the Data hadn't gone,
- 17:30beyond these couple Packers, and the couple of hackers, which
- 17:33them, no harm. That is not something that would
- 17:36normally be charged from one. That might be a big screw up
- 17:39and, you know, maybe he gets personally barred by the FTC,
- 17:42from serving on company boards or something or another, maybe
- 17:45they, you know, but it's just that is just a real outlier.
- 17:49It's a criminal offense. I mean, I'll meet you, not out
- 17:51of your story and, you know, better than I do.
- 17:53And I'm interested in especially is like this idea that were the
- 17:57prosecutors trying to get him. To flip on Travis kalanick
- 18:01bizarre can be sort of a double situation here where Joe gets
- 18:04defended, because he wasn't the CEO.
- 18:06He was at Sea. So on the other hand, why if the
- 18:10issue is that everything should run up to the CEO, why didn't
- 18:14Joe flip on Travis here? Because so the evidence, so they
- 18:18were trying to get to Travis who would have been a big feather in
- 18:21any us attorney's cap and they did get evidence from Joe on
- 18:25that and that, that evidence was actually a fairly substantial
- 18:28there, you know. Lots of texts and foot and phone
- 18:31calls and conversations and Travis said things like, yes,
- 18:35the this be great. If it's a bug Bounty, but there
- 18:38wasn't a direct cover this stuff up.
- 18:41Don't let the FTC find out about there.
- 18:43Wasn't a smoking God. So there was a bigger paper
- 18:46trail on Joe, because he was kind of in the middle of it.
- 18:50The whole time, it's weird to call this a cover-up when there
- 18:54were like, you know, I would forget the something, like, 30
- 18:56people who know about it. This was not a, you know, Go
- 18:59meet you take some cash, you know and and meet somebody in a
- 19:02back alley with a briefcase, right?
- 19:04You know they work through the bug Bounty platform, you know
- 19:07hacker one the communications team up to Rachel, Whetstone
- 19:12knew the facts of the case within 24 hours.
- 19:15She's the chief Communications officer for Uber right time,
- 19:17right? And so she did Travis, did I
- 19:21meet Joe told everybody he was supposed to tell?
- 19:25So I mean talk to Travis whether or not to, you know, you okay.
- 19:27Make sure you coordinate with the general counsel in that he
- 19:29Didn't say that including that this stuff had been downloaded
- 19:32by the hackers and that was basically acts and everyone, in
- 19:35time to recover it, they were going to try going to try and
- 19:38suppress it and that's another thing.
- 19:39It's like it's not, you know that NBA is pretty shady but
- 19:44they were using this whole process to identify who these
- 19:46people were because they were Anonymous.
- 19:48When all this started and they stayed Anonymous to a lot of it
- 19:52and because they were getting them to sign things and if they
- 19:54did it with an electronic signature, it would leave their
- 19:57IP address and then be able to track them.
- 19:59They did that. And then they surprised they
- 20:01surprised them by showing up in person and saying now we need
- 20:03your real names to sign this or the banks, not gonna let go, you
- 20:06know, there they'll flag the idea of the IRS.
- 20:09And so, that's really important. And they did that not because
- 20:11they want to get these kids arrested.
- 20:13That's true. But because they figured that
- 20:16that was the only way to reassure themselves.
- 20:18That these guys really aren't going to do something worse with
- 20:20the data and there. They basically get these hackers
- 20:22to say, oh, you were like working on behalf of uber,
- 20:25basically, right? Isn't that part of the agreement
- 20:27or my misunderstanding that Well, I mean part of the bug
- 20:30Bounty program is like they were reporting a vulnerability and
- 20:34thanks for that. And here's your reward, right?
- 20:36And you know, 100 K is a lot of money.
- 20:39Sure. Not for Uber though.
- 20:40It's not a problem over and for the amount of damage that could
- 20:44have been done with that data. That's, that's actually a pretty
- 20:47reasonable. I'm certainly not saying it's a
- 20:48bad corporate decision. I'm just saying, you know, their
- 20:51moves, there are fun. Things Dara said, later there
- 20:53are different stories, you know, between when he was fired and
- 20:56now, but Dara said like Daris Most recent version, was he
- 21:02fired him because that one he couldn't trust.
- 21:04Joe Sullivan after that email that under, you know, that
- 21:07underplayed the breach. But that he would have made the
- 21:10same payment himself that, that was an appropriate payment.
- 21:13So, I mean, it looks to me like, they were looking for, you know,
- 21:16the feds were hoping to get to Travis and missed and, you know,
- 21:20Dara wants Uber 2.0. He doesn't want any trace of bad
- 21:24Stars allowed to fire. He's allowed to fire people.
- 21:26I do. I agree with what Tom said, not
- 21:29not And I understand that you burst sort of help this case,
- 21:31but they're allowed to like fire.
- 21:32Somebody who feels like I'm trying to clean up the company
- 21:35and you're not being open about everything that's happening.
- 21:39I get that. Yeah, they announced this hack.
- 21:41They have two people in my story that they're firing over it,
- 21:44Craig Clark and Joe Sullivan and they say, okay, we're cleaning
- 21:47house. But like yeah, I mean the they
- 21:50were the people who did it and our had to like a different
- 21:52point of view on whether needed to be disclosed to the
- 21:55government. I mean, is that and then they
- 21:58did settle with all these State governments, they paid more than
- 22:01100 million in fines to State AG's.
