Latest / All Out War / The Enoch Deception: False Origins and Spiritual Dangers
Transcript
- Turner Miles: Well what's up everybody? Welcome to another episode of All Out War. I am Turner and I am joined in the studio with Rosie. What's up, Rosie? Hey, what's up, man? So I just got a question for you. Yes. What do I need to know? Hey, this is a pretty good one. I just literally found this out driving over here. Okay. So did you know I'll give you a little story. Okay. 1996. Re remote viewer. Courtney Brown, who is from the one of the army's like remote viewers from their program. Okay. Appeared on Art Bell, Coast to Coast. Okay. Claiming that an enormous alien spacecraft was traveling behind the Hayley Bop comet. Yes. So the story spread widely through Bell's show, and then the Heaven's Gate Colt became convinced that the comet was connected to an extra de extraterrestrial next level. And then they all killed themselves. Everyone knows that. Yeah. Heaven's Gate. Heaven's Gate. Yeah. But if you follow the connection there, so it was actually a connection from the government's remote viewing program. What? Through Art Bell. Wow, dude. So they were listening to Art Bell. huh. And she was so sh she what do you so that was Courtney's a guy. sorry. I thought was a woman, Courtney. I know. Sorry. I think so. Sorry, Courtney, if you're still alive and you're listening to this and we will not have remote viewers on, just so everyone knows. all right, so Haley I I remember that because they all wore like the shoes and they all died in the bunk beds and stuff and it was in California, right? Yeah. And they still have two members and maybe that are I can be corrected on this, but I'm pretty sure they have a couple members who still update the website. They like their job was to stay around so they could keep the website up. So how did you get that? Did you draw the short straw? Everybody else is gonna go on a spaceship and get out to he you know, to heaven and you're gonna you get the short straw. Hey, I'm really sorry, Bob. Listen, there's only thirty one seats. Yeah. You're thirty two. you can't ascend. Can't ascend, bro. Listen, if you just would have listened a little bit earlier, you know. Yeah. that's well that's interesting. that's crazy to think about that. that caused that whole thing to happen the way it did anyways. Wow. Well, we haven't very let's just jump into this 'cause we have a we have a very special episode. This is one that we're we're probably going to get a lot of hate for. And I think I think that we're gonna get a lot of hate for it because this is something that I personally have you know, just believed and thought I thought an error about. And we're gonna discuss the controversy of the book of Enoch and the controversy in the sense that it's really taken a hold of so much of the truther and conspiracy community and much of the evangelical church. And I wanna start off by basically just like a public apology, if you will, a repentant, a repentance to anybody that we may have misled who's listened to us talk about in encouraging the book of Enoch. that was an ignorant position that I took, I believe. And I did not do that out of any malice or intent to lead someone down a wrong pathway. But what I did want to do was just correct it today by saying, forgive me. And if I offended, you know, you or caused you to go into a direction that God did not want you to go or that the Holy Spirit did not want you to go. Please forgive me and please return back to where you need to be on that position. And as a podcast, we we very much value truth and and that's exactly what we want to always be premiered. So and as we go through the podcast, hopefully just listen to this and you will be able to understand why we took that position, why we take that position and why I've moved away from the position I used to hold with the book of Enoch. But maybe Just to clarify, 'cause I I was talking about this too. Same here. Like I know I think we always were pretty good on the the line of like we never said you should read this, this is part of the canon. Right, right. We never said it was canon. We're not out that far, and this isn't trying to justify it, but like we're gonna go further that like we probably gave it more credence. Yeah. Even though we kind of couched it in yeah, that but It's too far now. It's it's become yeah, we'll crazy. We'll outline some of those you know, we'll we'll we'll definitely like outline some of those things through the through the rest of this episode. But we also have a guest with us tonight and it's he needs no introduction, but you've never seen his face on our podcast, and it's my good friend John Brisson from We've Read the Documents. John, how are you, buddy? hold on, John. I can't hear you. I'm muted, that is my bad. thank you for having me back on on War Brothers. Glad to be here with Rosie and Turner. I love you guys very much. You guys are very dear personal friends and brothers in Christ, and I'm glad to be back. So thank you for having me. We're thankful to have you. John, tell us a a little bit before like your like how how long have you been chewing on this John this Book of Enoch thing? I'd say about two years, maybe three years. I myself also at one time thought it had merit and value. I have now since repented from that. I do not believe it any longer. I'll go as far as to say I think the book of Eno book book of Enoch itself is actually demonic. Mm. which is probably going to upset a lot of people who who who are listening. but hopefully we at least I will be able to put forth a case of maybe if s of of some information that has not been presented before. Or maybe people have not thought before, that that holds the book of Enoch in in high regard. I know there's people that, you know, don't believe that I guess there are some people who believe the book of Enoch is divinely inspired, right? That should be part of the canon of the Bible, right? That's the most extreme approach. I very much heavily disagree with that. And we might go over some parts of the book of Enoch that directly contradict scripture. and then you have some people who don't think it is divinely inspired or should be scripture or added to the canon, but think that there is a good enough amount of truth for them to base a biblical worldview on. which I disagree with that now myself. That was the position that I held held previously. and now I think that I don't think it holds any any truth or If it does, it's not worth the amount of misdirection and issues that you have with the text itself being all over the place and contradicting itself, that it would be very difficult for someone to ascertain any truth with it instead of why why wouldn't you just go to the, you know, sixty six books of the Bible that we have, which we believe is divinely inspired in God's word for our truth. Right? Mm-hmm. Yeah. Hundred percent. Yeah, that's good. Let's go back and start historically, some things that are kind of buried when it comes into research because I remember when I first started checking out the Book of Enoch and heard about it. and it what it was is it was kind of like a Heiser Dr. Heiser kind of introduced us a little bit to that and then also through Hy not only just through Heiser, but other guests that we've had on in the past. that hold to the book of Enoch. but the th common the common defense of the book that I hear is, well, it's quoted in scripture. you know, Jesus quoted it and Jude quoted it's found in the New Testament. And and then you also hear about how like, well, it was found with the Dead Sea scrolls. And so so was the New Testament and aspects of the New Testament. And so my thought is like as I think about it, it was like there was like this innocence To embracing it. Now I will publicly say, as I've s just said a few minutes ago, we never we never equated the book of Enoch with scripture. That's not something that we did. It wasn't something that we felt like would ever be put in there. but we we thought that maybe it did fill in some gaps with some of the theology that was missing or some stories that maybe were missing. It's useful to read to get background. Yeah. To get into the mind of at least that's kind of right. That so those are the common like kind of defenses for Christians that would defend the book of Enoch. Those were a lot of those things. and so I just wanted to kind of like take like kind of start there and kind of dismantle why those things are not actually the case and why you need to be very, very careful about really embracing the book of Enoch. So can we start with some of that stuff? Yeah, that's a that's a very much multifaceted question. Well yeah, I'm sorry. it was fine. I guess I'll try to break it down. Can we break it down into chunks, maybe? Sure. Yeah. okay, so maybe the first chunk is the quotation of Jude and Second Peter and possibly Jesus, and I've seen as far as Josh Peck claims James, which is completely insane in my opinion. but but and but well you know Jude and and in Second Peter and later Jesus. okay, so I will primarily stick with Jude because that is the one that I have studied the most. And actually it is my belief that it is likely that some parts of Jude were maybe possibly written to rebuke the Essenes or people who had Essene like beliefs. And I know that most Christians look at the book of Jude as to be a rebuke of false teachers, which I believe that it is. They'll go as far as saying maybe there's rebukes to Gnosticism, which I think that there is, but I also think that there is also rebukes to possibly the Essenes and and their beliefs, which we might go a little bit more into that later. But so, you know, Jude, I'm gonna read from the King James Version. And Enoch also the seventh from Adam prophesied of these, saying, Behold, the Lord cometh forth tens of thousands of his saints to execute judgment upon all, and to convince all that are ungodly among them of all their ungodly deeds, which they have ungodly committed, and all of their hard speeches, which ungodly sinners have spoken against him. And then you have first Enoch one nine. I'm going to read through from the R. H. Charles Ethiopic Gies translation. And behold, he cometh with ten thousands of his holy ones to execute judgment upon all. And to destroy all ungodly and to convict all flesh of all of all their works of their ungodliness, which they have ungodly committed, and all the hard things which ungodly sinners have spoken against him. Okay, so there's for Enoch we have the a full copy of the Ethiopic we think is the complete first Enoch, right? That's the only one that we have goes to the book of the Watchers, which is chapters one through thirty six. And then later the astronom astronomical book, the apocalypse of weeks, the pop book of dreams, epistle of Enoch, Birth of Noah, the Parables, and then you have chapter 108, which I believe were all written by separate people to some degree, or separate groups of people. it was not written by Enoch, it's pseudo pigraphal, which is how we have the sixty-six books of our Bible, okay, because we believe that we know who wrote them, right? at least we have an idea of who wrote them or the early church, even for the New Testament. I know the authorship of Hebrews is disputed between Paul and Barnabas, for example, but there's enough evidence to point to in the early church belief as well that Paul and or Barnabas wrote Hebrews, right? So there's enough testament to the books, the sixty six books of the Bible that are given that none of them are known as pseudo epigrapha. Meaning we have no idea who wrote said book, right? Which is why the Jews excluded Enoch from their scriptures, because they had no idea truly who who wrote it. Now the Essenes, we did f if if the Essenes were who were in Qumran, which I believe that they were, there were copies of book of book of Enoch found there, but we know that the Jews themselves and their collection of the old testament do not include Enoch, right? And so right then and there that's problematic because Enoch didn't write it. We have no idea who wrote it. And it contradicts itself multiple times. We'll get to that later, which we all three of us I would assume believe that scripture does not contradict itself as the word of God. But the book of Enoch multiply contradicts itself, even contradicts scripture, which again is highly problematic for those who think it's divinely inspired. When it directly in multiple places contradict scripture. Okay. So that's even problematic there and of itself. but that's mainly more to the divinely inspired people, or that it should be canon or it should be, you know, considered a book that we use for doctrine compared to those who just look at it as maybe adding in a little bit of extra knowledge, the context of this you know, the intra testamental period or before that we don't have right now, right? And so, you know, I saw f I find that all to be problematic and there've been various dating between three hundred and fifty BC, all the way up to maybe chapter one hundred eight being written after and inserted in after A D, up maybe up to a hundred A D, roughly. Maybe. so that's really problematic and for people who are trying to get down to the bottom of the truth of the book of Enoch, but there's enough evidence