Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Parental Rights vs. Student Privacy: Navigating the Post-Mirabelli Landscape
Transcript
- 0:03Hello, everyone. Welcome to today's program,
- 0:07Parental Rights versus Student Privacy, Navigating
- 0:10the Post -Mara Belli Landscape. I'm Alapoli Castro,
- 0:14Director of Education and Professional Development
- 0:16at Beverly Hills Bar Association. And today,
- 0:18I'm delighted to introduce our speakers, Dr.
- 0:21Sarah Young and Catherine Linge. Dr. Sarah Young
- 0:24is a partner, Atkinson, Andelson, Loya, Rudd,
- 0:27and Romo, where she serves as general counsel
- 0:29to school districts and educational agencies,
- 0:32advising on compliance, policy development, governance,
- 0:35instructional programs, employment matters, and
- 0:37conducting impartial investigations, including
- 0:40UCP and Title IX matters. Her legal practice
- 0:44is uniquely informed by advanced academic credentials,
- 0:48including a master's degree, or excuse me, master's
- 0:51degrees in education and specialist. education
- 0:53and a PhD in educational policy, as well as hands
- 0:57-on experience as an executive director at Capistrano
- 0:59Unified School District, where she focused on
- 1:02special education compliance and informal dispute
- 1:04resolution. Katherine Lenge is an associate at
- 1:08Anderson, Loya, Rudd and Romo, where she represents
- 1:12educational institutions in school districts
- 1:15in labor and employment matters, general education
- 1:18law and compliance with particular expertise
- 1:20in title line investigations, former resolution
- 1:23and trauma -informed strategies. She advises
- 1:27clients on a broad range of issues, including
- 1:29discrimination, harassment, retaliation, bullying,
- 1:32and employee misconduct, and is trained to conduct
- 1:35investigations in compliance with California
- 1:38law and federal regulations. We're so excited
- 1:40to hear what they have to share, so I'm going
- 1:42to turn it over to them. Hello, everybody. My
- 1:48name is Katherine Lingye. Thank you everyone
- 1:52for taking time out of your Tuesday afternoon
- 1:54to attend this MCLE about parents' rights and
- 1:58student privacy. I'll let my amazing co -presenter
- 2:02Sarah introduce herself as well. It's nice to
- 2:06see you guys. I'm here in the Southland as well.
- 2:08So I hope you're enjoying beautiful summer day
- 2:10and I'm happy to talk with you about this topic.
- 2:14It's very timely. We had just these decisions
- 2:18issued, and there's new decisions issued every
- 2:20day about parents' rights. And so I'll talk a
- 2:24little bit about a newer decision that didn't
- 2:26even make the slide when I get to my portion
- 2:28of this. But Katherine's going to get us started
- 2:30with some general parents' rights in education
- 2:33as we lead into kind of our Supreme Court cases.
- 2:39All right, so as part of our presentation today,
- 2:43we'll walk you through the existing parental
- 2:46rights in the Education Code. We'll discuss the
- 2:49two landmark U .S. Supreme Court cases, Mahmoud
- 2:51v. Taylor and Mirabelli v. Bonta, and we'll discuss
- 2:55some practical implications that arose from these
- 2:59cases. And then we'll have some time for questions
- 3:01and answers as well. But as a general overview,
- 3:05Mamoud dealt with parents' rights to opt out
- 3:08of material in public school curriculum. And
- 3:11really the main issue that the court answered
- 3:13in that case was, does a public school violate
- 3:17parental religious rights when it exposes students
- 3:20to instruction on gender and sexuality without
- 3:23prior parental notice or the opportunity to opt
- 3:27out of the instruction? So really the key there
- 3:30is parental notice, but more importantly, the
- 3:33opportunity to opt out. And in Mirabelli, the
- 3:37main issue that the court answered was whether
- 3:40a public school violates parents religious rights
- 3:43and their substantive due process rights when
- 3:46it withholds information from parents about their
- 3:48students gender presentation at school. Before
- 3:52we kind of jump into the content a bit further,
- 3:55I wanted to define some key terms that will come
- 3:57up a lot over the course of this presentation.
- 4:01So Local education agencies, we call them LEAs.
- 4:05It's really just a California public school district,
- 4:08K through 12. Public school administrators are
- 4:11going to be things like your school principals,
- 4:14maybe the superintendent. Certificated employees
- 4:17are just school teachers or other district staff
- 4:22that require a certification. And then pursuant
- 4:27to education code section 210 .7. I want to talk
- 4:31a little bit about gender, gender expression,
- 4:33and gender identity. So gender just means your
- 4:37sex. It includes a person's gender identity and
- 4:40gender expression. Gender expression is a person's
- 4:44gender -related appearance and behavior, whether
- 4:47or not this is stereotypically associated with
- 4:50the person's assigned sex at birth. And then
- 4:53gender identity is a person's internal understanding
- 4:57of their own gender. or the perception of a person's
- 5:02gender. So this may include male, female, or
- 5:05a combination of both, neither. It's a spectrum,
- 5:09right? So a gender different from the person's
- 5:12sex assigned at birth is also possible, or transgender,
- 5:16however that person defines their gender identity.
- 5:21Okay, next slide please. Okay. So cases like
- 5:28Mirabelli and Mahmood really affirmed parental
- 5:31rights in the educational context. But it's important
- 5:35to note that pursuant to the California Education
- 5:38Code, parents already have a set of pretty expansive
- 5:42rights as it relates to their students. And California
- 5:46Education Code section 51100 outlines the statutory
- 5:52rights. of parents and legal guardians of public
- 5:55school students to be informed about and also
- 5:58participate in their children's education. And
- 6:02it establishes a framework designed to foster
- 6:05a kind of mutually supportive partnership, more
- 6:09or less, between families and educators. So there
- 6:13are other individual sections of the Ed Code
- 6:17as well that include some provisions regarding
- 6:19things like notification, consent, opt out, parent
- 6:25involvement, but this specific section of the
- 6:28Ed Code is really a key area when it comes to
- 6:33parents' rights. So over the next few slides,
- 6:36you'll see that the Ed Code, specifically Ed
- 6:41Code section 51101, kind of creates a list, right?
- 6:48And it's 16 ways that Essentially, parents and
- 6:52guardians of public school students have the
- 6:55right to be informed by the school and to participate
- 6:58in the education of their children. And I won't
- 7:01walk you through each one, but just to kind of
- 7:03touch on a few over the next few slides. So parents
- 7:06have the right to meet with their children's
- 7:09teacher or principal. They have the right to
- 7:12volunteer their time and resources to receive
- 7:16the results of their child's academic performance.
