Latest / Newcomer Pod / Business Tea, the Creator Economy Downturn, Twitter Drama & TikTok's Chinese Influence (w/Taylor Lorenz)
Transcript
- 0:05Welcome. So what kind of salad welcome
- 0:13everybody to dead cat? Very exciting episode I sort of
- 0:18sward off and you know 2023 talking too much about media and
- 0:23I worry that I'm about to directly contradict that but a
- 0:26guest I can never turn away and happy to have on this.
- 0:30Joe Taylor Lorenz, thanks for coming on dead cat.
- 0:32Nice to have you. Thanks for having me and a very
- 0:36well timed story like right in our wheelhouse here.
- 0:40You know you wrote about FTX and sort of all the little I don't
- 0:44know you have right have better language for them but like the
- 0:46Twitter characters who have been sort of doing reporting and
- 0:51super interesting like topic so I can you just like give a
- 0:56little background first on what your synopsis of the Like
- 1:00Twitter scoop machine /. T accounts is, yeah, so I mean,
- 1:05I wrote this story. It just went up, but I actually
- 1:08initially wrote it back when FTX story broke.
- 1:12And I don't know if you remember how crazy the internet was, like
- 1:14that whole week but all of these accounts on Twitter and some sub
- 1:19Sakura's, and YouTubers were kind of like all hands on deck.
- 1:22Posting 24/7 about FTX this stuff like autism Capital,
- 1:26right? Y'all like really weird name.
- 1:27Mario nozzle the Twitter. His face, right?
- 1:30They have these huge Twitter spaces at the top characters,
- 1:33like come on. I mean, it's pretty amazing.
- 1:35Yeah. And so I mean, what I noticed is
- 1:38that and I feel like, I write this every news event, it's the
- 1:40same story, but it reminded me a little bit of like, the Johnny
- 1:43Depp Amber Heard stuff. We're like, it's this breaking
- 1:46news, kind of event where everyone uses it as an
- 1:49opportunity to capture an audience.
- 1:50And I think one thing that these influencers for lack of a better
- 1:53word did better than the mainstream media is really tell
- 1:57the story, like Captivate people with the story and And these
- 2:00kind of 24/7 updates gossip things like that.
- 2:03And so yeah, I just wrote about how they kind of, I use the word
- 2:06outshine, there's no word for like out attention.
- 2:08But basically like, you know, they're like stealing eyeballs
- 2:12away from the mainstream media with this type of coverage.
- 2:15Like you said, I compare it a lot to drama channels and T
- 2:17accounts which was also a 50. You got to tweak them a little
- 2:22bit because there's sort of a condescension, you know, of like
- 2:24oh we don't see ourselves that way.
- 2:26But because I know, right, Smart parallel, it's like TMZ does
- 2:32great reporting. And then there are these sort of
- 2:34Gossip style accounts that do it on sort of Pop Culture stuff
- 2:38like that, call themselves t-accounts and then you can sort
- 2:41of extend that metaphor. Exactly as you do in the story
- 2:44to two business report it. And that's what we sort of saw
- 2:47was some of these crypto accounts.
- 2:49I love somebody tweeted that the FTX thing is like the James
- 2:53Charles, versatility, drama geddon, but Borg, but for
- 2:56business people, Yeah. And so that's kind of what I
- 3:00noticed. Of course everyone is funny
- 3:01because the story came out then everyone's like you forgot, you
- 3:03know, XYZ influencer and there were so many.
- 3:07I took a handful of the ones that I noticed, right?
- 3:10When it was all happening. But you know, there's a lot and
- 3:12there are people doing really great work to.
- 3:14It's not to say that everyone using the internet to break
- 3:16news. Is, I mean not doing stuff.
- 3:18Like, Steven from coffee, Zilla has done great reporting, that
- 3:21guide make burgers Berg not his real name, but the Dirty Bubble
- 3:25media, you know, he's exposed real fraud.
- 3:27So in the autism capital, I mean, I see that a lot.
- 3:30It has gotten some stuff right? Right some stuff wrong
- 3:32sometimes. Yeah, I would say that.
- 3:34So I would say we're like Mike burgers, burgers, whatever, and
- 3:37coffees Villa or like the New York Times and Washington Post,
- 3:41you know, autism capital is like the Daily Mail, you know, it's
- 3:44like 20% of the stuff is wrong. You kind of want to click on it.
- 3:48Anyway, sometimes they do get something first, but I think
- 3:51people know that, I mean, I give people much more credit I hate
- 3:54when the media is like oh you know so dangerous.
- 3:57It's like look, we love Gossip. I think it's fine to consume
- 4:00unverified gossip as long as you're taking it as that, you
- 4:03know, it's hard for me not to read this as sort of a
- 4:06narcissist where it's like, where do I fit in, right?
- 4:09I'm all, I'm a sub stacker. But clearly I have I'm all of,
- 4:13you know, old media. I literally came up newspaper
- 4:16internships, you know, clearly sort of inculcated in the cult
- 4:21of Old Guard media. But my real question is, do you
- 4:24think this media versus like these accounts Is T accounts or
- 4:29whatever we're calling them will last.
- 4:31Right? Because right now, I still think
- 4:33in sort of the newspaper construction of the world,
- 4:37there's like some sort of tabloid you see in the grocery
- 4:40store is still seen as sort of like the media world where these
- 4:43like, Twitter accounts are seen as like something else.
- 4:47I don't know. How do you draw the lines?
- 4:49And like, you ever just I just want to relinquish sometimes the
- 4:52reporter Banner because you're just setting up expectations
- 4:55that all these little accounts don't have to have.
- 4:58So anytime Time they succeed. People are like pleasantly
- 5:01surprised. Well I think that's a thing.
- 5:02People are pleasantly surprised. I wouldn't say that.
- 5:05All of them are going to be seen as reputable.
- 5:07Like I mean, you have to develop a reputation to be reputable.
- 5:10I think most people recognize like these accounts as
- 5:13inherently non reputable but they're still enticing to
- 5:16follow. I mean, yes, I think this is
- 5:20this going to be around. I mean this is the whole way
- 5:22that media has been moving for 20 years.
- 5:23It's right. I think what it's only hitting
- 5:26business and I think it hit this businesslike.
- 5:28I mean, we've seen all of these shows happen in women's culture,
- 5:32like, I say, women's culture but like, you know, Beauty fashion
- 5:35entertainment. And I think with the business
- 5:37world, it's been this morning showing direct started sort of
- 5:40with some of these celebrities, you know, goop or whatever
- 5:43community. And then, it became a big issue
- 5:45in Silicon Valley. Exactly.
- 5:47That's the thing. They're the last people to it.
- 5:49I can't once again, Silicon Valley is the last person to
- 5:52discover something and yet they take it as if there is, you
- 5:55know, they're talking citizen journalism, the usage of the
- 5:57term citizens. Journalism peaked in 2004.
- 6:00Like I mean I started as a vlogger like people used to call
- 6:03US citizen journalist. Very funny.
- 6:05But this is why you're not supposed to come on the show.
- 6:08It's like oh she's antagonist. If he sees or you know anybody
- 6:11no not at all. I mean, I mean, some PCS
- 6:13obviously made a lot of money, you know, recognizing this
- 6:16early. Like all the ones that invested
- 6:18in all those companies I just mean the ones and actually VC is
- 6:21not really adapt way to describe them because it's like Elon it's
- 6:26the coinbase sky apology. It's the people who want it to
- 6:29be cultural Warriors about this. Yeah.
- 6:31And it's just like, we've had the cultural war and like
- 6:34they've already won guys, like, you know, don't worry, but I
- 6:38will say, like, what I think is interesting or the reason that
- 6:40it's affecting sort of entering, I think this corner of the
- 6:43finance world is like there is a hostility towards Legacy systems
- 6:47in crypto and also cryptos just like the most online thing ever,
- 6:50you know, everything's public. So it's easy to dig through
- 6:52receipts and stuff like that. And no one is more online.
- 6:56I think than the crypto people like, they're like, Ogden to
- 6:59Twitter with their brains. So I think all of this was like
- 7:02a perfect storm. I mean the big scoop on FTX came
- 7:07from coin desk and that's like that isn't media sensibility.
- 7:11I mean there's some debate about whether like the media gets
- 7:13credit is like an industry rag because a lot of the people who
- 7:17want to shit on the media you know are like really just want
- 7:19to shoot on like the big Outlets.
- 7:21But anyway that's that's a side debate.
- 7:23We had to Antonio Garcia Martinez on an earlier episode.