- 22:03And now there are two convictions and also, we haven't
- 22:05brought up the fact that the hackers themselves, who got who
- 22:08participate in the bug Bounty? I believe, they also pled guilty
- 22:11in this case, so if the, if the legal system works at all every
- 22:14part of it settlements jury convictions hackers, pleading
- 22:18like every part of it has come down on one side of this.
- 22:22Sorry that was more passionate than I expected to be.
- 22:24But I don't know II feel a little crazy on it.
- 22:27It's like this this has been borne out.
- 22:29Out. Well can I ask you know, when it
- 22:31comes to the state of uber and the way they win Vault were
- 22:34involved in this case because technically this is not their
- 22:36case. They're not suing him.
- 22:38This is the US government that is making the case here.
- 22:41Dhara testifies here. He testifies to the fact that he
- 22:44just couldn't trust Joe anymore, why he fired him and I guess
- 22:48people below him why does the either prosecution or defense?
- 22:51And I imagine it might have been the defense never subpoena.
- 22:55Travis, why do you think Travis never appears at all in the
- 22:58trial? It seemed like he Have been a
- 22:59key person to kind of make the case, one way or the other as to
- 23:03whether or not this was a cover-up or how many people
- 23:05should have known about this? Did that ever come up in
- 23:07discussion? Like, strategically why?
- 23:09He never appeared at all? I'm sure did, I don't know, I
- 23:12wasn't privy to those discussions.
- 23:14I don't know why. Yeah, if I were Travis, if I did
- 23:17get subpoenaed by other side, I would have asked for immunity
- 23:19and the FEDS, you know, that's probably not a good look for
- 23:23them, so they probably wouldn't have offered it.
- 23:25So probably he would have been like a hostile witness for
- 23:28either side. Side.
- 23:29We could plead the fifth, right? I mean he could plead the fifth,
- 23:32which is not going to help the defense or the prosecution and
- 23:36it's not going to make him look good either.
- 23:38So I mean, it would be you dragging him in there and then
- 23:40it wouldn't be productive. That's my best.
- 23:42Guess off the top, my head interesting.
- 23:44I mean, I do think there's I was going to say this earlier but
- 23:47you know, I feel like there's a classic human story where
- 23:50somebody is sort of, you know, the do-gooder Boy Scout and then
- 23:53they get sort of dragged into this somewhat sort of shady
- 23:58organization with No, the leader, who's trying to sort of
- 24:01complicate things, and yeah, the sort of ethical boundaries get
- 24:06tested. And then the sort of clean guy
- 24:09ends up the one, you know, because they made the call and
- 24:12sup, the one on the hook even though the architect of it, all
- 24:16probably set the organization up in that direction.
- 24:18Pushed people to behave in that way.
- 24:20But then knew better than to, you know, put their name to it.
- 24:23I feel like that's like sort of a classic classic story where
- 24:27it's like, yeah, if you want to be, Sort of the Boy Scout.
- 24:31You have to stick to your principles.
- 24:32Even this Mucky organization. So I think that's a little too
- 24:36Pat, but as I wrote, my story, bug bounties have been used to
- 24:40hide a host of ills increasingly significant time this happened.
- 24:44So they get used to pay respectable hackers who are
- 24:48trying to do the right thing. And they also get, they pay
- 24:53people to shut the hell up, right?
- 24:55They, they you know, they are as likely as not to come with
- 24:58non-disclosure agreement. Now and some of those apply to
- 25:02things that, you know, the company should be required to
- 25:04disclose and are not and are not disclosing, not just something
- 25:08they're not fixing but like beaches that are you know,
- 25:10things that probably led to previous breaches.
- 25:13It's the real, the real world in this stuff is pretty ugly,
- 25:16right? My guess is.
- 25:17The Joe thought he was Skating close to the edge, but it wound
- 25:20up doing the, you know, the right thing by.
- 25:23You can make a really good argument that he was doing the
- 25:26right thing by Uber users because They went through all
- 25:30these hoops, there were some shady language.
- 25:33There's some stuff that should have been disclosed but the data
- 25:36didn't get out. And if he'd and if they had
- 25:38called the feds on these guys, the day, they very well might
- 25:41have gotten now. Yeah.
- 25:42And I think nobody here is like, oh my God, the public was so
- 25:45terribly victimized this cry. You know.
- 25:48Yeah. Yeah.
- 25:48I mean it's very much did he follow the letter of some law?
- 25:52Not did he have some terrible effect for a bunch of drivers or
- 25:56people? It seems like exactly.
- 25:57Like you're saying, I think that's important.
- 25:59You remember, right? Right.
- 26:00Yeah. Well, that's what's interesting
- 26:02about this case because, you know, you obviously covered it
- 26:04and that's how I was Googling it.
- 26:06I did see that almost every major Outlet did have some
- 26:08reportage of it as it was going along, but the trial didn't set
- 26:12the world on fire, you know, it didn't become the Elizabeth
- 26:14Holmes trial or think of any other high-level Tech trials.
