Latest / Toronto Talks / Driverless Trains, Smarter Transit, with Transdev Canada's Arthur Nicolet
Transcript
- 0:00So much more data.
- 0:01Much more data, but at the end, it's not just for the engineer, for the companies,
- 0:06and to maintain the trend, but also for the benefit of the passengers.
- 0:10Hello, I'm Giles Gherson, and this is Toronto Talks, the voice of Toronto's business community.
- 0:16What are we talking about?
- 0:18Each episode is a conversation with top business leaders about how they're shaping growth,
- 0:23driving competitiveness, and building up our economy.
- 0:26It's about what they believe it will take to make sure the Toronto region remains one of the world's great global cities.
- 0:33Here's today's conversation.
- 0:35Arthur, welcome to Toronto Talks.
- 0:37Great to have you here.
- 0:38I think what's really interesting, why it's great to have you here, is Toronto is in the middle of a huge transit build-out.
- 0:45The Toronto region is, I should say, which started a number of years ago.
- 0:49We're kind of in the middle of it now.
- 0:52And the company that you represent, TransDev Canada, plays a significant role in all of this.
- 0:59It's a very important company, but hardly anybody, I imagine, knows the role you play.
- 1:03So we thought it would be really useful to have you come and talk a little bit about the role that TransDev plays in the scheme of things, in the transit world.
- 1:10And, of course, you don't just operate in Canada.
- 1:13You operate across the world.
- 1:15And so I think it's really interesting to get a sense of what experiences you've had and what you bring then to the Canadian market and the Toronto market specifically.
- 1:24So to start off, maybe tell us a little bit about Transdev and the role you play.
- 1:30I mean, just in general terms, we'll get into specifics in a minute.
- 1:33Of course.
- 1:34Transdev is the mobility company.
- 1:37So we are really a multimodal operator.
- 1:39really all modes of transportation from rail, buses, ferries, gondolas, bicycles, all modes of
- 1:47transportation. That's really the approach. We are a worldwide leader. We operate in more than 20
- 1:52countries. So all different, you know, contexts, environments, that's where we bring our value,
- 1:59our knowledge, our experience and challenges as well. And what we bring also to the Canadian
- 2:05market. And that's really unique. When you look at the global market, there is no equivalent in
- 2:12terms of private company, which are multimodal companies. So when we speak with an authority,
- 2:19with a client, could be a private one, could be a city, we can answer with all modes of
- 2:25transportation. It's not just a one-way thinking with just one mode. We look at the situation
- 2:31and we can give advice on how to manage that.
- 2:35And so, you know, when TransDev came to Canada,
- 2:38it was a very mature company and, as you said, very multimodal.
- 2:42How did it start, though?
- 2:43It presumably started with one mode, and I'm assuming in France.
- 2:48Is that right?
- 2:49Oh, we started with a really humble, you know, situation,
- 2:52with just a couple of buses around Montreal.
- 2:56Oh, in Montreal, okay.
- 2:57Yeah, in the south of Montreal.
- 2:59And then we grew the business.
- 3:01We grew the business all across Canada, so for the past eight years.
- 3:06So that was a fantastic development through RFPs, M&As as well, and organic growth.
- 3:14So we really developed the business, and now we are really in all six provinces, one territory.
- 3:20So we have a large footprint.
- 3:22So you talk about being an operator.
- 3:24I mean, that's an important word.
- 3:27I think when people think about transiting in Canada, and particularly in Toronto, you
- 3:32say, well, you've got the provincial government is responsible for the GO commuter rail system.
- 3:38The TTC is responsible for the transit system.
- 3:41They're the operators, but no, maybe not.
- 3:44Transdev plays a role.
- 3:45So what role, how do you define, can you explain a little bit about what operating a system
- 3:51means for a private company?
- 3:54In Canada, especially in Ontario, it starts by providing the drivers to find the right
- 4:01talents, find the mechanics.
- 4:03That's as simple as that, but that's complex.
- 4:06So under contract to the TTC or Metrolinx?
- 4:09Or under the contract of Metrolinx, of course.
- 4:12So we provide the workforce.
- 4:15We train the workforce.
- 4:16We find the talents.
- 4:18Sometimes we bring also and we give advice to our clients how we should design.
- 4:24That's part of some of PPP projects.
- 4:27We bring ideas.
- 4:28We challenge the projects.
- 4:31That's why some clients are asking TransDev to be in the project.