- 7:19If you can go to the next slide. They also have
- 7:24the right to be informed of their child's progress
- 7:27in school. This is kind of an important one as
- 7:30it relates to Mahmood, but they also have the
- 7:33right to examine the curriculum materials of
- 7:36their child's class. Next slide please. They
- 7:42have the right to do things like receive information
- 7:45about any psychological testing the school does
- 7:48involving their child. And they also have the
- 7:50right to deny permission to give that test. They
- 7:53can question anything in their child's record
- 7:56that the parent feels is inaccurate, misleading,
- 8:00an invasion of privacy. So these rights under
- 8:04the Ed Code, they are fairly expansive. However,
- 8:08they're They're obviously not without limitation,
- 8:10right? If a parent wants to volunteer, they're
- 8:15going to be subject to things like fingerprinting.
- 8:19Being on campus, you know, has to be without
- 8:22disruption. You'll be subject to volunteering
- 8:25rules. Any kind of notification requirement,
- 8:29right? We'll have to be within a reasonable time.
- 8:32So, so there are limitations, but overall. Pursuant
- 8:36to the parents do have pretty expansive rights
- 8:39already as it relates to their students. Okay,
- 8:48another existing parental right in the education
- 8:51code involves the California healthy you. Act,
- 8:55which is enumerated in Ed Code sections 51930
- 8:59through 51939. Now, under this Act, school districts
- 9:06must provide comprehensive sexual health education,
- 9:11which includes information about HIV prevention.
- 9:16And this has to be provided twice, so once in
- 9:19middle school and then at least once in high
- 9:22school. And comprehensive sexual health education
- 9:26includes things like education regarding human
- 9:30development, sexuality, education on pregnancy,
- 9:35contraception, STIs, things like that. You can
- 9:39go to the next slide, please. Great. And so under
- 9:45the Act, parents are allowed to remove or opt
- 9:49their student out from all or a part of this
- 9:53education. But it's important to note that parent
- 9:58consent under the California Healthy Youth Act
- 10:01is passive. So this means that a school district
- 10:06can't require parents to opt into the education,
- 10:11right? However, the district must provide notice
- 10:13to the families at the beginning of the year,
- 10:16basically explaining These are the educational
- 10:18materials, they're available for inspection by
- 10:21you, and you do have the right to opt out if
- 10:25you choose to do so. Next slide, please. Thank
- 10:32you. Okay, just a couple other general consent
- 10:36provisions of the Ed Code to note before we kind
- 10:39of move on to Mahmood. Ed code section 51513,
- 10:45it requires notification and written consent
- 10:48prior to any type of testing, surveying, where
- 10:54you're asking questions about the student's personal
- 10:57beliefs or practices regarding sex, family, religion,
- 11:00things like that. Or if you're asking them questions
- 11:05about their parents regarding those kind of same
- 11:07topics. Ed code section 6614 is kind of similar.
- 11:14Basically, it just says that you can't administer
- 11:16a test or assessment as part of a statewide kind
- 11:22of initiation regarding sex, family, life, religion,
- 11:30what have you. And then education code 48980
- 11:35is just the annual notice requirement that school
- 11:39districts are subject to. Okay, next slide. Okay,
- 11:46so transitioning over to Mahmood V. Taylor. We'll
- 11:50walk through kind of an outline of the next slides
- 11:53on the following slide. Okay. So we'll walk through
- 12:02the background of the case, what the U .S. Supreme
- 12:06Court decided, some impacts and considerations
- 12:10to keep in mind, some potential compliance issues
- 12:15for LEAs, and then really what does this mean
- 12:18for LEA students and their parents moving forward.
- 12:26Okay, so turning to the factual background of
- 12:29Mahmood. So in this case, there was a school
- 12:33district which included LGBTQ plus inclusive
- 12:37storybooks as part of its K through five language
- 12:41curriculum. And this curriculum was adopted by
- 12:44the board district wide. And so these books were
- 12:48specifically designed to bring in a more diverse
- 12:52and inclusive discussion regarding these LGBTQ
- 12:56plus issues like gay marriage and gender identity.
- 13:00So a threshold we like to ask our clients when
- 13:04we're evaluating curriculum and any potential
- 13:07MAMUD implications is, do you have a board adopted
- 13:11set of curriculum designed to bring in these
- 13:14inclusive topics? If not, you're not Squarely
- 13:19within my mood, but there are still several implications
- 13:22of the decision that that may still affect you.
- 13:26And so the district initially allowed parents
- 13:30to opt out of the section discussing these books,
- 13:33but. What happened is the opt outs became too
- 13:38burdensome for the district, so they then moved
- 13:41away from that and they started requiring students
- 13:44to. participate in this board approved curriculum.
- 13:49This upset parents, three families filed suit,
- 13:53and these families weren't trying to necessarily
- 13:56stop the books for everyone. Instead, their complaints
- 14:00focused largely on the lack of notice and the
- 14:03lack of ability to opt out. And the reason these
- 14:07families wanted the opportunity to opt out is
- 14:10because they believed that the instruction around
- 14:14these books, a specific curriculum impacted their
- 14:19free exercise of their religion and also conflicted
- 14:23with their personally held religious beliefs.
- 14:26And the district's response to these suits really
- 14:30relied on This disruption piece and the management
- 14:35issues piece and they said that these opt outs
- 14:38caused a significant management issue and they
- 14:42also argued that allowing other students to opt
- 14:45out may potentially stigmatize students who do
- 14:49identify as LGBTQ plus in the classroom. So those
- 14:53were kind of their their main arguments there.
- 14:56Next slide please. So the U .S. Supreme Court
- 15:03comes in, they granted a preliminary injunction.