- 26:18Well, nobody seen this guy's the embodiment of Travis kalanick
- 26:21Arrow, who Burr. I mean, I think that's, you
- 26:22know, it didn't become a proxy for that and write morally
- 26:26ambiguous. And right, right, it did sort of
- 26:29Like this was you know the government's attempt to bring
- 26:32some accountability to Travis era Uber and like we're saying
- 26:36it ended up falling on this one you know prior to this point
- 26:39pretty clean actor in the infosec community and you know
- 26:43it sounds like the government made a compelling case here that
- 26:46he was a bad actor in this particular way here but the
- 26:48actual harm to you know the average citizenry just wasn't
- 26:54there. So I mean is it fair to say
- 26:56that? He is kind of a Fall Guy for a
- 26:58larger issue. You that, you know, he wasn't a
- 27:00solely responsible for but, you know, there had to be some head
- 27:03on a stake somewhere. As far as the government was
- 27:05concerned, in terms of charging him at night, I think the answer
- 27:09is yes and, you know, I don't think they were taking into
- 27:12account. I mean, they I think they were
- 27:14trying to make an example of him in, like uber land, but I don't,
- 27:19I think they may be less than thrilled about the example,
- 27:22they're sitting in Chief security officer land where
- 27:25people are freaking out and are you know, worrying if they what
- 27:28their own life Ability is, I mean, it's already like
- 27:30famously. One of the worst jobs on the
- 27:32planet. I mean, Alex Stamos used to joke
- 27:35that like to. So comes from a Greek word,
- 27:38meaning, he who has sacrificed after a breach, Alex Davis,
- 27:43former Chief security officer at Facebook, I guess.
- 27:47Yeah, that's a great line. I mean, it's, you know, it's up
- 27:49there with Russian Submariner and Chinese coal miner, you
- 27:52don't want to be C. So even before this, I mean you,
- 27:55you know, there's like you only get famous if you fail, right?
- 27:59You can Also make the argument and I've covered the security
- 28:01industry for more than 20 years now and like you know the most
- 28:04important person in chart in for a company's security is a CEO.
- 28:10It's not the Seesaw and the second most important is the CFO
- 28:13right? Because he's deciding how he or
- 28:15she or deciding how much you can spend on defense which is like
- 28:20you know make stuff from the bottom line disappear and super
- 28:24hard to Value what gain you get from it.
- 28:27So you know many people Are in the position of, you know,
- 28:31Twitter comes to mind mudgett Twitter, where you give this
- 28:33awesome responsibility and no actual power.
- 28:36It needs to be like a cultural thing because, you know, every
- 28:40everybody else narrow zation has to play ball.
- 28:42They didn't add Twitter and they didn't it.
- 28:44Over the infosec community of, as you said they were watching
- 28:47this case, very closely, they obviously are not happy with the
- 28:50outcome, in terms of making the job, even more of a liability
- 28:54for the people who do it, but was there any sense from it
- 28:57among the infosec community that No Joe didn't, maybe handle this
- 29:01in the best possible way. And there was some sloppiness in
- 29:04the writing of the ndaa. The the correspondence he had
- 29:06with the people above him that maybe someone who tell the RTC
- 29:10if you're in a negotiation with them if you have other skeletons
- 29:12in your closet. Like I mean, yeah.
- 29:14Clearly what the government wants.
- 29:16You're right? Yeah, I guess my.
- 29:17Yeah. The question is is we're, was
- 29:18there a sense of it of saying? Yes.
- 29:21Overall, he did the right thing except for in the very specific
- 29:23ways of the government nailed him and if he were just a little
- 29:26more careful here he could have been well clear.
- 29:29Or they put this in a Layman way, it's like, no reporter
- 29:32wants your reporter convicted, right?
- 29:33Reporters always cheer for like, Free Press cases.
- 29:37But then sometimes there are particulars of them and like
- 29:39some, you know, you're like, well, Gawker maybe shouldn't
- 29:42have published like a terrible sex, you know.
- 29:45It's like, okay, I understand why Cecil would always say don't
- 29:47convict to see so journalists never want to see journalists
- 29:50convicted, but then these things get decided in the fact
- 29:52patterns. And like, yeah, I guess is
- 29:55they're sort of a fact pattern that can separate this from what
- 29:59Says are doing a sort of day-to-day.
- 30:02So first of all, I would say that there are some instances
- 30:04where I think people reporter should get sued for libel and
- 30:07lose. Hi, I'm not going to defend
- 30:09every single member of my profession.
- 30:12I think I could defend half of them.
- 30:14So I think the majority feeling among Chief security officers is
- 30:19that Joe got a really bad deal. And I again, I mean there's a
- 30:22lot of evidence on both sides here, but one of the things that
- 30:24came out is they Joe was never accused of Joe was was grilled
- 30:28by the FTC and he I was never accused of lying to the FTC
- 30:31they, you know, it was a sin of omission where somebody else was
- 30:35sending in the thing. And one of them bajillion emails
- 30:37that Joe was supposed to read, but miss Priss prison can
- 30:40include not Omission, right? It isn't an Omission has to be
- 30:45an active thing, but it doesn't. It doesn't have to be a direct
- 30:48lie. Like you can.
- 30:49That's correct. Right.
- 30:50That's correct, right? But you know, like I said, this
- 30:52is not, this is not a slam-dunk case and the jury struggled for
- 30:55four days Right Stuff. Mmm, most cheap security.
- 30:59Sir Chief information security, officers are deeply unhappy
- 31:03about this. They're used to being
- 31:04scapegoated by their own companies and now they have to
- 31:08worry about being scapegoated by the feds and you know, in some
- 31:11cases in collusion with their companies.
- 31:14They you know it's not just that era fire damage that you know,
- 31:17Dara had him frog marched into the US, attorney's office.
- 31:20I mean the hack was never like a core Uber Scandal, that's part
- 31:24of what's bizarre about this whole thing.
- 31:26It was sort of like a trailing end thing.
- 31:29I mean, my understanding is this, Uber hack was like
- 31:31disclosed and like one of the Whistleblower they had like some
- 31:35security officer at Uber like sent a letter like seemingly.