to show that it's written by multiple authors throughout hundreds of years. you know, which again would be f would be okay per se if it's a cr if it's a collection of different writers giving their accounts and it's all put together under one person, right? Yeah. But that's not the the book says it's Enoch. It's his revelation, right? So that's very that's very, very much an issue. any questions so far, brother? No, that sounds pretty good. And I was just gonna say, just for anyone who doesn't know, what is pseudo pigrapha? Good question. pseudopigrapha means that a work is attested to somebody who did not write it. Right. And that was something that was common back then because they want like to Put more emphasis like why would someone write it and claim that it's Enoch for just asking the dumb questions? they would write it so that they would give whatever the fanfiction they wrote importance. Like we have, for example, the Acts of Paul, which were not written by Paul, that was rejected by the early church because it was pretty much fanfiction that was written. I think so much so, if I remember correctly, the person who wrote it was actually re rejected from his position in in in the church at the time. I have to go back and remember exactly who that was, but you know, so that you know, so that's why is because it's it's pr it's practically fan fiction. It's practically okay, let me write something that's not true and just stick Enoch's, you know, which the Bible gives very little information about Enoch. What do we have? Genesis and Hebrews. And now you could add, you could also say, you know, stick at Peter and and Jude, but there's not like there's hardly any information about Enoch, other than that he was a righteous man who did not taste death and w you know went to heaven, right? So that's really all we have. Now some people think that he might return as one of the two witnesses with Elijah because neither one of them tasted death. I believe that could be true. I also hold to Moses and Elijah as well. Yeah. but no but nonetheless though yeah that was actually that was an excellent question, Rosie. But that that's that's why And also I would say like the a lot of people think that like I heard somebody say I heard a it was on a dot a different podcast, but it was basically a clip of a guy and he was like, Well, because Jude used it, it was obvious and he's like the brother of Jesus, so it's obvious that he was like they had the book of Enoch in their house and it was being read like all the time. And so they were trying to like give this validation to the book of Al of Enoch and actually elevate it to where it was like on par with scripture. and that's a super dangerous position to be in. And it was easily debunked because of the fact that they were poor, number one, and didn't to to have scrolls and to have those things that are would be, you know, found in libraries or synagogues or with the wealthy, it just wouldn't have been practical. They just wouldn't have had that. I mean Jesus was That was David Carico who said that by the way from now UC T V. It's an absurd statement. Thank you. Yeah, it is absurd. Yeah. And and so they're Hebrew roots people, right? I'm pretty sure. That is correct, yes. Yeah. Yeah. Well they They claim they're not. They they claim they're not, but I would say they are Judaizers. Both John Powders and David Carigo, yes. They claim they're not Hebrew roots, but they keep the law and the Sabbath and the peace and stuff like that. Yeah, well that's a that's been a whole troubling movement for years. That's and the book of Enoch is extremely extr extremely like like esteemed in those movements. Like so I I know that that that doesn't surprise me that they would be Hebrew I didn't know the guy was Hebrew roots, but that would that makes sense. Yeah. so I like and also too there was a something that I heard and learned that it that it borrows heavily from the Babylonian because of the angels and the the seraphim and all these like descriptions of these angels borrow heavily like the watchers that whole terminology comes out of the time from Daniel and and so it's like they're borrowing from this whole I don't know I don't want to call it occultic, but I guess it it would just be polytheistic, po some kind of non not worshiping the one true God, that's for sure, but in the sense of that they were i inviting in was I can't find the words. I'm trying to find the words. What am I It's basically Nan worship, which the Essenes were were participating in. That and also but even in the Babylonian time, the the the watchers were part of their mystical kind of belief system. And so they took these this mist that it was mystical is what I was trying to learn. mystical belief system borrowed in from from the Babylonians, and then they literally just weave it in to the story of Enoch, and then it's and now here we are. after, you know, two thousand years after the New Testament's been written, and here we are and we're we're the watchers are a big thing. It's like, there's watchers that are still around and you know, and so it it's not even a biblical term. I in fact the the terminology watchers in the Old Testament was only I think used two times and both of them were in very negative places. One of them was mystical and in connection with the Babylonians. So And it was used by Nebuchadnezzar. It wasn't used by Daniel himself, it was used by Nebuchadnezzar. Correct, correct. In the book of Daniel. But yes, it was used by Nebuchadnezzar. That's correct. I I I didn't recall. That wasn't Daniel's worldview. Correct. Well, yeah, Daniel had the proper worldview with with with God the Father. That's that's gonna hurt that's gonna make a lot of people angry. But yeah, yeah. It is tough. So I I guess go ahead, go ahead, I'm sorry, go ahead and turn up. No, it is tough because you know, it's like in Like so like the the the part where like you and I, John, we were discussing this like a week ago or whatever, and we were talking about like how like well what about because I still have this issue, like do the demons come from the fallen you know, the the disembodied spirits of the fallen of the dead Nephilim? Like and that's a that's a huge Enoch connection point for so many people. I mean, Heiser basically, you know, cornerstone that whole th theology, you know, position. And I think that you know, I still h hold that there is a possibility for that because there's room for that in scripture. i i is it wrong or right? I don't know. I'm I'm holding super loosely to that because it's not an essential doctrine. John, you said you gave me a great theory in response to that. You you thought that the that the demons could actually be the angels that fell that were not put into Tartarus. Yeah, the spirit yeah, the de they could be d the angels that fell that did not commit sexual sin. 'cause I don't Hold as of right now the sons of Seth Augustinian theory. but I do believe that they could have been the angels that, as Aaron Fotchman points out, committed folly, right? They committed sexual sin, right? They were the ones who were locked away in Tartarus, that's mentioned in Second Peter, and the rest of the fallen angels are demons and spirits that are are left to roam the earth. so that's the way I look at it now. I also believe. possibly still hold the disembodied spirits of the Nephilim as well too, but that primarily comes Enoch. I don't I'm still looking through scripture. I'm still trying to f you know, figure this part out and pray about it and and a you know, ask the Holy Spirit to guide me into what interpretation is correct and ask other fellow brothers and sisters in Christ and elders and stuff like that and everything. But that those are the two positions I'm holding in my head right now. Primarily leaning towards not the disembodied spirits of the Nephilim, to be honest with you. Yeah. I mean No matter what you think, it was definitely not divinely inspired scripture. It was definitely not something that was, you know, that God intended to be part of the canon of scripture. which is it which is a huge like you have to start there because if something's not intended to be canon in scripture and and you're embracing it as such, you're already on the wrong path. So you gotta clear up that first of all and foremost, and which is fine. Like I like we said before. We never equated it with scripture. I I the most that I got to it was that it was like I look at like the writings of Josephus as like, hey, I'll use Josephus as a you know as a supplemental thing to give me some information about stuff. He's a historian or whatever. You know what I mean? it's never on par with scripture. It's never to be taken. I'll quote Josephus if it's pertinent to back up something else that's already been, you know, theologically proven in scripture, you know, if it actually backs up something else that we firmly believe in and that's been proven. So the Enoch, that's kind of how I held it in that spot, but it's definitely not to be, you know, held in as scripture. But what about the people that believe, John, that like, it was, you know, they it's a re it's a book that was removed because it has secret knowledge and it has like you know, it was there's this conspiracy about it was being banned from the Bible and, you know, what about that whole theory right there? That's Gnostic thinking. Yeah. Not saying they're Gnostic, but that's Gnostic thinking. Yeah. You don't think that God has given us what we need that is most important. Now I understand I'm gonna bring up first Enoch real quick, just for one quick second. Sure. get our A R H Charles. so right here, the part where they the the I'll I'll right the opening the introduction. The words of the blessing of Enoch, wherewith he blessed the elect and righteous who will be living in the day of tribulation when all wicked and godless are to be removed. and he took his parable and said, Enoch, a righteous man, whose eyes were opened by God, saw the vision of the holy one in the heavens, which angels showed to me, and from where I heard everything, and from them I understood as I saw, but not for this generation, but for a remote one which is for to come, right? So a lot of people are like, Are we that remote generation? Because now we have access to the book of Enoch. You know, and that to me, you know, everything that we have in we know like Revelation. Revelation is the end, right? Yeah. It is the revelation of Jesus Christ. It is the end. You know, nut there's there's nothing in the Bible, and it's been long decided that the canon closes with revelation, that there's not anything else after that point that would eventually be discovered that would give us context of the future. Especially when Enoch does not discuss what we know is the end with the return of our Lord and Savior Jesus Christ or a rapture wherever you stand, whether it's pre trib, mid trib, or post trib, it doesn't give an accurate account of Christian eschatology within it, which should be problematic to begin with. But the way it sets up, and actually I would say it even gives you an escene. li you know, children of the light versus the children of the dark, one final battle, right? Which isn't talked about in scripture as far as then there'll be a messianic age afterwards where the Jews will rule the Gentiles for all eternity, right? That's not the ending of our Bible. So again, like Kind of that blending of the scene like how much were the Essenes involved with the writing of Enoch? How much were the they were definitely involved with the propagation of it, I would assume, as scribes that were in various cities. and I believe this might have been maybe one of their secret texts, possibly, which is speculation of whether or not that they were, you know, selling some of the secret stuff that they were copying down and stuff like that and everything. Yeah. you know, and all that comes from Josephus' information about the Essenes. you know, but Yeah, am among others, but still nonetheless, I would say that that opening of for a remote generation, right? That makes it feel like it's special and makes it feel like it could be to you and you're the person who has the secret knowledge that other Christians don't have through the book of Enoch. And that knowledge does not line up with the Bible or scripture and contradicts itself and is not even written by Enoch or written by multiple people, that's all problematic in my opinion. Yeah. Yeah. So what do we say to somebody who says, Well, what about, you know, it was left out of the canon scripture, but it's in the Ethiopian Orthodox Bible. 