Latest / Free Cities Podcast / 142 - Michael Mainelli: Solving Wicked Problems
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Free Cities podcast. My name is Timothy Allen and this is the official podcast
- 0:17of the Free Cities Foundation.
- 0:30Hello and welcome to this episode number 142 of the Free Cities podcast, brought to you as always by our wonderful sponsor Veritas Villages.
- 0:43Veritas Villages are off-grid, energy, self-sufficient luxury communities in Latin America designed for freedom lovers just like yourself.
- 0:53Bitcoin is accepted at all villages, including for the purchase of property there.
- 1:01For more info, www.ecovillages.life forward slash free cities.
- 1:08That's a link to a page about Veritas Village Coronado, one of their Panama projects.
- 1:16They also have another Panama project.
- 1:18Veritas Village, Chiriqui. That's a riverfront home site property. They have Playa Pacifica
- 1:26in Nicaragua. That's a beach community. And hot off the presses in Costa Rica, they've just
- 1:34acquired land in Atenas for a new community. www.ecovillages.life forward slash free cities
- 1:45for more info. Please mention us if you choose to do business with them. And if you're interested,
- 1:52Patrick, their CEO, has his own YouTube channel and he interviewed me a couple of weeks ago.
- 1:58Look in the show notes for a link to that. Right. Today's episode, well, it's with a gentleman by
- 2:04the name of Michael Minnelli. He's a British scientist, economist and accountant known for
- 2:12being the chairman of ZN, I think a little better known as the Sheriff of the City of London,
- 2:202019 to 2021, and probably most notable, at least in my eyes, he was the 695th Lord Mayor
- 2:31of the City of London. Yes, I know. Sorry to those of you from the US. I'm fully aware that
- 2:39the American mind cannot comprehend that fact, but you're going to go and have to deal with it.
- 2:46Yes, we have very old things over here on the other side of the pond. I'm jesting, but ironically,
- 2:53Michael is American-born, and as you will hear, still retains much of his US accent. I met him
- 3:01in London a couple of weeks ago, and we discussed, amongst other things, the City of London, of course,
- 3:07It's history and governance, the concept of private cities and free zones, regulation and the roles of government and the free market.
- 3:18And the best part for me, wicked problems and dilemma analysis.
- 3:24Now, if you're not sure what dilemma analysis or wicked problems are, here's a quick 101 to prepare you for what's to come.
- 3:32They're both strategies for dealing with problems.
- 3:37Dilemma analysis is about choosing between difficult but defined moral options.
- 3:42Wicked problems involve deep complexity with no clear boundaries or permanent solutions.
- 3:49A couple of examples that really helped me.
- 3:52Dilemma analysis.
- 3:53A doctor must decide whether to respect a patient's autonomy or break confidentiality to prevent harm.
- 4:01That's a good one.
- 4:02Wicked problem, climate change, poverty, health care reform, urban planning, or as Michael says, governance.
- 4:13He believes governance is one of the biggest wicked problems of our time.
- 4:19And I think I would agree with him.
- 4:20Many thanks to Michael for hosting me in the Square Mile.
- 4:24The pleasure was all mine, Michael.
- 4:26Many thanks also to Christopher Almanis, ANT, CB, Bullish Mike, Cousin Vinny, Dovidas, Matthias.
- 4:37Many thanks for actually choosing to offer your own hard-earned Bitcoin to this podcast's strategic Bitcoin reserve in the form of a monthly subscription.
- 4:50If you find any value here, please consider doing this also yourself if you haven't done it.
- 4:56Hit the subscribe button on the Fountain app and you will gain early access to very long interviews and bonus episodes.
- 5:07The next bonus episode is coming up in a couple of weeks.
- 5:09It will be part two of my epic chat with what shall I call him?
- 5:15The thinking man's Bitcoiner.
- 5:17Yes, GG, the one and only.
- 5:19That's an episode only available to subscribers.
- 5:23But above all else, as a subscriber, you will get that warm, fuzzy feeling inside that you're supporting our work and mission here at the Free Cities podcast.
- 5:35Many thanks to you all. Right. Time for the conversation now.
- 5:39Oh, I forgot to mention I'm in Latvia.
- 5:42I'm here to do another round of interviews at and around the Honey Badger Conference.
- 5:48Loads of great stuff coming up.
- 5:50Look out for those over the next few months. Right, the conversation is coming. You've arrived at the gate. Now pay your toll and enter the city. Find a quiet spot, sit back, relax and enjoy my conversation with Michael Minelli.
- 6:06right um michael i think um i it's very hard to know where to start actually because
- 6:24we are a podcast interested in free cities free zones etc etc and there are so many ways to
- 6:31approach that from where you are as far as i can tell i mean i haven't done a huge amount of
- 6:37delving into your backstory but enough to make me realize that there are a number of ways to
- 6:42approach this i think that the the best one for me and the easiest one was to come at it from the
- 6:52and i found this in very interesting that you you were the 695th lord mayor of london is that right
- 6:59That's right.
- 6:59Which in itself is quite astonishing.
- 7:03I'm not sure I know any organisations that have 695 former people in charge, maybe.
- 7:10I mean, the City of London must be one of the, on a, on a, what was certainly one of the oldest currently existing special economic zones.
- 7:20Would you call it a special, special economic zone?
- 7:22I mean, what was the original purpose behind the City of London?
- 7:27When you go right back in history, was it something that just formed naturally, as you would expect a group of people in one place deciding, okay, we need to create a system here?
- 7:39The formation of the City of London is lost to some degree in a history that is not very well recorded and also quite a bit lost in legend.
- 7:50So sometimes the legends overrun the facts.
- 7:52if you were to look at its age i would argue it is probably the oldest continuous democracy in the
- 8:02world and the the the other crowd who might have a go and say it's they would be the tin vault in
- 8:09douglas on the isle of man and there are different versions of how much this had to do with anglo
- 8:16Saxons and Vikings and all sorts of craziness. But what probably distinguishes the city of London
- 8:23was the ability to use the old Roman walls. So London itself was founded, if I get it right,
- 8:29AD 42. The Romans come over, Boudicca burns them down a decade later, but they persist.
- 8:37And the Romans leave in 400 AD. And we don't know why they left. And again, their arguments that
- 8:46They were absorbed in the native population and a few leaders left and their arguments
- 8:50say they kind of left en masse.
- 8:52But the most important thing is that the city of London itself was unoccupied.
- 8:57So the city of London constitutes just over 677 acres.
- 9:03We don't have that much land, so we pay attention to 1.2 square miles is another way of looking
- 9:10at it and 2.2 or something square kilometers.
- 9:13Anyway, there are arguments again about that.
- 9:15but the old Roman walls extended from what we would see today as Blackfriars to the Tower of London and then up and around what is called London Wall still The modern city largely follows that pattern
- 9:27It's a little bit extended from outside that initial wall, but not by very much.
- 9:33Are the gates Roman?
- 9:34The gates were Roman, yep.
- 9:36And again, arguments about the numbers of gates.
- 9:39Some would say five, some would say seven.
- 9:40but Alder's Gate, Bishop's Gate, Alt Gate without the other, New Gate which was put in well after the Romans, hence New, and so on.
- 9:52So you've got the gate system, the walls all set up roughly around the 200s.
- 9:58The Romans had a wooden palisade and then they went down to Maidstone and Kent and barges would come up and they built the wall itself.
- 10:06When London was unoccupied, and the archaeological evidence is really clear, 200 years of no occupation from 400 to 600, the people such as they were were occupying what we would today call Fleet Street, which was then called London Vic or London Port.
- 10:24And I don't know, to me it looked probably a bit like a science fiction film set, Planet of the Apes or something, that there were all these temples overgrown and people sort of scurrying in the walls, but they stayed out.
- 10:35And then suddenly, for reasons we don't understand, they moved almost en masse at 600 in and set up 25 wards and Beatles to run those wards.
- 10:45And then, again, there are arguments on this.
- 10:47The earliest would claim that sometime around 640 AD, we began electing sheriffs to hang over a pair of sheriffs following the Roman consular model of two consuls.
- 10:57That's one argument.
- 10:59Some people would say the sheriffs came later.
- 11:01And this is where I say legend overruns things.
- 11:03So you'll hear things that the word sheriff comes from shire, reeve, which means a shire, and reeve is a tax collector.
- 11:10But that would imply there was a king to have a shire.
- 11:13And, of course, the city of London isn't a shire anyway.
- 11:15Some people would point to the fact that the ancient word shire means just any kind of habitation.
- 11:20So the habitation tax collector, which is probably what I would buy into, is the most likely.
- 11:25But the term sheriff originates again.
- 11:28Then something emerged as well, something called the Court of Hustings, which was an original meeting outdoors and related to the Saxons had a concept of folk moots that the people should get together.
- 11:41And again, arguments about how often, but probably about twice a year and have a folk moot where they would sort of shout things out and talk things through.
- 11:49So we've got records, particularly like of the folk moots and the Hustings going back to the 7800s.
- 11:56So we know that they were around.
- 11:58Then we have the concept of aldermen for the wards. Again, some history tests, and a lot of these texts were done off of legend as opposed to primary research, would say the aldermen didn't really emerge until roughly the 1100s.
- 12:16Again, that seems rather inconsistent.
- 12:20My best guess would be that the aldermen emerged around the 900s, and sometime around
- 12:26the year 1000 to 1100, we had a court of common council.
- 12:31The reason I'm agonizing over this is there's a particular date that everybody knows in
- 12:34English history, which is 1066.
- 12:37This is when William I enters the country, comes up to the walls of the city with, we
- 12:42We estimate about 6,000 men having landed at Hastings with possibly 8,000.
- 12:47Beats Harold, comes up to the city, and he meets 20,000 people on the wall.
- 12:53And he decides this is not a battle he wants to fight.
- 12:56And he leaves basically the city alone.
- 12:59He trots around.
- 13:00He actually goes, believe it or not, to Runnymede at one point.
- 13:02So don't confuse that with King John.
- 13:04But Runnymede was quite a popular place to stop and do your monarchical rights.
- 13:09And then he goes up to Birkhamstead.
- 13:11And so it's all quite a mess. But he comes back in 1067 and negotiates a treaty with the city, which we call the Charter of William I, because he never conquered the city. This then leads to a lot of tussles with the monarchy. And I'm hardly a monarchical historian, but we have a treaty of 1132, 1189. A lot of people focus on 1215, the Magna Carta, but with reference to the city, the Magna Carta merely says the city will keep all of her rights.
- 13:41and that. So the concept of an independent city-state is probably far too strong,
- 13:46but there certainly was enough tension that they were allowed to elect their own sheriffs,
- 13:51they were allowed to raise their own taxes, but to pay them over as well, and to set a lot of the
- 13:57trade rights. Now again, this wouldn't be particularly astounding, except that London
- 14:01has always been 20-25% of English GDP. So you've got this very large city-state.
