Latest / Coopers' Code / Lifecycle of a Case, Phase 10 & 11: Liens & Case closing
Transcript
- 0:00Howdy, and welcome to another episode of Cooper's Code Life
- 0:03Cycle of a Case series where we provide tools and tactics for
- 0:08the different phases of a case. We're compiling all of these
- 0:11episodes into a playlist on our YouTube channel.
- 0:13So head on over there if you want to see them all.
- 0:20Once the case is resolved and by resolution, I mean it's either
- 0:25settled, one has a judgment that has been been made final, the
- 0:29the appeal is, is done. However it is is is completed.
- 0:33Then there are a few more steps that that one needs to go
- 0:37through in terms of the resolution process.
- 0:39And there were different places we could have put this.
- 0:41I feel it's most appropriate at the case closing the section
- 0:44because it's one of the final steps and and here we're talking
- 0:48about a minors compromise. So what is a minors compromise?
- 0:52When one has a a minor or someone who is otherwise
- 0:58incapacitated, In essence, someone where a guardian of
- 1:02litem has been appointed, someone who is there to help
- 1:05guide the the person who can't take care of themselves in all
- 1:09ways. That's what's known as a minors
- 1:12compromise. You have to have the court's
- 1:14approval of the resolution. So in settlement terms, the
- 1:20court is actually going to take a look at whether the settlement
- 1:23is OK and, and just some some public policy behind this.
- 1:27There is a concern that someone, a minor or someone who is
- 1:31otherwise incapacitated can't take care of themselves.
- 1:35And in that situation, those individuals need the court, a
- 1:41judicial officer to step in and make sure that everything is OK,
- 1:45That family members aren't taking advantage of the person,
- 1:48that the insurance company who resolved the cases and taking
- 1:50advantage of the person and say, you know, getting them to settle
- 1:53a case for cheap. That the lawyer who represented
- 1:55the person isn't taking advantage of them in terms of
- 1:58the the fees that were charged or the costs that were incurred.
- 2:02And judicial officers take their jobs very seriously, as they
- 2:06should when they're going through this process.
- 2:08So a minors compromise uses a judicial council form.
- 2:12It is subjected to a high level of scrutiny.
- 2:15And the court will go through and see how did this case
- 2:18resolve? What number did it resolve for?
- 2:21Because most of these are settlements, If it's a verdict,
- 2:23it's they're not going to question the verdict because the
- 2:27jury did the verdict and, and that process has all been done.
- 2:30But because most of them are settlements, the court is going
- 2:32to take a look and, and make its own assessment about whether
- 2:35this settlement is is is acceptable.
- 2:38The court is also going to take a close look at where the money
- 2:41is going. So that's making sure that the
- 2:44fees are an appropriate amount of fees, that the costs are
- 2:49handled appropriately and know that in a minor's compromise
- 2:52that the attorneys are obligated to share in the costs to the
- 2:58tune of their attorneys fees. What do I mean by that?
- 3:02If you are charging a 25% fee for a minor, which is a a
- 3:05relatively standard minor's fee, then if you expended $100 in
- 3:12costs, 75 of of those dollars would be paid by the minor
- 3:18associated with the minor. 25 of those would be paid by the
- 3:22attorney. So that's that's the sharing in
- 3:24the costs. So the court is going to take a
- 3:27look at that to make sure that that is complied with.
- 3:29The court is also going to take a look at where the money is
- 3:31going. There are three ways in a minors
- 3:34compromise that the money can be handled.
- 3:36None of them are are great outcomes, but you need to
- 3:40recognize that the court wants to make sure that it is the
- 3:44minors money and the miner ultimately has the control over
- 3:48the money even if that miner can't control it in the moment.
- 3:52So the old tiny initial way that this was handled is what's known
- 3:57as a blocked account. So a blocked account, it means
- 4:01the money goes to a bank, it gets deposited in a special kind
- 4:05of account, and the only way that money can be withdrawn from
- 4:09that account is by going to court and saying to a judicial
- 4:13officer, hey, we need to withdraw money for X.