- 4:38But when you say operator, it sort of almost implies that you find, say, the workforce,
- 4:45You train the workforce, but they are still employed by the TTC or Metrolinx, no?
- 4:51Or are they employed by you?
- 4:52They are employed by us.
- 4:53Okay.
- 4:54So that's due.
- 4:55Well, to TTC.
- 4:57No, that's totally separate.
- 4:58Okay.
- 4:59So really, for project like the Azel-McAllian line, we recruit the employee, and the employee
- 5:08would be transdev employees.
- 5:10Okay.
- 5:10But they can come from everywhere.
- 5:12Right.
- 5:12Some of our workers, they come from TTC or they can come from any kind of industry.
- 5:17Okay.
- 5:18So let's think about, you know, I know one of the big projects, obviously, that is underway now is the Ontario Line, significant expansion of the subway system for Toronto.
- 5:31We see a station is being built now.
- 5:35The line is being built.
- 5:36Tunneling is taking place.
- 5:38What sort of role would you play in a project like that?
- 5:43At the early stage, and that's something that we promote a lot just to involve an operator
- 5:49like Transdev.
- 5:51At the early stage, it's great because we bring our expertise from everywhere on the place.
- 5:56So basically, we will challenge, of course, the designer on the way they do.
- 6:03So you're brought in right in the very early stages.
- 6:06Exactly.
- 6:06And I believe it brings a lot of value of PPP project.
- 6:10Because of course, it's a different point of view, of course.
- 6:14We are looking for the long term, what would be the cost, what would be the benefit for
- 6:19the passengers.
- 6:20And I believe it's pretty aligned with authorities also sometimes, because it's more long-term
- 6:25vision.
- 6:26For us, a good transit system is a transit system with a high level of ridership, a huge
- 6:34usage from the population.
- 6:35That would be a successful one.
- 6:37And that matters for us.
- 6:38So all the KPIs around that, the safety KPIs, the on-time performance, the commercial speed
- 6:45will matter a lot because we know that will play a big role for the ridership.
- 6:49But not only that, because as I said, we are a multimodal operator.
- 6:53So we always think about all the modes of transportation around the backbone.
- 7:00It's not just the backbone.
- 7:01If we want that the backbone works, we need to have around that a good network of bus,
- 7:08a good network of last mine, first mine, everything should work if we want that big system work.
- 7:13Now, Arthur, presumably, if I'm the TTC, I'm responsible for the Ontario line being built,
- 7:20along with the provincial government, Metrolinks, I also want to maximize the use of it.
- 7:26I want as many passengers as I can get.
- 7:29I'm interested in all the things that you've just mentioned.
- 7:31So where would you come in and say, here's an idea, or here is something we discovered in another city
- 7:37that you might want to think about here?
- 7:39I'm thinking that's how you're kind of expressing it.
- 7:42What would be some of the things that you would bring to a project like this?
- 7:47As an example, we brought the signaling question topic, as you may know.
- 7:52Big issue here.
- 7:55That's a challenge.
- 7:56But that's also an opportunity for lots, the transit project.
- 7:59For faster headways.
- 8:00Exactly.
- 8:02You spoke during the transit symposium about that.
- 8:06But that's a key challenge.
- 8:07It's a quick win.
- 8:08It's a low-hanging fruit.
- 8:10Just if we standardize with signaling for LRTs, but I would speak more about LRTs, that
- 8:16could increase the commercial speed and the benefit for the passenger.
- 8:20Of course, the passenger, they will-
- 8:22They want faster trips.
- 8:24Exactly.
- 8:24That's as simple as that.
- 8:25They want to go to point A to point B faster than with the cars.
- 8:30Yes.
- 8:30So we have to consider everything around that.
- 8:34So that's hopeful because, I mean, I think, you know, one of the projects that, you know, that was troubled, I think, for quite a while was the Eglinton Crosstown project here.
- 8:43Now it's up and running.
- 8:44I think people are very pleased with it.
- 8:46And it kind of, I think, plays a significant role in easing congestion and moving more people to transit.
- 8:56But it was a long, long project.
- 8:59And one of the things that I think that people talked about during it is issues like signaling, getting the right sort of signaling technology so that you can move these LRTs vehicles much more quickly.
- 9:17Again, I believe the question is just the early involvement of an operator.
- 9:23And the operator, you know, at the early stage of each major project, we should have an operator.