- 15:08And while some people may say, you know, this
- 15:11is a temporary decision, the majority, when you're
- 15:14kind of reading through this decision, they seem
- 15:17pretty firm in their explanation. So I don't
- 15:21get the sense that they will stray too far on
- 15:24their decision in the future. In any event, the
- 15:28injunction basically said, you know, you have
- 15:30to stop preventing parents from opting out and
- 15:33instead you have to go back to at least offering
- 15:35parents the ability to opt out of the specific
- 15:39curriculum. And the court's rationale was really
- 15:42that by requiring elementary school students
- 15:46to participate in the LGBTQ plus storybook curriculum,
- 15:51the district pressured students to reject their
- 15:55own personal or family beliefs that may contradict
- 15:59the message in this curriculum. Specifically,
- 16:04the court found that the storybooks conveyed
- 16:07specific viewpoints that posed, quote, a real
- 16:11threat of undermining the religious beliefs and
- 16:15practices that the parents wish to instill. And
- 16:18the court reasoned that because topics like gay
- 16:22marriage and gender identity were depicted using
- 16:25what they believed was a normative message, they
- 16:29felt that this curriculum was essentially designed
- 16:32to disrupt the thinking of how students, you
- 16:35know, thought or were taught at home about concepts
- 16:39like sexuality and gender. So, ultimately, the
- 16:44court found that the district's decision to refuse
- 16:48to provide notice and to also prohibit the parents
- 16:52from opting their children out of this specific
- 16:55curriculum, infringe on the parents' rights to
- 16:59the free exercise of their religion and to also
- 17:02direct the religious upbringing of their children.
- 17:07Specifically in this case, the court applied
- 17:10strict scrutiny Although they only really went
- 17:14into that analysis for about a page or so of
- 17:19the decision, but either way the court found
- 17:22there really was no compelling state interest
- 17:25and that the purpose of the curriculum was not
- 17:29tailored to that specific goal. Okay, next slide
- 17:34please. So this specific quote we kind of pulled
- 17:39and highlighted. because this is the quote from
- 17:43the case and from the majority opinion that we
- 17:46rely on most when looking at opt -out requests
- 17:49and how to fashion subsequent opt -out forms.
- 17:55And the quote says, the question of whether a
- 17:59law substantially interferes with the religious
- 18:02development of a child will always be fact intensive.
- 18:05It will depend on the specific religious beliefs
- 18:09and practices asserted, as well as the specific
- 18:11nature of the educational requirement or curricular
- 18:14feature at issue. Educational requirements targeted
- 18:19towards very young children, for example, may
- 18:21be analyzed differently from those requirements
- 18:24for high school students. A court must also consider
- 18:27the specific context in which the instruction
- 18:30or materials at issue are presented. Are they
- 18:33presented in a neutral manner or are they presented
- 18:36in a manner that is hostile to religious viewpoints
- 18:39and designed to impose upon students a quote
- 18:42pressure to conform? And so when we're doing
- 18:47this analysis, we look mostly at. The families
- 18:52sincerely held beliefs and whether the curriculum
- 18:55really undermines that and we we want to avoid.
- 19:00Telling families, you know. that belief in whatever
- 19:04religion you are is not correct. This is the
- 19:07belief or something like that. Because the belief
- 19:11is going to be personal to them. It may vary
- 19:15by family. It may even vary by individual within
- 19:18that family, right? So it really is fact intensive.
- 19:22But to avoid kind of an overall free for all,
- 19:27right? You can put the ball back in the family,
- 19:30the family's court or the student's court and
- 19:33you can create an opt out form that is set up
- 19:36for them to explain to the LEA, you know, what
- 19:40their specific religious beliefs are and what
- 19:44specific curriculum interferes with that belief
- 19:47and how so. So kind of saying to them, help us
- 19:51understand the connection and leaning back on
- 19:54them to make that connection for you instead
- 19:57of you kind of taking that on yourself. In reading
- 20:03the majority opinion, though it is likely that
- 20:08the court may allow this connection to be quite
- 20:11broad regarding what a sincerely held religious
- 20:16belief is, it can't be as broad as something
- 20:18like I want to opt out of all LGBTQ plus curriculum.
- 20:24In that case, families will have to justify how
- 20:28all LGBTQ plus curriculum, you know, interferes
- 20:33with their religious beliefs. Instead, we're
- 20:35looking at, you know, what book, what lesson,
- 20:37what specific curriculum conflicts with their
- 20:40belief. And that connection as to why the curriculum
- 20:45conflicts with the belief will also Assist the
- 20:48district and the teacher if they decide to provide
- 20:53some type of secondary education plan for the
- 20:55student as well. Okay. Okay, yeah, we're on the
- 21:04right slide. So it's important to know based
- 21:06off of this, this quote here. The question is
- 21:11not mere exposure. So mere exposure is not the
- 21:15determination here, right? Simply being exposed
- 21:17to LGBTQ plus individuals in the curriculum,
- 21:22like historical figures who may be gay, would
- 21:25not necessarily trigger Mahmood. Instead, we're
- 21:29looking at whether the curriculum would substantially
- 21:32interfere. or pose a real threat of undermining
- 21:36religious beliefs by imposing these kind of normative
- 21:40ideas on the students. Okay, next slide. Okay,
- 21:51again, Mammut is really focused on LGBTQ plus
- 21:55material. However, the decision does not specifically
- 21:59define what constitutes LGBTQ plus related materials.
- 22:05It also doesn't really discuss how to handle
- 22:09the mere presence of LGBTQ plus individuals in
- 22:12instructional material. It's important to note
- 22:18that right now, it is focused on that specific
- 22:21kind of curriculum, but in the future it may
- 22:23eventually apply to. curriculum beyond LGBTQ
- 22:28plus material, depending on its application.
- 22:34And again, when we're reading over the decision,
- 22:36the majority opinion really focused in on and
- 22:39took issue with that kind of quote normative
- 22:42aspects of the storybooks in question. So specifically,
- 22:47you know, regarding same sex marriage, they felt
- 22:51that the books presented same sex marriage is
- 22:54not merely an existing practice, but instead
- 22:59they framed it as a perspective that should be
- 23:03celebrated and positively reinforced, which made
- 23:08parents feel like it undermined, and the court
- 23:12feel like it undermined parents' ability to kind
- 23:15of present opposite viewpoints. And then regarding
- 23:20gender identity, the court took issue with the
- 23:24book's assertion that at any point in our lives,
- 23:27we can, you know, choose to identify with whatever
- 23:31gender we feel is personal to ourselves. And
- 23:36they felt that the book and the corresponding
- 23:38curriculum presented a, you know, if the student
- 23:43had a contrary view, that maybe gender was you
- 23:48know, not as fluid that that was something to
- 23:51be reprimanded for or kind of looked down upon.