- 7:26He was sort of like does coin desk out but My point right
- 7:29here. So we I deep in all these
- 7:33peoples heads at this point. But you know, I guess for these
- 7:36Twitter accounts it's still sort of needs to make its way to like
- 7:41the big authoritative outlets for people to sort of have
- 7:45confidence in them. Yeah.
- 7:46Even the people consuming the accounts like their worldviews
- 7:50must ultimately sort of net out with more reputable so but
- 7:54again, I think more reputable sources don't have to be than
- 7:58you are. At times, it will look at
- 7:59someone like Stephen coffee Zilla.
- 8:01Like he's been able to get real accountability on these crypto
- 8:03scams people know. Okay, if he's talking about
- 8:06something he's authoritative on you know so I think it's just a
- 8:09reputational thing. And I think that what Legacy
- 8:12Media companies don't realize and refuse to realize is that
- 8:16they are not. The only ones it is not true
- 8:18that until it's published in a Legacy Media Outlet, you know.
- 8:21Oh nothing can happen. You know, there are the final
- 8:24word, no reputation is something you build and there's a lot of
- 8:27very reputable. Content creators?
- 8:29Yes. Okay, I'm obsessed with this
- 8:32topic of like, just like reputation online, right, which
- 8:35was sort of raised with holy Lon Twitter badge problem where he
- 8:40didn't seem to understand what the value of badges were in a
- 8:43certain way, badges can take away the power of media
- 8:47institutions because it's you know Twitter sort of designating
- 8:51certain people is reliable my question to you and this has no
- 8:55easy answer. But like where do you see
- 8:58Reputation going like the next couple years.
- 9:02It's just like hard if you just drop in to Twitter to know.
- 9:05Like even I follow a script dose of this coffee person, you're
- 9:08saying oh, they're the reliable one autism Capital.
- 9:12Sometimes, like, how do we get to the point where we have,
- 9:14like, more of a scoop scorecard? Or it's just like, who's getting
- 9:18stuff right? Or do you see any effort to like
- 9:21outside of, like, people have to join media organizations?
- 9:25That build such a big reputation and people sort of understand
- 9:28them? How does the layperson track
- 9:30reputations? It's really hard because you
- 9:33like you said, you don't know the background on a lot of these
- 9:35people, they're not right. I mean, ideally these people
- 9:38become big enough that they become household names, right?
- 9:41And you kind of know the gist, you know about them.
- 9:45I mean a lot of people would say that the New York Times is not
- 9:47reputable, right? Because they disagree with you
- 9:49know, so I think yeah, reputation is something, you
- 9:52know? Eric I've thought about a lot
- 9:53because my own reputation is so good and I'm like, What's Up?
- 9:58It's very polarized at this point.
- 10:00Well, it's right. Which is so crazy to me because
- 10:03like I just see all this stuff online and I'm like anyone that
- 10:05knows me knows that. Like this is just delusionally,
- 10:09this is not who I am. This is not what I even espouse,
- 10:11but it's very hard to correct that because your reputation is
- 10:15not your own right. Like you.
- 10:17It used to be this top-down thing where you could kind of
- 10:19declare and you still can, obviously you can build your own
- 10:22presence online, but I think it's very much crowdsourced
- 10:24reputation for all, which is not good.
- 10:27I mean, I imagine that there are I need better ways to filter it.
- 10:30You mentioned the Twitter verification thing.
- 10:31I'm interested to see like with sub stack to like how do they
- 10:36you know, handle reputation. Right?
- 10:38Well, we have badges now for based on how many crappy Pizza,
- 10:42great but like Alex Berenson, you know, who I think people
- 10:46would say, is not reputable like right, you know, he can still
- 10:49get one of those badges. I don't know.
- 10:50I think there's no good proxy for it and the verification
- 10:53thing is like brought a lot of these tensions to light.
- 10:56I mean, part of your, you know, You know, Tucker Carlson.
- 11:00Sadly loves to make you a character.
- 11:03I mean he knows you're not like that.
- 11:05I mean right? It's just people want a foil to
- 11:10create the storylines that they want, right?
- 11:12I mean that's sort of how these YouTube accounts work in the
- 11:14same ways in that everybody she's telling a story and you
- 11:18need to sort of villainize somebody in like at least in the
- 11:23lower Stakes world of non politics, it feels like
- 11:26everybody's sort of in on it because You're getting
- 11:29villainized and makes you more of a character and that's good
- 11:31for you. I don't like but politics is
- 11:34serious. I guess.
- 11:35How do you separate that? You drink by a fire hose, like
- 11:38all this tea culture on YouTube where it feels like the stakes
- 11:40are lower. And then you see it playing out
- 11:43in politics, where it affects you in the stakes.
- 11:45Feel higher. I don't know.
- 11:46How do you make sense of the world here?
- 11:48Yeah. Well, the stakes are higher,
- 11:50right? Eric.
- 11:50It's like, I mean, that, this is literally how Donald Trump.
- 11:54And, by the way, I covered the 2016 election, you know, and
- 11:57this is stuff that I cover it. Is this battle for online
- 12:00attention. It's funny.
- 12:01You know, when I was just arguing with someone so many
- 12:03people, it's like people see my work, and I think there's this
- 12:07Narrative of like, oh, she's writing about, like, you said, a
- 12:09silly things or entertainment, adjacent things influencers, it
- 12:12seen as very like teen feminized, but online influence
- 12:17is shaping. Everything old are, you know?
- 12:19She's 87. I know, right?
- 12:22It's the way the age three is so funny, too, because like, it's
- 12:25very obvious. When I graduated college and
- 12:27started work, Because I've been so fun.
- 12:30Like where do you think this like lost decade came from like,
- 12:34what was I do it? Yeah, sorry for conducts.
- 12:36I just feel like you've articulated very well but you
- 12:39get hit from both ways. When you were a young reporter,
- 12:42I was like, oh she doesn't know anything.
- 12:44And then as soon as you're sort of of the age of, you know, I
- 12:48don't know, credibility, it's like already and you're all
- 12:50you're too old to be like worried about creators and so
- 12:54there's a lot of varied, obviously, gendered sort of
- 12:58gate. Keeping just to sort of come at
- 13:00you on Twitter, which is hilarious.
- 13:02Because anyone that watches YouTube like there was one week
- 13:04last year I think was last year, the year before but it was like
- 13:07Trisha Paytas, Jeffree Star. Shane Dawson.
- 13:10And keemstar. Oh, and Phil DeFranco got
- 13:12involved were all fighting. And I'm like, these people are
- 13:15all like between ages of like 38 and 45 lat.
- 13:20If you think YouTube drama is only for teenagers.
- 13:22Like please, please spend some time on YouTube, right?
- 13:25I mean, that's the thing. Is online influence.
- 13:27It reminds me of Technology. Right?
- 13:28It's like people think of things as a toy and they don't take it
- 13:32seriously. At first, a lot of, you know,
- 13:33consumers with this whole kayfabe sort of culture like the
- 13:36fake fights, I mean, obviously Trump would do it all the time.
- 13:40I mean to certain degree were literally experience unit with
- 13:43the speaker of the house right now where there isn't like this,
- 13:46super Advanced like policy agenda, their seemingly getting
- 13:51everything they want in terms of like rules changes to the house
- 13:55but what they really want, like all the stories basically say is
- 13:57just Tab like the fight on Fox News.
- 14:01Like there was that one of the members of Congress didn't even
- 14:03go vote until he got done with his TV hit because it's like the
- 14:07obvious priorities. I don't know.
- 14:08Like our culture is just do you think it's because of YouTube or
- 14:13like? Yeah, do you think the internet
- 14:15has changed our culture to make it sort of less serious and have
- 14:18these drama fights in every pocket?
- 14:21Obviously, I mean, this is what algorithmic, this is the
- 14:23consequence of things like algorithmic these that optimized
- 14:26for attention. I mean You know, if you're going
- 14:29to set up the social internet, the way that we have it set up,
- 14:31this is the type of thing it's going to incentivize.
- 14:33It's going to reward engagement over all else which is that's
- 14:38the system we have now that's why we obviously need to build a
- 14:41better. Would you go back to The
- 14:43Gatekeepers like is are? No, no definitely see that.
- 14:47I'm more mixed. I Believe In The Gatekeepers
- 14:49little, I mean there was value in like, you know, the New York
- 14:53Times sort of learning about something and deciding this is
- 14:57like to pet. So we're not going to cover it,
- 15:00you know, like 100 by tens dick pics or something and so then it
- 15:04wouldn't seep into the culture and the culture wouldn't become
- 15:07about that. Now, we live in this world where
- 15:10there's almost like a fatalism to what gets covered because the
- 15:14internet's obviously much more powerful than any of these
- 15:17institutions. Yeah, I mean, I'm a Believer.