- 4:16Usually what ends up happening is that money sits there until
- 4:18the minor turns 18 and then one goes to court and asked the
- 4:22court to release that money. The downsides of a blocked
- 4:25account are huge. I I would say it is the least
- 4:29favorable option for resolving a case.
- 4:33Why? Having been through this process
- 4:35once with a client who, who insisted on using this, this
- 4:38vehicle, I went with the client to the bank and we were there
- 4:44for five hours and we were there for five hours because the
- 4:48branches don't have anyone who really have any level of
- 4:51sophistication, even at the, the larger downtown branches.
- 4:54So they are having to reach out to their headquarters and to
- 4:58legal to try and figure out just what the heck you're asking for.
- 5:01And it scares them because they're not common, so they
- 5:05don't know how to do it. And, and eventually we were able
- 5:08to put it through, but then five years later I'm back in court
- 5:13representing that client to have the money withdrawn.
- 5:15And the interest rates for these blocked accounts are kind of
- 5:18standard savings rates and well, interest rates have gone up over
- 5:22the last year or so. Generally interest for these are
- 5:26pretty poor relative to other investment vehicles.
- 5:30So I, I would say if you have to do a minors compromise, just
- 5:37recognize that a blocked account is, is really not the best way
- 5:40to go with them. The other vehicles that that are
- 5:45what I would suggest is, is good potential vehicles is a cut in a
- 5:49529. So what is a cut in a 529?
- 5:52That's, that's California uniform transfer to minors Act
- 5:57529. How is that different than a
- 5:59standard 529? And what is a 529?
- 6:02A 529 is a tax deferred vehicle for providing money to a child
- 6:10where in essence when the money comes out, you don't have to pay
- 6:13taxes on it, but when the money comes out you can only use it
- 6:17for specific purposes. So 520 nines are are a common
- 6:21investment vehicle for parents saving for their kids college.
- 6:26So you get the benefit of it going into the market, you get
- 6:28the benefit of the the the tax profile reduction and you're
- 6:34able to withdraw it for tuition payments for college or other
- 6:38college associated costs, books, living expenses, They're spelled
- 6:43out specifically under under the the rules in under 529.
- 6:47So how's it cutting a 529 different than a 529 a 529, even
- 6:53if you make it in the name of your child is owned by the
- 6:56parent. So give you an example.
- 7:00Our son Bennett, we opened up a 529 for him.
- 7:03If I suddenly decided that I didn't like Bennett anymore and
- 7:06I was going to want to use that money for my niece, bad joke.
- 7:11But I could in theory say, well, we're not going to use that for
- 7:15Bennett. We're going to use it for, for,
- 7:18for my niece. Bennett does not own the 529,
- 7:21even though I originally opened it in his name.
- 7:24A cut in a 529 is different. A cut in a 529 is owned by the
- 7:29minor. So when you go to court with the
- 7:32minors compromise if a 529 is is considered to be a good vehicle.
- 7:37So most kids are going to do some form of of education post
- 7:42high school. If that's the case, a couple of
- 7:45529 can be a very good vehicle for parking this money.
- 7:48The other vehicle that that is tends to be a very good one that
- 7:52it needs for most structure brokers, they're going to want
- 7:56to work with a dollar figure typically over I, I think it's
- 8:00$50,000 at this point. So if you have an amount of
- 8:06money and a 529 may not be the the right vehicle, then a
- 8:11structure is another good way to to do that.
- 8:13Why is the structure useful? Structure allows you to get the
- 8:17benefit of market returns. So you can put the money into
- 8:20that that taxed free annuity and then the money comes out when
- 8:26the kid is, you know, at some point past the age of 18.
- 8:30So there are an infinite ways to structure funds, but a a common
- 8:37way of doing that is is having them come out as lump sum
- 8:39payments, almost like a 529 to pay for for college or pay for a
- 8:49deposit on a house or, or some other way of of having that
- 8:52money come out in chunks. Sometimes parents like to make
- 8:56sure that kids don't have too much access to too much money
- 9:00right away. So it may not all come out when
- 9:02they're 18. Some of it may come out
- 9:04depending on how much money they're receiving when they are
- 9:07closer to 25. Also, if if you have a very high
- 9:11value case where you've got an incapacitated minor and their
- 9:14expenses are going to need to be taken care of above and beyond
- 9:18what the parents can afford and above and beyond what government
- 9:21services provide, then you, you may end up with a situation
- 9:24where that structure is starting to pay earlier in the process.