'Cause that's a Well the Ethiopian The Ethiop Ethio the Ethiopian Orthodox Bible just throws in everything. It throws in literally everything in the kitchen sink with it. And so, like, I mean, there's even second or third century New Testament apocryphal texts that are added into the Ethiopian Bible. You know, you have all the Old Testament apocryphal, including the Book of Enochs and the Book of Jubilees, which the book of Jubilees contradicts everything as well, too. you know, and then you so you the the Ethiopian okay so the Ethiopian Bible is when you put everything in. And say it's all divinely inspired and there's not really hardly any thought to it. It's just lumping it all in. And I and I know some people might get upset at me about that, but again, there's there's there's there's disputes between various Ethiopian ch Orthodox churches about exactly if it's in the canon or not. Yeah. So they don't even there's no counsel to determine of whether or not by the Ethiopian Orthodox Church. That's even it's i e it even considered canon by their own church. Okay. And so there's different you can go to one Ethiopian ch Orthodox Church. let's say you go to one in the city in America, and they'll say it is, and you go to another in the city of America, and it won't be included in their Bibles. So the even there it's not as uniform as people think that it is. So a lot of you and this there's a YouTube video you can look it You look up Ethiopian Bible AI generated translation. And a lot of the Ethiopian Bibles that you buy on Amazon are not even officially translated. They're just artificially intelligence translated. So how can you even trust them? So a lot of people that are getting these Ethiopian Bibles has got my book of Enoch and my book of Jubilees and everything, you You're using an AI translation. You're not even using now. I have issues with R. H. Charles. We're gonna get to that later, but at least you're not giving getting somebody who knows the languages, someone who's trying to do an earnest translation, right? You know, you don't have that. Instead, you have artificial intelligence generated translation that you're reading thinking it's the word of God. Yeah. That's a oof. So let's talk about R. H. Charles a little bit because I don't think a lot of our listeners know who that is and the importance that he plays in the Book of Enoch. Yeah, so he was one of the the the main people that would translate many of the Old Testament Apocrypha into English. he was a scholar, he was a theologian he was an Anglican and he was alive from the mid 1800s up until I think nineteen twenties, thirties. and he was someone who had translated Enoch into English from Ethiopian Giz version twice. He did it twice. And the second version when we get later when we talk about one of my main issues with Enoch, which it is my belief that Enoch says the book of Enoch, the Giz translation specifically. And again we have the Gez we have no other language translation other than English that it's been translated to other than Gies. We have fragments of Aramaic, we have fragments of Greek, we have fragments of Latin. There's supposedly loss that is written about a Coptic version that doesn't exist anymore. we have I think fragments in Syriac as well too. But the main one that we have is the Gies copy. And we have I think h hundreds of manuscripts, not Not more, I think it's maybe 140, 150, somewhere around there if I remember. I'm not I get this calculus, I get numbers off a little bit. I'm apologize for that if I do. but but but but anyway, to my point is is we have s of course some, you know, they were they were found in Qumran came for about eleven copies of it in Aramaic, right? And we still have fragments of it in Aramaic, Greek, and other languages. But the main one that's used, and what they'll do is they'll they'll they'll check the Gies copy, which is the Ethiopic language, to the fragments that we have in Greek, or the fragments that we have that are that is Aramaic, or the copy I think they may even have full copies of Aramaic. I don't remember they found for the Dead Sea Scrolls. And I think it was in the fourth cave, if I remember. but they could they compare them and they say, okay, so like do they say the same thing, right? And In some places they don't. Which is problematic in and of itself, right? Right. So if we so if we take the I guess we can get to it. I guess one pro main problem I have with it is one of the main problems I have with the book of Enoch is that it lays out if you're using the Giaz translation, if you're even using in R. H. Charles, what he tried to hide, and he even admits it because he tried and I'll get to that, is There the part where Enoch is discussing, and I want to bring it up, I'll bring up my notes on it real quick. Let me f find it. I believe that it's I believe the book of Enoch, at least the main translation that people read, it equates Enoch himself as being the Messiah. And that's first Enoch seventy one fourteen. And I'm reading from the Gies manuscript. Thou art the son of man who art born unto righteousness, and righteousness abides over thee, and righteousness of the Hedodies for seeks these. Okay. Now later Charles admitted that and said, well, we have a lost prior scripture where the angel Raphael is actually pointing to Jesus and telling Enoch that this is the son of man. Hmm. So he writes that in his in his In his in his notes down the bottom that we have a pre where like a footnote. I haven't been able to find that history of any scholarship that even existed. Okay, so his original translation, what I just read, the nine eighteen ninety three one, says, Thou art the son of man. And then in nineteen twelve one, he changes to this is the son of man. And that's Raphael talking to whom? God. Where is Enoch? In the inner chamber in the first heaven. So he's so the to set the story, Enoch was taken up into the first heaven. Raphael the angel is speaking to God and r presents Enoch to God, and as he presents him to God, he's telling him, This is the Son of Man. That is correct, yes. Wow. Wow. How many people miss that when they read the book of Enoch? Right? most people think that it's just really like the R. H. Charles version that he's talking about Jesus who is not mentioned. So R. H. Charles, this guy, was he a pa you said he was Anglican. Was he a pastor? He's Anglican, yes. he I I mean I always known him as to be a professor, he was a teacher. He was a theologian. Okay. Scholar. He was a scholar. So he he changed it, never presented evidence for it. Nope. And and it's remains in the scripture, but there's a footnote or it remains in the script. That footnote is where he said that he believes there is a missing part where Raphael is speaking to Gotcha. that Jesus is present and he's speaking to Jesus, announcing that to Enoch that Jesus is the son of man. And they've never they've never found a portion of a sc of a scroll in Nope not to my knowledge. Not to my knowledge, no. In no language. So With the not to my knowledge, no. Now and I will say this to be fair, the Greek fragments that we have, we have one Greek fragment that has it framed that Enoch is the son of man, but we have another Greek fat fragment that does not make it seem like that may have been where maybe Charles had gotten it from, but I don't think he had access to it at the time. So we have two different Contradictory Greek fragments about that statement as well, too. But the Gias Ethiopic version of all the manuscripts, it all points to Enoch being the son of man, which is the primary version everybody re reference to and looks at, etc. So Yeah, I was just gonna say one thing, if anyone, now that we have video, yeah, people keep and you you keep looking at me whenever I start giggling. Yeah. 'Cause I just think of That gay ass translation. So that's why I keep giggling. Sorry about that. Okay. It's kind of fitting though, I think. But the other thing is so the fact that he updated it and changed the verbiage between the two, was that he was trying to hide something, or was there like what was the reasoning behind it? Like he doesn't give it. Okay. Hmm. So to me it's very odd. I can't say for sure, but it seems like to me the only reason why you would do that was to hide it. He didn't have to tell himself. At least he at least admitted it down the bottom. Yeah, I mean, like at best it was like, Hey, maybe I mistranslated this thing and maybe it should be this way. At worst, it's like, man, the Christian I I need this is this is bumping into Jesus and his, you know, him being the son of man. So I need to like change this so it doesn't appear that I'm presenting Enoch as the son of man. Now do you think that that there was so like i let's go worst case scenario do you think that there was like this was placed in there to draw people away from Jesus as the Messiah because it's it's like a pr yes. It would be a pre incarnate. It would be like, you know, like a lot of people view the King of Salem, right? You know, like this pre incarnate of Jesus, you know, or The angel of the Lord, as it's many times put in scripture, where you see Jesus like with Joshua talking and things like that. do you think that they were trying to kind of draw into that and make Enoch be that kind of a guy? Yes. I will expound that a minute. I just want to read from the second edition of the book of Enoch by R. H. Charles, nineteen twelve, page one hundred forty five. And he writes in the note specifically. Lost passage wherein the Son of Man was described as accompanying the head of days and Enoch asked one of the angels concerning the Son of Man as to who he was, right? So again, where's this lost passage? It's never been found. Hmm. And I mean, a another key point that you had brought up about the gre again, aside from the gay ass translation, is you have the two Greek fragments that so I mean No matter where it is, you have one translation from the same document that gets changed to totally different meanings, right? Like Yeah, one is calling him the son of God and or son of man and the other one saying he's not. Yeah. It's like trying he's basically like it it he's trying to pro ch protect the book of Enoch by softening the language when he updates it because he's like, this could be problematic. But then like you said, that's another important point of even in the other language of Greek, they contradicted it. So there's there's nothing like basically there's no one translation that not like what we have with the Old Testament books or the New Testament where it is the same. There is no contradiction throughout different translations of that book. Right. You know, there might be small little things of because people are handwriting it, but there's no blatant contradictions like, this guy's Jesus or or He is or he isn't. Right. no. Right. Yeah. Yeah. And so right here we have the different translations. So the Lawrence eighteen thirty two says, Thou art the offspring of man. Shao eighteen eighty two says thou art the son of man. Charles eighteen ninety three says, Thou art the son of man, right? Charles nineteen twelve when he changes it, this is the son of man. And the the Nicholsburg Vanderkamp Hermonia translation, which Wes Hove says is the best one, supposedly, allegedly. That is the one where they tried to put together all the fragments that they had, the Ethiopic ver you know, versions, the Greek text, Aramaic fragments and et cetera. And it they write, You are the son of man. That's not good. That's not good at all. So let me ask you a question because, you know, we know that there's a lot of groups that were trying to infiltrate especially early on in the New Testament. the you had the Judaizers, you had the Gnostics, you had you know, those are specifically spoken of against in in the New Testament scriptures, warnings, you know, in particular. Is there some kind of like Masonic Kabbalistic influence or agenda that was attached to some of these things by by any chance. Do do we know if this guy R H was a Freemason or part of the Illuminati or anything like that? No proof. No proof. We know that where we got the Ethiopic version from was the explorer James Bruce, who was a Freemason who claims to be related to Robert the Bruce. and so that's where we but I mean there was he brought back three copies if I remember correctly. So yeah, I mean that is I mean, there's the free ma free Masonic connection. and actually I need to actually go back and say this. I apologize. I conflated first Enoch seventy one with something I want to discuss later, which is another part of first Enoch. There are no Greek parts of Enoch seventy one. It's it's only in the Gies. So again It's there is no Greek. the one that I want to discuss with the Greek, I'm sorry I got it confused, was where all sin is ascribed to, which I they you know, there's various interpretations of the book of Enoch of who sin is ascribed to. We can get to that later. jump in, that's fine. But that is first Enoch ten. So that was the one that I had gotten I had mistaken with first Enoch seventy one. So there are no Ethiopic I mean there are no Greek Fragments for E 1 Enoch 71. We just have the Ethiopic ones. Well manuscripts. Talk let's talk about what you were going to say there about where all sin is, you know. so for that one would be first Enoch ten, eight, and the whole earth has been corrupted through the works that were taught by Azazel to him ascribe all sin. Okay. And so the book contradicts itself multiple times in this part. and so I I went through and I did streams and I have to do one more that cover all this of the contradiction between the translations, the copper contradiction between the Greek and the Ethiopic and and what it ends up saying and the two different Greek fragments that they have, one from the Codex Panopolantis and us and the other for Cincilius. And the book of Enoch in multiple places. throughout first Enoch, describes who is in the involvement for sin. And even