- 23:55So again, they just felt that the curriculum
- 23:58really created these normative beliefs that students
- 24:03were kind of pressured into following. Okay,
- 24:09next slide. Okay, so some considerations to keep
- 24:14in mind. LEAs need to be aware that there are
- 24:21state and federal laws prohibiting discrimination
- 24:24and that also provide protections against harassment
- 24:29based on protected characteristics because LEAs
- 24:33have an obligation to provide a discrimination
- 24:37free education and work environment. So the overarching
- 24:41principle to kind of keep in mind there is that
- 24:44LEAs must ensure that their curriculum meets
- 24:47all California required standards for students,
- 24:51including any type of curriculum standards that
- 24:54involve anti -discrimination, anti -harassment,
- 24:56things like that. However, if a parent or a student
- 25:00opts out of mandated curriculum based on their
- 25:04religious objections, then the LEA must follow
- 25:07the various opt -out provisions that Mahmood
- 25:11implemented. Another kind of important caveat
- 25:15here is Mahmood doesn't discuss what to do if
- 25:20a student is opted out of instruction. So one
- 25:24of the students in Mahmood, when they had opted
- 25:27out of the curriculum, they just went and they
- 25:30sat in the hallway outside of the classroom during
- 25:32the lesson, but the majority opinion didn't really
- 25:36comment further on those facts and say whether
- 25:39that was sufficient or Yeah, so we'll discuss
- 25:44some other gray areas that the decision didn't
- 25:48fully provide guidance on in a few slides. Okay,
- 25:52next slide. Okay, so what are we kind of looking
- 26:01for when making recommendations of whether Mahmood
- 26:06is applicable? We're looking at, first and foremost,
- 26:10how is the information presented? Is it being
- 26:13presented in a neutral matter? So, for example,
- 26:17if part of the curriculum discusses Harvey Milk,
- 26:21are we discussing how he was a significant figure
- 26:24in California politics and his role in advocating
- 26:28for LGBTQ plus rights? Or is the curriculum stating,
- 26:33you know, this was Harvey Milk's message and
- 26:36kind of applying pressure to conform to that
- 26:39message. If it's the latter, you may implicate
- 26:43Mahmood and opt -out rights may be applicable.
- 26:48You'll also want to consider the age of the students.
- 26:51So the younger students which were at issue in
- 26:54Mahmood may require you to kind of take a closer
- 26:58look at whether curriculum requires an opt -out.
- 27:03And we find with older students, you know, they
- 27:06may have a better ability to differentiate between
- 27:10what the curriculum is promoting and what their
- 27:14personally held beliefs are, and they may not
- 27:16feel as much of that pressure. Okay, next slide.
- 27:27All right, some other things to keep in mind
- 27:29when making recommendations to clients are some
- 27:33of the following. So a lot of LEAs note the administrative
- 27:41burden when implementing opt -out requirements.
- 27:44And as we discussed previously, the majority
- 27:47opinion didn't really seem to think there was
- 27:50much of a burden. In practice, I think we see
- 27:54that there is an administrative burden, but because
- 27:59of the majority's opinion, that may not be a
- 28:03compelling argument, right, when an LEA wants
- 28:06to kind of push back. However, the dissent did
- 28:11kind of note that there would be some disruption
- 28:15because of the opt -out requirements specifically
- 28:18on student learning and development. And then
- 28:23again, you know, you'll always want to assess
- 28:25what is a sincerely held religious belief, Does
- 28:30the curriculum as written constitute more than
- 28:32just exposure to a topic? Ultimately, does it
- 28:37threaten to kind of undermine religious beliefs
- 28:40of the students in the class? Okay, next slide.
- 28:48So what does this actually mean? How is this
- 28:51impacting LEAs, parents, students? Overall, under
- 28:58the MIMU decision, LEAs now have an affirmative
- 29:01obligation to provide parents with notice and
- 29:05the opportunity to opt out of any type of curriculum
- 29:08that may substantially interfere with the religious
- 29:12development of their child. Any challenges under
- 29:17the free exercise clause are going to be fact
- 29:20-intensive and fact -specific. That's kind of
- 29:23the main takeaway from this. The facts may differ
- 29:27by community, family, age range. If you have
- 29:32clients all over, right, you may see the facts
- 29:37vary a bit. This isn't a one size fits all answer.
- 29:41You'll still have to undergo a fact intensive
- 29:45analysis. And so this is a somewhat gray standard,
- 29:50right? We don't have kind of a bright line standard
- 29:54from the court for notice. We don't have a standard
- 29:57for what opting out needs to look like, time
- 30:01frame, sincerely held religious belief, things
- 30:05like that. So we can take what we have from a
- 30:08mood and kind of give best guidance. But like
- 30:12I said, the decision really doesn't offer a bright
- 30:15line rule on what opt out requirements and notice
- 30:18will look like. So kind of to look ahead, the
- 30:23The exact boundaries of this decision and how
- 30:25it impacts the day to day classroom are a bit.
- 30:29Unclear, but with most issues, right? Which are
- 30:33case law kind of dependent. We hope to get clarity
- 30:37through through the reasoning that comes from
- 30:40judicial decisions in the coming years. I will
- 30:46just add on that. Bringing it back to what Catherine
- 30:50said in the beginning when she was going over
- 30:52some of what Ed code says in. Section 5, 1, 1,
- 30:581, in California, which again, we have different
- 31:02laws in other states. It has always been a parent,
- 31:06right? I would say always, but in the most recent
- 31:09past for the time that we can all remember, it
- 31:12has been a right. the parents can access the
- 31:15curriculum in their classroom. So parents have
- 31:18had that ability to go see what their students
- 31:19are learning. In the recent past, if you have
- 31:22a kid in our public schools particularly, but
- 31:25a lot of the private schools do this too, your
- 31:28students are learning things that are on Google
- 31:29Classroom. The curriculum is available on the
- 31:32website already. And a lot of districts have
- 31:35a board policy and board policies are available
- 31:37on websites. 6141 .2. which was already a religious
- 31:45opt out. So it is not a required one. It is a
- 31:49voluntary one, but most school districts in California
- 31:52already had this. And so that was that if there
- 31:56was curriculum happening in your schools that
- 31:58you had a religious objection to, it's where,
- 32:01you know, if there's. a dissection is happening.
- 32:07If there is things happening in your classrooms
- 32:09that you don't want, you would go to your principal
- 32:11and say, this is happening at my school. I saw
- 32:14it in the curriculum. I have a religious objection,
- 32:16a conscientious objection. Let's work through
- 32:18this. You worked through it with your principal.
- 32:21You got an alternative assignment. Where Mahmood
- 32:24has taken us in California is this notification
- 32:27piece. And so what does notification look like?