- 9:27All of this is very nuanced. All of this gets a close court
- 9:30review as you prepare for a minors compromise hearing.
- 9:34Recognize that because of the nuance with these and because of
- 9:37the questions that the court can ask that it's, it's not unusual
- 9:41to end up having to go to a hearing more than once for a
- 9:44minors compromise. They might want more
- 9:46information. There often times are things
- 9:48that they want in terms of we want to see proof that the money
- 9:52was deposited, so submit that within 90 days and then we'll
- 9:55have an order show cause for the deposit that comes off so long
- 9:58as you submit the proof of that with the court.
- 10:01A parallel piece to the minors compromise in resolving cases
- 10:04are what are known as special needs trusts.
- 10:07So if you have an individual who is receiving a lot of
- 10:12governmental benefits, one of the things to consider is
- 10:16whether a special needs trust is something that is going to be
- 10:19appropriate. Now, recognizing that
- 10:22governmental benefits programs and thresholds can change, what
- 10:26I'm going to do is, is just talk in very general terms about a
- 10:29special needs trust, what it is and, and generally how it's
- 10:32done. This is a specialized vehicle
- 10:35and it is best to get a specialized lawyer who who does
- 10:38special needs trusts if that's something that you're going to
- 10:41need in your case. So, and I'm bringing it up
- 10:45shortly after talking about minors compromises because often
- 10:48times it's an incapacitated minor, somebody who's had very
- 10:52traumatic injuries, who may be receiving some form of, of
- 10:56medical, who may be receiving some form of other support
- 11:01services. Often times you you might need
- 11:05to do a special needs trust in association with a minors
- 11:08compromise. The the other place where you
- 11:10see it is somebody who has such profound injuries that they may
- 11:15not be working again, whether that's the the way the person
- 11:19came to you with their their case or whether it is a result
- 11:23of the injury, you're going to want to make sure that they are
- 11:26able to continue to receive benefits.
- 11:29So what is a special needs trust?
- 11:31A special needs trust is a specialized vehicle.
- 11:35Again, best to hire the an attorney who who does use on a
- 11:39regular basis where the money that the injured party receives
- 11:44goes into this trust and can only be used for very specific
- 11:47things. Now, the benefit is that it
- 11:51allows them to, to maintain their governmental benefits.
- 11:55So if they're on SSDI, if they're on medical, if they have
- 12:00other benefits that they're receiving, they're able to keep
- 12:02receiving those. The, the special needs trust
- 12:05though, can only be used for very specific things.
- 12:10So they can't just get that money parked there and go out
- 12:12and, you know, buy a Mercedes. That said, if they need a
- 12:17specialized transportation vehicle because they are
- 12:21disabled, arguably you could use that money to buy a specialized
- 12:26transportation van to, to move from point A to point B.
- 12:30So these are things that that will benefit them that aren't
- 12:34going to be covered by their governmental benefits programs.
- 12:37They're also very specific reporting requirements for
- 12:40special needs trusts. So really the take away here is
- 12:44if you have a client who's dependent upon governmental
- 12:47benefits, just have a bell go off in your head that I might
- 12:51want to look up special needs trusts and, and see about
- 12:55consulting with a special needs trust lawyer about whether this
- 12:58is the right vehicle for the client.
- 13:01One additional piece on this, because it's specialized and
- 13:04because it's outside of the scope of the representation of
- 13:06most personal injury lawyers that that is typically a case
- 13:09cost. You know, so if it costs 4 to
- 13:13$7000 to set one of these up and, and my, my pricing might be
- 13:19off. It's been a while since I've,
- 13:21I've, I've had to do one of these.
- 13:22That's a cost that is usually absorbed by the client and
- 13:26typically approved by the court if it is built into the minors
- 13:29compromise. If there's a minors comp
- 13:31associated with a special needs trust.