later in the parable of Enoch, even something I mentioned in my which is toward the end of First Enoch, in my Enoch videos covering this, was they're very close to what it's said in Romans, as by one, you know, one man sin entered the world and by death by sin, and so death passed by all men for all that have sinned, right? And so Enoch contradicts itself in that because in the book of you know the giants it says sin is ascribed to Azazel to the parable of Enoch it says that sin is ascribed to a man according to their deeds. So it's contradictory even in itself there. and so again, you know, as Christians, we believe that because of you know Adam disobeying God and eating from the tree of the knowledge of good and evil, because of him, sin and death entered into the world, right? And so it's not because of the teachings of the fallen angels, which even the book of Enoch mentions that that is heavenly knowledge that was brought down, right? The ability to make weapons of warfare, the ability to make makeup, for example, you know, those were secrets in heaven that the fallen angels had taken and taught to men, right? That these are, you know, written in heavenly tablets, it's heavily information. and through that, Azazel, the fallen angel that brought man this information ascribes all of hu of mankind's sin. Right. Now I understand that that's a debated passage of Enoch through the translations, but that is the way that it the book kind of sets up because there is no true Garden of Eden complete story there with Adam and Eve that we have in Genesis, right? Or even before that is talked about in Romans, we can know through the Old Testament itself that because of Adam and Eve's rebellion against God that sin and death had entered into the world, right? We don't even need Romans and Paul's greater exegesis through, you know, through the Holy Spirit living within him to come to that conclusion. But Enoch doesn't really. Teach that. And and so, you know, what I had titled the the the series that I had done on my channel on this was the Nephilim made me do it. Wasn't me. It was Nephilim. They taught me the secret, you know, heavenly knowledge on the heavenly tablets, about weapons of warfare, which we know the Bible says the weapons of warfare came from Tubal King, right? And the lenient King, which is another thing. The book of Enoch is supposed to be from the lineage of the the lineage not of Cain but of Seth. and so a lot of people ask me, Well, does it mean Enoch's son of you know, son of Jared or son of you know Cain? And it's like, no, he's not from the lineage of Cain. It's from the lineage of Seth. That's who they base the book off of. And to answer one of your previous points, Turner. Is that the Essenes in my belief, and I read this scholarly paper that kind of backs up first, second, and third Enoch and also discuss the beliefs of the Essenes too and their worships of angels and using angels names as passwords and stuff like that and everything, among other things, that they says they rejected this the second temple and they rejected the sacrificial system that was in place during the time that the Essenes were alive. They rejected Moses and they rejected Aaron. So they needed a priest because they also talk about the sons of Zadok, right? So the priest that they looked to actually, and the person that they looked to specifically was Enoch. And so if that's the case, then you have this veneration of Enoch over Moses that we even have that is talked about what's the I can't believe I'm drawing a blank on his name. The the Jewish Philo of Alexandria talks about. and he upholds Moses, interestingly enough. but so you know, I believe the Essenes venerated Enoch, and we do have through the writings of Epiphamus of Salamis, for example, that the Essenes, you it's it's Rife in what I call Essene revisionism, not to get too off too out in the woods, weeds, but that most of the Essenes became Christians because they had the correct calendar, the three hundred sixty-four-day solar calendar, which comes from all the Essene writings, the Book of Jubilees and the Book of Enoch, where the Jewish people at that time followed a lunar solar calendar, not a three hundred and sixty-four-day calendar. That is a lie. and the Bible shows that that is a lie. and so they were not looking Two four to or for Jesus. The whole prophecy that the Essenes were waiting for Jesus the Messiah and knew his exact date, and and even there's even now saying close to the date of his second coming and all that is a bunch of just revisionist nonsense. You know, the Essenes, a lot of them that we know through later church history. And it does appear to be true based off of, you know, the writings of Josephus and the rituals and stuff like that and everything. they became Gnostics, not Christians. I like to get y'all's opinions on that, but that's just, you know, like what it seems like to me. I mean, if you listen to if you listen to like Ken Johnson or we've who's been a guest on our podcast, I feel like we're gonna have to go through and like scrub a bunch of guests for guests on our podcast, but you know, it is what it is. We that's one thing I can say, Rosie. You and I have we've always tried to be open to learning and admitting our mistakes. but I will say this about Ken Johnson led me to believe that they were becoming Christians, that most of them left the no the Essenes and became Christians. And I'm sure he would admit I'm not accusing him of being a liar or anything like that, but what I I'm sure he would admit that some of became Gnostics. I mean, it was a pretty strong and growing and large movement in that time period. So but yeah, I mean What do you say? mean I mean, like I said, in the early church in the New Testament, the two groups that were by both Paul, John, P all of them were warning us against the Judaizers and against the Gnostics. Like those were the two primary groups that were warned about in the New Testament. And it makes And maybe the Essenes. Maybe the Essenes. The Essenes could have been the Gnostics they were warning about. Yeah. Possibly. Possibly. John, you were a Gnostic, so historically Gnosticism And I upholded these scenes when I was a Gnostic. I thought Jesus was an Essene. Yeah. I mean I've heard very much taught New Age Gnosticism. Very much taught New Age Gnosticism belief. Well, the the most recent one that I've heard is that John the Baptist was an Essen. I was gonna say, yeah, I remember Ken Johnson was talking about that, that you know, because he was they were these kind of I mean they're like the communist socialist guys that all live out there and they live forever and like all this or not forever, but they lived Special Diet. Special diet, which is like I mean, I I feel like Ken even said that they without going too close, I mean that like that is like a very Gnostic thing. Like it it is kind of like hippy dippy, like the more mystical of them. Yeah. You know, like out there. Like it which sounds special. Pretty believable. But yeah, I remember he talked about like John the Baptist that he could have been like living with them and that's why he was kind of this wild man that you know eating locusts and honey and you know, all this kind of crazy stuff. But I was gonna ask John about that too. Yeah. Like what do you I want to give the specific verse. Yeah. So I think First Timothy four may have been a writing of Paul warning about the Essenes. And I believe the Herodians in the New Testament. may have been possibly made up of the scenes. The zealots may have possibly been made up of the scenes too. Not all zealots were Essenes, but at least some Essenes became zealots. And so we have we have for example, there was an Essene prophet that had prophesied about Herod, right, and his rise to power, right? So Herod was friendly with the Essenes. you know, and we have that information from Josephus and Philo, for example, of Alexandria. and so but f I'm gonna read first Timothy, let me get up real quick, just 'cause this sounds like everything that you had just mentioned, Rosie, it seems to me that First Timothy four like let me read this to you and let me think about what you know about what Ken Johnson has taught about the scenes. Now the spirit speaketh expressly that in the latter times sh some shall depart from the faith, giving heeds to seducing spirits and doctrines of devils. Speaking lies and hypocrisy, having their conscience seared with a hot iron, forbidden to marry and commanding to abstain from meats which God have to receive with thanksgiving of them which know the truth, right? So a couple of things apart on that. So we know that's happening right now in the future, right? Judaizers, forbidding to marry that we see in the Catholic Church and so on and so forth. But that's what those were teachings of the Essenes as well, too, to abstain from meats. the forbidding to marry as well too as well was was rife with the seeds so much so that they would take young Padawans almost from like Star Wars, you know, young adepts that they would train and and raise them in Esseen like ways. you know, and so it's it's quite interesting. And also right here, later on too as well, but refuse profane and old wise fables and exercise themselves and un under godliness, right? So It's just interesting that, you know, that's put there specifically in the end times and kind of having Paul echo that later. Let me find another part of as well too. you guys talking riff for a minute, that kinda merges that in. Give me one quick second. So let me find it real quick. Yeah, like I was pulling up something here where it I this I'm reading from a this is an Orthodox like f priest, yeah, I I can't remember blanked on what they they call who's big that I know like has a a a very big podcast and that I think they actually uphold 'cause I know the Orthodox have a not and I'm not talking about the Ethiopian, but like they have the three views of like books of the Bible where they're like, This is canon. This is not canon, but it's helpful. Yeah. And then like if it shouldn't be preached from the pulpit and then like stuff you should avoid. And I know Enoch and like Jubilees and I think other cano stuff is in that second category. It's like personal, but we don't preach it from the pulpit. Right. It could be helpful. But I'm reading from one of his blogs about this, and it says throughout the Second Temple period, the Enochic the Enochic tradition represented a powerful rival to Phariseeism. Phariseeism that is later ultimately prevailed and was transformed into rabbinic Judaism in the late antiquity has skewed historical recollection of the actual religious state of affairs. And Nakhic Judaism is sometimes categorized by scholars as non-Torah based Judaism. The idea of non Torah based Judaism may seem like a contradiction to modern ears, but yeah, it sounds like there is almost like Two different I mean th that right there, non Torah based Judaism is what Yeah. Christian Christianity is kind of what the the Jews are like, Well, we're not I'm sorry, I I totally just mistaken that, but it was like What did you pick up? Because I just hit like a brain fog. Well when I read that out, does that align with read it again for me? Enochic Judaism is sometimes categorized by scholars as non-Torah-based Judaism. And that was the interesting from the Pharisees that like Jesus, so it's like this second one, but where's I going with that? Is like I could see that. When I when I read that it kind of was like along the same lines of making the case that like the Enochic Jews would be like the Essenes, right? 