- 15:20I obviously work and Legacy Media now.
- 15:22So I believe in the, you know, the promise of of Legacy Media
- 15:27but I don't want to live in a world where that is the only
- 15:32dominant system only because I remember that world from when I
- 15:35was younger and it was horrible. Like I mean there's just the
- 15:39certain war in the Middle East. Yeah, misguided and nobody
- 15:43complained and also just like, I mean, on a personal level like
- 15:46that's what got me in. I like got into writing about
- 15:49this stuff because these mainstream Outlets were writing
- 15:51about influencers in the internet in such a ridiculous
- 15:54way and I was like I'm gonna do it myself, you know?
- 15:58So Think there's flaws, I think we obviously need a better
- 16:00system, you know. I think it's tempting and Times
- 16:03of disruption, right to be like, oh well, let's just go back to
- 16:06the old one because, you know, you kind of get nostalgic and
- 16:10stuff, but it's like, no, no, no.
- 16:11We need to move forward. We just need it.
- 16:13Like you're saying, we need this infrastructure.
- 16:15All of this is very new, you know, right.
- 16:17Well we don't even know how to talk about someone like Elon
- 16:21Musk like if any I mean the media probably even more than
- 16:25like Twitter is struggled with people like you.
- 16:28Trump and musk who clearly lie all the time, but are also
- 16:34beloved in some cases for very valid reasons and and people
- 16:38could have the view that, like them being honest.
- 16:41Consistently is not the thing they value the most.
- 16:43But, but the media is very saying, someone just like,
- 16:46doesn't have like a consistent rep.
- 16:48You know, good track record of honesty become such a moral
- 16:53Claim about like their whole being that the media feels like
- 16:55very uncomfortable calling it out, right.
- 16:58I mean, I think a lot of criticism and fair criticism of
- 17:01the media is Legacy Media, as you know, deference to power and
- 17:06deference to other Legacy institutions and corporations,
- 17:09right? You hear that a lot and when I
- 17:11talk to people especially people that get most of their news from
- 17:13the internet, they're sick of that corporate media
- 17:17environment, right? And so then they sort of over
- 17:20correct by listening to some billionaire on Twitter right
- 17:25now. So it's like, okay, but I do
- 17:27think that like, you know, oh, the media industry as a whole
- 17:30needs to look in the mirror and be like, okay, who are we not
- 17:32talking to you because we're just serving this one audience,
- 17:35right, right. Yeah, it's so easy.
- 17:38I mean, one of my last chord is a Bloomberg.
- 17:40I don't wanna get into the whole thing, but like I basically it
- 17:43was, you know, in my newsletter. So I sort of free to have
- 17:47opinions, but they wouldn't admit it.
- 17:49And I just sort of was suggesting the Ted Cruz was
- 17:52playing footsie with q and on by getting really upset about the
- 17:55whole Netflix. Cuties thing.
- 17:57Yeah. And like Bloomberg went
- 17:59ballistic that I was suggesting a connection even though Cruz
- 18:02people, you know, you know, I didn't ask whose people for
- 18:06comment because it was like a column type situation.
- 18:08So then, of course, Bloomberg sort of wielded that as like,
- 18:10well, you have to ask for comment, which, like, in any,
- 18:13you know, it's like and then we did and they didn't comment,
- 18:17right? It's like what, where's the
- 18:18comment distance? Ted Cruz, please, distance.
- 18:21I was begging them like distance yourself from q and on just say
- 18:24Q nouns like laughable and I would never been, of course they
- 18:26didn't. And so the Media is like you
- 18:29know even Bloomberg sort of deference to you know they want
- 18:33to keep their sources in in the hill and play the game the right
- 18:35way and so it's a powerful force.
- 18:38Yeah. I mean do you see media
- 18:40especially it's like the entitlement of certain people.
- 18:44I worked in d.c. media for two years so I can say this but it's
- 18:48just I understand that you know I understand where the
- 18:50resentment comes from. That said I think that Legacy
- 18:54Media institutions are at very crucial, check on Democracy
- 18:57because only Currently in this media environment have the
- 19:01resources to do a lot of this, like, really intense
- 19:04accountability journalism, that these content creators, who many
- 19:07of them are amazing, and given the resources could do a lot
- 19:09better work, you know, don't and there's value in certain
- 19:13reporters having like Leverage over sources or like I worry,
- 19:18sometimes that you sort of the intense, High scrutiny interview
- 19:22right in this world where people just go on, like, Lex freedmen.
- 19:26And he asks like, I mean, they're interesting.
- 19:28In, but it just sort of in some ways fills, whatever public
- 19:32appetite there is to hear from, you know, a tech CEO while they
- 19:37don't have as much pressure to. Like, I don't know, sit down
- 19:41with the New York Times be reporter.
- 19:42Who's worried about all the sort of serious story lines or I
- 19:47don't know. It was this never where we ever
- 19:49in the situation where be reporters had.
- 19:51I mean, it sort of Ebbs and flows, but is there a solution
- 19:53to this? Or what, what's going to get
- 19:55these people in front of the pen and paper of The hard serious,
- 20:00be reporters. I think it goes back to
- 20:02audience, right? What audience, you're trying to
- 20:04reach. If you are just trying to reach
- 20:05your fans anyway or convince people to be fans.
- 20:08Yeah, you're going to go on those friendly podcast.
- 20:10I would say people in powerful situations still might do
- 20:13antagonist, eight interviews. I mean, I just think of
- 20:15celebrities which is again all of this stuff.
- 20:17It's like so much of it starts in entertainment.
- 20:19Celebrity culture than bleeds out to politics and business but
- 20:22like you know celebrities will do this to they'll just have
- 20:25these BS red carpet reporters and stuff but sometimes Will
- 20:28Smith is a good example, right? He fucked up, he wanted to do
- 20:32that sort of accountability interview with, you know, a
- 20:36television journalist because he knew that that was something
- 20:39like he knew. That like fans wanted his feet
- 20:42to be held to the fire and like he had fucked up and that was a
- 20:44way to like redeem his own credibility.
- 20:47And so I think, you know, are they going to be our day?
- 20:49I don't think Business Leaders are going to do those types of
- 20:51like casual interviews anymore. Like I don't think they have to,
- 20:55but I do think that you know, if you You mess up publicly, you
- 20:59need to reach people. Like at the end of the day human
- 21:02beings, thankfully do care about reputation.
- 21:04And so, if you have a reputation for seriousness, that is the
- 21:08value, that will last more than like, whatever the current
- 21:11battle lines are on like Media or maybe you just don't want to
- 21:14lose your money, right? Like no one's, but you're, you
- 21:18know, it's like, you're hemorrhaging money, your movies
- 21:20are being canceled shit. Do you think media like the big
- 21:24Outlets like New York Times post?
- 21:27Maybe with this line of thinking, it's almost, like,
- 21:29should they have restricted reporters more on Twitter like
- 21:32the strength of their brand was being sort of authoritative when
- 21:37there's sort of this, like, tea culture?
- 21:39I don't know, like, some of your own fights.
- 21:41Yeah. Art like, people will like shit
- 21:44on Taylor. The Twitter Persona, when I feel
- 21:46like if they went through all your stories, there would be
- 21:48nothing really. Oh, and that's another with my
- 21:50work though, those, they're not reading, right, but the Twitter
- 21:53thing is a double-edged sword for you, right?
- 21:56Oh 100% %. I mean internet it gives and
- 21:58takes right and I hadn't audience before Twitter, like I
- 22:01got into media because of my Tumblr, audience, and blogging.
- 22:06I mean, that's I built my own audience before.
- 22:08Well, I had a platform before Twitter, and I have a platform
- 22:11mean, I have way more followers on Tick Tock than I do on
- 22:13Twitter. So I know the media is obsessed
- 22:16with Twitter. That is certainly not my end-all
- 22:19be-all at all. I mostly just go in there to
- 22:21yell at other people lately, but I think like, in terms of
- 22:24journalists in general building brands, Whatever.
- 22:27I've always said, I understand if I was CEO of a media company,
- 22:31I wouldn't want my journalist building brands.
- 22:32Of course, I want them serving me.
- 22:34I totally respect that perspective, right?
- 22:37But as a journalist I don't think that's that's not, you
- 22:39know, that obviously, your, your incentives are not aligned in
- 22:43that space. That said, it can be very
- 22:46beneficial to of these companies in terms of generating
- 22:50subscribers to hire big-name Brands.
- 22:52Right? So it depends.