- 14:07And you might say, well, what about York? What about Bristol? What about Manchester,
- 14:13Birmingham? Pick your place. Truth is, I think that there were certain problems with these.
- 14:19The English system was very, very centralized. The French system was very centralized.
- 14:26And both of these systems didn't lead to the establishment of independent cities. I think
- 14:31London just by virtue of size and history had been able to kind of hold its own.
- 14:36which is in contrast for example to the holy roman empire the hanseatic league the northern
- 14:42italian city states which were you know proper city states but you know london had its own
- 14:48militia in fact we still have a police force today because we always had our own militia
- 14:52and we are what's called incorporated by prescription from time immemorial that's our
- 14:58legal status so we're allowed to do anything we can prove that we did before the time of
- 15:03Richard the Lionheart. So that's a kind of an encapsulated version of it. But to say city-state
- 15:09is far too strong to assert your rights, if they did exist even in law, would be unrealistic in
- 15:17the modern era. So it is slightly anachronistic, but it does give us a little bit of freedom of
- 15:22movement. And I think that's particularly important because in a centralized system like
- 15:27the British system, it's actually difficult to relate to other cities. And having the city of
- 15:32London, which is four times larger than the next European city, able to link up directly with other
- 15:38cities around the world is a good thing and gives Britain, you know, an extra degree of freedom
- 15:42and diplomacy. So to get it straight, because I like to, I want to formulate a sort of a picture
- 15:52of this in my mind, was when the city of London was uninhabited for that 200 year period, were the
- 16:01Were people living where they were living?
- 16:03Were they also within the boundary of,
- 16:06was there a walled boundary?
- 16:08Like why weren't they using the city of London?
- 16:09That seems to.
- 16:10Well, so they were living at broadly,
- 16:14basically what we would today call fleet streets.
- 16:16So they kind of moved to the West
- 16:18and they clearly were using a port,
- 16:20the fleet to do the port work that they did.
- 16:24A lot of curiosity as to whether or not
- 16:26London Bridge had always been a block.
- 16:27You couldn't get north of London Bridge
- 16:29with the sailing ship anyway.
- 16:30sorry I'm saying not north you couldn't get west of London Bridge with a sailing ship so it was
- 16:35always a bit of a block there so this is a kind of a it's it's a very misty period between 400 and
- 16:40600. Why weren't they using the walls? Well this is where you get into medieval defenses and again
- 16:46I'm not a Tudor historian I'm not a medieval historian I'm not a military historian but the
- 16:52way that it's been explained to me when you've got a walled city it's actually hard to defend if you
- 16:58have sufficient numbers of people because somebody kind of just comes in the backside while you're
- 17:03sort of trying to defend the front side. And one of the legends about the 20,000 people on the wall
- 17:10is that the sheriffs got out old women and things and put armor on them and they were all up on the
- 17:15walls roaring, you know. And from where William was, it's just a lot of people. But if he'd only
- 17:22seen sort of a third of the wall occupied. He might have been tempted to split forces,
- 17:28go around, divide them. And that's where it gets to become hard.
- 17:32And still trying to get this vision in my mind, what was the population of London area at that
- 17:40point? Are we talking about when you say that the conurbation moved to Fleet Street, for example,
- 17:45was that just that area and then nothing else? Or was it a case of London was relatively sprawling,
- 17:51not as much obviously anywhere near what it is today, but was it obvious when the City of London was re-inhabited
- 17:59that it was a separate place to the growing city of the rest of London, if you see what I mean?
- 18:05Yes, it does appear that people left London Vic by and large and moved into the city, therefore leaving it empty.
- 18:14And this comes back if you look at a lot of the maps from 1066 onwards.
- 18:21You'll see there's this little sliver strip connecting London with the palaces at Westminster and not much else.
- 18:27So they had pretty much moved back in.
- 18:30Equally, though, you're talking about very small populations here.
- 18:35They could put 20 adults on the wall which would imply at best 30 as the population of the city in 1066 The city population is running at around 30 as late as the early 1500s In fact the largest city in Europe in the early 1500s
- 18:52was Antwerp with about 100,000.
- 18:55And do you happen to know if it was a conscious decision
- 18:58to maintain the city of London as the city of London
- 19:01while the rest of London as a whole grew
- 19:05and became political and became, you know, all those things?
- 19:09There were a number of things, particularly throughout the 1700s as the city walls started to become very, very occupied, when there were discussions with central government back and forth.
- 19:23And you had various factions saying we should be the governing body of London as it expands into villages outside.
- 19:30And others who said strictly let's stick to the city.
- 19:33That second group sticking strictly to the city won out.
- 19:37you could argue it was a bad thing. You know, a lot of people like to make land grabs. I certainly
- 19:43see that on television a lot these days, you know, expanding is a good thing. There's another
- 19:48argument that in a centralized nation, it's very difficult to maintain a power center in the
- 19:55capital. It just leads to conflict. So take America and Washington, D.C. It's very difficult
- 20:04for Washington to establish something, whereas mayors of New York or Chicago or LA can establish
- 20:10positions of power.
- 20:12But to have two powerful people in a single city frequently leads to trouble.
- 20:17So I think restricting the city was probably a realistic outcome for London.
- 20:24And you can see some of the struggles that London has had over the years with the precursor
- 20:30of the GLA and Ken Livingston, and then later Boris Johnson and Sadiq Khan. These are complicated
- 20:36positions when the Parliament is sitting there in the Capitol at the same time.
- 20:44So what is the day-to-day relationship between the City of London and London then on the whole?
- 20:52I mean, I lived in London for eight years. I worked on Fleet Street. I worked for a newspaper.
- 20:58and we i it was you know i thought i knew quite a lot about london and i knew there was a for
- 21:04example a private police force here because whenever we were here i was a photographer
- 21:08there was and there was private land that was i remember people thinking well that shouldn't be
- 21:14private land you know that's a walkway i should i should be out of you know so there's a lot of
- 21:19mystery about it and the corporation of london and what it means etc etc so what is the actual
- 21:26day-to-day relationship between, you know, say.
- 21:31Well, I've always described the City of London as a democratic workers in residence, cooperative.
- 21:38We really kind of control the area.
- 21:41And so concepts of private probably don't apply in the way that you just implied, but
- 21:46that they're owned by the corporation.
- 21:47Yes.
- 21:48But that's a body that is representing those people who work in the city and the 8,000
- 21:54residents.
- 21:54So those who have the vote.
- 21:57And again, this is an interesting bit about as a workers' cooperative and all those structures
- 22:01I spoke about, hustings and folkments and all that, the Anglo-Saxons really had this
- 22:06concept of people had a right to vote.
- 22:09But they focused typically on economically productive people.
- 22:13So the early franchise didn't come to you because you had property, which is again a
- 22:17modern notion that if I have property, then I get the vote.
- 22:19In fact, there it was, well, you can have property and not get the vote.
- 22:23You would be unlikely to have property though if you weren't economically productive, so
- 22:26the two came together.
- 22:27But you could be economically productive without property and get the vote.
- 22:31And it was really the were you usefully contributing that got you the vote.
- 22:35And that was kind of important.
- 22:37It was still today.
- 22:38So our workers have the vote.
- 22:41It's a complicated system with one in 10 votes per worker as opposed to residents with a
- 22:46full vote.
- 22:47But broadly, that's the concept.
- 22:50And I go through that because that then leads you into a discussion on this idea of public and private, even with the police force.
- 23:00So the police force, I'm not trying to play games here, you know, it's there to support the workers and residents who are in the city.
- 23:09It's not a private force.
- 23:11Whereas, for example, we have private security forces out at Canary Wharf, but that's a private security force, not a police force.
- 23:19and our police force is therefore public.
- 23:21Relations.
- 23:23Well, relations with London, wider London, are very, very good.
- 23:28We host a government dinner every year for all 32 boroughs,
- 23:32and Sadiq Khan, whoever is the mayor of London, is the primary person.
- 23:37Speaking alongside the Lord Mayor,
- 23:40we raise quite substantial amounts of tax money,
- 23:43well over a billion on our land,
- 23:45And we give, I believe last count was 90% of that goes or over 90% goes to other boroughs.
- 23:51So a lot of the stuff that people say the city is very rich and it's ceremonial and it pays for ceremonies.
- 23:56I wouldn't claim you're rich, but we do have ceremonies and we do have medieval funds that we're spending on that.
- 24:03But actually as a local government, the local government functions.
- 24:06So we are not a local government.
- 24:08We have local authority powers.
- 24:10But those powers are exercised well within the tax break.
- 24:13We benchmark ourselves and give the surplus, because we don't have as many schools, we have very few roads.
- 24:20So we benchmark ourselves in that, and that is then given into the general pot for London.
- 24:26It's an often unremarked point that we actually do hand those monies out.
- 24:33Personal relations, honestly, I like Sadiq Khan, and I wouldn't claim that we're talking to each other every day or anything,
- 24:39but get on very well with them when I was Lord Mayor.
- 24:41I understand. Well, I know that my predecessor did well, and I assume my successor is doing well.
- 24:47So relations are really quite smooth because everybody wants to help greater London. We were
- 24:52big supporters when Ken Livingston wanted to get his bikes going. We were enormous supporters of
- 24:58Crossrail, putting in seed money to help get that going. So, you know, our interests and the interests
- 25:04of greater London are almost always very closely aligned. But Sadiq has a very different set of
- 25:10powers because of the way that the GLA has been constructed with the other boroughs.
- 25:15Anyway, I'm probably at the end.
- 25:16This is probably something for Tony Travers, who's the great LSE professional in London.
- 25:21I'm fascinated because it's a bit of an anomaly, I suppose, really, to think in terms of
- 25:28the city of London being a separate entity.
- 25:32I think it's interesting because, like you mentioned that if you show productivity,
- 25:39you have a vote here if you're a resident, right?
- 25:42What do you vote on?
- 25:45And do people vote?
- 25:46I mean, do people who live in houses here
- 25:50go and vote on things and stuff here?
- 25:51Yes, very much so.
- 25:53Well, the majority of it,
- 25:55I can't recall us ever holding a referendum.
- 25:58It was certainly not in my time, perhaps,
- 26:00and some historian will correct me.
- 26:02But no, you're typically voting for your common councillor,
- 26:05your alderman.
- 26:05This used to be an annual thing to vote for common council and aldermen are elected for
- 26:11six years in kind of a senatorial type system.
- 26:14In fact, aldermen are really elected for life legally, but we make a pledge that we will
- 26:19stand down every six years for reelection rather than having to run a new bill through
- 26:24parliament.