'Cause they're the ones that follow Enoch and like revere him in this kind of way. Is that's kind of making the case from like and this is from an Orthodox priest that they're kind of like, yeah, the proto Christians that does it does that make sense? And that's it sounds like the argument that Ken Johnson also makes. Right, right. Very similar to that. And they're kind of like this, and this is where I was going with it is like this is kind of what I remember Ken's kind of position on is like, yeah, there's these proto Christians that they're different because they saw the I don't like where it's the non Torah based Judaism, which but he says that became what the rabbinic Judaism is. Yeah. Which interesting is after the Second Temple was destroyed because they didn't have like Rabbinic Judaism because they didn't have Yeah, rabbis. Yeah. Yeah. And yeah. Like modern Judaism is non rabbinic Judaism because or non Torah Judaism because they have rabbis and they don't have the second temple the temple anymore. And I would just say that non Torah means that they're not ab adhering to the first five books of the Bible. You know. So they're just literally departing from what would be considered their doctrines, you know, if you will. a huge part of our belief system is the Old Testament. You know, you don't get the fulfillment of the new without the base of the old. Yeah. So if they're departing from it's non Torah Judaism, just almost like it's it it and actually is probably very weird thing that it's not even like proto Christians, but they're not even like kind of Jew. That's why I was like trying to read this and keep it straight as I'm like saying it because it's like, well, they're not rabbi the rabbinic Jews, because so that's more to say that they are the Christians, but at the same time if they totally reject the Torah, then they're not the Christians because we revere the Torah as part of the whole you know, it's yeah. Well, it's weird. They're just weirdos. I think of yeah, well it's definitely it's departure. I it's mystical. I think it's it's it's probably cabalic infused at some level and probably has some mysticism that's intertwined in there. I mean, if you're gonna depart from the Torah, you're departing from what God has given as a the beginnings of a nice you know, guardrail of belief system. And you can open it opens you up to anything else. And that's sort of like what I'm thinking about here when I think about like this whole Enoch thing in general, is that like as a believer, we have the canon of scripture which gives us a safe, you know, lane to walk in with guardrails on each side. And and then when you choose to open yourself up to other texts, like John was talking about earlier, like how Ethiopians just kinda like, Hey, it's the kitchen sink, let's let's let it all in and you misappropriate it as scripture equal to scripture, you're moving you're removing those guardrails and you're opening yourself up to having potential of any belief system or very much opening yourself up to to varied belief systems that are most certainly not going to be on the same level of truth and move you and depart you from orthodoxy. Orthodoxy being like Little Little O orthodoxy, yeah. And so that's kinda like what I think about when I s think that, you know, John, did Yeah. I was just gonna say just 'cause you brought it up, and I'm not sure if we were gonna bring this up. I think we had talked about it before, but like when you just talked about Kabbalah. Yeah the Kabbalists do have an interesting tradition about Enoch. Is that not correct, John? Well that would be th Metatron, third Enoch. that Enoch became Metatron. supernaturally changed into an angel from He transformed. transformed into Metatron. Enoch was the first tranny. Okay. Is that is is that safe to say? Is that safe to say that Enoch was the first tranny? I mean, yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I look the old st the old school old testament Enoch That's you know, from Genesis, that guy was was righteous. That dude was straight up above bar. Yeah. This other Enoch that's all mystical. the made up one who doesn't exist. He's a tranny. Fake and gay. I I I I wanted to go back to I meant to before before First Timothy. Okay. So Colossians two, sixteen so l so let no one judge you in food nor drink or regarding a festival or new moon or sabbath which is shadow things to come of the substance of Christ, and no one cheat you of your reward, taking delight in false humility and worship of angels, intruding into those things which has not seen vainly puffed up by his own fleshly mind, right? And then later a stating for me to give me to marriage and stuff like that, everything that you s later see in the end times and stuff. and you know, I think that those could be possible rebukes to Both Gnostics and the Essenes, because the Essenes were worshiping angels. They were I'm gonna get the direct Josephus quote up, but they were using angels' names as secret passwords. they were writing text down with angels. For example, you know, Raphael is not mentioned in the Bible. The angel that's supposedly over your salvation, Fanuel, is not mentioned in in the Bible. So they have a whole bunch of angels that are mentioned within the book of Enoch that are not mentioned within the Bible. so it is you know, if if the Essenes, if the Book of Enoch is Essene literature and you know came from Qumran, and Qumran where where where the Essenes were centrally located, even though they were according to Josephus, in a lot of the major cities, ske sc you know, scout scattered about in apartments as scribes. they weren't just aesthetics stuck in Qumran. then, you know, they were kind of, you know, pushing this information out there. and then they did worship Agels. Let me see I can find that clip. Or that clip that that quote for Josephus real quick. about let me see should be yeah. Josephus and that he will never conceal anything from those from his own sect, nor discover any of the doctrines to others, no through anyone would compel him to do so at the hazard of his life. Moreover, he swears to communicate their doctrines to no one otherwise than he has received them himself. That he will abstain from robbery and he will equally preserve the books belonging to their sects and the names of the angels or messengers that was specifically given unto them. That's a mouthful. I was trying to listen to you as you read that. Can you just read part of that again, the the very beginning part? Yeah, yeah, yeah. and this is this is just he was talking about the commander that was with him that was in the scene. Okay. And that he would neither conceal anything from those of his own sect nor discover any of their doctrines to others nor not anyone should compel him so to do at the hazard of his life. Wherever he swears to communicate their doctrines to no one and and otherwise then he has received themselves and they abstain from robbery, and we'll equally preserve the books belonging to their sects and the names of angels or messengers. Okay, so he's basically saying, like, we're not going to disclose anything, we're going to keep this close to the chest, and we're also not going to accept other stuff. I mean, is that essentially what you're saying? Yeah, preserve the books that they have in their own scene sect as well as using the names of angels as kind of like some sort of oath or some sort of password. Yeah. Just kind of going off of that, I was interested, just 'cause you brought it up that I just wanted to Google just from my own I was pretty sure that I knew that this was the answer. Okay. Sure. there's only two angels named in the canon, which are Michael and Gabriel. huh. Right? Correct. And I looked it up of how many other angels are in 'cause Raphael, I know because I have Enoch Catholic friends. Catholic friends is that Is that in the Apocrypha? Yeah, so it's in Tobit as well. It should be in Tobit. Right. And but it's also in Enoch, but I I it just got me thinking 'cause I was listening to a a podcast with like a Catholic exorcist, which was interesting. I like hearing about him and I can't remember exactly. I think it was Ripinger. Or whatever it was. the new the guy it was on Sean Ryan. I think so, yeah. I think so. I think that's where it was. But he's mak he he I actually like the guy personally. Yeah, I I'm not a Catholic, I don't ascribe to Catholicism, but I like I mean when he was just talking about like, yeah, we have these angels and blah blah blah blah blah. And I know like from my Catholic friends, they 'cause Catholic theology is like we know that there's this kind of angels and this is the hierarchy of angels. These are names of like good angels that you know we call out and I think Tobit is in the Catholic canon. yeah yeah in Catholic and the Orthodox Bibles. It is. But I was just wondering like w that just got me thinking of you know, is there You know, is there other angels or like how do they treat I I was just more interested in like i i i what there is to say about angels or do we know of any other kind of influence and like from the Essenes view of angels and how that goes into like modern day kind of new agey stuff because I know New agers like they talk about all kinds of angels all the time. Like Metatron is like outside of Yeah, just cabalistic Jews, like that's a name that gets thrown into New Age stuff and Enoch and you know, all this other kind of stuff. Is there is there basically what I'm asking and kind of setting up for is is there Like how have the Essenes view on angels kind of continued on and like left, you know, outside of just Catholics and You know, w where where where is the tentacles of their s thinking like where has it ended up nowadays? Once it became Gnostics, you have the Apocryphon of John, this which I used to believe to be true, where Jesus gave hidden say sayings to the apostle John, that the angel there was an angel pretty much over the creation of every body part of Adam, including his penis. Nice. Wait. There is an angel that was I haven't read the I will say we're pretty good, listener and viewer. Didn't read a lot I I I'll speak for myself, but I'm pretty sure Turner's Didn't read a lot of the Nagamadi library scrolls there, Rosie. Can't say that, no. I I I drew a line at some stuff where I'm like, Th there's no reason I should be reading any of that. Yeah, yeah. to let it into my brain. But so are you saying my man Adam had an angel who just made his penis? And that that's the angel's whole job was to make his penis? That is correct. Nice. It was Yao de Bayoth and the three hundred and sixty five angels constructed Adam's physical and psychic body. That's not really All right. That's all we got for all our work tonight. Good night, everybody. Thank you very much. Good night. Yeah. I mean, there's more notes, right? I'm sorry, I'm I didn't mean to come on, man. That's why people watch. It's entertaining. But Okay, how about It what about the fact that I feel like there's one other thing that we're you know hold on it goes even more to that. Okay. A Rabbi a Rabbi and I'm probably pronouncing this demon's name wrong, assigned to the penis, Elio assigned to the testicles. it's that it gets that literally that detail. Yes, it does. They broke it down. I used to believe this to be true. So what what was the name of the one that the testicles? Which what was that? Elio. I was gonna say he was the one that made the sphincter, because that guy had a crappy job, right? I mean, look, Paul said like we're you know, we're all parts of the body, right? Like, and he's like some need it for modesty. I don't think you meant it like that. I don't think he meant it like that. Agreed, agreed, 100%. Now I know this was an interesting point to kind of tie it to some more actual I think we had alluded to answer your question. Does it answer your question, Rosie? That it got so bad that they tried to put divine council belief systems into into creation that you had three hundred and sixty five angels you along with Yadaba, the chief archon, who is our god, okay, the god of all creation. and within him there is only light, there is no darkness, but to the Gnostics would be known as Yadbeah. they he created every single part the angels created with him created every single part of Adam's body. I mean th th made in their image. Yeah. That's a weird one. I don't want to see some of those angels. I have to talk to my angel because Like if I made his im I sorry, this is this is going really bad. Sorry. That's right. Here. I got I got a point. Let's bring it back. yeah. So thank you, Rosen. The good real thing. You had alluded to this, I think, John, at the beginning. Is so th one of the the reasons that the people who do say that Enoch should be like you sh it should be canon, except for, you know, they took it out, you know, for whatever is because like Jude quoted it and there's some other ones and I know we only really talked about Jude, but like what how did there is a verse or they always say, Jesus quoted it. Is there any validity to that? Like did Jesus No. Okay. So I had heard I had heard that the Beatitude or not the Beatitudes, the parable some of the parables were borrowed from Enoch that Jesus quoted. That's what I had I had actually read that in a Enoch commentary that somebody had written. Wild vast speculation. Now Enoch, it's even speculated again, was it based for Jude, was it based off of Enochian tradition? And was Jude some parts of it a possible polemic against Essene beliefs and against Enochian beliefs? Possibly. or you know, but but yeah, so I mean you had Paul quoting Epimenes, right? in Titus about yeah Cretans are always liars, evil beasts, etcetera, right? does does that mean that Paul signs off everything that Epimenes said? Right, correct, correct. Yeah. Right. So even if it's not just based off of Anokia an Enochian tradition that's lost. And but again you you can take the Lord returning with The Lord returning with the saints, right? We believe that happens when he faces the Antichrist and the false prophet, right? you can get that if I remember correctly, is it his Eu? You can get that from the let me let me let me look, but you don't even have to get that from the book of Enoch. Huh. I don't know if I've heard this before. Let me find it. Find it, John. Find it. It's somewhere in the Old Testament where it's very similar. You guys can go on and talk. I don't want to be fill feeling dead air the podcast. Your clicks of your keyboard. No no no no no no no no it's it's A S R with your clicks of your keyboard. It's Zachariah. Then the Lord God may the the Lord may my God will come and all the holy ones with him. All right. Zachariah coming with his holy ones. and so again, like that echoes what is said in Jude that supposedly Enoch said. Hmm. Interesting. So they they misquote what Zechariah said to Enoch. They attribute it to Enoch. Is that what you're saying? Yeah, sure. Yeah. Yeah. Because Jesus isn't gonna you know, talking about his