- 9:30But not just as an advisor, the operator who will really operate.
- 9:34Well, you're going to use it.
- 9:35Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 9:36Who will be accountable for the transition.
- 9:38It's not a true region that we plan projects without the operator at the table, but it sounds like we did.
- 9:44I mean, it seems to me that these projects have evolved quite substantially in terms of how they're managed and the governance of them and the planning.
- 9:53In relatively few years, it seems like they've changed quite a lot.
- 9:56But it's still hard to imagine that, say, 15 years ago when some of these projects were planned, that they didn't bring the operator in right at the start.
- 10:05But my sense is it was more sequential.
- 10:08That's correct.
- 10:09But now the game is changing.
- 10:11Yeah.
- 10:11And I believe the situation is totally different and that would be the benefit of the upcoming projects.
- 10:18So, of course, we learn also.
- 10:20We try things.
- 10:23And I believe there is a real importance now on what the operator are saying in those projects
- 10:30because we are a small piece of the stakes at the beginning, of course,
- 10:36because everything is around the building, is construction, is technology.
- 10:41But sometimes, because of that, we miss the operation piece and the passenger piece, the ridership, what would be the real efficiency, not just running a transit or just operating there, but with higher ridership, the performance, the quality of that.
- 11:00We are working around those major projects, but it should benefit the population at the end.
- 11:05As you mentioned, at the Board of Trade, we had a conference recently on multimodal transit and transportation.
- 11:14And what I want to do is bring together some of these ideas to make sure that we have a seamless system.
- 11:19I think, as you point out, one of the problems with transit can be that each part of the system works well, but doesn't connect well.
- 11:28And I think it really becomes, as I tried to say in my remarks then, you want to maximize
- 11:34the effectiveness and efficiency of the assets you do have because you're going to build new
- 11:38ones, but really to get sure to maximize the number of people using it, you want the system
- 11:43to kind of connect well.
- 11:45And you mentioned at the outset of this conversation that TransDev manages, as you said, multimodal
- 11:50systems, so trains, buses, and bicycles.
- 11:54So explain that.
- 11:57So is it what you're saying?
- 12:00I get off at the subway stop and I find a bicycle from a bike share service that you might control or operate?
- 12:12What's the connection between operating the transit system and a bicycle ride share?
- 12:19It would start with simple things.
- 12:22How long does it take to go from the bicycle station to the train station?
- 12:30How long does it take?
- 12:31Sometimes it could be more than 20 minutes.
- 12:34Okay.
- 12:35So is the one available then?
- 12:36Because you are on the path to go there is not really practical.
- 12:44And that's a key challenge.
- 12:47Sometimes it's better to just five minutes walk or even less than that.
- 12:51200 meters around the station.
- 12:54So the way we design, we implement the bicycle station is key.
- 12:59That's the same for the bus.
- 13:00The bus station should be really, really close.
- 13:03We know that each time that you change of mode,
- 13:06you can lose nearly 20% of ridership.
- 13:10So if you want to reduce this percentage,
- 13:12you have to design really closely all modes of transportation
- 13:17just to go from one mode to another one.
- 13:21So it's why the look for the upcoming project is really a global project.
- 13:25If we want that it works, really looking at what's the network design, the bus of the network design, bicycles, could be the ferries, could be the gondolas.
- 13:33Everything should be linked if we want to create really successful transit projects.
- 13:38I mean, as you know, one of the issues that the Board of Trade has been pushing is we've got fair integration now in our region, thanks to the provincial government spending a fair bit of money to underwrite a single fair system, which is terrific.
- 13:53We fought for that for a long time.
- 13:54But now we're very much asking for service integration.
- 13:58And a bit like what you're talking about, we've got many or quite a few municipal transit systems that all operate in this region, whether it's MyWay and Mississauga, whether it's the North York subway system, or the York region subway system, and Peel and so on, and then coming into Toronto itself where the TTC operates, and then the GO system operating as well as a commuter rail system.
- 14:23the schedules aren't at all connected.
- 14:27And I think one of the things we learned was that Europe,
- 14:30the European rail system is a single scheduling system,
- 14:34unified, united.
- 14:36So passengers can go from one to the next easily.
- 14:40We don't even have that in the Toronto region,
- 14:41but is that something that TransDiv can play a role in,
- 14:44for example,
- 14:45because when you're talking about a multimodal system,
- 14:47it's being able to go from a bus, as you said,
- 14:50to a subway system, to a subway.