- 26:25And we've adhered to that for, I forget, something like 30 or 40 years.
- 26:30The common councilors used to be elected every single year, but that changed a few years back
- 26:34Now they're elected every four years.
- 26:36Again, every year was getting a bit silly.
- 26:38So elections are very big in the city, and I think we've calmed them down to the point
- 26:42that they now make sense.
- 26:45Every four years is about right.
- 26:46So that's what the residents are doing.
- 26:48The wards themselves are quite tiny.
- 26:50So I have in my ward of Broad Street, three common counselors.
- 26:55There's a hundred common counselors in total.
- 26:57So that would work out to be four per ward plus one alderman.
- 27:01So three is a little bit smaller than average.
- 27:03I think the largest one has 10, next one down eight.
- 27:06So you can kind of get some feel for the range of voters in it.
- 27:10And that roughly, in my case, equates to between around just under 25,000 workers and I think about 26 residents.
- 27:18So I have what's called a business ward.
- 27:21And then there are other wards where the residents are more numerous.
- 27:24And so you get a flavor there.
- 27:27I, of course, you know, in running for office, I'm really going on things.
- 27:31therefore probably of more interest to the business person which is rubbish, crime,
- 27:39bicycles that are in the way or violating the law. Obviously they'd like to have their taxes
- 27:45and rates reduced but they're not onerous so that actually doesn't come up as much as you might think
- 27:49it did. And then they're very interested and this is where the city begins to establish its unique
- 27:54character. The workers are very interested in what we're doing to represent and build business.
- 28:00What are we doing with incubators?
- 28:02What are we doing with international trade delegations What are we doing on regulation and financial services or AI or whatever So they want to see us promoting the city that way The residents are
- 28:15you know, typical residents. They want to make sure they're living in a clean environment. So
- 28:19even as an alderman, you do quite a bit. Things like what takes up my time, rubbish. A lot of my
- 28:26time is taken up on noise problems, light problems, people blocking light on each other.
- 28:33I've had issues to do with broadband, broadband, broadband, you know, to be the world's capital
- 28:39city and to have what I think I would describe as mediocre broadband is not the finest.
- 28:45We had a lot of problems with shredder vans over the years. These are vans that drive into the city
- 28:50and insist that they're doing on-site shredding, which means they pull up on the footpath and then
- 28:55they start their engine up. I call them, you know, kind of portable particulate polluters
- 28:59because they come in and when they should just take the stuff out and shred it outside. But
- 29:03the law firm or whatever says, you know, you must shred it on site. So we have a lot of these kinds
- 29:09of little things. And then of course we, the city does manage a lot of wider things. So we manage
- 29:14800 acres up at Hampstead Heath. We manage Epping Forest, the walls of dairy. There are a lot of
- 29:21little bits of Bob's around the country, which the city has volunteered to manage our support
- 29:26over the centuries. And those two come up. And so we have a very rich panoply of things to do.
- 29:32What about things like regulations, though? I mean, do you have any kind of regulatory autonomy?
- 29:40In the...
- 29:41I mean, say you mentioned the businesses are often obviously very interested in what you're
- 29:48doing for business. Can you adapt regulation of the wider British or English regulation?
- 29:55The strict answer is it depends. So under the original Markets Act, I think it was at six and
- 30:04a quarter miles or six miles and 345 pace or something like that. The idea was that a farmer
- 30:12could go to market in the city, and this would be regulated.
- 30:16So you could walk in, sell some stuff, and come home.
- 30:19That was the deal.
- 30:21And the city had a monopoly on the regulation of all markets in that area.
- 30:26Now, today, that extends to Smithfield, Billingsgate,
- 30:31and New Spitalfields, which is just inside that.
- 30:37And so, therefore, we're regulating fish.
- 30:39were regulating beef, chicken, and meats,
- 30:44and were regulating fruit and veg in those markets.
- 30:47But there was a time when those markets were everything.
- 30:50Now, you'll say, well, technically you're regulating them,
- 30:54but they're not that vital, is what some might argue.
- 30:58That did extend in the olden days into a variety of other areas,
- 31:02which got very confusing.
- 31:04For example, the early stock exchanges,
- 31:06a lot of the things that went on in the Royal Exchange, the original insurance markets.
- 31:12And a lot of this, when I came to the city in the 80s, very early 80s, was run through what were
- 31:17called SROs, self-regulatory organizations. So Lloyd's was one because it runs the markets for
- 31:23insurance. It's not an insurer, it runs the markets for it. But there were ones for the
- 31:27independent financial advisors, for the stockbrokers, for the pensions providers.
- 31:31This was swept away in 1998 from memory in a long debate running when labor took power in 1997 and wanted to create a unitary financial services regulator.
- 31:46financial services being just under 40% of what we do, that clearly is a large chunk of our
- 31:51regulatory remit. If we had thought that we could do it because these were markets within
- 31:58a day's walk or half a day's walk, fine. In truth, it's worked out as a kind of a
- 32:04very much a national thing. So our work in regulation in financial services is mostly
- 32:11focused on lobbying for things we think are for the good of the industry or the good of the country.
- 32:16And that's a different thing than the idea that we are the regulator, which in days gone by, we did have a role in regulation, but that's over a generation ago.
- 32:28So you wouldn't find, for example, NatWest, someone in one of the buildings, one of the companies having slightly different regulatory powers.
- 32:40Is that something that people wonder about?
- 32:43I mean, presumably the opportunity legally might be there if you looked into it, if you really looked into it.
- 32:53But better than anywhere.
- 32:55Very slim.
- 32:56Very slim.
- 32:57But I think where this leads us to is what is regulation?
- 33:02Because a lot of people seem to focus on regulation as solely a government prerogative.
- 33:07and if you've really been tuned into this we've been running these markets for hundreds of years
- 33:14and so self-forming markets do not need national regulation and i and i point repeatedly to what i
- 33:21call community-enforced standards markets which are what the srls were the self-regulatory
- 33:26organizations had good and bad and there'll be people out there muttering uh oh you know this
- 33:32guy's going on but he's forgotten about maxwell and the pension scandal no i haven't there were
- 33:37scandals under the SROs, but there's some pretty big scandals that go on today.
- 33:41So I could go about RBS, GRG, I could go on about PPI.
- 33:45So the form of regulation is intriguing, but when you look at a variety of areas even more
- 33:52deeply, so if you take, for example, food safety, maritime sector, petroleum products,
- 34:00A lot of areas are handled by the ISO standard system, which has within it quite a rich grouping.
- 34:09So I call it community-enforced standards markets because these tend to arise because people in an industry want to have a good industry.
- 34:18And there's a tension there between wanting to keep the cowboys out and having standards that are too high that you can't make money.
- 34:25And the best people to interpret that in many cases are the people in the industry.
- 34:30So take food safety. So you're eating prawns from Vietnam that have been shipped across the world. Well, there was a lab in Vietnam that tested them. Then they were packaged according to international standards. Then they were transported and they needed to be refrigerated to particular standards. And the people who did that met a standard for transportation under temperature and blah, blah, blah. And then they came here and then they were on your supermarket shelf and then you bought them with a sell-by date and the contents of where they came from.
- 34:58Now, the way that the governments run that is they say you will adhere to the ISO standards.
- 35:05If you break them and we find out, then all heck will break loose, which is fair enough.
- 35:12There are criminal and civil sanctions for breaking those rules.
- 35:17However, the government regulatory element of it is actually to let those standards evolve.
- 35:22So if there's a new standard for labeling or there's a new standard for determining colors on prawns where your pink prawns are no longer pink because they've outlawed the coloring agent or whatever, that's all being done largely through the international system, not by the British government.
- 35:38And the British government, quite rightly, adds to that a layer of food inspectors and
- 35:43all, but they're sampling.
- 35:46They're trying to make sure, in essence, that the private auditors who are also in the system
- 35:51are doing their job.
- 35:53So the system consists of a body of standards run typically through the WTO and ISO, but
- 36:01sometimes originating as national standards.
- 36:03In Britain, we have BS standards.
- 36:04The aspiration for most BS standards is that they will become an international standard or merge with other ones.
- 36:12Then the standards are separate from the inspectors, and the inspectors are of two types.
- 36:18There are the accreditors, typically one accreditation agency per nation.
- 36:23Here is the United Kingdom Accreditation Service, and I'm not executive on that.
- 36:27And then we have certifiers.
- 36:30So the accreditor is not allowed to check people to the standard.
- 36:34the accreditor is only allowed to check that the certifier is good for certifying.
- 36:39Why is that? Because we want to keep competition in the system.
- 36:42And so we will often have many certifiers for one line.
- 36:46And there are many specialist lines, you know, asbestos removal,
- 36:50I mentioned petroleum products, electrical products, grading systems for roadworks.
- 36:58We have 800 certification bodies in Britain.
- 37:00And then those rely on laboratories,
- 37:04which we also accredit, and there are about 3,500 of those
- 37:07is one reasonably good estimate.
- 37:10But as the accreditation body, we are quite tight.
- 37:13We're only about 350 people,
- 37:15because we're just making sure these people
- 37:17are competent to do the checking,
- 37:18and then they go out and do all the checking
- 37:21in a competitive environment, which industry appreciates,
- 37:24because it's unlike a government inspector,
- 37:27when the government inspectors do come in
- 37:29areas and there are certain areas where government inspectors come in they just tell you how much
- 37:33they're going to charge you that's tough um well i mean i think the the common sort of the lay person
- 37:41would see regulation as something the government does to business so you're saying on the whole
- 37:46the market is is is generating these things in its own self-interest it's a i've actually i think
- 37:54the average person thought of that i've had unfortunately i'm the lay person and i just
- 37:58assume that it's some conniving government telling me what to do and what I can and can't do.
- 38:02And again, it depends on the business year. And so if you're running a security
- 38:06thing, supplying nightclubs and pubs as security guards, you will know that you've got to get them
- 38:13all certified and authorized. Well, that's all private sector stuff. The government has said,
- 38:17we'd like to make sure that security guards are authorized and happy to deal with that system.
- 38:25Corgi gas, for some of you are older people, you might remember.
- 38:29I do remember, yeah.
- 38:30That was a private sector system.
- 38:33A few cowboys, so to speak, had blown up some tower blocks,
- 38:37and the gas industry said, if we don't get this under control, nobody's going to buy gas.
- 38:42Isn't it true in maritime law as well?
- 38:45It's all generated by the market, and it's all enforced by...
- 38:51I know it would be enforced by the flag of the ship, wouldn't it?
- 38:56Really.
- 38:57It's really enforced by the harbour master.
- 39:00No, but I mean, I often, we talk a lot about cruise ships on this podcast because they're
- 39:05a really interesting model of a private city, basically.
- 39:08They are a floaty private city.