- 31:40I think shaking them for money and then so then this hack was
- 31:43in that and so then there becomes more of a likelihood
- 31:46that it comes out, you know, but it was my point is just sort of
- 31:49a tail end Scandal. So it is sort of absurd that
- 31:52this would be sort of the most litigated Travis conviction.
- 31:57Yeah. I mean, it's like it's not even
- 31:58getting Al On income tax evasion, it's like getting a
- 32:01third-tier goon on Al cabone Squad charged with a crime.
- 32:05And that goon actually happened to have been a pretty clean guy
- 32:07up to that point. It just sounded like he did
- 32:10potentially or, I guess as the law said, you know, break it in
- 32:13the very particular way in which he was charged.
- 32:15I mean, it is, it is bizarre. I agree with you.
- 32:17There is another Uber executive, who has pled guilty to
- 32:21something, though, not for his activity.
- 32:25I think a tuber necessary, Anthony Lewandowski, of course.
- 32:29Of course, LED guilty for stealing Trade Secrets and then
- 32:32was pardoned by President Trump. I feel like that whole news
- 32:36cycle, got totally washed away because like it was at the end
- 32:39of the Trump presidency and then January 6th happened.
- 32:41But Anthony Lewandowski, you know, the whole way mogai plead
- 32:45guilty and then was pardoned by Trump.
- 32:47So, I think, you know, I, somebody was laughing to me, an
- 32:50Uber, former, Uber exact was like, you know, are we going to
- 32:53get another pardon for, you know, it's a sorry jokes about
- 32:57Joe, but yeah. Well, Joe Biden.
- 32:59You know, step up here, I mean, what is the expectation in terms
- 33:02of a sentencing for this kind of a, you know crime?
- 33:05So I mean, in theory could get up to eight years, you know?
- 33:09I don't know if they're mandatory minimums, I, you know,
- 33:11or what the accepted range is, you know, he didn't help them by
- 33:16testifying against anybody else. The real answer is, I don't
- 33:20know, you know, and I don't normally cover criminal trials,
- 33:23so you know, maybe he gets maybe he gets a couple years and maybe
- 33:28it's Station or something, but it would be deeply unpleasant
- 33:33for anybody, but he's a former Federal prosecutor.
- 33:35So to put them in a federal jail with people that he has jailed,
- 33:38or would have, you know? That's that's that's not cool.
- 33:42So I'm guessing he would be segregated somehow.
- 33:45Yes, cyber jail. Jesus.
- 33:46Did he's a former Federal prosecutor.
- 33:48I mean I you have to Imagine That animated.
- 33:50The prosecutor is somewhat that this of all people who should be
- 33:53sort of the letter of the law. Yes.
- 33:56And they argued that here is here's one guy who does know
- 33:58what Miss prism Of the felonies, right?
- 34:00The only only person in the Cordia, what sort of precedent
- 34:04do you think the government was trying to set with this case
- 34:07here? Because it is like we've said,
- 34:09multiple times a bit of a tangential crime when it comes
- 34:11to Uber itself or even the broader like hack Community.
- 34:15I don't even think it's the most interesting hack I've heard of
- 34:17in the last like Year let alone five to 10 years.
- 34:20I mean if you were to look at what kind of outcome broadly
- 34:25that the government was trying to get from this, you know
- 34:27Lessons Learned. What would you say it is?
- 34:29Is, you know the most check most charitably?
- 34:32I would say that they're trying to send a message that just
- 34:35because the CEO is a cowboy doesn't excuse you, from doing
- 34:40what the cowboy wants at the expense of the law.
- 34:44I guess you could also say that, you know, reaches are bigger
- 34:48deal than they used to be security, is a bigger deal than
- 34:51it used to be. There's all kinds of National
- 34:53Security implications, you know, we, the US has sanctioned
- 34:57ransomware groups that Too close to the Russian government.
- 35:01You don't they don't they would rather those people not get paid
- 35:04off in fact, that's one of the few ways you do get in trouble,
- 35:06is if you send a ransom payment to one of these sanctions
- 35:09groups, you know, so maybe everybody shoot is just has to
- 35:13be on their toes. More about how they treat
- 35:15beaches including the disclosure aspect.
- 35:17Can I ask any part of the purpose of this show is we try
- 35:20to go a bit behind the scenes of the reporting of Stories on the
- 35:23relationship that reporters have with the company.
- 35:25I mean, this is an interesting case of, you know, Uber is
- 35:29obviously a key material presence within this trial.
- 35:33They're obviously providing evidence that is very useful for
- 35:36the prosecution here, but you know what?
- 35:38Sort of, you know, information interference?
- 35:40Did you sort of get from Uber as you were doing the story in
- 35:44terms of, you know, trying to encourage a specific point of
- 35:47view? I mean, how much were they
- 35:48trying to influence the coverage of this case in any way?
- 35:51Because I think it's look transparently.
- 35:54I've seen it a lot. Uber is very interested in the
- 35:56story, but I'd be interested in seeing from your perspective.
- 35:59What? I didn't have much interaction
- 36:00with them, you know, in the end stages of this, when they fire
- 36:05Joe, it was weird that they did not go to any security
- 36:10reporters. They went to an overview of
- 36:13where they want to lose her. Well, I mean, I think that they
- 36:17were spinning hard when they fired him that like they here's
- 36:21the root of all of our problems. We did a big investigation and
- 36:25we found this horrible stuff. Mean, there's a lot of nuance.
- 36:29I hear ya. They don't say the bug Bounty.
- 36:31I mean, they go on the record about the story.
