Latest / Views and News with Clarence Ford / Christa Pike’s Botched Execution Raises Questions About the Myth of a ‘Painless’ Death
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: As we welcome Dr. Julian Coplin, lecturer in bioethics at
- 0:04Speaker 1: Monash University. It's great to have you with us, Dr. Coplin.
- 0:08Speaker 2: Thank you. It's very good to be here.
- 0:10Speaker 1: Yeah, I think an important conversation. South Africa has a
- 0:13Speaker 1: very violent society. We grapple with related issues often. Let's
- 0:19Speaker 1: talk about the legal injection as it pertains to the
- 0:23Speaker 1: Krista Pike situation and execution specifically. And, you know, for us,
- 0:30Speaker 1: it kind of looks clean. It looks maybe sterile as well.
- 0:36Speaker 1: It looks like a peaceful medical procedure, maybe. But it's
- 0:41Speaker 1: not what it appears to be, is it?
- 0:44Speaker 2: I think you're completely right. I think that part of
- 0:46Speaker 2: the appeal of a lethal injection is that it does
- 0:48Speaker 2: look quite peaceful. It does look quite medical and orderly,
- 0:53Speaker 2: at least when it goes well. And it does seem like,
- 0:55Speaker 2: in principle, we should be able to execute people quite
- 1:02Speaker 2: peacefully using drugs. This is something that we do without pets,
- 1:05Speaker 2: with pet euthanasia. This is something that we do in
- 1:08Speaker 2: jurisdictions that practice voluntary assisted dying. But in practice, it
- 1:12Speaker 2: tends not to go quite so well in lethal injections.
- 1:15Speaker 2: There was a study quite a few years ago now
- 1:18Speaker 2: that was looking at rates of executions that were botched
- 1:22Speaker 2: across different types in the U.S., and lethal injections sort
- 1:26Speaker 2: of won that race with about 7% of them being botched.
- 1:30Speaker 2: And I think the difficulties are twofold. One is that
- 1:35Speaker 2: for the procedure to work, you need an access to
- 1:37Speaker 2: good high quality drugs and the pharmaceutical companies that are
- 1:41Speaker 2: manufacturing these are unwilling to sell them for the purpose
- 1:44Speaker 2: of execution. And the EU has been kind of further
- 1:47Speaker 2: leaning on some of these these pharmaceutical companies to ensure
- 1:54Speaker 2: that none of the drugs that they sell are used
- 1:56Speaker 2: for this purpose, which means that the drugs are often, well,
- 2:01Speaker 2: either bought on the black or the grey market or
- 2:03Speaker 2: from compounding pharmacies that might not have the same kind
- 2:06Speaker 2: of quality control as a major manufacturer. The other difficulty
- 2:10Speaker 2: is that you do need somebody capable of establishing an
- 2:14Speaker 2: IV line involved. And the difficulty is that Very few
- 2:19Speaker 2: doctors are willing to be involved in the taking of life.
- 2:22Speaker 2: And in fact, most major medical professional associations, including in
- 2:27Speaker 2: the US, tell their members that they are prohibited or
- 2:32Speaker 2: not allowed to engage in any aspect of an execution
- 2:37Speaker 2: because it's thought to be inconsistent with the ethos of
- 2:40Speaker 2: the medical profession. So when you put that together, you
- 2:42Speaker 2: have something that in principle could work quite well still
- 2:46Speaker 2: resulting in these cases like Krista Pike's, where we don't
- 2:49Speaker 2: know exactly what went wrong, but something went terribly wrong,
- 2:53Speaker 2: and she suffered quite significantly without death even eventually being
- 3:01Speaker 2: brought about.
- 3:05Speaker 1: In an article for Monash Lens, bioethics lecturer and our
- 3:09Speaker 1: guest Julian Copland examined the ethical contradictions of capital punishment
- 3:15Speaker 1: arguing that even those who support the death penalty should
- 3:19Speaker 1: be troubled by the possibility of unnecessary suffering. So I
- 3:23Speaker 1: think just in that opening salvo, Doctor, you suggested that
- 3:26Speaker 1: maybe The poison that was administered wasn't the real thing.
- 3:32Speaker 1: You also said that doctors are, let's just say, medical
- 3:38Speaker 1: ethics prevent doctors from participating. You suggested maybe that a
- 3:42Speaker 1: doctor wasn't present. Can you confirm that?
- 3:46Speaker 2: I believe in this case there was a doctor present.