- 13:33So that's minors compromises that special needs trusts.
- 13:37The other part that is part of the the case closing process are
- 13:41liens. Now I I want to stop here and
- 13:44say this is a cursory overview of liens.
- 13:49It is not a deep dive into liens and strategies for lien
- 13:52resolution. For that.
- 13:54I recommend people, if that's really what what you want to
- 13:58hear about, pause here, go to one of our first episodes.
- 14:03I have the wonderful Hendrick White who was with us and and
- 14:06the lean specialist. He he does a deep dive into how
- 14:11we address the various types of leans and and and the pros,
- 14:15cons, benefits and and that negotiating strategies.
- 14:19But as a case closing piece, one of the things that one needs to
- 14:24do is, is go through and make sure that all of the liens are
- 14:26addressed. Why is this usually done at the
- 14:28end? Well, you can come up with
- 14:30strategies and you can sometimes negotiate with lien claimants
- 14:34earlier on in the case. Almost all the time they want to
- 14:38know how much money did you get and what are your fees going to
- 14:41be? And then they'll start talking
- 14:43with you about negotiating those resolutions.
- 14:46So there are standard liens, almost all of these are are
- 14:51going to be some form of, of medical lien.
- 14:53The standard liens are are typically resolved under the
- 14:57common fund doctrine where you are able to say, look, you would
- 15:02have not gotten a dollar unless we did our work.
- 15:05Our fees are 1/3 or 40% and we spent $10,000 and you're on the
- 15:09hook on a pro rata share of that.
- 15:11And, and so you start there and start trying to negotiate them
- 15:14down. If there's not a lot of money,
- 15:16if, if this is a, a minimum policy, you know, a $30,000
- 15:21policy, then sometimes what you'll end up with is rule of
- 15:25thirds and that. And that is, look, everyone's
- 15:29going to have to take a bath on this.
- 15:30So, you know, our, our fees are 1/3, the client's getting a
- 15:33third, you get a third. Different carriers respond
- 15:38differently to fee reductions. Just just know that going in.
- 15:42And, and the reason I say this is because sometimes we will
- 15:45reduce in cases where there's not a lot of insurance, there's
- 15:48a significant injury and the, the client probably would have
- 15:53gotten the policy even if we weren't there, we will reduce
- 15:57our fee. We want to make sure that the
- 15:59fee is commiserate with the work that was being done on the case.
- 16:04And that can sometimes be beneficial with some carriers to
- 16:07say, look, we're not taking a fee in this case.
- 16:09We'd ask you to waive your lien. Sometimes I'll do it, but on
- 16:13occasion you'll come across a carrier who will say, oh, you're
- 16:16not taking a fee. Well, jeez, that just means the
- 16:19clients get more money so we don't need to reduce our our
- 16:23lien as much. Or if you're not taking a fee,
- 16:26then the common fund is not applicable here.
- 16:28So just get a sense as to who you're dealing with before you
- 16:32start indicating that there's going to be a few reduction.
- 16:35You can sound sound them out on how they respond to few
- 16:38reductions. The other awful, awful lien that
- 16:43that people come across on occasion are are one is known as
- 16:46self funded ERISA liens. Those self funded ERISA liens
- 16:49are are just terrible. I mean, there's there's no way
- 16:53around it. Usually they've contracted
- 16:55around all of the tools that we have in state court to reduce
- 17:00liens and they're subject to to federal law.
- 17:02So they can do that. The only thing I think there are
- 17:04worse than self funded ERISA liens are union pension fund
- 17:10liens, Costco liens. Those have come up recently for
- 17:13us. Those entities typically will
- 17:16reach out to the the member that the person who's insured and say
- 17:20we aren't going to cover any of your, it looks like you were
- 17:22involved in something awful. We're not going to cover any of
- 17:25your medical expenses going forward unless you sign off on
- 17:28this thing that in essence, the payments you're receiving are a
- 17:32loan against any resolution that you have.
- 17:35Some of these will even say that if you receive money, we won't
- 17:39pay for any of your medical care going forward from the incident
- 17:43once the lien is resolved. So just just know that there are
- 17:47some of these awful, awful ones out there and they're a pain in
- 17:50the ass to deal with. Medicare and and medical require
- 17:55one to go through the CMS portal.