- 36:33It's not like they like, you know, I think I quoted dhara in
- 36:37this story. They don't talk about the bug
- 36:38Bounty. They certainly talked about this
- 36:41size of the breach. I mean, it's true, Uber paid
- 36:44hackers to delete stolen data on 57 million people company paid
- 36:47hackers, 100,000, delete info, keep quiet, right?
- 36:50But this is again, this is the difference between, you know,
- 36:53his being fired and the actual case, I mean you would think
- 36:56Uber at this point, this is something that happened in the
- 36:58past. They would Care as much about,
- 37:00you know, let the law and and, you know, the legal system, take
- 37:04its course. It's interesting to me Joseph
- 37:06that they actually were not that kind of involved at all in your
- 37:09coverage and and pushing You One Direction or another.
- 37:11Well, at this point there's this copious public record to.
- 37:13So, that's, you know, when people are testifying under
- 37:16oath, I find that a lot more convincing than what people are
- 37:19saying, outside of Court. Yeah, let's broaden this out a
- 37:22bit because I've said, you know, there are broader implications
- 37:25here. So you were saying that, you
- 37:27know, in the sea so Community this verdict Was met with kind
- 37:30of Terror that they felt. They've already taken one of the
- 37:32worst jobs in the world and made it even worse.
- 37:35I mean, anything more to that aspect.
- 37:37I mean, what do you see in terms of outcomes from, you know,
- 37:40getting a, you know, a sea. So, on the hook for what, some
- 37:45people in, the community would view is fairly standard, so I'll
- 37:48give you one tangible thing in one less tangible thing.
- 37:51The tangible thing is that csos are looking for personal lawyers
- 37:56to advise them on what their Would be for any feelings on the
- 38:01job. The less tangible thing, which I
- 38:04think is dangerous, is that Cecil's will now be much more
- 38:07likely to go. Go, the mud drought, and blow
- 38:09the whistle and call in the feds by whatever.
- 38:13You know, legal means stage can. So they're not risking anything
- 38:17which is, you know, a real harsh gambled to take one and so on.
- 38:22But that will make them seen internally as like Internal
- 38:26Affairs officers as this as cops.
- 38:29Soooo. And that may mean that people
- 38:31under them, with security responsibilities, keep things
- 38:35from them because they don't want that to get reported out
- 38:39and that's kind of a disaster. That's like, the thing where
- 38:41like, you know, in a police Internal Affairs unit, like, you
- 38:45know, they're gave him the cold shoulder by other officers
- 38:48because they're the ones hunting for cops.
- 38:50So that's miserable like, you know, like I said, you know,
- 38:53cisos got to have the culture on their side.
- 38:55They got to have the CEO, the CFO and other departments on.
- 38:59Side. And if they are now, if they
- 39:01become seen as someone that could rat you out, like a
- 39:04compliance officer, then that's a bad Dynamic that takes a tough
- 39:09Dynamic and makes it, let's, let's get rid of internal
- 39:11affairs suing. I don't know.
- 39:13I just don't see how a think, you know, these investigations
- 39:16being disclosed to the government is so bad.
- 39:19I mean, you know, there are lots, you know, they're plenty
- 39:21of SEC filings where, you know, a company says, you know, some
- 39:25hack happened and they happen too often.
- 39:28Is it that damning, the Company that it would be publicly
- 39:30announced generally, no, I mean, the stigma has gone away for
- 39:34most of this. They are starting with when
- 39:36Google said, you know, owned up to getting hacked by the
- 39:38Chinese. Nobody thinks that Google's a
- 39:39bunch of idiots. So, I mean, it is continued.
- 39:43We everybody gets hacked. The US government gets hacked,
- 39:46you know, there's, you know, the NSA has been badly hacked.
- 39:49I don't think disclosure is a bad thing.
- 39:50I'm in favor of disclosure. I'm in favor of more Force
- 39:53disclosure. I'm talking about like this,
- 39:56this unanticipated impact, which Could be under, which could be
- 40:00bad. Yeah, for a core security.
- 40:02And, you know, maybe we'll know more but security might not get
- 40:04much better. Do you think that this in a way
- 40:07is going to have a hugely deleterious effect on bug Bounty
- 40:10programs that companies will just back away from that as a
- 40:12whole because they see that it just skirts the line into an
- 40:16area that if the FTC for whatever reason wanted to
- 40:19prosecute someone for it. They could find a way to do it I
- 40:22think they're going to make bug Bounty programs more fraud.
- 40:24It's also true that some of them deserve to be more fraud that
- 40:28the you know, they are DNA. Oh, there are are there
- 40:30slathering makeup on a pig? Sometimes the you know the early
- 40:35bug Bounty programs were seen as part of a coordinated,
- 40:38vulnerability disclosure program, which is from the old
- 40:42days when a hacker says, hey you've got this problem.
- 40:45If you don't fix it, I'll go public.
- 40:47I'll give you 90 days or whatever it is the, which is
- 40:49what Google gives people when it finds a bad flaws and somebody
- 40:53else's program. That's kind of industry standard
- 40:56and then usually the company fixes it.
- 40:58But at this, Yes, that really a bug.
- 41:00It's a feature or, you know, it's not really urgent.
- 41:02We'll get around to it later. It's not that severe.
- 41:04Then the person goes public. The way bug Bounty programs have
- 41:08evolved. They get most of their money
- 41:10from the companies and they're seen by some companies as a way
- 41:14to control the hacking Community.