- 22:53Do I want my beat reporters building up their own brands on?
- 22:57My back. No, but what I go out and
- 22:59recruit some big-name columnist because they're going to bring
- 23:02in subscribers. Yes.
- 23:03So I think it depends on goals. It depends on give-and-take, for
- 23:06me, it's been, yeah, it's been a double-edged sword.
- 23:08I don't even know. It's mostly been bad in terms of
- 23:11the harassment, but it's been good.
- 23:12In the sense that I think a lot of people who weren't familiar
- 23:15with my work, see people ranting about me and then read.
- 23:20And I mean, it's amazing. I mean, you got a lot of
- 23:22interviews for your FTX story. It's like I feel like you're
- 23:25getting even sort of people in my Skeptically, not on the
- 23:28Taylor side of Twitter drama are still picking up the phone and
- 23:32talking to you for a lot of these stories.
- 23:34Yeah. Because also I do think I do a
- 23:36good job with my story. I mean, I don't know, like I
- 23:39don't I think also at, you know, I'm talking to influencers and I
- 23:43do have authority in that space because it's a space that I've
- 23:46always covered. You know, the second half of
- 23:48this conversation, we're going to talk about the state of the
- 23:52Creator economy. But before I got to that and
- 23:53since we're talking about Twitter and I mean one of your
- 23:56recent story, Ruiz was on sort of the whole Elon Musk flight
- 24:01Jet tracking situation and basically throwing water on the
- 24:05idea that there was like a real security threat.
- 24:09Yeah, what happened with that story?
- 24:10By the way, I mean, it's a classic musk situation and that
- 24:13we all just like, move on to the next thing.
- 24:15Well, what happened is, I was on Twitter and I saw him tweet out
- 24:19this video. That was like, you know, do you
- 24:22know this man? And this video XYZ and I was
- 24:25like, all right, I'm going to find In the video quickly, found
- 24:28the guy in the video found him, even before the police found
- 24:31him, I spoke to him. I reached out to him was a whole
- 24:35thing. So I reached out to be Lon, hey,
- 24:37you asked for the guy in the video, I know who it is.
- 24:40You know, will you talk to us, withdrew her?
- 24:42Well, my colleague who did this right together?
- 24:45No, of course not. He didn't want to talk to us.
- 24:46And then I, and then he banned me, right after every shot for
- 24:49coming. And I was like, what the hell
- 24:51and then it was like this made-up, excuse for Banning me
- 24:53about like it was that I violated the, my tweet that was
- 24:56Violet. It was like, I promoted my
- 24:58Instagram account. It was like ridiculous.
- 25:00I think he was searching hard on that one, but Drew is still
- 25:04banned but these Drew refuses to your rescue.
- 25:07The stupid. I'm Cox.
- 25:11And that's gonna be the subject line here.
- 25:14No, no, no. But anyway, that was what kicked
- 25:18off that story? But I thought it was such a good
- 25:19example because when we actually untangled what happened it was
- 25:23not as Elon was representing it at all.
- 25:25And I think it's just a classic example.
- 25:27Of all of you online, right? Do you think Twitter is going to
- 25:32die or what is your view? No.
- 25:35And do you think people are just gone like hysterical?
- 25:37No. Yeah, I don't think it's gonna
- 25:38die. I do think people are a little.
- 25:41I mean, just I think it becoming like the musk storyline Place
- 25:46heard it. Almost as much as anything it
- 25:48was just becoming. It's like the storyline can't
- 25:50just be one thing all the time. I mean, I've never been somebody
- 25:54who's like, oh, I don't know. The whole service is about to
- 25:56shut. It down and I thought people are
- 25:58getting a little crazy about that but I had yeah, but I had
- 26:02the fight with one of my friends over that because he was like
- 26:04the service is going to shut down and I was like, you are
- 26:06delusional. Yeah.
- 26:08But you think Twitter lives on fine?
- 26:11I mean, I just think of other sort of examples of tech
- 26:14platforms. And I think, unless the
- 26:16companies actively shuttering it like Vine for instance, it kind
- 26:20of just goes on to Oblivion, like it turns into a ghost town,
- 26:23right? Like, it's I think that like,
- 26:26people didn't I'll leave, you know, Tumblr didn't shut down,
- 26:29but everyone kind of migrated onto Twitter and I think
- 26:33already, we're seeing people know the roles that Twitter used
- 26:36to play in terms of real-time news in terms of reaching people
- 26:39at scale. I think actually Tick Tock has
- 26:40completely taken over all of that average.
- 26:43People like I mean I was just thinking, it's like if you see a
- 26:46fire on the side of the highway, no one else has seen it yet.
- 26:49You take a video of it. It used to be that you'd
- 26:51probably post that on Twitter writing.
- 26:53People's first instinct is like oh shit, I better show this one
- 26:56to talk, right? If you post on Twitter it's just
- 26:58so other people can steal your video.
- 27:00Yeah, actually get the audience yourself.
- 27:04Yeah. And also just like, I think
- 27:06that's just the algorithmic discovery there, you know, it's
- 27:08going to get seen, but I don't think like, Twitter is gonna go
- 27:12away or whatever. Also, you know, you and I are in
- 27:14Tech, like, tech people are so addicted to Twitter.
- 27:17They're not going to leave their Cloud on the table.
- 27:18Well, I just I, you know, so many of the fights that happen
- 27:22on Twitter are just like pretending Twitter is real life
- 27:26and I think the More everyone just disengages with that idea.
- 27:30Like the happier and less conflicted, we will be yeah, the
- 27:34Creator economy. So I feel like there are lots.
- 27:36We're changing gears, you know. Yeah, I think there's been a
- 27:40lot. There's this sort of sense out
- 27:42there that the Creator economy, I don't know, has been overhyped
- 27:45or at least is a business story or a little bit.
- 27:48Some of the investment in Creator.
- 27:50Stuff, is pulling back her? I don't know.
- 27:52What's the meme in the air about the Creator economy?
- 27:55Am I saying it, right? And what's your view on it as
- 27:58the expert here? Yeah, I know.
- 28:01Well, I have to say the term Creator economy becomes kind of
- 28:05like, it bane of my existence. I like it.
- 28:08I do. I mean here's the thing, I think
- 28:10having covered this industry, it's like, there's been so many
- 28:13names for everything like names for creators.
- 28:16You know? I remember when people were
- 28:18called so web-ready is and you are 80.
- 28:23Yeah, exactly. Now I'm just a millennial and
- 28:25Ancient One. You But I started in 2009, you
- 28:28know, and and the term Creator as you know which was pioneered
- 28:31by next new networks which wasn't even acquired by YouTube,
- 28:34I think until 2011. So that's really when the term
- 28:36took off in terms of a YouTuber Creator which is what, you know,
- 28:39where it's sort of seeped out from.
- 28:40But I think that I mean the influencer industry is also what
- 28:44I would call it. I think that it's like, it's
- 28:46been going again. This is a ship that's been
- 28:48happening for 20 years that I think.
- 28:50When the pandemic hit VCS and investors were like, oh wait,
- 28:54what is this? Like a lot of VCS And I noticed
- 28:57a lot of feces that never paid attention to Media before
- 29:00suddenly be interested in like, you know, this world.
- 29:05And I think the ones that were like a little burned by digital
- 29:07media. We're not as like full hyped on
- 29:09it, but yeah, and then he started publishing all this
- 29:11stuff. And, like you said, there was
- 29:12this whole hype cycle, which was great, but I think a lot of
- 29:16those Investments were really bad Investments, like it's not
- 29:19that there isn't a market and this isn't a huge
- 29:21multibillion-dollar industry. It's just that, like, they hyped
- 29:24this group of startups where there wasn't really a Need.
- 29:27And I think that showed just think of maybe a
- 29:28misunderstanding of the market, and the opportunities.
- 29:32I mean, because most of the money is just flowing to the
- 29:35Creator's themselves as sort of add Brands, like that trend is
- 29:40still continuing, even if there's an advertising pull back
- 29:43and then building your own, I mean, that's the big thing.
- 29:46Like, right is productizing yourself like the happy Dad,
- 29:48Seltzer from now, or whatever, right?
- 29:50Like yeah, that's been the trend for 7 years now, is that move
- 29:53towards Promoting your own stuff which again is like I think this
- 29:58has been another misunderstanding of Silicon
- 30:00Valley maybe just like not realizing that a lot of this
- 30:03infrastructure was already in place like they don't
- 30:06necessarily need XYZ platform for ex-wife like but I think
- 30:10it's you know it's like all types Cycles it's good because
- 30:12money flows into the space and it accelerates and right makes
- 30:15all these cool changes and most startups don't survive right?