- 32:30How do you notify? When do you notify? Is it
- 32:33just Telling parents our curriculum is on our
- 32:37website. Here you go. Is it saying no, you have
- 32:40to tell people at the beginning of a unit and
- 32:42then how do we address? Really functionally and
- 32:45strategically in an informed way in a way that
- 32:48people want their community to be involved. Hey,
- 32:52we're going to be talking about this in class,
- 32:53but oh, we have a parent speaker that came in
- 32:55and brought a book. I wasn't expecting and what
- 32:58do we do with those families who don't want to
- 33:00get badgered and knocked on the door? notified
- 33:03every time, oh, you're doing a lesson? Well,
- 33:05I don't want to be told about it. It's triggering
- 33:08for me to keep getting notice about this because
- 33:11we like this in our home or we don't like it
- 33:13and we don't want to keep getting what that might
- 33:15be. And so working through those issues, those
- 33:18opportunities for discussion, that is something
- 33:22that wasn't thought about by people in robes.
- 33:26And we're having to figure that out. So that's
- 33:28all part of my mood that we're uniquely situated
- 33:31for in California. because we already had a lot
- 33:34of this involvement in rights that just wasn't
- 33:37something maybe people thought about. So I'm
- 33:41going to take you to another case, Mirabelli
- 33:43versus Bonta. So you can go on to the next one.
- 33:47My dream, in case all of you want to know, slash
- 33:49my nightmare, is to be the name in one of these.
- 33:52I'm sure Mr. Bonta is whatever, but I never want
- 33:55to be the name on a lawsuit. It's just the name
- 33:58like Young. I hope it never happens. Why are
- 34:01we here? I'm going to give you a little factual
- 34:03background of how Mirabelli versus Bonta made
- 34:06it up to the Supreme Court and is continuing
- 34:08to make its way through our court system today.
- 34:11A little background about the law, the lower
- 34:14court proceedings, the emergency dock and appeal
- 34:16to the U .S. Supreme Court, and then the activity
- 34:19that has been happening since then because it
- 34:22is an ongoing case. And then there are other
- 34:24cases now that are spawning from it as This case
- 34:29is just continuing to gather traction from a
- 34:33parent rights perspective, but also from a employment
- 34:37law perspective. And so how this is working and
- 34:40what this is looking like for our schools, for
- 34:42our students, and for employees that work in
- 34:45our schools. So why are we here? Go on our next
- 34:50one. Actually, this is two cases that came together.
- 34:55But in 2023, there was a school district. that
- 34:58shall not be named, that adopted a parental notification
- 35:02policy that required certificated employees,
- 35:04which that's any employee that has to have a
- 35:06credential from the state, and administrators
- 35:09who also have to have credentials, to notify
- 35:12parents when they observed students, saw students,
- 35:15learned about students, who requested to use
- 35:18a different name and pronoun from their legal
- 35:21name. So if I told a teacher, don't call me Sarah,
- 35:25call me Sean, my teacher was required to call
- 35:28my parents. If my teacher saw that happening
- 35:32on the playground and saw me telling peers to
- 35:36do that, they had to call my parents. Similarly,
- 35:39if a teacher saw a student access programs, activities,
- 35:43or facilities that didn't align with my biological
- 35:45sex, they had to call my parent. So if they saw
- 35:48me walking into A male restroom or a gender neutral
- 35:53restroom that doesn't align with my assumed gender.
- 35:56They needed to call my parents. The policy also
- 36:01required that if I requested the change information
- 36:03in my official or unofficial records, so. Ask
- 36:07that they change the preferred name on a document
- 36:09call my parents. This policy went through their
- 36:14board, got approved, put up on their website.
- 36:17And Mr. Bonta sued the school district. The state
- 36:20sued the school district. The California legislature
- 36:25then passed AB 1955 and 2023 to be effective
- 36:29that January to prohibit any other school districts
- 36:32from adopting or enforcing similar policies or
- 36:36policies that would require employees to disclose
- 36:40information about students' sexual orientation.
- 36:42their gender identity or their gender expression
- 36:45without students' consent. So if a student didn't
- 36:48say, yes, tell my parents, you couldn't tell
- 36:51parents as a staff member. So in response to
- 36:54what was happening, the state came and said,
- 36:56we're passing this. Next slide is actually that
- 37:02statute. So on the next slide, we have what 1955
- 37:04did, and that added some provisions to the Ed
- 37:07Code. You can read them. They're online. Point
- 37:123 says an employee can not be required to disclose
- 37:17information about a student's sexual orientation,
- 37:19gender identity, or gender expression to anyone
- 37:21else without the pupil's consent. So my employer
- 37:24cannot tell me to do that. And then the state
- 37:27said, this isn't a change of the law. We're just
- 37:29declaring existing law. And similarly, the next
- 37:33one says a school district can't enforce any
- 37:36existing rule or policy or regulation that requires
- 37:40employees to do this. So again, if you have 1,
- 37:43you can't enforce it. That is what 1955 did.
- 37:48So we have this in place. We have the state suing.
- 37:52And then something else happens in another school
- 37:55district on our next slide down South. They have
- 38:01a gender non -disclosure policy in place. The
- 38:04gender non -disclosure policy that's in place,
- 38:07if you want it to Google, it is board policy
- 38:10or AR 5145 .3. So board policy or administrative
- 38:15regulation 5145 .3. It is a non -discrimination
- 38:21policy for students. And in that is language
- 38:24very typically throughout pretty much every district
- 38:27that says, We're not going to tell your parents
- 38:31unless the student wants us to, unless another
- 38:36law requires us to. That's usually what the language
- 38:38says. But in Escondido, it was implemented and
- 38:41enforced a little bit differently and staff was
- 38:44actually clearly directed, don't tell parents
- 38:47and also lie to parents. There was some staff
- 38:49members that felt that they were very pressured
- 38:51to be actively dishonest. So it was like, don't
- 38:55tell people, put stickers over kids' names, rip
- 38:58down work from classrooms, be dishonest, deceitful,
- 39:02keep it from parents in every way you can. That's
- 39:07how these staff members felt, very pressured.
- 39:09So two teachers challenge the policies on religious
- 39:12grounds, saying requiring us to use students
- 39:15preferred names and pronouns at school, and then
- 39:17prohibiting us from disclosing it to parents
- 39:20violates our religious beliefs. So we feel like
- 39:23we're lying to parents that's against our religion.
- 39:28As a result, some parents and the teachers got
- 39:31together and brought a class action lawsuit.
- 39:33They felt like. This was misleading, parents
- 39:37are guardians. That is the lawsuit Mirabelli
- 39:39versus Bonta. It's parents, it's teachers, and
- 39:42they are suing. So that lawsuit is making its
- 39:46way up through California Supreme Court, and
- 39:48we're going to follow it along its pathway here.