- 41:16Because if they don't, if they don't shut up and take the money
- 41:19then they don't get to participate in the in the bug
- 41:22Bounty program anymore and there's like, you know, two or
- 41:25three big bug Bounty platforms. And if you're not welcome on any
- 41:29a of them, then you're it's going to be much harder for you
- 41:31to make a living without selling your vulnerability information
- 41:34to governments or the private sector or brokers, who might
- 41:38flip it to somebody who flips and somebody flips it to.
- 41:40The Chinese is a very, very uncontrolled rolled out there
- 41:45and Bug bounties were one way to bring people towards the light
- 41:49and I'm afraid that if they are doing a lot less of that now
- 41:52than they could. Are you covering the whole by
- 41:54Nance hack? By the way?
- 41:55Or like I'm not in part, because there's so many crypto.
- 41:59Acts these days that, you know, you wouldn't do anything else
- 42:02and in part because in this particular case, there don't
- 42:05appear to be human victims, there were tokens that were
- 42:07lying around so it's not as bad as some of the others.
- 42:11Oh interesting. Just like 500 million just like
- 42:14on so yeah with it just created out of thin air.
- 42:17I guess if somebody gets their hands on it, right?
- 42:20That's fascinating, actually. What I mean have you written
- 42:22much about crypto hacks? I mean like you bring up, it's
- 42:24very difficult to, you know, discuss things in terms of human
- 42:27terms and they're so common, these days.
- 42:29Days. I mean, what's you know, in the,
- 42:30in the infosec community? What is the thinking on the
- 42:33security of your shit in the web three world?
- 42:37It's terrible. But you know, it's like the
- 42:41whole crypto stuff reminds me of 1999 when I was covering
- 42:44the.com, boom. And you know the stuff is absurd
- 42:47on its face. So like you know, how do I
- 42:50really want to devote my time to explaining, you know, how this
- 42:53particular one is a little more absurd than others or can I just
- 42:56let people figure that out for themselves and then, you know,
- 42:58go expose something that's you know, it's actually kind of
- 43:00hidden. It's just Anna said that.
- 43:02That's my general. Take on it.
- 43:04I'm interested in crypto as a as a means to launder money.
- 43:07I'm interested in it as like kind of the rocket fuel of the
- 43:11ransomware plague, and it's, you know, kind of interesting that,
- 43:14you know, North Korea and other unpleasant places are, you know,
- 43:18using it. The, it sort of monetizes pure
- 43:21hacking in a way that nothing else has.
- 43:24I mean, we're talking about like a bug, Bounty payments, are not
- 43:26enough to compete with what the NSA or somebody else is going to
- 43:30pay you for vulnerability information.
- 43:32What really, you know, you can also use that information to do
- 43:34that. Can yourself, right?
- 43:35And you can make a tidy sum of Of money.
- 43:37So I mean an enormous percentage of crypto that's floating
- 43:40around. There has been stolen from
- 43:42somebody else who have it at some point or another.
- 43:44I feel like the bug Bounty program in crypto is literally
- 43:47just you like taking the money and then saying, hey look, I
- 43:49just got a hundred thousand dollars of crypto coins because
- 43:52your stuff is so hackable, there's my bounce.
- 43:54And then they like pleat there. Like if you give us 90 percent
- 43:56back, we'll let you keep 10% of it.
- 43:59I just did want to talk about my book a little bit so yeah,
- 44:01absolutely, yeah. Because of some of these things
- 44:04go, you know, go back to it. So the people in the book were
- 44:07People that came up with coordinated Bonner, boy
- 44:09disclosure, you know, one of the people are quoted in my article.
- 44:12Katy Mercer has a net, these the people that did the coronation
- 44:17and not by coincidence or people who wrestled with ethical
- 44:20questions all the freaking time and, you know, being now, you
- 44:25know, I guess a better than this stop.
- 44:27One of the things I was trying to do was convey to newer people
- 44:31and security you know give them a set of shoulders to stand on.
- 44:34They can choose whichever one they want because they often
- 44:37Agreed with each other but to think about think about these
- 44:41sort of philosophical questions because now unlike before but
- 44:46it's a nice clean profession, where I can go to a nice college
- 44:48and get a nice job at a nice company, new Cyber things
- 44:51without ever having to think about.
- 44:53Are there some circumstances where you should break the law
- 44:56are there? You know what, if your your
- 44:58employer wants you to put in a backdoor?
- 45:00What do you do there and meet their fascinating ethical issues
- 45:04that come up every day and security and a It bothers me
- 45:08that people were like, 25 years old without any history of, you
- 45:12know, you know, playing in the gray areas.
- 45:16Are, you know, are more inclined to do what they're told.
- 45:18Then to figure out for themselves.
- 45:20What is ethical? Can you tell us a little bit
- 45:21about the cult of the dead cow? What is it?
- 45:23And how does it involve current gubernatorial candidate in
- 45:27Texas? They do Roark who was not the
- 45:30not the only politician to call for loosen marijuana laws like
- 45:35about. So yeah, I expose the better
- 45:36work it As a teen hacker, but it's not like what's funny is
- 45:39that his politics actually kind of match what he was doing back
- 45:42then. I mean he's like exposed for
- 45:44having like pushed for the things.
- 45:46He's like, you know, pushing force a politician.
- 45:49So it's a pretty clean exposure. You're like, Beto is just as
- 45:52cool as you thought, right? Step you want to take away our
- 45:55guns. A lot of people thought he was
- 45:58but well you know, I just thought he was a pretty white
- 46:00boy and then I read, this is the first and this is the most
- 46:02interesting thing I've heard of dryer.
- 46:04Yeah. He was sort of fake cool.
- 46:05And then it was like oh maybe is Is real.