- 14:54We can bring an added value on that. Just bringing an example how it works elsewhere,
- 15:00how it works in Europe, how it works in Australia, in the US as well. And I believe there is a strong
- 15:06benefit with a single authority, I would say, of course, to manage the phrase, as you said,
- 15:11sometimes to have the same information. Because everything we do to ease the way to use the system.
- 15:19So wayfinding, for example, is very different.
- 15:21Or we can find in Europe, like looking at transport for London.
- 15:26There is just one brand, just one site, just one fare for everybody living there.
- 15:33It's simple.
- 15:34It works.
- 15:35The population doesn't care who is doing the job.
- 15:38They care how it's simple it is for them just to go to A to B.
- 15:43That's the goal.
- 15:44That's really the goal.
- 15:45So everything that we are doing collectively and we need to, all the stakeholders will play a positive and will have a positive impact for the population.
- 15:53When you look at the transit system in the Toronto region, what are the big gaps then to you in terms of a well-functioning multimodal system that could maximize usage?
- 16:06And obviously, maximizing usage reduces congestion on our roads.
- 16:10So there's a huge benefit to that.
- 16:13There are a lot of wonderful and great projects ongoing.
- 16:18So it's coming.
- 16:19It's really coming.
- 16:20And you talk about Ontario and Ontario will bring a lot of added value for the population
- 16:28and in terms of commercial speed to move from a place to another.
- 16:33So lots of great things.
- 16:35Maybe we can do a bit better in terms of integration.
- 16:38Yeah.
- 16:39That seems to be the big issue.
- 16:41A bit more.
- 16:41A bit more.
- 16:43So thinking and be on the population side, just seamless on the fares, I believe it's really a great initiative.
- 16:49We just push more and more, even maybe on the information side.
- 16:54Well, information is key.
- 16:56Yeah, and the difference, I think right now, GO system, TTC, the different municipal transit agencies all have different wayfinding.
- 17:05So it's not common.
- 17:06So if you're a passenger, you're not going to see the same kind of information across the system.
- 17:11It'll be different each time you cross a municipal border, basically.
- 17:16And I think that's what you're alluding to.
- 17:17So it would be a benefit.
- 17:19And it would be a benefit.
- 17:21That's not from transit, but we are saying that, you know, lots of major authorities across the world,
- 17:27they are just one single website, just to say, or one single hub.
- 17:31I believe that something will play a positive role, a positive impact for Toronto.
- 17:38That's a given.
- 17:39Right.
- 17:39Now, as the operator of the Ontario line, when it is up and running, which is probably five or six years away now, but time is marching on, we're going to have driverless trains.
- 17:50These are going to be, in a sense, automated trains, which you see around the world, but I think relatively new here.
- 17:58Talk a little bit about that.
- 17:59That's going to be a new thing for the TTC system, I think, to have driverless trains.
- 18:04But I think what it means is a fully automated system can move much more quickly.
- 18:08I think that's the logic.
- 18:10Really?
- 18:11Ontario will be really a showroom that's, you know, the high end in terms of transit system.
- 18:18Do you have a way for it just to be a bit more technical?
- 18:20So everything is automatized.
- 18:23You have screen doors.
- 18:25You can increase the number of trains per hour by 30%.
- 18:31Really?
- 18:32That's huge.
- 18:33That's really improving when you have-
- 18:35Because you know their safety.
- 18:36So the driver or the train coming in, there's no likelihood anybody's going to do anything.
- 18:42Exactly.
- 18:42So he can move more quickly.
- 18:43Right now, the trains, as you know, the TTC is always interesting.
- 18:46They come in very slowly into the station.
- 18:48Yeah, for safety reasons.
- 18:49For safety reasons.
- 18:50But there's long pauses through a station, right?
- 18:53Exactly.
- 18:53The amount of time spent in a station is actually quite long.
- 18:56So that will really improve, especially for rush hour,
- 18:59whether you have a major event when it's crowded.
- 19:01Yeah.
- 19:02It will improve a lot.
- 19:03So you have more safety.
- 19:05you will have more frequency for the train, more capacity.
- 19:10So really something really, you know, the high end,
- 19:13even in North America, that would be, we can be proud of that.
- 19:16Well, that's going to be exciting.
- 19:18And again, really interesting because on the interior line,
- 19:21you'll have essentially very different trains with, as you said,
- 19:25on the stations, you have these screens preventing people
- 19:28from getting to the train until the train has arrived.