- 39:11And as a result, it's a brilliant example because nobody goes onto a cruise ship thinking they're
- 39:18They're walking into a private governance model and they don't actually care who's in charge.
- 39:23They care they're getting a good service from the ship, which is basically.
- 39:27And as a result, the ship doesn't want to kill anyone, doesn't want to hurt anyone, doesn't want to, you know.
- 39:32And the regulations adhere to that.
- 39:35But there's no one, you know, there's no one walking around the ship making sure XYZ is happening.
- 39:40It's a really interesting example of basically what a lot of people in the free cities movement would like to see on land more.
- 39:50That kind of free market city.
- 39:53Well, we could talk in a minute or two about how they could promote that because I would promote that.
- 39:59But I would argue that they haven't quite understood how regulation already works.
- 40:03Now, on a cruise ship, that's a really interesting area.
- 40:07Well, ships in general are very interesting.
- 40:08so the international maritime organization the IMO is based here in London it's the only UN
- 40:15entity based in the UK as its headquarters remember it has no navy it has no coast guard
- 40:25so it's a good talking shop where people get together and discuss the issues that they face
- 40:31and what they want to do and it can only move as fast as the average not the slowest member but
- 40:37And it's made great strides, in my opinion, on areas like low sulfur, on fuel efficiency, on reducing maritime noise for cetaceans.
- 40:51It's actually done a lot, but it's got to talk.
- 40:54And then they typically work through standards.
- 40:58But who enforces those standards?
- 41:00And it is really mostly the harbor master.
- 41:03So when you go into a harbor, a typical ship like one of your cruise ships will probably have about 50 or 60 certificates of various forms.
- 41:13There'll be a load line exemption on the techniques of the vessel, whether the vessel complies with maritime safety rules, riding rules, moments, all that.
- 41:23There will be food safety because there's food on board.
- 41:25So they'll have various certificates showing that they have been audited typically by a private sector organization.
- 41:33that is internationally recognized.
- 41:35So the BSI could do it for any ship,
- 41:38SGS, Yarsley, Bureau of Veritas,
- 41:41TUV, and Deutschland.
- 41:43So these will come on.
- 41:44And the harbormaster, it's up to the harbormaster
- 41:46to decide whether she or he accepts such a certificate.
- 41:49And they accept it from a credible organization.
- 41:52Certificate is typically backed up with insurance,
- 41:54which they also wish to see.
- 41:55So the insurer says to the ship,
- 41:57I'm not insuring you if you don't meet the standards,
- 42:00but I'm an insurer.
- 42:01I don't know how to run a kitchen.
- 42:02So just meet the food safety standards and the inspections on that.
- 42:07And that's the enforcement.
- 42:08So when you're on the high seas, yes, there's nobody walking around on deck.
- 42:12Or let me be more accurate, nobody needs to walk around on deck.
- 42:16Of course, a proper ship does actually have a lot of inspectors on board who make sure that things are being done the right way in fire safety, fire inspection, man overboard drills, lifeboat drills, et cetera.
- 42:28And the system is, therefore, largely private.
- 42:31But a ship is absolutely useless if you can't get into a port.
- 42:35So the harbormasters really do have a lot of control, and they don't want to let you
- 42:39into a port if you're going to be dumping a bunch of sick people, or you're going to
- 42:42be discharging waste into their harbor, or if you're so badly crude that you smash into
- 42:47other ships.
- 42:48This is just a harbormaster's nightmare.
- 42:50So it's they who say, you can't come in until you've met all of the international standards.
- 42:55Also, unlike other cities, land-based cities, they face the problem of people leaving very, very easily and choosing another city as well or choosing another ship because there's plenty of them.
- 43:09I mean, I really love it as a model.
- 43:12It's beautiful because it has all the characteristics of me personally,
- 43:17how I would like to see cities competing with each other.
- 43:21Ease of coming and going so that there's a pressure there to be a good city.
- 43:26And at the same time, having regulations which are derived from keeping people happy, basically.
- 43:33Well, you know, I've got a fairly strong IT background.
- 43:36and people in IT would say, oh, this never happens in IT. But it does. I mean, things are inspected
- 43:42before they leave the shop. We have the CE mark for all of the kit and equipment. But when you
- 43:47look at the kind of, there's a whole set of standards where you want to plug into a network
- 43:52and you can only plug into the network if you meet its protocol. I see you've got a Bitcoin pin on.
- 43:58So, you know, a Bitcoin pin is a pretty good example. You could, I'm going to write my own
- 44:03Bitcoin system and tell Bitcoin what to do. Well, that's sweet, but it's not going to get you very
- 44:06far. So a lot of the CIT standards, you can't do something if you don't meet that standard.
- 44:16I might argue you'd be better to call that a protocol because the protocol sort of is take
- 44:21it or leave it. There's just no way to participate in the system unless you do it. And the standards
- 44:26tend to need a bit more auditing because people are tempted to cheat, cut a little bit, put
- 44:32too much water in your prawns or color them with something that you didn't want to actually eat if
- 44:36you knew what it was. So it's that kind of a system. And it's protocol on the one hand is
- 44:41tough. You'll just have to follow it whether you like it or not. Standard is kind of,
- 44:46we got to make sure you follow it. Well, I say the problem with protocols,
- 44:53it's not a problem with protocols. In the sense of free cities and the idea of
- 44:59independent jurisdictions, at the moment, it's very difficult to decide to create a new protocol
- 45:05and try it out, which is one of the issues we talk about so much on this podcast. What is your
- 45:11opinion on the idea of private cities, for example? Do you know about Prospera,
- 45:17usually? Are you in favor or against? Do you think it's a good, bad idea?
- 45:24I'm not in favor. I'm not against. I don't know enough about protocol to comment on it,
- 45:28But I did, for example, mention Canary Wharf earlier.
- 45:30You know, that's a good example.
- 45:32There are lots of gated communities.
- 45:34So there's a whole spectrum of kind of, I run a little extra security force to keep my neighborhood safe.
- 45:40And we all voluntarily pay up a bit to this is an isolated area and I'm in charge of it.
- 45:45And I'm responsible for all the planning and things.
- 45:48I've got no qualms.
- 45:50I'm really into experimentation.
- 45:51And I feel one of the problems we're facing in the world is the increasing over-centralization of many forces and how do we engage local democracy.
- 46:03Now, I've got no specific answers to that.
- 46:07I've long been a proponent of land value tax, but that's because I believe that it's a better way to look at taxation and keeping the tax revenues local, but also encouraging the locals to make the most of it, which has always been the problem.
- 46:21I mean, in Britain, we're running, I forget the exact number, but I know it's over 90% and I believe well over 90% of the funds that local governments raise are given to the central government.
- 46:31And then they get back according to a formula.
- 46:33Not very motivational in terms of trying to improve your local area to increase your tax take.
- 46:40And this is the sort of area where land value tax begins to really play.
- 46:44I think the city of London does exhibit elements of land value tax I trying to remember how much of the city we own I think it probably around the 10 mark But the idea has always been I think the city strategy that we want
- 46:59to create prosperity, which is why we work so hard with businesses. Because if you don't
- 47:05have prosperity, you don't have anything. Once you've got that prosperity, how do you
- 47:09reinvest it? Well, I think you reinvest it in two ways. One is improving the physical
- 47:13environment, and the second is improving the business environment so that you attract more
- 47:17business and more people.
- 47:19And then we believe strongly in the idea that you're sharing that prosperity around.
- 47:24So we do a lot on charity work, City Bridges Trust, and the delivery companies give away,
- 47:31I think it's 85 million a year.
- 47:32The city gives away another significant sum.
- 47:35So we're looking at well around the 150 million mark, something like that, of funds dispersed
- 47:41to try and help those who are not as well off.
- 47:44So it's a good virtuous system.
- 47:47And then within that, even though we are a city,
- 47:50I would argue we have four things on our mind.
- 47:53One is the rule of law.
- 47:56Second one is defense and security.
- 47:57Third is access to talent and skills.
- 48:00And the fourth one is open and fair trade.
- 48:04You know, a city-state tends to follow
- 48:06traditional economic liberal principles
- 48:09and likes things like you want property rights, you want free speech, you want individual rights,
- 48:15but those in turn imply control, keeping government at a reasonable level.
- 48:22I'm not saying small government or large government, but definitely not just government for its own sake.
- 48:27Then moving on to open and fair trade very much comes out of that and free movement.
- 48:33So you've got kind of three what I'd call ethical principles,
- 48:36the individual rights free speech and property rights and those then imply economic principles
- 48:42now in our case if i go back to the four that i mentioned earlier as i started let me reverse
- 48:47defense and security never forget it a lot of people do you know and you know your your um
- 48:56cruise ship you know needs to repel borders there's got to be a way to do it uh in our case
- 49:02it's fairly obvious. People don't bring money to a war zone. But in addition to that, they don't
- 49:08bring money to a cybersecurity hazard either. So we do use our police force, and our police force
- 49:14is in fact the national cyber and national anti-fraud element. So those are important to us,
- 49:20and we're prepared to spend on that. Second thing is on the rule of law. Again,
- 49:25a bit like regulation. For most people, this means a judge in a courtroom.
- 49:29Well, that's certainly the case in criminal, but when you come to civil, in fact, going
- 49:36near a courtroom is a bad thing.
- 49:38Commercial people really don't want to go near courtrooms if they can avoid it.
- 49:43So the very tail end of that is seen in the courtroom, but there are a lot of disputes.
- 49:48And those are typically handled through arbitration, mediation, conciliation from time to time,
- 49:54expert determination.
- 49:55These things are settled out of court, not because there's a court case, but just settled
- 49:59long before the court cases arise.
- 50:03So it's a huge thing.
- 50:04And then there's just a general environment that you need of my word is my bond.
- 50:09Do you really want to do business in a place where every time somebody says something to
- 50:14you, they're up to something?
- 50:15So it actually benefits everybody to have a certain level of norms.
- 50:20I hate to use the word trust because that's a very loaded word.
- 50:23But I know I can rely on both things here, and I'll just be a little careful as opposed
- 50:28to I'm so careful that I never actually can contract a deal with anyone because I can't
- 50:32trust anyone, then the whole of commerce collapses.
- 50:36So we want that.
- 50:37I think access to talent and skills speaks for itself, and open and fair trade, there's
- 50:42no point in doing it.
- 50:44And I sum all that up as treating all comers fairly.
- 50:47But you're at the whim of the, in terms of all those things, you are at the whim of the
- 50:58government, not yourself, your own government.
- 51:00If you want to attract new business, for example, there is a limit to what you can do.
- 51:07You can make the place nice, you can make it secure, but you can't attract people in
- 51:11the same way that, say, something like Prospera could.