second coming, he's not gonna quote Enoch, he's gonna quote Zechariah. I mean So that it's not even confusing. Sorry, Jude. I'm not saying pr specifically that he's quoting from Ezekiel, he could be, but what I I Zachariah, he could be. But what I'm saying is is we don't need the book of Enoch to get what is quoted there. Right. Right. And it and again it doesn't necessarily come from the book of Enoch. It could come from an Enoch tradition that is lost. Mm-hmm. Does that make sense? You guys understand what I'm saying? Mm-hmm. Yeah. Understand what you're saying. Yeah. Cool. Well I mean it's a possibility the book of Enoch got writer got that from Zachariah. If Jude borrowed from the Book of Enoch. Right. Right. I don't think Jude borrowed from the Book of Enoch, personally. I I just from a lost Enochic tradition. Yeah. Saying that is divinely inspired. I do believe it to be true because we have it backed up from Zechariah. Right. That's that's why you can that's why you can bank on that. Because a pr a true prophet of God said it. You know, beforehand. Which the Bible does say Enoch is a prophet. Right. Yeah. Yeah. It does. I think Hebrews mentions it, right? I think so offhand if I remember correctly. Yes, let me s let me look. To make sure right. No, it's Jude actually. Hebrews is more of its faith, more of the faith of Enoch. But yeah. Jude is mentioned as a prophet in the New Testament. Yeah, 'cause it says he prophesied about the Lord's coming judgment, right? In Jude. Yeah, yeah. I couldn't remember if Hebrews had often mentioned it too, but no. Well, I don't really have much more to say. I mean I feel like we've unpacked this. There's probably more questions to to more things to talk about with this, but I think that I think that right now just the basic of it is that it's pseudographical, it's not it's not backed by scripture. There's no historical findings to back it up. The language is been confused and changed in the the text has been changed fundamentally to attribute Enoch in a in a mes messianic representation, which is heretical because there's only one, that's Jesus. And then and then also the the possible Gnostic and Masonic influence because of of Can I can can I give one Gnostic thing before we before we cut off the podcast before we go right. I another question for you too. Yes, yes. And I this this was the passage that when I read it when I first became born again after I read the Bible, I was reading first Enoch and I was reading the apocryphal literature and kind of getting into it. But there were parts of first Enoch that still as a former Gnostic I was like Wait a wait a minute. And so the big one that stood out to me then was Enoch forty two. Wisdom found no place where she might dwell. Then a dwelling place was assigned her in the heavens. Wisdom went out to make her dwelling among the children of men and found no dwelling place. Wisdom returned to her place and took her seat among the angels. And her righteousness went out from her chambers whom she sought not sh she found, and dwelt with them as a rain in a desert in a dew on a thirsty land. Now I understand that wisdom is personified in in in in Proverbs as a woman. You know, there's a difference between some people saying that it's the wisdom of Jesus or the wisdom of the Holy Spirit in Proverbs. I understand there's a debate between that. But nonetheless, the main issue that I found with that, and it does sound like Sophia to me, Sophia falling and then returning to the monad, okay, in her redemption. Okay. Nonetheless, the difference here that we have between the wisdom of God, wisdom of the Holy Spirit, or Holy Spirit in and of itself is there is no unrighteousness. So in part three where it says, An unrighteousness went out from her chambers, whom she s not sought found and dwelt with them as a rain in a desert do on a thirsty land, I'll get the exact quote from Gnosticism for where the unrighteousness of wisdom or Sophia comes from. But that's a Gnostic belief. That's not a biblical belief. There is no unrighteousness with God's wisdom. There is no unrighteousness with the wisdom of Jesus or the wisdom of the Holy Spirit or the wisdom of both. Right. Yeah. Yeah. And so when I read that, as someone who used to falsely pray to Sophia, I had a, you know, a check in my own spirit and probably, you know, checked by the Holy Spirit where I went, wait, what? Huh? That's not right. yeah, for sure, dude. I I the fact that God had his hand on you so strongly in that moment and that he was he was giving you a discernment just by reading that text. He was giving you a great discernment. And that's all that's amazing I that's just proof, right, that you're born again, number one, but also that God's spirit leads us, the spirit of truth leads us in all truth. And you know, I don't know, man. May i you know, let me just let me connect that back to the book of Enoch for a second, but I Remember first opening up the tran I got the Heiser, you know, translation of Enoch that he had. Remember that? And that was the first one I looked at and it was a it was a commentary alongside with the text and all that stuff. And and I remember I was listening to it on audiobook and in my truck driving and I just remember like getting a weird like I don't go by woo woo feelings, but I had a definite like something was in my gut. That wasn't right. It didn't feel right. It didn't sound right. And just the language that was being used and sounded being used was so biblical sounding. You know what I mean? Like the way it felt like I was reading Revelation on some expanded version of it, you know. And so my question is like or not my question, but my I guess my point is is if you've had that experience, just like John had reading that verse and getting clarity about Sophia not being wisdom, but God being wisdom and the spirit. Coming from truly from the mind of Cod, the Holy Spirit. Do you get a not a discernment, a nudge, something in your spirit about Enoch? You know, and I would say just if you're on the fence about this and maybe you've been poo pooing it and and the whole time we've been talking about it, but maybe it's an opportunity for you to stop for a second and just actually genuinely pray and ask the Lord, God, do you want me to read this book? Do you want me to spend time in this? is this something I need to cast aside and just turn right back to the scriptures? And trust in the scriptures. And the the thing is is so crazy about this, you know, I remember, you know, when I s when we started this podcast and I started down this truther journey, if you will, like this sort of like it's like a side street to conspiracy conspiracy culture because it's like biblically, you know, adjacent. I felt like maybe there was something to this that I had been missing and had had been held back, like there was some kind of knowledge that had been held back from me. And the truth is is everything I needed was found in the Bible I held my hands and trusted in anyways. I didn't need any of this extra stuff. And I I have a I have a true belief that I think that, you know, John, I think and I may have said this to you, I think there's going to be a deconstruction of all of these truth or conspiracy things. I think they're gonna see yeah, I mean I get it, Epstein, you know, right it it's terrible. Right? It was hidden from us. Like i there's this there's this and John, you you uncovered this with all your work with the Finders. Like there is this undercurrent of evil that is that is running right alongside of of the culture, just underneath everything, and it has a great influence and it has an agenda and it's satanic more than likely. And it's there, but to know about it and then to go deep into it and try and and and figure out who the players are and all that stuff, it can really drag you down a path that is not healthy. And I think there's going to be a whole bunch of people that have that were believers that are maybe raised in church, mature Christians who have ventured down these pathways and are going to have to deconstruct out of it to get back into proper theological doctrine, proper you know, standing with Christ and in the idea of what the scriptures say and And they're gonna have to throw away a lot of things that they have picked up along the way. That's my belief. And I think that's gonna happen. I think God's going to like w it's his bride, right? He's going to perfect his church. He's going to like as the Bible tells us it it's like he will, you know, work out your salvation, right? He who began a good work in you will carry it out to completion, as we're promised in scripture. So I think God's gonna do these things. And I think there's gonna be a mass exodus out of this a deconstruction movement that's actually healthy. We need it. I I think there's been so many whack I mean, mud floods, you know, t what what the orphan trains, like I mean, think about it. Paul Stabbs, the the Nephilim look like clowns and he's gone down this whole pathway of the of like the full preterist, you know, like with with that stuff, which is crazy to you know, like It just all these pathways just have other exits that go into deeper and more heretical things that leave move you away from the truth. You know, Paul Stobbs on our podcast, which John, you know, you you've you spoke to him and we s we spoke to him shortly after you guys had spoken to him on your other podcast that you were doing by their fruits. And He kind of like blew up after that. Like I remember he started getting making the rounds on all these different podcasts about the Nephilim look like cro clowns and and and I think the truth is is that that guy it's sad because he was telling us how he was new in the faith. Like I remember I had we we talked to him after you know, we talked to him after the podcast and and I remember it was me and Rosie, I don't think you were there. It was me and Jessica and I remember he was telling us about his new faith. He was telling us about how he's fairly new in his faith and he was trying to work out some things and and it was all very intriguing to him and very and and I got the sense that he was just a baby Christian, but his experience that he portrayed to us was that, hey, I went on this drug and I saw these things and everything that I was learning about the Nephilim, these things that were behind the veil, if you will, were were just the descriptions of that I was fine. So maybe the Nephilim look like clowns. And it was like a crazy it was a stretch it was a stretch, you know, for for me. I remember when we finished that one, I was like, Wow, okay, where are where are we? Like, where are we going? You know what mean? but what's sad is that Paul has now moved into heretical belief system. And I've checked in with them a couple of times and I don't have the influence in his life to try and bring him back. I mean, you can Warner brother, you can try, you know, I don't know where he stands right now. mean I mean I'll I'll s I'll say this. I don't I don't know if he's a full preterist. I know he's a postmillennialist. Yeah, for sure. He's full preterist news to me. but I do know that he was in I know he's entertaining reincarnation from a postmillennialist standpoint. Him being a former new ager is really, really, really bad. Yeah. Well the f the preterist thing came about when he started to believe in you know, we were doing those those episodes a few like a year or two ago. about just with the mud floods and the and it was like again hidden information that was not that people don't know and it was r you know it was repressed you know like we had civilizations that were highly advanced and you know all these things and it's like nothing points to that scripturally like nothing proves that they try and tie it in and then they were also talk that we're living in Satan's little season, you know, which is Satan's little season post millennialism. Yeah, so that's a very new eschatology. Yeah, it's very new. It like i i but the thing is, is like my my whole point of this is not to crap on Paul Stobbs or anybody else, Ken Johnson. I'm not trying to do that. What I'm trying to do is is to show is that there if you depart from little orthodoxy in Christianity, you run the risk of picking up false teachings and adopting them into your theology in a very, very sly and un It's very you don't notice it. It's super it's super low key. But it has a huge effect. Yeah. And just to hop in here, like w one of the things I was thinking of when you were saying that of like the deconstruction of that's gonna be happening, like dude, when we were like to that was a big thing for me that like not to deconstruct stuff and I'll say, you know, there's still stuff that I believe like there there is like what you're talking about, like the Finders is a very real thing. That's of course. You know, that's that's how we got connected, John. Like I remember I stumbled upon one of your videos. I'm like, my god, he's the only guy I've seen talk about this. there are real conspiracies out there. We are not like saying we're like there that there's not crazy stuff like Yeah, yeah. I'm gonna say I still believe Pizzagate. Like I still believe that there's stuff yeah like that. So we're not like totally throwing that out. Well the emails are like proving it. Like