- 30:18And so I think these are like oh shit maybe we didn't understand,
- 30:21you know, this Market that's all right.
- 30:22And a lot of the people getting screwed her Like you didn't have
- 30:25a big following and it's like if you had a newsletter on Facebook
- 30:27and they were paying you, some upfront thing, you know, is it a
- 30:32crisis? I guess, I don't know it.
- 30:34So you're getting free money before and now it's coming to an
- 30:37end. Like I don't know how sorry like
- 30:39I feel for you but yeah. Well they were like I mean I
- 30:42think it's like a lot of people built creators sort type
- 30:45features like you said, and then like paid money to boost it.
- 30:48I liked this thing that Mike mignola no wrote he's at
- 30:52Lightspeed now he's he made a pod Just at that makes it easier
- 30:55to make podcast. And you just talked about sort
- 30:57of like he called it the creativity supply chain.
- 31:00But he's talked about like, creative tools and how there is
- 31:02a market for Creative tools. Maybe not like these Niche,
- 31:06things of like, allowing specific creators to do specific
- 31:08things with their product, but like, creative tools.
- 31:11Like, we all need those, and they're very useful products,
- 31:14like description of the makes it easier to edit.
- 31:16We're using Riverside right now, which makes it easier to record
- 31:18a podcast. Yeah, that sort of thing, right?
- 31:21Or yeah, exactly. And it's hard.
- 31:23I mean, I don't It's investing in companies, very much, a game
- 31:28of luck to, but I think that's where a lot of the contraction
- 31:31is coming from. I've literally been through.
- 31:33I'm sure you remember to just so many things of is the influencer
- 31:37world over. I remember in 2017, when the FTC
- 31:39started cracking down, and it was like same thing, like, he's
- 31:42the Creator economy dead or whatever, you know, people.
- 31:45None of these shifts in media, media is only getting more
- 31:48distributed Legacy systems are only losing influence.
- 31:51So, like, those are ships that have been happening for 20
- 31:53years, it It's not going to do is sort of like, you know, and
- 31:57I've been guilty of this in in the business world.
- 32:00It's like is this.com is this the.com bust?
- 32:03And it's like well, clearly Tech isn't going away.
- 32:06Whereas in.com and really felt like maybe it was but it's just
- 32:09like, is this a really bad sort of downturn and are sort of the
- 32:13dominant players really going to get hurt it?
- 32:15It's like no one thinks text going away.
- 32:17No one thinks these creators are going away but if if everybody's
- 32:21pulling back, what does that mean for them?
- 32:22And obviously yeah there's been a lot of Like free money on both
- 32:26both sides. Yeah.
- 32:28And I think that's going to obviously contract like the,
- 32:30it's going to be the smaller ones.
- 32:32I mean, mr. Beast is going to be fine.
- 32:34I have a, this girl that I know that graduated journalism school
- 32:37just went to work for mr. Beats do, I think that's a good
- 32:40example of the future of media. You know, I always say that
- 32:43like, if I was graduating college today, there's no way in
- 32:46hell I would be going to try and work at the New York Times.
- 32:50You know, like no, it's just not where media is going.
- 32:54And so, you know, I think things like that, always free and it is
- 32:58a good corrective. I mean, the reality is, most
- 33:02people don't care about like news, they want, they want like
- 33:06content create but, you know, they want like, advice about
- 33:08their lives or it's something that is a creator that I guess,
- 33:12you know, inside the head of a crater at the moment is just how
- 33:16much am I news only or how much am I sort of investor Tech, you
- 33:21know, as I think about even like this podcast, you know, I Love
- 33:24like what's in the moment, sort of like what's the story line?
- 33:28But there is like such an audience demand obviously for
- 33:31for advice and great. Great journalism.
- 33:34You know can be instructive, you know, if I feel like that's why
- 33:37people love like biographies, you know?
- 33:39I read Ashley Vance's must biography.
- 33:41And I think on the e-book you can sort of see where people
- 33:43take notes and a lot of this stuff they like is just like
- 33:46musk's like business wisdom, you know, it's like journalists or
- 33:48reading it for like the craft and like the Scoops and then
- 33:52regular people are like how can I Like in some small part of my
- 33:56life like emulate these successful people and we have
- 33:59such a like skewed view. I don't know of what, right?
- 34:02I mean part of the problem I like do you think the media is
- 34:05just like lost track of like, what the consumer wants and like
- 34:07how much should consumer want dry?
- 34:10Like, we were monopolies for a while, right?
- 34:12So we lost touch with what people wanted, a hundred
- 34:14percent. I mean, I think of this all the
- 34:16time with the rise of mommy bloggers, which I know is a
- 34:19term. A lot of women don't like, but
- 34:20for lack of a better term. The reason that that entire
- 34:24Kaboom happened was because women's media was not talking to
- 34:29Mom's the way that they were, you know, there were giving like
- 34:31the worst advice ever. It was like how to clean up for
- 34:33your husband before he gets home when these moms were like no I
- 34:36want advice for like you know when my nipples get raw from
- 34:40breastfeeding or like I won't be able to talk about these hard
- 34:42things and so I think that's something that the Creator
- 34:45economy and I would consider bloggers among that shift.
- 34:47You know it does it meets consumer demands in a better way
- 34:50because they're forced to compete which as we know is Is
- 34:53usually a good thing. Hey, Miss Taylor's Pro
- 34:56capitalism to hear like, well, I'm going to be, I don't know.
- 34:59I've never said, I'm Auntie capital.
- 35:00I know, I know, but I'm saying I feel like there's this in come
- 35:03down the foil to the crypto people.
- 35:07I know look. So people are like I do but
- 35:09they're like okay and we're going to fix that with tokens,
- 35:12right? Right.
- 35:13I think those disruptions are a good thing.
- 35:16I think the problem becomes, when you add all these
- 35:19algorithmic seeds on top of it and things, get Warped.
- 35:23Right. And because then everybody's
- 35:25chasing incentives created by these platforms that have
- 35:28nothing to do with like truth or lie, you know, it's just sort of
- 35:32whatever it right. I mean that's sort of been so
- 35:34much of the Facebook coverage on, you know, I feel like
- 35:38there's been a lot of talk about just sort of YouTube, being such
- 35:42a generous place for pain out creators relative to the rest,
- 35:47or like, what what's your view on sort of the state of platform
- 35:51compensation for creators and like, do you see any movement?
- 35:55Yeah, I love, I mean, Hank. Green is just like the best on
- 36:00all of us and if you've seen his videos, is a great, I love him.
- 36:03And his brother there, I mean, I watch way too much Tick Tock.
- 36:05So yeah, of course, well Hank made these like amazing YouTube
- 36:09videos just breaking down. How bad Tick-Tock is for
- 36:11creators in terms of payment, right?
- 36:13Specifically calling attention. I thought I was jealous that I
- 36:16didn't write this Leg Takedown of Creator funds myself because
- 36:20the whole notion is like, you only have one pie and it gets
- 36:23split more and more ways through creators enter into the fund.
- 36:25YouTube is always just given a cut of AD revenue and I think
- 36:28that's actually smart business and it's a little aoz for
- 36:31stability and it's undeniably a better way.
- 36:34Now, it is more generous to creators and I think YouTube is,
- 36:37you know, Twitch also was doing that meant which now is like,
- 36:41you know, grabbing more money. They're getting greedy.
- 36:43I think they realize again, these are they do have a
- 36:45monopoly? I mean, I do it think that are
- 36:47like platform ecosystem is, is not competitive enough, right?
- 36:51Right. So I don't know if how friendly
- 36:52YouTube will be forever, but I do I've generally and this is
- 36:56wonky Tech territory, but like I've been much more in favor of
- 37:01I love Congress to pass like a revenue share law, or like a
- 37:05platform rake law. Like I feel like Democrats have
- 37:08Gotten so excited about antitrust, is the solution, and
- 37:12it just like how many are there really going to be that many
- 37:15like video players or is it more about?
- 37:18Okay, there's probably a couple dominant ones and we just need
- 37:21to like their vital institutions for our society and so we're
- 37:25going to regulate them like auto manufacturers or something or
- 37:29Airlines you know it's just like these are really fixed
- 37:31industries that have a lot of power and we need to protect
- 37:36like you know the pilots and the workers and Passengers.
- 37:39I'm yeah, I don't know. What is that going to happen?
- 37:43Do you think that? I feel like they don't even know
- 37:45what? Like a fenced area is right?
- 37:47I think they're learning. I mean, you know, these things
- 37:49take so long but I just think I don't know.