- 19:32You'll have signaling that's much quicker.
- 19:34You'll have automated trains, very different from the rest, from lines, say, one and two.
- 19:39Does that work well to have sort of very different systems on different lines of a subway system?
- 19:46Does that happen in other cities?
- 19:47Of course.
- 19:48Of course.
- 19:49That's continuous improvement.
- 19:50Okay.
- 19:50And we have to deal with innovation, even in this kind of project.
- 19:54Every year you have new innovation coming, and we have to consider, like, AI.
- 19:59That AI is also a piece of innovation in the Ontario line.
- 20:04We will have the capacity.
- 20:06We will collect the data.
- 20:07We can anticipate any cracks in the rail.
- 20:10We will have the opportunity to reduce the service interruption, which would benefit again for the passengers.
- 20:16So preventative maintenance, preventative...
- 20:18Exactly. Everything is around that.
- 20:20We can monitor pretty much everything on the train, which is also new.
- 20:26So much more data.
- 20:27Much more data.
- 20:29But at the end, it's not just for the engineer, for the companies.
- 20:33and to well maintain the train, but also for the benefit of the passengers.
- 20:36Reduce the service interruption is the key element.
- 20:38Oh, absolutely.
- 20:39Punctuality is a top priority also for the passengers.
- 20:43So we'll see, I think, something very different than when the interior line opens
- 20:46in terms of speed of the trains, the way they come into the station and leave the station,
- 20:51the amount of time they spend in the station, the headway,
- 20:54which is the time gap between trains, will be shorter, it sounds like.
- 20:59Exactly. Just to give you an example, on the line one,
- 21:03the commercial speed is around 30 kilometers.
- 21:05In Ontario, it would be 40 kilometers.
- 21:08Okay.
- 21:09So it's much more faster.
- 21:11And you see that in Europe.
- 21:12I mean, I think people, it's interesting.
- 21:14I mean, I was in London recently.
- 21:15I was in Paris earlier in the year.
- 21:17And it does strike you that the trains come into the station quite quickly.
- 21:22They open the doors.
- 21:23People get in.
- 21:24They shut the doors.
- 21:25Off they go quite quickly compared to here where it kind of seems more leisurely.
- 21:30And part of it is, I think, on large portions of the system now, we've got fairly old signaling.
- 21:36So there's safety reasons why they have to slow down for certain periods.
- 21:39But then when they come into the station, as I've said, they come in quite slowly.
- 21:42And it seems like a long pause.
- 21:44It doesn't seem like you're in a hurry.
- 21:46It seems more like, you know, more leisurely, as I say.
- 21:49So that will be different.
- 21:50That will be quite exciting, I think.
- 21:52Oh, definitely.
- 21:53That will bring a lot.
- 21:55Definitely.
- 21:56Because, again, it's the high end in terms of transit system, you know, GOA4.
- 22:01So it's really the last version.
- 22:03But Arthur, it's going to be interesting because once the interior line is open
- 22:05and people experience this kind of faster movement,
- 22:09I think there'll be pressure, I'm assuming, on lines one and two for people to say,
- 22:13well, you know, why do I not have this?
- 22:15Why is it so much slower on these lines?
- 22:17I mean, I can assume that there'll be a lot of pressure to upgrade those systems.
- 22:21Yeah, and, you know, all the big cities around the world, they are doing that.
- 22:25sub-ruade on all the metro lines just to bring them to a GOA4, so the high end in terms of automation.
- 22:33Right.
- 22:34It's fascinating.
- 22:35Last thing.
- 22:35We're running out of time here, but this is a great conversation.
- 22:38I know that you mentioned when you talked about multimodal, you said gondolas.
- 22:43And I know that in Europe and in some other places, gondolas are becoming a form of transit,
- 22:49not just to go up a mountainside for tourists, but actually to move commuters.
- 22:56is there a prospect of that in a city like Toronto?
- 22:59Oh, I really believe.
- 23:00Where would we, could you imagine one, for example?
- 23:04On the first one, I would imagine it would be
- 23:06from the Toronto center to the island,
- 23:08just in the front.
- 23:10It could be a way just,
- 23:11not just to replace the ferries,
- 23:14but just in complement.
- 23:15Yeah.
- 23:15And that brings a lot.