the fact that we have the emails. Yeah. And I mean and there was a basement. And they're doing weird stuff you know what I mean? Like there is that kind of stuff. And Jump it up like w we're not throwing or at least I'm not saying that like I totally denouncing everything and I'm no longer a conspira you know, like all that kind of stuff. Like there there's so much truth to it. But two things out there. but what I was gonna say is that's why I think the three of us and I know we always say on the podcast, like that's why discernment is so important. That's why and we say this like all the time is you have to read your Bible to know what it says so that when there's other stuff that comes out, you're like, Okay, well that's not true because I know what the Bible says, like it just clearly you can just throw off stuff like immediately there's no way that's true, it's contradictory. Boom. Right. But if you don't know what's in the Bible Right. And the actual Bible, like not these apocrypha texts and you know, the fruits of all that and it gets weird about orthodoxy having other Bibles or Catholic. You know what I mean? Like but if you stick with I don't know, the sixty six books that I think but I mean this isn't like a full like we're Burning down everything that we've done for the past like what's Yeah, please don't take it that way. But Well, the book of Enoch is not good. Like I I'm I'm to the point now where I'm not gonna read it. I'm not gonna keep a copy of it anymore. And and but I I have to reject it. Yeah, but I mean I I was thinking throughout all of this is like there's a lot that like Ryan Peterson's book he does because he w we interviewed him for When his second book like had just came out that day, I think, or something like that, how it lined up, or the next day or before. that when you read his book, he he he I mean he said he's like, I don't like the book of Enoch. I do not use the book of Enoch. And he can build out the case for like the Nephilim were a real thing. Yeah. They like i and this is where I was going from when you said about there's almost like this feeling of there's I've been missing parts of the Bible that makes more sense to me. And I remember I always kinda thought of it like this as like I'm cool with like sounding like an idiot and people thinking or or just having like this very elementary education like Sunday school thing where they're like God drowned the whole world because they're all bad. Like I'm totally cool with not needing more than that. I remember you saying that back in the day. Yeah, okay, cool. I believe that. I you don't need to tell me more. I Don't really question it because it's God. Like I don't need Nephilim lore to Right. Convince me when you find out like there's tribes that were like bad and there's like more of a supernatural thing. It's like, that that makes more sense, that gives me more. But you can find that not in you don't need the book of Enoch to s say all this extra stuff. So it's not also like you I'm not throwing out like if there's stuff that's in the Bible, like read And Peterson's books. Well, it kind of reminds me like what you're saying, like this and forgive me, I didn't mean to step on it. It's kind of like a if you run into like you run into like a Jehovah's Witness or a Mormon. Yeah. Like they have this language that sounds very familiar, very Christian, but they're way off. And once you get like you start walking down the path with them, it's gonna lead you very far astray. And That is how I kind of see this with the Book of Enoch. What it the capability that it has is that, hey, if it sounds good, it feels it seems like everything on its surface level seems and sounds and feels like it's right and good. But then if you follow it to its logical place, you're gonna un you're gonna uncover the fact that it wasn't it you know, it all these things we've been talking about today. Like, you know, it's it's pseudographical, it's it you know, it was the a Freemason helped bring back copies from it, you know, the it was changed in the text with the with the writings and it actually you know attributes Enoch to be a Messiah d be the Messiah a and all these other things that we've been discussing and the Gnostic influence and the Essenes, all th all that. Like so like when you start to uncover it, just like with Mormonism, you're gonna uncover a bunch of stuff that is not good, not right and is wrong. And and that's why it's good to just kinda outright just reject it in my opinion. Like You're not you're not losing anything by just saying, Correct. Don't need that anymore. Hundred percent. Hundred percent. Yeah. The Bible has everything we need. There's nothing And I I got saved in nineteen eighty eight. Most of our some of our listeners weren't even born back then. Yeah. But it God kept me through the Word of God, he kept me from eighty eight until even to today. You know what I mean? Like just the word of God was sufficient. The Bi the sixty six books of the Bible were sufficient. So Now, were there giants? Yes. They were. Is there room to think that when those giants were killed in the flood, which they were, most of them, that I mean well, all everything was except for Noah and his family, right? That that those disembodied souls became demons? Possibly. Is there scripture to back that? Not at all. So you just have to kind of leave openness for some of that stuff and not you don't have to venture down those things. down the down those pathways necessarily. If you want to explore and look at them, that's fine. But just be really, really careful. Be really careful. Like understand like what what the possibilities are before you embrace things like that totally. Yeah. John, sorry I didn't mean to hijack everything there. No, that no, that was perfect, boys. so let me ask you this. I didn't I got some more questions for you. And I know Rosie wants to get asked yes. Yes. All right. So first off the Old Testament, God called judgment on the human race or groups of civilizations within the human race by the by their own sin and their own actions, and God was long suffering in that you know he would take he would give t certain amount of time, sometimes even a long ver amount of time before the Israelites would go to war. even be commanded to wipe out certain people. Now, a lot of the Nephilim worldview type people will say it was because they had Nephilim blood and that's why God had commanded to do 'cause he was just wiping out people with Nephilim blood or people that were or that were not people were just for Nephilim. why can't we just believe what the Bible says and it's just that they were wicked people? Yeah. You understand what I'm saying? Yeah. I believe that. I mean yeah. I mean whether they were giants or not, whether they were Nephilim or not, they were wicked. They needed they needed to be killed. Yeah. I mean God lost that's he he said, I regretted that I even made them. Right? Is that a proof text to say that they weren't But a lot of people say But a lot of people s a lot of people say that they have a have a almost judge God like Job and say they have issues with God if you know they didn't have any Nephilim DNA or they weren't giants or whatever, that these people were people that God had commanded the Israelites to kill. But then again, he flooded the whole world. Right. Yeah. I mean So how does that line up? You guys understand what I'm saying? Like it's theologically problematic. Yeah. Yeah. I mean b yeah. The way like that's again the way that I look at it is like and I agree with it. It's like if they are if they do have Nephilim blood, that like it doesn't change my theology to like if that is true, okay, that makes more sense, but they they had to die anyway. Like God wanted them dead. They were bad people. I'm cool with that. If it turns out that it's true that they were Nephilim, Okay, that makes a little bit more sense, but I don't need to rationalize it. That's like the fun Isn't everybody dead is it I was gonna say, isn't everybody dead by the end of recorded history and time when God enters in and burns up all existence? Yeah. Yeah, we all have a count. God enters into time and space. I mean we have a count. Yeah, everybody has a count. So yeah, so I wanna read this I I wanna read this part for what I read in in Enoch forty two of where I believe that it has Gnostic components. So right here, because this is from I'll get the name of the book. Textual and comparative explorations in first and second Enoch. So because chapter forty two is reworking of chapter thirty-nine five or vice versa, the former's connection with Enoch forty-one three is hardly productive for a theological interpretation of chapter forty two. Such an endeavor must be guided mainly by Enoch thirty-nine five instead of since righteousness in thirty-nine five stands in place with unrighteousness does in forty two three. This raises question as to whether chapter forty two's personified wisdom and unrighteousness are but two aspects of a single entity. That would agree with traditions that see the book of Proverbs, Celestial Lady Wisdom and Hellish, Whorish Lady Folly as a singular being, a notion attested in the Zohar, where a form of Shekinah is identified with the demon Lilith. The Naghamadi literature, the thunder perfect mind, I am a whore and the holy one. I am the wife and the virgin. And Mandian text, Ginza Rabia book, six, I am darkness, I am light, I am error, I am truth. Forty first Enoch 42 may indicate quite ancient roots for such a notion. So there you go, right? The whole iniquity of wisdom we see in the Zohar, the thunder perfect line, mine, which is Gnostic, and the Mandian Ginza Rabia book six I am darkness, I am light, I am our, I am our I am truth. so you have celestial wisdom being compared to hellish whorish lady folly. So again, you know, if if if if if the angels were attributed to folly, which was having sex with humans, and that was the crime that they had committed, then again, like all this fits is is first Enoch forty two is satanic. It's wicked, it's Gnostic. Yeah. There's no there's no other way to take it eventually it is what it is. That's yeah. John, your your internet connection I think is going you're you're skipping frames and your thing it's like a rough signal there. It's the Do I sound bad on the mic? No, you sound good. You sound good. That's good, yeah. Okay. It's the I might stop the camera then so that at least that way I don't look like I'm I'm glitching. those being y'all two together. You can do a steward st That way it doesn't look like I'm like glitching like a like and also maybe there's a bandwidth issue or something. But okay, lightning round. What questions were you gonna ask me, Rosie? Lightning round. So here's another thing that I know is a lot of people say, which is like r again, before the do we we know that the Council of Nicaea was like they didn't just come to keep books out, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. And a lot of like the canon That was built, you know, so they say, or you know, people I'm not trying to set this up in any kind of way, but there's a lot of press emphasis on what church fathers thought this is authentic, this is not authentic, this book you know, there's church fathers that like y I don't want to say unanimously agree, 'cause nut they never unanimously agree, and it wasn't like it's not like all of them lived for one particular time it was like a rolling thing. So I get the get all that. But one of the arguments for the book of Enoch being authentic, that it should be in the canon, is that they will say that there are church fathers who did think that it should be. And I found just a a couple of like quite a a number of them that they're not all, you know, Gnostics, like Tertullian, Irenaeus, Clement of Alexandria, Justin Martyr, Athenagoras and Commodius and Anatolius or Clement of Alexandria may have been. The whole originistic school, there's a lot of problems in the Alexandrian school, not to go too much into it now, but a lot of problems in the Alexandrian school and the writings of the thinkers of that came out of Alexandria, Egypt. Right. To be fair. Right. But I mean, is it W what w what would you say if like some of them 'cause like Irenaeus, like against heresies, like you know what mean? That's he did a lot of really good. He was like an Orthodox, like you know, Christian that was a good church father and like his whole Yeah, like really tried to correct the church and like in a good way and keep him on track. And if he, you know, upheld some aspects of like Enochian literature and you know W what would you say to like some of these that would say, well, church fathers thought that they did? Yeah. And some good church fathers, or at least one of them. Me personally. Well with Ireneus, Irenaeus he he thought it was more of being he put in high authority, which most there's a lot of good Christians that do now. It doesn't mean they're right. So Michael Heiser, a lot of people considered him to be one right. And You know, I have some issues with things that Heiser believed, but to use that same logic, again, Araneus isn't right about everything. Right. And Heiser ain't right about everything. So again, like, yeah, do I like hi Araneus is against heresies? Yeah, do I think that it's