- 46:08He was cooler back then he was like Kristin Cinema.
- 46:10There was the punk band Tunes, but yeah, but I digress.
- 46:13So the cult of the dead cow is the oldest hacking group that is
- 46:16so functional in the United States.
- 46:19It is also the most influential hacking group in the history of
- 46:22the United States. It was spawned in the 1980s in
- 46:25Texas by some bulletin board operators.
- 46:28And if you don't know what that is, you can ask your
- 46:31grandparents, they morphed several times, but we're always
- 46:34sort of at The Cutting Edge of hacking which makes them You're
- 46:37really interesting vehicle to talk about all these, you know,
- 46:40choices that were made and why they were made.
- 46:43If you came of age in the 80s, in the time of the movie War
- 46:47Games, you would know the cult of the dead cow through their
- 46:49funny frequently profane satiric text files which could be about
- 46:53anything and we're sometimes political and then because they
- 46:56were sort of like the cool kids in the hacking.
- 46:58Seen some people with actual hard, courts, sophistication and
- 47:03hacking through asked to, you know, we're invited to join and
- 47:07The Joint. So that includes people from The
- 47:09Loft, the Great. Boston hackerspace folks that
- 47:14testified before Congress in 1998.
- 47:16That any one of them could take down the internet in half an
- 47:19hour. So these technical people came
- 47:21on, and then in Def con, the great, you know, giant packing
- 47:25convention. That was sort of coming of age
- 47:27and getting really big in those years, The Cult of the dead cow
- 47:31through CDs into the crowd, the conveyed and back orifice, and
- 47:35then back off his 2000, which were Success of programs that
- 47:38would allow pretty much anybody to hack a Windows machine and
- 47:41that was certainly controversial at the time, but that help to
- 47:44get press, which helped put actual pressure on Microsoft, to
- 47:48fix things because Microsoft has Monopoly and was not being
- 47:50responsible. When people like the loch said,
- 47:53hey you have this major following the architecture.
- 47:55So they were like, they were pushing the envelope.
- 47:57A certain using the media to try and put pressure on these big
- 48:01pretty Untouchable software makers.
- 48:03And then they invented hacktivism they coined the term
- 48:06hacktivism Stay defined as security work in service of
- 48:09human rights which includes per International treaty the right
- 48:13to information. So they got sort of political in
- 48:17hacking terms and then more broadly they pushed or to
- 48:20include a browser because they were releasing their own, they
- 48:22were own browser for tour and they helped Inspire the citizen
- 48:26Lab at the Munk School of International Affairs at the
- 48:29University of Toronto. Then citizen lab are the world's
- 48:33greatest experts on tracking how government spy on their own
- 48:36people. They you know, if you know about
- 48:38the Pegasus spyware that the government's use on their own
- 48:42people. That's largely because the
- 48:43citizen lab and they do this all the time.
- 48:46Are they active today? The cult of the dead cow, they
- 48:48are they are. But they're, you know, they're
- 48:49grown-ups. They actually are, you know, you
- 48:52have some new members now, did you out them all?
- 48:54Or is it sort of secret? Or what's the level of like, we
- 48:56know who everybody is? So one of the supply isn't
- 49:00surprises in writing the book is that in the end, all of the core
- 49:04members through the history of the group agreed to let Use
- 49:07their real names, including people, you know, some had been
- 49:09added before. So Peters at Joe was a member
- 49:13most recently, famous for testifying in Congress about the
- 49:16security disaster. That is Twitter crew through who
- 49:19had been outed. He was a founder of a Vera code,
- 49:22which is a billion-dollar very important security company.
- 49:25Module, also ran darpa's cyber grant-making.
- 49:28So, these are very serious people, but many others had not
- 49:31been added including the founder of the group and b'etor warp,
- 49:34who is now running for governor. They're letting new People in
- 49:38there, how it was initiation or what it's all terribly secret.
- 49:41The one rule is, you cannot ask to join because that would make
- 49:44all their interactions unpleasant because everybody
- 49:46would ask to join. So you, it's kind of like, was
- 49:49it the best line I thought was when I added Bay do with
- 49:52anybody's permission? I didn't, you know, they were,
- 49:54they were ready? Lobster, beta loved it.
- 49:56I mean, that's, that's a I wouldn't, I wouldn't say bed.
- 49:59I loved it. You know, there were he got, he
- 50:01got in a world of pain because of, you know, hit the teenage
- 50:04not Amis, text files that he wrote, you know, So much with
- 50:08one of which is kind of misogynist and you know, another
- 50:11just, you know, seems naive like imagine a world without money
- 50:14was was was one of his whatever, nobody wants what they wrote
- 50:17when they were 16 to be, you know, published.
- 50:19And then if that's your real name when you're running for
- 50:21office, right? Again all this makes him sound
- 50:23more interesting than he is now, but that's a separate topic.
- 50:26So the others I think came forward in part because better
- 50:29was coming forward and they wanted to show solidarity
- 50:31because he had the most to lose. So the new members they have
- 50:34added, one of them has made a name for herself While fighting
- 50:37revenge porn, South get laws passed just helped get you know,
- 50:42some measure of Peace of Mind for some victims of revenge porn
- 50:46and is help. Press social media companies to
- 50:48do more policing for it and then there's another woman who is
- 50:51sort of helped stop harassers within the infosec community,
- 50:56you know which is you know a checkered group like any other
- 50:58industry. So it's actually kind of cool.
- 51:00One of the things on them is that they had very, very few
- 51:02women and also few minorities like a lot of hacking In the
- 51:071990s, the they did have some of each in fact better was the one
- 51:10that gender integrated because the dead cow.