- 39:51So initially in December, On our next slide December
- 39:5422nd, 2025, I feel sometimes it's like when people
- 39:59say school districts, you did this on purpose
- 40:02and I want to tell every parent, I guarantee.
- 40:05That like transportation did not talk to maintenance
- 40:08and they didn't do anything on purpose when.
- 40:10You get some mean letter from one department
- 40:12on the same day. It's something else. I'm sure
- 40:14the court didn't do this on purpose, but it feels
- 40:16awful that you like give decisions on Christmas
- 40:20or a decision that's like. something on Pride
- 40:23Month or like Black History Month like this decision
- 40:25came out the week of Christmas. So on December
- 40:2822nd, the U .S. court granted permanent injunctive
- 40:32relief to the parents and guardians and teachers
- 40:35about non -disclosure laws. So they said Escondido
- 40:40School District and State of California, you
- 40:43cannot implement or enforce any provision of
- 40:46California law that would permit or require an
- 40:50employee to mislead a parent regarding gender
- 40:53presentation at school. Can't do it. You also
- 40:57can't require school employees use a name or
- 40:59pronoun that doesn't match their legal name or
- 41:01their natal pronoun if a parent or guardian has
- 41:04communicated an objection to that use. Okay.
- 41:08And then the state was putting together training
- 41:10materials. Your training materials had to include
- 41:13a statement. about parents' constitutional right
- 41:16to be informed about gender and congruence. So
- 41:20this comes down in December. Immediately, the
- 41:23state of California moves for an emergency stay,
- 41:27and the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals granted
- 41:29that. That was in January. So right after the
- 41:33Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals grants the stay,
- 41:36the parents and the teachers files the Supreme
- 41:40Court for an intervention. And that case was
- 41:43heard by the Supreme Court and a decision was
- 41:48issued in March. So we can go to that. I think
- 41:54you can skip. Well, we'll go through the next
- 41:56slides. Go ahead. So next slide. This was the
- 41:58actual injunction that was issued by the district
- 42:01court. So defendants, which is again the state
- 42:04and the school district, Escondido, they couldn't
- 42:09have employees directly lie to parents. They
- 42:14couldn't access, they couldn't prevent parents
- 42:18from accessing educational records. They could
- 42:21not use different sets of pronouns when speaking
- 42:23to parents than when they were speaking to the
- 42:25kids. They couldn't kind of code switch intentionally
- 42:28again to mislead or lie. They couldn't require
- 42:34employees to use different names or pronouns
- 42:37if the employee didn't want to. They couldn't
- 42:40require employees to tell kids and use different
- 42:43pronouns with kids. And then they couldn't interfere
- 42:46with a teacher or school administrator or counselor
- 42:49or staff member from communicating to parents
- 42:51that a child had been using a different pronoun,
- 42:54right? Next slide. The other part, again, there's
- 43:01a mandatory training that if you work in grades
- 43:04seven through 12, if you're a credentialed employee
- 43:08working in grades seven through 12, you have
- 43:09to do a training. The training is about the prevalence
- 43:14of LGBTQ students who commit suicide, who are
- 43:18bullied, your requirement to intervene in those
- 43:21areas to prevent bullying, to be proactive to
- 43:24prevent suicide, some of the laws about facility
- 43:28use, pronoun use, those kinds of things. the
- 43:30state was required to put information about parents
- 43:34rights in that training. Okay, so. He switched
- 43:39to the Supreme Court on March 2nd, 2026. The
- 43:42Supreme Court issues a decision. That's on our
- 43:46next slide. So in that issue in that decision,
- 43:50they vacated the stay, so they re implemented
- 43:53the injunction, but only as to parents, not as
- 43:57to teachers. It's a little complicated, and we're
- 44:00not sure why that is. This is not a surprise,
- 44:04given the Supreme Court, its current makeup,
- 44:07and the other types of decisions it's implementing
- 44:09and issuing right now. So again, like today,
- 44:12the Supreme Court issued a decision about transgender
- 44:14athletes. Not a surprise. Some surprising statements,
- 44:20but not a surprise in it. This one, not a surprise.
- 44:23You have a decision where they said, California's
- 44:27policies, the way they are, substantially interfere
- 44:30with the rights of parents to guide the religious
- 44:33development of their children. They went right
- 44:35to religion just like they did in Mahmood. They
- 44:38said, hey, parents are the primary protector
- 44:42of children's best interests, and that's well
- 44:45established, the Supreme Court. The interest
- 44:48of California in advancing student safety and
- 44:51privacy, and that's what you're saying is your
- 44:54interest in not disclosing, I'm going to, what
- 44:57does the child want? That is not compelling enough
- 45:01to overcome the substantial interest of parents
- 45:04in guiding the religious upbringing and the upbringing
- 45:07of their children. So parents, not the state,
- 45:12are the primary authority with respect to the
- 45:15upbringing of their children, the education of
- 45:17their children. And part of that is the right
- 45:20not to be shut out of decisions that involve
- 45:23their children and their children's mental health.
- 45:26They can't make those decisions if they're not
- 45:29informed. Gender dysphoria is a mental health
- 45:34issue. It's a condition that has an important
- 45:36bearing on children's mental health. So if they're
- 45:38not informed about the full aspect of their children,
- 45:42they can't make informed decisions. Part of that
- 45:45is parental notification. So parents need to
- 45:47be part of the discussion and you can't withhold
- 45:51information. That's part of the underlying theme
- 45:55of Mirabelli. When you continue on, the court
- 46:00says California's policies trigger strict scrutiny.
- 46:03We're using a strict scrutiny standard because
- 46:05they substantially interfere with the rights
- 46:07of parents to guide religious development. So
- 46:10we're going to Mahmood, we're using strict scrutiny.
- 46:13They're saying, look, we use that over there
- 46:14with introduction of storybooks, but here we're
- 46:18actually talking about kids and their behavior,
- 46:20gender transition, pronoun use. Like this is
- 46:22a case for strict scrutiny. They also said everyone
- 46:26here, the state, the district, the teachers,
- 46:29the parents, we all agree that children safety.