- 37:52Antitrust is the vehicle for it versus a bill.
- 37:55That sort of says, here's here's, you know, you probably
- 37:58need like a rat, you know, Revenue threshold.
- 38:01Like you don't want small startups to have to deal with
- 38:03this, but it's some sighs. Yeah, I wonder what that would
- 38:07look like. I yes, to me, it's hard to
- 38:09Picture only because I feel like people within the media, don't
- 38:12even grasp, you know, the stuff and I don't know, but it would
- 38:16be interesting. I mean, I think Something's
- 38:19Gotta Give, You know, and I do think that, like, it's been
- 38:21really fun to watch Tick, Tock come in, and just like force.
- 38:26All of these companies to, like, be on their toes because I, you
- 38:29know, I was getting a little like flat wine.
- 38:32I think 2017, 2018. And so literally, the last
- 38:35episode was sort of about how consumer apps have Pretty much
- 38:40flubbed, you know, like there's the clubhouse hype there was all
- 38:42this people really wanted to like will consumer into being
- 38:48but besides, you know, of course Tick Tock which, you know, a lot
- 38:51of the money is in in China. I mean, do you agree?
- 38:54It sounds like you're agreeing with that thesis.
- 38:55But yeah, we've been in sort of like a consumer app, winter,
- 38:59right? I think so too.
- 39:02Yeah, it seems like that. Only because all these apps,
- 39:05like you said, they get hype and then they kind of fizzle.
- 39:07Yeah, be real are. Are you optimistic or yeah?
- 39:11I mean again. I think it depends how they can
- 39:13evolve their product, that's always the challenge.
- 39:17It's like, sometimes you come up with this interesting new
- 39:19format, can you scale it and scale it while retaining that
- 39:24audience? I think that's very hard to do.
- 39:26We just seems like yeah France. I think it's Pete, you know.
- 39:29It's just sort of peaked at so many of these things you know?
- 39:32Yeah. You have to keep growth.
- 39:33Is everything. Yeah I mean Nikita beer keeps me
- 39:37doing his quiz apps. Oh yeah.
- 39:40Yeah. Well, if you keep your
- 39:42expectations, you know it's just like what's the new one is?
- 39:45Like you Heidi? Okay.
- 39:48Yeah. I like those little like viral
- 39:50things. I think it's like you go into it
- 39:52and I think he would agree with this, like, you think he's
- 39:54pretty clear-eyed about, you know, it's not like he's
- 39:57necessarily trying to evolve that into the Next Generation
- 39:59social platform, maybe he is, but I think I think it's like
- 40:02there's room for those viral apps, but staying power.
- 40:05I don't think that everyone wants to be connected either.
- 40:08Like I don't Don't think I think I think what Tick-Tock did in
- 40:11terms of removing the need to follow people and putting so
- 40:15much of a burden on the user and forcing them to develop these
- 40:19permanent connections. I think is actually I don't
- 40:21think that's the future so are you not worried about like the
- 40:23China issue or what's your view on?
- 40:26Oh my God, I my view is if you all these people the same people
- 40:30there's a great does Moto video actually about this that I was
- 40:32about to share on Tick-Tock if you have concerns about data
- 40:35privacy rate Tick-Tock. Let's talk about The privacy
- 40:39because the people that are you know, it's all amped on
- 40:42Tick-Tock are the same ones that are, you know, totally fine with
- 40:45Facebook stealing. All of our data, like China can
- 40:47buy us data. China is, you know, Tick-Tock is
- 40:50not the only Chinese app. You know, there's tons of us
- 40:53data firms. That would happily sell our data
- 40:55to Chinese interests. I think it's just totally
- 40:58overhyped BS. It's, none of us.
- 41:00Consistent. Of course, it's like, first of
- 41:02all, we don't have a Smoking Gun but second of all, it's like,
- 41:04okay, fine. I'm willing to accept that, you
- 41:07know, maybe, Okay. We should talk about like
- 41:10Chinese or foreign entities, buying our data.
- 41:13That means we need comprehensive data privacy reform.
- 41:15Right now we're so far away from that and no one is even talking
- 41:18about that. It's just like, let's villainize
- 41:20Tick-Tock. All right, I have to this is
- 41:23good. We actually disagree on
- 41:24something here, Ami and you've been pretty positive unticked.
- 41:28I would say, from what I've? I'm not positive.
- 41:31I think that like, I think that's good.
- 41:32Beatriz, got it? Yeah.
- 41:35All right, the two things I'll say, like, first of all.
- 41:39This speech code and I'm not saying this specific to what
- 41:41China is doing but there's a lot of self-censorship because of
- 41:45tick-tocks content moderation. No, nothing compared to
- 41:48Instagram nothing but here on. Okay, just let me.
- 41:51Yeah, I know that's true but like I'm not saying because it's
- 41:55Chinese, I'm just saying the fact that like Tic, Tacs
- 41:58deciding, whether people can say suicide or not, like everyone
- 42:00says on alived, just okay. I'll let you talking all.
- 42:04You don't want that in the hands of a Chinese company even if
- 42:07they're making the Same decisions that a US company
- 42:10would it's just, it feels like such a like this is like the
- 42:14morality of our society and there's a lot of value.
- 42:17No, I would just want in the hands of Americans and not
- 42:21people who are sort of at the whims of the Chinese Communist
- 42:24party. Then my number two point which
- 42:25is very different, is just like if China is not going to let
- 42:30American apps compete competitively in China.
- 42:33It's terrible like foreign policy business strategy,
- 42:37whatever to I'm like have one of the dominant consumer apps, the
- 42:41United States I guess if we like son, if Facebook's allowed to
- 42:44compete in China, I'm more opening to revisit but it just,
- 42:49we're suckers at the moment. Let me respond to two things.
- 42:52Number one Tick Tock is far more permissive than Instagram.
- 42:56I say this as somebody who has lost multiple Instagram accounts
- 42:58and is constantly getting Community guidelines violations.
- 43:01Okay. I can't even say, haha, like I
- 43:03can't remember what I got banned for the other day.
- 43:05I mean, I've been banned for saying stuff about women when
- 43:07I'm a woman like I mean there's just is so in its tells me that
- 43:12people have spent zero time on Instagram, because Instagram is
- 43:15the strictest platform out there in terms of what you can say and
- 43:18what you can't say in my opinion.
- 43:21Yeah. And I think many, I mean,
- 43:22there's entire movement me movement that agrees with that.
- 43:26So I think I mean I guess I'm Marc Andreessen can walk
- 43:29arm-in-arm freestyle. I have always, I have I have
- 43:33never, I have I know people say, are you for censorship that is
- 43:36just never, that is not true and I never have Have an eye.
- 43:40You know, I don't agree with that.
- 43:41I am very, I think it's important to have open
- 43:44discussions and like I said, I tweeted this recently.
- 43:46I'm like if people on Twitter, I had to spend one day on
- 43:48Instagram actually using it like the way that people do to share
- 43:52news and have conversations, they would be radicalized
- 43:54because it's very restrictive. And look I get wide right
- 43:58because they've gotten a lot of criticism on safety and I think
- 44:00they've cracked down because of that.
- 44:02But if you know it just it drives me crazy.
- 44:05Where do you think all those terms came from on a live that
- 44:08started on YouTube? That was a you Tube and
- 44:09Instagram thing far before Tick-Tock.
- 44:11So whatever I agree. I mean, I guess Instagrams worse
- 44:15and it's American. I accept them.
- 44:17Yeah. But well it's worse on that
- 44:19issue. Right?
- 44:21And so I think that like you know if you want to dock a
- 44:24company lets you know go there. The second thing I will say is
- 44:27like I get what you're saying in terms of maybe you don't want
- 44:29China setting like a Chinese interest setting, those speech
- 44:32rules but there's no, there's no evidence that they are doing any
- 44:36of that, I guess. And in fact is a country Like
- 44:39had Jack ma like Running Scared, like the most powerful business
- 44:44Elites, you know, I just feel like China.
- 44:46But again, the u.s. totally their horse in the mirror, look,
- 44:51it's an authoritarian country. However, Tick Tock is a global
- 44:55platform and, you know, especially with the content
- 44:57moderation stuff. It's very localized.
- 45:00And we in America are there's nothing that, you know, your
- 45:04censored at on Tick-Tock I've ever seen that, is it equally
- 45:08censored on Instagram other Platforms.
- 45:10I will say also you know what you're saying about.
- 45:12Oh we can't compete in China. So why should they whatever?
- 45:16I think I'm sorry, y-you whatever.