- 51:14So I figure that counselors is he still skill?
- 51:16Like, could he hack anything today?
- 51:18So it was a different era. It was basically text files.
- 51:22He also did some other stuff, he did some more driving.
- 51:25He did use credit cards that did not strict strictly belong to
- 51:28him. And I would like to give a
- 51:30shout-out to the statute of limitations with eliminating.
- 51:32These people to talk to me. They weren't major crimes.
- 51:36I don't know what the state of His Arts are now but he did run
- 51:39a, you did run a, an internet company after graduating
- 51:43college, when he went back to Texas.
- 51:44And that is what and that included, kind of as an
- 51:47offshoot. Like I kind of an all weekly
- 51:49type of electronic publication, which is why people asked him to
- 51:53run for city city council which he did.
- 51:55So that actually did launch him into politics, fascinating
- 51:59though, the one that testified against Twitter sort of during
- 52:02the Elan case, which one was that?
- 52:04That's not just Peter Peter bug sacko.
- 52:07And he's one of these right? Don't remember he was easy as
- 52:10both The Loft and the cult of the dead cow and you know him
- 52:13pretty well or like you wrote about them I mean yes you think
- 52:16he was motivated to help heal on or like where what's his order
- 52:19is sympathies or do you have a read on his motivations to come
- 52:23out on this? Is it motivation and nothing to
- 52:25do with you on? He had decided to come out.
- 52:27He was fired before, Ilan made his move and he decided to go
- 52:31pursue legal whistleblower Avenue before Ilan showed up.
- 52:36So Ilan, was this this weird element that came in at the end,
- 52:40but he was on the road that he was leaving.
- 52:41He made it more supportive to you on anyway.
- 52:44Like no, I mean it while it wound up being of some benefit
- 52:48to Ilan. Yeah, it didn't really help but
- 52:51during obviously every news Cycles through certain prism and
- 52:54it came out when people are obsessed with a lawsuit.
- 52:57So just to answer the initial question, his motivation was
- 53:01that Jack had brought him on to make Twitter users safer after
- 53:07Here is a hideous reaches and he wasn't able to do that on the
- 53:11inside for a variety of reasons. And so he decided to do it from
- 53:14the outside because this is going to apply real pressure and
- 53:18possible additional regulation. On to Twitter it'll be easier if
- 53:22Twitter remains a publicly traded company because one of
- 53:25the few levers of authority over Twitter is the SEC and if mosque
- 53:29takes it private then you don't have you don't have that.
- 53:33It looks like mosques going to wind up with it.
- 53:35So this might this might have been The last chance for
- 53:38Meaningful public oversight, do you think someone like a Mudge?
- 53:40I mean he represents someone coming from the hacker
- 53:43Community. Going to be Chief security
- 53:45officer at a major corporation there, maybe been a few that
- 53:49have gone that like hacking to corporate route in the light of
- 53:52the Sullivan verdict and maybe just the general trend of the
- 53:55industry is that kind of is there more cynicism about that
- 53:58the belief that you can actually help these companies by working
- 54:01on the inside at all. Or you begin to see fewer and
- 54:04fewer people from the hacking World, want to take corporate
- 54:06jobs. Anyway, that is, it's a tough
- 54:08question, the hackers and security people are at one time,
- 54:12you know, unbelievably cynical with good reason.
- 54:15And also basically idealists because the ones that aren't
- 54:19idealists are the ones you don't hear about.
- 54:20They're just out stealing stuff, you know?
- 54:23Or they're hatching really, you know, impressive exploits which
- 54:26they sell on sell on the black market or the gray Market, which
- 54:29is legal. So the ones who hear about are
- 54:31generally trying to make things better.
- 54:32And, you know, one of the reasons I wrote the wrote The
- 54:35Cult of the dead cow book was to try and I and, you know, revive
- 54:38that, you know, rescue load the word hacker from like a negative
- 54:42connotation because hackers are actually by definition critical
- 54:44thinkers and that's, that's incredibly valuable in society.
- 54:48I think that this will make people on the margins less
- 54:51likely to want to a big corporate job with a title and a
- 54:54car and some money. I think some will still do it
- 54:57because you do have a fair amount of levers there to affect
- 55:01good. But again, one of the points of
- 55:03the book is that there are many different ways that hackers
- 55:05could contribute to a better world.
- 55:07In government and nonprofits open source projects like you
- 55:11know back when these guys were starting they were kind of
- 55:12making it up as they win. But now, there are serious.
- 55:15Technologists of an ethical bent working for members of Congress.
- 55:18Some of them are actually in Congress.
- 55:20The Red Cross has technical gurus and most International has
- 55:24Tech gurus are lots of different ways to do good with a hacking
- 55:27mentality and, and Technical sense, now, than there were
- 55:30been. And, you know, I see so, it's
- 55:33looking a little less attractive now than it was before.
- 55:36And before wasn't Looking at attractive.
- 55:38So likelihood that Beto o'roarke is the new C, so at boober, not
- 55:42very high. I think very, very low, hmm.
- 55:46Keep looking over, thanks so much Joseph from all of us here
- 55:49at the cult of the dead cat. We enjoyed enjoyed this
- 55:54conversation. Thanks so much for joining and
- 55:57yeah we'll have you back on here soon.
- 55:58Thanks so much. This is great.
- 55:59Okay, thanks doctor. Goodbye, goodbye.
- 56:14Goodbye, goodbye, goodbye, goodbye.
- 56:17Goodbye.