- 51:15has a system where you can choose from OEC direct regulations throughout the world. You're here,
- 51:21you're stuck with the UK regulations, you have to do it that way. So what does that actually mean
- 51:25in real time? How is it that you attract people to the city particularly? How is that different
- 51:35from the government giving incentives for business to come to the UK in general, say, for example?
- 51:41in a realistic sense there are going to be conflicts and there are and you know good one
- 51:49would be on immigration so we would like we don't want open access but we definitely want access to
- 51:56the talent skills that we need and once we've decided we need so and so and she's out of
- 52:01bulgaria and we need her to work here we we all whinge if there's any kind of paperwork or cost
- 52:06to it that's outrageous how should i be doing this but but in truth there are going to be
- 52:10conflicts here. Secondly, as I mentioned earlier, we are able to lobby and negotiate with central
- 52:15government, and it's in central government's interest for us to be healthy. So it's not like
- 52:19it's quite a battle or anything like that. It's just people have different priorities. The
- 52:22government's got priorities on keeping boat people out. It's got a national zeitgeist of making sure
- 52:29that people feel that they're being treated fairly. So it's a process of negotiation,
- 52:33and I think, bluntly, Prospero, when it gets bigger, we'll start to find that those problems
- 52:39will arise as well. So when it comes to us locally attracting business, well, clearly we're not doing
- 52:47it on actually having lower taxes or anything, but we're doing it on our adherence to those four
- 52:52principles. So we do a lot on arbitration, mediation, and civil, much more than I think
- 52:58people realize. There's a whole court system up at Rawls. The London Chamber of Commerce runs the
- 53:04the Chamber of Arbitration and Mediation.
- 53:09So at that level, we're doing quite a bit on the rule of law.
- 53:11I mentioned the police, but also our emphasis on cyber essentials, all sorts of things that
- 53:16we do to try and lock down there.
- 53:19So we're doing a lot.
- 53:20We're also doing a heck of a lot on trying to improve the built environment, which takes
- 53:24time.
- 53:25But one of the great things I'm very proud of is over the last 15, 20 years, we've seen
- 53:30the re-emergence of many of the little old alleyways.
- 53:33Well, the re-emergence of alleyways,
- 53:35they may not be the same old ones,
- 53:36that you can now walk through the city.
- 53:38It's more permeable.
- 53:40And then we have many plans to increase that.
- 53:42One of the other things we do a lot of is,
- 53:46my theme last year's Lord Mayor was Connect to Prosper,
- 53:49trying to celebrate the many connections that we make.
- 53:52So we like to make more connections.
- 53:55So even things like the permeable areas,
- 53:58you and I run into each other in an alley,
- 54:00hey, Tim, good to see you. What's happening? And we try and increase that. We have the livery
- 54:03company movement, which is 50,000 strong, making sure people meet at that level. We support all
- 54:09sorts of clubs and associations. We hold conferences, Gloria, our Innovate Finance
- 54:14conferences, our tech conferences, et cetera. Level 39 over at Canary Wharf was half funded
- 54:20by the city because we wanted to increase the connectivity on fintech. So we're always doing
- 54:25things to make people meet each other. And all those make London a very attractive place.
- 54:30I can genuinely vouch that a lot of people who've left London for other places have come back
- 54:35because it just lacks the vibrancy. Maybe the taxes are a bit high, maybe it's a little dirty,
- 54:41but you know what? I miss the buzz. And I'm sick and tired of kind of going from office block to
- 54:48office block for a formal meeting and not actually meeting anybody or having new things in my life.
- 54:53It's that novelty and new connections that we try and foster. So there's a lot that we can and do do.
- 54:59as an entity here in the centre.
- 55:04I've still got loads of questions about the City of London,
- 55:08but I want to move on because I think we're going to end up
- 55:10speaking for too long on that particular subject,
- 55:12and I'm sure I've heard you talk about this kind of stuff before.
- 55:15But something that I did find interesting
- 55:18and that I'd never heard of before is,
- 55:21and Peter mentioned this to me in the context of what you do here.
- 55:27It's ZN, right?
- 55:28yeah and he he he described this phrase dilemma analysis which i'd never heard of before can you
- 55:36talk a little bit about that and what it what it is what it means and yeah and then i'm gonna and
- 55:43then depending on what you say i want to ask you some questions about um it was i'd never heard of
- 55:47it before um so i think when i looked it up as well it was also called um it had another name but
- 55:54But maybe you could explain it in terms of dilemma analysis.
- 55:57Well, yeah, you can start with dilemmas, and you can move on to trilemmas and quadrilemmas
- 56:01and all sorts of things.
- 56:03Yeah I think Xion very much was set up 30 years ago 31 years ago and it was set up as a commercial think tank to try and go out and find problems to solve that would keep us all busy and interested We had no shortage So we done a lot in the climate change space
- 56:22We've done a lot on funding of SMEs.
- 56:26We've done a lot on developing countries' growth.
- 56:29We're probably most famous these days for running three fairly large indices.
- 56:33One is called the Smart Centers Index.
- 56:36and this is looking at how commercial centers are good at taking advantage of ideas and innovation
- 56:43and deploying technology. So it's not smart cities in the sense of, you know, are the traffic lights
- 56:49wired operating? It's much more about smart centers. And we have our global financial centers
- 56:53index, which is looking at how good the center is for deploying finance and taking advantage of new
- 57:01financial products, and the two overlap a lot. And we have our global green finance index,
- 57:05which is looking at that specific area.
- 57:08We're currently looking at a new creative services industry as well.
- 57:12And so our advice tends to be to go into centres.
- 57:15We track about 140 cities and advise them on how to improve what they're doing.
- 57:21So it's quite related, oddly, mentally to the work that I do individually at the corporation.
- 57:28But the ideas behind what Peter called dilemma analysis,
- 57:33which was that there are certain problems which the solution to which is not apparent because there are conflicting things working against each other.
- 57:45Is that a good way to describe it?
- 57:47Yeah, it is.
- 57:48We would probably term those wicked problems.
- 57:50Yes, wicked problems.
- 57:51That was the other, yes.
- 57:53But wicked as in, not as in evil.
- 57:56Wicked just because hard to crack.
- 57:58Nor the Wizard of Oz or anything.
- 57:59No, it's wicked.
- 58:00The term originated in two sectors. One was aerospace, and the other was actually urban planning in the 50s and 60s in America.
- 58:11And those are the two areas where they realized that there are a lot of problems that are messy, aggressive, and circular.
- 58:19And it's a bit like the old Irish expression, I wouldn't start from here to get there.
- 58:24You know, it's this, you know, what do I do? And we've got tons of democracy and local democracy we spoke about.
- 58:30earlier, new types of voting systems, how to handle poverty.
- 58:36You know, I look at the 17 Sustainable Development Goals and go, well, there's a whole list of
- 58:40things the world would like to solve.
- 58:42So we're not sure to them.
- 58:44How do you deal with that though?
- 58:46Well, we wrote a book 10 years ago called The Price of Fish, which was all about how
- 58:51to solve wicked problems in economics.
- 58:53we took for our basis of it was
- 58:57we'd seen Feynman's Easy Pieces series
- 59:04where he tries to teach physics simply.
- 59:07And there was a lovely piece of work done by a physicist,
- 59:10David Deutsch, called The Fabric of Reality.
- 59:13And David Deutsch said that the Greeks had a concept of a man,
- 59:17and it was a man, could know everything.
- 59:20What did that mean?
- 59:21well, it didn't mean he knew the name of every chicken in every village.
- 59:25It was more that he had a series of mental tools that allowed him to look at the world and analyze situations.
- 59:36Now, the Greek's tools may have been a little bit crude.
- 59:39Why, oh great Tim, is there thunder?
- 59:42It's because of the thunder god, Michael.
- 59:44Well, that was a good explanation.
- 59:46So there was that.
- 59:47But David then went off onto physics and obviously being into quantum mechanics.
- 59:53Quantum mechanics is one of the disciplines.
- 59:55But interestingly, he picked epistemology, computational, theory, and evolution as the other three.
- 1:00:01So if you understood those four, he felt you could look at physics.
- 1:00:06And I thought that was a great approach.
- 1:00:07And I said, what would it be for economics?
- 1:00:10And so we had a good look at it.
- 1:00:12And I did a series of 29 lectures on it.
- 1:00:16It's your listeners are welcome to go to Gresham College and see.
- 1:00:20But I chose choice, choice theory.
- 1:00:23How do we make decisions?
- 1:00:26Economics was equivalent to his kind of quantum mechanics.
- 1:00:29All the basic stuff's about supply and demand and positional goods and all that.
- 1:00:37Evolution really stands up.
- 1:00:38You've got to look and say, once I get these entities there, what are they likely to do to maximize?
- 1:00:46their lifespan to persist in going, and what are they going to do in terms of spawning new things?
- 1:00:51So very good point, very good overlap. And the last one was systems theory. Now systems theory
- 1:00:57is if I was to pick one area that people aren't taught enough in school, and it wouldn't require
- 1:01:02much, is a very advanced set of techniques for analyzing complex situations and decomposing them.
- 1:01:11And it's from systems theory, largely the chaos theory came and from chaos theory came
- 1:01:18complexity theory.
- 1:01:20And this is ways that people try and look at an environment to take a railway system.
- 1:01:27Our railways are running late, Tim, fix them.
- 1:01:30Where do you start?
- 1:01:32So you've got to start breaking it down to, well, there's tracks and there's delays and
- 1:01:36there's maintenance.
- 1:01:37And that's probably what's causing.
- 1:01:38Hang on.
- 1:01:39Let me look at the timetable.
- 1:01:40Could the timetable change to all that?
- 1:01:43Would it change if we had faster trains?
- 1:01:45Would it change if I could stop the passengers boarding too late so they weren't halting
- 1:01:50the trains?
- 1:01:51You get into, oh my gosh, there's a lot of things.
- 1:01:53Just answer simple question of how do you make the trains run on time?
- 1:01:57And systems theory helps you, gives you a set of very simple tools to decompose that.
- 1:02:01So, I mean, when I looked into it very briefly, I couldn't help thinking that what, say for
- 1:02:09example, a lot of people in the Free Cities movement, what they're trying to solve is very
- 1:02:14much a wicked problem. But it's the problem of governance and the way that we're governed,
- 1:02:20or the way that a place lays out its own rules. And democracy comes up a lot because democracy is
- 1:02:29not the democratic process, at least the one we see currently. A lot of people vote on something
- 1:02:35that gets someone into power that then creates rules.
- 1:02:39In that process, quite a few people are disenfranchised
- 1:02:42because they were, just by the fact they were born in a country,
- 1:02:46suddenly now something is happening in their country
- 1:02:48that they are probably not a part of.