- 45:18You know what I'm saying? I think that we live we want to
- 45:20live in a globalized society, right?
- 45:22I mean, I don't know that it's really good to have this hyper
- 45:25nationalist thing where were suddenly were drawing borders.
- 45:27I think that it's a little bit of a taste of our own medicine,
- 45:30like we've exported Facebook, all over.
- 45:32Look at the Havoc. It's rot in different democracy.
- 45:35So I get it. Maybe, maybe these platforms
- 45:38shouldn't be Global, I guess that's Argument.
- 45:40I don't know. What do I support colloquialism?
- 45:42I'm Steve just wheeled the fact that we they can compete in the
- 45:46united there like a global power.
- 45:49It's not like this is some developing country anymore the
- 45:52needs to like protect its own industry.
- 45:53Like they have thriving meteorites.
- 45:56Are you gonna say that tight, right?
- 45:58I just think like these. These rules are very, it's a
- 46:00very slippery slope. You say Chinese companies can't
- 46:03do business in America. I mean, look at all these.
- 46:05He'll they'll allow American technology companies to compete.
- 46:09I Enjoying. That's so I mean, I think that's
- 46:12really interesting Earth because like, there's so much
- 46:15entanglement isn't like League of Legends, like have huge
- 46:19Chinese ownership, like I can tag entangling all of that.
- 46:23Maybe I think that's an interesting point and I mean, on
- 46:25the must story, which we talked about in the Alex Stamos
- 46:27episode. I mean musk's wealth is so tied
- 46:30into China and I just want to also flag just sort of in the
- 46:33China in the are sort of thing. I mean, Peter teal recently gave
- 46:37a big speech where I took his Take away to be being that the
- 46:41Republican Party should focus on China.
- 46:43Confrontation is one of their main issues, which I don't
- 46:46really know how that plays out in Silicon Valley, where so many
- 46:50Silicon Valley companies are totally tied in with China
- 46:54particular, right? And if we're going to talk about
- 46:57authoritarian regimes, let's talk about the Saudis as well,
- 47:00right? Like look at musk, you know,
- 47:02Hamming it up. Just sure recently, you know,
- 47:05those regimes, it's felt like we get their money and a lot of
- 47:09Times we blow it on like we work you know is like that so bad for
- 47:12us. Whereas China, you know, they're
- 47:14setting policy with Hollywood there.
- 47:17You know and I just feel like Tick Tock is such an app where
- 47:20such subtle mom you know you could just boost something and
- 47:23nobody would know because it's like, what's the a, I think,
- 47:25like right now, we believe in this sort of, like, purity of
- 47:28the algorithm, but for all, we know, somebody could put your
- 47:31thumb on the scale, one, or the other.
- 47:32If you want to talk about nefarious, algorithms we've yet
- 47:35to see that harm from Tick-Tock. I don't doubt that it will come
- 47:38Tick. Tock is The way The Tick-Tock
- 47:40functions in terms of the mass mob behavior is terrifying, and
- 47:44I think we'll end up corrib lie, but I don't know I, you know,
- 47:47it's interesting. I don't have strong, I mean I
- 47:49have strong opinions about the content moderation stuff because
- 47:52it's like my thing. But Alex Stamos you mentioned is
- 47:55like, really smart and security and I very much, you know, trust
- 47:58him on a lot of security like that type of stuff for sure.
- 48:01I'm gonna ask a question, you are saying your aunt, ice the
- 48:04anti-censorship thing. Like do you think we got in like
- 48:07a period where we were to like, Awkward School D.
- 48:10Like, I feel like, one of your incidents like souring you with
- 48:13Silicon Valley, was the whole Clubhouse like retard.
- 48:16Are we? Yeah, because I could Infuse.
- 48:18Yeah, let's be clear. What's his name?
- 48:20Ben Horowitz, said that word and I thought it was Marc
- 48:23Andreessen. Both bald white guys who I've
- 48:25never had anything to do with and and other reporter who I
- 48:29will not name tweeted that first.
- 48:31So I know I'm persecuted because I confused the two in a single
- 48:34tweet that I immediately corrected you made the mistake
- 48:37and you crack it and they take advantage of They don't really
- 48:40explain the whole story that someone said it and there was
- 48:42just a confusion of here. I confuse which without her van
- 48:45driessen would you do things? Like it's a little way, it might
- 48:48be sorrier. One other thing.
- 48:49Let me just clarify. If you read my fucking tweet,
- 48:52I'm defending her. I'm defending.
- 48:54I said, basically, like, if you're going to act like my
- 48:58thesis with my thread, which I deleted immediately within two
- 49:01minutes was like, you know, if you're gonna get mad at this one
- 49:03co-founder of and reason for saying this word, there's seven
- 49:06other people on stage. He didn't say anything.
- 49:08So quote Unquote. Hold those people accountable as
- 49:11well. You know, I feel like if you
- 49:13are, I'll there was definitely a period where everybody was like,
- 49:17tattletaling, on people for saying particular words, right?
- 49:20Line. I've never been, I'm not part of
- 49:22that. I am now and I don't, I don't I
- 49:25think that's a complete Miss intentional.
- 49:28Miss Miss construing what I said and I look if I want to call
- 49:32somebody out, I call someone out.
- 49:33I'm not doing it. Like in some passive way as you
- 49:36know, I'm not like right. I know that's what.
- 49:39I mean. Yeah.
- 49:41I mean I'm sure I was on team Taylor on that at the time, but
- 49:44it does feel like I don't know, I thought it was an objection to
- 49:47the word. Well of course I mean I think
- 49:49it's an ableist word. I'm just saying if you crazy
- 49:52earlier in this, I mean, yeah, exactly.
- 49:54We said I know. I'm just saying you just like,
- 49:57I'm not going to say, I'm not going to say that.
- 50:00Totally I mean look, is this something that I personally care
- 50:03about but I would never say that.
- 50:05That means that you shouldn't be able to type something and put
- 50:09it on Twitter, let you know. I mean, I guess my feeling
- 50:12always do them but it doesn't mean it should be banned or I'm
- 50:15not saying I don't think it but platforms role.
- 50:18I think we as a society can develop social norms and of
- 50:21course, different groups, develop social norms of what you
- 50:23consider acceptable. What you consider racist,
- 50:25whatever? I don't know that.
- 50:27That is the platform's roll to determine that.
- 50:31And again, this this is why I think we need.
- 50:33As I have always said, despite the fact that people love to
- 50:36say, I'm cancel culture, whatever, I think that, we, as
- 50:39users. Sirs deserve the ability to
- 50:42control our environments on the internet right now.
- 50:45It's like everyone's subjected to this one thing and everyone's
- 50:47trying to put their different roles on it.
- 50:49I mean, that's why something like Discord.
- 50:50It's like, okay, you can set the rules and people can engage,
- 50:53sometimes you want to be in the mass mess of it all, and you
- 50:56don't give a shit like you want to scrap a people find.
- 50:58Sometimes you want to safer, quote, unquote environment, and
- 51:02I think you should be able to set those terms.
- 51:03And I do think I do think part of what sort of broke
- 51:06everybody's brains. Unlike the media in Silicon
- 51:08Valley is just Any reporters, or it's like you the backlash
- 51:13against you, like, showing up at the lives of tick-tock to her,
- 51:16which obviously, like door knocking a source is the most
- 51:19like traditional, like mediate, like, I will defend that to my
- 51:23death and it's absurd. And like Antonio Garcia
- 51:26Martinez, I think, was trying to say basically like, what if a
- 51:29random like Twitter accounted? I'm like yeah, but were they
- 51:32doing it to like find get comment, or were they just
- 51:34really like intimidate someone anyway, so I stand by that
- 51:37hundred percent but I do think the media is sort of like It's
- 51:41an authority figure, it's like the police.
- 51:42It's like when you show up at somebody's door, there's a like
- 51:45implicit. Like we, you know, we're coming
- 51:47for you. And similarly when we blow
- 51:50something up with big followings and retweet people, it feels
- 51:53like we're sort of like, yeah, the cops are like the tattletale
- 51:57sort of, you know, depends, you can frame it different ways.
- 52:00But, you know, anytime a big account or an authority figure
- 52:03blows people up on these social media platforms, like Marc
- 52:05Andreessen, right? I mean they yeah, they do, I
- 52:08start they've Balaji block me because I wanted to do an
- 52:12interview request, so I see it less, but I feel like the
- 52:15call-out culture is sort of like, calm down on Twitter a
- 52:17little bit. I think so.
- 52:19I mean, I think a little bit, I think all of them were getting
- 52:22way too online during the pandemic.