a hundred percent accurate? No, I don't think it's a hundred percent accurate. And so just because he found something to be in high regard doesn't necessarily mean that it should be or that that's true. you know, because these people are not infallible. and we do know now something that he did not know at the time. Correct. that I would assume he did not know at the time, that you know the book of Enoch is cobbled together throughout centuries and is a pseudopigophil writing. So he I don't think he considered to be word of God. he was just using it to shape his doctrine that a lot of Christians do today, and he was just wrong as a lot of those Christians are today, sadly. Yeah, and I was gonna say the same thing just to be an Irenaeus defender. And I mean this is just true is we don't even know if what he was talking about as the book of Enoch is what we have today. You know what I mean? Well that's true. That's a good point. That is true, yes. It like that isn't a good argument, even if he did hold it in high authority, and there are some points you know what I mean? Like we just don't know. The other so it's not It wasn't cared for in the same way that it needed to be protected because Yeah. You know what I mean? So the other thing I would I would say add to that if if I could is that the way that information today is so readily available, back then they didn't you know, Paul, you know, think about Paul writing his letters, right? He would they would get the letter, then they would circulate it through the churches and they would try and make copies as accurate as possible so that they could read them to other congregations. And it was just extremely tedious and painful work to get information throughout the church. And so us having like literally you googled historical stuff that would have taken somebody in that time period, they would never would have had they never would have had access. Yeah. You know, so so that's part of our benefit of where we live today. But the other side of it too is I think about something that Ryan Peterson said that I I o it I it sticks with me because it's like actually pretty cool. It was like how much heresy keeps someone out of heaven. Like everybody had a little bit of heresy Because they didn't have the full picture. And I think that there's still possibilities of that today, e even because, you know, like we're still making discoveries, archaeologically and they're proving parts of scripture or disproving things that we thought might be scripture adjacent or you know, or whatever. And I think that that that was those are the two things that I was thinking about is that like the the the ability to get information the way we do today was not there. So irony is maybe was just like this is something I've had for my existence as a believer. No and maybe, you know, somebody handed it to him or taught it to him and it was, you know, you trust these people, you're not gonna always question. and then secondly, like just the the the idea that there's we're all gonna die with something that we think about or believe and it's not accura accurate scripturally. Nobody's gonna die with the perfect theology. Nobody. So I mean the I'm trying to think of like some little clever way to like sum it up as like There is like there that's not to say like just because no one will have perfect theology. Like no one will because there are people that are in heav there's Baptists that are like you have to dunk you know, w we're full dunkers and then there's sprinklers. You know what I mean? That like they will both there are people who hold to one or the other and say the other one is totally wrong, there's no way. Right. Like Or demons or you know, spiritual warfare. Like, you know, but You can ha so you I wanna say you can have perfect theology, but you can also not have perfect theology. The perfect theology is very simple. It's a gospel. Jesus died, like Jesus is the Son of God. Yeah. He die he lived a perfect life. He died for your sins. He rose again from three days, and he's seated at the right hand of Father, he's coming back to like you can have perfect Sunday school theology and that's what you need to get into heaven. It Like the other stuff people will get wrong because there presumably there is one way of like what did what is real bapt like I'm just picking baptism because that's divided so many things is yeah, sex of church, yeah. It's full immersion. Spoken like a true Baptist. John, turn your camera back on. I want to see your lovely face. Okay. All right. So w I guess we can close by this. I want to read a few quotes from Blavatsky's Secret Doctrine, volume two, about what she thinks about the book of Enoch. perfect. This is great. All right. So here we go. This is page 531 to what a couple of quotes that you guys had said throughout the stream. The Latin Church is not always logical as a Catholic Church, not prudent either. She declares the book of Enoch as a procrypha and has gone so far as to claim through the cardinal Kajiton and other luminaries of the church, the rejection from the canon or even the book of Jude, who th who though an inspired apostle quotes from and thus sanctifies the book of Enoch, which is alleged to be an apocryphal work. Fortunately, some of the dogmatics perceive the peril in time. Had they accepted Catajon's resolution, they would have forced to reject likewise the fourth gospel, as St. John bars literally from Enoch and places in the mouth of Jesus a whole sentence from. Wow. So right there. Hmm. Yeah. I'm not done. I'm not done. All right. So here's another one. Secret Doctrine, Volume two, page five thirty-two. As usual, however, they were all right and all wrong. To accept Enoch as a biblical character, a single living man is like accepting Adam as the first man. Enoch was a generic title applied to and born by scores of individuals at all times and ages and in every race and nation. So maybe easily inferred from the fact that the ancient Talmudists and the teachers of Midrashism are not agreed generally in their views about Hanukkah. The son of Eurid. Some say Enoch was a great saint, beloved by God, and taken alive to heaven, and and others maintain that he was a sorcerer, a wicked magician. This shows only that Enoch or its equivalent was in term even during the days of later Talmudis, which meant seer, adept in the secret wisdom, without any specific specification as the character of title bearer. So again, how the Theosophists title Barrel Jesus, they also title Barrel Enoch as well, too. I find that very interesting. I want to find the final what I call kill shot quote. Let's go. G give me a minute. If you have any questions that you want to ask me to finish up, Rosie, I could probably do both at the same time, but there's one that I consider to be the kill shot quote. Well, while you're looking that up, I was just gonna I was gonna close the show out with this, but it's probably better that we close it out on something else. If you were also wondering who made the butt talks of Adam His name was Badook. What was his name? Badu. B E D O U K. no, sorry. He cre he created the right buttock and Arabie created the left buttock. Dude, so one gets that specific in the apocalypse of John. yeah yeah. 'Cause I I googled which angel created out of butthole. And it said there's not a specific one. But it has Vadook and Araby that created one. Viduque and Airby. So it's like, dude, I this stuff writes itself. You don't even have to make jokes. No, and then the other one, though Pethrow created his intestines. So butthole? Nope. But everything else. Right, right. We still don't have the actual sphincter. Who it's like of the sphincter was part of of of badook and the other half was aridon or whatever maybe that's like what you find out when you become like a 33rd degree mason they tell you that's the real secret who create which angel secret some guy some guy pulls you into a back room and he's like okay sit down you need to know this Adam's butthole this is the angel name this is the secretest secret passcard ever it was angel el sphincto dominio The buttle. Alright, I'm trying to find it. I read it I read it with Steven from the Biblical Hitman. Shout out to Steven. I'll try to find it. I might have to type it in to see if I can find it. But there is a passage, the Secret Doctrine, Volume Two, where Bavatsky, and I'm not paraphrasing, says that the book of Enoch is the initiation, it's the mysteries for the Christians. Wow. Dude, that's that's heavy. That's a big deal. That's a big deal. That is a big deal. And and she's made it 'cause I mean Blavatsky has a big one. Didn't she have some like crazy prophecies about like just the the moving forward of like the end times and s s some of the That would be Alice Bailey, her disciple? Alice Bailey, that's who it was, yes. Okay. Man. So w I mean, what are your thoughts about all that? I mean, is that I'm distracted by the gray in your beard that looks amazing. see hey Yes. I f I I think I found it. Secret Doctrines two two hundred and twenty nine. That was that was pretty quick. That was pretty awesome. Can I go on? that's all it says. That's the only thing I found. Can you get that can you pull it up what it's what it actually says? Can you pull that up? I think that's what John's doing right now. What page? I just have two twenty nine, is all it says. That ASRM, dude. Just putting me to sleep. Sounds so good. The little clickety clack of the keyboard. What's that? Hold on, let me see if I can find it. page two twenty nine. Okay. You found it? I don't know if this is it. But what is I'm quoting now. But what is in reality the book of Enoch itself from which the author is revelation? Okay. Do you want me to read it? Yes. Okay, okay. But what is in reality the Book of Eno Enoch itself, from which the author of Revelation and even Saint John of the Fourth Gospel have so profusiv profusely quoted it it it is simply a book of initiation giving out allegory and cautious phraseology, the program of certain archaic mysteries performed in the inner temples. Is that what you're thinking of? Yes. There you go. So if you read the whole if you read the whole passage, there's more to that. If you read the whole passage, she's talking about how the book of Enoch is only for the the the the there's more to that though. That's you there's more in that, but that's that's where it's at. That's where it's at. But she talks about how it is initiation into the mysteries, it brings you further into the mysteries and and you know, how it was y could use by the what they call the Christians the Orthodox, right? used by them to initiate them into the mysteries pretty much. and so yeah, I mean that's spot on. Me and me and Steven covered it specifically the whole quote it's like a almost a paragraph, but it it it it's it's right there. It's right there. Yeah. It says right here too, she dedicated an entire section of this concept titled The Book of Enoch The Origin and Foundation of Christianity. Wow. Origin and foundation. Yes. Wow. So we see Sounds like a lot I think it's a great place. John, thank you for unpacking that for us and helping us out so much with that. you know, always it's great to have you with us. And look, if you're on the fence about this, just we we laid out A lot of great arguments. Just do the research yourself. Dig in yourself. Find it for yourself. Find out if you think that this is true or not. And you know, if you if you're disappointed with us, you know, I'm sorry, but I would much rather stick close to the truth and to Jesus than to any person on this planet. So there you go. And do not be a respecter of persons. Amen. Amen. Thank you, John. Well, John, we'll have you on again soon 'cause we've got some other stuff we want to talk about in the future. And you're always a well you have an open door, so you just Like literally. You you're you're like you are the third host of of All Out War. You've been on more than any other guest, and we always we always love you. But and first video guest. And our first video guest, yes. True, yes. You can just see my shiny bald head in all its HD glory. Amen. Four K baby. Thank you, brothers. Thank you, brothers. thank you for having me back on. God bless everyone who's listening. I know this is a tough subject. I know that we're going to challenge a lot of your preconceived notions and beliefs. it wasn't this was not something I decided to wake up one morning and my own power all of a sudden decided just to start saying a whole bunch of nonsense. I wrestled with this for months and years years of the Holy Spirit wrestling within me too and I now reject the book of Enoch. I flat out think it's demonic. Yeah. I flat out think it's demonic. I think it's demonically and I think it's it's to I think it's to lead Christians away in the end times, away from standing firm in the word and instead giving over to Essen and Gnostic revisionism and giving over to Judaizing in some aspects. The book of Enoch has steered some people to Judaizing as well. Mm-hmm and to give them their itching ears over to seducing fables. So Yeah. And in English genealogies and etc, etc. So same the book of Jubile Jubilees. So all right, brothers, I love you guys. All right. Love you too, man. All right, we will catch you guys next time. On all at war.