- 3:50Speaker 2: Mark Fowler is what I've read, although... I think the
- 3:53Speaker 2: number of doctors that are willing to engage in executions
- 3:57Speaker 2: are few and far between. Mark Fowler had been involved
- 4:02Speaker 2: in a previous botched execution just a few months prior
- 4:05Speaker 2: where he wasn't able to establish an IV line. I
- 4:08Speaker 2: believe I read in the media, though I don't have
- 4:10Speaker 2: any deeper insight than this, but I had read that
- 4:13Speaker 2: it had been 10 years since he had last done
- 4:15Speaker 2: this procedure and that he wasn't able to work in hospitals.
- 4:21Speaker 2: at the time that he was engaging with the prison
- 4:26Speaker 2: for these two executions. Okay.
- 4:28Speaker 1: So this is his gig then. When a drug, and
- 4:33Speaker 1: we're talking about pentobarbital, I believe, when it fails to
- 4:35Speaker 1: kill someone and it leaves them gasping and in pain,
- 4:41Speaker 1: what line has the state really crossed here?
- 4:46Speaker 2: So when you think about the punishments that we administer
- 4:49Speaker 2: to There are a lot of people who are opposed
- 4:52Speaker 2: to the death penalty and I'm one of those people,
- 4:55Speaker 2: but even those who agree with the death penalty do
- 4:59Speaker 2: want to keep some boundaries around what we can do
- 5:02Speaker 2: to punish somebody. So there's this idea that maybe death
- 5:06Speaker 2: is an appropriate punishment if you've taken somebody else's life,
- 5:10Speaker 2: but we don't extend that to physical pain and suffering.
- 5:12Speaker 2: We don't torture someone who has tortured others. And Krista Pike, uh,
- 5:17Speaker 2: was convicted of torturing someone, the same person that she
- 5:23Speaker 2: had murdered. But this isn't something that we do, and
- 5:27Speaker 2: Norris is something that I think we should do, and
- 5:29Speaker 2: Norris is something that I think many people would be
- 5:31Speaker 2: willing to do. So, there's a kind of limit around
- 5:35Speaker 2: physical pain and suffering. At the same time, execution methods
- 5:39Speaker 2: aren't supposed to impose additional suffering beyond what's required to
- 5:44Speaker 2: end someone's life. And this is why we have something
- 5:47Speaker 2: like the lethal injection, which looks quite orderly and safe
- 5:51Speaker 2: and controlled, as opposed to something like burning someone at
- 5:53Speaker 2: the stake, which you cannot do in Tennessee or anywhere
- 5:57Speaker 2: that I'm kind of aware of, any jurisdiction that I'm
- 6:00Speaker 2: aware of, because that kind of involves this additional suffering
- 6:04Speaker 2: beyond what's necessary to bring about the end of that life.
- 6:08Speaker 2: So even if we think maybe in principle death is
- 6:11Speaker 2: an appropriate punishment, something seems to be going wrong in
- 6:16Speaker 2: trying to bring about that death. We're also inflicting the
- 6:20Speaker 2: kind of suffering that we would never accept as treatment of,
- 6:25Speaker 2: I guess, any prisoner, regardless of what they had done. Yeah.
- 6:30Speaker 1: So in Africa, a violent society, we have a problem
- 6:33Speaker 1: with violent crime in this particular country. And people believe
- 6:37Speaker 1: that the death penalty is an effective deterrent, and that's
- 6:41Speaker 1: what they want. And understandably so. The question is, is
- 6:46Speaker 1: the death penalty effective, and especially as a deterrent for
- 6:51Speaker 1: such crime?
- 6:54Speaker 2: It's a really good question and a really important question.
- 6:57Speaker 2: I should say I'm a philosopher, so I'm not deeply
- 7:02Speaker 2: engaged in the kind of empirical, you know, studies and
- 7:05Speaker 2: research into the death penalty as a deterrent, but my
- 7:08Speaker 2: understanding is that the evidence is at the very least
- 7:12Speaker 2: flimsy and contested. And when you look at US states
- 7:16Speaker 2: that practice the death penalty and those that don't, well,
- 7:19Speaker 2: it isn't the case that the states that practice the
- 7:24Speaker 2: death penalty have lower rates of violent crime. Now that
- 7:26Speaker 2: doesn't prove anything. There can be all kinds of confounding factors.