- 1:02:50And one of the ways you solve that is in the private city, for example,
- 1:02:54like a cruise ship, you say, well, here's a contract, sign it,
- 1:02:58this is the rules, abide by the rules.
- 1:03:01If you don't like these rules, there's another one over there.
- 1:03:03There's another city state over there or another free city over there.
- 1:03:06You could go and use that.
- 1:03:08It certainly is a very wicked problem, the problem of governance.
- 1:03:13And I would say probably, from my perspective at least, where we're at in the moment is, I think there are a lot of people unhappy.
- 1:03:22It seems at least in my world, maybe I've probably skewed in one direction.
- 1:03:26But maybe if I went out on the street and said, do you like the way you're being governed to the average person here?
- 1:03:31They probably don't think about it, in all honesty, but amongst people that do think about it, it's a wicked problem.
- 1:03:39And so how would you go about solving it?
- 1:03:42See, my response would be, okay, there's an easy way to begin the process of solving that, and that's create a market of governance.
- 1:03:53We don't really have a very obvious market in governance at the moment.
- 1:04:00You could move to another country, but the governance model is often roughly the same.
- 1:04:07Or you could go somewhere where you really don't want to go, where they've got a terrible governance model.
- 1:04:12So how would you go about solving that?
- 1:04:15And I'd be interested to know what you think might be a good solution if you would sort of...
- 1:04:20Wow. Details, details.
- 1:04:25You're absolutely correct.
- 1:04:27Governance is very much a wicked problem.
- 1:04:29and I would argue it's one of the biggest problems of the day.
- 1:04:34One thing I have muttered is
- 1:04:36it would be really good to have an ISO standard
- 1:04:38for good governance.
- 1:04:42They'd never let it happen.
- 1:04:43Well, ISO would, but the idea...
- 1:04:45That's what I mean.
- 1:04:46Yeah, but ISO would allow it to happen,
- 1:04:48but, you know, who would...
- 1:04:49They wouldn't enforce it.
- 1:04:50Would the mayor of New York accept that he was being shut up?
- 1:04:52Well, it's more like who would enforce it
- 1:04:54because we're relying on them to enforce it on themselves.
- 1:04:57You could in terms of attractiveness, you could say, hey, we're a well-governed town,
- 1:05:02and we've had people in to audit us on it, and we know what the international standard is,
- 1:05:07and we meet it. Many standards start that way. That's what I mean. They're community-enforced
- 1:05:14standards markets. They're not government-enforced, that was my point earlier. And the way to start
- 1:05:19that is through a bit of competition. So if there's a competitive environment, people then
- 1:05:23often reach out for standards, but let's park that one for now, that it's one.
- 1:05:28The second thing is is there a lot of anger and frustration out What was that film Network in 1970 I mad as hell and I not gonna take it anymore I think there is actually quite a bit of that around at the moment in quite a number of countries
- 1:05:43Not all, by the way, but quite a few countries. I was at a breakfast a few weeks ago where some
- 1:05:48champ stood up at a club and ranted on for five minutes at a politician who's not in power.
- 1:05:56And he wasn't being nasty. He was just frustrated. Why can't we get potholes? Why are schools not
- 1:06:01functioning. Why are you? And so there's a lot of that going on at the moment. And that probably is
- 1:06:05an indicator of, is it more or less, or are we just cranky old men? Who knows? But I would have
- 1:06:10argued there does seem to be a fairly high degree of tension. What could be done about it?
- 1:06:16Well, I think the first thing is, I pick on three things if you don't mind. The first one is
- 1:06:22democracy itself. Is voting every four or five years, depending on what your system is,
- 1:06:27really democracy? I mean, how involved are you? You know, you said democracy is we vote people
- 1:06:33into power. Well, is it? I thought it was being involved in things. Now, how could we be more
- 1:06:38involved? So I would encourage your listeners to explore, but maybe not wholly adopt, things like
- 1:06:43liquid democracy and the pirate parties, where, you know, the idea in these, as I express, I'm not
- 1:06:49sure they would express it this way, is that we have transferable votes for the formulation of
- 1:06:54policy in the parties. So you're an expert on the environment. I'm an expert on oil trading.
- 1:07:01I will do the petrochemical thing. You give me your vote. I give you my vote
- 1:07:05for the environment. You give me your vote for chemical trading. We create the policies.
- 1:07:11So you walk into an environmental meeting and say, we're going to, I don't know,
- 1:07:15ban air conditioners, whatever, whatever's on your mind. And you've got 10,000 votes,
- 1:07:20but that's the policy, then we vote on the policy as a whole. And again, I might have transferable
- 1:07:25votes. So everybody's actually being involved in the formations of the policies. Whereas at the
- 1:07:30moment we have kind of a strange situation where we vote people into office and then they kind of
- 1:07:33tell us what their policies are, but they try and put them in a supposedly some type of statement
- 1:07:43of what their policies are before they get into office, their manifesto, but they try and be as
- 1:07:48vague as possible. And then they shift ground. So, you know, it's actually putting it on the
- 1:07:53front foot. The second thing is, you know, being involved in democracy, if you're more frustrated
- 1:07:58now, well, we'll join a political party and political party membership, as you know, is
- 1:08:02through the floor. So am I going to, who am I going to blame? I'm not going to blame anybody,
- 1:08:07but I think we should perhaps pay more attention to working with the parties before the vote.
- 1:08:12And I think the parties could do a lot more things like liquid democracy,
- 1:08:15people's assemblies to engage people beforehand in how they're doing policies rather than,
- 1:08:22well, we won't say what our policy is because if we did, somebody might attack it and then we won't
- 1:08:27get into office. And the key thing is to get into power. I disagree. The key thing is not to get
- 1:08:31into power. The key thing is to have good policies for the nation or the state or the city. So that's
- 1:08:37one element. Second element is there's a popular kind of approach, which I, you know, if only
- 1:08:44Xi Jinping were running this place, or in the old days, at least Mussolini made the
- 1:08:50trains run on time.
- 1:08:52Actually, Mussolini didn't.
- 1:08:53The trains were running on time before him.
- 1:08:55In fact, they deteriorated slightly, well, very, very rapidly at the tail end, but slightly
- 1:09:00under his rule.
- 1:09:02But what I think people are admiring is the consistency of a dictator.
- 1:09:07Once a dictator's made up his or her mind, they tend to follow that through.
- 1:09:11whereas in democracy we're very good at making a decision you know we get up every morning and make
- 1:09:17a different decision and that's the problem so the solution to some of that is inaction and it's
- 1:09:25before people's eyes if they'll look we face this on the climate change front with a lot of flip
- 1:09:30flopping and i wrote a paper over 20 years ago on what i call policy performance bonds so these
- 1:09:38were bonds whose interest rates rose if it turned out that people hadn't managed to meet
- 1:09:45their own policy.
- 1:09:46Now, before I try and make myself sound like a genius, I'm just extending an idea that Margaret
- 1:09:51Thatcher had in 82 when she created inflation-linked bonds.
- 1:09:56So her inflation-linked bonds, if she said inflation was going to be 2% and it was 4%,
- 1:10:02then you got 2% on the bond in addition to whatever the coupon rate was.
- 1:10:07She had to do that because nobody in Europe believed that Britain would actually repay.
- 1:10:11They'd never repaid in full.
- 1:10:13It had always been, you know, lend us a hundred pounds and we'll repay you in, you know, 60 pounds worth of pounds, even though it's a hundred pounds back.
- 1:10:21And so there was a lot of frustration about that.
- 1:10:23And she, she created those.
- 1:10:24And I just said, that's clearly extensible.
- 1:10:27And we've seen a very interesting policy performance bond in Malaysia where the interest rate on the bond goes up if they don't improve education in the state.
- 1:10:35So again, going back to these city states, if you've made a promise, how are you backing
- 1:10:41it up?
- 1:10:42Now, the greatest success we had was in March 22, the government of Chile issued such a
- 1:10:48bond for climate purposes.
- 1:10:50A 20-year bond based on targets eight years out, which was therefore 2030.
- 1:10:57The two targets were a reduction in greenhouse gas emissions from, I think it was 112.3 megatons
- 1:11:04to 95 megatons and an increase in renewables in the grid from 45% to 60.
- 1:11:09So if they don't make that on a straight line to 2030 and from 2030 for another 12 years,
- 1:11:17they pay a higher interest rate.
- 1:11:19So now I'm like, okay, the government of Chile means this.
- 1:11:22When I would traditionally have invested in the energy sector in Chile, I would have maybe
- 1:11:26put 50% in renewables and 50% in fossil fuels.
- 1:11:30But it's pretty clear the government of Chile doesn't want fossil fuels.
- 1:11:34But I still don't fully trust the government, so I'll buy a little bit of the bond, you see.
- 1:11:38Or I'll buy a lot of the bond or whatever.
- 1:11:40So it becomes the proper hedge for the government policy, which if you think about it in this kind of wicked solutions,
- 1:11:47massive, aggressive, and circular, it actually encourages you to go, wait a minute, the government must mean this.
- 1:11:53So you actually accelerate the government policy because everybody's like, no way they're going to change this.
- 1:11:58So you begin to see a rapid bit.
- 1:12:00As I say, that was a $2 billion issue, $2 billion in March 22.
- 1:12:05And they've issued many subsequent issues since with varying targets and things like that.
- 1:12:11Now, that's putting your money where your mouth is.
- 1:12:13And I think a lot of that starts to solve some of this democratic flip-flopping of choice all the time.
- 1:12:20And, of course, it also raises, wait a minute, you wanted a 20-year policy, right?
- 1:12:25And you thought you would just do it when you got out of bed?
- 1:12:28No, so you're forcing the decisions to be made big time.
- 1:12:32And so people are less inclined just to make a snap decision because a snap decision on that's there.
- 1:12:38It also does a lot of good alignment of government timeframes and infrastructure and business timeframes because governments make all these statements.
- 1:12:47You know, we're going to have heat pumps.
- 1:12:49No, we're not.
- 1:12:50We're going to only have EV vehicles.
- 1:12:52No, we're not.
- 1:12:53And these sort of flip-flops really hurt business because business is running on a 20 to 25-year
- 1:12:58timeframe.
- 1:12:59So if government wants people to make 20 to 25-year decisions, then it should too.
- 1:13:04And I think you could see that at city, state, and national levels.
- 1:13:07And it is happening.
- 1:13:09These bonds have come out in Chile, Uruguay has copied them, Thailand issued an environmental
- 1:13:13one in November.
- 1:13:14And I think it will happen.
- 1:13:16Yeah, I mean, the problem is, like you say, the flip-flopping happens because the system
- 1:13:26now works with a strategy of the important thing is to be in power, not the important
- 1:13:32thing is to have a particular policy.