- 52:24I mean, obviously, we're still in a pandemic but like in 2020,
- 52:27right? Yeah, it's really it, you know,
- 52:29it's funny with the door knocking thing, too.
- 52:31Because I do understand, you know, People not understanding
- 52:35that or feeling like that, I think it's so often to we expect
- 52:40that digital things will stay digital, right?
- 52:42So we expect, right? And so I think it's like
- 52:44suddenly jarring to be like, oh shit, this is the real world,
- 52:47right? And even people, I mean my
- 52:49family's been swatted multiple times.
- 52:51I've dealt with all the stuff, it's like the people even.
- 52:54Harassers will sink it in there, headed still digital, you know,
- 52:58they're living this digital world and they're not realizing
- 53:00like, no. This is all the real world,
- 53:02right? I mean, I think one of our
- 53:03profound Holmes was Society divided, like some up, like a
- 53:07core problem. I think we have in society.
- 53:08It's that people that if you were at dinner with them you
- 53:12would hate them. Are your preferred political
- 53:15candidate? It's like, like, Rudy Giuliani,
- 53:17like some of these people. Their children, hate that right?
- 53:21Like, from everything I can tell like, some of these people, so
- 53:23give your children hate you. That should matter much more
- 53:28than like, I don't know whether you're good at doing like a CNN
- 53:31or Fox News hit. And I feel like, Social media is
- 53:35totally failed to deliver the information that people who sit
- 53:39down with these people and people who know them better than
- 53:41anyone don't like them. And like, I don't know how so
- 53:44the internet solves that but that's Silicon Valley people go
- 53:48solve that like that's what I want someone to solve like, how
- 53:51do I reputations as good humans? Actually, like count for
- 53:54something online. Well, also just online as we
- 53:57know is so performative and you have this across the political
- 54:00Spectrum, right? Like this performative bullshit
- 54:03that kind of is Is made to bolster your reputation and
- 54:06nobody knows what you do in private, right hard.
- 54:09It's hard to know. You never really know if someone
- 54:11online is quote, unquote, good or bad, you know?
- 54:14I mean, you, you know, through their behavior in there talking
- 54:17and stuff, but it's hard to know them, you know, you're never
- 54:19going to know them personally, probably, right.
- 54:21But yeah, I mean, I don't know the lives of tick-tock stuff.
- 54:24I did my job and I absolutely did not docs her for somebody
- 54:27that concerns. So concerned about doxing.
- 54:29She tweeted a picture of me at her doorstep, where you could
- 54:33see, not only The street, she lived on her soda change in
- 54:36Dallas, and then there are constant like, oh, you linked
- 54:38her real estate license which had the address of her company,
- 54:41that's like, yeah, that's it was our payment on a house.
- 54:44Of course, it was like, oh my God.
- 54:48I mean, this is where you guys took out the link to anywhere.
- 54:57Yeah, they took out the link, I think because of all the I don't
- 55:00remember, the exact reason why probably because people were
- 55:02misrepresenting it that's like somebody liking to Washington.
- 55:04Post.com and then me going on Twitter.
- 55:06Oh my god, I've been dogs. Do link to this address in d.c.?
- 55:09Yeah, that's the company address.
- 55:11You live in LA lady. She was living in l.a. she's
- 55:13even admitted that she lived in LA and I visited her house,
- 55:16right? That sheets that, you know, by
- 55:18the way, it's like, where are you registered to vote?
- 55:20Where do you pay your cell phone bill?
- 55:21Like, where are you actually living like, no, I would never
- 55:24linked that. I would never reveal her
- 55:25address. And yet, here, she is tweeting a
- 55:27photo of me at her door that reveals everything.
- 55:29So, it's just a surprise. Yeah, no, I would never linked
- 55:32to someone's home address. I mean, we need We need more
- 55:34people to actually care about whether someone's a liar.
- 55:38Like, I mean, there's just like a lot of people in our society
- 55:40right now who don't seem to prioritize like people who are
- 55:44honest enough, I don't know that.
- 55:46That's not a social media problem that's like a priorities
- 55:49values problem. I think social media feeds into
- 55:53it because people develop these parasocial relationships and
- 55:56they just want to basically eat up content from people that they
- 56:00agree with you know and there's no intellectual consistency.
- 56:04See to it. I'ma let you go even I and I
- 56:07also didn't know this would turn into well, I think it's good.
- 56:10Some of these scandals like Austin drama drama and I'll
- 56:14clear the air like, you know, this is why people should give
- 56:20interviews. It's like useful, like, oh I
- 56:22didn't realize that this thing people think is like, you know,
- 56:25slight against you is different than the facts that you consume
- 56:28on Twitter, but I had another point was going to say we were
- 56:32talking about I don't know. Tick Tock.
- 56:36Oh yeah. I mean lives of tick-tock.
- 56:38You probably can't see this but it's terrible.
- 56:41I mean it's and the fact that you'll on is so supportive.
- 56:43I mean, she's so mean-spirited. Like who would want What are you
- 56:48doing? Valuable for society?
- 56:50Like I find it so so sad and that I mean, you were the one to
- 56:53say this is really driving a core part of like the Republican
- 56:57Party conversation and that's absolutely true in the media so
- 57:01bad, it stating that. So, yeah, you don't get enough
- 57:03credit for some of that stuff. This is a Taylor Lorenz tribute
- 57:07podcast. But but, yeah, I mean, I think I
- 57:09do this is the sort of overly sincere wrap up, but I do think
- 57:13like podcasting YouTube like long-form audio where You can
- 57:17really like get a sense of someone.
- 57:20He's really the response to Twitter where people can just
- 57:23like and cable news, which is terrible, you know, where you
- 57:26actually hopefully get more of a glimpse into someone's Soul.
- 57:29So I guess to the extent there, the rise of long form.
- 57:34I mean you tweet Joe Rogan but like Joe Rogan that's like, I
- 57:36think it's good for the world like, long form with people.
- 57:40Listen to them. Joe Rogan needs to fact-check
- 57:43stuff before goes on his show. Yes, it just tweeted.
- 57:47Ridiculous or he just he they rented for 11 minutes about a
- 57:50fake tweet that I cannot believe anyone would fall for it but
- 57:54right on the show on the show him and Brett Weinstein, right?
- 57:59Well this is the sort of low expectations like the genie.
- 58:02I need to I need to Foster lower expectations for myself because
- 58:05then if you clear them people you know it's all like what you
- 58:09do relative to your expectations where nobody expects him to be
- 58:12honored percent, right? Yeah, it's always what if they
- 58:15say I always think of this to its Like under-promise
- 58:18over-deliver, exactly. And I again, I yeah, I agree
- 58:22with you Eric. I think long form and places
- 58:26like podcasting where you can have a conversation, it just you
- 58:29get a sense of who someone is, you know, a lot, right better?
- 58:33That's not to say that misinformation can't spread all
- 58:35the time on podcasts because it does.
- 58:36I mean, Rush partisan bullshit comes out on podcasts.
- 58:39Well, there's a very different thing between a podcast where
- 58:43it's like back and forth and you're really trying versus
- 58:45like, you know, I mean right wing You know, I used to listen
- 58:48to Rush Limbaugh sort of as to know the other side and you know
- 58:52there's no there was no search for truth there.
- 58:55There's such a performance. So I'm not saying you can't feel
- 58:58many many hours of audio content with like total manipulation,
- 59:03but I do think the sort of conversational human podcasting,
- 59:09a gives me some Hope For Humanity in 2023 good.
- 59:13I love it. Great, you have a last word or
- 59:16what? What do you mean?
- 59:17It's excited about in 2023. That's that's the last word
- 59:19inter. Well, yeah, my goal for 2020
- 59:22three is to not. Yeah, it's to do more stuff
- 59:26outside. That's more talking about the
- 59:27stuff that I care about outside of Twitter.
- 59:29I think media people are so on Twitter but my book comes out
- 59:33this year. So that's like one big thing
- 59:36October. I knew the headline, but remind
- 59:38me extremely online. It's about the rise of the
- 59:42attention ecosystem online, Creator world's kind of just
- 59:45like how media. He became what it is great.
- 59:49We will look forward to it. Thank you very much for coming
- 59:52on the podcast. Thanks for having me.
- 59:54Cool, great, yay. Okay, I was fine.
- 59:56Oh my God, I was so fun. Goodbye, goodbye.
- 1:00:12Goodbye, goodbye, goodbye, goodbye.
- 1:00:14Goodbye. Goodbye, goodbye.
- 1:00:12Goodbye, goodbye, goodbye, goodbye.
- 1:00:14Goodbye.