- 17:57Those can be negotiated and there are other tactics, all
- 18:00born being one of them. I'm just going to say the case
- 18:03Auburn, Google it, AI it and and and if you have a case where
- 18:09that might be the right strategy, consider using some of
- 18:11the tools available there. But just know that you need to
- 18:14go through that process and, and generally though they are
- 18:20willing to negotiate and, and get better outcomes on liens.
- 18:24So one final piece on liens. Why are liens so important to
- 18:28fight on? It's because every dollar you
- 18:31save a client on the lien side is, is an actual dollar in their
- 18:35pocket. These are not subject to fees.
- 18:37And so while it takes all of us a little bit of extra work,
- 18:40sometimes a lot of extra work to engage in lean fights, know that
- 18:44that it's highly beneficial for the client and and it's just,
- 18:47it's part of the service that we offer.
- 18:49We're the here to fight to get the most money we possible can
- 18:52for our clients, both from the settlement or verdict side, we
- 18:56want to get that number really high.
- 18:57And then on the lean side, we want to get that number really
- 18:59low so that you get that nice big differential in between the
- 19:02two. And that's the client's money.
- 19:05When one is is, is finally done with the case, one will have
- 19:11what is known as a distribution report.
- 19:12That's what we refer to it as internally distribution report
- 19:17will list the money that is coming in, the attorney's fees,
- 19:22the costs and and then how that money is being distributed.
- 19:27So in essence the the net to the client, we will usually do at
- 19:33least two distributions. So distribution number one will
- 19:36reserve money for the lien, meaning the full amount of
- 19:40whatever the lien is. If the lien is $50,000 or
- 19:43reserve 50, go ahead and pay the client and then that 50 will
- 19:48hold and and do the lien negotiation.
- 19:50And when we're finally done with the lien negotiation, we will do
- 19:53a second distribution report. The learning all share going
- 19:58forward is that lawyers tends to not be great at math.
- 20:03Lawyers tend to be eager to get cases, get the money to the
- 20:07clients. I recommend that if you have a
- 20:11bookkeeper, that your bookkeeper do the distribution report.
- 20:13And then if you have another smart person in your office who
- 20:17knows how to do math, have that person go through and double
- 20:20check things. The reason for that is the
- 20:23distribution report is going to be one of the last moments you
- 20:25have to engage with your client. And if there is a math error,
- 20:28and particularly if there's a math error that is
- 20:32disadvantageous to your client, while you can can redo it, it's
- 20:37it's really embarrassing and it leaves a bad taste in the
- 20:39client's mouth. So having a a second set of eyes
- 20:43on that is a good way to reduce the chances of errors.
- 20:47The other piece on that is on your cost side.
- 20:50It's a good opportunity for you to go through and make sure that
- 20:53all the costs were properly entered in the case.
- 20:56So in any environment there is the chance of an error being
- 21:01made in terms of things being flagged wrong in bookkeeping.
- 21:04So as the lawyer who's handled the case, going through and, and
- 21:09seeing, you know, all the expert costs, all the deposition costs,
- 21:15any travel fees or hotel fees, if you see things where like, Oh
- 21:19yeah, you know, I ended up standing an extra night to do X
- 21:22that should not have been included on my client's behalf.
- 21:24That's your opportunity to go through and strike those so that
- 21:27the client is not the one going through and questioning you.
- 21:29You just want to make sure that you're as above board as
- 21:32possible and, and, and do the right thing as far as that's
- 21:35concerned. An additional piece that we like
- 21:38to do is on our distribution report we will usually have a
- 21:42second page that tells us exactly where the money is going
- 21:47and how the money is going. So what do I mean by that?
- 21:50If we're receiving fees that no, the dollar figure that we're
- 21:54receiving and how it's transferring from the client
- 21:57trust account to our account, usually by wire.
- 22:01Is it the same with costs? Because costs are going to be a
- 22:02second line item. If there's a referral fee, what
- 22:05that referral fee is or Co counsel fee is?