- 23:17It brings, you know,
- 23:19as a transportation mode,
- 23:21but it's also something which could be iconic
- 23:25for a city.
- 23:26The difference between, I would say, an LRT and a Gordola system,
- 23:29a Gordola system is five times cheaper.
- 23:32- Five times cheaper?
- 23:33- Five times cheaper.
- 23:35It's faster. - Well, there's no tunneling.
- 23:36- No tunneling.
- 23:37It's faster to build.
- 23:39So if you want to go fast, if you want to go cheap,
- 23:43if you want to be effective, it makes sense.
- 23:46But it's--
- 23:47- Does it have the passengers, the number of passengers?
- 23:49- The passenger, it's a bit lower than the LRT system.
- 23:53But still, depending.
- 23:55So, of course, everything is around making the case around the transit system,
- 24:00what would be the ridership, what are the targets.
- 24:03But sometimes it makes sense just to look at the different modes of transportation.
- 24:07As I told you, you know, Transdev, we bring all the solutions, all modes of transportation.
- 24:12And we are not, you know, stuck in one mode.
- 24:14I believe that we need to have the discussion with the authority.
- 24:19What's the final goal for the authority?
- 24:21Except if you're going to do different transit, if you're going to think outside the box and think about different transit systems, you need to plan for that.
- 24:27So, for example, you think about the waterfront here.
- 24:29We're building buildings, you know, all up and down Queen's Cay.
- 24:33A gondola system, I'm assuming, if we were to think about that, five times cheaper.
- 24:37But presumably the gondola system would have to do a loop.
- 24:40Is there space here for that?
- 24:42Or we already used up all that space?
- 24:45I'm not, you know, I can't.
- 24:47I can't as well, you know, like that.
- 24:49But I'm just thinking that if you want to plan something.
- 24:51I believe it's a system really flexible.
- 24:53Yeah.
- 24:54And by the way, most of the big cities,
- 24:56they are using this system when you have tracks,
- 24:59rivers to cross,
- 25:01when you have really challenging environments
- 25:04where launching an LRT system,
- 25:08it's complex or costly.
- 25:10So it makes a lot of sense when we are closer in a river,
- 25:14when you have limits.
- 25:15We've got tracks here,
- 25:17and if you're crossing from the center of Toronto,
- 25:19like the core of Toronto,
- 25:21even Front Street to get to
- 25:23Queens Quay for example
- 25:25you're crossing the Gardner, you're crossing
- 25:27railway tracks and so on, I mean they're overhead
- 25:30but
- 25:32it's not a huge distance
- 25:34but would something have gone to
- 25:35lower for something like that or do you need longer
- 25:38distances like to the island?
- 25:39No, definitely
- 25:42there's always
- 25:43we need to find a balance in each project
- 25:45of course when it's too short
- 25:48you can't really leverage sometimes
- 25:49a transit system. It's like doing a LRT of two kilometers.
- 25:53Not worth it.
- 25:54Make no sense.
- 25:54Yeah.
- 25:55So we need to provide an added value on that. So of course, we have to think about that,
- 26:00just throwing the ideas. We need to make the analysis, but it could make sense depending on
- 26:04how you want to design that, how long, what would be when you start the line, where it's ending.
- 26:12Interesting.
- 26:12Yeah. But definitely makes sense. And it's happening in a lot of the cities. It could
- 26:18make sense it's not just one one size well i think the cost of transit we we did a study i mean the
- 26:23cost of transit is rising very rapidly i think it's close to you know toronto now it's close to a
- 26:27billion dollars a kilometer so if you could do it five times cheaper yeah to get the you know to get
- 26:32the benefit uh for passengers i think that would be worth looking at and that's the same for the
- 26:37operation by the way as well okay not right of course because it's far less complex yeah right
- 26:43Arthur, thank you
- 26:45great conversation, really enjoyed the conversation
- 26:48it looks like the sky's the limit
- 26:50in terms of transit if we're talking about gondolas
- 26:52but as well
- 26:53we're obviously looking forward to the Ontario Line
- 26:55coming here and what the benefits
- 26:57that's going to bring, so great work
- 26:59and glad to have TransDev
- 27:02involved in the
- 27:03operation of our transit system here
- 27:05Thank you so much
- 27:07Thanks for listening to Toronto Talks
- 27:10conversations with the leaders
- 27:11shaping the region's economy.
- 27:13Follow us wherever you get your podcasts.
- 27:45ご視聴ありがとうございました