- 7:31Speaker 2: It's a space that is, you know, continuing to be
- 7:34Speaker 2: debated and looked at, but it's shakier than it might
- 7:39Speaker 2: first seem. I think part of the problem is that
- 7:42Speaker 2: if you're thinking about the kind of context in which
- 7:46Speaker 2: somebody takes a life, it's really unclear how much they
- 7:54Speaker 2: are rationally projecting forward into weighing the possibilities of various
- 7:59Speaker 2: kinds of punishment if they are caught. But whether it
- 8:03Speaker 2: works as a deterrence, I'm not sure. But I would
- 8:09Speaker 2: be very cautious about accepting this seemingly very sensible thing
- 8:16Speaker 2: without sort of going quite deeply into this very murky, contested,
- 8:21Speaker 2: empirical arguments back and forth about what it actually does.
- 8:24Speaker 1: Yeah, I know a colleague of mine, John Matham, was
- 8:28Speaker 1: sharing some stats on Friday, I think it was, our
- 8:30Speaker 1: stats about was it mass killings in the United States
- 8:33Speaker 1: of America and in states where the death penalty was, well,
- 8:41Speaker 1: part of the response. In fact, there were more such
- 8:46Speaker 1: violent crimes than in states where there wasn't a death
- 8:48Speaker 1: penalty or it was outlawed. So I don't know if
- 8:51Speaker 1: that is sufficient evidence.
- 8:54Speaker 2: Well, it's definitely a good reason not to just, you know,
- 8:59Speaker 2: It's definitely a good reason to.
- 9:01Speaker 1: Be very careful. But the conclusion for people is a
- 9:06Speaker 1: dead murderer can't murder. And it's a pretty fair position,
- 9:11Speaker 1: to say the very least. But let's understand Krista's crying out.
- 9:17Speaker 1: What actually happens inside the body when a lethal dose
- 9:20Speaker 1: of that central nervous system, depressant essentially, fails to stop
- 9:24Speaker 1: the heart? What happens?
- 9:28Speaker 2: It's a really excellent question. I think in this case,
- 9:32Speaker 2: she fell asleep. She could be heard moaning. She could
- 9:36Speaker 2: be heard snoring after a while. It is supposed to
- 9:44Speaker 2: suppress the nervous system. It's supposed to end breathing. As
- 9:51Speaker 2: I mentioned, there are some theories about what went wrong here.
- 9:55Speaker 2: And We're not sure if it's a case of the
- 9:58Speaker 2: drug not having been, you know, up to standard, if
- 10:01Speaker 2: it had degraded, or if maybe the drugs had pulled
- 10:04Speaker 2: in the tissue of her arm instead of getting into
- 10:06Speaker 2: her blood. But one way or another, what seemed to
- 10:10Speaker 2: happen is that she had arms that swelled up that
- 10:18Speaker 2: seem to be very painful. I've heard, at least from
- 10:21Speaker 2: her lawyers, some speculation that it's unclear what will happen
- 10:26Speaker 2: with them and if they'll regain proper functionality. But also,
- 10:30Speaker 2: having put her into this deeply sedated state where the
- 10:36Speaker 2: poison wasn't quite killing her and she was potentially not
- 10:41Speaker 2: getting enough oxygen. There were quite a few days where
- 10:43Speaker 2: it was an open question whether she would come out
- 10:45Speaker 2: the other side of this with brain damage. And that
- 10:49Speaker 2: would be its own interesting can of worms, among other reasons,
- 10:53Speaker 2: because it might mean that she wouldn't be considered cognitively
- 10:59Speaker 2: competent to face the death penalty again after she recovered.
- 11:04Speaker 2: if she had lost enough cognitive capacity. But, you know, essentially,
- 11:08Speaker 2: this higher dose of pentobarbazole is supposed to kill people,
- 11:13Speaker 2: so we don't really have a great wealth of evidence
- 11:19Speaker 2: of what happens in cases like this, where it ends
- 11:23Speaker 2: up maybe inside the tissues of the arm, or maybe
- 11:26Speaker 2: where a weaker, too weaker dose is being administered, and it's...
- 11:33Speaker 2: going to be interesting in a fairly bleak kind of
- 11:37Speaker 2: way to see what happens to Krista and her health
- 11:41Speaker 2: in the weeks ahead.