- 22:08And again, is that going by check?
- 22:09Is it going by wire? If it's going by wire to what
- 22:11account? Same with the client money, same
- 22:14with lean money. The reason for this is so that
- 22:17you have a one stop shopping. Should anything come up down the
- 22:21road to say odd, this is this is how all the money got handled.
- 22:24In this particular case, it's it's nice to have that all in
- 22:26one place. Finally, with the distribution
- 22:29report, we usually like to do and and and recommend all
- 22:34lawyers do a client exit interview.
- 22:38And that exit interview is is twofold.
- 22:41It's to help make sure that the client feels like everything is
- 22:47is done and the IDOT and T cross and make sure any sort of final
- 22:51instructions are, are are covered with a client.
- 22:54And then also to learn where one excelled and where one can
- 22:58improve. So when I say confirm everything
- 23:02is done, you want to make sure like you've received your funds.
- 23:06Do you have any questions about what we've done?
- 23:08Do you have any questions about what we're doing with your case
- 23:10file? For example, we can make a, a
- 23:12digital copy of the case file available to the client.
- 23:15We will tell the clients typically that we, we will
- 23:19maintain your digital file for a minimum of five years.
- 23:22And, and realistically, we often times don't do more thorough
- 23:26purges absent your request that we do purge it.
- 23:29So we told them that, so that if something comes up down the
- 23:33road, a medical record that they want, they perhaps didn't save
- 23:36in the right place or or didn't ask us for, we have that and we
- 23:39can give it to them. We also will typically answer
- 23:43any client questions. We want to make sure that they
- 23:46know that that typically personal injury resolutions are,
- 23:50are a not taxable in terms of what they received as far as
- 23:53those dollars are concerned. And that if that question comes
- 23:56up with their accountant, they or their accountant should feel
- 24:00free to reach out to us and we can point them to IRS
- 24:02periodicals as far as that's concerned.
- 24:05We want to be encouraged as much feedback as possible.
- 24:09And so you want to create and, and invite opportunities to
- 24:13provide feedback where one can improve.
- 24:15Are there ways in which you feel we could have done better in
- 24:20terms of how, how we're handling the case, how, how responsive
- 24:24were we? Would you have liked more
- 24:26communication, less communication?
- 24:28Those are all ways where, where one can learn what's beneficial
- 24:32in terms of, of, of how to help people going forward.
- 24:35We always encourage them to call with any sort of future
- 24:39questions that they have. One of the things you you want
- 24:42to do is is you are working with your clients is remember that
- 24:45your clients often times become future referral sources.
- 24:48So to keep that door open. Hey, you know if anything comes
- 24:52up with you or a loved one or a friend, consider us your your
- 24:56first line of offence even if it's outside or our practice
- 25:00area reaching out to us. We often times know somebody in
- 25:02the area we can help point you in the right direction as far as
- 25:05that's concerned. Then when you are are totally
- 25:09done. You want to make sure that you
- 25:11you formalize that that we thanks for being a client.
- 25:14We've resolved your case. The representation is formally
- 25:19ending at this point. You continue to be a friend of
- 25:21the firm forever going forward. And then if you've had a good
- 25:26relationship with the client and you feel that a review is
- 25:29appropriate, you want to see if they're going to be willing to
- 25:32review you. Google reviews and and other
- 25:35reviews tend to be very helpful in that client development
- 25:38process, getting future referrals, getting future
- 25:40business. So that's the case closing
- 25:43process in a in a nutshell. Thank you for tuning in.
- 25:46If you enjoyed this, We're compiling all of these episodes
- 25:49into a playlist on our YouTube channel.
- 25:51So head on over there if you want to see them all.
- 25:54If you're enjoying what we're doing here with Cooper's code,
- 25:56please help us extend our reach by giving us a five star review
- 25:59on Apple Podcasts and consider sharing an episode with a
- 26:01friend. Please e-mail us at podcast at
- 26:04Cooper's dot law with questions, comments, feedback and
- 26:06suggestions you have for who you'd like to see on the show.
- 26:10To all of you doing justice out there, happy hunting.