- 1:13:35So it becomes a game of winning the election and nothing else.
- 1:13:41And as a result, on the whole, and you can say whatever you want to win the election
- 1:13:45these days it appears and then almost i mean america's just happened in america as well so
- 1:13:51many people who thought oh trump's come relatively that's a fresh i some fresh ideas happening and
- 1:13:59lo and behold when government actually kicked in and the truth came then all that stuff goes out
- 1:14:06the window all the reducing the size of government maybe keep the spending down that sounds great
- 1:14:11But then when the reality of running a massive country kicks in, it's like, no, actually, let's have another trillion dollar bill.
- 1:14:21Why not?
- 1:14:21Just don't tell anyone.
- 1:14:22But I often wonder whether it's just a function of the size of all this stuff.
- 1:14:27Because the other thing, obviously, that a lot of us are into is decentralizing things down to a bit like what you've got here.
- 1:14:36You've got a smaller.
- 1:14:37Well, no, but I mean, in the city, you're a small jurisdiction.
- 1:14:41in a way. And that's really much easier to keep everyone... The democratic system, I think,
- 1:14:47works much better on a small scale like this. Or even possibly on a scale like this, really,
- 1:14:55in a place where people, probably less political, they just want
- 1:14:59a good service. They're like, is it good here? You know, are people running this place well?
- 1:15:06Okay. Then really, then I'll just let them do that. Am I making money? I'm a merchant. I'm
- 1:15:11working here within these walls. Is my business doing well? Is everyone happy? Are we, are we,
- 1:15:17are the, you know, my morals, are the morals of the people in charge? Are they, are they good as
- 1:15:23well. But once you try and scale that up to even the size of the UK, I think, it becomes difficult,
- 1:15:30I think. Well, the size matters, and I would agree with that. And this comes up constantly
- 1:15:37in discussions that I have globally. What's the right size? There's a particularly interesting
- 1:15:44book written by a friend of mine, James Bryding. We went to high school together, and James is
- 1:15:49Swiss, and he wrote a book called Too Big to Fail about six years ago. He wouldn't explain it like
- 1:15:56this, but I will, because he's not on the program. Fair enough, he looks at eight countries who are
- 1:16:02small, the largest being the Netherlands with 17 million. Obviously, Switzerland is in there with
- 1:16:07nine point whatever million. I won't get them all, but Denmark, Sweden, Ireland, Singapore. He left
- 1:16:14Norway out because everybody said, oh, Norway is just rich. But he said, these are countries,
- 1:16:18and I want to measure how well they do. And the measures that he picked were the educational system,
- 1:16:27the healthcare system, the environment, the infrastructure, and how they treated the
- 1:16:32disadvantaged and the elderly. And there are metrics for these internationally. They're
- 1:16:35slightly imperfect because they're qualitative measures to some degree. But you know if you've
- 1:16:41We've been to any of those.
- 1:16:43They beat the heck out of Germany, France, Spain, Italy, Britain.
- 1:16:48They also beat the heck out of America because everybody's focused on this GDP number.
- 1:16:55And the way I express Jim's book, which I don't think appears anywhere in there, is this raises the fundamental question.
- 1:17:01What are the economies of scale of the nation state?
- 1:17:05So supposedly, as you get bigger, you should be more efficient.
- 1:17:08It should be easier to run the place.
- 1:17:10None of this, oh, it's so hard to run a large place.
- 1:17:14Why is a small place so well run?
- 1:17:16Latvia, 1.3 million people, more unicorns per capita, a fully automated governmental system.
- 1:17:23Somehow 1.3 million people are operating a system that we 67 million have been unable to afford.
- 1:17:29So, you know, parse that one.
- 1:17:31You can see some of the difficulties.
- 1:17:33Now, then you move on to the other side.
- 1:17:35Well, hang on.
- 1:17:36Let's take this to the extreme.
- 1:17:38and frankly we should be operating groups of 50 or whatever.
- 1:17:42There is a lot of corruption.
- 1:17:44The city, bluntly, had a bad reputation,
- 1:17:46particularly in the 1700s and early 1800s,
- 1:17:49as being corrupt.
- 1:17:51We have the corrupt boroughs of Britain,
- 1:17:53well of England actually strictly, but anyway.
- 1:17:56So you've got this tension.
- 1:17:58Some of this comes back to looking at
- 1:18:00some of the other federal nations.
- 1:18:02So Germany is a very good example, 16 Lender,
- 1:18:05I think 3,000 gomenda.
- 1:18:07Italy is not so decentral.
- 1:18:10Spain has got tensions because it's got a regional decentralization.
- 1:18:15Canada, Australia, and then, of course, we come to America,
- 1:18:18which Britons tend to fixate as their comparator for reasons.
- 1:18:21But in America, there's a high degree of risk tolerance
- 1:18:26for people failing in governments at county and state level.
- 1:18:32And in Britain, there's a kind of no postcode lottery.
- 1:18:35and Thatcher, you can tell that, you know, I look at her in the round, nevertheless was one of those
- 1:18:41politicians who believed that there was a lot of corruption going on locally and the best thing to
- 1:18:45do was to centralize it. So with decentralization comes risk of variance in performance and
- 1:18:52potential local corruption. But without decentralization, you lose any engagement
- 1:18:58to the population at a level that they can effectively do anything. I often think that
- 1:19:05the Brexit vote was due to people mystically desiring more decentralization. It wasn't
- 1:19:11warm beer and spitfires they were voting for. I think they were voting for Mid-Victoriana. That
- 1:19:16was something along the lines of, hey, there are young women dying in childbirth. What are we going
- 1:19:22to do about it? Well, Tim, we're going to go set up a maternity hospital here in Manchester,
- 1:19:26because we would do it.
- 1:19:29We had that sort of motivation
- 1:19:30and freedom of maneuver to play that game.
- 1:19:34And I think people were looking for that
- 1:19:37a little bit in Britain.
- 1:19:38I think there are some other countries
- 1:19:40where they are looking for a bit more centralization.
- 1:19:42When you say that the risk in decentralization
- 1:19:47is corruption,
- 1:19:48I would argue that that's a better way
- 1:19:51to deal with corruption though
- 1:19:52because it's limited to a smaller geographic area or a smaller place.
- 1:19:59The same goes for, a lot of people say,
- 1:20:02well, if you have too much decentralized, you have a lot of warring factions.
- 1:20:07And I would say, well, that's better than two massive states warring against each other,
- 1:20:13which also happens.
- 1:20:14You know, I'd rather see small battles between states
- 1:20:17than the US front decide to fight China for example which is basically the alternative So I don know I would still say on paper at least because it hard to find contemporary examples of this
- 1:20:32where you would find lots and lots of quite small competing places.
- 1:20:39Well, I agree with you, I guess, even on the corruption point.
- 1:20:45I was sort of more explaining that when you fragment, you're going to create a lot more opportunities.
- 1:20:50And that leads to the notion of competition.
- 1:20:55So a good place that runs, and I'll give Jim his due, and I lived there for a little bit,
- 1:21:00is Switzerland.
- 1:21:02The amount of decentralization in Switzerland, and that's the other thing that you encounter
- 1:21:05in Britain when you talk about Switzerland.
- 1:21:07Well, there are only 9 million people we can't learn from.
- 1:21:09I'm like, well, actually, given the way that they're performing, I think we could.
- 1:21:12Yes, well, it doesn't matter.
- 1:21:13It's very inefficient.
- 1:21:15Well, it's not inefficient because it engages people.
- 1:21:18So you've got 26 cantons.
- 1:21:20You've got the Swiss system.
- 1:21:22You've got the referenda going at the Cantonal level and the national level.
- 1:21:26Britons only kind of wake up when there's a national Swiss referendum.
- 1:21:28But the local stuff is very, very, very vibrant.
- 1:21:32But there's competition.
- 1:21:33And everybody is ferociously passionate about their local area, the group that they come from, and all that.
- 1:21:41Now, that competition, they've got in balance.
- 1:21:44You can obviously have competitions.
- 1:21:45It's out of control.
- 1:21:46but competition is important but competition equally means you've got to know the rules of
- 1:21:50the game and so where i would go is that most of the countries that have decentralized well
- 1:21:56have thought about it very hard they tend to have a written constitution and it tends to be
- 1:22:01something along the lines of this is national right this is state this is local and then we
- 1:22:07carve the units up whereas uh you know here we've we've done it by the history of of wales scotland
- 1:22:15Northern Ireland. So we are, you know, when you talk to me, well, we've already done devolution.
- 1:22:20Yeah, but that was like 10% of the population. The other 90% haven't been decentralized.
- 1:22:26So there's a lot of structural issues in setting up, but you need competition,
- 1:22:30but to have competition be good, you've got to have very clear rules so that people are fighting
- 1:22:35to evolve better systems as opposed to fighting each other entity to entity.
- 1:22:40Also, of course, Switzerland has a really feel-good tax code, let's say.
- 1:22:48Isn't it right that they can decide where their tax money goes and they can decide to
- 1:22:54withhold it from certain parts of the economy, parts of the government?
- 1:22:58Is that true?
- 1:22:59No.
- 1:23:00Oh, have I misheard that?
- 1:23:02Yeah, yeah.
- 1:23:03There's a tiny bit of maneuvering on a few areas, but nothing of...
- 1:23:06I just know some people that really love that about
- 1:23:10The key thing though is that your local canton taxes, see?
- 1:23:15So the share taken by the federal government is actually quite low.
- 1:23:18So if you make your local canton more efficient, you will pay a lower tax rate.
- 1:23:22So that's good competition.
- 1:23:24And this is a time when we've got places like the OECD saying, oh, there should be a unified
- 1:23:28international tax.
- 1:23:30I mean, my problem has always been that human beings are apes and we do really well when
- 1:23:39we balance competition and cooperation. And as I said earlier, the competition needs to be focused
- 1:23:45on improvement as opposed to taking each other down. That's it. And there are ways of structuring
- 1:23:51that. But we also cooperate. And so we need to get both of those right. And in the case of Switzerland,
- 1:24:01it's better than average for sure. And it turns up in the numbers.
- 1:24:04um yeah and it's also probably true i would say at least in my experience i live in a very
- 1:24:10close-knit community let's say in a sparsely populated part of the country but the ability
- 1:24:18that by scaling down and decentralizing the governance structure means that you tend to
- 1:24:25have face-to-face contact more with the people that you're actually governing with alongside or
- 1:24:32who are governing you and that makes a massive difference a massive difference if you're
- 1:24:37plonked in the washington and you're talking about someone in ohio you don't actually i don't think
- 1:24:44it's even feasible to care to honestly care like i don't i don't think it's a is a bad thing i just
- 1:24:50don't think you can care i don't think you really can but when it's your neighbor or when it's
- 1:24:54someone that you can go and knock on their door actually and things like that it makes governance
- 1:24:58works really well that way because people respond and we know this from the internet you can say all
- 1:25:04kinds of stuff on the internet but you try saying that someone's face you don't you don't and once
- 1:25:09again it's a function of scale like we've got this i don't know i i'm i'm very much i would love to see
- 1:25:17thousands of competing switzerland's even smaller than switzerland are all over the place i think it
- 1:25:24be phenomenal because we now live in this world where you can vote with your feet quite easily.
