Latest / The National Debt Podcast with Fexingo: Treasury, Borrowing, and Long-Term Fiscal Outlook / Why Foreign Demand for US Debt Is Cooling
Transcript
- Lucas: So, the 30-year Treasury yield just crossed five point two percent. That's a number we haven't seen in decades, and it's got me thinking about something we don't talk about enough: who's actually buying all this debt. Luna: Right, because if the buyers start to waver, that's when the math gets really uncomfortable. Lucas: Exactly. And here's the thing — for years, foreign central banks were the bedrock of the Treasury market. Japan and China alone held over a trillion each at their peak. But the trend has been quietly shifting, and the latest data shows that foreign demand is cooling just as the federal government needs to roll over a mountain of debt. Luna: We've talked about the refinancing cliff before, but how does foreign demand factor into that? Lucas: Let's put some numbers around it. Foreign holdings of US Treasuries are still around eight trillion, but the percentage of marketable debt held abroad has been drifting down. It was over thirty percent in 2015; now it's closer to twenty-five. That's a meaningful shift. And it's happening just as the federal deficit is running at one point seven seven trillion for the fiscal year, with debt to gdp at one hundred twenty-two point six percent. Luna: So if foreigners are stepping back, who fills the gap? Domestic buyers? Lucas: That's the hope. But domestic buyers — pension funds, mutual funds, banks — they're also dealing with their own constraints. And the Treasury has been leaning more on short-term bills, which is a sign that demand at the long end is getting harder to source. Luna: Why would foreign demand be cooling now, especially when yields are going up? You'd think higher yields would attract more buyers. Lucas: You'd think that, but it's not just about yield. There's a structural element. Look at Japan — they've been major buyers for decades, but Japanese investors are now finding better returns at home, with the Bank of Japan finally normalizing policy. And China, well, there's a geopolitical dimension. They've been gradually diversifying away from US debt as part of their broader de-dollarization push. Luna: Interesting. So it's not a panic, but a slow grind lower. Lucas: Exactly. It's a gradual shift in the marginal buyer. And that's what matters for the Treasury. When you have a thinner foreign bid, the Treasury has to offer more yield to clear its auctions. That's part of why we're seeing term premiums go up — the extra compensation investors demand for holding long-duration bonds. Luna: We talked about the term premium back in episode one thirty-seven. But can you remind us how that connects to foreign demand? Lucas: Sure. The term premium is the extra yield investors get for taking on the risk of holding a long-term bond versus rolling over short-term bills. When foreign buyers were always there, they provided a steady bid that kept that premium low. Now, as they pull back, the market has to price in more uncertainty — who's going to absorb all these new issues? That pushes the term premium up, and that's a big part of why the 30-year is at five point two percent. Luna: So, how much of that five point two percent is just the term premium versus expectations of future short rates? Lucas: That's the million-dollar question. The Fed's been holding rates at three point six three percent, and the market sees cuts coming, but the long end is still elevated. That gap — between the 10-year at four point six eight and the 2-year at four point two three — that's a forty-seven basis point spread, and it's partly about term premium. I'd argue a significant chunk of that is the rising term premium. Luna: But is foreign demand actually falling, or just not growing as fast as the debt pile? Lucas: That's a fair distinction. Foreign holdings aren't collapsing, but they're not keeping pace with the explosion in debt. And when the Treasury has to issue a record amount, even a slight lag from foreign buyers means the domestic market has to absorb a bigger share. Luna: Speaking of domestic buyers, I saw that US banks are stepping in but they're also facing liquidity rules that make holding long-duration Treasuries expensive. Does that push the Treasury to do even more short-term borrowing? Lucas: It does. We saw that in the last financing update — the Treasury's been increasing the share of bills as a percentage of total marketable debt, and that's a warning sign. Bills are cheap now, but they have to be rolled over constantly. It's like a credit card with a low teaser rate — it works until it doesn't. Luna: So, what's the tipping point? At what point do foreign investors say 'enough'? Lucas: The tipping point isn't a single auction; it's if the dollar starts to lose its reserve status. That's the real anchor. Foreign investors hold Treasuries because they're the ultimate safe haven — liquid, deep, and dollar-denominated. If the fiscal path gets so rocky that the dollar's credibility is questioned, then you'd see a more sudden shift. Luna: And that would be a self-fulfilling prophecy — higher yields, more deficit, weaker dollar. Lucas: Right. And we're not there yet. But the fact that we're having this conversation, and that the 30-year is printing five point two, shows the market is starting to ask these questions. Look at the headlines from last week — the Fed is divided on inflation, growth slowed to one point five percent in Q2, and China's factory activity unexpectedly contracted. Global demand for US assets is not what it used to be. Luna: So, what does this mean for the average person? Why should they care if Japan or China buys fewer Treasuries? Lucas: Because it filters through to their mortgage rates, their credit card rates, their car loans. The Treasury sets the risk-free benchmark for everything else. If foreign demand wanes, the federal government pays more, and that cost eventually trickles down. Plus, if the government is spending more on interest, that's less room in the budget for anything else. Luna: And interest on the debt is already over a trillion a year, right? Lucas: That's right. Interest costs are now the fastest-growing major budget item. And every basis point of yield on the 30-year adds billions to the annual interest bill. So, this isn't just about bond traders — it's about fiscal capacity. Luna: So, what would you say is the one thing to watch in the next few months? Lucas: I'd watch the quarterly refunding announcements and the auction bidding stats. Specifically, the bid to cover ratios — if those start to fall consistently, that's a sign that demand isn't keeping up with supply. And also watch the dollar index. If it starts to slide in a disorderly way, that's a red flag. Luna: So, it's not a cliff, but a slow erosion. I guess that's the more realistic way to think about it. Lucas: Yeah, slow erosion is a good way to put it. And it's a process that's been going on for years. The question is whether it accelerates or stabilizes. That's what we'll be watching. Luna: You know, this kind of deep-dive analysis is exactly why we keep this show ad-free. We want to give you the real mechanics without any corporate noise. If that’s been valuable to you, you can support the work at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Lucas: Yeah, it’s a small way to keep this kind of conversation going. But back to the data — another thing I find interesting is how the Treasury’s own advisory committee has started to flag the changing composition of buyers. They’re not panicking, but they’re definitely paying attention. Luna: What are they saying specifically? Lucas: They’ve noted that foreign official holdings have been declining, and they’re questioning whether the domestic investor base can absorb the projected supply in the next decade. They’re also talking about the possibility of having to issue more long-duration debt to lock in rates before they go higher. But that’s a double-edged sword. Luna: Because if you issue long-duration debt now at five percent, you’re locking in that cost for thirty years. But if you wait, it could be even higher. Lucas: Exactly. It’s a gamble either way. And it’s a gamble that has direct implications for the national debt trajectory. Every basis point on the 30-year adds billions in interest payments. So, the Treasury’s decision on the maturity structure is almost as important as the size of the deficit itself. Luna: So, in a way, the challenge isn't just the trillion-dollar deficits, but also the terms on which we're borrowing. Lucas: That's the crux. The deficits are the headline, but the borrowing terms are the silent multiplier. And with foreign demand fading, the terms are getting tougher. I think we'll look back on this period as the moment when the US had to start paying a real price for its debt — not just in absolute terms, but in the risk premium that foreign investors are demanding. Luna: And that’s the story that’s going to unfold over the next few years. Thanks for joining us on this deep dive. Lucas: Yep. Until next time, keep an eye on those auction numbers.