- 46:32Overriding issue, but we're all focused on here
- 46:36and an injunction promotes children's safety
- 46:39by guaranteeing that fit parents have a role
- 46:43in the consequential decisions in children's
- 46:46lives. The injunction permits parents to shield
- 46:49children from unfit parents by enforcing child
- 46:52abuse laws and removing children from parental
- 46:55custody in appropriate cases. So a significant
- 47:00argument used when staff members, district staff
- 47:06want to withhold information from parents is
- 47:11when students will say, and it's true, there
- 47:15is There's data for this. It's not just, oh,
- 47:18it's anecdotal. There's data for this. But I
- 47:22don't want to tell my parents I believe I will
- 47:24be harmed, whether it's because it's on an extreme,
- 47:27is it going to a conversion camp? Less extreme,
- 47:30it's just a fear of not being accepted. There's
- 47:33some fear of being harmed for a student. If whatever,
- 47:37it's a pronoun use, it's a name change, it's
- 47:40a gender expression and identity, fear. The decision
- 47:46tells you, and the way that this kind of rolls
- 47:49out is. If as a district employee, you have a
- 47:54concern that a student is at risk. For neglect
- 47:57or abuse, your answer isn't just withhold from
- 48:01a parent. It is you have an obligation to file
- 48:05a mandated report. A suspected child abuse or
- 48:09neglect that has to go part and parcel. And so,
- 48:13if you are withholding. It's because you have
- 48:15filed abuse and neglect report, but then is being
- 48:19investigated. That is where they're going, okay,
- 48:22you have fit parents and you have a concern about
- 48:25an unfit parents. We're only allowed to withhold
- 48:28information under very other circumstances in
- 48:32the state when we also couple it with the actual
- 48:35report of abuse and neglect that then is investigated.
- 48:39And so they're saying, you can't just make this
- 48:41unilateral decision based on nothing. Oh, I'm
- 48:43not going to tell a parent. It's because I am
- 48:46making an appropriate report of suspected abuse
- 48:49and neglect. And we as district representatives,
- 48:54we do hold people accountable for not making
- 48:58unfounded, unauthorized reports. They have to
- 49:01be made in good faith. It's violative of professional
- 49:04standards not to be making those appropriately.
- 49:09The impact of this decision on our next slide
- 49:11is this affected parent plaintiffs, not teachers.
- 49:14So they did not explain why we didn't lift the
- 49:18stay as to teacher plaintiffs, but so much of
- 49:21this is so interconnected. If parents have these
- 49:24rights, teachers have an obligation then to implement
- 49:27things certain lives. There are teacher rights
- 49:29embedded in these, but those have to do with
- 49:32accommodations and supports, and that was not
- 49:34even discussed in this decision. This case absolutely
- 49:38reaffirmed parents' rights. It continued a pathway
- 49:42we're seeing at the Supreme Court level of parents
- 49:45have a right to be informed of and involved in
- 49:47children's educations. Parents are the driver
- 49:50of education, public or private. They have a
- 49:55key component in the education system. But this
- 49:58is not a decision on the merits. This case was
- 50:00kicked back, and it is continuing through the
- 50:03court case. You know, the nitty gritty of what
- 50:06the policy is going to look like, what the training
- 50:08on this policy is going to look like. That is
- 50:10all to be worked out. How parent notification
- 50:14looks, what records will look like. All of this
- 50:18has to be kind of tweaked a little bit. And one
- 50:22of the things that really matters in our school
- 50:24system is this is about children. We have a lot
- 50:28of 18 year olds in our schools. That's in our
- 50:30land of special ed, all of our 18 to 22 year
- 50:33olds who aren't conserved. But even in our public
- 50:35schools with transitional kindergarten, we see
- 50:39a lot of 18 and 19 year olds in our high schools
- 50:41right now. This case, this is for students who
- 50:44are under 18. At 18, rights transition to a student
- 50:48themselves. So we're talking about students 17
- 50:51and below. Okay. So part of Mirabelli recognized
- 51:00parents rights to be informed about mental health.
- 51:02They focused a lot on gender dysphoria is a condition
- 51:06that has a bearing on mental health. Parents
- 51:08need to be informed. Employed training has to
- 51:12include information about parents rights to be
- 51:14informed. There is a training. The importance
- 51:19of parents being a member of a school team. We
- 51:22see this a lot, but it really focused on making
- 51:26sure this was explicit. So if you go on CDE's
- 51:29website, you can look up like CDE Mirabelli statement.
- 51:32It's there. It's in bold. It's an exact statement
- 51:34they were ordered to do. It's on a training that
- 51:38people do for Keenan. It's on a training that
- 51:40if you do that I gave, it's there. You're required
- 51:42to have it. Let's see. March 3rd, CDE came out
- 51:50and issued a statement about Mirabelli. They
- 51:51sent it out to every school district to make
- 51:54sure that all of the districts in the state were
- 51:57aware of Mirabelli, of the Mirabelli decision,
- 52:00of the impact. They made a request. I skipped.
- 52:04I had a couple slides. Sorry. On March 6th, there
- 52:08was a motion to modify the state that was not
- 52:11granted. So the motion was not granted. The injunction.
- 52:18All of that we are doing what the Supreme Court
- 52:21said. We are implementing the Supreme Court decision
- 52:24at this point. Right now the way that we kind
- 52:41of explain it to some of our districts is. If
- 52:45you are a staff member and you are trying to
- 52:47implement Mirabelli as you were finishing out
- 52:49the school year and you were trying to figure
- 52:50out what to do as a staff member, you are fundamentally
- 52:54prohibited from misleading or being dishonest
- 52:58or lying to a parent about a student's gender
- 53:01identity or gender expression. That includes
- 53:04pronouns. That includes the name they use. So
- 53:08how that looks in your classroom. is when students
- 53:12are using a different name, we don't change their
- 53:14name when we're talking to parents. We don't
- 53:16change their name on our role system. Or if we
- 53:20use ClassDojo or Parent Portal, the name we use
- 53:22with kids is the name we use with parents. The
- 53:25name we use with kids is the name we use on our
- 53:27emails to parents, on our communications with
- 53:29parents. And that's how we avoid misleading or
- 53:33misidentifying or being not truthful or dishonest.
- 53:39We have parents who then say, wait, wait, wait.
- 53:43You're calling my kid X and my kid is Y and I
- 53:47disagree and I don't want you to do that. We
- 53:50are now legally required to do the parents preference.
- 53:53So if you turn around and you go to a kid and
- 53:55you say, hey, I know Sarah is your legal name
- 53:58and you really want to go by Sean. But your mom
- 54:01has said or your dad or your parent guardian,
- 54:04whoever has said, I can't call you that. I have
- 54:06to call you this. Then we're working with our
- 54:09mental health professionals and our other staff
- 54:11to say, either let's do some family meetings,
- 54:15let's do some teamwork. Or if calling you Sarah
- 54:19is causing freak outs and I'm not allowed to
- 54:22call you Sean, your preferred gender, your preferred
- 54:25name, I'm going to call you students. I'm going
- 54:28to call you something that is completely unevented.