- 1:25:29Moving from place to place is the easiest it's probably ever been in the history of the world,
- 1:25:35I would imagine. Really, because moving from Herefordshire to London used to be a big deal,
- 1:25:41but now people go to Dubai for the weekend.
- 1:25:43Well I agree with you on the difficulty of having empathy with 350 million people or 1 3 billion people or whatever I mean it ludicrous to claim that Theoretically you can I think I can feel something for large
- 1:25:59numbers of deaths, but that's about it. However, just to extend the competition point to one element,
- 1:26:09government is arguably getting now across the OECD running just under 40% of GDP.
- 1:26:15In Britain it's running at 44%.
- 1:26:20Operationally, and again it depends on whether you count health workers in, local government
- 1:26:26workers in, I would off the cuff say about 20% of people really work for government.
- 1:26:34Because of that 40% a lot of it is transfers to handle some of the imbalances in the system.
- 1:26:43Now, why am I going up this route?
- 1:26:46We use competition to increase efficiency in all sorts of walks of life.
- 1:26:52You wouldn't watch an Olympics where people weren't competing.
- 1:26:55You wouldn't watch the football.
- 1:26:57We know that competition gets the best out of people.
- 1:26:59That's why we celebrate the Olympians, how supreme they are.
- 1:27:02Why did they work 18 hours a day and take supplements and live in poverty for four years to win a gold medal?
- 1:27:09You know, it's competition works.
- 1:27:11So why doesn't competition apply to government?
- 1:27:16And this is why I believe the tax thing is important, because it doesn't mean low taxes
- 1:27:23are a good thing.
- 1:27:25It means what I want to see is value for money.
- 1:27:28So I can have a high tax regime with high quality infrastructure, a low tax regime with
- 1:27:33low quality infrastructure.
- 1:27:34Basically, I get what I pay for.
- 1:27:35The other thing I definitely don't want is low quality infrastructure and a high tax
- 1:27:40regime, you see. Now that's the kind of structural element to it. But equally, there are things,
- 1:27:47I put this into a lecture years ago, why don't I have passport office A and passport office B?
- 1:27:52Oh, but you don't understand we need standards. We can have standards. I can have a common ledger
- 1:27:56that both passport offices share to say, Tim got a passport for me, so I'm not issuing one
- 1:28:02extra. That's all doable. But competing on the operational service,
- 1:28:08driver license authorities actually lots of areas of government if you think it should be done in
- 1:28:12government then can it also be done in a competitive way um i think i have a much more crude opinion
- 1:28:21on that and i and it's that um with the monopoly on violence the incentive is taken away to compete
- 1:28:30and then it gets
- 1:28:33it's compounding over time
- 1:28:35as more unproductive people
- 1:28:37are attracted to a position of power
- 1:28:40and all the merchants end up leaving
- 1:28:43all the actual entrepreneurs
- 1:28:44actually the people that add value
- 1:28:46end up leaving
- 1:28:47and the whole thing collapses
- 1:28:48and that's the life cycle of
- 1:28:50I don't know
- 1:28:51I think in a practical way though
- 1:28:55there's a lot that government could do
- 1:28:58And a lot of this was tried and continues to be tried, to be fair.
- 1:29:04I remember we had in the 90s when we had a whole bunch of privatizations throughout the
- 1:29:1280s and early 90s.
- 1:29:14And in the 90s, I think it was 1994, there was a government white paper on the civil service,
- 1:29:19which had a beautiful title called Continuity and Change, which is kind of, you want to
- 1:29:24have both.
- 1:29:25But there was also at that time something called prior options.
- 1:29:31The cabinet office did do this.
- 1:29:33And in fact, I did one on an agency.
- 1:29:36For agencies, you were supposed to see, did this thing need to be done at all?
- 1:29:42If it needed to be done, did it need to be done by government?
- 1:29:45If it needed to be done, it needed to be done by government.
- 1:29:48Were there ways of involving the private sector?
- 1:29:50And the funny bit about this prior options, it was off of a single memo written to the cabinet office in 92 for memory.
- 1:29:59But it was very, very cogent and coherent.
- 1:30:01And I followed that with one agency and the MOD.
- 1:30:05And it wasn't a bad framework.
- 1:30:07But once it is going to be done in government, I would add that little, could it be done competitively?
- 1:30:13Because when you say could it be done by the private sector, unless you're going to establish another monopoly, and that's often done as well.
- 1:30:19We have a tendency to give out, in my opinion, contracts that are too big.
- 1:30:24Why?
- 1:30:24Because if we centralize a contract, we'll save money.
- 1:30:27But we never seem to save the money and nobody ever goes back and looks at it.
- 1:30:30And I've long been a proponent that when you're doing some outsourcing, if you've got the
- 1:30:36scale to do it as two or perhaps even three, do it because they will compete with each
- 1:30:40other.
- 1:30:41And there's some good examples of large organizations.
- 1:30:44I can't name, but one big retailer in Britain did that with escalators and lifts.
- 1:30:48They said to three companies, well, they said to multiple companies, we're offering a tender, but for one third of the estate.
- 1:30:55And then they got the three who'd won together and said, you have to cooperate.
- 1:31:00If he's failing, one of the three, if A, B, and C are together and B is not doing so well, you, A, and C, need to help him and tell him how you're achieving better results than he is, or we'll replace him.
- 1:31:11And are you sure you want us to replace him So it started a kind of lovely bit of competition you know competition and cooperation in that environment So there are creative ways of doing it And back to governance I know we got time yet
- 1:31:24Last question.
- 1:31:26Just to end on a high note, let's say.
- 1:31:29Do you have a preferred level of governance?
- 1:31:32Do you have a preferred?
- 1:31:33We were talking about, I mean, you're just there, like, as in the free market, how much should the free market solve our problems?
- 1:31:41and what would be the correct role of government? Someone who is in that position of power,
- 1:31:49what did you see as your correct position? Were there times when you thought, actually,
- 1:31:56that's not really a job for a government, that's the job for the free market? And what's
- 1:32:01the job? What is the actual job for the government?
- 1:32:04Hmm.
- 1:32:05It's funny because I gave a lecture which ended on Goldilocks government, neither too
- 1:32:15much nor too right.
- 1:32:16You know, what's the meter?
- 1:32:17So it's an excellent question and I addressed it 20 years ago and I'm trying to remember
- 1:32:21what I said then.
- 1:32:22No.
- 1:32:23But no, it is a pretty good question.
- 1:32:26I think the real question is, is there any operational service delivery role that government should do?
- 1:32:36And I would push that to the extreme.
- 1:32:39Okay.
- 1:32:39But when I look at things that nonprofit organizations do, they typically do four things.
- 1:32:49The first thing is they develop a sense of community.
- 1:32:52the second thing that they do is they deliver direct services
- 1:32:58the third thing that they do is that they try effectively to change systems and the last one
- 1:33:06they try and do is expand frontiers so let me give you an example let's imagine we're a blind
- 1:33:11charity like rnib and rnib does do this there's a sense of community we're both blind and i you
- 1:33:19I could use a little bit of support here.
- 1:33:21And they get people together.
- 1:33:22They have chat lines and talks.
- 1:33:24And, you know, there's a community.
- 1:33:25I think government can do that.
- 1:33:29But that's equally done by churches and faith communities
- 1:33:32and livery companies and whatever associations you want.
- 1:33:35And I believe government doesn't need to do that.
- 1:33:38There is a sense of national community
- 1:33:39when there's a national tragedy.
- 1:33:41But I sometimes think government does too much.
- 1:33:43So it now becomes a, the nation is doing everything,
- 1:33:46when actually it could be much more decentralized and local.
- 1:33:50The second area is, as I said, it was delivering services.
- 1:33:54And the RNIB does that.
- 1:33:56They will sell you watches for the blind and canes and all that.
- 1:34:00They'll deliver meals to people who need them.
- 1:34:03So there's that level.
- 1:34:04Government does not need to do that.
- 1:34:06That's exactly what the private sector is for.
- 1:34:09And back to that old trope about the Russians asking who controls the bread deliveries in London
- 1:34:14and the answer being nobody.
- 1:34:16So you can do that.
- 1:34:18Third level up is changing systems.
- 1:34:21That I think could be as much as 50% government.
- 1:34:24That's where the policies are in.
- 1:34:26But that's government in the sense of government
- 1:34:28plus the democratic system, plus think tanks,
- 1:34:31plus people are thinking,
- 1:34:32how would I change the systems back to systems theory
- 1:34:34to make something a lot more efficient
- 1:34:37and useful and interesting?
- 1:34:40The last bit is expanding frontiers.
- 1:34:42And here, this would typically be research.
- 1:34:46And again, going back to RNIB, they do research on preventing blindness, ameliorating blindness, causes of blindness.
- 1:34:51You know, it's all good stuff.
- 1:34:55I personally, despite having been in research, believe that government has a role there in terms of funding education that's huge.
- 1:35:03providing common expensive facilities like wind tunnels or hydro tanks or you know CERN
- 1:35:12accelerators that kind of thing where that's actually very very helpful I don't believe
- 1:35:18government is particularly good at blue sky research but it can definitely sustain it so
- 1:35:23you know as I cut through those four areas I hope that gives you a flavor that to me it's a rich
- 1:35:28question, but it requires a lot of self-discipline. Back to that cabinet office memo on prior options.
- 1:35:35Does it need to be done here? Okay, maybe it does a little bit. If so, how much can be done by the
- 1:35:40private sector? We need to push that envelope a lot. That does lead to some troubling areas
- 1:35:45in many cases. Is the health sector a private or public question? Would I go for a wholly private
- 1:35:53police force? That's an interesting question as well. So these are questions for us to have honest
- 1:35:59debates on. And in a sense, it turns, you want an upbeat ending, you know, we are where we are,
- 1:36:04isn't too bad. It's just, we are frustrating ourselves because quite rightly, we want to improve.
- 1:36:11Michael, thank you very much indeed for spending a few, nearly an hour and a half.
- 1:36:18Sorry to keep you so long. I'd love to carry on. I've still got a million and one questions,
- 1:36:23but many, many thanks indeed.
- 1:36:25Most welcome, Tim.
- 1:36:25Really nice to chat with you guys.