- 11:44Speaker 1: Yeah, lots of questions in. Martin writes on the WhatsApp line,
- 11:47Speaker 1: the death penalty is not a deterrent, but it is
- 11:52Speaker 1: retribution and justice for the victim's family. Some murders are
- 11:56Speaker 1: so cruel and senseless that the death penalty is a
- 12:00Speaker 1: just Punishment, that is Martin's view of that. I have
- 12:03Speaker 1: no doubt a lot of people would echo the same sentiment.
- 12:07Speaker 1: And a lot of people wanting to know, will they
- 12:11Speaker 1: try to re-kill her? Does she go through the same
- 12:15Speaker 1: process after having been administered two doses? And wasn't one
- 12:19Speaker 1: dose enough? What happened?
- 12:22Speaker 2: Well, this is... an unprecedented situation. There's a legal question here,
- 12:28Speaker 2: and I guess a philosophical question as well, but there's
- 12:30Speaker 2: a legal question, which is whether they can try to
- 12:32Speaker 2: execute her again. And the answer to that question depends
- 12:37Speaker 2: on whether we consider the punishment to have been completed
- 12:43Speaker 2: because the full procedure for the execution was followed out.
- 12:49Speaker 2: Two doses of the drugs were pushed. Everything happened according
- 12:55Speaker 2: to protocol. And in every other case where the protocol
- 12:59Speaker 2: has been followed in full, the prisoner has died. There
- 13:02Speaker 2: have been other botched executions where they weren't able to
- 13:05Speaker 2: administer the drug in full. They weren't able to establish
- 13:08Speaker 2: an IV line, for example. And in some of those cases,
- 13:11Speaker 2: the prisoners were then executed using different methods later on.
- 13:16Speaker 2: But here, we need to work out whether we think
- 13:21Speaker 2: that whether we think that the execution has been completed
- 13:25Speaker 2: because everything that was supposed to be carried out was
- 13:29Speaker 2: carried out, or whether we think it hasn't been completed
- 13:31Speaker 2: because she continues to live.
- 13:33Speaker 1: Yeah, maybe God had other plans for her. And that
- 13:36Speaker 1: is what some other people are saying. I'd like to
- 13:38Speaker 1: hear it from a bioethical perspective. What is your view
- 13:45Speaker 1: on her then going back maybe for another dose? So I....
- 13:53Speaker 2: I'm not sure if I have a very principled, professional,
- 13:57Speaker 2: bioethical view on this.
- 13:59Speaker 1: You have a view on the first dose. You have
- 14:00Speaker 1: a view on the first dose.
- 14:02Speaker 2: Yes. But I have a sort of personal, deep intuition that, gosh,
- 14:09Speaker 2: the amount what has been inflicted here is quite serious.
- 14:16Speaker 2: It is something that risks her death. It's very, very
- 14:22Speaker 2: surprising that she survived, and it's something that resulted in
- 14:27Speaker 2: significant suffering. There is also the matter of the kind
- 14:31Speaker 2: of many years in prison ahead of the execution attempts,
- 14:36Speaker 2: the dread leading up to the day. I think that
- 14:38Speaker 2: there is enough that has happened here that you can
- 14:42Speaker 2: look at this and say, gosh, this prisoner has been.
- 14:47Speaker 2: Has experienced an apt and appropriate punishment. Even if we
- 14:52Speaker 2: are worried about something like deterring other crimes, we might think, well,
- 14:57Speaker 2: a 99% chance of death combined with the kind of
- 15:01Speaker 2: physical suffering and question marks around brain damage and bodily
- 15:05Speaker 2: functioning after a failed attempt, that would surely seem to
- 15:08Speaker 2: be enough for a deterrent. Or we might think, if
- 15:13Speaker 2: our attitude is retribution, if that's what we're after, Surely
- 15:17Speaker 2: something fairly significant has happened to Krista Pike here. I
- 15:23Speaker 2: do understand that some people might think the taking of
- 15:25Speaker 2: a life should result in the forfeiting of a life,
- 15:28Speaker 2: but I do think that a very significant punishment has
- 15:32Speaker 2: been carried out, and I would like to hope that
- 15:35Speaker 2: maybe her sentence might be commuted to something like life
- 15:37Speaker 2: in prison.
- 15:39Speaker 1: Yeah, that's quite an ordeal. We're going to rest it there,
- 15:43Speaker 1: but thank you, Dr. Julian Copland, a lecturer in bioethics
- 15:47Speaker 1: at Monash University. Is there such a thing as a
- 15:52Speaker 1: painless death? Clearly not. Leaves a lot of questions, Krista
- 15:58Speaker 1: Pike's botched execution.