- 54:31Actually, I call all my kids when I was teacher
- 54:32dude. Hey, dude. What's up, dude? But we cannot
- 54:38call kids things in conflict with their parents'
- 54:41beliefs once their parents have expressed that
- 54:43to us. And that can be a really hard and difficult
- 54:45conversation. So working through those and working
- 54:48with those. Similarly, we can't hide records.
- 54:53We can't do anything to be hiding and dishonest.
- 54:56But we can work with families and work. with
- 54:59our staff to put the most trained capable person
- 55:03to lead those conversations to get everyone on
- 55:05the same page because that's what we want. We
- 55:07want everyone to be successful. We want everyone
- 55:09to have a safe school experience and to be the
- 55:12most supported by everyone. There was a the last
- 55:18couple slides was the court explaining their
- 55:21rationale and it is a powerful rationale. If
- 55:24you want to skip ahead to slide 39. When the
- 55:28court was explaining why there is this rationale
- 55:32for unless you have a child that you believe
- 55:35is actively abused or neglected and you're filing
- 55:39a CPS report and you're moving through that,
- 55:42why do you have to disclose to parents? Why do
- 55:45parents have to be part of this process? And
- 55:47the court said, when the PO child attempted to
- 55:50commit suicide, had she succeeded? She'd been
- 55:53successful and died by suicide. It would have
- 55:57been the parents who lived with that decision.
- 56:00They were the ones, not Mr. Vonta. Mr. Vonta
- 56:03wasn't sitting at bedside there with that girl.
- 56:05Mr. Thurmond wasn't sitting at the bedside with
- 56:07that girl. The teacher wasn't sitting. The principal
- 56:11wasn't sitting there. And had she succeeded,
- 56:13it wouldn't have been the parents who would have
- 56:15lived with that for the rest of their lives.
- 56:17They could have done something about it if they
- 56:19had been told ahead of time. So that was why
- 56:24the court Made the decision the way they did
- 56:27and. The next slide says at the bottom, those
- 56:32teachers, those administrators, Mr. Vanta, Mr.
- 56:35Thurmond, when the semester is over, those kids
- 56:37are gone. It's not their problem anymore, but
- 56:39for the parents, this continues to be their problem.
- 56:44I might have lots of other feelings about. You
- 56:48know, no teachers don't stop caring about kids
- 56:50when they're not in their classroom and we have
- 56:52a lot of feelings, but. But yes, in a balancing
- 56:54test, I didn't birth that child. It is their
- 56:58child. And that's where the court side is. The
- 57:01end of the day, this is the person and this is
- 57:04a family that lives with a decision about whether
- 57:06or not information is shared with them. And so
- 57:09the court erred on the kind of emergency ruling
- 57:13the Supreme Court erred at. We are going to find
- 57:16that this injunction, this day we're going to
- 57:18do this because this is likely to cause harm.
- 57:21if we were not pulled it this way. Now, while
- 57:23the case is decided on the merits, this is what
- 57:25we're doing. And it continues to work its way
- 57:28through the court system. Who knows what the
- 57:30eventual decision will be, how it will shake
- 57:32out, where things will be nitty gritty. If you're
- 57:35familiar at all with California law, you'll know
- 57:37that there's a lot of rights that pass over to
- 57:40kids at 12 about their own mental health, about
- 57:43their own ability to seek medical treatment.
- 57:46Maybe we'll see some things that pass over to
- 57:4812. I don't know. But right now, absolutely.
- 57:53We tell folks, we tell staff, you cannot mislead,
- 57:57you cannot be dishonest. Parents have a right
- 58:00to be part of their children's education. And
- 58:02we see that throughout the Ed Code. We're just
- 58:04seeing it one more way here in the land of gender.
- 58:08What is unique about Mirabelli, and if you kind
- 58:12of have seen this in the decision, is there is
- 58:14a bifurcation here between gender and sexual
- 58:18orientation. So gender, gender identity, gender
- 58:22expression, all of that is part of the Mirabelli
- 58:25decision, but sexual orientation is not part
- 58:27of it. It's not discussed. That is still a wholly
- 58:29private issue. And part of that is that, you
- 58:33know, that is something we just don't really
- 58:36address that at school. I like to say, like someone
- 58:38who investigates sexual harassment, please don't
- 58:40do anything sex related at school. It's gross
- 58:42and it's icky. but kids do. And so sexual orientation
- 58:46continues to be a private topic. And so everything
- 58:49we just said about what you need to share with
- 58:51families is really unique to gender, gender identity,
- 58:55and gender expression. It doesn't cross over
- 58:57into sexual orientation. It's 4 .59. We've talked
- 59:02for an hour. And we can do a little bit of Q
- 59:05&A, but I do have to run. And so I don't think
- 59:08any, we have one Q &A in the chat. Oh, and it's
- 59:12a good one. Assuming separated divorced parents
- 59:16and there's one who is happy with gender identity
- 59:20and gender expression and another who objects,
- 59:23who controls. People have children and they happily
- 59:29agreed at one point and then they get divorced
- 59:30and they disagree about everything. So if you
- 59:34share legal custody, then it would be no different
- 59:37than if you were married. And if a parent objects,
- 59:41you have to go with the parent who objects. Hopefully,
- 59:45we would work through that with all of that happy
- 59:47team bonding. But that would be a time where,
- 59:50if both parents have legal custody and have legal
- 59:53rights, an objecting parent would have the ability
- 59:56to stop a process. If not, both parents have
- 59:59legal custody and legal rights. And that would
- 1:00:02flop all of that over the window. All right.
- 1:00:09Catherine, anything you want to add? I'm going
- 1:00:11to hop off, but it was lovely to see you all.
- 1:00:14So thank you so much for having us. Thank you,
- 1:00:16Sarah. And thank you again, everyone, for spending
- 1:00:20your Tuesday afternoon with us. It was really
- 1:00:23important that we put this MCLE on on the last
- 1:00:27day of Pride Month to discuss an important topic
- 1:00:31that intersects with LGBTQ plus issues in the
- 1:00:35law and also the education sector, which we know
- 1:00:39we work in every day. So happy Pride Month and
- 1:00:43again thank you for taking the time to be here
- 1:00:46today. This concludes today's presentation. Thank
- 1:00:50you so much Katherine and Sarah for a fantastic
- 1:00:52presentation today and thank you to our audience.
- 1:00:54Have a great day everybody.